The Unz Review: An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewJames Petras Archive
US War Strategists: Military Defeats and Political Success
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks


In a previous article (‘US: The Century of Lost Wars”) I recorded the repeated US military defeats over the past two decades. In this discussion I will describe the role of military strategists who bear responsibility for the US defeats, but also for Israeli political successes.

The key to this apparent contradiction is to uncover how and why the destruction of Israeli adversaries prolonged costly US military invasions.

The two outcomes are inter-related. The same US military strategists whose policies lead to failed US wars in the Middle East facilitated and augmented the power of Israel.

US war strategists’ operations reflect ‘dual loyalties’. On the one-hand they receive their elite education and high positions in the US, while their political loyalties to Tel Aviv express their Israel First strategic decisions.

Our hypothesis is that dual loyalist strategists have fabricated threats, identified adversaries and committed hundreds of thousands of US soldiers to losing wars based on calculations that effectively increase Israeli power and influence in the Middle East.

We will proceed by identifying the war strategists and their policies and conclude by proposing an alternative framework for re-thinking the relationship between dual citizens and military strategy.

The ‘Best and the Brightest’: The Blind Ally of Military Defeats

There is an apparent contradiction between the high academic achievements of elite military strategists and their abominable record in pursuing military conflicts.

Most, if not all, policy makers who led the US in prolonged wars against Iraq, Somalia, Libya, Yemen, Afghanistan, Lebanon and Syria were Israel-firsters, either Zionists or Israeli ‘fellow travelers’.

In each of these wars, the Israel firster war strategists, (1) identified the enemy, (2) exaggerated the threat to the US and (3) grossly inflated the military capacity of the targeted country. They started with Iraq and Afghanistan and then proceeded to the other nations, all opponents of Israel.

By ‘coincidence’ all countries supported the Palestinians’ rights of self-determination and opposed Israeli annexation and colonization of Arab lands.

Driven by their loyalty to Israel’s ‘expansionist goals’, the military strategists ignored the ‘real world’ political and economic costs to the US people and state. Professional and academic credentials, nepotism and tribal loyalties, each contributed to the Israel firsters advance to securing strategic decision-making positions and elite advisory posts in the Pentagon, State Department, Treasury and White House.

Their policies led to an unending trillion-dollar war in Afghanistan; losing wars in Libya, Iraq and Syria; and costly economic sanctions against Iran.

The main beneficiary was Israel which confronted less political and military opposition; zero cost in lives and money; and substantial gains in territory.

Why did the Yale, Harvard, Princeton, Chicago, Johns Hopkins’ cum laude graduates repeatedly produce the worst possible military outcomes?

In part because the US acted as an instrument of another power (Israel). Moreover, the Israel firsters never were obliged to reflect in self-criticism nor to admit their failures and rectify their disastrous strategies..

Their refusal to assume their responsibilities resulted from several causes. Their criteria for success was based on whether their policies advanced Israeli goals, not US interests.

Moreover, while their decisions were objectionable to US citizens they were supported by the 52 Presidents of the Major American Jewish Organization including the powerful Zionist lobby, AIPAC, which dictated Middle East policy to both political parties and the US Congress.

Ordinarily, military strategists whose policies lead to repeated political disasters are denounced, fired or even investigated for treasons. In our experience nothing of the sort happened.

The best and the brightest rotated between six-digit jobs in Washington to seven-digit positions on Wall Street, or secured positions in lucrative law firms in Washington and New York (many with offices in Israel) or were appointed to prestigious academic posts in Ivy League universities.

What Should be Done?

There are countervailing measures which can lessen the impact of the strategic policies of the Israel Firsters. Academic Israel firsters should be encouraged to remain in Academia; rather than serve Israel in the State.

If they remain in the Ivory Tower they will inflict less destructive policies on American citizens and the state.

Secondly, since the vast-majority of Israel firsters are more likely to be arm chair war monger, who have not risked their lives in any of the wars that they promote, obligatory recruitment into combat zones would dampen their ardor for wars.

Thirdly, as matters stand, since many more Israel firsters choose to serve in the so-called Israeli Defense (sic) Force (IDF) they should reimburse US taxpayers for their free ride to education, health and welfare .

Fourthly, since most Israel firsters who volunteer to join the IDF prefer shooting unarmed Palestinian protesters, medics, journalists and kite flying kids they should be drafted into the US Army to serve in Afghanistan and face armed Taliban fighters surrounding Kabul, an experience which might knock a bit of realism in their dreams of converting the Middle East into an Israeli fiefdom.

Many national loyalties are forged by shared lives with families and friends of US soldiers who endure endless wars. Israel firsters dispatched to the war front would receive existential experiences that the Harvard, Princeton and Yale military strategists who make wars for Israel failed to understand.

Obligatory courses on the genocide of millions of Palestinian, Iraqi, Syrian, and Libyan people would enrich Israel firsters understanding of “holocausts’ in diverse ethno-religious settings.

Face to face encounters in life threatening military situations, where superior arms do not prevail, would deflate the hubris, arrogance and superiority complexes which fuel the tribal loyalties of Israel firsters.

In conclusion we offer modest suggestions for educated and cultured scientists, doctors, artists and entrepreneurs:

1/ Convert your skills to raising a new generation which will defend democratic values and social solidarity and eschew wars, persecution and phony claims of anti-semitism against critics of an ethnically exclusionary state.

2/ Forsake exclusive control of the mass media which glorifies Israeli war crimes and denigrates critics as ‘anti’ Semites for speaking truth to power.

Let’s join together to liberate America from military entanglements that privilege multi-billion-dollar have-nots to Israel while thirty million Us workers lack health coverage and forty percent of upstate New York children live in poverty.

Yes, there is an honorable place for everyone who joins in solidarity with the victims of Israeli First war strategists.

• Category: Foreign Policy • Tags: American Military, Israel, Israel Lobby 
Hide 72 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. We can no longer afford the luxury of political parties. They are not only anti-democratic prima facie, but leave our body politic susceptible to infection by foreign bodies, as our first president wisely observed in his farewell address to the nation:

    Parties become potent engines by which cunning, ambitious, and unprincipled men will be enabled to subvert the power of the people and to usurp for themselves the reins of government, destroying afterwards the very engines which have lifted them to unjust dominion”. The disorders and miseries which result gradually incline the minds of men to seek security and repose in the absolute power of an individual; and sooner or later the chief of some prevailing faction, more able or more fortunate than his competitors, turns this disposition to the purposes of his own elevation, on the ruins of public liberty.

    Without looking forward to an extremity of this kind (which nevertheless ought not to be entirely out of sight), the common and continual mischiefs of the spirit of party are sufficient to make it the interest and duty of a wise people to discourage and restrain it. It serves always to distract the public councils and enfeeble the public administration. It agitates the community with ill-founded jealousies and false alarms, kindles the animosity of one part against another, foments occasionally riot and insurrection. It opens the door to foreign influence and corruption, which finds a facilitated access to the government itself through the channels of party passions. Thus the policy and the will of one country are subjected to the policy and will of another“.

    • Replies: @Uncle Sam
  2. Miro23 says:

    And while they’re at it, they could investigate 9/11 and start arresting suspects.

    None of it is going to happen. US congressmen are blind on one subject, and no one will risk their career in academia, the media or elsewhere by honestly speaking about Israel or the US Jewish lobby.

    It’s a question of power and fear, so change will likely come externally through US military over-reach.

    There’s the famous saying that generals are always preparing to fight the last war, and the US is right on track with that one, ignoring the reality that the next major war is inevitably nuclear. Modern nuclear war means devastating strikes on US territory, vaporizing such places as New York, Washington or Los Angeles.

    There’s no real awareness of this, and the public doesn’t have a clue. At least the Russians have public nuclear shelters and regular evacuation drills so they can see the risk.

  3. Outlaw AIPAC.
    Require dual citizens to choose one or the other; those who do not choose America must be immediately deported.
    Pass a Constitutional amendment against granting military aid to ANY country.

  4. Ultimately, diaspora fealty to Likud politics is “not good for the Jews.”

  5. Sound, straightforward analysis by Petras. Yes, these serial, preemptive wars conducted by Washington against various foes of Israel are exactly what they seem to be: gangster operations designed to kill, incapacitate and maim. Does the term ‘mass murder’ not fit?

    The willful and needless destruction of weak, distant nations sure looks like an expression of pro-Zionist State Terror from my vantage point.

    What about yours?

    • Agree: RadicalCenter
  6. Realist says:

    In a previous article (‘US: The Century of Lost Wars”) I recorded the repeated US military defeats over the past two decades.

    When speaking of the US lost wars why leave out Korea and Vietnam?

    • Replies: @Herald
  7. Herald says:

    Probably because they are not too obviously related to Israel, though they are both indelible stains on the US copybook.

    • Replies: @Realist
  8. The “war strategists” do what they do because they’re evil. They’re “demon-possessed”; there’s no reasoning with them.

    I think not enough people are willing to acknowledge the moral culpability of those who willingly do the dirty work for a lie and a paycheck. It is the moral bankruptcy of the “order followers” that turns the evil thoughts and desires of the 0.1% into the horrific reality of the 99%. Those displaying the “mark of the beast” are the indispensable nuts and bolts of the Satanic empire.

    • Agree: Druid
    • Replies: @The Scalpel
  9. Realist says:

    Probably because they are not too obviously related to Israel, though they are both indelible stains on the US copybook.

    Agreed not related to Israel, but US losses just the same.

    • Replies: @Herald
  10. LondonBob says:

    The wars in MENA have been a disaster for the West, great triumphs for Israel. Give the neocons credit.

  11. TG says:

    Perhaps. But there is another potential angle here.

    A key point is that these wars were not merely failures – they were pointless. In other words, it made no military difference if the United States had won or lost. This means that of the trillions of dollars spent on such wars, there didn’t need to be any sort of real accounting, and the profits were sky-high. And the profits must continue to flow, as now so many of the rich are counting on them…

    In a real war – like WWII – there has to be at least some efficiency in procurement, or we could lose, and losing would have real consequences. Hence war profiteering, while it still existed, was kept within more-or-less tolerable levels. But in Afghanistan or Iraq etc? It doesn’t matter! Spend $1000/gallon of gasoline. Spend $100 million on a water treatment plant that never runs. A nice business to be in, if you can.

    • Replies: @jilles dykstra
  12. The US never went to wars to win. Only to sustain them for as long as possible.

    • Replies: @jilles dykstra
  13. Wally says:

    The more people learn about the scam of the fake ‘6,000,000 Jews’ the better.
    That easily debunked, impossible narrative is the sword and the shield for Israel / Jew Firsters.
    The scientifically impossible ‘6M Jews, 5M others, & gas chambers’ nonsense silences free speech and enables Jews & to push their violence inciting hatred down everyone’s throat. Which enables the wars where US soldiers die, US taxpayers pay, and Zionist thugs profit.

    Must reading here, the Revisionist comments and posted references are devastating to the vile ‘Holocaust Industry’. That fraud is finally being exposed in the mainstream.
    As Ron Unz says: “Does anybody seriously believe something so totally ridiculous?”
    American Pravda: Holocaust Denial, by Ron Unz:
    Challenging the ridiculously fake ‘6M Jews’ is now mainstream:
    on Irving & ‘holocaust’: Ron Unz: A Defender of Truth:

  14. The prime example of turning a defeat into a political success for me is Dunkirk 1940.
    Hitler, in an effort to get peace with Great Britain, let the British Expeditionary Force go, Churchill turned this defeat into a brilliant military success.

    • Replies: @Charles Carroll
  15. @General Hummus

    FDR did want to win, however, he did not want a quick defeat of Germany, without USA military involvement.
    The May 1941 Rudolf Hess papers still are secret, the only reason I can imagine is that Hess came with reasonable peace proposals.

    • Replies: @Charles Carroll
  16. @TG

    It reminds me of a statement in one of Deighton’s cold war spy novels ‘the object of the game is that the game is continued’.
    I suppose the same can be said about the war on drugs.

  17. Alfred says:

    Direct democracy – with internet voting on everything substantial – is the way to go. No bill that is more than one page long.

    One-year non-renewable terms for politicians who are there to implement that which the people have decided.

    Just look at what a scandal the Jews who largely control the British so-called Labour Party are making because their leader is trying to get the grassroots to choose their Members of Parliament. That is a small step in the right direction. When the decision-making is dispersed, it is impossible for the Jews to corrupt everyone.

    The Israelis are having a fit. Good.

    Corbyn’s Labour, which may soon govern UK, is now an anti-Israel protest group

  18. anon[317] • Disclaimer says:

    hypothesis: “dual loyalist strategists have fabricated threats, identified adversaries and committed hundreds of thousands of US soldiers to losing wars based on calculations that effectively increase Israeli power and influence in the Middle East.

    The hypothesis is not provable//disprovable as written, it needs to be broken down into its premises, and
    rewritten to make all of its assertions visible and to reduce its claims to a negative statement that can be proved wrong upon the showing of just one provable actual factual positive/ .
    1. what constitutes a dual loyalist. strategist? 8 million words might satisfy the explaination
    a. How is a military strategist identified? Hired hands holding positions in USA congress, or P or VP?
    Members of OPEC, Members of the Russian Federation, Members of AIPAC?
    Members of the Federal Reserve? University Professors? Mayors of Cities? Military Commanders?
    Employees of the Foreign Service? Lobbyist? Member of the Media?
    b. what qualifies a person to be a military strategist?
    is just being hired enough? is training evidenced by degree required, ?
    c. Are the grades and classes of such strategist?

    2. For strategic concerns how does one distinguish a
    a. fabricated threat from a real threat (are both not imaginary?)?
    b. fabricated adversary from a real adversary?
    c. a lost war if the war had no terminal outcome?

    3. what is a loyalist, what is a dual loyalist? What is a loyalist as it applies to military strategic planning?
    dual loyalist strategist

    (Israel loyal Trojans embedded by training, upbringing, wealth and culture into positions within the USA society that governs America )

    I argue that the peacetime military in the USA does not fight wars with outcome intent to win or lose. The object of such planned war is to create chaos. In every place ( d/n matter if the place is a nation state or just a tribe) that a person, party, government or leader threatens to or actually is a threat to the political power enjoyed by Israel or to the profit a wall street oil or public stock company or oligarch expects to make. In addition to benefiting Israel strategic military planned wars benefit Israeli companies ( both those based in UK, America, Saudi Arabia, and in Israel) and the profits and needs of these companies are a big part of the objects which the Israeli strategic military Trojan planners use their chaos induced by war to help.

    Chaos is the object of regime Change, privatization is post regime change toolused to prevent the place, person or thing chaosed from recovering. Privatization splinters the public domain into millions of privately controlled parts and allows the attacking powers to further develop the chaos over time, even after the military part of the war is over, or in suspense. Effectively, chaos and privatization make efficient governance impossible.

    But I agree with JP, until we quit analyzing articles without reference to standards, axioms, hypothesis or theories the list here will do nothing important, without reference to well documented standards, axioms, hypothesis or theories the comments will fail to achieve a result that humanity can use to deny those who produce and disseminate fraudulent propaganda or that humanity can use to identify and confront those who plan wars that benefit interest foreign to the purpose and intent of having the USA govern Americans.

    IMO the object of the comments ought to be transparent to the individual articles. Develop better more user friendly Fraud control methods should be the object of the comments as extracted from the articles. The purpose should be to empower the masses to understand the world they live in. how the world they live in is controlled by interest actually opposed to their needs and well-being, to identify who controls these opposed to the American Interest decision making, and to give the masses a better view of how they should view the world in which they live.

  19. Anonymous[373] • Disclaimer says:
    @Fidelios Automata

    Require dual citizens to choose one or the other, like these dual citizens?

    • But our citizenship is in Jewheaven. (Philippians 3:20)
    • So now you Gullible Goyim are no longer strangers and foreigners. You are citizens along with all of Jewgod’s holy Jew people. (Ephesians 2:19)

    These dual citizens, about 70% of the US, feel they owe it to the Jews.

    • For if the Gullible Goyim have shared in the Jews’ spiritual blessings, they owe it to the Jews to share with them their material blessings. (Romans 15:27)

    Should we ban the Jew Testament too? It’s worse than AIPAC.

  20. Desert Storm is the one exception to the string of defeats described in the article. Why? Because that war was about oil and protecting the petrodollar, i.e. US national interests. Because American interests were at stake, overwhelming force was used to accomplish the job as quick as possible. All of the middle eastern wars since them have been about shaping the strategic environment for Israel. The US is “winning” those (in the Charlie Sheen sense) only as long as the wars continue and more Muslims than Americans are getting killed. The US military is not incompetent or incapable, rather, they are being misused by political forces that see them as a tool and their servicemembers as mercenaries.

    • Replies: @Wally
  21. Sean says:

    The wars for Israel are coming to an end, after Iran gets crushed there will be no support for Palestinian terrorism and what the Israelis have been most afraid of all these years will come to pass: peaceful Palestinians winning the sympathy of the world and the diplomatic process moving inexorably forward to a substantial withdrawal from the West Bank. Zionism will collapse.

    Strongly suggestive of a genetic basis for the greater prevalence of affective disorder among Jews is their finding that among Jews bipolar affective disorder constituted a higher percentage of all affective disorder than was the case in gentile populations in the United States or Sweden. Individuals with bipolar affective disorder have periods of intense euphoria or paranoid‑anger as well as periods of despondency, worry, and hopelessness‑‑exactly the traits expected to characterize individuals who are extreme on affect intensity.

    [iii]. In an epidemiological study based on interviews of a stratified sample of the 1949‑1958 birth cohort in Israel, Levav and his colleagues (1993) found that bipolar affective disorder I (a form of manic‑depression) was more common among those deriving from Europe. The most common diagnosis was generalized anxiety disorder and labile personality disorder, the latter characterized by periods of depression and hypomania. Again, the suggestion is that Ashkenazi Jews have highly reactive nervous systems and are prone to alternating between intensely positive and intensely negative emotions.

    Even very intelligent people may not be able to see what their real interests are in the distant future. Strong support for the USSR was entirely mainstream in the American Jewish community for decades based on the elite status of Jews in the Soviet Union, but it eventually became clear, certainly by the 1970s and especially to neoconservative Jews, that the USSR was not good for the Jews any longer. As I emphasize in APTSDA, Jews are flexible strategizers (Richard Alexander’s felicitous term). When one strategy fails, another will be adopted.

    America has destroyed (Iraq) or is about to destroy (Iran) those supporting terrorism against Israel. The real enemy of Israel is the Palestinians of the occupied territories, who now present an insoluble problem for Israel if it wishes to remain a democratic and Jewish state.

    Now that Palestinian terrorism has been stymied by Sharon’s Wall and the toppling or alienation of friendly governments, the Palestinians’ weakness-mandated military passivity will make their moral case overwhelming. The cause of the peaceful Palestinian population will be irresistible to the international community. Bipartisan official US policy is for a Palestinian state. There can be little doubt what the erstwhile Israel lobby’s reaction will be when America brings about the begining of the end of the Zionist dream. These sensitive, emotional and reactive people will view it as a calamity visited on world Jewry by white Gentiles. Jewish-American public intellectuals will not start any more foreign wars (Israeli will be finished for Jews in the same way as South Africa is for whites: the best people leaving), but simply destroy white Gentile society by turning it against itself. And they have the people skills to do it.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    , @ploni almoni
  22. Ahoy says:

    @ Anonymous (373)
    Certainly the Jew Testament must be thrown out. The JewdeoChristian crap is an olive oil and vinegar mix. It needs continuous stirring. A nice Jewish game/trap that Christians fell in head first.

  23. One can only hope Dr. Alan Sabrosky’s words will come to fruition.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    , @Agent76
  24. Zionists and Zionist dual citizens control every facet of the U.S. government and MSM and MIC and have for over 100 years since the Zionist bankers got their FED passed through a corrupt congress which gave the Zionist bankers the ability to create money out of thin air and then charge the government and the people interest on this ether created money. Also in 1913 the Zionists got the IRS act passed and this allowed the gov to tax the incomes of Americans to pay for the wars that the Zionists were the instigators and agent provocateurs in starting with WWI right on down through the Mideast.

    Then the Zionists attacked America on 911 in a diabolical draconian attack that killed some 3000 Americans and was blamed on the Arabs when in fact the Zionists were the perpetrators of the attack and every thinking American knows that the Zionists and Zionist controlled deep state did the attack and gave them the excuse to plunge America into the Mideast slaughter house for Israels Zionist NWO.

    America will never be free until the Zionist privately owned FED is abolished and the IRS is repealed and the power to create money is returned to the U.S. gov as it was prior to December 23, 1913. As long as the Zionist bankers control our money we will never be free and the wars will continue for the profit of the Zionist bankers and the MIC.

    Orwell wrote in his book 1984 that the controllers did not want to win wars , the wars were meant to be continous and an enemy was needed and to be created if necessary and the wars served as control vehicle over the people and war hysteria kept the peoples minds off of their troubles and wars increased the power of the state and this is where the zionists have America today.

    The zionists have perfected their control over the U.S. and they are going to destroy America as all parasites always destroy their host.

    Read the PROTOCOLS OF ZION to see what the zionists have done and are doing to America.

  25. Anonymous[932] • Disclaimer says:

    To destroy white Gentile society was Jewsus’ goal. Read Matthew 20:25, Mark 10:42, and Luke 22:25. Jewsus was very specifically anti-Gentile.

  26. Anonymous[932] • Disclaimer says:
    @Johnny Walker Read

    Not while 75% of Americans worship a Jewish Rabbi who denounced Gentiles. They’re afraid of burning in hell forever, and will do anything to avoid the anger of Jewhovah.

  27. Wally says:
    @Wally Streeter

    “Because that war was about oil and protecting the petrodollar”

    Is that why European, Russian & Chinese firms got the lions share of the oil contracts?

    Oil, not. That’s just a ruse. Israel again.

    • Agree: Agent76
    • Replies: @Johnny Rico
  28. The Israeli gains and the American losses haven’t reached a tipping point in which the additional negative balances would severely impact the native born, i.e. the ones with dual personalities, traits and citizenship to the point of no return. In as much as every Jew wants to see the state of Israel firmly established in all its supposed previous territories as well as glories on the American taxpayers’ dime, he isn’t about to sacrifice his ease of life in America… he will only release enough leash that the dog under his control doesn’t choke to death or he isn’t given the runaround by the canine!

  29. Sean says:

    In 1993 there was the WTC truck bombing, which CIA Director James Woolsey said was the work of Iraqi Intelligence. In 2001 there was 9/11, and in 2003 the United States invaded Iraq and withdrew American military forces from Saudi Arabia.

    Osama bin Laden wanted U S forces out of Saudi Arabia, and the American deep state, intuitively understanding that Jews would ideologically implode America if Israel was defeated by suicide bombers, wanted an excuse to topple the suicide bomber-sponsoring Saddam. Everyone got what they wanted. Now the Saudis are firmly on the US side against their ancient Persian enemy, and and have lost interest in the Palestinians.

    • Replies: @Agent76
  30. Ahoy says:

    The third paragraph of your comment is ALL THE MONEY. Congrats!

  31. Agent76 says:

    September 28, 2018 Breaking! Putin in Azerbaijan: Israel will have to leave Moscow’s sphere of influence

  32. Agent76 says:

    Good post, and here is a accurate and informative read.

    November 20, 2005 Osama bin with Zbigniew Brzezinski, 1979

    Global Research Editor’s Note: This article originally published by Global Research in 2005 sheds light on the nature of Al Qaeda, an intelligence construct used by Washington to destabilize and destroy sovereign countries, while sustaining the illusion of an outside enemy, which threatens the security of the Western World.

    • Replies: @Sean
  33. Agent76 says:
    @Johnny Walker Read

    This article will reveal more than most even know about from the faux free press and be sure and help others view what they currently do not.

    September 07, 2016 September 11, 2001: The 15th Anniversary of the Crime and Cover-up of the Century “What Really Happened”?

    New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani to be trucked away and shipped to China – an order that constitutes disturbing a crime scene – which is a federal crime.

  34. Agent76 says:

    Sep 5, 2016 9/11 Suspects: Rudy Giuliani

    Mayor Giuliani oversaw the illegal destruction of the 9/11 crime scene and is criminally liable for the deaths of hundreds of emergency workers for not passing on prior warnings about the collapses of the Twin Towers.

  35. @Fidelios Automata

    I think you need to click your heels together first.

  36. Svigor says:

    In a previous article (‘US: The Century of Lost Wars”) I recorded the repeated US military defeats over the past two decades. In this discussion I will describe the role of military strategists who bear responsibility for the US defeats, but also for Israeli political successes.

    Winning according to the Petras Doctrine really isn’t on the War Party’s menu. The point is to secure Israel’s dominance by reducing any regional rival (largely successful), ensure constant US military presence in the region (largely successful), and justify DoD budgets (hugely successful).

  37. @Wally


    Did you know that they use oil to make the gasoline that makes your car go vroooom? Asking for a friend.

    • Replies: @Druid
    , @phil
  38. These people should be dealt with as traitors! The ones who aren’t decision making murderers, or who haven’t stolen money for themselves or Israel, should be shunned and be encouraged to give up their citizenship and move to an Israel that has been completely cut off and isolated. The thieves and criminals should be treated as traitors and have their citizenship revoked and their assets seized for starters. Depending upon the severity of their crimes, harsh prison sentences followed by deportation to Israel, or the death penalty should follow. Anything less is a mockery of everything from justice to the memories of the countless victims of the animals.

    Afterwards, similar justice should be dished out to their SJW cousins who have done everything possible to turn the nation upside-down and destroy it.

    Should these psychopathic traitors get leniency just because of their tribal affiliation?

    • Replies: @Druid
  39. Sean says:

    There had been a large US army in presence in Saudi Arabia for over a decade, but it left in 2003.
    They invaded one Arab oil producing country and left another.

    • Agree: Agent76
  40. Realist says:

    What Should be Done?

    It doesn’t matter what should be done….what matters is what will be done.
    The answer to that is nothing

  41. Realist says:
    @Fidelios Automata

    Outlaw AIPAC.

    Better yet outlaw stupidity…neither will be done.

    • Replies: @Druid
  42. Druid says:
    @Johnny Rico

    Did you know that Iraq and Iran SELL oil at reasonable prices. No need to go to war for it. The wars are for Israel. Your not acknowledging or realizing this makes you suspect

    • Replies: @Johnny Rico
  43. Druid says:

    Why deported to Israel. That’s a Palestinian homeland stolen by these Zios.

    • Replies: @OilcanFloyd
  44. This goes back to the Boer War when Cecil Rhodes and others, most effectively Alfred Milner, got the idea of waging war to seize natural resources, like the gold mines in South Africa. This idea grew into an elite club that works to conquer the world for the Anglo Saxon white race. They plotted to annihilate Germany secretly forging alliances with Russia and France unknown to the British Government except for the elite’s members. With the help of the Rothschilds, they established the misnamed Federal Reserve in 1913 which was used to finance WW1 a year later. They lit the fuse in the Balkans with their agents stirring up trouble. Germany was beat after one year, but the bankers kept financing and providing arms to them causing the deaths of millions for 3 more years. They have no regard for life. They invented the concentration camps in South Africa where they killed 40,000 women and children. They just ruthlessly pursue their goal. What is going on in the ME parallels this M.O. They have infiltrated the U.S. and have partnered with Israel. They now want to annihilate Russia. The states in the ME are their stepping stones, and they have no regard for the troops or people of the ME. NATO is pushing eastward towards Russia in preparation for the war. They have faith in their technology to succeed in a first strike. The Deep State is going after Trump, because he is not anti-Russian.

    • Replies: @Druid
    , @Shahna
  45. @Fidelios Automata

    But AIPAC are our new founding fathers who replaced the Constitution with the Patriot Act.

  46. @jilles dykstra

    The success being that Germany is now a vassal state of the empire.

  47. @Sean

    What you are really going to do is simply kill all those Palestinians. Who are you kidding? Your real goal is to murder them and to follow Deuteronomy: Leave nothing that breathes alive. Mendacity flows out of every orifice.

  48. @jilles dykstra

    After Stalingrad, Washington got very afraid that the USSR was going to overrun all of Europe, so they had to get involved.

  49. What you are really going to do is simply kill all those Palestinians. Who are you kidding? Your real goal is to murder them and to follow Deuteronomy: Leave nothing that breathes alive. Mendacity flows out of every orifice. You are the terrorist, not the Iraqis, not the Iranians. You. And you will kill more afterwards because that is your nature.

    • Agree: Druid
  50. Druid says:

    I am at a loss to understand how we let a POS ME country with it’s sociopathic Talmudist followers (qualify obviously not all the people there) use and abuse us, bankrupt us with their wars, etc., etc

    • Replies: @Anon
  51. Druid says:
    @Charles Carroll

    So true and well said. Rhodes was a murdering, thieving psychopath. He first cheated, the annihilated the Matabele

  52. Druid says:

    Unfortunately, you’re right, though I might change stupidity to ignorance. I meet more people who in their gut know something is horribly wrong but don’t know or research at all

  53. The author apparently fails to understand that the object of US instigated wars is fighting wars not winning them. Won wars generate no profits.

    • Agree: Shahna
  54. The Scalpel says: • Website
    @Harold Smith

    “It is the moral bankruptcy of the “order followers” that turns the evil thoughts and desires of the 0.1% into the horrific reality of the 99%. ”

    This is the simple answer to the question, “Why is there war?”

  55. Anon[364] • Disclaimer says:

    Not at all difficult to understand.

    “For if the Gentiles have shared in the Jews’ spiritual blessings, they owe it to the Jews to share with them their material blessings.” (Romans 15:27)

    Christians care way more about a silly afterlife narrative than anything you might consider important in real life on earth.

  56. Uncle Sam says:
    @Godfree Roberts

    The American political system based on the ideology of a constitutional republic has collapsed and cannot be revived. This collapse is largely due to the fact that the Jewish people have made a complete, total and utter mockery out of that system. That is the principal reason; there are other reasons as well but they are beyond the scope of this brief commentary.

    This political system largely benefits the Jews and their Gentile camp followers. It is highly injurious to the Gentile population of this country. In fact, it is a danger to them because they could be incinerated in a nuclear holocaust. Moreover, under the so-called “democratic process” people who are citizens in theory can and should participate in it. However, if they want to, they have to be willing to expose themselves to criticism, opposition and/or different points of view. Just about every lobby in America has an opposition and they, for the most part, do not demonize, slander or vilify their opposition.

    However, with the Jewish pro-Israel lobby the situation is radically different. The Jews, since they consider themselves to be a special people, will brook no criticism or opposition. In other words, they take maximum advantage of this system for their own selfish reasons and label people who oppose them or criticize them as anti-Semites, bigots , racists and so on. With their control of the mass media and the monetary system they can enforce this intellectual terrorism. And in the process make a mockery out of this system.

    In short, if you want to participate in a political process and do not wish to be opposed or criticized, then stay the hell out of it.

    At the time the founding fathers established this country, only white men who owned property could vote. They probably could not have foreseen how the constitutional republic that they set up would devolve into a plutocracy. In their time, it does not appear that money played such an important and corrosive role in politics. If they could see how the system they set up has been so perverted and denigrated thru money and mass communication propaganda, I do not think they would have established a constitutional republic.

    The Jews, on the other hand, consider plutocracy as their most effective and practical way of having and maintaining power. This poses a serious problem for Gentile Americans because there is no way they can confront this power. They cannot defend themselves against the Jewish power. In others words, “democracy” or the “democratic process” are detrimental to their needs and wants, and could become deadly.

    The only solution to this problem is the proverbial man on the white horse, i.e., a Caesar, a Napoleon, Mussolini or Hitler. Anyone who thinks otherwise is kidding himself.

    • Replies: @Phil
  57. denk says:

    Trump got his comeuppance.

  58. Shahna says:

    There is an apparent contradiction between the high academic achievements of elite military strategists and their abominable record in pursuing military conflicts.

    Not sure why you find it necessary to highlight the ‘apparent’ as tho’ it’s not really so. The US has had, in its entirety, two military successes: their civil war and their war against Grenada.

  59. Shahna says:
    @Charles Carroll

    They invented the concentration camps in South Africa where they killed 40,000 women and children.

    And they killed them by adding ground glass to their food.
    …That’s the Brits for you.

    Real, proper, decent, “our values” people.

  60. phil says:
    @Johnny Rico

    Believe it or not, the US is now the world’s #1 energy producer.

  61. @Druid

    Why not an isolated and defunded Israel? Where should they go? They’ve already proven over and over and over that they can’t live among other people without lying, cheating, stealing, killing, and causing constant chaos. I understand that the Palestinians have been wronged, but that isn’t my fight

  62. Ahoy says:

    If Trump succeeds on the America First, maybe America will avoid the fate of a third world country. A path that the Rabis have led the country to.

    • Replies: @Harold Smith
  63. @Ahoy

    “If Trump succeeds on the America First, maybe America will avoid the fate of a third world country. A path that the Rabis have led the country to. ”

    First, how can Trump “succeed” at something that he’s not trying to do? (Obviously, he puts jewish/israeli interests first). Second what exactly is a “third world country” and what is its ineluctable “fate” as such? Third, that video is about 2.5 years old and it’s long since clear to anyone paying attention that Trump is a jew puppet ruler, so how is it that the “jewish elite” hate Trump? To quote one comment on the video:

    “The Jewish elite do not hate Trump. If they did his daughter wouldn’t be married to one, he never would have been successful in life, and he never would have had an Evangelical Christian (sic) cuck as his running mate.”

    Like many others, David Duke has been fooled.

  64. Ahoy says:

    @ Harold Smith

    I agree with the picture you describe. Intuitively, I don’t believe he is another Johnson who ate up the *Liberty*or Bush the lesser with the Twin Towers. Also, Soros is waging a war against him since day one and his closest associates. General Flynn, whom they tried to put to jail, was in St. Louis the other day to receive some award, and during his acceptance speech he lent his voice to Patrik Henry’s cry *Give me Liberty or give me Death*.

    May be I pay too much attention on non front page news. In the M.E. he gave them Jerusalem (a no hamburger for the U.S.) instead of boots on the ground that Netanyahu is desparately asking for.

    Third world country. Ukraine. With the exception there the Nazis are ok with Soros, in the U.S. no. Would you ever expect this to happen in New York? California is worse.

    • Replies: @Harold Smith
  65. @Ahoy

    “Intuitively, I don’t believe he is another Johnson who ate up the *Liberty*or Bush the lesser with the Twin Towers.”

    Neither do I; Trump is obviously far worse.

    “Also, Soros is waging a war against him since day one and his closest associates. ”

    Also, Assad gassed his own people; and Vladimir Putin poisoned the Skripals; and Iran is building nuclear weapons; etc., etc., etc.

    The problem with claims like this is that is they’re just words; cheap talk. They’re bare assertions. The air is thick with such claims, and I’ve learnt that you generally can’t take them at face value; rather, you have to do a little observation and reasoning before you decide what to believe.

    For example, it doesn’t make sense to me that Assad would “gas his own people” since he would have nothing to gain by so doing and he would risk creating a pretext for an attack by the U.S. government. Similarly, it doesn’t make sense that Putin would want to kill the Skripals; or that he would use nerve gas even if he did.

    Since Trump’s foreign policy is basically a continuation/escalation of Obama’s foreign policy, and since Soros didn’t seem to have a problem with Obama, I don’t see any reason why Soros would be “waging a war” against Trump (whatever that exactly means). If Trump actually did pull the troops out of Afghanistan and Syria, refused to arm the “government” of Ukraine, etc. (i.e. if Trump actually put America first) then I could at least see a plausible reason for anti-Trump animus by the establishment. But as it is now, no, I don’t believe anyone is “out to get” Trump.

    “Third world country. Ukraine. With the exception there the Nazis are ok with Soros, in the U.S. no. Would you ever expect this to happen in New York? California is worse.”

    Expect what to happen? What is it that makes a country “third world”?

  66. Ahoy says:

    @ Harold Smith

    If you think that picture of to day’s New York, is a sign of a first rate coyntry, then I give up.

    On Ukraine start with history 101 to discover Catherine the Great and slowly come up to New York mega banker Schiff, who send Trotsky with mountains of money to kill the Tsar’s family . He, together with Rockeffeller and Morgan, bought the FED from Wilson and enslaved the American people. The big march toward wold domination started immediately after WW2.

    If Trump follows globalist Zion policy because his son in law is a Jew remains to be seen. Many times the phenomena deceive. In the case of Ukraine the Obama times, Nouland policy, has been thrown out the window regardless what Pompeo says.

    • Replies: @Harold Smith
  67. @Ahoy

    “If you think that picture of to day’s New York, is a sign of a first rate coyntry, then I give up.”

    I asked you what I thought was a simple question. I asked you what you meant by a “third world country.”

    But rather than answer the question, you wave your hands, rant about Ukraine, and post a picture (bereft of any explanation) of a woman stepping over barricade tape at a subway station apparently somewhere in NY city.

    Then, apparently with regard to the picture, you ask me:

    “Would you ever expect this to happen in New York?”

    Since the picture was presented without any explanation, I asked you: “Expect what to happen?”

    What was I supposed to infer from the picture; that the sine qua non of a third world country is an overweight woman stepping over barricade tape at a subway station somewhere?

  68. Agent76 says:

    Dec 7, 2015 The U.S. School That Trains Dictators & Death Squads

    On November 22, thousands gathered at the gates of Fort Benning, GA at the 25th annual protest of the School of the Americas to memorialize the tens of thousands of people who lost their lives at the hands of the U.S. Empire’s brutally repressive juntas it used to rule Latin America by force.

Current Commenter

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone

 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments have been licensed to The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All James Petras Comments via RSS
Talk TV sensationalists and axe-grinding ideologues have fallen for a myth of immigrant lawlessness.
The unspoken statistical reality of urban crime over the last quarter century.
Which superpower is more threatened by its “extractive elites”?
How a Young Syndicate Lawyer from Chicago Earned a Fortune Looting the Property of the Japanese-Americans, then Lived...
Becker update V1.3.2