The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection$
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 TeasersiSteve Blog
Was This the 9/11 New Jersey Celebration Trump Remembered?

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • B
Show CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeThanksLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

On 9/11 there were numerous reports of celebrating Middle Easterners in New Jersey, but this is the one that appears to have been most carefully documented. From ABC News on an incident that has since been pretty much memory-holed:

Were Israelis Detained on Sept. 11 Spies?

Millions saw the horrific images of the World Trade Center attacks, and those who saw them won’t forget them. But a New Jersey homemaker saw something that morning that prompted an investigation into five young Israelis and their possible connection to Israeli intelligence.

Maria, who asked us not to use her last name, had a view of the World Trade Center from her New Jersey apartment building. She remembers a neighbor calling her shortly after the first plane hit the towers.

She grabbed her binoculars and watched the destruction unfolding in lower Manhattan. But as she watched the disaster, something else caught her eye.

Maria says she saw three young men kneeling on the roof of a white van in the parking lot of her apartment building. “They seemed to be taking a movie,” Maria said.

The men were taking video or photos of themselves with the World Trade Center burning in the background, she said. What struck Maria were the expressions on the men’s faces. “They were like happy, you know … They didn’t look shocked to me. I thought it was very strange,” she said.

She found the behavior so suspicious that she wrote down the license plate number of the van and called the police. Before long, the FBI was also on the scene, and a statewide bulletin was issued on the van.

The plate number was traced to a van owned by a company called Urban Moving. Around 4 p.m. on Sept. 11, the van was spotted on a service road off Route 3, near New Jersey’s Giants Stadium. A police officer pulled the van over, finding five men, between 22 and 27 years old, in the vehicle. The men were taken out of the van at gunpoint and handcuffed by police.

The arresting officers said they saw a lot that aroused their suspicion about the men. One of the passengers had $4,700 in cash hidden in his sock. Another was carrying two foreign passports. A box cutter was found in the van. But perhaps the biggest surprise for the officers came when the five men identified themselves as Israeli citizens.

According to the police report, one of the passengers told the officers they had been on the West Side Highway in Manhattan “during the incident” — referring to the World Trade Center attack. The driver of the van, Sivan Kurzberg, told the officers, “We are Israeli. We are not your problem. Your problems are our problems. The Palestinians are the problem.” The other passengers were his brother Paul Kurzberg, Yaron Shmuel, Oded Ellner and Omer Marmari.

When the men were transferred to jail, the case was transferred out of the FBI’s Criminal Division, and into the bureau’s Foreign Counterintelligence Section, which is responsible for espionage cases, ABCNEWS has learned.

One reason for the shift, sources told ABCNEWS, was that the FBI believed Urban Moving may have been providing cover for an Israeli intelligence operation. …

Steven Gordon, the attorney for the five Israeli detainees, acknowledged that his clients’ actions on Sept. 11 would easily have aroused suspicions. “You got a group of guys that are taking pictures, on top of a roof, of the World Trade Center. They’re speaking in a foreign language. They got two passports on ’em. One’s got a wad of cash on him, and they got box cutters. Now that’s a scary situation.”

But Gordon insisted that his clients were just five young men who had come to America for a vacation, ended up working for a moving company, and were taking pictures of the event.

The five Israelis were held at the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn, ostensibly for overstaying their tourist visas and working in the United States illegally. Two weeks after their arrest, an immigration judge ordered them to be deported. But sources told ABCNEWS that FBI and CIA officials in Washington put a hold on the case.

The five men were held in detention for more than two months. Some of them were placed in solitary confinement for 40 days, and some of them were given as many as seven lie-detector tests.

Since their arrest, plenty of speculation has swirled about the case, and what the five men were doing that morning. Eventually, The Forward, a respected Jewish newspaper in New York, reported the FBI concluded that two of the men were Israeli intelligence operatives.

Vince Cannistraro, a former chief of operations for counterterrorism with the CIA who is now a consultant for ABCNEWS, said federal authorities’ interest in the case was heightened when some of the men’s names were found in a search of a national intelligence database.

According to Cannistraro, many people in the U.S. intelligence community believed that some of the men arrested were working for Israeli intelligence. Cannistraro said there was speculation as to whether Urban Moving had been “set up or exploited for the purpose of launching an intelligence operation against radical Islamists in the area, particularly in the New Jersey-New York area.”

Under this scenario, the alleged spying operation was not aimed against the United States, but at penetrating or monitoring radical fund-raising and support networks in Muslim communities like Paterson, N.J., which was one of the places where several of the hijackers lived in the months prior to Sept. 11.

For the FBI, deciphering the truth from the five Israelis proved to be difficult. One of them, Paul Kurzberg, refused to take a lie-detector test for 10 weeks — then failed it, according to his lawyer. Another of his lawyers told us Kurzberg had been reluctant to take the test because he had once worked for Israeli intelligence in another country.

Sources say the Israelis were targeting these fund-raising networks because they were thought to be channeling money to Hamas and Islamic Jihad, groups that are responsible for most of the suicide bombings in Israel. …

Despite the denials, sources tell ABCNEWS there is still debate within the FBI over whether or not the young men were spies.

I doubt if this was terribly important incident, although I have to say I was surprised to see how seriously the FBI took it.

My guess is that there are many casual ties between Israeli intelligence, Israeli business interests (e.g., telecom software), organized crime (e.g., the Ecstasy pill trade), and Israeli illegal immigrants in the U.S.

For example, I can vaguely recall decades ago the marketing research firm I worked for being subjected to intrusive “Israeli art students.” Were they selling bad paintings? Were they trying to spy on us? Both? It didn’t seem like any kind of sophisticated effort. What in the world kind of info could you steal by barging around the hallways of a consumer packaged goods research firm with the office manager trying to throw you out? It was more like just something that random aggressive Israeli young people might think might turn out to be a good idea. Or maybe they could sell some crummy paintings. Or maybe it would just be a fun adventure.

But that’s how good intelligence systems work: you can’t afford to pay for full timers to cover everything, so you exchange gossip with merchants and journalists on your side and encourage them to be pushy about finding out stuff.

For example, the Tom Hanks character in Spielberg’s “Bridge of Spies” is portrayed as a humble insurance lawyer who just happens to get picked by the local bar association to defend the arrested Soviet spymaster Rudolf Abel. But in reality, the man Hanks portrays had been the head lawyer for the CIA’s predecessor, the OSS, in WWII. After the war he went into commercial law because it pays better than being a government lawyer. But the American government continued to trust him to handle delicate deals, just as the remarkably prosperous East German lawyer he negotiated the Francis Gary Powers swap with had been vetted by his side.

As far as I can tell, U.S. intelligence is fairly hamstrung by fear of leaks and traitors. For example, a friend applied for a job as a CIA analyst, but it took forever for the security checks so he took a job in private industry instead. My impression is that Israeli intelligence is more free-wheeling because it trusts Israeli Jews (with the exception of that technician who spilled the beans that, yes, Israel has nukes). But I’m speculating because what do I know?

 
Hide 440 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. Is the use of ‘pushy’ antisemitic?

    • Replies: @marty
    @Blobby5

    I once knew a U. Chicago mba student who described another jew thusly: "he'll do well in life, he's pushy, obnoxious."

  2. Israel seems to work on trust in many ways. E.g. how exactly do they verify your Jewishness when you apply for citizenship there? It would seem to be something easy to fake, and yet Israel is pretty good at keeping itself Jewish.

    • Replies: @Cwhatfuture
    @jtgw

    For citizenship, it is not difficult. Certain names are Jewish and you have to present some proof of the fact that you are Jewish (your Bar Mitzvah certificate). The real check is marriage. The rabbis are very strict and will subject you to a trial, where witnesses and evidence are presented. All in all they manage it well - if limiting the numbers of Jews is the goal, which it seems to be. Conversion to Judaism is hard. They are not looking for converts.

    Replies: @jtgw

    , @Steve Sailer
    @jtgw

    There are a whole bunch of websites run by Jews that evaluate how Jewish various celebrities are. My impression is that gentiles have no clue how much mental energy Jews devote to such questions.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @yaqub the mad scientist, @Ben Tzot-Abrit, @Stephen R. Diamond, @Dahlia

    , @sprfls
    @jtgw

    Who said they do a good job? Obviously I don't know the exact numbers here, but for example a significant amount of non-Jewish Soviets emigrated to Israel in the 80s and 90s.

    Replies: @Dave Pinsen, @cwhatfuture, @Karl

    , @Karl
    @jtgw

    >> how exactly do they verify your Jewishness when you apply for citizenship there?

    the same sort of way that Ireland verifies that one of your four grandparents was Irish, before giving you your Irish passport.

    I notice that Ireland just put some money into copying the "Birthright" program.

    Didn't Michelle Bachmann just get her Swiss dual-loyalty credentials?

    Philippines process for granting dual-citizenship to its large diaspora,runs pretty much the same way.

    In MANY of the world's second-tier countries, if you REALLY want to gain citizenship, repeated applications of money and persistence, will get you there. Lawyers exist.

    , @Lugash
    @jtgw

    And in America, we allow American born foreign spies and their foreign born spy husbands to emigrate to the United States, after kidnapping people on foreign soil:

    http://www.sptimes.com/2004/03/21/Worldandnation/The_spy___and_the_man.shtml

    , @shk12344
    @jtgw

    Israel can always do a DNA test for Jewish ancestry.

    Russian-speakers who want to make aliya could need DNA test

    http://www.timesofisrael.com/russian-speakers-who-want-to-immigrate-could-need-dna-test/

  3. The picture I remember was of about five men seen from behind looking across the river at the twin towers and rejoicing. They were said to be Israelis. They would obviously be happy because now the US would go to war against Arabs. I’ve read that Israelis had some inkling that an attack was imminent, and that US intelligence did also, “Their hair was on fire”, but that the administration ignored US intelligence. For example, of course, Bush thought it would be racist to profile Arabs. I have not read if US intelligence did or did not receive leads from the Israelis.

    • Replies: @NOTA
    @Robert Hume

    Even if the Israelis knew ahead of time, why would they send people in the field who knew ahead of time, and put them in a position to be arrested and questioned by the FBI?

    Replies: @cwhatfuture

    , @Anonymous
    @Robert Hume

    They were filming the attack. The were apprehended for 40+ days and failed lie detector tests.

    One of them inadvertently admitted on live Israeli TV they were there to 'document the event'

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tRfhUezbKLw

    There are a lot of things that were reported on at the time of the attack that were simply never followed up on. Here is Fox news footage from 2001, alleging that Israel knew what was going to happen.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LbkQddEDPs0


    Any way you slice it, Israel is rotten in it's dealings with the US. There is no way they should be considered an 'ally' and the fact that they receive aid from the American taxpayer is an outrage.

    Replies: @tanabear

  4. It seems that some Arabs in New York City did have prior knowledge of the attack and were looking forward to it.

    Prior Knowledge of Sept. 11 Not Just Urban Legend
    Posted Sept. 10, 2002
    By Jeffrey Scott Shapiro

    “What are you looking at?” asked the schoolteacher as she approached one of her freshman students. The boy, a young Palestinian, seemed captivated as he stared out the window across Brooklyn toward the lower downtown area of Manhattan.

    “Do you see those two buildings?” he asked while pointing toward the World Trade Center. “They won’t be standing there next week.” It was noon, Sept. 6, 2001.

    Antoinette DiLorenzo didn’t take her student’s comment all too seriously. Of course the twin towers would be there next week, she assured him. The student shook his head and reiterated his prediction until his 15-year old brother, a sophomore, elbowed him and told him to be quiet. “He’s just kidding,” the older boy said politely.

    Five days later at 8:45 a.m., DiLorenzo heard a loud explosion from the north. Thunderstruck, she turned to the window and eventually watched both towers collapse into shattered glass and crumbled steel.

    Many people believed this story was nothing more than an urban legend when they first heard it. Everyone has heard similar stories in the wake of such a disaster. Despite the almost unbelievable circumstances of the story, I was able to confirm it last October while working as a crime reporter for the Journal News, a New York-based Gannett newspaper. Catie Marshall, a spokeswoman for the New York City Board of Education, confirmed that school officials reported the incident to police and that the matter had since been taken over by the FBI Joint Terrorist Task Force (FBI-JTTF).

    New Utrecht High School was closed Sept. 12, 2001, but as soon as it reopened the following morning, a shaken DiLorenzo quietly approached a New York City Police Department (NYPD) school-safety officer in the school’s first-floor lobby. Soon, a dozen investigators stormed the school, interrogating students and searching lockers.

    After federal agents questioned DiLorenzo, police detectives questioned her fourth-period class to see if anyone else had heard the boy’s comments. Once the detectives were finished, the boy and his brother forcibly were taken to the 62nd Precinct headquarters, where two investigators with the FBI-JTTF questioned them for several hours. Their father, who was in Israel at the time of the attacks, was scheduled to fly home Sept. 11 on a commercial airliner, but he was delayed when all flights to the United States were grounded.

    More at the following webpage:

    http://www.prisonplanet.com/prior_knowledge_of_sept_11_not_just_urban_legend.htm

    • Replies: @SPMoore8
    @Mike Sylwester

    That's a terrible article. The basic premise is that a lot of 10-12 year old Arabs know precise details about terror attacks, but no one else does.

    It's not as though they were instant messaging Osama. There has to be a chain of how the knowledge is disseminated from Thrush Central (here, OBL) all the way down to these boys, and how no one else in that chain of dissemination leaked the information, or was arrested, charged, and convicted.

    The icing on the cake comes at the end of the article when the paranoid author recounts a story of an Arab boy who told people not to fly on November 12: of course, the date the flight AA 587 to the Dominican Republic crashed in Queens. Author says: "authorities say it was an accident. I'm not so sure." Hey, I had to put air in one of my tires this morning. I thought it was routine maintenance, but now, I'm not so sure .....

    , @greysquirrell
    @Mike Sylwester

    PrisonPlanet is not a decent source, because while it occassionally may have some worthy news , it is too often neck deep in unsutantiated conspiracy news.

    The problem in believeing the story you quote is that there is no way the planners of 9-11 would have told or discussed their plans in a manner that some highschool kids could overhear and then babble about it.

    Unless I can see some mainstream news sites report on the same claim , I'm chalking it up to propaghanda. The article reporting the kids were Palestinian also arouses my suspicion. None of the 9-11 Hijackers were Palestinian, so it wouldn't be like their unlces or older brothers or dads were discussing it and these kids overheard it.

    Replies: @Bugg

  5. “But Gordon insisted that his clients were just five young men who had come to America for a vacation, ended up working for a moving company.”

    Because who doesn’t eventually end up working for a Jersey moving company when they’re on vacation? I still regale friends and family members with stories of the time I visited London and spent the entire three weeks working 14 hour a day shifts frying chicken at KFC Halal. Even more memorable was that trip to Thailand back in middle school, where I spent a week turning tricks for a local pimp, Prayut. He and I are still penpals, exchanging Christmas cards, Hanukkah presents, homemade porn, and updates on our latest T cell counts. Good times…

    • Agree: Romanian
    • LOL: JohnnyWalker123
    • Replies: @AndrewR
    @Wilkey

    Lmao! I've seen some funny comments on this site but yours takes the cake. You could write for Family Guy.

    Replies: @MW

    , @ben tillman
    @Wilkey

    LOL! Absolutely hilarious.

  6. I could have sworn the so-called “dancing Israelis” were in Brooklyn?

  7. Steve: “I doubt if this was terribly important incident.”

    You might want to look into the incident a little bit more. The Dancing Israeli’s were giddy with delight right after the first tower was struck. Three of the 5 were members of the Mossad. They stated that they were there to document the events. The cameras were setup prior to the attacks. Also look into Dominick Suter and Urban Moving Systems.

    • Replies: @Seth
    @tanabear

    The idea that these guys were up to anything in particular is absurd.

    They were filming the WTC as it burned...like everyone else with a camera in a two mile radius. On tv later one of them said in bad English that he was "documenting" the event and the loonies took that to mean that he had been sent there to do it.

    Why would the Mossad need to have the most spectacular event in American history specially "documented?"

    NYC is filled with illegal immigrants who say they are tourists and are doing some work in the meantime. Not unusual.

    Movers are often paid in cash. $4700 among 4 people may sound like a lot of money to some fevered conspiracy theorist but if that was all their money it's really not that much.

    Replies: @Jasper Been, @tanabear

  8. Don’t forget the part about how these guys, and their Urban Moving Systems colleagues, were arrested in two white Urban Moving Systems vans, respectively containing traces of explosives, and packed with explosives. All public record. The footage, police transcript, police forensic record, MSM news record, their interrogation record under lie detector, all public record.

  9. Overheard in Mossad headquarters:

    “Oy vey! We put these guys on the payroll, and they do a sack dance on a van roof! We’re supposed to be the smart ones here, but our people just can’t help themselves sometimes. Even their country-western songs know the score: ‘you never count your money, when you’re sitting at the table.’”

  10. @Wilkey
    "But Gordon insisted that his clients were just five young men who had come to America for a vacation, ended up working for a moving company."

    Because who doesn't eventually end up working for a Jersey moving company when they're on vacation? I still regale friends and family members with stories of the time I visited London and spent the entire three weeks working 14 hour a day shifts frying chicken at KFC Halal. Even more memorable was that trip to Thailand back in middle school, where I spent a week turning tricks for a local pimp, Prayut. He and I are still penpals, exchanging Christmas cards, Hanukkah presents, homemade porn, and updates on our latest T cell counts. Good times...

    Replies: @AndrewR, @ben tillman

    Lmao! I’ve seen some funny comments on this site but yours takes the cake. You could write for Family Guy.

    • Replies: @MW
    @AndrewR

    As absurd as it sounds to an American, this is exactly what my Israeli cousin did, though "vacation" might be a misleading word. It is very common for young Israelis to take a few years after their army service and putter around the world, working as necessary. And there are lots of Israeli moving companies in the US, for whatever reason. So when my cousin needed work after a month or two doing nothing, he reached out to a childhood friend of his who, sure enough, ran a moving company in the US.

    Replies: @Karl

  11. Is Josef Schuster, the president of the Central Council of Jews in Germany, yet one more secret reader of yours?

    And by the way, Pollard’s sinecure didn’t last long…

  12. @jtgw
    Israel seems to work on trust in many ways. E.g. how exactly do they verify your Jewishness when you apply for citizenship there? It would seem to be something easy to fake, and yet Israel is pretty good at keeping itself Jewish.

    Replies: @Cwhatfuture, @Steve Sailer, @sprfls, @Karl, @Lugash, @shk12344

    For citizenship, it is not difficult. Certain names are Jewish and you have to present some proof of the fact that you are Jewish (your Bar Mitzvah certificate). The real check is marriage. The rabbis are very strict and will subject you to a trial, where witnesses and evidence are presented. All in all they manage it well – if limiting the numbers of Jews is the goal, which it seems to be. Conversion to Judaism is hard. They are not looking for converts.

    • Replies: @jtgw
    @Cwhatfuture

    Speaking of Jewish names, I always thought Alfred Rosenberg was pretty ironic.

    Replies: @Wally

  13. Regardless, here are some future Syrian immigrants to the US celebrating 9/11.

  14. @jtgw
    Israel seems to work on trust in many ways. E.g. how exactly do they verify your Jewishness when you apply for citizenship there? It would seem to be something easy to fake, and yet Israel is pretty good at keeping itself Jewish.

    Replies: @Cwhatfuture, @Steve Sailer, @sprfls, @Karl, @Lugash, @shk12344

    There are a whole bunch of websites run by Jews that evaluate how Jewish various celebrities are. My impression is that gentiles have no clue how much mental energy Jews devote to such questions.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Steve Sailer

    "There are a whole bunch of websites run by Jews that evaluate how Jewish various celebrities are. My impression is that gentiles have no clue how much mental energy Jews devote to such questions."

    Obsession with racial purity. Nurturing ancient grievances. A belief in thier own superiority.

    Those traits remind me of another people I once heard about...........can't remember who.

    Replies: @Wally

    , @yaqub the mad scientist
    @Steve Sailer

    Maybe the government needs to pass a kind of Dawes Act to help resolve the conflicting quantum blood/lineal descent debate between Reform and more conservative sects, and tie congressional funding for Israel the way the BIA hands out props to reservations.

    , @Ben Tzot-Abrit
    @Steve Sailer

    You are correct about this. Some Jews also don't grasp how much other Jews devote to this. After 40 years of marriage, my father's side of the family is still flabbergasted at how much energy my mother's side of the family spends on this.

    Replies: @el topo

    , @Stephen R. Diamond
    @Steve Sailer

    Do you observe that all kinds of Jews attend to this? Or just the religious Jews?

    I think it's mostly the religious ones.

    , @Dahlia
    @Steve Sailer

    Funniest example I've ever seen of this...

    Years ago, and I'm 95% sure it was John Podhoretz, was commenting at National Review's blog. He had gotten excited about Ben Roethlisberger (pre-scandal), wondering if he was Jewish. Perhaps it was a Super Bowl, but lots of eyes were on him for some reason. So John googled it and posted what is the funniest bit of trolling I personally have ever come across...

    When you googled Ben Roethlisberger and Jewish, the first entry was an excited, eager, hyperventilating promised expose of whether Ben, indeed, was Jewish. When you clicked the link, you were brought to a single page with a single sentence in plain type at the very top of the page, just like what your opened desktop .txt file would look like:
    Sorry, Jews, he's not one of yours.

    Replies: @SFG

  15. I’ve always thought there was a Mossad link to 9/11, but I understand any skepticism when it comes to things like this. They have to be smart and sleuthy enough to do whatever they did undercover, but dumb and undisciplined enough that some of their agents get caught dancing and celebrating the attack? Doesn’t mesh. Oh well.

  16. Anonymous • Disclaimer says:

    “For example, a friend applied for a job as a CIA analyst, but it took forever for the security checks so he took a job in private industry instead.”

    Uh …. Steve…. you do realize that’s exactly what he would have told you if he had been hired by the CIA?

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Anonymous

    He complains a lot about how he proved on 10/14/2002 that Saddam couldn't afford a nuclear bomb program anymore but nobody would listen to him.

    Replies: @Josh, @Thomas O. Meehan

    , @Anonymous
    @Anonymous

    If he had been hired as a CIA analyst he would have said "I've been hired by the government in Virginia," not "I'm moving to New Mexico."

  17. @Steve Sailer
    @jtgw

    There are a whole bunch of websites run by Jews that evaluate how Jewish various celebrities are. My impression is that gentiles have no clue how much mental energy Jews devote to such questions.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @yaqub the mad scientist, @Ben Tzot-Abrit, @Stephen R. Diamond, @Dahlia

    “There are a whole bunch of websites run by Jews that evaluate how Jewish various celebrities are. My impression is that gentiles have no clue how much mental energy Jews devote to such questions.”

    Obsession with racial purity. Nurturing ancient grievances. A belief in thier own superiority.

    Those traits remind me of another people I once heard about………..can’t remember who.

    • Replies: @Wally
    @Mr. Anon

    But Sailer is correct.

    Next.

  18. The Israeli technician who blew the whistle on Israel’s nuke program was Mordechai Vanunu. From his Wiki page:

    Mordechai Vanunu (Hebrew: מרדכי ואנונו‎; born 14 October 1954), also known as John Crossman,[2][3] is an Israeli former nuclear technician and peace activist[4] who, citing his opposition to weapons of mass destruction, revealed details of Israel’s nuclear weapons program to the British press in 1986.[5][6] He was subsequently lured to Italy by a Mossad agent, where he was drugged and abducted by Israeli intelligence agents.[5] He was transported to Israel and ultimately convicted in a trial that was held behind closed doors.[5]
    Vanunu spent 18 years in prison, including more than 11 in solitary confinement. Released from prison in 2004, he became subject to a broad array of restrictions on his speech and movement. Since then he has been arrested several times for violations of those restrictions, including giving various interviews to foreign journalists and attempting to leave Israel. He says he suffered “cruel and barbaric treatment” at the hands of Israeli authorities while imprisoned, and suggests that his treatment would have been different if he had not converted to Christianity from Judaism.[7]
    In 2007, Vanunu was sentenced to six months in prison for violating terms of his parole. The sentence was considered unusual even by the prosecution who expected a suspended sentence. In response, Amnesty International issued a press release on 2 July 2007, stating that “The organisation considers Mordechai Vanunu to be a prisoner of conscience and calls for his immediate and unconditional release.”[8] In May 2010, Vanunu was arrested and sentenced to three months in jail on a charge that he met foreigners in violation of conditions of his 2004 release from jail.

    • Replies: @Anonymous, @This Is Our Home
    @Black Death

    The treatment seems pretty fair for a traitor. Indeed it is more moderate than what the US has done to Pollard; I probably would have shot them both.

    Replies: @Black Death

    , @AnotherDad
    @Black Death

    Vanunu's certainly wasn't Pollard level of treason.

    No one was at all confused that the Israelis had nuclear weapons. They didn't sign the NPT for a reason. One expects US\Soviet intelligence had at least ballpark estimates of where they were at. What Vanunu provided was some public confirmation of scale.

    My two-bit analysis: I don't think he harmed Israel at all. Leftists painted nuclear deterrence as "terror", but i slept like a baby my whole youth. Wasn't waking in a cold sweat thinking the Russkis were going to nuke me, because they knew with certainty what would happen to them if they did. Arab hostiles now know with certainty what fate awaits them--their cities, muslim holy sites ... gone--if they really try to push Israel into the sea. (And they haven't tried to do so since.) Yet, Israel can continue to parrot whatever their bogus line is "won't be the first to introduce" to the US.

    But that said, plain fact is, Israel elects a government and its their job--not Vanunu's--to decide to release what information about their nuclear program at what time for maximum benefit to their nation's security. Ergo Vanunu's a traitor. The Israelis would be well within normal respectable rules of fair play to take him out back and shoot him.

    Pollard's nothing but a traitor, selling off actual operational intelligence methods, info that hindered intelligence collection and harmed US security for cash money. He should have been drawn and quartered, boiling oil dribbled down his throat and his innards pulled out and burned. That someone is giving him a job on Wall Street suggests said someone is not an American.

    Replies: @D. K.

  19. My first reaction when I heard Trump’s account was that he was confusing what he thought he remembered with the fairly well documented story of the “dancing” Israelis in New Jersey celebrating the collapse of the Twin Towers. I notice that neither Trump nor the MSM outlets trying to debunk Trump (NBC Nightly News had a lead piece last night) mentioned the incident involving the Israeli “movers.” Who doesn’t carry $4700 in cash hidden in his sock? You never know when you are going to run into a bargain and don’t want to use your credit card. I have been doing it for years. I admit it’s kind of hard when you live in Florida and generally don’t wear socks.

  20. You write there were “numerous reports” of Midwesterners celebrating on 9/11. I know about the Israelis in the van– and Carl Cameron’s Fox News reports on them, etc. But others? Sad to say, it’s important. Trump can get away with saying a lot of politically incorrect stuff, but he can’t just make stuff up, it’s really not presidential.

    • Replies: @nglaer
    @nglaer

    I meant Mideasterners--it's your silly spellcheck.

    , @Bill Jones
    @nglaer

    " it’s really not presidential."

    "Now who's being Naive, Kay?"

    Replies: @Hunsdon

    , @Desiderius
    @nglaer


    he can’t just make stuff up, it’s really not presidential
     
    One would hope.

    Don't think the current occupant feels that way.
  21. @nglaer
    You write there were "numerous reports" of Midwesterners celebrating on 9/11. I know about the Israelis in the van-- and Carl Cameron's Fox News reports on them, etc. But others? Sad to say, it's important. Trump can get away with saying a lot of politically incorrect stuff, but he can't just make stuff up, it's really not presidential.

    Replies: @nglaer, @Bill Jones, @Desiderius

    I meant Mideasterners–it’s your silly spellcheck.

  22. @Anonymous

    "For example, a friend applied for a job as a CIA analyst, but it took forever for the security checks so he took a job in private industry instead."
     
    Uh .... Steve.... you do realize that's exactly what he would have told you if he had been hired by the CIA?

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @Anonymous

    He complains a lot about how he proved on 10/14/2002 that Saddam couldn’t afford a nuclear bomb program anymore but nobody would listen to him.

    • Replies: @Josh
    @Steve Sailer

    Oh...him.

    , @Thomas O. Meehan
    @Steve Sailer

    I lived in New Jersey at the time of the attack and was working in law enforcement. I recall reports of Arabs celebrating on the streets of Paterson or Passaic. At this remove I can't say I saw video of said jubilation, but it was reported and taken at face value by a very large percentage of the population. At the same time the airwaves were full of footage of Palestinians openly celebrating. Those were the circumstances. It would be surprising if no one among the notoriously unassimilated ME populations in their ethnic ghettos hadn't celebrated a bit. At the same time it is possible that Trump saw the dancing Palestinians and conflated them with the reports from Paterson and or Passaic.

    That said, I think it is possible that footage exists but is lost or being withheld.

    If Trump is delusional about the dancing arabs of Passaic, he shares that delusion with millions of fellow New York area citizens.

    Replies: @Ron Unz, @Anonymous

  23. The Dancing Israelis appear in the 2005 documentary The Protocols of Zion. The Jewish filmmaker investigates the story expecting to find another antijewish canard like he does in all the other parts of the film, but he discovers the guys to have been actual Israeli intelligence assets. They appeared on an Israeli talk show after their release and the filmmaker includes a clip of this in the documentary.

    Well worth watching.

  24. What in the world kind of info could you steal by barging around the hallways of a consumer packaged goods research firm with the office manager trying to throw you out

    Running a moving company, on the other hand…

  25. As far as I can tell, U.S. intelligence is fairly hamstrung by fear of leaks and traitors. For example, a friend applied for a job as a CIA analyst, but it took forever for the security checks so he took a job in private industry instead.

    I once considered working for FBI or CIA. I got application packages from each. I had familial connection to CIA, but no relationship to FBI. The FBI package was at least 50 pages and required exhaustive detail including all schools attended and dates of attendance along with grades (do you have your third grade report cards?). They demanded all family connections to second cousin along with detail like date of birth and photos. It was, putting it mildly, incredibly over the top. The CIA application was a bit different. Again, I had some family connection including covert operatives one of whom lost his life in Turkey and another in Laos. But the CIA application package was two pages. I’ve had far more intrusive applications for corporate weenie jobs. Name, date of birth, SSN, address, college, and employment – that’s all they wanted. What I took from this was that FBI is occupied by paper pushers, bureaucrats, lawyers, and accountants, demanding every i be dotted and every t crossed to cover their own asses. The CIA, on the other hand, is far more cowboy in orientation and looking more for specific attributes it can exploit in labor talent. It’s easy to understand how the two organizations can spectacularly fail to work together.

    • Replies: @Josh
    @Stan D Mute

    Or they can get your info for themselves, than you very much.

    , @al gore rhythms
    @Stan D Mute


    The FBI package was at least 50 pages and required exhaustive detail including all schools attended and dates of attendance along with grades (do you have your third grade report cards?). They demanded all family connections to second cousin along with detail like date of birth and photos. It was, putting it mildly, incredibly over the top
     
    Shouldn't this be subject to a 'disparate impact' challenge? If you moved to America as a young child from the chaotic Third World then it might be hard to prove family connections or school grades.

    Replies: @Stan D Mute

  26. I vividly remember footage on CNN of Palestinians in the West Bank celebrating 9/11 right after it happened, which is probably what Trump has in his mind’s eye when he says he saw “thousands and thousands” of Muslims cheering it (though 20 or so in a crowded film frame is what I remember). I don’t think I ever heard of the Jersey City incident, but there are 2001 news reports of police investigating a Muslim celebration that didn’t bear fruit which Trump, living nearby, probably read about. Since the reports are very similar and happened at the same time it’s likely Trump’s memory is conflating two separate but similar news stories.

  27. @Cwhatfuture
    @jtgw

    For citizenship, it is not difficult. Certain names are Jewish and you have to present some proof of the fact that you are Jewish (your Bar Mitzvah certificate). The real check is marriage. The rabbis are very strict and will subject you to a trial, where witnesses and evidence are presented. All in all they manage it well - if limiting the numbers of Jews is the goal, which it seems to be. Conversion to Judaism is hard. They are not looking for converts.

    Replies: @jtgw

    Speaking of Jewish names, I always thought Alfred Rosenberg was pretty ironic.

    • Replies: @Wally
    @jtgw

    Speaking of non-Jewish names, I always thought Kirk Douglas was pretty ironic.

    Replies: @jtgw, @Kevin O'Keeffe

  28. O/T I can’t remember if I’ve posted this here or not but I’ve made a prediction that Hillary will choose a hispanic man for VP. Another woman steals her thunder, a white man isn’t “progress”, an asian man too irrelevant, a well-spoken black man in very short supply. A Hispanic male VP charges up her side of the immigration vote. I’m sure there are a couple possible choices in the Dem. party somewhere.

    As for the republicans, if its Trump he’s completely unpredictable. If its an establishment candidate, it looks like they cut a deal with Kasich to get the VP role in exchange for leading the attack against Trump.

    • Replies: @nglaer
    @jackmcg

    http://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2015/11/22/dnc_vice_chair_tulsi_gabbard_toppling_secular_dicators_like_hussein_qaddafi_assad_is_counterproductive_because_is_directly_helps_isis__al-qaeda.html

    Trump should choose Tulsi Gabbard, would send a lot of good and confusing signals.

    Replies: @jackmcg

    , @Kevin O'Keeffe
    @jackmcg

    "I can’t remember if I’ve posted this here or not but I’ve made a prediction that Hillary will choose a hispanic man for VP. Another woman steals her thunder, a white man isn’t “progress”, an asian man too irrelevant, a well-spoken black man in very short supply. A Hispanic male VP charges up her side of the immigration vote. I’m sure there are a couple possible choices in the Dem. party somewhere."

    Hillary has all but stated her intent to nominate HUD Secretary Julian* Castro as her Veep. Steve's talked about it, actually.

    *Pronounced "whoolian," for all you micro-aggressing sh*tlords who had the temerity to suppose he pronounced it like the old Roman Emperor

    Replies: @NOTA

  29. As far as I can tell, U.S. intelligence is fairly hamstrung by fear of leaks and traitors. For example, a friend applied for a job as a CIA analyst, but it took forever for the security checks

    Both the FBI and the CIA put potential hires through a battery of lie detector tests in which they are asked whether or not they’ve committed the most mundane of “illegal” acts, such as downloading music for free or parking in a handicap spot. If you admit it, you don’t get hired. If you say you didn’t, but the machine says you did, you don’t get hired. Obviously, no young man in America is as squeaky clean as their standards demand; the result is that the spooks and G-men simply hire the best liars.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Seth Largo

    If you broke the law, just tell the truth.

    Replies: @donut, @ShaslA, @SFG

  30. Those “dancing Israelis” allegedly went on Israeli television to recount their tale and said that they were there “to document the event”. This TV bit starts at around 6:10 in this video:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStJ5BgadPs

  31. “For example, I can vaguely recall decades ago the marketing research firm I worked for being subjected to intrusive “Israeli art students.” Were they selling bad paintings? Were they trying to spy on us? Both?”

    Did they ever sell a single painting? Based on that Salon article, it pretty clearly was a spy-ring. And the notion that dozens of Israelis passing themselves off as students would be engaged in spying without it being an actual operation of the Israeli government is ridiculous. But some official fromt he Israeli government assured us that “Israel does not spy on the United States”.

    It seems odd that they seemed to be targeting the DEA so much…..why?

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Mr. Anon

    The Israeli government tosses a certain amount of money toward a lot of things. For example, it funds college students to engage in online hasbara. But that doesn't necessarily mean that every tweet is signed off on by Netanyahu's office.

    Some of these low level things may just be to try out enthusiastic young volunteers and see who turns out to be good at it.

    Other stuff could just be intelligence people doing a little drug dealing on the side.

  32. WhatEvvs [AKA "Internet Addict"] says:

    I’ve always thought that they were drug dealers. Might a moving company not be a nicely convenient cover for drug dealing?

    Israelis have a well deserved rep for unmitigated shamelessness, but doing something like this, blabbing so openly to their arresting officers? Couldn’t the Mossad do a bit better than this?

  33. @Mr. Anon
    @Steve Sailer

    "There are a whole bunch of websites run by Jews that evaluate how Jewish various celebrities are. My impression is that gentiles have no clue how much mental energy Jews devote to such questions."

    Obsession with racial purity. Nurturing ancient grievances. A belief in thier own superiority.

    Those traits remind me of another people I once heard about...........can't remember who.

    Replies: @Wally

    But Sailer is correct.

    Next.

  34. Fox News briefly did a piece on the Israeli spying

    http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article7545.htm

    It very quickly found its was down the memory tube.

    • Replies: @tbraton
    @Bill Jones

    That's what I remember seeing. Thanks for jogging my memory. It was a very well done piece, as I recall.

  35. I too met some Israeli “art students,” just before 9/11 in fact. Young, tan-colored guys, typical Israeli type young men. I have sometimes wondered if they were among those guys with the van. The region of the country is right, and the timing is right.

    They were brought into the US by a charitable Jewish organization, which will remain nameless. I will not say how I met them, but I can’t help but share something that still makes me laugh:

    Having taken some art history in college, and having a long appreciation for the painting of certain periods, I of course worked the subject into a conversation with one of the “students.” I described some of my favorite art, and I asked him things like, “who are your favorite painters,” and “what period or type of art are you interested in.” It was like talking to a dairy cow. (So much for the vaunted Jewish IQ.) This guy clearly knew nothing about art and had no interest in it. He couldn’t even fake it, and he basically sucked at conversation.

    One would think Mossad would have prepared their spies for this situation, but they didn’t.

    I forgot about those guys until the story came out in the weeks after 9/11.

    • Thanks: JohnnyWalker123
  36. @jtgw
    @Cwhatfuture

    Speaking of Jewish names, I always thought Alfred Rosenberg was pretty ironic.

    Replies: @Wally

    Speaking of non-Jewish names, I always thought Kirk Douglas was pretty ironic.

    • Replies: @jtgw
    @Wally

    I'm not sure I get it.

    , @Kevin O'Keeffe
    @Wally

    "Kirk Douglas" was, effectively, a stage name. He was born Issur Danielovitch.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar

  37. I admit, the “Dancing Israelis” did come to mind when Trump went off on his latest rant. Perhaps he’s trying to send some kind of coded signal to the Deep Staters, basically saying “I KNOW, so you better think twice on how far you want to push me.”

    But more likely, he was probably thinking of the footage of Palistinians dancing in the streets over in Israel. I clearly remember all of the networks showing that footage. It’s easy to see how memories could become jumbled on that day. If I were him, I’d at least backtrack on the “thousands and thousands” part. I know he doesn’t like to admit he’s wrong, but I don’t think even his most hardcore supporters will think less of him for it.

    • Replies: @jackmcg
    @Hapalong Cassidy

    Yes, Trump is good at this.

    Most conspicuously, he says "Border Walls work... ask Israel how well they work."

    Some doubt his sincerity, and I get that, but I believe Trump is an alt-righter with the right touch of conspiracy theory who would find himself right at home in these corners of the internet.

    I know they say he's "not politically correct", but I think he knows when to be politically correct, while still tracing the edges of this stuff so that it makes all of us think "he knows!".

  38. @tanabear
    Steve: "I doubt if this was terribly important incident."

    You might want to look into the incident a little bit more. The Dancing Israeli's were giddy with delight right after the first tower was struck. Three of the 5 were members of the Mossad. They stated that they were there to document the events. The cameras were setup prior to the attacks. Also look into Dominick Suter and Urban Moving Systems.

    Replies: @Seth

    The idea that these guys were up to anything in particular is absurd.

    They were filming the WTC as it burned…like everyone else with a camera in a two mile radius. On tv later one of them said in bad English that he was “documenting” the event and the loonies took that to mean that he had been sent there to do it.

    Why would the Mossad need to have the most spectacular event in American history specially “documented?”

    NYC is filled with illegal immigrants who say they are tourists and are doing some work in the meantime. Not unusual.

    Movers are often paid in cash. $4700 among 4 people may sound like a lot of money to some fevered conspiracy theorist but if that was all their money it’s really not that much.

    • Agree: This Is Our Home
    • Replies: @Jasper Been
    @Seth

    It is revealing the parts you attempt to explain and the other aspects you choose not to address.

    , @tanabear
    @Seth

    Seth: "The idea that these guys were up to anything in particular is absurd."

    If it was absurd then they wouldn't have been contained for 71 days and questioned about their activities on 09/11/2001 over and over again. They obviously had to arouse some sort of suspicion and stand out from other witnesses of the towers burning otherwise the police would not have been called. Urban Moving Systems/Company was apparently a front company for the Mossad. Three of the suspects were Mossad agents. This is very suspicious.

    But why were they so giddy and happy?

    From the FBI report: "...one of the males appeared to be taking still photographs and video of the other males with the WTC in the background. All of the males appeared to be jovial in that they smiled, hugged one another, and gave "high fives".

    "Film obtained from the 35mm camera of one of the detainees was later developed and processed by the Newark Division. The photos clearly corroborate [Blank's] statements in that the Israelis are visibly happy on nearly all of the photgraphs."

    Replies: @Seth

  39. OT

    I was checking the BBC file on Turkey’s latest bear baiting:

    Former UK Foreign Office official says Russia will do ‘very little’
    Posted at12:31
    Reza Afshar, a former UK Foreign Office official in charge of Britain’s policy on Syria tweets:

    Reza Afshar @RezaMac
    #Turkey shoots down #Russia plane. Guess what Russia will do. Very little. Fears about confronting Russia have always been overblown. #Syria
    6:31 PM – 24 Nov 2015
    6363 Retweets 3131 like

    This sounded so remarkably complacent that I looked this guy up. He is a walking disaster: lead UK dip on Libya bombing, pressed hard to arm “moderate” Syrian rebels; lead UK dip on narcotics control in Afghanistan; lead dip on Cameron’s earlier scheme to bomb Assad, etc.

    And he keeps mysteriously rising. Now with a big with a New York Davos-level diplomacy group:

    http://independentdiplomat.org/about-us/staff/reza-afshar/

    Sent from my iPad

  40. Alas for paper storage and microfiche, when you could go over the entire paper, down to the classifieds. Go electronic, and that article may be in the oubliette.

    I do remember reading about a teenage Palestinian boy in Paterson saying, “Now they know how we feel.”

    • Replies: @Tracy
    @Polymath


    I do remember reading about a teenage Palestinian boy in Paterson saying, “Now they know how we feel.”
     
    That's funny, because I was glued to the TV that day, almost mesmerized by what was going on, and know that video was played and replayed over and over -- except one, which was of an Israeli saying exactly what you attribute above to some Palestinian teenager. That, I think, was the only video I didn't see a hundred times that day (being hyperbolic here, obviously, with the "hundred" times, but straight-up about it). I've been unable to find that footage anywhere since, but I most definitely saw it. Once. On 9-11, during regular news broadcasts, on some channel such as CNN or FOX or whatever it was.

    Replies: @Bill Jones, @onetwothree

  41. @Mr. Anon
    "For example, I can vaguely recall decades ago the marketing research firm I worked for being subjected to intrusive “Israeli art students.” Were they selling bad paintings? Were they trying to spy on us? Both?"

    Did they ever sell a single painting? Based on that Salon article, it pretty clearly was a spy-ring. And the notion that dozens of Israelis passing themselves off as students would be engaged in spying without it being an actual operation of the Israeli government is ridiculous. But some official fromt he Israeli government assured us that "Israel does not spy on the United States".

    It seems odd that they seemed to be targeting the DEA so much.....why?

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    The Israeli government tosses a certain amount of money toward a lot of things. For example, it funds college students to engage in online hasbara. But that doesn’t necessarily mean that every tweet is signed off on by Netanyahu’s office.

    Some of these low level things may just be to try out enthusiastic young volunteers and see who turns out to be good at it.

    Other stuff could just be intelligence people doing a little drug dealing on the side.

  42. @nglaer
    You write there were "numerous reports" of Midwesterners celebrating on 9/11. I know about the Israelis in the van-- and Carl Cameron's Fox News reports on them, etc. But others? Sad to say, it's important. Trump can get away with saying a lot of politically incorrect stuff, but he can't just make stuff up, it's really not presidential.

    Replies: @nglaer, @Bill Jones, @Desiderius

    ” it’s really not presidential.”

    “Now who’s being Naive, Kay?”

    • Replies: @Hunsdon
    @Bill Jones

    Zing! Almost always an apt reference.

  43. There are various 9/11 stories about suspicious trucks, some of them involving Israelis. Here is one such story.

    9-11 Cop Breaks Silence – Israeli Mossad Involvement in Attacks

    By Dave Gahary –
    September 23, 2011

    …. Sgt. Scott DeCarlo has never spoken to the media about the details of that day except for two 30-second cameo appearances in Internet videos from undetermined sources. In fact, DeCarlo confirmed that this is the first, and last, interview he will ever grant in regard to this subject. …

    Although not scheduled to work that day [9/11], DeCarlo reported anyway and “was posted on the highway” to prevent traffic from entering New York City.

    “There was a BOLO, which is a ‘Be On the Look Out’ for a particular van, perhaps loaded with explosives,” explained DeCarlo, “that may have been on its way to destroy the George Washington Bridge.”

    DeCarlo explained: “It [the suspicious van] happened to come our way, and I grabbed my sergeant … and said: ‘Hey, man, that’s our van.’ It wasn’t the exact license plate given reported — it was off by one numeral — but I said: ‘That’s gotta be it; it’s just too close.’”

    He continued: “The van was coming off the [N.J.] Turnpike trying to get on Route 3. Traffic was rolling at two miles an hour, so we got in front of the van on foot, weapons drawn, and stopped it.”

    All five of the Israeli spies refused to exit their vehicle, so DeCarlo was forced to get physical.

    “We asked them to get out of the van, but they didn’t listen,” he said. “So, we . . . put them in handcuffs and did it as quickly as possible.” ….

    DeCarlo then described what happened after the spies were dragged from their van. “When we removed them, one of the guys that was rather chatty said: ‘We’re not your enemy, we’re your friend. Our enemies are your enemies,’” DeCarlo said. “At that point they said they were from Israel. They kept saying, ‘Hey, we’re on your side.’”

    “We brought them over to the New Jersey State Police holding cells in the Meadowlands Stadium, and that’s the last I saw of them,” he said. ….

    https://archive.org/stream/9-11CopBreaksSilence-IsraeliMossadInvolvementInAttacks/9-11CopBreaksSilence-IsraeliMossadInvolvementInAttacks_djvu.txt

  44. John Updike’s last novel “Terrorist” was about a Muslim kid in Paterson, NJ who becomes a terrorist.

    • Replies: @WhatEvvs
    @Steve Sailer

    There was a real case of a nice kid from the NYC area who grew up to be a famous (in the Muslim world) propagandist: Margaret Marcus, a Jewish woman. Someone wrote a book about her, "The Convert," which wasn't too good. She was kind of an interesting character. Most of her kids ended up emigrating to the US and operating gas stations and stuff.

  45. @Wally
    @jtgw

    Speaking of non-Jewish names, I always thought Kirk Douglas was pretty ironic.

    Replies: @jtgw, @Kevin O'Keeffe

    I’m not sure I get it.

  46. @Steve Sailer
    @jtgw

    There are a whole bunch of websites run by Jews that evaluate how Jewish various celebrities are. My impression is that gentiles have no clue how much mental energy Jews devote to such questions.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @yaqub the mad scientist, @Ben Tzot-Abrit, @Stephen R. Diamond, @Dahlia

    Maybe the government needs to pass a kind of Dawes Act to help resolve the conflicting quantum blood/lineal descent debate between Reform and more conservative sects, and tie congressional funding for Israel the way the BIA hands out props to reservations.

  47. @jackmcg
    O/T I can't remember if I've posted this here or not but I've made a prediction that Hillary will choose a hispanic man for VP. Another woman steals her thunder, a white man isn't "progress", an asian man too irrelevant, a well-spoken black man in very short supply. A Hispanic male VP charges up her side of the immigration vote. I'm sure there are a couple possible choices in the Dem. party somewhere.

    As for the republicans, if its Trump he's completely unpredictable. If its an establishment candidate, it looks like they cut a deal with Kasich to get the VP role in exchange for leading the attack against Trump.

    Replies: @nglaer, @Kevin O'Keeffe

    • Replies: @jackmcg
    @nglaer

    I wouldn't put any VP choice past him. I wonder if Gabbard is down for the immigration cause though.

  48. Yes, I remember the story about the van, and I also remember that Netanyahu was interviewed on 9/11 and said something that at the time I thought was fairly odd (something about how the attacks were good for Israel, which I thought was completely inappropriate under the circumstances.)

    A contextual fact that shouldn’t be underestimated: 9/11 took place three months after the Dolphinarium suicide bombing (1 June 01) that killed a score of Israelis. (There!) I remember the attack brought me up short because I wasn’t familiar with suicide bombing which became much more common later.

    However, the point is that 9/11 did facilitate American empathy and support for Israel (including the invasion of Iraq which was partly justified by the notion of WMD’s used against Israel, as well as reward payments to the families of suicide bombers.)

    Having said that I don’t want to pursue 9/11 conspiracies. I don’t think it’s unreasonable to argue that the US had some foreknowledge of “an” attack, rather much like possible US foreknowledge of an attack before December 7, 1941, but that is not the same as being actively involved in it.

    Even so, both Israel and the advocates of a US “security state” “benefited” from 9/11, and that’s why these theories are out there.

  49. A disgruntled MOSSAD officer wrote an expose´ (“By Way of Deception”) that detailed how MOSSAD is small and poor, but punches above its weight by employing Jews to spy in their local countries and use their businesses to pay for it all. Sort of like how Pollard suddenly got employed on Wall Street or something. The actual professional case officers are very few in number, but who needs them when high-status Jews throughout the world will hook you up with either information or influence.

    • Replies: @Chiron
    @Drakejax

    They're called 'sayanim', its well known among some circles that what really makes the MOSSAD so powerful is wealthy and influential jews in countries like US, UK, France and Russia gaving premium information for the israelis.

    Jacob Cohen, a French-jew who became anti-Zionist admitted in a book that the MOSSAD recruits sayanim inside the French Freemasonry (the Judeo-Masonic conspiracy is quite plausible when you look into it), its likely that high-level Masonic lodges are used by the MOSSAD to recruit powerful jews and gentiles (known às Shabbo Goyim).

    , @Cwhatfuture
    @Drakejax

    If he had been anything but a low level clerk, which is what he was, he would already be dead or have been "brought back" to Israel for trial.

    , @Zed, Lord of the Brutals
    @Drakejax

    Many intelligence agencies do the same thing. If you're in a technical field of interest to the US IC and a 'reliable' US citizen, you may be approached and interviewed, either before and/or after you've attended any sort of foreign technical events (symposiums, conferences, etc etc) or simply involved in routine foreign business.

  50. I am reminded of the fictional treatment of the sayanim, the Mossad’s broad network of Jewish fellow travelers, in Tim Power’s book Three Days to Never. Their devotion to the cause is often quite shallow, but the things asked are often quite trivial, so it evens out.

    That is fiction, but the feel of it matches up with things I’ve read about Cold War era spying, for example American Spies: Espionage against the United States from the Cold War to the Present by Michael J. Sulick. If the request is small enough, people’s consciences don’t seem bothered much.

  51. @Black Death
    The Israeli technician who blew the whistle on Israel's nuke program was Mordechai Vanunu. From his Wiki page:

    Mordechai Vanunu (Hebrew: מרדכי ואנונו‎; born 14 October 1954), also known as John Crossman,[2][3] is an Israeli former nuclear technician and peace activist[4] who, citing his opposition to weapons of mass destruction, revealed details of Israel's nuclear weapons program to the British press in 1986.[5][6] He was subsequently lured to Italy by a Mossad agent, where he was drugged and abducted by Israeli intelligence agents.[5] He was transported to Israel and ultimately convicted in a trial that was held behind closed doors.[5]
    Vanunu spent 18 years in prison, including more than 11 in solitary confinement. Released from prison in 2004, he became subject to a broad array of restrictions on his speech and movement. Since then he has been arrested several times for violations of those restrictions, including giving various interviews to foreign journalists and attempting to leave Israel. He says he suffered "cruel and barbaric treatment" at the hands of Israeli authorities while imprisoned, and suggests that his treatment would have been different if he had not converted to Christianity from Judaism.[7]
    In 2007, Vanunu was sentenced to six months in prison for violating terms of his parole. The sentence was considered unusual even by the prosecution who expected a suspended sentence. In response, Amnesty International issued a press release on 2 July 2007, stating that "The organisation considers Mordechai Vanunu to be a prisoner of conscience and calls for his immediate and unconditional release."[8] In May 2010, Vanunu was arrested and sentenced to three months in jail on a charge that he met foreigners in violation of conditions of his 2004 release from jail.

    Replies: @Anonymous, @This Is Our Home, @AnotherDad

  52. @Mike Sylwester
    It seems that some Arabs in New York City did have prior knowledge of the attack and were looking forward to it.

    Prior Knowledge of Sept. 11 Not Just Urban Legend
    Posted Sept. 10, 2002
    By Jeffrey Scott Shapiro

    "What are you looking at?" asked the schoolteacher as she approached one of her freshman students. The boy, a young Palestinian, seemed captivated as he stared out the window across Brooklyn toward the lower downtown area of Manhattan.

    "Do you see those two buildings?" he asked while pointing toward the World Trade Center. "They won't be standing there next week." It was noon, Sept. 6, 2001.

    Antoinette DiLorenzo didn't take her student's comment all too seriously. Of course the twin towers would be there next week, she assured him. The student shook his head and reiterated his prediction until his 15-year old brother, a sophomore, elbowed him and told him to be quiet. "He's just kidding," the older boy said politely.

    Five days later at 8:45 a.m., DiLorenzo heard a loud explosion from the north. Thunderstruck, she turned to the window and eventually watched both towers collapse into shattered glass and crumbled steel.

    Many people believed this story was nothing more than an urban legend when they first heard it. Everyone has heard similar stories in the wake of such a disaster. Despite the almost unbelievable circumstances of the story, I was able to confirm it last October while working as a crime reporter for the Journal News, a New York-based Gannett newspaper. Catie Marshall, a spokeswoman for the New York City Board of Education, confirmed that school officials reported the incident to police and that the matter had since been taken over by the FBI Joint Terrorist Task Force (FBI-JTTF).

    New Utrecht High School was closed Sept. 12, 2001, but as soon as it reopened the following morning, a shaken DiLorenzo quietly approached a New York City Police Department (NYPD) school-safety officer in the school's first-floor lobby. Soon, a dozen investigators stormed the school, interrogating students and searching lockers.

    After federal agents questioned DiLorenzo, police detectives questioned her fourth-period class to see if anyone else had heard the boy's comments. Once the detectives were finished, the boy and his brother forcibly were taken to the 62nd Precinct headquarters, where two investigators with the FBI-JTTF questioned them for several hours. Their father, who was in Israel at the time of the attacks, was scheduled to fly home Sept. 11 on a commercial airliner, but he was delayed when all flights to the United States were grounded.
     

    More at the following webpage:

    http://www.prisonplanet.com/prior_knowledge_of_sept_11_not_just_urban_legend.htm

    Replies: @SPMoore8, @greysquirrell

    That’s a terrible article. The basic premise is that a lot of 10-12 year old Arabs know precise details about terror attacks, but no one else does.

    It’s not as though they were instant messaging Osama. There has to be a chain of how the knowledge is disseminated from Thrush Central (here, OBL) all the way down to these boys, and how no one else in that chain of dissemination leaked the information, or was arrested, charged, and convicted.

    The icing on the cake comes at the end of the article when the paranoid author recounts a story of an Arab boy who told people not to fly on November 12: of course, the date the flight AA 587 to the Dominican Republic crashed in Queens. Author says: “authorities say it was an accident. I’m not so sure.” Hey, I had to put air in one of my tires this morning. I thought it was routine maintenance, but now, I’m not so sure …..

  53. @Black Death
    The Israeli technician who blew the whistle on Israel's nuke program was Mordechai Vanunu. From his Wiki page:

    Mordechai Vanunu (Hebrew: מרדכי ואנונו‎; born 14 October 1954), also known as John Crossman,[2][3] is an Israeli former nuclear technician and peace activist[4] who, citing his opposition to weapons of mass destruction, revealed details of Israel's nuclear weapons program to the British press in 1986.[5][6] He was subsequently lured to Italy by a Mossad agent, where he was drugged and abducted by Israeli intelligence agents.[5] He was transported to Israel and ultimately convicted in a trial that was held behind closed doors.[5]
    Vanunu spent 18 years in prison, including more than 11 in solitary confinement. Released from prison in 2004, he became subject to a broad array of restrictions on his speech and movement. Since then he has been arrested several times for violations of those restrictions, including giving various interviews to foreign journalists and attempting to leave Israel. He says he suffered "cruel and barbaric treatment" at the hands of Israeli authorities while imprisoned, and suggests that his treatment would have been different if he had not converted to Christianity from Judaism.[7]
    In 2007, Vanunu was sentenced to six months in prison for violating terms of his parole. The sentence was considered unusual even by the prosecution who expected a suspended sentence. In response, Amnesty International issued a press release on 2 July 2007, stating that "The organisation considers Mordechai Vanunu to be a prisoner of conscience and calls for his immediate and unconditional release."[8] In May 2010, Vanunu was arrested and sentenced to three months in jail on a charge that he met foreigners in violation of conditions of his 2004 release from jail.

    Replies: @Anonymous, @This Is Our Home, @AnotherDad

    The treatment seems pretty fair for a traitor. Indeed it is more moderate than what the US has done to Pollard; I probably would have shot them both.

    • Replies: @Black Death
    @This Is Our Home

    @Roger Rediger

    No, the treatment that Vanunu received is harsher - read the link provided by Anonymous - 51. There is no doubt that Vanunu was a traitor, and the Israeli government had every right to punish him. But his offense, like Pollard's, took place almost thirty years ago, and his freedom is still severely restricted - no different from Pollard. But here are the major differences - agree or disagree with him, Vanunu acted out of conviction - he never profited from his actions. Pollard was a hired spy, bought and paid for by the Israeli government. No doubt Pollard was sincerely motivated to help Israel, but he also got a ton of cash for what he did. Pollard also peddled his stolen information to other nations, including China, Pakistan and South Africa. Numerous high Israeli officials, including several prime ministers, have acknowledged that they were aware of Pollard's activities. So much for our "special relationship." It wasn't until the US Congress threatened to cut off all aid to Israel that full Israeli cooperation was secured.

    But that was then and this is now. I think both Pollard and Vanunu should be allowed to go where they want to go - Pollard to Israel and Vanunu to the US.

  54. BobX [AKA "Bob who~does not doubt some celebrated"] says:

    Perhaps not thousands but I think there were some celebrating.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W5BtQgTGOI4

    • Replies: @Ron Unz
    @BobX


    Perhaps not thousands but I think there were some celebrating.
     
    Well, just out of curiosity, I decided to watch your YouTube clip, showing a special CNN report on "Homegrown Hate" which documented those "fanatic hate-filled American Muslims" who were celebrating the attacks. Sure, enough, they were there and interviewed, two of them, preaching outside a large NYC Mosque whose leadership was very unhappy about their presence, disagreed with them 100%, and hoped they would go away. Well, I think you can find two people to advocate almost anything in a big city like NYC.

    But the story is even more intriguing than that. Those two Muslims boldly call for the killing of American servicemen, say that Osama bin Laden is the perfect Muslim and their spiritual leader, and demand that Israel should be nuked off the face of the map. They were quite articulate (in a hate-filled way) and the reporters noted they seemed legally expert in knowing exactly what they could and could not say under First Amendment protections. As a minor aside, the journalists also mentioned the curious detail that both "Muslims" were actually Jews who'd converted to Islam, and (presumably with the zeal of the convert) decided to become fanatic pro-terrorist Muslims, willing and able to spend all their time outside a leading NYC mosque advocating terrorism and praising Osama bin Laden, except for the their visits to the CNN offices. Their distinctive New York Jewish accents seemed to have a clear Brooklyn tinge to me.

    Something tells me that both of them may have recently become fanatic Donald Trump supporters, and will give CNN interviews explaining that they support The Donald because they're 100% convinced that he plans to set up concentration camps for all American Jews, blacks, and homosexuals the moment he gets into office.

    Ha, ha, ha....

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

  55. @Steve Sailer
    @Anonymous

    He complains a lot about how he proved on 10/14/2002 that Saddam couldn't afford a nuclear bomb program anymore but nobody would listen to him.

    Replies: @Josh, @Thomas O. Meehan

    Oh…him.

  56. @Anonymous

    "For example, a friend applied for a job as a CIA analyst, but it took forever for the security checks so he took a job in private industry instead."
     
    Uh .... Steve.... you do realize that's exactly what he would have told you if he had been hired by the CIA?

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @Anonymous

    If he had been hired as a CIA analyst he would have said “I’ve been hired by the government in Virginia,” not “I’m moving to New Mexico.”

  57. @Stan D Mute

    As far as I can tell, U.S. intelligence is fairly hamstrung by fear of leaks and traitors. For example, a friend applied for a job as a CIA analyst, but it took forever for the security checks so he took a job in private industry instead.
     
    I once considered working for FBI or CIA. I got application packages from each. I had familial connection to CIA, but no relationship to FBI. The FBI package was at least 50 pages and required exhaustive detail including all schools attended and dates of attendance along with grades (do you have your third grade report cards?). They demanded all family connections to second cousin along with detail like date of birth and photos. It was, putting it mildly, incredibly over the top. The CIA application was a bit different. Again, I had some family connection including covert operatives one of whom lost his life in Turkey and another in Laos. But the CIA application package was two pages. I've had far more intrusive applications for corporate weenie jobs. Name, date of birth, SSN, address, college, and employment - that's all they wanted. What I took from this was that FBI is occupied by paper pushers, bureaucrats, lawyers, and accountants, demanding every i be dotted and every t crossed to cover their own asses. The CIA, on the other hand, is far more cowboy in orientation and looking more for specific attributes it can exploit in labor talent. It's easy to understand how the two organizations can spectacularly fail to work together.

    Replies: @Josh, @al gore rhythms

    Or they can get your info for themselves, than you very much.

  58. @Seth Largo

    As far as I can tell, U.S. intelligence is fairly hamstrung by fear of leaks and traitors. For example, a friend applied for a job as a CIA analyst, but it took forever for the security checks
     
    Both the FBI and the CIA put potential hires through a battery of lie detector tests in which they are asked whether or not they've committed the most mundane of "illegal" acts, such as downloading music for free or parking in a handicap spot. If you admit it, you don't get hired. If you say you didn't, but the machine says you did, you don't get hired. Obviously, no young man in America is as squeaky clean as their standards demand; the result is that the spooks and G-men simply hire the best liars.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    If you broke the law, just tell the truth.

    • Replies: @donut
    @This Is Our Home

    Not if you weren't convicted .

    , @ShaslA
    @This Is Our Home

    Doesn't work like that.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    , @SFG
    @This Is Our Home

    I think the point is the CIA actually wants good liars. Think about it--spies have to lie all the time as part of their jobs. It's a core skill.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

  59. Graham Greene wonderfully captured the haphazard world of spycraft in Our Man in Havana, in which a lowly vacuum cleaner salesman gets recruited to spy for the Brits in Cuba. Things go haywire in a most comical fashion. Well worth reading, and the movie (with Ernie Kovacs) is decent, too.

    • Agree: SPMoore8
  60. @Bill Jones
    Fox News briefly did a piece on the Israeli spying

    http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article7545.htm

    It very quickly found its was down the memory tube.

    Replies: @tbraton

    That’s what I remember seeing. Thanks for jogging my memory. It was a very well done piece, as I recall.

  61. @Blobby5
    Is the use of 'pushy' antisemitic?

    Replies: @marty

    I once knew a U. Chicago mba student who described another jew thusly: “he’ll do well in life, he’s pushy, obnoxious.”

  62. I once considered working for FBI or CIA. I got application packages from each. I had familial connection to CIA, but no relationship to FBI. The FBI package was at least 50 pages and required exhaustive detail including all schools attended and dates of attendance along with grades (do you have your third grade report cards?). They demanded all family connections to second cousin along with detail like date of birth and photos. It was, putting it mildly, incredibly over the top.

    Ever watched The Americans? That’s why it was so “over the top”; they wanted to make sure you were born and raised here, and not living a cover story.

    Just guessing, but, the CIA, on the other hand, probably just had a different process; if they decided to hire you (probably a lot less likely than the FBI hiring you), they would then put you through the wringer.

    A disgruntled MOSSAD officer wrote an expose´ (“By Way of Deception”) that detailed how MOSSAD is small and poor, but punches above its weight by employing Jews to spy in their local countries and use their businesses to pay for it all. Sort of like how Pollard suddenly got employed on Wall Street or something. The actual professional case officers are very few in number, but who needs them when high-status Jews throughout the world will hook you up with either information or influence.

    IIRC, the word for these Jews is “sayanim.”

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Svigor

    "Ever watched The Americans? That’s why it was so “over the top”; they wanted to make sure you were born and raised here, and not living a cover story."

    The worst ever FBI mole, Robert Hanssen, was born and raised in America.

    I saw a couple episodes of "The Americans". It seemed ridiculous. I think it unlikely that it's a realistic portrayal of espionage (for example, I imagine that murdering a defector in your own garage is not a very smart thing for a deep-cover agent to do). Yeah, the show has some former spooks as technical advisors. Technical advisors often just get ignored by writers, directors, and producers.

  63. @Polymath
    Alas for paper storage and microfiche, when you could go over the entire paper, down to the classifieds. Go electronic, and that article may be in the oubliette.

    I do remember reading about a teenage Palestinian boy in Paterson saying, "Now they know how we feel."

    Replies: @Tracy

    I do remember reading about a teenage Palestinian boy in Paterson saying, “Now they know how we feel.”

    That’s funny, because I was glued to the TV that day, almost mesmerized by what was going on, and know that video was played and replayed over and over — except one, which was of an Israeli saying exactly what you attribute above to some Palestinian teenager. That, I think, was the only video I didn’t see a hundred times that day (being hyperbolic here, obviously, with the “hundred” times, but straight-up about it). I’ve been unable to find that footage anywhere since, but I most definitely saw it. Once. On 9-11, during regular news broadcasts, on some channel such as CNN or FOX or whatever it was.

    • Replies: @Bill Jones
    @Tracy

    "The internet is forever" is only true about things that don't matter.

    , @onetwothree
    @Tracy

    There were lots of people recording everything to VHS (or whatever) that day, so anything that was broadcast surely still exists.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

  64. The recruiting is pretty simple. An Israeli agent goes on tour of the USA speaking at synagogues around the country on some innocuous subject.

    The rabbi who coordinates each whistlestop identifies likely helpers in the congregation who would be amenable to helping out.

    When the agent arrives in town, he speaks to each potential recruit privately and feels them out to see if they are willing to help. Perhaps they could provide a cover job for an Israeli agent. Maybe supply the Mossad with letterhead or business cards to provide cover. Or agree to be a mail drop, receiving mail and setting it aside for someone to pick up later.

    Not every Jew will agree to help, of course. But the nice thing–the thing that makes such low-key recruiting quite safe–is that no Jew would ever rat out a fellow Jew, even if he turns down the request and declines to assist the Mossad.

    This safety is enhanced by Jewish religious law. Being a “moser” (one who rats out a fellow Jew to gentiles) is a death penalty offense.

    Google “mosrim death penalty”.

    The same ethnic/racial solidarity also works for Muslim jihadis. This is why even “moderate” Muslims are an existential threat to the West. They can be counted on to look the other way and say nothing, particularly in Muslim ghettos like Molenbeek and Malmo.

    Mao got it right with his dictum about revolutionaries swimming through the local population like fish in the sea.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Big Bill


    This safety is enhanced by Jewish religious law. Being a “moser” (one who rats out a fellow Jew to gentiles) is a death penalty offense.
     
    I must have missed all those beheadings those damn Jews have done for 'mosing.'
    , @SFG
    @Big Bill

    It might actually be a way to attract sayanim--perhaps they work with receptive rabbis, and you could probably find one or two in major metropolitan areas--but mosrim? You think dentists in Scarsdale and college professors in Newton are running around beheading anyone?

    I have no clue how Israeli intelligence cultivates sources, but I doubt expecting Temple Emanu-El in the Miami suburbs to rub people out is part of it.

  65. In a clear bit of white supremacist propaganda today, Jeff Bezos landed a rocket on its retractable landing gear after a sub-orbital launch mission. In the video, there was not even one Diversity. Obviously this is impossible – success without Diversities just cannot happen – and thus proves Bezos a racist.

    http://www.engadget.com/2015/11/24/blue-origin-reusable-rocket-landing/

    • Replies: @Buzz Mohawk
    @Stan D Mute


    In a clear bit of white supremacist propaganda today, Jeff Bezos landed a rocket on its retractable landing gear after a sub-orbital launch mission.
     
    You might want to inform certain supergenius bloggers of this event. They are under the impression that nobody in America can launch a rocket anymore.

    Oh, BTW, we are still receiving cool data from the Pluto flyby that was accomplished recently by an American spacecraft launced on an American rocket.

    I know. This just doesn't fit here.

    Now back to your regular programming..."Somebody's up to something! And we have no control over it!..."

    Replies: @D. K., @5371

    , @Je Suis Charlie Martel
    @Stan D Mute

    Hilarious

    , @Romanian
    @Stan D Mute

    I'm a bit disappointed that SpaceX did not beat them to it. Blue Origin's stuff has been vaporware for some time and has engaged in some lame practices, like hiring SpaceX's people on propulsion and such after they had developed innovative tech (though, apparently, according to the Musk biography, his companies have a high turnover because he's hard to work with). The thing is that it was a bit of a lame attempt: the rocket reached space, not orbit, which requires much more energy and would have made the return much more difficult; the rocket is a lot smaller, because it's not meant to be usable, but a tech platform, while SpaceX attempts to land rockets after they have launched a payload. The near misses of SpaceX were thrilling in themselves, like the rocket falling just as it should have landed, but I appreciate what they were trying to do a bit more. Having just read the Musk biography that Tyler Cowen of MR recommended, I am convinced that I would not want to ever know him, except to discuss Mars a bit. Definitely not work for him. But he's the kind of person that gets things done, and SpaceX has accomplished more with less than Blue Origin. They stole the reusable rocket thunder in a cheap way, compared to how SpaceX was doing it. Yes, I'm a cheerleader. Still, at least things are finally moving. Maybe my children will have their flying cars and Mars bases.

    Replies: @Stan D Mute

  66. I live in Bergen County, New Jersey. Today the county’s newspaper, The Record, published an interesting article about the accusations that local Moslems celebrated the 9/11 attacks.

    Most of the accusations were about Moslems in Jersey City, which is in Hudson County, and Paterson, which is in Passaic County. Since Bergen County is between those two counties, The Record actively investigated the accusations.

    On that day, 9/11, there indeed was a “deluge” of accusations from local people who said they personally saw such celebrations. Many such accusations were reported and discussed on local talk-radio stations. So, accusations about celebrating Moslems were exceptionally intense in this geographic area.

    Law enforcement officials, civil rights advocates and news reporters who were working in the immediate aftermath of the attacks said Monday that they were deluged with calls and emails from people who claimed to have witnessed celebrations in Jersey City and Paterson, but that they had found no persuasive evidence to back up any of those accounts.

    …. the rumors were started when people called in reported sightings of Muslims celebrating in New Jersey to a New York City talk radio station. ….

    The Record … reported on Sept 13, 2001, that rumors of Muslim celebrations were unfounded but that the story had been difficult to dispel, “moving briskly through e-mails, telephone conversations, and at least one radio show.”

    John Chadwick, a former Record reporter, said he went to Paterson at least three times on that Sept. 12 to check out dozens of tips that Muslims were celebrating, only to find the streets vacated and most of the stores closed.

    “I’ve never experienced such a disconnect,” Chadwick said. “Not only was there no celebration, there was like nobody around. The shops seemed to be closed. There was nobody on the streets. I sensed that people were just scared.”

    For days afterward, Chadwick said, he continued to receive emails from readers who said they had seen televised reports of celebrations and wanted to know why the paper was not covering it.

    “I would try to respond, ‘ If you saw this, let us know what channel was it? What was the news source?” Chadwick said. “Nobody ever came forward.” …

    [Jerry] Spagnola, the former Paterson police chief, traced the origin of the story to television news reports shortly after the attacks that showed images of people protesting in the Middle East then flashed to pictures of empty streets in Paterson, where announcers explained, there is a large Muslim population. ….

    http://www.northjersey.com/news/trump-s-comments-of-9-11-celebrations-in-n-j-renew-long-standing-debate-1.1461485

    • Replies: @Mike Sylwester
    @Mike Sylwester

    Yesterday, I collected from the Internet the following statements of people about Moslems seen celebrating in New Jersey on 9/11.


    I drove with family members though Patterson, N.J. that morning, after the planes hit. It’s not the kind of thing you forget. We witnessed people in traditional Muslim garb dancing, jumping, shouting and celebrating like their team had won the Super Bowl, just as Trump said.

    I didn’t see thousands of Muslims celebrating but I absolutely saw a pocket, perhaps 100, jumping for joy at the sight of the smoke rising from where the Twin Towers used to be. .... these events were a commonly accepted fact by Jerseyans.

    --------

    I had my business on Pennsylvania Ave in Paterson, N.J. I saw people on Crooks Ave. and Main Street cheering and raising Middle Eastern flags.

    I’ll tell you exactly where I was. I had stopped in at Biggs bagels on crooks ave by the railroad tracks. I was wondering why all these crazy people were cheering. Find out a few minutes later America was under attack. I saw it with my own eyes.

    I witnessed pure evil. Donald Trump is right.”

    --------

    What was happening is that they were in stores or small gathering cheering and when they were noticed they stopped. that is what happened when my sister saw them after she got gas and looked in the store to find someone to pay. she saw them gathered around a tv cheering and jumping up and down. When they saw her they stopped, I am sure that's what a lot of people are talking about. Many were seen celebrating. So the police would not have been aware, as in my sister's case. I had heard many stories like that throughout New Jersey.

    -------

    They were in the streets banging on the cars trying to drive through the crowd in the street. The muslims were shouting death to Americans and allah is great [and] other crap I didn't understand. We were amused until a car with 3 young women mistakenly turned on to main st.

    The muslims were banging on their windows and screaming, thats when we came out of our car and pushed the muslims off their car helped them back out and get back to the parkway.

    -------

    I experienced/ witnessed many incidents of Muslims celebrating 9/11 in North Brunswick. I was in a grocery store when I heard the plane crashed on the store radio. The Muslim man in line next to me turned and spit on me. I'll never forget it.

    -------

    I live in Hudson County. It did happen in West New York. Saw it with my own eyes. I don't need a media outlet to tell me what I witnessed just a few feet from me. People in cars, honking they're horns and waiving their flags.

    ------

    I saw black and Arab people in NEWARK PATH MARK SUPERMARKET - dancing and cheering as the TOWERS BURNED !!! and in JERSEY CITY - pockets of people in the streets shouting and laughing - TRUMP IS CORRECT

    -------

    So when I was driving a bus threw paterson that day in the morning to see it and other people seen as well ..does it mean we where dreaming of what took place...

    --------

    I saw it FIRST HAND! I drove an ambulance all over NJ. They were celebrating in the streets. I always wonder why they were never rounded up and sent to their homeland.

    -------

    It absolutely happened in Paterson. The police even had some of the streets closed off to traffic because of it. I was in Paterson on the 12th for business and the whole area around Crooks Avenue was covered in people celebrating.

    ----------

    Want proof that Muslims celebrated as they heard of 9/11 attacks? 100s of young men laughing, dancing, cheering; I saw them.

    ----------

    The Muslims were celebrating until they realized the backlash soon to follow. I saw it.

    ----------

    I saw it, too. The day and age we live in doesn't change the fact that Muslims did in fact party after 9/11 in jersey city. Love or hate trump, it happened

    ----------

    There is a service station in my town, near Edison, NJ, it was owned by Muslims at the time of 9-11. Many members of our community saw the workers there celebrating that day. That station was shunned by the locals as word spread and was eventually sold to new owners.

    [follow-up comment:]

    I'm a liberal Democrat and I saw the same thing from the Palestinian workers on 30th Street and 11th Avenue gas service station. Its closed now.

    ----------

    I lived and grew up in South Paterson NJ. I knew lots of people in law enforcement. Someone I knew at the time from the Passaic County's Prosecutors office told me that there were hundreds of people dancing in the streets when the Towers were attacked. Moreover, Paterson police were keeping people out of the city lest they felt it appropriate to attack some of the revelers. ....

    ----------

    I was a volunteer firefighter sent to the Hoboken FD to cover their turf while they were in NYC. I saw it with my own eyes while going through Jersey City too.

    ----------

    I lived in northwest nj...and yes, they were celebrating in patterson...not thousands but a couple of hundred.... WE SAW IT and will NEVER forget it!

    ----------

    It certainly did happen! I worked in Jersey City that day!

    ----------

    I actually saw them in Patterson NJ. I was one of the people who had to hold back fellow firefighters from going back there to fight with them.

    ----------

    I work in Paterson New Jersey. Many residents I've spoken to recently remember the celebrations that day. 2 were police officers called to protect the Muslims from others who were upset by the display. They (Muslims) danced and cheered. They still live here.

    ----------

    I was there. I saw it too. I was working in Hoboken, and drove through Jersey City and Newark back and forth to my home. Muslims were there. They were celebrating.

    ----------

    I do remember seeing this. This is one of those politically incorrect things we want to forget about 9/11. .... I do remember those Muslims who were celebrating and chanting/yelling in the streets in New Jersey. To say they represented all Muslims is a lie. To say they did not exist is also a lie.

    ----------

    I lived in Hoboken at the time and while I didn't witness these celebrations, I know plenty of people (i.e. former co-workers) who did.

    ----------

    This is true the people of Jersey City took to the streets in riot on Journal Square the reports where telling people to stay away.

    ----------

    Yes he is right I live in NJ and witnessed children stomping on a flag that fell off a car while their parents laughed . Let the truth be told

    ----------

    I saw in Paterson, N.J. about 30 to 50 men yelling and cheering in the street.waving their flags...

    ----------

    I lived in Staten Island new york at the time of 911 attacks .... Later that day, i went to liquor store on forest ave. There were young Muslim men, on the roof toop, waving a flag, as I enter the store about 5 young men, Muslims were smiling and dancing as they gave me candy. .... I latter went into a small grouciers store on Muslim men young and old were cheering when they were listen to the radio. ....
     
    http://nj1015.com/former-gov-difrancesco-i-dont-remember-people-celebrating-911-in-nj/

    https://www.facebook.com/nj1015/posts/10153456648123451

    http://www.bizpacreview.com/2015/11/23/live-jersey-trump-right-muslims-celebrate-911-nj-saw-277082

    http://www.northjersey.com/news/trump-s-comments-of-9-11-celebrations-in-n-j-renew-long-standing-debate-1.1461485

    Replies: @James Kabala, @KA

  67. Russian entry into Turkish airspace lasted ‘seconds’: U.S. official

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The United States believes Russia’s incursion into Turkish airspace on Tuesday likely lasted only a matter of seconds before Turkey shot down a Russian warplane, a U.S. official said, saying the assessment was based on preliminary indications.

    The official, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said the United States was still investigating the incident.

    Damage control? Seems like US unofficially admitting within hours that the Turks were itching to shoot down a Russian plane.

    • Replies: @tbraton
    @Svigor

    Any peep of protest from the U.S. or EU about the steady stream of rubber rafts carrying "Syrian refugees" from Turkey to Lesbos and thereby violating the territorial waters of Greece?

  68. WhatEvvs [AKA "Internet Addict"] says:
    @Steve Sailer
    John Updike's last novel "Terrorist" was about a Muslim kid in Paterson, NJ who becomes a terrorist.

    Replies: @WhatEvvs

    There was a real case of a nice kid from the NYC area who grew up to be a famous (in the Muslim world) propagandist: Margaret Marcus, a Jewish woman. Someone wrote a book about her, “The Convert,” which wasn’t too good. She was kind of an interesting character. Most of her kids ended up emigrating to the US and operating gas stations and stuff.

  69. WhatEvvs [AKA "Internet Addict"] says:

    OT, the front page of the NYT has the shooting of 5 people at a Black Lives Matter rally. No word on the 16 shot at the hippity hop party in New Orleans.

    • Replies: @TangoMan
    @WhatEvvs

    Here is the BBC reporting the same story. Notice how they discard the reporting rule of not mentioning the race of the shooters.


    Three white men wearing masks have shot five people protesting about the fatal police shooting of a black man in Minneapolis, say witnesses.
     

    Replies: @Steve Austen

    , @Hippopotamusdrome
    @WhatEvvs

    Counter protest at BLM protest. BLM'ers chase away counter protesters and pursue them down the street. Then pursuing party gets shot at.

    5 People Shot Near BLM Protest

    Replies: @WhatEvvs

  70. @nglaer
    @jackmcg

    http://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2015/11/22/dnc_vice_chair_tulsi_gabbard_toppling_secular_dicators_like_hussein_qaddafi_assad_is_counterproductive_because_is_directly_helps_isis__al-qaeda.html

    Trump should choose Tulsi Gabbard, would send a lot of good and confusing signals.

    Replies: @jackmcg

    I wouldn’t put any VP choice past him. I wonder if Gabbard is down for the immigration cause though.

  71. @Stan D Mute

    As far as I can tell, U.S. intelligence is fairly hamstrung by fear of leaks and traitors. For example, a friend applied for a job as a CIA analyst, but it took forever for the security checks so he took a job in private industry instead.
     
    I once considered working for FBI or CIA. I got application packages from each. I had familial connection to CIA, but no relationship to FBI. The FBI package was at least 50 pages and required exhaustive detail including all schools attended and dates of attendance along with grades (do you have your third grade report cards?). They demanded all family connections to second cousin along with detail like date of birth and photos. It was, putting it mildly, incredibly over the top. The CIA application was a bit different. Again, I had some family connection including covert operatives one of whom lost his life in Turkey and another in Laos. But the CIA application package was two pages. I've had far more intrusive applications for corporate weenie jobs. Name, date of birth, SSN, address, college, and employment - that's all they wanted. What I took from this was that FBI is occupied by paper pushers, bureaucrats, lawyers, and accountants, demanding every i be dotted and every t crossed to cover their own asses. The CIA, on the other hand, is far more cowboy in orientation and looking more for specific attributes it can exploit in labor talent. It's easy to understand how the two organizations can spectacularly fail to work together.

    Replies: @Josh, @al gore rhythms

    The FBI package was at least 50 pages and required exhaustive detail including all schools attended and dates of attendance along with grades (do you have your third grade report cards?). They demanded all family connections to second cousin along with detail like date of birth and photos. It was, putting it mildly, incredibly over the top

    Shouldn’t this be subject to a ‘disparate impact’ challenge? If you moved to America as a young child from the chaotic Third World then it might be hard to prove family connections or school grades.

    • Replies: @Stan D Mute
    @al gore rhythms


    Shouldn’t this be subject to a ‘disparate impact’ challenge? If you moved to America as a young child from the chaotic Third World then it might be hard to prove family connections or school grades.

     

    Great observation! In fact, this was back in the early 1990's so predates the "disparate impact" era. I'd expect that today a letter from your Imam or village witch doctor in crayon or goat blood would suffice for an "above top secret" clearance and GS15 job.
  72. @Tracy
    @Polymath


    I do remember reading about a teenage Palestinian boy in Paterson saying, “Now they know how we feel.”
     
    That's funny, because I was glued to the TV that day, almost mesmerized by what was going on, and know that video was played and replayed over and over -- except one, which was of an Israeli saying exactly what you attribute above to some Palestinian teenager. That, I think, was the only video I didn't see a hundred times that day (being hyperbolic here, obviously, with the "hundred" times, but straight-up about it). I've been unable to find that footage anywhere since, but I most definitely saw it. Once. On 9-11, during regular news broadcasts, on some channel such as CNN or FOX or whatever it was.

    Replies: @Bill Jones, @onetwothree

    “The internet is forever” is only true about things that don’t matter.

  73. • Replies: @SPMoore8
    @Truth

    I really don't see the relevance of this unless the shooters were members of the Woodrow Wilson Brigade or the Stanford White Power Legion (that would be SWPL, for short).

    On the other hand, it would be relatively simple to cherry pick stories about black assailants assaulting whites, amirite?

    Replies: @Truth

    , @D. K.
    @Truth

    Yeah, you people sure can pick your victims, martyrs and heroes, Zippi:

    http://www.vdare.com/posts/look-how-the-minneapolis-star-tribune-describes-a-black-mob-attack-on-white-protesters-five-people-shot-near-black-lives-matter-protest-in-minneapolis

    Replies: @SPMoore8

    , @D. K.
    @Truth

    Here, in full, is a comment, from another Web site, about an actual murder (and sexual-assault) victim:

    "Amanda Blackburn was in the wrong place at the wrong time; she was in the confines of her own home 150 years after emancipation and 50 years after LBJ's War on Poverty."

    Replies: @Romanian

    , @AnotherDad
    @Truth

    Truth, believe it or not, white people have rights to.

    BLM is protesting--the death of a serial criminal and girlfriend beater--on public property. Despite some BLM flack talking about "people who did not belong there", white anti-pro-thuggery protesters *also* have the right to be there and protest the protesters.

    Unfortunately, most blacks (like a lot of leftists) can not fathom the concept of people being allow to disagree with them, so unsurprisingly BLM types try and chase these counter protesters off. And indeed apparently had them on the run.

    Wasn't there, but i'll say, i'd rather shoot than let a black mob (even a mob of two or three) catch me. Blacks readily assault whites (and each other). Once down they'll kick and stomp you. You're lucky if you don't end up with serious injury, or being a vegetable, or dead.

    George Zimmerman would quite likely be a vegetable in some hospital if he hadn't been packing when attacked by the thug Trayvon Martin, who was witnessed raining down blows "MMA sytle" and smacking Zimmerman's head into the sidewalk.

    Here, we had this kid Kris Kime at Mardi Gras about 15 years back, who went to the assistance of a girl some black thugs were assaulting and had knocked down. For his trouble, some black thug whacked him on the head, knocking him down where upon a bunch of black thugs started kicking the crap outta him ... while Seattle police--obeying the PC orders of their leftist political bosses--just stood around the sidelines watching.

    Whites who are going to be around blacks are smart to be armed. Especially if you're in a "progressive" jurisdiction where PC is turning the police into useless timeservers while feral blacks run free. And if attacked they *should* fire. Hey, the state will no doubt try to railroad you--like they tried with Zimmerman. But better to end up in prison, then beaten and stomped dead like Kris Kime.

    ~~~
    Truth, i know you have a different take on the capabilities and behavior of your people. And that's fine.

    The simple approach that works for your folks and my folks--separation. Your people run your affairs--have the level of policing and tolerate the level of violence that your people desire. And my people run our affairs and have the level of policing and intolerance for thuggery and violence that we find allows for civilized life. Win-win.

    Replies: @Truth

    , @tbraton
    @Truth

    "Uh Oh!…Part LXII!"

    I hate to inform you, but you are in clear violation of the NFL's exclusive license from the Romans to use Roman numerals. Pay up!

  74. @Tracy
    @Polymath


    I do remember reading about a teenage Palestinian boy in Paterson saying, “Now they know how we feel.”
     
    That's funny, because I was glued to the TV that day, almost mesmerized by what was going on, and know that video was played and replayed over and over -- except one, which was of an Israeli saying exactly what you attribute above to some Palestinian teenager. That, I think, was the only video I didn't see a hundred times that day (being hyperbolic here, obviously, with the "hundred" times, but straight-up about it). I've been unable to find that footage anywhere since, but I most definitely saw it. Once. On 9-11, during regular news broadcasts, on some channel such as CNN or FOX or whatever it was.

    Replies: @Bill Jones, @onetwothree

    There were lots of people recording everything to VHS (or whatever) that day, so anything that was broadcast surely still exists.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @onetwothree

    For example, the four part Fox series from that era on Israeli spying on the U.S. by Carl Cameron (?) was spiked but exists in a lot of nooks of the Internet.

  75. @Steve Sailer
    @jtgw

    There are a whole bunch of websites run by Jews that evaluate how Jewish various celebrities are. My impression is that gentiles have no clue how much mental energy Jews devote to such questions.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @yaqub the mad scientist, @Ben Tzot-Abrit, @Stephen R. Diamond, @Dahlia

    You are correct about this. Some Jews also don’t grasp how much other Jews devote to this. After 40 years of marriage, my father’s side of the family is still flabbergasted at how much energy my mother’s side of the family spends on this.

    • Replies: @el topo
    @Ben Tzot-Abrit

    This is true. As a partial Jew, I have always been fascinated with the question of Jewishness and am able to view it from different angles, as it were. I also have an extremely keen Jewdar and am able to spot Jews and mischlings quite accurately.
    I have friends who are full Jews, however, who seem not at all interested in their Jewishness and completely downplay its significance, though they have many obviously Jewish traits (and typical liberal Jewish politics).

    Replies: @SFG

  76. @Hapalong Cassidy
    I admit, the "Dancing Israelis" did come to mind when Trump went off on his latest rant. Perhaps he's trying to send some kind of coded signal to the Deep Staters, basically saying "I KNOW, so you better think twice on how far you want to push me."

    But more likely, he was probably thinking of the footage of Palistinians dancing in the streets over in Israel. I clearly remember all of the networks showing that footage. It's easy to see how memories could become jumbled on that day. If I were him, I'd at least backtrack on the "thousands and thousands" part. I know he doesn't like to admit he's wrong, but I don't think even his most hardcore supporters will think less of him for it.

    Replies: @jackmcg

    Yes, Trump is good at this.

    Most conspicuously, he says “Border Walls work… ask Israel how well they work.”

    Some doubt his sincerity, and I get that, but I believe Trump is an alt-righter with the right touch of conspiracy theory who would find himself right at home in these corners of the internet.

    I know they say he’s “not politically correct”, but I think he knows when to be politically correct, while still tracing the edges of this stuff so that it makes all of us think “he knows!”.

  77. @onetwothree
    @Tracy

    There were lots of people recording everything to VHS (or whatever) that day, so anything that was broadcast surely still exists.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    For example, the four part Fox series from that era on Israeli spying on the U.S. by Carl Cameron (?) was spiked but exists in a lot of nooks of the Internet.

  78. Okay, I’ll ask — did you ever take a Spanish class at Glendale College … ? If so, do you remember a fellow student named Dan Harmon?

  79. In the year 2000, my home in San Jose was visited by two very attractive young ladies who characterized themselves as “Israeli art students,” and claimed to be selling paintings door-to-door. At the time, I was living with my father (due to the fact I’d recently spent a year in the county jail, as a result of my 20something involvement in some embarrassingly imbecile shenanigans, pertaining to a right-wing extremist organization that was very active during the 1990s), and my father was the chief-of-maintenance for a large industrial facility in Silicon Valley (one that most definitely had potential national security-related implications; they weren’t designing social media apps, LOL). Anyhoo, over the course of the next two weeks, both my father and I kept running into these same “Israeli art students” all over town, in San Jose, in Sunnyvale, in Palo Alto…seemingly wherever we went. I was told I was “paranoid,” for believing they were following us, but realistically, I don’t see any other possibility. They tried to get into the facility where my father worked, at one point, but were denied access.

    • Replies: @Boomstick
    @Kevin O'Keeffe

    When I had a small office in an office park I used to get regular cold calls from "art salesmen." Their schtick was to say that they had some art that had been ordered by someone else in the building but that they had since moved out. Rather than take the art back they said they'd cut a deal and give it to me for a rock bottom price.

    They were just selling cheap knockoff Ansel Adams reproductions, obviously without paying any licensing fees. The story was about cancelled orders was just part of the sales pitch. There are plenty of similar scams, including door-to-door meat salesmen. One of the most famous is the "white box speaker" sales guys. They'll cadge you in parking lots and tell you they were making a delivery on expensive stereo speakers, but the deal fell through. Rather than take them back they'll sell you these top-flight speakers for a low, low price. The speakers are actually crap and the price is inflated, but the story helps make the sale.

    If the "Israeli art students" were actually spies I'd expect them to conceal their foreign extraction. From an information gathering standpoint it's a negative to volunteer that information, but probably a positive for making sales of overpriced art.

    Replies: @greysquirrell, @Kevin O'Keeffe, @G Pinfold

  80. @Seth
    @tanabear

    The idea that these guys were up to anything in particular is absurd.

    They were filming the WTC as it burned...like everyone else with a camera in a two mile radius. On tv later one of them said in bad English that he was "documenting" the event and the loonies took that to mean that he had been sent there to do it.

    Why would the Mossad need to have the most spectacular event in American history specially "documented?"

    NYC is filled with illegal immigrants who say they are tourists and are doing some work in the meantime. Not unusual.

    Movers are often paid in cash. $4700 among 4 people may sound like a lot of money to some fevered conspiracy theorist but if that was all their money it's really not that much.

    Replies: @Jasper Been, @tanabear

    It is revealing the parts you attempt to explain and the other aspects you choose not to address.

  81. @AndrewR
    @Wilkey

    Lmao! I've seen some funny comments on this site but yours takes the cake. You could write for Family Guy.

    Replies: @MW

    As absurd as it sounds to an American, this is exactly what my Israeli cousin did, though “vacation” might be a misleading word. It is very common for young Israelis to take a few years after their army service and putter around the world, working as necessary. And there are lots of Israeli moving companies in the US, for whatever reason. So when my cousin needed work after a month or two doing nothing, he reached out to a childhood friend of his who, sure enough, ran a moving company in the US.

    • Replies: @Karl
    @MW

    >>> It is very common for young Israelis to take a few years after their army service and putter around the world, working as necessary


    "Just out of the service
    And he's looking for his fun"



    http://www.lyricsmode.com/lyrics/j/judy_collins/someday_soon.html

  82. @Truth
    Uh Oh!...Part LXII!

    Be careful what you axe for.

    http://qz.com/558326/white-men-shot-several-people-at-a-black-lives-matter-rally-in-minneapolis/?utm_source=YPL

    Replies: @SPMoore8, @D. K., @D. K., @AnotherDad, @tbraton

    I really don’t see the relevance of this unless the shooters were members of the Woodrow Wilson Brigade or the Stanford White Power Legion (that would be SWPL, for short).

    On the other hand, it would be relatively simple to cherry pick stories about black assailants assaulting whites, amirite?

    • Replies: @Truth
    @SPMoore8



    it would be relatively simple to cherry pick stories about black assailants assaulting whites, amirite?
     
    From having been on this site for 9 years...I would concur.

    Replies: @D. K.

  83. @jtgw
    Israel seems to work on trust in many ways. E.g. how exactly do they verify your Jewishness when you apply for citizenship there? It would seem to be something easy to fake, and yet Israel is pretty good at keeping itself Jewish.

    Replies: @Cwhatfuture, @Steve Sailer, @sprfls, @Karl, @Lugash, @shk12344

    Who said they do a good job? Obviously I don’t know the exact numbers here, but for example a significant amount of non-Jewish Soviets emigrated to Israel in the 80s and 90s.

    • Replies: @Dave Pinsen
    @sprfls

    I would think Israel's laxity regarding that post-Soviet wave was intentional. Israel's leaders likely saw it as a demographic bulwark against Arabs as well as against Mizrahi Jews.

    Replies: @AnotherDad, @Steve Sailer

    , @cwhatfuture
    @sprfls

    The standards for immigration are not so high - as long as you have one Jewish grandparent, you qualify. But the standards for marriage and children and those children being registered as Jewish are very high. That falls under the rabbis and they are strict. Many, if not most, of the non-Jewish soviets who arrived then have long ago left Israel by the way. And why would they stay in Israel which is under constant pressure and low level terror, when you can get to Europe, or Canada or even the US? Canada especially is favored because education is valued in their immigration system. Israel has been far more successful than Europe in keeping out unwanted populations. Israel has also been incredibly successful in having their Jewish immigrants become "Israelified", to make up a word.

    , @Karl
    @sprfls

    >> Who said they do a good job?

    Ever since the 1750's (first publication of a Hebrew-language mathematics school-text), nationalistic Zionism has been almost completely led by non-religious Jews.

    It is easily possible to paint the picture that "Judaism" as a stand-alone, organized "religion", didn't really exist until after the Roman destruction of the Second Temple. Hebrew kings - up to & including Herod - never (to my memory of the bible) tried to dual-hat themselves as a High Priest. Actually, quite a few of them used tax monies to support pagan shrines. The municipality of Jerusalem still gives away free Christmas trees every year. In fact, it's going to happen in a coupla weeks.


    Even deep within the bowels of the Temple bureaucracy itself, the King always had total control of crowd-control and even liturgical arrangements. 1 Chronicles 25. Kinda like mosques nowadays in the Gulf states?

    Replies: @kaganovitch

  84. Perhaps the media that is so interested in Donald Trump’s description of 9/11 Muslim celebrations in the tri-state area might like to follow up on these verified facts-
    http://www.prisonplanet.com/prior_knowledge_of_sept_11_not_…
    “What are you looking at?” asked the schoolteacher as she approached one of her freshman students. The boy, a young Palestinian, seemed captivated as he stared out the window across Brooklyn toward the lower downtown area of Manhattan.
    “Do you see those two buildings?” he asked while pointing toward the World Trade Center. “They won’t be standing there next week.” It was noon, Sept. 6, 2001″.

  85. Israel does not pick intelligence agents at random, nor do they “trust” any Jewish Israeli or foreign Jew. They pick intelligence agents from the pool of army recruits. They have the full intelligence and physical and pyschological profile of every 18 year old Israeli. And from that pool, they do not pick idiots. The same pool provides the persons they use to screen at airports. To survive in Israel’s neighborhood, you need a good intelligence agency, not one staffed by illegals working at a US moving company.

    • Replies: @Drakejax
    @cwhatfuture

    Don't confuse professional intelligence agents, who in Israel's case are very well vetted and trained, with the thousands of various contacts and assets they utilize. A German just got convicted for having been retained by the CIA; he worked as a mail handler for the German intelligence agency. The German was the asset, the actual "agents" worked in another country.

    Replies: @cwhatfuture

  86. Instapundit here references the Washington Post Sept 18, 2001 referring to tailgate viewing parties in Jersey watching and celebrating the Twin Towers collapse. Referencing Muslims.

    Muslims around the nation celebrated and danced in the streets, which was reported, just barely, at the time.

    Trump was/is correct.
    —————————–
    As for intelligence, the US has been very, very bad as has British intelligence in human sources, but very, very, VERY good in technical intelligence. We and the British were reading in near real time in WWII German and Japanese codes down to battlefield movements. We had an enourmous lead in satellite spying which combined with the U2 and SR72 gave us good ideas of the general abilities and intentions of the Soviets (a key reason we did not launch a nuclear attack in the dark). We tapped undersea cables the Soviets thought were impossible to tap.

    Recently the US/Israeli intelligence effort to hamper Iran’s nuclear program was entirely technical. Stuxnet was very successful.

    Human sources are generally over-rated. They are too subject to bias and tale-telling (Ahmed Chalabi), turning and doubling, and often merely duplicate the tremendous amount of open source information that can be collated and analyzed.

    I would be EXTREMELY dubious of “Israeli” citizens — since a non trivial portion are Arab Muslims. There is also a thriving Israeli organized crime movement.

    The CEO of say, Teva, who was refused an Avis Rental Car by a couple of Black female service reps because he was Israeli, is highly unlikely to be either a spy or a criminal. The real threat as always comes from insiders, Robert Hanssen, Aldric Ames, Jonathon Pollard, the Walker family. And its usually related to sex or money or both.

    • Replies: @nglaer
    @Whiskey

    Instapundit here references the Washington Post Sept 18, 2001 referring to tailgate viewing parties in Jersey watching and celebrating the Twin Towers collapse. Referencing Muslims.

    Muslims around the nation celebrated and danced in the streets, which was reported, just barely, at the time.

    Trump was/is correct.


    Thank you Whiskey. Am not usually on your ideological wavelength. This, (or instapundit's) is an important factoid. My optimism is restored.

    Replies: @gcochran

  87. @Wally
    @jtgw

    Speaking of non-Jewish names, I always thought Kirk Douglas was pretty ironic.

    Replies: @jtgw, @Kevin O'Keeffe

    “Kirk Douglas” was, effectively, a stage name. He was born Issur Danielovitch.

    • Replies: @Reg Cæsar
    @Kevin O'Keeffe

    And he was born in Amsterdam.

    But not that Amsterdam.

  88. I recall seeing a youtube clip of a western news channel misrepresenting Palestinian celebration as American muslim celebration. That could be what people say they saw on TV.

  89. @jackmcg
    O/T I can't remember if I've posted this here or not but I've made a prediction that Hillary will choose a hispanic man for VP. Another woman steals her thunder, a white man isn't "progress", an asian man too irrelevant, a well-spoken black man in very short supply. A Hispanic male VP charges up her side of the immigration vote. I'm sure there are a couple possible choices in the Dem. party somewhere.

    As for the republicans, if its Trump he's completely unpredictable. If its an establishment candidate, it looks like they cut a deal with Kasich to get the VP role in exchange for leading the attack against Trump.

    Replies: @nglaer, @Kevin O'Keeffe

    “I can’t remember if I’ve posted this here or not but I’ve made a prediction that Hillary will choose a hispanic man for VP. Another woman steals her thunder, a white man isn’t “progress”, an asian man too irrelevant, a well-spoken black man in very short supply. A Hispanic male VP charges up her side of the immigration vote. I’m sure there are a couple possible choices in the Dem. party somewhere.”

    Hillary has all but stated her intent to nominate HUD Secretary Julian* Castro as her Veep. Steve’s talked about it, actually.

    *Pronounced “whoolian,” for all you micro-aggressing sh*tlords who had the temerity to suppose he pronounced it like the old Roman Emperor

    • Replies: @NOTA
    @Kevin O'Keeffe

    So, how'd the emperor pronounce it? I assume not all that close to the English pronunciation, but I really don't know.

    Replies: @Richard S, @Glossy

  90. Re foreknowledge of the 9/11 attack. Well, yes, just as the French had a pretty good idea that something was coming in Paris before that most recent attack, and also before Charlie Hebdo. There was unusual jihadi behavior and chatter, and intelligence chiefs were nervous.

    Nothing was done because of PC. Anyone advocating action was tarred with Islamaphobia, and racism, so everyone just sat around. The action to be done was extremely tight border controls, interviews, massive mobilization of the police and security forces. Nothing like that could be done or would be done until after.

    Now, we either have a secret war like that against the OAS during De Gaulle’s term, or simply deport lots of Muslims. I suspect neither will happen in the West, instead ever increasing Jihadi attacks because the killing is the point, of domination and control. Until things just snap.

    Reasonable reform measures that produce safety and security while not being horrible and vicious are impossible because of the dependency of the elite of bashing Bad Whites for social signaling and social unity; along with Muslim votes in Europe and Black votes in the US.

    • Agree: Jim Don Bob
    • Replies: @bomag
    @Whiskey

    Until things just snap

    Ha! More like the West just lies down and dies.

  91. I really don’t see the relevance of this unless the shooters were members of the Woodrow Wilson Brigade or the Stanford White Power Legion (that would be SWPL, for short).

    On the other hand, it would be relatively simple to cherry pick stories about black assailants assaulting whites, amirite?

    Man’s just fighting with whatever weapon is at hand. Not his fault whites don’t give him much.

  92. @Stan D Mute
    In a clear bit of white supremacist propaganda today, Jeff Bezos landed a rocket on its retractable landing gear after a sub-orbital launch mission. In the video, there was not even one Diversity. Obviously this is impossible - success without Diversities just cannot happen - and thus proves Bezos a racist.

    http://www.engadget.com/2015/11/24/blue-origin-reusable-rocket-landing/

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @Je Suis Charlie Martel, @Romanian

    In a clear bit of white supremacist propaganda today, Jeff Bezos landed a rocket on its retractable landing gear after a sub-orbital launch mission.

    You might want to inform certain supergenius bloggers of this event. They are under the impression that nobody in America can launch a rocket anymore.

    Oh, BTW, we are still receiving cool data from the Pluto flyby that was accomplished recently by an American spacecraft launced on an American rocket.

    I know. This just doesn’t fit here.

    Now back to your regular programming…”Somebody’s up to something! And we have no control over it!…”

    • Replies: @D. K.
    @Buzz Mohawk

    American kids have been launching rockets, on their own, for generations, by now, haven't they? Can any of them, say, take astronauts to and from the International Space Station, these days? Can Jeff Bezos' boys perform that service, now? By the way, just to refresh our collective memory, what was the actual launch date of that Pluto fly-by, Buzz?

    , @5371
    @Buzz Mohawk

    So a billionaire scumbag can fly 100 km up and then land, which the X-15 could do sixty years ago, but unlike the X-15 he can't choose where to go or where to land and can't put anyone aboard. BFD.

  93. @Buzz Mohawk
    @Stan D Mute


    In a clear bit of white supremacist propaganda today, Jeff Bezos landed a rocket on its retractable landing gear after a sub-orbital launch mission.
     
    You might want to inform certain supergenius bloggers of this event. They are under the impression that nobody in America can launch a rocket anymore.

    Oh, BTW, we are still receiving cool data from the Pluto flyby that was accomplished recently by an American spacecraft launced on an American rocket.

    I know. This just doesn't fit here.

    Now back to your regular programming..."Somebody's up to something! And we have no control over it!..."

    Replies: @D. K., @5371

    American kids have been launching rockets, on their own, for generations, by now, haven’t they? Can any of them, say, take astronauts to and from the International Space Station, these days? Can Jeff Bezos’ boys perform that service, now? By the way, just to refresh our collective memory, what was the actual launch date of that Pluto fly-by, Buzz?

  94. Take that! Obama: Climate summit a ‘powerful rebuke’ to terrorists

    President Obama declared Tuesday that next week’s climate change summit in Paris would be a “powerful rebuke” to terrorists

    What a maroon.

    • Replies: @donut
    @Svigor

    Did he specify which terrorists he means ?

  95. @cwhatfuture
    Israel does not pick intelligence agents at random, nor do they "trust" any Jewish Israeli or foreign Jew. They pick intelligence agents from the pool of army recruits. They have the full intelligence and physical and pyschological profile of every 18 year old Israeli. And from that pool, they do not pick idiots. The same pool provides the persons they use to screen at airports. To survive in Israel's neighborhood, you need a good intelligence agency, not one staffed by illegals working at a US moving company.

    Replies: @Drakejax

    Don’t confuse professional intelligence agents, who in Israel’s case are very well vetted and trained, with the thousands of various contacts and assets they utilize. A German just got convicted for having been retained by the CIA; he worked as a mail handler for the German intelligence agency. The German was the asset, the actual “agents” worked in another country.

    • Replies: @cwhatfuture
    @Drakejax

    The implication in several of the posts here is that very low level assets (the moving company illegals) would have had knowledge of a Mossad plot on 9/11. That is absurd. That would mean the Israeli intelligence agency would be staffed by idiots and that persons posting on this blog and various internet nuts would have uncovered the great secret. If the Mossad can penetrate Iran and kill Iranian nuclear scientists, which by all accounts they did, despite the scientists being under tight guard and despite the Iranians being aware the Israelis had every intention of killing them, no one on this blog has uncovered anything at all about the Mossad. Or maybe I am a secret Mossad Elks Club Masonic Temple Super "Shabbo Goy" - as someone here so eloquently put it.

    Replies: @Rurik

  96. @sprfls
    @jtgw

    Who said they do a good job? Obviously I don't know the exact numbers here, but for example a significant amount of non-Jewish Soviets emigrated to Israel in the 80s and 90s.

    Replies: @Dave Pinsen, @cwhatfuture, @Karl

    I would think Israel’s laxity regarding that post-Soviet wave was intentional. Israel’s leaders likely saw it as a demographic bulwark against Arabs as well as against Mizrahi Jews.

    • Replies: @AnotherDad
    @Dave Pinsen


    I would think Israel’s laxity regarding that post-Soviet wave was intentional. Israel’s leaders likely saw it as a demographic bulwark against Arabs as well as against Mizrahi Jews.
     
    Do these truly non-Jewish Russians actually stick in Israel? I'd think almost all of them who don't identify as Jewish would have tried to get on the US. (There sure seem to be a heck of a lot of Russians--and other ex-Soviets--swarming around these days.) Israel seems like a nice place, but it's a nice place for a particular people. If you don't really identify as Jewish i don't see why you'd stick there.

    ~~~

    Not up on things Israeli, but my very rough take:
    -- they've gotten the Arab fertility down now to near replacement--and they can always decide (at high political cost) to toss Arabs out.
    -- their long term demographic future is most endangered by the Haredi who have incredibly high (African level) fertility but are absolute parasites, sucking up welfare and (legally) dodging military service; they used to be trivial but are now broaching 10% of the population and will rapidly expand--given their fertility--beyond that

    I hate parasites--high, low and in-between. They are a cancer. They suck the life from nations and need to be rooted out, suppressed or tossed out. I don't keep up with Israeli affairs--not my people--but i haven't heard that normal secular\religious Israelis have devised any coherent plan to deal with this menace.

    Replies: @Karl, @bomag

    , @Steve Sailer
    @Dave Pinsen

    Ariel Sharon was a really Slavic-looking guy. I can't remember if one of his parents came from a Russian group that converted to Judaism in Russia.

    Replies: @kaganovitch

  97. @Drakejax
    A disgruntled MOSSAD officer wrote an expose´ ("By Way of Deception") that detailed how MOSSAD is small and poor, but punches above its weight by employing Jews to spy in their local countries and use their businesses to pay for it all. Sort of like how Pollard suddenly got employed on Wall Street or something. The actual professional case officers are very few in number, but who needs them when high-status Jews throughout the world will hook you up with either information or influence.

    Replies: @Chiron, @Cwhatfuture, @Zed, Lord of the Brutals

    They’re called ‘sayanim’, its well known among some circles that what really makes the MOSSAD so powerful is wealthy and influential jews in countries like US, UK, France and Russia gaving premium information for the israelis.

    Jacob Cohen, a French-jew who became anti-Zionist admitted in a book that the MOSSAD recruits sayanim inside the French Freemasonry (the Judeo-Masonic conspiracy is quite plausible when you look into it), its likely that high-level Masonic lodges are used by the MOSSAD to recruit powerful jews and gentiles (known às Shabbo Goyim).

  98. @Black Death
    The Israeli technician who blew the whistle on Israel's nuke program was Mordechai Vanunu. From his Wiki page:

    Mordechai Vanunu (Hebrew: מרדכי ואנונו‎; born 14 October 1954), also known as John Crossman,[2][3] is an Israeli former nuclear technician and peace activist[4] who, citing his opposition to weapons of mass destruction, revealed details of Israel's nuclear weapons program to the British press in 1986.[5][6] He was subsequently lured to Italy by a Mossad agent, where he was drugged and abducted by Israeli intelligence agents.[5] He was transported to Israel and ultimately convicted in a trial that was held behind closed doors.[5]
    Vanunu spent 18 years in prison, including more than 11 in solitary confinement. Released from prison in 2004, he became subject to a broad array of restrictions on his speech and movement. Since then he has been arrested several times for violations of those restrictions, including giving various interviews to foreign journalists and attempting to leave Israel. He says he suffered "cruel and barbaric treatment" at the hands of Israeli authorities while imprisoned, and suggests that his treatment would have been different if he had not converted to Christianity from Judaism.[7]
    In 2007, Vanunu was sentenced to six months in prison for violating terms of his parole. The sentence was considered unusual even by the prosecution who expected a suspended sentence. In response, Amnesty International issued a press release on 2 July 2007, stating that "The organisation considers Mordechai Vanunu to be a prisoner of conscience and calls for his immediate and unconditional release."[8] In May 2010, Vanunu was arrested and sentenced to three months in jail on a charge that he met foreigners in violation of conditions of his 2004 release from jail.

    Replies: @Anonymous, @This Is Our Home, @AnotherDad

    Vanunu’s certainly wasn’t Pollard level of treason.

    No one was at all confused that the Israelis had nuclear weapons. They didn’t sign the NPT for a reason. One expects US\Soviet intelligence had at least ballpark estimates of where they were at. What Vanunu provided was some public confirmation of scale.

    My two-bit analysis: I don’t think he harmed Israel at all. Leftists painted nuclear deterrence as “terror”, but i slept like a baby my whole youth. Wasn’t waking in a cold sweat thinking the Russkis were going to nuke me, because they knew with certainty what would happen to them if they did. Arab hostiles now know with certainty what fate awaits them–their cities, muslim holy sites … gone–if they really try to push Israel into the sea. (And they haven’t tried to do so since.) Yet, Israel can continue to parrot whatever their bogus line is “won’t be the first to introduce” to the US.

    But that said, plain fact is, Israel elects a government and its their job–not Vanunu’s–to decide to release what information about their nuclear program at what time for maximum benefit to their nation’s security. Ergo Vanunu’s a traitor. The Israelis would be well within normal respectable rules of fair play to take him out back and shoot him.

    Pollard’s nothing but a traitor, selling off actual operational intelligence methods, info that hindered intelligence collection and harmed US security for cash money. He should have been drawn and quartered, boiling oil dribbled down his throat and his innards pulled out and burned. That someone is giving him a job on Wall Street suggests said someone is not an American.

    • Agree: Jim Don Bob
    • Replies: @D. K.
    @AnotherDad

    "Back in 1986, Vanunu, a junior technician at the Dimona nuclear reactor, gave Israel’s nuclear secrets to The Sunday Times, claiming he did so out of opposition to weapons of mass destruction."

    How is that "treason?" It is just "whistle-blowing"-- much the same as Snowden's, more recently. Except, of course, that Vanunu's information merely confirmed what was already widely assumed, whereas much of what Snowden has revealed, thus far, has shocked both citizens, politicians and foreign leaders. "Treason" is defined as fighting for, or otherwise adhering to, an "enemy"-- which does not include the "free press" in an allied nation!

    Replies: @AnotherDad, @Stan D Mute

  99. @sprfls
    @jtgw

    Who said they do a good job? Obviously I don't know the exact numbers here, but for example a significant amount of non-Jewish Soviets emigrated to Israel in the 80s and 90s.

    Replies: @Dave Pinsen, @cwhatfuture, @Karl

    The standards for immigration are not so high – as long as you have one Jewish grandparent, you qualify. But the standards for marriage and children and those children being registered as Jewish are very high. That falls under the rabbis and they are strict. Many, if not most, of the non-Jewish soviets who arrived then have long ago left Israel by the way. And why would they stay in Israel which is under constant pressure and low level terror, when you can get to Europe, or Canada or even the US? Canada especially is favored because education is valued in their immigration system. Israel has been far more successful than Europe in keeping out unwanted populations. Israel has also been incredibly successful in having their Jewish immigrants become “Israelified”, to make up a word.

  100. MW, yes, lots of (not American?) kids travel abroad on working vacations. Lots of food & bev kids around here are Irish or eastern Europeans, for example.

  101. @SPMoore8
    @Truth

    I really don't see the relevance of this unless the shooters were members of the Woodrow Wilson Brigade or the Stanford White Power Legion (that would be SWPL, for short).

    On the other hand, it would be relatively simple to cherry pick stories about black assailants assaulting whites, amirite?

    Replies: @Truth

    it would be relatively simple to cherry pick stories about black assailants assaulting whites, amirite?

    From having been on this site for 9 years…I would concur.

    • Agree: SPMoore8
    • Replies: @D. K.
    @Truth

    Since a particular demographic group (age x sex x race) comprising only about 2% of our resident population commits about half of all of the murders in the United States-- year in and year out, decade after decade-- no "cherry-picking" is necessary.

  102. WhatEvvs [AKA "Internet Addict"] says:

    What with the downing of this Russian jet, and the Wikileaks revelation that Turkey is on the side of ISIS, what does the Sailer crystal ball say about the new Turkish PM?

    The party has for a long time been supported by the Cemaat Movement of exiled Islamic cleric Fethullah Gülen, whose influence in the judiciary has helped to weaken the opposition against the AKP.[17]

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justice_and_Development_Party_(Turkey)

    Because I don’t understand any of it.

  103. @This Is Our Home
    @Black Death

    The treatment seems pretty fair for a traitor. Indeed it is more moderate than what the US has done to Pollard; I probably would have shot them both.

    Replies: @Black Death

    @Roger Rediger

    No, the treatment that Vanunu received is harsher – read the link provided by Anonymous – 51. There is no doubt that Vanunu was a traitor, and the Israeli government had every right to punish him. But his offense, like Pollard’s, took place almost thirty years ago, and his freedom is still severely restricted – no different from Pollard. But here are the major differences – agree or disagree with him, Vanunu acted out of conviction – he never profited from his actions. Pollard was a hired spy, bought and paid for by the Israeli government. No doubt Pollard was sincerely motivated to help Israel, but he also got a ton of cash for what he did. Pollard also peddled his stolen information to other nations, including China, Pakistan and South Africa. Numerous high Israeli officials, including several prime ministers, have acknowledged that they were aware of Pollard’s activities. So much for our “special relationship.” It wasn’t until the US Congress threatened to cut off all aid to Israel that full Israeli cooperation was secured.

    But that was then and this is now. I think both Pollard and Vanunu should be allowed to go where they want to go – Pollard to Israel and Vanunu to the US.

  104. @AnotherDad
    @Black Death

    Vanunu's certainly wasn't Pollard level of treason.

    No one was at all confused that the Israelis had nuclear weapons. They didn't sign the NPT for a reason. One expects US\Soviet intelligence had at least ballpark estimates of where they were at. What Vanunu provided was some public confirmation of scale.

    My two-bit analysis: I don't think he harmed Israel at all. Leftists painted nuclear deterrence as "terror", but i slept like a baby my whole youth. Wasn't waking in a cold sweat thinking the Russkis were going to nuke me, because they knew with certainty what would happen to them if they did. Arab hostiles now know with certainty what fate awaits them--their cities, muslim holy sites ... gone--if they really try to push Israel into the sea. (And they haven't tried to do so since.) Yet, Israel can continue to parrot whatever their bogus line is "won't be the first to introduce" to the US.

    But that said, plain fact is, Israel elects a government and its their job--not Vanunu's--to decide to release what information about their nuclear program at what time for maximum benefit to their nation's security. Ergo Vanunu's a traitor. The Israelis would be well within normal respectable rules of fair play to take him out back and shoot him.

    Pollard's nothing but a traitor, selling off actual operational intelligence methods, info that hindered intelligence collection and harmed US security for cash money. He should have been drawn and quartered, boiling oil dribbled down his throat and his innards pulled out and burned. That someone is giving him a job on Wall Street suggests said someone is not an American.

    Replies: @D. K.

    “Back in 1986, Vanunu, a junior technician at the Dimona nuclear reactor, gave Israel’s nuclear secrets to The Sunday Times, claiming he did so out of opposition to weapons of mass destruction.”

    How is that “treason?” It is just “whistle-blowing”– much the same as Snowden’s, more recently. Except, of course, that Vanunu’s information merely confirmed what was already widely assumed, whereas much of what Snowden has revealed, thus far, has shocked both citizens, politicians and foreign leaders. “Treason” is defined as fighting for, or otherwise adhering to, an “enemy”– which does not include the “free press” in an allied nation!

    • Replies: @AnotherDad
    @D. K.


    How is that “treason?” It is just “whistle-blowing”
     
    Fair point. At some level i agree with you that the treason bar is not really met, it's hard to see the harm to Israel. And i drew a clear distinct from what Pollard did which was selling out the US for Pollard's private and ethnocentric interests.

    I wouldn't quite dignify Vanunu with "whistle blowing" though--at least not from a "citizen of Israel" perspective. Whistle blowing generally connotes that you're exposing some useful info--generally about official malfeasance--to your citizenry that *needs* exposure and is being kept from the people. (They are dumping toxic waste; this drug doesn't work; this multi-billion dollar fighter doesn't perform very well; etc.) None of that is really true here. There's no malfeasance. Israel has a nuclear weapons program. The citizenry know that and support it. Their elected officials are duly informed. The level of revelation of extent and technical sophistication is really a political\foreign policy question to be sorted out by their elected governments.

    Replies: @D. K.

    , @Stan D Mute
    @D. K.


    much of what Snowden has revealed, thus far, has shocked both citizens, politicians and foreign leaders.
     
    Anyone "shocked" by Snowden's stories was a terribly naive fool. We knew long before Snowden that NSA was building a shiny new $2 billion data center in Utah and that they already operated more DC space than google. We've known for a long time that uttering a certain sequence of words on your telephone will yield a knock on your door within hours. And we knew of Harris' Stingray, Triggerfish, and Kingfish type devices since the advent of cell phones. Obviously the surveillance tech has kept up with the consumer tech. All Snowden did was confirm what we already "knew" (deduced).
  105. @Buzz Mohawk
    @Stan D Mute


    In a clear bit of white supremacist propaganda today, Jeff Bezos landed a rocket on its retractable landing gear after a sub-orbital launch mission.
     
    You might want to inform certain supergenius bloggers of this event. They are under the impression that nobody in America can launch a rocket anymore.

    Oh, BTW, we are still receiving cool data from the Pluto flyby that was accomplished recently by an American spacecraft launced on an American rocket.

    I know. This just doesn't fit here.

    Now back to your regular programming..."Somebody's up to something! And we have no control over it!..."

    Replies: @D. K., @5371

    So a billionaire scumbag can fly 100 km up and then land, which the X-15 could do sixty years ago, but unlike the X-15 he can’t choose where to go or where to land and can’t put anyone aboard. BFD.

  106. @jtgw
    Israel seems to work on trust in many ways. E.g. how exactly do they verify your Jewishness when you apply for citizenship there? It would seem to be something easy to fake, and yet Israel is pretty good at keeping itself Jewish.

    Replies: @Cwhatfuture, @Steve Sailer, @sprfls, @Karl, @Lugash, @shk12344

    >> how exactly do they verify your Jewishness when you apply for citizenship there?

    the same sort of way that Ireland verifies that one of your four grandparents was Irish, before giving you your Irish passport.

    I notice that Ireland just put some money into copying the “Birthright” program.

    Didn’t Michelle Bachmann just get her Swiss dual-loyalty credentials?

    Philippines process for granting dual-citizenship to its large diaspora,runs pretty much the same way.

    In MANY of the world’s second-tier countries, if you REALLY want to gain citizenship, repeated applications of money and persistence, will get you there. Lawyers exist.

  107. @Mike Sylwester
    It seems that some Arabs in New York City did have prior knowledge of the attack and were looking forward to it.

    Prior Knowledge of Sept. 11 Not Just Urban Legend
    Posted Sept. 10, 2002
    By Jeffrey Scott Shapiro

    "What are you looking at?" asked the schoolteacher as she approached one of her freshman students. The boy, a young Palestinian, seemed captivated as he stared out the window across Brooklyn toward the lower downtown area of Manhattan.

    "Do you see those two buildings?" he asked while pointing toward the World Trade Center. "They won't be standing there next week." It was noon, Sept. 6, 2001.

    Antoinette DiLorenzo didn't take her student's comment all too seriously. Of course the twin towers would be there next week, she assured him. The student shook his head and reiterated his prediction until his 15-year old brother, a sophomore, elbowed him and told him to be quiet. "He's just kidding," the older boy said politely.

    Five days later at 8:45 a.m., DiLorenzo heard a loud explosion from the north. Thunderstruck, she turned to the window and eventually watched both towers collapse into shattered glass and crumbled steel.

    Many people believed this story was nothing more than an urban legend when they first heard it. Everyone has heard similar stories in the wake of such a disaster. Despite the almost unbelievable circumstances of the story, I was able to confirm it last October while working as a crime reporter for the Journal News, a New York-based Gannett newspaper. Catie Marshall, a spokeswoman for the New York City Board of Education, confirmed that school officials reported the incident to police and that the matter had since been taken over by the FBI Joint Terrorist Task Force (FBI-JTTF).

    New Utrecht High School was closed Sept. 12, 2001, but as soon as it reopened the following morning, a shaken DiLorenzo quietly approached a New York City Police Department (NYPD) school-safety officer in the school's first-floor lobby. Soon, a dozen investigators stormed the school, interrogating students and searching lockers.

    After federal agents questioned DiLorenzo, police detectives questioned her fourth-period class to see if anyone else had heard the boy's comments. Once the detectives were finished, the boy and his brother forcibly were taken to the 62nd Precinct headquarters, where two investigators with the FBI-JTTF questioned them for several hours. Their father, who was in Israel at the time of the attacks, was scheduled to fly home Sept. 11 on a commercial airliner, but he was delayed when all flights to the United States were grounded.
     

    More at the following webpage:

    http://www.prisonplanet.com/prior_knowledge_of_sept_11_not_just_urban_legend.htm

    Replies: @SPMoore8, @greysquirrell

    PrisonPlanet is not a decent source, because while it occassionally may have some worthy news , it is too often neck deep in unsutantiated conspiracy news.

    The problem in believeing the story you quote is that there is no way the planners of 9-11 would have told or discussed their plans in a manner that some highschool kids could overhear and then babble about it.

    Unless I can see some mainstream news sites report on the same claim , I’m chalking it up to propaghanda. The article reporting the kids were Palestinian also arouses my suspicion. None of the 9-11 Hijackers were Palestinian, so it wouldn’t be like their unlces or older brothers or dads were discussing it and these kids overheard it.

    • Replies: @Bugg
    @greysquirrell

    I recall seeing the New Utrecht High School Palestinian kid being part of a documentary on PBS or History or some other cable channel. Made a few attempts to search for it, but admittedly nothing comes up now. You can note that several of the 9/11 hijackers did live in apartments in Brooklyn and New Jersey in the years prior to 9/11, attended mosques in NYC (specifically one on 3rd Avenue and one on Bedford Avenue in Brooklyn) and probably had some contacts with people they knew from their time there, and perhaps spoke to their old friends in the run-up to that day.Grant you that sounds like speculation, if logical.

  108. @nglaer
    You write there were "numerous reports" of Midwesterners celebrating on 9/11. I know about the Israelis in the van-- and Carl Cameron's Fox News reports on them, etc. But others? Sad to say, it's important. Trump can get away with saying a lot of politically incorrect stuff, but he can't just make stuff up, it's really not presidential.

    Replies: @nglaer, @Bill Jones, @Desiderius

    he can’t just make stuff up, it’s really not presidential

    One would hope.

    Don’t think the current occupant feels that way.

  109. @Robert Hume
    The picture I remember was of about five men seen from behind looking across the river at the twin towers and rejoicing. They were said to be Israelis. They would obviously be happy because now the US would go to war against Arabs. I've read that Israelis had some inkling that an attack was imminent, and that US intelligence did also, "Their hair was on fire", but that the administration ignored US intelligence. For example, of course, Bush thought it would be racist to profile Arabs. I have not read if US intelligence did or did not receive leads from the Israelis.

    Replies: @NOTA, @Anonymous

    Even if the Israelis knew ahead of time, why would they send people in the field who knew ahead of time, and put them in a position to be arrested and questioned by the FBI?

    • Replies: @cwhatfuture
    @NOTA

    Why would Israelis use illegals working as movers to record such an event and celebrate it publicly? Because according to the sleuths on this board, not only are the Israeli intelligence agencies dumb, they verge on the retarded.

    Replies: @Zed, Lord of the Brutals

  110. @Seth
    @tanabear

    The idea that these guys were up to anything in particular is absurd.

    They were filming the WTC as it burned...like everyone else with a camera in a two mile radius. On tv later one of them said in bad English that he was "documenting" the event and the loonies took that to mean that he had been sent there to do it.

    Why would the Mossad need to have the most spectacular event in American history specially "documented?"

    NYC is filled with illegal immigrants who say they are tourists and are doing some work in the meantime. Not unusual.

    Movers are often paid in cash. $4700 among 4 people may sound like a lot of money to some fevered conspiracy theorist but if that was all their money it's really not that much.

    Replies: @Jasper Been, @tanabear

    Seth: “The idea that these guys were up to anything in particular is absurd.”

    If it was absurd then they wouldn’t have been contained for 71 days and questioned about their activities on 09/11/2001 over and over again. They obviously had to arouse some sort of suspicion and stand out from other witnesses of the towers burning otherwise the police would not have been called. Urban Moving Systems/Company was apparently a front company for the Mossad. Three of the suspects were Mossad agents. This is very suspicious.

    But why were they so giddy and happy?

    From the FBI report: “…one of the males appeared to be taking still photographs and video of the other males with the WTC in the background. All of the males appeared to be jovial in that they smiled, hugged one another, and gave “high fives“.

    Film obtained from the 35mm camera of one of the detainees was later developed and processed by the Newark Division. The photos clearly corroborate [Blank’s] statements in that the Israelis are visibly happy on nearly all of the photgraphs.”

    • Replies: @Seth
    @tanabear

    Do you imagine that Mossad spies are so clumsily trained that they high-five each other and dance and smile in public when their mission comes off?

    You ask why they were happy. Who knows? Maybe they were just jerks.

    Replies: @tanabear

  111. @Kevin O'Keeffe
    @jackmcg

    "I can’t remember if I’ve posted this here or not but I’ve made a prediction that Hillary will choose a hispanic man for VP. Another woman steals her thunder, a white man isn’t “progress”, an asian man too irrelevant, a well-spoken black man in very short supply. A Hispanic male VP charges up her side of the immigration vote. I’m sure there are a couple possible choices in the Dem. party somewhere."

    Hillary has all but stated her intent to nominate HUD Secretary Julian* Castro as her Veep. Steve's talked about it, actually.

    *Pronounced "whoolian," for all you micro-aggressing sh*tlords who had the temerity to suppose he pronounced it like the old Roman Emperor

    Replies: @NOTA

    So, how’d the emperor pronounce it? I assume not all that close to the English pronunciation, but I really don’t know.

    • Replies: @Richard S
    @NOTA

    Something like "Guy-uz Yule-lee-uz Kae-sar"; but then technically he was never emperor :)

    Replies: @kaganovitch, @ben tillman

    , @Glossy
    @NOTA

    I would guess that the ancient pronunciation was Yoolian.

    Replies: @Romanian

  112. Even if the Israelis knew ahead of time, why would they send people in the field who knew ahead of time, and put them in a position to be arrested and questioned by the FBI?

    The way I always heard it (i.e., the speculation), they were tracking Muslim terrorists in the US and knew there would or might be an attack, which would make your question kind of nonsensical; not as if they’d just disappear into thin air the moment they were forewarned.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Svigor

    Even if they didn't know an attack would or might happen, they still would have filmed it. Wouldn't anyone? If they were engaged in surveilance they would have had video-cameras, and most people who had video-cameras on that that day, who weren't in immediate danger, filmed what they could of the attacks.

  113. @Dave Pinsen
    @sprfls

    I would think Israel's laxity regarding that post-Soviet wave was intentional. Israel's leaders likely saw it as a demographic bulwark against Arabs as well as against Mizrahi Jews.

    Replies: @AnotherDad, @Steve Sailer

    I would think Israel’s laxity regarding that post-Soviet wave was intentional. Israel’s leaders likely saw it as a demographic bulwark against Arabs as well as against Mizrahi Jews.

    Do these truly non-Jewish Russians actually stick in Israel? I’d think almost all of them who don’t identify as Jewish would have tried to get on the US. (There sure seem to be a heck of a lot of Russians–and other ex-Soviets–swarming around these days.) Israel seems like a nice place, but it’s a nice place for a particular people. If you don’t really identify as Jewish i don’t see why you’d stick there.

    ~~~

    Not up on things Israeli, but my very rough take:
    — they’ve gotten the Arab fertility down now to near replacement–and they can always decide (at high political cost) to toss Arabs out.
    — their long term demographic future is most endangered by the Haredi who have incredibly high (African level) fertility but are absolute parasites, sucking up welfare and (legally) dodging military service; they used to be trivial but are now broaching 10% of the population and will rapidly expand–given their fertility–beyond that

    I hate parasites–high, low and in-between. They are a cancer. They suck the life from nations and need to be rooted out, suppressed or tossed out. I don’t keep up with Israeli affairs–not my people–but i haven’t heard that normal secular\religious Israelis have devised any coherent plan to deal with this menace.

    • Replies: @Karl
    @AnotherDad

    >> Israel seems like a nice place, but it’s a nice place for a particular people. If you don’t really identify as Jewish i don’t see why you’d stick there.


    nonsense. Even muslims are embraced if they are loyal to the State: the Circassians. Doing very nicely, HEAVILY represented in upper ranks of the carabinieri (Border Police) and even, nowadays, seen in the Air Force technical academies. Not surprising, as their IQs are on the right-hand side of the curve..... they are actual caucasians.

    Russians are often, conservative traditional whites. Not very many want to be ruled by a de Blasio. Places like England are even worse. Also, traditional Slavic culture is well appreciated in Israel. Google on "dancekessem"


    I am not aware of ANY categorical yeridah of Russians ==qua== Russians from Israel. They are STRONGLY entrenched in Israel. Almost government websites have a click-for-Russian-language icon.

    , @bomag
    @AnotherDad

    In the ongoing massive social experiment on planet Earth the plan to deal with population is to turn everyone into a modern Progressive and thus sterilize them. Not everyone is going to go along, so we will see how it works out.

  114. @Whiskey
    Instapundit here references the Washington Post Sept 18, 2001 referring to tailgate viewing parties in Jersey watching and celebrating the Twin Towers collapse. Referencing Muslims.

    Muslims around the nation celebrated and danced in the streets, which was reported, just barely, at the time.

    Trump was/is correct.
    -----------------------------
    As for intelligence, the US has been very, very bad as has British intelligence in human sources, but very, very, VERY good in technical intelligence. We and the British were reading in near real time in WWII German and Japanese codes down to battlefield movements. We had an enourmous lead in satellite spying which combined with the U2 and SR72 gave us good ideas of the general abilities and intentions of the Soviets (a key reason we did not launch a nuclear attack in the dark). We tapped undersea cables the Soviets thought were impossible to tap.

    Recently the US/Israeli intelligence effort to hamper Iran's nuclear program was entirely technical. Stuxnet was very successful.

    Human sources are generally over-rated. They are too subject to bias and tale-telling (Ahmed Chalabi), turning and doubling, and often merely duplicate the tremendous amount of open source information that can be collated and analyzed.

    I would be EXTREMELY dubious of "Israeli" citizens -- since a non trivial portion are Arab Muslims. There is also a thriving Israeli organized crime movement.

    The CEO of say, Teva, who was refused an Avis Rental Car by a couple of Black female service reps because he was Israeli, is highly unlikely to be either a spy or a criminal. The real threat as always comes from insiders, Robert Hanssen, Aldric Ames, Jonathon Pollard, the Walker family. And its usually related to sex or money or both.

    Replies: @nglaer

    Instapundit here references the Washington Post Sept 18, 2001 referring to tailgate viewing parties in Jersey watching and celebrating the Twin Towers collapse. Referencing Muslims.

    Muslims around the nation celebrated and danced in the streets, which was reported, just barely, at the time.

    Trump was/is correct.

    Thank you Whiskey. Am not usually on your ideological wavelength. This, (or instapundit’s) is an important factoid. My optimism is restored.

    • Replies: @gcochran
    @nglaer

    It never happened, not in the US. Whiskey is never correct.

    Replies: @James Kabala

  115. @NOTA
    @Kevin O'Keeffe

    So, how'd the emperor pronounce it? I assume not all that close to the English pronunciation, but I really don't know.

    Replies: @Richard S, @Glossy

    Something like “Guy-uz Yule-lee-uz Kae-sar”; but then technically he was never emperor 🙂

    • Replies: @kaganovitch
    @Richard S

    It is Julian Castro we are referring to, as in the Emperor Julian the Apostate not Julius

    , @ben tillman
    @Richard S


    Something like “Guy-uz Yule-lee-uz Kae-sar”
     
    Kie-sar. First syllable is just like the first syllable of the German "Kaiser".
  116. If US intel is hamstrung by fear of traitors, it is not hard to understand why. As a multiracial state, we have PC telling us to trust everyone but practical experience to tell that we can’t. For many, dual loyalties would be an improvement.

  117. @sprfls
    @jtgw

    Who said they do a good job? Obviously I don't know the exact numbers here, but for example a significant amount of non-Jewish Soviets emigrated to Israel in the 80s and 90s.

    Replies: @Dave Pinsen, @cwhatfuture, @Karl

    >> Who said they do a good job?

    Ever since the 1750’s (first publication of a Hebrew-language mathematics school-text), nationalistic Zionism has been almost completely led by non-religious Jews.

    It is easily possible to paint the picture that “Judaism” as a stand-alone, organized “religion”, didn’t really exist until after the Roman destruction of the Second Temple. Hebrew kings – up to & including Herod – never (to my memory of the bible) tried to dual-hat themselves as a High Priest. Actually, quite a few of them used tax monies to support pagan shrines. The municipality of Jerusalem still gives away free Christmas trees every year. In fact, it’s going to happen in a coupla weeks.

    Even deep within the bowels of the Temple bureaucracy itself, the King always had total control of crowd-control and even liturgical arrangements. 1 Chronicles 25. Kinda like mosques nowadays in the Gulf states?

    • Replies: @kaganovitch
    @Karl

    "Hebrew kings – up to & including Herod – never (to my memory of the bible) tried to dual-hat themselves as a High Priest. "

    Your memory is off fwiw. Pretty much the entire hasmonean dynasty was dual hat . Herod didn't try it because he was unfit for priestly caste due to ancestry.

  118. @Svigor
    Russian entry into Turkish airspace lasted 'seconds': U.S. official

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The United States believes Russia's incursion into Turkish airspace on Tuesday likely lasted only a matter of seconds before Turkey shot down a Russian warplane, a U.S. official said, saying the assessment was based on preliminary indications.

    The official, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said the United States was still investigating the incident.
     
    Damage control? Seems like US unofficially admitting within hours that the Turks were itching to shoot down a Russian plane.

    Replies: @tbraton

    Any peep of protest from the U.S. or EU about the steady stream of rubber rafts carrying “Syrian refugees” from Turkey to Lesbos and thereby violating the territorial waters of Greece?

  119. @Truth
    Uh Oh!...Part LXII!

    Be careful what you axe for.

    http://qz.com/558326/white-men-shot-several-people-at-a-black-lives-matter-rally-in-minneapolis/?utm_source=YPL

    Replies: @SPMoore8, @D. K., @D. K., @AnotherDad, @tbraton

    • Replies: @SPMoore8
    @D. K.

    Based on my personal knowledge of the Occupy movement, I would bet (a) that this had nothing to do with race, (b) it was a drug deal gone bad.

  120. @Drakejax
    A disgruntled MOSSAD officer wrote an expose´ ("By Way of Deception") that detailed how MOSSAD is small and poor, but punches above its weight by employing Jews to spy in their local countries and use their businesses to pay for it all. Sort of like how Pollard suddenly got employed on Wall Street or something. The actual professional case officers are very few in number, but who needs them when high-status Jews throughout the world will hook you up with either information or influence.

    Replies: @Chiron, @Cwhatfuture, @Zed, Lord of the Brutals

    If he had been anything but a low level clerk, which is what he was, he would already be dead or have been “brought back” to Israel for trial.

  121. @Kevin O'Keeffe
    In the year 2000, my home in San Jose was visited by two very attractive young ladies who characterized themselves as "Israeli art students," and claimed to be selling paintings door-to-door. At the time, I was living with my father (due to the fact I'd recently spent a year in the county jail, as a result of my 20something involvement in some embarrassingly imbecile shenanigans, pertaining to a right-wing extremist organization that was very active during the 1990s), and my father was the chief-of-maintenance for a large industrial facility in Silicon Valley (one that most definitely had potential national security-related implications; they weren't designing social media apps, LOL). Anyhoo, over the course of the next two weeks, both my father and I kept running into these same "Israeli art students" all over town, in San Jose, in Sunnyvale, in Palo Alto...seemingly wherever we went. I was told I was "paranoid," for believing they were following us, but realistically, I don't see any other possibility. They tried to get into the facility where my father worked, at one point, but were denied access.

    Replies: @Boomstick

    When I had a small office in an office park I used to get regular cold calls from “art salesmen.” Their schtick was to say that they had some art that had been ordered by someone else in the building but that they had since moved out. Rather than take the art back they said they’d cut a deal and give it to me for a rock bottom price.

    They were just selling cheap knockoff Ansel Adams reproductions, obviously without paying any licensing fees. The story was about cancelled orders was just part of the sales pitch. There are plenty of similar scams, including door-to-door meat salesmen. One of the most famous is the “white box speaker” sales guys. They’ll cadge you in parking lots and tell you they were making a delivery on expensive stereo speakers, but the deal fell through. Rather than take them back they’ll sell you these top-flight speakers for a low, low price. The speakers are actually crap and the price is inflated, but the story helps make the sale.

    If the “Israeli art students” were actually spies I’d expect them to conceal their foreign extraction. From an information gathering standpoint it’s a negative to volunteer that information, but probably a positive for making sales of overpriced art.

    • Replies: @greysquirrell
    @Boomstick

    I had that happen to me once; a Semi truck pulled up into our subdividion and wanted to sell us some 'high' quality furniture that they were supposed to deliver but the buyer reneged and they couldn't drive all the way back to some other State with it.

    How can this type of sales be effective? Most people are really averse to door to door salesman and will decline. Seems like a waste of time and money to cold call on people.

    , @Kevin O'Keeffe
    @Boomstick

    "When I had a small office in an office park I used to get regular cold calls from “art salesmen.” Their schtick was to say that they had some art that had been ordered by someone else in the building but that they had since moved out. Rather than take the art back they said they’d cut a deal and give it to me for a rock bottom price.

    They were just selling cheap knockoff Ansel Adams reproductions, obviously without paying any licensing fees. The story was about cancelled orders was just part of the sales pitch. There are plenty of similar scams, including door-to-door meat salesmen. One of the most famous is the “white box speaker” sales guys. They’ll cadge you in parking lots and tell you they were making a delivery on expensive stereo speakers, but the deal fell through. Rather than take them back they’ll sell you these top-flight speakers for a low, low price. The speakers are actually crap and the price is inflated, but the story helps make the sale.

    If the “Israeli art students” were actually spies I’d expect them to conceal their foreign extraction. From an information gathering standpoint it’s a negative to volunteer that information, but probably a positive for making sales of overpriced art."

    OK, but that doesn't really explain why they followed my dad and I all over Santa Clara County for a week or two, does it? How many times could the two of us run into them all over various "Silicon Valley" locales, before it stopped being "a coincidence?"

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    , @G Pinfold
    @Boomstick

    The scam works on greed, so it's very effective. The simplest is to imply that the goods are 'dodgy'. So for example: 'A bottle of Chanel Number 5 for a fiver, but better make it quick. I can't hang around, if you know what I mean?' Often an insider makes the first purchase, setting off the marks. Of course, the sting is that the goods are actually dodgy; not stolen, but 2 dollar knock-offs. As with all these schemes, its hard to catch someone twice, so they rely on fresh meat. But as PT Barnum said...

    BTW, as as non-Israeli student, I sold 'original oil paintings' door to door for a guy named Friedman. I was never equipped with a Minox camera or anything, but then I never made Salesman-of-the-Week either, so who knows?

  122. @MW
    @AndrewR

    As absurd as it sounds to an American, this is exactly what my Israeli cousin did, though "vacation" might be a misleading word. It is very common for young Israelis to take a few years after their army service and putter around the world, working as necessary. And there are lots of Israeli moving companies in the US, for whatever reason. So when my cousin needed work after a month or two doing nothing, he reached out to a childhood friend of his who, sure enough, ran a moving company in the US.

    Replies: @Karl

    >>> It is very common for young Israelis to take a few years after their army service and putter around the world, working as necessary

    “Just out of the service
    And he’s looking for his fun”

    http://www.lyricsmode.com/lyrics/j/judy_collins/someday_soon.html

  123. WhatEvvs [AKA "Internet Addict"] says:

    Sorry, OT. Read the comments. A corner has been turned.

    http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/25/us/minneapolis-shooting-protest-police-jamar-clark.html?_r=0

    It’s not every day that you get immediate, swift, fact-check their asses from the NY Times.

    • Replies: @Boomstick
    @WhatEvvs

    NYT:


    On Monday night, community members asked the men what they were doing and asked them to remove their masks, she said, but they refused and were then escorted away.
     
    It's not that hard to figure out what went on here. Citizens were filming something the #BLM didn't want filmed, and #BLM goons attempted to run them off with physical violence. ("refused and were then escorted away.") Things got dodgy and the people being "escorted" pulled their pieces, perhaps justifiably and perhaps not.
  124. listening to the radio station Jersey 101.5 today, Dennis and Judy , used their program to ask Jersey residents if they recalled seeing anyone celebrating on 9/11.

    dozens of callers remembered seeing Muslims in Paterson and Jersey City rejoicing or celebrating that day…the hosts were somewhat surprised, as they acknowledged most of the callers appeared credible and the callers themselves did sound convincing. Dennis made it known he does not support Trump, but he seemed to believe many of the callers.

    • Replies: @Dave Pinsen
    @Travis

    Mark Simone on WWOR confirmed it today as well, and pointed out that smart phones with video capability didn't exist then, hence the paucity of video.

  125. @D. K.
    @AnotherDad

    "Back in 1986, Vanunu, a junior technician at the Dimona nuclear reactor, gave Israel’s nuclear secrets to The Sunday Times, claiming he did so out of opposition to weapons of mass destruction."

    How is that "treason?" It is just "whistle-blowing"-- much the same as Snowden's, more recently. Except, of course, that Vanunu's information merely confirmed what was already widely assumed, whereas much of what Snowden has revealed, thus far, has shocked both citizens, politicians and foreign leaders. "Treason" is defined as fighting for, or otherwise adhering to, an "enemy"-- which does not include the "free press" in an allied nation!

    Replies: @AnotherDad, @Stan D Mute

    How is that “treason?” It is just “whistle-blowing”

    Fair point. At some level i agree with you that the treason bar is not really met, it’s hard to see the harm to Israel. And i drew a clear distinct from what Pollard did which was selling out the US for Pollard’s private and ethnocentric interests.

    I wouldn’t quite dignify Vanunu with “whistle blowing” though–at least not from a “citizen of Israel” perspective. Whistle blowing generally connotes that you’re exposing some useful info–generally about official malfeasance–to your citizenry that *needs* exposure and is being kept from the people. (They are dumping toxic waste; this drug doesn’t work; this multi-billion dollar fighter doesn’t perform very well; etc.) None of that is really true here. There’s no malfeasance. Israel has a nuclear weapons program. The citizenry know that and support it. Their elected officials are duly informed. The level of revelation of extent and technical sophistication is really a political\foreign policy question to be sorted out by their elected governments.

    • Replies: @D. K.
    @AnotherDad

    There was plenty of Israeli malfeasance-- like their stealing American supplies of uranium from Pennsylvania!

    Replies: @AnotherDad

  126. @AnotherDad
    @Dave Pinsen


    I would think Israel’s laxity regarding that post-Soviet wave was intentional. Israel’s leaders likely saw it as a demographic bulwark against Arabs as well as against Mizrahi Jews.
     
    Do these truly non-Jewish Russians actually stick in Israel? I'd think almost all of them who don't identify as Jewish would have tried to get on the US. (There sure seem to be a heck of a lot of Russians--and other ex-Soviets--swarming around these days.) Israel seems like a nice place, but it's a nice place for a particular people. If you don't really identify as Jewish i don't see why you'd stick there.

    ~~~

    Not up on things Israeli, but my very rough take:
    -- they've gotten the Arab fertility down now to near replacement--and they can always decide (at high political cost) to toss Arabs out.
    -- their long term demographic future is most endangered by the Haredi who have incredibly high (African level) fertility but are absolute parasites, sucking up welfare and (legally) dodging military service; they used to be trivial but are now broaching 10% of the population and will rapidly expand--given their fertility--beyond that

    I hate parasites--high, low and in-between. They are a cancer. They suck the life from nations and need to be rooted out, suppressed or tossed out. I don't keep up with Israeli affairs--not my people--but i haven't heard that normal secular\religious Israelis have devised any coherent plan to deal with this menace.

    Replies: @Karl, @bomag

    >> Israel seems like a nice place, but it’s a nice place for a particular people. If you don’t really identify as Jewish i don’t see why you’d stick there.

    nonsense. Even muslims are embraced if they are loyal to the State: the Circassians. Doing very nicely, HEAVILY represented in upper ranks of the carabinieri (Border Police) and even, nowadays, seen in the Air Force technical academies. Not surprising, as their IQs are on the right-hand side of the curve….. they are actual caucasians.

    Russians are often, conservative traditional whites. Not very many want to be ruled by a de Blasio. Places like England are even worse. Also, traditional Slavic culture is well appreciated in Israel. Google on “dancekessem”

    I am not aware of ANY categorical yeridah of Russians ==qua== Russians from Israel. They are STRONGLY entrenched in Israel. Almost government websites have a click-for-Russian-language icon.

  127. Well, I can’t remember the exact details, but about a month after 9/11, an Israeli military officer and a local Jewish associate were caught red-handed sneaking explosives and guns into the Mexican Parliament building, a story which immediately produced banner headlines in some of the leading Mexican newspapers but strangely enough was scarcely reported in the U.S. Under strong diplomatic pressure, both suspects were eventually deported back to Israel, just like all the ones caught in the NYC area around 9/11.

    A few years earlier, that Haim Saban Israeli fellow had bought the Univision television network, and perhaps if things had turned out a bit differently, horrific scenes of the destruction of the Mexican parliament by apparent “Arab terrorists” would have been broadcast 24/7 into every Hispanic home in America for the next twelve months.

    In attempting to extract reality from our imperfect media, it’s always important to consider the distortioning effects of probable skew and adjust accordingly…

    • Replies: @Boomstick
    @Ron Unz

    There were two men found with one Glock 9mm inside the Mexican parliament building. The only mentions of explosives I can find are on crazed conspiracy sites.

    http://archivo.eluniversal.com.mx/nacion/68324.html

    The man had a license to carry a concealed weapon and was a security guard. It's easy to forget you're wearing a pistol and accidentally go into restricted areas.

    Replies: @Ron Unz

  128. @AnotherDad
    @D. K.


    How is that “treason?” It is just “whistle-blowing”
     
    Fair point. At some level i agree with you that the treason bar is not really met, it's hard to see the harm to Israel. And i drew a clear distinct from what Pollard did which was selling out the US for Pollard's private and ethnocentric interests.

    I wouldn't quite dignify Vanunu with "whistle blowing" though--at least not from a "citizen of Israel" perspective. Whistle blowing generally connotes that you're exposing some useful info--generally about official malfeasance--to your citizenry that *needs* exposure and is being kept from the people. (They are dumping toxic waste; this drug doesn't work; this multi-billion dollar fighter doesn't perform very well; etc.) None of that is really true here. There's no malfeasance. Israel has a nuclear weapons program. The citizenry know that and support it. Their elected officials are duly informed. The level of revelation of extent and technical sophistication is really a political\foreign policy question to be sorted out by their elected governments.

    Replies: @D. K.

    There was plenty of Israeli malfeasance– like their stealing American supplies of uranium from Pennsylvania!

    • Replies: @AnotherDad
    @D. K.


    There was plenty of Israeli malfeasance– like their stealing American supplies of uranium from Pennsylvania!
     
    I'm speaking about Vanunu from the perspective of Israel--of which he was a citizen and pledged a secrecy oath when he took his job.

    From the perspective of America, those responsible for the Apollo plant diversion--if there was a diversion; it's still quite possible it was simply the most sloppily run, leakiest, uranium enrichment plant in the US--should have been brought to justice and executed.
  129. @Truth
    Uh Oh!...Part LXII!

    Be careful what you axe for.

    http://qz.com/558326/white-men-shot-several-people-at-a-black-lives-matter-rally-in-minneapolis/?utm_source=YPL

    Replies: @SPMoore8, @D. K., @D. K., @AnotherDad, @tbraton

    Here, in full, is a comment, from another Web site, about an actual murder (and sexual-assault) victim:

    “Amanda Blackburn was in the wrong place at the wrong time; she was in the confines of her own home 150 years after emancipation and 50 years after LBJ’s War on Poverty.”

    • Replies: @Romanian
    @D. K.

    And she was pregnant. Somebody suggested we should not just measure crime by bodycount, but by number of perpetrators too. It took three people to rape and kill that poor woman.

  130. Anonymous • Disclaimer says:
    @Robert Hume
    The picture I remember was of about five men seen from behind looking across the river at the twin towers and rejoicing. They were said to be Israelis. They would obviously be happy because now the US would go to war against Arabs. I've read that Israelis had some inkling that an attack was imminent, and that US intelligence did also, "Their hair was on fire", but that the administration ignored US intelligence. For example, of course, Bush thought it would be racist to profile Arabs. I have not read if US intelligence did or did not receive leads from the Israelis.

    Replies: @NOTA, @Anonymous

    They were filming the attack. The were apprehended for 40+ days and failed lie detector tests.

    One of them inadvertently admitted on live Israeli TV they were there to ‘document the event’

    There are a lot of things that were reported on at the time of the attack that were simply never followed up on. Here is Fox news footage from 2001, alleging that Israel knew what was going to happen.

    Any way you slice it, Israel is rotten in it’s dealings with the US. There is no way they should be considered an ‘ally’ and the fact that they receive aid from the American taxpayer is an outrage.

    • Replies: @tanabear
    @Anonymous

    America is an ally of Israel, but Israel is not an ally of the Unites States. That is how the relationship works.

    Yes, Carl Cameron and Fox News did some good initial reporting on this issue, but then they went quiet. I wonder what could have happened? Fox News also removed their report from their website on the Israel art student spy ring after only two days. They never said the information was wrong or inaccurate. Fox News: Fair, balanced, and unafraid....except of the Israeli Lobby.

  131. @Steve Sailer
    @jtgw

    There are a whole bunch of websites run by Jews that evaluate how Jewish various celebrities are. My impression is that gentiles have no clue how much mental energy Jews devote to such questions.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @yaqub the mad scientist, @Ben Tzot-Abrit, @Stephen R. Diamond, @Dahlia

    Do you observe that all kinds of Jews attend to this? Or just the religious Jews?

    I think it’s mostly the religious ones.

  132. @Stan D Mute
    In a clear bit of white supremacist propaganda today, Jeff Bezos landed a rocket on its retractable landing gear after a sub-orbital launch mission. In the video, there was not even one Diversity. Obviously this is impossible - success without Diversities just cannot happen - and thus proves Bezos a racist.

    http://www.engadget.com/2015/11/24/blue-origin-reusable-rocket-landing/

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @Je Suis Charlie Martel, @Romanian

    Hilarious

  133. @al gore rhythms
    @Stan D Mute


    The FBI package was at least 50 pages and required exhaustive detail including all schools attended and dates of attendance along with grades (do you have your third grade report cards?). They demanded all family connections to second cousin along with detail like date of birth and photos. It was, putting it mildly, incredibly over the top
     
    Shouldn't this be subject to a 'disparate impact' challenge? If you moved to America as a young child from the chaotic Third World then it might be hard to prove family connections or school grades.

    Replies: @Stan D Mute

    Shouldn’t this be subject to a ‘disparate impact’ challenge? If you moved to America as a young child from the chaotic Third World then it might be hard to prove family connections or school grades.

    Great observation! In fact, this was back in the early 1990’s so predates the “disparate impact” era. I’d expect that today a letter from your Imam or village witch doctor in crayon or goat blood would suffice for an “above top secret” clearance and GS15 job.

  134. @Stan D Mute
    In a clear bit of white supremacist propaganda today, Jeff Bezos landed a rocket on its retractable landing gear after a sub-orbital launch mission. In the video, there was not even one Diversity. Obviously this is impossible - success without Diversities just cannot happen - and thus proves Bezos a racist.

    http://www.engadget.com/2015/11/24/blue-origin-reusable-rocket-landing/

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @Je Suis Charlie Martel, @Romanian

    I’m a bit disappointed that SpaceX did not beat them to it. Blue Origin’s stuff has been vaporware for some time and has engaged in some lame practices, like hiring SpaceX’s people on propulsion and such after they had developed innovative tech (though, apparently, according to the Musk biography, his companies have a high turnover because he’s hard to work with). The thing is that it was a bit of a lame attempt: the rocket reached space, not orbit, which requires much more energy and would have made the return much more difficult; the rocket is a lot smaller, because it’s not meant to be usable, but a tech platform, while SpaceX attempts to land rockets after they have launched a payload. The near misses of SpaceX were thrilling in themselves, like the rocket falling just as it should have landed, but I appreciate what they were trying to do a bit more. Having just read the Musk biography that Tyler Cowen of MR recommended, I am convinced that I would not want to ever know him, except to discuss Mars a bit. Definitely not work for him. But he’s the kind of person that gets things done, and SpaceX has accomplished more with less than Blue Origin. They stole the reusable rocket thunder in a cheap way, compared to how SpaceX was doing it. Yes, I’m a cheerleader. Still, at least things are finally moving. Maybe my children will have their flying cars and Mars bases.

    • Replies: @Stan D Mute
    @Romanian


    The near misses of SpaceX were thrilling in themselves, like the rocket falling just as it should have landed, but I appreciate what they were trying to do a bit more.
     
    But did Musk at least properly credit his (near) success to ¡Diversity! or like Bezos pretend it was all done by white folks whom we know "didn't build this"?

    Maybe my children will have their flying cars and Mars bases.
     
    Yeah, you should probably set your hopes a bit lower. I'll be happy if my kids aren't forced to pay jizya and the country still has indoor plumbing.

    Replies: @Romanian

  135. 9/11 was the second time that Muslims tried to bring down those towers. It was only a matter of time before they had another go.

    • Agree: Travis
  136. @D. K.
    @Truth

    Here, in full, is a comment, from another Web site, about an actual murder (and sexual-assault) victim:

    "Amanda Blackburn was in the wrong place at the wrong time; she was in the confines of her own home 150 years after emancipation and 50 years after LBJ's War on Poverty."

    Replies: @Romanian

    And she was pregnant. Somebody suggested we should not just measure crime by bodycount, but by number of perpetrators too. It took three people to rape and kill that poor woman.

  137. @jtgw
    Israel seems to work on trust in many ways. E.g. how exactly do they verify your Jewishness when you apply for citizenship there? It would seem to be something easy to fake, and yet Israel is pretty good at keeping itself Jewish.

    Replies: @Cwhatfuture, @Steve Sailer, @sprfls, @Karl, @Lugash, @shk12344

    And in America, we allow American born foreign spies and their foreign born spy husbands to emigrate to the United States, after kidnapping people on foreign soil:

    http://www.sptimes.com/2004/03/21/Worldandnation/The_spy___and_the_man.shtml

  138. @NOTA
    @Kevin O'Keeffe

    So, how'd the emperor pronounce it? I assume not all that close to the English pronunciation, but I really don't know.

    Replies: @Richard S, @Glossy

    I would guess that the ancient pronunciation was Yoolian.

    • Replies: @Romanian
    @Glossy

    It was. I mean it. I did two years of Latin in school.

  139. @nglaer
    @Whiskey

    Instapundit here references the Washington Post Sept 18, 2001 referring to tailgate viewing parties in Jersey watching and celebrating the Twin Towers collapse. Referencing Muslims.

    Muslims around the nation celebrated and danced in the streets, which was reported, just barely, at the time.

    Trump was/is correct.


    Thank you Whiskey. Am not usually on your ideological wavelength. This, (or instapundit's) is an important factoid. My optimism is restored.

    Replies: @gcochran

    It never happened, not in the US. Whiskey is never correct.

    • Replies: @James Kabala
    @gcochran

    I think people have forgotten how raw emotions (understandably) were on 9/11. If there had really been a huge crowd of thousands cheering the attacks in public, the result would have been a battle in the streets between them and non-Muslims. Especially in the New York metropolitan area! A small group or a single individual might well have ended up outright lynched. Who knows what might have gone on behind closed doors, but huge demonstrations in public could not have happened without consequences.

    Replies: @gcochran

  140. @Ron Unz
    Well, I can't remember the exact details, but about a month after 9/11, an Israeli military officer and a local Jewish associate were caught red-handed sneaking explosives and guns into the Mexican Parliament building, a story which immediately produced banner headlines in some of the leading Mexican newspapers but strangely enough was scarcely reported in the U.S. Under strong diplomatic pressure, both suspects were eventually deported back to Israel, just like all the ones caught in the NYC area around 9/11.

    A few years earlier, that Haim Saban Israeli fellow had bought the Univision television network, and perhaps if things had turned out a bit differently, horrific scenes of the destruction of the Mexican parliament by apparent "Arab terrorists" would have been broadcast 24/7 into every Hispanic home in America for the next twelve months.

    In attempting to extract reality from our imperfect media, it's always important to consider the distortioning effects of probable skew and adjust accordingly...

    Replies: @Boomstick

    There were two men found with one Glock 9mm inside the Mexican parliament building. The only mentions of explosives I can find are on crazed conspiracy sites.

    http://archivo.eluniversal.com.mx/nacion/68324.html

    The man had a license to carry a concealed weapon and was a security guard. It’s easy to forget you’re wearing a pistol and accidentally go into restricted areas.

    • Replies: @Ron Unz
    @Boomstick


    There were two men found with one Glock 9mm inside the Mexican parliament building. The only mentions of explosives I can find are on crazed conspiracy sites.
     
    No, I don't think that's correct. The story was naturally huge in Mexico at the time and when I looked into the matter maybe a decade ago, at least some of the local newspaper accounts mentioned that the Israeli military guy had been caught carrying explosive devices into the Mexican parliament building, which is hardly the sort of detail I'd easily forget.

    Replies: @AnonymousCoward

  141. @Truth
    Uh Oh!...Part LXII!

    Be careful what you axe for.

    http://qz.com/558326/white-men-shot-several-people-at-a-black-lives-matter-rally-in-minneapolis/?utm_source=YPL

    Replies: @SPMoore8, @D. K., @D. K., @AnotherDad, @tbraton

    Truth, believe it or not, white people have rights to.

    BLM is protesting–the death of a serial criminal and girlfriend beater–on public property. Despite some BLM flack talking about “people who did not belong there”, white anti-pro-thuggery protesters *also* have the right to be there and protest the protesters.

    Unfortunately, most blacks (like a lot of leftists) can not fathom the concept of people being allow to disagree with them, so unsurprisingly BLM types try and chase these counter protesters off. And indeed apparently had them on the run.

    Wasn’t there, but i’ll say, i’d rather shoot than let a black mob (even a mob of two or three) catch me. Blacks readily assault whites (and each other). Once down they’ll kick and stomp you. You’re lucky if you don’t end up with serious injury, or being a vegetable, or dead.

    George Zimmerman would quite likely be a vegetable in some hospital if he hadn’t been packing when attacked by the thug Trayvon Martin, who was witnessed raining down blows “MMA sytle” and smacking Zimmerman’s head into the sidewalk.

    Here, we had this kid Kris Kime at Mardi Gras about 15 years back, who went to the assistance of a girl some black thugs were assaulting and had knocked down. For his trouble, some black thug whacked him on the head, knocking him down where upon a bunch of black thugs started kicking the crap outta him … while Seattle police–obeying the PC orders of their leftist political bosses–just stood around the sidelines watching.

    Whites who are going to be around blacks are smart to be armed. Especially if you’re in a “progressive” jurisdiction where PC is turning the police into useless timeservers while feral blacks run free. And if attacked they *should* fire. Hey, the state will no doubt try to railroad you–like they tried with Zimmerman. But better to end up in prison, then beaten and stomped dead like Kris Kime.

    ~~~
    Truth, i know you have a different take on the capabilities and behavior of your people. And that’s fine.

    The simple approach that works for your folks and my folks–separation. Your people run your affairs–have the level of policing and tolerate the level of violence that your people desire. And my people run our affairs and have the level of policing and intolerance for thuggery and violence that we find allows for civilized life. Win-win.

    • Replies: @Truth
    @AnotherDad


    The simple approach that works for your folks and my folks–separation. Your people run your affairs–have the level of policing and tolerate the level of violence that your people desire.
     
    Cool, what states are you giving us? I like California.

    Replies: @ATate

  142. Anonymous • Disclaimer says:

    I think Trump was just exaggerating in his salesman way to excite the crowds rather than misremembering anything. His comment was that he saw thousands of Muslims cheering in New Jersey with his own eyes, which was to suggest that he personally witnessed it rather than just seeing it on the news. It’s probably not a huge presumption to think that there were Muslims in New Jersey and elsewhere in the US that applauded the 9/11 attacks, and he was probably just exaggerating this fact to make a popular political speech.

  143. @D. K.
    @AnotherDad

    "Back in 1986, Vanunu, a junior technician at the Dimona nuclear reactor, gave Israel’s nuclear secrets to The Sunday Times, claiming he did so out of opposition to weapons of mass destruction."

    How is that "treason?" It is just "whistle-blowing"-- much the same as Snowden's, more recently. Except, of course, that Vanunu's information merely confirmed what was already widely assumed, whereas much of what Snowden has revealed, thus far, has shocked both citizens, politicians and foreign leaders. "Treason" is defined as fighting for, or otherwise adhering to, an "enemy"-- which does not include the "free press" in an allied nation!

    Replies: @AnotherDad, @Stan D Mute

    much of what Snowden has revealed, thus far, has shocked both citizens, politicians and foreign leaders.

    Anyone “shocked” by Snowden’s stories was a terribly naive fool. We knew long before Snowden that NSA was building a shiny new $2 billion data center in Utah and that they already operated more DC space than google. We’ve known for a long time that uttering a certain sequence of words on your telephone will yield a knock on your door within hours. And we knew of Harris’ Stingray, Triggerfish, and Kingfish type devices since the advent of cell phones. Obviously the surveillance tech has kept up with the consumer tech. All Snowden did was confirm what we already “knew” (deduced).

  144. @WhatEvvs
    OT, the front page of the NYT has the shooting of 5 people at a Black Lives Matter rally. No word on the 16 shot at the hippity hop party in New Orleans.

    Replies: @TangoMan, @Hippopotamusdrome

    Here is the BBC reporting the same story. Notice how they discard the reporting rule of not mentioning the race of the shooters.

    Three white men wearing masks have shot five people protesting about the fatal police shooting of a black man in Minneapolis, say witnesses.

    • Replies: @Steve Austen
    @TangoMan

    And getting the race of Barack's would be sons completely wrong.

  145. @Boomstick
    @Kevin O'Keeffe

    When I had a small office in an office park I used to get regular cold calls from "art salesmen." Their schtick was to say that they had some art that had been ordered by someone else in the building but that they had since moved out. Rather than take the art back they said they'd cut a deal and give it to me for a rock bottom price.

    They were just selling cheap knockoff Ansel Adams reproductions, obviously without paying any licensing fees. The story was about cancelled orders was just part of the sales pitch. There are plenty of similar scams, including door-to-door meat salesmen. One of the most famous is the "white box speaker" sales guys. They'll cadge you in parking lots and tell you they were making a delivery on expensive stereo speakers, but the deal fell through. Rather than take them back they'll sell you these top-flight speakers for a low, low price. The speakers are actually crap and the price is inflated, but the story helps make the sale.

    If the "Israeli art students" were actually spies I'd expect them to conceal their foreign extraction. From an information gathering standpoint it's a negative to volunteer that information, but probably a positive for making sales of overpriced art.

    Replies: @greysquirrell, @Kevin O'Keeffe, @G Pinfold

    I had that happen to me once; a Semi truck pulled up into our subdividion and wanted to sell us some ‘high’ quality furniture that they were supposed to deliver but the buyer reneged and they couldn’t drive all the way back to some other State with it.

    How can this type of sales be effective? Most people are really averse to door to door salesman and will decline. Seems like a waste of time and money to cold call on people.

  146. @D. K.
    @AnotherDad

    There was plenty of Israeli malfeasance-- like their stealing American supplies of uranium from Pennsylvania!

    Replies: @AnotherDad

    There was plenty of Israeli malfeasance– like their stealing American supplies of uranium from Pennsylvania!

    I’m speaking about Vanunu from the perspective of Israel–of which he was a citizen and pledged a secrecy oath when he took his job.

    From the perspective of America, those responsible for the Apollo plant diversion–if there was a diversion; it’s still quite possible it was simply the most sloppily run, leakiest, uranium enrichment plant in the US–should have been brought to justice and executed.

  147. el topo [AKA "darryl revok"] says:
    @Ben Tzot-Abrit
    @Steve Sailer

    You are correct about this. Some Jews also don't grasp how much other Jews devote to this. After 40 years of marriage, my father's side of the family is still flabbergasted at how much energy my mother's side of the family spends on this.

    Replies: @el topo

    This is true. As a partial Jew, I have always been fascinated with the question of Jewishness and am able to view it from different angles, as it were. I also have an extremely keen Jewdar and am able to spot Jews and mischlings quite accurately.
    I have friends who are full Jews, however, who seem not at all interested in their Jewishness and completely downplay its significance, though they have many obviously Jewish traits (and typical liberal Jewish politics).

    • Replies: @SFG
    @el topo

    Funny. I guess I could say the same. How many Mischlingen who have gotten skeptical of the tribe are there here? I thought I was the only one, but it seems fairly common at the fringes of the alt-right.

  148. Anonymous • Disclaimer says:

    Steve’s gripping anecdote about his friend getting deprived of his shot at Tom Clancy-style bureaucratic glory, due to the punctilious nature of the feds, reminded me of the recent 60 Minutes story on security clearance for Snowden (and He-She Manning, and the spree killer of color at the Naval Yard). All of the details were fairly outrageous but in Snowden’s case, a CIA alert on him was circumvented when he wrote that his work there was “classified” (BTW, so far no smoking matza-ball there aside from the ethnic stripe of his libertarian reporter patron; but I’m confident the case will be cracked). Thus when you make your dark-matter speculations about the overly careful CIA (recently working Iraqi WMD tipsters in such technical niches as a German Burger King franchise) it’s a small relief at least to see your freely offered disclaimer of having no clue. Although it would be nice if you elucidated the off-the-cuff Ecstasy smuggling remark– the last big story on that in the Miami Herald didn’t seem to have a lot of Hebraic overtones at first glance, to a layman’s eyes.

    • Replies: @SPMoore8
    @Anonymous

    German Burger King franchise Do they serve their Whoppers on Kaiser rolls?

    Replies: @SFG, @Ozymandias

  149. @Romanian
    @Stan D Mute

    I'm a bit disappointed that SpaceX did not beat them to it. Blue Origin's stuff has been vaporware for some time and has engaged in some lame practices, like hiring SpaceX's people on propulsion and such after they had developed innovative tech (though, apparently, according to the Musk biography, his companies have a high turnover because he's hard to work with). The thing is that it was a bit of a lame attempt: the rocket reached space, not orbit, which requires much more energy and would have made the return much more difficult; the rocket is a lot smaller, because it's not meant to be usable, but a tech platform, while SpaceX attempts to land rockets after they have launched a payload. The near misses of SpaceX were thrilling in themselves, like the rocket falling just as it should have landed, but I appreciate what they were trying to do a bit more. Having just read the Musk biography that Tyler Cowen of MR recommended, I am convinced that I would not want to ever know him, except to discuss Mars a bit. Definitely not work for him. But he's the kind of person that gets things done, and SpaceX has accomplished more with less than Blue Origin. They stole the reusable rocket thunder in a cheap way, compared to how SpaceX was doing it. Yes, I'm a cheerleader. Still, at least things are finally moving. Maybe my children will have their flying cars and Mars bases.

    Replies: @Stan D Mute

    The near misses of SpaceX were thrilling in themselves, like the rocket falling just as it should have landed, but I appreciate what they were trying to do a bit more.

    But did Musk at least properly credit his (near) success to ¡Diversity! or like Bezos pretend it was all done by white folks whom we know “didn’t build this”?

    Maybe my children will have their flying cars and Mars bases.

    Yeah, you should probably set your hopes a bit lower. I’ll be happy if my kids aren’t forced to pay jizya and the country still has indoor plumbing.

    • Replies: @Romanian
    @Stan D Mute


    Yeah, you should probably set your hopes a bit lower. I’ll be happy if my kids aren’t forced to pay jizya and the country still has indoor plumbing.
     
    You made me laugh out loud. There should be a thread like that.

    Seriously, yeah, space. Lots of potential disappointments there, but people who lived through the optimism of the 1960s and 1970s would know that a lot better than I. I'm sure Musk's companies pay some indirect protection money in the form of caterers and the like to compensate for the lack of melanin on-staff.

    Replies: @bomag

  150. @Glossy
    @NOTA

    I would guess that the ancient pronunciation was Yoolian.

    Replies: @Romanian

    It was. I mean it. I did two years of Latin in school.

  151. @Stan D Mute
    @Romanian


    The near misses of SpaceX were thrilling in themselves, like the rocket falling just as it should have landed, but I appreciate what they were trying to do a bit more.
     
    But did Musk at least properly credit his (near) success to ¡Diversity! or like Bezos pretend it was all done by white folks whom we know "didn't build this"?

    Maybe my children will have their flying cars and Mars bases.
     
    Yeah, you should probably set your hopes a bit lower. I'll be happy if my kids aren't forced to pay jizya and the country still has indoor plumbing.

    Replies: @Romanian

    Yeah, you should probably set your hopes a bit lower. I’ll be happy if my kids aren’t forced to pay jizya and the country still has indoor plumbing.

    You made me laugh out loud. There should be a thread like that.

    Seriously, yeah, space. Lots of potential disappointments there, but people who lived through the optimism of the 1960s and 1970s would know that a lot better than I. I’m sure Musk’s companies pay some indirect protection money in the form of caterers and the like to compensate for the lack of melanin on-staff.

    • Replies: @bomag
    @Romanian

    Lots of potential disappointments there, but people who lived through the optimism of the 1960s and 1970s would know that a lot better than I.

    Pretty much the theme was that the gov't shouldn't countenance spending money on advancements in space while we had all these social problems on Earth, problems that will soon be solved if we could just spend more money on them.

    The social problems have shown themselves to be completely fractal, while our gov't, via the various iron laws of bureaucracy, Peter principles, mass wasting, and general increase in entropy; has become much less able to get things done.

    The advances in tech, helped greatly by the Moon missions etc., has now made the current private sector efforts possible. Let's hope it bears fruit.

    Replies: @Romanian

  152. I think this is another case where Trump’s big mouth comes out with something from the far corner of his brain.

    It seems to me that there’s two Donald Trumps: the sane one who’s often honest and quite right about things that people like him usually deny and the other one that’s off in la-la land somewhere. The bad thing is that it looks like sane Donald ends up believing his own BS a lot of the time.

    Anyway, for those who are interested, here’s links to two articles from nj.com that indicate that there were no cheering thousands in Jersey City or anywhere else in New Jersey, either.

    http://www.nj.com/politics/index.ssf/2015/11/trump_says_old_news_clip_shows_hes_owed_an_apology.html

    “Shai Goldstein, the former New Jersey regional director of the Anti-Defamation League, said it’s possible that Trump and others are confusing alleged cheering in New Jersey with celebrations that occurred in the West Bank on 9/11.

    “Nothing happened in Jersey City nor Paterson,” Goldstein told NJ Advance Media. “No one knew when the Twin Towers fell who was responsible and investigations by the ADL concluded there were no celebrations of any kind — none — in Paterson or any where else in New Jersey.”

    http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2015/11/star-ledger_coverage_of_nj_muslim_communities_in_t.html?hootPostID=68175e4af508e144b6be8fdc791a1f1b#incart_river_home

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @notsaying

    "the ADL concluded there were no celebrations of any kind — none — in Paterson or any where else in New Jersey.”

    Not what ABC News concluded.

    Replies: @notsaying

  153. Um. No. That’s not what Trump remembers. He’s lying. Anyone who doesn’t think he’s lying is lying to themself.

    Yes. There were celebrations in other parts of the world. But not in New Jersey. He can’t admit he’s wrong.

    Sign of bad character in a bad person.

    The article posted has little if anything to do with the current Trump controversy.

  154. @TangoMan
    @WhatEvvs

    Here is the BBC reporting the same story. Notice how they discard the reporting rule of not mentioning the race of the shooters.


    Three white men wearing masks have shot five people protesting about the fatal police shooting of a black man in Minneapolis, say witnesses.
     

    Replies: @Steve Austen

    And getting the race of Barack’s would be sons completely wrong.

  155. I doubt if this was terribly important incident, although I have to say I was surprised to see how seriously the FBI took it.

    they had a video camera set up to watch the first plane hit the tower

    than means they had advance knowledge

    and they were clearly celebrating the horror

    the imbeciles then went on Israeli television to explain that they were there to “document the event’

    that means that they knew it was going to happen, were Israeli intelligence and perhaps significantly, their bosses and higher-ups in the Israeli government didn’t think it was important to warn the Americans that this singularly evil crime event was about to happen

    Personally I consider that important, since we send billions of dollars to Israel every year, I think it’s rather ungrateful for them to take all that money and then cynically watch us being murdered with cameras rolling and then dancing and high-fiving at our loss, even if they do think that- USS Liberty like- it will cause us to kill their (myriad and well-earned) enemies for them.

    And then Bibi blurted out of the attacks that “they’re very good”, before amending it and considering the PR repercussions, to say something like ‘well, it’s good for Israel’, or some such thing

    one more reason I consider this a rather important incident is because of the way all our politicians, and especially the presidential candidates from both parties are always clamoring to demand that ‘Israel is our best ally ever!’ and ‘we can never do enough for Israel!’, it just seems a little unseemly when you consider how Israel treats the American tax payer and dances around as they’re horrifically slaughtered or dropping from the towers or dying slowly in the flames.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Rurik

    "they had a video camera set up to watch the first plane hit the tower"

    Do we know that? From what? This ABC News story begins with eyewitness Maria's account, who didn't start looking until after the first tower was hit. After a while she noticed the Israelis.

    Replies: @Rurik, @tanabear

  156. OT – Sweden chucks the towel in.

    http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/nov/24/sweden-asylum-seekers-refugees-policy-reversal

    “Sweden needs “respite” from the tens of thousands of refugees knocking at its door, the government has said, announcing tough measures to deter asylum seekers in a sharp reversal of its open-door policy towards people fleeing war and persecution.
    The country’s generous asylum regime would revert to the “EU minimum”, Sweden’s prime minister, Stefan Löfven, said on Tuesday, revealing that most refugees would receive only temporary residence permits from April.
    Identity checks would be imposed on all modes of transport, and the right to bring families to Sweden would be severely restricted, he said.”

    The Greens’ deputy prime minister, Åsa Romson, broke into tears as she announced the measures.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Anonymous Nephew

    Thanks, I'll post.

  157. @tanabear
    @Seth

    Seth: "The idea that these guys were up to anything in particular is absurd."

    If it was absurd then they wouldn't have been contained for 71 days and questioned about their activities on 09/11/2001 over and over again. They obviously had to arouse some sort of suspicion and stand out from other witnesses of the towers burning otherwise the police would not have been called. Urban Moving Systems/Company was apparently a front company for the Mossad. Three of the suspects were Mossad agents. This is very suspicious.

    But why were they so giddy and happy?

    From the FBI report: "...one of the males appeared to be taking still photographs and video of the other males with the WTC in the background. All of the males appeared to be jovial in that they smiled, hugged one another, and gave "high fives".

    "Film obtained from the 35mm camera of one of the detainees was later developed and processed by the Newark Division. The photos clearly corroborate [Blank's] statements in that the Israelis are visibly happy on nearly all of the photgraphs."

    Replies: @Seth

    Do you imagine that Mossad spies are so clumsily trained that they high-five each other and dance and smile in public when their mission comes off?

    You ask why they were happy. Who knows? Maybe they were just jerks.

    • Replies: @tanabear
    @Seth

    Well, a few of them were members of the Mossad and they were dancing, smiling and having a gay ole time. So you seem to have trouble accepting reality. It isn't important if they were well-trained. It is only important that the American media is.

  158. Hokie says:

    organized crime (e.g., the Ecstasy pill trade)

    Weird that you mention that. I was just reading about how a lot of the funds from Project Coast ended up being used by Wouter Basson t0 buy the chemical precursors to Ecstasy. The post-Apartheid government couldn’t figure out where the chemicals or money went, and somehow two biotech guys (Dr. Larry Ford and Pat Riley from Biofem in California) ended up dying. Nothing in there mentioned the Israelis though.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Hokie

    http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/israelis-at-center-of-ecstasy-drug-trade-1.13809

  159. I also have an extremely keen Jewdar and am able to spot Jews and mischlings quite accurately.

    Well, you must have the gene for it or a license to practice or something, because when I say stuff like this I’m condemned as an icky “ANTISEMITE!!!”

    Although it would be nice if you elucidated the off-the-cuff Ecstasy smuggling remark– the last big story on that in the Miami Herald didn’t seem to have a lot of Hebraic overtones at first glance, to a layman’s eyes.

    Israelis dominate ecstasy trade

  160. @Rurik

    I doubt if this was terribly important incident, although I have to say I was surprised to see how seriously the FBI took it.
     
    they had a video camera set up to watch the first plane hit the tower

    than means they had advance knowledge

    and they were clearly celebrating the horror

    the imbeciles then went on Israeli television to explain that they were there to "document the event'

    that means that they knew it was going to happen, were Israeli intelligence and perhaps significantly, their bosses and higher-ups in the Israeli government didn't think it was important to warn the Americans that this singularly evil crime event was about to happen

    Personally I consider that important, since we send billions of dollars to Israel every year, I think it's rather ungrateful for them to take all that money and then cynically watch us being murdered with cameras rolling and then dancing and high-fiving at our loss, even if they do think that- USS Liberty like- it will cause us to kill their (myriad and well-earned) enemies for them.

    And then Bibi blurted out of the attacks that "they're very good", before amending it and considering the PR repercussions, to say something like 'well, it's good for Israel', or some such thing

    one more reason I consider this a rather important incident is because of the way all our politicians, and especially the presidential candidates from both parties are always clamoring to demand that 'Israel is our best ally ever!' and 'we can never do enough for Israel!', it just seems a little unseemly when you consider how Israel treats the American tax payer and dances around as they're horrifically slaughtered or dropping from the towers or dying slowly in the flames.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    “they had a video camera set up to watch the first plane hit the tower”

    Do we know that? From what? This ABC News story begins with eyewitness Maria’s account, who didn’t start looking until after the first tower was hit. After a while she noticed the Israelis.

    • Replies: @Rurik
    @Steve Sailer

    They went on television and said they were there to "document the event". They had the camera set up and were seen celebrating after the FIRST plane hit.

    from a link:

    "Witnesses reported they had set cameras PRIOR to the first plane strike"

    here:

    https://wikispooks.com/wiki/9-11/Israel_did_it

    I can and will research it further if that is a significant point for you. I'd be happy to find out all I can.

    But what we do know is, as I've said, they had a camera set up when the first plane hit. (I don't have proof right now that it was filming at the moment, but since George Bush has stated publically that he too saw the first plane his the tower, we know there were several cameras watching).

    So, since they had a camera set up (presumably for the purpose of filming the event), and since they admitted that they were there to "document the event, it seems reasonable to assume that the camera was filming. No?

    , @tanabear
    @Steve Sailer

    Steve: "Do we know that? From what?"

    They started filming and photographing themselves right after the first plane hit the North Tower. At that point how did they know it was a terrorist attack? Most of the assumptions were that it was some kind of horrible accident. It wasn't until the second plane hit the South Tower that everyone became aware of a coordinated attack. So why so giddy over a random plane flying into a building? Also I wonder why we have never seen any of these photographs? Rhetorical question.

    Also from the FBI report: "'A former Urban Moving Systems employee later contacted the Newark Division with information indicating that he had quit his employment with Urban Moving Systems due to high amount of anti-American sentiment present among Urban's employees. The former employee stated that an Israeli employee of Urban had even once remarked, 'Give us twenty (20) years and we'll take over your media and destroy your country.'"

    p.s. And these are our allies.

  161. @Hokie

    organized crime (e.g., the Ecstasy pill trade)
     
    Weird that you mention that. I was just reading about how a lot of the funds from Project Coast ended up being used by Wouter Basson t0 buy the chemical precursors to Ecstasy. The post-Apartheid government couldn't figure out where the chemicals or money went, and somehow two biotech guys (Dr. Larry Ford and Pat Riley from Biofem in California) ended up dying. Nothing in there mentioned the Israelis though.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

  162. the same sort of way that Ireland verifies that one of your four grandparents was Irish, before giving you your Irish passport.

    No shit? I’ve got an Irish grandma. Do they have Apartheid there, too?

    Aw, I checked. “Irish grandparent” means a grandparent born in Ireland. Not the same at all.

  163. @Drakejax
    @cwhatfuture

    Don't confuse professional intelligence agents, who in Israel's case are very well vetted and trained, with the thousands of various contacts and assets they utilize. A German just got convicted for having been retained by the CIA; he worked as a mail handler for the German intelligence agency. The German was the asset, the actual "agents" worked in another country.

    Replies: @cwhatfuture

    The implication in several of the posts here is that very low level assets (the moving company illegals) would have had knowledge of a Mossad plot on 9/11. That is absurd. That would mean the Israeli intelligence agency would be staffed by idiots and that persons posting on this blog and various internet nuts would have uncovered the great secret. If the Mossad can penetrate Iran and kill Iranian nuclear scientists, which by all accounts they did, despite the scientists being under tight guard and despite the Iranians being aware the Israelis had every intention of killing them, no one on this blog has uncovered anything at all about the Mossad. Or maybe I am a secret Mossad Elks Club Masonic Temple Super “Shabbo Goy” – as someone here so eloquently put it.

    • Replies: @Rurik
    @cwhatfuture


    The implication in several of the posts here is that very low level assets (the moving company illegals) would have had knowledge of a Mossad plot on 9/11. That is absurd.
     
    speaking of foreknowledge of the attacks, did you know Al Franken wrote in his book that he was warned not to go to work at the WTC that day?

    One of the widely disseminated stories was that no Jews died in the collapse of the Trade Towers because they had received calls telling them not to go to work that day. To tell you the truth, I got the Jew call. I had an office in the Trade Center where I used to do most of my writing. The call came from former New York mayor Ed Koch. “Al,” he told me, “don’t go to work on the twenty-third day of Elul [September 11 – ed].”

    just Google it

    isn't that a curious phenomena? First that it was widely enough known that people were warning (certain) other people about it, and then that he'd write such a thing in a book!

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @SFG, @Mr. Anon, @This Is Our Home

  164. Steve, this is a ridiculous Larry David CYI episode.
    http://gorillavid.in/tmvxajjvpqzl
    He accuses the LA weatherman of predicting rain so people change plans and the weatherman has the course wide open the next day when it is sunny.

    Here is the with links to the episodes. My wife is hooked on the show.
    http://thewatchseries.to/serie/curb_your_enthusiasm

  165. Some of this may be because of a photo Instapundit posted years ago of some yuppies on a roof looking blase as they looked on as the WTC burned.

    Another odd I thing I saw on the local news. I forget how long it was after, maybe 3-4 hours. A reporter was reporting on the incident from what he said was the closest he could get to the site while not interfering in the rescue, 20-30 blocks I remember. I saw a woman jogging behind him.

  166. @notsaying
    I think this is another case where Trump's big mouth comes out with something from the far corner of his brain.

    It seems to me that there's two Donald Trumps: the sane one who's often honest and quite right about things that people like him usually deny and the other one that's off in la-la land somewhere. The bad thing is that it looks like sane Donald ends up believing his own BS a lot of the time.

    Anyway, for those who are interested, here's links to two articles from nj.com that indicate that there were no cheering thousands in Jersey City or anywhere else in New Jersey, either.

    http://www.nj.com/politics/index.ssf/2015/11/trump_says_old_news_clip_shows_hes_owed_an_apology.html

    "Shai Goldstein, the former New Jersey regional director of the Anti-Defamation League, said it's possible that Trump and others are confusing alleged cheering in New Jersey with celebrations that occurred in the West Bank on 9/11.

    "Nothing happened in Jersey City nor Paterson," Goldstein told NJ Advance Media. "No one knew when the Twin Towers fell who was responsible and investigations by the ADL concluded there were no celebrations of any kind — none — in Paterson or any where else in New Jersey."

    http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2015/11/star-ledger_coverage_of_nj_muslim_communities_in_t.html?hootPostID=68175e4af508e144b6be8fdc791a1f1b#incart_river_home

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    “the ADL concluded there were no celebrations of any kind — none — in Paterson or any where else in New Jersey.”

    Not what ABC News concluded.

    • Replies: @notsaying
    @Steve Sailer

    If we are going to argue this in terms of what Donald Trump could have seen on TV or in person or what the ADL could have used as evidence that proved thousands cheered, I don't think we can count the ABC News story, can we?

    The experience of the eyewitness Maria was not captured by a video or broadcast on TV and the ABC News story was about just five people.

    Did I miss something?

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

  167. @Dave Pinsen
    @sprfls

    I would think Israel's laxity regarding that post-Soviet wave was intentional. Israel's leaders likely saw it as a demographic bulwark against Arabs as well as against Mizrahi Jews.

    Replies: @AnotherDad, @Steve Sailer

    Ariel Sharon was a really Slavic-looking guy. I can’t remember if one of his parents came from a Russian group that converted to Judaism in Russia.

    • Replies: @kaganovitch
    @Steve Sailer

    Sharon's mother is from a Subbotnik family

  168. @gcochran
    @nglaer

    It never happened, not in the US. Whiskey is never correct.

    Replies: @James Kabala

    I think people have forgotten how raw emotions (understandably) were on 9/11. If there had really been a huge crowd of thousands cheering the attacks in public, the result would have been a battle in the streets between them and non-Muslims. Especially in the New York metropolitan area! A small group or a single individual might well have ended up outright lynched. Who knows what might have gone on behind closed doors, but huge demonstrations in public could not have happened without consequences.

    • Agree: NOTA
    • Replies: @gcochran
    @James Kabala

    Of course.

  169. @Steve Sailer
    @Rurik

    "they had a video camera set up to watch the first plane hit the tower"

    Do we know that? From what? This ABC News story begins with eyewitness Maria's account, who didn't start looking until after the first tower was hit. After a while she noticed the Israelis.

    Replies: @Rurik, @tanabear

    They went on television and said they were there to “document the event”. They had the camera set up and were seen celebrating after the FIRST plane hit.

    from a link:

    “Witnesses reported they had set cameras PRIOR to the first plane strike”

    here:

    https://wikispooks.com/wiki/9-11/Israel_did_it

    I can and will research it further if that is a significant point for you. I’d be happy to find out all I can.

    But what we do know is, as I’ve said, they had a camera set up when the first plane hit. (I don’t have proof right now that it was filming at the moment, but since George Bush has stated publically that he too saw the first plane his the tower, we know there were several cameras watching).

    So, since they had a camera set up (presumably for the purpose of filming the event), and since they admitted that they were there to “document the event, it seems reasonable to assume that the camera was filming. No?

  170. OT

    A brisk response in the London Telegraph to a Muslim Uber driver who berated an ageing actress, so good.

    But this paragraph truly shocked me: “Astonishingly, according to one Belgian official speaking yesterday on Radio 4, the population of Brussels, the capital of Europe, is 40 per cent Muslim. Shell-shocked politicians now admit there has been perilously little integration. ”

    Did the writer not know? Did she not read the papers? Is this going to be the excuse then, we didn’t know?

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/islamic-state/12014689/Frances-Barber-is-right-Islamic-extremism-is-making-London-unrecognisable.html

  171. @Boomstick
    @Kevin O'Keeffe

    When I had a small office in an office park I used to get regular cold calls from "art salesmen." Their schtick was to say that they had some art that had been ordered by someone else in the building but that they had since moved out. Rather than take the art back they said they'd cut a deal and give it to me for a rock bottom price.

    They were just selling cheap knockoff Ansel Adams reproductions, obviously without paying any licensing fees. The story was about cancelled orders was just part of the sales pitch. There are plenty of similar scams, including door-to-door meat salesmen. One of the most famous is the "white box speaker" sales guys. They'll cadge you in parking lots and tell you they were making a delivery on expensive stereo speakers, but the deal fell through. Rather than take them back they'll sell you these top-flight speakers for a low, low price. The speakers are actually crap and the price is inflated, but the story helps make the sale.

    If the "Israeli art students" were actually spies I'd expect them to conceal their foreign extraction. From an information gathering standpoint it's a negative to volunteer that information, but probably a positive for making sales of overpriced art.

    Replies: @greysquirrell, @Kevin O'Keeffe, @G Pinfold

    When I had a small office in an office park I used to get regular cold calls from “art salesmen.” Their schtick was to say that they had some art that had been ordered by someone else in the building but that they had since moved out. Rather than take the art back they said they’d cut a deal and give it to me for a rock bottom price.

    They were just selling cheap knockoff Ansel Adams reproductions, obviously without paying any licensing fees. The story was about cancelled orders was just part of the sales pitch. There are plenty of similar scams, including door-to-door meat salesmen. One of the most famous is the “white box speaker” sales guys. They’ll cadge you in parking lots and tell you they were making a delivery on expensive stereo speakers, but the deal fell through. Rather than take them back they’ll sell you these top-flight speakers for a low, low price. The speakers are actually crap and the price is inflated, but the story helps make the sale.

    If the “Israeli art students” were actually spies I’d expect them to conceal their foreign extraction. From an information gathering standpoint it’s a negative to volunteer that information, but probably a positive for making sales of overpriced art.

    OK, but that doesn’t really explain why they followed my dad and I all over Santa Clara County for a week or two, does it? How many times could the two of us run into them all over various “Silicon Valley” locales, before it stopped being “a coincidence?”

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Kevin O'Keeffe

    "How many times could the two of us run into them all over various “Silicon Valley” locales, before it stopped being “a coincidence?”

    Right. I live in a suburban area of similar density and size to Silicon Valley, the San Fernando Valley, and I almost never run into the same individuals multiple times in a month.

    Perhaps the Israeli Art Students thing was a traditional Israeli-kids-abroad mild scam that Israeli intelligence (or economic espionage guys) occasionally piggybacked off to target high value sites?

  172. This is from a Fox News link

    at the bottom

    The New York Times reported Thursday that a group of five men had set up video cameras aimed at the Twin Towers prior to the attack on Tuesday, and were seen congratulating one another afterwards.

    my emphasis

    http://www.foxnews.com/story/2001/09/14/one-arrested-others-detained-at-ny-airports.html

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Rurik

    Thanks, now can you find the NYT article the Fox article is citing?

    I'm not saying they got it wrong -- like I said, in reading this old article from ABC News, I was surprised to learn how serious the FBI was about interrogating these guys, like 40 days in solitary.

    Replies: @Rurik, @This Is Our Home

  173. @NOTA
    @Robert Hume

    Even if the Israelis knew ahead of time, why would they send people in the field who knew ahead of time, and put them in a position to be arrested and questioned by the FBI?

    Replies: @cwhatfuture

    Why would Israelis use illegals working as movers to record such an event and celebrate it publicly? Because according to the sleuths on this board, not only are the Israeli intelligence agencies dumb, they verge on the retarded.

    • Replies: @Zed, Lord of the Brutals
    @cwhatfuture

    You want a realistic depiction of the IC? Watch the movie "Spies Like Us" and "Office Space."

  174. @Truth
    Uh Oh!...Part LXII!

    Be careful what you axe for.

    http://qz.com/558326/white-men-shot-several-people-at-a-black-lives-matter-rally-in-minneapolis/?utm_source=YPL

    Replies: @SPMoore8, @D. K., @D. K., @AnotherDad, @tbraton

    “Uh Oh!…Part LXII!”

    I hate to inform you, but you are in clear violation of the NFL’s exclusive license from the Romans to use Roman numerals. Pay up!

  175. Heard on NPR today (paraphrasing): “Muslims are the main victims of ISIS, they’re the main group battling ISIS, and now they’re the people being blamed for ISIS.”

    Yeah, well, that’s because ISIS is Muslim, you jackasses. Perhaps more to the point, the people victimized by ISIS and the people fighting ISIS are far less Muslim than ISIS is. These people have their (stupid) rhetoric well-honed from the better part of a century spent whitewashing blacks.

    “the ADL concluded there were no celebrations of any kind — none — in Paterson or any where else in New Jersey.”

    Well, I guess that makes everything all white then, doesn’t it?

    The implication in several of the posts here is that very low level assets (the moving company illegals) would have had knowledge of a Mossad plot on 9/11. That is absurd.

    Dunno. Take it up with the people who made those posts. The fact I am stating is that there was speculation in the wake of 9/11 that the Mossad agents were tracking terrorists in America and knew attacks were imminent.

    Or maybe I am a secret Mossad Elks Club Masonic Temple Super “Shabbo Goy” – as someone here so eloquently put it.

    The famous Jewish comedic genius is on display, I suppose.

    • Replies: @Cwhatfuture
    @Svigor

    Yes, you supposed right on that one point. On all the rest you supposed wrong.

  176. @Rurik
    This is from a Fox News link

    at the bottom

    The New York Times reported Thursday that a group of five men had set up video cameras aimed at the Twin Towers prior to the attack on Tuesday, and were seen congratulating one another afterwards.

    my emphasis

    http://www.foxnews.com/story/2001/09/14/one-arrested-others-detained-at-ny-airports.html

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    Thanks, now can you find the NYT article the Fox article is citing?

    I’m not saying they got it wrong — like I said, in reading this old article from ABC News, I was surprised to learn how serious the FBI was about interrogating these guys, like 40 days in solitary.

    • Replies: @Rurik
    @Steve Sailer

    I tried Steve..

    seems to be 'memory holed', but if that one detail would make a difference to the narrative for you, I'll still find what I can.

    I notice you didn't consider my little blurt about how George Bush said publically (and on camera) that he saw the first plane hit WTC tower- curious. Did you know that? Does it matter to your mind if he said it or even if he did see it?

    I don't know where you stand on the whole 911 thing. A lot of people consider it prudent to not care too much. Perhaps it is.

    On a semi-related note Carl Cameron of Fox News did a story on Israeli "art student' spies rounded up after 911

    'evidence linking these Israelis to 9-11 is classified. I cannot tell you about evidence that has been gathered. It's classified information.'


    http://www.salon.com/2002/05/07/students/

    http://www.antiwar.com/justin/j030802.html

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    , @This Is Our Home
    @Steve Sailer


    Thanks, now can you find the NYT article the Fox article is citing?

    I’m not saying they got it wrong — like I said, in reading this old article from ABC News, I was surprised to learn how serious the FBI was about interrogating these guys, like 40 days in solitary
     
    I have found the New York Time article quoted here: http://www.911myths.com/index.php/Dancing_Israelis

    It helpfully comes with a lot of other information that makes this all look silly. Not that a theory like this needs to be made to look sillier.

    If I needed to document 9/11, having planned it. I would set up a camera from inside a closed apartment window and leave it set up. I certainly wouldn't send five Israeli bums to party on down in a very visible location with money in a sock...indeed I wouldn't even document it, as the rest of the world would do that for me, and what would I gain?

    I especially wouldn't have my hobo spies go on television and admit to it!

    The 9/11 truth movement is a cancer on alternative politics in the West. It sucks the life out of any feasible movement and slurs all of us by association. Donald Trump avoids this slur because he never gives succour to it and he obviously is not part of it, even if the insaniacs somehow believe that he is secretly messaging them. The 9/11 'theory' can only be believed by those who have never organised anything even as big as a bake sale...

    This means that not only is the message polluted but because the message is now largely the messenger, our message is associated with a toxic mixture of self-aggrandising liars and the obviously crazy.

    You should not ban these guys, but please do not entertain them.

    God, I wish I might recommend your blog to others but some things are just too hard to recover from being associated with. Unz.com is now not only the site for opinions rendered taboo by the PC zeitgeist but also for opinions so utterly nuts that the zeitgeist rejects them too; can we not save it for infowars.com or some other place that has been telling the US population that they'll be in FEMA camps tomorrow for the past 15 years?

    Courses of action could include:

    1. A mirror site with no comments; which is technically easy.

    2. A mirror site with conspiracy nonsense comments moderated out; which would take more time but would be more useful.

    3. You address this type of thinking in your blog posts; which would cover a generally interesting topic but may distract you from bigger things. Still, you have greater experience of this type of thinking than the majority of public intellectuals.

    Replies: @Rurik, @Ron Unz

  177. @Steve Sailer
    @notsaying

    "the ADL concluded there were no celebrations of any kind — none — in Paterson or any where else in New Jersey.”

    Not what ABC News concluded.

    Replies: @notsaying

    If we are going to argue this in terms of what Donald Trump could have seen on TV or in person or what the ADL could have used as evidence that proved thousands cheered, I don’t think we can count the ABC News story, can we?

    The experience of the eyewitness Maria was not captured by a video or broadcast on TV and the ABC News story was about just five people.

    Did I miss something?

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @notsaying

    The Israelis' lawyer admitted they were acting suspiciously and that Maria's reactions were reasonable.

    The FBI took the suspicions seriously.

  178. @Kevin O'Keeffe
    @Boomstick

    "When I had a small office in an office park I used to get regular cold calls from “art salesmen.” Their schtick was to say that they had some art that had been ordered by someone else in the building but that they had since moved out. Rather than take the art back they said they’d cut a deal and give it to me for a rock bottom price.

    They were just selling cheap knockoff Ansel Adams reproductions, obviously without paying any licensing fees. The story was about cancelled orders was just part of the sales pitch. There are plenty of similar scams, including door-to-door meat salesmen. One of the most famous is the “white box speaker” sales guys. They’ll cadge you in parking lots and tell you they were making a delivery on expensive stereo speakers, but the deal fell through. Rather than take them back they’ll sell you these top-flight speakers for a low, low price. The speakers are actually crap and the price is inflated, but the story helps make the sale.

    If the “Israeli art students” were actually spies I’d expect them to conceal their foreign extraction. From an information gathering standpoint it’s a negative to volunteer that information, but probably a positive for making sales of overpriced art."

    OK, but that doesn't really explain why they followed my dad and I all over Santa Clara County for a week or two, does it? How many times could the two of us run into them all over various "Silicon Valley" locales, before it stopped being "a coincidence?"

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    “How many times could the two of us run into them all over various “Silicon Valley” locales, before it stopped being “a coincidence?”

    Right. I live in a suburban area of similar density and size to Silicon Valley, the San Fernando Valley, and I almost never run into the same individuals multiple times in a month.

    Perhaps the Israeli Art Students thing was a traditional Israeli-kids-abroad mild scam that Israeli intelligence (or economic espionage guys) occasionally piggybacked off to target high value sites?

  179. @notsaying
    @Steve Sailer

    If we are going to argue this in terms of what Donald Trump could have seen on TV or in person or what the ADL could have used as evidence that proved thousands cheered, I don't think we can count the ABC News story, can we?

    The experience of the eyewitness Maria was not captured by a video or broadcast on TV and the ABC News story was about just five people.

    Did I miss something?

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    The Israelis’ lawyer admitted they were acting suspiciously and that Maria’s reactions were reasonable.

    The FBI took the suspicions seriously.

  180. @Boomstick
    @Kevin O'Keeffe

    When I had a small office in an office park I used to get regular cold calls from "art salesmen." Their schtick was to say that they had some art that had been ordered by someone else in the building but that they had since moved out. Rather than take the art back they said they'd cut a deal and give it to me for a rock bottom price.

    They were just selling cheap knockoff Ansel Adams reproductions, obviously without paying any licensing fees. The story was about cancelled orders was just part of the sales pitch. There are plenty of similar scams, including door-to-door meat salesmen. One of the most famous is the "white box speaker" sales guys. They'll cadge you in parking lots and tell you they were making a delivery on expensive stereo speakers, but the deal fell through. Rather than take them back they'll sell you these top-flight speakers for a low, low price. The speakers are actually crap and the price is inflated, but the story helps make the sale.

    If the "Israeli art students" were actually spies I'd expect them to conceal their foreign extraction. From an information gathering standpoint it's a negative to volunteer that information, but probably a positive for making sales of overpriced art.

    Replies: @greysquirrell, @Kevin O'Keeffe, @G Pinfold

    The scam works on greed, so it’s very effective. The simplest is to imply that the goods are ‘dodgy’. So for example: ‘A bottle of Chanel Number 5 for a fiver, but better make it quick. I can’t hang around, if you know what I mean?’ Often an insider makes the first purchase, setting off the marks. Of course, the sting is that the goods are actually dodgy; not stolen, but 2 dollar knock-offs. As with all these schemes, its hard to catch someone twice, so they rely on fresh meat. But as PT Barnum said…

    BTW, as as non-Israeli student, I sold ‘original oil paintings’ door to door for a guy named Friedman. I was never equipped with a Minox camera or anything, but then I never made Salesman-of-the-Week either, so who knows?

  181. @Steve Sailer
    @Dave Pinsen

    Ariel Sharon was a really Slavic-looking guy. I can't remember if one of his parents came from a Russian group that converted to Judaism in Russia.

    Replies: @kaganovitch

    Sharon’s mother is from a Subbotnik family

  182. @Anonymous
    Steve's gripping anecdote about his friend getting deprived of his shot at Tom Clancy-style bureaucratic glory, due to the punctilious nature of the feds, reminded me of the recent 60 Minutes story on security clearance for Snowden (and He-She Manning, and the spree killer of color at the Naval Yard). All of the details were fairly outrageous but in Snowden's case, a CIA alert on him was circumvented when he wrote that his work there was "classified" (BTW, so far no smoking matza-ball there aside from the ethnic stripe of his libertarian reporter patron; but I'm confident the case will be cracked). Thus when you make your dark-matter speculations about the overly careful CIA (recently working Iraqi WMD tipsters in such technical niches as a German Burger King franchise) it's a small relief at least to see your freely offered disclaimer of having no clue. Although it would be nice if you elucidated the off-the-cuff Ecstasy smuggling remark-- the last big story on that in the Miami Herald didn't seem to have a lot of Hebraic overtones at first glance, to a layman's eyes.

    Replies: @SPMoore8

    German Burger King franchise Do they serve their Whoppers on Kaiser rolls?

    • Replies: @SFG
    @SPMoore8

    Nein, but all ze burger patties are exactly 1 kg, nicht wahr?

    , @Ozymandias
    @SPMoore8

    "German Burger King franchise Do they serve their Whoppers on Kaiser rolls?"

    They're available on the local menu in Hamburg.

    @tbraton
    There's a photo out there somewhere showing the base of #7 before it fell. The rubble field from the collapsed tower destroyed about a third of 7's footprint, and after hours of uncontrolled burning it was expected to fall. Nothing unusual about it. And you know, if you wanted to take down a tower, recruiting Islamic fundamentalists to fly a plane into it is a much better plan than a surreptitious demolition. The initial explosion will blow the fire proofing off, and the resulting fire is more than hot enough to weaken the structure (ignoring any insane arguments about "melting point").

    Replies: @SPMoore8

  183. Though Israel is a famously fractious society, Israelis tend to agree on one thing: Their strongest supporters are an inherently dupable people.

    “Most Israelis think Americans are pro-Israel and we can sell them anything, especially mud from the Dead Sea,” said David Lifshitz, the lead writer for the Israeli comedy show “Eretz Nehederet,” or “Wonderful Land.”

    “Or — just regular mud with a ‘Dead Sea’ sticker on it.”

    Read more: http://forward.com/news/israel/216074/what-do-israelis-think-about-americans-start-with/#ixzz3sScmalQk

  184. @Richard S
    @NOTA

    Something like "Guy-uz Yule-lee-uz Kae-sar"; but then technically he was never emperor :)

    Replies: @kaganovitch, @ben tillman

    It is Julian Castro we are referring to, as in the Emperor Julian the Apostate not Julius

  185. @Steve Sailer
    @Rurik

    Thanks, now can you find the NYT article the Fox article is citing?

    I'm not saying they got it wrong -- like I said, in reading this old article from ABC News, I was surprised to learn how serious the FBI was about interrogating these guys, like 40 days in solitary.

    Replies: @Rurik, @This Is Our Home

    I tried Steve..

    seems to be ‘memory holed’, but if that one detail would make a difference to the narrative for you, I’ll still find what I can.

    I notice you didn’t consider my little blurt about how George Bush said publically (and on camera) that he saw the first plane hit WTC tower- curious. Did you know that? Does it matter to your mind if he said it or even if he did see it?

    I don’t know where you stand on the whole 911 thing. A lot of people consider it prudent to not care too much. Perhaps it is.

    On a semi-related note Carl Cameron of Fox News did a story on Israeli “art student’ spies rounded up after 911

    ‘evidence linking these Israelis to 9-11 is classified. I cannot tell you about evidence that has been gathered. It’s classified information.’

    http://www.salon.com/2002/05/07/students/

    http://www.antiwar.com/justin/j030802.html

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Rurik

    "I notice you didn’t consider my little blurt about how George Bush said publically (and on camera) that he saw the first plane hit WTC tower- curious. Did you know that? Does it matter to your mind if he said it or even if he did see it?"

    And what is so odd about that?

    "I don’t know where you stand on the whole 911 thing. A lot of people consider it prudent to not care too much. Perhaps it is. "

    A lot of people consider it prudent not to indulge in the kind of insanity that has largely come to characterizes the "Truther" movement.

    Replies: @Rurik

  186. It just occurred to me what Donald Trump remembers seeing and confused with thousands of Muslims in New Jersey cheering the collapse of the Twin Towers was actually seeing thousands of blacks across the country cheering the acquittal of O.J. Simpson. Who could forget that display of civic virtue, a large segment of the U.S. population actually cheering the acquittal of a brutal murderer? Oh, that’s right, the two victims were white. Nothing to get excited about.

  187. @Karl
    @sprfls

    >> Who said they do a good job?

    Ever since the 1750's (first publication of a Hebrew-language mathematics school-text), nationalistic Zionism has been almost completely led by non-religious Jews.

    It is easily possible to paint the picture that "Judaism" as a stand-alone, organized "religion", didn't really exist until after the Roman destruction of the Second Temple. Hebrew kings - up to & including Herod - never (to my memory of the bible) tried to dual-hat themselves as a High Priest. Actually, quite a few of them used tax monies to support pagan shrines. The municipality of Jerusalem still gives away free Christmas trees every year. In fact, it's going to happen in a coupla weeks.


    Even deep within the bowels of the Temple bureaucracy itself, the King always had total control of crowd-control and even liturgical arrangements. 1 Chronicles 25. Kinda like mosques nowadays in the Gulf states?

    Replies: @kaganovitch

    “Hebrew kings – up to & including Herod – never (to my memory of the bible) tried to dual-hat themselves as a High Priest. ”

    Your memory is off fwiw. Pretty much the entire hasmonean dynasty was dual hat . Herod didn’t try it because he was unfit for priestly caste due to ancestry.

  188. @James Kabala
    @gcochran

    I think people have forgotten how raw emotions (understandably) were on 9/11. If there had really been a huge crowd of thousands cheering the attacks in public, the result would have been a battle in the streets between them and non-Muslims. Especially in the New York metropolitan area! A small group or a single individual might well have ended up outright lynched. Who knows what might have gone on behind closed doors, but huge demonstrations in public could not have happened without consequences.

    Replies: @gcochran

    Of course.

  189. @cwhatfuture
    @Drakejax

    The implication in several of the posts here is that very low level assets (the moving company illegals) would have had knowledge of a Mossad plot on 9/11. That is absurd. That would mean the Israeli intelligence agency would be staffed by idiots and that persons posting on this blog and various internet nuts would have uncovered the great secret. If the Mossad can penetrate Iran and kill Iranian nuclear scientists, which by all accounts they did, despite the scientists being under tight guard and despite the Iranians being aware the Israelis had every intention of killing them, no one on this blog has uncovered anything at all about the Mossad. Or maybe I am a secret Mossad Elks Club Masonic Temple Super "Shabbo Goy" - as someone here so eloquently put it.

    Replies: @Rurik

    The implication in several of the posts here is that very low level assets (the moving company illegals) would have had knowledge of a Mossad plot on 9/11. That is absurd.

    speaking of foreknowledge of the attacks, did you know Al Franken wrote in his book that he was warned not to go to work at the WTC that day?

    One of the widely disseminated stories was that no Jews died in the collapse of the Trade Towers because they had received calls telling them not to go to work that day. To tell you the truth, I got the Jew call. I had an office in the Trade Center where I used to do most of my writing. The call came from former New York mayor Ed Koch. “Al,” he told me, “don’t go to work on the twenty-third day of Elul [September 11 – ed].”

    just Google it

    isn’t that a curious phenomena? First that it was widely enough known that people were warning (certain) other people about it, and then that he’d write such a thing in a book!

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Rurik

    But Stuart Smiley didn't get the call so he died tragically on 9/11, which is why you never see him around anymore.

    Replies: @James Kabala, @Rurik

    , @SFG
    @Rurik

    It was probably a joke. He is a comedian, after all.

    I actually thought Stuart Smalley was a pretty good sendup of therapy culture. If you lived in New York in the 80s and 90s, you heard that stuff all the time.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    , @Mr. Anon
    @Rurik

    "...........speaking of foreknowledge of the attacks, did you know Al Franken wrote in his book that he was warned not to go to work at the WTC that day?"

    It was a joke. He often used to make them - he was a comedian.

    , @This Is Our Home
    @Rurik

    Um...he was joking. He called it 'the Jew call.' I Googled it and lots of site are holding it up as proof of something nefarious. Lots of sites are clearly written by idiots.

    Replies: @AnonymousCoward, @D. K.

  190. @Seth
    @tanabear

    Do you imagine that Mossad spies are so clumsily trained that they high-five each other and dance and smile in public when their mission comes off?

    You ask why they were happy. Who knows? Maybe they were just jerks.

    Replies: @tanabear

    Well, a few of them were members of the Mossad and they were dancing, smiling and having a gay ole time. So you seem to have trouble accepting reality. It isn’t important if they were well-trained. It is only important that the American media is.

  191. @D. K.
    @Truth

    Yeah, you people sure can pick your victims, martyrs and heroes, Zippi:

    http://www.vdare.com/posts/look-how-the-minneapolis-star-tribune-describes-a-black-mob-attack-on-white-protesters-five-people-shot-near-black-lives-matter-protest-in-minneapolis

    Replies: @SPMoore8

    Based on my personal knowledge of the Occupy movement, I would bet (a) that this had nothing to do with race, (b) it was a drug deal gone bad.

  192. @Anonymous
    @Robert Hume

    They were filming the attack. The were apprehended for 40+ days and failed lie detector tests.

    One of them inadvertently admitted on live Israeli TV they were there to 'document the event'

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tRfhUezbKLw

    There are a lot of things that were reported on at the time of the attack that were simply never followed up on. Here is Fox news footage from 2001, alleging that Israel knew what was going to happen.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LbkQddEDPs0


    Any way you slice it, Israel is rotten in it's dealings with the US. There is no way they should be considered an 'ally' and the fact that they receive aid from the American taxpayer is an outrage.

    Replies: @tanabear

    America is an ally of Israel, but Israel is not an ally of the Unites States. That is how the relationship works.

    Yes, Carl Cameron and Fox News did some good initial reporting on this issue, but then they went quiet. I wonder what could have happened? Fox News also removed their report from their website on the Israel art student spy ring after only two days. They never said the information was wrong or inaccurate. Fox News: Fair, balanced, and unafraid….except of the Israeli Lobby.

  193. @Rurik
    @cwhatfuture


    The implication in several of the posts here is that very low level assets (the moving company illegals) would have had knowledge of a Mossad plot on 9/11. That is absurd.
     
    speaking of foreknowledge of the attacks, did you know Al Franken wrote in his book that he was warned not to go to work at the WTC that day?

    One of the widely disseminated stories was that no Jews died in the collapse of the Trade Towers because they had received calls telling them not to go to work that day. To tell you the truth, I got the Jew call. I had an office in the Trade Center where I used to do most of my writing. The call came from former New York mayor Ed Koch. “Al,” he told me, “don’t go to work on the twenty-third day of Elul [September 11 – ed].”

    just Google it

    isn't that a curious phenomena? First that it was widely enough known that people were warning (certain) other people about it, and then that he'd write such a thing in a book!

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @SFG, @Mr. Anon, @This Is Our Home

    But Stuart Smiley didn’t get the call so he died tragically on 9/11, which is why you never see him around anymore.

    • Replies: @James Kabala
    @Steve Sailer

    Unfunny comedians deserve to be taken literally.

    , @Rurik
    @Steve Sailer

    Osama wins another one

    I had to take a look

    it's not Smiley, it's Smalley

    https://skinnybymonday.files.wordpress.com/2012/08/stuart-smalley.jpg

    as in 'small'..

    ; )

    Replies: @Truth

  194. Dahlia says:
    @Steve Sailer
    @jtgw

    There are a whole bunch of websites run by Jews that evaluate how Jewish various celebrities are. My impression is that gentiles have no clue how much mental energy Jews devote to such questions.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @yaqub the mad scientist, @Ben Tzot-Abrit, @Stephen R. Diamond, @Dahlia

    Funniest example I’ve ever seen of this…

    Years ago, and I’m 95% sure it was John Podhoretz, was commenting at National Review’s blog. He had gotten excited about Ben Roethlisberger (pre-scandal), wondering if he was Jewish. Perhaps it was a Super Bowl, but lots of eyes were on him for some reason. So John googled it and posted what is the funniest bit of trolling I personally have ever come across…

    When you googled Ben Roethlisberger and Jewish, the first entry was an excited, eager, hyperventilating promised expose of whether Ben, indeed, was Jewish. When you clicked the link, you were brought to a single page with a single sentence in plain type at the very top of the page, just like what your opened desktop .txt file would look like:
    Sorry, Jews, he’s not one of yours.

    • Replies: @SFG
    @Dahlia

    That is...more humor and distance than I would expect from J-Pod.

    Replies: @Charles Erwin Wilson

  195. @Steve Sailer
    @Rurik

    But Stuart Smiley didn't get the call so he died tragically on 9/11, which is why you never see him around anymore.

    Replies: @James Kabala, @Rurik

    Unfunny comedians deserve to be taken literally.

  196. @Steve Sailer
    @Rurik

    But Stuart Smiley didn't get the call so he died tragically on 9/11, which is why you never see him around anymore.

    Replies: @James Kabala, @Rurik

    Osama wins another one

    I had to take a look

    it’s not Smiley, it’s Smalley

    as in ‘small’..

    ; )

    • Replies: @Truth
    @Rurik


    it’s not Smiley, it’s Smalley
     
    Steve went to school in Houston.
  197. @WhatEvvs
    Sorry, OT. Read the comments. A corner has been turned.

    http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/25/us/minneapolis-shooting-protest-police-jamar-clark.html?_r=0

    It's not every day that you get immediate, swift, fact-check their asses from the NY Times.

    Replies: @Boomstick

    NYT:

    On Monday night, community members asked the men what they were doing and asked them to remove their masks, she said, but they refused and were then escorted away.

    It’s not that hard to figure out what went on here. Citizens were filming something the #BLM didn’t want filmed, and #BLM goons attempted to run them off with physical violence. (“refused and were then escorted away.”) Things got dodgy and the people being “escorted” pulled their pieces, perhaps justifiably and perhaps not.

  198. Some had speculated that FDR had intelligence warning about the imminent attack in Pearl Harbor, but chose to do nothing in order to motivate an isolationist public to join the charge into war.

    I am still constantly hearing about ridiculous conspiracy theories that those attacks in 2001 were an inside job false flag operation. In this case the theories are absurd because the US has never needed such an extreme casus belli to go to war. Some other trumped up incident would have been sufficient to mobilize the public and the troops. It’s not that I don’t believe in conspiracies by the powerful. Rather I’m convinced that many conspiracies are so effective and remain secret that the public would never imagine or suspect what happened. The more ridiculous stories keep the usual suspects distracted from investigating the real ones and undermine any of their credibility if they ever do stumble upon anything real. In this case, what if it wasn’t exactly an inside job but rather that the Israelis had reliable intelligence about the likelihood of that attack but chose not to pursue the leads very diligently or aggressively?

    • Replies: @tbraton
    @Thin-Skinned Masta-Beta

    But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers. I'm generally not one who subscribes to conspiracy theories, but, when faced with such disturbing, inexplicable facts, one has to conclude that we don't have the entire story.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon, @tanabear, @Mr. Anon

  199. @Svigor
    Heard on NPR today (paraphrasing): "Muslims are the main victims of ISIS, they're the main group battling ISIS, and now they're the people being blamed for ISIS."

    Yeah, well, that's because ISIS is Muslim, you jackasses. Perhaps more to the point, the people victimized by ISIS and the people fighting ISIS are far less Muslim than ISIS is. These people have their (stupid) rhetoric well-honed from the better part of a century spent whitewashing blacks.

    “the ADL concluded there were no celebrations of any kind — none — in Paterson or any where else in New Jersey.”
     
    Well, I guess that makes everything all white then, doesn't it?

    The implication in several of the posts here is that very low level assets (the moving company illegals) would have had knowledge of a Mossad plot on 9/11. That is absurd.
     
    Dunno. Take it up with the people who made those posts. The fact I am stating is that there was speculation in the wake of 9/11 that the Mossad agents were tracking terrorists in America and knew attacks were imminent.

    Or maybe I am a secret Mossad Elks Club Masonic Temple Super “Shabbo Goy” – as someone here so eloquently put it.
     
    The famous Jewish comedic genius is on display, I suppose.

    Replies: @Cwhatfuture

    Yes, you supposed right on that one point. On all the rest you supposed wrong.

  200. @greysquirrell
    @Mike Sylwester

    PrisonPlanet is not a decent source, because while it occassionally may have some worthy news , it is too often neck deep in unsutantiated conspiracy news.

    The problem in believeing the story you quote is that there is no way the planners of 9-11 would have told or discussed their plans in a manner that some highschool kids could overhear and then babble about it.

    Unless I can see some mainstream news sites report on the same claim , I'm chalking it up to propaghanda. The article reporting the kids were Palestinian also arouses my suspicion. None of the 9-11 Hijackers were Palestinian, so it wouldn't be like their unlces or older brothers or dads were discussing it and these kids overheard it.

    Replies: @Bugg

    I recall seeing the New Utrecht High School Palestinian kid being part of a documentary on PBS or History or some other cable channel. Made a few attempts to search for it, but admittedly nothing comes up now. You can note that several of the 9/11 hijackers did live in apartments in Brooklyn and New Jersey in the years prior to 9/11, attended mosques in NYC (specifically one on 3rd Avenue and one on Bedford Avenue in Brooklyn) and probably had some contacts with people they knew from their time there, and perhaps spoke to their old friends in the run-up to that day.Grant you that sounds like speculation, if logical.

  201. @This Is Our Home
    @Seth Largo

    If you broke the law, just tell the truth.

    Replies: @donut, @ShaslA, @SFG

    Not if you weren’t convicted .

  202. @Steve Sailer
    @Rurik

    "they had a video camera set up to watch the first plane hit the tower"

    Do we know that? From what? This ABC News story begins with eyewitness Maria's account, who didn't start looking until after the first tower was hit. After a while she noticed the Israelis.

    Replies: @Rurik, @tanabear

    Steve: “Do we know that? From what?”

    They started filming and photographing themselves right after the first plane hit the North Tower. At that point how did they know it was a terrorist attack? Most of the assumptions were that it was some kind of horrible accident. It wasn’t until the second plane hit the South Tower that everyone became aware of a coordinated attack. So why so giddy over a random plane flying into a building? Also I wonder why we have never seen any of these photographs? Rhetorical question.

    Also from the FBI report: “‘A former Urban Moving Systems employee later contacted the Newark Division with information indicating that he had quit his employment with Urban Moving Systems due to high amount of anti-American sentiment present among Urban’s employees. The former employee stated that an Israeli employee of Urban had even once remarked, ‘Give us twenty (20) years and we’ll take over your media and destroy your country.’”

    p.s. And these are our allies.

  203. @el topo
    @Ben Tzot-Abrit

    This is true. As a partial Jew, I have always been fascinated with the question of Jewishness and am able to view it from different angles, as it were. I also have an extremely keen Jewdar and am able to spot Jews and mischlings quite accurately.
    I have friends who are full Jews, however, who seem not at all interested in their Jewishness and completely downplay its significance, though they have many obviously Jewish traits (and typical liberal Jewish politics).

    Replies: @SFG

    Funny. I guess I could say the same. How many Mischlingen who have gotten skeptical of the tribe are there here? I thought I was the only one, but it seems fairly common at the fringes of the alt-right.

  204. @Dahlia
    @Steve Sailer

    Funniest example I've ever seen of this...

    Years ago, and I'm 95% sure it was John Podhoretz, was commenting at National Review's blog. He had gotten excited about Ben Roethlisberger (pre-scandal), wondering if he was Jewish. Perhaps it was a Super Bowl, but lots of eyes were on him for some reason. So John googled it and posted what is the funniest bit of trolling I personally have ever come across...

    When you googled Ben Roethlisberger and Jewish, the first entry was an excited, eager, hyperventilating promised expose of whether Ben, indeed, was Jewish. When you clicked the link, you were brought to a single page with a single sentence in plain type at the very top of the page, just like what your opened desktop .txt file would look like:
    Sorry, Jews, he's not one of yours.

    Replies: @SFG

    That is…more humor and distance than I would expect from J-Pod.

    • Replies: @Charles Erwin Wilson
    @SFG

    Though he should be J-Ackass instead of J-Pod. His brays are pure and unmixed moonbattery.

    I would like to think he could be dissuaded from his stupidity. Reason and experience argue forcefully against that outcome.

    Replies: @TWS

  205. @Rurik
    @cwhatfuture


    The implication in several of the posts here is that very low level assets (the moving company illegals) would have had knowledge of a Mossad plot on 9/11. That is absurd.
     
    speaking of foreknowledge of the attacks, did you know Al Franken wrote in his book that he was warned not to go to work at the WTC that day?

    One of the widely disseminated stories was that no Jews died in the collapse of the Trade Towers because they had received calls telling them not to go to work that day. To tell you the truth, I got the Jew call. I had an office in the Trade Center where I used to do most of my writing. The call came from former New York mayor Ed Koch. “Al,” he told me, “don’t go to work on the twenty-third day of Elul [September 11 – ed].”

    just Google it

    isn't that a curious phenomena? First that it was widely enough known that people were warning (certain) other people about it, and then that he'd write such a thing in a book!

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @SFG, @Mr. Anon, @This Is Our Home

    It was probably a joke. He is a comedian, after all.

    I actually thought Stuart Smalley was a pretty good sendup of therapy culture. If you lived in New York in the 80s and 90s, you heard that stuff all the time.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @SFG

    The one where Stuart Smalley therapizes Michael Jordan is pretty funny. "I know what you are thinking: all the other players are better than me, I can't make a shot, I'm just no good. But, you've got to tell yourself: darn it, I'm pretty good and people like me!"

  206. @SPMoore8
    @Anonymous

    German Burger King franchise Do they serve their Whoppers on Kaiser rolls?

    Replies: @SFG, @Ozymandias

    Nein, but all ze burger patties are exactly 1 kg, nicht wahr?

    • Agree: Spmoore8
  207. @SFG
    @Rurik

    It was probably a joke. He is a comedian, after all.

    I actually thought Stuart Smalley was a pretty good sendup of therapy culture. If you lived in New York in the 80s and 90s, you heard that stuff all the time.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    The one where Stuart Smalley therapizes Michael Jordan is pretty funny. “I know what you are thinking: all the other players are better than me, I can’t make a shot, I’m just no good. But, you’ve got to tell yourself: darn it, I’m pretty good and people like me!”

  208. @jtgw
    Israel seems to work on trust in many ways. E.g. how exactly do they verify your Jewishness when you apply for citizenship there? It would seem to be something easy to fake, and yet Israel is pretty good at keeping itself Jewish.

    Replies: @Cwhatfuture, @Steve Sailer, @sprfls, @Karl, @Lugash, @shk12344

    Israel can always do a DNA test for Jewish ancestry.

    Russian-speakers who want to make aliya could need DNA test

    http://www.timesofisrael.com/russian-speakers-who-want-to-immigrate-could-need-dna-test/

  209. @Svigor
    Take that! Obama: Climate summit a ‘powerful rebuke’ to terrorists

    President Obama declared Tuesday that next week’s climate change summit in Paris would be a “powerful rebuke” to terrorists
     
    What a maroon.

    Replies: @donut

    Did he specify which terrorists he means ?

  210. I can’t believe there are so many questions surrounding 9/11 and Israeli involvement, and nobody in power seems the least bit interested in getting to the bottom of it.

    It’s truly a mystery.

    • Replies: @tanabear
    @Anonymous

    Anonymous: "It’s truly a mystery."

    I know, shocking isn't it? Who would have thought that people in power care more about power than the truth?

    , @ben tillman
    @Anonymous


    I can’t believe there are so many questions surrounding 9/11 and Israeli involvement, and nobody in power seems the least bit interested in getting to the bottom of it.

    It’s truly a mystery.
     
    The PNACkers were the prime suspects, and their network extended into the government, so it's natural to suspect some government involvement, especially in view of otherwise hard-to-explain facts like the failure of the military to intercept the hijacked planes and the government's decision to destroy the crime scene so quickly.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

  211. @Wilkey
    "But Gordon insisted that his clients were just five young men who had come to America for a vacation, ended up working for a moving company."

    Because who doesn't eventually end up working for a Jersey moving company when they're on vacation? I still regale friends and family members with stories of the time I visited London and spent the entire three weeks working 14 hour a day shifts frying chicken at KFC Halal. Even more memorable was that trip to Thailand back in middle school, where I spent a week turning tricks for a local pimp, Prayut. He and I are still penpals, exchanging Christmas cards, Hanukkah presents, homemade porn, and updates on our latest T cell counts. Good times...

    Replies: @AndrewR, @ben tillman

    LOL! Absolutely hilarious.

  212. @Anonymous Nephew
    OT - Sweden chucks the towel in.

    http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/nov/24/sweden-asylum-seekers-refugees-policy-reversal

    "Sweden needs “respite” from the tens of thousands of refugees knocking at its door, the government has said, announcing tough measures to deter asylum seekers in a sharp reversal of its open-door policy towards people fleeing war and persecution.
    The country’s generous asylum regime would revert to the “EU minimum”, Sweden’s prime minister, Stefan Löfven, said on Tuesday, revealing that most refugees would receive only temporary residence permits from April.
    Identity checks would be imposed on all modes of transport, and the right to bring families to Sweden would be severely restricted, he said."

    The Greens’ deputy prime minister, Åsa Romson, broke into tears as she announced the measures.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    Thanks, I’ll post.

  213. @SFG
    @Dahlia

    That is...more humor and distance than I would expect from J-Pod.

    Replies: @Charles Erwin Wilson

    Though he should be J-Ackass instead of J-Pod. His brays are pure and unmixed moonbattery.

    I would like to think he could be dissuaded from his stupidity. Reason and experience argue forcefully against that outcome.

    • Replies: @TWS
    @Charles Erwin Wilson

    Pod the Lesser.

  214. @Boomstick
    @Ron Unz

    There were two men found with one Glock 9mm inside the Mexican parliament building. The only mentions of explosives I can find are on crazed conspiracy sites.

    http://archivo.eluniversal.com.mx/nacion/68324.html

    The man had a license to carry a concealed weapon and was a security guard. It's easy to forget you're wearing a pistol and accidentally go into restricted areas.

    Replies: @Ron Unz

    There were two men found with one Glock 9mm inside the Mexican parliament building. The only mentions of explosives I can find are on crazed conspiracy sites.

    No, I don’t think that’s correct. The story was naturally huge in Mexico at the time and when I looked into the matter maybe a decade ago, at least some of the local newspaper accounts mentioned that the Israeli military guy had been caught carrying explosive devices into the Mexican parliament building, which is hardly the sort of detail I’d easily forget.

    • Replies: @AnonymousCoward
    @Ron Unz

    You can also find the archived version of the official, Mexican govt. site confirming the explosives.

    https://wikispooks.com/wiki/2001_Mexican_legislative_assembly_attack

    Replies: @Ron Unz

  215. @Anonymous
    I can't believe there are so many questions surrounding 9/11 and Israeli involvement, and nobody in power seems the least bit interested in getting to the bottom of it.

    It's truly a mystery.

    Replies: @tanabear, @ben tillman

    Anonymous: “It’s truly a mystery.”

    I know, shocking isn’t it? Who would have thought that people in power care more about power than the truth?

  216. @Rurik
    @cwhatfuture


    The implication in several of the posts here is that very low level assets (the moving company illegals) would have had knowledge of a Mossad plot on 9/11. That is absurd.
     
    speaking of foreknowledge of the attacks, did you know Al Franken wrote in his book that he was warned not to go to work at the WTC that day?

    One of the widely disseminated stories was that no Jews died in the collapse of the Trade Towers because they had received calls telling them not to go to work that day. To tell you the truth, I got the Jew call. I had an office in the Trade Center where I used to do most of my writing. The call came from former New York mayor Ed Koch. “Al,” he told me, “don’t go to work on the twenty-third day of Elul [September 11 – ed].”

    just Google it

    isn't that a curious phenomena? First that it was widely enough known that people were warning (certain) other people about it, and then that he'd write such a thing in a book!

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @SFG, @Mr. Anon, @This Is Our Home

    “………..speaking of foreknowledge of the attacks, did you know Al Franken wrote in his book that he was warned not to go to work at the WTC that day?”

    It was a joke. He often used to make them – he was a comedian.

  217. @Rurik
    @Steve Sailer

    I tried Steve..

    seems to be 'memory holed', but if that one detail would make a difference to the narrative for you, I'll still find what I can.

    I notice you didn't consider my little blurt about how George Bush said publically (and on camera) that he saw the first plane hit WTC tower- curious. Did you know that? Does it matter to your mind if he said it or even if he did see it?

    I don't know where you stand on the whole 911 thing. A lot of people consider it prudent to not care too much. Perhaps it is.

    On a semi-related note Carl Cameron of Fox News did a story on Israeli "art student' spies rounded up after 911

    'evidence linking these Israelis to 9-11 is classified. I cannot tell you about evidence that has been gathered. It's classified information.'


    http://www.salon.com/2002/05/07/students/

    http://www.antiwar.com/justin/j030802.html

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “I notice you didn’t consider my little blurt about how George Bush said publically (and on camera) that he saw the first plane hit WTC tower- curious. Did you know that? Does it matter to your mind if he said it or even if he did see it?”

    And what is so odd about that?

    “I don’t know where you stand on the whole 911 thing. A lot of people consider it prudent to not care too much. Perhaps it is. ”

    A lot of people consider it prudent not to indulge in the kind of insanity that has largely come to characterizes the “Truther” movement.

    • Replies: @Rurik
    @Mr. Anon



    George Bush said publically (and on camera) that he saw the first plane hit WTC tower- curious. Did you know that? Does it matter to your mind if he said it or even if he did see it?”
     
    And what is so odd about that?

     

    first plane

    let that sink in for a minute

    ok

    here, let me help

    here's the video

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eyi33ftRUZY

    you can find it all over the Internet if you look, (or cared)

    but for people with a functioning brain, for George Bush to have seen the FIRST plane hit the tower, which he clearly did from what he says, then that means that he was watching a live video feed of the "terrorist" attacks on that day. Someone had a camera set up and Bush happened to be watching before he went into that classroom.

    the kind of insanity that has largely come to characterizes the “Truther” movement.
     
    insanity indeed

    it literally is a kind of insanity to watch building seven implode and tell yourself that is was office fires that did it

    or to see president George Bush talking about watching the FIRST plane hit the tower and consider it of no consequence

    rather I wouldn't so much put it down to insanity as I would intellectual and moral cowardice

    ; )

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

  218. Now that we have rediscovered that is was Israelis dancing in New Jersey, the story will plunge right back down the memory hole.

  219. @AnotherDad
    @Truth

    Truth, believe it or not, white people have rights to.

    BLM is protesting--the death of a serial criminal and girlfriend beater--on public property. Despite some BLM flack talking about "people who did not belong there", white anti-pro-thuggery protesters *also* have the right to be there and protest the protesters.

    Unfortunately, most blacks (like a lot of leftists) can not fathom the concept of people being allow to disagree with them, so unsurprisingly BLM types try and chase these counter protesters off. And indeed apparently had them on the run.

    Wasn't there, but i'll say, i'd rather shoot than let a black mob (even a mob of two or three) catch me. Blacks readily assault whites (and each other). Once down they'll kick and stomp you. You're lucky if you don't end up with serious injury, or being a vegetable, or dead.

    George Zimmerman would quite likely be a vegetable in some hospital if he hadn't been packing when attacked by the thug Trayvon Martin, who was witnessed raining down blows "MMA sytle" and smacking Zimmerman's head into the sidewalk.

    Here, we had this kid Kris Kime at Mardi Gras about 15 years back, who went to the assistance of a girl some black thugs were assaulting and had knocked down. For his trouble, some black thug whacked him on the head, knocking him down where upon a bunch of black thugs started kicking the crap outta him ... while Seattle police--obeying the PC orders of their leftist political bosses--just stood around the sidelines watching.

    Whites who are going to be around blacks are smart to be armed. Especially if you're in a "progressive" jurisdiction where PC is turning the police into useless timeservers while feral blacks run free. And if attacked they *should* fire. Hey, the state will no doubt try to railroad you--like they tried with Zimmerman. But better to end up in prison, then beaten and stomped dead like Kris Kime.

    ~~~
    Truth, i know you have a different take on the capabilities and behavior of your people. And that's fine.

    The simple approach that works for your folks and my folks--separation. Your people run your affairs--have the level of policing and tolerate the level of violence that your people desire. And my people run our affairs and have the level of policing and intolerance for thuggery and violence that we find allows for civilized life. Win-win.

    Replies: @Truth

    The simple approach that works for your folks and my folks–separation. Your people run your affairs–have the level of policing and tolerate the level of violence that your people desire.

    Cool, what states are you giving us? I like California.

    • Replies: @ATate
    @Truth

    Your folks can't even hold Compton for Christ's sake. What makes you think a bunch of Lavarias's and Latavia's can hold Venice or Carlsbad from the Brown Horde?

    Let alone the entire state.

  220. @Svigor

    I once considered working for FBI or CIA. I got application packages from each. I had familial connection to CIA, but no relationship to FBI. The FBI package was at least 50 pages and required exhaustive detail including all schools attended and dates of attendance along with grades (do you have your third grade report cards?). They demanded all family connections to second cousin along with detail like date of birth and photos. It was, putting it mildly, incredibly over the top.
     
    Ever watched The Americans? That's why it was so "over the top"; they wanted to make sure you were born and raised here, and not living a cover story.

    Just guessing, but, the CIA, on the other hand, probably just had a different process; if they decided to hire you (probably a lot less likely than the FBI hiring you), they would then put you through the wringer.

    A disgruntled MOSSAD officer wrote an expose´ (“By Way of Deception”) that detailed how MOSSAD is small and poor, but punches above its weight by employing Jews to spy in their local countries and use their businesses to pay for it all. Sort of like how Pollard suddenly got employed on Wall Street or something. The actual professional case officers are very few in number, but who needs them when high-status Jews throughout the world will hook you up with either information or influence.
     
    IIRC, the word for these Jews is "sayanim."

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “Ever watched The Americans? That’s why it was so “over the top”; they wanted to make sure you were born and raised here, and not living a cover story.”

    The worst ever FBI mole, Robert Hanssen, was born and raised in America.

    I saw a couple episodes of “The Americans”. It seemed ridiculous. I think it unlikely that it’s a realistic portrayal of espionage (for example, I imagine that murdering a defector in your own garage is not a very smart thing for a deep-cover agent to do). Yeah, the show has some former spooks as technical advisors. Technical advisors often just get ignored by writers, directors, and producers.

  221. @Svigor

    Even if the Israelis knew ahead of time, why would they send people in the field who knew ahead of time, and put them in a position to be arrested and questioned by the FBI?
     
    The way I always heard it (i.e., the speculation), they were tracking Muslim terrorists in the US and knew there would or might be an attack, which would make your question kind of nonsensical; not as if they'd just disappear into thin air the moment they were forewarned.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    Even if they didn’t know an attack would or might happen, they still would have filmed it. Wouldn’t anyone? If they were engaged in surveilance they would have had video-cameras, and most people who had video-cameras on that that day, who weren’t in immediate danger, filmed what they could of the attacks.

  222. @Richard S
    @NOTA

    Something like "Guy-uz Yule-lee-uz Kae-sar"; but then technically he was never emperor :)

    Replies: @kaganovitch, @ben tillman

    Something like “Guy-uz Yule-lee-uz Kae-sar”

    Kie-sar. First syllable is just like the first syllable of the German “Kaiser”.

  223. I’m really surprised no one has mentioned the E-Team Israeli art students who installed a balcony on the 91st floor of the WTC in March 2001.

    This shenanigans was reported on in the NYT.

    For more info go to COTT.

    Terrifying pictures of a lot of weird stuff going on at the WTC in the months before those “dancing moslems.”

    Sincerely,

    – Arturo

  224. @Rurik
    @Steve Sailer

    Osama wins another one

    I had to take a look

    it's not Smiley, it's Smalley

    https://skinnybymonday.files.wordpress.com/2012/08/stuart-smalley.jpg

    as in 'small'..

    ; )

    Replies: @Truth

    it’s not Smiley, it’s Smalley

    Steve went to school in Houston.

  225. @Anonymous
    I can't believe there are so many questions surrounding 9/11 and Israeli involvement, and nobody in power seems the least bit interested in getting to the bottom of it.

    It's truly a mystery.

    Replies: @tanabear, @ben tillman

    I can’t believe there are so many questions surrounding 9/11 and Israeli involvement, and nobody in power seems the least bit interested in getting to the bottom of it.

    It’s truly a mystery.

    The PNACkers were the prime suspects, and their network extended into the government, so it’s natural to suspect some government involvement, especially in view of otherwise hard-to-explain facts like the failure of the military to intercept the hijacked planes and the government’s decision to destroy the crime scene so quickly.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @ben tillman

    "The PNACkers were the prime suspects, and their network extended into the government, so it’s natural to suspect some government involvement, especially in view of otherwise hard-to-explain facts like the failure of the military to intercept the hijacked planes and the government’s decision to destroy the crime scene so quickly."

    The government did not destroy the crime scene. They hauled the debris somewhere else. They do the same thing with every single airplane crash.

    And I have never understood the fixation on the fact that the government didn't shoot down the planes. It was an extraordinary event. And no matter what people - even military people do - in wargaming and exercises and the like - people don't really expect things like that to happen. If Air Force pilots had robot-like followed orders to shoot down planes full of innocent people............would that make you feel better? Would it make you feel better about the US military and government if they were quick to issue and follow orders like that?

    Replies: @ben tillman, @Ron Unz

  226. @Ron Unz
    @Boomstick


    There were two men found with one Glock 9mm inside the Mexican parliament building. The only mentions of explosives I can find are on crazed conspiracy sites.
     
    No, I don't think that's correct. The story was naturally huge in Mexico at the time and when I looked into the matter maybe a decade ago, at least some of the local newspaper accounts mentioned that the Israeli military guy had been caught carrying explosive devices into the Mexican parliament building, which is hardly the sort of detail I'd easily forget.

    Replies: @AnonymousCoward

    You can also find the archived version of the official, Mexican govt. site confirming the explosives.

    https://wikispooks.com/wiki/2001_Mexican_legislative_assembly_attack

    • Replies: @Ron Unz
    @AnonymousCoward


    You can also find the archived version of the official, Mexican govt. site confirming the explosives.
     
    Excellent. It's always nice to confirm that my memory wasn't playing tricks on me after so many years.

    Replies: @BobX, @Boomstick

  227. @WhatEvvs
    OT, the front page of the NYT has the shooting of 5 people at a Black Lives Matter rally. No word on the 16 shot at the hippity hop party in New Orleans.

    Replies: @TangoMan, @Hippopotamusdrome

    Counter protest at BLM protest. BLM’ers chase away counter protesters and pursue them down the street. Then pursuing party gets shot at.

    5 People Shot Near BLM Protest

    • Replies: @WhatEvvs
    @Hippopotamusdrome

    &@boomstick,

    Meanwhile, the original focus of the protest, Jamar Clark or some other such stupid name, beat his girlfriend so badly she needed surgery. I learned that from a random comment. No word on her from The NY Times.

  228. If you trace the web reports that mention explosives back far enough they usually go to a single source.

    Google translation from El Universal:

    The security guard Guersson Smeke Salvador, arrested two days inside the Chamber of Deputies with the former Israeli military course Sauar Ben Zvi has a license to carry a 9mm weapon. issued by the Secretariat of National Defense (SDN), effective December 31 this year.
    This is an “individual” license filed before the SDN earlier this year and issued by the agency earlier this year. Sources at the Attorney General’s Office noted that Guersson Salvador is the only of the two detainees who are duly registered with the Ministry of Public Security.
    “But the other person, who was not armed, we have no clear data and we are still investigating,” they said.

    No explosives. A single security guard with one Glock.

    In the jumpy days after 9/11 there were all sorts of bogus reports.

  229. @Drakejax
    A disgruntled MOSSAD officer wrote an expose´ ("By Way of Deception") that detailed how MOSSAD is small and poor, but punches above its weight by employing Jews to spy in their local countries and use their businesses to pay for it all. Sort of like how Pollard suddenly got employed on Wall Street or something. The actual professional case officers are very few in number, but who needs them when high-status Jews throughout the world will hook you up with either information or influence.

    Replies: @Chiron, @Cwhatfuture, @Zed, Lord of the Brutals

    Many intelligence agencies do the same thing. If you’re in a technical field of interest to the US IC and a ‘reliable’ US citizen, you may be approached and interviewed, either before and/or after you’ve attended any sort of foreign technical events (symposiums, conferences, etc etc) or simply involved in routine foreign business.

  230. @Big Bill
    The recruiting is pretty simple. An Israeli agent goes on tour of the USA speaking at synagogues around the country on some innocuous subject.

    The rabbi who coordinates each whistlestop identifies likely helpers in the congregation who would be amenable to helping out.

    When the agent arrives in town, he speaks to each potential recruit privately and feels them out to see if they are willing to help. Perhaps they could provide a cover job for an Israeli agent. Maybe supply the Mossad with letterhead or business cards to provide cover. Or agree to be a mail drop, receiving mail and setting it aside for someone to pick up later.

    Not every Jew will agree to help, of course. But the nice thing--the thing that makes such low-key recruiting quite safe--is that no Jew would ever rat out a fellow Jew, even if he turns down the request and declines to assist the Mossad.

    This safety is enhanced by Jewish religious law. Being a "moser" (one who rats out a fellow Jew to gentiles) is a death penalty offense.

    Google "mosrim death penalty".

    The same ethnic/racial solidarity also works for Muslim jihadis. This is why even "moderate" Muslims are an existential threat to the West. They can be counted on to look the other way and say nothing, particularly in Muslim ghettos like Molenbeek and Malmo.

    Mao got it right with his dictum about revolutionaries swimming through the local population like fish in the sea.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @SFG

    This safety is enhanced by Jewish religious law. Being a “moser” (one who rats out a fellow Jew to gentiles) is a death penalty offense.

    I must have missed all those beheadings those damn Jews have done for ‘mosing.’

  231. @cwhatfuture
    @NOTA

    Why would Israelis use illegals working as movers to record such an event and celebrate it publicly? Because according to the sleuths on this board, not only are the Israeli intelligence agencies dumb, they verge on the retarded.

    Replies: @Zed, Lord of the Brutals

    You want a realistic depiction of the IC? Watch the movie “Spies Like Us” and “Office Space.”

    • Agree: Travis
  232. @Rurik
    @cwhatfuture


    The implication in several of the posts here is that very low level assets (the moving company illegals) would have had knowledge of a Mossad plot on 9/11. That is absurd.
     
    speaking of foreknowledge of the attacks, did you know Al Franken wrote in his book that he was warned not to go to work at the WTC that day?

    One of the widely disseminated stories was that no Jews died in the collapse of the Trade Towers because they had received calls telling them not to go to work that day. To tell you the truth, I got the Jew call. I had an office in the Trade Center where I used to do most of my writing. The call came from former New York mayor Ed Koch. “Al,” he told me, “don’t go to work on the twenty-third day of Elul [September 11 – ed].”

    just Google it

    isn't that a curious phenomena? First that it was widely enough known that people were warning (certain) other people about it, and then that he'd write such a thing in a book!

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @SFG, @Mr. Anon, @This Is Our Home

    Um…he was joking. He called it ‘the Jew call.’ I Googled it and lots of site are holding it up as proof of something nefarious. Lots of sites are clearly written by idiots.

    • Replies: @AnonymousCoward
    @This Is Our Home

    Yes, read the surrounding context in his book, it's an obvious joke.

    Also, after you read and confirm this, make sure to come back here and retract your mistake, so that no other researchers are suckered into embarrassing themselves.

    , @D. K.
    @This Is Our Home

    Yes, but to the best of my knowledge, the suspicious warning to Odigo employees, which I posted a link about, above, has never been explained, let alone explained away...!?!

    Here is that link, again, to a news story, from Israel itself, published fifteen days after 9/11:

    http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/odigo-says-workers-were-warned-of-attack-1.70579

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

  233. Are Israeli mafias really muling “club drugs” (as opposed to legal pharma which they’re quite involved in)? That sounds more like the type of thing those “Pain and Gain” meatheads in So. Florida specialized in. In fact it seems kinda like a not-worth-checking innuendo filler for an “e.g.” tidbit… They might swim in the same waters, sure. But the frankly bizarre conceit that cutthroat ex-Mossad gangsters are flooding the heartland with MDMA (depressed blue-collare whites have taken up raving with glow-sticks & pacifiers?) is either your Pulitzer in waiting or you just made it up.

    I’d also be open to the possibility that it comes from your own experience, in-between 3am blog posts hitting the EDM scene in warehouses off Lankershim Boulevard. After all there’s a lot we don’t know about you, and your lifestyle does seem a bit odd.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Scotty G. Vito

    It was enough of a thing that there was a 2010 Jesse Eisenberg movie about it:

    "Holy Rollers is a 2010 independent film written by Antonio Macia, directed by Kevin Asch, and starring Jesse Eisenberg, Justin Bartha, Ari Graynor, Danny Abeckaser, Q-Tip and Jason Fuchs. Holy Rollers is inspired by actual events in the late nineties when Hasidic Jews were recruited as mules to smuggle ecstasy from Europe into the United States.[1]"

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holy_Rollers_(film)

    I don't know anything about drug trades, so I can't tell you if it's still true, but it was a thing about 15 years ago: Ecstasy was heavily an international Jewish business with a major Israeli connection, the way cocaine was a Colombian thing in 1980.

  234. @Scotty G. Vito
    Are Israeli mafias really muling "club drugs" (as opposed to legal pharma which they're quite involved in)? That sounds more like the type of thing those "Pain and Gain" meatheads in So. Florida specialized in. In fact it seems kinda like a not-worth-checking innuendo filler for an "e.g." tidbit... They might swim in the same waters, sure. But the frankly bizarre conceit that cutthroat ex-Mossad gangsters are flooding the heartland with MDMA (depressed blue-collare whites have taken up raving with glow-sticks & pacifiers?) is either your Pulitzer in waiting or you just made it up.

    I'd also be open to the possibility that it comes from your own experience, in-between 3am blog posts hitting the EDM scene in warehouses off Lankershim Boulevard. After all there's a lot we don't know about you, and your lifestyle does seem a bit odd.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    It was enough of a thing that there was a 2010 Jesse Eisenberg movie about it:

    “Holy Rollers is a 2010 independent film written by Antonio Macia, directed by Kevin Asch, and starring Jesse Eisenberg, Justin Bartha, Ari Graynor, Danny Abeckaser, Q-Tip and Jason Fuchs. Holy Rollers is inspired by actual events in the late nineties when Hasidic Jews were recruited as mules to smuggle ecstasy from Europe into the United States.[1]”

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holy_Rollers_(film)

    I don’t know anything about drug trades, so I can’t tell you if it’s still true, but it was a thing about 15 years ago: Ecstasy was heavily an international Jewish business with a major Israeli connection, the way cocaine was a Colombian thing in 1980.

  235. @This Is Our Home
    @Rurik

    Um...he was joking. He called it 'the Jew call.' I Googled it and lots of site are holding it up as proof of something nefarious. Lots of sites are clearly written by idiots.

    Replies: @AnonymousCoward, @D. K.

    Yes, read the surrounding context in his book, it’s an obvious joke.

    Also, after you read and confirm this, make sure to come back here and retract your mistake, so that no other researchers are suckered into embarrassing themselves.

  236. @Truth
    @SPMoore8



    it would be relatively simple to cherry pick stories about black assailants assaulting whites, amirite?
     
    From having been on this site for 9 years...I would concur.

    Replies: @D. K.

    Since a particular demographic group (age x sex x race) comprising only about 2% of our resident population commits about half of all of the murders in the United States– year in and year out, decade after decade– no “cherry-picking” is necessary.

  237. @This Is Our Home
    @Rurik

    Um...he was joking. He called it 'the Jew call.' I Googled it and lots of site are holding it up as proof of something nefarious. Lots of sites are clearly written by idiots.

    Replies: @AnonymousCoward, @D. K.

    Yes, but to the best of my knowledge, the suspicious warning to Odigo employees, which I posted a link about, above, has never been explained, let alone explained away…!?!

    Here is that link, again, to a news story, from Israel itself, published fifteen days after 9/11:

    http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/odigo-says-workers-were-warned-of-attack-1.70579

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @D. K.

    Two Israel-based employees, in Israel(!), of a company which did not have an office in the towers received a message warning them of a terrorist attack on somewhere....that's not even a coincidence, it is entirely unrelated.

    http://www.911myths.com/index.php/Odigo

    Replies: @D. K.

  238. Gentlemen :

    The coincidences just keep piling up.

    I am surprised no one has mentioned yet the “E-Team” :

    http://robscholtemuseum.nl/mark-dotzler-thoughts-on-the-wtc-artists/

    This was a group of Israeli Art students who were given exclusive access to seven critical stories of the WTC north tower to perform an “art installation” that consisted among other things of the giant office-window billboard spelling out “E TEAM”, and an actual balcony they installed for a few hours by removing a pane of glass.

    This is the real deal people, it’s getting hotter.

    Even the NYT wrote about the E-team and their 91st-floor balcony :

    http://www.nytimes.com/2001/08/18/nyregion/balcony-scene-unseen-atop-world-episode-trade-center-assumes-mythic-qualities.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm

    There’s a lot of Israeli art students and e-team (explosives team?) stuff on crimes of the times today.

    One thing that is absolutely freaking me out :

    The boxes and boxes and boxes of BB 18 on the 91st floor of the Israeli art students E-Team project.

    Prepare to get spooked :

    http://www.littelfuse.com/products/fuse-blocks-fuseholders-and-fuse-accessories/dead-front-fuse-holders/powr-busbar/bb18.aspx

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Arturo

    "This was a group of Israeli Art students who were given exclusive access to seven critical stories of the WTC north tower to perform an “art installation”..."

    They were not Israeli; they were Austrian.

    "The boxes and boxes and boxes of BB 18 on the 91st floor of the Israeli art students E-Team project.

    Prepare to get spooked :

    http://www.littelfuse.com/products/fuse-blocks-fuseholders-and-fuse-accessories/dead-front-fuse-holders/powr-busbar/bb18.aspx"

    Yeah - that's real spooky to anyone who thinks that electricity is magic. Those aren't bomb fuse holders (I don't think there even is such a thing) - they are electric fuse holders - common power distribution equipment, of the kind one might typically find in a power-panel in an office building. It is not surprising that there would be empty boxes for that stuff laying around.

    Everything is a mystery to the stupid.

    , @slumber_j
    @Arturo

    The WTC was host to a number of artists over the years: the space there was always a hard sell, and there were therefore a lot of vacancies, so I imagine it was a tax dodge.

    One of a couple of examples I'm aware of was the tenancy of the preposterously named but magnificent painter Rackstraw Downes. Here's a painting of his of some raw interior space there:

    http://www.art21.org/images/rackstraw-downes/untenanted-space-in-the-world-trade-center-winter-sun-1998?slideshow=1

    Replies: @Dave Pinsen

  239. @AnonymousCoward
    @Ron Unz

    You can also find the archived version of the official, Mexican govt. site confirming the explosives.

    https://wikispooks.com/wiki/2001_Mexican_legislative_assembly_attack

    Replies: @Ron Unz

    You can also find the archived version of the official, Mexican govt. site confirming the explosives.

    Excellent. It’s always nice to confirm that my memory wasn’t playing tricks on me after so many years.

    • Replies: @BobX
    @Ron Unz

    Ron

    I don't think the link AC provides is all he claims it to be. The web archive link refers to "a 9 mm caliber weapon". You value the Pravda link for what you think it is worth.

    Google translate of text from link:

    THE PGR INFORMS ABOUT SITUATION
    SUBJECT ARRESTED IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
     
    Regarding the situation of the 2 subjects detained last Wednesday near the Legislative Palace of San Lazaro, the Attorney General's Office reports that the Israeli citizen Saer Ben-Zvi and Saar Noam Ben Zvi was made available to the First Court of "A" Federal Criminal Proceedings in Mexico City, Distrito while the Mexican Salvador Gersson Smeck will release order issued stocks with the law, because no items were found for your consignment.

    Under that when he was arrested Gersson Smeck carrying a 9 mm caliber weapon, was released reserves of the law and gave sight to the Secretariat of National Defense regarding the permit to carry a firearm with that account.

    The Israeli Ben Zvi was admitted to the Men's Prison north slope that will resolve their legal status, as likely responsible for the commission of crimes of violation of the General Population Act, provided for and punished by Articles 123 and 143 General Population Act, all in connection with the 6th. And 7th., Section 1, 8. 9th and 13th, Fraction II of the Federal Penal Code, which start is given to the relevant criminal proceedings.

    Replies: @Ron Unz

    , @Boomstick
    @Ron Unz

    The Google translation of what is claimed to be the Mexican government account:

    "THE PGR INFORMS ABOUT THE SITUATION OF INDIVIDUALS ARRESTED IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
    Regarding the situation of the 2 subjects detained last Wednesday near the Legislative Palace of San Lazaro, the Attorney General's Office reports that the Israeli citizen Saer Ben-Zvi and Saar Noam Ben Zvi was made available to the First Court of "A" Federal Criminal Proceedings in Mexico City, Distrito while the Mexican Salvador Gersson Smeck will release order issued stocks with the law, because no items were found for your consignment.
    Under that when he was arrested Gersson Smeck carrying a 9 mm caliber weapon, was released reserves of the law and gave sight to the Secretariat of National Defense regarding the permit to carry a firearm with that account.
    The Israeli Ben Zvi was admitted to the Men's Prison north slope that will resolve their legal status, as likely responsible for the commission of crimes of violation of the General Population Act, provided for and punished by Articles 123 and 143 General Population Act, all in connection with the 6th. And 7th., Section 1, 8. 9th and 13th, Fraction II of the Federal Penal Code, which start is given to the relevant criminal proceedings. [1]"

    One guy licensed to carry a Glock, one guy arrested for immigration problems.

    Replies: @bunga, @bunga

  240. @Thin-Skinned Masta-Beta
    Some had speculated that FDR had intelligence warning about the imminent attack in Pearl Harbor, but chose to do nothing in order to motivate an isolationist public to join the charge into war.

    I am still constantly hearing about ridiculous conspiracy theories that those attacks in 2001 were an inside job false flag operation. In this case the theories are absurd because the US has never needed such an extreme casus belli to go to war. Some other trumped up incident would have been sufficient to mobilize the public and the troops. It's not that I don't believe in conspiracies by the powerful. Rather I'm convinced that many conspiracies are so effective and remain secret that the public would never imagine or suspect what happened. The more ridiculous stories keep the usual suspects distracted from investigating the real ones and undermine any of their credibility if they ever do stumble upon anything real. In this case, what if it wasn't exactly an inside job but rather that the Israelis had reliable intelligence about the likelihood of that attack but chose not to pursue the leads very diligently or aggressively?

    Replies: @tbraton

    But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers. I’m generally not one who subscribes to conspiracy theories, but, when faced with such disturbing, inexplicable facts, one has to conclude that we don’t have the entire story.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @tbraton


    But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers. I’m generally not one who subscribes to conspiracy theories, but, when faced with such disturbing, inexplicable facts, one has to conclude that we don’t have the entire story.
     
    Have you ever looked this up to see how an expert would answer your query? It seems that they ahve put a lot of effort into it and are very well-informed of the technical details. Why would they lie?

    http://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/design/a3524/4278874/

    Replies: @Truth

    , @Mr. Anon
    @tbraton

    "But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner."

    Do you know anything - anything at all - about WTC 7 other than what you saw on a grainy YouTube video? And if it was all part of some vast conspiracy, why didn't the conspirators fly a plane into WTC 7, to complete the illusion? They forgot? Oops.........We wanted to engineer the destruction of these three buildings and make people believe that it was due to airplanes, but we forgot to fly an airplane into one of them.

    Replies: @Truth

    , @tanabear
    @tbraton

    tbraton: "World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers..."

    It wasn't entirely identical. The North and South towers were destroyed top-down. Word Trade Tower 7 was more of a conventional looking demolition; but still a masterpiece of demolition science.

    The phrase "conspiracy theory" is just used as an ad hominem. What explanation best fits the available evidence? It certainly isn't the official account.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

    , @Mr. Anon
    @tbraton

    "But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers."

    WTC was directly adjacent to the collapsing WTC 1; it was hosed down by debris. It also burned for the better part of the day, and not little fires either. Take a look at these pictures, which the "Truther" crowd never talks about., as they do not fit their narrative.

    WTC 7 Fires

  241. @D. K.
    @This Is Our Home

    Yes, but to the best of my knowledge, the suspicious warning to Odigo employees, which I posted a link about, above, has never been explained, let alone explained away...!?!

    Here is that link, again, to a news story, from Israel itself, published fifteen days after 9/11:

    http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/odigo-says-workers-were-warned-of-attack-1.70579

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    Two Israel-based employees, in Israel(!), of a company which did not have an office in the towers received a message warning them of a terrorist attack on somewhere….that’s not even a coincidence, it is entirely unrelated.

    http://www.911myths.com/index.php/Odigo

    • Replies: @D. K.
    @This Is Our Home

    This, below, is the entire Ha'aretz article, copy and pasted directly from its own Web site:

    ***

    Odigo, the instant messaging service, says that two of its workers received messages two hours before the Twin Towers attack on September 11 predicting the attack would happen, and the company has been cooperating with Israeli and American law enforcement, including the FBI, in trying to find the original sender of the message predicting the attack.

    Yuval Dror 26.09.2001 00:00 Updated: 12:43 AM

    Odigo, the instant messaging service, says that two of its workers received messages two hours before the Twin Towers attack on September 11 predicting the attack would happen, and the company has been cooperating with Israeli and American law enforcement, including the FBI, in trying to find the original sender of the message predicting the attack.

    Micha Macover, CEO of the company, said the two workers received the messages and immediately after the terror attack informed the company's management, which immediately contacted the Israeli security services, which brought in the FBI.

    "I have no idea why the message was sent to these two workers, who don't know the sender. It may just have been someone who was joking and turned out they accidentally got it right. And I don't know if our information was useful in any of the arrests the FBI has made," said Macover. Odigo is a U.S.-based company whose headquarters are in New York, with offices in Herzliya.

    As an instant messaging service, Odigo users are not limited to sending messages only to people on their "buddy" list, as is the case with ICQ, the other well-known Israeli instant messaging application.

    Odigo usually zealously protects the privacy of its registered users, said Macover, but in this case the company took the initiative to provide the law enforcement services with the originating Internet Presence address of the message, so the FBI could track down the Internet Service Provider, and the actual sender of the original message.

    http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/odigo-says-workers-were-warned-of-attack-1.70579

    ***

    Do you notice anything that has been added to the article, in the source that you cite? Should we trust your source, or the actual newspaper's own Web site? If the warning was non-specific, and sent to employees in Israel, rather than to employees at the company's New York headquarters, a stone's throw from Ground Zero, why were they making such a fuss about it, both in Israel and in the United Sates, and why has the actual text of the message never been published, to squelch the rumors that nearby workers, in downtown Manhattan, had received such a warning, a couple of hours before the attacks on the World Trade Center Twin Towers? Why has the sender never been publicly identified, and his explanation for the message expounded? Even if the two Odigo employees who received the message were located in Israel-- whether permanently or merely at the time-- did the message, whatever it actually said, specify an attack in Israel, Manhattan, or nowhere in the world in particular?

    Replies: @D. K., @D. K.

  242. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Steve Sailer
    @Rurik

    Thanks, now can you find the NYT article the Fox article is citing?

    I'm not saying they got it wrong -- like I said, in reading this old article from ABC News, I was surprised to learn how serious the FBI was about interrogating these guys, like 40 days in solitary.

    Replies: @Rurik, @This Is Our Home

    Thanks, now can you find the NYT article the Fox article is citing?

    I’m not saying they got it wrong — like I said, in reading this old article from ABC News, I was surprised to learn how serious the FBI was about interrogating these guys, like 40 days in solitary

    I have found the New York Time article quoted here: http://www.911myths.com/index.php/Dancing_Israelis

    It helpfully comes with a lot of other information that makes this all look silly. Not that a theory like this needs to be made to look sillier.

    If I needed to document 9/11, having planned it. I would set up a camera from inside a closed apartment window and leave it set up. I certainly wouldn’t send five Israeli bums to party on down in a very visible location with money in a sock…indeed I wouldn’t even document it, as the rest of the world would do that for me, and what would I gain?

    I especially wouldn’t have my hobo spies go on television and admit to it!

    The 9/11 truth movement is a cancer on alternative politics in the West. It sucks the life out of any feasible movement and slurs all of us by association. Donald Trump avoids this slur because he never gives succour to it and he obviously is not part of it, even if the insaniacs somehow believe that he is secretly messaging them. The 9/11 ‘theory’ can only be believed by those who have never organised anything even as big as a bake sale…

    This means that not only is the message polluted but because the message is now largely the messenger, our message is associated with a toxic mixture of self-aggrandising liars and the obviously crazy.

    You should not ban these guys, but please do not entertain them.

    God, I wish I might recommend your blog to others but some things are just too hard to recover from being associated with. Unz.com is now not only the site for opinions rendered taboo by the PC zeitgeist but also for opinions so utterly nuts that the zeitgeist rejects them too; can we not save it for infowars.com or some other place that has been telling the US population that they’ll be in FEMA camps tomorrow for the past 15 years?

    Courses of action could include:

    1. A mirror site with no comments; which is technically easy.

    2. A mirror site with conspiracy nonsense comments moderated out; which would take more time but would be more useful.

    3. You address this type of thinking in your blog posts; which would cover a generally interesting topic but may distract you from bigger things. Still, you have greater experience of this type of thinking than the majority of public intellectuals.

    • Replies: @Rurik
    @This Is Our Home


    I especially wouldn’t have my hobo spies go on television and admit to it!
     
    but yet they did Robert

    and to Steve's point, if these guys were a joke, why did the FBI keep them for so long?

    are the FBI also "self-aggrandising liars and the obviously crazy"?

    .

    BTW. I posted a reply here to someone regarding the video of George Bush describing his reaction to seeing the FIRST plane hit the tower, but it wasn't published, so don't worry Robert, there is some censorship going on here ; )

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    , @Ron Unz
    @This Is Our Home


    This means that not only is the message polluted but because the message is now largely the messenger, our message is associated with a toxic mixture of self-aggrandising liars and the obviously crazy.

    You should not ban these guys, but please do not entertain them.

    God, I wish I might recommend your blog to others but some things are just too hard to recover from being associated with. Unz.com is now not only the site for opinions rendered taboo by the PC zeitgeist but also for opinions so utterly nuts that the zeitgeist rejects them too
     
    I really like it when some random, anonymous ultra-right-wing Internet nut suddenly shows up here and within a couple of weeks is telling everyone how the entire website should be completely changed. As far as I can see, you're mostly interested in fanatically denouncing Muslims and "anti-Semites" so maybe you're just Whiskey's long-lost brother or something...

    Replies: @AnonymousCoward, @This Is Our Home

  243. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @tbraton
    @Thin-Skinned Masta-Beta

    But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers. I'm generally not one who subscribes to conspiracy theories, but, when faced with such disturbing, inexplicable facts, one has to conclude that we don't have the entire story.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon, @tanabear, @Mr. Anon

    But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers. I’m generally not one who subscribes to conspiracy theories, but, when faced with such disturbing, inexplicable facts, one has to conclude that we don’t have the entire story.

    Have you ever looked this up to see how an expert would answer your query? It seems that they ahve put a lot of effort into it and are very well-informed of the technical details. Why would they lie?

    http://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/design/a3524/4278874/

    • Replies: @Truth
    @This Is Our Home


    Why would they lie?
     
    The "expert" who original edited this article is the is the Brother of Michael Chertoff, who at the time was the acting Director of Homeland Security.

    Maybe that's why.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Hunsdon

  244. @Mike Sylwester
    I live in Bergen County, New Jersey. Today the county's newspaper, The Record, published an interesting article about the accusations that local Moslems celebrated the 9/11 attacks.

    Most of the accusations were about Moslems in Jersey City, which is in Hudson County, and Paterson, which is in Passaic County. Since Bergen County is between those two counties, The Record actively investigated the accusations.

    On that day, 9/11, there indeed was a "deluge" of accusations from local people who said they personally saw such celebrations. Many such accusations were reported and discussed on local talk-radio stations. So, accusations about celebrating Moslems were exceptionally intense in this geographic area.

    Law enforcement officials, civil rights advocates and news reporters who were working in the immediate aftermath of the attacks said Monday that they were deluged with calls and emails from people who claimed to have witnessed celebrations in Jersey City and Paterson, but that they had found no persuasive evidence to back up any of those accounts.

    .... the rumors were started when people called in reported sightings of Muslims celebrating in New Jersey to a New York City talk radio station. ....

    The Record ... reported on Sept 13, 2001, that rumors of Muslim celebrations were unfounded but that the story had been difficult to dispel, “moving briskly through e-mails, telephone conversations, and at least one radio show.”

    John Chadwick, a former Record reporter, said he went to Paterson at least three times on that Sept. 12 to check out dozens of tips that Muslims were celebrating, only to find the streets vacated and most of the stores closed.

    “I’ve never experienced such a disconnect,” Chadwick said. “Not only was there no celebration, there was like nobody around. The shops seemed to be closed. There was nobody on the streets. I sensed that people were just scared.”

    For days afterward, Chadwick said, he continued to receive emails from readers who said they had seen televised reports of celebrations and wanted to know why the paper was not covering it.

    “I would try to respond, ‘ If you saw this, let us know what channel was it? What was the news source?” Chadwick said. “Nobody ever came forward.” ...

    [Jerry] Spagnola, the former Paterson police chief, traced the origin of the story to television news reports shortly after the attacks that showed images of people protesting in the Middle East then flashed to pictures of empty streets in Paterson, where announcers explained, there is a large Muslim population. ....
     
    http://www.northjersey.com/news/trump-s-comments-of-9-11-celebrations-in-n-j-renew-long-standing-debate-1.1461485

    Replies: @Mike Sylwester

    Yesterday, I collected from the Internet the following statements of people about Moslems seen celebrating in New Jersey on 9/11.

    I drove with family members though Patterson, N.J. that morning, after the planes hit. It’s not the kind of thing you forget. We witnessed people in traditional Muslim garb dancing, jumping, shouting and celebrating like their team had won the Super Bowl, just as Trump said.

    I didn’t see thousands of Muslims celebrating but I absolutely saw a pocket, perhaps 100, jumping for joy at the sight of the smoke rising from where the Twin Towers used to be. …. these events were a commonly accepted fact by Jerseyans.

    ——–

    I had my business on Pennsylvania Ave in Paterson, N.J. I saw people on Crooks Ave. and Main Street cheering and raising Middle Eastern flags.

    I’ll tell you exactly where I was. I had stopped in at Biggs bagels on crooks ave by the railroad tracks. I was wondering why all these crazy people were cheering. Find out a few minutes later America was under attack. I saw it with my own eyes.

    I witnessed pure evil. Donald Trump is right.”

    ——–

    What was happening is that they were in stores or small gathering cheering and when they were noticed they stopped. that is what happened when my sister saw them after she got gas and looked in the store to find someone to pay. she saw them gathered around a tv cheering and jumping up and down. When they saw her they stopped, I am sure that’s what a lot of people are talking about. Many were seen celebrating. So the police would not have been aware, as in my sister’s case. I had heard many stories like that throughout New Jersey.

    ——-

    They were in the streets banging on the cars trying to drive through the crowd in the street. The muslims were shouting death to Americans and allah is great [and] other crap I didn’t understand. We were amused until a car with 3 young women mistakenly turned on to main st.

    The muslims were banging on their windows and screaming, thats when we came out of our car and pushed the muslims off their car helped them back out and get back to the parkway.

    ——-

    I experienced/ witnessed many incidents of Muslims celebrating 9/11 in North Brunswick. I was in a grocery store when I heard the plane crashed on the store radio. The Muslim man in line next to me turned and spit on me. I’ll never forget it.

    ——-

    I live in Hudson County. It did happen in West New York. Saw it with my own eyes. I don’t need a media outlet to tell me what I witnessed just a few feet from me. People in cars, honking they’re horns and waiving their flags.

    ——

    I saw black and Arab people in NEWARK PATH MARK SUPERMARKET – dancing and cheering as the TOWERS BURNED !!! and in JERSEY CITY – pockets of people in the streets shouting and laughing – TRUMP IS CORRECT

    ——-

    So when I was driving a bus threw paterson that day in the morning to see it and other people seen as well ..does it mean we where dreaming of what took place…

    ——–

    I saw it FIRST HAND! I drove an ambulance all over NJ. They were celebrating in the streets. I always wonder why they were never rounded up and sent to their homeland.

    ——-

    It absolutely happened in Paterson. The police even had some of the streets closed off to traffic because of it. I was in Paterson on the 12th for business and the whole area around Crooks Avenue was covered in people celebrating.

    ———-

    Want proof that Muslims celebrated as they heard of 9/11 attacks? 100s of young men laughing, dancing, cheering; I saw them.

    ———-

    The Muslims were celebrating until they realized the backlash soon to follow. I saw it.

    ———-

    I saw it, too. The day and age we live in doesn’t change the fact that Muslims did in fact party after 9/11 in jersey city. Love or hate trump, it happened

    ———-

    There is a service station in my town, near Edison, NJ, it was owned by Muslims at the time of 9-11. Many members of our community saw the workers there celebrating that day. That station was shunned by the locals as word spread and was eventually sold to new owners.

    [follow-up comment:]

    I’m a liberal Democrat and I saw the same thing from the Palestinian workers on 30th Street and 11th Avenue gas service station. Its closed now.

    ———-

    I lived and grew up in South Paterson NJ. I knew lots of people in law enforcement. Someone I knew at the time from the Passaic County’s Prosecutors office told me that there were hundreds of people dancing in the streets when the Towers were attacked. Moreover, Paterson police were keeping people out of the city lest they felt it appropriate to attack some of the revelers. ….

    ———-

    I was a volunteer firefighter sent to the Hoboken FD to cover their turf while they were in NYC. I saw it with my own eyes while going through Jersey City too.

    ———-

    I lived in northwest nj…and yes, they were celebrating in patterson…not thousands but a couple of hundred…. WE SAW IT and will NEVER forget it!

    ———-

    It certainly did happen! I worked in Jersey City that day!

    ———-

    I actually saw them in Patterson NJ. I was one of the people who had to hold back fellow firefighters from going back there to fight with them.

    ———-

    I work in Paterson New Jersey. Many residents I’ve spoken to recently remember the celebrations that day. 2 were police officers called to protect the Muslims from others who were upset by the display. They (Muslims) danced and cheered. They still live here.

    ———-

    I was there. I saw it too. I was working in Hoboken, and drove through Jersey City and Newark back and forth to my home. Muslims were there. They were celebrating.

    ———-

    I do remember seeing this. This is one of those politically incorrect things we want to forget about 9/11. …. I do remember those Muslims who were celebrating and chanting/yelling in the streets in New Jersey. To say they represented all Muslims is a lie. To say they did not exist is also a lie.

    ———-

    I lived in Hoboken at the time and while I didn’t witness these celebrations, I know plenty of people (i.e. former co-workers) who did.

    ———-

    This is true the people of Jersey City took to the streets in riot on Journal Square the reports where telling people to stay away.

    ———-

    Yes he is right I live in NJ and witnessed children stomping on a flag that fell off a car while their parents laughed . Let the truth be told

    ———-

    I saw in Paterson, N.J. about 30 to 50 men yelling and cheering in the street.waving their flags…

    ———-

    I lived in Staten Island new york at the time of 911 attacks …. Later that day, i went to liquor store on forest ave. There were young Muslim men, on the roof toop, waving a flag, as I enter the store about 5 young men, Muslims were smiling and dancing as they gave me candy. …. I latter went into a small grouciers store on Muslim men young and old were cheering when they were listen to the radio. ….

    http://nj1015.com/former-gov-difrancesco-i-dont-remember-people-celebrating-911-in-nj/

    https://www.facebook.com/nj1015/posts/10153456648123451

    http://www.bizpacreview.com/2015/11/23/live-jersey-trump-right-muslims-celebrate-911-nj-saw-277082

    http://www.northjersey.com/news/trump-s-comments-of-9-11-celebrations-in-n-j-renew-long-standing-debate-1.1461485

    • Replies: @James Kabala
    @Mike Sylwester

    "The police even had some of the streets closed off to traffic because of it."

    How can this not be documented somewhere in a contemporaneous source if it is true? This claim, unlike most of the others, actually involves a public use of public resources that should have left some trace in the public record. (My overuse of the word "public" is deliberate.) If anyone thinks that this might be true, he should file a freedom of information request with the Paterson PD.

    You can talk all you want about the liberal media, but there were already early blogs, Yahoo and Usenet groups that often still have accessible archives, etc. You also have Fox News and (especially) the New York Post that would not have been inclined to join a cover-up (if not for true conservative principles, then at least for love of the sensationalistic).

    Replies: @D. K.

    , @KA
    @Mike Sylwester

    Around 911 incident , reports were coming of celebrations in Palestine territory and Saddam rejoicing at the sight of the plane striking twin towers but no one reported a single incident of any group pf Muslim celebrating this 911 incident either in US ,Canada,UK,or France .
    Even when Thomas Friedman falsely claimed that no one from Muslim countries had condemned the attack , this behavior supposedly from muslim in US was not told . I am sure he would have followed it up to show this if for nothing but for to prove this as an evidence of the silent invisible support of anger against US among Muslims

  245. I, for one, always carry five grand in cash with me, in case I have to pay “movers.” I just assumed everyone else does as well.

  246. “Ever watched The Americans? That’s why it was so “over the top”; they wanted to make sure you were born and raised here, and not living a cover story.”

    The worst ever FBI mole, Robert Hanssen, was born and raised in America.

    I saw a couple episodes of “The Americans”. It seemed ridiculous. I think it unlikely that it’s a realistic portrayal of espionage (for example, I imagine that murdering a defector in your own garage is not a very smart thing for a deep-cover agent to do). Yeah, the show has some former spooks as technical advisors. Technical advisors often just get ignored by writers, directors, and producers.

    Which episodes did you watch? The series gets much better as it goes on. The first season is mediocre, but it really ramps up after that. It’s now the most reactionary thing I’ve ever seen on TV, but with masterfully-crafted plausible deniability.

    But no, it’s not at all a realistic portrayal of espionage, which is something I suspect is impossible to do in an entertaining way. (And yes, there’s more cheesy kung-fu and butt-kicking-babe action than there needs to be, though it’s used pretty sparingly compared to schlock like Alias) You can have drama and action, or realistic espionage, but not both, at least not in a series that follows the same characters all the way through. Good spies lead exceptionally boring lives, at least as far as any observers are concerned. You should give it another chance.

    Even if they didn’t know an attack would or might happen, they still would have filmed it. Wouldn’t anyone? If they were engaged in surveilance they would have had video-cameras, and most people who had video-cameras on that that day, who weren’t in immediate danger, filmed what they could of the attacks.

    Sure, that’s plausible too. I have long since filed 9/11 and surrounding events into a folder titled, “We’ll Probably Never Know.”

  247. The thing you have to be able to do to see the reactionary* nature of The Americans is watch it in a detached way, and think about the episodes after you watch. If you’re someone who can’t stand back from what the totally-full-of-shit leftist characters are saying, and can’t watch them without rooting for them, you won’t be able to enjoy it. But if you can read between the lines, it’s great political TV, IMO. I think we’ll have confirmation or denial of my take on the show if it’s able to wrap up in an organized way, instead of being abruptly canceled (which is not at all a given, what with the show’s low ratings); the ultimate fate of the characters will tell us a lot.

    *Mostly reactionary in two senses: 1) I suspect the show-runner is simply presenting what he sees as the truth, and that winds up being reactionary in effect 2) showing both sides of the story is reactionary nowadays.

  248. @Big Bill
    The recruiting is pretty simple. An Israeli agent goes on tour of the USA speaking at synagogues around the country on some innocuous subject.

    The rabbi who coordinates each whistlestop identifies likely helpers in the congregation who would be amenable to helping out.

    When the agent arrives in town, he speaks to each potential recruit privately and feels them out to see if they are willing to help. Perhaps they could provide a cover job for an Israeli agent. Maybe supply the Mossad with letterhead or business cards to provide cover. Or agree to be a mail drop, receiving mail and setting it aside for someone to pick up later.

    Not every Jew will agree to help, of course. But the nice thing--the thing that makes such low-key recruiting quite safe--is that no Jew would ever rat out a fellow Jew, even if he turns down the request and declines to assist the Mossad.

    This safety is enhanced by Jewish religious law. Being a "moser" (one who rats out a fellow Jew to gentiles) is a death penalty offense.

    Google "mosrim death penalty".

    The same ethnic/racial solidarity also works for Muslim jihadis. This is why even "moderate" Muslims are an existential threat to the West. They can be counted on to look the other way and say nothing, particularly in Muslim ghettos like Molenbeek and Malmo.

    Mao got it right with his dictum about revolutionaries swimming through the local population like fish in the sea.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @SFG

    It might actually be a way to attract sayanim–perhaps they work with receptive rabbis, and you could probably find one or two in major metropolitan areas–but mosrim? You think dentists in Scarsdale and college professors in Newton are running around beheading anyone?

    I have no clue how Israeli intelligence cultivates sources, but I doubt expecting Temple Emanu-El in the Miami suburbs to rub people out is part of it.

  249. E.g., I defy anyone with any sense of how leftist the media is, and how audience-manipulation in American media works, to watch The Americans’ depiction of the South African storyline and tell me that wasn’t one of the most right-wing things on TV, ever. But at the same time, completely deniable.

    • Replies: @Truth
    @Svigor


    The Americans’ depiction of the South African storyline and tell me that wasn’t one of the most right-wing things on TV, ever.

     

    I agree. That plus the storyline where she was porking the knee-grow.
  250. Rediger, SFG: is it really hard to imagine that for a sophisticated bunch like the Jews, “death penalty” evolved into “social death penalty”? Why so obtuse?

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Svigor


    Rediger, SFG: is it really hard to imagine that for a sophisticated bunch like the Jews, “death penalty” evolved into “social death penalty”? Why so obtuse?
     
    The Jews I know mostly hang out with non-Jews. Not sure if they'd much care if some other Jews shunned them. Maybe their grandparents would, but do people that old really socialise much?

    Even if they swam in a school of only Jews, how would it work? Mossad would instruct their friends to ignore them? Why wouldn't they be aggrieved and sell their story to the paper? And why would their friends listen to a Mossad agent over their friends.

    The whole thing just seems beyond unlikely.

    While I'm sure that Israel can persuade some ordinary Jews to help them with small stuff (who doesn't want to be a spy?) the rest of your stuff just seems otherworldly to me.

    Have you met any Jews? They're pretty normal people (minus the black uniformed bearded lot.)
    , @SFG
    @Svigor

    Because they're not the same thing. There's always some guy who flies off the handle and goes off the reservation. 'Don't talk about Mossad or all your friends will ignore you' is not enough to keep *some* guy from squealing. If Mossad was actually going to hunt you down like the Mafia, that would be something else.

    I'm not saying Mossad doesn't assassinate people--we know they do. I'm saying it's unlikely Jewish identity is strong enough every single person is going to keep secret the Israelis asking them for favors. Probably they're smart enough to know who to ask. Do you actually know any Jews? Lots of people drift away, and 70% outmarry by now.

  251. @SPMoore8
    @Anonymous

    German Burger King franchise Do they serve their Whoppers on Kaiser rolls?

    Replies: @SFG, @Ozymandias

    “German Burger King franchise Do they serve their Whoppers on Kaiser rolls?”

    They’re available on the local menu in Hamburg.


    There’s a photo out there somewhere showing the base of #7 before it fell. The rubble field from the collapsed tower destroyed about a third of 7’s footprint, and after hours of uncontrolled burning it was expected to fall. Nothing unusual about it. And you know, if you wanted to take down a tower, recruiting Islamic fundamentalists to fly a plane into it is a much better plan than a surreptitious demolition. The initial explosion will blow the fire proofing off, and the resulting fire is more than hot enough to weaken the structure (ignoring any insane arguments about “melting point”).

    • Replies: @SPMoore8
    @Ozymandias

    Apropos of the second part of your comment, I will weigh in on 9/11 briefly, if you don't mind.

    I didn't see the planes hit but I watched the scene for about an hour, I was stuck in traffic. Actually I didn't want to watch. I glanced over once in awhile.

    Black gray smoke rose from both up to the convection layer and then moved south. I knew about a half dozen people who worked there, most survived, partly because they were late or had the day off. I remember when the smoke turned white on South Tower that was a good thing; it meant the fire was under control, or so I thought. The building bent over and collapsed straight down about 10 minutes later. By the time the second tower collapsed there was already so much smoke you could hardly see what was happening.

    I don't think there's any big mystery. The North tower had the top ten floors collapse on the the remainder, the force just knocked out the rest like dominoes. South tower, from where I was in Jersey, seemed to bend over to the South -- I thought I was hallucinating -- but then the force of 30-40 floors reestablished itself straight up down and then down.

    I don't think there's a big mystery to what happened. It's clear that pilot #2 almost missed his target. The fire weakened the supports for the upper floors, and they came down with increasing force due to the velocity of the fall. I think the terrorists may have thought they might "knock them over", I don't think they expected them to collapse the way they did.

    It's possible that some intelligence service(s) had some vague warning of something before the attack. I think that's at least as possible as foreknowledge of a possible Japanese attack in December, 1941. That would be about it.

    Replies: @Dave Pinsen

  252. @This Is Our Home
    @Seth Largo

    If you broke the law, just tell the truth.

    Replies: @donut, @ShaslA, @SFG

    Doesn’t work like that.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @ShaslA

    I guess it depends how badly you broke the law. I'm pretty sure you can have downloaded music illegally etc.

  253. @ben tillman
    @Anonymous


    I can’t believe there are so many questions surrounding 9/11 and Israeli involvement, and nobody in power seems the least bit interested in getting to the bottom of it.

    It’s truly a mystery.
     
    The PNACkers were the prime suspects, and their network extended into the government, so it's natural to suspect some government involvement, especially in view of otherwise hard-to-explain facts like the failure of the military to intercept the hijacked planes and the government's decision to destroy the crime scene so quickly.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “The PNACkers were the prime suspects, and their network extended into the government, so it’s natural to suspect some government involvement, especially in view of otherwise hard-to-explain facts like the failure of the military to intercept the hijacked planes and the government’s decision to destroy the crime scene so quickly.”

    The government did not destroy the crime scene. They hauled the debris somewhere else. They do the same thing with every single airplane crash.

    And I have never understood the fixation on the fact that the government didn’t shoot down the planes. It was an extraordinary event. And no matter what people – even military people do – in wargaming and exercises and the like – people don’t really expect things like that to happen. If Air Force pilots had robot-like followed orders to shoot down planes full of innocent people…………would that make you feel better? Would it make you feel better about the US military and government if they were quick to issue and follow orders like that?

    • Replies: @ben tillman
    @Mr. Anon


    And I have never understood the fixation on the fact that the government didn’t shoot down the planes. It was an extraordinary event. And no matter what people – even military people do – in wargaming and exercises and the like – people don’t really expect things like that to happen. If Air Force pilots had robot-like followed orders to shoot down planes full of innocent people…………would that make you feel better?
     
    Intercepting and shooting down are different things. And the fact that you are unaware of the government's explanation for the failure to intercept should tell you that you don't know the full story -- not even the full *official* story.

    The government did not destroy the crime scene. They hauled the debris somewhere else. They do the same thing with every single airplane crash.
     
    No, they've never done the same thing with any other airplane crash because there never was any airplane crash for which they could do the same thing. These crashes, taken together, were unique.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    , @Ron Unz
    @Mr. Anon

    FYI...

    https://www.unz.com/article/911-the-mother-of-all-coincidences/

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

  254. @tbraton
    @Thin-Skinned Masta-Beta

    But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers. I'm generally not one who subscribes to conspiracy theories, but, when faced with such disturbing, inexplicable facts, one has to conclude that we don't have the entire story.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon, @tanabear, @Mr. Anon

    “But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner.”

    Do you know anything – anything at all – about WTC 7 other than what you saw on a grainy YouTube video? And if it was all part of some vast conspiracy, why didn’t the conspirators fly a plane into WTC 7, to complete the illusion? They forgot? Oops………We wanted to engineer the destruction of these three buildings and make people believe that it was due to airplanes, but we forgot to fly an airplane into one of them.

    • Replies: @Truth
    @Mr. Anon


    why didn’t the conspirators fly a plane into WTC 7, to complete the illusion? They forgot?
     
    Just taking a shot in the dark here: Because they knew that guys like you were going to believe it anyway?

    BTW Welcome back Grasshopper. Or maybe I was the one who left?

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

  255. @AnotherDad
    @Dave Pinsen


    I would think Israel’s laxity regarding that post-Soviet wave was intentional. Israel’s leaders likely saw it as a demographic bulwark against Arabs as well as against Mizrahi Jews.
     
    Do these truly non-Jewish Russians actually stick in Israel? I'd think almost all of them who don't identify as Jewish would have tried to get on the US. (There sure seem to be a heck of a lot of Russians--and other ex-Soviets--swarming around these days.) Israel seems like a nice place, but it's a nice place for a particular people. If you don't really identify as Jewish i don't see why you'd stick there.

    ~~~

    Not up on things Israeli, but my very rough take:
    -- they've gotten the Arab fertility down now to near replacement--and they can always decide (at high political cost) to toss Arabs out.
    -- their long term demographic future is most endangered by the Haredi who have incredibly high (African level) fertility but are absolute parasites, sucking up welfare and (legally) dodging military service; they used to be trivial but are now broaching 10% of the population and will rapidly expand--given their fertility--beyond that

    I hate parasites--high, low and in-between. They are a cancer. They suck the life from nations and need to be rooted out, suppressed or tossed out. I don't keep up with Israeli affairs--not my people--but i haven't heard that normal secular\religious Israelis have devised any coherent plan to deal with this menace.

    Replies: @Karl, @bomag

    In the ongoing massive social experiment on planet Earth the plan to deal with population is to turn everyone into a modern Progressive and thus sterilize them. Not everyone is going to go along, so we will see how it works out.

  256. @Arturo
    Gentlemen :

    The coincidences just keep piling up.

    I am surprised no one has mentioned yet the "E-Team" :

    http://robscholtemuseum.nl/mark-dotzler-thoughts-on-the-wtc-artists/

    This was a group of Israeli Art students who were given exclusive access to seven critical stories of the WTC north tower to perform an "art installation" that consisted among other things of the giant office-window billboard spelling out "E TEAM", and an actual balcony they installed for a few hours by removing a pane of glass.

    This is the real deal people, it's getting hotter.

    Even the NYT wrote about the E-team and their 91st-floor balcony :

    http://www.nytimes.com/2001/08/18/nyregion/balcony-scene-unseen-atop-world-episode-trade-center-assumes-mythic-qualities.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm

    There's a lot of Israeli art students and e-team (explosives team?) stuff on crimes of the times today.

    One thing that is absolutely freaking me out :

    The boxes and boxes and boxes of BB 18 on the 91st floor of the Israeli art students E-Team project.

    Prepare to get spooked :

    http://www.littelfuse.com/products/fuse-blocks-fuseholders-and-fuse-accessories/dead-front-fuse-holders/powr-busbar/bb18.aspx

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @slumber_j

    “This was a group of Israeli Art students who were given exclusive access to seven critical stories of the WTC north tower to perform an “art installation”…”

    They were not Israeli; they were Austrian.

    “The boxes and boxes and boxes of BB 18 on the 91st floor of the Israeli art students E-Team project.

    Prepare to get spooked :

    http://www.littelfuse.com/products/fuse-blocks-fuseholders-and-fuse-accessories/dead-front-fuse-holders/powr-busbar/bb18.aspx”

    Yeah – that’s real spooky to anyone who thinks that electricity is magic. Those aren’t bomb fuse holders (I don’t think there even is such a thing) – they are electric fuse holders – common power distribution equipment, of the kind one might typically find in a power-panel in an office building. It is not surprising that there would be empty boxes for that stuff laying around.

    Everything is a mystery to the stupid.

  257. BobX [AKA "Bob who~thinks Ron pats his own back to soon"] says:
    @Ron Unz
    @AnonymousCoward


    You can also find the archived version of the official, Mexican govt. site confirming the explosives.
     
    Excellent. It's always nice to confirm that my memory wasn't playing tricks on me after so many years.

    Replies: @BobX, @Boomstick

    Ron

    I don’t think the link AC provides is all he claims it to be. The web archive link refers to “a 9 mm caliber weapon”. You value the Pravda link for what you think it is worth.

    Google translate of text from link:

    THE PGR INFORMS ABOUT SITUATION
    SUBJECT ARRESTED IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
     
    Regarding the situation of the 2 subjects detained last Wednesday near the Legislative Palace of San Lazaro, the Attorney General’s Office reports that the Israeli citizen Saer Ben-Zvi and Saar Noam Ben Zvi was made available to the First Court of “A” Federal Criminal Proceedings in Mexico City, Distrito while the Mexican Salvador Gersson Smeck will release order issued stocks with the law, because no items were found for your consignment.

    Under that when he was arrested Gersson Smeck carrying a 9 mm caliber weapon, was released reserves of the law and gave sight to the Secretariat of National Defense regarding the permit to carry a firearm with that account.

    The Israeli Ben Zvi was admitted to the Men’s Prison north slope that will resolve their legal status, as likely responsible for the commission of crimes of violation of the General Population Act, provided for and punished by Articles 123 and 143 General Population Act, all in connection with the 6th. And 7th., Section 1, 8. 9th and 13th, Fraction II of the Federal Penal Code, which start is given to the relevant criminal proceedings.

    • Replies: @Ron Unz
    @BobX


    I don’t think the link AC provides is all he claims it to be. The web archive link refers to “a 9 mm caliber weapon”. You value the Pravda link for what you think it is worth.
     
    Well, I don't recall looking at any Mexican government website or reading something from Russian Pravda. What I read was a translation of one of the big articles in a leading Mexican newspaper, and I'm pretty sure it mentioned explosives or maybe hand grenades and electrical wiring as well as a handgun. Admittedly, that was almost ten years ago, but a few years back I noticed that some "conspiracy nuts" had scanned one of those Mexican front-page banner-headline stories and put the entire thing up on their website, so maybe it's still floating around somewhere.

    Anyway, regarding this sort of thing I'd much more trust an account in Russian Pravda than in American Pravda. But if you prefer to believe that everything you read about "controversial" subjects in The New York Times is 100% accurate, be my guest...
  258. @Ron Unz
    @AnonymousCoward


    You can also find the archived version of the official, Mexican govt. site confirming the explosives.
     
    Excellent. It's always nice to confirm that my memory wasn't playing tricks on me after so many years.

    Replies: @BobX, @Boomstick

    The Google translation of what is claimed to be the Mexican government account:

    “THE PGR INFORMS ABOUT THE SITUATION OF INDIVIDUALS ARRESTED IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
    Regarding the situation of the 2 subjects detained last Wednesday near the Legislative Palace of San Lazaro, the Attorney General’s Office reports that the Israeli citizen Saer Ben-Zvi and Saar Noam Ben Zvi was made available to the First Court of “A” Federal Criminal Proceedings in Mexico City, Distrito while the Mexican Salvador Gersson Smeck will release order issued stocks with the law, because no items were found for your consignment.
    Under that when he was arrested Gersson Smeck carrying a 9 mm caliber weapon, was released reserves of the law and gave sight to the Secretariat of National Defense regarding the permit to carry a firearm with that account.
    The Israeli Ben Zvi was admitted to the Men’s Prison north slope that will resolve their legal status, as likely responsible for the commission of crimes of violation of the General Population Act, provided for and punished by Articles 123 and 143 General Population Act, all in connection with the 6th. And 7th., Section 1, 8. 9th and 13th, Fraction II of the Federal Penal Code, which start is given to the relevant criminal proceedings. [1]”

    One guy licensed to carry a Glock, one guy arrested for immigration problems.

    • Replies: @bunga
    @Boomstick

    From the PGR (Mexican Department Of Justice) official web site comes an interesting story.

    As reported in La Vox De Aztlan, two men, one of them a former Israeli Colonel and Mossad agent, were arrested INSIDE the Mexican congress carrying 9mm pistols and dynamite, but were released following intense pressure from the Israeli Embassy.

    Army General and Head of the PGR Releases Two Israelis
    Arrested With Guns and Explosives Inside the Mexican Congress
    By Ernesto Cienfuegos La Voz de Aztlan
    October 15, 2001

    LOS ANGELES (ACN) - In a mind-blowing development, La Voz de Aztlan has learned that Mexican Army General Rafael Marcial Macedo de la Concha who heads the Procuraduría General de la República (Mexican Department of Justice) has released the retired Israeli Defense Forces colonel and presumed MOSSAD agent Salvador Guersson Smecke and Israeli illegal immigrant Saur Ben Zvi after both had penetrated the security of the Mexican Congress and where in possession of guns, hand grenades and explosives.

    http://www.rense.com/general17/mossadagentsarrested.htm

    , @bunga
    @Boomstick

    In February of 2000, Indian intelligence officials detained 11 members of what they thought was an Al Qaeda hijacking conspiracy. It was then discovered that these 11 "Muslim preachers" were all Israeli nationals! India's leading weekly magazine, The Week, reported:

    On January 12 Indian intelligence officials in Calcutta detained 11 foreign nationals for interrogation before they were to board a Dhaka-bound Bangladesh Biman flight. They were detained on the suspicion of being hijackers. "But we realized that they were tabliqis (Islamic preachers), so we let them go", said an Intelligence official.

    The eleven had Israeli passports but were believed to be Afghan nationals who had spent a while in Iran. Indian intelligence officials, too, were surprised by the nationality profile of the eleven. "They say that they have been on tabligh (preaching Islam) in India for two months. But they are Israeli nationals from the West Bank," said a Central Intelligence official. He claimed that Tel Aviv "exerted considerable pressure" on Delhi to secure their release. "It appeared that they could be working for a sensitive organization in Israel and were on a mission to Bangladesh," the official said.

    The Week (India) Aborted Mission. Investigation: Did Mossad attempt to infiltrate Islamic radical outfits in south Asia? By Subir Bhaumik. February 6, 2000. Google users enter: muslim tabliqis mossad

    http://web.archive.org/web/20030210204900/http://www.the-week.com/20feb06/events2.htm

  259. @Mr. Anon
    @Rurik

    "I notice you didn’t consider my little blurt about how George Bush said publically (and on camera) that he saw the first plane hit WTC tower- curious. Did you know that? Does it matter to your mind if he said it or even if he did see it?"

    And what is so odd about that?

    "I don’t know where you stand on the whole 911 thing. A lot of people consider it prudent to not care too much. Perhaps it is. "

    A lot of people consider it prudent not to indulge in the kind of insanity that has largely come to characterizes the "Truther" movement.

    Replies: @Rurik

    George Bush said publically (and on camera) that he saw the first plane hit WTC tower- curious. Did you know that? Does it matter to your mind if he said it or even if he did see it?”

    And what is so odd about that?

    first plane

    let that sink in for a minute

    ok

    here, let me help

    here’s the video

    you can find it all over the Internet if you look, (or cared)

    but for people with a functioning brain, for George Bush to have seen the FIRST plane hit the tower, which he clearly did from what he says, then that means that he was watching a live video feed of the “terrorist” attacks on that day. Someone had a camera set up and Bush happened to be watching before he went into that classroom.

    the kind of insanity that has largely come to characterizes the “Truther” movement.

    insanity indeed

    it literally is a kind of insanity to watch building seven implode and tell yourself that is was office fires that did it

    or to see president George Bush talking about watching the FIRST plane hit the tower and consider it of no consequence

    rather I wouldn’t so much put it down to insanity as I would intellectual and moral cowardice

    ; )

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Rurik


    first plane

    let that sink in for a minute

    ok
     

    I thought I saw footage of the first plane hitting the tower. No idea if I did, and although I was a child at the time I was more articulate than GWB.

    But anyway, as with all gotchas, the alternative to GWB making a mistake and confusing his words is that he decided to tell everyone he knew about 9/11. The latter is rather less likely.

    I just don't get why you can't work that out for yourself before you become the object of ridicule?

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @Rurik

    , @Mr. Anon
    @Rurik

    "first plane

    let that sink in for a minute

    ok

    here, let me help

    here’s the video"

    In that video that you posted, he did NOT say it was the first plane. He only said that he saw a plane hit the tower. Watch it again - and listen.

    And even if he did say first plane, so what? There is video of the first plane hitting.

    Or do you imagine that Bush's Mossad handlers had a private video feed set up for him, so that he could watch as the most egregious crime in American history was carrie out, knowing full well that he was a willing participant? And then, after all that, he admitted his culpability?

    You "truther" guys must be autistic. Or you're just stupid. I really don't care anymore. You are all loathsome f**ks.

    "it literally is a kind of insanity to watch building seven implode and tell yourself that is was office fires that did it"

    You are willfully stupid. It wasn't just office fires. The building had a f**king diesel fuel bunker in it to power back-up generators. Add to that, it was scoured by debris from the first impacts, and it had a make-shift cantilever structure becuause it was built over a subway station.

    "rather I wouldn’t so much put it down to insanity as I would intellectual and moral cowardice"

    F**k you. You idiots are stupid and crazy. You aren't worth the time of day.

    Replies: @Rurik

  260. @Whiskey
    Re foreknowledge of the 9/11 attack. Well, yes, just as the French had a pretty good idea that something was coming in Paris before that most recent attack, and also before Charlie Hebdo. There was unusual jihadi behavior and chatter, and intelligence chiefs were nervous.

    Nothing was done because of PC. Anyone advocating action was tarred with Islamaphobia, and racism, so everyone just sat around. The action to be done was extremely tight border controls, interviews, massive mobilization of the police and security forces. Nothing like that could be done or would be done until after.

    Now, we either have a secret war like that against the OAS during De Gaulle's term, or simply deport lots of Muslims. I suspect neither will happen in the West, instead ever increasing Jihadi attacks because the killing is the point, of domination and control. Until things just snap.

    Reasonable reform measures that produce safety and security while not being horrible and vicious are impossible because of the dependency of the elite of bashing Bad Whites for social signaling and social unity; along with Muslim votes in Europe and Black votes in the US.

    Replies: @bomag

    Until things just snap

    Ha! More like the West just lies down and dies.

  261. @tbraton
    @Thin-Skinned Masta-Beta

    But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers. I'm generally not one who subscribes to conspiracy theories, but, when faced with such disturbing, inexplicable facts, one has to conclude that we don't have the entire story.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon, @tanabear, @Mr. Anon

    tbraton: “World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers…”

    It wasn’t entirely identical. The North and South towers were destroyed top-down. Word Trade Tower 7 was more of a conventional looking demolition; but still a masterpiece of demolition science.

    The phrase “conspiracy theory” is just used as an ad hominem. What explanation best fits the available evidence? It certainly isn’t the official account.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @tanabear


    The phrase “conspiracy theory” is just used as an ad hominem. What explanation best fits the available evidence? It certainly isn’t the official account.
     
    What is it then?

    Replies: @tanabear

    , @Mr. Anon
    @tanabear

    "The phrase “conspiracy theory” is just used as an ad hominem."

    Spare us your "ad hominem" bullshit. I bet that you are quite cool with the concept of ad hominem, as long as the hominem in question is a Jew.

  262. @Romanian
    @Stan D Mute


    Yeah, you should probably set your hopes a bit lower. I’ll be happy if my kids aren’t forced to pay jizya and the country still has indoor plumbing.
     
    You made me laugh out loud. There should be a thread like that.

    Seriously, yeah, space. Lots of potential disappointments there, but people who lived through the optimism of the 1960s and 1970s would know that a lot better than I. I'm sure Musk's companies pay some indirect protection money in the form of caterers and the like to compensate for the lack of melanin on-staff.

    Replies: @bomag

    Lots of potential disappointments there, but people who lived through the optimism of the 1960s and 1970s would know that a lot better than I.

    Pretty much the theme was that the gov’t shouldn’t countenance spending money on advancements in space while we had all these social problems on Earth, problems that will soon be solved if we could just spend more money on them.

    The social problems have shown themselves to be completely fractal, while our gov’t, via the various iron laws of bureaucracy, Peter principles, mass wasting, and general increase in entropy; has become much less able to get things done.

    The advances in tech, helped greatly by the Moon missions etc., has now made the current private sector efforts possible. Let’s hope it bears fruit.

    • Replies: @Romanian
    @bomag

    I read somewhere that AA activists actually drove a cart and mule to NASA's gates to protest the wasteful spending on the Apollo program? Maybe something Paul Kersey wrote?

    On Steve Sailer's recommendation, I read Christopher Caldwell's book, "Reflections on the Revolutions in Europe", which I found frustratingly impartial, like written by an alien observer. He had a line there about "moving from not being able to end welfare because the recipients are too weak, to not being able to end it because they are too strong".

    I think it's pretty obvious that continued mass migrations into Europe and US will quell basic scientific research and other advances, just like South Africa's space and nuclear program went to hell. The priorities simply change.

  263. @Charles Erwin Wilson
    @SFG

    Though he should be J-Ackass instead of J-Pod. His brays are pure and unmixed moonbattery.

    I would like to think he could be dissuaded from his stupidity. Reason and experience argue forcefully against that outcome.

    Replies: @TWS

    Pod the Lesser.

  264. WhatEvvs [AKA "Internet Addict"] says:
    @Hippopotamusdrome
    @WhatEvvs

    Counter protest at BLM protest. BLM'ers chase away counter protesters and pursue them down the street. Then pursuing party gets shot at.

    5 People Shot Near BLM Protest

    Replies: @WhatEvvs

    &@boomstick,

    Meanwhile, the original focus of the protest, Jamar Clark or some other such stupid name, beat his girlfriend so badly she needed surgery. I learned that from a random comment. No word on her from The NY Times.

  265. @This Is Our Home
    @Steve Sailer


    Thanks, now can you find the NYT article the Fox article is citing?

    I’m not saying they got it wrong — like I said, in reading this old article from ABC News, I was surprised to learn how serious the FBI was about interrogating these guys, like 40 days in solitary
     
    I have found the New York Time article quoted here: http://www.911myths.com/index.php/Dancing_Israelis

    It helpfully comes with a lot of other information that makes this all look silly. Not that a theory like this needs to be made to look sillier.

    If I needed to document 9/11, having planned it. I would set up a camera from inside a closed apartment window and leave it set up. I certainly wouldn't send five Israeli bums to party on down in a very visible location with money in a sock...indeed I wouldn't even document it, as the rest of the world would do that for me, and what would I gain?

    I especially wouldn't have my hobo spies go on television and admit to it!

    The 9/11 truth movement is a cancer on alternative politics in the West. It sucks the life out of any feasible movement and slurs all of us by association. Donald Trump avoids this slur because he never gives succour to it and he obviously is not part of it, even if the insaniacs somehow believe that he is secretly messaging them. The 9/11 'theory' can only be believed by those who have never organised anything even as big as a bake sale...

    This means that not only is the message polluted but because the message is now largely the messenger, our message is associated with a toxic mixture of self-aggrandising liars and the obviously crazy.

    You should not ban these guys, but please do not entertain them.

    God, I wish I might recommend your blog to others but some things are just too hard to recover from being associated with. Unz.com is now not only the site for opinions rendered taboo by the PC zeitgeist but also for opinions so utterly nuts that the zeitgeist rejects them too; can we not save it for infowars.com or some other place that has been telling the US population that they'll be in FEMA camps tomorrow for the past 15 years?

    Courses of action could include:

    1. A mirror site with no comments; which is technically easy.

    2. A mirror site with conspiracy nonsense comments moderated out; which would take more time but would be more useful.

    3. You address this type of thinking in your blog posts; which would cover a generally interesting topic but may distract you from bigger things. Still, you have greater experience of this type of thinking than the majority of public intellectuals.

    Replies: @Rurik, @Ron Unz

    I especially wouldn’t have my hobo spies go on television and admit to it!

    but yet they did Robert

    and to Steve’s point, if these guys were a joke, why did the FBI keep them for so long?

    are the FBI also “self-aggrandising liars and the obviously crazy”?

    .

    BTW. I posted a reply here to someone regarding the video of George Bush describing his reaction to seeing the FIRST plane hit the tower, but it wasn’t published, so don’t worry Robert, there is some censorship going on here ; )

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Rurik


    but yet they did Robert
     
    I take it you don't have a second language.

    and to Steve’s point, if these guys were a joke, why did the FBI keep them for so long?
     
    Due diligence? Because they were art scamming criminals? Because they didn't want to look easy on them? Because they were freaked out by the whole situation?

    All of these explanations are infinitely more plausible than your alternative.

    BTW. I posted a reply here to someone regarding the video of George Bush describing his reaction to seeing the FIRST plane hit the tower, but it wasn’t published, so don’t worry Robert, there is some censorship going on here ; )
     
    So they kept it up until you, brave Rurik, pointed it out on Unz.com? Surely you're a troll, that is like a satire of paranoid schizophrenia.
  266. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Svigor
    Rediger, SFG: is it really hard to imagine that for a sophisticated bunch like the Jews, "death penalty" evolved into "social death penalty"? Why so obtuse?

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @SFG

    Rediger, SFG: is it really hard to imagine that for a sophisticated bunch like the Jews, “death penalty” evolved into “social death penalty”? Why so obtuse?

    The Jews I know mostly hang out with non-Jews. Not sure if they’d much care if some other Jews shunned them. Maybe their grandparents would, but do people that old really socialise much?

    Even if they swam in a school of only Jews, how would it work? Mossad would instruct their friends to ignore them? Why wouldn’t they be aggrieved and sell their story to the paper? And why would their friends listen to a Mossad agent over their friends.

    The whole thing just seems beyond unlikely.

    While I’m sure that Israel can persuade some ordinary Jews to help them with small stuff (who doesn’t want to be a spy?) the rest of your stuff just seems otherworldly to me.

    Have you met any Jews? They’re pretty normal people (minus the black uniformed bearded lot.)

  267. @ShaslA
    @This Is Our Home

    Doesn't work like that.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    I guess it depends how badly you broke the law. I’m pretty sure you can have downloaded music illegally etc.

  268. @Boomstick
    @Ron Unz

    The Google translation of what is claimed to be the Mexican government account:

    "THE PGR INFORMS ABOUT THE SITUATION OF INDIVIDUALS ARRESTED IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
    Regarding the situation of the 2 subjects detained last Wednesday near the Legislative Palace of San Lazaro, the Attorney General's Office reports that the Israeli citizen Saer Ben-Zvi and Saar Noam Ben Zvi was made available to the First Court of "A" Federal Criminal Proceedings in Mexico City, Distrito while the Mexican Salvador Gersson Smeck will release order issued stocks with the law, because no items were found for your consignment.
    Under that when he was arrested Gersson Smeck carrying a 9 mm caliber weapon, was released reserves of the law and gave sight to the Secretariat of National Defense regarding the permit to carry a firearm with that account.
    The Israeli Ben Zvi was admitted to the Men's Prison north slope that will resolve their legal status, as likely responsible for the commission of crimes of violation of the General Population Act, provided for and punished by Articles 123 and 143 General Population Act, all in connection with the 6th. And 7th., Section 1, 8. 9th and 13th, Fraction II of the Federal Penal Code, which start is given to the relevant criminal proceedings. [1]"

    One guy licensed to carry a Glock, one guy arrested for immigration problems.

    Replies: @bunga, @bunga

    From the PGR (Mexican Department Of Justice) official web site comes an interesting story.

    As reported in La Vox De Aztlan, two men, one of them a former Israeli Colonel and Mossad agent, were arrested INSIDE the Mexican congress carrying 9mm pistols and dynamite, but were released following intense pressure from the Israeli Embassy.

    Army General and Head of the PGR Releases Two Israelis
    Arrested With Guns and Explosives Inside the Mexican Congress
    By Ernesto Cienfuegos La Voz de Aztlan
    October 15, 2001

    LOS ANGELES (ACN) – In a mind-blowing development, La Voz de Aztlan has learned that Mexican Army General Rafael Marcial Macedo de la Concha who heads the Procuraduría General de la República (Mexican Department of Justice) has released the retired Israeli Defense Forces colonel and presumed MOSSAD agent Salvador Guersson Smecke and Israeli illegal immigrant Saur Ben Zvi after both had penetrated the security of the Mexican Congress and where in possession of guns, hand grenades and explosives.

    http://www.rense.com/general17/mossadagentsarrested.htm

  269. @Travis
    listening to the radio station Jersey 101.5 today, Dennis and Judy , used their program to ask Jersey residents if they recalled seeing anyone celebrating on 9/11.

    dozens of callers remembered seeing Muslims in Paterson and Jersey City rejoicing or celebrating that day...the hosts were somewhat surprised, as they acknowledged most of the callers appeared credible and the callers themselves did sound convincing. Dennis made it known he does not support Trump, but he seemed to believe many of the callers.

    Replies: @Dave Pinsen

    Mark Simone on WWOR confirmed it today as well, and pointed out that smart phones with video capability didn’t exist then, hence the paucity of video.

  270. @Boomstick
    @Ron Unz

    The Google translation of what is claimed to be the Mexican government account:

    "THE PGR INFORMS ABOUT THE SITUATION OF INDIVIDUALS ARRESTED IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
    Regarding the situation of the 2 subjects detained last Wednesday near the Legislative Palace of San Lazaro, the Attorney General's Office reports that the Israeli citizen Saer Ben-Zvi and Saar Noam Ben Zvi was made available to the First Court of "A" Federal Criminal Proceedings in Mexico City, Distrito while the Mexican Salvador Gersson Smeck will release order issued stocks with the law, because no items were found for your consignment.
    Under that when he was arrested Gersson Smeck carrying a 9 mm caliber weapon, was released reserves of the law and gave sight to the Secretariat of National Defense regarding the permit to carry a firearm with that account.
    The Israeli Ben Zvi was admitted to the Men's Prison north slope that will resolve their legal status, as likely responsible for the commission of crimes of violation of the General Population Act, provided for and punished by Articles 123 and 143 General Population Act, all in connection with the 6th. And 7th., Section 1, 8. 9th and 13th, Fraction II of the Federal Penal Code, which start is given to the relevant criminal proceedings. [1]"

    One guy licensed to carry a Glock, one guy arrested for immigration problems.

    Replies: @bunga, @bunga

    In February of 2000, Indian intelligence officials detained 11 members of what they thought was an Al Qaeda hijacking conspiracy. It was then discovered that these 11 “Muslim preachers” were all Israeli nationals! India’s leading weekly magazine, The Week, reported:

    On January 12 Indian intelligence officials in Calcutta detained 11 foreign nationals for interrogation before they were to board a Dhaka-bound Bangladesh Biman flight. They were detained on the suspicion of being hijackers. “But we realized that they were tabliqis (Islamic preachers), so we let them go”, said an Intelligence official.

    The eleven had Israeli passports but were believed to be Afghan nationals who had spent a while in Iran. Indian intelligence officials, too, were surprised by the nationality profile of the eleven. “They say that they have been on tabligh (preaching Islam) in India for two months. But they are Israeli nationals from the West Bank,” said a Central Intelligence official. He claimed that Tel Aviv “exerted considerable pressure” on Delhi to secure their release. “It appeared that they could be working for a sensitive organization in Israel and were on a mission to Bangladesh,” the official said.

    The Week (India) Aborted Mission. Investigation: Did Mossad attempt to infiltrate Islamic radical outfits in south Asia? By Subir Bhaumik. February 6, 2000. Google users enter: muslim tabliqis mossad

    http://web.archive.org/web/20030210204900/http://www.the-week.com/20feb06/events2.htm

  271. @Rurik
    @Mr. Anon



    George Bush said publically (and on camera) that he saw the first plane hit WTC tower- curious. Did you know that? Does it matter to your mind if he said it or even if he did see it?”
     
    And what is so odd about that?

     

    first plane

    let that sink in for a minute

    ok

    here, let me help

    here's the video

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eyi33ftRUZY

    you can find it all over the Internet if you look, (or cared)

    but for people with a functioning brain, for George Bush to have seen the FIRST plane hit the tower, which he clearly did from what he says, then that means that he was watching a live video feed of the "terrorist" attacks on that day. Someone had a camera set up and Bush happened to be watching before he went into that classroom.

    the kind of insanity that has largely come to characterizes the “Truther” movement.
     
    insanity indeed

    it literally is a kind of insanity to watch building seven implode and tell yourself that is was office fires that did it

    or to see president George Bush talking about watching the FIRST plane hit the tower and consider it of no consequence

    rather I wouldn't so much put it down to insanity as I would intellectual and moral cowardice

    ; )

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

    first plane

    let that sink in for a minute

    ok

    I thought I saw footage of the first plane hitting the tower. No idea if I did, and although I was a child at the time I was more articulate than GWB.

    But anyway, as with all gotchas, the alternative to GWB making a mistake and confusing his words is that he decided to tell everyone he knew about 9/11. The latter is rather less likely.

    I just don’t get why you can’t work that out for yourself before you become the object of ridicule?

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @This Is Our Home

    It's not like Manhattan on a sunny morning in 2001 didn't have a lot of video cameras in random hands, such as tourists. A few cameras were pointed at the WTC. Here's the first clip to come up on Google:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PNzWVLJkyiI

    , @Rurik
    @This Is Our Home


    I thought I saw footage of the first plane hitting the tower. No idea if I did
     
    you might have Robert. Most of us have. There is by now a well known video of the first plane hitting the tower, but that one was filmed quite by a fluke. For Bush to have seen it 'before he went into the Florida classroom' meant that the video he saw was not a fluke. But something that was deliberate.

    In and of itself, I could put this down to more of that chimp's bumbling idiocies, even if it's very eerie.

    But this little 'curiosity' is not the only thing that proves the official story of 911 is a lie.

    The most damning things are the way the BBC and other news outlets reported on the implosion of building seven before it happened. That my friend is proof of advance knowledge. No less so than if the BBC had reported that the first plane had struck the tower 20 minutes before it did. It proves that the person who handed those journalists the story knew the building was going to come down, and the ONLY ones that could have known that were the ones who wired it for its obvious controlled demolition. Perhaps it was Osama who had one of his henchmen hand the BBC journalist that story, but I doubt that.

    I just don’t get why you can’t work that out for yourself before you become the object of ridicule?
     
    just use logic and reason and try, try! to think

    how could they report on something that no living human could have ever anticipated, unless they knew


    and if they knew, then the whole thing stinks to high heaven, ya see?

    but you have to be able to use your brain and think in order to be able to draw conclusions. For too many people it's just easier to watch the TV and listen to the talking heads and politicians explain everything to them and they're happy to chew their cud and accept what ever narrative is being slung on any particular day.

    but not all of us ; )
  272. @tanabear
    @tbraton

    tbraton: "World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers..."

    It wasn't entirely identical. The North and South towers were destroyed top-down. Word Trade Tower 7 was more of a conventional looking demolition; but still a masterpiece of demolition science.

    The phrase "conspiracy theory" is just used as an ad hominem. What explanation best fits the available evidence? It certainly isn't the official account.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

    The phrase “conspiracy theory” is just used as an ad hominem. What explanation best fits the available evidence? It certainly isn’t the official account.

    What is it then?

    • Replies: @tanabear
    @This Is Our Home

    The official account can not even begin to explain the events of 9/11. The sine qua non of the 9/11 attacks is the collapse of World Trade Towers 1,2 and 7 on that day. The official version, to the extent that there is one, cannot account for these phenomena. The National Institutes of Standards and Technology(NIST) was tasked with investigating the collapses. For WTC 1 and 2 their analysis started from the time of the plane impacts until the buildings were poised for collapse, but they did not analyze the actual collapse. Or in their words, "although it does not actually include the structural behavior of the tower after the conditions for collapse initiation were reached and collapse became inevitable." They seem to punt the ball over to Zdenek Bazant in explaining the collapse. His theory is crush-down, crush up. A theory devoid of any evidence, replication, and historical precedence.

    WTC 7 is so obviously a controlled demolition that even defenders of the official story don't like to mention it. NIST did finally admit that the tower did collapse for 2.25 seconds in full-free fall, contradicting their initial statement that WTC7 did not enter free-fall and there was resistance provided. So unless you believe in the feasibility of momentum transfer at free-fall acceleration the official account is toast.

    Rurik: "The most damning things are the way the BBC and other news outlets reported on the implosion of building seven before it happened."

    Yes, how did everyone know that WTC7 was coming down before it collapsed, but after it collapsed they didn't have any idea how it fell? How is it possible to have certain knowledge of an unprecedented before it happens, but be completely clueless afterwards ???

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

  273. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Rurik
    @This Is Our Home


    I especially wouldn’t have my hobo spies go on television and admit to it!
     
    but yet they did Robert

    and to Steve's point, if these guys were a joke, why did the FBI keep them for so long?

    are the FBI also "self-aggrandising liars and the obviously crazy"?

    .

    BTW. I posted a reply here to someone regarding the video of George Bush describing his reaction to seeing the FIRST plane hit the tower, but it wasn't published, so don't worry Robert, there is some censorship going on here ; )

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    but yet they did Robert

    I take it you don’t have a second language.

    and to Steve’s point, if these guys were a joke, why did the FBI keep them for so long?

    Due diligence? Because they were art scamming criminals? Because they didn’t want to look easy on them? Because they were freaked out by the whole situation?

    All of these explanations are infinitely more plausible than your alternative.

    BTW. I posted a reply here to someone regarding the video of George Bush describing his reaction to seeing the FIRST plane hit the tower, but it wasn’t published, so don’t worry Robert, there is some censorship going on here ; )

    So they kept it up until you, brave Rurik, pointed it out on Unz.com? Surely you’re a troll, that is like a satire of paranoid schizophrenia.

  274. @This Is Our Home
    @Rurik


    first plane

    let that sink in for a minute

    ok
     

    I thought I saw footage of the first plane hitting the tower. No idea if I did, and although I was a child at the time I was more articulate than GWB.

    But anyway, as with all gotchas, the alternative to GWB making a mistake and confusing his words is that he decided to tell everyone he knew about 9/11. The latter is rather less likely.

    I just don't get why you can't work that out for yourself before you become the object of ridicule?

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @Rurik

    It’s not like Manhattan on a sunny morning in 2001 didn’t have a lot of video cameras in random hands, such as tourists. A few cameras were pointed at the WTC. Here’s the first clip to come up on Google:

  275. @This Is Our Home
    @D. K.

    Two Israel-based employees, in Israel(!), of a company which did not have an office in the towers received a message warning them of a terrorist attack on somewhere....that's not even a coincidence, it is entirely unrelated.

    http://www.911myths.com/index.php/Odigo

    Replies: @D. K.

    This, below, is the entire Ha’aretz article, copy and pasted directly from its own Web site:

    ***

    Odigo, the instant messaging service, says that two of its workers received messages two hours before the Twin Towers attack on September 11 predicting the attack would happen, and the company has been cooperating with Israeli and American law enforcement, including the FBI, in trying to find the original sender of the message predicting the attack.

    Yuval Dror 26.09.2001 00:00 Updated: 12:43 AM

    Odigo, the instant messaging service, says that two of its workers received messages two hours before the Twin Towers attack on September 11 predicting the attack would happen, and the company has been cooperating with Israeli and American law enforcement, including the FBI, in trying to find the original sender of the message predicting the attack.

    Micha Macover, CEO of the company, said the two workers received the messages and immediately after the terror attack informed the company’s management, which immediately contacted the Israeli security services, which brought in the FBI.

    “I have no idea why the message was sent to these two workers, who don’t know the sender. It may just have been someone who was joking and turned out they accidentally got it right. And I don’t know if our information was useful in any of the arrests the FBI has made,” said Macover. Odigo is a U.S.-based company whose headquarters are in New York, with offices in Herzliya.

    As an instant messaging service, Odigo users are not limited to sending messages only to people on their “buddy” list, as is the case with ICQ, the other well-known Israeli instant messaging application.

    Odigo usually zealously protects the privacy of its registered users, said Macover, but in this case the company took the initiative to provide the law enforcement services with the originating Internet Presence address of the message, so the FBI could track down the Internet Service Provider, and the actual sender of the original message.

    http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/odigo-says-workers-were-warned-of-attack-1.70579

    ***

    Do you notice anything that has been added to the article, in the source that you cite? Should we trust your source, or the actual newspaper’s own Web site? If the warning was non-specific, and sent to employees in Israel, rather than to employees at the company’s New York headquarters, a stone’s throw from Ground Zero, why were they making such a fuss about it, both in Israel and in the United Sates, and why has the actual text of the message never been published, to squelch the rumors that nearby workers, in downtown Manhattan, had received such a warning, a couple of hours before the attacks on the World Trade Center Twin Towers? Why has the sender never been publicly identified, and his explanation for the message expounded? Even if the two Odigo employees who received the message were located in Israel– whether permanently or merely at the time– did the message, whatever it actually said, specify an attack in Israel, Manhattan, or nowhere in the world in particular?

    • Replies: @D. K.
    @D. K.

    I found this, putatively from The Washington Post, but not from its own Web site (as its archive, pre-2005, is pay-to-play):

    ***

    Newsbytes (The Washington Post)
    September 28, 2001


    An official at Odigo today made a more substantial comment on warnings the instant messaging firm received prior to the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.

    The company's vice president of sales and marketing acknowledged that messages warning of attacks were received but would not comment on the contents of the messages. He had replied to a question about whether he could confirm that Odigo had received messages warning about the World Trade Center attacks. A sender in the alt.politics.bush newsgroup had written on Tuesday that Odigo workers received messages two hours before the Twin Towers attack on Sept. 11 predicting the attack would happen. The incident was also the subject of a report in the Ha'aretz daily newspaper in Israel, which on Wednesday quoted Odigo CEO Micha Macover as saying that "two workers received the messages predicting the attack would happen."

    Odigo Vice President of Sales and Marketing Alex Diamandis told Newsbytes Thursday that he could not comment on the text or origin of the message, but said that the sender of the instant message was not personally known to the Odigo employees. Even though the company usually protects the privacy of users, Odigo recorded the Internet protocol address of the message's sender to facilitate his or her identification, he said.

    The Odigo workers, based in the company's research and development and international sales office in Israel, were signed on to the same Odigo messaging server used by worldwide users of the company's free, Odigo-branded messaging software, Diamandis said today.

    Diamandis today in a telephone interview also said the warning message did not identify the World Trade Center as the attack target. Diamandis declined to reveal any other information contained in the message, including whether the warning named the targets for the attack.

    "Providing more details would only lead to more conjecture," he said.

    He did confirm that soon after the terrorist attacks on New York, the Odigo employees notified their management, who contacted Israeli security services. In turn, the FBI was informed of the instant-message warning.

    The Odigo service includes a feature called People Finder that allows users to seek out and contact others based on certain interests or demographics. Diamandis said Thursday that it was possible the attack warning was broadcast to other Odigo members, but the company has not received reports of other recipients of the message.

    In addition to operating its own messaging server network, Odigo has licensed its technology to over 100 service providers, portals, wireless carriers and corporations, according to the company.

    Odigo is at http//www.odigo.com .


    © 2001 The Washington Post Company

    ***

    Being an erstwhile attorney myself, rather than a marketing flack, I would take serious issue with Mr. Diamandis' flimsy claim that "[p]roviding more details would only lead to more conjecture." The opposite is infinitely closer to the truth....

    I also found this, from May 2002:

    ***

    Comverse, a supplier of software for multimedia-enhanced telecom services and a unit of Comverse Technology, Inc., has signed an agreement to acquire privately-held Odigo for $20 million in cash. Comverse already held a 12.4% interest in Odigo, and the two companies have been working closely together.

    “Comverse and Odigo have had a long standing-partnership and together have developed instant communications products and services that we have recently begun to offer to (telecom) operators around the world,” said Zeev Bregman, Comverse CEO. “This acquisition is consistent with our commitment to provide an open IP-based platform built upon technologies that allow us to deliver to operators a wide range of intelligent, multimodal communication services.”

    Odigo presently has millions of subscribers, many through licensing agreements with Prodigy, British Telecom and other companies.

    For quite some time Odigo has been focusing more on extending it’s messaging and presence capabilities to wireless networks. It appears that Comverse may have been the driving force in this strategy.

    What impact this aquisition has on the millions of existing Odigo users is unclear.

    [ http://bigblueball.com/discuss/topic/comverse-acquires-odigo/ ]

    ***

    Having read James Bamford's "The Shadow Factory" (2008), inter alia, I am fairly well aware of the role that Comverse plays in the surveilling of the American public....

    , @D. K.
    @D. K.

    This is one of the links that supposedly debunks the Odigo warning(s) as just another "9/11 myth":

    http://www.fpp.co.uk/online/01/09/WTC_Odigo2.html

    Here is the addendum to that link:

    ***

    Addendum, Saturday, December 29, 2001:

    THE above text is retrieved from the Google.com cache. The CNN.com website has removed this story, which some people felt uncomfortable about. The CNN search engine still lists the article when the word odigo is searched for, but the article has gone. We shall preserve it permanently here.

    ***

    CNN, no doubt, simply has a lack of server space, and cannot afford to keep on-line copies of all of its own news stories, especially not all of those stories on ephemeral subjects like 9/11....

  276. @This Is Our Home
    @Rurik


    first plane

    let that sink in for a minute

    ok
     

    I thought I saw footage of the first plane hitting the tower. No idea if I did, and although I was a child at the time I was more articulate than GWB.

    But anyway, as with all gotchas, the alternative to GWB making a mistake and confusing his words is that he decided to tell everyone he knew about 9/11. The latter is rather less likely.

    I just don't get why you can't work that out for yourself before you become the object of ridicule?

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @Rurik

    I thought I saw footage of the first plane hitting the tower. No idea if I did

    you might have Robert. Most of us have. There is by now a well known video of the first plane hitting the tower, but that one was filmed quite by a fluke. For Bush to have seen it ‘before he went into the Florida classroom’ meant that the video he saw was not a fluke. But something that was deliberate.

    In and of itself, I could put this down to more of that chimp’s bumbling idiocies, even if it’s very eerie.

    But this little ‘curiosity’ is not the only thing that proves the official story of 911 is a lie.

    The most damning things are the way the BBC and other news outlets reported on the implosion of building seven before it happened. That my friend is proof of advance knowledge. No less so than if the BBC had reported that the first plane had struck the tower 20 minutes before it did. It proves that the person who handed those journalists the story knew the building was going to come down, and the ONLY ones that could have known that were the ones who wired it for its obvious controlled demolition. Perhaps it was Osama who had one of his henchmen hand the BBC journalist that story, but I doubt that.

    I just don’t get why you can’t work that out for yourself before you become the object of ridicule?

    just use logic and reason and try, try! to think

    how could they report on something that no living human could have ever anticipated, unless they knew

    and if they knew, then the whole thing stinks to high heaven, ya see?

    but you have to be able to use your brain and think in order to be able to draw conclusions. For too many people it’s just easier to watch the TV and listen to the talking heads and politicians explain everything to them and they’re happy to chew their cud and accept what ever narrative is being slung on any particular day.

    but not all of us ; )

  277. @Ozymandias
    @SPMoore8

    "German Burger King franchise Do they serve their Whoppers on Kaiser rolls?"

    They're available on the local menu in Hamburg.

    @tbraton
    There's a photo out there somewhere showing the base of #7 before it fell. The rubble field from the collapsed tower destroyed about a third of 7's footprint, and after hours of uncontrolled burning it was expected to fall. Nothing unusual about it. And you know, if you wanted to take down a tower, recruiting Islamic fundamentalists to fly a plane into it is a much better plan than a surreptitious demolition. The initial explosion will blow the fire proofing off, and the resulting fire is more than hot enough to weaken the structure (ignoring any insane arguments about "melting point").

    Replies: @SPMoore8

    Apropos of the second part of your comment, I will weigh in on 9/11 briefly, if you don’t mind.

    I didn’t see the planes hit but I watched the scene for about an hour, I was stuck in traffic. Actually I didn’t want to watch. I glanced over once in awhile.

    Black gray smoke rose from both up to the convection layer and then moved south. I knew about a half dozen people who worked there, most survived, partly because they were late or had the day off. I remember when the smoke turned white on South Tower that was a good thing; it meant the fire was under control, or so I thought. The building bent over and collapsed straight down about 10 minutes later. By the time the second tower collapsed there was already so much smoke you could hardly see what was happening.

    I don’t think there’s any big mystery. The North tower had the top ten floors collapse on the the remainder, the force just knocked out the rest like dominoes. South tower, from where I was in Jersey, seemed to bend over to the South — I thought I was hallucinating — but then the force of 30-40 floors reestablished itself straight up down and then down.

    I don’t think there’s a big mystery to what happened. It’s clear that pilot #2 almost missed his target. The fire weakened the supports for the upper floors, and they came down with increasing force due to the velocity of the fall. I think the terrorists may have thought they might “knock them over”, I don’t think they expected them to collapse the way they did.

    It’s possible that some intelligence service(s) had some vague warning of something before the attack. I think that’s at least as possible as foreknowledge of a possible Japanese attack in December, 1941. That would be about it.

    • Replies: @Dave Pinsen
    @SPMoore8

    It's not just possible: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bin_Ladin_Determined_To_Strike_in_US

  278. @D. K.
    @This Is Our Home

    This, below, is the entire Ha'aretz article, copy and pasted directly from its own Web site:

    ***

    Odigo, the instant messaging service, says that two of its workers received messages two hours before the Twin Towers attack on September 11 predicting the attack would happen, and the company has been cooperating with Israeli and American law enforcement, including the FBI, in trying to find the original sender of the message predicting the attack.

    Yuval Dror 26.09.2001 00:00 Updated: 12:43 AM

    Odigo, the instant messaging service, says that two of its workers received messages two hours before the Twin Towers attack on September 11 predicting the attack would happen, and the company has been cooperating with Israeli and American law enforcement, including the FBI, in trying to find the original sender of the message predicting the attack.

    Micha Macover, CEO of the company, said the two workers received the messages and immediately after the terror attack informed the company's management, which immediately contacted the Israeli security services, which brought in the FBI.

    "I have no idea why the message was sent to these two workers, who don't know the sender. It may just have been someone who was joking and turned out they accidentally got it right. And I don't know if our information was useful in any of the arrests the FBI has made," said Macover. Odigo is a U.S.-based company whose headquarters are in New York, with offices in Herzliya.

    As an instant messaging service, Odigo users are not limited to sending messages only to people on their "buddy" list, as is the case with ICQ, the other well-known Israeli instant messaging application.

    Odigo usually zealously protects the privacy of its registered users, said Macover, but in this case the company took the initiative to provide the law enforcement services with the originating Internet Presence address of the message, so the FBI could track down the Internet Service Provider, and the actual sender of the original message.

    http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/odigo-says-workers-were-warned-of-attack-1.70579

    ***

    Do you notice anything that has been added to the article, in the source that you cite? Should we trust your source, or the actual newspaper's own Web site? If the warning was non-specific, and sent to employees in Israel, rather than to employees at the company's New York headquarters, a stone's throw from Ground Zero, why were they making such a fuss about it, both in Israel and in the United Sates, and why has the actual text of the message never been published, to squelch the rumors that nearby workers, in downtown Manhattan, had received such a warning, a couple of hours before the attacks on the World Trade Center Twin Towers? Why has the sender never been publicly identified, and his explanation for the message expounded? Even if the two Odigo employees who received the message were located in Israel-- whether permanently or merely at the time-- did the message, whatever it actually said, specify an attack in Israel, Manhattan, or nowhere in the world in particular?

    Replies: @D. K., @D. K.

    I found this, putatively from The Washington Post, but not from its own Web site (as its archive, pre-2005, is pay-to-play):

    ***

    Newsbytes (The Washington Post)
    September 28, 2001

    An official at Odigo today made a more substantial comment on warnings the instant messaging firm received prior to the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.

    The company’s vice president of sales and marketing acknowledged that messages warning of attacks were received but would not comment on the contents of the messages. He had replied to a question about whether he could confirm that Odigo had received messages warning about the World Trade Center attacks. A sender in the alt.politics.bush newsgroup had written on Tuesday that Odigo workers received messages two hours before the Twin Towers attack on Sept. 11 predicting the attack would happen. The incident was also the subject of a report in the Ha’aretz daily newspaper in Israel, which on Wednesday quoted Odigo CEO Micha Macover as saying that “two workers received the messages predicting the attack would happen.”

    Odigo Vice President of Sales and Marketing Alex Diamandis told Newsbytes Thursday that he could not comment on the text or origin of the message, but said that the sender of the instant message was not personally known to the Odigo employees. Even though the company usually protects the privacy of users, Odigo recorded the Internet protocol address of the message’s sender to facilitate his or her identification, he said.

    The Odigo workers, based in the company’s research and development and international sales office in Israel, were signed on to the same Odigo messaging server used by worldwide users of the company’s free, Odigo-branded messaging software, Diamandis said today.

    Diamandis today in a telephone interview also said the warning message did not identify the World Trade Center as the attack target. Diamandis declined to reveal any other information contained in the message, including whether the warning named the targets for the attack.

    “Providing more details would only lead to more conjecture,” he said.

    He did confirm that soon after the terrorist attacks on New York, the Odigo employees notified their management, who contacted Israeli security services. In turn, the FBI was informed of the instant-message warning.

    The Odigo service includes a feature called People Finder that allows users to seek out and contact others based on certain interests or demographics. Diamandis said Thursday that it was possible the attack warning was broadcast to other Odigo members, but the company has not received reports of other recipients of the message.

    In addition to operating its own messaging server network, Odigo has licensed its technology to over 100 service providers, portals, wireless carriers and corporations, according to the company.

    Odigo is at http//www.odigo.com .

    © 2001 The Washington Post Company

    ***

    Being an erstwhile attorney myself, rather than a marketing flack, I would take serious issue with Mr. Diamandis’ flimsy claim that “[p]roviding more details would only lead to more conjecture.” The opposite is infinitely closer to the truth….

    I also found this, from May 2002:

    ***

    Comverse, a supplier of software for multimedia-enhanced telecom services and a unit of Comverse Technology, Inc., has signed an agreement to acquire privately-held Odigo for $20 million in cash. Comverse already held a 12.4% interest in Odigo, and the two companies have been working closely together.

    “Comverse and Odigo have had a long standing-partnership and together have developed instant communications products and services that we have recently begun to offer to (telecom) operators around the world,” said Zeev Bregman, Comverse CEO. “This acquisition is consistent with our commitment to provide an open IP-based platform built upon technologies that allow us to deliver to operators a wide range of intelligent, multimodal communication services.”

    Odigo presently has millions of subscribers, many through licensing agreements with Prodigy, British Telecom and other companies.

    For quite some time Odigo has been focusing more on extending it’s messaging and presence capabilities to wireless networks. It appears that Comverse may have been the driving force in this strategy.

    What impact this aquisition has on the millions of existing Odigo users is unclear.

    (http://bigblueball.com/discuss/topic/comverse-acquires-odigo/ ]

    ***

    Having read James Bamford’s “The Shadow Factory” (2008), inter alia, I am fairly well aware of the role that Comverse plays in the surveilling of the American public….

  279. @This Is Our Home
    @tanabear


    The phrase “conspiracy theory” is just used as an ad hominem. What explanation best fits the available evidence? It certainly isn’t the official account.
     
    What is it then?

    Replies: @tanabear

    The official account can not even begin to explain the events of 9/11. The sine qua non of the 9/11 attacks is the collapse of World Trade Towers 1,2 and 7 on that day. The official version, to the extent that there is one, cannot account for these phenomena. The National Institutes of Standards and Technology(NIST) was tasked with investigating the collapses. For WTC 1 and 2 their analysis started from the time of the plane impacts until the buildings were poised for collapse, but they did not analyze the actual collapse. Or in their words, “although it does not actually include the structural behavior of the tower after the conditions for collapse initiation were reached and collapse became inevitable.” They seem to punt the ball over to Zdenek Bazant in explaining the collapse. His theory is crush-down, crush up. A theory devoid of any evidence, replication, and historical precedence.

    WTC 7 is so obviously a controlled demolition that even defenders of the official story don’t like to mention it. NIST did finally admit that the tower did collapse for 2.25 seconds in full-free fall, contradicting their initial statement that WTC7 did not enter free-fall and there was resistance provided. So unless you believe in the feasibility of momentum transfer at free-fall acceleration the official account is toast.

    Rurik: “The most damning things are the way the BBC and other news outlets reported on the implosion of building seven before it happened.”

    Yes, how did everyone know that WTC7 was coming down before it collapsed, but after it collapsed they didn’t have any idea how it fell? How is it possible to have certain knowledge of an unprecedented before it happens, but be completely clueless afterwards ???

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @tanabear

    You forgot to answer my question. I'll ask again: what is the most plausible theory in your opinion?

    Replies: @Truth, @tanabear

  280. @BobX
    @Ron Unz

    Ron

    I don't think the link AC provides is all he claims it to be. The web archive link refers to "a 9 mm caliber weapon". You value the Pravda link for what you think it is worth.

    Google translate of text from link:

    THE PGR INFORMS ABOUT SITUATION
    SUBJECT ARRESTED IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
     
    Regarding the situation of the 2 subjects detained last Wednesday near the Legislative Palace of San Lazaro, the Attorney General's Office reports that the Israeli citizen Saer Ben-Zvi and Saar Noam Ben Zvi was made available to the First Court of "A" Federal Criminal Proceedings in Mexico City, Distrito while the Mexican Salvador Gersson Smeck will release order issued stocks with the law, because no items were found for your consignment.

    Under that when he was arrested Gersson Smeck carrying a 9 mm caliber weapon, was released reserves of the law and gave sight to the Secretariat of National Defense regarding the permit to carry a firearm with that account.

    The Israeli Ben Zvi was admitted to the Men's Prison north slope that will resolve their legal status, as likely responsible for the commission of crimes of violation of the General Population Act, provided for and punished by Articles 123 and 143 General Population Act, all in connection with the 6th. And 7th., Section 1, 8. 9th and 13th, Fraction II of the Federal Penal Code, which start is given to the relevant criminal proceedings.

    Replies: @Ron Unz

    I don’t think the link AC provides is all he claims it to be. The web archive link refers to “a 9 mm caliber weapon”. You value the Pravda link for what you think it is worth.

    Well, I don’t recall looking at any Mexican government website or reading something from Russian Pravda. What I read was a translation of one of the big articles in a leading Mexican newspaper, and I’m pretty sure it mentioned explosives or maybe hand grenades and electrical wiring as well as a handgun. Admittedly, that was almost ten years ago, but a few years back I noticed that some “conspiracy nuts” had scanned one of those Mexican front-page banner-headline stories and put the entire thing up on their website, so maybe it’s still floating around somewhere.

    Anyway, regarding this sort of thing I’d much more trust an account in Russian Pravda than in American Pravda. But if you prefer to believe that everything you read about “controversial” subjects in The New York Times is 100% accurate, be my guest…

  281. @D. K.
    @This Is Our Home

    This, below, is the entire Ha'aretz article, copy and pasted directly from its own Web site:

    ***

    Odigo, the instant messaging service, says that two of its workers received messages two hours before the Twin Towers attack on September 11 predicting the attack would happen, and the company has been cooperating with Israeli and American law enforcement, including the FBI, in trying to find the original sender of the message predicting the attack.

    Yuval Dror 26.09.2001 00:00 Updated: 12:43 AM

    Odigo, the instant messaging service, says that two of its workers received messages two hours before the Twin Towers attack on September 11 predicting the attack would happen, and the company has been cooperating with Israeli and American law enforcement, including the FBI, in trying to find the original sender of the message predicting the attack.

    Micha Macover, CEO of the company, said the two workers received the messages and immediately after the terror attack informed the company's management, which immediately contacted the Israeli security services, which brought in the FBI.

    "I have no idea why the message was sent to these two workers, who don't know the sender. It may just have been someone who was joking and turned out they accidentally got it right. And I don't know if our information was useful in any of the arrests the FBI has made," said Macover. Odigo is a U.S.-based company whose headquarters are in New York, with offices in Herzliya.

    As an instant messaging service, Odigo users are not limited to sending messages only to people on their "buddy" list, as is the case with ICQ, the other well-known Israeli instant messaging application.

    Odigo usually zealously protects the privacy of its registered users, said Macover, but in this case the company took the initiative to provide the law enforcement services with the originating Internet Presence address of the message, so the FBI could track down the Internet Service Provider, and the actual sender of the original message.

    http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/odigo-says-workers-were-warned-of-attack-1.70579

    ***

    Do you notice anything that has been added to the article, in the source that you cite? Should we trust your source, or the actual newspaper's own Web site? If the warning was non-specific, and sent to employees in Israel, rather than to employees at the company's New York headquarters, a stone's throw from Ground Zero, why were they making such a fuss about it, both in Israel and in the United Sates, and why has the actual text of the message never been published, to squelch the rumors that nearby workers, in downtown Manhattan, had received such a warning, a couple of hours before the attacks on the World Trade Center Twin Towers? Why has the sender never been publicly identified, and his explanation for the message expounded? Even if the two Odigo employees who received the message were located in Israel-- whether permanently or merely at the time-- did the message, whatever it actually said, specify an attack in Israel, Manhattan, or nowhere in the world in particular?

    Replies: @D. K., @D. K.

    This is one of the links that supposedly debunks the Odigo warning(s) as just another “9/11 myth”:

    http://www.fpp.co.uk/online/01/09/WTC_Odigo2.html

    Here is the addendum to that link:

    ***

    Addendum, Saturday, December 29, 2001:

    THE above text is retrieved from the Google.com cache. The CNN.com website has removed this story, which some people felt uncomfortable about. The CNN search engine still lists the article when the word odigo is searched for, but the article has gone. We shall preserve it permanently here.

    ***

    CNN, no doubt, simply has a lack of server space, and cannot afford to keep on-line copies of all of its own news stories, especially not all of those stories on ephemeral subjects like 9/11….

  282. @This Is Our Home
    @Steve Sailer


    Thanks, now can you find the NYT article the Fox article is citing?

    I’m not saying they got it wrong — like I said, in reading this old article from ABC News, I was surprised to learn how serious the FBI was about interrogating these guys, like 40 days in solitary
     
    I have found the New York Time article quoted here: http://www.911myths.com/index.php/Dancing_Israelis

    It helpfully comes with a lot of other information that makes this all look silly. Not that a theory like this needs to be made to look sillier.

    If I needed to document 9/11, having planned it. I would set up a camera from inside a closed apartment window and leave it set up. I certainly wouldn't send five Israeli bums to party on down in a very visible location with money in a sock...indeed I wouldn't even document it, as the rest of the world would do that for me, and what would I gain?

    I especially wouldn't have my hobo spies go on television and admit to it!

    The 9/11 truth movement is a cancer on alternative politics in the West. It sucks the life out of any feasible movement and slurs all of us by association. Donald Trump avoids this slur because he never gives succour to it and he obviously is not part of it, even if the insaniacs somehow believe that he is secretly messaging them. The 9/11 'theory' can only be believed by those who have never organised anything even as big as a bake sale...

    This means that not only is the message polluted but because the message is now largely the messenger, our message is associated with a toxic mixture of self-aggrandising liars and the obviously crazy.

    You should not ban these guys, but please do not entertain them.

    God, I wish I might recommend your blog to others but some things are just too hard to recover from being associated with. Unz.com is now not only the site for opinions rendered taboo by the PC zeitgeist but also for opinions so utterly nuts that the zeitgeist rejects them too; can we not save it for infowars.com or some other place that has been telling the US population that they'll be in FEMA camps tomorrow for the past 15 years?

    Courses of action could include:

    1. A mirror site with no comments; which is technically easy.

    2. A mirror site with conspiracy nonsense comments moderated out; which would take more time but would be more useful.

    3. You address this type of thinking in your blog posts; which would cover a generally interesting topic but may distract you from bigger things. Still, you have greater experience of this type of thinking than the majority of public intellectuals.

    Replies: @Rurik, @Ron Unz

    This means that not only is the message polluted but because the message is now largely the messenger, our message is associated with a toxic mixture of self-aggrandising liars and the obviously crazy.

    You should not ban these guys, but please do not entertain them.

    God, I wish I might recommend your blog to others but some things are just too hard to recover from being associated with. Unz.com is now not only the site for opinions rendered taboo by the PC zeitgeist but also for opinions so utterly nuts that the zeitgeist rejects them too

    I really like it when some random, anonymous ultra-right-wing Internet nut suddenly shows up here and within a couple of weeks is telling everyone how the entire website should be completely changed. As far as I can see, you’re mostly interested in fanatically denouncing Muslims and “anti-Semites” so maybe you’re just Whiskey’s long-lost brother or something…

    • Replies: @AnonymousCoward
    @Ron Unz

    You know, his name, Robert Rediger, literally means Robert "Edit/Rewrite".

    Rediger is a verb, and describes what an newspaper editor moderating his writers would be doing.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    , @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz


    I really like it when some random, anonymous ultra-right-wing Internet nut suddenly shows up here and within a couple of weeks is telling everyone how the entire website should be completely changed. As far as I can see, you’re mostly interested in fanatically denouncing Muslims and “anti-Semites” so maybe you’re just Whiskey’s long-lost brother or something…
     
    Anti Semites are fine, isn't everyone a bit anti-semitic? Just please stick to the even faintly plausible.

    Muslims are fine, actually I really like many I know, I just don't think that Arabs are at home in Europe, which makes me no more radical than the majority of Europeans and practically all of our ancestors, and the Arabs and South Asians themselves, when they're being honest.

    The bias of my comments on this site is pretty explainable. I'm only motivated to comment when I have cause to strongly disagree.

    As for my suggestions, take them or leave them, obviously that is your choice. That I was minded to make suggestions was only because I appreciate this site, so no need to take it personally. Why else would I make suggestions that I believe would allow this site a wider audience?
  283. @bomag
    @Romanian

    Lots of potential disappointments there, but people who lived through the optimism of the 1960s and 1970s would know that a lot better than I.

    Pretty much the theme was that the gov't shouldn't countenance spending money on advancements in space while we had all these social problems on Earth, problems that will soon be solved if we could just spend more money on them.

    The social problems have shown themselves to be completely fractal, while our gov't, via the various iron laws of bureaucracy, Peter principles, mass wasting, and general increase in entropy; has become much less able to get things done.

    The advances in tech, helped greatly by the Moon missions etc., has now made the current private sector efforts possible. Let's hope it bears fruit.

    Replies: @Romanian

    I read somewhere that AA activists actually drove a cart and mule to NASA’s gates to protest the wasteful spending on the Apollo program? Maybe something Paul Kersey wrote?

    On Steve Sailer’s recommendation, I read Christopher Caldwell’s book, “Reflections on the Revolutions in Europe”, which I found frustratingly impartial, like written by an alien observer. He had a line there about “moving from not being able to end welfare because the recipients are too weak, to not being able to end it because they are too strong”.

    I think it’s pretty obvious that continued mass migrations into Europe and US will quell basic scientific research and other advances, just like South Africa’s space and nuclear program went to hell. The priorities simply change.

  284. @Mike Sylwester
    @Mike Sylwester

    Yesterday, I collected from the Internet the following statements of people about Moslems seen celebrating in New Jersey on 9/11.


    I drove with family members though Patterson, N.J. that morning, after the planes hit. It’s not the kind of thing you forget. We witnessed people in traditional Muslim garb dancing, jumping, shouting and celebrating like their team had won the Super Bowl, just as Trump said.

    I didn’t see thousands of Muslims celebrating but I absolutely saw a pocket, perhaps 100, jumping for joy at the sight of the smoke rising from where the Twin Towers used to be. .... these events were a commonly accepted fact by Jerseyans.

    --------

    I had my business on Pennsylvania Ave in Paterson, N.J. I saw people on Crooks Ave. and Main Street cheering and raising Middle Eastern flags.

    I’ll tell you exactly where I was. I had stopped in at Biggs bagels on crooks ave by the railroad tracks. I was wondering why all these crazy people were cheering. Find out a few minutes later America was under attack. I saw it with my own eyes.

    I witnessed pure evil. Donald Trump is right.”

    --------

    What was happening is that they were in stores or small gathering cheering and when they were noticed they stopped. that is what happened when my sister saw them after she got gas and looked in the store to find someone to pay. she saw them gathered around a tv cheering and jumping up and down. When they saw her they stopped, I am sure that's what a lot of people are talking about. Many were seen celebrating. So the police would not have been aware, as in my sister's case. I had heard many stories like that throughout New Jersey.

    -------

    They were in the streets banging on the cars trying to drive through the crowd in the street. The muslims were shouting death to Americans and allah is great [and] other crap I didn't understand. We were amused until a car with 3 young women mistakenly turned on to main st.

    The muslims were banging on their windows and screaming, thats when we came out of our car and pushed the muslims off their car helped them back out and get back to the parkway.

    -------

    I experienced/ witnessed many incidents of Muslims celebrating 9/11 in North Brunswick. I was in a grocery store when I heard the plane crashed on the store radio. The Muslim man in line next to me turned and spit on me. I'll never forget it.

    -------

    I live in Hudson County. It did happen in West New York. Saw it with my own eyes. I don't need a media outlet to tell me what I witnessed just a few feet from me. People in cars, honking they're horns and waiving their flags.

    ------

    I saw black and Arab people in NEWARK PATH MARK SUPERMARKET - dancing and cheering as the TOWERS BURNED !!! and in JERSEY CITY - pockets of people in the streets shouting and laughing - TRUMP IS CORRECT

    -------

    So when I was driving a bus threw paterson that day in the morning to see it and other people seen as well ..does it mean we where dreaming of what took place...

    --------

    I saw it FIRST HAND! I drove an ambulance all over NJ. They were celebrating in the streets. I always wonder why they were never rounded up and sent to their homeland.

    -------

    It absolutely happened in Paterson. The police even had some of the streets closed off to traffic because of it. I was in Paterson on the 12th for business and the whole area around Crooks Avenue was covered in people celebrating.

    ----------

    Want proof that Muslims celebrated as they heard of 9/11 attacks? 100s of young men laughing, dancing, cheering; I saw them.

    ----------

    The Muslims were celebrating until they realized the backlash soon to follow. I saw it.

    ----------

    I saw it, too. The day and age we live in doesn't change the fact that Muslims did in fact party after 9/11 in jersey city. Love or hate trump, it happened

    ----------

    There is a service station in my town, near Edison, NJ, it was owned by Muslims at the time of 9-11. Many members of our community saw the workers there celebrating that day. That station was shunned by the locals as word spread and was eventually sold to new owners.

    [follow-up comment:]

    I'm a liberal Democrat and I saw the same thing from the Palestinian workers on 30th Street and 11th Avenue gas service station. Its closed now.

    ----------

    I lived and grew up in South Paterson NJ. I knew lots of people in law enforcement. Someone I knew at the time from the Passaic County's Prosecutors office told me that there were hundreds of people dancing in the streets when the Towers were attacked. Moreover, Paterson police were keeping people out of the city lest they felt it appropriate to attack some of the revelers. ....

    ----------

    I was a volunteer firefighter sent to the Hoboken FD to cover their turf while they were in NYC. I saw it with my own eyes while going through Jersey City too.

    ----------

    I lived in northwest nj...and yes, they were celebrating in patterson...not thousands but a couple of hundred.... WE SAW IT and will NEVER forget it!

    ----------

    It certainly did happen! I worked in Jersey City that day!

    ----------

    I actually saw them in Patterson NJ. I was one of the people who had to hold back fellow firefighters from going back there to fight with them.

    ----------

    I work in Paterson New Jersey. Many residents I've spoken to recently remember the celebrations that day. 2 were police officers called to protect the Muslims from others who were upset by the display. They (Muslims) danced and cheered. They still live here.

    ----------

    I was there. I saw it too. I was working in Hoboken, and drove through Jersey City and Newark back and forth to my home. Muslims were there. They were celebrating.

    ----------

    I do remember seeing this. This is one of those politically incorrect things we want to forget about 9/11. .... I do remember those Muslims who were celebrating and chanting/yelling in the streets in New Jersey. To say they represented all Muslims is a lie. To say they did not exist is also a lie.

    ----------

    I lived in Hoboken at the time and while I didn't witness these celebrations, I know plenty of people (i.e. former co-workers) who did.

    ----------

    This is true the people of Jersey City took to the streets in riot on Journal Square the reports where telling people to stay away.

    ----------

    Yes he is right I live in NJ and witnessed children stomping on a flag that fell off a car while their parents laughed . Let the truth be told

    ----------

    I saw in Paterson, N.J. about 30 to 50 men yelling and cheering in the street.waving their flags...

    ----------

    I lived in Staten Island new york at the time of 911 attacks .... Later that day, i went to liquor store on forest ave. There were young Muslim men, on the roof toop, waving a flag, as I enter the store about 5 young men, Muslims were smiling and dancing as they gave me candy. .... I latter went into a small grouciers store on Muslim men young and old were cheering when they were listen to the radio. ....
     
    http://nj1015.com/former-gov-difrancesco-i-dont-remember-people-celebrating-911-in-nj/

    https://www.facebook.com/nj1015/posts/10153456648123451

    http://www.bizpacreview.com/2015/11/23/live-jersey-trump-right-muslims-celebrate-911-nj-saw-277082

    http://www.northjersey.com/news/trump-s-comments-of-9-11-celebrations-in-n-j-renew-long-standing-debate-1.1461485

    Replies: @James Kabala, @KA

    “The police even had some of the streets closed off to traffic because of it.”

    How can this not be documented somewhere in a contemporaneous source if it is true? This claim, unlike most of the others, actually involves a public use of public resources that should have left some trace in the public record. (My overuse of the word “public” is deliberate.) If anyone thinks that this might be true, he should file a freedom of information request with the Paterson PD.

    You can talk all you want about the liberal media, but there were already early blogs, Yahoo and Usenet groups that often still have accessible archives, etc. You also have Fox News and (especially) the New York Post that would not have been inclined to join a cover-up (if not for true conservative principles, then at least for love of the sensationalistic).

    • Replies: @D. K.
    @James Kabala

    Are you referring to this "Fox News" [Channel, infra]?

    http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/israeli_spyring_fox.html

    Yes, there are our old friends at Comverse....

  285. You also have Fox News and (especially) the New York Post that would not have been inclined to join a cover-up (if not for true conservative principles, then at least for love of the sensationalistic).

    That’s the crucial point. If even the slightest hint of something like that had happened, the fanatical neocons and their media outlets would have blasted it 24/7. It’s about as plausible that a huge KKK march by Harvard faculty members was ignored by the NYT and the rest of the MSM. The likelihood is dead-flat-zero.

    Trump “remembers” he saw it lots of times on TV, and all those other local dimwits similarly “remember” they saw it and describe it on their Facebook pages, which causes more people to “remember” it as well.

    Bear in mind that by 2004, around 40% of Americans “knew” that we’d invaded Iraq because Saddam had attacked us on 9/11, and a year or two later 40% of the American troops in Iraq believed the same thing…

    • Replies: @matt
    @Ron Unz


    a year or two later 40% of the American troops in Iraq believed the same thing...
     
    You're being too kind. It was actually 85% of our brave (and stupid) men and women in uniform who believed that.

    Replies: @Ron Unz

    , @inertial
    @Ron Unz


    Bear in mind that by 2004, around 40% of Americans “knew” that we’d invaded Iraq because Saddam had attacked us on 9/11, and a year or two later 40% of the American troops in Iraq believed the same thing…
     
    Actually, there is just as much evidence that Iraq was behind 911 (or knew about it) as Israel was. That is to say, nothing like a real proof, but if you squinted in the right way you could see the "dots" that could be connected in a way that aligned with your personal demonology. Those 40% American weren't dumber than you, they simply had been influenced by a different kind of bias.
  286. @James Kabala
    @Mike Sylwester

    "The police even had some of the streets closed off to traffic because of it."

    How can this not be documented somewhere in a contemporaneous source if it is true? This claim, unlike most of the others, actually involves a public use of public resources that should have left some trace in the public record. (My overuse of the word "public" is deliberate.) If anyone thinks that this might be true, he should file a freedom of information request with the Paterson PD.

    You can talk all you want about the liberal media, but there were already early blogs, Yahoo and Usenet groups that often still have accessible archives, etc. You also have Fox News and (especially) the New York Post that would not have been inclined to join a cover-up (if not for true conservative principles, then at least for love of the sensationalistic).

    Replies: @D. K.

    Are you referring to this “Fox News” [Channel, infra]?

    http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/israeli_spyring_fox.html

    Yes, there are our old friends at Comverse….

  287. Want to see some of the documents from the 1800-page FBI report, exclusively about these arrested Israelis?

  288. @Ron Unz
    @This Is Our Home


    This means that not only is the message polluted but because the message is now largely the messenger, our message is associated with a toxic mixture of self-aggrandising liars and the obviously crazy.

    You should not ban these guys, but please do not entertain them.

    God, I wish I might recommend your blog to others but some things are just too hard to recover from being associated with. Unz.com is now not only the site for opinions rendered taboo by the PC zeitgeist but also for opinions so utterly nuts that the zeitgeist rejects them too
     
    I really like it when some random, anonymous ultra-right-wing Internet nut suddenly shows up here and within a couple of weeks is telling everyone how the entire website should be completely changed. As far as I can see, you're mostly interested in fanatically denouncing Muslims and "anti-Semites" so maybe you're just Whiskey's long-lost brother or something...

    Replies: @AnonymousCoward, @This Is Our Home

    You know, his name, Robert Rediger, literally means Robert “Edit/Rewrite”.

    Rediger is a verb, and describes what an newspaper editor moderating his writers would be doing.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @AnonymousCoward

    Isn't Robert Rediger the university president who converts Francois to Islam in "Submission?"

    Replies: @AnonymousCoward, @This Is Our Home

  289. @Arturo
    Gentlemen :

    The coincidences just keep piling up.

    I am surprised no one has mentioned yet the "E-Team" :

    http://robscholtemuseum.nl/mark-dotzler-thoughts-on-the-wtc-artists/

    This was a group of Israeli Art students who were given exclusive access to seven critical stories of the WTC north tower to perform an "art installation" that consisted among other things of the giant office-window billboard spelling out "E TEAM", and an actual balcony they installed for a few hours by removing a pane of glass.

    This is the real deal people, it's getting hotter.

    Even the NYT wrote about the E-team and their 91st-floor balcony :

    http://www.nytimes.com/2001/08/18/nyregion/balcony-scene-unseen-atop-world-episode-trade-center-assumes-mythic-qualities.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm

    There's a lot of Israeli art students and e-team (explosives team?) stuff on crimes of the times today.

    One thing that is absolutely freaking me out :

    The boxes and boxes and boxes of BB 18 on the 91st floor of the Israeli art students E-Team project.

    Prepare to get spooked :

    http://www.littelfuse.com/products/fuse-blocks-fuseholders-and-fuse-accessories/dead-front-fuse-holders/powr-busbar/bb18.aspx

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @slumber_j

    The WTC was host to a number of artists over the years: the space there was always a hard sell, and there were therefore a lot of vacancies, so I imagine it was a tax dodge.

    One of a couple of examples I’m aware of was the tenancy of the preposterously named but magnificent painter Rackstraw Downes. Here’s a painting of his of some raw interior space there:

    http://www.art21.org/images/rackstraw-downes/untenanted-space-in-the-world-trade-center-winter-sun-1998?slideshow=1

    • Replies: @Dave Pinsen
    @slumber_j

    The big scandal of the WTC is that it was built by the Port Authority of NY and NJ in the first place. In the '80s, the toll on the George Washington Bridge was $4. Today, it's $14 ($12 off peak with EZ Pass), and the bridge has been paid off for decades. A lot of the money goes to pay for the WTC.

    Replies: @D. K.

  290. @AnonymousCoward
    @Ron Unz

    You know, his name, Robert Rediger, literally means Robert "Edit/Rewrite".

    Rediger is a verb, and describes what an newspaper editor moderating his writers would be doing.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    Isn’t Robert Rediger the university president who converts Francois to Islam in “Submission?”

    • Replies: @AnonymousCoward
    @Steve Sailer

    Aha... it makes sense that this commenter wasn't clever enough to invent such a creative name himself, thanks for the catch

    , @This Is Our Home
    @Steve Sailer


    Isn’t Robert Rediger the university president who converts Francois to Islam in “Submission?”
     
    If our societies are going to look like the Middle East, primitive and full of mindless conspiracy theorising, then I might as well at least get 4 wives out of it.

    And this is the way things are going, when it comes to society 'fertile' is the prerequisite virtue.
  291. @Ron Unz

    You also have Fox News and (especially) the New York Post that would not have been inclined to join a cover-up (if not for true conservative principles, then at least for love of the sensationalistic).
     
    That's the crucial point. If even the slightest hint of something like that had happened, the fanatical neocons and their media outlets would have blasted it 24/7. It's about as plausible that a huge KKK march by Harvard faculty members was ignored by the NYT and the rest of the MSM. The likelihood is dead-flat-zero.

    Trump "remembers" he saw it lots of times on TV, and all those other local dimwits similarly "remember" they saw it and describe it on their Facebook pages, which causes more people to "remember" it as well.

    Bear in mind that by 2004, around 40% of Americans "knew" that we'd invaded Iraq because Saddam had attacked us on 9/11, and a year or two later 40% of the American troops in Iraq believed the same thing...

    Replies: @matt, @inertial

    a year or two later 40% of the American troops in Iraq believed the same thing…

    You’re being too kind. It was actually 85% of our brave (and stupid) men and women in uniform who believed that.

    • Replies: @Ron Unz
    @matt



    a year or two later 40% of the American troops in Iraq believed the same thing…
     
    You’re being too kind. It was actually 85% of our brave (and stupid) men and women in uniform who believed that.
     
    Touche. When I wrote that comment, I couldn't quite remember the actual figure, and thought it might be 60% but decided to play safe with 40%. However, 85% is a real surprise. That "Realist" fellow seems to end half his comments by saying "people are stupid" so I hope he reads this thread.
  292. Well, I just finished tracking down a difficult bug, so I might as well summarize my own casual perspective regarding the 9/11 attacks, which hasn’t much changed since the mid-2000s.

    (1) First, I think that the totally disorganized and frightened behavior of Bush and some other top American officials conclusively proves that the American government *as a entity* did not know about or expect the attacks; thus, the left-fringe claims of an “inside job” in that sense are absurd. However, there seems a very real possibility that a tiny number of key enemy agents or collaborators situated at crucial nodes within the governmental machinery were involved in the conspiracy, which is an entirely different thing. Needless to say, I doubt any of these American conspirators were Islamicist fanatics.

    (2) A considerable number of Israelis were caught in the immediate vicinity of the 9/11 attacks behaving in an *exceptionally* suspicious manner, and in some cases reportedly carrying explosives. At least a number of these individuals were later revealed to be Mossad agents, and others among their close associates quickly fled the country to avoid interrogation. Meanwhile, not a single Islamicist agent was caught anywhere in the vicinity, or indeed (as I recall) anywhere in the entire country. At the very least, this almost conclusively proves that Mossad knew the exact time and location of the planned attacks, while there is absolutely no evidence that the leadership of the FBI or the CIA had any such information.

    (3) Israel is a normal country, with a normal government. If Mossad knew the exact time and location of the planned attacks and had deployed a considerable number of its agents to observe, report, and record the attacks, it is absolutely certain that the top Israeli leaders also had this information and had approved those deployments.

    (4) Does this prove that the Israeli Mossad was actually behind the attacks? Not necessarily. But the key conclusion is that aside from the attackers themselves, the only government in the world with absolute, precise knowledge of the exact timing and nature of the attacks were the Israelis. Under these circumstances if America were a normal country run by a normal government, we would have certainly taken all necessary measures—howsoever harsh—to ensure that we learned every last iota of what the Israelis knew, when they knew it, and how they came to know it, while also tracking down and eliminating each and every American collaborator in the attacks, together with their entire network of fellow-travelers and co-conspirators.

    However, America is not a normal country run by a normal government, so almost no one cares about any of these things.

    • Replies: @Rob McX
    @Ron Unz


    If Mossad knew the exact time and location of the planned attacks and had deployed a considerable number of its agents to observe, report, and record the attacks, it is absolutely certain that the top Israeli leaders also had this information and had approved those deployments.
     
    That's the part I don't get. Once the attack had been planned, anyone who had any connection with it would be better off getting well away from the area. I don't see the advantage in sticking around - if the plan started to go wrong at the last minute, it would be too late to do anything about it. As for observing and recording it, they could hardly find out anything that wouldn't be in the news the next day anyway.

    Replies: @Ron Unz, @Rurik

    , @Drakejax
    @Ron Unz

    In an above comment I reference an expose´about MOSSAD that discussed their use of Jewish locals to augment their otherwise meagre operational force. That same book also alleges that Israeli intelligence had specific advance warning of the 1983 attack on our Marine barracks in Beirut and decided to not share the information with us. The book implies that it was done out of sheer indifference; but I would imagine such decisions would be made by people thinking about strategy and not emotions. If Israel had specific advance knowledge (or even just suspicion) of 9-11, it would be very interesting to somehow know why they kept it to themselves. My guess is because they knew America's retaliation would be to Israel's benefit, whereas thwarting the attacks would not trigger the same retaliation. So it is plausible that they decided to just sit back and watch while eating popcorn.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    , @Rurik
    @Ron Unz


    However, America is not a normal country run by a normal government, so almost no one cares about any of these things.
     
    I became cynical after Waco when I watched what our government did to those people. I've since seen video that shows by the rapid, multiple muzzle flashes that they were machine gunning the only exit to that burning building. The autopsy reports showed that there were piles of dead bodies at the exit who're riddled with bullets. They were the lucky ones I guess. But you can imagine that once the building was set on fire (the FBI admits having lied about using flammable gas canisters) that even if those people were "wackos" and deserved to die, that instinct would have taken over and they'd want to escape the flames. But from the evidence it seems clear that our government wanted those people to burn alive. (reminds me of Dresden in a way)

    And when it was all over, and before the ashes had settled, they arrested the surviving victims of that terrible massacre and charged them with all kinds of crimes.

    Then they had the gall to try to run Janet Reno for governor of Florida and the couple that was in the White House at the time are trying to get back in as we speak.

    Trying to reconcile myself to all of that, and then watching what they did on 911, and the avalanche of evidence that proves that 911 did not happen the way they said it did, and they had to be forced to even have an investigation, and then wanted it headed up by Henry Kissinger!, just all of it is enough to temp a person to become cynical at the cow-like exceptionalism of the American people.

    Thanks Ron, for providing this great site that seems an oasis of truth in an otherwise Orwellian matrix of lies.

    I hope everyone is enjoying a great holiday ; )

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

  293. @This Is Our Home
    @Seth Largo

    If you broke the law, just tell the truth.

    Replies: @donut, @ShaslA, @SFG

    I think the point is the CIA actually wants good liars. Think about it–spies have to lie all the time as part of their jobs. It’s a core skill.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @SFG


    I think the point is the CIA actually wants good liars. Think about it–spies have to lie all the time as part of their jobs. It’s a core skill.
     
    They can interview for that in other ways. It is crucial for them to note down all of your blackmail appropriate personal information and just as crucial that you tell them the truth when they ask.

    The easiest way to find all of this about you is to do a bit of research and find out oneof the many ways in which all people break the law or have weird sexual kinks or whatever, then they can ask you and if you lie about one of your known flaws then you're out. It also means that you tell them a lot of truths they didn't know.

    Admit everything and admit it in a relaxed and open manner.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

  294. @Svigor
    Rediger, SFG: is it really hard to imagine that for a sophisticated bunch like the Jews, "death penalty" evolved into "social death penalty"? Why so obtuse?

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @SFG

    Because they’re not the same thing. There’s always some guy who flies off the handle and goes off the reservation. ‘Don’t talk about Mossad or all your friends will ignore you’ is not enough to keep *some* guy from squealing. If Mossad was actually going to hunt you down like the Mafia, that would be something else.

    I’m not saying Mossad doesn’t assassinate people–we know they do. I’m saying it’s unlikely Jewish identity is strong enough every single person is going to keep secret the Israelis asking them for favors. Probably they’re smart enough to know who to ask. Do you actually know any Jews? Lots of people drift away, and 70% outmarry by now.

  295. @SPMoore8
    @Ozymandias

    Apropos of the second part of your comment, I will weigh in on 9/11 briefly, if you don't mind.

    I didn't see the planes hit but I watched the scene for about an hour, I was stuck in traffic. Actually I didn't want to watch. I glanced over once in awhile.

    Black gray smoke rose from both up to the convection layer and then moved south. I knew about a half dozen people who worked there, most survived, partly because they were late or had the day off. I remember when the smoke turned white on South Tower that was a good thing; it meant the fire was under control, or so I thought. The building bent over and collapsed straight down about 10 minutes later. By the time the second tower collapsed there was already so much smoke you could hardly see what was happening.

    I don't think there's any big mystery. The North tower had the top ten floors collapse on the the remainder, the force just knocked out the rest like dominoes. South tower, from where I was in Jersey, seemed to bend over to the South -- I thought I was hallucinating -- but then the force of 30-40 floors reestablished itself straight up down and then down.

    I don't think there's a big mystery to what happened. It's clear that pilot #2 almost missed his target. The fire weakened the supports for the upper floors, and they came down with increasing force due to the velocity of the fall. I think the terrorists may have thought they might "knock them over", I don't think they expected them to collapse the way they did.

    It's possible that some intelligence service(s) had some vague warning of something before the attack. I think that's at least as possible as foreknowledge of a possible Japanese attack in December, 1941. That would be about it.

    Replies: @Dave Pinsen

  296. @slumber_j
    @Arturo

    The WTC was host to a number of artists over the years: the space there was always a hard sell, and there were therefore a lot of vacancies, so I imagine it was a tax dodge.

    One of a couple of examples I'm aware of was the tenancy of the preposterously named but magnificent painter Rackstraw Downes. Here's a painting of his of some raw interior space there:

    http://www.art21.org/images/rackstraw-downes/untenanted-space-in-the-world-trade-center-winter-sun-1998?slideshow=1

    Replies: @Dave Pinsen

    The big scandal of the WTC is that it was built by the Port Authority of NY and NJ in the first place. In the ’80s, the toll on the George Washington Bridge was $4. Today, it’s $14 ($12 off peak with EZ Pass), and the bridge has been paid off for decades. A lot of the money goes to pay for the WTC.

    • Agree: SPMoore8
    • Replies: @D. K.
    @Dave Pinsen

    Robert Moses, even though he was not a lawyer by training, was the man who turned public works into a perpetual bonanza for bondholders, rather than a mundane tax shelter of limited duration, because of the way that he was able to manipulate and control the state legislature. Robert Caro's Pulitzer Prize-winning biography of Moses, "The Power Broker" (1974), is a long, but fascinating, education in how a brilliant bureaucrat, who thoroughly understands the system and its players, can come to dominate the politicians at whose pleasure he ostensibly serves.

    Replies: @Dave Pinsen

  297. @Ron Unz
    Well, I just finished tracking down a difficult bug, so I might as well summarize my own casual perspective regarding the 9/11 attacks, which hasn't much changed since the mid-2000s.

    (1) First, I think that the totally disorganized and frightened behavior of Bush and some other top American officials conclusively proves that the American government *as a entity* did not know about or expect the attacks; thus, the left-fringe claims of an "inside job" in that sense are absurd. However, there seems a very real possibility that a tiny number of key enemy agents or collaborators situated at crucial nodes within the governmental machinery were involved in the conspiracy, which is an entirely different thing. Needless to say, I doubt any of these American conspirators were Islamicist fanatics.

    (2) A considerable number of Israelis were caught in the immediate vicinity of the 9/11 attacks behaving in an *exceptionally* suspicious manner, and in some cases reportedly carrying explosives. At least a number of these individuals were later revealed to be Mossad agents, and others among their close associates quickly fled the country to avoid interrogation. Meanwhile, not a single Islamicist agent was caught anywhere in the vicinity, or indeed (as I recall) anywhere in the entire country. At the very least, this almost conclusively proves that Mossad knew the exact time and location of the planned attacks, while there is absolutely no evidence that the leadership of the FBI or the CIA had any such information.

    (3) Israel is a normal country, with a normal government. If Mossad knew the exact time and location of the planned attacks and had deployed a considerable number of its agents to observe, report, and record the attacks, it is absolutely certain that the top Israeli leaders also had this information and had approved those deployments.

    (4) Does this prove that the Israeli Mossad was actually behind the attacks? Not necessarily. But the key conclusion is that aside from the attackers themselves, the only government in the world with absolute, precise knowledge of the exact timing and nature of the attacks were the Israelis. Under these circumstances if America were a normal country run by a normal government, we would have certainly taken all necessary measures---howsoever harsh---to ensure that we learned every last iota of what the Israelis knew, when they knew it, and how they came to know it, while also tracking down and eliminating each and every American collaborator in the attacks, together with their entire network of fellow-travelers and co-conspirators.

    However, America is not a normal country run by a normal government, so almost no one cares about any of these things.

    Replies: @Rob McX, @Drakejax, @Rurik

    If Mossad knew the exact time and location of the planned attacks and had deployed a considerable number of its agents to observe, report, and record the attacks, it is absolutely certain that the top Israeli leaders also had this information and had approved those deployments.

    That’s the part I don’t get. Once the attack had been planned, anyone who had any connection with it would be better off getting well away from the area. I don’t see the advantage in sticking around – if the plan started to go wrong at the last minute, it would be too late to do anything about it. As for observing and recording it, they could hardly find out anything that wouldn’t be in the news the next day anyway.

    • Replies: @Ron Unz
    @Rob McX


    That’s the part I don’t get. Once the attack had been planned, anyone who had any connection with it would be better off getting well away from the area.
     
    I'd tend to agree, but it's clear that the Israelis have been getting more and more reckless and brazen over the last few decades, though admittedly not without cause. They got away with the Lavon Attacks, they got away with the Liberty Attack, and there are strong suspicions of numerous other, very big things they've gotten away with or at least tried. Their leaders probably thought that even if they were caught, their media and political assets would just bail them out, which after all is exactly what happened.

    My own guess is that the "five dancing Israelis" weren't actually acting under orders, but had just decided to take some souvenir shots they could show their friends back home about how successful the overall operation had been.

    Anyway, the undeniable fact is that there *were* a whole bunch of Israeli Mossad agents all around the exact scene of 9/11 attacks, so for whatever reason their leaders apparently don't think like you and I do. "Pride Goeth Before a Fall"...

    Replies: @anonymous, @This Is Our Home

    , @Rurik
    @Rob McX


    if the plan started to go wrong at the last minute,
     
    it did

    in all likelihood the plane that vanished over Shanksville was intended to hit building seven, thereby providing the pretext for that building to fall. When the plane never arrived, they had to scramble for a contingency and just decided to "pull it", and that's why we have that smoking gun.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

  298. @Dave Pinsen
    @slumber_j

    The big scandal of the WTC is that it was built by the Port Authority of NY and NJ in the first place. In the '80s, the toll on the George Washington Bridge was $4. Today, it's $14 ($12 off peak with EZ Pass), and the bridge has been paid off for decades. A lot of the money goes to pay for the WTC.

    Replies: @D. K.

    Robert Moses, even though he was not a lawyer by training, was the man who turned public works into a perpetual bonanza for bondholders, rather than a mundane tax shelter of limited duration, because of the way that he was able to manipulate and control the state legislature. Robert Caro’s Pulitzer Prize-winning biography of Moses, “The Power Broker” (1974), is a long, but fascinating, education in how a brilliant bureaucrat, who thoroughly understands the system and its players, can come to dominate the politicians at whose pleasure he ostensibly serves.

    • Replies: @Dave Pinsen
    @D. K.

    The real bonanza is for the Port Authority. There are PA cops making $200k per year for sitting around near the bridge.

  299. @Ron Unz
    Well, I just finished tracking down a difficult bug, so I might as well summarize my own casual perspective regarding the 9/11 attacks, which hasn't much changed since the mid-2000s.

    (1) First, I think that the totally disorganized and frightened behavior of Bush and some other top American officials conclusively proves that the American government *as a entity* did not know about or expect the attacks; thus, the left-fringe claims of an "inside job" in that sense are absurd. However, there seems a very real possibility that a tiny number of key enemy agents or collaborators situated at crucial nodes within the governmental machinery were involved in the conspiracy, which is an entirely different thing. Needless to say, I doubt any of these American conspirators were Islamicist fanatics.

    (2) A considerable number of Israelis were caught in the immediate vicinity of the 9/11 attacks behaving in an *exceptionally* suspicious manner, and in some cases reportedly carrying explosives. At least a number of these individuals were later revealed to be Mossad agents, and others among their close associates quickly fled the country to avoid interrogation. Meanwhile, not a single Islamicist agent was caught anywhere in the vicinity, or indeed (as I recall) anywhere in the entire country. At the very least, this almost conclusively proves that Mossad knew the exact time and location of the planned attacks, while there is absolutely no evidence that the leadership of the FBI or the CIA had any such information.

    (3) Israel is a normal country, with a normal government. If Mossad knew the exact time and location of the planned attacks and had deployed a considerable number of its agents to observe, report, and record the attacks, it is absolutely certain that the top Israeli leaders also had this information and had approved those deployments.

    (4) Does this prove that the Israeli Mossad was actually behind the attacks? Not necessarily. But the key conclusion is that aside from the attackers themselves, the only government in the world with absolute, precise knowledge of the exact timing and nature of the attacks were the Israelis. Under these circumstances if America were a normal country run by a normal government, we would have certainly taken all necessary measures---howsoever harsh---to ensure that we learned every last iota of what the Israelis knew, when they knew it, and how they came to know it, while also tracking down and eliminating each and every American collaborator in the attacks, together with their entire network of fellow-travelers and co-conspirators.

    However, America is not a normal country run by a normal government, so almost no one cares about any of these things.

    Replies: @Rob McX, @Drakejax, @Rurik

    In an above comment I reference an expose´about MOSSAD that discussed their use of Jewish locals to augment their otherwise meagre operational force. That same book also alleges that Israeli intelligence had specific advance warning of the 1983 attack on our Marine barracks in Beirut and decided to not share the information with us. The book implies that it was done out of sheer indifference; but I would imagine such decisions would be made by people thinking about strategy and not emotions. If Israel had specific advance knowledge (or even just suspicion) of 9-11, it would be very interesting to somehow know why they kept it to themselves. My guess is because they knew America’s retaliation would be to Israel’s benefit, whereas thwarting the attacks would not trigger the same retaliation. So it is plausible that they decided to just sit back and watch while eating popcorn.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Drakejax

    A lot of intelligence stuff is kind of random with reports that turn out to be accurate being overlooked: "My wife's cousin's kid is kind of a 'tard. He's an illegal alien working as a mover in Paterson, NJ with a bunch of other morons from the old neighborhood in Tel Aviv. My wife's always begging me to give him some Mossad work to make his mother proud of him. So, on the grounds that he does speak Arabic, I put him on the budget to keep tabs on the Arabs in Paterson for $4700 per year, which he keeps in his sock if you can believe that. He thinks he and his buddies are Mossad agents and they sent me a weekly report about what they overhear at the falafel huts where they eat lunch. It's mostly gibberish. But the evening of 9/11, the Prime Minister ordered us to go back through all our reports to see if anybody had reported anything. Sure enough, at 5am I find it there in black and white: at a gas station in Paterson, two Arabs in line ahead of him said: "The Two Towers will fall." I must have figured at the time they were probably Tolkien fans and paid no more attention to to it than to the rest of the nonsense he sends me.

    "Then it turns out my wife's cousin and the other idiot movers got picked up by the local cops for celebrating their big spy coup predicting 9/11. Ehud told me he'd kill me with his bare hands if we didn't shut them up before the Americans found out. Fortunately we had a line into an Israeli close personal friend of New Jersey governor McGreevey and he made sure a friendly prosecutor got into see them and give them our proposition before the FBI took them away and sweated them for six weeks."

  300. @Rob McX
    @Ron Unz


    If Mossad knew the exact time and location of the planned attacks and had deployed a considerable number of its agents to observe, report, and record the attacks, it is absolutely certain that the top Israeli leaders also had this information and had approved those deployments.
     
    That's the part I don't get. Once the attack had been planned, anyone who had any connection with it would be better off getting well away from the area. I don't see the advantage in sticking around - if the plan started to go wrong at the last minute, it would be too late to do anything about it. As for observing and recording it, they could hardly find out anything that wouldn't be in the news the next day anyway.

    Replies: @Ron Unz, @Rurik

    That’s the part I don’t get. Once the attack had been planned, anyone who had any connection with it would be better off getting well away from the area.

    I’d tend to agree, but it’s clear that the Israelis have been getting more and more reckless and brazen over the last few decades, though admittedly not without cause. They got away with the Lavon Attacks, they got away with the Liberty Attack, and there are strong suspicions of numerous other, very big things they’ve gotten away with or at least tried. Their leaders probably thought that even if they were caught, their media and political assets would just bail them out, which after all is exactly what happened.

    My own guess is that the “five dancing Israelis” weren’t actually acting under orders, but had just decided to take some souvenir shots they could show their friends back home about how successful the overall operation had been.

    Anyway, the undeniable fact is that there *were* a whole bunch of Israeli Mossad agents all around the exact scene of 9/11 attacks, so for whatever reason their leaders apparently don’t think like you and I do. “Pride Goeth Before a Fall”…

    • Replies: @anonymous
    @Ron Unz

    Why won't somebody expose this, or at least dig a bit deeper? This is a big, juicy story.

    Is the entire media that corrupt?

    It's madness that nobody is looking into this situation—especially when you consider the damage that has been done to America in the aftermath of these events.

    Replies: @Rurik

    , @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz


    My own guess is that the “five dancing Israelis” weren’t actually acting under orders, but had just decided to take some souvenir shots they could show their friends back home about how successful the overall operation had been.
     
    If Israeli had planned 9/11 and it were found out, that would be the end of their country.

    So I can definitely see why the Israeli government would have maintained opsec so loose that 5 random bozos were told and could sit back and watch the event.

    Anyway, the undeniable fact is that there *were* a whole bunch of Israeli Mossad agents all around the exact scene of 9/11 attacks, so for whatever reason their leaders apparently don’t think like you and I do. “Pride Goeth Before a Fall”…
     
    I've seen nothing that makes it undeniable. Just a lot of quickly disproven rumours. Regardless, that there are MOSSAD affiliates (agents is a real stretch even if you can these rumours at face value) in New York is hardly surprising.

    Replies: @Ron Unz

  301. @matt
    @Ron Unz


    a year or two later 40% of the American troops in Iraq believed the same thing...
     
    You're being too kind. It was actually 85% of our brave (and stupid) men and women in uniform who believed that.

    Replies: @Ron Unz

    a year or two later 40% of the American troops in Iraq believed the same thing…

    You’re being too kind. It was actually 85% of our brave (and stupid) men and women in uniform who believed that.

    Touche. When I wrote that comment, I couldn’t quite remember the actual figure, and thought it might be 60% but decided to play safe with 40%. However, 85% is a real surprise. That “Realist” fellow seems to end half his comments by saying “people are stupid” so I hope he reads this thread.

  302. anonymous • Disclaimer says:
    @Ron Unz
    @Rob McX


    That’s the part I don’t get. Once the attack had been planned, anyone who had any connection with it would be better off getting well away from the area.
     
    I'd tend to agree, but it's clear that the Israelis have been getting more and more reckless and brazen over the last few decades, though admittedly not without cause. They got away with the Lavon Attacks, they got away with the Liberty Attack, and there are strong suspicions of numerous other, very big things they've gotten away with or at least tried. Their leaders probably thought that even if they were caught, their media and political assets would just bail them out, which after all is exactly what happened.

    My own guess is that the "five dancing Israelis" weren't actually acting under orders, but had just decided to take some souvenir shots they could show their friends back home about how successful the overall operation had been.

    Anyway, the undeniable fact is that there *were* a whole bunch of Israeli Mossad agents all around the exact scene of 9/11 attacks, so for whatever reason their leaders apparently don't think like you and I do. "Pride Goeth Before a Fall"...

    Replies: @anonymous, @This Is Our Home

    Why won’t somebody expose this, or at least dig a bit deeper? This is a big, juicy story.

    Is the entire media that corrupt?

    It’s madness that nobody is looking into this situation—especially when you consider the damage that has been done to America in the aftermath of these events.

    • Replies: @Rurik
    @anonymous


    Why won’t somebody expose this, or at least dig a bit deeper? This is a big, juicy story.

    Is the entire media that corrupt?

    It’s madness that nobody is looking into this situation
     
    just compare it to the coverage of the attack on the USS Liberty

    That was an all out aggressive act of war and cowardly act of treachery against Israel's most generous and important ally. It would have sold newspapers like the attack on Peal Harbor, but there wasn't a peep. Not so much as a cricket's chirp. There was instead threats to the surviving sailors that if they mentioned it they'd be court-martialed.

    The all pervasive silence (or disinformation if anything) regarding the media and 911 certainly has precedent.

    Is the entire media that corrupt?
     
    yes
  303. @This Is Our Home
    @tbraton


    But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers. I’m generally not one who subscribes to conspiracy theories, but, when faced with such disturbing, inexplicable facts, one has to conclude that we don’t have the entire story.
     
    Have you ever looked this up to see how an expert would answer your query? It seems that they ahve put a lot of effort into it and are very well-informed of the technical details. Why would they lie?

    http://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/design/a3524/4278874/

    Replies: @Truth

    Why would they lie?

    The “expert” who original edited this article is the is the Brother of Michael Chertoff, who at the time was the acting Director of Homeland Security.

    Maybe that’s why.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Truth


    The “expert” who original edited this article is the is the Brother of Michael Chertoff, who at the time was the acting Director of Homeland Security.

    Maybe that’s why.
     
    And the experts who read it but kicked up no fuss? How many millions of people are supposedly in on this?

    Replies: @Truth

    , @Hunsdon
    @Truth

    Truth: I'd like to apologize. I've come to regard you as a "Johnny One Note" poster, and I was wrong. I like you a lot better when you branch out from what seems to be your usual shtick. (Despite the knee-grow comment in your post immediately following.) Yeah, I know, my comment will change your life, what can I say?

    Replies: @Truth, @Mr. Anon

  304. @Svigor
    E.g., I defy anyone with any sense of how leftist the media is, and how audience-manipulation in American media works, to watch The Americans' depiction of the South African storyline and tell me that wasn't one of the most right-wing things on TV, ever. But at the same time, completely deniable.

    Replies: @Truth

    The Americans’ depiction of the South African storyline and tell me that wasn’t one of the most right-wing things on TV, ever.

    I agree. That plus the storyline where she was porking the knee-grow.

  305. @D. K.
    @Dave Pinsen

    Robert Moses, even though he was not a lawyer by training, was the man who turned public works into a perpetual bonanza for bondholders, rather than a mundane tax shelter of limited duration, because of the way that he was able to manipulate and control the state legislature. Robert Caro's Pulitzer Prize-winning biography of Moses, "The Power Broker" (1974), is a long, but fascinating, education in how a brilliant bureaucrat, who thoroughly understands the system and its players, can come to dominate the politicians at whose pleasure he ostensibly serves.

    Replies: @Dave Pinsen

    The real bonanza is for the Port Authority. There are PA cops making $200k per year for sitting around near the bridge.

  306. @Mr. Anon
    @tbraton

    "But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner."

    Do you know anything - anything at all - about WTC 7 other than what you saw on a grainy YouTube video? And if it was all part of some vast conspiracy, why didn't the conspirators fly a plane into WTC 7, to complete the illusion? They forgot? Oops.........We wanted to engineer the destruction of these three buildings and make people believe that it was due to airplanes, but we forgot to fly an airplane into one of them.

    Replies: @Truth

    why didn’t the conspirators fly a plane into WTC 7, to complete the illusion? They forgot?

    Just taking a shot in the dark here: Because they knew that guys like you were going to believe it anyway?

    BTW Welcome back Grasshopper. Or maybe I was the one who left?

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Truth

    "Just taking a shot in the dark here: Because they knew that guys like you were going to believe it anyway?"

    Guys like me? You mean guys who know something about physics?

    Whereas the "Truth" movement appeals to guys like you - who believe that cars can be fueled with water.

    "BTW Welcome back Grasshopper. Or maybe I was the one who left?"

    You're back? Time off for good behavior, perhaps?

    I've always been here. You were the one who was gone. You should keep it that way. You weren't missed.

  307. @Steve Sailer
    @AnonymousCoward

    Isn't Robert Rediger the university president who converts Francois to Islam in "Submission?"

    Replies: @AnonymousCoward, @This Is Our Home

    Aha… it makes sense that this commenter wasn’t clever enough to invent such a creative name himself, thanks for the catch

  308. @Steve Sailer
    @Anonymous

    He complains a lot about how he proved on 10/14/2002 that Saddam couldn't afford a nuclear bomb program anymore but nobody would listen to him.

    Replies: @Josh, @Thomas O. Meehan

    I lived in New Jersey at the time of the attack and was working in law enforcement. I recall reports of Arabs celebrating on the streets of Paterson or Passaic. At this remove I can’t say I saw video of said jubilation, but it was reported and taken at face value by a very large percentage of the population. At the same time the airwaves were full of footage of Palestinians openly celebrating. Those were the circumstances. It would be surprising if no one among the notoriously unassimilated ME populations in their ethnic ghettos hadn’t celebrated a bit. At the same time it is possible that Trump saw the dancing Palestinians and conflated them with the reports from Paterson and or Passaic.

    That said, I think it is possible that footage exists but is lost or being withheld.

    If Trump is delusional about the dancing arabs of Passaic, he shares that delusion with millions of fellow New York area citizens.

    • Replies: @Ron Unz
    @Thomas O. Meehan


    I lived in New Jersey at the time of the attack and was working in law enforcement. I recall reports of Arabs celebrating on the streets of Paterson or Passaic. At this remove I can’t say I saw video of said jubilation, but it was reported and taken at face value by a very large percentage of the population...That said, I think it is possible that footage exists but is lost or being withheld.
     
    As I mentioned earlier, I find such claims *exceptionally* implausible.

    Don't forget that the Neocons had absolute and total control of a substantial portion of the local and national media at that point, plus the Giuliani Admin, and were using it to promote the tremendous domestic dangers from of Arabs/Muslims. Large numbers of totally innocent such individuals, minding their own business, were grabbed up by the police due to mass hysteria, and kept under arrest for quite a long time. As far as I'm aware, not a single one was every proven to be directly sympathetic to the terrorist attacks. In fact, some of the Neocons quickly began pressing for a mass-internment of Arabs/Muslims, much like happened with the Japanese in WWII, and to that end they began publishing books and articles saying that FDR had been totally legally and morally justified in the Japanese Internment.

    If any such video footage existed, they would have broadcast it 24/7 (unless, of course, you agree with the Jewish-activists that the American media is fanatically anti-Jewish and anti-Israel).

    At the same time the airwaves were full of footage of Palestinians openly celebrating.
     
    Although I've never never investigated it, I'm *extremely* skeptical that such alleged celebration overseas occurred in more than a small handful of cases. All that happens is that some 30-second video shot is endlessly looped over FoxNews or ABC, with voice-over explanation by the anchor, and that becomes the reality of rightwing dimwits everywhere. Indeed, the whole thing might easily have been staged.

    If Trump is delusional about the dancing arabs of Passaic, he shares that delusion with millions of fellow New York area citizens.
     
    Well, I agree with you there. And I'd bet that many, many millions of American blacks (and whites) also believe that the KKK has been burning black churches all around the country and that white racist police have been randomly killing black children everywhere for eating skittles. Or perhaps you've never heard of the Black Lives Matter movement...

    As I've said before, Trump is a totally ignorant buffoon, and given our current ideological principles, the rightful political representative of many millions of Buffoon-Americans...

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @This Is Our Home, @inertial, @Thomas O. Meehan

    , @Anonymous
    @Thomas O. Meehan

    Trump repeatedly asserted that there were "thousands and thousands", which would imply large crowds in the streets celebrating. "Millions" of Tri-State area citizens certainly don't recall "thousands and thousands" celebrating in the streets in the aftermath of 9/11. It seems pretty likely that this is just Trump's trademark exaggerating salesmanship, if not outright lying.

    It'd be hard to believe if there weren't any Muslims in New Jersey happy about the attacks and some groups of them celebrating out in the streets in the aftermath, but that wasn't what Trump suggested and wasn't the image he was trying to convey with his remarks of "thousands and thousands".

    Replies: @Thomas O. Meehan

  309. @Rurik
    @Mr. Anon



    George Bush said publically (and on camera) that he saw the first plane hit WTC tower- curious. Did you know that? Does it matter to your mind if he said it or even if he did see it?”
     
    And what is so odd about that?

     

    first plane

    let that sink in for a minute

    ok

    here, let me help

    here's the video

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eyi33ftRUZY

    you can find it all over the Internet if you look, (or cared)

    but for people with a functioning brain, for George Bush to have seen the FIRST plane hit the tower, which he clearly did from what he says, then that means that he was watching a live video feed of the "terrorist" attacks on that day. Someone had a camera set up and Bush happened to be watching before he went into that classroom.

    the kind of insanity that has largely come to characterizes the “Truther” movement.
     
    insanity indeed

    it literally is a kind of insanity to watch building seven implode and tell yourself that is was office fires that did it

    or to see president George Bush talking about watching the FIRST plane hit the tower and consider it of no consequence

    rather I wouldn't so much put it down to insanity as I would intellectual and moral cowardice

    ; )

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

    “first plane

    let that sink in for a minute

    ok

    here, let me help

    here’s the video”

    In that video that you posted, he did NOT say it was the first plane. He only said that he saw a plane hit the tower. Watch it again – and listen.

    And even if he did say first plane, so what? There is video of the first plane hitting.

    Or do you imagine that Bush’s Mossad handlers had a private video feed set up for him, so that he could watch as the most egregious crime in American history was carrie out, knowing full well that he was a willing participant? And then, after all that, he admitted his culpability?

    You “truther” guys must be autistic. Or you’re just stupid. I really don’t care anymore. You are all loathsome f**ks.

    “it literally is a kind of insanity to watch building seven implode and tell yourself that is was office fires that did it”

    You are willfully stupid. It wasn’t just office fires. The building had a f**king diesel fuel bunker in it to power back-up generators. Add to that, it was scoured by debris from the first impacts, and it had a make-shift cantilever structure becuause it was built over a subway station.

    “rather I wouldn’t so much put it down to insanity as I would intellectual and moral cowardice”

    F**k you. You idiots are stupid and crazy. You aren’t worth the time of day.

    • Replies: @Rurik
    @Mr. Anon


    In that video that you posted, he did NOT say it was the first plane. He only said that he saw a plane hit the tower. Watch it again – and listen.

    And even if he did say first plane, so what? There is video of the first plane hitting.
     
    he said he was outside the Florida classroom when he saw the plane hit the tower and that he thought it must be a bad pilot. We all know that the second plane didn't hit until he was well inside the classroom and reading about the pet goat. If it were the second plane then even someone as monumentally stupid as George Bush would have figured out that a second plane hitting the towers was not just a coincidence or pilot error, don't you think?

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UpdjFV6nYB4

    and just for you, I'm posting again a video of building seven falling. There are thousands upon thousands of architects and structural engineers and building engineers and demolition experts and other professionals that have put their names and reputations on the line by going public and saying that there is no way that building seven could have fallen the way it did due to office fires or any of the structural damage it suffered.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mamvq7LWqRU

    here's a controlled demolition expert

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=877gr6xtQIc

    he's since died in a car crash
  310. @Drakejax
    @Ron Unz

    In an above comment I reference an expose´about MOSSAD that discussed their use of Jewish locals to augment their otherwise meagre operational force. That same book also alleges that Israeli intelligence had specific advance warning of the 1983 attack on our Marine barracks in Beirut and decided to not share the information with us. The book implies that it was done out of sheer indifference; but I would imagine such decisions would be made by people thinking about strategy and not emotions. If Israel had specific advance knowledge (or even just suspicion) of 9-11, it would be very interesting to somehow know why they kept it to themselves. My guess is because they knew America's retaliation would be to Israel's benefit, whereas thwarting the attacks would not trigger the same retaliation. So it is plausible that they decided to just sit back and watch while eating popcorn.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    A lot of intelligence stuff is kind of random with reports that turn out to be accurate being overlooked: “My wife’s cousin’s kid is kind of a ‘tard. He’s an illegal alien working as a mover in Paterson, NJ with a bunch of other morons from the old neighborhood in Tel Aviv. My wife’s always begging me to give him some Mossad work to make his mother proud of him. So, on the grounds that he does speak Arabic, I put him on the budget to keep tabs on the Arabs in Paterson for $4700 per year, which he keeps in his sock if you can believe that. He thinks he and his buddies are Mossad agents and they sent me a weekly report about what they overhear at the falafel huts where they eat lunch. It’s mostly gibberish. But the evening of 9/11, the Prime Minister ordered us to go back through all our reports to see if anybody had reported anything. Sure enough, at 5am I find it there in black and white: at a gas station in Paterson, two Arabs in line ahead of him said: “The Two Towers will fall.” I must have figured at the time they were probably Tolkien fans and paid no more attention to to it than to the rest of the nonsense he sends me.

    “Then it turns out my wife’s cousin and the other idiot movers got picked up by the local cops for celebrating their big spy coup predicting 9/11. Ehud told me he’d kill me with his bare hands if we didn’t shut them up before the Americans found out. Fortunately we had a line into an Israeli close personal friend of New Jersey governor McGreevey and he made sure a friendly prosecutor got into see them and give them our proposition before the FBI took them away and sweated them for six weeks.”

  311. @tanabear
    @This Is Our Home

    The official account can not even begin to explain the events of 9/11. The sine qua non of the 9/11 attacks is the collapse of World Trade Towers 1,2 and 7 on that day. The official version, to the extent that there is one, cannot account for these phenomena. The National Institutes of Standards and Technology(NIST) was tasked with investigating the collapses. For WTC 1 and 2 their analysis started from the time of the plane impacts until the buildings were poised for collapse, but they did not analyze the actual collapse. Or in their words, "although it does not actually include the structural behavior of the tower after the conditions for collapse initiation were reached and collapse became inevitable." They seem to punt the ball over to Zdenek Bazant in explaining the collapse. His theory is crush-down, crush up. A theory devoid of any evidence, replication, and historical precedence.

    WTC 7 is so obviously a controlled demolition that even defenders of the official story don't like to mention it. NIST did finally admit that the tower did collapse for 2.25 seconds in full-free fall, contradicting their initial statement that WTC7 did not enter free-fall and there was resistance provided. So unless you believe in the feasibility of momentum transfer at free-fall acceleration the official account is toast.

    Rurik: "The most damning things are the way the BBC and other news outlets reported on the implosion of building seven before it happened."

    Yes, how did everyone know that WTC7 was coming down before it collapsed, but after it collapsed they didn't have any idea how it fell? How is it possible to have certain knowledge of an unprecedented before it happens, but be completely clueless afterwards ???

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    You forgot to answer my question. I’ll ask again: what is the most plausible theory in your opinion?

    • Replies: @Truth
    @This Is Our Home

    I can only answer your question, with a question, Socratic style; Look at the video of the Pentagon being "hit by an airplane", no hurry, I'll wait.

    OK, you have the video of "the Pentagon being hit by an airplane" up on youtube? Good. Not tell me, where is the airplane?

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    , @tanabear
    @This Is Our Home

    Broadly speaking the 9/11 Truth Movement is trying to accomplish two things.

    1) Showing that the official story is false and incomplete

    2) Providing an alternate explanation as to what happened and holding the perpetrators accountable.

    The first goal has been accomplished. The official story is false on almost every level. This is a resolved scientific matter. It is no more controversial than the question of whether the Earth is round or flat. For the second goal to be accomplished there would need to be an actual investigation into 9/11. Since there has not been an open investigation we can only surmise as to what may have happened. We do know that the three towers were destroyed via a planned demolition. This is the starting point from where an investigation should begin.

    But 9/11 did meet the neo-cons need for a "new Pearl Harbor event" that they believed was necessary for transforming the Middle-East and the American military. It was the foundational event that allowed for all pre-existing neo-con policies to be put into effect.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @This Is Our Home

  312. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Ron Unz
    @This Is Our Home


    This means that not only is the message polluted but because the message is now largely the messenger, our message is associated with a toxic mixture of self-aggrandising liars and the obviously crazy.

    You should not ban these guys, but please do not entertain them.

    God, I wish I might recommend your blog to others but some things are just too hard to recover from being associated with. Unz.com is now not only the site for opinions rendered taboo by the PC zeitgeist but also for opinions so utterly nuts that the zeitgeist rejects them too
     
    I really like it when some random, anonymous ultra-right-wing Internet nut suddenly shows up here and within a couple of weeks is telling everyone how the entire website should be completely changed. As far as I can see, you're mostly interested in fanatically denouncing Muslims and "anti-Semites" so maybe you're just Whiskey's long-lost brother or something...

    Replies: @AnonymousCoward, @This Is Our Home

    I really like it when some random, anonymous ultra-right-wing Internet nut suddenly shows up here and within a couple of weeks is telling everyone how the entire website should be completely changed. As far as I can see, you’re mostly interested in fanatically denouncing Muslims and “anti-Semites” so maybe you’re just Whiskey’s long-lost brother or something…

    Anti Semites are fine, isn’t everyone a bit anti-semitic? Just please stick to the even faintly plausible.

    Muslims are fine, actually I really like many I know, I just don’t think that Arabs are at home in Europe, which makes me no more radical than the majority of Europeans and practically all of our ancestors, and the Arabs and South Asians themselves, when they’re being honest.

    The bias of my comments on this site is pretty explainable. I’m only motivated to comment when I have cause to strongly disagree.

    As for my suggestions, take them or leave them, obviously that is your choice. That I was minded to make suggestions was only because I appreciate this site, so no need to take it personally. Why else would I make suggestions that I believe would allow this site a wider audience?

  313. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Steve Sailer
    @AnonymousCoward

    Isn't Robert Rediger the university president who converts Francois to Islam in "Submission?"

    Replies: @AnonymousCoward, @This Is Our Home

    Isn’t Robert Rediger the university president who converts Francois to Islam in “Submission?”

    If our societies are going to look like the Middle East, primitive and full of mindless conspiracy theorising, then I might as well at least get 4 wives out of it.

    And this is the way things are going, when it comes to society ‘fertile’ is the prerequisite virtue.

  314. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @SFG
    @This Is Our Home

    I think the point is the CIA actually wants good liars. Think about it--spies have to lie all the time as part of their jobs. It's a core skill.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    I think the point is the CIA actually wants good liars. Think about it–spies have to lie all the time as part of their jobs. It’s a core skill.

    They can interview for that in other ways. It is crucial for them to note down all of your blackmail appropriate personal information and just as crucial that you tell them the truth when they ask.

    The easiest way to find all of this about you is to do a bit of research and find out oneof the many ways in which all people break the law or have weird sexual kinks or whatever, then they can ask you and if you lie about one of your known flaws then you’re out. It also means that you tell them a lot of truths they didn’t know.

    Admit everything and admit it in a relaxed and open manner.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @This Is Our Home

    Funny how this description of CIA hiring sounds like a Skull and Bones meeting.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

  315. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Truth
    @This Is Our Home


    Why would they lie?
     
    The "expert" who original edited this article is the is the Brother of Michael Chertoff, who at the time was the acting Director of Homeland Security.

    Maybe that's why.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Hunsdon

    The “expert” who original edited this article is the is the Brother of Michael Chertoff, who at the time was the acting Director of Homeland Security.

    Maybe that’s why.

    And the experts who read it but kicked up no fuss? How many millions of people are supposedly in on this?

    • Replies: @Truth
    @This Is Our Home

    “It would not be impossible to prove with sufficient repetition and a psychological understanding of the people concerned that a square is in fact a circle. They are mere words, and words can be molded until they clothe ideas and disguise.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels

    “Think of the press as a great keyboard
    on which the government can play.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels

    “The most brilliant propagandist technique will yield no success unless one fundamental principle is borne in mind constantly - it must confine itself to a few points and repeat them over and over.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels

    “If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it. The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie. It thus becomes vitally important for the State to use all of its powers to repress dissent, for the truth is the mortal enemy of the lie, and thus by extension, the truth is the greatest enemy of the State.”
    - Joseph Goebbels

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

  316. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Ron Unz
    @Rob McX


    That’s the part I don’t get. Once the attack had been planned, anyone who had any connection with it would be better off getting well away from the area.
     
    I'd tend to agree, but it's clear that the Israelis have been getting more and more reckless and brazen over the last few decades, though admittedly not without cause. They got away with the Lavon Attacks, they got away with the Liberty Attack, and there are strong suspicions of numerous other, very big things they've gotten away with or at least tried. Their leaders probably thought that even if they were caught, their media and political assets would just bail them out, which after all is exactly what happened.

    My own guess is that the "five dancing Israelis" weren't actually acting under orders, but had just decided to take some souvenir shots they could show their friends back home about how successful the overall operation had been.

    Anyway, the undeniable fact is that there *were* a whole bunch of Israeli Mossad agents all around the exact scene of 9/11 attacks, so for whatever reason their leaders apparently don't think like you and I do. "Pride Goeth Before a Fall"...

    Replies: @anonymous, @This Is Our Home

    My own guess is that the “five dancing Israelis” weren’t actually acting under orders, but had just decided to take some souvenir shots they could show their friends back home about how successful the overall operation had been.

    If Israeli had planned 9/11 and it were found out, that would be the end of their country.

    So I can definitely see why the Israeli government would have maintained opsec so loose that 5 random bozos were told and could sit back and watch the event.

    Anyway, the undeniable fact is that there *were* a whole bunch of Israeli Mossad agents all around the exact scene of 9/11 attacks, so for whatever reason their leaders apparently don’t think like you and I do. “Pride Goeth Before a Fall”…

    I’ve seen nothing that makes it undeniable. Just a lot of quickly disproven rumours. Regardless, that there are MOSSAD affiliates (agents is a real stretch even if you can these rumours at face value) in New York is hardly surprising.

    • Replies: @Ron Unz
    @This Is Our Home


    If Israeli had planned 9/11 and it were found out, that would be the end of their country.
     
    Not really---only if it also gets on national TV instead of the Kardashians and Football. The Media creates Reality, and if the Media doesn't report it, it doesn't exist. After all, the Lavon Attacks and the Liberty Attack are absolutely documented and confirmed, and all that happened was America increased its financial tribute payments to Israel. Meanwhile, in a different matter John McCain still ranks as America's greatest Vietnam War Hero...

    Incidentally, for someone who just suddenly showed up and wants the website to stop publishing all sorts of things he doesn't like, you certainly seem to be leaving a *lot* of comments, though none of them seem very intelligent or interesting to me. So maybe you'd be happier just going back to FoxNews or whatever.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

  317. @This Is Our Home
    @SFG


    I think the point is the CIA actually wants good liars. Think about it–spies have to lie all the time as part of their jobs. It’s a core skill.
     
    They can interview for that in other ways. It is crucial for them to note down all of your blackmail appropriate personal information and just as crucial that you tell them the truth when they ask.

    The easiest way to find all of this about you is to do a bit of research and find out oneof the many ways in which all people break the law or have weird sexual kinks or whatever, then they can ask you and if you lie about one of your known flaws then you're out. It also means that you tell them a lot of truths they didn't know.

    Admit everything and admit it in a relaxed and open manner.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    Funny how this description of CIA hiring sounds like a Skull and Bones meeting.

    • Agree: This Is Our Home
    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Steve Sailer

    http://isteve.blogspot.com/2014/01/tom-wolfe-on-skull-and-bones.html

    Funny how we know that the CIA sponsored painters and writers (such as Peter Matthiessen), but nobody seems to have ever asked that question about the most influential journalist of his generation, who got his Ph.D. from the CIA-affiliated Yale American Studies Dept.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

  318. @Steve Sailer
    @This Is Our Home

    Funny how this description of CIA hiring sounds like a Skull and Bones meeting.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    http://isteve.blogspot.com/2014/01/tom-wolfe-on-skull-and-bones.html

    Funny how we know that the CIA sponsored painters and writers (such as Peter Matthiessen), but nobody seems to have ever asked that question about the most influential journalist of his generation, who got his Ph.D. from the CIA-affiliated Yale American Studies Dept.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Steve Sailer

    Wouldn't it be great to sit on a fund of money so big and have so much discretion over it that essentially you can become an old-fashioned 'patron of the arts?'

    Although, perhaps you don't need so much money as who doesn't want to be a spy?

  319. @This Is Our Home
    @tanabear

    You forgot to answer my question. I'll ask again: what is the most plausible theory in your opinion?

    Replies: @Truth, @tanabear

    I can only answer your question, with a question, Socratic style; Look at the video of the Pentagon being “hit by an airplane”, no hurry, I’ll wait.

    OK, you have the video of “the Pentagon being hit by an airplane” up on youtube? Good. Not tell me, where is the airplane?

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Truth


    I can only answer your question, with a question, Socratic style; Look at the video of the Pentagon being “hit by an airplane”, no hurry, I’ll wait.

    OK, you have the video of “the Pentagon being hit by an airplane” up on youtube? Good. Not tell me, where is the airplane?
     
    Of course that does not answer my question. You propose no theory, you just point out that reality is complicated and say 'see!'

    Nonetheless, I'll get dragged in and humour you.

    The video looks legit to me, considering the low number of frames per minute(!) on the footage and the speed at which an aircraft would cover the distance of the camera's purview.

    Let's guesstimate:

    There's 1 frame every 1 second.

    The distance covered by the aircraft is 100 metres.

    This means that to be unclear on the footage the aircraft would only need to be travelling at 360km per hour, which is rather a lot less than a dive bombing aircraft would at. Hence there's a more than likely chance that the aircraft would not be captured on the footage.

    Of course the aircraft actually is just visible at the 7 second mark on the right...so now you're probably going to talk some nonsense about CGI or something...and we go round and round the insanity loop again and again and again.

    Propose a better theory!

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BXgtsavot5A

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @Truth

  320. @This Is Our Home
    @Truth


    The “expert” who original edited this article is the is the Brother of Michael Chertoff, who at the time was the acting Director of Homeland Security.

    Maybe that’s why.
     
    And the experts who read it but kicked up no fuss? How many millions of people are supposedly in on this?

    Replies: @Truth

    “It would not be impossible to prove with sufficient repetition and a psychological understanding of the people concerned that a square is in fact a circle. They are mere words, and words can be molded until they clothe ideas and disguise.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels

    “Think of the press as a great keyboard
    on which the government can play.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels

    “The most brilliant propagandist technique will yield no success unless one fundamental principle is borne in mind constantly – it must confine itself to a few points and repeat them over and over.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels

    “If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it. The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie. It thus becomes vitally important for the State to use all of its powers to repress dissent, for the truth is the mortal enemy of the lie, and thus by extension, the truth is the greatest enemy of the State.”
    – Joseph Goebbels

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Truth

    So everything is a lie because a dead Nazi made some self-aggrandising statements about how great and powerful a liar he was?

    Nevermind that this:

    “The most brilliant propagandist technique will yield no success unless one fundamental principle is borne in mind constantly – it must confine itself to a few points and repeat them over and over.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels


    Summarises the 9/11 'truth' movement perfectly...

    , @Mr. Anon
    @Truth

    "“If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it."

    And that's exactly what the so-called "Truthers" have done. Although to be fair to them, they don't consider it to be a lie - they are just deluded and/or crazy, autistic, or stupid people.

  321. @Steve Sailer
    @Steve Sailer

    http://isteve.blogspot.com/2014/01/tom-wolfe-on-skull-and-bones.html

    Funny how we know that the CIA sponsored painters and writers (such as Peter Matthiessen), but nobody seems to have ever asked that question about the most influential journalist of his generation, who got his Ph.D. from the CIA-affiliated Yale American Studies Dept.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    Wouldn’t it be great to sit on a fund of money so big and have so much discretion over it that essentially you can become an old-fashioned ‘patron of the arts?’

    Although, perhaps you don’t need so much money as who doesn’t want to be a spy?

  322. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Truth
    @This Is Our Home

    I can only answer your question, with a question, Socratic style; Look at the video of the Pentagon being "hit by an airplane", no hurry, I'll wait.

    OK, you have the video of "the Pentagon being hit by an airplane" up on youtube? Good. Not tell me, where is the airplane?

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    I can only answer your question, with a question, Socratic style; Look at the video of the Pentagon being “hit by an airplane”, no hurry, I’ll wait.

    OK, you have the video of “the Pentagon being hit by an airplane” up on youtube? Good. Not tell me, where is the airplane?

    Of course that does not answer my question. You propose no theory, you just point out that reality is complicated and say ‘see!’

    Nonetheless, I’ll get dragged in and humour you.

    The video looks legit to me, considering the low number of frames per minute(!) on the footage and the speed at which an aircraft would cover the distance of the camera’s purview.

    Let’s guesstimate:

    There’s 1 frame every 1 second.

    The distance covered by the aircraft is 100 metres.

    This means that to be unclear on the footage the aircraft would only need to be travelling at 360km per hour, which is rather a lot less than a dive bombing aircraft would at. Hence there’s a more than likely chance that the aircraft would not be captured on the footage.

    Of course the aircraft actually is just visible at the 7 second mark on the right…so now you’re probably going to talk some nonsense about CGI or something…and we go round and round the insanity loop again and again and again.

    Propose a better theory!

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @This Is Our Home

    Hundreds of motorists stuck in traffic jams saw the airliner hit the Pentagon, just as lots of New Yorkers saw the first airliner strike the North WTC. (The whole world saw the second airliner hit the South WTC.)

    Replies: @Rurik

    , @Truth
    @This Is Our Home

    No, Pluto, the question is, where are the bodies, where are the seats, where are the jet engines, where are the wings, where are the windows, where is the luggage; etc..etc.

    Stick with this thing, it gets easier.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Boomstick

  323. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Truth
    @This Is Our Home

    “It would not be impossible to prove with sufficient repetition and a psychological understanding of the people concerned that a square is in fact a circle. They are mere words, and words can be molded until they clothe ideas and disguise.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels

    “Think of the press as a great keyboard
    on which the government can play.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels

    “The most brilliant propagandist technique will yield no success unless one fundamental principle is borne in mind constantly - it must confine itself to a few points and repeat them over and over.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels

    “If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it. The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie. It thus becomes vitally important for the State to use all of its powers to repress dissent, for the truth is the mortal enemy of the lie, and thus by extension, the truth is the greatest enemy of the State.”
    - Joseph Goebbels

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

    So everything is a lie because a dead Nazi made some self-aggrandising statements about how great and powerful a liar he was?

    Nevermind that this:

    “The most brilliant propagandist technique will yield no success unless one fundamental principle is borne in mind constantly – it must confine itself to a few points and repeat them over and over.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels

    Summarises the 9/11 ‘truth’ movement perfectly…

  324. @This Is Our Home
    @Truth


    I can only answer your question, with a question, Socratic style; Look at the video of the Pentagon being “hit by an airplane”, no hurry, I’ll wait.

    OK, you have the video of “the Pentagon being hit by an airplane” up on youtube? Good. Not tell me, where is the airplane?
     
    Of course that does not answer my question. You propose no theory, you just point out that reality is complicated and say 'see!'

    Nonetheless, I'll get dragged in and humour you.

    The video looks legit to me, considering the low number of frames per minute(!) on the footage and the speed at which an aircraft would cover the distance of the camera's purview.

    Let's guesstimate:

    There's 1 frame every 1 second.

    The distance covered by the aircraft is 100 metres.

    This means that to be unclear on the footage the aircraft would only need to be travelling at 360km per hour, which is rather a lot less than a dive bombing aircraft would at. Hence there's a more than likely chance that the aircraft would not be captured on the footage.

    Of course the aircraft actually is just visible at the 7 second mark on the right...so now you're probably going to talk some nonsense about CGI or something...and we go round and round the insanity loop again and again and again.

    Propose a better theory!

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BXgtsavot5A

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @Truth

    Hundreds of motorists stuck in traffic jams saw the airliner hit the Pentagon, just as lots of New Yorkers saw the first airliner strike the North WTC. (The whole world saw the second airliner hit the South WTC.)

    • Replies: @Rurik
    @Steve Sailer


    Hundreds of motorists stuck in traffic jams saw the airliner hit the Pentagon
     
    I think they saw a plane heading towards the Pentagon, I don't think any of them saw it hit. But there must have been at least hundreds of video cameras all over the Pentagon. It must be some of the most surveilled real estate in the world. From what I understand the FBI went around to all of the gas stations and convenience stores in the vicinity and confiscated any and all video evidence they could find.

    To this day the only video that's out that I know of is the few second clip that shows something hitting and exploding, but it's impossible to make out what it is.

    Why don't they just put out some of the videos that show the passenger jet hitting the Pentagon and put this all to rest. It seems more than likely that they have it, no?

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

  325. @This Is Our Home
    @Truth


    I can only answer your question, with a question, Socratic style; Look at the video of the Pentagon being “hit by an airplane”, no hurry, I’ll wait.

    OK, you have the video of “the Pentagon being hit by an airplane” up on youtube? Good. Not tell me, where is the airplane?
     
    Of course that does not answer my question. You propose no theory, you just point out that reality is complicated and say 'see!'

    Nonetheless, I'll get dragged in and humour you.

    The video looks legit to me, considering the low number of frames per minute(!) on the footage and the speed at which an aircraft would cover the distance of the camera's purview.

    Let's guesstimate:

    There's 1 frame every 1 second.

    The distance covered by the aircraft is 100 metres.

    This means that to be unclear on the footage the aircraft would only need to be travelling at 360km per hour, which is rather a lot less than a dive bombing aircraft would at. Hence there's a more than likely chance that the aircraft would not be captured on the footage.

    Of course the aircraft actually is just visible at the 7 second mark on the right...so now you're probably going to talk some nonsense about CGI or something...and we go round and round the insanity loop again and again and again.

    Propose a better theory!

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BXgtsavot5A

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @Truth

    No, Pluto, the question is, where are the bodies, where are the seats, where are the jet engines, where are the wings, where are the windows, where is the luggage; etc..etc.

    Stick with this thing, it gets easier.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Truth


    No, Pluto, the question is, where are the bodies, where are the seats, where are the jet engines, where are the wings, where are the windows, where is the luggage; etc..etc.

    Stick with this thing, it gets easier.
     
    So the plane is not on the video becomes the plane wreckage is not on the video? Ok, there's plenty of recorded witnesses to seeing the wreckage from close up; I guess they're in on it too? Really who isn't?

    You have still failed to advance any alternative theory AND your objections directly contradict Ron Unz's about Israelis being behind it. After all, if it was a missile, why would the Pentagon cover it up?

    Replies: @Truth

    , @Boomstick
    @Truth

    http://www.rense.com/general32/phot.htm

    Includes many photos of aircraft wreckage inside the Pentagon. If you look long enough you can also find photos of the bodies, the APU, nose gear and so on.

    Replies: @Truth

  326. Now, Stephen and Robert, all I see here is a hole in a building, if you see a plane sticking out of it, please point it out to me.

    You see gentlemen, it’s quite simple, they can make you believe ANYTHING THEY WANT at ANYTIME THEY WANT. Even when it is not there. They can show you the photos and the videos of the truth E VEN AFTER it happens, and you will not see it.

    We’re screwed thanks to you.

    • Replies: @D. K.
    @Truth

    From Wikipedia.org:

    ***

    Barbara Kay Olson (née Bracher; December 27, 1955 – September 11, 2001) was an American lawyer and conservative television commentator who worked for CNN, Fox News Channel, and several other outlets.[1] She was a passenger on American Airlines Flight 77 en route to a taping of Bill Maher's television show Politically Incorrect when it was flown into the Pentagon in the September 11 attacks. Her original plan had been to fly to California on September 10, but delayed until the next morning so that she could wake up with her husband on his birthday, September 11.[2][3]

    ***

    The husband, now widower, in question, was Ted Olson. On September 11, 2001, he was serving as the Solicitor General of the United States. His wife called him from the airplane, after it had been hijacked, as many other doomed passengers called their own loved ones, that morning, from their hijacked flights.

    If Barbara Olson's flight was not flown into the Pentagon, that morning, where is that airplane, now? Where are Barbara Olson, her fellow airline travelers, the flight's crew, and the hijackers who were named as having been on that particular flight? Who planted the airplane's black boxes inside the Pentagon, where they were discovered "in the wee small hours of the morning" of Friday, September 14, 2001? Who planted the debris on the lawn of the Pentagon, in the immediate aftermath of the crash, as photographed that morning and included on the flight's Wikipedia.org entry? Which mind altering drugs are easiest to procure, there in Kuwait?

    Replies: @Truth

  327. @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz


    My own guess is that the “five dancing Israelis” weren’t actually acting under orders, but had just decided to take some souvenir shots they could show their friends back home about how successful the overall operation had been.
     
    If Israeli had planned 9/11 and it were found out, that would be the end of their country.

    So I can definitely see why the Israeli government would have maintained opsec so loose that 5 random bozos were told and could sit back and watch the event.

    Anyway, the undeniable fact is that there *were* a whole bunch of Israeli Mossad agents all around the exact scene of 9/11 attacks, so for whatever reason their leaders apparently don’t think like you and I do. “Pride Goeth Before a Fall”…
     
    I've seen nothing that makes it undeniable. Just a lot of quickly disproven rumours. Regardless, that there are MOSSAD affiliates (agents is a real stretch even if you can these rumours at face value) in New York is hardly surprising.

    Replies: @Ron Unz

    If Israeli had planned 9/11 and it were found out, that would be the end of their country.

    Not really—only if it also gets on national TV instead of the Kardashians and Football. The Media creates Reality, and if the Media doesn’t report it, it doesn’t exist. After all, the Lavon Attacks and the Liberty Attack are absolutely documented and confirmed, and all that happened was America increased its financial tribute payments to Israel. Meanwhile, in a different matter John McCain still ranks as America’s greatest Vietnam War Hero…

    Incidentally, for someone who just suddenly showed up and wants the website to stop publishing all sorts of things he doesn’t like, you certainly seem to be leaving a *lot* of comments, though none of them seem very intelligent or interesting to me. So maybe you’d be happier just going back to FoxNews or whatever.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz


    Not really—only if it also gets on national TV instead of the Kardashians and Football. The Media creates Reality, and if the Media doesn’t report it, it doesn’t exist
     
    So now everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up 9/11? Even those who lost family members? Even the many parts of the media which are both anti-American and anti-Israel (outside of America?) And not one of these millions of people has broken ranks?

    How can anyone believe this?


    After all, the Lavon Attacks and the Liberty Attack are absolutely documented and confirmed, and all that happened was America increased its financial tribute payments to Israel
     
    I really don't want to go down this crazy rabbit hole, but those events are obviously different in scale and mistakes often do happen in war, and people understand this; despite their frustration when it happens.

    Meanwhile, in a different matter John McCain still ranks as America’s greatest Vietnam War Hero…
     
    Again, I don't know the details but I do know that burnishing one man's reputation is a great deal easier than what you're suggesting about 9/11. I also enjoyed your article.

    In the end:

    1. No-one is proposing a more plausible alternative theory.

    2. Claiming that 9/11 was anything but the normal account requires the whole world's media, the whole US security force, a huge number of independent experts and their families, the government of Russia and China plus their minions, to all be colluding to perpetrate a hoax in order to do what? If all of these guys are capable of operating with such discipline together there is absolutely no point in them bothering, they'd be beyond powerful and you'd be long dead; as would I.

    It also beggars belief - humans never have acted like that ever. Indeed this is so crazy that I no longer believe that you, Ron Unz, are serious. I have no idea what your angle is but please, be kind to this poor nobody and give me a clue, I can't bare this level of curiosity. Even a small clue!

    Replies: @Ron Unz, @Hunsdon

  328. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Truth
    @This Is Our Home

    No, Pluto, the question is, where are the bodies, where are the seats, where are the jet engines, where are the wings, where are the windows, where is the luggage; etc..etc.

    Stick with this thing, it gets easier.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Boomstick

    No, Pluto, the question is, where are the bodies, where are the seats, where are the jet engines, where are the wings, where are the windows, where is the luggage; etc..etc.

    Stick with this thing, it gets easier.

    So the plane is not on the video becomes the plane wreckage is not on the video? Ok, there’s plenty of recorded witnesses to seeing the wreckage from close up; I guess they’re in on it too? Really who isn’t?

    You have still failed to advance any alternative theory AND your objections directly contradict Ron Unz’s about Israelis being behind it. After all, if it was a missile, why would the Pentagon cover it up?

    • Replies: @Truth
    @This Is Our Home

    I just showed you a photo. That makes the question quite simple; are you going to believe what you have heard or what you see. All that other shit that you are talking is, at this point, totally negligible.

    From where I sit there are three possibilities from those photos I posted:

    1. There is a plane in that picture that hit the Pentagon, and somehow, for 14 years, I have failed to see it. If this is the case, please point it out.

    2. There is no plane.

    3. There was a plane that hit the pentagon, and somehow it disappeared (which leads to 3a. Harry Blackstone or Chris Angel was in the vicinity at the time.

    4. These pictures, along with hundreds of others available have somehow been altered to remove a plane.

    Which of these is your point, or, if you have another point that I am somehow missing, feel free to share.

    BTW; this question, if you are as intelligent as you say you are.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

  329. @Thomas O. Meehan
    @Steve Sailer

    I lived in New Jersey at the time of the attack and was working in law enforcement. I recall reports of Arabs celebrating on the streets of Paterson or Passaic. At this remove I can't say I saw video of said jubilation, but it was reported and taken at face value by a very large percentage of the population. At the same time the airwaves were full of footage of Palestinians openly celebrating. Those were the circumstances. It would be surprising if no one among the notoriously unassimilated ME populations in their ethnic ghettos hadn't celebrated a bit. At the same time it is possible that Trump saw the dancing Palestinians and conflated them with the reports from Paterson and or Passaic.

    That said, I think it is possible that footage exists but is lost or being withheld.

    If Trump is delusional about the dancing arabs of Passaic, he shares that delusion with millions of fellow New York area citizens.

    Replies: @Ron Unz, @Anonymous

    I lived in New Jersey at the time of the attack and was working in law enforcement. I recall reports of Arabs celebrating on the streets of Paterson or Passaic. At this remove I can’t say I saw video of said jubilation, but it was reported and taken at face value by a very large percentage of the population…That said, I think it is possible that footage exists but is lost or being withheld.

    As I mentioned earlier, I find such claims *exceptionally* implausible.

    Don’t forget that the Neocons had absolute and total control of a substantial portion of the local and national media at that point, plus the Giuliani Admin, and were using it to promote the tremendous domestic dangers from of Arabs/Muslims. Large numbers of totally innocent such individuals, minding their own business, were grabbed up by the police due to mass hysteria, and kept under arrest for quite a long time. As far as I’m aware, not a single one was every proven to be directly sympathetic to the terrorist attacks. In fact, some of the Neocons quickly began pressing for a mass-internment of Arabs/Muslims, much like happened with the Japanese in WWII, and to that end they began publishing books and articles saying that FDR had been totally legally and morally justified in the Japanese Internment.

    If any such video footage existed, they would have broadcast it 24/7 (unless, of course, you agree with the Jewish-activists that the American media is fanatically anti-Jewish and anti-Israel).

    At the same time the airwaves were full of footage of Palestinians openly celebrating.

    Although I’ve never never investigated it, I’m *extremely* skeptical that such alleged celebration overseas occurred in more than a small handful of cases. All that happens is that some 30-second video shot is endlessly looped over FoxNews or ABC, with voice-over explanation by the anchor, and that becomes the reality of rightwing dimwits everywhere. Indeed, the whole thing might easily have been staged.

    If Trump is delusional about the dancing arabs of Passaic, he shares that delusion with millions of fellow New York area citizens.

    Well, I agree with you there. And I’d bet that many, many millions of American blacks (and whites) also believe that the KKK has been burning black churches all around the country and that white racist police have been randomly killing black children everywhere for eating skittles. Or perhaps you’ve never heard of the Black Lives Matter movement…

    As I’ve said before, Trump is a totally ignorant buffoon, and given our current ideological principles, the rightful political representative of many millions of Buffoon-Americans…

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz


    Although I’ve never never investigated it, I’m *extremely* skeptical that such alleged celebration overseas occurred in more than a small handful of cases. All that happens is that some 30-second video shot is endlessly looped over FoxNews or ABC, with voice-over explanation by the anchor, and that becomes the reality of rightwing dimwits everywhere. Indeed, the whole thing might easily have been staged.
     
    You have no idea how hated America was and is...there are billions of people all over the world who were practically ecstatic when it happened, both Muslim and not.

    There are a whole heap of different reasons for this. Some are justified and some are totally irrational and some are in-between; but there was no shortage of people who loved 9/11; even among White Americans. Humans can be quite callous, I suppose.

    , @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz


    As I’ve said before, Trump is a totally ignorant buffoon, and given our current ideological principles, the rightful political representative of many millions of Buffoon-Americans…
     
    Which politician is more likely to run the American government in the interest of the American people? Or is that an ignorant and buffoonish sentiment for poor people?

    Replies: @Ron Unz

    , @inertial
    @Ron Unz

    Eh, I dunno. You must recall the first days after 911, the time when President Bush went to a mosque and declared Islam to be a "Religion of Peace." I got a strong impression that our elites got genuinely scared that the unwashed masses were about to go on a anti Muslim pogrom spree. There was A LOT of that Religion of Peace propaganda coming from all over at that time, and the Neocons were very much a part of that. I don't feel like digging up links on my phone, but surely you remember why Ann Coulter was fired by National Review?

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    , @Thomas O. Meehan
    @Ron Unz

    I take second place to no one in abhorrence of the neocons. But, you might consider that it was FOX news, Neocon central, that broke the story of the dancing Israeli's. They went on to spike their own story. It seems to have taken a few hours or days of reportage after the attack for the official narrative to lock in.

    "As I’ve said before, Trump is a totally ignorant buffoon, and given our current ideological principles, the rightful political representative of many millions of Buffoon-Americans…"

    No I don't think the problem lies with our principles. We have no principles. All we have are easily manipulated sentiments. It's the tragedy of Democracy. Who could expect good governance to result from a system representing the whims and delusions of masses of asses?

  330. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Ron Unz
    @This Is Our Home


    If Israeli had planned 9/11 and it were found out, that would be the end of their country.
     
    Not really---only if it also gets on national TV instead of the Kardashians and Football. The Media creates Reality, and if the Media doesn't report it, it doesn't exist. After all, the Lavon Attacks and the Liberty Attack are absolutely documented and confirmed, and all that happened was America increased its financial tribute payments to Israel. Meanwhile, in a different matter John McCain still ranks as America's greatest Vietnam War Hero...

    Incidentally, for someone who just suddenly showed up and wants the website to stop publishing all sorts of things he doesn't like, you certainly seem to be leaving a *lot* of comments, though none of them seem very intelligent or interesting to me. So maybe you'd be happier just going back to FoxNews or whatever.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    Not really—only if it also gets on national TV instead of the Kardashians and Football. The Media creates Reality, and if the Media doesn’t report it, it doesn’t exist

    So now everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up 9/11? Even those who lost family members? Even the many parts of the media which are both anti-American and anti-Israel (outside of America?) And not one of these millions of people has broken ranks?

    How can anyone believe this?

    After all, the Lavon Attacks and the Liberty Attack are absolutely documented and confirmed, and all that happened was America increased its financial tribute payments to Israel

    I really don’t want to go down this crazy rabbit hole, but those events are obviously different in scale and mistakes often do happen in war, and people understand this; despite their frustration when it happens.

    Meanwhile, in a different matter John McCain still ranks as America’s greatest Vietnam War Hero…

    Again, I don’t know the details but I do know that burnishing one man’s reputation is a great deal easier than what you’re suggesting about 9/11. I also enjoyed your article.

    In the end:

    1. No-one is proposing a more plausible alternative theory.

    2. Claiming that 9/11 was anything but the normal account requires the whole world’s media, the whole US security force, a huge number of independent experts and their families, the government of Russia and China plus their minions, to all be colluding to perpetrate a hoax in order to do what? If all of these guys are capable of operating with such discipline together there is absolutely no point in them bothering, they’d be beyond powerful and you’d be long dead; as would I.

    It also beggars belief – humans never have acted like that ever. Indeed this is so crazy that I no longer believe that you, Ron Unz, are serious. I have no idea what your angle is but please, be kind to this poor nobody and give me a clue, I can’t bare this level of curiosity. Even a small clue!

    • Replies: @Ron Unz
    @This Is Our Home


    So now everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up 9/11? Even those who lost family members?
     
    Well, I wouldn't phrase it in exactly those words, but---Yes, quite possibly so.

    The Liberty Incident was probably the most serious military attack on American naval forces since WWII, resulting in over 200 dead and wounded American servicemen. The true facts were very quickly known at the time and have been endlessly confirmed since. Unless "everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up" that attack, why has it been so effectively hushed up for almost fifty years?

    My impression is that rightwing Internet-activists such as yourself go around endlessly claiming that the entire MSM constantly hides and "hushes up" the bad behavior of Muslims or blacks or illegal immigrants or whatever, and in quite a number of cases, you do have the facts on your side. Then you turn around and claim that only a "crazy conspiracy-nut" could believe that the MSM could hide or cover-up *vastly* more touchy matters, matters protected by *vastly* more powerful and influential groups.

    Steve's often told the story of that popular Hispanic national news-anchor, who during his book-tour was badgered by Jon Stewart into finally hinting that Jews actually constituted a very powerful group in the media. He was immediately purged and totally "disappeared." So what do you think would happen to any MSM person who revealed himself to be a "crazy conspiracy-nut" by pointing out some very suspicious behavior by numerous Mossad agents in connection with 9/11?

    Frankly, I've only given the slightest attention to 9/11 issues, and that was almost a decade ago, so although I'm reasonably confident my casual comments above are basically correct, I can't really vouch for them with great certainty, e.g. I totally misremembered those 40% vs. 85% figures upthread. However, I've also published several major articles on the utter "unreliability" of the MSM on matters of enormous importance. Since you're so new here and seem so totally ignorant or maybe just dishonest. If it's the former, you might want to read those articles and decide for yourself if your confidence in the MSM is really warranted:

    https://www.unz.com/article/our-american-pravda/

    https://www.unz.com/runz/american-pravda-when-tokyo-rose-ran-for-president/

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Bill Jones

    , @Hunsdon
    @This Is Our Home

    Robert Rediger said: mistakes often do happen in war . . . .

    Hunsdon said: If we are discussing the USS Liberty, you are not helping your case. Ignorant, or duplicitous, hmm.

    Replies: @Ron Unz

  331. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Ron Unz
    @Thomas O. Meehan


    I lived in New Jersey at the time of the attack and was working in law enforcement. I recall reports of Arabs celebrating on the streets of Paterson or Passaic. At this remove I can’t say I saw video of said jubilation, but it was reported and taken at face value by a very large percentage of the population...That said, I think it is possible that footage exists but is lost or being withheld.
     
    As I mentioned earlier, I find such claims *exceptionally* implausible.

    Don't forget that the Neocons had absolute and total control of a substantial portion of the local and national media at that point, plus the Giuliani Admin, and were using it to promote the tremendous domestic dangers from of Arabs/Muslims. Large numbers of totally innocent such individuals, minding their own business, were grabbed up by the police due to mass hysteria, and kept under arrest for quite a long time. As far as I'm aware, not a single one was every proven to be directly sympathetic to the terrorist attacks. In fact, some of the Neocons quickly began pressing for a mass-internment of Arabs/Muslims, much like happened with the Japanese in WWII, and to that end they began publishing books and articles saying that FDR had been totally legally and morally justified in the Japanese Internment.

    If any such video footage existed, they would have broadcast it 24/7 (unless, of course, you agree with the Jewish-activists that the American media is fanatically anti-Jewish and anti-Israel).

    At the same time the airwaves were full of footage of Palestinians openly celebrating.
     
    Although I've never never investigated it, I'm *extremely* skeptical that such alleged celebration overseas occurred in more than a small handful of cases. All that happens is that some 30-second video shot is endlessly looped over FoxNews or ABC, with voice-over explanation by the anchor, and that becomes the reality of rightwing dimwits everywhere. Indeed, the whole thing might easily have been staged.

    If Trump is delusional about the dancing arabs of Passaic, he shares that delusion with millions of fellow New York area citizens.
     
    Well, I agree with you there. And I'd bet that many, many millions of American blacks (and whites) also believe that the KKK has been burning black churches all around the country and that white racist police have been randomly killing black children everywhere for eating skittles. Or perhaps you've never heard of the Black Lives Matter movement...

    As I've said before, Trump is a totally ignorant buffoon, and given our current ideological principles, the rightful political representative of many millions of Buffoon-Americans...

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @This Is Our Home, @inertial, @Thomas O. Meehan

    Although I’ve never never investigated it, I’m *extremely* skeptical that such alleged celebration overseas occurred in more than a small handful of cases. All that happens is that some 30-second video shot is endlessly looped over FoxNews or ABC, with voice-over explanation by the anchor, and that becomes the reality of rightwing dimwits everywhere. Indeed, the whole thing might easily have been staged.

    You have no idea how hated America was and is…there are billions of people all over the world who were practically ecstatic when it happened, both Muslim and not.

    There are a whole heap of different reasons for this. Some are justified and some are totally irrational and some are in-between; but there was no shortage of people who loved 9/11; even among White Americans. Humans can be quite callous, I suppose.

  332. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Ron Unz
    @Thomas O. Meehan


    I lived in New Jersey at the time of the attack and was working in law enforcement. I recall reports of Arabs celebrating on the streets of Paterson or Passaic. At this remove I can’t say I saw video of said jubilation, but it was reported and taken at face value by a very large percentage of the population...That said, I think it is possible that footage exists but is lost or being withheld.
     
    As I mentioned earlier, I find such claims *exceptionally* implausible.

    Don't forget that the Neocons had absolute and total control of a substantial portion of the local and national media at that point, plus the Giuliani Admin, and were using it to promote the tremendous domestic dangers from of Arabs/Muslims. Large numbers of totally innocent such individuals, minding their own business, were grabbed up by the police due to mass hysteria, and kept under arrest for quite a long time. As far as I'm aware, not a single one was every proven to be directly sympathetic to the terrorist attacks. In fact, some of the Neocons quickly began pressing for a mass-internment of Arabs/Muslims, much like happened with the Japanese in WWII, and to that end they began publishing books and articles saying that FDR had been totally legally and morally justified in the Japanese Internment.

    If any such video footage existed, they would have broadcast it 24/7 (unless, of course, you agree with the Jewish-activists that the American media is fanatically anti-Jewish and anti-Israel).

    At the same time the airwaves were full of footage of Palestinians openly celebrating.
     
    Although I've never never investigated it, I'm *extremely* skeptical that such alleged celebration overseas occurred in more than a small handful of cases. All that happens is that some 30-second video shot is endlessly looped over FoxNews or ABC, with voice-over explanation by the anchor, and that becomes the reality of rightwing dimwits everywhere. Indeed, the whole thing might easily have been staged.

    If Trump is delusional about the dancing arabs of Passaic, he shares that delusion with millions of fellow New York area citizens.
     
    Well, I agree with you there. And I'd bet that many, many millions of American blacks (and whites) also believe that the KKK has been burning black churches all around the country and that white racist police have been randomly killing black children everywhere for eating skittles. Or perhaps you've never heard of the Black Lives Matter movement...

    As I've said before, Trump is a totally ignorant buffoon, and given our current ideological principles, the rightful political representative of many millions of Buffoon-Americans...

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @This Is Our Home, @inertial, @Thomas O. Meehan

    As I’ve said before, Trump is a totally ignorant buffoon, and given our current ideological principles, the rightful political representative of many millions of Buffoon-Americans…

    Which politician is more likely to run the American government in the interest of the American people? Or is that an ignorant and buffoonish sentiment for poor people?

    • Replies: @Ron Unz
    @This Is Our Home



    As I’ve said before, Trump is a totally ignorant buffoon
     
    Which politician is more likely to run the American government in the interest of the American people? Or is that an ignorant and buffoonish sentiment for poor people?
     
    Well, some pro-Trump commenter put it very well a couple of weeks ago, saying that Trump was 95% a clown and 5% a patriot, which made him much better than almost all the other candidates.

    I'd more or less tend to agree with that. Except for Trump and Bernie Sanders, all the other candidates are totally worthless, and many of them *extremely* dangerous in their foreign policy views as well. I strongly disagree with Sanders about lots of important things, but he'd be my top choice for now, with Trump probably a very distant second.
  333. @Truth
    Now, Stephen and Robert, all I see here is a hole in a building, if you see a plane sticking out of it, please point it out to me.

    https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Pentagon_on_9.11_-_2.jpg


    http://findyourcharleston.com/charleston-real-estate-blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/pentagon.jpg

    You see gentlemen, it's quite simple, they can make you believe ANYTHING THEY WANT at ANYTIME THEY WANT. Even when it is not there. They can show you the photos and the videos of the truth E VEN AFTER it happens, and you will not see it.

    We're screwed thanks to you.

    Replies: @D. K.

    From Wikipedia.org:

    ***

    Barbara Kay Olson (née Bracher; December 27, 1955 – September 11, 2001) was an American lawyer and conservative television commentator who worked for CNN, Fox News Channel, and several other outlets.[1] She was a passenger on American Airlines Flight 77 en route to a taping of Bill Maher’s television show Politically Incorrect when it was flown into the Pentagon in the September 11 attacks. Her original plan had been to fly to California on September 10, but delayed until the next morning so that she could wake up with her husband on his birthday, September 11.[2][3]

    ***

    The husband, now widower, in question, was Ted Olson. On September 11, 2001, he was serving as the Solicitor General of the United States. His wife called him from the airplane, after it had been hijacked, as many other doomed passengers called their own loved ones, that morning, from their hijacked flights.

    If Barbara Olson’s flight was not flown into the Pentagon, that morning, where is that airplane, now? Where are Barbara Olson, her fellow airline travelers, the flight’s crew, and the hijackers who were named as having been on that particular flight? Who planted the airplane’s black boxes inside the Pentagon, where they were discovered “in the wee small hours of the morning” of Friday, September 14, 2001? Who planted the debris on the lawn of the Pentagon, in the immediate aftermath of the crash, as photographed that morning and included on the flight’s Wikipedia.org entry? Which mind altering drugs are easiest to procure, there in Kuwait?

    • Replies: @Truth
    @D. K.

    As I said earlier, Sheepskin, do you believe what you hear, or do you believe what you see.

    https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Pentagon_on_9.11_-_2.jpg

    http://findyourcharleston.com/charleston-real-estate-blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/pentagon.jpg

    We really don't need to go much further than that.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

  334. @Ron Unz
    Well, I just finished tracking down a difficult bug, so I might as well summarize my own casual perspective regarding the 9/11 attacks, which hasn't much changed since the mid-2000s.

    (1) First, I think that the totally disorganized and frightened behavior of Bush and some other top American officials conclusively proves that the American government *as a entity* did not know about or expect the attacks; thus, the left-fringe claims of an "inside job" in that sense are absurd. However, there seems a very real possibility that a tiny number of key enemy agents or collaborators situated at crucial nodes within the governmental machinery were involved in the conspiracy, which is an entirely different thing. Needless to say, I doubt any of these American conspirators were Islamicist fanatics.

    (2) A considerable number of Israelis were caught in the immediate vicinity of the 9/11 attacks behaving in an *exceptionally* suspicious manner, and in some cases reportedly carrying explosives. At least a number of these individuals were later revealed to be Mossad agents, and others among their close associates quickly fled the country to avoid interrogation. Meanwhile, not a single Islamicist agent was caught anywhere in the vicinity, or indeed (as I recall) anywhere in the entire country. At the very least, this almost conclusively proves that Mossad knew the exact time and location of the planned attacks, while there is absolutely no evidence that the leadership of the FBI or the CIA had any such information.

    (3) Israel is a normal country, with a normal government. If Mossad knew the exact time and location of the planned attacks and had deployed a considerable number of its agents to observe, report, and record the attacks, it is absolutely certain that the top Israeli leaders also had this information and had approved those deployments.

    (4) Does this prove that the Israeli Mossad was actually behind the attacks? Not necessarily. But the key conclusion is that aside from the attackers themselves, the only government in the world with absolute, precise knowledge of the exact timing and nature of the attacks were the Israelis. Under these circumstances if America were a normal country run by a normal government, we would have certainly taken all necessary measures---howsoever harsh---to ensure that we learned every last iota of what the Israelis knew, when they knew it, and how they came to know it, while also tracking down and eliminating each and every American collaborator in the attacks, together with their entire network of fellow-travelers and co-conspirators.

    However, America is not a normal country run by a normal government, so almost no one cares about any of these things.

    Replies: @Rob McX, @Drakejax, @Rurik

    However, America is not a normal country run by a normal government, so almost no one cares about any of these things.

    I became cynical after Waco when I watched what our government did to those people. I’ve since seen video that shows by the rapid, multiple muzzle flashes that they were machine gunning the only exit to that burning building. The autopsy reports showed that there were piles of dead bodies at the exit who’re riddled with bullets. They were the lucky ones I guess. But you can imagine that once the building was set on fire (the FBI admits having lied about using flammable gas canisters) that even if those people were “wackos” and deserved to die, that instinct would have taken over and they’d want to escape the flames. But from the evidence it seems clear that our government wanted those people to burn alive. (reminds me of Dresden in a way)

    And when it was all over, and before the ashes had settled, they arrested the surviving victims of that terrible massacre and charged them with all kinds of crimes.

    Then they had the gall to try to run Janet Reno for governor of Florida and the couple that was in the White House at the time are trying to get back in as we speak.

    Trying to reconcile myself to all of that, and then watching what they did on 911, and the avalanche of evidence that proves that 911 did not happen the way they said it did, and they had to be forced to even have an investigation, and then wanted it headed up by Henry Kissinger!, just all of it is enough to temp a person to become cynical at the cow-like exceptionalism of the American people.

    Thanks Ron, for providing this great site that seems an oasis of truth in an otherwise Orwellian matrix of lies.

    I hope everyone is enjoying a great holiday ; )

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Rurik

    So the US government's two great enemies are Muslims and the Branch Davidians? Were the latter an existential threat to Israel too?

    Replies: @Rurik

  335. @Rob McX
    @Ron Unz


    If Mossad knew the exact time and location of the planned attacks and had deployed a considerable number of its agents to observe, report, and record the attacks, it is absolutely certain that the top Israeli leaders also had this information and had approved those deployments.
     
    That's the part I don't get. Once the attack had been planned, anyone who had any connection with it would be better off getting well away from the area. I don't see the advantage in sticking around - if the plan started to go wrong at the last minute, it would be too late to do anything about it. As for observing and recording it, they could hardly find out anything that wouldn't be in the news the next day anyway.

    Replies: @Ron Unz, @Rurik

    if the plan started to go wrong at the last minute,

    it did

    in all likelihood the plane that vanished over Shanksville was intended to hit building seven, thereby providing the pretext for that building to fall. When the plane never arrived, they had to scramble for a contingency and just decided to “pull it”, and that’s why we have that smoking gun.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Rurik


    it did

    in all likelihood the plane that vanished over Shanksville was intended to hit building seven, thereby providing the pretext for that building to fall. When the plane never arrived, they had to scramble for a contingency and just decided to “pull it”, and that’s why we have that smoking gun.
     
    Why would they need a contingency? The towers were hit, that's all that really mattered.

    Replies: @Rurik

  336. @anonymous
    @Ron Unz

    Why won't somebody expose this, or at least dig a bit deeper? This is a big, juicy story.

    Is the entire media that corrupt?

    It's madness that nobody is looking into this situation—especially when you consider the damage that has been done to America in the aftermath of these events.

    Replies: @Rurik

    Why won’t somebody expose this, or at least dig a bit deeper? This is a big, juicy story.

    Is the entire media that corrupt?

    It’s madness that nobody is looking into this situation

    just compare it to the coverage of the attack on the USS Liberty

    That was an all out aggressive act of war and cowardly act of treachery against Israel’s most generous and important ally. It would have sold newspapers like the attack on Peal Harbor, but there wasn’t a peep. Not so much as a cricket’s chirp. There was instead threats to the surviving sailors that if they mentioned it they’d be court-martialed.

    The all pervasive silence (or disinformation if anything) regarding the media and 911 certainly has precedent.

    Is the entire media that corrupt?

    yes

  337. @Mr. Anon
    @Rurik

    "first plane

    let that sink in for a minute

    ok

    here, let me help

    here’s the video"

    In that video that you posted, he did NOT say it was the first plane. He only said that he saw a plane hit the tower. Watch it again - and listen.

    And even if he did say first plane, so what? There is video of the first plane hitting.

    Or do you imagine that Bush's Mossad handlers had a private video feed set up for him, so that he could watch as the most egregious crime in American history was carrie out, knowing full well that he was a willing participant? And then, after all that, he admitted his culpability?

    You "truther" guys must be autistic. Or you're just stupid. I really don't care anymore. You are all loathsome f**ks.

    "it literally is a kind of insanity to watch building seven implode and tell yourself that is was office fires that did it"

    You are willfully stupid. It wasn't just office fires. The building had a f**king diesel fuel bunker in it to power back-up generators. Add to that, it was scoured by debris from the first impacts, and it had a make-shift cantilever structure becuause it was built over a subway station.

    "rather I wouldn’t so much put it down to insanity as I would intellectual and moral cowardice"

    F**k you. You idiots are stupid and crazy. You aren't worth the time of day.

    Replies: @Rurik

    In that video that you posted, he did NOT say it was the first plane. He only said that he saw a plane hit the tower. Watch it again – and listen.

    And even if he did say first plane, so what? There is video of the first plane hitting.

    he said he was outside the Florida classroom when he saw the plane hit the tower and that he thought it must be a bad pilot. We all know that the second plane didn’t hit until he was well inside the classroom and reading about the pet goat. If it were the second plane then even someone as monumentally stupid as George Bush would have figured out that a second plane hitting the towers was not just a coincidence or pilot error, don’t you think?

    and just for you, I’m posting again a video of building seven falling. There are thousands upon thousands of architects and structural engineers and building engineers and demolition experts and other professionals that have put their names and reputations on the line by going public and saying that there is no way that building seven could have fallen the way it did due to office fires or any of the structural damage it suffered.

    here’s a controlled demolition expert

    he’s since died in a car crash

  338. There is nothing more annoying than the way that evidence-based reasoning about the Dancing Israelis can be derailed by “no plane” speculation. The evidence surrounding Dominic Suter is infinitely more important and telling than grainy, ambiguous footage which is of no import – since, like Sailer said, hundreds of people witnessed the plane, the plane motor was recovered, etc.

    Truth, get back to the subject of the thread: the Israelis, and Urban Moving Systems.

  339. @Kevin O'Keeffe
    @Wally

    "Kirk Douglas" was, effectively, a stage name. He was born Issur Danielovitch.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar

    And he was born in Amsterdam.

    But not that Amsterdam.

  340. An Isræli named “Paul”?

  341. @Steve Sailer
    @This Is Our Home

    Hundreds of motorists stuck in traffic jams saw the airliner hit the Pentagon, just as lots of New Yorkers saw the first airliner strike the North WTC. (The whole world saw the second airliner hit the South WTC.)

    Replies: @Rurik

    Hundreds of motorists stuck in traffic jams saw the airliner hit the Pentagon

    I think they saw a plane heading towards the Pentagon, I don’t think any of them saw it hit. But there must have been at least hundreds of video cameras all over the Pentagon. It must be some of the most surveilled real estate in the world. From what I understand the FBI went around to all of the gas stations and convenience stores in the vicinity and confiscated any and all video evidence they could find.

    To this day the only video that’s out that I know of is the few second clip that shows something hitting and exploding, but it’s impossible to make out what it is.

    Why don’t they just put out some of the videos that show the passenger jet hitting the Pentagon and put this all to rest. It seems more than likely that they have it, no?

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Rurik


    Why don’t they just put out some of the videos that show the passenger jet hitting the Pentagon and put this all to rest. It seems more than likely that they have it, no?
     
    No. Do you guys believe that the moon landings were faked too?

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

  342. @Bill Jones
    @nglaer

    " it’s really not presidential."

    "Now who's being Naive, Kay?"

    Replies: @Hunsdon

    Zing! Almost always an apt reference.

  343. @This Is Our Home
    @tanabear

    You forgot to answer my question. I'll ask again: what is the most plausible theory in your opinion?

    Replies: @Truth, @tanabear

    Broadly speaking the 9/11 Truth Movement is trying to accomplish two things.

    1) Showing that the official story is false and incomplete

    2) Providing an alternate explanation as to what happened and holding the perpetrators accountable.

    The first goal has been accomplished. The official story is false on almost every level. This is a resolved scientific matter. It is no more controversial than the question of whether the Earth is round or flat. For the second goal to be accomplished there would need to be an actual investigation into 9/11. Since there has not been an open investigation we can only surmise as to what may have happened. We do know that the three towers were destroyed via a planned demolition. This is the starting point from where an investigation should begin.

    But 9/11 did meet the neo-cons need for a “new Pearl Harbor event” that they believed was necessary for transforming the Middle-East and the American military. It was the foundational event that allowed for all pre-existing neo-con policies to be put into effect.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @tanabear

    "The first goal has been accomplished. The official story is false on almost every level. This is a resolved scientific matter."

    That is absolutely false - a baseless assertion made by someone who in all likelihood has no idea what he's talking about. You may think so, but who cares? Who are you? What do you know about physics or engineering? Evidently, nothing.

    One thing you have accomplished though: you've made common cause with a guy like "Truth" - a bona fide stereotype of the bragging, know-nothing affirmative-action black-man. How does that make you feel?

    Replies: @tanabear, @Hunsdon, @Truth

    , @This Is Our Home
    @tanabear


    The first goal has been accomplished. The official story is false on almost every level. This is a resolved scientific matter. It is no more controversial than the question of whether the Earth is round or flat
     
    Lol. I'm watching the documentary 'The Men Who Stare At Goats.' What is about the US that produces such kooks?
  344. Anonymous • Disclaimer says:
    @Thomas O. Meehan
    @Steve Sailer

    I lived in New Jersey at the time of the attack and was working in law enforcement. I recall reports of Arabs celebrating on the streets of Paterson or Passaic. At this remove I can't say I saw video of said jubilation, but it was reported and taken at face value by a very large percentage of the population. At the same time the airwaves were full of footage of Palestinians openly celebrating. Those were the circumstances. It would be surprising if no one among the notoriously unassimilated ME populations in their ethnic ghettos hadn't celebrated a bit. At the same time it is possible that Trump saw the dancing Palestinians and conflated them with the reports from Paterson and or Passaic.

    That said, I think it is possible that footage exists but is lost or being withheld.

    If Trump is delusional about the dancing arabs of Passaic, he shares that delusion with millions of fellow New York area citizens.

    Replies: @Ron Unz, @Anonymous

    Trump repeatedly asserted that there were “thousands and thousands”, which would imply large crowds in the streets celebrating. “Millions” of Tri-State area citizens certainly don’t recall “thousands and thousands” celebrating in the streets in the aftermath of 9/11. It seems pretty likely that this is just Trump’s trademark exaggerating salesmanship, if not outright lying.

    It’d be hard to believe if there weren’t any Muslims in New Jersey happy about the attacks and some groups of them celebrating out in the streets in the aftermath, but that wasn’t what Trump suggested and wasn’t the image he was trying to convey with his remarks of “thousands and thousands”.

    • Replies: @Thomas O. Meehan
    @Anonymous

    My point, which you completely miss, is that Muslim celebrations in Passaic and or Paterson were widely reported in the press at that time. Many took them to be true. So, Trump is not making things up out of whole cloth.

    If Trump is overstating his case as with "Thousands," that deserves to be criticized.

  345. @Truth
    @Mr. Anon


    why didn’t the conspirators fly a plane into WTC 7, to complete the illusion? They forgot?
     
    Just taking a shot in the dark here: Because they knew that guys like you were going to believe it anyway?

    BTW Welcome back Grasshopper. Or maybe I was the one who left?

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “Just taking a shot in the dark here: Because they knew that guys like you were going to believe it anyway?”

    Guys like me? You mean guys who know something about physics?

    Whereas the “Truth” movement appeals to guys like you – who believe that cars can be fueled with water.

    “BTW Welcome back Grasshopper. Or maybe I was the one who left?”

    You’re back? Time off for good behavior, perhaps?

    I’ve always been here. You were the one who was gone. You should keep it that way. You weren’t missed.

  346. @tanabear
    @This Is Our Home

    Broadly speaking the 9/11 Truth Movement is trying to accomplish two things.

    1) Showing that the official story is false and incomplete

    2) Providing an alternate explanation as to what happened and holding the perpetrators accountable.

    The first goal has been accomplished. The official story is false on almost every level. This is a resolved scientific matter. It is no more controversial than the question of whether the Earth is round or flat. For the second goal to be accomplished there would need to be an actual investigation into 9/11. Since there has not been an open investigation we can only surmise as to what may have happened. We do know that the three towers were destroyed via a planned demolition. This is the starting point from where an investigation should begin.

    But 9/11 did meet the neo-cons need for a "new Pearl Harbor event" that they believed was necessary for transforming the Middle-East and the American military. It was the foundational event that allowed for all pre-existing neo-con policies to be put into effect.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @This Is Our Home

    “The first goal has been accomplished. The official story is false on almost every level. This is a resolved scientific matter.”

    That is absolutely false – a baseless assertion made by someone who in all likelihood has no idea what he’s talking about. You may think so, but who cares? Who are you? What do you know about physics or engineering? Evidently, nothing.

    One thing you have accomplished though: you’ve made common cause with a guy like “Truth” – a bona fide stereotype of the bragging, know-nothing affirmative-action black-man. How does that make you feel?

    • Replies: @tanabear
    @Mr. Anon

    People use the monikers "conspiracy theorist", "kook", or "tinfoil hat wearers" to refer to 9/11 truth seekers so they can deflect from the fact that they have no real arguments for the government's case. What does the 9/11 Truth Movement actually believe? They believe that explosive charges can blow things up. They believe that demolition chargers can be used to bring down steel-framed high-rises. This is not a controversial position. This is routinely how steel-framed buildings are destroyed. It only becomes "kooky" if you believe this is what happened on 9/11. People defending the official narrative are making claims that have no scientific basis. Have any of their claims been subjected to the experimental method? Can we witness a crush-down, crush-up, momentum transfer at free-fall acceleration, inward of the perimeter columns due to the catenary action of the sagging floor trusses, a steel-framed high-rise being demolished with fire, instead of explosives? No, none of this has been replicated. So instead of saying that I'm a kook, you can just demonstrate that the 9/11 truth seekers are wrong. It should be simple if the government's account is rock solid.

    In short, 9/11 truth seekers believe that the noon-day sky is blue, that water will wet you and fire will burn; that explosives can blow stuff up. And that all this was also true on 09/11/2001.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    , @Hunsdon
    @Mr. Anon

    Oh come on now. Can't you work in a good "shuckin' and jivin'" reference to Truth while you're at it?

    , @Truth
    @Mr. Anon


    One thing you have accomplished though: you’ve made common cause with a guy like “Truth” – a bona fide stereotype of the bragging, know-nothing affirmative-action black-man. How does that make you feel?
     
    I take offense to the insinuation... that I've accomplished something.
  347. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @tanabear
    @This Is Our Home

    Broadly speaking the 9/11 Truth Movement is trying to accomplish two things.

    1) Showing that the official story is false and incomplete

    2) Providing an alternate explanation as to what happened and holding the perpetrators accountable.

    The first goal has been accomplished. The official story is false on almost every level. This is a resolved scientific matter. It is no more controversial than the question of whether the Earth is round or flat. For the second goal to be accomplished there would need to be an actual investigation into 9/11. Since there has not been an open investigation we can only surmise as to what may have happened. We do know that the three towers were destroyed via a planned demolition. This is the starting point from where an investigation should begin.

    But 9/11 did meet the neo-cons need for a "new Pearl Harbor event" that they believed was necessary for transforming the Middle-East and the American military. It was the foundational event that allowed for all pre-existing neo-con policies to be put into effect.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @This Is Our Home

    The first goal has been accomplished. The official story is false on almost every level. This is a resolved scientific matter. It is no more controversial than the question of whether the Earth is round or flat

    Lol. I’m watching the documentary ‘The Men Who Stare At Goats.’ What is about the US that produces such kooks?

  348. @Rurik
    @Ron Unz


    However, America is not a normal country run by a normal government, so almost no one cares about any of these things.
     
    I became cynical after Waco when I watched what our government did to those people. I've since seen video that shows by the rapid, multiple muzzle flashes that they were machine gunning the only exit to that burning building. The autopsy reports showed that there were piles of dead bodies at the exit who're riddled with bullets. They were the lucky ones I guess. But you can imagine that once the building was set on fire (the FBI admits having lied about using flammable gas canisters) that even if those people were "wackos" and deserved to die, that instinct would have taken over and they'd want to escape the flames. But from the evidence it seems clear that our government wanted those people to burn alive. (reminds me of Dresden in a way)

    And when it was all over, and before the ashes had settled, they arrested the surviving victims of that terrible massacre and charged them with all kinds of crimes.

    Then they had the gall to try to run Janet Reno for governor of Florida and the couple that was in the White House at the time are trying to get back in as we speak.

    Trying to reconcile myself to all of that, and then watching what they did on 911, and the avalanche of evidence that proves that 911 did not happen the way they said it did, and they had to be forced to even have an investigation, and then wanted it headed up by Henry Kissinger!, just all of it is enough to temp a person to become cynical at the cow-like exceptionalism of the American people.

    Thanks Ron, for providing this great site that seems an oasis of truth in an otherwise Orwellian matrix of lies.

    I hope everyone is enjoying a great holiday ; )

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    So the US government’s two great enemies are Muslims and the Branch Davidians? Were the latter an existential threat to Israel too?

    • Replies: @Rurik
    @This Is Our Home


    So the US government’s two great enemies are Muslims and the Branch Davidians?
     
    when I mentioned how they machine gunned the people trying to get out of that burning building, did you secretly fanaticize that you could have been the one pulling the trigger?

    come on now Robert, be honest..

    Were the latter an existential threat to Israel too?
     
    as a matter of fact it was the Israeli diplomats in DC that were the most outraged at what had happened. Did you know that? They almost recalled their ambassador over the incident. Something about people dying in a real holocaust by the very definition of the word. It enraged their racial memories of government committed atrocities and their collective sense of tikkun olam. Bill Clinton almost lost all the support he'd received from Hollywood and the Jewish community because of the universal rage by the world's Jews over what had happened. Jewish lawyer were literally fighting each other to represent the Davidian survivors for free. Massive amounts of donations came in from Jews all over the world in support of those persecuted Christians who died in that literal holocaust.
  349. @Rurik
    @Steve Sailer


    Hundreds of motorists stuck in traffic jams saw the airliner hit the Pentagon
     
    I think they saw a plane heading towards the Pentagon, I don't think any of them saw it hit. But there must have been at least hundreds of video cameras all over the Pentagon. It must be some of the most surveilled real estate in the world. From what I understand the FBI went around to all of the gas stations and convenience stores in the vicinity and confiscated any and all video evidence they could find.

    To this day the only video that's out that I know of is the few second clip that shows something hitting and exploding, but it's impossible to make out what it is.

    Why don't they just put out some of the videos that show the passenger jet hitting the Pentagon and put this all to rest. It seems more than likely that they have it, no?

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    Why don’t they just put out some of the videos that show the passenger jet hitting the Pentagon and put this all to rest. It seems more than likely that they have it, no?

    No. Do you guys believe that the moon landings were faked too?

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @This Is Our Home

    "No. Do you guys believe that the moon landings were faked too?"

    I suspect that a lot of them do.

  350. “he said he was outside the Florida classroom when he saw the plane hit the tower and that he thought it must be a bad pilot. We all know that the second plane didn’t hit until he was well inside the classroom and reading about the pet goat. If it were the second plane then even someone as monumentally stupid as George Bush would have figured out that a second plane hitting the towers was not just a coincidence or pilot error, don’t you think?”

    There is nothing inciriminating in anything he said. Nothing you’ve said about this proves anything, except that you are obtuse and/or demented.

    “and just for you, I’m posting again a video of building seven falling. There are thousands upon thousands of architects and structural engineers and building engineers and demolition experts and other professionals that have put their names and reputations on the line by going public and saying that there is no way that building seven could have fallen the way it did due to office fires or any of the structural damage it suffered.”

    Thousands and Thousands? I think you’re exagerating. First of all – architects are irrelevant – they aren’t structural engineers. Secondly, there are “thousands upon thousands” of structural and demolition engineers who believe that the buildings were destroyed just as explained in the “official story”.

    “here’s a controlled demolition expert

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=877gr6xtQIc”

    Yes, here’s a dutch expert, giving a cursory opinion based on the same grainy you-tube video that every “Truther” has seen, without benefit of any of the other details of the buildings collapse. That was an Iranian-state TV interview, by the way. No agenda there, I’m sure.

    “he’s since died in a car crash”

    Yes, years after that interview. But nobody dies in car crashes, do they, in less it is willed by the all-powerful conspirators.

    As I said, to stupid people like you, everything is a mystery.

    • Replies: @Ron Unz
    @Mr. Anon


    There is nothing inciriminating in anything he said. Nothing you’ve said about this proves anything, except that you are obtuse and/or demented.
     
    Obviously the statements of "W" regarding what he remembers seeing on TV and when he saw it are *extremely* weak evidence of anything, except perhaps his empty-headedness.

    “he’s since died in a car crash”

    Yes, years after that interview. But nobody dies in car crashes, do they, in less it is willed by the all-powerful conspirators.
     

    Actually, from what I recall reading on the Internet around the time it happened, that Dutch demolitions expert was unlucky enough to die in a single-car accident just a few days after he was interviewed on Iranian TV and said the WTC collapse definitely looked like a "controlled demolition" to him. If so, then presumably other such experts became convinced that rendering any such discordant opinions on broadcast TV might become a similar source of "bad luck." At the time, it was one of the datapoints that made me increasingly "suspicious" of the official narrative. However, it was all some years ago and perhaps my memory is playing tricks on me, so someone might want to check the dates.
    , @Rurik
    @Mr. Anon


    As I said, to stupid people like you.
     
    actually I don't need any engineers or architects or demolition experts or anyone else to tell me building seven was a controlled demolition

    it's obvious to anyone with half a functioning brain

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

  351. @Truth
    @This Is Our Home

    “It would not be impossible to prove with sufficient repetition and a psychological understanding of the people concerned that a square is in fact a circle. They are mere words, and words can be molded until they clothe ideas and disguise.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels

    “Think of the press as a great keyboard
    on which the government can play.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels

    “The most brilliant propagandist technique will yield no success unless one fundamental principle is borne in mind constantly - it must confine itself to a few points and repeat them over and over.”
    ― Joseph Goebbels

    “If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it. The lie can be maintained only for such time as the State can shield the people from the political, economic and/or military consequences of the lie. It thus becomes vitally important for the State to use all of its powers to repress dissent, for the truth is the mortal enemy of the lie, and thus by extension, the truth is the greatest enemy of the State.”
    - Joseph Goebbels

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

    ““If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it.”

    And that’s exactly what the so-called “Truthers” have done. Although to be fair to them, they don’t consider it to be a lie – they are just deluded and/or crazy, autistic, or stupid people.

  352. “I really don’t want to go down this crazy rabbit hole, but those events are obviously different in scale and mistakes often do happen in war, and people understand this; despite their frustration when it happens.”

    There are good reasons to believe that the attack on the U.S.S. Liberty was not a mistake, but rather a deliberate act.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Mr. Anon


    There are good reasons to believe that the attack on the U.S.S. Liberty was not a mistake, but rather a deliberate act.
     
    I read the Wikipedia page. It is very interesting.

    Unlike 9/11 there are plenty of plausible theories proposed as to why and how the Israelis might have done it on purpose.

    There are some solid reasons to believe that the attack on the U.S. Liberty was not a mistake, but rather a deliberate attack. Even one that would motivate me to do the same if I were Israeli. Nonetheless I am not sold.

    People do crazy risky stuff in existential wars but still, it is quite crazy. Not nearly as crazy as false flagging 9/11 of course. Not even in the same ballpark.
  353. @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz


    Not really—only if it also gets on national TV instead of the Kardashians and Football. The Media creates Reality, and if the Media doesn’t report it, it doesn’t exist
     
    So now everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up 9/11? Even those who lost family members? Even the many parts of the media which are both anti-American and anti-Israel (outside of America?) And not one of these millions of people has broken ranks?

    How can anyone believe this?


    After all, the Lavon Attacks and the Liberty Attack are absolutely documented and confirmed, and all that happened was America increased its financial tribute payments to Israel
     
    I really don't want to go down this crazy rabbit hole, but those events are obviously different in scale and mistakes often do happen in war, and people understand this; despite their frustration when it happens.

    Meanwhile, in a different matter John McCain still ranks as America’s greatest Vietnam War Hero…
     
    Again, I don't know the details but I do know that burnishing one man's reputation is a great deal easier than what you're suggesting about 9/11. I also enjoyed your article.

    In the end:

    1. No-one is proposing a more plausible alternative theory.

    2. Claiming that 9/11 was anything but the normal account requires the whole world's media, the whole US security force, a huge number of independent experts and their families, the government of Russia and China plus their minions, to all be colluding to perpetrate a hoax in order to do what? If all of these guys are capable of operating with such discipline together there is absolutely no point in them bothering, they'd be beyond powerful and you'd be long dead; as would I.

    It also beggars belief - humans never have acted like that ever. Indeed this is so crazy that I no longer believe that you, Ron Unz, are serious. I have no idea what your angle is but please, be kind to this poor nobody and give me a clue, I can't bare this level of curiosity. Even a small clue!

    Replies: @Ron Unz, @Hunsdon

    So now everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up 9/11? Even those who lost family members?

    Well, I wouldn’t phrase it in exactly those words, but—Yes, quite possibly so.

    The Liberty Incident was probably the most serious military attack on American naval forces since WWII, resulting in over 200 dead and wounded American servicemen. The true facts were very quickly known at the time and have been endlessly confirmed since. Unless “everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up” that attack, why has it been so effectively hushed up for almost fifty years?

    My impression is that rightwing Internet-activists such as yourself go around endlessly claiming that the entire MSM constantly hides and “hushes up” the bad behavior of Muslims or blacks or illegal immigrants or whatever, and in quite a number of cases, you do have the facts on your side. Then you turn around and claim that only a “crazy conspiracy-nut” could believe that the MSM could hide or cover-up *vastly* more touchy matters, matters protected by *vastly* more powerful and influential groups.

    Steve’s often told the story of that popular Hispanic national news-anchor, who during his book-tour was badgered by Jon Stewart into finally hinting that Jews actually constituted a very powerful group in the media. He was immediately purged and totally “disappeared.” So what do you think would happen to any MSM person who revealed himself to be a “crazy conspiracy-nut” by pointing out some very suspicious behavior by numerous Mossad agents in connection with 9/11?

    Frankly, I’ve only given the slightest attention to 9/11 issues, and that was almost a decade ago, so although I’m reasonably confident my casual comments above are basically correct, I can’t really vouch for them with great certainty, e.g. I totally misremembered those 40% vs. 85% figures upthread. However, I’ve also published several major articles on the utter “unreliability” of the MSM on matters of enormous importance. Since you’re so new here and seem so totally ignorant or maybe just dishonest. If it’s the former, you might want to read those articles and decide for yourself if your confidence in the MSM is really warranted:

    https://www.unz.com/article/our-american-pravda/

    https://www.unz.com/runz/american-pravda-when-tokyo-rose-ran-for-president/

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz


    The Liberty Incident was probably the most serious military attack on American naval forces since WWII, resulting in over 200 dead and wounded American servicemen. The true facts were very quickly known at the time and have been endlessly confirmed since. Unless “everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up” that attack, why has it been so effectively hushed up for almost fifty years?
     
    So it is completely the opposite to 9/11 conspiracy theories, which have never been disproven because they've never been proposed - proposing a theory requires you to offer an alternative explanation. Also people talk endlessly about 9/11 stuff.

    My impression is that rightwing Internet-activists such as yourself go around endlessly claiming that the entire MSM constantly hides and “hushes up” the bad behavior of Muslims or blacks or illegal immigrants or whatever, and in quite a number of cases, you do have the facts on your side.
     
    People don't like to talk about things which they think make them sound impolite or rude. That is not even close to being the same as repeatedly lying to the public about who murdered 3000 of them, many their own family members, in the most televised event in human history.

    Steve’s often told the story of that popular Hispanic national news-anchor, who during his book-tour was badgered by Jon Stewart into finally hinting that Jews actually constituted a very powerful group in the media. He was immediately purged and totally “disappeared.”
     
    Do you have any sense of scale or perspective? Do I really have to explain to you how having the power and will to get someone fired is nothing like having it to hide a conspiracy involving millions like 9/11 would have to?

    Do you build an ark when a couple of rain drops fall?


    However, I’ve also published several major articles on the utter “unreliability” of the MSM on matters of enormous importance
     
    Again, these compare, in no way, in scale, to what you are alleging.

    You seem convinced that because you can find some lies, everything is a lie; but you can always find lies and everything is never only lies. So your thought process is essentially false. It is based on an emotional reaction as opposed to a cool balancing of the facts, which is a common problem.


    My impression is that rightwing Internet-activists such as yourself
     
    What have I said which that right wing?

    Replies: @ben tillman

    , @Bill Jones
    @Ron Unz

    The Official Version of 9/11 goes something like this...

    Directed by a beardy-guy from a cave in Afghanistan, ( This well appointed Suite
    http://www.edwardjayepstein.com/nether_fictoid3.htm

    according to the London Times): nineteen hard-drinking, coke-snorting, devout Muslims enjoy lap dances before their mission to meet Allah...

    Using nothing more than craft knifes, they overpower cabin crew, passengers and pilots on four planes...

    And hangover or not, they manage to give the world's most sophisticated air defense system the slip...

    Unfazed by leaving their “How to Fly a Passenger Jet” guide in the car at the airport, they master the controls in no-time and score direct hits on two towers, causing THREE to collapse completely...

    Our masterminds even manage to overpower the odd law of physics or two... and the world watches in awe as steel-framed buildings fall symmetrically - through their own mass - at free-fall speed, for the first time in history.

    Despite all their dastardly cunning, they stupidly give their identity away by using explosion-proof passports, which survive the fireball undamaged and fall to the ground... only to be discovered by the incredible crime-fighting sleuths at the FBI...

    …Meanwhile down in Washington...

    Hani Hanjour, having previously flunked 2-man Cessna flying school, gets carried away with all the success of the day and suddenly finds incredible abilities behind the controls of a Boeing...

    Instead of flying straight down into the large roof area of the Pentagon, he decides to show off a little...

    Executing an incredible 270 degree downward spiral, he levels off to hit the low facade of the world's most heavily defended building...

    ...all without a single shot being fired.... or ruining the nicely mowed lawn... and all at a speed just too fast to capture on video...

    ...Later, in the skies above Pennsylvania...

    So desperate to talk to loved ones before their death, some passengers use sheer willpower to connect mobile calls that otherwise would not be possible until several years later...

    And following a heroic attempt by some to retake control of Flight 93, it crashes into a Shankesville field leaving no trace of engines, fuselage or occupants... except for the standard issue Muslim terrorists bandana...

    ...Further south in Florida...

    President Bush, our brave Commander-in-Chief continues to read “My Pet Goat” to a class full of primary school children... shrugging off the obvious possibility that his life could be in imminent danger...

    ...In New York...

    World Trade Center leaseholder Larry Silverstein blesses his own foresight in insuring the buildings against terrorist attack only six weeks previously...

    While back in Washington, Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld and Paul Wolfowitz shake their heads in disbelief at their own luck in getting the 'New Pearl Harbor' catalyzing event they so desired to pursue their agenda of world domination...

    And finally, not to be disturbed too much by reports of their own deaths, at least seven of our nineteen suicide hijackers turn up alive and kicking in mainstream media reports...

    And If you don't believe this, you are a conspiracy theorist.

    Replies: @Anonymous

  354. @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz


    As I’ve said before, Trump is a totally ignorant buffoon, and given our current ideological principles, the rightful political representative of many millions of Buffoon-Americans…
     
    Which politician is more likely to run the American government in the interest of the American people? Or is that an ignorant and buffoonish sentiment for poor people?

    Replies: @Ron Unz

    As I’ve said before, Trump is a totally ignorant buffoon

    Which politician is more likely to run the American government in the interest of the American people? Or is that an ignorant and buffoonish sentiment for poor people?

    Well, some pro-Trump commenter put it very well a couple of weeks ago, saying that Trump was 95% a clown and 5% a patriot, which made him much better than almost all the other candidates.

    I’d more or less tend to agree with that. Except for Trump and Bernie Sanders, all the other candidates are totally worthless, and many of them *extremely* dangerous in their foreign policy views as well. I strongly disagree with Sanders about lots of important things, but he’d be my top choice for now, with Trump probably a very distant second.

  355. @This Is Our Home
    @Truth


    No, Pluto, the question is, where are the bodies, where are the seats, where are the jet engines, where are the wings, where are the windows, where is the luggage; etc..etc.

    Stick with this thing, it gets easier.
     
    So the plane is not on the video becomes the plane wreckage is not on the video? Ok, there's plenty of recorded witnesses to seeing the wreckage from close up; I guess they're in on it too? Really who isn't?

    You have still failed to advance any alternative theory AND your objections directly contradict Ron Unz's about Israelis being behind it. After all, if it was a missile, why would the Pentagon cover it up?

    Replies: @Truth

    I just showed you a photo. That makes the question quite simple; are you going to believe what you have heard or what you see. All that other shit that you are talking is, at this point, totally negligible.

    From where I sit there are three possibilities from those photos I posted:

    1. There is a plane in that picture that hit the Pentagon, and somehow, for 14 years, I have failed to see it. If this is the case, please point it out.

    2. There is no plane.

    3. There was a plane that hit the pentagon, and somehow it disappeared (which leads to 3a. Harry Blackstone or Chris Angel was in the vicinity at the time.

    4. These pictures, along with hundreds of others available have somehow been altered to remove a plane.

    Which of these is your point, or, if you have another point that I am somehow missing, feel free to share.

    BTW; this question, if you are as intelligent as you say you are.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Truth

    Or there's a verge in the lawn and a slight slope which renders a lot of what you imagine you can see actually unseeable.

    It's happened to me. I remember being a young child and breaking into tears because the ski run looked much harder at the beginning than it actually was. Once i was persuaded onto the slope it was actually very easy. I learnt from this experience and did not worry again. This is a common misperception that all skiers can relate to. You believe you see a lot of the slope but actually you don't.

    There are plenty of websites which make this point in more technical terms, but I don't suppose you looked. It's much more fun to be in possession of secret information.

    , @Mr. Anon
    @Truth

    There are three possibilities, but then you list four. Anyway, there is a fifth possibility: Airplanes don't crash like they do in the movies. They don't take three minutes to slow to a halt as they do in movies like "Cliffhanger". They stop in the time it takes them to traverse their own length at whatever speed they impact at. They disintegrate.

    Replies: @Truth

  356. @D. K.
    @Truth

    From Wikipedia.org:

    ***

    Barbara Kay Olson (née Bracher; December 27, 1955 – September 11, 2001) was an American lawyer and conservative television commentator who worked for CNN, Fox News Channel, and several other outlets.[1] She was a passenger on American Airlines Flight 77 en route to a taping of Bill Maher's television show Politically Incorrect when it was flown into the Pentagon in the September 11 attacks. Her original plan had been to fly to California on September 10, but delayed until the next morning so that she could wake up with her husband on his birthday, September 11.[2][3]

    ***

    The husband, now widower, in question, was Ted Olson. On September 11, 2001, he was serving as the Solicitor General of the United States. His wife called him from the airplane, after it had been hijacked, as many other doomed passengers called their own loved ones, that morning, from their hijacked flights.

    If Barbara Olson's flight was not flown into the Pentagon, that morning, where is that airplane, now? Where are Barbara Olson, her fellow airline travelers, the flight's crew, and the hijackers who were named as having been on that particular flight? Who planted the airplane's black boxes inside the Pentagon, where they were discovered "in the wee small hours of the morning" of Friday, September 14, 2001? Who planted the debris on the lawn of the Pentagon, in the immediate aftermath of the crash, as photographed that morning and included on the flight's Wikipedia.org entry? Which mind altering drugs are easiest to procure, there in Kuwait?

    Replies: @Truth

    As I said earlier, Sheepskin, do you believe what you hear, or do you believe what you see.

    We really don’t need to go much further than that.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Truth

    Sorry I thought that you forgot to link to the photo as it was moderated in a different order.

    I then assumed that you were linking to the photos of the Pentagon lawn taken from ground level.

    These aerial photos are even easier to explain as they are taken some time after the event. When a great deal of wreckage has been cleared up. There are even props holding up part of the Pentagon wall!

    Also, if you fly a jet into a building with depth it will pass through the first few layers which will then collapse behind it covering a lot of the airplane parts. Surely that's pretty obvious?

    Replies: @Truth

  357. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Ron Unz
    @This Is Our Home


    So now everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up 9/11? Even those who lost family members?
     
    Well, I wouldn't phrase it in exactly those words, but---Yes, quite possibly so.

    The Liberty Incident was probably the most serious military attack on American naval forces since WWII, resulting in over 200 dead and wounded American servicemen. The true facts were very quickly known at the time and have been endlessly confirmed since. Unless "everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up" that attack, why has it been so effectively hushed up for almost fifty years?

    My impression is that rightwing Internet-activists such as yourself go around endlessly claiming that the entire MSM constantly hides and "hushes up" the bad behavior of Muslims or blacks or illegal immigrants or whatever, and in quite a number of cases, you do have the facts on your side. Then you turn around and claim that only a "crazy conspiracy-nut" could believe that the MSM could hide or cover-up *vastly* more touchy matters, matters protected by *vastly* more powerful and influential groups.

    Steve's often told the story of that popular Hispanic national news-anchor, who during his book-tour was badgered by Jon Stewart into finally hinting that Jews actually constituted a very powerful group in the media. He was immediately purged and totally "disappeared." So what do you think would happen to any MSM person who revealed himself to be a "crazy conspiracy-nut" by pointing out some very suspicious behavior by numerous Mossad agents in connection with 9/11?

    Frankly, I've only given the slightest attention to 9/11 issues, and that was almost a decade ago, so although I'm reasonably confident my casual comments above are basically correct, I can't really vouch for them with great certainty, e.g. I totally misremembered those 40% vs. 85% figures upthread. However, I've also published several major articles on the utter "unreliability" of the MSM on matters of enormous importance. Since you're so new here and seem so totally ignorant or maybe just dishonest. If it's the former, you might want to read those articles and decide for yourself if your confidence in the MSM is really warranted:

    https://www.unz.com/article/our-american-pravda/

    https://www.unz.com/runz/american-pravda-when-tokyo-rose-ran-for-president/

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Bill Jones

    The Liberty Incident was probably the most serious military attack on American naval forces since WWII, resulting in over 200 dead and wounded American servicemen. The true facts were very quickly known at the time and have been endlessly confirmed since. Unless “everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up” that attack, why has it been so effectively hushed up for almost fifty years?

    So it is completely the opposite to 9/11 conspiracy theories, which have never been disproven because they’ve never been proposed – proposing a theory requires you to offer an alternative explanation. Also people talk endlessly about 9/11 stuff.

    My impression is that rightwing Internet-activists such as yourself go around endlessly claiming that the entire MSM constantly hides and “hushes up” the bad behavior of Muslims or blacks or illegal immigrants or whatever, and in quite a number of cases, you do have the facts on your side.

    People don’t like to talk about things which they think make them sound impolite or rude. That is not even close to being the same as repeatedly lying to the public about who murdered 3000 of them, many their own family members, in the most televised event in human history.

    Steve’s often told the story of that popular Hispanic national news-anchor, who during his book-tour was badgered by Jon Stewart into finally hinting that Jews actually constituted a very powerful group in the media. He was immediately purged and totally “disappeared.”

    Do you have any sense of scale or perspective? Do I really have to explain to you how having the power and will to get someone fired is nothing like having it to hide a conspiracy involving millions like 9/11 would have to?

    Do you build an ark when a couple of rain drops fall?

    However, I’ve also published several major articles on the utter “unreliability” of the MSM on matters of enormous importance

    Again, these compare, in no way, in scale, to what you are alleging.

    You seem convinced that because you can find some lies, everything is a lie; but you can always find lies and everything is never only lies. So your thought process is essentially false. It is based on an emotional reaction as opposed to a cool balancing of the facts, which is a common problem.

    My impression is that rightwing Internet-activists such as yourself

    What have I said which that right wing?

    • Replies: @ben tillman
    @This Is Our Home


    Do you have any sense of scale or perspective? Do I really have to explain to you how having the power and will to get someone fired is nothing like having it to hide a conspiracy involving millions like 9/11 would have to?
     
    A conspiracy involving millions? What?

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

  358. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Truth
    @This Is Our Home

    I just showed you a photo. That makes the question quite simple; are you going to believe what you have heard or what you see. All that other shit that you are talking is, at this point, totally negligible.

    From where I sit there are three possibilities from those photos I posted:

    1. There is a plane in that picture that hit the Pentagon, and somehow, for 14 years, I have failed to see it. If this is the case, please point it out.

    2. There is no plane.

    3. There was a plane that hit the pentagon, and somehow it disappeared (which leads to 3a. Harry Blackstone or Chris Angel was in the vicinity at the time.

    4. These pictures, along with hundreds of others available have somehow been altered to remove a plane.

    Which of these is your point, or, if you have another point that I am somehow missing, feel free to share.

    BTW; this question, if you are as intelligent as you say you are.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

    Or there’s a verge in the lawn and a slight slope which renders a lot of what you imagine you can see actually unseeable.

    It’s happened to me. I remember being a young child and breaking into tears because the ski run looked much harder at the beginning than it actually was. Once i was persuaded onto the slope it was actually very easy. I learnt from this experience and did not worry again. This is a common misperception that all skiers can relate to. You believe you see a lot of the slope but actually you don’t.

    There are plenty of websites which make this point in more technical terms, but I don’t suppose you looked. It’s much more fun to be in possession of secret information.

  359. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Rurik
    @Rob McX


    if the plan started to go wrong at the last minute,
     
    it did

    in all likelihood the plane that vanished over Shanksville was intended to hit building seven, thereby providing the pretext for that building to fall. When the plane never arrived, they had to scramble for a contingency and just decided to "pull it", and that's why we have that smoking gun.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    it did

    in all likelihood the plane that vanished over Shanksville was intended to hit building seven, thereby providing the pretext for that building to fall. When the plane never arrived, they had to scramble for a contingency and just decided to “pull it”, and that’s why we have that smoking gun.

    Why would they need a contingency? The towers were hit, that’s all that really mattered.

    • Replies: @Rurik
    @This Is Our Home


    Why would they need a contingency? The towers were hit, that’s all that really mattered.
     
    are you really commenting on a public forum about an event as important as 911 with little or no actual knowledge of what the fuck you're even talking about?

    building seven was not hit by a plane genius

    that's the whole point!
  360. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Mr. Anon
    "I really don’t want to go down this crazy rabbit hole, but those events are obviously different in scale and mistakes often do happen in war, and people understand this; despite their frustration when it happens."

    There are good reasons to believe that the attack on the U.S.S. Liberty was not a mistake, but rather a deliberate act.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    There are good reasons to believe that the attack on the U.S.S. Liberty was not a mistake, but rather a deliberate act.

    I read the Wikipedia page. It is very interesting.

    Unlike 9/11 there are plenty of plausible theories proposed as to why and how the Israelis might have done it on purpose.

    There are some solid reasons to believe that the attack on the U.S. Liberty was not a mistake, but rather a deliberate attack. Even one that would motivate me to do the same if I were Israeli. Nonetheless I am not sold.

    People do crazy risky stuff in existential wars but still, it is quite crazy. Not nearly as crazy as false flagging 9/11 of course. Not even in the same ballpark.

  361. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Truth
    @D. K.

    As I said earlier, Sheepskin, do you believe what you hear, or do you believe what you see.

    https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Pentagon_on_9.11_-_2.jpg

    http://findyourcharleston.com/charleston-real-estate-blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/pentagon.jpg

    We really don't need to go much further than that.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    Sorry I thought that you forgot to link to the photo as it was moderated in a different order.

    I then assumed that you were linking to the photos of the Pentagon lawn taken from ground level.

    These aerial photos are even easier to explain as they are taken some time after the event. When a great deal of wreckage has been cleared up. There are even props holding up part of the Pentagon wall!

    Also, if you fly a jet into a building with depth it will pass through the first few layers which will then collapse behind it covering a lot of the airplane parts. Surely that’s pretty obvious?

    • Replies: @Truth
    @This Is Our Home




    Or there’s a verge in the lawn and a slight slope which renders a lot of what you imagine you can see actually unseeable.
     


    Surely that’s pretty obvious?
     
    Thanks, Bob. I'm done.
  362. @Ron Unz

    You also have Fox News and (especially) the New York Post that would not have been inclined to join a cover-up (if not for true conservative principles, then at least for love of the sensationalistic).
     
    That's the crucial point. If even the slightest hint of something like that had happened, the fanatical neocons and their media outlets would have blasted it 24/7. It's about as plausible that a huge KKK march by Harvard faculty members was ignored by the NYT and the rest of the MSM. The likelihood is dead-flat-zero.

    Trump "remembers" he saw it lots of times on TV, and all those other local dimwits similarly "remember" they saw it and describe it on their Facebook pages, which causes more people to "remember" it as well.

    Bear in mind that by 2004, around 40% of Americans "knew" that we'd invaded Iraq because Saddam had attacked us on 9/11, and a year or two later 40% of the American troops in Iraq believed the same thing...

    Replies: @matt, @inertial

    Bear in mind that by 2004, around 40% of Americans “knew” that we’d invaded Iraq because Saddam had attacked us on 9/11, and a year or two later 40% of the American troops in Iraq believed the same thing…

    Actually, there is just as much evidence that Iraq was behind 911 (or knew about it) as Israel was. That is to say, nothing like a real proof, but if you squinted in the right way you could see the “dots” that could be connected in a way that aligned with your personal demonology. Those 40% American weren’t dumber than you, they simply had been influenced by a different kind of bias.

    • Agree: This Is Our Home
  363. Trump’s Twitter account posted this link:

    Credible Source on 9-11 Muslim Celebrations: FBI

    http://wkrg.com/2015/11/25/credible-source-on-9-11-muslim-celebrations-fbi

    One retired FBI agent says Donald Trump’s claims of seeing Muslim celebrations following the attacks on 9-11 are absolutely plausible.

    Jim Burkett was an assistant special agent in charge with the FBI’s office in Boston during 9-11 and afterward. He says during that time the office received tons of phone calls from people who feared more attacks and others reporting suspicious activity.

    Many of those calls, said Burkett, came from concerned and angry Americans reporting Muslim’s celebrating over the destruction of the twin towers and damage to the Pentagon. The calls were logged, reports were made and there were “stacks and stacks” of them, he said.

    But the retired agent says even though video of celebrations following 9-11 is hard to find, he says it means Trump’s claims are highly plausible.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    @Martin

    Actually, what's really funny is that Trump tweeted a link to the Infowars site to support his contention about the 9/11 Muslim celebration, especially in light of what this comment thread has developed into. Infowars is probably the most popular and prominent 9/11 Truth conspiracy website.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

  364. @Ron Unz
    @Thomas O. Meehan


    I lived in New Jersey at the time of the attack and was working in law enforcement. I recall reports of Arabs celebrating on the streets of Paterson or Passaic. At this remove I can’t say I saw video of said jubilation, but it was reported and taken at face value by a very large percentage of the population...That said, I think it is possible that footage exists but is lost or being withheld.
     
    As I mentioned earlier, I find such claims *exceptionally* implausible.

    Don't forget that the Neocons had absolute and total control of a substantial portion of the local and national media at that point, plus the Giuliani Admin, and were using it to promote the tremendous domestic dangers from of Arabs/Muslims. Large numbers of totally innocent such individuals, minding their own business, were grabbed up by the police due to mass hysteria, and kept under arrest for quite a long time. As far as I'm aware, not a single one was every proven to be directly sympathetic to the terrorist attacks. In fact, some of the Neocons quickly began pressing for a mass-internment of Arabs/Muslims, much like happened with the Japanese in WWII, and to that end they began publishing books and articles saying that FDR had been totally legally and morally justified in the Japanese Internment.

    If any such video footage existed, they would have broadcast it 24/7 (unless, of course, you agree with the Jewish-activists that the American media is fanatically anti-Jewish and anti-Israel).

    At the same time the airwaves were full of footage of Palestinians openly celebrating.
     
    Although I've never never investigated it, I'm *extremely* skeptical that such alleged celebration overseas occurred in more than a small handful of cases. All that happens is that some 30-second video shot is endlessly looped over FoxNews or ABC, with voice-over explanation by the anchor, and that becomes the reality of rightwing dimwits everywhere. Indeed, the whole thing might easily have been staged.

    If Trump is delusional about the dancing arabs of Passaic, he shares that delusion with millions of fellow New York area citizens.
     
    Well, I agree with you there. And I'd bet that many, many millions of American blacks (and whites) also believe that the KKK has been burning black churches all around the country and that white racist police have been randomly killing black children everywhere for eating skittles. Or perhaps you've never heard of the Black Lives Matter movement...

    As I've said before, Trump is a totally ignorant buffoon, and given our current ideological principles, the rightful political representative of many millions of Buffoon-Americans...

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @This Is Our Home, @inertial, @Thomas O. Meehan

    Eh, I dunno. You must recall the first days after 911, the time when President Bush went to a mosque and declared Islam to be a “Religion of Peace.” I got a strong impression that our elites got genuinely scared that the unwashed masses were about to go on a anti Muslim pogrom spree. There was A LOT of that Religion of Peace propaganda coming from all over at that time, and the Neocons were very much a part of that. I don’t feel like digging up links on my phone, but surely you remember why Ann Coulter was fired by National Review?

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @inertial

    And the greatest allies the neo-cons had in dispelling the unease that people (naturally) have had about muslim immigration has been..............the Truthers. By directing blame for the attacks on 9/11 away from muslims, they serve to rob anti-immigrationists of one of their best arguments against immigration.

    The fact is, the everything-is-a-false-flag crowd are among the most useful tools that globalist elites have ever had.

  365. @Truth
    @This Is Our Home

    No, Pluto, the question is, where are the bodies, where are the seats, where are the jet engines, where are the wings, where are the windows, where is the luggage; etc..etc.

    Stick with this thing, it gets easier.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Boomstick

    http://www.rense.com/general32/phot.htm

    Includes many photos of aircraft wreckage inside the Pentagon. If you look long enough you can also find photos of the bodies, the APU, nose gear and so on.

    • Replies: @Truth
    @Boomstick

    I got exactly this far;




    Most of the heaped scrap is unrecognizable,
     

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

  366. @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz


    Not really—only if it also gets on national TV instead of the Kardashians and Football. The Media creates Reality, and if the Media doesn’t report it, it doesn’t exist
     
    So now everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up 9/11? Even those who lost family members? Even the many parts of the media which are both anti-American and anti-Israel (outside of America?) And not one of these millions of people has broken ranks?

    How can anyone believe this?


    After all, the Lavon Attacks and the Liberty Attack are absolutely documented and confirmed, and all that happened was America increased its financial tribute payments to Israel
     
    I really don't want to go down this crazy rabbit hole, but those events are obviously different in scale and mistakes often do happen in war, and people understand this; despite their frustration when it happens.

    Meanwhile, in a different matter John McCain still ranks as America’s greatest Vietnam War Hero…
     
    Again, I don't know the details but I do know that burnishing one man's reputation is a great deal easier than what you're suggesting about 9/11. I also enjoyed your article.

    In the end:

    1. No-one is proposing a more plausible alternative theory.

    2. Claiming that 9/11 was anything but the normal account requires the whole world's media, the whole US security force, a huge number of independent experts and their families, the government of Russia and China plus their minions, to all be colluding to perpetrate a hoax in order to do what? If all of these guys are capable of operating with such discipline together there is absolutely no point in them bothering, they'd be beyond powerful and you'd be long dead; as would I.

    It also beggars belief - humans never have acted like that ever. Indeed this is so crazy that I no longer believe that you, Ron Unz, are serious. I have no idea what your angle is but please, be kind to this poor nobody and give me a clue, I can't bare this level of curiosity. Even a small clue!

    Replies: @Ron Unz, @Hunsdon

    Robert Rediger said: mistakes often do happen in war . . . .

    Hunsdon said: If we are discussing the USS Liberty, you are not helping your case. Ignorant, or duplicitous, hmm.

    • Replies: @Ron Unz
    @Hunsdon


    Hunsdon said: If we are discussing the USS Liberty, you are not helping your case. Ignorant, or duplicitous, hmm.
     
    Regarding the Liberty Incident, here's a nice tidbit that I may or may not have previously mentioned somewhere on this website...

    The NSA naturally has all the radio intercepts between the Israeli pilots and their military commanders, repeatedly ordering them to destroy the U.S.S. Liberty and leave no survivors (I suspect there's actually a chance that their failure was partly due to their considerable reluctance to follow such seemingly astonishing orders). Since those radio intercepts were presumably swept up along with everything in the entire region, it presumably took them at least a few weeks to separate those out and get them translated from the Hebrew. Since some of the dead on the ship were NSA people, I'd assume the NSA people back home were *quite* unhappy about what they discovered, but there wasn't much that they or their later successors could do once LBJ and their other political masters had made their decision to totally suppress and whitewash the incident.

    However, one of my old friends was Bill Odom, the three-star general who ran the NSA for Reagan, and Bill was a sharp fellow. The story I heard is that he arranged for those particular Israeli radio intercepts to be used each year in the official NSA training process given to all entering officers, in which they are given real-life examples demonstrating the effectiveness of NSA technology and techniques. I don't know the exact details, but it wouldn't surprise me if hundreds or even thousands of mid- or high-ranking NSA officials there days are therefore certainly aware of the exact details of the Liberty Incident, although it probably remains unknown to 99.5% of the American public.

    Replies: @Hunsdon, @Rurik

  367. @Truth
    @This Is Our Home


    Why would they lie?
     
    The "expert" who original edited this article is the is the Brother of Michael Chertoff, who at the time was the acting Director of Homeland Security.

    Maybe that's why.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Hunsdon

    Truth: I’d like to apologize. I’ve come to regard you as a “Johnny One Note” poster, and I was wrong. I like you a lot better when you branch out from what seems to be your usual shtick. (Despite the knee-grow comment in your post immediately following.) Yeah, I know, my comment will change your life, what can I say?

    • Replies: @Truth
    @Hunsdon

    Well thank you Hunsdon, although there is certainly no need to apologize. I have to quarrel with you just a bit on the rest though.

    No matter how we may come to frame it, this is, against its better wishes, a site about, dedicated to, and with the almost 'one note' attention to, knee-grows, and gets moreso on almost a daily basis.

    It's a bit like Roissy, or one of the other's 'game' sites; it masquerades being about women, but it is truly, unmistakably about men...

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    , @Mr. Anon
    @Hunsdon

    The fact that you agree with "Truth" doesn't give you pause to question what you believe? If somebody's judgement is poor in N different things, how much do you trust his judgement in the N+1th thing?

  368. @Mr. Anon
    @tanabear

    "The first goal has been accomplished. The official story is false on almost every level. This is a resolved scientific matter."

    That is absolutely false - a baseless assertion made by someone who in all likelihood has no idea what he's talking about. You may think so, but who cares? Who are you? What do you know about physics or engineering? Evidently, nothing.

    One thing you have accomplished though: you've made common cause with a guy like "Truth" - a bona fide stereotype of the bragging, know-nothing affirmative-action black-man. How does that make you feel?

    Replies: @tanabear, @Hunsdon, @Truth

    People use the monikers “conspiracy theorist”, “kook”, or “tinfoil hat wearers” to refer to 9/11 truth seekers so they can deflect from the fact that they have no real arguments for the government’s case. What does the 9/11 Truth Movement actually believe? They believe that explosive charges can blow things up. They believe that demolition chargers can be used to bring down steel-framed high-rises. This is not a controversial position. This is routinely how steel-framed buildings are destroyed. It only becomes “kooky” if you believe this is what happened on 9/11. People defending the official narrative are making claims that have no scientific basis. Have any of their claims been subjected to the experimental method? Can we witness a crush-down, crush-up, momentum transfer at free-fall acceleration, inward of the perimeter columns due to the catenary action of the sagging floor trusses, a steel-framed high-rise being demolished with fire, instead of explosives? No, none of this has been replicated. So instead of saying that I’m a kook, you can just demonstrate that the 9/11 truth seekers are wrong. It should be simple if the government’s account is rock solid.

    In short, 9/11 truth seekers believe that the noon-day sky is blue, that water will wet you and fire will burn; that explosives can blow stuff up. And that all this was also true on 09/11/2001.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @tanabear

    People defending the "official narrative" as you style it have far more scientific basis than you do.

    For example, it has long been known that fires can bring down steel framed buildings. That is why the designers take such precautions to avoid fires and extinguish them quickly. That is why they routinely put fire proofing on the girders. So tell us, why do they put insulation on the girders, if it is impossible for the girders to be effected by fire? I mean - they are made of steel, aren't they? They won't burn under any imaginable set of circumstances. So why do it?

    And anyway, what technical training do you have? What is your particular area of expertise? Why should I give a damn about your opinion?

  369. @Mr. Anon
    "he said he was outside the Florida classroom when he saw the plane hit the tower and that he thought it must be a bad pilot. We all know that the second plane didn’t hit until he was well inside the classroom and reading about the pet goat. If it were the second plane then even someone as monumentally stupid as George Bush would have figured out that a second plane hitting the towers was not just a coincidence or pilot error, don’t you think?"

    There is nothing inciriminating in anything he said. Nothing you've said about this proves anything, except that you are obtuse and/or demented.

    "and just for you, I’m posting again a video of building seven falling. There are thousands upon thousands of architects and structural engineers and building engineers and demolition experts and other professionals that have put their names and reputations on the line by going public and saying that there is no way that building seven could have fallen the way it did due to office fires or any of the structural damage it suffered."

    Thousands and Thousands? I think you're exagerating. First of all - architects are irrelevant - they aren't structural engineers. Secondly, there are "thousands upon thousands" of structural and demolition engineers who believe that the buildings were destroyed just as explained in the "official story".

    "here’s a controlled demolition expert

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=877gr6xtQIc"

    Yes, here's a dutch expert, giving a cursory opinion based on the same grainy you-tube video that every "Truther" has seen, without benefit of any of the other details of the buildings collapse. That was an Iranian-state TV interview, by the way. No agenda there, I'm sure.

    "he’s since died in a car crash"

    Yes, years after that interview. But nobody dies in car crashes, do they, in less it is willed by the all-powerful conspirators.

    As I said, to stupid people like you, everything is a mystery.

    Replies: @Ron Unz, @Rurik

    There is nothing inciriminating in anything he said. Nothing you’ve said about this proves anything, except that you are obtuse and/or demented.

    Obviously the statements of “W” regarding what he remembers seeing on TV and when he saw it are *extremely* weak evidence of anything, except perhaps his empty-headedness.

    “he’s since died in a car crash”

    Yes, years after that interview. But nobody dies in car crashes, do they, in less it is willed by the all-powerful conspirators.

    Actually, from what I recall reading on the Internet around the time it happened, that Dutch demolitions expert was unlucky enough to die in a single-car accident just a few days after he was interviewed on Iranian TV and said the WTC collapse definitely looked like a “controlled demolition” to him. If so, then presumably other such experts became convinced that rendering any such discordant opinions on broadcast TV might become a similar source of “bad luck.” At the time, it was one of the datapoints that made me increasingly “suspicious” of the official narrative. However, it was all some years ago and perhaps my memory is playing tricks on me, so someone might want to check the dates.

  370. @Mr. Anon
    @tanabear

    "The first goal has been accomplished. The official story is false on almost every level. This is a resolved scientific matter."

    That is absolutely false - a baseless assertion made by someone who in all likelihood has no idea what he's talking about. You may think so, but who cares? Who are you? What do you know about physics or engineering? Evidently, nothing.

    One thing you have accomplished though: you've made common cause with a guy like "Truth" - a bona fide stereotype of the bragging, know-nothing affirmative-action black-man. How does that make you feel?

    Replies: @tanabear, @Hunsdon, @Truth

    Oh come on now. Can’t you work in a good “shuckin’ and jivin’” reference to Truth while you’re at it?

  371. @Hunsdon
    @This Is Our Home

    Robert Rediger said: mistakes often do happen in war . . . .

    Hunsdon said: If we are discussing the USS Liberty, you are not helping your case. Ignorant, or duplicitous, hmm.

    Replies: @Ron Unz

    Hunsdon said: If we are discussing the USS Liberty, you are not helping your case. Ignorant, or duplicitous, hmm.

    Regarding the Liberty Incident, here’s a nice tidbit that I may or may not have previously mentioned somewhere on this website…

    The NSA naturally has all the radio intercepts between the Israeli pilots and their military commanders, repeatedly ordering them to destroy the U.S.S. Liberty and leave no survivors (I suspect there’s actually a chance that their failure was partly due to their considerable reluctance to follow such seemingly astonishing orders). Since those radio intercepts were presumably swept up along with everything in the entire region, it presumably took them at least a few weeks to separate those out and get them translated from the Hebrew. Since some of the dead on the ship were NSA people, I’d assume the NSA people back home were *quite* unhappy about what they discovered, but there wasn’t much that they or their later successors could do once LBJ and their other political masters had made their decision to totally suppress and whitewash the incident.

    However, one of my old friends was Bill Odom, the three-star general who ran the NSA for Reagan, and Bill was a sharp fellow. The story I heard is that he arranged for those particular Israeli radio intercepts to be used each year in the official NSA training process given to all entering officers, in which they are given real-life examples demonstrating the effectiveness of NSA technology and techniques. I don’t know the exact details, but it wouldn’t surprise me if hundreds or even thousands of mid- or high-ranking NSA officials there days are therefore certainly aware of the exact details of the Liberty Incident, although it probably remains unknown to 99.5% of the American public.

    • Replies: @Hunsdon
    @Ron Unz

    That would be subtlety on a level I would hope for, but not necessarily expect, from the USG. Superb! Thanks to our host's host.

    , @Rurik
    @Ron Unz


    (I suspect there’s actually a chance that their failure was partly due to their considerable reluctance to follow such seemingly astonishing orders).
     
    it'd be better if this story had a name for the pilot, but anyways

    Israeli Pilot Speaks Up

    Fifteen years after the attack, an Israeli pilot approached Liberty survivors and then held extensive interviews with former Congressman Paul N. (Pete) McCloskey about his role. According to this senior Israeli lead pilot, he recognized the Liberty as American immediately, so informed his headquarters, and was told to ignore the American flag and continue his attack. He refused to do so and returned to base, where he was arrested.


    https://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/msg107033.html
  372. @Anonymous
    @Thomas O. Meehan

    Trump repeatedly asserted that there were "thousands and thousands", which would imply large crowds in the streets celebrating. "Millions" of Tri-State area citizens certainly don't recall "thousands and thousands" celebrating in the streets in the aftermath of 9/11. It seems pretty likely that this is just Trump's trademark exaggerating salesmanship, if not outright lying.

    It'd be hard to believe if there weren't any Muslims in New Jersey happy about the attacks and some groups of them celebrating out in the streets in the aftermath, but that wasn't what Trump suggested and wasn't the image he was trying to convey with his remarks of "thousands and thousands".

    Replies: @Thomas O. Meehan

    My point, which you completely miss, is that Muslim celebrations in Passaic and or Paterson were widely reported in the press at that time. Many took them to be true. So, Trump is not making things up out of whole cloth.

    If Trump is overstating his case as with “Thousands,” that deserves to be criticized.

  373. @This Is Our Home
    @Truth

    Sorry I thought that you forgot to link to the photo as it was moderated in a different order.

    I then assumed that you were linking to the photos of the Pentagon lawn taken from ground level.

    These aerial photos are even easier to explain as they are taken some time after the event. When a great deal of wreckage has been cleared up. There are even props holding up part of the Pentagon wall!

    Also, if you fly a jet into a building with depth it will pass through the first few layers which will then collapse behind it covering a lot of the airplane parts. Surely that's pretty obvious?

    Replies: @Truth

    Or there’s a verge in the lawn and a slight slope which renders a lot of what you imagine you can see actually unseeable.

    Surely that’s pretty obvious?

    Thanks, Bob. I’m done.

  374. @Mr. Anon
    @tanabear

    "The first goal has been accomplished. The official story is false on almost every level. This is a resolved scientific matter."

    That is absolutely false - a baseless assertion made by someone who in all likelihood has no idea what he's talking about. You may think so, but who cares? Who are you? What do you know about physics or engineering? Evidently, nothing.

    One thing you have accomplished though: you've made common cause with a guy like "Truth" - a bona fide stereotype of the bragging, know-nothing affirmative-action black-man. How does that make you feel?

    Replies: @tanabear, @Hunsdon, @Truth

    One thing you have accomplished though: you’ve made common cause with a guy like “Truth” – a bona fide stereotype of the bragging, know-nothing affirmative-action black-man. How does that make you feel?

    I take offense to the insinuation… that I’ve accomplished something.

  375. @Ron Unz
    @Hunsdon


    Hunsdon said: If we are discussing the USS Liberty, you are not helping your case. Ignorant, or duplicitous, hmm.
     
    Regarding the Liberty Incident, here's a nice tidbit that I may or may not have previously mentioned somewhere on this website...

    The NSA naturally has all the radio intercepts between the Israeli pilots and their military commanders, repeatedly ordering them to destroy the U.S.S. Liberty and leave no survivors (I suspect there's actually a chance that their failure was partly due to their considerable reluctance to follow such seemingly astonishing orders). Since those radio intercepts were presumably swept up along with everything in the entire region, it presumably took them at least a few weeks to separate those out and get them translated from the Hebrew. Since some of the dead on the ship were NSA people, I'd assume the NSA people back home were *quite* unhappy about what they discovered, but there wasn't much that they or their later successors could do once LBJ and their other political masters had made their decision to totally suppress and whitewash the incident.

    However, one of my old friends was Bill Odom, the three-star general who ran the NSA for Reagan, and Bill was a sharp fellow. The story I heard is that he arranged for those particular Israeli radio intercepts to be used each year in the official NSA training process given to all entering officers, in which they are given real-life examples demonstrating the effectiveness of NSA technology and techniques. I don't know the exact details, but it wouldn't surprise me if hundreds or even thousands of mid- or high-ranking NSA officials there days are therefore certainly aware of the exact details of the Liberty Incident, although it probably remains unknown to 99.5% of the American public.

    Replies: @Hunsdon, @Rurik

    That would be subtlety on a level I would hope for, but not necessarily expect, from the USG. Superb! Thanks to our host’s host.

  376. @Boomstick
    @Truth

    http://www.rense.com/general32/phot.htm

    Includes many photos of aircraft wreckage inside the Pentagon. If you look long enough you can also find photos of the bodies, the APU, nose gear and so on.

    Replies: @Truth

    I got exactly this far;

    Most of the heaped scrap is unrecognizable,

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Truth

    "I got exactly this far;

    Most of the heaped scrap is unrecognizable,"

    And shit doesn't look like food. But do you doubt that it started out as food?

  377. @Ron Unz
    @Thomas O. Meehan


    I lived in New Jersey at the time of the attack and was working in law enforcement. I recall reports of Arabs celebrating on the streets of Paterson or Passaic. At this remove I can’t say I saw video of said jubilation, but it was reported and taken at face value by a very large percentage of the population...That said, I think it is possible that footage exists but is lost or being withheld.
     
    As I mentioned earlier, I find such claims *exceptionally* implausible.

    Don't forget that the Neocons had absolute and total control of a substantial portion of the local and national media at that point, plus the Giuliani Admin, and were using it to promote the tremendous domestic dangers from of Arabs/Muslims. Large numbers of totally innocent such individuals, minding their own business, were grabbed up by the police due to mass hysteria, and kept under arrest for quite a long time. As far as I'm aware, not a single one was every proven to be directly sympathetic to the terrorist attacks. In fact, some of the Neocons quickly began pressing for a mass-internment of Arabs/Muslims, much like happened with the Japanese in WWII, and to that end they began publishing books and articles saying that FDR had been totally legally and morally justified in the Japanese Internment.

    If any such video footage existed, they would have broadcast it 24/7 (unless, of course, you agree with the Jewish-activists that the American media is fanatically anti-Jewish and anti-Israel).

    At the same time the airwaves were full of footage of Palestinians openly celebrating.
     
    Although I've never never investigated it, I'm *extremely* skeptical that such alleged celebration overseas occurred in more than a small handful of cases. All that happens is that some 30-second video shot is endlessly looped over FoxNews or ABC, with voice-over explanation by the anchor, and that becomes the reality of rightwing dimwits everywhere. Indeed, the whole thing might easily have been staged.

    If Trump is delusional about the dancing arabs of Passaic, he shares that delusion with millions of fellow New York area citizens.
     
    Well, I agree with you there. And I'd bet that many, many millions of American blacks (and whites) also believe that the KKK has been burning black churches all around the country and that white racist police have been randomly killing black children everywhere for eating skittles. Or perhaps you've never heard of the Black Lives Matter movement...

    As I've said before, Trump is a totally ignorant buffoon, and given our current ideological principles, the rightful political representative of many millions of Buffoon-Americans...

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @This Is Our Home, @inertial, @Thomas O. Meehan

    I take second place to no one in abhorrence of the neocons. But, you might consider that it was FOX news, Neocon central, that broke the story of the dancing Israeli’s. They went on to spike their own story. It seems to have taken a few hours or days of reportage after the attack for the official narrative to lock in.

    “As I’ve said before, Trump is a totally ignorant buffoon, and given our current ideological principles, the rightful political representative of many millions of Buffoon-Americans…”

    No I don’t think the problem lies with our principles. We have no principles. All we have are easily manipulated sentiments. It’s the tragedy of Democracy. Who could expect good governance to result from a system representing the whims and delusions of masses of asses?

  378. @Mr. Anon
    @ben tillman

    "The PNACkers were the prime suspects, and their network extended into the government, so it’s natural to suspect some government involvement, especially in view of otherwise hard-to-explain facts like the failure of the military to intercept the hijacked planes and the government’s decision to destroy the crime scene so quickly."

    The government did not destroy the crime scene. They hauled the debris somewhere else. They do the same thing with every single airplane crash.

    And I have never understood the fixation on the fact that the government didn't shoot down the planes. It was an extraordinary event. And no matter what people - even military people do - in wargaming and exercises and the like - people don't really expect things like that to happen. If Air Force pilots had robot-like followed orders to shoot down planes full of innocent people............would that make you feel better? Would it make you feel better about the US military and government if they were quick to issue and follow orders like that?

    Replies: @ben tillman, @Ron Unz

    And I have never understood the fixation on the fact that the government didn’t shoot down the planes. It was an extraordinary event. And no matter what people – even military people do – in wargaming and exercises and the like – people don’t really expect things like that to happen. If Air Force pilots had robot-like followed orders to shoot down planes full of innocent people…………would that make you feel better?

    Intercepting and shooting down are different things. And the fact that you are unaware of the government’s explanation for the failure to intercept should tell you that you don’t know the full story — not even the full *official* story.

    The government did not destroy the crime scene. They hauled the debris somewhere else. They do the same thing with every single airplane crash.

    No, they’ve never done the same thing with any other airplane crash because there never was any airplane crash for which they could do the same thing. These crashes, taken together, were unique.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @ben tillman

    "No, they’ve never done the same thing with any other airplane crash because there never was any airplane crash for which they could do the same thing."

    You are wrong. In an accident investigation, the airplane wreckage is not pieced together where the plane crashes. They haul it away to a building somewhere to piece it together.

    Replies: @ben tillman

  379. @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz


    The Liberty Incident was probably the most serious military attack on American naval forces since WWII, resulting in over 200 dead and wounded American servicemen. The true facts were very quickly known at the time and have been endlessly confirmed since. Unless “everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up” that attack, why has it been so effectively hushed up for almost fifty years?
     
    So it is completely the opposite to 9/11 conspiracy theories, which have never been disproven because they've never been proposed - proposing a theory requires you to offer an alternative explanation. Also people talk endlessly about 9/11 stuff.

    My impression is that rightwing Internet-activists such as yourself go around endlessly claiming that the entire MSM constantly hides and “hushes up” the bad behavior of Muslims or blacks or illegal immigrants or whatever, and in quite a number of cases, you do have the facts on your side.
     
    People don't like to talk about things which they think make them sound impolite or rude. That is not even close to being the same as repeatedly lying to the public about who murdered 3000 of them, many their own family members, in the most televised event in human history.

    Steve’s often told the story of that popular Hispanic national news-anchor, who during his book-tour was badgered by Jon Stewart into finally hinting that Jews actually constituted a very powerful group in the media. He was immediately purged and totally “disappeared.”
     
    Do you have any sense of scale or perspective? Do I really have to explain to you how having the power and will to get someone fired is nothing like having it to hide a conspiracy involving millions like 9/11 would have to?

    Do you build an ark when a couple of rain drops fall?


    However, I’ve also published several major articles on the utter “unreliability” of the MSM on matters of enormous importance
     
    Again, these compare, in no way, in scale, to what you are alleging.

    You seem convinced that because you can find some lies, everything is a lie; but you can always find lies and everything is never only lies. So your thought process is essentially false. It is based on an emotional reaction as opposed to a cool balancing of the facts, which is a common problem.


    My impression is that rightwing Internet-activists such as yourself
     
    What have I said which that right wing?

    Replies: @ben tillman

    Do you have any sense of scale or perspective? Do I really have to explain to you how having the power and will to get someone fired is nothing like having it to hide a conspiracy involving millions like 9/11 would have to?

    A conspiracy involving millions? What?

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @ben tillman

    Yes, millions. Take the Western media, their families, US, Chinese, Russian and European governments and their security forces, and their families and actually you probably have 7 figures.

    All individuals with widely different interests and circumstances which have constantly changed in the intervening years and yet none have deemed it fit to come forward with information confirming your 'theory' - although I don't know why you call it one when it amounts to nothing more than saying no.

    Replies: @KA, @ben tillman, @Ron Unz

  380. @Mr. Anon
    @ben tillman

    "The PNACkers were the prime suspects, and their network extended into the government, so it’s natural to suspect some government involvement, especially in view of otherwise hard-to-explain facts like the failure of the military to intercept the hijacked planes and the government’s decision to destroy the crime scene so quickly."

    The government did not destroy the crime scene. They hauled the debris somewhere else. They do the same thing with every single airplane crash.

    And I have never understood the fixation on the fact that the government didn't shoot down the planes. It was an extraordinary event. And no matter what people - even military people do - in wargaming and exercises and the like - people don't really expect things like that to happen. If Air Force pilots had robot-like followed orders to shoot down planes full of innocent people............would that make you feel better? Would it make you feel better about the US military and government if they were quick to issue and follow orders like that?

    Replies: @ben tillman, @Ron Unz

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz

    Again he proposes nothing...the argument is half teenage solipsist and half 'we are destined to be friends to meet as your birthday is July 9 and mine is Aug 8 and 6 plus 9 equals 15 which added to 1 equals 8 plus 8' maiden aunt - the mother of all coincidence indeed!

    It is no surprise that there's huge overlap between Nostrodamus fans and 9/11 Truthers. The thought process is the same.

    As another commenter so well said. You can make just as good links of Iraq to 9/11. There were indeed many links from Iraq to the Al Qaeda plotters and even Iran to the same plotters; and this is what they emphasise on Fox News. Forgetting like Unz.com does that there are always many links because life is complicated...

    Replies: @KA, @KA

  381. @ben tillman
    @Mr. Anon


    And I have never understood the fixation on the fact that the government didn’t shoot down the planes. It was an extraordinary event. And no matter what people – even military people do – in wargaming and exercises and the like – people don’t really expect things like that to happen. If Air Force pilots had robot-like followed orders to shoot down planes full of innocent people…………would that make you feel better?
     
    Intercepting and shooting down are different things. And the fact that you are unaware of the government's explanation for the failure to intercept should tell you that you don't know the full story -- not even the full *official* story.

    The government did not destroy the crime scene. They hauled the debris somewhere else. They do the same thing with every single airplane crash.
     
    No, they've never done the same thing with any other airplane crash because there never was any airplane crash for which they could do the same thing. These crashes, taken together, were unique.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “No, they’ve never done the same thing with any other airplane crash because there never was any airplane crash for which they could do the same thing.”

    You are wrong. In an accident investigation, the airplane wreckage is not pieced together where the plane crashes. They haul it away to a building somewhere to piece it together.

    • Replies: @ben tillman
    @Mr. Anon


    You are wrong. In an accident investigation, the airplane wreckage is not pieced together where the plane crashes. They haul it away to a building somewhere to piece it together.
     
    But the issue isn't the airplane wreckage; it's the building wreckage. Very few airplane crashes involve damaged or destroyed buildings. And this was the first to involve a destroyed high-rise that was supposed to be indestructible under the circumstances.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

  382. @inertial
    @Ron Unz

    Eh, I dunno. You must recall the first days after 911, the time when President Bush went to a mosque and declared Islam to be a "Religion of Peace." I got a strong impression that our elites got genuinely scared that the unwashed masses were about to go on a anti Muslim pogrom spree. There was A LOT of that Religion of Peace propaganda coming from all over at that time, and the Neocons were very much a part of that. I don't feel like digging up links on my phone, but surely you remember why Ann Coulter was fired by National Review?

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    And the greatest allies the neo-cons had in dispelling the unease that people (naturally) have had about muslim immigration has been…………..the Truthers. By directing blame for the attacks on 9/11 away from muslims, they serve to rob anti-immigrationists of one of their best arguments against immigration.

    The fact is, the everything-is-a-false-flag crowd are among the most useful tools that globalist elites have ever had.

  383. @Truth
    @This Is Our Home

    I just showed you a photo. That makes the question quite simple; are you going to believe what you have heard or what you see. All that other shit that you are talking is, at this point, totally negligible.

    From where I sit there are three possibilities from those photos I posted:

    1. There is a plane in that picture that hit the Pentagon, and somehow, for 14 years, I have failed to see it. If this is the case, please point it out.

    2. There is no plane.

    3. There was a plane that hit the pentagon, and somehow it disappeared (which leads to 3a. Harry Blackstone or Chris Angel was in the vicinity at the time.

    4. These pictures, along with hundreds of others available have somehow been altered to remove a plane.

    Which of these is your point, or, if you have another point that I am somehow missing, feel free to share.

    BTW; this question, if you are as intelligent as you say you are.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

    There are three possibilities, but then you list four. Anyway, there is a fifth possibility: Airplanes don’t crash like they do in the movies. They don’t take three minutes to slow to a halt as they do in movies like “Cliffhanger”. They stop in the time it takes them to traverse their own length at whatever speed they impact at. They disintegrate.

    • Replies: @Truth
    @Mr. Anon

    No Mr. Anon, my good friend, I could give a speech (literally) to an audience for 45 minutes without notes, about the inconsistencies, physical, scientific, social, and aeronautical, involved in the World Trade Center "bombings." That is the level to which I have studied this event. The reason I start with the Pentagon is because it is a whole different level of absurdity. Addition before subtraction, as it were.

    A Boeing 757 is 175' long and 125' wide (wingspan) and I can post pictures of the "crash scene" that clearly "seem" to indicate an accident scene with a wall on a building is pushed backward.

    I ask one very simple question; "where is the plane?"

    I get, invariably, a series on responses that indicate that somehow the 125' wings, which should have been laying out on the lawn, somehow disintegrated in a "nuclear plasma fire" so intense that even the pentagon's own cameras couldn't capture it.

    So basically what it comes down to is that you will chose to believe either what you are told, or what you see. We don't need to go into Jews, Aye-Rabs, Mossad, false flags or anything else at this point in time.

    Now if you chose to believe the former, the next question is quite simple; "do you have any value as a sentient human being at all? or are you, as a PHD Philosophy professor that I know, would term you; "a consumer"?

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

  384. @This Is Our Home
    @Rurik


    Why don’t they just put out some of the videos that show the passenger jet hitting the Pentagon and put this all to rest. It seems more than likely that they have it, no?
     
    No. Do you guys believe that the moon landings were faked too?

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “No. Do you guys believe that the moon landings were faked too?”

    I suspect that a lot of them do.

  385. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Ron Unz
    @Mr. Anon

    FYI...

    https://www.unz.com/article/911-the-mother-of-all-coincidences/

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    Again he proposes nothing…the argument is half teenage solipsist and half ‘we are destined to be friends to meet as your birthday is July 9 and mine is Aug 8 and 6 plus 9 equals 15 which added to 1 equals 8 plus 8’ maiden aunt – the mother of all coincidence indeed!

    It is no surprise that there’s huge overlap between Nostrodamus fans and 9/11 Truthers. The thought process is the same.

    As another commenter so well said. You can make just as good links of Iraq to 9/11. There were indeed many links from Iraq to the Al Qaeda plotters and even Iran to the same plotters; and this is what they emphasise on Fox News. Forgetting like Unz.com does that there are always many links because life is complicated…

    • Replies: @KA
    @This Is Our Home

    "According to a source at Fox News Channel the president of ADL ,Araham Foxman,telephoned executives at Fox News's parent,News Corp to demand a st- down in the wake of the Cameron reportage . The source said that Foxman told the News Corp executives,
    " Look,you guys have generally been pretty fair to Israel. What are you doing putting this stuff out there ? You are killing us"
    The Fox News source continued," As good old boys will do over coffee in Manhattan,it was like ,well what we can we do about this" ?
    Finally,FoxNews said " Stop e mailing ,Stop slamming us. Stop being in our face,and well stop being in your face-by way of taking our story down off the web.
    WE WILL NOT RETRACT IT ,WE WILL NOT DISABOW IT ;WE STAND BY IT BUT WE AT LEAST TAKE IT OFF THE WEB"""
    ( emphasis is mine)
    Following this meeting ,within four days of the posting of Cameron's series on Fox News .Com ,the transcripts disappeared ,replaced by the message " This Story no longer exists"

    CHEERING MOVERS AND ART STUDENT SPIES
    WHAT DID ISRAEL KNOW IN ADVANCE OF THE 9/11 ATTACKS?
    COUNTER PUNCH 2007,3 &4 of 22 issue by CHRISTOPHER KETCHAM

    Forward ,the Jewish Magazine has covered it and has covered other Israeli involvement


    May be Foxman should challenge Countrrpunch ! What about a defamation!
    Trump should kneel down at 911 site and apologize to Americans for not knowing the truth .

    , @KA
    @This Is Our Home

    Only link I could find among Iran Iraq,and Al Qaida is the one or another varieties of the same religion.
    I guess that is good enough for the Frum to coin the term " Axis of Evil" m good enough for one judges to pass verdict of millions in damages and good enough for the Neo cons to make wars on all three and more.

  386. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @ben tillman
    @This Is Our Home


    Do you have any sense of scale or perspective? Do I really have to explain to you how having the power and will to get someone fired is nothing like having it to hide a conspiracy involving millions like 9/11 would have to?
     
    A conspiracy involving millions? What?

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    Yes, millions. Take the Western media, their families, US, Chinese, Russian and European governments and their security forces, and their families and actually you probably have 7 figures.

    All individuals with widely different interests and circumstances which have constantly changed in the intervening years and yet none have deemed it fit to come forward with information confirming your ‘theory’ – although I don’t know why you call it one when it amounts to nothing more than saying no.

    • Replies: @KA
    @This Is Our Home

    This is a comment taken from mondoweiss.net

    ""
    MRW-
    "I’ve heard about the Israeli movers’ story down through the years and never been very interested in it, it’s in s being in a gray zone of unproveable assertions.

    Unprovable assertions?

    Grant Smith secured the truth of the matter with a FOIA from the FBI. He published them, and a rebuttal to the Trump claim on Antiwar.com, on November 24, 2015.

    “Joyous Celebration” during 9/11 World Trade Center Attack

    “…five (5) Israeli nationals, detained in conjunction with the TWINBOMB investigation, had videotaped the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center and may have possessed foreknowledge of the same…”
    link to israellobby.org

    A Youtube compilation of news reports on September 11, 2001 including the woman who first saw the men beneath her apartment building celebrating the downing of the WTC thinking they were ‘Middle Eastern’ (at 4:12), and the East Rutherford NJ cop, Scott deCarlo, (at 4:31) who arrested the Israelis on the turnpike. Don’t miss minute 5:00. These are the returning Israelis explaining on Israeli TV months later, and after they were released from a Brooklyn jail and whisked home, that they had gone to NYC “to document the event”:


    You should note that the FBI’s May 3, 2012, 70-page file copy of Wayne Madsen report on “The Israeli Art Students and Movers” (in Grant Smith’s FOIA listing) contains a stunning list of names, identities, and addresses of Israelis involved in spying on the US.

    Smith’s FBI document haul total nearly 400 pages of provable “assertions.”

    Did Trump inadvertently open a hornet’s nest?

    - See more at: http://mondoweiss.net/2015/11/celebration-laughing-israelis#sthash.iq6o3QzQ.dpuf"

    , @ben tillman
    @This Is Our Home


    Yes, millions. Take the Western media, their families, US, Chinese, Russian and European governments and their security forces, and their families and actually you probably have 7 figures.
     
    You're presuming that millions of people know the truth. That's a ludicrous presumption, without which your argument fails.

    It's entirely possible that no one in the media has independent knowledge of the truth and that the media simply report what the government tells them. Whether or not the government's story is true, the media could certainly report it without having any special knowledge that would make them "in on it". And, even if some in the media thought or knew that the government's story was false or incomplete in some way, that wouldn't mean that all of them -- millions of them -- did.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    , @Ron Unz
    @This Is Our Home

    Well, as I've mentioned upthread I've never really investigated the 9/11 attacks, partly because I was so heavily involved in a (largely unsuccessful) software project during the entire decade of the 2000s. Also, so many of the heated arguments---issues of free-fall building-collapse velocities, nanothermite residues, 747 flying speeds, and such---seemed so highly technical and far beyond my limited expertise to evaluate. But the capture of all those Israeli Mossad agents in the immediate vicinity of the attacks seemed a very clear-cut datapoint, and (as I recall) was even heavily documented on the main "9/11 Conspiracy Debunking" website.

    However, one of the very nice things about this small website is that along with all the fanatics and lunatics, it also attracts lots of extremely knowledgeable commenters, and one of these just brought to my attention the following lengthy YouTube clips. Although I was too busy to watch more than a few minutes, much of the information provided seemed extremely persuasive to me, and certainly shifts my opinion a good deal. After all, if you can't believe the FBI and the top American MSM about what happened during the 9/11 attacks, whom can you believe? Anyway, I'd encourage interested readers to watch the clips, and decide for themselves what they think.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbz7Oazjz74

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QphxGBXiA-M

    Replies: @AnonymousCoward

  387. @This Is Our Home
    @Rurik

    So the US government's two great enemies are Muslims and the Branch Davidians? Were the latter an existential threat to Israel too?

    Replies: @Rurik

    So the US government’s two great enemies are Muslims and the Branch Davidians?

    when I mentioned how they machine gunned the people trying to get out of that burning building, did you secretly fanaticize that you could have been the one pulling the trigger?

    come on now Robert, be honest..

    Were the latter an existential threat to Israel too?

    as a matter of fact it was the Israeli diplomats in DC that were the most outraged at what had happened. Did you know that? They almost recalled their ambassador over the incident. Something about people dying in a real holocaust by the very definition of the word. It enraged their racial memories of government committed atrocities and their collective sense of tikkun olam. Bill Clinton almost lost all the support he’d received from Hollywood and the Jewish community because of the universal rage by the world’s Jews over what had happened. Jewish lawyer were literally fighting each other to represent the Davidian survivors for free. Massive amounts of donations came in from Jews all over the world in support of those persecuted Christians who died in that literal holocaust.

  388. @Hunsdon
    @Truth

    Truth: I'd like to apologize. I've come to regard you as a "Johnny One Note" poster, and I was wrong. I like you a lot better when you branch out from what seems to be your usual shtick. (Despite the knee-grow comment in your post immediately following.) Yeah, I know, my comment will change your life, what can I say?

    Replies: @Truth, @Mr. Anon

    Well thank you Hunsdon, although there is certainly no need to apologize. I have to quarrel with you just a bit on the rest though.

    No matter how we may come to frame it, this is, against its better wishes, a site about, dedicated to, and with the almost ‘one note’ attention to, knee-grows, and gets moreso on almost a daily basis.

    It’s a bit like Roissy, or one of the other’s ‘game’ sites; it masquerades being about women, but it is truly, unmistakably about men…

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Truth


    No matter how we may come to frame it, this is, against its better wishes, a site about, dedicated to, and with the almost ‘one note’ attention to, knee-grows, and gets moreso on almost a daily basis.
     
    You're seeing a completely different site than I am seeing. Perhaps it is just your reflection?

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

  389. @Mr. Anon
    "he said he was outside the Florida classroom when he saw the plane hit the tower and that he thought it must be a bad pilot. We all know that the second plane didn’t hit until he was well inside the classroom and reading about the pet goat. If it were the second plane then even someone as monumentally stupid as George Bush would have figured out that a second plane hitting the towers was not just a coincidence or pilot error, don’t you think?"

    There is nothing inciriminating in anything he said. Nothing you've said about this proves anything, except that you are obtuse and/or demented.

    "and just for you, I’m posting again a video of building seven falling. There are thousands upon thousands of architects and structural engineers and building engineers and demolition experts and other professionals that have put their names and reputations on the line by going public and saying that there is no way that building seven could have fallen the way it did due to office fires or any of the structural damage it suffered."

    Thousands and Thousands? I think you're exagerating. First of all - architects are irrelevant - they aren't structural engineers. Secondly, there are "thousands upon thousands" of structural and demolition engineers who believe that the buildings were destroyed just as explained in the "official story".

    "here’s a controlled demolition expert

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=877gr6xtQIc"

    Yes, here's a dutch expert, giving a cursory opinion based on the same grainy you-tube video that every "Truther" has seen, without benefit of any of the other details of the buildings collapse. That was an Iranian-state TV interview, by the way. No agenda there, I'm sure.

    "he’s since died in a car crash"

    Yes, years after that interview. But nobody dies in car crashes, do they, in less it is willed by the all-powerful conspirators.

    As I said, to stupid people like you, everything is a mystery.

    Replies: @Ron Unz, @Rurik

    As I said, to stupid people like you.

    actually I don’t need any engineers or architects or demolition experts or anyone else to tell me building seven was a controlled demolition

    it’s obvious to anyone with half a functioning brain

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Rurik

    "actually I don’t need any engineers or architects or demolition experts or anyone else to tell me building seven was a controlled demolition....."

    Right, you don't need knowledge.

    "it’s obvious to anyone with half a functioning brain."

    Well my brain is nearly fully functioning, and even only half functioning it would function better than yours, and your conclusions aren't obvious to me.

    Replies: @Rurik

  390. @This Is Our Home
    @Rurik


    it did

    in all likelihood the plane that vanished over Shanksville was intended to hit building seven, thereby providing the pretext for that building to fall. When the plane never arrived, they had to scramble for a contingency and just decided to “pull it”, and that’s why we have that smoking gun.
     
    Why would they need a contingency? The towers were hit, that's all that really mattered.

    Replies: @Rurik

    Why would they need a contingency? The towers were hit, that’s all that really mattered.

    are you really commenting on a public forum about an event as important as 911 with little or no actual knowledge of what the fuck you’re even talking about?

    building seven was not hit by a plane genius

    that’s the whole point!

  391. @Ron Unz
    @Hunsdon


    Hunsdon said: If we are discussing the USS Liberty, you are not helping your case. Ignorant, or duplicitous, hmm.
     
    Regarding the Liberty Incident, here's a nice tidbit that I may or may not have previously mentioned somewhere on this website...

    The NSA naturally has all the radio intercepts between the Israeli pilots and their military commanders, repeatedly ordering them to destroy the U.S.S. Liberty and leave no survivors (I suspect there's actually a chance that their failure was partly due to their considerable reluctance to follow such seemingly astonishing orders). Since those radio intercepts were presumably swept up along with everything in the entire region, it presumably took them at least a few weeks to separate those out and get them translated from the Hebrew. Since some of the dead on the ship were NSA people, I'd assume the NSA people back home were *quite* unhappy about what they discovered, but there wasn't much that they or their later successors could do once LBJ and their other political masters had made their decision to totally suppress and whitewash the incident.

    However, one of my old friends was Bill Odom, the three-star general who ran the NSA for Reagan, and Bill was a sharp fellow. The story I heard is that he arranged for those particular Israeli radio intercepts to be used each year in the official NSA training process given to all entering officers, in which they are given real-life examples demonstrating the effectiveness of NSA technology and techniques. I don't know the exact details, but it wouldn't surprise me if hundreds or even thousands of mid- or high-ranking NSA officials there days are therefore certainly aware of the exact details of the Liberty Incident, although it probably remains unknown to 99.5% of the American public.

    Replies: @Hunsdon, @Rurik

    (I suspect there’s actually a chance that their failure was partly due to their considerable reluctance to follow such seemingly astonishing orders).

    it’d be better if this story had a name for the pilot, but anyways

    Israeli Pilot Speaks Up

    Fifteen years after the attack, an Israeli pilot approached Liberty survivors and then held extensive interviews with former Congressman Paul N. (Pete) McCloskey about his role. According to this senior Israeli lead pilot, he recognized the Liberty as American immediately, so informed his headquarters, and was told to ignore the American flag and continue his attack. He refused to do so and returned to base, where he was arrested.

    https://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/msg107033.html

  392. @Mr. Anon
    @Truth

    There are three possibilities, but then you list four. Anyway, there is a fifth possibility: Airplanes don't crash like they do in the movies. They don't take three minutes to slow to a halt as they do in movies like "Cliffhanger". They stop in the time it takes them to traverse their own length at whatever speed they impact at. They disintegrate.

    Replies: @Truth

    No Mr. Anon, my good friend, I could give a speech (literally) to an audience for 45 minutes without notes, about the inconsistencies, physical, scientific, social, and aeronautical, involved in the World Trade Center “bombings.” That is the level to which I have studied this event. The reason I start with the Pentagon is because it is a whole different level of absurdity. Addition before subtraction, as it were.

    A Boeing 757 is 175′ long and 125′ wide (wingspan) and I can post pictures of the “crash scene” that clearly “seem” to indicate an accident scene with a wall on a building is pushed backward.

    I ask one very simple question; “where is the plane?”

    I get, invariably, a series on responses that indicate that somehow the 125′ wings, which should have been laying out on the lawn, somehow disintegrated in a “nuclear plasma fire” so intense that even the pentagon’s own cameras couldn’t capture it.

    So basically what it comes down to is that you will chose to believe either what you are told, or what you see. We don’t need to go into Jews, Aye-Rabs, Mossad, false flags or anything else at this point in time.

    Now if you chose to believe the former, the next question is quite simple; “do you have any value as a sentient human being at all? or are you, as a PHD Philosophy professor that I know, would term you; “a consumer”?

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Truth


    No Mr. Anon, my good friend, I could give a speech (literally) to an audience for 45 minutes without notes, about the inconsistencies, physical, scientific, social, and aeronautical, involved in the World Trade Center “bombings.” That is the level to which I have studied this event.
     
    !

    A Boeing 757 is 175′ long and 125′ wide (wingspan) and I can post pictures of the “crash scene” that clearly “seem” to indicate an accident scene with a wall on a building is pushed backward.
     
    If you follow the link, you can easily see how, if the plane in the picture had been going a touch faster, its wreckage would have been entirely invisible to someone outside the house; and it only hit a little house not a deep, high and massive building like the Pentagon.

    Of course, the plane was probably going relatively slowly as the pilot was trying not to crash it as opposed to trying to crash it!

    http://washington.cbslocal.com/2013/05/31/plane-crashes-into-apartment-building-near-dulles-airport/

    This took me two minutes to look up. I fear your 'noteless' 45 minute speech would not portray a flattering image of you.

    , @Mr. Anon
    @Truth

    "No Mr. Anon, my good friend,"

    Can the chumminess. I am not your friend. You are not mine. By your own admission at this site, you are not even a friend to your own son, so you are certainly not my friend.

    :I could give a speech (literally) to an audience for 45 minutes without notes, about the inconsistencies, physical, scientific, social, and aeronautical, involved in the World Trade Center “bombings.” That is the level to which I have studied this event."

    Yes, I am sure you are prepard to give lengthy speeches about any number of thing about which you know nothing. "physical, scientific,.....aeronautical,...". You know nothing about any of those things. You are a J-school grad who thinks that there are cars that can be fueled with water. Your opinions on technical matters are worthless.

    ""I ask one very simple question; “where is the plane?”"

    Simple is your speed. The plane disintegrated. It wasn't designed for the loads involved in smashing into a building (the fuselage) or the ground (the wings, after they had been sheared off).

    I believe what I see. You believe what a stupid person thinks makes them seem smart.

  393. KA [AKA "Carthage"] says:
    @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz

    Again he proposes nothing...the argument is half teenage solipsist and half 'we are destined to be friends to meet as your birthday is July 9 and mine is Aug 8 and 6 plus 9 equals 15 which added to 1 equals 8 plus 8' maiden aunt - the mother of all coincidence indeed!

    It is no surprise that there's huge overlap between Nostrodamus fans and 9/11 Truthers. The thought process is the same.

    As another commenter so well said. You can make just as good links of Iraq to 9/11. There were indeed many links from Iraq to the Al Qaeda plotters and even Iran to the same plotters; and this is what they emphasise on Fox News. Forgetting like Unz.com does that there are always many links because life is complicated...

    Replies: @KA, @KA

    “According to a source at Fox News Channel the president of ADL ,Araham Foxman,telephoned executives at Fox News’s parent,News Corp to demand a st- down in the wake of the Cameron reportage . The source said that Foxman told the News Corp executives,
    ” Look,you guys have generally been pretty fair to Israel. What are you doing putting this stuff out there ? You are killing us”
    The Fox News source continued,” As good old boys will do over coffee in Manhattan,it was like ,well what we can we do about this” ?
    Finally,FoxNews said ” Stop e mailing ,Stop slamming us. Stop being in our face,and well stop being in your face-by way of taking our story down off the web.
    WE WILL NOT RETRACT IT ,WE WILL NOT DISABOW IT ;WE STAND BY IT BUT WE AT LEAST TAKE IT OFF THE WEB”””
    ( emphasis is mine)
    Following this meeting ,within four days of the posting of Cameron’s series on Fox News .Com ,the transcripts disappeared ,replaced by the message ” This Story no longer exists”

    CHEERING MOVERS AND ART STUDENT SPIES
    WHAT DID ISRAEL KNOW IN ADVANCE OF THE 9/11 ATTACKS?
    COUNTER PUNCH 2007,3 &4 of 22 issue by CHRISTOPHER KETCHAM

    Forward ,the Jewish Magazine has covered it and has covered other Israeli involvement

    May be Foxman should challenge Countrrpunch ! What about a defamation!
    Trump should kneel down at 911 site and apologize to Americans for not knowing the truth .

  394. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Truth
    @Hunsdon

    Well thank you Hunsdon, although there is certainly no need to apologize. I have to quarrel with you just a bit on the rest though.

    No matter how we may come to frame it, this is, against its better wishes, a site about, dedicated to, and with the almost 'one note' attention to, knee-grows, and gets moreso on almost a daily basis.

    It's a bit like Roissy, or one of the other's 'game' sites; it masquerades being about women, but it is truly, unmistakably about men...

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    No matter how we may come to frame it, this is, against its better wishes, a site about, dedicated to, and with the almost ‘one note’ attention to, knee-grows, and gets moreso on almost a daily basis.

    You’re seeing a completely different site than I am seeing. Perhaps it is just your reflection?

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @This Is Our Home

    "You’re seeing a completely different site than I am seeing. Perhaps it is just your reflection?"

    Like a lot of blacks, "Truth" is almost solely interested in things black. He almost never pipes up in these threads on any topic other than blacks. So for him, this site is almost exclusively about "knee-grows". Conspiracy theories are an exception, as he imagines himself to be smart. Of course he isn't. He has said in the past that he believes that there are cars that are fueled with water. He things that Deepak Chopra is a deep thinker. He has routinely exhibited that unique blend of smugness and false erudition that is the hallmark of the incompetent.

    Replies: @Truth

  395. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Truth
    @Mr. Anon

    No Mr. Anon, my good friend, I could give a speech (literally) to an audience for 45 minutes without notes, about the inconsistencies, physical, scientific, social, and aeronautical, involved in the World Trade Center "bombings." That is the level to which I have studied this event. The reason I start with the Pentagon is because it is a whole different level of absurdity. Addition before subtraction, as it were.

    A Boeing 757 is 175' long and 125' wide (wingspan) and I can post pictures of the "crash scene" that clearly "seem" to indicate an accident scene with a wall on a building is pushed backward.

    I ask one very simple question; "where is the plane?"

    I get, invariably, a series on responses that indicate that somehow the 125' wings, which should have been laying out on the lawn, somehow disintegrated in a "nuclear plasma fire" so intense that even the pentagon's own cameras couldn't capture it.

    So basically what it comes down to is that you will chose to believe either what you are told, or what you see. We don't need to go into Jews, Aye-Rabs, Mossad, false flags or anything else at this point in time.

    Now if you chose to believe the former, the next question is quite simple; "do you have any value as a sentient human being at all? or are you, as a PHD Philosophy professor that I know, would term you; "a consumer"?

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

    No Mr. Anon, my good friend, I could give a speech (literally) to an audience for 45 minutes without notes, about the inconsistencies, physical, scientific, social, and aeronautical, involved in the World Trade Center “bombings.” That is the level to which I have studied this event.

    !

    A Boeing 757 is 175′ long and 125′ wide (wingspan) and I can post pictures of the “crash scene” that clearly “seem” to indicate an accident scene with a wall on a building is pushed backward.

    If you follow the link, you can easily see how, if the plane in the picture had been going a touch faster, its wreckage would have been entirely invisible to someone outside the house; and it only hit a little house not a deep, high and massive building like the Pentagon.

    Of course, the plane was probably going relatively slowly as the pilot was trying not to crash it as opposed to trying to crash it!

    http://washington.cbslocal.com/2013/05/31/plane-crashes-into-apartment-building-near-dulles-airport/

    This took me two minutes to look up. I fear your ‘noteless’ 45 minute speech would not portray a flattering image of you.

  396. @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz

    Again he proposes nothing...the argument is half teenage solipsist and half 'we are destined to be friends to meet as your birthday is July 9 and mine is Aug 8 and 6 plus 9 equals 15 which added to 1 equals 8 plus 8' maiden aunt - the mother of all coincidence indeed!

    It is no surprise that there's huge overlap between Nostrodamus fans and 9/11 Truthers. The thought process is the same.

    As another commenter so well said. You can make just as good links of Iraq to 9/11. There were indeed many links from Iraq to the Al Qaeda plotters and even Iran to the same plotters; and this is what they emphasise on Fox News. Forgetting like Unz.com does that there are always many links because life is complicated...

    Replies: @KA, @KA

    Only link I could find among Iran Iraq,and Al Qaida is the one or another varieties of the same religion.
    I guess that is good enough for the Frum to coin the term ” Axis of Evil” m good enough for one judges to pass verdict of millions in damages and good enough for the Neo cons to make wars on all three and more.

  397. @This Is Our Home
    @ben tillman

    Yes, millions. Take the Western media, their families, US, Chinese, Russian and European governments and their security forces, and their families and actually you probably have 7 figures.

    All individuals with widely different interests and circumstances which have constantly changed in the intervening years and yet none have deemed it fit to come forward with information confirming your 'theory' - although I don't know why you call it one when it amounts to nothing more than saying no.

    Replies: @KA, @ben tillman, @Ron Unz

    This is a comment taken from mondoweiss.net

    “”
    MRW-
    “I’ve heard about the Israeli movers’ story down through the years and never been very interested in it, it’s in s being in a gray zone of unproveable assertions.

    Unprovable assertions?

    Grant Smith secured the truth of the matter with a FOIA from the FBI. He published them, and a rebuttal to the Trump claim on Antiwar.com, on November 24, 2015.

    “Joyous Celebration” during 9/11 World Trade Center Attack

    “…five (5) Israeli nationals, detained in conjunction with the TWINBOMB investigation, had videotaped the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center and may have possessed foreknowledge of the same…”
    link to israellobby.org

    A Youtube compilation of news reports on September 11, 2001 including the woman who first saw the men beneath her apartment building celebrating the downing of the WTC thinking they were ‘Middle Eastern’ (at 4:12), and the East Rutherford NJ cop, Scott deCarlo, (at 4:31) who arrested the Israelis on the turnpike. Don’t miss minute 5:00. These are the returning Israelis explaining on Israeli TV months later, and after they were released from a Brooklyn jail and whisked home, that they had gone to NYC “to document the event”:

    You should note that the FBI’s May 3, 2012, 70-page file copy of Wayne Madsen report on “The Israeli Art Students and Movers” (in Grant Smith’s FOIA listing) contains a stunning list of names, identities, and addresses of Israelis involved in spying on the US.

    Smith’s FBI document haul total nearly 400 pages of provable “assertions.”

    Did Trump inadvertently open a hornet’s nest?

    – See more at: http://mondoweiss.net/2015/11/celebration-laughing-israelis#sthash.iq6o3QzQ.dpuf”

  398. @This Is Our Home
    @ben tillman

    Yes, millions. Take the Western media, their families, US, Chinese, Russian and European governments and their security forces, and their families and actually you probably have 7 figures.

    All individuals with widely different interests and circumstances which have constantly changed in the intervening years and yet none have deemed it fit to come forward with information confirming your 'theory' - although I don't know why you call it one when it amounts to nothing more than saying no.

    Replies: @KA, @ben tillman, @Ron Unz

    Yes, millions. Take the Western media, their families, US, Chinese, Russian and European governments and their security forces, and their families and actually you probably have 7 figures.

    You’re presuming that millions of people know the truth. That’s a ludicrous presumption, without which your argument fails.

    It’s entirely possible that no one in the media has independent knowledge of the truth and that the media simply report what the government tells them. Whether or not the government’s story is true, the media could certainly report it without having any special knowledge that would make them “in on it”. And, even if some in the media thought or knew that the government’s story was false or incomplete in some way, that wouldn’t mean that all of them — millions of them — did.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @ben tillman


    You’re presuming that millions of people know the truth. That’s a ludicrous presumption, without which your argument fails.

    It’s entirely possible that no one in the media has independent knowledge of the truth and that the media simply report what the government tells them. Whether or not the government’s story is true, the media could certainly report it without having any special knowledge that would make them “in on it”. And, even if some in the media thought or knew that the government’s story was false or incomplete in some way, that wouldn’t mean that all of them — millions of them — did
     
    Ah yes because the media were so GWB friendly that they'd simply report what he told them, no questions asked. What world do you live in?

    Replies: @ben tillman

  399. @Mr. Anon
    @ben tillman

    "No, they’ve never done the same thing with any other airplane crash because there never was any airplane crash for which they could do the same thing."

    You are wrong. In an accident investigation, the airplane wreckage is not pieced together where the plane crashes. They haul it away to a building somewhere to piece it together.

    Replies: @ben tillman

    You are wrong. In an accident investigation, the airplane wreckage is not pieced together where the plane crashes. They haul it away to a building somewhere to piece it together.

    But the issue isn’t the airplane wreckage; it’s the building wreckage. Very few airplane crashes involve damaged or destroyed buildings. And this was the first to involve a destroyed high-rise that was supposed to be indestructible under the circumstances.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @ben tillman

    "And this was the first to involve a destroyed high-rise that was supposed to be indestructible under the circumstances."

    It was not supposed to be "indestructible". No building is. Nothing is.

    Replies: @ben tillman

  400. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:

    I wish the truth lot would get their stories straight. I suppose it is very difficult when they can’t be bothered to even come up with a story.

    For example, was the Pentagon hit with a missile to cover the fact that United 93 went down in a field or was WTC7 rigged with explosives because that plane was supposed to hit it?

    Enquiring minds needs to know!

    Furthermore, if Israel was behind it and not Al Qaeda, what did they hope to achieve? Did they hope to achieve the invasion of Iraq or the suppression of the Palestinians?

    I imagine that their main aim would be the latter, but then why not frame a Palestinian group instead of one based in the Hindu Kush?

    And if the merely coincidental links between Saddam and Al Qaeda somehow prove that the whole thing was a frame-up to get Saddam, why did they not frame a terrorist group with better links with him? There were many! Indeed, why on earth would they invade Afghanistan first?

    It is all very fun to pretend to be an expert because you can obsess over the ways in which the account of an event has inconsistencies, every account for every event does, but as soon as you try to apply your soi disant expertise to actually explain anything you will quickly find that it is not expertise at all, it is just lacking perspective.

    Anyone who proposes that the normal account of 9/11 is mostly false needs to propose a more plausible alternative, and yet no-one ever does! They won’t! Why?

    • Replies: @vinteuil
    @This Is Our Home

    Thanks, Robert Rediger, for your calm & reasonable comments. I hope you draw strength from the fact that the dunces are all in league against you.

  401. @This Is Our Home
    @ben tillman

    Yes, millions. Take the Western media, their families, US, Chinese, Russian and European governments and their security forces, and their families and actually you probably have 7 figures.

    All individuals with widely different interests and circumstances which have constantly changed in the intervening years and yet none have deemed it fit to come forward with information confirming your 'theory' - although I don't know why you call it one when it amounts to nothing more than saying no.

    Replies: @KA, @ben tillman, @Ron Unz

    Well, as I’ve mentioned upthread I’ve never really investigated the 9/11 attacks, partly because I was so heavily involved in a (largely unsuccessful) software project during the entire decade of the 2000s. Also, so many of the heated arguments—issues of free-fall building-collapse velocities, nanothermite residues, 747 flying speeds, and such—seemed so highly technical and far beyond my limited expertise to evaluate. But the capture of all those Israeli Mossad agents in the immediate vicinity of the attacks seemed a very clear-cut datapoint, and (as I recall) was even heavily documented on the main “9/11 Conspiracy Debunking” website.

    However, one of the very nice things about this small website is that along with all the fanatics and lunatics, it also attracts lots of extremely knowledgeable commenters, and one of these just brought to my attention the following lengthy YouTube clips. Although I was too busy to watch more than a few minutes, much of the information provided seemed extremely persuasive to me, and certainly shifts my opinion a good deal. After all, if you can’t believe the FBI and the top American MSM about what happened during the 9/11 attacks, whom can you believe? Anyway, I’d encourage interested readers to watch the clips, and decide for themselves what they think.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbz7Oazjz74

    Video Link

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QphxGBXiA-M
    Video Link

    • Replies: @AnonymousCoward
    @Ron Unz

    Thanks Ron,

    The author of the videos is an occasional reader of the site, and friend of David Cole from Vdare. Let me know if you'd like me to hook you up with him.

  402. @BobX
    Perhaps not thousands but I think there were some celebrating.



    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W5BtQgTGOI4

    Replies: @Ron Unz

    Perhaps not thousands but I think there were some celebrating.

    Well, just out of curiosity, I decided to watch your YouTube clip, showing a special CNN report on “Homegrown Hate” which documented those “fanatic hate-filled American Muslims” who were celebrating the attacks. Sure, enough, they were there and interviewed, two of them, preaching outside a large NYC Mosque whose leadership was very unhappy about their presence, disagreed with them 100%, and hoped they would go away. Well, I think you can find two people to advocate almost anything in a big city like NYC.

    But the story is even more intriguing than that. Those two Muslims boldly call for the killing of American servicemen, say that Osama bin Laden is the perfect Muslim and their spiritual leader, and demand that Israel should be nuked off the face of the map. They were quite articulate (in a hate-filled way) and the reporters noted they seemed legally expert in knowing exactly what they could and could not say under First Amendment protections. As a minor aside, the journalists also mentioned the curious detail that both “Muslims” were actually Jews who’d converted to Islam, and (presumably with the zeal of the convert) decided to become fanatic pro-terrorist Muslims, willing and able to spend all their time outside a leading NYC mosque advocating terrorism and praising Osama bin Laden, except for the their visits to the CNN offices. Their distinctive New York Jewish accents seemed to have a clear Brooklyn tinge to me.

    Something tells me that both of them may have recently become fanatic Donald Trump supporters, and will give CNN interviews explaining that they support The Donald because they’re 100% convinced that he plans to set up concentration camps for all American Jews, blacks, and homosexuals the moment he gets into office.

    Ha, ha, ha….

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @Ron Unz

    One was a convert from Judaism. The other members of the group were not. They often had no idea how to stay within the law as they had some pretty serious brushes with the law, including one of them going to prison for 25 years!

    The wikipedia page is pretty detailed..

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_Muslim

  403. @Martin
    Trump's Twitter account posted this link:

    Credible Source on 9-11 Muslim Celebrations: FBI

    http://wkrg.com/2015/11/25/credible-source-on-9-11-muslim-celebrations-fbi

    One retired FBI agent says Donald Trump’s claims of seeing Muslim celebrations following the attacks on 9-11 are absolutely plausible.

    Jim Burkett was an assistant special agent in charge with the FBI’s office in Boston during 9-11 and afterward. He says during that time the office received tons of phone calls from people who feared more attacks and others reporting suspicious activity.

     


    Many of those calls, said Burkett, came from concerned and angry Americans reporting Muslim’s celebrating over the destruction of the twin towers and damage to the Pentagon. The calls were logged, reports were made and there were “stacks and stacks” of them, he said.
     

    But the retired agent says even though video of celebrations following 9-11 is hard to find, he says it means Trump’s claims are highly plausible.
     

    Replies: @Anonymous

    Actually, what’s really funny is that Trump tweeted a link to the Infowars site to support his contention about the 9/11 Muslim celebration, especially in light of what this comment thread has developed into. Infowars is probably the most popular and prominent 9/11 Truth conspiracy website.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Anonymous

    "Infowars is probably the most popular and prominent 9/11 Truth conspiracy website."

    And a lot of "truthers" believe that Infowars is a disinfo site and that Alex Jones is an NWO stooge.

    People who will believe anything will indeed believe anything.

  404. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @Ron Unz
    @BobX


    Perhaps not thousands but I think there were some celebrating.
     
    Well, just out of curiosity, I decided to watch your YouTube clip, showing a special CNN report on "Homegrown Hate" which documented those "fanatic hate-filled American Muslims" who were celebrating the attacks. Sure, enough, they were there and interviewed, two of them, preaching outside a large NYC Mosque whose leadership was very unhappy about their presence, disagreed with them 100%, and hoped they would go away. Well, I think you can find two people to advocate almost anything in a big city like NYC.

    But the story is even more intriguing than that. Those two Muslims boldly call for the killing of American servicemen, say that Osama bin Laden is the perfect Muslim and their spiritual leader, and demand that Israel should be nuked off the face of the map. They were quite articulate (in a hate-filled way) and the reporters noted they seemed legally expert in knowing exactly what they could and could not say under First Amendment protections. As a minor aside, the journalists also mentioned the curious detail that both "Muslims" were actually Jews who'd converted to Islam, and (presumably with the zeal of the convert) decided to become fanatic pro-terrorist Muslims, willing and able to spend all their time outside a leading NYC mosque advocating terrorism and praising Osama bin Laden, except for the their visits to the CNN offices. Their distinctive New York Jewish accents seemed to have a clear Brooklyn tinge to me.

    Something tells me that both of them may have recently become fanatic Donald Trump supporters, and will give CNN interviews explaining that they support The Donald because they're 100% convinced that he plans to set up concentration camps for all American Jews, blacks, and homosexuals the moment he gets into office.

    Ha, ha, ha....

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    One was a convert from Judaism. The other members of the group were not. They often had no idea how to stay within the law as they had some pretty serious brushes with the law, including one of them going to prison for 25 years!

    The wikipedia page is pretty detailed..

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_Muslim

  405. @ben tillman
    @Mr. Anon


    You are wrong. In an accident investigation, the airplane wreckage is not pieced together where the plane crashes. They haul it away to a building somewhere to piece it together.
     
    But the issue isn't the airplane wreckage; it's the building wreckage. Very few airplane crashes involve damaged or destroyed buildings. And this was the first to involve a destroyed high-rise that was supposed to be indestructible under the circumstances.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “And this was the first to involve a destroyed high-rise that was supposed to be indestructible under the circumstances.”

    It was not supposed to be “indestructible”. No building is. Nothing is.

    • Replies: @ben tillman
    @Mr. Anon


    It was not supposed to be “indestructible”. No building is. Nothing is.
     
    You misquoted me, and you know it. It was "indestructible under the circumstances", which means "when hit by a jet airliner".

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

  406. @This Is Our Home
    @Truth


    No matter how we may come to frame it, this is, against its better wishes, a site about, dedicated to, and with the almost ‘one note’ attention to, knee-grows, and gets moreso on almost a daily basis.
     
    You're seeing a completely different site than I am seeing. Perhaps it is just your reflection?

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “You’re seeing a completely different site than I am seeing. Perhaps it is just your reflection?”

    Like a lot of blacks, “Truth” is almost solely interested in things black. He almost never pipes up in these threads on any topic other than blacks. So for him, this site is almost exclusively about “knee-grows”. Conspiracy theories are an exception, as he imagines himself to be smart. Of course he isn’t. He has said in the past that he believes that there are cars that are fueled with water. He things that Deepak Chopra is a deep thinker. He has routinely exhibited that unique blend of smugness and false erudition that is the hallmark of the incompetent.

    • Replies: @Truth
    @Mr. Anon

    Wait a minute Bro, someone earlier gave me the highest possible compliment on the planet earth (and he wasn't the first) in saying that you and I thought alike.

    How do you explain that one, Grasshopper?

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

  407. @Truth
    @Mr. Anon

    No Mr. Anon, my good friend, I could give a speech (literally) to an audience for 45 minutes without notes, about the inconsistencies, physical, scientific, social, and aeronautical, involved in the World Trade Center "bombings." That is the level to which I have studied this event. The reason I start with the Pentagon is because it is a whole different level of absurdity. Addition before subtraction, as it were.

    A Boeing 757 is 175' long and 125' wide (wingspan) and I can post pictures of the "crash scene" that clearly "seem" to indicate an accident scene with a wall on a building is pushed backward.

    I ask one very simple question; "where is the plane?"

    I get, invariably, a series on responses that indicate that somehow the 125' wings, which should have been laying out on the lawn, somehow disintegrated in a "nuclear plasma fire" so intense that even the pentagon's own cameras couldn't capture it.

    So basically what it comes down to is that you will chose to believe either what you are told, or what you see. We don't need to go into Jews, Aye-Rabs, Mossad, false flags or anything else at this point in time.

    Now if you chose to believe the former, the next question is quite simple; "do you have any value as a sentient human being at all? or are you, as a PHD Philosophy professor that I know, would term you; "a consumer"?

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

    “No Mr. Anon, my good friend,”

    Can the chumminess. I am not your friend. You are not mine. By your own admission at this site, you are not even a friend to your own son, so you are certainly not my friend.

    :I could give a speech (literally) to an audience for 45 minutes without notes, about the inconsistencies, physical, scientific, social, and aeronautical, involved in the World Trade Center “bombings.” That is the level to which I have studied this event.”

    Yes, I am sure you are prepard to give lengthy speeches about any number of thing about which you know nothing. “physical, scientific,…..aeronautical,…”. You know nothing about any of those things. You are a J-school grad who thinks that there are cars that can be fueled with water. Your opinions on technical matters are worthless.

    “”I ask one very simple question; “where is the plane?””

    Simple is your speed. The plane disintegrated. It wasn’t designed for the loads involved in smashing into a building (the fuselage) or the ground (the wings, after they had been sheared off).

    I believe what I see. You believe what a stupid person thinks makes them seem smart.

  408. @Rurik
    @Mr. Anon


    As I said, to stupid people like you.
     
    actually I don't need any engineers or architects or demolition experts or anyone else to tell me building seven was a controlled demolition

    it's obvious to anyone with half a functioning brain

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “actually I don’t need any engineers or architects or demolition experts or anyone else to tell me building seven was a controlled demolition…..”

    Right, you don’t need knowledge.

    “it’s obvious to anyone with half a functioning brain.”

    Well my brain is nearly fully functioning, and even only half functioning it would function better than yours, and your conclusions aren’t obvious to me.

    • Replies: @Rurik
    @Mr. Anon

    demolition experts or anyone else to tell me building seven was a controlled demolition…..”

    here's the building going down that is obviously a controlled demolition

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mamvq7LWqRU

    it's a modern 47 story steel frame building

    these building are built to withstand jet plane impacts and earthquakes and to stand for hundreds of years

    they don't just plop into their basement when there's an office fire

    it's impossible

    steel doesn't just give out completely and vaporize magically into ether because some beams got a little hot. If they did, then they wouldn't build them like that. Just try to think, try! If steel frame high rises were in jeopardy of falling down every time there was an office fire, the whole world would be demanding that they be reinforced and built differently and all the existing ones either removed or completely reengineered so this doesn't happened and people are crushed in collapsing buildings all over the place.

    But none of this had been done. People everybody with half a functioning brain knows and can see from the videos that this building was brought down in an obvious controlled demolition.

    so, if you have at least half a brain that is functioning, and you still can't see the obvious, then what is possible is that you're not too stupid to see the obvious, but rather that you're lying. That is always a possibility. Certainly all the official experts pretending that building seven fell because of the office fires are lying for money or some other agenda. Obviously that could be the case with you too. Huh?

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

  409. @tanabear
    @Mr. Anon

    People use the monikers "conspiracy theorist", "kook", or "tinfoil hat wearers" to refer to 9/11 truth seekers so they can deflect from the fact that they have no real arguments for the government's case. What does the 9/11 Truth Movement actually believe? They believe that explosive charges can blow things up. They believe that demolition chargers can be used to bring down steel-framed high-rises. This is not a controversial position. This is routinely how steel-framed buildings are destroyed. It only becomes "kooky" if you believe this is what happened on 9/11. People defending the official narrative are making claims that have no scientific basis. Have any of their claims been subjected to the experimental method? Can we witness a crush-down, crush-up, momentum transfer at free-fall acceleration, inward of the perimeter columns due to the catenary action of the sagging floor trusses, a steel-framed high-rise being demolished with fire, instead of explosives? No, none of this has been replicated. So instead of saying that I'm a kook, you can just demonstrate that the 9/11 truth seekers are wrong. It should be simple if the government's account is rock solid.

    In short, 9/11 truth seekers believe that the noon-day sky is blue, that water will wet you and fire will burn; that explosives can blow stuff up. And that all this was also true on 09/11/2001.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    People defending the “official narrative” as you style it have far more scientific basis than you do.

    For example, it has long been known that fires can bring down steel framed buildings. That is why the designers take such precautions to avoid fires and extinguish them quickly. That is why they routinely put fire proofing on the girders. So tell us, why do they put insulation on the girders, if it is impossible for the girders to be effected by fire? I mean – they are made of steel, aren’t they? They won’t burn under any imaginable set of circumstances. So why do it?

    And anyway, what technical training do you have? What is your particular area of expertise? Why should I give a damn about your opinion?

  410. @tbraton
    @Thin-Skinned Masta-Beta

    But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers. I'm generally not one who subscribes to conspiracy theories, but, when faced with such disturbing, inexplicable facts, one has to conclude that we don't have the entire story.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon, @tanabear, @Mr. Anon

    “But then there is the very disturbing fact that, in addition to the Twin Towers, which were hit by the two airliners, World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers.”

    WTC was directly adjacent to the collapsing WTC 1; it was hosed down by debris. It also burned for the better part of the day, and not little fires either. Take a look at these pictures, which the “Truther” crowd never talks about., as they do not fit their narrative.

    WTC 7 Fires

  411. @This Is Our Home
    I wish the truth lot would get their stories straight. I suppose it is very difficult when they can't be bothered to even come up with a story.

    For example, was the Pentagon hit with a missile to cover the fact that United 93 went down in a field or was WTC7 rigged with explosives because that plane was supposed to hit it?

    Enquiring minds needs to know!

    Furthermore, if Israel was behind it and not Al Qaeda, what did they hope to achieve? Did they hope to achieve the invasion of Iraq or the suppression of the Palestinians?

    I imagine that their main aim would be the latter, but then why not frame a Palestinian group instead of one based in the Hindu Kush?

    And if the merely coincidental links between Saddam and Al Qaeda somehow prove that the whole thing was a frame-up to get Saddam, why did they not frame a terrorist group with better links with him? There were many! Indeed, why on earth would they invade Afghanistan first?

    It is all very fun to pretend to be an expert because you can obsess over the ways in which the account of an event has inconsistencies, every account for every event does, but as soon as you try to apply your soi disant expertise to actually explain anything you will quickly find that it is not expertise at all, it is just lacking perspective.

    Anyone who proposes that the normal account of 9/11 is mostly false needs to propose a more plausible alternative, and yet no-one ever does! They won't! Why?

    Replies: @vinteuil

    Thanks, Robert Rediger, for your calm & reasonable comments. I hope you draw strength from the fact that the dunces are all in league against you.

  412. @tanabear
    @tbraton

    tbraton: "World Trade Center Building #7, which was definitely not hit by any airliner, completely collapsed in nearly identical fashion as the Twin Towers..."

    It wasn't entirely identical. The North and South towers were destroyed top-down. Word Trade Tower 7 was more of a conventional looking demolition; but still a masterpiece of demolition science.

    The phrase "conspiracy theory" is just used as an ad hominem. What explanation best fits the available evidence? It certainly isn't the official account.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Mr. Anon

    “The phrase “conspiracy theory” is just used as an ad hominem.”

    Spare us your “ad hominem” bullshit. I bet that you are quite cool with the concept of ad hominem, as long as the hominem in question is a Jew.

  413. @Truth
    @Boomstick

    I got exactly this far;




    Most of the heaped scrap is unrecognizable,
     

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “I got exactly this far;

    Most of the heaped scrap is unrecognizable,”

    And shit doesn’t look like food. But do you doubt that it started out as food?

  414. Ron Unz’s comments on this thread have been quite an eye-opener, for me.

    If I were Steve Sailer, or Jayman, or Razib Khan, I’d be looking for a new sugar daddy, ASAP.

    Unz isn’t quite as rich as George Soros or Carlos Slim, but he’s just as self-interested, and just as untrustworthy.

    • Agree: This Is Our Home
    • Replies: @ben tillman
    @vinteuil


    Ron Unz’s comments on this thread have been quite an eye-opener, for me.
     
    I should hope so. The faculty of critical thinking would do you some good.
  415. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @ben tillman
    @This Is Our Home


    Yes, millions. Take the Western media, their families, US, Chinese, Russian and European governments and their security forces, and their families and actually you probably have 7 figures.
     
    You're presuming that millions of people know the truth. That's a ludicrous presumption, without which your argument fails.

    It's entirely possible that no one in the media has independent knowledge of the truth and that the media simply report what the government tells them. Whether or not the government's story is true, the media could certainly report it without having any special knowledge that would make them "in on it". And, even if some in the media thought or knew that the government's story was false or incomplete in some way, that wouldn't mean that all of them -- millions of them -- did.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    You’re presuming that millions of people know the truth. That’s a ludicrous presumption, without which your argument fails.

    It’s entirely possible that no one in the media has independent knowledge of the truth and that the media simply report what the government tells them. Whether or not the government’s story is true, the media could certainly report it without having any special knowledge that would make them “in on it”. And, even if some in the media thought or knew that the government’s story was false or incomplete in some way, that wouldn’t mean that all of them — millions of them — did

    Ah yes because the media were so GWB friendly that they’d simply report what he told them, no questions asked. What world do you live in?

    • Replies: @ben tillman
    @This Is Our Home


    Ah yes because the media were so GWB friendly that they’d simply report what he told them, no questions asked. What world do you live in?
     
    The real world.

    I didn't even say the media reported what the government said. I just said they *could* do so, and it wouldn't require them to know whether it was true or false. Your bad faith is palpable.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

  416. @Anonymous
    @Martin

    Actually, what's really funny is that Trump tweeted a link to the Infowars site to support his contention about the 9/11 Muslim celebration, especially in light of what this comment thread has developed into. Infowars is probably the most popular and prominent 9/11 Truth conspiracy website.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “Infowars is probably the most popular and prominent 9/11 Truth conspiracy website.”

    And a lot of “truthers” believe that Infowars is a disinfo site and that Alex Jones is an NWO stooge.

    People who will believe anything will indeed believe anything.

  417. @This Is Our Home
    @ben tillman


    You’re presuming that millions of people know the truth. That’s a ludicrous presumption, without which your argument fails.

    It’s entirely possible that no one in the media has independent knowledge of the truth and that the media simply report what the government tells them. Whether or not the government’s story is true, the media could certainly report it without having any special knowledge that would make them “in on it”. And, even if some in the media thought or knew that the government’s story was false or incomplete in some way, that wouldn’t mean that all of them — millions of them — did
     
    Ah yes because the media were so GWB friendly that they'd simply report what he told them, no questions asked. What world do you live in?

    Replies: @ben tillman

    Ah yes because the media were so GWB friendly that they’d simply report what he told them, no questions asked. What world do you live in?

    The real world.

    I didn’t even say the media reported what the government said. I just said they *could* do so, and it wouldn’t require them to know whether it was true or false. Your bad faith is palpable.

    • Replies: @This Is Our Home
    @ben tillman


    The real world.

    I didn’t even say the media reported what the government said. I just said they *could* do so, and it wouldn’t require them to know whether it was true or false
     
    Using 'could' in the 'it is just about not impossible' sense, when constructing argument, is something we find precocious and intelligent in young children.

    Replies: @ben tillman

  418. @Mr. Anon
    @ben tillman

    "And this was the first to involve a destroyed high-rise that was supposed to be indestructible under the circumstances."

    It was not supposed to be "indestructible". No building is. Nothing is.

    Replies: @ben tillman

    It was not supposed to be “indestructible”. No building is. Nothing is.

    You misquoted me, and you know it. It was “indestructible under the circumstances”, which means “when hit by a jet airliner”.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @ben tillman

    "You misquoted me, and you know it. It was “indestructible under the circumstances”, which means “when hit by a jet airliner”."

    I didn't miquote you. You don't understand the design criteria of the World Trade Center towers. They were designed to withstand impact by a 707 landing at Kennedy. You know what that means?

    Not much.

    Nobody in the late 1960s could really design a building to absolutely withstand an impact. They could say it would. But in the absence of testing (and obviously there was no testing), nobody would really know. They barely had finite-element codes to calculate things like that then, and they were not very sophisticated.

    And in any event, a 707 at landing speed (maybe 16o mph) and low on fuel is a lot different than a 767 at 500 mph 1/2 to 3/4 laden with fuel.

  419. @vinteuil
    Ron Unz's comments on this thread have been quite an eye-opener, for me.

    If I were Steve Sailer, or Jayman, or Razib Khan, I'd be looking for a new sugar daddy, ASAP.

    Unz isn't quite as rich as George Soros or Carlos Slim, but he's just as self-interested, and just as untrustworthy.

    Replies: @ben tillman

    Ron Unz’s comments on this thread have been quite an eye-opener, for me.

    I should hope so. The faculty of critical thinking would do you some good.

  420. @ben tillman
    @Mr. Anon


    It was not supposed to be “indestructible”. No building is. Nothing is.
     
    You misquoted me, and you know it. It was "indestructible under the circumstances", which means "when hit by a jet airliner".

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “You misquoted me, and you know it. It was “indestructible under the circumstances”, which means “when hit by a jet airliner”.”

    I didn’t miquote you. You don’t understand the design criteria of the World Trade Center towers. They were designed to withstand impact by a 707 landing at Kennedy. You know what that means?

    Not much.

    Nobody in the late 1960s could really design a building to absolutely withstand an impact. They could say it would. But in the absence of testing (and obviously there was no testing), nobody would really know. They barely had finite-element codes to calculate things like that then, and they were not very sophisticated.

    And in any event, a 707 at landing speed (maybe 16o mph) and low on fuel is a lot different than a 767 at 500 mph 1/2 to 3/4 laden with fuel.

  421. @Mr. Anon
    @This Is Our Home

    "You’re seeing a completely different site than I am seeing. Perhaps it is just your reflection?"

    Like a lot of blacks, "Truth" is almost solely interested in things black. He almost never pipes up in these threads on any topic other than blacks. So for him, this site is almost exclusively about "knee-grows". Conspiracy theories are an exception, as he imagines himself to be smart. Of course he isn't. He has said in the past that he believes that there are cars that are fueled with water. He things that Deepak Chopra is a deep thinker. He has routinely exhibited that unique blend of smugness and false erudition that is the hallmark of the incompetent.

    Replies: @Truth

    Wait a minute Bro, someone earlier gave me the highest possible compliment on the planet earth (and he wasn’t the first) in saying that you and I thought alike.

    How do you explain that one, Grasshopper?

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Truth

    "Wait a minute Bro, someone earlier gave me the highest possible compliment on the planet earth (and he wasn’t the first) in saying that you and I thought alike.

    How do you explain that one, Grasshopper?":

    Well shitbird, it's a lie (if that's the right word for someone like you, who doesn't even know what the truth is). Nobody said that.

  422. And shit doesn’t look like food. But do you doubt that it started out as food?

    Oh, thanks for clearing that up, now I get it.

    So if you can’t show me the plane, show me the Jolly Green Giant who ingested it.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Truth

    ""And shit doesn’t look like food. But do you doubt that it started out as food?""

    "Oh, thanks for clearing that up, now I get it."

    Good. Maybe someday you'll be able to distinguish it from shineola too.

    Replies: @Truth

  423. This Is Our Home [AKA "Robert Rediger"] says:
    @ben tillman
    @This Is Our Home


    Ah yes because the media were so GWB friendly that they’d simply report what he told them, no questions asked. What world do you live in?
     
    The real world.

    I didn't even say the media reported what the government said. I just said they *could* do so, and it wouldn't require them to know whether it was true or false. Your bad faith is palpable.

    Replies: @This Is Our Home

    The real world.

    I didn’t even say the media reported what the government said. I just said they *could* do so, and it wouldn’t require them to know whether it was true or false

    Using ‘could’ in the ‘it is just about not impossible’ sense, when constructing argument, is something we find precocious and intelligent in young children.

    • Replies: @ben tillman
    @This Is Our Home


    Using ‘could’ in the ‘it is just about not impossible’ sense, when constructing argument, is something we find precocious and intelligent in young children.
     
    Thanks for sharing that, apropos of nothing! It does say a lot about your own character and intelligence, however.
  424. @Mr. Anon
    @Rurik

    "actually I don’t need any engineers or architects or demolition experts or anyone else to tell me building seven was a controlled demolition....."

    Right, you don't need knowledge.

    "it’s obvious to anyone with half a functioning brain."

    Well my brain is nearly fully functioning, and even only half functioning it would function better than yours, and your conclusions aren't obvious to me.

    Replies: @Rurik

    demolition experts or anyone else to tell me building seven was a controlled demolition…..”

    here’s the building going down that is obviously a controlled demolition

    it’s a modern 47 story steel frame building

    these building are built to withstand jet plane impacts and earthquakes and to stand for hundreds of years

    they don’t just plop into their basement when there’s an office fire

    it’s impossible

    steel doesn’t just give out completely and vaporize magically into ether because some beams got a little hot. If they did, then they wouldn’t build them like that. Just try to think, try! If steel frame high rises were in jeopardy of falling down every time there was an office fire, the whole world would be demanding that they be reinforced and built differently and all the existing ones either removed or completely reengineered so this doesn’t happened and people are crushed in collapsing buildings all over the place.

    But none of this had been done. People everybody with half a functioning brain knows and can see from the videos that this building was brought down in an obvious controlled demolition.

    so, if you have at least half a brain that is functioning, and you still can’t see the obvious, then what is possible is that you’re not too stupid to see the obvious, but rather that you’re lying. That is always a possibility. Certainly all the official experts pretending that building seven fell because of the office fires are lying for money or some other agenda. Obviously that could be the case with you too. Huh?

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Rurik

    "steel doesn’t just give out completely and vaporize magically into ether because some beams got a little hot. If they did, then they wouldn’t build them like that."

    Nobody says they vaporize, you witless boob. Steel loses it's strength when heated enough.

    "Just try to think, try! If steel frame high rises were in jeopardy of falling down every time there was an office fire, the whole world would be demanding that they be reinforced and built differently and all the existing ones either removed or completely reengineered so this doesn’t happened and people are crushed in collapsing buildings all over the place."

    Why do you think they insulate the steel then? They do so in case there is a fire - to keep it cool until the fire can be extinguised. Which, for most skyscraper fires is pretty quick. But in unusual circumstances - like when a massive fire burns for a long time (as with WTC7) or when the insulation is scoured off the beams by flying shrapnel (WTC1&2) and then a massive fire burns for an hour or so, the structure can fail.

    I noticed that you ignored the pictures I posted (or rather, the link thereto) of just how massive the fires in WTC7 were. That is typical of deranged paranoids - ask for evidence, then - when it is given - ignore it and move to the next spurious point.

    You spout off like an idiot, knowing nothing about anything, and indeed apparently not even having any common sense. Go back to whatever rock you crawled out from under and howl at the world there.

  425. @Truth
    @Mr. Anon

    Wait a minute Bro, someone earlier gave me the highest possible compliment on the planet earth (and he wasn't the first) in saying that you and I thought alike.

    How do you explain that one, Grasshopper?

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “Wait a minute Bro, someone earlier gave me the highest possible compliment on the planet earth (and he wasn’t the first) in saying that you and I thought alike.

    How do you explain that one, Grasshopper?”:

    Well shitbird, it’s a lie (if that’s the right word for someone like you, who doesn’t even know what the truth is). Nobody said that.

  426. @Truth

    And shit doesn’t look like food. But do you doubt that it started out as food?
     
    Oh, thanks for clearing that up, now I get it.

    So if you can't show me the plane, show me the Jolly Green Giant who ingested it.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “”And shit doesn’t look like food. But do you doubt that it started out as food?””

    “Oh, thanks for clearing that up, now I get it.”

    Good. Maybe someday you’ll be able to distinguish it from shineola too.

    • Replies: @Truth
    @Mr. Anon




    Good. Maybe someday you’ll be able to distinguish it from shineola too.
     
    That's a cute one, Ya Big Sexy Studd!

    Hey was like 8 when that movie came out, I forgot you're such and old fart.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

  427. @Ron Unz
    @This Is Our Home

    Well, as I've mentioned upthread I've never really investigated the 9/11 attacks, partly because I was so heavily involved in a (largely unsuccessful) software project during the entire decade of the 2000s. Also, so many of the heated arguments---issues of free-fall building-collapse velocities, nanothermite residues, 747 flying speeds, and such---seemed so highly technical and far beyond my limited expertise to evaluate. But the capture of all those Israeli Mossad agents in the immediate vicinity of the attacks seemed a very clear-cut datapoint, and (as I recall) was even heavily documented on the main "9/11 Conspiracy Debunking" website.

    However, one of the very nice things about this small website is that along with all the fanatics and lunatics, it also attracts lots of extremely knowledgeable commenters, and one of these just brought to my attention the following lengthy YouTube clips. Although I was too busy to watch more than a few minutes, much of the information provided seemed extremely persuasive to me, and certainly shifts my opinion a good deal. After all, if you can't believe the FBI and the top American MSM about what happened during the 9/11 attacks, whom can you believe? Anyway, I'd encourage interested readers to watch the clips, and decide for themselves what they think.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbz7Oazjz74

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QphxGBXiA-M

    Replies: @AnonymousCoward

    Thanks Ron,

    The author of the videos is an occasional reader of the site, and friend of David Cole from Vdare. Let me know if you’d like me to hook you up with him.

  428. @Mr. Anon
    @Truth

    ""And shit doesn’t look like food. But do you doubt that it started out as food?""

    "Oh, thanks for clearing that up, now I get it."

    Good. Maybe someday you'll be able to distinguish it from shineola too.

    Replies: @Truth

    Good. Maybe someday you’ll be able to distinguish it from shineola too.

    That’s a cute one, Ya Big Sexy Studd!

    Hey was like 8 when that movie came out, I forgot you’re such and old fart.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Truth

    I don't know what movie you're talking about. It's a common expression.

  429. @Truth
    @Mr. Anon




    Good. Maybe someday you’ll be able to distinguish it from shineola too.
     
    That's a cute one, Ya Big Sexy Studd!

    Hey was like 8 when that movie came out, I forgot you're such and old fart.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    I don’t know what movie you’re talking about. It’s a common expression.

  430. Well, as I’ve mentioned upthread I’ve never really investigated the 9/11 attacks, partly because I was so heavily involved in a (largely unsuccessful) software project during the entire decade of the 2000s.

    There are important lessons to be learned from unsuccessful software projects …

  431. @This Is Our Home
    @ben tillman


    The real world.

    I didn’t even say the media reported what the government said. I just said they *could* do so, and it wouldn’t require them to know whether it was true or false
     
    Using 'could' in the 'it is just about not impossible' sense, when constructing argument, is something we find precocious and intelligent in young children.

    Replies: @ben tillman

    Using ‘could’ in the ‘it is just about not impossible’ sense, when constructing argument, is something we find precocious and intelligent in young children.

    Thanks for sharing that, apropos of nothing! It does say a lot about your own character and intelligence, however.

  432. @Hunsdon
    @Truth

    Truth: I'd like to apologize. I've come to regard you as a "Johnny One Note" poster, and I was wrong. I like you a lot better when you branch out from what seems to be your usual shtick. (Despite the knee-grow comment in your post immediately following.) Yeah, I know, my comment will change your life, what can I say?

    Replies: @Truth, @Mr. Anon

    The fact that you agree with “Truth” doesn’t give you pause to question what you believe? If somebody’s judgement is poor in N different things, how much do you trust his judgement in the N+1th thing?

  433. @Rurik
    @Mr. Anon

    demolition experts or anyone else to tell me building seven was a controlled demolition…..”

    here's the building going down that is obviously a controlled demolition

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mamvq7LWqRU

    it's a modern 47 story steel frame building

    these building are built to withstand jet plane impacts and earthquakes and to stand for hundreds of years

    they don't just plop into their basement when there's an office fire

    it's impossible

    steel doesn't just give out completely and vaporize magically into ether because some beams got a little hot. If they did, then they wouldn't build them like that. Just try to think, try! If steel frame high rises were in jeopardy of falling down every time there was an office fire, the whole world would be demanding that they be reinforced and built differently and all the existing ones either removed or completely reengineered so this doesn't happened and people are crushed in collapsing buildings all over the place.

    But none of this had been done. People everybody with half a functioning brain knows and can see from the videos that this building was brought down in an obvious controlled demolition.

    so, if you have at least half a brain that is functioning, and you still can't see the obvious, then what is possible is that you're not too stupid to see the obvious, but rather that you're lying. That is always a possibility. Certainly all the official experts pretending that building seven fell because of the office fires are lying for money or some other agenda. Obviously that could be the case with you too. Huh?

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    “steel doesn’t just give out completely and vaporize magically into ether because some beams got a little hot. If they did, then they wouldn’t build them like that.”

    Nobody says they vaporize, you witless boob. Steel loses it’s strength when heated enough.

    “Just try to think, try! If steel frame high rises were in jeopardy of falling down every time there was an office fire, the whole world would be demanding that they be reinforced and built differently and all the existing ones either removed or completely reengineered so this doesn’t happened and people are crushed in collapsing buildings all over the place.”

    Why do you think they insulate the steel then? They do so in case there is a fire – to keep it cool until the fire can be extinguised. Which, for most skyscraper fires is pretty quick. But in unusual circumstances – like when a massive fire burns for a long time (as with WTC7) or when the insulation is scoured off the beams by flying shrapnel (WTC1&2) and then a massive fire burns for an hour or so, the structure can fail.

    I noticed that you ignored the pictures I posted (or rather, the link thereto) of just how massive the fires in WTC7 were. That is typical of deranged paranoids – ask for evidence, then – when it is given – ignore it and move to the next spurious point.

    You spout off like an idiot, knowing nothing about anything, and indeed apparently not even having any common sense. Go back to whatever rock you crawled out from under and howl at the world there.

  434. @Mike Sylwester
    @Mike Sylwester

    Yesterday, I collected from the Internet the following statements of people about Moslems seen celebrating in New Jersey on 9/11.


    I drove with family members though Patterson, N.J. that morning, after the planes hit. It’s not the kind of thing you forget. We witnessed people in traditional Muslim garb dancing, jumping, shouting and celebrating like their team had won the Super Bowl, just as Trump said.

    I didn’t see thousands of Muslims celebrating but I absolutely saw a pocket, perhaps 100, jumping for joy at the sight of the smoke rising from where the Twin Towers used to be. .... these events were a commonly accepted fact by Jerseyans.

    --------

    I had my business on Pennsylvania Ave in Paterson, N.J. I saw people on Crooks Ave. and Main Street cheering and raising Middle Eastern flags.

    I’ll tell you exactly where I was. I had stopped in at Biggs bagels on crooks ave by the railroad tracks. I was wondering why all these crazy people were cheering. Find out a few minutes later America was under attack. I saw it with my own eyes.

    I witnessed pure evil. Donald Trump is right.”

    --------

    What was happening is that they were in stores or small gathering cheering and when they were noticed they stopped. that is what happened when my sister saw them after she got gas and looked in the store to find someone to pay. she saw them gathered around a tv cheering and jumping up and down. When they saw her they stopped, I am sure that's what a lot of people are talking about. Many were seen celebrating. So the police would not have been aware, as in my sister's case. I had heard many stories like that throughout New Jersey.

    -------

    They were in the streets banging on the cars trying to drive through the crowd in the street. The muslims were shouting death to Americans and allah is great [and] other crap I didn't understand. We were amused until a car with 3 young women mistakenly turned on to main st.

    The muslims were banging on their windows and screaming, thats when we came out of our car and pushed the muslims off their car helped them back out and get back to the parkway.

    -------

    I experienced/ witnessed many incidents of Muslims celebrating 9/11 in North Brunswick. I was in a grocery store when I heard the plane crashed on the store radio. The Muslim man in line next to me turned and spit on me. I'll never forget it.

    -------

    I live in Hudson County. It did happen in West New York. Saw it with my own eyes. I don't need a media outlet to tell me what I witnessed just a few feet from me. People in cars, honking they're horns and waiving their flags.

    ------

    I saw black and Arab people in NEWARK PATH MARK SUPERMARKET - dancing and cheering as the TOWERS BURNED !!! and in JERSEY CITY - pockets of people in the streets shouting and laughing - TRUMP IS CORRECT

    -------

    So when I was driving a bus threw paterson that day in the morning to see it and other people seen as well ..does it mean we where dreaming of what took place...

    --------

    I saw it FIRST HAND! I drove an ambulance all over NJ. They were celebrating in the streets. I always wonder why they were never rounded up and sent to their homeland.

    -------

    It absolutely happened in Paterson. The police even had some of the streets closed off to traffic because of it. I was in Paterson on the 12th for business and the whole area around Crooks Avenue was covered in people celebrating.

    ----------

    Want proof that Muslims celebrated as they heard of 9/11 attacks? 100s of young men laughing, dancing, cheering; I saw them.

    ----------

    The Muslims were celebrating until they realized the backlash soon to follow. I saw it.

    ----------

    I saw it, too. The day and age we live in doesn't change the fact that Muslims did in fact party after 9/11 in jersey city. Love or hate trump, it happened

    ----------

    There is a service station in my town, near Edison, NJ, it was owned by Muslims at the time of 9-11. Many members of our community saw the workers there celebrating that day. That station was shunned by the locals as word spread and was eventually sold to new owners.

    [follow-up comment:]

    I'm a liberal Democrat and I saw the same thing from the Palestinian workers on 30th Street and 11th Avenue gas service station. Its closed now.

    ----------

    I lived and grew up in South Paterson NJ. I knew lots of people in law enforcement. Someone I knew at the time from the Passaic County's Prosecutors office told me that there were hundreds of people dancing in the streets when the Towers were attacked. Moreover, Paterson police were keeping people out of the city lest they felt it appropriate to attack some of the revelers. ....

    ----------

    I was a volunteer firefighter sent to the Hoboken FD to cover their turf while they were in NYC. I saw it with my own eyes while going through Jersey City too.

    ----------

    I lived in northwest nj...and yes, they were celebrating in patterson...not thousands but a couple of hundred.... WE SAW IT and will NEVER forget it!

    ----------

    It certainly did happen! I worked in Jersey City that day!

    ----------

    I actually saw them in Patterson NJ. I was one of the people who had to hold back fellow firefighters from going back there to fight with them.

    ----------

    I work in Paterson New Jersey. Many residents I've spoken to recently remember the celebrations that day. 2 were police officers called to protect the Muslims from others who were upset by the display. They (Muslims) danced and cheered. They still live here.

    ----------

    I was there. I saw it too. I was working in Hoboken, and drove through Jersey City and Newark back and forth to my home. Muslims were there. They were celebrating.

    ----------

    I do remember seeing this. This is one of those politically incorrect things we want to forget about 9/11. .... I do remember those Muslims who were celebrating and chanting/yelling in the streets in New Jersey. To say they represented all Muslims is a lie. To say they did not exist is also a lie.

    ----------

    I lived in Hoboken at the time and while I didn't witness these celebrations, I know plenty of people (i.e. former co-workers) who did.

    ----------

    This is true the people of Jersey City took to the streets in riot on Journal Square the reports where telling people to stay away.

    ----------

    Yes he is right I live in NJ and witnessed children stomping on a flag that fell off a car while their parents laughed . Let the truth be told

    ----------

    I saw in Paterson, N.J. about 30 to 50 men yelling and cheering in the street.waving their flags...

    ----------

    I lived in Staten Island new york at the time of 911 attacks .... Later that day, i went to liquor store on forest ave. There were young Muslim men, on the roof toop, waving a flag, as I enter the store about 5 young men, Muslims were smiling and dancing as they gave me candy. .... I latter went into a small grouciers store on Muslim men young and old were cheering when they were listen to the radio. ....
     
    http://nj1015.com/former-gov-difrancesco-i-dont-remember-people-celebrating-911-in-nj/

    https://www.facebook.com/nj1015/posts/10153456648123451

    http://www.bizpacreview.com/2015/11/23/live-jersey-trump-right-muslims-celebrate-911-nj-saw-277082

    http://www.northjersey.com/news/trump-s-comments-of-9-11-celebrations-in-n-j-renew-long-standing-debate-1.1461485

    Replies: @James Kabala, @KA

    Around 911 incident , reports were coming of celebrations in Palestine territory and Saddam rejoicing at the sight of the plane striking twin towers but no one reported a single incident of any group pf Muslim celebrating this 911 incident either in US ,Canada,UK,or France .
    Even when Thomas Friedman falsely claimed that no one from Muslim countries had condemned the attack , this behavior supposedly from muslim in US was not told . I am sure he would have followed it up to show this if for nothing but for to prove this as an evidence of the silent invisible support of anger against US among Muslims

  435. @Ron Unz
    @This Is Our Home


    So now everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up 9/11? Even those who lost family members?
     
    Well, I wouldn't phrase it in exactly those words, but---Yes, quite possibly so.

    The Liberty Incident was probably the most serious military attack on American naval forces since WWII, resulting in over 200 dead and wounded American servicemen. The true facts were very quickly known at the time and have been endlessly confirmed since. Unless "everyone in the media is in on the conspiracy to hush up" that attack, why has it been so effectively hushed up for almost fifty years?

    My impression is that rightwing Internet-activists such as yourself go around endlessly claiming that the entire MSM constantly hides and "hushes up" the bad behavior of Muslims or blacks or illegal immigrants or whatever, and in quite a number of cases, you do have the facts on your side. Then you turn around and claim that only a "crazy conspiracy-nut" could believe that the MSM could hide or cover-up *vastly* more touchy matters, matters protected by *vastly* more powerful and influential groups.

    Steve's often told the story of that popular Hispanic national news-anchor, who during his book-tour was badgered by Jon Stewart into finally hinting that Jews actually constituted a very powerful group in the media. He was immediately purged and totally "disappeared." So what do you think would happen to any MSM person who revealed himself to be a "crazy conspiracy-nut" by pointing out some very suspicious behavior by numerous Mossad agents in connection with 9/11?

    Frankly, I've only given the slightest attention to 9/11 issues, and that was almost a decade ago, so although I'm reasonably confident my casual comments above are basically correct, I can't really vouch for them with great certainty, e.g. I totally misremembered those 40% vs. 85% figures upthread. However, I've also published several major articles on the utter "unreliability" of the MSM on matters of enormous importance. Since you're so new here and seem so totally ignorant or maybe just dishonest. If it's the former, you might want to read those articles and decide for yourself if your confidence in the MSM is really warranted:

    https://www.unz.com/article/our-american-pravda/

    https://www.unz.com/runz/american-pravda-when-tokyo-rose-ran-for-president/

    Replies: @This Is Our Home, @Bill Jones

    The Official Version of 9/11 goes something like this…

    Directed by a beardy-guy from a cave in Afghanistan, ( This well appointed Suite
    http://www.edwardjayepstein.com/nether_fictoid3.htm

    according to the London Times): nineteen hard-drinking, coke-snorting, devout Muslims enjoy lap dances before their mission to meet Allah…

    Using nothing more than craft knifes, they overpower cabin crew, passengers and pilots on four planes…

    And hangover or not, they manage to give the world’s most sophisticated air defense system the slip…

    Unfazed by leaving their “How to Fly a Passenger Jet” guide in the car at the airport, they master the controls in no-time and score direct hits on two towers, causing THREE to collapse completely…

    Our masterminds even manage to overpower the odd law of physics or two… and the world watches in awe as steel-framed buildings fall symmetrically – through their own mass – at free-fall speed, for the first time in history.

    Despite all their dastardly cunning, they stupidly give their identity away by using explosion-proof passports, which survive the fireball undamaged and fall to the ground… only to be discovered by the incredible crime-fighting sleuths at the FBI…

    …Meanwhile down in Washington…

    Hani Hanjour, having previously flunked 2-man Cessna flying school, gets carried away with all the success of the day and suddenly finds incredible abilities behind the controls of a Boeing…

    Instead of flying straight down into the large roof area of the Pentagon, he decides to show off a little…

    Executing an incredible 270 degree downward spiral, he levels off to hit the low facade of the world’s most heavily defended building…

    …all without a single shot being fired…. or ruining the nicely mowed lawn… and all at a speed just too fast to capture on video…

    …Later, in the skies above Pennsylvania…

    So desperate to talk to loved ones before their death, some passengers use sheer willpower to connect mobile calls that otherwise would not be possible until several years later…

    And following a heroic attempt by some to retake control of Flight 93, it crashes into a Shankesville field leaving no trace of engines, fuselage or occupants… except for the standard issue Muslim terrorists bandana…

    …Further south in Florida…

    President Bush, our brave Commander-in-Chief continues to read “My Pet Goat” to a class full of primary school children… shrugging off the obvious possibility that his life could be in imminent danger…

    …In New York…

    World Trade Center leaseholder Larry Silverstein blesses his own foresight in insuring the buildings against terrorist attack only six weeks previously…

    While back in Washington, Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld and Paul Wolfowitz shake their heads in disbelief at their own luck in getting the ‘New Pearl Harbor’ catalyzing event they so desired to pursue their agenda of world domination…

    And finally, not to be disturbed too much by reports of their own deaths, at least seven of our nineteen suicide hijackers turn up alive and kicking in mainstream media reports…

    And If you don’t believe this, you are a conspiracy theorist.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    @Bill Jones


    So desperate to talk to loved ones before their death, some passengers use sheer willpower to connect mobile calls that otherwise would not be possible until several years later…
     
    Alexander Dewdney is a Canadian mathematician and computer scientist and Professor Emeritus at the University of Western Ontario. He did a series of experiments in which cell phone calls were attempted from planes and did not go through, which suggests that the cell phone calls on 9/11 may not have been possible. He did the experiment for a Japanese TV program in 2003:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=WJ9Lg7Zaw30#t=610
  436. Anonymous • Disclaimer says:
    @Bill Jones
    @Ron Unz

    The Official Version of 9/11 goes something like this...

    Directed by a beardy-guy from a cave in Afghanistan, ( This well appointed Suite
    http://www.edwardjayepstein.com/nether_fictoid3.htm

    according to the London Times): nineteen hard-drinking, coke-snorting, devout Muslims enjoy lap dances before their mission to meet Allah...

    Using nothing more than craft knifes, they overpower cabin crew, passengers and pilots on four planes...

    And hangover or not, they manage to give the world's most sophisticated air defense system the slip...

    Unfazed by leaving their “How to Fly a Passenger Jet” guide in the car at the airport, they master the controls in no-time and score direct hits on two towers, causing THREE to collapse completely...

    Our masterminds even manage to overpower the odd law of physics or two... and the world watches in awe as steel-framed buildings fall symmetrically - through their own mass - at free-fall speed, for the first time in history.

    Despite all their dastardly cunning, they stupidly give their identity away by using explosion-proof passports, which survive the fireball undamaged and fall to the ground... only to be discovered by the incredible crime-fighting sleuths at the FBI...

    …Meanwhile down in Washington...

    Hani Hanjour, having previously flunked 2-man Cessna flying school, gets carried away with all the success of the day and suddenly finds incredible abilities behind the controls of a Boeing...

    Instead of flying straight down into the large roof area of the Pentagon, he decides to show off a little...

    Executing an incredible 270 degree downward spiral, he levels off to hit the low facade of the world's most heavily defended building...

    ...all without a single shot being fired.... or ruining the nicely mowed lawn... and all at a speed just too fast to capture on video...

    ...Later, in the skies above Pennsylvania...

    So desperate to talk to loved ones before their death, some passengers use sheer willpower to connect mobile calls that otherwise would not be possible until several years later...

    And following a heroic attempt by some to retake control of Flight 93, it crashes into a Shankesville field leaving no trace of engines, fuselage or occupants... except for the standard issue Muslim terrorists bandana...

    ...Further south in Florida...

    President Bush, our brave Commander-in-Chief continues to read “My Pet Goat” to a class full of primary school children... shrugging off the obvious possibility that his life could be in imminent danger...

    ...In New York...

    World Trade Center leaseholder Larry Silverstein blesses his own foresight in insuring the buildings against terrorist attack only six weeks previously...

    While back in Washington, Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld and Paul Wolfowitz shake their heads in disbelief at their own luck in getting the 'New Pearl Harbor' catalyzing event they so desired to pursue their agenda of world domination...

    And finally, not to be disturbed too much by reports of their own deaths, at least seven of our nineteen suicide hijackers turn up alive and kicking in mainstream media reports...

    And If you don't believe this, you are a conspiracy theorist.

    Replies: @Anonymous

    So desperate to talk to loved ones before their death, some passengers use sheer willpower to connect mobile calls that otherwise would not be possible until several years later…

    Alexander Dewdney is a Canadian mathematician and computer scientist and Professor Emeritus at the University of Western Ontario. He did a series of experiments in which cell phone calls were attempted from planes and did not go through, which suggests that the cell phone calls on 9/11 may not have been possible. He did the experiment for a Japanese TV program in 2003:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=WJ9Lg7Zaw30#t=610

  437. @Truth
    @AnotherDad


    The simple approach that works for your folks and my folks–separation. Your people run your affairs–have the level of policing and tolerate the level of violence that your people desire.
     
    Cool, what states are you giving us? I like California.

    Replies: @ATate

    Your folks can’t even hold Compton for Christ’s sake. What makes you think a bunch of Lavarias’s and Latavia’s can hold Venice or Carlsbad from the Brown Horde?

    Let alone the entire state.

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to All Steve Sailer Comments via RSS