The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection$
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewPhilip Giraldi Archive
The White Helmets Ride Again
How easy it is to give awards to terrorists
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • B
Show CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

I am often asked to explain why countries like Iran appear to be so aggressive, involving themselves in foreign wars and seeking to create alliances that they know will provoke the worst and most paranoid responses from some of their neighbors. My response is invariably that perceptions of threat depend very much on which side of the fence you are standing on. Saudi Arabia and Israel might well perceive Iranian actions as aggressive given the fact that all three countries are competing for dominance in the same region, but Iran, which is surrounded by powerful enemies, could equally explain its activity as defensive, seeking to create a belt of allies that can be called upon if needed if a real shooting war breaks out.

The United States and Israel are, of course, masters at seeing everything as a threat, justifying doing whatever is deemed necessary to defend against what are perceived to be enemies. They even exercise extraterritoriality, with Washington claiming a right to go after certain categories of “terrorists” in countries with which it is not at war, most particularly Afghanistan, Yemen and Somalia. Israel does likewise in its attacks on Lebanon and Syria. Both Tel Aviv and Washington have regularly crossed the line drawn by international legal authorities in terms of what constitutes initiating a “just” or “legal” war, i.e. an imminent threat to use force by a hostile power. Neither Israel nor the United States has really been threatened by an enemy or enemies in the past seventy years, so the definition of threat has been expanded to include after-the-fact as with 9/11 and potential as in the case of Israel and Iran.

The “which side of the fence” formulation has also had some interesting spin-offs in terms of how so-called non-state players that use violence are perceived and portrayed. Nearly all widely accepted definitions of terrorism include language that condemns the “use of politically motivated violence against non-combatants to provoke a state of terror.”

It is quite easy to identify some groups that are unambiguously “terrorist.” Islamic State in Syria (ISIS) and its various affiliates fit the definition perfectly, but even in that case there is some ambiguity by those state actors who are ostensibly pledged to eradicate terrorists. There have been credible claims that the United States has been protecting the last enclaves of ISIS in order to maintain its “right” to stay in Syria, allegedly based on the stated objective of completely destroying the group before withdrawal. As long as ISIS is still around in Syria, Washington will have an admittedly illegal justification for doing likewise.

There are two notable groups that should be universally condemned as terrorists but are not for political reasons. They are the Mujaheddin e Khalq (MEK), Iranian dissidents that are based in Paris and Washington, and the so-called White Helmets who have been active in Syria. MEK is particularly liked by Israel and its friends inside the Beltway because it retains resources inside Iran that enable it to carry out assassinations and sabotage, and if it is only Iranians that are dying, that’s okay.

MEK has been on the State Department roster of foreign terrorist organizations since the list was established in 1997. Its inclusion derives from its having killed six Americans in the 1970s and from its record of violence both inside and outside Iran since that time. The group was driven out of Iran, denied refuge in France, and eventually armed and given a military base by Iraq’s leader Saddam Hussein. Saddam used the group to carry out terrorist acts inside Iran. MEK is widely regarded as a cult headed by a husband and wife team Massoud and Maryam Rajavi. Its members were required to be celibate and there are reports that they are subjected to extensive brainwashing, physical torture, severe beatings even unto death, and prolonged solitary confinement if they question the leadership. One scholar who has studied them describes their beliefs as a “weird combination of Marxism and Islamic fundamentalism.” Like many other terrorist groups MEK has a political wing that operates openly referred to as the National Council of Resistance of Iran (NCRI), which is based in Paris, and another front organization called Executive Action which operates in Washington.

MEK was regarded as a terrorist group until 2012, when it was taken off the Special Designation list by Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. It was removed because multi-million dollar contracts with Washington lobbying firms experienced at “working” congress backed up by handsome speaking fees had induced many prominent Americans to join the chorus supporting NCRI. Prior to 2012, speaking fees for the group started at \$15,000 and went up from there. Former Pennsylvania governor Ed Rendell reported more than \$150,000 in honoraria. Rudy Giuliani has been paid generously for years at \$20,000 per appearance for brief, twenty-minute speeches. Bear in mind that MEK was a listed terrorist group at the time and accepting money from it to promote its interests should have constituted material support of terrorism.

The group’s well-connected friends have included prominent neocons like current National Security Advisor John Bolton and ex-CIA Directors James Woolsey, Michael Hayden and Porter Goss as well as former Generals Anthony Zinni, Peter Pace, Wesley Clark, and Hugh Shelton. Traditional conservatives close to the Trump Administration like Newt Gingrich, Fran Townsend and Secretary of Transportation Elaine Chao are also fans of NCRI. Townsend in particular, as a self-proclaimed national security specialist, has appeared on television to denounce Iran, calling its actions “acts of war” without indicating that she has received money from an opposition group.

MEK’s formula for success in removing itself from the terrorism lift involved paying its way through a corrupt political system. More interesting perhaps is the tale of the White Helmets, who have just been given the 2019 Elie Wiesel Award by the National Holocaust Museum, with the citation “These volunteer rescue workers have saved lives on all sides of the conflict in Syria. Their motto is ‘To save one life is to save all of humanity.’”

The White Helmets have been praised by those who hate the government of President Bashar al-Asad in Syria and want to see it removed because of its role as a leading element in the propaganda campaign that seeks to instigate violence or use fabricated information to depict the Damascus government as guilty of slaughtering its own citizens. The propaganda is intended to terrorize the civilian population, which is part of the definition of terrorism.

Favorable media coverage derives from the documentary The White Helmets, which was produced by the group itself and tells a very convincing tale promoted as “the story of real-life heroes and impossible hope.” It is a very impressive piece of propaganda, so much so that it has won numerous awards including the Oscar for Best Documentary Short last year and the White Helmets themselves were nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize. More to the point, however, is the undeniable fact that the documentary has helped shape the public understanding of what is going on in Syria, describing the government in Damascus in purely negative terms.

Recently, with the Syrian Army closing in on the last White Helmet affiliates still operating in the country, the Israeli government, assisted by the United States, staged an emergency humanitarian evacuation of the group’s members and their families to Israel and then on to Jordan. It was described in a BBC article that included “The IDF said they had ‘completed a humanitarian effort to rescue members of a Syrian civil organization and their families’, saying there was an ‘immediate threat to their lives.’ The transfer of the displaced Syrians through Israel was an exceptional humanitarian gesture. Although Israel is not directly involved in the Syria conflict, the two countries have been in a state of war for decades. Despite the intervention, the IDF said that ‘Israel continues to maintain a non-intervention policy regarding the Syrian conflict.’”

All of the Israeli assertions are nonsense, including its claimed “humanitarianism” and “non-intervention” in the Syrian war, where it has been bombing almost daily. The carefully edited scenes of heroism under fire that have been filmed and released worldwide conceal the White Helmets’ relationship with the al-Qaeda affiliated group Jabhat al-Nusra and its participation in the torture and execution of “rebel” opponents. Indeed, the White Helmets only operate in rebel held territory, which enables them to shape the narrative both regarding who they are and what is occurring on the ground.

The White Helmets travelled to bombing sites with their film crews trailing behind them. Once at the sites, with no independent observers, they are able to arrange or even stage what is filmed to conform to their selected narrative. Exploiting their access to the western media, the White Helmets thereby de facto became a major source of “eyewitness” news regarding what was going on in those many parts of Syria where European and American journalists were quite rightly afraid to go, all part of a broader largely successful “rebel” effort to manufacture fake news that depicts the Damascus government as engaging in war crimes directed against civilians, an effort that has led to several attacks on government forces and facilities by the U.S. military. This is precisely the propaganda that has been supported both by Tel Aviv and Washington.

Perhaps the most serious charge against the White Helmets consists of the evidence that they actively participated in the atrocities, to include torture and murder, carried out by their al-Nusra hosts. There have been numerous photos of the White Helmets operating directly with armed terrorists and also celebrating over the bodies of execution victims and murdered Iraqi soldiers. The group’s jihadi associates regard the White Helmets as fellow “mujahideen” and “soldiers of the revolution.”

So, the National Holocaust Museum, which is taxpayer funded, has given an apparently prestigious award to a terrorist group, something which could have been discerned with even a little fact checking. And the museum also might have been sensitive to how the White Helmets have been used in support of Israeli propaganda vis-à-vis Syria. Perhaps, while they are at it, the museum’s board just might also want to check out Elie Wiesel, for whom the award is named. Wiesel, who was a chronicler of Jewish victimhood while persistently refusing to acknowledge what Israel was doing to the Palestinians, notoriously mixed fact and fiction in his best-selling holocaust memoir Night. Ironically, the award and recipient are well matched in this case as mixing fact and fiction is what both Elie Wiesel and the White Helmets are all about.

Philip M. Giraldi, Ph.D., is Executive Director of the Council for the National Interest, a 501(c)3 tax deductible educational foundation that seeks a more interests-based U.S. foreign policy in the Middle East. Website is, address is P.O. Box 2157, Purcellville VA 20134 and its email is [email protected]

Hide 101 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. Whitewolf says:

    At this stage of the game the US government shouldn’t even bother with all the ludicrous cover stories. No one believes any of them anymore.

    • Agree: TimeTraveller
  2. Anonymous[245] • Disclaimer says:

    None of this would happen without the complicit approval of 72% of traitorous Americans who believe they’re going to be paid-off a “hundredfold” (Matthew 19:19) by the allegedly morally-superior Chosenites (Acts 3:25 & Romans 9:4) in the afterlife, while sitting in their flamboyantly decorated (Revelation 21:21) Jerusalem retirement condos. It’s time to feed the Superjew-worshipers to the lions like the the Roman White Patriarchal Fascists did.


  3. Talk about swamps in need of draining and stables in need of cleaning! If only we had the sense to leave the cretins of the ME and Africa to their own devices. Meanwhile, we dither over more “important” problems like the ever-changing demands of sexually confused Sodomites, government-funded “refugee” settlement and what to do about the horror of plastic straws.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
  4. m___ says:

    The article, the piece.

    Most of it is about tactics, method, financing, local theater, global goals. Any agenda, should see the pathways suggested by the article as “inevitable” (French for no way around it), all parties that have substance cannot get around it. Be it since in conflicting stances, the behavior and methods of the opponent dictates response and ways of response. The US, and as much France, fill out the list of your choice, any corporation (Colombia coal bananas and proxy para-military two dozen years ago), by outsourcing terrorism should be regarded as terrorists, terrorist method, terrorism promotion.

    Terrorism is hardly about the “good and the bad”, it is simply an indicator of tactics, method. There is no more cruelty, if not less in giving a neck shot to a subversive as droning from a distance and do away with a dozen. Admittedly it is more folkloric, some graphics to grasp on to for the public, to define positively the official opponent as the “terrorist”.

    Of course all this is debatable, at infinitum. If war had rules, and these rules were adhered to, human nature would suffocate of indigestion.

    • Replies: @anon
    , @Curmudgeon
  5. Anon[277] • Disclaimer says: • Website

    This is funny.

    • Replies: @anon
  6. Bill65 says:

    Another excellent article from Philip Giraldi highlighting the Orwellian world were are living in. Surely if people read this they can only wake up to the reality of what is going on in the Middle East . I
    only wish it could be more widely read than on just a few websites which is sadly the case and why most people remain ignorant of the facts.

    • Replies: @Z-man
    , @AnonFromTN
  7. Anonymous[235] • Disclaimer says:
    @Unrepentant Conservative

    Without industrial civilization, we could leave the ME and Africa to their own devices. Now, since America thinks they need to commute 45 miles which takes an hour and a half to work in a 2 ton mechanical marvel, instead of walking to work in a nice small village, which would be totally embarrassing and uncivilized, we absolutely need ME oil and African minerals. They’re vital to our freedom of travel.

  8. Greg Bacon says: • Website

    The WH are just another part of the Pentagon war machine, designed not to protect Americans so much as to invade and bust up nations Israel wants destroyed and those that Wall Street want to loot and keep those pesky Rooskies from thinking they can be a world power.

    The WH’s Mannequin Challenge was a screw-up on their part, exposing them for the frauds they are.

    No one actually doing rescue work would wear BLACK overalls. They show dirt easily and worse, the color absorbs heat and that’s one thing you don’t want to happen, since rescue work is physically demanding, making one sweat profusely, as I know from my days as career firefighter. Wearing a black outfit during a Syrian Summer is just plain stupid, but the color sure does help compliment the actual white helmet.

    • Replies: @The Alarmist
  9. KenH says:

    and if it is only Iranians that are dying, that’s okay.

    If Jews were dying that would be anti-semitism and a second holocaust.

  10. God bless Murka, the Red Queen Trump, and the pimp of both, Israhell..

    • Agree: Moi
    • Replies: @Moi
  11. Anon[424] • Disclaimer says:

    Nobody believes anymore the White helmets , the skripals , the sirian girl , the maidans , the BBC , the NY lies , the wapo , the economist , the nobel prizes , the otanics , the false science , the angloamerican tiresome propaganda and lies .

    Remember the Maine .

    • Replies: @Whitewolf
  12. Zionists control every facet of the U.S. government and with this control have been the agent provocateur in every war the U.S. has been involved in starting with WWI and on down to the wars in the Mideast and in fact ISIS aka AL CIADA has been a creation of the Zionists in not only the U.S. but also in Britain.

    The white helmets are but a branch of ISIS aka AL CIADA and have been used to create a false narrative of the war in the Mideast, and the Zionists are experts at creating false narratives in every thing they are involved in and especially the wars that the Zionists have involved America in.

    Zionist Israel with the zionist controlled deep state attacked the WTC on 911 and killed some 3000 Americans and got away with it and every thinking American knows that Israel and the zionists did it and with that act the zionists revealed themselves to be the killers and liars that they are.

    Zionists will destroy America, that is their goal under their zionist NWO.

  13. @Anonymous

    Without industrial civilization, we could leave the ME and Africa to their own devices. Now, since America thinks they need to commute 45 miles which takes an hour and a half to work in a 2 ton mechanical marvel, instead of walking to work in a nice small village, which would be totally embarrassing and uncivilized, we absolutely need ME oil and African minerals. They’re vital to our freedom of travel.

    They are also vital to “maintaining” (loosely) 7.5 billion, soon to be 10 billion, people on the planet. This will ultimately fail, but that is a knock-on effect of “industrial civilization”.

    “Their own devices” would not support their populations. Soon enough, being “non-essential” will carry a heavy price – even in the industrial world.

  14. anon[201] • Disclaimer says:

    have you figured out yet that the environmentalist movement was a fraud?

  15. anon[455] • Disclaimer says:

    yes, but you hit on a big point “outsourcing terrorism”; just what is outsourcing.? I presume you meant
    the out-sourcer to be a government and the outside source to be a non government, the out-sourcee or privateer?
    Making that assumption.. outsourcing terrorism is a special case of privatization. A government has privatized; (that is, licensed to a private person, army or other third party, from the government’s own monopoly on authority to use deadly force), the authority of government to use deadly force and to inflict destructive or bodily harm against a victim target of the out-sourcer government.

    Giraldi says perceptions of threat depend .. on..the engineered propaganda from the culture “your- self” has adopted; meaning to which or, to whose, propaganda do you reference when you are called upon to determine that something is acceptable, reasonable, or likely true? Practically no one would believe a human on earth could throw a quarter from earth to the moon; nearly every earth bound human would believe it reasonable that a quarter could be thrown from one side of a 60′ foot road to another. .

    Tell me what you believe (search engine, and social mainstream media giants are trying to identify personal belief system of everyone in the world) and I will tell you how “you personally” will react to a particular set of facts engineered into a particular product of propaganda.

    From each set of real or invented facts many different sets of propaganda can be engineered.
    We call those who engineer propaganda to manipulate the minds of mass audiences, CPEs. Corrupt propaganda engineers.

    If you think about it the opposite of inventing and presenting propaganda is the invention of a conspiracy theory. So defense to propaganda = conspiracy theory. (propaganda “divided by”/conspiracy theory) = 1.
    A conspiracy theorist derives a theory that connects the facts and events presented in a propaganda into a different, but invented propaganda. Both propaganda come from the same set of facts, circumstances and events; each propaganda presents a different scenario, both presentations are from same set of facts, circumstances and events. Its the belief system of the audience that determines how a propaganda is perceived.
    The people that invent propaganda are called CPEs. meaning corrupt propaganda engineers, and the people who redirect the inventions of CPE designed propaganda into different scenarios are called conspiracy theorist.

    If everyone could recognize engineered propaganda, for what it is, the exploitation and manipulation of your behavior as a response to your perceptual abilities and your belief system, a lot of the crisis in the world could be eliminated. I believe a major function of alternative media is to teach not only the language of propaganda but also how to recognize it, dis-cipher it and to call it out for what it is, fraud, that should be criminalized.

    • Replies: @m___
  16. anastasia says:

    The lies of the world grow bigger and more brazen and more visible by the day. Nobel peace prizes for terrorists. What next

    • Replies: @Curmudgeon
    , @Bill Jones
  17. Z-man says:

    BTW ‘The Phora’, one of those sites is suddenly off line now, nowhere to be found. Maybe Big Brother is flexing it’s muscles.

  18. Z-man says:

    ‘One man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter’.

  19. @Bill65

    The author correctly states that White Helmets are terrorists. They are the PR crew of Al Nusra (Al Qaida in Syria), so it is only natural that the members of the group participated in many Al Nusra atrocities. The author failed to mention, however, that White Helmets are directly funded by the secret services of self-appointed “democratic” countries. That explains their success in the West more than anything. Unfortunately for the average Joe in the US, the US government, directly and via its secret services, is the main sponsor of terrorism in the world today.

  20. Great to know our govt. is the #1 sponsor of terrorism in the world. Whats not to like about people that cut kids heads off for fun?

    Freedom and democracy for Syria.

    • Replies: @ChuckOrloski
  21. @m___

    Actually, there were rules of war, among which were that civilians were not to be harmed, and that combatants must be in uniform. Combatants not in uniform were spies, and could be executed on the spot. Those aiding and abetting spies were also considered spies. All of these rules started with the Peace/Treaty of Westphalia in 1648, which became the basis for international relations and law.

    The Allies, or as some suggest All Lies, threw those rules out in WWII. The inversion of the rules became complete with the Stalinist show trials named the Nuremberg Military Tribunal. Torture became acceptable, as did the deliberate targeting of civilian populations. Not surprisingly, is the fact that the Zionists were terrorizing the civilian population in Palestine even in the 1920s. Of course, having no country made it easy for the rules not being applied to them.

    What we see today is the complete breakdown of the rules that existed for nearly 300 years. Cui bono? Those whose tribal name must not be spoken, of course.

    • Replies: @m___
  22. @anastasia

    Nobel peace prizes for terrorists.

    Given that Obama, who already had his Peace Prize, was droning innocent populations to death (terrorism), it seems the logical next step would be to identify the terrorists first, then give them a Peace Prize. Oh wait! That was already done in 1978.

    • Agree: chris
  23. Whitewolf says:

    Anyone who believes government narratives today is considered a moron basically by a lot of people. Western governments have destroyed their own credibility to a degree I wouldn’t have thought possible 20 years ago.

    • Agree: Agent76
  24. Agent76 says:

    Apr 29, 2016 The White Helmets – al Qaeda with a facelift

    ‘The White Helmets’, fake ‘Syrian humanitarian group, exposed as an al Qaeda support group headed by a British military man and funded by the US Government.

    Apr 9, 2017 No More

    April 07, 2017 Pentagon Trained Syria’s Al Qaeda “Rebels” in the Use of Chemical Weapons

    The Western media refutes their own lies

  25. Any group that supports and encourages celibacy can’t be all bad.

    I think the White Helmuts have been complicit in manufacturing the chemical gas accusations as well as part of staging the same.

    The short answer: the US should not be in Syria, Iraq, Afghanistan, or anywhere in which groups are engaged in civil conflicts. If we are choosing sides that demand our participation – we should so so and be done with the matter.

    No one likes to deal with this but the truth is now that the current executive signed on to the intel reports and assassination accusations — his foreign policy whatever it was on matters of intervention no longer belong to him. Both in Europe an d the US the interventionists remain obsessed with Russia — I don’t have any hopes this president will move in the direction of his original posturing regarding this region.

    If there was ever a chance for change, agreeing to the intel reports and GB assassination assails has knitted the matter in their favor.

    I am holding out for a clear stance on immigration, but I am not holding my breath.

  26. @Desert Fox

    Desert Fox said: “Zionists will destroy America, that is their goal under their zionist NWO.”

    Greetings, Desert Fox!

    Please be rise from your tank interior, look deep into the battlefield reality, and recognize what was/is popularly considered “America” is no more.

    On each level of individual citizenship, vital awareness & resistance requires acknowledgement that “We” are domiciled in the Zionist United States.

  27. @Desert Fox

    Zionists will destroy America, that is their goal under their zionist NWO.

    With the murder of Jamal Khashoggi and the falling off with USA, Israel is most to loose and Iran has most to gain.

    • Replies: @TimeTraveller
  28. All of the Israeli assertions are nonsense, including its claimed ‘humanitarianism’ and ‘non-intervention’ in the Syrian war, where it has been bombing almost daily

    Indeed. President al-Assad, interviewed in May by RT:

    ‘Since we were born—I’m talking about my generation and most of the generations now in Syria—we lived under the threat of the Israeli aggression. … The Israelis have been assassinating, killing, occupying for decades now, for around seven decades, in this region’.

  29. If the bombing victims were victims of actual bombs, how come no heroic White Bellends have been whacked using secondaries?
    I mean come on, even the Provos knew enough to set up those.

  30. John Bolton was also the neocon godfather to the MEK/Isis/WHelemts and unfourtunately the black hand John Bolton In a few months managed (as did NHalley) to destroy almost 3decades of Nuclear Accords with Russia…dating back to the Nixon presidency…Bolton is a lunatic rabid pro Israel Zionist…that will push the USA into a open confrontation with the rest of the WORLD…Bolton is a toxic carcinoma in the Trump cabinet…

    • Agree: Z-man
  31. @redmudhooch

    redmudhooch: “Great to know our govt. is the #1 sponsor of terrorism in the world.”

    Scranton greetings, redmudhooch!

    Fyi, re; your words above, suppose it’s a necessity to admit it’s “our” (my!) government, but I am still sufficiently alive to not become One with the evil, and say so.


  32. EagleEyeX says:

    ” Indeed. President al-Assad, interviewed in May by RT:

    ‘Since we were born—I’m talking about my generation and most of the generations now in Syria—we lived under the threat of the Israeli aggression. … The Israelis have been assassinating, killing, occupying for decades now, for around seven decades, in this region’.”

    this is what the world is oblivious to and does not care to hear. It is the basic point. The west is complicit in this charade and injustice. It is astonishing that the world just sits there and watches these people eat them alive. Drain their energy and milk them ……..amazing

  33. Linked below, am truly sorry to provide my Brothers here at U.R. with grim knowledge from Paul Craig Roberts latest great article, “It’s like watching a Western movie.”

    “The vast majority of the peoples in the world have no idea what is happening.”

    (Zigh) It’s worse, much worse.

    As a child during 1950’s and watching the cowboy versus Indian TV shows/flicks, I still had a sensible AWARENESS that some of the “war party” savages were the ones who should be depicted as wearing white feathers…, or more relevant today, wearing good guy discernable “Lone Ranger” white hats, but are presently showcased by the Jewish Corporate Media as donning deceptive designer, “White Helmets.”

    Good night, do good to self & read PCR’s entire article, and go under the Protection. Thanks!

  34. Art says:

    So, the National Holocaust Museum, which is taxpayer funded

    America has been too good to the Jews, it has taken them in – but look how they have taken over our culture, economy, and government.

    They have politically manipulated us, until America has become a cash cow and protector for the Jews.

    Shame on them – shame on us!

    Think Peace — Do No Harm — Art

    p.s. The time is now to reverse the situation.

    • Replies: @annamaria
  35. peterAUS says:

    OT warning.

    That “march” thing ain’t on the main page here anymore.

    Gone in limbo.
    Makes sense.

    Still, a bit curious.
    Hence, the question, last time, promise, Phil (or anyone which is, admit, unlikely), any post action brief report re the event?
    Any personal observation, insight, conclusion? Even just an impression, gut feeling only? Could be just one word.
    Like…say…”blah”, for example.

    BTW, I’ll understand if there isn’t any feedback. Which IS a sort of feedback, in fact.
    “Nothing”, of sort.

    Lucky us.

    • Replies: @Philip Giraldi
  36. @Anonymous

    We wouldn’t need to commute to work if our parents hadn’t surrendered the cities to the Vibrant Hordes.
    Africa Strikes Again.

    • Replies: @anon
  37. annamaria says:

    Why is Dmitry Alperovitch, a Jewish emigre from Russia and falsifier of extraordinary important information, still not in prison?

    “First, no one in the Federal Government—law enforcement or intelligence—was granted access to examine the computer servers and files on the DNC server even after the DNC claimed they had been hacked by a foreign government.

    Second, the steps that CrowdStrike [D. Alperovitch baby] allegedly took to shutdown computer hacking by Russia do not match the timeline of the actual download of the documents from the DNC server.

    Third, Seth Rich worked at the DNC and had access to the computer server and systems.”

    Seth Rich was Jewish, but this did not stop the “minders.”

    More on the DNC-paid fraud committed by D. Alperovitch:

    • Replies: @redmudhooch
  38. This is nothing more than a way for Israel to plant spies in Syria under the guise of search and rescue personnel.

  39. A bit OT but this is a great article on who is behind the recent social media purge and censorship. Worth reading. Surprise surprise its the neocons/ziocons..

    Facebook Censorship of Alternative Media “Just the Beginning,” Says Top Neocon Insider

    Sites banned were on this list, that includes sites such as Unz and Zero Hedge RT VDare

    Not good!

  40. @annamaria

    DNC was “hacked” by Mossad/Israel, and I suspect Seth Rich is just a Mossad agent and is very much alive.

    Who has benefited the most from Hillary losing, Trump winning? Iran deal gone. Jerusalem embassy. Palestinians cut off. Israel is getting everything they ever wanted.

    There is no Russia-gate. Only Israel-gate, but they will NEVER talk about that, same reason they will never tell you the details of the DNC server, Israel.

  41. niceland says:

    The difference between a “terrorist group” and the U.S, Israeli or Russian governments?

    I think we have to overcome the barriers of language.

    Great article Mr Giraldi.

    • Replies: @ChuckOrloski
  42. @Anonymous

    “… since America thinks they need to commute 45 miles which takes an hour and a half to work in a 2 ton mechanical marvel ….”

    Some jobs are actually worth it, bucko.

  43. @Greg Bacon

    Yes, true, but all you have to do is exchange headgear and you go from Good Guy to Bad Guy in mere seconds.

    I always wondered how the Jihadi in those beheading videos managed to keep the black uniform so pristinely clean of desert dust. I just assumed it was a studio shoot in front of a green-screen.

  44. anon[486] • Disclaimer says:
    @Dr. Krieger

    We wouldn’t need to commute to work if our great-grandparents had seen the perils of rapid travel, shunned horseless carriages and just walked. No time is saved, we just have to commute many times as far while spewing out many times more carbon dioxide and we are much fatter than we would have been if our forefathers had not been so stupid.

    • Replies: @The Alarmist
  45. @niceland

    With insight rooted in Orwell’s “Politics and the English language,” niceland suggested: “I think we have to overcome the barriers of language.”

    The common & consensus use of “US” to define America’s ruling government is untrue.

    It is the Zionist Occupied Government (ZOG) and from such interior starting point, American citizens who become aware of the misconception can begin to chant the positive religious-folk song, “We shall overcome one day.”

    Thanks, niceland.

  46. @peterAUS

    peterAUS – March was very disappointing, only a couple of hundred people showed up in spite of nearly a year of preparation. Usual left wing nonsense much in evidence with signs relating to black lives matter, support for illegal immigration, gay rights. Not helped by cold and windy weather. My wife and I dropped out at an early point.

    • Replies: @Z-man
    , @peterAUS
  47. didi says:

    Netanyahu probably knows that Trump is going to build the largest and most sophisticated US listening post anywhere in the world in Jerusalem. Of course that post will also be able to listen in on Netanyahu.

    • Replies: @anon
  48. anon[398] • Disclaimer says:

    lol, sure

    i hear its actually the other way around and that the israelis basically have a tap on all NSA-collected data

  49. Z-man says:
    @Philip Giraldi

    Usual left wing nonsense much in evidence with signs relating to black lives matter, support for illegal immigration, gay rights.

    Yep. I also see pro Palestinian pages on facebook who go off into the shit lib sphere. I’ve told them that ‘that course’ isn’t going to help your cause.

    • Agree: ChuckOrloski
  50. Moi says:
    @Johnny Walker Read

    Please add to the list son-in-law Damien who was also in The Omen.

    • LOL: Z-man
  51. @Garreth Smith

    It’s still too early to tell what the real fallout from the Khashoggi drama will be.

    Here are the big unanswered questions:

    1. If MBS is such a good friend to the West, why would all of the US Senate, CIA infested media outlets, and US-aligned, European puppet governments turn against him at once?

    2. Why elevate Turkey at the expense of Saudi Arabia?

    3. Is Iran really a winner if the militias they support are fighting Turkey-friendly militias in Syria?

    4. What is the endgame of the Khashoggi gambit? Arms mega-deals with Saudi remain intact, MBS still in power, and Saudi continues its anti-Iran policies undeterred.

    5. What did Pompeo tell the Saudis during his short visit that dramatically changed their tone? They had even threatened rapprochement with Iran before Pompeo calmed the waters.

    6. What did Gina Haspel tell the Turks that quieted Erdogan?

    • Replies: @Garreth Smith
    , @Art
  52. @anon

    “… spewing out many times more carbon dioxide ….”

    CO2 is good for the plants; more CO2 plus a bit of global warming might make it easier to feed all the people. Do you hate plants and people? We also follow stupid advice to eat frequently throughout the day.

    We’re fatter because we ingest too many carbs, sugar, heat-processed vegetable oils, and crap like high fructose corn syrup.

    BTW, in the good old days, manure dust was a serious pollution problem in big cities; the horseless carriage was considered a godsend.

    • Replies: @james charles
    , @anon
  53. peterAUS says:
    @Philip Giraldi

    Thank you for the prompt reply.

    I wasn’t trying to be difficult, just to confirm my own observation (from a bit of Internet research).

    Totally agree with:

    March was very disappointing, only a couple of hundred people showed up in spite of nearly a year of preparation. Usual left wing nonsense much in evidence with signs relating to black lives matter, support for illegal immigration, gay rights.

    My wife and I dropped out at an early point.


    We know this is neither place nor time for serious conversation about the topic but I’ll try to summarize a couple of, maybe, interesting points.

    Firstly, there IS an important place for this type of effort and I do respect people who do that. It COULD grow from disappointing into serious. I mean, even this article topic is related to the very beginning of troubles in Syria. They started with protests.
    And…hehe…of all people you definitely know how it went in Romania etc and Communism in Europe.

    The thing with protests is, again as so well known to many in USA/West, they must have huge numbers and, more importantly, they must be violent. There must be confrontation between security forces and protesters/marchers. Only that makes TPTBs uncomfortable enough to do something. Concede….or escalate.

    Peaceful protests can’t accomplish anything in the current paradigm.

    And we know that to motivate people to get into scuffles with security forces is just one simple thing: skin in the game.
    The last time it was a possibility of draft and death/mutilation in jungles of SE Asia. Now…..nothing.

    I just have a feeling we’ll see real marches sooner or later. What will motivate people, then, is just that M.A.D. option hanging over their heads.

    The only question is…will it be too little and too late.

    • Replies: @NoseytheDuke
  54. @TimeTraveller

    It’s still too early to tell what the real fallout from the Khashoggi drama will be.

    Yes, I agree it is too early to tell anything. What I understand that KSA Royals are not happy with Trump tweeting almost daily that King Salman will not last more than two weeks without USA Military backing. Arabs are too sensitives, and it doesn’t go well with common Arabs in the streets of KSA. In other Arabs’ and Muslims’ countries, King Salman is becoming a laughing stock.

    Additionally, they are also sick of Trump turning against all their allies and sanctioning the almost the whole world, so they have decided to take matters in their own hands. They feel like they cannot rely on Trump anymore.

    Since, KSA like Qatar have lost in Syria, they (KSA) probably have now decided to join the Resistance of Axis (Russia, Syria, Iran and Hezbollah), as Turkey and Qatar are already leaning towards joining the Resistance of Axis. So, KSA doesn’t want to be left out alone in their own backyard. Time to make peace in their own backyard and not rely on Trump as he might turn against them anytime.

    Jamal Khashoggi being a KSA assets and being part of their intelligence is maybe not dead, and has safely whisked off to KSA.

    • Replies: @TimeTraveller
  55. Art says:

    If MBS is such a good friend to the West, why would all of the US Senate, CIA infested media outlets, and US-aligned, European puppet governments turn against him at once?

    Easy answer — suck up to the Jews.

    The Jews have their eye on the prize — the prize is ALL of Palestine.

    The Zionist Israelis do not want MBS and Kushner to make a deal regarding giving ANY land to the Palestinians.

    Think Peace — Do No Harm — Art

  56. @Art

    Insightfully, Art wrote:The Jews have their eye on the prize — the prize is ALL of Palestine.”

    Greetings, Art!

    One matter.

    What inclined you to figure Jared Kushner wants to make a deal that entails giving any (“Greater Israel”) land back to Palestinians?
    Uh, is there a throwaway part? Maybe the Gaza Strip?

    Thank you!

  57. @Art

    The Zionist Israelis do not want MBS and Kushner to make a deal regarding giving ANY land to the Palestinians.

    The deal wouldn’t have given the Palestinians anything. Jerusalem and the return of refugees were already taken off of the table, and these are the biggest issues. Whatever they were to receive would have been humiliating, and temporary.

    I believe that the Khashoggi gambit is intended to give the Zionist project a new lease on life, but I don’t yet see how.

    • Replies: @Art
  58. @Garreth Smith

    Since, KSA like Qatar have lost in Syria, they (KSA) probably have now decided to join the Resistance of Axis 

    Not likely:
    “Saudi Arabia puts IRGC on terror list”

    • Replies: @Garreth Smith
  59. @The Alarmist

    “Negative impacts of global warming on agriculture, health & environment far outweigh any positives.”

    • Replies: @Sparkon
  60. anon[169] • Disclaimer says:
    @The Alarmist

    plus a bit of global warming might make it easier to feed all the people….

    why would you want to do that?

    the ones you want to feed will just breed more…….that you’ll need to feed……..who’ll breed more…..that you’ll need to feed…

    • Replies: @The Alarmist
  61. anon[169] • Disclaimer says:

    The Jews have their eye on the prize — the prize is ALL of Palestine.

    i hear the prize is everything between the Tigris and Euphrates

    Think Peace – Do No Harm…… <— its catchy

  62. Sparkon says:
    @james charles

    Negative aspects of global cooling far outweigh any dubious negatives of global warming.

    • Replies: @james charles
  63. @peterAUS

    Actually, large peaceful protests and marches can accomplish much by building the critical mass to reach the tipping point of awareness where public opinion is denied only at great political risk. The protests usually only turn violent when the establishment uses paid provocateurs to stir up trouble which is then reported in a way that discredits the protesters and ignores the reasons for the popularity of the marches.

  64. @anon

    You have to have somebody to use all that weaponry on. As Mr. Trump noted with KSA, arms are big biz for the USA.

  65. m___ says:

    See original m___ comment text:

    …and these rules were adhered to,

    Thanks to elaborate on it.

  66. @Sparkon

    But there is not global cooling!!

    • Replies: @Sparkon
    , @anon
  67. @anastasia

    Kissinger got his 45 years ago.

  68. Very inspired & vital, please read Paul Craig Roberts article below, “The triumph of evil.”

    Our Controllers are jeopardizing the entire planet and I suggest Mr. Robert’s article now requires a wild-fire like distribution.

    With respect and Thank you!

  69. Am not a Professor given to issue assignments, but below is an article which begs for mass American attention.

  70. Talha says:

    Beautiful photograph, thought people on this thread might enjoy…


    • Replies: @Garreth Smith
  71. Sparkon says:
    @james charles

    But there is not global cooling!!

    In truth, we should thank our lucky stars to live in a period of warmth and bounty on our beautiful planet, because climate changes, and it will change again, perhaps soon.

    In fact, the most recent period of global cooling, known as the Little Ice Age ended less than 200 years ago during the 19th century:

    Little Ice Age (LIA), climate interval that occurred from the early 14th century through the mid-19th century, when mountain glaciers expanded at several locations, including the European Alps, New Zealand, Alaska, and the southern Andes
    The Little Ice Age followed the Medieval Warming Period (roughly 900–1300 ce) and preceded the present period of warming that began in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.
    –Encyclopedia Britannica

    During the Little Ice Age, superstitious humans blamed witches for the cooling climate, deteriorating conditions, failed crops, and other misfortunes. Many tens of 1000s of these innocent wretches were falsely accused of witchcraft and burned alive at the stake.

    The murderous witch-burning ignoramuses were encouraged and led in their bogus beliefs and extreme actions by none other than the Roman Catholic Pope Innocent VIII himself, who in his Papal Bull of 1454 blamed all sorts of misfortune on witches:

    “[m]any persons of both sexes, unmindful of their own salvation and straying from the Catholic Faith, have abandoned themselves to devils, incubi and succubi, and by their incantations, spells, conjurations, and other accursed charms and crafts, enormities and horrid offences, have slain infants yet in the mother’s womb…have blasted the produce of the earth,… these wretches furthermore afflict and torment men and women… with terrible and piteous pains and sore diseases… they hinder men from performing the sexual act and women from conceiving… the abominations and enormities in question remain unpunished not without open danger to the souls of many and peril of eternal damnation.

    –Summis desiderantes affectibus

    Currently, climate alarmists and other ignoramuses inexplicably curse the mild conditions on planet Earth, and demonize the beneficial trace gas CO₂ for our good fortune.

    Truly, Mother Nature has gassed her own people.

    Yes, we are indeed the beneficiaries of the mighty molecule that roared, which helps our crops and plants grow big and strong while using less water, and also adds that sparkling zip to your favorite beverage. In fact, just as your beer or soda goes flat as it warms, so too the oceans outgas CO₂ as they warm, and that is the most likely explanation for the recent modest increases in atmospheric CO₂, because atmospheric concentration of CO₂ lags behind temperature by about 800 years, as revealed by the ice core records.

    The oceans are big, and they give up their carbon dioxide slowly, unlike your canned beer that goes flat fast, so drink up.

    Climate changes. And it will change again, perhaps soon. Recently, our Sun has been virtually spotless, leading some scientists to predict an impending Maunder Minimum, a condition last witnessed during the depths of the Little Ice Age.

    “solar activity will fall by 60 percent during the 2030s to conditions last seen during the ‘mini ice age’ that began in 1645,”

    Some may like it hot, but few will like it cold.

    Bottom line: enjoy global warming; it may not last.

    • Replies: @james charles
  72. anon[389] • Disclaimer says:
    @james charles

    Not Yet!!

    but we should prepare for it now because its only a matter of time

    • Replies: @james charles
  73. @TimeTraveller

    Not likely:
    “Saudi Arabia puts IRGC on terror list”

    Very true TimeTraveller, as you mentioned before it is too early to tell anything. Regarding IRGC being put on the terror list, I don’t see the elephant in the room. The three stooges, who work in concert are KSA, Bahrain, and UAE, but I don’t see UAE in this.

    Half of UAE citizens, especially Dubai are Iranians, who speak Arabic in the souq and speak Persian at home. Dubai is where sanction busting occurs through Straight of Hormuz.

  74. @Talha

    Beautiful photograph, thought people on this thread might enjoy…

    Even after 70 years of suffering, these people are full of Hamas meaning, courage and zeal. Hamas, a befitting name!

    Hamas is an acronym of the Arabic phrase حركة المقاومة الاسلامية or Harakat al-Muqāwama al-Islāmiyya, meaning “Islamic Resistance Movement”. The Arabic word ‘hamas’ (حماس) means “courage” or “zeal”.

    • Replies: @Desert Fox
    , @Talha
  75. @Garreth Smith

    Hamas is a Mossad front, a total creation of Israel.

  76. tac says:

    This site has an extensive collection of videos, photos, and clips that shows the true nature–the hoax–that is the white helmets:

    Also some more takes here:

  77. Talha says:
    @Garreth Smith

    It’s amazing, they are still willing to face off with literal slings in the face of snipers and tanks! Pretty incredible!


  78. It’s amazing, they are still willing to face off with literal slings in the face of snipers and tanks! Pretty incredible!

    Yes, incredible! I understand that one of the other meaning for Hamas is Motivation. They seem to be very motivated to get rid of all the Israelis.

    It seems that in Jamal Khashoggi’s matter, KSA is digging themselves in a quagmire:

    1. For 15 days they claimed that Jamal left the consulate unharmed.
    2. Then they said, he died in fist fit.
    3. Which was later changed to choke hold.
    4. Now, the KSA Prosecutor General saying that it was, “Predetermined”.
    5. Erdogan is demanding that since the crime was committed on Turkey’s soil, all those connected with the crime should be tried in Turkey.
    6. Syria is being welcomed back in Arab League.

  79. Art says:

    I believe that the Khashoggi gambit is intended to give the Zionist project a new lease on life, but I don’t yet see how.

    Think that the Saudis are just arrogant and stupid. What can you expect from men who wear dresses instead of pants, and cover their women’s faces?

    Someone should tell them to put on pants!

    Think Peace — Do No Harm — Art

  80. @Sparkon

    “Currently, climate alarmists and other ignoramuses inexplicably curse the mild conditions on planet Earth, and demonize the beneficial trace gas CO₂ for our good fortune. ”

    “For climate change, there are many scientific organizations that study the climate. These alphabet soup of organizations include NASA, NOAA, JMA, WMO, NSIDC, IPCC, UK Met Office, and others. Click on the names for links to their climate-related sites. There are also climate research organizations associated with universities. These are all legitimate scientific sources.

    If you have to dismiss all of these scientific organizations to reach your opinion, then you are by definition denying the science. If you have to believe that all of these organizations, and all of the climate scientists around the world, and all of the hundred thousand published research papers, and physics, are all somehow part of a global, multigenerational conspiracy to defraud the people, then you are, again, a denier by definition. 

    So if you deny all the above scientific organizations there are a lot of un-scientific web sites out there that pretend to be science. Many of these are run by lobbyists (e.g.., Climate Depot, run by a libertarian political lobbyist, CFACT), or supported by lobbyists (e.g., JoannaNova, WUWT, both of whom have received funding and otherwise substantial support by lobbying organizations like the Heartland Institute), or are actually paid by lobbyists to write Op-Eds and other blog posts that intentionally misrepresent the science.”

    • Replies: @AnonFromTN
    , @Sparkon
  81. @anon

    “Not Yet!!
    but we should prepare for it now because its only a matter of time”


  82. anon[384] • Disclaimer says:

    Olmert- I was brought down by rich US Jews-

    Now Cynthia McKinneys father accused the Jews of bringing her downfall.- JTA . That is conspiracy theory of the Antisemite according to Counterpunch’s article by- Steve King and the Tipping Point for the Republican Party?
    by CAMILO GÓMEZ + the links —

    that says McKinney’s column (read here) which accuses George Soros and Alan Greenspan of participating in a plot to deliberately destabilize the world economy in order to install a “one-world government”, uses Chang’s term for this purported conspiracy: “the Shadow Money-Lenders” (not coincidentally, the title of Chang’s most recent book). Typical of such conspiracy theories, Chang and McKinney connect this to an ancient plot which took shape under the hidden hand of the Rothschilds. McKinney puts a somewhat confused post-colonial third-world spin on this by citing Haiti as an example of what she says is planned for the rest of the world, the apparent link being that she happens to be in Haiti at the moment. Her leftist, “shock doctrine” approach also serves to make the essentially fascist contents of her column more palatable.”

    Lets get this right : ISIS and Al Quiada are determined to spread their version of the Islam through jihadist destabilizing the entire ME ,SE Asia and threatening other non -Muslim countries to establish “a Umma” that traces its connection to Qutub is anti Islamic-” antisemitism”. ( Unfortunately we don’t have term . We need a term to convey the same gravity , dastardly connotation and importance ,vulgar prejudice ,stereotypy ,hatred with potential dangerous consequences for the gentiles ) .

    Lets this part get right – I will be associated with Chang if I use the term “the shadow money -lender “.


  83. The Anglo-American Zionist’s unnecessary & immoral proxy war upon Syria could at any moment start WWIII.

    Please consider Veterans Today report, below?

  84. @james charles

    As the Russian joke puts it, “can I have cutlets separately and flies separately?” The Earth is currently warming, this is a fact. However, there is as much scientific evidence for this being the result of human activity as there was that Earth cooling is the result of the witchcraft (see comment #71). So, science has data that the climate is getting warmer, but has no data that human activity is the cause.

    • Replies: @james charles
  85. Sparkon says:
    @james charles

    If you have to dismiss all of these scientific organizations to reach your opinion, then you are by definition denying the science.

    I do reject bogus science, nonfactual statements, and illogical arguments irrespective of source, while I certainly do accept the valid arguments of many credible scientists who dispute both man-made global warming and the demonization of CO₂. My authorities have more appeal than yours, and our science is better than yours as well.

    It is important to understand that the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration is not a fake news organization. Neither is NASA. Neither is the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.

    — Paul Craig Roberts

    The IPCC is not a fake news organization, eh? Well, strictly speaking, it is more accurate to call the IPCC a fake science organization, but perhaps somehow PCR hasn’t heard about Climategate.

    “If there were any doubts remaining after reading the first Climategate e-mails, the new batch of e-mails that appeared on the web today [November 22] make it clear that the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change is an organized conspiracy dedicated to tricking the world into believing that global warming is a crisis that requires a drastic response,” said Myron Ebell, Director of the Competitive Enterprise Institute’s Center on Energy and Environment.

    Climategate II: More Smoking Guns From The Global Warming Establishment

    The Hockey Stick – Mann and IPCC deny and erase the Little Ice Age

    Climate alarmists like Michael Mann and the IPCC have been busted for smoothing even erasing natural climate variations in Earth’s past in order to amplify and accentuate any modern warming.

    Paris Stunned As Scientists Debunk Climate Change Hysteria

    …scientists have stunned attendees at the UN’s climate change conference in Paris recently by debunking claims that global warming is man-made.

    The scientists say that while the science refutes the UN’s claim that man-made carbon emissions are to blame for global warming, they claim that the UN is pressing ahead with its sinister ‘climate regime’ agenda, which includes: destroying industrial civilization, propping up kleptocrats with Western tax funds, and seizing control of the global economy under the guise of regulating the immensely beneficial “gas of life,” also known as carbon dioxide.


    Dr. Robert Carter: “Global warming is not happening,” he explained…that long-term cooling was predicted. Carter’s presentation…totally shredded the outlandish notion that CO2 — exhaled by humans and critical to life — is “carbon pollution” in need of regulation…he said, even at current atmospheric concentrations, the Earth and the plants it supports are “starving” for more CO2. And in the past, CO2 concentrations were some 10 to 15 times higher.

    Also speaking at the summit was Dr. Willie Soon, an astrophysicist and geoscientist at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics. The UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), he explained, “is totally anti-science, and is harming science.” Emphasizing the massive role played by the sun in the Earth’s incomprehensibly complex climate system, Soon narrowed in on one particular claim in the IPCC report on the issue that he said made a complete mockery of science. “The IPCC is pure gangster science,”

    Another top scientist at the summit was University of Virginia Professor Emeritus Dr. Fred Singer… “There has been no statistically significant warming in 18 years,” he told the summit, showing a slide comparing observed temperatures with the various bogus predictions made by “climate models” relied upon by the UN, all of which predicted warming as CO2 increased. “The models don’t work. We should not use them to make policy.” He also noted that carbon dioxide — “the original plant food,” as he called it — is very valuable. “Plants are starving. They want more CO2,” Singer added.

    Essentially, the internationally respected scientist continued, the climate has always changed due to natural forces — warming, cooling, and so on — from the beginning. And so, that means the obvious hypothesis that natural forces are still driving climate change, as they always have, must be shown to be false by proponents of the man-made climate change propaganda. In other words, the burden to show that the recent minor changes are attributable to mankind is on the alarmists who want to empower the UN, control CO2, and redistribute wealth. So far, though, the alarmists have failed, and they have a tough job ahead, Singer said.

    “This is about money and power,” Singer told The New American in an interview, adding that governments had purchased the cooperation of many scientists on climate alarmism. “Science plays a small role, and mostly it’s being misused.” “It’s a matter of really trying to control things,” Singer said, noting that control of CO2 means control of economies and ultimately, people. What is being plotted right now at the nearby UN COP21 summit, he added, is a “direct subsidy to kleptocracies,” which are pocketing the climate loot and hiding it in their bank accounts. “It’s a matter of the poor in rich countries supporting the rich in the poor countries,” Singer concluded.

    • Replies: @james charles
  86. @Sparkon

    “If you have to dismiss all of these scientific organizations to reach your opinion, then you are by definition denying the science”

  87. @AnonFromTN

    “A natural cycle requires a forcing, and no known forcing exists that fits the fingerprints of observed warming – except anthropogenic greenhouse gases.”

    • Replies: @AnonFromTN
  88. annamaria says:

    Meanwhile, in the Kaganat of Nuland (former Ukraine), Israeli citizen Kolomojsky’ baby “Azov” is on the march:

    • Replies: @Z-man
  89. annamaria says:

    More on the Ukrainian tragedy: “Monetary Fund (IMF) data indicates Ukraine is the poorest country in Europe”

    Let’s see the degree of the EU/US help for the disintegrating Ukraine:

    “Ukraine and Hungary … are divided over the situation in the region of Transcarpathia or Zakarpattya in western Ukraine… Budapest believes that Ukraine is infringing upon the rights of the ethnic Hungarian minority, who make up 12% of that region’s population. Ukrainian nationalist groups have been taking aggressive actions against local ethnic Hungarians.
    … a “death list” noted the names of Transcarpathian Hungarians in Ukraine, plus a call for the collective deportation of Ukrainian-Hungarian dual citizens, which was posted on the Ukrainian parliament’s website. In addition, Ukraine is setting up military installations near the Hungarian border.

    Ukraine’s 2017 language law … mandates that all public education beyond the fourth grade be conducted in the Ukrainian language. This has been resisted by Hungarian, Polish, and Romanian minority communities. …

    According to the Poland in English website, the Ukrainian Institute of National Remembrance forbade the search for and exhumation of the remains of Polish victims of wars and conflicts that occurred on the territory of Ukraine. Their bilateral relations also worsened after an amendment to Poland’s law on the Institute of National Remembrance (IPN), which among other provisions, criminalized the denial of human-rights abuses committed by Ukrainian nationalists between 1925 and 1950.”

  90. Z-man says:

    Kaganat of Nuland


    • Replies: @annamaria
  91. @james charles

    Science holds that a correlation cannot be a proof of cause-and-effect relationship. Say, if the same red Honda is on the road when I drive to work, this does not mean that it’s on the road because I drive to work. Seeing correlations as cause-and-effect relationships is called superstition. That’s how rituals emerge, from cavemen to modern adepts of all religions.

    I’ve heard this kind of “argument” before. In the last decade of the Soviet Union the level of Caspian sea was noticeably decreasing. Lots of “environmental activists” claimed that as it correlated with the use of water from the main river feeding it, Volga, this decrease in level was because we took too much water from Volga. Then about 15 years ago, while the same amount of water was still taken from Volga, the level of Caspian sea began to rise. “Environmental activists” were suddenly silent. BTW, it keeps rising now, even though more and more water is taken from Volga every year.

    Point is, we know so little that jumping to conclusions is the silliest thing we can do. Science teaches you humility, whereas what “activists” of all stripes are preaching is “know-it-al” arrogance.

    • Replies: @james charles
  92. annamaria says:

    The ugly shed that Nuland-Kagan has built: “Post-Maidan Suicide of Ukrainian Small Business”

    “… now the bandits pretending that they are the state authorities try to hold elections in Ukraine. … They won’t actually be able to do it. During the previous parliamentary elections the counting of votes was controlled by armed gangs. The only persons to gain seats in parliament were those who were allowed to do so by gangs, at the order of the authorities and in coordination with the US Embassy. … today the US is indifferent to who will win in Ukraine. …

    Clever people left [Ukraine] long ago. The stupid ones fight for Ukrainian European integration. … Society in general believes that business equals Jews, and Jews “stole everything”. Moreover, a considerable part of nationalist, pro-Russian, and even the part of the Ukrainian society that feels nostalgic for the USSR suffers from a sharp form of anti-Semitism. Businessmen, like Jews at the time of inquisition, are alien to all. Even the patriotic ones.”

    “Ukrainian Nazi Dmitry Yarosh announced the recruitment of children for the “extermination of Russia:”

    “The leader of the Ukrainian nationalists and the commander of the punitive [neo-Nazi] “Azov” regiment Andrey Biletsky is ready to become the sole presidential candidate from the nationalist forces of Ukraine:”

    — A Q for the 52 main American Jewish organizations: When will the ADL and Simon Wiesenthal Center begin their righteous hunting for Nuland-Kagan, Pyatt, Kolomojsky and Bibi, which all are directly responsible for the ongoing revival of Nazism and the dramatic rise in real anti-Judaism in Ukraine?

    • Replies: @anon
  93. @AnonFromTN

    “A natural cycle requires a forcing, and no known forcing exists that fits the fingerprints of observed warming – except anthropogenic greenhouse gases.”

    • Replies: @NoseytheDuke
  94. anon[332] • Disclaimer says:

    “Ukrainian Nazi Dmitry Yarosh announced the recruitment of children for the “extermination of Russia”….

    cui bono?

    a New Khazaria, cleared of whites

  95. Steve Hayes says: • Website

    The penultimate paragraph: “There have been numerous photos of the White Helmets operating directly with armed terrorists and also celebrating over the bodies of execution victims and murdered Iraqi soldiers.” Not Iraqi, Syrian.

  96. @NoseytheDuke

    “The sun’s energy has decreased since the 1980s but the Earth keeps warming faster than before.”

    • Replies: @anon
  97. anon[332] • Disclaimer says:
    @james charles

    well you should do something about it

    are you cutting back on your carbon footprint?

  98. I haven’t read all the comments, but has anyone mentioned the fact that the White Helmets were founded by an ex-UK military intelligence guy (do you ever really ‘leave’ military intelligence)?

  99. Sink says:

    Why is there no government funded museum to commemorate the genocide of Christians that has been ongoing since the beginning of the faith?

  100. m___ says:

    There definitely is a layer below words, that being meaning. Itself heavily dependent on the individual brain(s) words are thrown against. There is no understanding, only mind games.

Current Commenter

Leave a Reply -

 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments have been licensed to The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Commenting Disabled While in Translation Mode
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Philip Giraldi Comments via RSS
Personal Classics
Shouldn't they recuse themselves when dealing with the Middle East?
A Modern Guernica Enabled by Washington
Pressuring Candidates Even Before They Are Nominated
But is it even a friend?
The gagged whistleblower goes on the record.
Today’s CIA serves contractors and bureaucrats—not the nation.