The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewJohn Derbyshire Archive
I'm Impressed with Neil DeGrasse Tyson (Whoever He Is) On El Paso Shootings
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

Adapted from the latest Radio Derb, available exclusively on

Last week’s headliners were two mass shootings: one in El Paso, Texas last Saturday morning, followed in the small hours of Sunday morning by another in Dayton, Ohio. The El Paso shooter killed 22 people; the second killed nine. The El Paso guy is in custody; the Dayton one was killed by police.

Sincere condolences from Radio Derb to the wounded and bereaved. But this is a nation of a third of a billion people, though, and ghastly things will happen—some of them by human agency, some by natural catastrophes.

I guess my attitude is just fatalistic. Of the public reactions to these two events, the only one that really returned an echo from my bosom was the one by TV astronomer Neil deGrasse Tyson. Tweeted Tyson on Sunday:

Tyson’s tweet occasioned much screeching and pearl-clutching from goodthinking types. [Dr. Neil deGrasse Tyson slammed for tweet about mass shooting data, by Nick Givas, Fox News, August 6, 2019] He responded with a half-hearted apology, which of course nobody accepted.[Neil deGrasse Tyson’s Tweet About Mass Shootings Was Bad. His Apology May Have Been Worse, by Justin Bariso,, August 7, 2019]

I can’t claim much engagement with Tyson. I’ve never read one of his books or watched one of his TV programs.

That’s not from any antipathy; I know next to nothing about the guy. The only pop-science books I read are ones editors send me for review, and it just happens that no-one’s sent me one of Tyson’s books. I don’t watch much TV—some conservative commentary, currently Tucker Carlson, and now and then a sitcom that tickles my fancy.

So I’ve totally missed Tyson, without prejudice. (Except that, like everyone else not thoroughly brainwashed, I assume by reflex that any black person doing science on TV is an Affirmative-Action hire. Reflexes like that are among the evil consequence s of Affirmative Action, and I don’t think tell us anything important about either the subject or the object).

I’m with Tyson on this one, anyway. I’m a numbers guy, and plainly so is he. With news events like this all sorts of cognitive biases kick in. You could start your googling with the phrase “salience bias.”

That especially applies when politicians and their media stooges amp up the salience for all they’re worth.

Sorry, but I prefer the cooler numerical approach. Hey, Mr. Tyson: You ever in Long Island? I’ll buy you a drink. I’m an astronomy buff from way back; my high school had a 12-inch reflector.

And of course the politicians and pundits milked the killings for all they were worth. Since competitive politics right now is mostly among contenders for next year’s Democratic Presidential nomination, and pundits break about nine to one Democrat, most of the commentary blamed the events on President Trump and the 63 million deplorables who, in violation of all the laws of nature, voted for him in 2016.

Squeezing political points out of the El Paso and Dayton horrors wasn’t easy, though.

It looked at first as if it was going to be easy. Both the shooters were white, so the Main Stream Media could freely portray them as psychopathic monsters. Well, they are—or in the Dayton guy’s case, were—psychopathic monsters; but then, so are the black murderers who commit most of our mass shootings but get way less media coverage and generate very little interest among politicians.

And then, the El Paso killer had (allegedly) posted a manifesto online. It’s 2,400 words—which is fairly brief, as these things go. The manifesto of 2011 Norwegian mass killer Anders Breivik ran to half a million words.[ Breivik sent ‘manifesto’ to 250 UK contacts hours before Norway killings, by Matthew Taylor, Guardian, July 26, 2011]

There was enough in those 2,400 words, though, for the CultMarx mob to argue that the killer was inspired by President Trump–even though the killer himself, in the manifesto, explicitly told us he’d formed his ideas before Trump showed up.

The main point that got the CultMarx mob’s attention: the killer writing that:

This attack is a response to the Hispanic invasion of Texas … I am simply defending my country from cultural and ethnic replacement brought on by an invasion.

With a hundred thousand people a month coming in across our southern border without permission, terms like “invasion” and “ethnic replacement” don’t seem hyperbolic to me. And yes, some of Donald Trump’s past statements indicate similar lines of thinking; although in two and a half years as Chief Executive he hasn’t actually done much to defend our nation’s demographic stability.

Other notions expressed in the El Paso guy’s manifesto are un-Trumpian or actually anti-Trumpian; he grumbles about corporate greed and the degradation of the environment, for instance.

So the guy has a lot of different beefs he was working off, some of them approximately Trumpian. The way he worked them off was by murdering 22 random strangers in a Walmart store. That was insane; and yes, the guy is a psychopathic monster.

Crazy people get their inspiration the way the rest of us do, from listening, reading, and personal experience. What they then do with their inspiration tells you nothing about the content of the source material.

Fifty years ago l ast week—August 9th, 1969—Charlie Manson and his gang murdered Sharon Tate and four other people in Beverly Hills. Manson claimed a Beatles song, “Helter Skelter,” as his inspiration.

This tells you absolutely nothing about the Beatles, or about their music, or about people who like their music.

And nobody ever claimed it did.

Crazy people do crazy stuff for reasons that make sense to no-one but themselves.

They’re crazy.


Milking last weekend’s horrors for CultMarx talking points got even more difficult—or, as the progressives say, “problematic”—when it turned out that the Dayton killer was Antifa. He didn’t leave a manifesto behind, but he did leave a long trail on social media that left no doubt.

The Dayton Daily News in fact reported on Tuesday that the killer had been present at a May 25th rally protesting the KKK. He had showed up in full Antifa gear, complete with face bandanna, sunglasses, and a gun, possibly the same gun he used last weekend.

This has of course proved deeply uninteresting to the Democratic candidates and their media shills. Here’s a random headline, this one from CNN, dated Wednesday—the day after the Dayton Daily News report. Headline: Dayton shooter had an obsession with violence and mass shootings, police say.

You have to read 300 words into the report before the word “Antifa” shows up.

But while I doubt there are any direct political causes for events like these, there may very well be deeper social causes.

In between news stories about those mass killings last weekend, my eye fell upon this unrelated item. Headline from the Daily Mail: A Quarter of Millennials Say They Have no Friends, Study Finds. [by Natalie Rahhal,, August 2, 2019]

Hmm. The Dayton killer—the Antifa guy—was a millennial, 24 years old.

On the strict definition, the El Paso guy was just post-millennial, 21 years old. “Generation Z,” the post-millennials are sometimes called. So how are they doing?

Different headline, this one from VoiceOfEurope: Gen Z Crisis: “9 in 10 young Brits think their lives are meaningless. [by Arthur Lyons, August 5, 2019]

Just a couple more data points on this theme.

First data point: The sister of the Dayton shooter, who was one of those killed in the shooting, identified as a guy. Her birth name was Megan, but to a close circle of friends she was Jordan.[Dayton shooter Connor Betts’ slain sister was a transgender man: report, by Natalie O’Neill, NY Post,August 9, 2019]

Second data point: That Dayton shooter participated as vocalist in a fringe music scene called “pornogrind.” Two of the bands he performed with bore the names Menstrual Munchies and Putrid Liquid.

I really, really don’t want to know any more about pornogrind, but by all means look it up if you have the stomach for it.

I have no comment of my own on those two data points, but I’ll borrow one from Carson Robison: There’s something cockeyed somewhere.”

John Derbyshire [email him] writes an incredible amount on all sorts of subjects for all kinds of outlets. (This no longer includes National Review, whose editors had some kind of tantrum and fired him.) He is the authorof We Are Doomed: Reclaiming Conservative Pessimism and several other books. He has had two books published by com: FROM THE DISSIDENT RIGHT (also available in Kindle) and FROM THE DISSIDENT RIGHT II: ESSAYS 2013.

(Republished from VDare by permission of author or representative)
Hide 95 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. Tyson’s comment was both logical and rational……so naturally the Bolsheviks lit right into him.

    • Agree: getaclue, Old Prude
    • Replies: @Richard B
  2. Ken52 says:

    The Helter Skelter explanation for the Manson murders was made up by Bugliosi. Read new book
    Chaos: Charles Manson the CIA and the secret history of the sixties – tom o’neill. Amazing. Manson appears to be a pawn used by the CIA in MKUltra program.

    • Replies: @getaclue
  3. Recommend “Goodbye Helter Skelter”, George Stimson (Peasenhall Press 2014) as a more believable explication than Bugliosi.

  4. Thomm says:

    Tyson’s tweet would have been more powerful if he cited annual numbers.

    Mass-shooting deaths still register at the 300-400 level per year.

    Compare that to 45,000 suicides and 40,000 car accidents.

  5. MEH 0910 says:

    • Replies: @Realist
    , @Richard B
    , @Svigor
  6. Manson claimed a Beatles song, “Helter Skelter,” as his inspiration

    More evidence that the classics are being taken over by young Asian women:

  7. Neil De Grasse Tyson also wants to shut down completely the H-1B..L1B Visa Programs completely…He has been very open about this…And he said that he wants the H1B-L1B Visa Programs shut down forever…

  8. Timeline:

    On 23 July 2019, US Attorney General & ‘former’ CIA officer William Barr, was speaking at Fordham University:

    « Barr concluded his speech by stating that he anticipated “a major incident may well occur at any time that will galvanize public opinion” » leading to legal demands for the end of privacy more repression etc

    On the same day, 23 July 2019, FBI Director Christopher Wray spoke to the US Senate, where he surprised many by saying that, “The most persistent threats to the nation and to U.S. interests abroad are homegrown violent extremists (HVEs), domestic terrorists …”

    Five days later, on 28 July, there was the California Garlic Festival mass shooting

    Six days after that, on 3 August, there was the El Paso Texas Wal-Mart mass shooting

    Followed in turn within a few hours, on 4 August in the early a.m., by the Dayton Ohio Peppers Bar mass shooting

    Leading to mass calls for more surveillance, cyber-monitoring etc just as US Attorney General Barr had anticipated 12 days earlier

    No doubt all a coincidence

    • Replies: @Richard B
  9. I am a huge fan, Derb; however, both yourself and Mr. Tyson are pretty clearly off the mark, here. Terrorism, or the random slaughter of innocents, or whatever you choose to call it, is substantively different from automobile accidents and medical errors. For terrorism is an attack on a people’s ability to move freely about their own society. It is an attack on the very concept of civil society.

    I have often heard libtards of various stripes make the argument that, say, Islamic terrorism counts for a “very small proportion of deaths [or even murders] in a given country,” and thus, the implication is, we should not worry overmuch about immigration (of course, they are quite wrong) Well, most murders are committed by small-time criminals, their victims tending to be other small-time criminals, in disputes over territory, money, respect, etc. The average little old lady or six-year-old is generally not threatened by such crimes; neither are they prevented from going about their business. But once you start gunning down little old ladies in the street, it becomes not just an attack on specific people, but on the very ability of people to live their lives in a free society.

    You are better with numbers than I will ever be, but in this instance, your vaunted numeracy quite failed you.

    • Agree: Realist
  10. It is also possible to commit murder after reading the Oxford English Dictionary.

    • Replies: @Jim bob Lassiter
  11. Realist says:

    I’m Is Impressed…

    What the hell is that?

  12. Realist says:
    @MEH 0910

    Neil deGrasse Tyson

    Ongoing research continues to demonstrate conclusively that your IQ is an excellent predictor of your score on an IQ test.

    3:41 PM – Mar 10, 2015

    Tyson must not have done very well on his IQ test

    • Replies: @95Theses
  13. The NRA Gun Owners are going to have their guns taken away….and it’s their own fault…

    And here is why:NRA Gun Owners are Civic Nationalist Cucks who had no problem with importing LEGALLY highly RACIALIZED nonwhite Democratic Party Voters as long as they pay their taxes and obeyed the CONSTITUTION…But what happens when the nonwhite LEGAL IMMIGRANTS who pay their taxes…breed and reproduce on US SOIL?……ANSWER:Nonwhites become a majority in the US……Majority in the US MILITARY….Majority in Police Departments across the US…Majority of Federal Prosecutors….Majority of County Prosecutors….Majority of State Prosecutors…..Majority of Federal Judges….Majority of State and County Prosecutors….and they Elect an anti-Whitey POTUS……

    The Civic Nationalist CUCKED NRA Gun Owners are gonna have their guns taken away….and they will comply…..for they were faggots all along…


  14. Not Mr D’s biggest fan, but his point about “cockeyed” re “sister” is spot on.
    His tran’s sister just “happens” to be among the targets?
    Oh boy! Sounds like the main twist/plot line from James Ellroy’s “LA Confidential”. (Ellroy: the greatest US (actually the world’s greatest ) crime/Noir writer in the last 30 odd years, hands down).
    And yes, it’s pretty rich, that El Paso is way-way played up compared to Dayton.
    Pretty rich but pretty predictable — US Pravda.

  15. KenH says:

    I’ve never paid much attention to Neil Degrasse Tyson only because I suspected he was being promoted as another black guy instructing whitey about science. Similar to how when there’s a newspaper article or news segment about computing technology there’s always blacks around as if black skin connotes computer interest and expertise.

    Needless to say I’ve gained a great deal of respect for Mr. Degrasse Tyson since he provided context and espoused common sense in the wake of the El Paso and Dayton shootings and didn’t go all woke and hyperventilate about white suepremacist tear-ERR.

    The Dayton shooter was a left wing, antifa and Pocahontas Warren supporting satanist. CNN actually reported this but it seems a lot of other mainstream outlets are slow to acknowledge this and spend much more time on the El Paso shooting since it fits their narrative.

  16. 95Theses says:

    Good luck at the Broken Clock Awards, Dr. Tyson!

    But here are some links with actual data that are more useful than a Tyson tweet:

    Everything you know about AR15s might be a lie
    2016, June 22 | Brandon

    This is a follow-up to our article reporting concerning 20+ years of FBI data, ‘assault rifle’ fatalities continue to decline.

    The purpose of this article, and our previous one are to highlight just the facts – That despite becoming the overwhelmingly most popular firearm in the United States, AR15s are by and large only used by civilians for recreational activities, and that a new assault weapons ban would be extraordinarily ineffective. This, based on 20+ years of data provided by the FBI and DOJ concerning the number of crimes committed with rifles including ones like the AR15.

    Percentage of Murders Involving Rifles & Assault Weapons

    20+ years of FBI data – “Assault Rifles” pose little threat to public safety
    2016, June 21 | Brandon

    … Since 1995 (the year after the 1994-2004 Assault Weapons Ban), the FBI has maintained a very detailed list of how many people have died at the hands of assault weapons and/or rifles, which are merged into the same group. Therefore, we can make a solid comparison on what gun violence looks like.

    In 2014, you are 67% less likely to be murdered by an assault weapon or rifle than you were in 1995.

    • Replies: @Curmudgeon
  17. 95Theses says:

    And this guy’s famous? Sheesh!

  18. Rich says:

    Tyson and the Brazil woman are two prominent left wing blacks who have come out against blaming Trump for these two mass shootings. Is this a reward for Trump helping their fellow black, that rapper in Sweden, get released from custody? Trump has been bending over backwards to get blacks to support him, it will be hilarious if it works. I’ve never believed in the “Legend of the black Republican”, but imagine if they do vote for him? The dems will get the vapors.

  19. There was enough …for the CultMarx mob to argue that the killer was inspired by President Trump

    Title of the manifesto: “The Inconvenient Truth”. Where have I heard that before?

    “El Paso Shooting Suspect’s Manifesto Echoes Al Gore’s Language”

    “El Paso Shooter Identified Online As Gore Supporter Who Didn’t Like ‘decimation of the environment’”

  20. Nah.

    What he could have said:

    “On average, across 48hrs, in Chicago alone, 24 people are shot with guns.”


    The El Paso Killer Loved Trump. Do You? Then You’re Responsible, Too.

    CJ Werleman

    …the direct result of the President of the United States referring to immigrants, asylum seekers and refugees as “invaders,” “rapists” and “terrorists.”

  22. Gunner says:

    Libtards are already saying the Dayton guy was a Deplorable pretending to be Antifa on social media.

  23. Hillbob says:

    The same logic is good for wars of aggression, killing of innocents around the world,killing of scientists by the mossad etc. Yeah, so many die in their dirt holes and huts anyway.
    Guns are good , guns are great guns do not carry hate. Hence, every citizen of the USA should be given a gun by right(provided by the state). If someone refuses to own one he should be jailed, unless he can find someone else who is willing to accept this(his) birthright. Long Live guns. Long live the killing of innocents. We is so great

  24. unit472 says:

    It is interesting that while the number of murders where the victim is selected at random by the killer have not changed much over the years the methodology has.

    Beginning in the late sixties we had a surge in ‘serial killers’. Zodiacs, Nightstalkers, Sons of Sam etc. seemed to be erupting everywhere. These guys seemed to enjoy their notoriety but as their numbers grew it became harder and harder to achieve celebrity killer status. First you had to kill more and more people and do it with an identifiable M.O. so the public and police would recognize a killing as your ‘work’ and, second, not get caught, at least until you had a decent body count.

    In the 1980’s we began to see a shift away from the ‘serial killer’ to the ‘active shooter’ style of multilple random murders. Luby’s Cafe, the San Diego McDonalds and so many USPS workers going on shooting sprees the term ‘going postal’ entered the language. With the deaths of John Gacy and Jeffrey Dahmer in 1994 the era of the ‘superstar’ serial killer was over and the active shooter became the dominant form of mass murder.

    The why of this makes for interesting speculation. As mentioned serial killing requires a lot of hard work over an extended period of time. Selecting victims, concealing the body and avoiding detection grew more difficult as technology and forensic science advanced. As the case of the Golden State Killer has shown, once the police have your DNA your ability to avoid identification and arrest maybe over. OTOH anyone with a semiautomatic firearm can become a fearsome active shooter able to kill dozens of people in just a minute or two though your chances of escape are also minimal. It requires no cunning, no planning just a willingness to be ruthless. If you kill enough people or you attack a particularly vulnerable population such as school children you can achieve the same level of media infamy as the serial killers of old without all the stress of a multi year murder campaign.

    • Replies: @getaclue
  25. @95Theses

    Does this all mean that if someone is shot with a shotgun, the shotgun is not an assault weapon?

    • Replies: @Swamper_01
  26. ElPaso and Dayton were false flags. Manson was a false flag.

  27. getaclue says:

    Bugliosi also wrote, and got lots of publicity for his “position” in the Mainslime Media, that the “Lone Nutter” Oswald was the only Kennedy shooter–the only people who are of this opinion are idiots, payed off shills, or “in on it” with the CIA/Deep State etc.–the NYSlimes is big on this “truth” so we all know it is a total lie just for that reason alone!– if not for the mountain of evidence that Oswald actually seems to have worked for the CIA (only ex-Marine who defected to Cuba that flew back on a military transport (only possible way given the evidence of flight times) and was never prosecuted or investigated for his conduct) and was in fact the patsy he claimed to be before the Mobbed up Jew Assassin (look at the photo of the murder of Oswald and how Ruby pulled the trigger pointing with his index finger and using his middle one on the trigger — “normal” people don’t do that shooting a pistol, trained assassins do,yes–a real pro!) was allowed to deliver the kill shot as two big Policemen held Oswald in place for it.

    So given that it seems Bugliosi was probably always on the payroll or associated with the “Intelligence Agency” types who are behind these things with their friends in the Mafia. The single best book on the JFK Murder as to why it was done and by who was actually written by big shot Mafiosa Sam Giancana’s brother Chuck (Sam shared Mistress(s) with JFK…), who was actually on the scene as his brother, a psychopath from birth basically, moved up the ladder in the Chicago Mob and finally joined forces with his enablers/”friends” in the CIA–the book tells the whys and hows and is very credible (its called “Double Cross”)–so credible it was stuffed down the rabbit hole immediately and is completely ignored. (Its very obvious Chuck risked his life writing it when you read it). Interestingly, I have come across several times in researching that ex-Sheriff’s in the area where Manson and Family were camped out knew he was there and wanted to raid/arrest the thieving gang led by an ex-Con surrounded by drugged out teen age women– but were given orders “from above” not to do so, they obviously weren’t “ripe” enough yet for picking….

  28. getaclue says:

    Not to go into this at length, but since you mentioned them specifically– there is substantial evidence Zodiac, Son of Sam etc. were all networked in with Satanist groups and were part of “Occult Workings” — a real “term of art” in that line of endeavor…by such public serial murdering it seems you can cause a certain type of society wide “shock” and have quite an effect on the future trajectory of a country, or so they believed it seems…given the history before and after maybe they are right?– Berkowitz has actually come out and said this and the cops involved with him agree…it seems the influence of this “group” is vast and gets hidden quite a bit as they are quite the “Occult” force in “Entertainment” and elsewhere–sort of like an adjunct to the massive secret society Masons, a hidden nasty little brother….

    The site does a great job breaking down their symbolism in big entertainer’s “acts” like Taylor Swift recently baptized in, Madonna etc. you can’t see the videos and the breakdown with out knowing that what he’s saying is dead accurate, you would have to be brain dead–the “covering of the eye” thing and other symbolism is everywhere, outrageous, and can’t be random–and if it’s not random then these people are extremely powerful and “in charge” (more and more open about it too, it seems….) they definitely target young people/teens the most it seems–which should be kind of a “wake up call” for normals who don’t “believe” in such things–it’s stuck in your face daily….

  29. Ron Unz says:

    Well, it’s perfectly correct that the bodycount of the Walmart Massacre is pretty insignificant compared to the total number of people in this country who die each year from car accidents or the flu. But I wonder…

    Suppose some Hispanic guy had gone into a Walmart somewhere and massacred 22 white people because they were white. Would Derb and his VDare friends be making the same argument that the incident was totally insignificant and should be ignored by the media given the far larger number of people dying from car accidents or the flu?…

  30. I saw Tyson’s comments and was impressed, usually he is as wacky as Bill Nye or Stephen Hawking.

    What will now happen to his career as a celebrity scientist?

  31. John Derbyshire: “With a hundred thousand people a month coming in across our southern border without permission, terms like “invasion” and “ethnic replacement” don’t seem hyperbolic to me. … [but he] was insane; and yes, the guy is a psychopathic monster.”

    How else to repel an invasion but by force? Politely ask them to leave? You may say let the gov’t handle it, but plainly, it hasn’t and won’t.

  32. Will says:

    What’s even more remarkable is that these “shootings” are obvious hoaxes. The fact that ANYONE believes this level of ongoing “violence”, all using the SAME WEAPON, featuring lone wolf gunmen who usually die or from whom we never hear from again, manifestos/ideologies galore, etc. is organic is mind-boggling.

    El Paso:



    • Replies: @Twodees Partain
  33. @Amerimutt Golems

    Adolph Hitler read the Bible– twice. You don’t smoke the same cigarettes as me and I cain’t git no satisfaction.

  34. @Ron Unz

    If he were a Hispanic that had no business being in the country in the first place, I’d say not.

    • Replies: @Thomm
  35. Richard B says:
    @MEH 0910

    “Ongoing research continues to demonstrate that 90% of IQ tests are half mental.” NGT

    Kidding aside, you know you’re dealing with an AA hire when you read “Ongoing” and “continues” not just in the same sentence, but in the same subordinate clause.

    • Replies: @Truth
  36. Richard B says:

    “No doubt all a coincidence”

    More like a cohencidence.

  37. Richard B says:
    @Robert Dolan

    “The Dayton Daily News in fact reported on Tuesday that the killer had been present at a May 25th rally protesting the KKK.”

    Speaking of Bolsheviks, the only KKK that exists today is The Kvetching Kosher Khazars.

    There is NO KKK.
    There are NO Neo-Nazis.
    And there are NO White Supremacists.

    They’re all fictions manufactured by the Bolsheviks at The ADL/SPLC via The FBI’s database.

    That’s been going on for years.

    Which explains all of the kvetching.

    They know we know.

  38. Tusk says:
    @Ron Unz

    Well most of the outrage against Terrorism is against foreign agents causing harm to the native population, whereas El Paso and Christchurch are natives attacking foreigners. A complete reverse in how the violence is directed. A person has the right to be outraged if someone breaks into their home, but the intruder does not have the right to be upset if he is attacked. In regard to the immigration I don’t blame those incentivized for acting upon their desires, the faceless and eternal state apparatus that cares not who it rules but only that it benefits it or its minions. This is not to say that terrorism or illegal alien violence is even important, it falls similarly into the numbers that Tyson describes, it is equally as arbitrary in the grand scheme of things but the logic behind the violence is important.

    With 100k people coming each month and no action being taken by the Government people are going to react violently to achieve their goals but equally any ‘attacks’ seem to be just distractions to bog people down in current events instead of actual long term goals. People would be better off ignoring these events. Just as the political space is constantly clogged up with pointless moral issues that detract everyone (Gay rights, transgender rights, hate speech, reparations…etc etc) the Demographic argument is being plagued with the same moralisms (free healthcare, racism from whites, whether or not everyone has a right to come to America) that detract from actual answers.

    With Africans even being included in those crossing the border, hoping to come to the promised land, demographic fears for White American’s are justified. I agree that people should stop focusing on foreigners murdering native whites, while they are justified the issue is that the ruling elite are the ones pushing this. We shouldn’t blame the tools of destruction but instead those that wield them. Here’s another important question: Who/What is to blame for the 250 medical error deaths each day? How many of those deaths are White people, how many of those are from foreign born doctors?

    As Andrew Joyce wrote on TOO: “an analysis that revealed non-British doctors (25% of the total) were responsible for at least 80% of tribunal cases in 2016”

    If those numbers are similar in America then what is the point of worrying about Islamic terrorism or illegal immigrants? The Government is importing ‘skilled’ people that evidently are causing more harm than those combined. The moral outrage over cultural connotations of mass shootings should not override the statistical reality of harm done in society and who is causing it.

    • Replies: @Twodees Partain
  39. @Rich

    I’ve never believed in the “Legend of the black Republican”, but imagine if they do vote for him?

    In the primary he got a lot of support from blacks, at least the ones I knew personally. That didn’t surprise me. Blacks are hurt more than whites by mass immigration from Mexico and points south, and Trump was the only one even talking about cutting into that.

    If Trump had spent the last couple of years backing up his talk with action on immigration he might well draw more black votes next year than any Republican since Nixon pulled over 20% in 1960. As it is, there’s nothing Trump can offer blacks that they can’t get more of from the Democrat du jour.

  40. @Ron Unz

    ” Would Derb and his VDare friends be making the same argument that the incident was totally insignificant and should be ignored by the media given the far larger number of people dying from car accidents or the flu?…”

    Is that what they said? I missed that part. No, actually I didn’t miss it because it isn’t there. Now, I did read the part of the article that showed a tweet by Tyson who made an observation that offers a perspective on the media’s coverage of what really appears to be a manufactured event complete with a patsy who supposedly wrote a manifesto.

    Clip what you think you read that supports your hyperbolic claim that Derb says the incident is insignificant and should be ignored by the media. Paste it here where I can read it. You can’t because it’s bullshit, ain’t it, Ron?

  41. @Tusk

    “With 100k people coming each month and no action being taken by the Government ”

    I think it’s even worse than that, Tusk. My understanding is that the 100K figure is the number of invaders the BP is sure of based on arrests and evidence of more who got away. A larger figure could reasonably be assumed given the fact that the BP can’t be everywhere all the time.

    Sorry for picking one point out of your comment. You presented a lot more and it’s all food for thought.


    • Replies: @Tusk
  42. @Will

    I agree. In several instances witnesses reported seeing several shooters in black BDUs instead of the lone gunman the police always end up claiming. In El Paso it seems clear that one guy couldn’t have put out enough accurately aimed fire to hit all the victims in the time between the camera catching him coming in the door and the cops grabbing him outside.

    One big development is that the ones staging the attacks have now started actually killing people instead of just claiming a body count in the media coverage.

    • Replies: @Will
  43. I agree that ‘The Derb” is a numbers guy. A pile of No. 2!

    • Replies: @Old Prude
  44. Tusk says:
    @Twodees Partain

    No thank you or pointing it out, because you are correct. I’ve read (and often agreed) that for everyone caught at least one most likely gets through. The amount of manpower and resources to capture one person is immense, considering you cannot plan for everything or have everyone everywhere at once many will get through. It is very important to considerthis when anyone looks at ‘official’ stats.

    • Replies: @Twodees Partain
  45. Binyamin says:
    @Ron Unz

    Good point Ron. What I fail to understand is this- you are basically a racially tolerant person who is relaxed about legal high skill immigration. What on earth do you gain by providing a platform for some of the most extreme and potentially violent racialists – white nationalists, segregationists, KKK supporters, neo nazis (the designations are interchangeable). You may feel sorry for some of these so called ‘writers’ who cannot get their work published elsewhere. Ever wondered why? Do you realise that by default or otherwise Unz has become one of the main outlets for the online radicalisation of disaffected white males and some of these no hopers are turning into violent extremists? Imagine the infamy bestowed upon you if in future it transpires that a white nationalist mass killer’s online ranting’s are traced back to UNZ review? Ron, I am afraid we are perilously close to this situation. Don’t believe me?- Read some of the comments on the website you have created.
    Just to make it clear, I am not accusing John Derbyshire of being a violent extremist. His is a sad case. In a previous incarnation Derb was a successful writer of popular science books. His book the Prime Obsession is one of the best books on Prime Numbers and I have read it twice. Unfortunately, something happened to his brain and he was re-incarnated as a white nationalist. So sad!

  46. Beliavsky says:

    There is something especially terrible about a group of people, unknown to the murderer, being killed because of their race. So the El Paso shooting gets attention beyond its sheer numbers. That said, how much national attention did Colin Ferguson’s 1993 rampage get?

  47. Jameswolf says:

          The  leftists   and  promotors   of  open borders  are using  the argument that   migrants are not safe in Mexico  because  very often in  Mexico     some gangs  kill people.         But  then USA can use the same argument  to deny asylum to all   people of caravans and coming to USA from any country:
        USA can argue:  “sorry,  but USA is very dangerous for  you, some crazy people  may shoot  and kill you any time and anywhere,   remember  the shooter  at Las Vegas, and now the killer of El Paso, and many others.  So, bye  bye,  go to find   asylum in some other country, NOT in USA.  THis is not a safe place”. Why dont  the   American politicians  use their brains   to stop  immigration?  The immigrants use all type of tricks to enter and USA is not using the brain cells.  
    Now Russia wants migrants, then Mr Trump should negociate with him: “We can send some millions to Russia, my friend Vladimir, do you want them?” Then all guys from caravans can be sent to Russia, if they dont want, they must come back to their countries or stay in Mexico, there they will have all the Mexican love. Mr AMLO says he loves Central Americans, and he signed the pact with United Nations, so he must take them.  

  48. @Tusk

    True, government numbers are not to be trusted. As the old saying goes: Figures don’t lie, but liars can figure.

  49. KenH says:
    @Ron Unz

    I don’t think Derb or anyone said the media should ignore the Wal-Mart shooting but in this case the (((media))) literally lost their minds and began hollering “white soopremacist tear-err” at the top of their lungs as if there’s pasty faced evildoers behind every tree waiting to jump out with semi-auto rifles and terrorize “communities of color”.

    The (((media)) conducted weeklong coverage that amounted to the biggest anti-white hatefest I’ve ever seen. It was used to dehumanize all white Americans who don’t hate their race and culture and who still dare to think that we should seal our border and deport illegal aliens.

    If the Wal-Mart shooter was Latino and the victims white then we’d we treated to mainstream coverage that is brief, bland and politically neutral. Whites would be lectured that only racists and white nationalist would be angered and offended by the crime. Race never matters when whites are the victims in case you hadn’t noticed.

    The interracial crime statistics prove that whites are about eight times more likely to be victims of Latino violent crime than the reverse and the El Paso shooter barely put a dent in that disparity.

    Reverse the races and it would be you who would remain stoic while trotting out your age adjusted crime statistics to demonstrate that white outrage is much ado about nothing and that Latinos are nearly as law abiding as the Japanese.

    • Replies: @Alden
  50. Old Prude says:
    @Shafar Nullifidian

    Aren’t you supposed to report to your eighth grade homeroom? Oh, that’s right it’s summer vacation, still.

  51. Truth says:
    @Ron Unz


    Well if it was a knee-grow who murdered 22 whites, derby and the rest would have you thinking bubonic plague had returned.

    • Replies: @Rich
    , @Twodees Partain
  52. Truth says:
    @Richard B

    “AA”, should have two periods, Sport.

  53. @Rich

    More black/Hispanic/female employment!!!

    Stop cycling Donald. We don’t GAF bout these diversity sinecures. You should be embarrassed.

    Support jobs for the WHITE MEN WHO ELECTED YOU & Defend you from attax by these groups that Hate you!

  54. Rich says:

    And yet, the Negro who killed 5 Dallas cops is forgotten. The Negro who killed 8 co-workers in Hartford is forgotten. The Negroes who raped, tortured and murdered Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom are barely spoken about. The black fellow who killed 2 cops in Brooklyn is never spoken of. Who remembers Dewayne Craddock, another strong Negro American, who killed 12 of his co-workers in Virginia Beach just a few short months ago?Do you guys still say a mass for Gary Martin(Negro) who killed 5 of his co-workers? And your most (un)famous mass murderer of all, good old black man Colin Ferguson, 6 dead. The media doesn’t report, or dwell on, black mass murderers because that’s not the narrative they want to push.

    • Replies: @Truth
    , @KenH
  55. Truth says:

    Love the imagination.

    They’re all being downplayed by the MSM, but you got their names, qnd victim counts, from the mass media, and still remember them.

  56. KenH says:

    Don’t forget young Kevin Shifflett who was happily playing in his front yard before a deranged black supremacist walked up to him and cut his throat, killing him. Police later found a letter from the black killer to Louis Farrakhan expressing admiration for him. The story has been memory holed since it first occurred.

    Had a white man who supported David Duke murdered a black child we’d still be hearing about it today as an example of white soopremacist tear-err.

  57. Rich says:

    You’re joking, right? I remember those names because I do my best to go beyond the media blackout and narrative. I’ll bet there were more news stories about Emmitt Till in the last few years than any about the very recent rape,toture, murder of Channnon Christian and Christopher Newsom by a gang of blacks. Imagine if the races had been reversed? We’d never hear the end of it and leftists would be trying to make it a mandatory course for grade schools, while Colin Kaepernick led you guys on marches to protest his not being a very good QB and making sure you buy only Nike products. Or whatever else that bored millionaire pretends to care about.

    The narrative is more important than the truth to the controlled media. Right now your people are benefiting from that. All it takes is a change in the wind and you guys will sincerely regret getting in bed with those degenerates. Call yourself “truth “, but do everything you can to avoid the truth.

    • Replies: @Rich
    , @Truth
  58. Those who are about and loose, with autos, ice picks, knives, petrol bombs, matches, etc…. get them out and put away ! JFK AND LBJ close most mental hospitals, so those inmates went some where…. Castro flushed his loonies across to our shores via a boat lift, as his answer to Cuban crime… and they are here, reproducing, and doing what the crazed do! Those need a locked place to call home, as we use to have and use….. One reason I carry a concealed weapon, licensed to do so, veteran, and victim of those who just have it their way ! I can provide a real Surprise !

  59. Derbyshire, if you’re getting ready for your China trip, make sure that you and your Chinese family stop in Hong Kong. They need freedom fighters. Your Chinese offspring are the perfect ago for freedom fighters.

  60. Rich says:

    I wrote this comment as a reply to “Truth” comment 55. otherwise it looks a little strange.

  61. Truth says:

    For the 30th time, my friend please start using your head. God gave it to you for a reason.

    This Christian Channon thing being so hush-hush that it was buried by the MSM, so I guess you got the info from a secret list passed around the Brooklyn Pipefitter’s Union Hall?

    • Replies: @J1234
  62. J1234 says:

    please start using your head. God gave it to you for a reason.

    And that doesn’t apply to you? If you don’t think there isn’t a regular bias against whites in the reporting of violent interracial encounters, from almost countless MSM sources, you either aren’t very smart or you’re intentionally lying for moral reasons, as people on the left often do. Since you don’t see the 48 hours video you provided as an example of this, there’s another example currently in the news.

    In Colorado, white cops recently shot and killed an armed black man in the back has he ran away and seemed to reach in his pants for his gun. (They had reason to believe he had a gun, as he was one of two people who fit the description of perps in a robbery just a few minutes before.) But you have to watch actual raw video to see what actually happened. The ABC report, however, presents the “facts” using a standard ploy: David Muir says the man “at one point had his hands in the air running away…he then was shot.” Not true, but they show a freeze frame of the video with the suspect in a hands slightly raised position, anyway.

    This misrepresents the truth to the point of lying. He did not have his hands in the air when he was shot, his hands looked like they were going for the gun in his pants at that time. In fact, the amount of time that he had his hands raised amounts to a fraction of a second (after he was shot)…which is why they freeze framed it. However, even the heavily edited video they present (which stops right at the point of the shooting, but continues the audio, for some strange reason) reveals that the suspect had his hands going towards the waist of his pants…not the normal position that a person keeps their arms at when running full speed. But this is shown later in the news piece, after David Muir tries to insinuate that the suspect was shot while his hands were in the air.

    In the full bodycam video, the gun is shown very clearly coming through the bottom of the suspect’s pants when the cops deal with him while he’s on the ground, but of course, ABC doesn’t show that. In fact, ABC only mentions a gun a minute or so into the video, and even then, they only state that the police claim they found a gun…even though the full body cam video makes it pretty clear there was a gun. The news report calls it “an object.” Here’s the full body cam video.

    Lot’s of bias in the news.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    , @Truth
    , @Mr. Anon
  63. First data point: The sister of the Dayton shooter, who was one of those killed in the shooting, identified as a guy. Her birth name was Megan, but to a close circle of friends she was Jordan.

    Looks like mental illness runs in the family.

  64. Alden says:

    Don’t forget the pitiful photos and sobbing interviews with old Hispanic women with grandchildren in their arms worried about a back lash against Hispanics by evil White NAAAZIS.

  65. Mr. Anon says:

    “Truth” doesn’t care. He’ll excuse any bad behavior by blacks because he’s black. Don’t bother interacting with him. He doesn’t argue in good faith. He’s also astoundingly stupid. He is a flat-earther. Literally. He actually believes the Earth is flat. He’s a moron.

    • Replies: @Truth
    , @Svigor
  66. @Truth

    Yes, but you only wish you were a knee-grow. You’re only fooling yourself by trying to pretend to be one here.

    • Replies: @Truth
  67. Truth says:
    @Mr. Anon

    Grasshopper, for ten years now you’ve been acting like a Negro. Why can’t you just be my Nigga for a change?

    Here, peace offering; the latest Space-X landing. He even shouts out to you by name at :42

    • Replies: @Thomm
    , @Thomm
  68. Mr. Anon says:

    See what I mean? “Truth” responded to my comment by doubling down on his whole flat-earth “space is fake” delusion. He thinks a You Tube video by some retard is convincing evidence.

    As I said, he is a moron.

    • Replies: @J1234
  69. J1234 says:

    I did…when it was widely reported five years ago. (Huffpost, CBS News, etc.)

  70. J1234 says:
    @Mr. Anon

    Yeah, and it only took him four days to find an example of a white people killing blacks in a news story…from five years ago. Problem is, I remember the story from back then because it was all over the news at the time. Proving my point.

    One of the blacks in the comment section of another blog wanted to have a sort of IQ showdown with one of his white critics. I looked at some of the black guy’s other posted material and said, “you may not want to do that.”

    • Replies: @Truth
  71. Truth says:

    Oh no, Old Sport, I think you misunderstand; I can find stories of white people killing black people quite easily,

    Here’s one:

    Here’s another one:

    Here’s another:

    How about one more:

    Now understand Old Sport; that search took me roughly 8 seconds and I could continue posting these stories, likely, for another 20 minutes.

    I do not remember any wall-to-wall news coverage, riots, rallies with Jessie Jackson or any of that shit because I HAD TO LOOK FOR THESE STORIES. Therefore as with the Joliet story I posted above, the press did not make any particular issue of a white person killing a black person.

    And the reason I posted the Joliet story is because you brought up Christian Channon (which, for the record, Blaise Pascal, happened twelve years ago) Is because that was a strange and heinous crime… and was probably exceeded by your cousins from Joliet who after murdering these two men had sex atop their lifeless bodies.

    So there it is, Buckwheat, you and Stepin’ Fechit’ (Mr. Anon) and Rochester (Rich) learned a valuable lesson today; duh main ain’t alwayz tryna hol’ yo pepul down.

    Tomorrow we’ll go into multiplication and division.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    , @J1234
  72. Thomm says:

    Grasshopper, for ten years now you’ve been acting like a Negro.

    Note the reason why these White Trashionalists merged into ‘wigger’ subculture and become the new definition of the term.

    • Agree: Truth
    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
  73. Mr. Anon says:

    Note the reason why these White Trashionalists merged into ‘wigger’ subculture and become the new definition of the term.

    Sure. I’m supposedly a wigger – yet you are making common cause with commenter ‘Truth’ – a walking, talking stereotype of the stupid, self-assured, incompetent black man.

    Try harder, street-shitter.

  74. Mr. Anon says:

    How about one more:

    You f**king moron. That was a well known hoax – not the murder, but the attribution of it to a white guy. Here is the guy the police arrested for the crime:

    He look white to you?


    • Replies: @Truth
  75. J1234 says:

    because you brought up Christian Channon

    No I didn’t. You’re confusing me with someone else.

    I was making a point about about how MSM news outlets usually bias the reporting of violent interracial crimes in favor of blacks, as I pointed out in the ABC David Muir piece. Never made a reference to the Tennessee murder. I used the Colorado shooting of the armed robber as an example. I know…it’s really hard to keep all of those facts and stories straight, isn’t it?

    You do understand that the stories you posted only prove my point, right? Or did you forget what my point was?

    My point (as I just said) was that MSM outlets bias the reporting of interracial violence in favor of blacks. The headlines of those stories that you posted all scream, “White person kills black person,” or some variation, which proves my point.

    Or would prove my point, were they from the MSM, but they aren’t. The all SJW advocacy type sites or publications. Now, you could prove me wrong by finding some MSM headlines that scream, “Black people kill white people,” or some variation, but good luck with that. And I’d need several so that you don’t go down the typical path of conflating the general with the specific (and vice versa.)

  76. Thomm says:

    Keep in mind that ‘Mr. Anon’ has openly admitted in the past that he would rather have sex with a white man than a black woman, since racial solidarity trumps sexual orientation, in his mind.


    Note that these faggots :

    i) Say a black man (you) is a white man.
    ii) Say a white man (me) is a South Asian man.

    Anyone with an IQ above 70 knows that if you want to hate on a group, you actually have to attack someone from that group. These 70-IQ faggots can’t seem to even get that right.

    If he took off his gimp suit and went outside, he might know more. Then again, mainstream white people keep these degenerates out of our neighborhoods (with good reason).

    If white women were presented a button that, if pressed, would make all White Trashionalists disappear, they would not merely press it, but pay money to be the first to do the honors.

    Heh heh heh heh

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
  77. Thomm says:
    @Jim bob Lassiter

    If he were a Hispanic that had no business being in the country in the first place, I’d say not.

    So when the Southwest was annexed by the US from Mexico, there were no people living there?

    An illegal has no business being in the US.

    But a Hispanic, who might be second, third, or fourth generation, certainly does.

    • Replies: @Jim bob Lassiter
  78. Mr. Anon says:

    And the other 3?

    Why should I imagine those are any more accurate than the obvious howler? I’m not your fact checker.

    In any event, blacks commit far more murders, both in absolute numbers and per capita. They commit far more interracial murders. These are all well known facts. You are a liar who cares nothing for facts. And you’re a moron too.

  79. Mr. Anon says:

    Now – you are just straight up lying. I have never said any such thing, you vile, odious piece of shit.

    • Replies: @Truth
  80. Truth says:
    @Mr. Anon

    Does somebody need a time out?

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    , @Thomm
  81. Thomm says:

    You are a moron.

    That is about as total an admission of shambolic defeat as one will ever see. Epic pwnage.

    Truth destroyed this ‘Mr. Anon’ wigger. Truth didn’t even need my help. Truth presented facts, and the Trashionalist didn’t like the facts, so can only respond with ‘you are a moron’.

    We are watching evolution at work here. Mother nature herself wants certain wastematter to be removed from the gene pool (WN wiggers in this case), which is what is happening before our eyes right here.

    • LOL: Truth
  82. @Curmudgeon

    Of course! But only after they successfully get those demon possessed AR15’s banned. Once they do, they’ll go after shotguns and more powerful handguns, I’m sure. Only by totally disarming the American people can they enact their globalist agenda fully, as the people will have no way to resist the well armed jackbooted thugs (the police).

    The question is, will the people really accept these obviously deceptive tactics and allow themselves to be disarmed?

  83. @Thomm

    Thanks for the clarification. I certainly did not mean to state or imply otherwise.

    • Replies: @Thomm
  84. Thomm says:
    @Jim bob Lassiter

    Thanks for the clarification. I certainly did not mean to state or imply otherwise.

    Cool. You are a better man than many of the WNs here*.

    *Who say even US-born blacks and Hispanics should be expelled. Yet, they never explain how they will get all the recipient countries to agree to take up the expelled former American’s citizenship, or how to ascertain which country an African American should be sent to. Mulattos should be kicked out too, according to them, but they never say where to.

    • Replies: @bomag
    , @Jim bob Lassiter
  85. bomag says:

    Who say even US-born blacks and Hispanics should be expelled. Yet, they never explain how they will get all the recipient countries to agree to take up the expelled former American’s citizenship, or how to ascertain which country an African American should be sent to. Mulattoes should be kicked out too, according to them, but they never say where to.

    LOL. Some may say this, but it is hardly a mainstream WN view.

    Most realize the future is living with who is here; they want to quit subsidizing the flood and allow freedom of association; maybe pay people to leave.

    • Replies: @Svigor
  86. @Thomm

    Life can just be made hard on anchor babies and their families and they’ll return on their own to their respective countries of origin.

  87. Svigor says:
    @MEH 0910

    Back before my third and final Twitter ban, I used to light into Tyson pretty good. I remember once he posted some idiotic illogical crap about climate change and I tore him to shreds.

  88. Svigor says:

    All the wog cares about is wogs, and that they’re allowed to stay. Which explains his hatred of Whites who care about Whites.

  89. Svigor says:
    @Mr. Anon

    Don’t forget the cars that run on water (suppressed by TPTB or some such, IIRC) thing, and the fact that all white female celebrities are actually post-op men. Didn’t know he’s a flat-Earther, but it fits.

    What’s amazing is how many years he managed to hide his dementia.

  90. Will says:
    @Twodees Partain

    One big development is that the ones staging the attacks have now started actually killing people instead of just claiming a body count in the media coverage.

    When you have evidence of dead people and wounding/trauma, let us know. Until then, your claim is based on ZERO evidence.

  91. Tyson, a while ago: “global warming is real.”
    Tyson, now: “mass shootings are not a major threat.”
    Twitter: YOU KKK NAZI!
    Tyson: Listen, Twitter, that’s not how this “evidence” thing works. You can’t just…
    Twitter: SHUT UP!

Current Commenter

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone

 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments have been licensed to The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All John Derbyshire Comments via RSS