The Unz Review: An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewPatrick Cockburn Archive
The Resignation of the Iraqi Prime Minister May Not Halt the Protests
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

Protesters in Iraq have won their first big success by forcing the resignation of the Iraqi prime minister, Adel Abdul-Mahdi, after the killing of 45 unarmed protesters by the Iraqi security forces in a single day. As the news spread, the crack of celebratory fireworks replaced that of gunshots in Baghdad’s Tahrir Square, which has been the epicentre of demonstrations since they began two months ago.

The impending departure of Mahdi is a symbolic victory for the protests, but too many people have been killed for it to quell what is close to a mass uprising by the majority Shia community. He had proved an ineffectual leader and the entire ruling elite in Iraq is probably too corrupt and too determined to hang on to power to make the radical reforms demanded by the protesters.

The announcement that the prime minister was stepping down came after 36 hours in which the security forces had switched from killing individual demonstrators to massacres on a larger scale – with as many as 50 people shot dead on a bridge in the southern city of Nasiriya – bringing the number killed to 408, as well as thousands more wounded, since 1 October.

Compare this horrific casualty list over eight weeks with that in Hong Kong, where just one protester has been killed and one has died accidentally since protests started six months ago. Compare also the vast and sympathetic publicity given to the Hong Kong protests with the limited interest in the savage and unprecedented government clampdown in Iraq.

Probably the world has got used to Iraqis being murdered in large numbers, whether it is by Isis, Saddam Hussein or the US air force, so it is no longer considered news.

But history is made by unreported massacres. “It plants hatred in the heart,” a Palestinian once said of a mass killing by Israeli troops decades ago in Gaza in which his uncle had been killed.

The violence is seen as only affecting Iraqis, but it has the potential to reshape the politics of the Middle East. Since the Iranian revolution in 1979, one of the most powerful political and military forces in the region has been the increasing strength of Shia communities under Iranian leadership. Over the last 40 years, this coalition has outfought and outmanoeuvred enemies such as the US, Israel and Saudi Arabia in Lebanon, Syria, Yemen and, above all, in Iraq.

The importance of the Iraq-Iran alliance is so great because two-thirds of Iraq’s 38 million population are Shia and it has a 900-mile-long border with Iran. Since the fall of Saddam Hussein in 2003, Iraq has had a Shia-dominated government that usually acted in unison with Iran. Iraqi Shia differ in many respects from their Iranian co-religionists, but they have seen them until recently as an essential ally in the struggle with Isis. The holiest Shia shrines are in the Iraqi cities of Najaf and Karbala, to which millions of Iranian pilgrims flood every year.

But in the last two months, this victorious, Iranian-led Shia coalition has been fractured as pro-Iranian sections of the Iraqi security services and paramilitary groups repeatedly shot down Shias protesting about the lack of jobs, inadequate social services and pervasive corruption on the part of Iraq’s ruling elite. These protests were initially on a small scale and only gained momentum because of the government’s overreaction to what was at first a very minor threat.

From the first, there was little effort to conceal the role of Iran in masterminding the repression. Reports surfaced at an early stage that General Qassem Soleimani, the head of the Quds Force – the foreign arm of the Revolutionary Guards in Iran – had decided that the protests were part of a foreign plot and the best way to deal with them was with “a whiff of grapeshot”.

Many generals in history have thought the same thing and, through violent but failed repression, have turned limited expressions of discontent into open revolts. In the Iraqi case, the protesters became virulently anti-Iranian.

The outcome of the counterproductive and futile attempts by pro-Iranian forces in Iraq to crush the protests may be the beginnings of a sea change in the politics of the Middle East. The previously triumphant alliance of the Iranian and Iraqi Shia – a coalition that had seen off the US and its allies – may be irretrievably broken. The Iranians and their Iraqi allies have done more to break the link between the two countries in the last eight weeks than Washington and Riyadh succeeded in doing in years of trying.

Why did Iran overreact? President Trump’s policy of “maximum pressure” on Iran has not proved very successful, but it has made the Iranian leadership, always paranoid and prone to conspiracy theories, nervous and likely to exaggerate anything that looks like a threat. Paradoxically, this feeling of vulnerability on the part of Iran is linked to a sense of hubris born out of its repeated victories in proxy wars in the region.

But these successes produced a new weakness in the Iranian-led Shia coalition: it acquired an interest in Lebanon, Iraq and Syria in maintaining the political status quo, however unjust, corrupt and incompetent it might be. In Iraq, for instance, the predominantly Shia ruling class might once have been heroic opponents of Saddam Hussein, but they have long since transmuted into a dysfunctional kleptocracy that is hostile to reform.

Shia leaders rebuffed critics of their failings by appealing to communal solidarity against existential threats from al-Qaeda-type groups, but that excuse lost traction in the last few years as Isis was defeated. In Iraq, the discontent goes particularly deep because much of the Shia population – the Sunni and Kurds have kept out of it – wonders why they are without jobs, water and electricity in a country that earns $7bn a month from oil exports.


The departure of Adel Abdul-Mahdi as prime minister is unlikely to defuse the protests, because the Iraqi state is probably incapable of reforming itself. An alternative for the government is full-scale repression: trying to stamp out dissent by killing or arresting protesters. But that option has failed so far because the protesters have shown heroic resolve in continuing to demonstrate despite being shot down and without taking up arms themselves – though most Iraqi families own one or more guns. The protesters can see that militarisation of the crisis would be much in the government’s interest, because it could then justify its use of lethal force. But this self-restraint will not last forever and there have already been so many deaths as to “plant hatred in the hearts” of many Iraqis that will not disappear.

(Republished from The Independent by permission of author or representative)
• Category: Foreign Policy • Tags: Iran, Iraq 
Hide 11 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. Kali says:

    Paddy Cockburn, just a lone bleeding heart speaking out for those poor opressed (mostly by Iran of course) Iraqi’s. I can almost smell your tears from here.. or something!

    But Paddy, you sickening establishment shill, where are the photographs? Where’s the footage?

    Maybe it’s not your tears I can smell? Could it possibly be your bollox!?

    FREE JULIAN ASSANGE – this world desparately needs real jounalists!

  2. A123 says:

    Despite many claims to the contrary, U.S. Sanctions have successfully limited the ability of the authoritarian regime in Tehran to collect cash. Ayatollah Khameni had a choice:
    — Spend on the needs of people
    — Waste funds on nuclear weapons and ballistic missiles
    He chose weapons over people. The Iranian government and its proxies are now reaping the rewards of that choice.

    Lebanon, Syria, and Iraq all share a similar path forward, ridding themselves of Iranian proxies & rejoining the civilized community of nations. Without Iranian interference, the conflict in Syria will wind down allowing refugees to return home. All sides win except for violent Iranian groups like al’Hezbollah.

    As long as Iran remains a socialist theocracy, leaders isolated from the people, it is hard to see a road forward. I hope for peace, however it is hard to see a sociopath like Khameni voluntarily stepping down. Ultimately, the Iranian people will have to get rid of him.

    PEACE 😇

  3. “one protester has been killed in Hong Kong”?

    Who? When? By whom?

  4. Reports surfaced at an early stage that General Qassem Soleimani, the head of the Quds Force – the foreign arm of the Revolutionary Guards in Iran – had decided that the protests were part of a foreign plot

    He’s right about that. And should Iraq descend into anarchy and chaos who should police the country to reestablish peace and stability: UN, NATO/USA, or Iran?

  5. @A123

    “Waste funds on nuclear weapons”.
    Some lies are just so handy that they just have to be whipped out, & waved round at any opportunity….

  6. Biff says:

    He chose weapons over people.

    Quit picking on Trump, Obama, Bush, Clinton….. etc….

  7. @A123

    Lebanon, Syria and Iraq know they will be raped, murdered and looted by the “civilized community of nations” and this is why they strugle against joining it. Without Iranian help Lebanon, Syria and Iraq would have met a terrible fate. As it is refugees are returning to Syria thanks to the defeat of the “civilized world’s” proxy army of terrorist rapers, murderers and looters.

  8. Poor Paddy,
    It must get boring putting out Hasbara week after week, feeding the Eye whilst feeding the mortgage. Sucks to be a Cockburn I guess.
    Sounds like a big ole Israeli-NWO masturbation fantasy to me Paddy. Iran overreacts and squanders solidarity with the Iraqi Shia.
    Tune in next week for more disinfo from your local Mossad-CIA shill: Lyin’ Paddy Cockburn.

  9. Is it just me, or does this sound exactly like what Clean Break was supposed to be: Install a controlled Shia leadership in order to splinter the Shia population in Iraq and sow discourse in the community.

  10. anonymous[307] • Disclaimer says:

    [The Resignation of the Iraqi Prime Minister May Not Halt the Protests]

    You in the dress of ‘Journalist’, but in fact you are an MI6-CIA-Mossad agent in the business of propaganda to decieve dummies for the interest of the Evil empire and its colony Britain and the zionis baby killers. You go and fuck yourself liars. Either you expose your masters or you fuck off terrorists apologists and their propaganda tools.

    he reason that YOU and your masters, US-Israel-UK spreading these lies is that the Iraqi prime minister, Adel Abdul-Mahdi, WAS NOT YOUR PUPPET and did not accept being a servant, like YOU, for the evil empire and its stooges. The PM did not allow Iraq to be used against Iran and PM made few agreement with CHINA that you and your masters did not like IDIOT liar.

    [From the first, there was little effort to conceal the role of Iran in masterminding the repression. Reports surfaced at an early stage that General Qassem Soleimani, the head of the Quds Force – the foreign arm of the Revolutionary Guards in Iran – had decided that the protests were part of a foreign plot and the best way to deal with them was with “a whiff of grapeshot”.]

    YOU the liar propagandist: Why Iraqi people should go against Iran? Iran has helped Iraqis where You and evil US-Israel-Britain killed Iraqi people and is trying to partition Iraq to create the second Israel -‘kurdistan’ and doing so you HAVE KILLED millions of Iraqi people and millions more as refuges. Why are you lying, idiot propagandist?

    Who sanctioned Iraq, resulting in the death of half a million Iraqi children? Who invaded Iraq and humiliated the country, occupied the country where still is under occupation? Who dropped depleted uranium on Iraqi cities, causing children even today to be born disfigured and mutated? Who unleashed Daesh on Iraq? Who robbed Iraq Museum and libraries? Who killed over 1200 Iraqi scientists to deny Iraq development? who sanctioned Iraq to bring the economy down?

    It is here that it becomes clear that the Saudis and Americans are directing these thugs to attack Iran inside Iraq. Fortunately, in Iraq they have been exposed as well. The Iraqi Foreign Ministry condemned the incident in strongest terms, saying the attack had been perpetrated “by strangers … distant from the reality of demonstrations taking place in a number of Iraqi cities.”

    If these constructed riots is not the work of YOU and your masters US-Israel-Saudis-Britain, then who else benefit? Iraqi people that you made slaves and destroyed their countries.

    Trump, a jewish mafia member and the faggot MBS and the war criminal Netanyahu must all be shot and you stop your lies ant once, otherwise you are remember not as a ‘journalist’ but as a liar and propagandist for the zionist mass murderers and thieves, IMPORTER.

  11. The protests have been usurped to violence by the CIA, and US mercenaries, for the sole purpose of continuing the kneecapping of yet another ME country.

Current Commenter

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone

 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments have been licensed to The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Patrick Cockburn Comments via RSS
Personal Classics
Full Story of the Taliban's Amazing Jailbreak
"They Can't Even Protect Themselves, So What Can They Do For Me?"
"All Hell is Breaking Loose with Muqtada" Warlord: the Rise of Muqtada al-Sadr