The Unz Review: An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewJohn Derbyshire Archive
The Sound of Europe: So Long, Farewell, Political Center
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

A striking feature of last weekend’s AmRen conference—other than its youthfulness, I mean—was its international flavor.

There were ten speakers. Subtracting out Jared Taylor’s address and Sam Dickson’s traditional benediction, the other eight broke out by nationality as: a Mexican, a South African, an Estonian, two Belgians, and three Americans. (I’m counting Editor Peter Brimelow as an American).(Videos of James Edwards, Peter Brimelow, Fernando Cortés, Filip Dewinter, and Jared Taylor are now available at


That’s appropriate, because there have been some National Question developments particularly in Europe that are worth noting.

  • Austria

There’s an Austrian presidential election every six years, on a straight popular vote.

They just had that election. [Austria far right thwarted, Van der Bellen elected president, BBC, May 23, 2016] The winner was a chap named Alexander Van der Bellen, who ran as an independent. That was surprising enough in itself, as political power in Austria tends to belong to one or other of the two biggest parties, one center-right and one center-left.

In this presidential election, both of those parties were eliminated in the first round of voting a month ago. The center-left placed fourth, the center-right placed fifth. The two leading candidates went to a run-off election, and that’s the one we had last week.

The winner, and so the new president, ran as an independent. But in practice he’s a Left-liberal environmentalist. Austria’s a very pretty country—think mountains, lakes, edelweiss, lederhosen, and so on. Naturally environmentalism is strong there.

It’s surprising enough by itself for an independent to win the presidency. What’s even more surprising is that Mr. Van der Bellen won by just a whisker over his runoff opponent, Norbert Hofer of the Freedom Party. The actual size of the whisker: 0.7 percent, or about one vote out of 150.

The Freedom Party is the one you see tagged with the epithet “Far Right” in the Main Stream Media.

But since they just got 49.7 percent of the popular vote against Mr. Van der Bellen’s 50.3 percent, it seems a bit odd to call them “far” anything. There were seventeen American presidential elections in which the winning candidate got less of the popular vote than did Mr. Hofer. The list includes, for example, Harry Truman in 1948, Bill Clinton in both ’92 and ’96, Woodrow Wilson in both 1912 and 1916, and of course Abraham Lincoln in 1860. Do those presidents get an epithet beginning with the word “far”? If not, why not?

Mr. Hofer’s Freedom Party gets called “Far Right” because they’re National Conservatives who want to stop the Third World invasion of their country. The Left of course will tell you that, no, it’s because among their supporters are fans of the 20th century’s most famous Austrian—and I’m not talking about Maria von Trapp.

I’m sure they’re right. I have worked in politics at the ground level, attending constituency meetings for my local chapter of the Conservative Party back in the Margaret Thatcher years. Let me tell you, in case you don’t know: Politics at the base level attracts a fair number of lunatics.

Most people, however, even most constituency activists, are not lunatics. Should Austria’s Freedom Party win the next parliamentary election two years from now, Austria will not invade Poland or start erecting gas chambers. Trust me on this.

Austria of course, with no offense to anyone, is not a very important place. What happened there this election, though, is happening all over. The Center Left and Center Right are losing market share. They’re losing to, on the one hand, tree-hugging anti-capitalists like Mr. Van der Bellen and Bernie Sanders—another politician from a small, pretty, mountainous place—and on the other hand to secure-borders nationalists like Mr. Hofer and Donald Trump.

The pattern is unmistakable. Manual workers in Austria went 86 percent for Mr. Hofer; he only got 40 percent of white-collar workers.

Over to the U.S.A., where analyst Thomas Edsall just reported in the New York Times that Mrs. Clinton’s support among white men without college degrees is at fourteen percent.

That is a simply sensational figure. This is the Democratic Party, remember—the lunch-pail party, the party of the little guy. White men without college degrees,fourteen percent for the party’s presumptive nominee. That’s pretty much a lunatic fringe. Fourteen percent.

I note in passing, by the way, that Edsall’s column I just quoted bears the title:How Do You Solve a Problem Like Trump? [May 25, 2016]

Looks like Edsall has Austria on his mind, too.

  • Slovakia.

That’s the eastern bit of what we Cold War survivors recall as . Before it was Czechoslovakia it belonged to the D ual Monarchy of Austria-Hungary.

Visegrad_Four_vs._Merkel—Europe_In_The_Balance_VDARE_-_premier_news_outlet_for_patriotic_immigration_reform_-_2016-05-30_01.13.14Radio Derb devotees will recall us covering Slovakia back in February as one of the Visegrad Four nations: Pol and, Hungary, Czechia, and Slovakia, all of them robustly nationalist. I swooned over Slovakian Prime Minister Robert Fico’s saying back then that:

We will never make a voluntary decision that would lead to the formation of a unified Muslim community in Slovakia … Multi-culturalism is a fiction.

I mentioned that Slovakia had an election coming up in March. They duly had it.Mr. Fico is still Prime Minister, though now as head of a four-party coalition. [President Kiska will authorise Fico to form government, Slovak Spectator March 7, 2016

He’s still nationalist, too. Last week, in an interview with a local newswire service, the Prime Minister said: “It may look strange but sorry … Islam has no place in Slovakia.”

The European Union is trying to force quotas of so-called “asylum seekers” on all the countries of Europe. Prime Minister Fico is firmly against those quotas.

This small and inconsequential country is giving a big lesson. Mr. Fico’s party actually is center-left. It’s a Social Democratic party. He himself was once a Communist Party member.

So here’s an alternative for the Center Left and Center Right: Instead of watching your working-class support drain away to nationalists, steal some of the nationalists’ clothes.

Slovakia actually does have a strongly nationalist party: Marian Kotleba’s People’s Party. In those March elections they got eight percent of the vote, up from less than two percent last time around. They now have seats in parliament for the first time ever.

That’s why Center Left Prime Minister Fico is stealing their nationalist clothes. It’s roughly like Hillary Clinton calling for strict enforcement of our immigration laws, if you can imagine that.

Message to the centrist parties re nationalism: If you can’t beat ’em, join ’em.

But generally, it’s not happening.

The new party on the block: Alternative for Germany, AfD for short. AfD is a National Conservative party, and they are racking up double-digit percentages in local elections.

Earlier this month the AfD, at its annual conference, inserted the sentence “Islam does not belong to Germany” into its official policy platform.

That of course got the globalists gasping and sputtering. Here for example is German pundit Anna Sauerbrey [Email her] sputtering in English for the New York Times:

[AfD] refers to German culture as the “einheimische Kultur”—native culture—and describes the German nation as “a cultural unit” under threat from immigrant cultures. Its program for the state election in Baden-Württemberg in March stated: “Germany’s cultural foundation is being smashed by immigration.” …

It follows, at least for the new German right, that cultures can be compared and ranked—some are worth preserving, while others are invasive and inferior. German culture is under constant risk of losing its purity, and its defense is a core role of the state. It is a thinly veiled update of the old racist ideologies: culturism as the new racism.

[What Is German?, May 26, 2016]

familyofgermansSee how far the Left has traveled here? Time was they would scream and sputter at you for saying that some races are better than others. “It’s nothing to do with biology,” they’d shriek, “it’s just culture!” Now they scream and sputter if you say that some cultures are better than others.(Pictured right, the German MSM’s satirical picture of”einheimische Kultur”–and below that, the AfD’s reply.)

What people like Ms. Sauerbrey seem unable to grasp is that it is possible—in fact it’s rather familyofnongermansingermanycommon—to be against mass immigration without holding any opinion at all about whether one culture is better or worse than another.

I for example am fine with Islam. If people want to be Muslims, that’s absolutely OK with me. I don’t mind a bit. Jolly good luck to them. There are fifty-odd majority-Muslim nations where they can live out their lives in Islamic culture. Far as I’m concerned, they’re welcome to do so. I wish them joy.

If you want to be a Muslim, or a Zoroastrian, or an anarcho-syndicalist, or a blood-drinking head-hunter—go ahead. I wouldn’t dream of trying to interfere.

Just please stay in your own countries and be those things. Leave me in my country to enjoy the culture I grew up in and am familiar with: Modern, Western, not-very-religious, sexually egalitarian, easy-going, English-speaking social-democratic culture.


Is my culture better than yours? Pass. Is Islam a stupid, cruel, and wrong-headed religion? No idea. Does Sharia law entail a shackling, an enslavement of the human spirit? Beats my pair of jacks. Just, please, leave me the heck alone with the culture I know and am happy in; and I’ll return the favor.

Again, the German Center parties show no sign of adapting to the National Conservative challenge and recognizing this point.

But we have a saying here on the Alt Right (Dissident Right): That’s what separate countries are for.

John Derbyshire [email him] writes an incredible amount on all sorts of subjectsfor all kinds of outlets. (This no longer includes National Review, whose editors had some kind of tantrum and fired him. ) He is the author of We Are Doomed: Reclaiming Conservative Pessimism and several other books. He’s had two books published by FROM THE DISSIDENT RIGHT (also available in Kindle) and From the Dissident Right II: Essays 2013. His writings are archived

(Republished from VDare by permission of author or representative)
• Category: Foreign Policy • Tags: European Right, Immigration 
Hide 14 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. What, exactly, is wrong in that photo of the AfD prototypical family? If that’s what your enemies say about you, they’re doing your job of advertising.

  2. Richard says:

    There was a similar incident a few months ago when promoters of the Amazon series “The Man in the High Castle” put out an ad showing a 1950s type family with Aryan trappings, which they thought would strike the modern American as horrifying. After all, in Hollywood the twin peaks of evil are Nazi Germany and 1950s America. But it backfired on social media; amid the social dysfunction of 2016, a happy, confident white nuclear family living in a clean well-maintained neighborhood looks downright heavenly.

    They deleted it from their twitter feed.

    • Replies: @D. K.
    , @SFG
  3. Boris says:

    That’s what separate countries are for.

    I agree. Look at all of these awesome countries you could move to. Alt-right paradises, one and all. Go for it, you guys! I hear Slovakian women are quite friendly.

    • Replies: @D. K.
  4. “Czechia”?

    Bohemians and Moravians want us to call them by that atrocity? That’s like Turin’s asking us to
    use the name of a dodgy old Ford for their fair city.

    “Beijing” is unpronounceable in English; “Kolkata” looks stupid; “Mumbai” sounds stupid, as does “Myanmar”, “Yangon”, “Belarus”, “Moldova”, usw.— and “Sri Lanka” is nothing to write home about.

    These names may sound perfectly beautiful in their native tongues, but not in ours. That’s why we gave them august, euphonious, Anglicized counterparts. (Yes, OED, I capitalized “Anglicized”, and used a zed. So there!)

    “Kingdom of the Moravians and the Bohemians”, or KoMBo, sounds just fine to me.

  5. Rehmat says:

    I know John Derbyshire’s Israeli brothers are very happy over the victory of the anti-Muslim White supremacist party.

    But Slovakia’s Robert Fico has a long history of “Love Israel, Hate Muslim” policy.

    On Wednesday, Robert Fico, Israel-First Zionist prime minister of Slovakia began his third term by stepping up his anti-Muslim rhetoric just before the country takes over the EU Council presidency next month.

    “It may look strange but sorry – Islam has no place in Slovakia. The problem is not migrants coming in, but rather in them changing the face of the country,” he claimed.

    Fico supported his anti-Muslim rhetoric by quoting an advice from Maltese counterpart Joseph Muscat, who also fears the Muslim immigrants could bring back 220-year Muslim rule. Fisco also recommended that like Israel, European nations should use DNA test on all potential immigrants.

    Zuzana Števulová, Human Rights League, has condemned Fisco’s remarks in a statement, saying: “We are disgraced by the public statements of Prime Minister and by this letter we wish to show support to Islamic Foundation and its community, which lives with us peacefully for long years. Islamic Foundation in Slovakia acts as most visible voice of Muslims living in Slovakia and provides spiritual, cultural and social services to its community. Islamic Foundation is led by Mr. Mohammad Safwan Hasna.”

    There are nearly 5,000 Muslims living among 5.4 million country’s population – 68% of which is Catholic. The Slovak Christian majority refuse to forget the 150-year Turkish presence in the country, taking it as a pretext to bear grudge towards modern Muslims. Bratislava has refused to let Muslims build a mosque on a 1,000-square-meter plot since 2000.

    Like the rest of European nations, Slovakians too have been put to shame by the Holocaust Industry for killing or expelling tens of thousands of Jews during WWII. The Zionist Mafia claims that 88,951 Jews lived in Slovakia in the 1940s, of which only 800 remains in the country.

    Robert Fico has visited Israel on several occasions since 2007. In 2014, in a speech at the Holocaust memorial function in Bratislava Robert Fico apologized to the world Jewry for his country’s persecution of Slovakian Jews during WWII.

    • Replies: @D. K.
    , @RadicalCenter
  6. D. K. says:

    Had you grown up in your now-claimed country, the United States, from mid-1945 until your eighteenth birthday, Mr. Derbyshire, you would have found it quite religious, not very sexually egalitarian, and not very social-democratic. We were, however, overwhelmingly English-speaking, very modern, in the non-ideological sense of the word, unselfconsciously Western, and reasonably easy-going. It was a culture that suited us, and about which we were both content and optimistic. Most of us who lived through those years, even as young children of the Baby Boom Generation, miss it like our long-dead family members.

  7. D. K. says:

    My first-generation Slovak-American mother and her three sisters all were (and, in one case, still is) friendly. As for their relatives in Eastern Europe, after two generations under the jackboots of barbarians named Boris, and the like, it is a wonder that their women remain friendly at all.

  8. The center left and the center right are neither left right nor center. They are in it for the money. Ideology is bad for business. Both left and right in the U.S. have been driven into the political wilderness where they wandered for a generation leaving only Democrats and Republicans. BUT NOW THEY ARE BACK. We can have politics again!

  9. D. K. says:

    Feel free to list, for us all, all of the Muslim countries that allow White Christians from European countries to immigrate into the former, Rehmat.

  10. D. K. says:

    That poster beautifully illustrates the view of “liberal” American Jewry of 1950s America. Thus, the Immigration Act of 1965, courtesy of Representative Celler, et al. . . .

  11. @TomSchmidt

    This is a perfect example of the contempt the Left has for the ordinary person. A nuclear family with the wife staying home and baking cakes, three kids brought up traditionally? Obviously barely-educated scum of the earth and must be destroyed.

    Here in the U.S., this family would be called “rednecks”. The entire agenda of the Left is built on hating people like them.

    • Replies: @RadicalCenter
  12. @Rehmat

    I’d take Fico over Obama, Bushes, or Clintons any day.

    Get the fuck out, Rehmat.

  13. @Bizarro World Observer

    We have three kids and will try for more. We work hard to raise them fair but tough and proud.

    Fuck you, Rehmat pedophileprophet worshippers and negroes. Bring it on.

  14. SFG says:

    I thought it was supposed to be the contrast between the nice, happy family and the Nazi imagery…like one of those posters where everything looks great and then you notice the dead body or something.

Current Commenter

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone

 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments become the property of The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All John Derbyshire Comments via RSS