The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection$
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 TeasersiSteve Blog
WaPo: Census Proves Great Replacement Is Real and You Losers Need to Surrender
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information



=>

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • B
Show CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeThanksLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

From the Washington Post opinion page by Washington Post opinion columnist Jennifer Rubin:

The census reminds us America isn’t static. The GOP needs to deal with it.

Opinion by Jennifer Rubin, Columnist
Today at 10:00 a.m. EDT

The 2020 Census shows that while Whites remain the largest ethnicity group in the United States, the demographic decreased by 8.6 percent over the past decade. …

America is never static. … Indeed, that is the essence of America — a country not defined by racial or religious identity.

So, forget that stuff in the Preamble about the point of the Constitution being the general welfare of “ourselves and our posterity.” That got abrogated by Emma Lazarus’s poem.

That reality has, of course, freaked out a significant share of White Christians who do not see “their America” as predominate. It was never “theirs” to begin with, and the assumption that something is amiss if White Christians are not in charge is the essence of white supremacy and Christian nationalism. It is also fundamentally un-American; our country is defined, as President Biden rightly says, by an “idea.”

It is easy, then, to understand why a political party based increasingly on its appeal to White Christians has adopted so many anti-American traits. …

The GOP is so dependent on the right-wing media generator of White angst and resentment, and so fearful they will lose their grip among Whites, that they have chosen instead to try to hold back the demographic and cultural tide washing over them.

… However, unless and until Americans in rural areas demand responsible governance, embrace the true “idea” of America and reject the temptation of racism and authoritarianism, little will change.

In the meantime, urban Americans, who constitute a greater share of the population than ever before, will lose patience with anti-democratic techniques (e.g., the filibuster, voter suppression) designed to give rural Whites disproportionate power. Demography may not be destiny, but it brings the weaknesses of American democracy into focus.

 
Hide 163 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. Well, she did a good job of openly and honestly articulating the Jewish-American plan.

    • Disagree: Corvinus
    • Replies: @Hangnail Hans
    @JimDandy

    Rubin has always been pretty transparent about this stuff. There's little need to hide it anymore anyway.


    White Christians... the demographic and cultural tide washing over them.
     
    This is just part of their victory dance.

    PS; Did she really say "predominate" instead of predominant? Oh I forgot--grammar is white people stuff.

    Replies: @Richard B, @Ben tillman

    , @Anon
    @JimDandy


    Well, she did a good job of openly and honestly articulating the Jewish-American plan.
     
    Waiting for a fellow Jewish-American to call her out on it.

    Meanwhile media jews are having a meltdown over the peaceful transfer of power in Afghanistan. The prospect of Muslims and Christians not being at each other’s throats, or otherwise in turmoil, seems to cause them a lot of anxiety.

    The anxiety probably is not limited just to Muslims and Christians getting along, or being unified and strong internally, but extends to any outgroups getting along or having their shit together.

    Replies: @JimDandy, @SunBakedSuburb

    , @slumber_j
    @JimDandy

    Oh, you mean Jennifer Rubin: for a moment there I thought you were referring to Emma Lazarus.


    So, forget that stuff in the Preamble about the point of the Constitution being the general welfare of “ourselves and our posterity.” That got abrogated by Emma Lazarus’s poem.
     
    I'd call it doggerel, but whatever.

    Replies: @Hjgfdjji it ddffg

  2. The government’s not so hot either.

  3. yawzaa! datz makez senz, mah brutha

  4. They hate you and want you dead doesn’t sound so crazy anymore, does it Steve.

    • Disagree: Triteleia Laxa
    • Replies: @JohnnyWalker123
    @Citizen of a Silly Country

    "They" is such a vague term.

    Be more specific.

    Replies: @DCThrowback

    , @AnotherDad
    @Citizen of a Silly Country


    They hate you and want you dead doesn’t sound so crazy anymore, does it Steve.
     
    I think it's more "they hate you and demand you sit still and be looted". But if you don't agree or don't provide optimal looting ... then yeah--"dead" works.

    The implacable minoritarianism should not surprise:

    Jew are a middle-man minority, of course, they push minoritarianism. They don't like concepts like "majority rule", "republican government" that America was built upon. Or even the idea of "nation". What they like is empire, where the elites in charge are Jew friendly and insure the Jews are protected and have the right to middle man anywhere and everywhere without a coherent majority capable of pushing back. (What Jews now call "democracy" and say is "under threat" by people voting for their own interests and survival. E.g. Trump, Orban, etc.)

    The implacable hostility should not surprise:

    The Ashkenazi faced a detribalizing, integrating Christianity. To keep themselves as a separate tribe they had to jack up the tribal feeling and hostility--culturally and religiously. Essentially worshipping themselves as separate people, from all those nasty gentiles. Absent that hostility ... they'd have been integrated in with everyone else. (Some were.)

    No the surprise here is the sheer shortsightedness.

    Jews are supposed to be smart.

    Post-War the Jews were middle-manning freely in the richest, most powerful nation on earth. The WASPs had put in a test based "meritocracy" that played right into the Jews' strength. American Protestants are near the top of the charts in being willing to share their space with other tribes, and one of the most Jew friendly peoples on earth. America is inherently just more open, than the Jews are going to find anywhere else.

    Rationally Jews should have been thinking "This is great, as good as it gets", been dog-loyal citizens and worked to keep America as strong and healthy and prosperous as possible.

    But the key word there: "rationally". They just couldn't do it.

    The Jews just couldn't reign in their hostility. They had to tear it all down. Like blacks with crime, or the Irish with drink, the Jews and their destructive hostility--an itch they just must scratch.

    And America is it. No other nation was going to be so open anyway. But now everyone's seen this shit show. You think the Chinese are going to let Jews come in and loot as they rise toward the top? Anyone who gets their act together going to invite in Jews? LOL. People are stupid, but not that stupid.

    The two greatest lessons from America:
    -- Don't bring in the blacks.
    -- Don't let in the Jews.

    Replies: @Citizen of a Silly Country

  5. Ghouls

  6. Based Biden.

  7. It is also fundamentally un-American; our country is defined, as President Biden rightly says, by an “idea.”

    Our country defined by an “idea.” Isn’t that Citizenism?

    Steve, do you really want to be on their side?

    • Replies: @Elsewhere
    @Citizen of a Silly Country

    That's not citizenism. Citizenism simply means returning to "for us and for our posterity" with those who are currently citizens. This means that current citizens can decide to be choosy about who else, if any, are allowed to become new citizens. Indeed, they have a strong incentive to be choosy.

    Replies: @Citizen of a Silly Country, @ATBOTL

  8. Fight back, boycott Hollywood, cancel cable.

  9. @Citizen of a Silly Country
    They hate you and want you dead doesn't sound so crazy anymore, does it Steve.

    Replies: @JohnnyWalker123, @AnotherDad

    “They” is such a vague term.

    Be more specific.

    • Replies: @DCThrowback
    @JohnnyWalker123

    LOL

  10. Jennifer Rubin’s position here is completely factually inaccurate. But even setting that aside, if we grant for argument’s sake that hers is an opinion possible to hold, it is neither original to her nor does it receive from her any particular force of expression.

    In other words, this is not-even-wrong, secondhand dreck.

    And we pay people to write like this?

    • Replies: @kaganovitch
    @Intelligent Dasein

    And we pay people to write like this?

    Unless your name is Bezos,"we" don't do anything of the sort.

    , @Bill
    @Intelligent Dasein

    I've been baffled by this as well. Not only does she argue badly, but her prose is consistently awful. Surely they can find someone better than her.

  11. • LOL: JimDandy
    • Replies: @Gary in Gramercy
    @Hangnail Hans

    Lieu's a typical (i.e., hypocritical) Democrat, but does anyone seriously think Stanford can be bought for a $50,000 contribution when it took $5 million to get Jared Kushner into Harvard?

    A space in Stanford's entering freshman class probably goes for a low seven-figure sum -- although the child of a legacy Congressman might qualify for a discount.

    Note, however, that Lieu is too cheap to attempt a bribe of Stanford with his own money. That's the real outrage.

    Replies: @Barnard

  12. @JimDandy
    Well, she did a good job of openly and honestly articulating the Jewish-American plan.

    Replies: @Hangnail Hans, @Anon, @slumber_j

    Rubin has always been pretty transparent about this stuff. There’s little need to hide it anymore anyway.

    White Christians… the demographic and cultural tide washing over them.

    This is just part of their victory dance.

    PS; Did she really say “predominate” instead of predominant? Oh I forgot–grammar is white people stuff.

    • Agree: JimDandy, Charon, Right_On
    • Replies: @Richard B
    @Hangnail Hans


    Rubin has always been pretty transparent about this stuff. There’s little need to hide it anymore anyway.
     
    She might have to hide it when TSHTF, as it always seems to do with them.

    The kind of thinking that goes into infiltration, subversion, radical ingratitude, insane hatred, destruction and death is not the kind of thinking needed for competent social management. And, the fact is, they've never been very good at that and never will be.

    They've been at this forever. Babylon, Persia, Egypt, Greece, Rome, Christian Europe, Secular Europe, the revolutions of 17th century England, 18th century France, 20th century Russia and now the USA.

    Speaking of which, given the condition the USA is in right now, their victory dance is more like a Pyrrhic Victory dance. Not much to brag about. And now what's next?

    China. A people who, unlike whites, don't strike one as being all that into power-sharing, or being pushed around. In short, maybe Jewish Supremacy Inc. has has finally reached the end of the line. Where to next for them? The moon?

    Replies: @Anonymous, @Ben tillman

    , @Ben tillman
    @Hangnail Hans

    Yeah, that was a nice touch.

  13. Times like these are when the rural whites need to remind the urbanites just how much they need, what do you call it, ah yes food. Meats, grains, fruits and vegetables and of course taters, precious. Without fries America will come to a stand still. Not French fries of course, but freedom fries. They might lose their patience, but they won’t lose their appetites.

    • Replies: @SaneClownPosse
    @Jiminy

    Why do you think they are developing meatless meats?

    Replies: @Jiminy

    , @znon
    @Jiminy

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wW-4LU79qbU

    , @Bill
    @Jiminy

    How did that reminding work out for the kulaks?

  14. Jennifer Rubin and Charles Blow. Two disgusting people in one day here.

    • Agree: Ghost of Bull Moose
    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
    @Clyde

    I don't know how iSteve can stand it. It's like cleaning out the sewer line. Someone's gotta do it, but I'd guess the plumbing pays better.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar

    , @Citizen of a Silly Country
    @Clyde

    Blow is just a low level clerk. Rubin is part the ruling tribe. Don't conflate the two.

  15. That reality has, of course, freaked out a significant share of White Christians who do not see “their America” as predominate. It was never “theirs” to begin with, and the assumption that something is amiss if White Christians are not in charge is the essence of white supremacy and Christian nationalism. It is also fundamentally un-American; our country is defined, as President Biden rightly says, by an “idea.”

    “On the other hand, something would be greatly amiss if “my people” were not in charge, or if anyone dared to point it out.”

    They’ve been telling us for decades that we’re evil racists for noticing what they’ve been doing. Now that it’s too late, they tell us it was all inevitable anyway and we’re evil racists who deserve it in the first place.

  16. .. until Americans in rural areas demand responsible governance ..

    The urbanites have always been telling the hayseeds how to run their lives.

    When my ex-state’s constitution was first being negotiated, the city folk — mealymouth, narcissistic, lawyer types — wanted compulsory, public education for 180 d/yr. The country bumpkins wanted a voluntary system, e.g. the little red schoolhouse; 3m/yr, til 8th grade, was their norm.

    (The country folk won that battle, but foolishly compromised by agreeing to language that a compulsory system could be imposed by legislative vote. Of course the busybody progressives never sleep.)

  17. I outlined Rubin’s article for her, before she wrote it, as you requested here:

    They’re fully committed to the 2022 election. It seems ridiculously facile to base your entire worldview on partisan politics, but that’s where they are. Maybe they’ll contrast the rising tide of diversity with the “monochrome” Republican party and then use that to imply unfair gerrymandering and implicit racism. They’ll also try to represent themlsves as the patriots, if only as of the last 2 minutes, with some “We Iz Americca, we Iz patriots” stuff. I’ll give bonus points to any journalist who does this and dismisses all who disagree with them as Confederate rebels who need to be Sherman’d, with yet more absurd reference to Jan 6th as a terrorist insurgency threat that is the Confederate Attakkk/Pearl Harbour/9/11 combined.

    https://www.unz.com/isteve/how-will-the-press-spin-thursdays-census-announcement-of-a-declining-number-of-whites/#comment-4836289

    • Replies: @Polistra
    @Triteleia Laxa

    It seems ridiculously facile to base your entire worldview on partisan politics, but that’s where they are
     

    Facile? Or just effective? Casting every situation as good guys vs. bad guys may be oversimplifying just a tad, but it works for the vast majority of people. Notice how wars tend to be won by the good guys?

    Replies: @Triteleia Laxa

  18. In the meantime, urban Americans, who constitute a greater share of the population than ever before, will lose patience with anti-democratic techniques (e.g., the filibuster, voter suppression) designed to give rural Whites disproportionate power.

    Yeah, when the financial SHTF, they will lose even more patience when the deliveries of food are held up and power goes out. True, Jennifer, rural White people have disportioncate power.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    @Achmed E. Newman

    They'll just send armed forces to seize food by force from the 'peasants'. (See Russia in 1921-22 and 1932-33.)

    Replies: @Achmed E. Newman

  19. @Clyde
    Jennifer Rubin and Charles Blow. Two disgusting people in one day here.

    Replies: @Achmed E. Newman, @Citizen of a Silly Country

    I don’t know how iSteve can stand it. It’s like cleaning out the sewer line. Someone’s gotta do it, but I’d guess the plumbing pays better.

    • Replies: @Reg Cæsar
    @Achmed E. Newman


    I don’t know how iSteve can stand it. It’s like cleaning out the sewer line. Someone’s gotta do it, but I’d guess the plumbing pays better.
     
    Back in the previous century, Michael Medved said his job as a film critic made him a "glorified sewer inspector". I'm sure Steve can relate to that.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @iDeplorable

  20. The significant word in that excerpt is Christian.

    • Agree: JerseyJeffersonian
    • Replies: @Hjgfdjji it ddffg
    @Change that Matters

    The keyword is left out — GENTILE. Rubin is a racist.

  21. In the meantime, urban Americans, who constitute a greater share of the population than ever before…

    Those high quality “urban Americans,” when they’re not shooting each other wholesale…

    https://nypost.com/2021/08/15/cops-seek-mta-motorman-who-let-gal-pal-drive-d-train-in-nyc/

  22. Where did they get the idea we were the surrendering type?

    https://twitter.com/tummymuncher/status/1427021381456343043?s=20

    • Thanks: The Wild Geese Howard
    • Replies: @The Wild Geese Howard
    @Desiderius

    If those images are real it just proves the controllers are simply funnin' with us now.

    , @Currahee
    @Desiderius

    Different crew presumably.

    , @Polistra
    @Desiderius

    It's absolutely ridiculous for people to keep making these Saigon comparisons. The situations are nothing alike. No Viet Cong, for example. Plus, Kabul is at a much higher elevation and has considerably colder winters. People should try thinking about things before just saying whatever comes into their minds.

    https://twitter.com/RT_com/status/1426898972564770816

    Replies: @Bill

    , @AceDeuce
    @Desiderius

    Actually, we (the U.S.) don't fly CH-46s any more--The Kabul Shuffle (Hey Moe! Hey Moe!)/Saigon Redux is being done by the lookalike big brother of the 46--The CH-47 Chinook.

    So, optically--pretty damned similar superficially, but technically not the same airframe.

  23. Anon[725] • Disclaimer says:

    Rubin’s people, the Jews, spent centuries wandering the planet complaining they had no homeland. Then they got a homeland in Israel, and they’re still not content.

    In every country they live today, something is seriously wrong, according to them. They want every country remade to suit them. The more civilized your country, the more the Jews think it’s horrible.

    It never seems to occur to them that their problem is a fundamental inability to be happy. They have never learned how to find contentment. This is what happens when the most common personality types you have among your people are neuroticism and querulousness. Neuroticism seems to be a Ashkenazi thing, not so much Sephardic. The genetic bottleneck that created the Ashkenazis hundreds of years ago was obviously chockful of loons.

    The sooner Jews crossbreed with others and lose their Jewish identity and neurotic personality traits, the better off they and the rest of the planet will be.

    • Replies: @mc23
    @Anon

    See "You Gentiles" by Maurice Samuel written in 1924. He hasn't been canceled or disowned, sorta like the senile uncle who talks too much

    Here's one line:

    "We Jews, we are the destroyers and will remain the destroyers. Nothing you can do will meet our demands and needs. We will forever destroy because we want a world of our own."

    He received the Itzik Manger Prize for Yiddish literature posthumously in 1972.

    https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1889421.You_Gentiles

    , @Observator
    @Anon

    It's a hoary old fantasy that Jews were ever expelled from their wretched desert homeland. The Babylonian and Persian "captivities" were the tales of the families of the elite, who were held hostage to ensure that tribute payments would continue from the conquered province. There they incorporated many of the host nations’ dogmas and legends to their belief structure, such as the Creation myth and the Noah's Ark tale. Jews began to emigrate from Palestine in the time of Alexander the Great, not due to persecution (that would come seven centuries later under Christian rule) but for opportunities in the international trading centers in his great empire. By the time of Jesus the largest Jewish populations were in Egypt, Syria, and Italy. Sixty years after the Romans flattened Jerusalem, there were enough Jews still there that the Romans were able to kill another 200,000 of them when they staged yet another ill-advised insurrection. Their descendents were still there five centuries after that, to welcome the Islamic "invaders" as liberators from centuries of ill-treatment by Byzantine Christians. Offered a tax exemption if they converted to Islam, many did, and their descendants are the Arab Fellahim whom the recent European and American immigrants who call themselves "Israelis" are so vigorously persecuting today.

    Replies: @but an humble craftsman

  24. Anon[295] • Disclaimer says:
    @JimDandy
    Well, she did a good job of openly and honestly articulating the Jewish-American plan.

    Replies: @Hangnail Hans, @Anon, @slumber_j

    Well, she did a good job of openly and honestly articulating the Jewish-American plan.

    Waiting for a fellow Jewish-American to call her out on it.

    Meanwhile media jews are having a meltdown over the peaceful transfer of power in Afghanistan. The prospect of Muslims and Christians not being at each other’s throats, or otherwise in turmoil, seems to cause them a lot of anxiety.

    The anxiety probably is not limited just to Muslims and Christians getting along, or being unified and strong internally, but extends to any outgroups getting along or having their shit together.

    • Replies: @JimDandy
    @Anon

    And now if anyone suggests we get out of Iraq, they can scoff and say, "One word: Afghanistan."

    , @SunBakedSuburb
    @Anon

    "The prospect of Muslims and Christians not being at each other's throats ... seems to cause them a lot of anxiety"

    Yahweh's Babelization plan of divide and conquer continues its long and successful run.

  25. • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Desiderius


    Building actual resilient networked communities is the foundation of whatever is next

    — Diomedes Appreciator (@Erik26958705) August 15, 2021
     
    Australia's way ahead of the curve on that. Check out their new Detention Camp Centre for National Resilience.

    https://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/national/victoria/construction-of-mickleham-quarantine-camp-is-under-way-20210812-p58i50.html

    Resilience Centre! That sounds so much better than "Concentration Camp".
  26. Rubin:

    That reality has, of course, freaked out a significant share of White Christians who do not see “their America” as predominate. It was never “theirs” to begin with

    (((Echoes))) of Jon Leibowitz’s rant in 2016 (11 minutes in) :

    This country isn’t yours! You don’t own it! It never was! There is no real America!

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    (((Echoes))) of Jon Leibowitz’s rant in 2016 (11 minutes in)

    Yea thank God we have pro-White Christians like Steven Colbert to balance him out.

    Leibowitz is actually somewhat moderate while Colbert is a liberal's dream.

    Total race denier and constantly attacks the White mainstream.

    Colbert actually went after Stewart for suggesting that the virus could have come from a lab. Ironically he was clearly upset at Stewart for not following the MSM narrative.

    Steven fits the disfigured leftist perfectly. Kids probably made fun of his ear and now he is going to dedicate his life to attacking White society.

    I'm sure he has a small penis as well. His resentment vibes practically crack my tv screen.

    Leftist men tend to be very short, perverted/gay or have a disfigurement of some type. Gramsci was basically a dwarf with a limp. Robert Reich is 4'11. Even without Jewish leftists we would have this army of the bitter. Orwell actually wrote about this.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican

    , @Hangnail Hans
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Media Jew:

    This country isn’t yours! It never was! There is no real America!
     

    "Crowd Goes Wild"
  27. @Desiderius
    Where did they get the idea we were the surrendering type?

    https://twitter.com/tummymuncher/status/1427021381456343043?s=20

    Replies: @The Wild Geese Howard, @Currahee, @Polistra, @AceDeuce

    If those images are real it just proves the controllers are simply funnin’ with us now.

  28. Very few people listen to you Jennifer, because you’re not attractive, you’re not smart, you’re hostile, and you’re insane. ‘Tis.

  29. A lot of Jew blaming as usual but no blame for our race denying conservatives and their mindless embrace of libertarian theories.

    Rush Limbaugh made millions by indoctrinating rural Whites into believing that “Da Unions” must be to blame for those Black areas. Republicans gave him one of the highest civil awards.

    The GOP bet it all on the “Free market” being more important than race and they would rather eat third world sh-t than admit they were wrong.

    WELL PUT THAT BIB ON AND GET READY

    MEGADITTOS

    • Agree: Daniel H
    • Replies: @Ben tillman
    @John Johnson

    The race-denying conservatives were responding to indoctrination and incentives/disincentives produced by the Jewish community that built and enforced the atomizing moral framework within which they operated.

  30. Anonymous[419] • Disclaimer says:

    Dear Steve,

    Although your diagnoses are almost invariably correct, reading you for two decades left me wondering what value they offer. Mostly, you preach to the choir. The propaganda/conversion value seems to be quite low (naturally so). Your output can be more efficient/valuable if you start offering your thoughts on what is to be done about it. You must have thought about it. Why not up your societal value and start suggesting some practical ways to counteract what are effectively white extermination tendencies?

    Because, frankly, only constantly complaining about it is a sort of mental masturbation.

    • Replies: @anonymous
    @Anonymous


    Your output can be more efficient/valuable if you start offering your thoughts on what is to be done about it.
     
    Everyone has a role to play. Steve is very effective in his. How about some other people step up and carry the ball?
    , @SafeNow
    @Anonymous

    “Why not up your societal value and start suggesting some practical ways to counteract…” (addressed to Steve)

    Fair question. I will hazard a guess. I am assuming that by “practical,” you mean effective, and not perfunctory and useless. Steve is in good company. All the essayists, and commenters, have uniformly declined to do what you ask. If commenters have ever been specific and unmeasured, we did not see it, because it was moderated. I have posted “So what, specifically, is the plan of procedure?” many times, to no avail. The reason for not stating specifics, in my view, is this: If woke, quasi-religious ruthlessness continues to accelerate, the consequences of advocating specifics might, some day, be horrendous.

    I write this as a coward. As I have posted before, I was a spineless student at an “elite” New England university exactly when this all began, the late 60s.

    I am quite satisfied taking enjoyment in Steve’s great wit, insight, and intelligence as he observes and analyzes the world. (No, I am not his cousin.)

    Replies: @Intelligent Dasein, @Nicholas Stix, @Marty T

    , @epebble
    @Anonymous

    I will bite. The reason no solutions are being offered is because the problems are intractable - in the sense that in the political system we have, a much higher degree of political agreement is needed than we have or can have in near future.

    I will elaborate:

    1. Many persons are commenting, generally, on low number of births and dysgenic births. This is due to a multiplicity of factors: Increased education of women, a desire by educated (and even less educated women) to work outside the home in paying jobs for the satisfaction of being active in society and also to increase family income to enjoy a higher standard of living (than possible by a single income). Obviously, this leads to smaller family sizes. This also leads to dysgenic births as more educated women will have fewer children than less educated women.

    Now, a crude "solution" may be to discourage women from post secondary education and employment to promote more domesticity and motherhood. But we do not have any political process to achieve that, even if some people find it desirable.

    2. Many people are commenting, generally on high level of immigration. Unfortunately, nearly two thirds of immigration is for family unification. Thus even though many people want to reduce immigration, no one knows who should be prevented from bringing a spouse, child or a parent from abroad. As for employment immigration, businesses have a lot of clout - and can also make fairness argument - if Joe Sixpack can import a car from Japan or Korea (because of Global Free Trade in goods), How can the government prevent an employer from hiring a worker from abroad (Free Trade in labor)? Since we (consumers) want imported goods for better quality/lower price, employer (consumer of labor) also insists on the same. And remember, when you pick stocks based on P/E ratio, you are not preferring employers that prefer to hire Americans over foreigners.

    These are just two example I have picked. However, For every problem discussed, I can easily show that all possible solutions are politically intractable.

    Replies: @Neil Templeton

  31. @Jiminy
    Times like these are when the rural whites need to remind the urbanites just how much they need, what do you call it, ah yes food. Meats, grains, fruits and vegetables and of course taters, precious. Without fries America will come to a stand still. Not French fries of course, but freedom fries. They might lose their patience, but they won’t lose their appetites.

    Replies: @SaneClownPosse, @znon, @Bill

    Why do you think they are developing meatless meats?

    • Replies: @Jiminy
    @SaneClownPosse

    My wife made the mistake of buying a box of vegan prawns. They’re not prawns that solely eat vegetables, but things that resemble lumps of foam rubber, and the taste is beyond description, so I won’t bother you with it. But if I had the future in my hands, then they can keep it. I think I’ll start hunting rats, sparrows and pigeons to survive.

    Replies: @Joe Stalin

  32. @Jenner Ickham Errican
    Rubin:

    That reality has, of course, freaked out a significant share of White Christians who do not see “their America” as predominate. It was never “theirs” to begin with
     
    (((Echoes))) of Jon Leibowitz’s rant in 2016 (11 minutes in) :

    This country isn’t yours! You don’t own it! It never was! There is no real America!
     
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mNiqpBNE9ik&t=660s

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Hangnail Hans

    (((Echoes))) of Jon Leibowitz’s rant in 2016 (11 minutes in)

    Yea thank God we have pro-White Christians like Steven Colbert to balance him out.

    Leibowitz is actually somewhat moderate while Colbert is a liberal’s dream.

    Total race denier and constantly attacks the White mainstream.

    Colbert actually went after Stewart for suggesting that the virus could have come from a lab. Ironically he was clearly upset at Stewart for not following the MSM narrative.

    Steven fits the disfigured leftist perfectly. Kids probably made fun of his ear and now he is going to dedicate his life to attacking White society.

    I’m sure he has a small penis as well. His resentment vibes practically crack my tv screen.

    Leftist men tend to be very short, perverted/gay or have a disfigurement of some type. Gramsci was basically a dwarf with a limp. Robert Reich is 4’11. Even without Jewish leftists we would have this army of the bitter. Orwell actually wrote about this.

    • Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @John Johnson


    Steven fits the disfigured leftist perfectly. Kids probably made fun of his ear and now he is going to dedicate his life to attacking White society.

    I’m sure he has a small penis as well. His resentment vibes practically crack my tv screen.

    Leftist men tend to be very short, perverted/gay or have a disfigurement of some type. Gramsci was basically a dwarf with a limp. Robert Reich is 4’11. Even without Jewish leftists we would have this army of the bitter.
     

    Yes, I (more broadly) recently addressed the above here:

    https://www.unz.com/isteve/blackrock-is-looking-for-the-black-elizabeth-holmes/#comment-4820666 (#58)


    With Whites in America, it’s more complicated: Among “dissenters” there are Jews who are not White but sometimes claim to be Whites, there are gays, there are general malcontents—the latter can be divided into subcategories of: class resentment, personal awkwardness, poor socialization/broken homes, etc. I can get into specifics if you have certain subgroups in mind, at the risk of stating the obvious as with Blacks above.

    In short, what dissenters of any kind in America ‘need’, depending on subgroup, is varying combinations of retribution, public validation, and profitable/sexual “tangibles” to be paid to them.
     

  33. Jennifer Rubin wrong again:

    “The Naturalization Act of 1790 (1 Stat. 103, enacted March 26, 1790) was a law of the United States Congress that set the first uniform rules for the granting of United States citizenship by naturalization. The law limited naturalization to “free White person(s) … of good character”,

    The United States of America is very much built upon a shared European identity.

  34. Ladies and Gentlemen, your “conservative” voice in the mainstream press, Jen Rubin.

    • Agree: Charon, Daniel H
  35. It is also fundamentally un-American; our country is defined, as President Biden rightly says, by an “idea.”

    Biden, in his present condition, wouldn’t know an idea if it bit him in the tóin.

  36. Jennifer the Gargoyle just created at least 100,000 brand new “anti-semites.”

    • Disagree: Charon
  37. @Achmed E. Newman
    @Clyde

    I don't know how iSteve can stand it. It's like cleaning out the sewer line. Someone's gotta do it, but I'd guess the plumbing pays better.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar

    I don’t know how iSteve can stand it. It’s like cleaning out the sewer line. Someone’s gotta do it, but I’d guess the plumbing pays better.

    Back in the previous century, Michael Medved said his job as a film critic made him a “glorified sewer inspector“. I’m sure Steve can relate to that.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Reg Cæsar


    Back in the previous century, Michael Medved said his job as a film critic made him a “glorified sewer inspector“. I’m sure Steve can relate to that.
     
    At heart, Michael Medved probably agrees with Rubin.
    , @iDeplorable
    @Reg Cæsar


    @Achmed E. Newman

    I don’t know how iSteve can stand it. It’s like cleaning out the sewer line. Someone’s gotta do it, but I’d guess the plumbing pays better.

    Back in the previous century, Michael Medved said his job as a film critic made him a “glorified sewer inspector“. I’m sure Steve can relate to that.

     

    Oh great now the two jabbering geriatrics are replying to each other. It was better when you two grannies just kept it to off-topic babble and inane pics.

    Replies: @Achmed E. Newman

  38. Sort of related: So what’s the ratio of Haitian refugees admitted to the US related to deaths from this latest earthquake? 20:1?

    1300 hundred dead so far, so that would be 26,000 thousand Haitians to be admitted to the US. Quick, someone find out where the whitest places in the country are, so we know exact where to put them!

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Mike Tre

    1300 hundred dead so far, so that would be 26,000 thousand Haitians to be admitted to the US. Quick, someone find out where the whitest places in the country are, so we know exact where to put them!

    Democrats run the government so they will put Haitians and Africans in White areas and Afghans in Black areas.

    My wife knows someone that was forced to open a business in a Black area to get a green card. Those Koreans in Black areas aren't there by choice.

    Anyone can get into the US if they show that they have the money to open a business and will go where they are told. It actually takes quite a bit of capital though, over 100k and there are a bunch of rules to make sure you aren't scamming the system.

  39. @Desiderius
    Where did they get the idea we were the surrendering type?

    https://twitter.com/tummymuncher/status/1427021381456343043?s=20

    Replies: @The Wild Geese Howard, @Currahee, @Polistra, @AceDeuce

    Different crew presumably.

  40. That reality has, of course, freaked out a significant share of White Christians who do not see “their America” as predominate.

    Isn’t “predominate” a verb, not an adjective? Shouldn’t this be “predominant”? Are there still editors?

    • Replies: @Ben tillman
    @Jim Lahey

    No, I don’t think there are editors anymore.

  41. @Desiderius
    https://twitter.com/Erik26958705/status/1426994626544742403?s=20

    Replies: @Mr. Anon

    Building actual resilient networked communities is the foundation of whatever is next

    — Diomedes Appreciator (@Erik26958705) August 15, 2021

    Australia’s way ahead of the curve on that. Check out their new Detention Camp Centre for National Resilience.

    https://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/national/victoria/construction-of-mickleham-quarantine-camp-is-under-way-20210812-p58i50.html

    Resilience Centre! That sounds so much better than “Concentration Camp”.

  42. @Reg Cæsar
    @Achmed E. Newman


    I don’t know how iSteve can stand it. It’s like cleaning out the sewer line. Someone’s gotta do it, but I’d guess the plumbing pays better.
     
    Back in the previous century, Michael Medved said his job as a film critic made him a "glorified sewer inspector". I'm sure Steve can relate to that.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @iDeplorable

    Back in the previous century, Michael Medved said his job as a film critic made him a “glorified sewer inspector“. I’m sure Steve can relate to that.

    At heart, Michael Medved probably agrees with Rubin.

  43. They should remake Red Dawn again but don’t bother with the enemy parachuting in.

    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
    @Ghost of Bull Moose

    I've been writing a lot about these modern Commies lately and had completely forgot about this post, Commies through the Ages, in which Red Dawn was referred to:


    I don't think there's any question that people of a left-wing bent, let's call it, have infiltrated all the institutions of the United States over the last 50 years. That means the Universities, the Media, Government at many levels, and even lower education. Peak Stupidity sees this as the successful campaign on the internal front in the Cold War, of which we won the campaign on the external front exactly 3 decades ago. We don't claim the people involved to be part of armies or any organizations that are related to those on the other side of the external Cold War. It's just that the results are the same as if America had been overrun during an operation Red Dawn, with the Reds having taken control of the whole show here, just the same.

    [SNIP]

    Yes, we are dealing with the same kind of people that the Russians failed to deal successfully with, the Chinese succumbed to, the Cubans, the Cambodians, and so on. We are much more heavily armed*. We need to understand this 2nd front of the war and who the enemy is. They will not be parachuting into Colorado. They don't need to. Those in the picture above are the enemy. No, don't ask them about the struggles of the proletariat and, no, they don't go carrying pictures of Chairman Mao.
     
  44. It was never “theirs” to begin with, and the assumption that something is amiss if White Christians are not in charge is the essence of white supremacy and Christian nationalism. It is also fundamentally un-American; our country is defined, as President Biden rightly says, by an “idea.”

    But Rubin certainly thinks the county is “ours” (her “ours”, not mine). Anyway, she needn’t worry. I certainly don’t believe that White Christians are in charge of this country.

    I’m really sick of this “America is an idea” bullshit. Think about what that really means. If America is an idea, then your “Americanness” is defined by your alliegiance to that idea. i.e., you must think a certain way to be “American”. Isn’t such mandated conformity of thought what used to be called “Un-American”? Who says I agree with this “Idea”, whatever it is? What if I don’t? Of course, it’s all just a feint. What it really means is “Don’t notice while we turn your country inside out, vandalize it, and loot whatever can be taken”.

    • Replies: @Anon
    @Mr. Anon


    If America is an idea, then your “Americanness” is defined by your alliegiance to that idea. i.e., you must think a certain way to be “American”.
     
    That sounds like a religion. And one whose standards of entry, which would be available to all 7 billion of the earth’s inhabitants, are lower than those of Christianity, Islam, and (treating it as a religion for the sake of comparison only) Judaism.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    , @The Germ Theory of Disease
    @Mr. Anon

    If America is just an "idea," then we can simply write the idea down on a piece of paper and mail it to the Third World, and then they won't have to bother coming here, they can just stay home and enjoy the idea.

    Replies: @jo shmo

  45. @Triteleia Laxa
    I outlined Rubin's article for her, before she wrote it, as you requested here:

    They’re fully committed to the 2022 election. It seems ridiculously facile to base your entire worldview on partisan politics, but that’s where they are. Maybe they’ll contrast the rising tide of diversity with the “monochrome” Republican party and then use that to imply unfair gerrymandering and implicit racism. They’ll also try to represent themlsves as the patriots, if only as of the last 2 minutes, with some “We Iz Americca, we Iz patriots” stuff. I’ll give bonus points to any journalist who does this and dismisses all who disagree with them as Confederate rebels who need to be Sherman’d, with yet more absurd reference to Jan 6th as a terrorist insurgency threat that is the Confederate Attakkk/Pearl Harbour/9/11 combined.

    https://www.unz.com/isteve/how-will-the-press-spin-thursdays-census-announcement-of-a-declining-number-of-whites/#comment-4836289

    Replies: @Polistra

    It seems ridiculously facile to base your entire worldview on partisan politics, but that’s where they are

    Facile? Or just effective? Casting every situation as good guys vs. bad guys may be oversimplifying just a tad, but it works for the vast majority of people. Notice how wars tend to be won by the good guys?

    • Replies: @Triteleia Laxa
    @Polistra

    It is effective at the partisan game, though the game is also rigged so that no one side wins for very long, which makes it a weird game to sacrifice more important things to play at.

    Replies: @Polistra

  46. Make sure to forward Rubin’s screed to your bourgeois (left/right, rich/poor no difference) friends and relations. They somehow think that this will not turn out bad for them. In fact, knowing yourself as the alt in the circle, they may approach you to discuss this looming disaster. At no point give them reassurance. Do not soothe their fear and anxieties. Contrary, pour it on. Let them no, without ambiguity, that the future of themselves and their own progeny will be fraught with violence, poverty, insecurity, strife and despair, all because their parents/grandparents couldn’t stand up to cucks and haters. This may make you feel a little better.

    Oh yeah, and notice the concern Rubin has for the GOP. Ha! I thought Rubin was sharper than that. People/friends NEVER vote Republican. Sit out elections if needs be. Sooner the cucks are swept from the scene the sooner we can organize some resistance and grab onto some usable real estate.

  47. @Desiderius
    Where did they get the idea we were the surrendering type?

    https://twitter.com/tummymuncher/status/1427021381456343043?s=20

    Replies: @The Wild Geese Howard, @Currahee, @Polistra, @AceDeuce

    It’s absolutely ridiculous for people to keep making these Saigon comparisons. The situations are nothing alike. No Viet Cong, for example. Plus, Kabul is at a much higher elevation and has considerably colder winters. People should try thinking about things before just saying whatever comes into their minds.

    • Replies: @Bill
    @Polistra

    Genius comment.

  48. @Ghost of Bull Moose
    They should remake Red Dawn again but don’t bother with the enemy parachuting in.

    Replies: @Achmed E. Newman

    I’ve been writing a lot about these modern Commies lately and had completely forgot about this post, Commies through the Ages, in which Red Dawn was referred to:

    I don’t think there’s any question that people of a left-wing bent, let’s call it, have infiltrated all the institutions of the United States over the last 50 years. That means the Universities, the Media, Government at many levels, and even lower education. Peak Stupidity sees this as the successful campaign on the internal front in the Cold War, of which we won the campaign on the external front exactly 3 decades ago. We don’t claim the people involved to be part of armies or any organizations that are related to those on the other side of the external Cold War. It’s just that the results are the same as if America had been overrun during an operation Red Dawn, with the Reds having taken control of the whole show here, just the same.

    [SNIP]

    Yes, we are dealing with the same kind of people that the Russians failed to deal successfully with, the Chinese succumbed to, the Cubans, the Cambodians, and so on. We are much more heavily armed*. We need to understand this 2nd front of the war and who the enemy is. They will not be parachuting into Colorado. They don’t need to. Those in the picture above are the enemy. No, don’t ask them about the struggles of the proletariat and, no, they don’t go carrying pictures of Chairman Mao.

  49. Good thing Jennifer Rubin is not some genocidal maniac, or else she’d be out writing some crazy shit…

    Seriously, do they not think there will be any blowback from this? You effectively disenfranchise the former majority population by swamping them with new populations, demonize them from every major media platform, justify attacks against them, and plot out ways to take all of their wealth, and they are just going to sit back and take it? They’re just going to shut up, keep working for less and less, keep paying more and more taxes, keep sending their kids off to the military? That all that magically created wealth getting hoovered up by the parasite classes will keep getting created?

    • Replies: @Hangnail Hans
    @Che Blutarsky

    You're essentially asking: aren't white people suddenly going to see through decades of mass media propaganda and stage a revolt against the ruling class?

    Does this question really need answering at this point? With each passing year, more and more people are drinking the kool-aid and remarking on its delightful flavor. More and more people. Not fewer and fewer.

    Replies: @San Fernando Curt, @Ben tillman

    , @Reality Check (Tikkun Olam)
    @Che Blutarsky

    They control every institution in the West, including financial and media.

    People won't fight back because their propaganda is so effective; more to the point, they were allowed a monopoly over major media content and flow.

    Essentially, 90% of the public takes in their propaganda, including from gatekeepers like Dave Rubin and his ilk (liberalism for America, Likudism for Israel, Talmudism for Jews to rule and goy to race mix/serve).

    This happened because the WASP elite did exactly zero to protect this country's infrastructure from these rats over a century ago. A sickening state.

    But hey, there are some brilliant Holocaust documentaries coming this year. Because genocide is the most evil thing in human history.

    And what happened to the Jews is so unique that it's literally THE Holocaust. There can be only one.

  50. @Jenner Ickham Errican
    Rubin:

    That reality has, of course, freaked out a significant share of White Christians who do not see “their America” as predominate. It was never “theirs” to begin with
     
    (((Echoes))) of Jon Leibowitz’s rant in 2016 (11 minutes in) :

    This country isn’t yours! You don’t own it! It never was! There is no real America!
     
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mNiqpBNE9ik&t=660s

    Replies: @John Johnson, @Hangnail Hans

    Media Jew:

    This country isn’t yours! It never was! There is no real America!

    “Crowd Goes Wild”

  51. Jennifer Rubin looks like a half woman/half chimanzee on TV. At least Charles Blow looks human.

    • Replies: @Reg Cæsar
    @anon


    Jennifer Rubin looks like a half woman/half chimanzee on TV. At least Charles Blow looks human.
     
    Looks Negro to me. Perhaps it's the Backpfeifengesicht which gives you that impression.
  52. The “flight from white” is real. If just removed all the racial preferences, this would largely disappear and people would stop claiming non white status.

    Even better, if we instituted real white privilege and have preferences to whites like we did blacks for the last 50 years, everyone would claim white status.

    • Replies: @3g4me
    @Gaius Gracchus

    @52 Gaius Gracchus: "Even better, if we instituted real white privilege and have preferences to whites like we did blacks for the last 50 years, everyone would claim white status."

    Great idea! Having people like Rubin, along with Fang Fang and Ashok and Jameel all claim White status would solve everything! Isn't it wonderful how easily things like genetics can be overcome by brilliant ideas?

  53. @Polistra
    @Triteleia Laxa

    It seems ridiculously facile to base your entire worldview on partisan politics, but that’s where they are
     

    Facile? Or just effective? Casting every situation as good guys vs. bad guys may be oversimplifying just a tad, but it works for the vast majority of people. Notice how wars tend to be won by the good guys?

    Replies: @Triteleia Laxa

    It is effective at the partisan game, though the game is also rigged so that no one side wins for very long, which makes it a weird game to sacrifice more important things to play at.

    • Replies: @Polistra
    @Triteleia Laxa




    It is effective at the partisan game, though the game is also rigged so that no one side wins for very long...
     
    Just watch.
  54. @Triteleia Laxa
    @Polistra

    It is effective at the partisan game, though the game is also rigged so that no one side wins for very long, which makes it a weird game to sacrifice more important things to play at.

    Replies: @Polistra

    It is effective at the partisan game, though the game is also rigged so that no one side wins for very long…

    Just watch.

  55. If it’s not static, it can also get whiter. There’s no reason it has to be a one-way ratchet. Denmark is nicer than the Democratic Republic of the Congo; run on an immigration policy that makes us more like Denmark.

    • Replies: @SunBakedSuburb
    @Dave Pinsen

    "run on an immigration policy that makes us more like Denmark"

    You will have to import Danes to do that. My experience with these people is they like to visit America, experience the wild life and such, but feel a measure of relief when they board the SAS jetliner for Kobenhavn. They quite like their manicured, homogenous, and boring little land. Rethink your plan!

  56. That traditional Jewish hatred of rural peasants is strong with this one.

  57. @Che Blutarsky
    Good thing Jennifer Rubin is not some genocidal maniac, or else she'd be out writing some crazy shit...

    Seriously, do they not think there will be any blowback from this? You effectively disenfranchise the former majority population by swamping them with new populations, demonize them from every major media platform, justify attacks against them, and plot out ways to take all of their wealth, and they are just going to sit back and take it? They're just going to shut up, keep working for less and less, keep paying more and more taxes, keep sending their kids off to the military? That all that magically created wealth getting hoovered up by the parasite classes will keep getting created?

    Replies: @Hangnail Hans, @Reality Check (Tikkun Olam)

    You’re essentially asking: aren’t white people suddenly going to see through decades of mass media propaganda and stage a revolt against the ruling class?

    Does this question really need answering at this point? With each passing year, more and more people are drinking the kool-aid and remarking on its delightful flavor. More and more people. Not fewer and fewer.

    • Replies: @San Fernando Curt
    @Hangnail Hans

    Hasn't started hurting yet. When it starts hurting, duck.

    , @Ben tillman
    @Hangnail Hans

    More and more drink the Kool-Aid while more and more notice what’s happening. The middle is disappearing.

  58. @Anonymous
    Dear Steve,

    Although your diagnoses are almost invariably correct, reading you for two decades left me wondering what value they offer. Mostly, you preach to the choir. The propaganda/conversion value seems to be quite low (naturally so). Your output can be more efficient/valuable if you start offering your thoughts on what is to be done about it. You must have thought about it. Why not up your societal value and start suggesting some practical ways to counteract what are effectively white extermination tendencies?

    Because, frankly, only constantly complaining about it is a sort of mental masturbation.

    Replies: @anonymous, @SafeNow, @epebble

    Your output can be more efficient/valuable if you start offering your thoughts on what is to be done about it.

    Everyone has a role to play. Steve is very effective in his. How about some other people step up and carry the ball?

  59. @Citizen of a Silly Country

    It is also fundamentally un-American; our country is defined, as President Biden rightly says, by an “idea.”
     
    Our country defined by an "idea." Isn't that Citizenism?

    Steve, do you really want to be on their side?

    Replies: @Elsewhere

    That’s not citizenism. Citizenism simply means returning to “for us and for our posterity” with those who are currently citizens. This means that current citizens can decide to be choosy about who else, if any, are allowed to become new citizens. Indeed, they have a strong incentive to be choosy.

    • LOL: 3g4me
    • Replies: @Citizen of a Silly Country
    @Elsewhere

    Whites will very soon be a minority of American citizens. Whose posterity are you talking about?

    Just because you're not ethnocentric,that doesn't mean other groups aren't.

    Citizenism is the idea that you owe as much loyalty to someone who possesses a piece of paper - American citizenship - as you do to your own extended family.

    I disagree. So does history.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar, @Anonymous

    , @ATBOTL
    @Elsewhere


    That’s not citizenism. Citizenism simply means returning to “for us and for our posterity” with those who are currently citizens. This means that current citizens can decide to be choosy about who else, if any, are allowed to become new citizens. Indeed, they have a strong incentive to be choosy.
     
    What a joke. Black car jackers, Chinese spies, Somalians, Guatemalans and H1B Indians who fired all the whites in the office are our "fellow citizens" nows. Their agenda on immigration is to open the border as wide as possible and that won't change.
  60. Anon[200] • Disclaimer says:
    @Mr. Anon

    It was never “theirs” to begin with, and the assumption that something is amiss if White Christians are not in charge is the essence of white supremacy and Christian nationalism. It is also fundamentally un-American; our country is defined, as President Biden rightly says, by an “idea.”
     
    But Rubin certainly thinks the county is "ours" (her "ours", not mine). Anyway, she needn't worry. I certainly don't believe that White Christians are in charge of this country.

    I'm really sick of this "America is an idea" bullshit. Think about what that really means. If America is an idea, then your "Americanness" is defined by your alliegiance to that idea. i.e., you must think a certain way to be "American". Isn't such mandated conformity of thought what used to be called "Un-American"? Who says I agree with this "Idea", whatever it is? What if I don't? Of course, it's all just a feint. What it really means is "Don't notice while we turn your country inside out, vandalize it, and loot whatever can be taken".

    Replies: @Anon, @The Germ Theory of Disease

    If America is an idea, then your “Americanness” is defined by your alliegiance to that idea. i.e., you must think a certain way to be “American”.

    That sounds like a religion. And one whose standards of entry, which would be available to all 7 billion of the earth’s inhabitants, are lower than those of Christianity, Islam, and (treating it as a religion for the sake of comparison only) Judaism.

    • Replies: @John Johnson
    @Anon

    That sounds like a religion. And one whose standards of entry, which would be available to all 7 billion of the earth’s inhabitants, are lower than those of Christianity, Islam, and (treating it as a religion for the sake of comparison only) Judaism.

    America is totally a religion and we just saw the result of both parties trying to spread it in Afghanistan.

    Both parties think there is some special equation that can turn any third world country into America or better and the populace doesn't matter. If you ask members from either party as to why this hasn't worked in a single instance they will respond with predictable answers like:
    They needed more freedom
    They needed more Christianity
    White people are to blame
    The government is to blame
    They needed more women involved
    They needed more capitalism
    You're just a racist

  61. @Clyde
    Jennifer Rubin and Charles Blow. Two disgusting people in one day here.

    Replies: @Achmed E. Newman, @Citizen of a Silly Country

    Blow is just a low level clerk. Rubin is part the ruling tribe. Don’t conflate the two.

  62. The idea, upon this country was founded, is definitely lost on these idiotic, left-wing reporters.

    Hint: It wasn’t tuition-free, compulsory, public education.

  63. Hey, at least she capitalized White. So tired of winning!

  64. @Mike Tre
    Sort of related: So what's the ratio of Haitian refugees admitted to the US related to deaths from this latest earthquake? 20:1?

    1300 hundred dead so far, so that would be 26,000 thousand Haitians to be admitted to the US. Quick, someone find out where the whitest places in the country are, so we know exact where to put them!

    Replies: @John Johnson

    1300 hundred dead so far, so that would be 26,000 thousand Haitians to be admitted to the US. Quick, someone find out where the whitest places in the country are, so we know exact where to put them!

    Democrats run the government so they will put Haitians and Africans in White areas and Afghans in Black areas.

    My wife knows someone that was forced to open a business in a Black area to get a green card. Those Koreans in Black areas aren’t there by choice.

    Anyone can get into the US if they show that they have the money to open a business and will go where they are told. It actually takes quite a bit of capital though, over 100k and there are a bunch of rules to make sure you aren’t scamming the system.

  65. @Hangnail Hans
    https://i.ibb.co/2WyMSfX/Capture-2021-08-15-19-48-39-2.png

    Replies: @Gary in Gramercy

    Lieu’s a typical (i.e., hypocritical) Democrat, but does anyone seriously think Stanford can be bought for a \$50,000 contribution when it took \$5 million to get Jared Kushner into Harvard?

    A space in Stanford’s entering freshman class probably goes for a low seven-figure sum — although the child of a legacy Congressman might qualify for a discount.

    Note, however, that Lieu is too cheap to attempt a bribe of Stanford with his own money. That’s the real outrage.

    • Replies: @Barnard
    @Gary in Gramercy

    Lieu being a member of Congress could explain the lower price. $50k plus various favors to be named later would be reasonable for Stanford.

  66. Anonymous[851] • Disclaimer says:

    Rubin may be calling for white capitulation, but is she wrong? The day is rapidly approaching when forces hostile to whites achieve an unassailable hold on all three branches of government, all the major corporate and non corporate institutions, and all military/police forces. It is important to note that this phenomenon isn’t isolated to the United States, as all major and minor white nations are undergoing a similar transformation. Even Russia is a very tenuous stronghold for whites to hinge their hopes on, as it has fallen into Globo control twice in just the previous century and is at least as likely as not to fall into those hands again by the time the demographic transition of the Western whites is complete.

    All of which is to say whites will soon find themselves powerless minorities across the board, without a single major nation state to act as their agent and protector. There will be nowhere to run to and no means by which to fight, which is why Rubin is absolutely justified to call for a white unconditional surrender. The irrevocable end of White Supremacy is a done deal at this point and its best case replacement is White Servility. Placing themselves at the mercy of people who will surely demand payback for historical wrongs real or perceived is certainly a bitter pill for whites to swallow, but in reality it’s the only option. As the famous line goes, whites can either do this the easy way or the hard way, and the hard way could lead to something far worse than merely second class citizenship and servitude.

    So Rubin’s position is certainly reasonable from a pure realpolitik perspective, but I would further argue it is also justified from a moral standpoint. I’m not referring to the pathetic notions of turning the other cheek and the “golden rule” that landed whites in this predicament in the first place. Rather I am referring to the only true morality, that of natural law. Whites have been on a bender of acting like effeminate, servile nu-humans for so long that they have just about become the perfect servant race. When they get hit they ask their attacker for forgiveness, when they accomplish something objectivity good they self flagellate and apologize for showing up the competition.

    There have been many peoples throughout history who have been conquered and enslaved through sheer discrepancy in numbers and firepower and though no fault of their own. In the case of the whites, their enslavement will come DESPITE having the whole balance of power on their side and purely due to an inherent defect of being mincing, virtue sniveling cucklings who delight in what I will politely term the “receptive” role in intra-racial interactions. If there has ever been a category of people who richly deserve their coming fate it is surely the white race in the 21st century. Whites have become so increasingly degenerate and eager to please that it’s possible by the time the 2050s and 60s roll around they will fully embrace the role of peasant and bed wench for the saintly superior people of color.

    But easy way or hard way it ultimately doesn’t matter. White Supremacy is coming to an end, and it is time for whites to face up to reality the same way conquered people had to throughout the ages when the new overlords dusted themselves off from the victorious battle came whip in hand to collect the spoils. As the bible says, there is nothing new under the sun.

    • Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @Anonymous


    All of which is to say whites will soon find themselves powerless minorities across the board, without a single major nation state to act as their agent and protector. There will be nowhere to run to and no means by which to fight, which is why Rubin is absolutely justified to call for a white unconditional surrender.
     
    LOL. You’re forgetting all the guns and ammo in the United States in civilian hands. You think there will be peace? Oh sweet summa chyle
    , @3g4me
    @Anonymous

    @66 Anonymous [851]:

    tl;dr Spread wide, close your eyes, and think of muh constitution.

  67. @Intelligent Dasein
    Jennifer Rubin's position here is completely factually inaccurate. But even setting that aside, if we grant for argument's sake that hers is an opinion possible to hold, it is neither original to her nor does it receive from her any particular force of expression.

    In other words, this is not-even-wrong, secondhand dreck.

    And we pay people to write like this?

    Replies: @kaganovitch, @Bill

    And we pay people to write like this?

    Unless your name is Bezos,”we” don’t do anything of the sort.

  68. @Anon
    @Mr. Anon


    If America is an idea, then your “Americanness” is defined by your alliegiance to that idea. i.e., you must think a certain way to be “American”.
     
    That sounds like a religion. And one whose standards of entry, which would be available to all 7 billion of the earth’s inhabitants, are lower than those of Christianity, Islam, and (treating it as a religion for the sake of comparison only) Judaism.

    Replies: @John Johnson

    That sounds like a religion. And one whose standards of entry, which would be available to all 7 billion of the earth’s inhabitants, are lower than those of Christianity, Islam, and (treating it as a religion for the sake of comparison only) Judaism.

    America is totally a religion and we just saw the result of both parties trying to spread it in Afghanistan.

    Both parties think there is some special equation that can turn any third world country into America or better and the populace doesn’t matter. If you ask members from either party as to why this hasn’t worked in a single instance they will respond with predictable answers like:
    They needed more freedom
    They needed more Christianity
    White people are to blame
    The government is to blame
    They needed more women involved
    They needed more capitalism
    You’re just a racist

  69. @anon
    Jennifer Rubin looks like a half woman/half chimanzee on TV. At least Charles Blow looks human.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar

    Jennifer Rubin looks like a half woman/half chimanzee on TV. At least Charles Blow looks human.

    Looks Negro to me. Perhaps it’s the Backpfeifengesicht which gives you that impression.

  70. Wait until Dick finds out what they were up to last summer.

    And this winter.

  71. • Replies: @J.Ross
    @Desiderius

    Yes, Tariq Ali claims (per docs, allegedly) that the Soyuz was actually cool with a divine-right monarchy on their border, because (1) there's nothing there anyway (but the bones of would-be conquerors) and (2) that was one stretch of border they didn't have to worry about. When they invaded, it was because their local pet idiots had undertaken a coup on their own and hashed it beyond polite pullout halfway through.
    Comparison: the Soviet withdrawal from Afghanistan was pretty good, it's seen as one of the things they did right. Our gerontocracy has already utterly failed to do as well as the late-stage Soviet Union. Let that sink in like an undercooled reactor core. Right now the Taliban has the Kabul airport (which we kind of need) surrounded and is taking shots at their leisure like they used to do with Tommy.
    Minimally Reanimated Corpse Biden just had a press conference in which he literally put all responsibility on Trump and the Afghans (what, no fancybear?) and then walked out without answering questions. Hohnecker in his final days was more credible.

  72. @Anonymous
    Dear Steve,

    Although your diagnoses are almost invariably correct, reading you for two decades left me wondering what value they offer. Mostly, you preach to the choir. The propaganda/conversion value seems to be quite low (naturally so). Your output can be more efficient/valuable if you start offering your thoughts on what is to be done about it. You must have thought about it. Why not up your societal value and start suggesting some practical ways to counteract what are effectively white extermination tendencies?

    Because, frankly, only constantly complaining about it is a sort of mental masturbation.

    Replies: @anonymous, @SafeNow, @epebble

    “Why not up your societal value and start suggesting some practical ways to counteract…” (addressed to Steve)

    Fair question. I will hazard a guess. I am assuming that by “practical,” you mean effective, and not perfunctory and useless. Steve is in good company. All the essayists, and commenters, have uniformly declined to do what you ask. If commenters have ever been specific and unmeasured, we did not see it, because it was moderated. I have posted “So what, specifically, is the plan of procedure?” many times, to no avail. The reason for not stating specifics, in my view, is this: If woke, quasi-religious ruthlessness continues to accelerate, the consequences of advocating specifics might, some day, be horrendous.

    I write this as a coward. As I have posted before, I was a spineless student at an “elite” New England university exactly when this all began, the late 60s.

    I am quite satisfied taking enjoyment in Steve’s great wit, insight, and intelligence as he observes and analyzes the world. (No, I am not his cousin.)

    • Replies: @Intelligent Dasein
    @SafeNow


    If commenters have ever been specific and unmeasured, we did not see it, because it was moderated.
     
    I have a general idea of a plan, and I have posted many versions of it here before. However, the rest of the commentariat engages in some pretty vicious crabology whenever anyone around here tries to be useful.

    The blog seems to be a place where mostly 50-something, well-off, embittered and perpetually constipated IYIs come to belch out their discomfort. They don't want that to change.

    Replies: @Anonymous, @Polistra, @iDeplorable

    , @Nicholas Stix, @Marty T
    @SafeNow

    It's probably the job of those that are younger than Steve (30s and 40s) to figure out what to do about it. And there are things to do. As long as we have tens of millions, land and weapons galore, don't tell me there's nothing that can be done.

    South Africa is 10 percent white. We're 58 percent white. Come on now.

    Replies: @Mrwolf

  73. • Thanks: Polistra, 3g4me
  74. @Jiminy
    Times like these are when the rural whites need to remind the urbanites just how much they need, what do you call it, ah yes food. Meats, grains, fruits and vegetables and of course taters, precious. Without fries America will come to a stand still. Not French fries of course, but freedom fries. They might lose their patience, but they won’t lose their appetites.

    Replies: @SaneClownPosse, @znon, @Bill

  75. @Elsewhere
    @Citizen of a Silly Country

    That's not citizenism. Citizenism simply means returning to "for us and for our posterity" with those who are currently citizens. This means that current citizens can decide to be choosy about who else, if any, are allowed to become new citizens. Indeed, they have a strong incentive to be choosy.

    Replies: @Citizen of a Silly Country, @ATBOTL

    Whites will very soon be a minority of American citizens. Whose posterity are you talking about?

    Just because you’re not ethnocentric,that doesn’t mean other groups aren’t.

    Citizenism is the idea that you owe as much loyalty to someone who possesses a piece of paper – American citizenship – as you do to your own extended family.

    I disagree. So does history.

    • Replies: @Reg Cæsar
    @Citizen of a Silly Country


    Citizenism is the idea that you owe as much loyalty to someone who possesses a piece of paper – American citizenship – as you do to your own extended family.
     
    "Citizenism is the idea that you owe as much loyalty to someone who possesses a piece of paper –


    https://npr.brightspotcdn.com/dims4/default/98b6399/2147483647/strip/true/crop/901x492+0+0/resize/880x481!/quality/90/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fnpr-brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com%2Flegacy%2Fsites%2Fwunc%2Ffiles%2F201509%2FDeedofSale_small_forWeb.jpg



    "– as you do to your own extended family."


    ("$425 in 1811 is worth $8,856.97 today")

    I disagree. So does history.
     
    Yup.
    , @Anonymous
    @Citizen of a Silly Country


    Citizenism is the idea that you owe as much loyalty to someone who possesses a piece of paper – American citizenship – as you do to your own extended family.
     
    To borrow from Joe Sobran: Citizenism would be a massive improvement over what we have now. It is clearly what we should be aiming for.

    Replies: @Citizen of a Silly Country, @Saxon

  76. @SafeNow
    @Anonymous

    “Why not up your societal value and start suggesting some practical ways to counteract…” (addressed to Steve)

    Fair question. I will hazard a guess. I am assuming that by “practical,” you mean effective, and not perfunctory and useless. Steve is in good company. All the essayists, and commenters, have uniformly declined to do what you ask. If commenters have ever been specific and unmeasured, we did not see it, because it was moderated. I have posted “So what, specifically, is the plan of procedure?” many times, to no avail. The reason for not stating specifics, in my view, is this: If woke, quasi-religious ruthlessness continues to accelerate, the consequences of advocating specifics might, some day, be horrendous.

    I write this as a coward. As I have posted before, I was a spineless student at an “elite” New England university exactly when this all began, the late 60s.

    I am quite satisfied taking enjoyment in Steve’s great wit, insight, and intelligence as he observes and analyzes the world. (No, I am not his cousin.)

    Replies: @Intelligent Dasein, @Nicholas Stix, @Marty T

    If commenters have ever been specific and unmeasured, we did not see it, because it was moderated.

    I have a general idea of a plan, and I have posted many versions of it here before. However, the rest of the commentariat engages in some pretty vicious crabology whenever anyone around here tries to be useful.

    The blog seems to be a place where mostly 50-something, well-off, embittered and perpetually constipated IYIs come to belch out their discomfort. They don’t want that to change.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    @Intelligent Dasein


    The blog seems to be a place where mostly 50-something, well-off, embittered and perpetually constipated IYIs come to belch out their discomfort. They don’t want that to change.
     
    Sadly, it does seem to be this way. More and more, this is reminiscent of Russian intelligentsia bitching helplessly about Bolsheviks all the while the Bolsheviks were looting and pillaging the country.
    , @Polistra
    @Intelligent Dasein



    the commentariat engages in some pretty vicious crabology [...]

    The blog seems to be a place where mostly 50-something, well-off, embittered and perpetually constipated IYIs come to belch out their discomfort.
     
    Classic I.D. "I hate everyone--and why am I not more popular?"

    Replies: @Intelligent Dasein, @Professional Slav

    , @iDeplorable
    @Intelligent Dasein


    have a general idea of a plan, and I have posted many versions of it here before. However, the rest....a place where mostly 50-something, well-off, embittered and perpetually constipated IYIs come to belch out their discomfort.
     
    Aren't you special and brave? Fag.

    Instead of spelling out your "plan" anonymously on a blog, go out and DO something other than calling yourself intelligent.

  77. @SaneClownPosse
    @Jiminy

    Why do you think they are developing meatless meats?

    Replies: @Jiminy

    My wife made the mistake of buying a box of vegan prawns. They’re not prawns that solely eat vegetables, but things that resemble lumps of foam rubber, and the taste is beyond description, so I won’t bother you with it. But if I had the future in my hands, then they can keep it. I think I’ll start hunting rats, sparrows and pigeons to survive.

    • Replies: @Joe Stalin
    @Jiminy


    I’ll start hunting rats
     
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XcDfWj3Sek0

    RAT Meat is Good.

    -- Shawn Woods
     
  78. @Hangnail Hans
    @JimDandy

    Rubin has always been pretty transparent about this stuff. There's little need to hide it anymore anyway.


    White Christians... the demographic and cultural tide washing over them.
     
    This is just part of their victory dance.

    PS; Did she really say "predominate" instead of predominant? Oh I forgot--grammar is white people stuff.

    Replies: @Richard B, @Ben tillman

    Rubin has always been pretty transparent about this stuff. There’s little need to hide it anymore anyway.

    She might have to hide it when TSHTF, as it always seems to do with them.

    The kind of thinking that goes into infiltration, subversion, radical ingratitude, insane hatred, destruction and death is not the kind of thinking needed for competent social management. And, the fact is, they’ve never been very good at that and never will be.

    They’ve been at this forever. Babylon, Persia, Egypt, Greece, Rome, Christian Europe, Secular Europe, the revolutions of 17th century England, 18th century France, 20th century Russia and now the USA.

    Speaking of which, given the condition the USA is in right now, their victory dance is more like a Pyrrhic Victory dance. Not much to brag about. And now what’s next?

    China. A people who, unlike whites, don’t strike one as being all that into power-sharing, or being pushed around. In short, maybe Jewish Supremacy Inc. has has finally reached the end of the line. Where to next for them? The moon?

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    @Richard B


    They’ve been at this forever. Babylon, Persia, Egypt, Greece, Rome, Christian Europe, Secular Europe, the revolutions of 17th century England, 18th century France, 20th century Russia and now the USA.
     
    What would you say the “this” is?

    Replies: @The Germ Theory of Disease

    , @Ben tillman
    @Richard B

    Agreed.

  79. @Citizen of a Silly Country
    @Elsewhere

    Whites will very soon be a minority of American citizens. Whose posterity are you talking about?

    Just because you're not ethnocentric,that doesn't mean other groups aren't.

    Citizenism is the idea that you owe as much loyalty to someone who possesses a piece of paper - American citizenship - as you do to your own extended family.

    I disagree. So does history.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar, @Anonymous

    Citizenism is the idea that you owe as much loyalty to someone who possesses a piece of paper – American citizenship – as you do to your own extended family.

    “Citizenism is the idea that you owe as much loyalty to someone who possesses a piece of paper –

    “– as you do to your own extended family.”

    (“\$425 in 1811 is worth \$8,856.97 today“)

    I disagree. So does history.

    Yup.

  80. @Citizen of a Silly Country
    @Elsewhere

    Whites will very soon be a minority of American citizens. Whose posterity are you talking about?

    Just because you're not ethnocentric,that doesn't mean other groups aren't.

    Citizenism is the idea that you owe as much loyalty to someone who possesses a piece of paper - American citizenship - as you do to your own extended family.

    I disagree. So does history.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar, @Anonymous

    Citizenism is the idea that you owe as much loyalty to someone who possesses a piece of paper – American citizenship – as you do to your own extended family.

    To borrow from Joe Sobran: Citizenism would be a massive improvement over what we have now. It is clearly what we should be aiming for.

    • Replies: @Citizen of a Silly Country
    @Anonymous

    Citizenism is a way to hide from the reality of our situation and not feel about your timidity.

    Citizenism may have had a chance to work forty years ago, though I doubt it would have worked then either. Regardless, it absolutely has no hope now. None. Zero.

    To pretend otherwise is delusional at best, cowardice at worst.

    , @Saxon
    @Anonymous

    Why should you aim for that when you can already see the rug will be pulled from underneath you as soon as you end up a vulnerable minority? Look at ghouls like that jewish WaPo writer, Jennifer Rubin. Same person who would talk about how important it is that minorities get their needs met and their voices heard is now saying that white minority rule MUST be prevented in the US. Biopower is all that matters. You need your people by blood on a land to maintain sovereignty and self-determination.

  81. @Anonymous
    Dear Steve,

    Although your diagnoses are almost invariably correct, reading you for two decades left me wondering what value they offer. Mostly, you preach to the choir. The propaganda/conversion value seems to be quite low (naturally so). Your output can be more efficient/valuable if you start offering your thoughts on what is to be done about it. You must have thought about it. Why not up your societal value and start suggesting some practical ways to counteract what are effectively white extermination tendencies?

    Because, frankly, only constantly complaining about it is a sort of mental masturbation.

    Replies: @anonymous, @SafeNow, @epebble

    I will bite. The reason no solutions are being offered is because the problems are intractable – in the sense that in the political system we have, a much higher degree of political agreement is needed than we have or can have in near future.

    I will elaborate:

    1. Many persons are commenting, generally, on low number of births and dysgenic births. This is due to a multiplicity of factors: Increased education of women, a desire by educated (and even less educated women) to work outside the home in paying jobs for the satisfaction of being active in society and also to increase family income to enjoy a higher standard of living (than possible by a single income). Obviously, this leads to smaller family sizes. This also leads to dysgenic births as more educated women will have fewer children than less educated women.

    Now, a crude “solution” may be to discourage women from post secondary education and employment to promote more domesticity and motherhood. But we do not have any political process to achieve that, even if some people find it desirable.

    2. Many people are commenting, generally on high level of immigration. Unfortunately, nearly two thirds of immigration is for family unification. Thus even though many people want to reduce immigration, no one knows who should be prevented from bringing a spouse, child or a parent from abroad. As for employment immigration, businesses have a lot of clout – and can also make fairness argument – if Joe Sixpack can import a car from Japan or Korea (because of Global Free Trade in goods), How can the government prevent an employer from hiring a worker from abroad (Free Trade in labor)? Since we (consumers) want imported goods for better quality/lower price, employer (consumer of labor) also insists on the same. And remember, when you pick stocks based on P/E ratio, you are not preferring employers that prefer to hire Americans over foreigners.

    These are just two example I have picked. However, For every problem discussed, I can easily show that all possible solutions are politically intractable.

    • Replies: @Neil Templeton
    @epebble

    How 'bout all the pro-birthrate White American folks move to Afghanistan, in return for an equal number of Afghans. Problem solved. New White American birthrate goes up in Afghanistan, new White Afghan immigrants get mired in the American version of "Graveyard of Empires."

  82. ‘…something is amiss if White Christians are not in charge…’

    I don’t suppose it’d do any good to point out that as a rule, when white Christians cease to be in charge, things almost invariably do go amiss?

    …and usually bloodily. Haiti, Bolshevik Russia, Indian partition, sub-Saharan Africa…

    Choo choo. Heeere we come!

  83. @John Johnson
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    (((Echoes))) of Jon Leibowitz’s rant in 2016 (11 minutes in)

    Yea thank God we have pro-White Christians like Steven Colbert to balance him out.

    Leibowitz is actually somewhat moderate while Colbert is a liberal's dream.

    Total race denier and constantly attacks the White mainstream.

    Colbert actually went after Stewart for suggesting that the virus could have come from a lab. Ironically he was clearly upset at Stewart for not following the MSM narrative.

    Steven fits the disfigured leftist perfectly. Kids probably made fun of his ear and now he is going to dedicate his life to attacking White society.

    I'm sure he has a small penis as well. His resentment vibes practically crack my tv screen.

    Leftist men tend to be very short, perverted/gay or have a disfigurement of some type. Gramsci was basically a dwarf with a limp. Robert Reich is 4'11. Even without Jewish leftists we would have this army of the bitter. Orwell actually wrote about this.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Steven fits the disfigured leftist perfectly. Kids probably made fun of his ear and now he is going to dedicate his life to attacking White society.

    I’m sure he has a small penis as well. His resentment vibes practically crack my tv screen.

    Leftist men tend to be very short, perverted/gay or have a disfigurement of some type. Gramsci was basically a dwarf with a limp. Robert Reich is 4’11. Even without Jewish leftists we would have this army of the bitter.

    Yes, I (more broadly) recently addressed the above here:

    https://www.unz.com/isteve/blackrock-is-looking-for-the-black-elizabeth-holmes/#comment-4820666 (#58)

    With Whites in America, it’s more complicated: Among “dissenters” there are Jews who are not White but sometimes claim to be Whites, there are gays, there are general malcontents—the latter can be divided into subcategories of: class resentment, personal awkwardness, poor socialization/broken homes, etc. I can get into specifics if you have certain subgroups in mind, at the risk of stating the obvious as with Blacks above.

    In short, what dissenters of any kind in America ‘need’, depending on subgroup, is varying combinations of retribution, public validation, and profitable/sexual “tangibles” to be paid to them.

  84. @SafeNow
    @Anonymous

    “Why not up your societal value and start suggesting some practical ways to counteract…” (addressed to Steve)

    Fair question. I will hazard a guess. I am assuming that by “practical,” you mean effective, and not perfunctory and useless. Steve is in good company. All the essayists, and commenters, have uniformly declined to do what you ask. If commenters have ever been specific and unmeasured, we did not see it, because it was moderated. I have posted “So what, specifically, is the plan of procedure?” many times, to no avail. The reason for not stating specifics, in my view, is this: If woke, quasi-religious ruthlessness continues to accelerate, the consequences of advocating specifics might, some day, be horrendous.

    I write this as a coward. As I have posted before, I was a spineless student at an “elite” New England university exactly when this all began, the late 60s.

    I am quite satisfied taking enjoyment in Steve’s great wit, insight, and intelligence as he observes and analyzes the world. (No, I am not his cousin.)

    Replies: @Intelligent Dasein, @Nicholas Stix, @Marty T

    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
    @Nicholas Stix

    Thanks, Nick. I just read your options. III seems the best option, and I don't see it as a political miracle. As I wrote in the recent PS post "Peak Stupidity, Pundits, and Governors, OH MY!", Federalism is not just for Constitutionalists anymore.

    Replies: @Nicholas Stix

  85. @Mr. Anon

    It was never “theirs” to begin with, and the assumption that something is amiss if White Christians are not in charge is the essence of white supremacy and Christian nationalism. It is also fundamentally un-American; our country is defined, as President Biden rightly says, by an “idea.”
     
    But Rubin certainly thinks the county is "ours" (her "ours", not mine). Anyway, she needn't worry. I certainly don't believe that White Christians are in charge of this country.

    I'm really sick of this "America is an idea" bullshit. Think about what that really means. If America is an idea, then your "Americanness" is defined by your alliegiance to that idea. i.e., you must think a certain way to be "American". Isn't such mandated conformity of thought what used to be called "Un-American"? Who says I agree with this "Idea", whatever it is? What if I don't? Of course, it's all just a feint. What it really means is "Don't notice while we turn your country inside out, vandalize it, and loot whatever can be taken".

    Replies: @Anon, @The Germ Theory of Disease

    If America is just an “idea,” then we can simply write the idea down on a piece of paper and mail it to the Third World, and then they won’t have to bother coming here, they can just stay home and enjoy the idea.

    • Agree: Mr. Anon
    • Thanks: Polistra, The Griffins
    • Replies: @jo shmo
    @The Germ Theory of Disease


    If America is just an “idea,” then we can simply write the idea down on a piece of paper and mail it to the Third World, and then they won’t have to bother coming here, they can just stay home and enjoy the idea.

     

    Comment of the Day!!
  86. I was thinking to about Tucker Carlson’s position on the Great Replacement. Specifically, that it all about getting enough Blue Team members that the D’s cannot lose.

    What color is the pill that is not quite accepting things? Pinkpilled? Regardless, The Blows and that Rubensesque creature don’t want you disenfranchised so they can have Team Blue in power forever. They want you disenfranchised because they hate you, and they want you dead.

    The last step of the plan is not, “they will never elect a President.” The last step is more like, “once upon a time, a pink-skinned race of demon-gods bestrode the land…”

    • Agree: Polistra
  87. Anonymous[419] • Disclaimer says:
    @Intelligent Dasein
    @SafeNow


    If commenters have ever been specific and unmeasured, we did not see it, because it was moderated.
     
    I have a general idea of a plan, and I have posted many versions of it here before. However, the rest of the commentariat engages in some pretty vicious crabology whenever anyone around here tries to be useful.

    The blog seems to be a place where mostly 50-something, well-off, embittered and perpetually constipated IYIs come to belch out their discomfort. They don't want that to change.

    Replies: @Anonymous, @Polistra, @iDeplorable

    The blog seems to be a place where mostly 50-something, well-off, embittered and perpetually constipated IYIs come to belch out their discomfort. They don’t want that to change.

    Sadly, it does seem to be this way. More and more, this is reminiscent of Russian intelligentsia bitching helplessly about Bolsheviks all the while the Bolsheviks were looting and pillaging the country.

    • Agree: 3g4me
  88. @Anon
    @JimDandy


    Well, she did a good job of openly and honestly articulating the Jewish-American plan.
     
    Waiting for a fellow Jewish-American to call her out on it.

    Meanwhile media jews are having a meltdown over the peaceful transfer of power in Afghanistan. The prospect of Muslims and Christians not being at each other’s throats, or otherwise in turmoil, seems to cause them a lot of anxiety.

    The anxiety probably is not limited just to Muslims and Christians getting along, or being unified and strong internally, but extends to any outgroups getting along or having their shit together.

    Replies: @JimDandy, @SunBakedSuburb

    And now if anyone suggests we get out of Iraq, they can scoff and say, “One word: Afghanistan.”

  89. @Intelligent Dasein
    @SafeNow


    If commenters have ever been specific and unmeasured, we did not see it, because it was moderated.
     
    I have a general idea of a plan, and I have posted many versions of it here before. However, the rest of the commentariat engages in some pretty vicious crabology whenever anyone around here tries to be useful.

    The blog seems to be a place where mostly 50-something, well-off, embittered and perpetually constipated IYIs come to belch out their discomfort. They don't want that to change.

    Replies: @Anonymous, @Polistra, @iDeplorable

    the commentariat engages in some pretty vicious crabology […]

    The blog seems to be a place where mostly 50-something, well-off, embittered and perpetually constipated IYIs come to belch out their discomfort.

    Classic I.D. “I hate everyone–and why am I not more popular?”

    • Replies: @Intelligent Dasein
    @Polistra

    Your paraphrase has not the same meaning as what I wrote. Not even close.

    This isn't the first time you've done something like that. Perhaps if you'd seek to understand before reacting, you might see things a little differently. On the other hand, if you want to behave like this, then it should surprise you least of all if I really was angry or hurt.

    , @Professional Slav
    @Polistra

    Looks like a nerve was hit right on the spot.

  90. @Richard B
    @Hangnail Hans


    Rubin has always been pretty transparent about this stuff. There’s little need to hide it anymore anyway.
     
    She might have to hide it when TSHTF, as it always seems to do with them.

    The kind of thinking that goes into infiltration, subversion, radical ingratitude, insane hatred, destruction and death is not the kind of thinking needed for competent social management. And, the fact is, they've never been very good at that and never will be.

    They've been at this forever. Babylon, Persia, Egypt, Greece, Rome, Christian Europe, Secular Europe, the revolutions of 17th century England, 18th century France, 20th century Russia and now the USA.

    Speaking of which, given the condition the USA is in right now, their victory dance is more like a Pyrrhic Victory dance. Not much to brag about. And now what's next?

    China. A people who, unlike whites, don't strike one as being all that into power-sharing, or being pushed around. In short, maybe Jewish Supremacy Inc. has has finally reached the end of the line. Where to next for them? The moon?

    Replies: @Anonymous, @Ben tillman

    They’ve been at this forever. Babylon, Persia, Egypt, Greece, Rome, Christian Europe, Secular Europe, the revolutions of 17th century England, 18th century France, 20th century Russia and now the USA.

    What would you say the “this” is?

    • Replies: @The Germ Theory of Disease
    @Anonymous

    "Would to God all the Lord's people were rent-seekers."
    -- Deuteronomy

  91. @Polistra
    @Intelligent Dasein



    the commentariat engages in some pretty vicious crabology [...]

    The blog seems to be a place where mostly 50-something, well-off, embittered and perpetually constipated IYIs come to belch out their discomfort.
     
    Classic I.D. "I hate everyone--and why am I not more popular?"

    Replies: @Intelligent Dasein, @Professional Slav

    Your paraphrase has not the same meaning as what I wrote. Not even close.

    This isn’t the first time you’ve done something like that. Perhaps if you’d seek to understand before reacting, you might see things a little differently. On the other hand, if you want to behave like this, then it should surprise you least of all if I really was angry or hurt.

  92. However, unless and until Americans in rural areas demand responsible governance, embrace the true “idea” of America and reject the temptation of racism and authoritarianism, little will change.

    In the meantime, urban Americans, who constitute a greater share of the population than ever before, will lose patience with anti-democratic techniques (e.g., the filibuster, voter suppression) designed to give rural Whites disproportionate power.

    TRANSLATION FROM BOLSHEVIK-SPEAK: if these damn kulaks don’t obey and behave, they will be arrested en masse, taken to forced labor camps, and then shot.

    P.S. if you want to know what’s coming. (re-)reading “Gulag Archipelago” might be a good idea just about now…

  93. @Anonymous
    @Richard B


    They’ve been at this forever. Babylon, Persia, Egypt, Greece, Rome, Christian Europe, Secular Europe, the revolutions of 17th century England, 18th century France, 20th century Russia and now the USA.
     
    What would you say the “this” is?

    Replies: @The Germ Theory of Disease

    “Would to God all the Lord’s people were rent-seekers.”
    — Deuteronomy

  94. @Anonymous
    Rubin may be calling for white capitulation, but is she wrong? The day is rapidly approaching when forces hostile to whites achieve an unassailable hold on all three branches of government, all the major corporate and non corporate institutions, and all military/police forces. It is important to note that this phenomenon isn't isolated to the United States, as all major and minor white nations are undergoing a similar transformation. Even Russia is a very tenuous stronghold for whites to hinge their hopes on, as it has fallen into Globo control twice in just the previous century and is at least as likely as not to fall into those hands again by the time the demographic transition of the Western whites is complete.

    All of which is to say whites will soon find themselves powerless minorities across the board, without a single major nation state to act as their agent and protector. There will be nowhere to run to and no means by which to fight, which is why Rubin is absolutely justified to call for a white unconditional surrender. The irrevocable end of White Supremacy is a done deal at this point and its best case replacement is White Servility. Placing themselves at the mercy of people who will surely demand payback for historical wrongs real or perceived is certainly a bitter pill for whites to swallow, but in reality it's the only option. As the famous line goes, whites can either do this the easy way or the hard way, and the hard way could lead to something far worse than merely second class citizenship and servitude.

    So Rubin's position is certainly reasonable from a pure realpolitik perspective, but I would further argue it is also justified from a moral standpoint. I'm not referring to the pathetic notions of turning the other cheek and the "golden rule" that landed whites in this predicament in the first place. Rather I am referring to the only true morality, that of natural law. Whites have been on a bender of acting like effeminate, servile nu-humans for so long that they have just about become the perfect servant race. When they get hit they ask their attacker for forgiveness, when they accomplish something objectivity good they self flagellate and apologize for showing up the competition.

    There have been many peoples throughout history who have been conquered and enslaved through sheer discrepancy in numbers and firepower and though no fault of their own. In the case of the whites, their enslavement will come DESPITE having the whole balance of power on their side and purely due to an inherent defect of being mincing, virtue sniveling cucklings who delight in what I will politely term the "receptive" role in intra-racial interactions. If there has ever been a category of people who richly deserve their coming fate it is surely the white race in the 21st century. Whites have become so increasingly degenerate and eager to please that it's possible by the time the 2050s and 60s roll around they will fully embrace the role of peasant and bed wench for the saintly superior people of color.

    But easy way or hard way it ultimately doesn't matter. White Supremacy is coming to an end, and it is time for whites to face up to reality the same way conquered people had to throughout the ages when the new overlords dusted themselves off from the victorious battle came whip in hand to collect the spoils. As the bible says, there is nothing new under the sun.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @3g4me

    All of which is to say whites will soon find themselves powerless minorities across the board, without a single major nation state to act as their agent and protector. There will be nowhere to run to and no means by which to fight, which is why Rubin is absolutely justified to call for a white unconditional surrender.

    LOL. You’re forgetting all the guns and ammo in the United States in civilian hands. You think there will be peace? Oh sweet summa chyle

  95. I wonder. Is there any other group people believe have disproportionate power? It’s a enigma. Perhaps Rubin should look into it.

    • Replies: @Hjgfdjji it ddffg
    @ErisGuy

    Oy vey!

  96. @Desiderius
    Where did they get the idea we were the surrendering type?

    https://twitter.com/tummymuncher/status/1427021381456343043?s=20

    Replies: @The Wild Geese Howard, @Currahee, @Polistra, @AceDeuce

    Actually, we (the U.S.) don’t fly CH-46s any more–The Kabul Shuffle (Hey Moe! Hey Moe!)/Saigon Redux is being done by the lookalike big brother of the 46–The CH-47 Chinook.

    So, optically–pretty damned similar superficially, but technically not the same airframe.

  97. @JimDandy
    Well, she did a good job of openly and honestly articulating the Jewish-American plan.

    Replies: @Hangnail Hans, @Anon, @slumber_j

    Oh, you mean Jennifer Rubin: for a moment there I thought you were referring to Emma Lazarus.

    So, forget that stuff in the Preamble about the point of the Constitution being the general welfare of “ourselves and our posterity.” That got abrogated by Emma Lazarus’s poem.

    I’d call it doggerel, but whatever.

    • Replies: @Hjgfdjji it ddffg
    @slumber_j

    I call it Constitutional law, because effectively it is.

  98. @Anon
    Rubin's people, the Jews, spent centuries wandering the planet complaining they had no homeland. Then they got a homeland in Israel, and they're still not content.

    In every country they live today, something is seriously wrong, according to them. They want every country remade to suit them. The more civilized your country, the more the Jews think it's horrible.

    It never seems to occur to them that their problem is a fundamental inability to be happy. They have never learned how to find contentment. This is what happens when the most common personality types you have among your people are neuroticism and querulousness. Neuroticism seems to be a Ashkenazi thing, not so much Sephardic. The genetic bottleneck that created the Ashkenazis hundreds of years ago was obviously chockful of loons.

    The sooner Jews crossbreed with others and lose their Jewish identity and neurotic personality traits, the better off they and the rest of the planet will be.

    Replies: @mc23, @Observator

    See “You Gentiles” by Maurice Samuel written in 1924. He hasn’t been canceled or disowned, sorta like the senile uncle who talks too much

    Here’s one line:

    “We Jews, we are the destroyers and will remain the destroyers. Nothing you can do will meet our demands and needs. We will forever destroy because we want a world of our own.”

    He received the Itzik Manger Prize for Yiddish literature posthumously in 1972.

    https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1889421.You_Gentiles

  99. One place to date when this started was what happened to the Paul people at the 2012 R Convention. In retrospect it’s likely that protecting Afghanistan was the likely rationale.

  100. @Anonymous
    @Citizen of a Silly Country


    Citizenism is the idea that you owe as much loyalty to someone who possesses a piece of paper – American citizenship – as you do to your own extended family.
     
    To borrow from Joe Sobran: Citizenism would be a massive improvement over what we have now. It is clearly what we should be aiming for.

    Replies: @Citizen of a Silly Country, @Saxon

    Citizenism is a way to hide from the reality of our situation and not feel about your timidity.

    Citizenism may have had a chance to work forty years ago, though I doubt it would have worked then either. Regardless, it absolutely has no hope now. None. Zero.

    To pretend otherwise is delusional at best, cowardice at worst.

    • Disagree: Corvinus
  101. @Anon
    Rubin's people, the Jews, spent centuries wandering the planet complaining they had no homeland. Then they got a homeland in Israel, and they're still not content.

    In every country they live today, something is seriously wrong, according to them. They want every country remade to suit them. The more civilized your country, the more the Jews think it's horrible.

    It never seems to occur to them that their problem is a fundamental inability to be happy. They have never learned how to find contentment. This is what happens when the most common personality types you have among your people are neuroticism and querulousness. Neuroticism seems to be a Ashkenazi thing, not so much Sephardic. The genetic bottleneck that created the Ashkenazis hundreds of years ago was obviously chockful of loons.

    The sooner Jews crossbreed with others and lose their Jewish identity and neurotic personality traits, the better off they and the rest of the planet will be.

    Replies: @mc23, @Observator

    It’s a hoary old fantasy that Jews were ever expelled from their wretched desert homeland. The Babylonian and Persian “captivities” were the tales of the families of the elite, who were held hostage to ensure that tribute payments would continue from the conquered province. There they incorporated many of the host nations’ dogmas and legends to their belief structure, such as the Creation myth and the Noah’s Ark tale. Jews began to emigrate from Palestine in the time of Alexander the Great, not due to persecution (that would come seven centuries later under Christian rule) but for opportunities in the international trading centers in his great empire. By the time of Jesus the largest Jewish populations were in Egypt, Syria, and Italy. Sixty years after the Romans flattened Jerusalem, there were enough Jews still there that the Romans were able to kill another 200,000 of them when they staged yet another ill-advised insurrection. Their descendents were still there five centuries after that, to welcome the Islamic “invaders” as liberators from centuries of ill-treatment by Byzantine Christians. Offered a tax exemption if they converted to Islam, many did, and their descendants are the Arab Fellahim whom the recent European and American immigrants who call themselves “Israelis” are so vigorously persecuting today.

    • Replies: @but an humble craftsman
    @Observator

    Not only is irony not dead, irony is lethal in this case.

  102. @Change that Matters
    The significant word in that excerpt is Christian.

    Replies: @Hjgfdjji it ddffg

    The keyword is left out — GENTILE. Rubin is a racist.

  103. @slumber_j
    @JimDandy

    Oh, you mean Jennifer Rubin: for a moment there I thought you were referring to Emma Lazarus.


    So, forget that stuff in the Preamble about the point of the Constitution being the general welfare of “ourselves and our posterity.” That got abrogated by Emma Lazarus’s poem.
     
    I'd call it doggerel, but whatever.

    Replies: @Hjgfdjji it ddffg

    I call it Constitutional law, because effectively it is.

  104. @ErisGuy
    I wonder. Is there any other group people believe have disproportionate power? It’s a enigma. Perhaps Rubin should look into it.

    Replies: @Hjgfdjji it ddffg

    Oy vey!

  105. @The Germ Theory of Disease
    @Mr. Anon

    If America is just an "idea," then we can simply write the idea down on a piece of paper and mail it to the Third World, and then they won't have to bother coming here, they can just stay home and enjoy the idea.

    Replies: @jo shmo

    If America is just an “idea,” then we can simply write the idea down on a piece of paper and mail it to the Third World, and then they won’t have to bother coming here, they can just stay home and enjoy the idea.

    Comment of the Day!!

  106. @Gaius Gracchus
    The "flight from white" is real. If just removed all the racial preferences, this would largely disappear and people would stop claiming non white status.

    Even better, if we instituted real white privilege and have preferences to whites like we did blacks for the last 50 years, everyone would claim white status.

    Replies: @3g4me

    @52 Gaius Gracchus: “Even better, if we instituted real white privilege and have preferences to whites like we did blacks for the last 50 years, everyone would claim white status.”

    Great idea! Having people like Rubin, along with Fang Fang and Ashok and Jameel all claim White status would solve everything! Isn’t it wonderful how easily things like genetics can be overcome by brilliant ideas?

  107. @Anonymous
    Rubin may be calling for white capitulation, but is she wrong? The day is rapidly approaching when forces hostile to whites achieve an unassailable hold on all three branches of government, all the major corporate and non corporate institutions, and all military/police forces. It is important to note that this phenomenon isn't isolated to the United States, as all major and minor white nations are undergoing a similar transformation. Even Russia is a very tenuous stronghold for whites to hinge their hopes on, as it has fallen into Globo control twice in just the previous century and is at least as likely as not to fall into those hands again by the time the demographic transition of the Western whites is complete.

    All of which is to say whites will soon find themselves powerless minorities across the board, without a single major nation state to act as their agent and protector. There will be nowhere to run to and no means by which to fight, which is why Rubin is absolutely justified to call for a white unconditional surrender. The irrevocable end of White Supremacy is a done deal at this point and its best case replacement is White Servility. Placing themselves at the mercy of people who will surely demand payback for historical wrongs real or perceived is certainly a bitter pill for whites to swallow, but in reality it's the only option. As the famous line goes, whites can either do this the easy way or the hard way, and the hard way could lead to something far worse than merely second class citizenship and servitude.

    So Rubin's position is certainly reasonable from a pure realpolitik perspective, but I would further argue it is also justified from a moral standpoint. I'm not referring to the pathetic notions of turning the other cheek and the "golden rule" that landed whites in this predicament in the first place. Rather I am referring to the only true morality, that of natural law. Whites have been on a bender of acting like effeminate, servile nu-humans for so long that they have just about become the perfect servant race. When they get hit they ask their attacker for forgiveness, when they accomplish something objectivity good they self flagellate and apologize for showing up the competition.

    There have been many peoples throughout history who have been conquered and enslaved through sheer discrepancy in numbers and firepower and though no fault of their own. In the case of the whites, their enslavement will come DESPITE having the whole balance of power on their side and purely due to an inherent defect of being mincing, virtue sniveling cucklings who delight in what I will politely term the "receptive" role in intra-racial interactions. If there has ever been a category of people who richly deserve their coming fate it is surely the white race in the 21st century. Whites have become so increasingly degenerate and eager to please that it's possible by the time the 2050s and 60s roll around they will fully embrace the role of peasant and bed wench for the saintly superior people of color.

    But easy way or hard way it ultimately doesn't matter. White Supremacy is coming to an end, and it is time for whites to face up to reality the same way conquered people had to throughout the ages when the new overlords dusted themselves off from the victorious battle came whip in hand to collect the spoils. As the bible says, there is nothing new under the sun.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @3g4me

    @66 Anonymous [851]:

    tl;dr Spread wide, close your eyes, and think of muh constitution.

  108. @Achmed E. Newman

    In the meantime, urban Americans, who constitute a greater share of the population than ever before, will lose patience with anti-democratic techniques (e.g., the filibuster, voter suppression) designed to give rural Whites disproportionate power.
     
    Yeah, when the financial SHTF, they will lose even more patience when the deliveries of food are held up and power goes out. True, Jennifer, rural White people have disportioncate power.

    Replies: @Anonymous

    They’ll just send armed forces to seize food by force from the ‘peasants’. (See Russia in 1921-22 and 1932-33.)

    • Agree: BB753
    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
    @Anonymous

    How many semi-auto rifles did the peasants of Russia have and how many woke "Warriors" came for the food?

  109. @Gary in Gramercy
    @Hangnail Hans

    Lieu's a typical (i.e., hypocritical) Democrat, but does anyone seriously think Stanford can be bought for a $50,000 contribution when it took $5 million to get Jared Kushner into Harvard?

    A space in Stanford's entering freshman class probably goes for a low seven-figure sum -- although the child of a legacy Congressman might qualify for a discount.

    Note, however, that Lieu is too cheap to attempt a bribe of Stanford with his own money. That's the real outrage.

    Replies: @Barnard

    Lieu being a member of Congress could explain the lower price. \$50k plus various favors to be named later would be reasonable for Stanford.

  110. Steve blocks any “what to do about it” posts. he sees his blog as a guy on the deck of the Titanic, snark commenting minute by minute as the ship goes down. and that’s it. he’s not interested in doing anything about it or offering a platform for anybody who wants to save the ship to talk about it.

    it’s his blog, he can do what he wants.

  111. @Reg Cæsar
    @Achmed E. Newman


    I don’t know how iSteve can stand it. It’s like cleaning out the sewer line. Someone’s gotta do it, but I’d guess the plumbing pays better.
     
    Back in the previous century, Michael Medved said his job as a film critic made him a "glorified sewer inspector". I'm sure Steve can relate to that.

    Replies: @Mr. Anon, @iDeplorable

    I don’t know how iSteve can stand it. It’s like cleaning out the sewer line. Someone’s gotta do it, but I’d guess the plumbing pays better.

    Back in the previous century, Michael Medved said his job as a film critic made him a “glorified sewer inspector“. I’m sure Steve can relate to that.

    Oh great now the two jabbering geriatrics are replying to each other. It was better when you two grannies just kept it to off-topic babble and inane pics.

    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
    @iDeplorable

    By special request:

    https://www.peakstupidity.com/images/post_1851A.jpg

    Thanks again, Adam Smith!

  112. @JohnnyWalker123
    @Citizen of a Silly Country

    "They" is such a vague term.

    Be more specific.

    Replies: @DCThrowback

    LOL

  113. Lot of people painting Rubin as a typical Zionist “ethnostate for me but not for thee” hypocrite. While true as far as she goes, I can tell you that ethnomasochism is a problem among Jews as well. Surveys show declining support for Israel among self-identified American Jews and increasing support for radical universalist causes like anti-racism and anti-capitalism. It’s not a secret that many Jews are their own worst enemy and apply the same suicidal ideas to their own country.

    • Replies: @Corvinus
    @jtgw

    “It’s not a secret that many Jews are their own worst enemy and apply the same suicidal ideas to their own country.“

    We are own worst enemy when making sweeping generalizations based on confirmation bias.

    Replies: @Jtgw

  114. I liked this reply to WaPo:

    • Replies: @J.Ross
    @Hi There

    Gotta be a good movie scene comparison here, but I can't place it: there's one set who, however they feel about supremacism, actually understand how things work, and then you have dumb over-enthusiastic kids who think they're immortal and they've already won.

    Replies: @Corvinus

    , @Mrwolf
    @Hi There

    We need to prevent rule by third worlders and primitives.

  115. Try a Google search and type “great r”.

    Q: How many more letters do you need to type before Google suggests the search term “great replacement”?

    A: All of them. Even if you type “great replacemen”, Google pretends that it cannot guess what you are looking for.

  116. @Anonymous
    @Citizen of a Silly Country


    Citizenism is the idea that you owe as much loyalty to someone who possesses a piece of paper – American citizenship – as you do to your own extended family.
     
    To borrow from Joe Sobran: Citizenism would be a massive improvement over what we have now. It is clearly what we should be aiming for.

    Replies: @Citizen of a Silly Country, @Saxon

    Why should you aim for that when you can already see the rug will be pulled from underneath you as soon as you end up a vulnerable minority? Look at ghouls like that jewish WaPo writer, Jennifer Rubin. Same person who would talk about how important it is that minorities get their needs met and their voices heard is now saying that white minority rule MUST be prevented in the US. Biopower is all that matters. You need your people by blood on a land to maintain sovereignty and self-determination.

  117. @Intelligent Dasein
    @SafeNow


    If commenters have ever been specific and unmeasured, we did not see it, because it was moderated.
     
    I have a general idea of a plan, and I have posted many versions of it here before. However, the rest of the commentariat engages in some pretty vicious crabology whenever anyone around here tries to be useful.

    The blog seems to be a place where mostly 50-something, well-off, embittered and perpetually constipated IYIs come to belch out their discomfort. They don't want that to change.

    Replies: @Anonymous, @Polistra, @iDeplorable

    have a general idea of a plan, and I have posted many versions of it here before. However, the rest….a place where mostly 50-something, well-off, embittered and perpetually constipated IYIs come to belch out their discomfort.

    Aren’t you special and brave? Fag.

    Instead of spelling out your “plan” anonymously on a blog, go out and DO something other than calling yourself intelligent.

  118. @Che Blutarsky
    Good thing Jennifer Rubin is not some genocidal maniac, or else she'd be out writing some crazy shit...

    Seriously, do they not think there will be any blowback from this? You effectively disenfranchise the former majority population by swamping them with new populations, demonize them from every major media platform, justify attacks against them, and plot out ways to take all of their wealth, and they are just going to sit back and take it? They're just going to shut up, keep working for less and less, keep paying more and more taxes, keep sending their kids off to the military? That all that magically created wealth getting hoovered up by the parasite classes will keep getting created?

    Replies: @Hangnail Hans, @Reality Check (Tikkun Olam)

    They control every institution in the West, including financial and media.

    People won’t fight back because their propaganda is so effective; more to the point, they were allowed a monopoly over major media content and flow.

    Essentially, 90% of the public takes in their propaganda, including from gatekeepers like Dave Rubin and his ilk (liberalism for America, Likudism for Israel, Talmudism for Jews to rule and goy to race mix/serve).

    This happened because the WASP elite did exactly zero to protect this country’s infrastructure from these rats over a century ago. A sickening state.

    But hey, there are some brilliant Holocaust documentaries coming this year. Because genocide is the most evil thing in human history.

    And what happened to the Jews is so unique that it’s literally THE Holocaust. There can be only one.

  119. “So, forget that stuff in the Preamble about the point of the Constitution being the general welfare of “ourselves and our posterity.”

    No one is forgetting it. Our officials and citizens, despite our enormous flaws, seek to create laws and policies for our current and future generations.

    “That got abrogated by Emma Lazarus’s poem.”

    According to Who/Whom? Regardless, our nation was built in immigration. It’s who we are. You wouldn’t be here otherwise.

    • Troll: The Griffins
    • Replies: @Reality Check (Tikkun Olam)
    @Corvinus

    How did the Jews end up in Israel?

    A country that has only existed since the 1940s, yet there is no talk of it being a 'nation of ideas' or a 'nation of immigrants', even as such phrases flow freely from Jews with both American and Israeli citizenship.

    Hell, why does an anti-racist country (the US) serve as a racialist/racist country's (aka Israel's) attack dog?

    Strange how contradictory all this is. Especially since the same people that demand this for the US -- and control world finance and western media -- demand the opposite for a country full of Khazar immigrants that has only existed since the 1940s. We have to repair the US, they say, by making it less racist and white, while they simultaneously create a racist/Zionist state via colonialism and outright theft. It's almost as if these people are lying, treasonous, genocidal maniacs or something.

  120. Get back to us when 1) the US stops bowing and scraping to the Jews and Israel at every turn, 2) the US media starts talking about ‘Jewish Supremacy’, 3) the media itself starts demanding that fewer Jews be hired, 4) the history of Jewish hatred and supremacy is explored openly in academia, government think tanks and Hollywood films, 5) Jews not only mouth a few words about Palestinian rights but, instead, start funding groups that will cause Israel to be flooded with Sub-Saharan Africans (no quick “deportations” to Europe and America this time), and 6) Israel agrees to a one-state solution where Jews are not allowed to rule (as Rubin demands for whites).

    It also is time that Jews apologize for both Zionism and the Talmud: a filthy book full of hatred for non-Jews. Where are the media reports and government condemnations of all this Jewish supremacy?

    Why don’t ‘atheists’ like Bill Maher condemn the Talmud?

  121. @Corvinus
    “So, forget that stuff in the Preamble about the point of the Constitution being the general welfare of “ourselves and our posterity.”

    No one is forgetting it. Our officials and citizens, despite our enormous flaws, seek to create laws and policies for our current and future generations.

    “That got abrogated by Emma Lazarus’s poem.”

    According to Who/Whom? Regardless, our nation was built in immigration. It’s who we are. You wouldn’t be here otherwise.

    Replies: @Reality Check (Tikkun Olam)

    How did the Jews end up in Israel?

    A country that has only existed since the 1940s, yet there is no talk of it being a ‘nation of ideas’ or a ‘nation of immigrants’, even as such phrases flow freely from Jews with both American and Israeli citizenship.

    Hell, why does an anti-racist country (the US) serve as a racialist/racist country’s (aka Israel’s) attack dog?

    Strange how contradictory all this is. Especially since the same people that demand this for the US — and control world finance and western media — demand the opposite for a country full of Khazar immigrants that has only existed since the 1940s. We have to repair the US, they say, by making it less racist and white, while they simultaneously create a racist/Zionist state via colonialism and outright theft. It’s almost as if these people are lying, treasonous, genocidal maniacs or something.

  122. @jtgw
    Lot of people painting Rubin as a typical Zionist "ethnostate for me but not for thee" hypocrite. While true as far as she goes, I can tell you that ethnomasochism is a problem among Jews as well. Surveys show declining support for Israel among self-identified American Jews and increasing support for radical universalist causes like anti-racism and anti-capitalism. It's not a secret that many Jews are their own worst enemy and apply the same suicidal ideas to their own country.

    Replies: @Corvinus

    “It’s not a secret that many Jews are their own worst enemy and apply the same suicidal ideas to their own country.“

    We are own worst enemy when making sweeping generalizations based on confirmation bias.

    • Troll: The Griffins
    • Replies: @Jtgw
    @Corvinus

    So you prefer to extrapolate from a sample of one?

    Replies: @John Milton's Ghost, @Corvinus

  123. Mad at anti-white zionist Jews like Jennifer Rubin? Get even, support the BDS movement:

    https://bdsmovement.net/

  124. @Jiminy
    @SaneClownPosse

    My wife made the mistake of buying a box of vegan prawns. They’re not prawns that solely eat vegetables, but things that resemble lumps of foam rubber, and the taste is beyond description, so I won’t bother you with it. But if I had the future in my hands, then they can keep it. I think I’ll start hunting rats, sparrows and pigeons to survive.

    Replies: @Joe Stalin

    I’ll start hunting rats

    RAT Meat is Good.

    — Shawn Woods

  125. @Elsewhere
    @Citizen of a Silly Country

    That's not citizenism. Citizenism simply means returning to "for us and for our posterity" with those who are currently citizens. This means that current citizens can decide to be choosy about who else, if any, are allowed to become new citizens. Indeed, they have a strong incentive to be choosy.

    Replies: @Citizen of a Silly Country, @ATBOTL

    That’s not citizenism. Citizenism simply means returning to “for us and for our posterity” with those who are currently citizens. This means that current citizens can decide to be choosy about who else, if any, are allowed to become new citizens. Indeed, they have a strong incentive to be choosy.

    What a joke. Black car jackers, Chinese spies, Somalians, Guatemalans and H1B Indians who fired all the whites in the office are our “fellow citizens” nows. Their agenda on immigration is to open the border as wide as possible and that won’t change.

  126. Is there already a term for this Qui phenomenon where they just come out and admit things? It’s not exactly the same thing as Streisand effect.

  127. Is there anything white men can dominate without the rainbow coalition bitching? Besides, you know, fentanyl deaths and suicides?

  128. @Anon
    @JimDandy


    Well, she did a good job of openly and honestly articulating the Jewish-American plan.
     
    Waiting for a fellow Jewish-American to call her out on it.

    Meanwhile media jews are having a meltdown over the peaceful transfer of power in Afghanistan. The prospect of Muslims and Christians not being at each other’s throats, or otherwise in turmoil, seems to cause them a lot of anxiety.

    The anxiety probably is not limited just to Muslims and Christians getting along, or being unified and strong internally, but extends to any outgroups getting along or having their shit together.

    Replies: @JimDandy, @SunBakedSuburb

    “The prospect of Muslims and Christians not being at each other’s throats … seems to cause them a lot of anxiety”

    Yahweh’s Babelization plan of divide and conquer continues its long and successful run.

  129. @Corvinus
    @jtgw

    “It’s not a secret that many Jews are their own worst enemy and apply the same suicidal ideas to their own country.“

    We are own worst enemy when making sweeping generalizations based on confirmation bias.

    Replies: @Jtgw

    So you prefer to extrapolate from a sample of one?

    • Replies: @John Milton's Ghost
    @Jtgw

    Corvinus likes hanging out here because his lefty buddies stopped having message boards years ago, when they realized they got owned by kids wearing pajamas with blow-up dolls in their closets. Don't worry about him, he's like bad furniture--outdated and not going anywhere, but can be safely ignored.

    , @Corvinus
    @Jtgw

    "So you prefer to extrapolate from a sample of one?"

    Of course not. It's just that for some people during the extrapolation process when considering the machinations of Jews (and Boomers), they overvalue the deviancy and malfeasance of these two groups.

    For example, when a person says that Jews tend to be more dishonest than non-Jews, on what basis is that judgement? Is it because of what they have been led to believe that this behavior is indicative of his/her ethnic marker, rather than his/her individual personality traits? Do we not take into account that an intelligent, verbose people are more likely to be deceitful, and that one's ethnicity has little to do with their conduct as a person?

  130. @Hangnail Hans
    @Che Blutarsky

    You're essentially asking: aren't white people suddenly going to see through decades of mass media propaganda and stage a revolt against the ruling class?

    Does this question really need answering at this point? With each passing year, more and more people are drinking the kool-aid and remarking on its delightful flavor. More and more people. Not fewer and fewer.

    Replies: @San Fernando Curt, @Ben tillman

    Hasn’t started hurting yet. When it starts hurting, duck.

  131. @Richard B
    @Hangnail Hans


    Rubin has always been pretty transparent about this stuff. There’s little need to hide it anymore anyway.
     
    She might have to hide it when TSHTF, as it always seems to do with them.

    The kind of thinking that goes into infiltration, subversion, radical ingratitude, insane hatred, destruction and death is not the kind of thinking needed for competent social management. And, the fact is, they've never been very good at that and never will be.

    They've been at this forever. Babylon, Persia, Egypt, Greece, Rome, Christian Europe, Secular Europe, the revolutions of 17th century England, 18th century France, 20th century Russia and now the USA.

    Speaking of which, given the condition the USA is in right now, their victory dance is more like a Pyrrhic Victory dance. Not much to brag about. And now what's next?

    China. A people who, unlike whites, don't strike one as being all that into power-sharing, or being pushed around. In short, maybe Jewish Supremacy Inc. has has finally reached the end of the line. Where to next for them? The moon?

    Replies: @Anonymous, @Ben tillman

    Agreed.

    • Disagree: SunBakedSuburb
  132. @Dave Pinsen
    If it’s not static, it can also get whiter. There’s no reason it has to be a one-way ratchet. Denmark is nicer than the Democratic Republic of the Congo; run on an immigration policy that makes us more like Denmark.

    Replies: @SunBakedSuburb

    “run on an immigration policy that makes us more like Denmark”

    You will have to import Danes to do that. My experience with these people is they like to visit America, experience the wild life and such, but feel a measure of relief when they board the SAS jetliner for Kobenhavn. They quite like their manicured, homogenous, and boring little land. Rethink your plan!

  133. @Hangnail Hans
    @JimDandy

    Rubin has always been pretty transparent about this stuff. There's little need to hide it anymore anyway.


    White Christians... the demographic and cultural tide washing over them.
     
    This is just part of their victory dance.

    PS; Did she really say "predominate" instead of predominant? Oh I forgot--grammar is white people stuff.

    Replies: @Richard B, @Ben tillman

    Yeah, that was a nice touch.

  134. @Intelligent Dasein
    Jennifer Rubin's position here is completely factually inaccurate. But even setting that aside, if we grant for argument's sake that hers is an opinion possible to hold, it is neither original to her nor does it receive from her any particular force of expression.

    In other words, this is not-even-wrong, secondhand dreck.

    And we pay people to write like this?

    Replies: @kaganovitch, @Bill

    I’ve been baffled by this as well. Not only does she argue badly, but her prose is consistently awful. Surely they can find someone better than her.

  135. @Jiminy
    Times like these are when the rural whites need to remind the urbanites just how much they need, what do you call it, ah yes food. Meats, grains, fruits and vegetables and of course taters, precious. Without fries America will come to a stand still. Not French fries of course, but freedom fries. They might lose their patience, but they won’t lose their appetites.

    Replies: @SaneClownPosse, @znon, @Bill

    How did that reminding work out for the kulaks?

  136. @Polistra
    @Desiderius

    It's absolutely ridiculous for people to keep making these Saigon comparisons. The situations are nothing alike. No Viet Cong, for example. Plus, Kabul is at a much higher elevation and has considerably colder winters. People should try thinking about things before just saying whatever comes into their minds.

    https://twitter.com/RT_com/status/1426898972564770816

    Replies: @Bill

    Genius comment.

  137. @Jtgw
    @Corvinus

    So you prefer to extrapolate from a sample of one?

    Replies: @John Milton's Ghost, @Corvinus

    Corvinus likes hanging out here because his lefty buddies stopped having message boards years ago, when they realized they got owned by kids wearing pajamas with blow-up dolls in their closets. Don’t worry about him, he’s like bad furniture–outdated and not going anywhere, but can be safely ignored.

  138. @Citizen of a Silly Country
    They hate you and want you dead doesn't sound so crazy anymore, does it Steve.

    Replies: @JohnnyWalker123, @AnotherDad

    They hate you and want you dead doesn’t sound so crazy anymore, does it Steve.

    I think it’s more “they hate you and demand you sit still and be looted”. But if you don’t agree or don’t provide optimal looting … then yeah–“dead” works.

    The implacable minoritarianism should not surprise:

    Jew are a middle-man minority, of course, they push minoritarianism. They don’t like concepts like “majority rule”, “republican government” that America was built upon. Or even the idea of “nation”. What they like is empire, where the elites in charge are Jew friendly and insure the Jews are protected and have the right to middle man anywhere and everywhere without a coherent majority capable of pushing back. (What Jews now call “democracy” and say is “under threat” by people voting for their own interests and survival. E.g. Trump, Orban, etc.)

    The implacable hostility should not surprise:

    The Ashkenazi faced a detribalizing, integrating Christianity. To keep themselves as a separate tribe they had to jack up the tribal feeling and hostility–culturally and religiously. Essentially worshipping themselves as separate people, from all those nasty gentiles. Absent that hostility … they’d have been integrated in with everyone else. (Some were.)

    No the surprise here is the sheer shortsightedness.

    Jews are supposed to be smart.

    Post-War the Jews were middle-manning freely in the richest, most powerful nation on earth. The WASPs had put in a test based “meritocracy” that played right into the Jews’ strength. American Protestants are near the top of the charts in being willing to share their space with other tribes, and one of the most Jew friendly peoples on earth. America is inherently just more open, than the Jews are going to find anywhere else.

    Rationally Jews should have been thinking “This is great, as good as it gets”, been dog-loyal citizens and worked to keep America as strong and healthy and prosperous as possible.

    But the key word there: “rationally”. They just couldn’t do it.

    The Jews just couldn’t reign in their hostility. They had to tear it all down. Like blacks with crime, or the Irish with drink, the Jews and their destructive hostility–an itch they just must scratch.

    And America is it. No other nation was going to be so open anyway. But now everyone’s seen this shit show. You think the Chinese are going to let Jews come in and loot as they rise toward the top? Anyone who gets their act together going to invite in Jews? LOL. People are stupid, but not that stupid.

    The two greatest lessons from America:
    — Don’t bring in the blacks.
    — Don’t let in the Jews.

    • Replies: @Citizen of a Silly Country
    @AnotherDad

    The phrase really should be: They hate you and want your people turned into helots.

    But that just doesn't roll of the tongue, so I'll stick with they hate you and want you dead.

    As to Jews and the United States (and, really, Britain before that), I wholeheartedly agree. By the 1960s, Jews were seen by gentile whites as just another white ethnic group and yet were able to act as a people apart. They were quickly gaining control of the commanding heights of the world's most powerful society, but the gentiles didn't notice or care.

    It was literally paradise on earth for the Jews. You'd think that they'd count themselves lucky and just ride that wonderful train. Instead, they worked diligently to destroy it.

    I'd agree that part of the reason is that it's simply in their nature. They do it over and over throughout history. They also never learn. It's always, "And then the people of country X for no reason at all attacked us and kicked us out. Us, the Jews, who had done so much for them. It's that weird anti-Semitism virus that seems to infect the minds of the goy."

    I'd also say that the Holocaust story started to become central to Jewish identity. And part of the Holocaust story is that white, Christian goys can turn into SS officers on a dime. That khaki-wearing neighbor of yours is just one bad economic downturn away from setting up gas chambers in Ohio. (And these gas chambers will be as magically efficient as the German ones.)

    If you assume that whites are always on the verge of trying to genocide your people, well, you'd tried to take away their power and ability to mobilize as well.

    To their credit, Jews accomplished their goal. Americans whites are truly a defeated people at this point. And looking at Biden's cabinet, it's obvious that Jews now openly run the country.

    But as you say, it's a pyrrhic victory. They now control a failing empire and more and more gentiles of all colors are noticing that fact. What's more, Europe is growing ever more Muslim, so not exactly Jew friendly. China and the East won't fall for their tricks, if for no other reason than Jews don't look like them - which is a bigger deal than people think.

    While Jews will continue to wield a lot of power, we likely have passed Peak Jew. Ironically, their power and influence is now tied a country that they helped to destroy.

    Replies: @ziggurat, @Anonymous

  139. @Desiderius
    https://twitter.com/ClimateAudit/status/1427017870085611525?s=20

    Replies: @J.Ross

    Yes, Tariq Ali claims (per docs, allegedly) that the Soyuz was actually cool with a divine-right monarchy on their border, because (1) there’s nothing there anyway (but the bones of would-be conquerors) and (2) that was one stretch of border they didn’t have to worry about. When they invaded, it was because their local pet idiots had undertaken a coup on their own and hashed it beyond polite pullout halfway through.
    Comparison: the Soviet withdrawal from Afghanistan was pretty good, it’s seen as one of the things they did right. Our gerontocracy has already utterly failed to do as well as the late-stage Soviet Union. Let that sink in like an undercooled reactor core. Right now the Taliban has the Kabul airport (which we kind of need) surrounded and is taking shots at their leisure like they used to do with Tommy.
    Minimally Reanimated Corpse Biden just had a press conference in which he literally put all responsibility on Trump and the Afghans (what, no fancybear?) and then walked out without answering questions. Hohnecker in his final days was more credible.

  140. @Hi There
    I liked this reply to WaPo:
    https://twitter.com/GadSaad/status/1426345719003324418

    Replies: @J.Ross, @Mrwolf

    Gotta be a good movie scene comparison here, but I can’t place it: there’s one set who, however they feel about supremacism, actually understand how things work, and then you have dumb over-enthusiastic kids who think they’re immortal and they’ve already won.

    • Replies: @Corvinus
    @J.Ross

    "Gotta be a good movie scene comparison here, but I can’t place it..."

    Indeed.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WQWhDvKEiSw

  141. Stonewall Jackson [AKA "Joker"] says:

    OK Sailer… explain how Ron Unz is different in his positions on white replacement than Rubin?

    The Failure of White Nationalism is in the spirit of his tribeswoman here Rubin….

    Unz is just another open border jew too… except he lets you publish on his website…

    Someone wondered exactly how does everyone else get deplatformed by the ADL but Unz manages to continue… hmm… could this be a honeytrap for DHS?

  142. Question, and please pardon my (admitted) naïveté.

    What’s in it for this particular branch of neoconservatism? She and John Podhoretz Normanson being the two examples that most readily come to mind? Why do they want to ethnically transform America goyim? The contrast with others, such as Dennis Prager, is stark. What’s going on in their minds?

  143. @AnotherDad
    @Citizen of a Silly Country


    They hate you and want you dead doesn’t sound so crazy anymore, does it Steve.
     
    I think it's more "they hate you and demand you sit still and be looted". But if you don't agree or don't provide optimal looting ... then yeah--"dead" works.

    The implacable minoritarianism should not surprise:

    Jew are a middle-man minority, of course, they push minoritarianism. They don't like concepts like "majority rule", "republican government" that America was built upon. Or even the idea of "nation". What they like is empire, where the elites in charge are Jew friendly and insure the Jews are protected and have the right to middle man anywhere and everywhere without a coherent majority capable of pushing back. (What Jews now call "democracy" and say is "under threat" by people voting for their own interests and survival. E.g. Trump, Orban, etc.)

    The implacable hostility should not surprise:

    The Ashkenazi faced a detribalizing, integrating Christianity. To keep themselves as a separate tribe they had to jack up the tribal feeling and hostility--culturally and religiously. Essentially worshipping themselves as separate people, from all those nasty gentiles. Absent that hostility ... they'd have been integrated in with everyone else. (Some were.)

    No the surprise here is the sheer shortsightedness.

    Jews are supposed to be smart.

    Post-War the Jews were middle-manning freely in the richest, most powerful nation on earth. The WASPs had put in a test based "meritocracy" that played right into the Jews' strength. American Protestants are near the top of the charts in being willing to share their space with other tribes, and one of the most Jew friendly peoples on earth. America is inherently just more open, than the Jews are going to find anywhere else.

    Rationally Jews should have been thinking "This is great, as good as it gets", been dog-loyal citizens and worked to keep America as strong and healthy and prosperous as possible.

    But the key word there: "rationally". They just couldn't do it.

    The Jews just couldn't reign in their hostility. They had to tear it all down. Like blacks with crime, or the Irish with drink, the Jews and their destructive hostility--an itch they just must scratch.

    And America is it. No other nation was going to be so open anyway. But now everyone's seen this shit show. You think the Chinese are going to let Jews come in and loot as they rise toward the top? Anyone who gets their act together going to invite in Jews? LOL. People are stupid, but not that stupid.

    The two greatest lessons from America:
    -- Don't bring in the blacks.
    -- Don't let in the Jews.

    Replies: @Citizen of a Silly Country

    The phrase really should be: They hate you and want your people turned into helots.

    But that just doesn’t roll of the tongue, so I’ll stick with they hate you and want you dead.

    As to Jews and the United States (and, really, Britain before that), I wholeheartedly agree. By the 1960s, Jews were seen by gentile whites as just another white ethnic group and yet were able to act as a people apart. They were quickly gaining control of the commanding heights of the world’s most powerful society, but the gentiles didn’t notice or care.

    It was literally paradise on earth for the Jews. You’d think that they’d count themselves lucky and just ride that wonderful train. Instead, they worked diligently to destroy it.

    I’d agree that part of the reason is that it’s simply in their nature. They do it over and over throughout history. They also never learn. It’s always, “And then the people of country X for no reason at all attacked us and kicked us out. Us, the Jews, who had done so much for them. It’s that weird anti-Semitism virus that seems to infect the minds of the goy.”

    I’d also say that the Holocaust story started to become central to Jewish identity. And part of the Holocaust story is that white, Christian goys can turn into SS officers on a dime. That khaki-wearing neighbor of yours is just one bad economic downturn away from setting up gas chambers in Ohio. (And these gas chambers will be as magically efficient as the German ones.)

    If you assume that whites are always on the verge of trying to genocide your people, well, you’d tried to take away their power and ability to mobilize as well.

    To their credit, Jews accomplished their goal. Americans whites are truly a defeated people at this point. And looking at Biden’s cabinet, it’s obvious that Jews now openly run the country.

    But as you say, it’s a pyrrhic victory. They now control a failing empire and more and more gentiles of all colors are noticing that fact. What’s more, Europe is growing ever more Muslim, so not exactly Jew friendly. China and the East won’t fall for their tricks, if for no other reason than Jews don’t look like them – which is a bigger deal than people think.

    While Jews will continue to wield a lot of power, we likely have passed Peak Jew. Ironically, their power and influence is now tied a country that they helped to destroy.

    • Replies: @ziggurat
    @Citizen of a Silly Country

    It's like the story of the scorpion and the frog. But perhaps, they plan to move to Greater Israel, if the West falls.

    , @Anonymous
    @Citizen of a Silly Country

    No, Jews thrive in multicultural and multiracial nations. Now is the best time to be a Jew in America and the future will only be better. The time of greatest danger for American Jews was the 1950s and 60s, when America was both racially monolithic and militantly anti-Communist, at a time when most Jews had left-wing sympathies. That danger has passed and is never coming back.

  144. @Nicholas Stix

    Thanks, Nick. I just read your options. III seems the best option, and I don’t see it as a political miracle. As I wrote in the recent PS post “Peak Stupidity, Pundits, and Governors, OH MY!”, Federalism is not just for Constitutionalists anymore.

    • Replies: @Nicholas Stix
    @Achmed E. Newman

    Thanks, Achmed. The importance of an invigorated, stubborn federalism cannot be overestimated. Pound away at it!

  145. @Anonymous
    @Achmed E. Newman

    They'll just send armed forces to seize food by force from the 'peasants'. (See Russia in 1921-22 and 1932-33.)

    Replies: @Achmed E. Newman

    How many semi-auto rifles did the peasants of Russia have and how many woke “Warriors” came for the food?

  146. @iDeplorable
    @Reg Cæsar


    @Achmed E. Newman

    I don’t know how iSteve can stand it. It’s like cleaning out the sewer line. Someone’s gotta do it, but I’d guess the plumbing pays better.

    Back in the previous century, Michael Medved said his job as a film critic made him a “glorified sewer inspector“. I’m sure Steve can relate to that.

     

    Oh great now the two jabbering geriatrics are replying to each other. It was better when you two grannies just kept it to off-topic babble and inane pics.

    Replies: @Achmed E. Newman

    By special request:

    Thanks again, Adam Smith!

    • Thanks: Adam Smith
  147. @Jtgw
    @Corvinus

    So you prefer to extrapolate from a sample of one?

    Replies: @John Milton's Ghost, @Corvinus

    “So you prefer to extrapolate from a sample of one?”

    Of course not. It’s just that for some people during the extrapolation process when considering the machinations of Jews (and Boomers), they overvalue the deviancy and malfeasance of these two groups.

    For example, when a person says that Jews tend to be more dishonest than non-Jews, on what basis is that judgement? Is it because of what they have been led to believe that this behavior is indicative of his/her ethnic marker, rather than his/her individual personality traits? Do we not take into account that an intelligent, verbose people are more likely to be deceitful, and that one’s ethnicity has little to do with their conduct as a person?

  148. @J.Ross
    @Hi There

    Gotta be a good movie scene comparison here, but I can't place it: there's one set who, however they feel about supremacism, actually understand how things work, and then you have dumb over-enthusiastic kids who think they're immortal and they've already won.

    Replies: @Corvinus

    “Gotta be a good movie scene comparison here, but I can’t place it…”

    Indeed.

  149. @John Johnson
    A lot of Jew blaming as usual but no blame for our race denying conservatives and their mindless embrace of libertarian theories.

    Rush Limbaugh made millions by indoctrinating rural Whites into believing that "Da Unions" must be to blame for those Black areas. Republicans gave him one of the highest civil awards.

    The GOP bet it all on the "Free market" being more important than race and they would rather eat third world sh-t than admit they were wrong.

    WELL PUT THAT BIB ON AND GET READY

    MEGADITTOS

    Replies: @Ben tillman

    The race-denying conservatives were responding to indoctrination and incentives/disincentives produced by the Jewish community that built and enforced the atomizing moral framework within which they operated.

  150. @Jim Lahey

    That reality has, of course, freaked out a significant share of White Christians who do not see “their America” as predominate.
     
    Isn't "predominate" a verb, not an adjective? Shouldn't this be "predominant"? Are there still editors?

    Replies: @Ben tillman

    No, I don’t think there are editors anymore.

  151. @Hangnail Hans
    @Che Blutarsky

    You're essentially asking: aren't white people suddenly going to see through decades of mass media propaganda and stage a revolt against the ruling class?

    Does this question really need answering at this point? With each passing year, more and more people are drinking the kool-aid and remarking on its delightful flavor. More and more people. Not fewer and fewer.

    Replies: @San Fernando Curt, @Ben tillman

    More and more drink the Kool-Aid while more and more notice what’s happening. The middle is disappearing.

  152. Just who reads Jennifer Rubin? Well, Steve does, but that’s his job. I suspect that a substantial proportion of her readers are people like me, who only read excerpts of her through Steve. (I made an exception, and read the entire, current “thing.”)

    What does Rubin believe in? As far as I can see, nothing. What she does is project her own genocidal hatred onto White, Christian patriots. However, I think that hatred is feigned.

    A columnist may deal with big ideas, big facts, focus on minutiae in a powerful way, contemplate conflict, write of his experiences, and muse humorously. The only part of the foregoing list that Rubin dealt with was big facts—the ongoing dispossession of the group who pays all the bills, and fights and dies in the wars for this country.

    Someone may say she contemplated conflict.

    “In the meantime, urban Americans, who constitute a greater share of the population than ever before, will lose patience with anti-democratic techniques (e.g., the filibuster, voter suppression) designed to give rural Whites disproportionate power.”

    And what might those “urban Americans” do? Riot, loot, and burn down America’s cities?

    Jennifer Rubin is part of the contemporary stupid Jew apocalypse, about which I’ve intermittently written for years. Although her support for Israel is tepid, she otherwise fits the Nazi stereotype of the Jewish intellectual without intellect (see also Max Boot, et al.), who has no reason for being in a position of influence. She, Boot, and many others are all in competition for the title Tommy Franks bestowed on Douglas Feith, of being “the fu–ing stupidest person on the planet.”

    • Thanks: David In TN
  153. @Observator
    @Anon

    It's a hoary old fantasy that Jews were ever expelled from their wretched desert homeland. The Babylonian and Persian "captivities" were the tales of the families of the elite, who were held hostage to ensure that tribute payments would continue from the conquered province. There they incorporated many of the host nations’ dogmas and legends to their belief structure, such as the Creation myth and the Noah's Ark tale. Jews began to emigrate from Palestine in the time of Alexander the Great, not due to persecution (that would come seven centuries later under Christian rule) but for opportunities in the international trading centers in his great empire. By the time of Jesus the largest Jewish populations were in Egypt, Syria, and Italy. Sixty years after the Romans flattened Jerusalem, there were enough Jews still there that the Romans were able to kill another 200,000 of them when they staged yet another ill-advised insurrection. Their descendents were still there five centuries after that, to welcome the Islamic "invaders" as liberators from centuries of ill-treatment by Byzantine Christians. Offered a tax exemption if they converted to Islam, many did, and their descendants are the Arab Fellahim whom the recent European and American immigrants who call themselves "Israelis" are so vigorously persecuting today.

    Replies: @but an humble craftsman

    Not only is irony not dead, irony is lethal in this case.

  154. @Achmed E. Newman
    @Nicholas Stix

    Thanks, Nick. I just read your options. III seems the best option, and I don't see it as a political miracle. As I wrote in the recent PS post "Peak Stupidity, Pundits, and Governors, OH MY!", Federalism is not just for Constitutionalists anymore.

    Replies: @Nicholas Stix

    Thanks, Achmed. The importance of an invigorated, stubborn federalism cannot be overestimated. Pound away at it!

  155. @SafeNow
    @Anonymous

    “Why not up your societal value and start suggesting some practical ways to counteract…” (addressed to Steve)

    Fair question. I will hazard a guess. I am assuming that by “practical,” you mean effective, and not perfunctory and useless. Steve is in good company. All the essayists, and commenters, have uniformly declined to do what you ask. If commenters have ever been specific and unmeasured, we did not see it, because it was moderated. I have posted “So what, specifically, is the plan of procedure?” many times, to no avail. The reason for not stating specifics, in my view, is this: If woke, quasi-religious ruthlessness continues to accelerate, the consequences of advocating specifics might, some day, be horrendous.

    I write this as a coward. As I have posted before, I was a spineless student at an “elite” New England university exactly when this all began, the late 60s.

    I am quite satisfied taking enjoyment in Steve’s great wit, insight, and intelligence as he observes and analyzes the world. (No, I am not his cousin.)

    Replies: @Intelligent Dasein, @Nicholas Stix, @Marty T

    It’s probably the job of those that are younger than Steve (30s and 40s) to figure out what to do about it. And there are things to do. As long as we have tens of millions, land and weapons galore, don’t tell me there’s nothing that can be done.

    South Africa is 10 percent white. We’re 58 percent white. Come on now.

    • Replies: @Mrwolf
    @Marty T

    There was a European nation that was almost in the same state America is now. Then in 1933 they had enough! Until more whites are personally affected, nothing will be done. But rest assured this can be corrected.

  156. @epebble
    @Anonymous

    I will bite. The reason no solutions are being offered is because the problems are intractable - in the sense that in the political system we have, a much higher degree of political agreement is needed than we have or can have in near future.

    I will elaborate:

    1. Many persons are commenting, generally, on low number of births and dysgenic births. This is due to a multiplicity of factors: Increased education of women, a desire by educated (and even less educated women) to work outside the home in paying jobs for the satisfaction of being active in society and also to increase family income to enjoy a higher standard of living (than possible by a single income). Obviously, this leads to smaller family sizes. This also leads to dysgenic births as more educated women will have fewer children than less educated women.

    Now, a crude "solution" may be to discourage women from post secondary education and employment to promote more domesticity and motherhood. But we do not have any political process to achieve that, even if some people find it desirable.

    2. Many people are commenting, generally on high level of immigration. Unfortunately, nearly two thirds of immigration is for family unification. Thus even though many people want to reduce immigration, no one knows who should be prevented from bringing a spouse, child or a parent from abroad. As for employment immigration, businesses have a lot of clout - and can also make fairness argument - if Joe Sixpack can import a car from Japan or Korea (because of Global Free Trade in goods), How can the government prevent an employer from hiring a worker from abroad (Free Trade in labor)? Since we (consumers) want imported goods for better quality/lower price, employer (consumer of labor) also insists on the same. And remember, when you pick stocks based on P/E ratio, you are not preferring employers that prefer to hire Americans over foreigners.

    These are just two example I have picked. However, For every problem discussed, I can easily show that all possible solutions are politically intractable.

    Replies: @Neil Templeton

    How ’bout all the pro-birthrate White American folks move to Afghanistan, in return for an equal number of Afghans. Problem solved. New White American birthrate goes up in Afghanistan, new White Afghan immigrants get mired in the American version of “Graveyard of Empires.”

  157. @Citizen of a Silly Country
    @AnotherDad

    The phrase really should be: They hate you and want your people turned into helots.

    But that just doesn't roll of the tongue, so I'll stick with they hate you and want you dead.

    As to Jews and the United States (and, really, Britain before that), I wholeheartedly agree. By the 1960s, Jews were seen by gentile whites as just another white ethnic group and yet were able to act as a people apart. They were quickly gaining control of the commanding heights of the world's most powerful society, but the gentiles didn't notice or care.

    It was literally paradise on earth for the Jews. You'd think that they'd count themselves lucky and just ride that wonderful train. Instead, they worked diligently to destroy it.

    I'd agree that part of the reason is that it's simply in their nature. They do it over and over throughout history. They also never learn. It's always, "And then the people of country X for no reason at all attacked us and kicked us out. Us, the Jews, who had done so much for them. It's that weird anti-Semitism virus that seems to infect the minds of the goy."

    I'd also say that the Holocaust story started to become central to Jewish identity. And part of the Holocaust story is that white, Christian goys can turn into SS officers on a dime. That khaki-wearing neighbor of yours is just one bad economic downturn away from setting up gas chambers in Ohio. (And these gas chambers will be as magically efficient as the German ones.)

    If you assume that whites are always on the verge of trying to genocide your people, well, you'd tried to take away their power and ability to mobilize as well.

    To their credit, Jews accomplished their goal. Americans whites are truly a defeated people at this point. And looking at Biden's cabinet, it's obvious that Jews now openly run the country.

    But as you say, it's a pyrrhic victory. They now control a failing empire and more and more gentiles of all colors are noticing that fact. What's more, Europe is growing ever more Muslim, so not exactly Jew friendly. China and the East won't fall for their tricks, if for no other reason than Jews don't look like them - which is a bigger deal than people think.

    While Jews will continue to wield a lot of power, we likely have passed Peak Jew. Ironically, their power and influence is now tied a country that they helped to destroy.

    Replies: @ziggurat, @Anonymous

    It’s like the story of the scorpion and the frog. But perhaps, they plan to move to Greater Israel, if the West falls.

  158. @Hi There
    I liked this reply to WaPo:
    https://twitter.com/GadSaad/status/1426345719003324418

    Replies: @J.Ross, @Mrwolf

    We need to prevent rule by third worlders and primitives.

  159. @Marty T
    @SafeNow

    It's probably the job of those that are younger than Steve (30s and 40s) to figure out what to do about it. And there are things to do. As long as we have tens of millions, land and weapons galore, don't tell me there's nothing that can be done.

    South Africa is 10 percent white. We're 58 percent white. Come on now.

    Replies: @Mrwolf

    There was a European nation that was almost in the same state America is now. Then in 1933 they had enough! Until more whites are personally affected, nothing will be done. But rest assured this can be corrected.

  160. @Polistra
    @Intelligent Dasein



    the commentariat engages in some pretty vicious crabology [...]

    The blog seems to be a place where mostly 50-something, well-off, embittered and perpetually constipated IYIs come to belch out their discomfort.
     
    Classic I.D. "I hate everyone--and why am I not more popular?"

    Replies: @Intelligent Dasein, @Professional Slav

    Looks like a nerve was hit right on the spot.

  161. I guess Jennifer Rubin will react like Chanty Binx, an SJW also known under the name of “Big Red” and Trigglypuff if someone do a little change of her text like this for example:
    …a more diverse, more inclusive society. this is fabulous news. now we need to prevent minority (((White))) rule….

    And they wonder why antisemitism is on the rise. Btw, Ashkanazis aren’t semetic people, how come it’s antisemitism?

    • Replies: @Hrw-500
    @Hrw-500

    Another detail then I forgot, there's an other "Great Replacement" then the medias don't cover a lot, the replacement of blacks by hispanics/latinos from what I saw on a thread on City-Data forums talking of an article from Takimag.
    http://www.city-data.com/forum/politics-other-controversies/3295330-blacks-being-displaced-latinos-california.html
    https://www.takimag.com/article/blackbuster-video/

  162. @Hrw-500
    I guess Jennifer Rubin will react like Chanty Binx, an SJW also known under the name of "Big Red" and Trigglypuff if someone do a little change of her text like this for example:
    ...a more diverse, more inclusive society. this is fabulous news. now we need to prevent minority (((White))) rule....

    And they wonder why antisemitism is on the rise. Btw, Ashkanazis aren't semetic people, how come it's antisemitism?

    Replies: @Hrw-500

    Another detail then I forgot, there’s an other “Great Replacement” then the medias don’t cover a lot, the replacement of blacks by hispanics/latinos from what I saw on a thread on City-Data forums talking of an article from Takimag.
    http://www.city-data.com/forum/politics-other-controversies/3295330-blacks-being-displaced-latinos-california.html
    https://www.takimag.com/article/blackbuster-video/

  163. Anonymous[199] • Disclaimer says:
    @Citizen of a Silly Country
    @AnotherDad

    The phrase really should be: They hate you and want your people turned into helots.

    But that just doesn't roll of the tongue, so I'll stick with they hate you and want you dead.

    As to Jews and the United States (and, really, Britain before that), I wholeheartedly agree. By the 1960s, Jews were seen by gentile whites as just another white ethnic group and yet were able to act as a people apart. They were quickly gaining control of the commanding heights of the world's most powerful society, but the gentiles didn't notice or care.

    It was literally paradise on earth for the Jews. You'd think that they'd count themselves lucky and just ride that wonderful train. Instead, they worked diligently to destroy it.

    I'd agree that part of the reason is that it's simply in their nature. They do it over and over throughout history. They also never learn. It's always, "And then the people of country X for no reason at all attacked us and kicked us out. Us, the Jews, who had done so much for them. It's that weird anti-Semitism virus that seems to infect the minds of the goy."

    I'd also say that the Holocaust story started to become central to Jewish identity. And part of the Holocaust story is that white, Christian goys can turn into SS officers on a dime. That khaki-wearing neighbor of yours is just one bad economic downturn away from setting up gas chambers in Ohio. (And these gas chambers will be as magically efficient as the German ones.)

    If you assume that whites are always on the verge of trying to genocide your people, well, you'd tried to take away their power and ability to mobilize as well.

    To their credit, Jews accomplished their goal. Americans whites are truly a defeated people at this point. And looking at Biden's cabinet, it's obvious that Jews now openly run the country.

    But as you say, it's a pyrrhic victory. They now control a failing empire and more and more gentiles of all colors are noticing that fact. What's more, Europe is growing ever more Muslim, so not exactly Jew friendly. China and the East won't fall for their tricks, if for no other reason than Jews don't look like them - which is a bigger deal than people think.

    While Jews will continue to wield a lot of power, we likely have passed Peak Jew. Ironically, their power and influence is now tied a country that they helped to destroy.

    Replies: @ziggurat, @Anonymous

    No, Jews thrive in multicultural and multiracial nations. Now is the best time to be a Jew in America and the future will only be better. The time of greatest danger for American Jews was the 1950s and 60s, when America was both racially monolithic and militantly anti-Communist, at a time when most Jews had left-wing sympathies. That danger has passed and is never coming back.

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to All Steve Sailer Comments via RSS
PastClassics
How America was neoconned into World War IV
“America’s strategic and economic interests in the Mideast and Muslim world are being threatened by the agony in...