The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection$
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewPepe Escobar Archive
The Siren Call of a ‘system Leader’
The United States may be destined for a shorter historical existence than the Mongol era established by Genghis Khan
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • B
Show CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

A considerable spectrum of the liberal West takes the American interpretation of what civilization consists of to be something like an immutable law of nature. But what if this interpretation is on the verge of an irreparable breakdown?

Michael Vlahos has argued that the US is not a mere nation-state but a “system leader” – “a civilizational power like Rome, Byzantium, and the Ottoman Empire.” And, we should add, China – which he did not mention. The system leader is “a universalistic identity framework tied to a state. This vantage is helpful because the United States clearly owns this identity framework today.”

Intel stalwart Alastair Crooke, in a searing essay, digs deeper into how this “civilizational vision” was “forcefully unfurled across the globe” as the inevitable, American manifest destiny: not only politically – including all the accouterments of Western individualism and neo-liberalism, but coupled with “the metaphysics of Judeo-Christianity, too”.

Crooke also notes how deeply ingrained the notion that victory in the Cold War “spectacularly affirmed” the superiority of the US civilizational vision among the US elite.

Well, the post-modern tragedy – from the point of view of US elites – is that soon this may not be the case anymore. The vicious civil war engulfing Washington for the past three years – with the whole world as stunned spectators – has just accelerated the malaise.

Remember Pax Mongolica

It’s sobering to consider that Pax Americana may be destined to a shorter historical existence than Pax Mongolica – established after Genghis Khan, the head of a nomad nation, went about conquering the world.

Genghis first invested in a trade offensive to take over the Silk Roads, crushing the Kara-Kitais in Eastern Turkestan, conquering Islamic Khorezm, and annexing Bukhara, Samarkand, Bactria, Khorasan and Afghanistan. The Mongols reached the outskirts of Vienna in 1241 and the Adriatic Sea one year after.

The superpower of the time extended from the Pacific to the Adriatic. We can barely imagine the shock for Western Christendom. Pope Gregory X was itching to know who these conquerors of the world were, and could be Christianized?

In parallel, only a victory by the Egyptian Mamluks in Galilee in 1260 saved Islam from being annexed to Pax Mongolica.

Pax Mongolica – a single, organized, efficient, tolerant power – coincided historically with the Golden Age of the Silk Roads. Kublai Khan – who lorded over Marco Polo – wanted to be more Chinese than the Chinese themselves. He wanted to prove that nomad conquerors turned sedentary could learn the rules of administration, commerce, literature and even navigation.

Yet when Kublai Khan died, the empire fragmented into rival khanates. Islam profited. Everything changed. A century later, the Mongols from China, Persia, Russia and Central Asia had nothing to do with their ancestors on horseback.

A jump cut to the young 21st century shows that the initiative, historically, is once again on the side of China, across the Heartland and lining up the Rimland. World-changing, game-changing enterprises don’t originate in the West anymore – as has been the case from the 16th century up to the late 20th century.

For all the vicious wishful thinking that coronavirus will derail the “Chinese century”, which will actually be the Eurasian Century, and amid the myopic tsunami of New Silk Roads demonization, it’s always easy to forget that implementation of myriad projects has not even started.

It should be in 2021 that all those corridors and axes of continental development pick up speed across Southeast Asia, the Indian Ocean, Central Asia, Southwest Asia, Russia and Europe, in parallel with the Maritime Silk Road configuring a true Eurasian string of pearls from Dalian to Piraeus, Trieste, Venice, Genoa, Hamburg and Rotterdam.

For the first time in two millennia, China is able to combine the dynamism of political and economic expansion both on the continental and maritime realms, something that the state did not experience since the short expeditionary stretch led by Admiral Zheng He in the Indian Ocean in the early 15th century. Eurasia, in the recent past, was under Western and Soviet colonization. Now it’s going all-out multipolar – a series of complex, evolving permutations led by Russia-China-Iran-Turkey-India-Pakistan-Kazakhstan.

Every player has no illusions about the “system leader” obsessions: to prevent Eurasia from uniting under one power – or coalition such as the Russia-China strategic partnership; ensure that Europe remains under US hegemony; prevent Southwest Asia – or the “Greater Middle East” – from being linked to Eurasian powers; and prevent by all means that Russia-China have unimpeded access to maritime lanes and trade corridors.

The message from Iran

In the meantime, a sneaking suspicion creeps in – that Iran’s game plan, in an echo of Donbass in 2014, may be about sucking US neocons into a trademark Russian cauldron in case the regime-change obsession is turbocharged.

There is a serious possibility that under maximum pressure Tehran might eventually abandon the JCPOA for good, as well as the NPT, thus openly inviting a US attack.

As it stands, Tehran has sent two very clear messages. The accuracy of the missile attack on the US Ayn Al-Asad base in Iraq, replying to the targeted assassination of Major General Qassem Soleimani, means that any branch of the vast US network of bases is now vulnerable.

And the fog of non-denial denials surrounding the downing of the CIA Battlefield Airborne Communications Node (BACN) – essentially an aerial spook shop – in Ghazni, Afghanistan also carries a message.

CIA icon Mike d’Andrea, known as ‘Ayatollah Mike’, The Undertaker, the Dark Prince, or all of the above, may or may not have been on board. Irrespective of the fact that no US government source will ever confirm or deny that Ayatollah Mike is dead or alive, or even that he exists at all, the message remains the same: your soldiers and spooks are also vulnerable.


Since Pearl Harbor, no nation has dared to stare down the system leader so blatantly, as Iran did in Iraq. Vlahos mentioned something I saw for myself in 2003, how “young American soldiers referred to Iraqis as ‘Indians’, as though Mesopotamia were the Wild West”. Mesopotamia was one the crucial cradles of civilization as we know it. Well, in the end, that $2 trillion spent to bomb Iraq into democracy did no favors to the civilizational vision of the ‘system leader’.

The Sirens and La Dolce Vita

Now let’s add aesthetics to our “civilizational” politics. Every time I visit Venice – which in itself is a living metaphor for both the flimsiness of empires and the Decline of the West – I retrace selected steps in The Cantos, Ezra Pound’s epic masterpiece.

Last December, after many years, I went back to the church of Santa Maria dei Miracoli, also known as “The jewel box”, which plays a starring role in The Cantos. As I arrived I told the custodian signora that I had come for “The Sirens”. With a knowing smirk, she lighted my way along the nave to the central staircase. And there they were, sculpted on pillars on both sides of a balcony: “Crystal columns, acanthus, sirens in the pillar head”, as we read in Canto 20.

These sirens were sculpted by Tullio and Antonio Lombardo, sons of Pietro Lombardo, Venetian masters of the late 15th and early 16th century – “and Tullio Romano carved the sirens, as the old custode says: so that since then no one has been able to carve them for the jewel box, Santa Maria dei Miracoli”, as we read in Canto 76.

Well, Pound misnamed the creator of the sirens, but, that’s not the point. The point is how Pound saw the sirens as the epitome of a strong culture – “the perception of a whole age, of whole congeries and sequence of causes, went into an assemblage of detail, whereof it would be impossible to speak in terms of magnitude”, as Pound wrote in Guide to Kulchur.

As much as his beloved masterpieces by Giovanni Bellini and Piero della Francesca, Pound fully grasped how these sirens were the antithesis of usura – or the “art” of lending money at exorbitant interest rates, which not only deprives a culture of the best of art, as Pound describes it, but is also one of the pillars for the total financialization and marketization of life itself, a process that Pound brilliantly foresaw, when he wrote in Hugh Selwyn Mauberley that, “all things are a flowing, Sage Heracleitus says; But a tawdry cheapness, shall reign throughout our days.”

La Dolce Vita will turn 60 in 2020. Much as Pound’s sirens, Fellini’s now mythological tour de force in Rome is like a black and white celluloid palimpsest of a bygone era, the birth of the Swingin’ Sixties. Marcello (Marcello Mastroianni) and Maddalena (Anouk Aimee), impossibly cool and chic, are like the Last Woman and the Last Man before the deluge of “tawdry cheapness”. In the end, Fellini shows us Marcello despairing at the ugliness and, yes, cheapness intruding in his beautiful mini-universe – the lineaments of the trash culture fabricated and sold by the ‘system leader’ about to engulf us all.

Pound was a human, all too human American maverick of unbridled classical genius. The ‘system leader’ misinterpreted him; treated him as a traitor; caged him in Pisa; and dispatched him to a mental hospital in the US. I still wonder whether he may have seen and appreciated La Dolce Vita during the 1960s, before he died in Venice in 1972. After all, there was a little cinema within walking distance of the house in Calle Querini where he lived with Olga Rudge.

“Marcello!” We’re still haunted by Anita Ekberg’s iconic siren call, half-immersed in the Fontana di Trevi. Today, still hostages of the crumbling civilizational vision of the ‘system leader’, at best we barely muster, as TS Eliot memorably wrote, a “backward half-look, over the shoulder, towards the primitive terror.”

(Republished from Asia Times by permission of author or representative)
Hide 14 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. bluedog says:

    Always an interesting read.!!!

    • Agree: Digital Samizdat
  2. Tom Verso says:

    Can anyone provide a link to images of the Tullio and Antonio Lombardo Sirens.

    Google search brings up a myriad of images; none of which look like “Crystal columns, acanthus, sirens in the pillar head”


    • Replies: @Weston Waroda
  3. Crazy Horse says: • Website

    “Since Pearl Harbor, no nation has dared to stare down the system leader so blatantly, as Iran did in Iraq. Vlahos mentioned something I saw for myself in 2003, how “young American soldiers referred to Iraqis as ‘Indians’, as though Mesopotamia were the Wild West”. Mesopotamia was one the crucial cradles of civilization as we know it. Well, in the end, that $2 trillion spent to bomb Iraq into democracy did no favors to the civilizational vision of the ‘system leader’.”

    Actually America or Turtle Island as the Indigenous population call it was far more civilized than state histographers as opposed actual historians have led us to believe and that the Mayans had a thriving urban and civilized culture while most Europeans were still living in caves;

    • Replies: @Showmethereal
  4. LindaJ says:

    Long live Pepe!

    • Agree: Crazy Horse
  5. @Tom Verso

    For what it’s worth, this seems to be one the sirens from the description in the article:

    However, a blogger disagrees with that assessment, and claims these are actually Ezra Pound’s sirens:

    • Replies: @Tom Verso
  6. So glad to have Pepe here at Unz. He’s been a fave of mine for about 15 years now. In fact, he was one of my very first ventures into alt-media. I discovered him at the quirky, off-beat website Asia Time Online. He has rarely disappointed me since then.

  7. Tom Verso says:
    @Weston Waroda

    Thank you very much.

    This is a big help in clarifying what I saw in my Google search. I was thinking the Sirens were full blown statues at the top of a column. Now I see that the Google images, while not perfectly clear if they are THE Sirens, are closer to the reality of lesser images at the base of the column.

    Also, maybe I’m aesthetically part of the ‘great unwashed’, relative to Pound and the writer, but frankly; I don’t see what is so moving about these renditions of the ancient Greek Sirens. But, of course, aesthetic judgements are inherently subjective.

    Thanks again.

  8. “Are we an effective team?”

  9. @Crazy Horse

    There were two cities in “the Americas” as big as London before European migration. Indeed there were numerous sophisticated tribes. What they lacked were guns – and immunization to European diseases.
    The portrayal of them as beasts (just as was done with Africans) was to justify the treatment they received and the taking of their resources. If you dehumanize them it makes it more palatable since much of what was done was contrary to biblical principal. But hey – they followed Emperor Constantine who claimed he had a vision of a cross with a voice telling him “in this go forth and conquer” (something close)… Well the warning against false prophets should have triggered alarm bells. His vision was in direct contrast to the words of the Messiah who said His kingdom is not of this earthly system…. Alas many many wars hage been fought and many people colonized based on that false understanding.

    • Agree: Crazy Horse, Ber, Bliss
    • Thanks: bluedog
  10. Many thanks to Mr. Escobar for reminding everyone of Ezra Pound. As I recall, he was committed in a mental hospital for speaking truth to power.

  11. QPSR says:

    I always enjoy reading Escobar’s writing about China. He know the history and he knows the deep, geo-strategic game that is being played. But caution – he is a highly partisan player.

    I don’t think any nation dislikes the United States of America more than our fellow Americans, the United States of Brazil, where Escobar hails from. It’s a Latin thing. It’s hard to have the world see the sharp distinction in North and SouthAmerica and Brazilians especially, squirm under the harsh reality. They blame it on the USA never bothering to examine their own political social and economic corruptions.

    A couple of reminders to help put this article in perspective.

    One of Escobar’s enduring thesis is that America is the trouble maker of the world and should soon be relegated to a lesser position. He fails to remember that after 1945 the US markets, which were opened to our allies, rebuilt Western Europe, Japan, South Korea The Philappines, and, since 1980, China, the US consumer raised 400,000,000 Chines peasants into the modern world almost exclusively. The US market has powered the world’s growth from global destruction in 1945 to the global markets we now have.
    It’s very convenient to forget this history, especially if you are trying to make a point.

    With complete dismissal, Escobar doesn’t mention Xinjiang or Tibet except to say that they are not Han Chinese ( most Chinese aren’t Han, all the non-Han Chinese tribes over the centuries were subdued.) And yet, in these two provinces the worst case of expropriation has and is occurring. Not since Europeans landed in the Americas has another nation completely overwhelmed two other nations – without a word from the global community. Millions of Uyghurs are in concentration camps and the most extreme forms of technological surveillance has been applied to them. And yet, Escobar talks about the moral decline of the West! At least we have a position to decline from. Like Israel, China has no qualms about taking what it wants.

    Poor Ezra Pound. Escobar spent some time lamenting the cruel treatment of Pound. For whatever reason, Pound favored Mussolini’s party and payed the price after the war by being locked up. never tortured. Released and died a free man. Escobar sees in this the cruelty of the US. But he has the temerity to complain about Pound without mentioning the four Chinese have disappeared since they reported on the virus.

    He talks about the wealth that China will bring to the world with its road and belt initiative. But that’s not the way China does business. All wealth will flow to China and all their junk will flow out to the world. Ask the Vietnamese. Ask the Africans. Ask the Americans!

    Escobar is an ideological agent for the Chinese. He writings are an almost verbatim rendering of the Chinese party line. He is good to read because he knows about the Big Game that underlies all the surface fuss.
    But he is hatefully against the US and has found safe harbor in China. Of course he doesn’t live there! He is not that careless.

  12. SPQR says:

    Escobar talks about China replacing the US as a “system leader”, or as Toynbee says, a universal state.
    I don’t think it will happen since universal states offer much more than simply commerce, which is what the Chinese State is offering. Universal States like Rome and the US offer a culture freedom. It offers law. Only a free state can produce a culture that can bind people. Everyone knows China is a totalitarian state. Whatever peace the Chinese offer comes at the price of a basic lack of human freedom.
    How will the Chinese state offer anything in the arts to the world? Let me know when you see a great work of art come out of China and don’t tell me Shen Yun!

    As China gains power and influence, when countries begin to see the costs of the Chinese system, opposition will grow externally and internally.
    And as Escobar stated, the US objective, our main strategic interest, is to make sure China doesn’t unite the Eurasian landmass. And we will have plenty of allies inside and outside of China.

  13. SPQR says:

    An anonymous Chinese writer living in N. America.
    This headline is from The Guardian.

    As Wuhan’s desperate and sick beg for help, China shuts them down

  14. SPQR says:

    Leaked records expose China’s Xinjiang camps
    Updated 11:33 AM EST February 17, 2020
Video 06:57
    Newly leaked Chinese records have revealed for the first time the system by which hundreds of thousands of Uyghurs have been monitored and detained in heavily fortified internment centers across Xinjiang. According to the leak, Chinese citizens can be sent to the camps for reasons such as growing beards, owning passports, or having too many children and their release may depend on how well their family behaves. CNN’s Ivan Watson reports.

    This is not and never will be a universal state.

Current Commenter

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone

 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments have been licensed to The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Commenting Disabled While in Translation Mode
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Pepe Escobar Comments via RSS
The Surprising Elements of Talmudic Judaism
Analyzing the History of a Controversial Movement
The Shaping Event of Our Modern World