The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection$
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewPat Buchanan Archive
Is a UK Crackup Ahead?
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • B
Show CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

David Cameron is the most successful Tory Party leader since Margaret Thatcher.

Yet history may also record that his success led to the crackup of his country, and Great Britain’s secession from the European Union.

How did Cameron’s Tories capture their majority?

First, they compiled a strong record to run on.

More critically, they attacked the Labour Party of Ed Miliband as too far left to govern, and warned that a Labour government would be hostage to a secessionist Scottish National Party, without whose votes Miliband could never reach a majority in Parliament.

Labour could not shake off the charge, because it was true.

The attack on the SNP as a subversive party secretly allied with Labour had an ancillary benefit for the Tories. It helped produce a SNP sweep of all but three of Scotland’s 59 seats. The Labour Party was virtually wiped out in Scotland, its northern bastion.

How Labour recovers from this amputation is hard to see.

What does this portend for the United Kingdom?

To keep Scotland within the UK, Cameron has promised a “devolution” of tax and spending powers to the Scottish Parliament.

But this will not be enough. For the Scots are going to be forced to sit in Westminster for five years and watch a Tory prime minister, acting on Tory principles, gut the social welfare state in which they believe. And, with Labour, the SNP will be helpless to stop it.

This situation seems certain to stir Scottish demands for a new referendum on independence, which would have a far better chance of succeeding than the last one — it lost 45-55.

What does the SNP want?

Retention of the social welfare state, British nuclear missile subs out of Scottish bases and Scotland out of the U.K. But Scottish nationalism is certain to generate a countervailing English nationalism.

Scotland’s demand for a divorce may soon find an echo in England.

Which brings us to the party that won 13 percent of the vote, three times the SNP total, but only a single seat in Parliament.

This is the United Kingdom Independence Party, whose populist leader Nicholas Farage resigned when he failed to win a seat of his own.

Nevertheless, the UKIP and the anti-EU Tories, some of whom sit in Cameron’s cabinet, have been promised a national referendum on secession from the EU by 2017.

Consider how the interests of these parties will push them all toward an England that is free of the EU and of Scotland both.

Unhappy with Tory policies, yet unable to alter them, the Scots are likely to create conflicts in Parliament that strengthen the forces of secession. Former SNP leader Alex Salmond, who won a seat in the Parliament, is promising it.

As for the Tories, with Scotland outside of the U.K., they would see a brighter future. For Scotland is lost to them, and in a U.K. of England, Wales and Northern Ireland, a Tory future is assured.

As for the UKIP, its goal of secession from the EU would be easier to achieve if the pro-EU Scots are out of the U.K. and unable to vote in the referendum on Britain’s future.

As for Labour, the SNP is now not only its dominant rival north of Hadrian’s Wall, it is a secessionist albatross draped around their neck in England. What good is Scotland to Labour now?

Yet the United Kingdom may be only the first of the nations of Old Europe to break up or break out of the EU.

Should Scotland leave the U.K., this would surely set off a reflex reaction in Catalonia in Spain, Veneto in Italy and Flanders in Belgium.

Moreover, the forces driving the European Union toward a breakup today seem far stronger than the forces for deepening the political and economic ties of Europe.

In postwar Europe, transnationalism and globalism, the opening and erasure of borders, the transfer of power from nation-states to transnational institutions and elites, all seemed inevitable.

No more. Jean Monnet is passe. Now is the time of Marine Le Pen and Nicola Sturgeon of the SNP. Patriotism, populism, nationalism are the growth stocks of 2015.

Northern nations like Germany and Holland are weary of carrying what they see as the lazier and more profligate EU members of Club Med. In Greece and Spain, populist parties are fed up with the endless austerity demands of the Germans.

Most of the countries of Europe have a secessionist party or an anti-immigration, anti-EU Party. Like Great Britain, some have both.

Across Europe, peoples are eager to recapture control of their borders from the EU and halt immigration, especially from across the Mediterranean, where war, terrorism, poverty and overpopulation are propelling north millions of Arabs, Africans and Muslims who are failing to assimilate into European societies.

These Europeans seek to re-establish their independence, to build nations that reflect their true identity, something we Americans went to war for in 1775, when we, too, threw the cousins out.

Patrick J. Buchanan is the author of the new book “The Greatest Comeback: How Richard Nixon Rose From Defeat to Create the New Majority.”

Copyright 2015

• Category: Foreign Policy • Tags: Britain, Scotland, UKIP 
Hide 15 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. Is a UK Crackup Ahead?

    Let’s all certainly hope so:

    Lest we forget George W Bush & Tony Blair have always been in love ^

  2. Priss Factor [AKA "The Priss Factor"] says:

    “Across Europe, peoples are eager to recapture control of their borders from the EU and halt immigration, especially from across the Mediterranean, where war, terrorism, poverty and overpopulation are propelling north millions of Arabs, Africans and Muslims who are failing to assimilate into European societies.”

    American Jewish foreign policy messed up the Middle East but Europeans have to pay the price.

    • Replies: @AnAnon
  3. I very much doubt it; Scotland will go the same way as (Northern) Ireland.

    The political configuration will realign to Unionist vs. non-Unionist (Scottish Tory, Labour & Lib Dems will have to merge to match the SNP since no all politics in Scotland are local).

  4. Anonymous • Disclaimer says:

    Scottish independence is now an inevitability.

  5. J Yan says:

    Wake me up when the queen is beheaded royals are dethroned.

  6. pyrrhus says:

    Given Britain’s grim long term economic future, with energy sources running out, massive food imports a necessity, and the albatross of muslim and African immigrants on welfare, Scotland may be better off to go it alone. The UK welfare state will not long survive…

    • Replies: @Jim
    , @AKAHorace
    , @Wizard of Oz
  7. Jim says:

    Is Scotland better able to sustain a welfare stae on its own? If they secede how will the oil fields be split?

    • Replies: @Wizard of Oz
  8. AnAnon says:
    @Priss Factor

    “American Jewish foreign policy messed up the Middle East but Europeans have to pay the price.” – Demographics are the primary cause of whats going on over there.

    As to Scottish independence, lets hope so, but the area is one giant welfare state. If they want self determination it is going to involve the sacrifice of the very welfare state they’d hope to preserve.

    • Replies: @Honorary Thief
  9. @AnAnon

    The only hope of Scottish rightism/conservativism/anti-welfare-statism is independence. Remove subordination to the larger UK, and the nationalist tendencies will be diverted in the rightward direction. Such is the order of things.

  10. AKAHorace says:


    If that was the way the SNP thought you would be right. Unfortunately for Scotland the SNP is even more pro immigrant than Labour.

  11. @pyrrhus

    If Great Britain is in trouble economically most of the rest of Europe is in a far worse state. And I’m not sure that its African immigration problem is even close to that of France and the Mediterranean members of the EU. Needs figures and consideration of the UK’s relatively free labor market.

  12. @Jim

    No, Scotland has been subsidised by England despite having oil at a much higher price than in 2015.

    • Replies: @Jim
  13. I have been looking for a way to get a big bet on the UK staying in the EU after the referendum. But the knowing punters have got there first and the odds are about 6 to 1 against a Yes vote.

    Why? Because the big money, really big money from the City of London, will be getting behind the PM – who will be campaigning for a No vote – and scaring the average citizen witless at the appalling risk they would be taking if they voted Yes, and people usually opt for the status quo anyway. But Cameron has been given a great opportunity to achieve some reform of the EU and of the UK’s position in it, starting with reforms the Germans (in particular) would like anyway. Cameron wouldn’t really want to curb immigration in a way which would reduce the UK’s competitive advantage in labour costs so it might be enough that he could reduce the burden that immigrants he can’t reject (ie. those from other EU countries) place on the welfare budget.

    If he’s well advised he will contrive to put so much responsibility on the Scottish devolved government that the prospect of not having Westminster to fall back on for help will scare the Scots off independence, especially as there will be plenty of Tories telling the Scots that they are welcome to secede.

  14. Jim says:
    @Wizard of Oz

    If the Scots want a very strong welfare state and are dependent on subsidies from the English then they probably won’t secede.

  15. Pedant says:

    The leader of UKIP is Nigel Farage, not Nicholas.

Current Commenter

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone

 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments have been licensed to The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Commenting Disabled While in Translation Mode
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Pat Buchanan Comments via RSS
The Surprising Elements of Talmudic Judaism
Analyzing the History of a Controversial Movement
How America was neoconned into World War IV