The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection$
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewPatrick Cockburn Archive
Forget Our Gaffes Around Brexit. Shamina Is the Real Threat.
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • B
Show CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

The decision of home secretary Sajid Javid to strip former Isis mother Shamima Begum of her British citizenship is evidently motivated by his wish to be seen – along with Theresa May – as tough and proactive amid the chaos and uncertainties of Brexit. The decision is probably illegal, given that Begum does not have a Bangladesh passport, but by the time the case works its way through the courts, the gesture will have served its turn.

The frenzy over the Begum story is partly impelled by the media’s desperation to report something other than Brexit. But taking away Begum’s right to a British passport is only the latest in a series of bizarre gestures by ministers designed to give the impression of a government in control at home and abroad, though the weirdness of its actions suggests one that is rattled and does not know where it is going.

Sending the giant aircraft carrier HMS Queen Elizabeth to disputed waters off China has a fine “Britain rules the waves” feel to it. Defence minister Gavin Williamson says it is a display of “hard power” and “lethality”. Except we do not rule the waves anywhere much and certainly not in the South China Sea, and to pretend otherwise gives a very large hostage to fortune.

There is even an ominous echo here, which probably passed Williamson by, of a spectacularly ill-judged bit of gesture strategy. Churchill sent the warships Prince of Wales and Repulse to the far east to serve as a “veiled threat” to deter Japanese aggression. Both vessels were promptly sunk by Japanese aircraft and their fate should have served as a warning to any power that bluffs without thinking through what will happen if that bluff is called.

The Chinese were never likely to react militarily to vague threats, but they did cancel trade talks with chancellor Philip Hammond. It was a curious moment to irritate a country with the world’s second largest economy just weeks before a post-Brexit Britain will be looking for new markets.

A few days later, Japan got a taste of Britain’s new ill-timed steeliness with foreign secretary Jeremy Hunt and international trade secretary Liam Fox causing offence in Tokyo by writing a letter telling the Japanese that “time is of the essence” when it comes to a new Anglo-Japanese trade deal and that both sides should show flexibility. The Japanese reportedly came close to stopping the trade talks in which they are visibly aware of having a stronger hand in dealing with Britain than when it was an EU member.

Anger towards Britain in Beijing and Tokyo will pass away if there are no more provocations, but a peculiar precedent is being set. Britain is already a weaker power because of Brexit and will have to learn the diplomatic language that goes with its new status as a lesser power.

The problem in dealing with China and Japan is similar to that in negotiating with the EU: the Brexiteer programme, in so far as they had one, supposed that the EU needed Britain more than Britain needs the EU, though everything that has happened since 2016 shows the opposite to be case.

The negative impact of dealing with the rest of the world through belligerent but empty gestures is so obvious that it can only be intended to befuddle a domestic audience. “Foreign policy ends at the water’s edge” is a cynical American political saying which means that foreign policy is really always about domestic politics.

Yet even this does not quite explain the sheer ineptitude of the government’s attempts to project strength in all directions. The prime example of this was the £14m contract with Seaborne Freight to provide ships to carry cargo between Ramsgate and Ostend in the event of a no-deal Brexit, despite the fact that the company had no ships or experience of operating them. The contract has now been cancelled after an Irish company backing it pulled out. Nevertheless, the hiring of the ghost ferry ships was extraordinary, even by the horrendous track record of transport secretary Chris Grayling.

The exceptional level of incompetence at the top of government catches one by surprise because every cabinet in history has been accused by opponents of unexampled stupidity. Deriding such failings has been so much the province of pub bores that sensible people switch off when they hear it. But Theresa May’s cabinet seems to surpass all its predecessors in the extent of the gap between what is said and what is done.

This may be explained by the chasm between what Brexit was supposed to deliver and what it will be, a gap that can only be bridged by wishful thinking or outright lies.

The personality of Theresa May must have a lot to do with this. I first noticed the disconnect between her words and deeds when, as Home Secretary, she was making sympathetic and intelligent speeches about mental illness. She went on doing so after she moved to Downing Street, but the number of hospital beds for those suffering from severe psychosis kept on shrinking and patients were increasingly transferred to hospitals hundreds of miles from their families who were their main support.

There were 5,800 deaths by suicide in the UK in the last year for which figures are available, making it the leading form of death for young people between 18 and 34. And how did May respond to these grim figures? Unsurprisingly, for those who had come to know her style, she made the useless gestures by appointing a minister for suicide prevention.


Some have interpreted the current crisis as a failure of the British political class as a whole. I am wary of this argument because it spreads the blame for disastrous policies too widely, which is highly convenient for the much smaller group who are really responsible. I remember a Japanese prime minister getting good marks for repentance in 2012 for saying the whole Japanese establishment was responsible for the Fukushima disaster, his audience failing to note that this let individuals off the hook apart from sharing in the general guilt.

The problem is perhaps less with pro-Brexit politicians than with the press that has sold a fantasy picture of Britain to half the population who are convinced that their country is far more important than it is. Travelling around Britain in the last few weeks, I have been struck by the conviction of Leave voters that the Germans will always want to sell their cars here and the French will want to sell their cheese to them whatever happens. People are deaf to the idea that the balance of power is very much against them.

Fortunately, it turns out that the real threat to Britain is Shamima Begum and her infant baby and that, at least, the government knows how to deal with.

(Republished from The Independent by permission of author or representative)
• Category: Foreign Policy • Tags: Britain, ISIS 
Hide 10 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. ISIS scum deserve a lot worse than being stripped of their citizenship. Begum is lucky.

  2. fenestol says:

    Kok-burn has lapsed into senility. I hope that his deep-state handlers will allow him to retire to a home for formerly useful idiots.

    • Agree: YetAnotherAnon
  3. If Shamima Begum is a naturalized citizen, she was required to take certain oaths and pledges.

    From her actions, it is clear that she would not have upheld her part in that, thereby nullifying her citizenship. Brexit or no Brexit, whether she was inside or outside the UK is irrelevant, her citizenship should be revoked. As for the child, she would have had to make application for that child to be a citizen, before hers was revoked, for the child to have any legitimate claim.

    • Replies: @Sean
  4. romar says:

    The current UK leadership is deluded to the point of madness. They act as if they thought Elisabeth was Victoria:
    “Only those of us who were born under Queen Victoria know what it feels like to assume, without questioning, that England is permanently top nation, that foreigners do not matter, and that if worst comes to the worst, Lord Salisbury will send a gunboat.” Ronald Knox
    Williamson must surely think he is Lord Salisbury, with all his anti-Russia nonsense. The Russians have noted that point:
    These delusions can’t end well…

  5. dvorak says:

    “Sending your only carrier to the South China Sea”: “Just NATO Things”

  6. Blake says:

    Deflect; Delay; Deny; Discount; Deceive; Divide; Dulcify; Discredit; Destroy.

  7. Sean says:

    It would be stupid for France and Britain to allow Britain make a success of Brexit, because Sweden and other countries would be much more likely to follow the UK out of the EU. Germany and France are going to try and ruin Britain, and the Japanese are going to wait until Britain is desperate.

    The problem is perhaps less with pro-Brexit politicians than with the press that has sold a fantasy picture of Britain to half the population who are convinced that their country is far more important than it is. Travelling around Britain in the last few weeks, I have been struck by the conviction of Leave voters that the Germans will always want to sell their cars here and the French will want to sell their cheese to them whatever happens. People are deaf to the idea that the balance of power is very much against them.

    It would have been much better for Britain if it had never gone into the EEC/ EU. Coming out is barely worth it now.

  8. Sean says:

    Fortunately, it turns out that the real threat to Britain is Shamima Begum and her infant baby

    At least we can do something about them. M ass immigration is ot so much a threat as already proven to be Britain’ nemesis: that’s mass immigration. The Home Secretary and the head of national counter-terrorism are Pakistani and Indian origin. Soon we will have an immigrant origin PM like Patrick’s Eire homeland already does.

  9. Bangladesh is actually capable of issuing passports? Like India of which they were once a part, they can’t even maintain a rail system bequeathed to them by the British seven decades ago. Trains in South Asia literally covered with human bodies as they transit their routes are a viral meme. When your Bangladeshi society produces virtually nothing but Bangladeshi’s, and by the millions each year, little things like infrastructure tend to get neglected.

  10. Mah buddy Tony Blair shore did a bang-up job across the pond!
    And ah do mean “bang up”!!
    As in we joined up to start them endless wars, and we both brung in millions o’ them imported immigrants.
    Them immigrants are all fambly values and such. As in they have five wives and twenny chillurn.
    They love their new guvmint – they show up rite on schedule ta’ git their welfare!!
    Best thing ’bout all them imported immigrants – we need lotsa police and cameras and inter-webs snoopin’ ta’ keep tabs on them.
    So we kin build up the police state faster ‘n ever.
    Which keeps them right-wing crazies under our watchful eyes.
    The cheap labor (at least them Europeans will work, even iff’n them A-rabs dont) is preventin’ a dangerous rise in middle-class wages.

Current Commenter

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone

 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments have been licensed to The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Commenting Disabled While in Translation Mode
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Patrick Cockburn Comments via RSS
Personal Classics
Full Story of the Taliban's Amazing Jailbreak
"They Can't Even Protect Themselves, So What Can They Do For Me?"
"All Hell is Breaking Loose with Muqtada" Warlord: the Rise of Muqtada al-Sadr