The Unz Review: An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewPhilip Giraldi Archive
Trump the Russian Puppet. A Story That Just Will Not Die
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information



=>
Credit: Strategic Culture Foundation/Wikimedia Commons

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Troll, or LOL with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used once per hour.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

Certainly, there are many things that President Donald Trump can rightly be criticized for, but it is interesting to note how the media and chattering classes continue to be in the grip of the highly emotional but ultimately irrational “Trump derangement syndrome (TDS).” TDS means that even the most ridiculous claims about Trump behavior can be regurgitated by someone like Jake Tapper or Rachel Maddow without anyone in the media even daring to observe that they are both professional dissemblers of truth who lie regularly to enhance their professional resumes.

There are two persistent bogus narratives about Donald Trump that are, in fact, related. The first is that his campaign and transition teams collaborated with the Russian government to defeat Hillary Clinton. Even Robert Mueller, he of the famous fact-finding commission, had to admit that that was not demonstrable. The only government that succeeded in collaborating with the incoming Trumpsters was that of Israel, but Mueller forgot to mention that or even look into it.

Nevertheless, Russia as a major contributing element in the Trump victory continues to be cited in the mainstream media, seemingly whenever Trump is mentioned, as if it were demonstrated fact. The fact is that whatever Russia did was miniscule and did not in any way alter the outcome of the election. Similarly, allegations that the Kremlin will again be at it in 2020 are essentially baseless fearmongering and are a reflection of the TDS desire to see the president constantly diminished in any way possible.

The other narrative that will not die is the suggestion that Donald Trump is either a Russian spy or is in some other, possibly psychological fashion, controlled by Russian President Vladimir Putin. That spy story was first floated by several former senior CIA officers who were closely tied to the Hillary Clinton campaign, apparently because they believed they would benefit materially if she were elected.

Former CIA Acting Director Michael Morell was the most aggressive promoter of Trump as Russian spy narrative. In August 2016, he wrote a New York Times op-ed entitled “I Ran the CIA. Now I’m endorsing Hillary Clinton.” Morell’s story began with the flat assertion that “Mrs. Clinton is highly qualified to be commander in chief. I trust she will deliver on the most important duty of a president – keeping our nation safe… Donald J. Trump is not only unqualified for the job, but he may well pose a threat to our national security.”

In his op-ed, Morell ran through the litany of then GOP candidate Trump’s observed personality and character failings while also citing his lack of experience, but he delivered what he thought to be his most crushing blow when he introduced Vladimir Putin into the discussion. Putin, it seems, a wily ex-career intelligence officer, is “trained to identify vulnerabilities in an individual and to exploit them. That is exactly what he did early in the primaries. Mr. Putin played upon Mr. Trump’s vulnerabilities… In the intelligence business, we would say that Mr. Putin had recruited Mr. Trump as an unwitting agent of the Russian Federation.”

How can one be both unwitting and a recruited agent? Some might roll their eyes at that bit of hyperbole, but Morell, who was a top analyst at the Agency but never acquired or ran an actual spy in his entire career, goes on to explain how Moscow is some kind of eternal enemy. For Morell that meant that Trump’s often stated willingness to work with Putin and the nuclear armed state he headed was somehow the act of a Manchurian Candidate, seen by Morell as a Russian interest, not an American one. So much for the presumed insider knowledge that came from the man who “ran the CIA.”

The most recent “former intelligence agents’” blast against Trump appeared in the Business Insider last month in an article entitled “US spies say Trump’s G7 performance suggests he’s either a ‘Russian asset’ or a ‘useful idiot’ for Putin.” The article cites a number of former government officials, including several from the CIA and FBI, who claimed that Trump’s participation at the recent G7 summit in Biarritz France was marked by pandering to Putin and the Kremlin’s interests, including a push to re-include Russia in the G-7, from which it was expelled after the annexation of Crimea.

One current anonymous FBI source cited in the article described the Trump performance as a “new low,” while a former senior Justice Department official, labeled Trump’s behavior as “directly out of the Putin playbook. We have a Russian asset sitting in the Oval Office.” An ex-CIA officer speculated that the president’s “intent and odd personal fascination with President Putin is worth serious scrutiny,” concluding that the evidence is “overwhelming” that Trump is a Russian asset, while other CIA and NSA veterans suggested that Trump might be flattering Putin in exchange for future business concessions in Moscow.

Another recently retired FBI special agent opined that Trump was little more than “useful idiot” for the Russians, though he added that it would not surprise him if there were also Russian spies in Trump’s inner circle.

The comments in the article are almost incoherent. They come from carefully selected current and former government employees who suffer from an excess of TDS, or possibly pathological paranoia, and hate the president for various reasons. What they are suggesting is little more than speculation and not one of them was able to cite any actual evidence to support their contentions. And, on the contrary, there is considerable evidence that points the other way. The US-Russia relationship is at its lowest point ever according to some observers and that has all been due to policies promoted by the Trump Administration to include the continuing threats over Crimea, sanctions against numerous Russian officials, abrogation of existing arms treaties, and the expansion of aggressive NATO activity right up to the borders with Russia.

Just this past week, the United States warned Russia against continuing its aerial support for the Syrian Army advance to eliminate the last major terrorist pocket in Idlib province. Once against, Washington is operating on the side of terrorists in Syria and against Russia, a conflict that the United States entered into illegally in the first place. Either Donald Trump acting as “the Russian agent” actually thinks threatening a Moscow that is pursuing its legitimate interests is a good idea or the labeling of the president as a “Putin puppet” or “useful idiot” is seriously misguided.

(Republished from Strategic Culture Foundation by permission of author or representative)
 
• Category: Ideology • Tags: American Media, Donald Trump, Russiagate 
Hide 41 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
    []
  1. Jewish Power is venal.

    All their puppets are said to be ‘patriots’ and ‘good Americans’, whereas anyone who displeases them is a ‘white supremacist’ or ‘Putin puppet’. Never mind Yeltsin was a Jewish puppet, a real one. Putin himself started out as a Jewish puppet and has never fully liberated himself from the Cabal. But, he’s still a bad guy because he said NO to globo-homo.

    As for proggy minions, they are dumb and will believe anything. These morons were glued to Rachel Madcow for 2 1/2 years. They are that clueless.

    • Agree: Felix Keverich
    • Replies: @mark green
  2. Phil

    It goes like this:

    A Democratic Politician and Republican Politician goes to AIPAC and pledges their allegiance to ISRAEL…..no problem….for this is the natural order of things…

    Trump attempts to have friendly relations with Christian Russia so the US can have beneficial economic relations with Christian Russia and prevent nuclear war….Well this is TREASON!!!!

    There now exist two race-based nations within the borders of the US….nonwhites vote on the basis of race…Whites vote on the basis of race….Trump’s Native Born White American Voting Bloc wants friendly relations with Christian Russia….The Nonwhite Democratic Party Voting Bloc+JEWS call us TRAITORS for wanting friendly relations with Christian Russian….But we are the Historic Racial Majority……

    So….in a nutshell…what drives the War against Christian Russia and Donald Trump’s Voting Bloc is the Democratic Party’s WHITE GENOCIDE WAR against European Christian Russia and THE WORKING CLASS HISTORIC NATIVE BORN WHITE AMERICAN MAJORITY…..Keep in mind what the Democratic Party is in 2019:KAMALA HARRIS AND PREET BHARRA…HINDU POWER!!!!

    I openly proclaim my “TREASON” against the majority nonwhite Democratic Party Voting Bloc!!!

    • Agree: Robert Dolan
    • Replies: @Authenticjazzzman
  3. So Phil pivots from a column where he blasts every conceivable action of the Trump Administration (all the way down to where Pence stayed in Ireland) to a column about how TDS is a huge problem in Washington.

  4. Trump’s links to Russia are all Chabad. The CFR Globalists that dominate mass media under the Haass leadership do not like the fact that the “Red Mafiya” Lubavichers have control of Russia and the United States.

    “All I knew about the way Chabad had ruthlessly inserted itself in to the circles of power and money in Putin’s Russia.” – https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-is-putin-s-pet-oligarch-abramovich-worthy-of-israeli-citizenship-1.6136441

    “Kushner was affiliated with the Chabad house at Harvard.” – https://washingtonmonthly.com/2017/11/27/the-odd-chabad-connection-between-putin-and-trump/

  5. Is it good or bad that I need only quote my remark of three days ago?

    ‘…Given Israel’s influence, for us to fret about Russian interference is literally like a whore crawling out of the motel room after her latest trick and fretting about how that bad man across the parking lot looked at her ankles.

    My first reaction when all this got started is ‘you have got to be kidding.’

    That’s still my reaction…’

    Israel bought Trump. Sheldon Adelson gave Trump twenty five million dollars. That the Zionists also bought Hillary Clinton just makes the point clearer.

    When it comes to foreign powers influencing our elections, Russia’s way behind the leader.

  6. @Bragadocious

    Integrity means critiquing what leaders actually do, rather than making up false accusations instead. You can’t expect to fight what’s wrong by means of lies, and if you try, you will make things even worse.

    • Replies: @Bragadocious
  7. @Fran Macadam

    Really. So you think the whole brouhaha over Pence “offending the Irish” is totally legit. Even though Phil’s link takes us to the Guardian, recently outed as a fake news outlet for MI6 (the source of the piss dossier if you recall).

    The world headquarters for TDS is London, and the Guardian is its megaphone. Apparently, that didn’t occur to Giraldi.

    https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2019-09-11-how-the-uk-security-services-neutralised-the-countrys-leading-liberal-newspaper/

  8. A123 says:

    In this case Giraldi is 100% correct.

    … highly emotional but ultimately irrational “Trump derangement syndrome (TDS).” TDS means that even the most ridiculous claims about Trump behavior can be regurgitated by someone like Jake Tapper or Rachel Maddow without anyone in the media even daring to observe that they are both professional dissemblers of truth who lie regularly to enhance their professional resumes.

    A Christian Populist, Russian Orthodox nation forming an alliance with a Christian Populist, Protestant nation. This could put the stake through the vampiric heart of anti-Christian Globalism.

    The thought of Christians with common values cooperating, is guaranteed to generate mouth-frothing hysteria from the TDS fringe. The Globalists need to keep the Cold War going between Christian nations so they can push elitist dogma like LGBT and Global Cooling/Warming/Change for their own enrichment.

    Fortunately, Americans in ever greater numbers are pushing the Fake Stream Media off switch (1).

    You would think that with the Democrat Primary well under way, a couple of far-left outlets devoted 24/7 to politics could not lose, but lose they are — and bigly. … MSNBC has still not recovered from the debunking of its three-year Russia Collusion Hoax and CNN is so monotonously dull with its fake news and hatred for Trump, even Democrats are staying away in droves.

    And, the numbers:

    Total Day:
    Fox News: 1.313 million
    MSNBC: 833,000
    CNNLOL: 665,00

    In all of cable TV during the primetime hours, Fox news came in second last week, behind only EPSN. MSNBC slid into third, while CNNLOL dropped to ninth, losing to the Hallmark Channel, HGTV, The Learning Channel, and Investigative Discovery.

    And, given Nielsen’s past attempts to sandbag Fox’s numbers odds are Fox is already outperforming the combined fakery of CNN + MSNBC.

    PEACE 😇
    _____

    (1) https://www.breitbart.com/the-media/2019/09/11/nolte-another-week-another-ratings-collapse-at-far-left-cnn-msnbc/

  9. @Bragadocious

    That is correct. Phil is thus not falling into the category of an extremist ideologue who cannot see past their own prejudices. That is the subject of the article in other words. If you’re looking for validation of your polarised world view maybe you came to the wrong place after all? No Nazis around here you tosser, this site is generally pro Russian given that the majority of its writers and readers seek the truth as such wherever it falls. It long since fell out of the US-dominated West anyway.

    • Replies: @Bragadocious
  10. Russia kicked out most of the oligarchs.

    Russia got tired of the communist jews.

    Russia got tired of the homos.

    Russia returned to Orthodox Christianity.

    Russia sides with Syria and Iran.

    Putin loves his country and tries to do what is best for his people.

    Of course the nose cannot stand any of this, because all of humanity must bow down and worship the nose.

  11. Lot says:

    Phil, you are correct for once in this article on all your main points. But what your fans really want is more Jew-bashing and Holocaust denial. Another article like this and you will start losing them.

    • Replies: @Colin Wright
  12. @Priss Factor

    Well said, Priss. Israel and its neocon scouts are constantly meddling in the affairs of other nations. The national fiasco that was Boris Yeltsin (and the rise of the Russian oligarchs) is a spectacular example of this toxic syndrome.

    It should also be remembered that Putin is loyal to and militarily supportive of Assad’s Syria as well as the Islamic Republic of Iran, two of Israel’s most enduring foes.

    It’s likely that the ongoing demonization of Putin’s Russia by our Zionized MSM as well as our thoroughly-compromised intelligence agencies has more than a little to do with the Israel’s abject desire to weaken Christian Russia and ultimately break the tattered alliance between Russia, Syria and Iran. Global Jewry never rests.

  13. In history-future, the Trump/Russia narrative will be held up as THE classic example of “fake news”. The spreaders of this SHIT will be held up as shining examples of shameless lying. The happy consumers of this DRECK will either have to swallow their massive grotesque stupidity, their toxic cynicism, or double down & double down again on their lies until their “bad conscience” rots out their minds, causing irreversible psychotic breakdown.

  14. 36 ulster says:

    By the crank whose just will not die.

  15. @Rabbitnexus

    Nazis, pro-Russian, wtf are you talking about you Bogan imbecile. Your retarded post literally had nothing to do with my comment.

    • Replies: @Rabbitnexus
  16. AWM says:

    I’m interested in:
    “prosecutors under President Vladimir Putin have charged Dokuchaev [a major in Russia’s FSB security service and its Information Security Center] and his boss with treason, accusing them of collaborating with the CIA just weeks after the Obama administration made public its conclusions that Russia had meddled in the 2016 presidential election.”
    The FSB collaborating with the CIA behind both Putin and Trump’s backs?
    No wonder the Democrats were so worried about what Trump and Putin talked about.
    https://www.theepochtimes.c…

  17. 36 ulster says:

    Oops! I “spoke” too soon. One cheer for Giraldi’s pushback concerning the Russia Scare. But it’ll be at the earliest 2021 before we can achieve detente with Moscow.

  18. “I Ran the CIA. Now I’m endorsing Hillary Clinton.”

    Two words: Contrarian Indicator.

  19. Anonymous[303] • Disclaimer says:

    “There are two persistent bogus narratives about Donald Trump that are, in fact, related. The first is that his campaign and transition teams collaborated with the Russian government to defeat Hillary Clinton. Even Robert Mueller, he of the famous fact-finding commission, had to admit that that was not demonstrable.”

    No, it was shown there was evidence that this happened, but it did not meet the required legal threshold. Stop lying.

    “The only government that succeeded in collaborating with the incoming Trumpsters was that of Israel, but Mueller forgot to mention that or even look into it.”

    Actually, it was several nations–Israel, Russia, UAE, and Saudi Arabia.

    It’s all outlined in great detail by Seth Abramson. Read his works and become educated.

    • Replies: @MarkinLA
    , @Alden
  20. Dear Giraldi,

    Glad Tidings! Don’t worry as yesterday both Netanyahu and Putin came to an agreement in Souchi that calls for celebrations!

    Putin will immediately remove Iran 80 KM from Israel borders in Syria, and eventually will remove them completely from Syria. In return The King Maker of Washington, Mr Netanyahu will remove America from Putin’s back, including the embargoes. Also, USA will not object for Russia to have a very strong base in Syria.

    Netanyahu assured Putin that all Three Branches of American Government will comply with his orders!

    • Replies: @Assad al-islam
  21. Heymrguda says:

    Throughout the flap over trump’s “collusion” with Putin, it has always amazed me that FDR’s administration was penetrated by soviet spies at the highest level, he presided over the massive transfer of not only military hardware but technology to the USSR long after the crisis with the Germans had passed. Basically, we defeated Nazi germany and replaced it with Stalin and the USSR, the whole thing the result of a deliberate process, or so it seems.
    Yet FDR is considered one of the best, if not the best, presidents we’ve ever had.

    • Agree: Alden
  22. @Assad al-islam

    People saw Putin joyously jumping up and down in the Power Corridors of Russia, shouting that my friendship with Mr. Netanyahu paid off. Putin also promised Netanyahu that he will get Liberman to throw his weight behind Netanyahu while forming the soon to be the next government. Putin said that Liberman being ex-Soviet citizen, they have lots of dirt on him. Netanyahu then stuck his hand out with his palm facing the floor and then Putin kissed the ring on Netanyahu’s finger.

    • Replies: @A123
  23. @Heymrguda

    “Yet FDR is considered one of the best, if not the best, presidents we’ve ever had.”

    This is true and ironic. After all, FDR (unlike Hitler) prolonged the Depression and steered America into WWII, which could have been avoided. These facts alone make him a failure.

    So why is FDR so adored by today’s dominant voices?

    FDR appeased the commies and crushed the anti-Semites (Nazis).

    FDR was good for the Jews. Hee’s grrreeeeaaat!

    • Replies: @MarkinLA
  24. A123 says:
    @Assad al-islam

    Putin also promised Netanyahu that he will get Liberman to throw his weight behind Netanyahu while forming the soon to be the next government. Putin said that Liberman being ex-Soviet citizen, they have lots of dirt on him.

    Intriguing as an idea, but difficult to execute. The Yisrael Beytenu party has been explicitly stating for months that they will not join a government with the Othodox parties (1):

    Yisrael Beytenu Chairman Avigdor Lieberman over the weekend called for the formation of a “national emergency government” … This government, he stressed, will exclude ultra-Orthodox parties Shas and United Torah Judaism, and far-right Otzma Yehudit leader Itamar Ben-Gvir.

    Putin would need dirt not just on Liberman, but also on enough junior leaders to prevent the Yisrael Beytenu party from ejecting Liberman after he publicly flip-flopped.

    History shows Putin has a very accurate grasp on risk-reward calculations. There seems to be a great deal of risk with this type of heavy handed intervention and not enough obvious reward. For this to work, there needs to be another piece to the puzzle we have not yet seen.

    PEACE
    ______

    (1) https://www.israelhayom.com/2019/06/16/yisrael-beytenu-chief-plans-to-force-unity-govt-exclude-haredi-parties/

  25. @Lot

    ‘Phil, you are correct for once in this article on all your main points. But what your fans really want is more Jew-bashing and Holocaust denial. Another article like this and you will start losing them.’

    You’re as dishonest as ever.

    Glancing over Giraldi’s articles for this year I see no examples of ‘Jew-Bashing’ and no instances of Holocaust denial.

    • LOL: Lot
  26. MarkinLA says:
    @mark green

    Then why is it that anytime you bring up FDR and the Holocaust on a Jewish site, you immediately get tons of bat-shit crazy comments about what FDR should have done to save Jews from Auschwitz? It seems that no suicide mission carried out by goys is too much if it saves one Jew.

    • Replies: @Curmudgeon
    , @Alden
  27. @Bragadocious

    My comment was a direct response to your questioning why Phil was formerly anti-Trump and then seemingly pro-Trump. As I said that comes from being neither. He is just writing as he sees it without bias. Fran gave you a similar answer. Being an extremist such subtleties probably escape you.

    • Replies: @Bragadocious
  28. [W]hy is it that anytime you bring up FDR and the Holocaust on a Jewish site, you immediately get tons of bat-shit crazy comments about what FDR should have done to save Jews…

    The self-serving ‘outrage’ directed towards FDR by nervy and nervous Zionists is a relatively modern phenomena. After all, Jews gained immense political influence in Washington during FDR’s tenure. FDR also provoked the Germans into declaring war.

    But FDR’s reputation took a hit when one Holocaust ‘expert’ (David S. Wyman) claimed in a book some 30 years ago that FDR could have saved countless European Jews during The Holocaust had only he wanted to; even though a far bigger conflict was raging out of control and enveloping much of the world. That event was called WWII.

    It is worth noting that the case could easily be made that the war itself could have been shortened–if not averted altogether–had diplomacy triumphed over militarism.

    That question however seldom interests Holocaust ‘experts’, many of whom have a Zionist ax to grind. In fact, most Zionists still consider WWII (where some 50 million humans died) ‘the good war’. It’s just the slaughter of Jews that gets them upset. Innocent goys, whole Christian countries… who cares?

    Meanwhile, these ‘experts’ count, sift, measure and mourn the casualties of one religious group only. This peculiar brand of hyper-ethnocentrism has produced dangerous levels of academic, political and judicial bias throughout America. This condition has produced a series of political catastrophes.

    For the past century, Jews (a tiny, dispersed minority) have been near the center of most every major conflict in the Western world. This extraordinary fact is getting harder and harder to hide (thus, their fading popularity.) Yet Jews still insist on playing the preeminent victim card. This is where THE Holocaust comes in. But the title ‘The Holocaust’ itself is haughty, inaccurate, and self-serving.

    [MORE]

    Not only is the alleged number of Jews ‘murdered’ by Germany during WWII surely exaggerated, but the alleged manner in which they were killed becomes less believable as one looks closer.

    Consider the context of The Holocaust. It was one chapter within the biggest international conflagration in human history (WWII) where the most barbaric military tactics ever used (the systematic aerial bombardment and burning of inhabited cities filled with woman and children) occurred on a regular basis–until nuclear weapons were finally used. The civilian toll was also the greatest in human history. With those horrific facts in mind, the purported ‘Holocaust’ borders on being something of a narcissistic misnomer. It has clearly been elevated for political purposes.

    The real Holocaust (if we are to use such a term) was WWII.

    See: Dresden, Hiroshima, Berlin, Nagasaki, Tokyo, Hamburg (and dozens more). Fifty million souls perished.

    To market and incessantly promote one politicized (and perhaps largely fictional) chapter in human history as ‘THE Holocaust’ when the the most catastrophic war in human history is being fought simultaneously is extremely self-centered.

    Holocaust-mania is a warped manifestation of delusional group narcissism.

    The war itself—WWII–was a far bigger, far more ghastly (when measured by death and destruction) than whatever may (or may not) have happened to one hyper-ethnocentric group during the final three years of the War. Plus, there’s the matter of action and guilt.

    Guilt does not lie only with the vanquished. Not by any means.

    The toxic and lethal spread of communism helped create the Fascist movement. Plus, far-flung Jewish groups in America and Europe waged economic war against Germany long before hostilities even erupted. We are seeing this pattern re-emerge today. The target is Iran. World Jewry is using its vast influence and power to subvert and destroy that ancient civilization.

    Recognizable patterns cannot be ignored.

    Activist Jews today are quite conscious of the growing awareness (and resentment) that is directed towards Israel and world Jewry. Their solution? Criminalize harsh speech when Jews are the target. After that, indoctrinate the children of their potential adversaries. Holocaust ‘education’ is fast becoming mandatory in both American and European public schools.

    But what about other important historical events?

    Jews, for instance, did play a pivotal role in the formation and orchestration of the Bolshevik Revolution (as well as the toxic spread of communism). Millions died.

    Jews did play a leading role in bringing in the US into The Great War (WWI) as well as the worst political conflict ever (WWII). Tens of millions died.

    Then there’s the oversized role played by Zionists in the historic and ongoing pandamonium unleashed in recent decades throughout the Middle East. These various upheavals include the deliberate (and unnecessary) destruction of Iraq and Libya, as well as the ongoing Zionist conquest of Palestine. Also let us not forget the piecemeal Zio-American dismemberment of Syria.

    More death. More destruction.

    More strategic silence about these events by elite media and academia. Israel gets preferential treatment.

    Growing public awareness of Jewish involvement in many of these preemptive apocalyptic episodes however is gaining traction, as it should.

    This rising awareness poses serious challenges to the Zionist establishment, as it should.

    What’s an righteous Zionist to do?

    After all, there are still wars to win: Iran, Syria, Lebanon, Palestine.

    Jewish activists understand that the best defense includes a good offense. This is where ‘Holocaust Remembrance’ and all the other special tributes (including continuous expressions of Jewish ‘outrage’) gain their authority, power and legitimacy.

    Complaining self-righteously about a respected President (FDR) who helped steer the US into WWII (with a lot of Jewish help) is a retroactive sanitation project for Jewish war hawks. Jewish ‘outrage’ serves to whitewash Jewish planning and Jewish participation in wars of aggression. It also projects the meme of Jewish innocence and Jewish victimhood.

    Public Jewish Anger demonstrations teach/remind the hapless (non-Jewish) observer (one again) about unique Jewish suffering and uniquely important Jewish victimhood.

    Jewish suffering (and innocence) is very real and therefore very important! (certainly more important than anything YOU have to say.)

    This PR maneuver is a very clever ploy. It also has lasting psychological impact.

    By vilifying iconic gentiles (like FDR) who ‘should have done more to protect Jews’, the familiar lesson is given: Protect righteous Jews. Dismiss anti-Semitic goyim.

    In depicting themselves as The Most Important victims, Jews (and Israel) gain status, political power, and protection from outside criticism. Therefore, expect to see more displays of righteous ‘Jewish anger’. They are upset and YOU are the reason why.

    It’s worth noting that the (alleged) Jewish experience during of WWII has also grown in significance as we get further away from the actual event. This is both unusual and odd.

    The memory and significance of historical events generally fade over time. Wounds heal. People pass on. New generations are born. Fresh challenges emerge. New hopes arise. But THE Holocaust just keeps getting bigger and bigger. It wasn’t always this way.

    As a child growing up in the 50s and 60s, virtually all the movies (and most of the literature) involving WWII concerned heroism, sacrifice, the broader military struggle and subsequent victory. The extensive memoirs of Churchill, de Gaulle, and Eisenhower bear this out. Not one of these three great men even mention ‘the Jews’ (or The Holocaust) in their voluminous books. Now it’s radically different. Today’s chatter about WWII focuses mostly on Hitler and the Holocaust.

    Why are Jews–who are relatively wealthy and powerful–obsessed with Jewish suffering and the safety of Jews, but not with the lives or well-being of others who are less fortunate?

    What about ‘diversity’? What about immigrants and refugees? Racial equality?

    Ha! That’s all for the goyim.

    File their deceptions under: Strategic Malignant Narcissism.

    • Agree: Robert Dolan
  29. @Rabbitnexus

    “Extremist”

    You know nothing, Aussie prick. You just embarrass yourself more with every post.

  30. AWM says:
    @Heymrguda

    FDR desired “convergence” with the Soviet Union and diplomatically recognized them in 1932 at the horror of Herbert Hoover. FDR played to his Globalist money masters every chance he got, and that is how his administration was the most compromised in history.

  31. @MarkinLA

    what FDR should have done to save Jews from Auschwitz?

    Yeah, actually having to work was the shits.

  32. Anonymous[216] • Disclaimer says:
    @Bragadocious

    Trump was not a preferred (((Deep Stete))) candidate. This was obvious even before he got elected because the Deep State never stopped burning whatever was left of their “credibility” in the captured MSM, CIA or FBI. Since then, he’s retreating and succumbing to his own (((Tribal))) influences but that’s not the same.

    There’s no paradox.

  33. anonymous[340] • Disclaimer says:

    Over at Consortium News, an author named Scott Ritter has a new article delving into the (counter)intelligence details, and which complements Mr. Giraldi’s insights in this and other articles. However, the name of the central player (Smolenkov) discussed by Mr. Ritter has apparently never appeared in any article or comment here at TUR.

    If Mr. Giraldi has the time, I’m interested in his assessment of the Ritter article. Thank you.

    • Replies: @anonymous
    , @Bill Jones
  34. anonymous[340] • Disclaimer says:
    @anonymous

    I now see that Mr. Ritter has generated attention in his own right. But I still would like to hear what Dr. Giraldi has to say about the article.

  35. @Heymrguda

    FED Best?

    Considered by whom?

  36. @anonymous

    Those of us with functioning memories recall Mr Ritter’s heroics during the early days of Bush the Lesser’s Regime.

    And the determined drive to destroy him by all the usual suspects.

    My tendency is to lend credence to his words.

  37. @War for Blair Mountain

    What REALLY drives the war against Russia is the left’s relentless campaign to push gay”rights” (as if they don’t already have every right imaginable) upon an unwilling VP, and then there is the left’s untold rage against Russsia for driving out communism, after these elements there are also your valid points.

    AJM “Mensa” qualified since 1973, airborne trained US army vet, and pro Jazz performer.

  38. Alden says:
    @Anonymous

    Seth Abrahamson? Why would someone named Seth Abrahamson be truthful about anything?

  39. Alden says:
    @Heymrguda

    Don’t forget Jewish 2nd generation communist Harry White, as assistant secretary of treasury sent the authentic plates for every American currency bill to Russia along with the formulas for the ink and paper.

    My conspiracy theory about the depression is that it was artificially created by the communists to bring about the starving masses willing to put up with FDR and his communist administrations. We almost got communist operative Henry Wallace as FDR’s 4 th Vice President when every Dr and nurse who saw FDR on the weekly newsreels knew he was dying of heart disease. The White working class prevailed over the White intellectuals and Jews at the convection and put in Truman as VP instead of continuing with Wallace. Even IBEW had turned against communism by 1944.

    All hail the alliance of the uneducated low life KKK and northern uneducated labor union members over the idiot intellectuals and Jews in the summer of 44 democratic convention. No wonder intellectuals and Jews hate southern Whites and useful workers so much.

  40. Alden says:
    @MarkinLA

    Father of a friend was a career navy officer. For 3 years in the late 1940s he was on a ship that ferried European refugees to America. He’d never been around Jews in his life. He learned to despise Jews on those trips. They were one and all demanding arrogant considered themselves superior even to the captain of the ship totally ungrateful. They always wanted more and more and argued argued and argued.
    Endless arguing or negotiation isn’t successful
    on navy ships.

    Another thing he noted. Because of the war, confiscation of food by the Germans the freezing year of 1946 etc, all the Europeans he encountered on that refugee ship were very thin and the children were small for their age.

    Except for the Jews who were normal weight. So they must have done OK while everybody else lost weight due to 5 years of food shortages.

Current Commenter
says:

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone


 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments become the property of The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Philip Giraldi Comments via RSS
Personal Classics
Shouldn't they recuse themselves when dealing with the Middle East?
A Modern Guernica Enabled by Washington
Pressuring Candidates Even Before They Are Nominated
But is it even a friend?
The gagged whistleblower goes on the record.
Today’s CIA serves contractors and bureaucrats—not the nation.