The Unz Review: An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 TeasersiSteve Blog
National Geographic: Genocide Is a Small Price to Pay for Invasion
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information



=>

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Troll, or LOL with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used once per hour.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

From National Geographic:

The first Europeans weren’t who you might think

Genetic tests of ancient settlers’ remains show that Europe is a melting pot of bloodlines from Africa, the Middle East, and today’s Russia.

BY ANDREW CURRY
PUBLISHED JULY 2019

The idea that there were once “pure” populations of ancestral Europeans, there since the days of woolly mammoths, has inspired ideologues since well before the Nazis. It has long nourished white racism, and in recent years it has stoked fears about the impact of immigrants: fears that have threatened to rip apart the European Union and roiled politics in the United States.

Now scientists are delivering new answers to the question of who Europeans really are and where they came from. Their findings suggest that the continent has been a melting pot since the Ice Age. Europeans living today, in whatever country, are a varying mix of ancient bloodlines hailing from Africa, the Middle East, and the Russian steppe.

The evidence comes from archaeological artifacts, from the analysis of ancient teeth and bones, and from linguistics. But above all it comes from the new field of paleogenetics. … In the process any notion of European genetic purity has been swept away on a tide of powdered bone.

The horsemanship the Yamnaya brought to Europe lives on in their native region. A rider at the Zaporizhzhya Cossack Museum on Ukraine’s Khortytsya Island demonstrates the acrobatic skills that made the Cossacks such feared warriors from the 1400s on.

Three major movements of people, it now seems clear, shaped the course of European prehistory. Immigrants brought art and music, farming and cities, domesticated horses and the wheel. They introduced the Indo-European languages spoken across much of the continent today. They may have even brought the plague. The last major contributors to western and central Europe’s genetic makeup—the last of the first Europeans, so to speak—arrived from the Russian steppe as Stonehenge was being built, nearly 5,000 years ago. They finished the job.

The Aryan invaders also 90% finished off the originators of Stonehenge, but look on the bright side. Being genocided is a small price to pay for being invaded. Think of all the innovative mutton cuisine that the Aryan conquerors must have brought with them.

In an era of debate over migration and borders, the science shows that Europe is a continent of immigrants and always has been. “The people who live in a place today are not the descendants of people who lived there long ago,” says Harvard University paleogeneticist David Reich. “There are no indigenous people—anyone who hearkens back to racial purity is confronted with the meaninglessness of the concept.” …

Within a few centuries, other people with a significant amount of Yamnaya DNA had spread as far as the British Isles. In Britain and some other places, hardly any of the farmers who already lived in Europe survived the onslaught from the east. In what is now Germany, “there’s a 70 percent to possibly 100 percent replacement of the local population,” Reich says. “Something very dramatic happens 4,500 years ago.” …

“To me, the new results from DNA are undermining the nationalist paradigm that we have always lived here and not mixed with other people,” Gothenburg’s Kristiansen says. “There’s no such thing as a Dane or a Swede or a German.” Instead, “we’re all Russians, all Africans.”

In other words, when the Nazis invaded the Soviet Union on June 22, 1941, they were just Yamnaya reclaiming their ancestral homeland. So nobody should have got so upset.

As we know now, the Fundamental Right to Invade is just Science.

In my 2018 review of David Reich’s book, I offered a demurral against the the increasingly popular idea that we should hold ourselves in the 21st Century to the moral standards of the genocidal steppe barbarians of 2500 BC.

But then I’m an extremist nutjob, so I would prefer rule of law to invasion.

https://twitter.com/nmassello/status/1150671747357847552

 
Hide 100 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. You’d think that since this took place 4000 years ago and since then patterns of population density and borders have created cohesive homogeneous populations would imply their existence and shared interest.

    It’s just getting too much. Does anything exist? It’s all just a hodge-podge of the same matter and energy.

    • Agree: bomag
    • Replies: @Justvisiting
    How long before "National Geographic" figures out their name is a vestige of white male chauvinism and changes it to "International Geographic"?

    These next few years are going to be truly nauseating.
  2. anonymous[751] • Disclaimer says:

    Absolute madness.

    So Iceland doesn’t exist because its parliament has only been running for a thousand years? How about the Japanese royal family at two thousand?

    No? No such thing as Icelandic or Japanese people? Their whole histories are “meaningless”?

    • Replies: @Richard B
    "Absolute madness" is right.

    Once again we have a racially chauvinistic Jewish nationalist using (abusing) science to denounce White natioalism and "racial purity" while hypocritically ignoring the requirement to prove one is racially a jew before they can become an Israeli citizen.

    And all done with the typical brazen effrontery that many rightfully find so obnoxious and irritating.

    Eventually, like every prominent jewish intellectual or pseudo-scientist from Marx, Freud, Einstein (the Mark Zuckerberg of Physics), The Frankfurt Schoool, The French School, Chomsky, S.J. Gould, Carl Sagan, Jared Diamond and whoever else I forgot to mention, he'll be discredted - after he's gotten his point across and the damage is done.

    This is why Schopenhauer said that nothing about Judaism can be confused with Reason.

    Intellectually jews operate out of a combination of alchemy and superficially sophisticated gossip.

    Which is why they HAVE to demonize all of our thinkers and pathologize our love for them.

    Again, the insanity of their racial fanaticism rears its ugly head in the form of pseudo-intellectual black magic passing itself off as real science and presented with contemptuous self-satisfaction.

    No wonder they came up with the idea of "antisemitism" since they inspire it in everyone they come into contact with. The word should be redefined to mean "the inevitable reaction to contact with jewish people.

    Even with all of their power they remain an obnoxious and unimpressive people.

    , @bored identity
    Not to mention Ancient Harkensteins; the authentic inventors of genetic hygiene.
  3. “The people who live in a place today are not the descendants of people who lived there long ago,” says Harvard University paleogeneticist David Reich. “There are no indigenous people”

    Your people have only been here for… 4500 years. So you are insane to support immigration restrictionism

    • Replies: @Corn
    “There are no indigenous people”

    Awesome! I’ll tell the Sioux to stop bitching. I’m sure that will go over well.
    , @Alden
    What about the cave paintings? One goes back about 66, 000 years in Maltrevsio Spain.

    DNA sample from 10,000 year old Cheddar Man found in Cheddar Gorge Somerset UK matched a local school teacher. He’s a direct descendant and there are others in the area ((Scientists)) claim Cheddar Man had dark brown skin. His pale White descendant has fair white skin.

    It’s Nat Geo, nothing but anti White propaganda

    , @dfordoom

    “The people who live in a place today are not the descendants of people who lived there long ago,” says Harvard University paleogeneticist David Reich. “There are no indigenous people”
     
    I'd suggest that David Reich shelve any plans he might have to visit Australia. Denying the existence of indigenous people would land him in a world of hurt. It might even land him in jail.

    It's the Current Year in Australia as well, but the Current Year isn't the same everywhere.
    , @Richard B
    "There are no indigenous people."

    Well, there goes half the reason for hating White America.

    So much for Identity Politics.

    Thanks Reich.

    The communist pseudo-intellectuals, and the politicians and media talking heads who repeat their talking points like the chattering of an idiot only less interesting, will want to use Reich's book as yet more White Man Bad ammo only to be stopped dead in thier tracks with that line.

    Again, Thanks Reich.

    What's AOC and Omar, et al. going to do now?

  4. The other thing this misses is that the peoples of Europe have been more contiguous for longer than those of Africa, the Middle East, the Arctic and mainland East Asia and the rest of the Americas.

    Only Australian Aborigines and South East Asia have them beat and India have them tied.

    • Replies: @obwandiyag
    Totally wrong. Just wrong. The Americas were fully populated while Europe was under a mile-thick ice sheet. In other words, when there was no such thing as "Europeans."
  5. Lot says:

    I really despise these liars.

    So happy to see the legacy media’s rapid death.

    The various woke clickbait companies are all collapsing too. Gawker, Vox, Vice, Buzzfeed: all chopping staff and cutting costs as their valuations have dropped 90%.

    Mic.com got $57 million in funding. Check out the site now: now just one woke clickbait article a week.

    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
    That's good to hear, Lot. It's not like I would have known, as I not only don't read any of those sites, I don't read any sites that bother to write about any of those sites.
    , @International Jew

    The various woke clickbait companies are all collapsing
     
    That might just be the churn and "creative destruction" typical of a young industry.
  6. The idea that there were once “pure” populations

    Yes, and he ‘skewers’ this with the same ‘logic’ which says that if even one person can be located whose existence and nature contradicts any stereotype, then not only is that stereotype invalid, it’s manifestly the opposite of fact.

    David Reich: “There are no indigenous people”

    Right? I mean, except for Africans, Amerinds, Jews in Palestine, that sort of thing.

    • Agree: jim jones, Hail
  7. Gregory Cochran’s extended review of Reich’s book begins here:

    https://westhunt.wordpress.com/2018/03/29/who-we-are-1/

    There are five or six parts. All are must reading. Cochran zaps the squid-ink and cuts to the chase.

    • Replies: @Unladen Swallow
    I think there are eleven different posts in total, spread over several weeks. Some of them are reviews of the different sections of the book, some are reviews of comments and criticisms of Reich and his work.

    Reich is only really skewered for the no pure races shtick justifying invasions, which of course this article is promoting as the new correct thinking.

  8. That article is responding to a position that precisely nobody takes.

    • Agree: International Jew
    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
    How would I know? I only take National Geographic for the pictures. Some of those Yamnayan ladies are stacked, man.
  9. All this tells us is that the best-of-the-best immigrants left their shithole lands to come take a shithole Europe away from less-deserving native Europeans, and having done all the heavy lifting for a few millenia, are now out of guilt allowing themselves to be overrun by the descendants of those low-energy types they left behind, who didn’t have the energy to transform their shitholes into something better but can scratch together enough for a boat-ride.

  10. We are all descended from violent invaders who killed all the men and raped all the women.

    Therefore, we must all welcome the next generation of violent invaders who will do the same to us –

    So they say.

  11. Climate Change: Must not be accepted, go full panic mode.
    Population Change: Must be accepted, go full Valium mode

    • Agree: YetAnotherAnon
    • Replies: @BenKenobi
    Nice distillation.

    Also --

    Climate Change: we must command the tides to cease!
    Population Change: hey it's like the weather, it changes. nothing we can do.
  12. The Yamnaya “Just Wanted A Better Life”?

    …and after the Yamnaya came the Huns, Mongols, Turks, Bulgars, Avars, Tatars*, et al. The Russian Czars reversed the overall East to West gene flow for awhile and people largely descended from the Yamnaya replaced (nice euphemism for genocide) the Siberian-Americans in most of their former territories north of the Rio Grande.

    More recently a mostly mestizo people have successfully launched a Reconquista/Lebensraum for La Raza into the U.S. and Northeast Asians are rapidly replacing whites here in elite educational institutions.

    Good Golly, we *have* “always been at war with Eastasia.”

    The truth is, of course, that most the world’s peoples see whites as weak and vulnerable(see lion, zebra) and want to see those in the West exterminated/absorbed.

    The 1965 Immigration & Naturalization Act is the moral and functional equivalent of the Wannsee Conference’s “Final Solution.” The Icky Part – that is to say, mass killings – might start much sooner than most would guess.

    * Bulgar, Avar, Tatar – Also See: the movie, “Avatar” – a screed of genocidal intensity – especially against white humans
    Hear Also: -an American Indian accent in one of the male alien braves of “Avatar” and a Caribbean accent in one of their old wise females.

    • Agree: HammerJack
    • Replies: @Charon
    Susan Rice condemns Chinese diplomat as 'racist disgrace'

    https://www-m.cnn.com/2019/07/15/politics/susan-rice-chinese-diplomat-tweets/index.html

    Funzapoppin!
  13. Steve Sailer says he offered a ‘demural’ when I believe the correct spelling of what he intended is ‘demurral’, for ‘expression of disagreement’

    Tho ‘demural’ is also a word, to ‘demuralise’ is to take a wall down, which we are also seeing with the mural art of historic white people that some now find ‘triggering’

    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
    Just a month or so ago, iSteve offered to demural a high school for the low, low price of 8 hundred and something odd thousand dollars... just sayin' ...
    , @Alden
    I don’t mind painting over the communist WPA murals in San Francisco at all. I do like then and the Beach Chalet which has one was one of our favorite drinking spots when it was still a construction workers local haven instead of a tourist trap.

    Most of the communist WPA murals have very unsubtle anti White sections.
  14. Double, Triple, Quadruple…Final Jeopardy?

    Category: Subspecies On Brink Of Extermination

    Answer: A corpse riddled with entrance wounds coming from multiple directions

    Question: What is in the center of The Coalition of the Fringes’ Circular Firing Squad?

    ….sigh…guess we had a good run for a time… : (

  15. So it would appear NAT GEO has been taken over by the we need to return to the 1300s crowd. Because that’s the technological level the New European It will be able to maintain.

    • Replies: @Paul Jolliffe
    "So it would appear NAT GEO has been taken over by the we need to return to the 1300s crowd. Because that’s the technological level the New European It will be able to maintain."

    Ah no.

    1300's Europeans invented the cannon, clocks, eyeglasses and the harpsichord.

    That is waaaaay beyond the technological sophistication of the looming hordes of "New European It"s.
    , @Richard B
    The New Europeans will be there until they've replaced the Real Europeans.

    After that, they'll be Smart Citied, ie; Placed into Smart Cities and vaporized.
  16. The moral of the farce we are living through is that rational discussion is the White man’s tool. These people only understand one cliched thing and that is the Will To Power. They will rationalize backwards in some clumsy nonsense way to justify their position. However, with different actors they’ll have a completely different position, and such, a different rationalization making both ungeneralizable. Trying to understand these people is like trying to understand why monkeys throw shit. It’s just what they do. Monkeys are going to throw shit and these people are going to “rationalize” the gibs. Why waste your time?

    Does Natgeo endorse Whites colonization efforts? Of course not, because that’s racist. One’s natural and healthy, and the other is racist. To replace their dying White readership NatGeo will eventually start including videos of White people being stomped on in the street to attract vibrant readers.

    • Replies: @Alden
    Good point. The most anti White segments of the media like Nat Geo Atlantic New Republic etc are only read by affluent aging Whites. Who will subscribe to them in another 20 years when their subscribers are all dead?
  17. @Lot
    I really despise these liars.

    So happy to see the legacy media’s rapid death.

    The various woke clickbait companies are all collapsing too. Gawker, Vox, Vice, Buzzfeed: all chopping staff and cutting costs as their valuations have dropped 90%.

    Mic.com got $57 million in funding. Check out the site now: now just one woke clickbait article a week.

    That’s good to hear, Lot. It’s not like I would have known, as I not only don’t read any of those sites, I don’t read any sites that bother to write about any of those sites.

    • Replies: @David
    Mr Newman, Achmed, if I may, Lot wrote this a few months ago:

    RT is a propaganda arm of a foreign dictatorship.

    Citing it is a shameful act for an American, regardless of its particular content.

    The Russians in 2016 also spread anti-white BLM propaganda. Whatever suits their agenda.
     
    Just to remind you he's a dirt bag.
  18. @Anon
    That article is responding to a position that precisely nobody takes.

    How would I know? I only take National Geographic for the pictures. Some of those Yamnayan ladies are stacked, man.

  19. @Brabantian
    Steve Sailer says he offered a 'demural' when I believe the correct spelling of what he intended is 'demurral', for 'expression of disagreement'

    Tho 'demural' is also a word, to 'demuralise' is to take a wall down, which we are also seeing with the mural art of historic white people that some now find 'triggering'

    Just a month or so ago, iSteve offered to demural a high school for the low, low price of 8 hundred and something odd thousand dollars… just sayin’ …

    • LOL: 68W58
  20. @Redneck farmer
    So it would appear NAT GEO has been taken over by the we need to return to the 1300s crowd. Because that's the technological level the New European It will be able to maintain.

    “So it would appear NAT GEO has been taken over by the we need to return to the 1300s crowd. Because that’s the technological level the New European It will be able to maintain.”

    Ah no.

    1300’s Europeans invented the cannon, clocks, eyeglasses and the harpsichord.

    That is waaaaay beyond the technological sophistication of the looming hordes of “New European It”s.

    • Agree: Desiderius
  21. so Europeans and European diaspora are a unique blend formed c. 4000 years ago of
    – original hunter-gatherers from Europe
    – early farmers from around the Aegean
    – Indo-European herders from the steppe
    and the rest is history.

    cool, good to know.

  22. In Britain and some other places, hardly any of the farmers who already lived in Europe survived the onslaught from the east. In what is now Germany, “there’s a 70 percent to possibly 100 percent replacement of the local population,” Reich says. “Something very dramatic happens 4,500 years ago.” …

    The real lesson here is “If you’re invaded, fight and win or be killed”.

    Counterinsurgency

    • Agree: Richard B
  23. Europeans are literally the descendants of a group of people who wiped out almost all the people who had lived in Europe before them. That explains so much of all the bad things that people of European descent are accused of.

    • Replies: @Anon
    Except that we are speaking of so called "wiping out" strictly within the Caucasoid race, and that intermixing was most of that process: accounting for the significantly differentiated haplotype variations within most modern Northwest European nations. ie: R1 and I1,I2.

    I'm still here and my y-DNA haplotype was most likely indigenous to the British Isles. Its difficult to find my phenotype anywhere (including the rest of Europe) unless you reference Scotland: from where my father originated, the person whom I resemble. I'm living proof that there was no wholesale "wiping out".

    My mother is from North Germany.

    Some invaders improve things, genetically and always otherwise, and some threaten to bring the world down to that of the animal. That is a large difference that is all the difference.

    Which is why your "bad things that Europeans are accused of", which is largely Jewish propaganda (especially when taking into account the broad brush that they use, as well as their own misdeeds in comparison), is nonsense in comparison to the societies of traditional European enemies and other targets.

    Last, no European invasion of anyone can ever justify African (or other) invasion of Europeans. These people are animals in comparison to us, to include our indigenous remnants and their past conquerers. Neither can our own infighting ever justify their invasion.
    , @Richard B
    "Europeans are literally the descendants of a group of people who wiped out almost all the people who had lived in Europe before them. That explains so much of all the bad things that people of European descent are accused of."

    White Man Bad. Mama make cocoa. Give blanket. Basement cold.
  24. I don’t see how Africans came to figure in the mix along the Steppenwolves, though.

    The Early Farmers seem to have been the offspring of native NW Anatolian foragers who did a lot of trekking once they’d invented cheese and biscuits. Along the Med, up the Danube (and even into N Africa, sshhh).
    “Assimilating” (the usual; expulsion, rape & massacre) the even more native Western hunter gatherers, whose Y-lines have disappeared from the face of the earth, although the Farmists scooped up a lot of genetic stuff (blue eyes?) from the hapless squaws.
    They buggered about in Europe for centuries until some sort of resurgence of native (male & female) forager-turned-farmer types set them back in the north, and caused the usual “fusion”. Only themselves to be steamrollered by probably steppoids, and turning into Corded Ware (sort of Yamna?).

    Then the actual Horde arrived in instalments, (in the wake of the Black Death : Part I ??), and guess what? No tea and biscuits for them. So they were naturally furious.

    But Africans? Of any sort, since the last glaciation? I don’t think so.

  25. Think of all the innovative mutton cuisine that the Aryan conquerors must have brought with them.

    • Replies: @Escher
    Genghis Khan and his Golden Horde turned quite a fair portion of the world into their own “cumdump” too.
  26. Aren’t these the same dorks who wear t-shirts with a picture of an Indian with a rifle captioned “The Original Homeland security?”

  27. “The people who live in a place today are not the descendants of people who lived there long ago,” says Harvard University paleogeneticist David Reich.

    Weird, I share Oetzi the Iceman’s Y chromosome and descend from people in the same area. And the men on my mother’s side share the common Scandanavian I-M253 Y chromosome of the non-Yamnaya “natives”.

    Do I not descend from them? Am I still not ancestrally European enough to have descended from the Early European Farmers and Western Hunter Gatherers?

    *Nasally voice*
    You see, a long time ago, a vast ice sheet retreated off this continent, and various people from the south and south east “immigrated” north/northwest to take advantage of the empty lands, therefore, you are not allowed to have a country today today.

  28. Yamnaya ffs.

    Before illiterate popularizers of science* took over, it was was known as pit grave culture and often wasn’t even capitalized.

    Yamnaya is just an adjective derived of Russian yama (яма) which means a pit. It’s not a place or anything, it refers simply to a distinct burial technique.

    * I need double scare quotes here.

    • Replies: @Intelligent Dasein
    It doesn't matter what side of the issue one takes. Whether you belong to the "we're all immigrants" camp or the "muh steppe barbarians prove evolution which somehow means I'm right to be a nationalist" camp (i.e. the Steve-o-sphere), anybody who argues anything based upon thinly sourced fairy tales about 4500-year-old population flows is still just in the business of retailing modernity. It doesn't do any good.
  29. (i) Pure races don’t exist.

    (ii) The evidence is that “races” are in fact mixtures of easily distinguished components.

    Observe that (ii) contradicts (i), for what are these components but races?

  30. you never existed goyims. you have no history you have no culture. there’s no such thing as white people.

    This message brought to you by Nat Geo’s Jewish editor.

  31. To whom is this person referring as supporters of the idea of pure populations of proto-Europeans?

  32. @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Think of all the innovative mutton cuisine that the Aryan conquerors must have brought with them.
     
    https://i.redd.it/8qq33g0mknz11.jpg

    Genghis Khan and his Golden Horde turned quite a fair portion of the world into their own “cumdump” too.

    • Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican
    You can blame Arnold for instigating that.

    https://i.ytimg.com/vi/_XUu3_pLPUE/maxresdefault.jpg
  33. The idea that there were once “pure” populations… has inspired ideologues since well before the Nazis.

    Of course. Read the Old Testament — there were a bunch of ideologues thousands of years ago who thought they were the Chosen People. They traced the purity of their bloodline all the way back to Adam…

  34. I’m other words a call to genocide White men. Egged on by gays and women.

    This will continue until we say never again and make it stick.

    • Agree: JMcG
  35. @hhh
    “The people who live in a place today are not the descendants of people who lived there long ago,” says Harvard University paleogeneticist David Reich. “There are no indigenous people"

    Your people have only been here for... 4500 years. So you are insane to support immigration restrictionism

    “There are no indigenous people”

    Awesome! I’ll tell the Sioux to stop bitching. I’m sure that will go over well.

    • Replies: @Forbes
    So, no more of these capitulations and compromises by granting gambling casino franchises to Amerindians.
  36. Personally I prefer Cossack sword dancing demonstrations to Cossack horsemanship demonstrations.
    https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=cossack+sword+dance&view=detail&mid=5AB9C821FF4D3AD902EF5AB9C821FF4D3AD902EF&FORM=VIRE

    • Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican
    Here ya go:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qtvsn9_y9S8

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IzbOilUqgwI
  37. Anon[381] • Disclaimer says:
    @anonotron
    Europeans are literally the descendants of a group of people who wiped out almost all the people who had lived in Europe before them. That explains so much of all the bad things that people of European descent are accused of.

    Except that we are speaking of so called “wiping out” strictly within the Caucasoid race, and that intermixing was most of that process: accounting for the significantly differentiated haplotype variations within most modern Northwest European nations. ie: R1 and I1,I2.

    I’m still here and my y-DNA haplotype was most likely indigenous to the British Isles. Its difficult to find my phenotype anywhere (including the rest of Europe) unless you reference Scotland: from where my father originated, the person whom I resemble. I’m living proof that there was no wholesale “wiping out”.

    My mother is from North Germany.

    Some invaders improve things, genetically and always otherwise, and some threaten to bring the world down to that of the animal. That is a large difference that is all the difference.

    Which is why your “bad things that Europeans are accused of”, which is largely Jewish propaganda (especially when taking into account the broad brush that they use, as well as their own misdeeds in comparison), is nonsense in comparison to the societies of traditional European enemies and other targets.

    Last, no European invasion of anyone can ever justify African (or other) invasion of Europeans. These people are animals in comparison to us, to include our indigenous remnants and their past conquerers. Neither can our own infighting ever justify their invasion.

  38. @El Dato
    Climate Change: Must not be accepted, go full panic mode.
    Population Change: Must be accepted, go full Valium mode

    Nice distillation.

    Also —

    Climate Change: we must command the tides to cease!
    Population Change: hey it’s like the weather, it changes. nothing we can do.

  39. In an era of debate over migration and borders, the science shows that Europe is a continent of immigrants and always has been.

    Which has no bearing on anything.

    Human progress depends on protecting what humans builds from destruction by other humans. Support for immigration in principle is support for human extinction.

  40. @Haruto Rat
    Yamnaya ffs.

    Before illiterate popularizers of science* took over, it was was known as pit grave culture and often wasn't even capitalized.

    Yamnaya is just an adjective derived of Russian yama (яма) which means a pit. It's not a place or anything, it refers simply to a distinct burial technique.

    * I need double scare quotes here.

    It doesn’t matter what side of the issue one takes. Whether you belong to the “we’re all immigrants” camp or the “muh steppe barbarians prove evolution which somehow means I’m right to be a nationalist” camp (i.e. the Steve-o-sphere), anybody who argues anything based upon thinly sourced fairy tales about 4500-year-old population flows is still just in the business of retailing modernity. It doesn’t do any good.

  41. Abe says:

    From Bernard Lewis’s THE ARABS IN HISTORY:

    What is an Arab?… A gathering of Arab leaders many years ago defined an Arab in these words: “Whoever lives in our country, speaks our language, is brought up in our culture and takes pride in our glory is one of us.”

    So simple really, less conditions than the fingers on one hand, yet our credentialed monomaniacs WHEN IT SUITS THEIR PURPOSES pretend they cannot understand such a commonsensical definition, and instead insist on Hadron Collider-like precision.

  42. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Susan_Goldberg

    “Susan Goldberg is an American journalist and editor in chief of National Geographic Magazine. She is the first woman to edit the magazine since it was first published in 1888.”

    Shouldn’t it be renamed Global Geographic to rid itself of the taint of nationalism?

  43. No Western country is allowed to have a “present tense” in which the wishes of those currently residing here must be respected. You can talk about 5000 years ago, you can talk about 5000 years from now, you can speak about slavery and you may speak about the multicultural future but what you may never speak about are the wishes of the people right here and right now. The West is allowed no “present tense”

    • Replies: @Desiderius
    Passive voice; dr
  44. I think 90% is only for the Y-DNA and in western coastal Europe. For the entire DNA, they took around 30% of the gene pool, the farmer being around 55% and the hunter gatherer 15%.

    But in Spain (except basque) and England it’s more like 60% farmer and 40% yamnaya.

    When you think about how they must have stopped male to reproduce and how they succeeded in replacing 40% of the population, even Handsmaid tale or GoT look soft.

    How Reich, and others, from there extract the main idea that White identity is plural (HG + Farmer + Yamnaya who were also Farmer and HG but from different place, Iran and Easr Europe) is really amazing. And also saying that the 19tj scientist, and Nazi, were completely wrong when the main message – a patriarchal warrior society coming from Caucasus submitted european culture and people to its will – is 100% correct.

    The two main ideas are immigration is genocide and our main ancestors – farmers – were submitted completely by our patriarchal ancestors, the aryan who gave us all our languages (except maybe Finnish, Estonian, carnelian, Magyar ans basque … )

    • Replies: @Bruno
    And for the mitochondrial dna, it’s not huge. So they didn’t probably brought many women with them. A bit like today’s migrants ?
  45. @Bruno
    I think 90% is only for the Y-DNA and in western coastal Europe. For the entire DNA, they took around 30% of the gene pool, the farmer being around 55% and the hunter gatherer 15%.

    But in Spain (except basque) and England it’s more like 60% farmer and 40% yamnaya.

    When you think about how they must have stopped male to reproduce and how they succeeded in replacing 40% of the population, even Handsmaid tale or GoT look soft.

    How Reich, and others, from there extract the main idea that White identity is plural (HG + Farmer + Yamnaya who were also Farmer and HG but from different place, Iran and Easr Europe) is really amazing. And also saying that the 19tj scientist, and Nazi, were completely wrong when the main message - a patriarchal warrior society coming from Caucasus submitted european culture and people to its will - is 100% correct.

    The two main ideas are immigration is genocide and our main ancestors - farmers - were submitted completely by our patriarchal ancestors, the aryan who gave us all our languages (except maybe Finnish, Estonian, carnelian, Magyar ans basque ... )

    And for the mitochondrial dna, it’s not huge. So they didn’t probably brought many women with them. A bit like today’s migrants ?

  46. I feel a lot better now about living in the New World, on top of Injun burial sites and whatever.

  47. Seems like Sumer springs to life about the same time the yamnaya are expanding.

    It was once said that Sumerians invented the wheel, now it’s that they got it from the Maikop up north.

    Mighty close to the steppe there!

  48. @Lot
    I really despise these liars.

    So happy to see the legacy media’s rapid death.

    The various woke clickbait companies are all collapsing too. Gawker, Vox, Vice, Buzzfeed: all chopping staff and cutting costs as their valuations have dropped 90%.

    Mic.com got $57 million in funding. Check out the site now: now just one woke clickbait article a week.

    The various woke clickbait companies are all collapsing

    That might just be the churn and “creative destruction” typical of a young industry.

    • Replies: @bomag
    Yes. I expect the sensibilities of those sites will rise again in an even more totalitarian form.
    , @Lot
    “That might just be the churn and “creative destruction” typical of a young industry.”

    Not that young anymore. Slate and Salon have been around for 20+ years as online only news/opinion sites.

    Lots of bad trends.

    First a steady and punishing decline in online ad rates.

    Second, their valuations are so low they can’t sell shares to fund operations, so they go into death spirals of cutting content staff, then losing audience, then cutting more.

    Third advertisers are migrating to Google and Facebook, and if you use them as brokers to get ad revenue, you have to compete with others using the same platform with each buy, and pay a bunch to Google/FB as a commission.

    Fourth, FB is shifting away from letting clickbait mills promote their articles for free and replacing it with pay to play. Just because a FB friend shares a buzzfeed article doesn’t mean you see it in your timeline.

    The end game I see is the clickbaiters that rely on free labor like Forbes and HuffPo surviving by getting rid of even more of their paid content staff. Then buzzfeed and Gawker type blogs that are mostly paid staff cutting back to a small shell of what they were 3-6 years ago when the VC money was flooding their way.
  49. “Nazis” mentioned in the first sentence, total garbage alert, typical Nat Geo , stopped reading the insert. More ” Cheddar-man” bull, easy to know

  50. @Alfa158
    Personally I prefer Cossack sword dancing demonstrations to Cossack horsemanship demonstrations.
    https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=cossack+sword+dance&view=detail&mid=5AB9C821FF4D3AD902EF5AB9C821FF4D3AD902EF&FORM=VIRE

    Here ya go:

  51. In other words, when the Nazis invaded the Soviet Union on June 22, 1941, they were just Yamnaya reclaiming their ancestral homeland. So nobody should have got so upset.

    Communists are the real racists, obviously.

  52. Whisky is made from barley and water. So pouring a gallon or so of barley broth into this cask of single malt whisky won’t make any difference.

  53. In other words, post-war de-colonization was a mistake.

    Fire up the Man-o-War, the scramble for Africa is back on.

  54. @vinteuil
    Gregory Cochran's extended review of Reich's book begins here:

    https://westhunt.wordpress.com/2018/03/29/who-we-are-1/

    There are five or six parts. All are must reading. Cochran zaps the squid-ink and cuts to the chase.

    I think there are eleven different posts in total, spread over several weeks. Some of them are reviews of the different sections of the book, some are reviews of comments and criticisms of Reich and his work.

    Reich is only really skewered for the no pure races shtick justifying invasions, which of course this article is promoting as the new correct thinking.

  55. @Altai
    You'd think that since this took place 4000 years ago and since then patterns of population density and borders have created cohesive homogeneous populations would imply their existence and shared interest.

    It's just getting too much. Does anything exist? It's all just a hodge-podge of the same matter and energy.

    How long before “National Geographic” figures out their name is a vestige of white male chauvinism and changes it to “International Geographic”?

    These next few years are going to be truly nauseating.

  56. @International Jew

    The various woke clickbait companies are all collapsing
     
    That might just be the churn and "creative destruction" typical of a young industry.

    Yes. I expect the sensibilities of those sites will rise again in an even more totalitarian form.

    • Replies: @International Jew
    That totalitarian form is already taking shape -- the shape of Google and Facebook acting as most people's news portal, reducing all the rest to "content providers".
  57. The idea that there were once “pure” populations of ancestral Europeans, there since the days of woolly mammoths, has inspired ideologues since well before the Nazis

    This is the kind of nonsense that fake history and Nazi caricatures produce. The eminent anthropologist Carleton Coon wrote the book, The Races of Europe in 1939. The races include among others, Nordic, Dinaric, Alpine, and Mediterranean.

    The other annoying thing about this article is that a field as arcane paleogenetics has to be corrupted to promote modern day diversity ideology. You just can’t tell the history of what happened in Europe thousands of years ago, it always must promote current woke ideology.

    “There are no indigenous people…”

    Note: This only applies to white people. I don’t think National Geographic and other left-wing rags are going to oppose Indigenous Peoples Day because they understand this term only applies to non-whites.

    “There’s no such thing as a Dane or a Swede or a German.” Instead, “we’re all Russians, all Africans.”

    This is first order BS. Let’s look at it another way. Instead of looking at people and genetics, let’s look at language. The English language is an amalgamation of old German, Norman-French, with a heavy importation of Latin and Greek words. Yet nobody would say that the English language doesn’t exist. You could understand all the prior languages that became English and still not understand English. English is a unique language and speaking every other language in the world will not enable you to speak correct English.

    The concept that when things are fused they created emergent properties and unique characteristics seem lost on these people. Bronze is an alloy, a mixture of copper and tin. Yet, no one says that Bronze doesn’t exist. It has different characteristics than either tin or copper. Europeans are a fusion between western hunter-gatherers, Neolithic farmers and pastoralists from the Steppe. This fusion created a unique race different from the rest.

    • Agree: Hypnotoad666
    • Replies: @Hypnotoad666
    If you ever want to troll an SJW, say something like "science disproves white supremacists because it shows Europeans evolved from Africans."
  58. Summary: New DNA results prove the nationalist paradigm. Defend the nation from invaders, or get exterminated.

    • Agree: ben tillman
    • Replies: @ben tillman
    Exactly. And that's why it's crucial for our enemy to monopolize the apparatus of public opinion formation.
  59. so if we’re all related then saying we don’t want any more immigrants isn’t “Racism”…….once can not be racists against ones relatives…….maybe they just don’t want more relatives over for dinner.

  60. @Roger
    Summary: New DNA results prove the nationalist paradigm. Defend the nation from invaders, or get exterminated.

    Exactly. And that’s why it’s crucial for our enemy to monopolize the apparatus of public opinion formation.

  61. @bomag
    Yes. I expect the sensibilities of those sites will rise again in an even more totalitarian form.

    That totalitarian form is already taking shape — the shape of Google and Facebook acting as most people’s news portal, reducing all the rest to “content providers”.

  62. @Escher
    Genghis Khan and his Golden Horde turned quite a fair portion of the world into their own “cumdump” too.

    You can blame Arnold for instigating that.

    [MORE]

  63. Current European genes mostly originated around the Black Sea instead of the North Sea. So what? And Europe has been a closed genepool for at least the last 4500 years. All of that is totally consistent with Europeans being genetically distinct.

    This “no pure race exists” talking point is kind of a pathetic rear guard action on the HBD front. It basically admits that distinct groups exist and just quibbles that they aren’t “pure” or super-duper old.

  64. Yamnaya weren’t Aryan. Aryan is an Indo Iranian word that started with the Andronovo-Sintashta-Srubnaya Indo-Iranians. These people exterminated the Yamnaya and Afanasievo cuktures, replacing Y-DNA R1b steppe Indo Europeans with Y-DNA R1a Indo-Iranians. Why insist on calling Yamnaya “Aryan” when they literally predate the Iranian language and have precisely zero Y-DNA R1a.

  65. @tanabear

    The idea that there were once “pure” populations of ancestral Europeans, there since the days of woolly mammoths, has inspired ideologues since well before the Nazis
     
    This is the kind of nonsense that fake history and Nazi caricatures produce. The eminent anthropologist Carleton Coon wrote the book, The Races of Europe in 1939. The races include among others, Nordic, Dinaric, Alpine, and Mediterranean.

    The other annoying thing about this article is that a field as arcane paleogenetics has to be corrupted to promote modern day diversity ideology. You just can't tell the history of what happened in Europe thousands of years ago, it always must promote current woke ideology.

    “There are no indigenous people..."
     
    Note: This only applies to white people. I don't think National Geographic and other left-wing rags are going to oppose Indigenous Peoples Day because they understand this term only applies to non-whites.

    “There’s no such thing as a Dane or a Swede or a German.” Instead, “we’re all Russians, all Africans.”
     
    This is first order BS. Let's look at it another way. Instead of looking at people and genetics, let's look at language. The English language is an amalgamation of old German, Norman-French, with a heavy importation of Latin and Greek words. Yet nobody would say that the English language doesn't exist. You could understand all the prior languages that became English and still not understand English. English is a unique language and speaking every other language in the world will not enable you to speak correct English.

    The concept that when things are fused they created emergent properties and unique characteristics seem lost on these people. Bronze is an alloy, a mixture of copper and tin. Yet, no one says that Bronze doesn't exist. It has different characteristics than either tin or copper. Europeans are a fusion between western hunter-gatherers, Neolithic farmers and pastoralists from the Steppe. This fusion created a unique race different from the rest.

    If you ever want to troll an SJW, say something like “science disproves white supremacists because it shows Europeans evolved from Africans.”

    • LOL: Lot
    • Replies: @Lot
    “If you ever want to troll an SJW”

    Other suggestions:

    “I don’t see race.”

    “I never owned any slaves. What about the Muslim pirates kidnapping Christian slaves?”

    “I am actually mixed race, my grama’s grama was a Cherokee princess.”

    “Most crime is black on black. I think the anti-police liberals are secretly OK with that, it let them take over Brooklyn which used to be black but is now all hipsters.”

    “Nobody kills more black children than abortions. Hundreds every single day.”

    “Liberals are so ignorant of economics and American history, it takes me a lot of emotional labor to educate them all the time.”
  66. This is a very good primer on the immigration rackets and who profits from it.

    https://theconservativetreehouse.com/2019/07/14/the-dc-illegal-immigration-business/

  67. @Ibound1
    No Western country is allowed to have a “present tense” in which the wishes of those currently residing here must be respected. You can talk about 5000 years ago, you can talk about 5000 years from now, you can speak about slavery and you may speak about the multicultural future but what you may never speak about are the wishes of the people right here and right now. The West is allowed no “present tense”

    Passive voice; dr

    • Replies: @Ibound1
    The deranged powers that be and govern and talk and print do not allow the West a “present tense”.
  68. @reactionry
    The Yamnaya "Just Wanted A Better Life"?

    ...and after the Yamnaya came the Huns, Mongols, Turks, Bulgars, Avars, Tatars*, et al. The Russian Czars reversed the overall East to West gene flow for awhile and people largely descended from the Yamnaya replaced (nice euphemism for genocide) the Siberian-Americans in most of their former territories north of the Rio Grande.

    More recently a mostly mestizo people have successfully launched a Reconquista/Lebensraum for La Raza into the U.S. and Northeast Asians are rapidly replacing whites here in elite educational institutions.

    Good Golly, we *have* "always been at war with Eastasia."

    The truth is, of course, that most the world's peoples see whites as weak and vulnerable(see lion, zebra) and want to see those in the West exterminated/absorbed.

    The 1965 Immigration & Naturalization Act is the moral and functional equivalent of the Wannsee Conference's "Final Solution." The Icky Part - that is to say, mass killings - might start much sooner than most would guess.

    * Bulgar, Avar, Tatar - Also See: the movie, "Avatar" - a screed of genocidal intensity - especially against white humans
    Hear Also: -an American Indian accent in one of the male alien braves of "Avatar" and a Caribbean accent in one of their old wise females.

    Susan Rice condemns Chinese diplomat as ‘racist disgrace’

    https://www-m.cnn.com/2019/07/15/politics/susan-rice-chinese-diplomat-tweets/index.html

    Funzapoppin!

    • Replies: @Justvisiting
    The Chinese diplomat declared that the black Emperor was a naked ape--heresy!
  69. @Desiderius
    Passive voice; dr

    The deranged powers that be and govern and talk and print do not allow the West a “present tense”.

  70. “There are no indigenous people—anyone who hearkens back to racial purity is confronted with the meaninglessness of the concept.”

    Most black Africans are indigenous to Africa.

  71. @Corn
    “There are no indigenous people”

    Awesome! I’ll tell the Sioux to stop bitching. I’m sure that will go over well.

    So, no more of these capitulations and compromises by granting gambling casino franchises to Amerindians.

  72. The post-Ice-Age European population was replaced at least twice, with a 90% genocide on the most recent occasion, which was more than a thousand years before Christ.

    How can you argue with someone who believes that, on these grounds, it is not a big deal if Europeans are living through another population replacement right now?

    When this is not simply an oddball opinion, but the majority view of the commentariat, we are in grave trouble.

    • Replies: @Sam Coulton
    There was not a "90% genocide" in Europe; 95% of the Y-DNA lineages in England and Southwest Europe (mainly C1 and I2) switched over to the Eastern European hunter gatherer lineage R1b in the Bronze Age. About 85% of the original mtDNA lineages in Western Europe (such as U) switched over to the Caucasian haplogroup HV.

    But the total autosomal ancestry changed much less; over 60% of the ancestry of Western Europeans is Western Hunter Gatherer/Early Neolithic Farmer. Note that the Neolithic "replacement" of Europe was not really an active replacement at all and did not involve sex-biased intermixing as the Bronze Age; if anything hunter gatherer males contributed more to Early Neolithic females than the inverse. In Scandinavia and central Europe aboriginal mtDNA actually appears to have been selected against more so than aboriginal Y-DNA: haplogroup I1 and I2 are at much greater frequencies than the aboriginal clades of mtDNA U.
  73. The horsemanship the Yamnaya brought to Europe lives on in their native region.

    This sentence is in contradiction to the thesis of the article, and the fact that the author could stick it in shows that he’s not honest.

  74. @International Jew

    The various woke clickbait companies are all collapsing
     
    That might just be the churn and "creative destruction" typical of a young industry.

    “That might just be the churn and “creative destruction” typical of a young industry.”

    Not that young anymore. Slate and Salon have been around for 20+ years as online only news/opinion sites.

    Lots of bad trends.

    First a steady and punishing decline in online ad rates.

    Second, their valuations are so low they can’t sell shares to fund operations, so they go into death spirals of cutting content staff, then losing audience, then cutting more.

    Third advertisers are migrating to Google and Facebook, and if you use them as brokers to get ad revenue, you have to compete with others using the same platform with each buy, and pay a bunch to Google/FB as a commission.

    Fourth, FB is shifting away from letting clickbait mills promote their articles for free and replacing it with pay to play. Just because a FB friend shares a buzzfeed article doesn’t mean you see it in your timeline.

    The end game I see is the clickbaiters that rely on free labor like Forbes and HuffPo surviving by getting rid of even more of their paid content staff. Then buzzfeed and Gawker type blogs that are mostly paid staff cutting back to a small shell of what they were 3-6 years ago when the VC money was flooding their way.

  75. @Achmed E. Newman
    That's good to hear, Lot. It's not like I would have known, as I not only don't read any of those sites, I don't read any sites that bother to write about any of those sites.

    Mr Newman, Achmed, if I may, Lot wrote this a few months ago:

    RT is a propaganda arm of a foreign dictatorship.

    Citing it is a shameful act for an American, regardless of its particular content.

    The Russians in 2016 also spread anti-white BLM propaganda. Whatever suits their agenda.

    Just to remind you he’s a dirt bag.

  76. @Hypnotoad666
    If you ever want to troll an SJW, say something like "science disproves white supremacists because it shows Europeans evolved from Africans."

    “If you ever want to troll an SJW”

    Other suggestions:

    “I don’t see race.”

    “I never owned any slaves. What about the Muslim pirates kidnapping Christian slaves?”

    “I am actually mixed race, my grama’s grama was a Cherokee princess.”

    “Most crime is black on black. I think the anti-police liberals are secretly OK with that, it let them take over Brooklyn which used to be black but is now all hipsters.”

    “Nobody kills more black children than abortions. Hundreds every single day.”

    “Liberals are so ignorant of economics and American history, it takes me a lot of emotional labor to educate them all the time.”

    • Replies: @Alden
    When I worked at a university I was once talking with a Chinese student I was friends with. Along comes a lesbian Hispanic activist SJW who was my affirmative action boss.

    So I introduced him to her as my son. He called me Mom. The lesbian Hispanic was just shocked , shocked that I, the blue eyed WASP devil had a Chinese son.
  77. In an era of debate over migration and borders, the science shows that Europe is a continent of immigrants and always has been.

    Except for the 4,000 years when there was no immigration!

  78. I let my National Geographic subscription run out after the Race does not Exist issue

  79. “I prefer the rule of law” c’mon, man. If they changed the law to let everyone in, you’d prefer that?

    I mean, I can sympathize with the idea that non-whites are why we can’t have rule of law, and that rule of law is a white thing, but that doesn’t seem very citizenist…

  80. @James N. Kennett
    The post-Ice-Age European population was replaced at least twice, with a 90% genocide on the most recent occasion, which was more than a thousand years before Christ.

    How can you argue with someone who believes that, on these grounds, it is not a big deal if Europeans are living through another population replacement right now?

    When this is not simply an oddball opinion, but the majority view of the commentariat, we are in grave trouble.

    There was not a “90% genocide” in Europe; 95% of the Y-DNA lineages in England and Southwest Europe (mainly C1 and I2) switched over to the Eastern European hunter gatherer lineage R1b in the Bronze Age. About 85% of the original mtDNA lineages in Western Europe (such as U) switched over to the Caucasian haplogroup HV.

    But the total autosomal ancestry changed much less; over 60% of the ancestry of Western Europeans is Western Hunter Gatherer/Early Neolithic Farmer. Note that the Neolithic “replacement” of Europe was not really an active replacement at all and did not involve sex-biased intermixing as the Bronze Age; if anything hunter gatherer males contributed more to Early Neolithic females than the inverse. In Scandinavia and central Europe aboriginal mtDNA actually appears to have been selected against more so than aboriginal Y-DNA: haplogroup I1 and I2 are at much greater frequencies than the aboriginal clades of mtDNA U.

  81. “You see, 4,500 years ago, Aryan steppe barbarians invaded Western Europe from Russia and killed off much of the indigenous population. So, modern Europeans should relax.”

    Putting aside your obvious false equivalence regarding yesteryears conquerors and today’s immigrants, human history is indeed replete with people being on the move, with dramatic consequences. It would seem that the ancestors of modern Europeans would have much more in common with the Aryan steppies given both group’s propensity for invading the world and inviting the world. Ah, memories, from the immortal words of Reverend Josiah Strong (1885).

    “Nothing can save the inferior race but a ready and pliant assimilation. Whether the feebler and more abject races are going to be regenerated and raised up, is already very much of a question. What if it should be God’s plan to people the world with better and finer material?…Civilized nations are everywhere supplanting barbarous nations, and they succeed mainly, though not exclusively, through their arts, which are the products of the intellect.”

    “Thus the Finns were supplanted by the Aryan races in Europe and Asia, the Tartars by the Russians, and thus the aborigines of North America, Australia and New Zealand are now disappearing before the all-conquering Anglo-Saxons…Whether the extinction of inferior races before the advancing Anglo-Saxon seems to the reader sad or otherwise, it certainly appears probable…The Anglo-Saxon has established himself in climates totally diverse–Canada, South Africa, and India–and, through several generations, has preserved his essential race characteristics.”

    “…Thus, while on this continent God is training the Anglo-Saxon race for its mission, a complemental work has been in progress in the great world beyond. God has two hands. Not only is He preparing in our civilization the die with which to stamp the nations, He is preparing mankind to receive our impress.”

    • Replies: @Sam Coulton
    The Indo Europeans were from the Pontic-Caspian steppe and West Russian forest plain, which is in Europe. They were also not Aryan (Andronovo-Sintashta) as I have tried to explain to you dummies numerous times before. They did get genocided by Aryans in the Eurasian steppe belt, however.
  82. Who believes a word in Nat Geo since it was taken over by Jews.

    My mother the science teacher and environmentalist gave all her grandchildren life long Nat Geo subscriptions on their tenth birthdays. That was 30 to 40 years ago when Nat Geo was not a lying sack of Jewish anti White propaganda

    Even Ranger Rick, which she gave her grandchildren from 5 to 15 is now a lying sack. Mom’s grandchildren now subscribe to Ranger Rick for her great grandchildren. At least Ranger Rick improves their reading skills and is not nearly as politically correct as the school reading lists.

    Unbelievably lunatic liberal.
    There’s one book in the THIRD GRADE that pushes transgender. It’s a good story about a toy rabbit and different owners for about 50 years. Sometimes it’s dressed as a boy and gets a boy’s name. Sometimes it’s a girl’s name dressed as a girl. The first owner lost it. 50 years later she goes into a shop with her little grand daughter finds it all refurbished and buys it for the granddaughter.

    What to do, especially if your kids love school, like the teachers have lots of friends?? Tell them everything they’re learning except for math is a total lie?

    • Replies: @Corvinus
    "Who believes a word in Nat Geo since it was taken over by Jews."

    You come across as a buffoon when making such charges. Unfortunately, you are part and parcel to the Trumpian cleavage that has led the Coalition of the Fringes Left and Right to become even more hardened in their opinion of "Fake News", "Fake Science","Fake American", etc. Thankfully, normies realize that getting information about a requires reading from different angles and perspectives , then carefully contemplating what those ideas mean, rather than outright dismissing everything as being "false" or "fake". Your thought process only facilitates ignorance rather than enlightenment.
    , @Lot
    Have they honored the “lifetime subscription” the entire time?
  83. @Brabantian
    Steve Sailer says he offered a 'demural' when I believe the correct spelling of what he intended is 'demurral', for 'expression of disagreement'

    Tho 'demural' is also a word, to 'demuralise' is to take a wall down, which we are also seeing with the mural art of historic white people that some now find 'triggering'

    I don’t mind painting over the communist WPA murals in San Francisco at all. I do like then and the Beach Chalet which has one was one of our favorite drinking spots when it was still a construction workers local haven instead of a tourist trap.

    Most of the communist WPA murals have very unsubtle anti White sections.

  84. @KunioKun
    The moral of the farce we are living through is that rational discussion is the White man's tool. These people only understand one cliched thing and that is the Will To Power. They will rationalize backwards in some clumsy nonsense way to justify their position. However, with different actors they'll have a completely different position, and such, a different rationalization making both ungeneralizable. Trying to understand these people is like trying to understand why monkeys throw shit. It's just what they do. Monkeys are going to throw shit and these people are going to "rationalize" the gibs. Why waste your time?

    Does Natgeo endorse Whites colonization efforts? Of course not, because that's racist. One's natural and healthy, and the other is racist. To replace their dying White readership NatGeo will eventually start including videos of White people being stomped on in the street to attract vibrant readers.

    Good point. The most anti White segments of the media like Nat Geo Atlantic New Republic etc are only read by affluent aging Whites. Who will subscribe to them in another 20 years when their subscribers are all dead?

  85. @Corvinus
    "You see, 4,500 years ago, Aryan steppe barbarians invaded Western Europe from Russia and killed off much of the indigenous population. So, modern Europeans should relax."

    Putting aside your obvious false equivalence regarding yesteryears conquerors and today's immigrants, human history is indeed replete with people being on the move, with dramatic consequences. It would seem that the ancestors of modern Europeans would have much more in common with the Aryan steppies given both group's propensity for invading the world and inviting the world. Ah, memories, from the immortal words of Reverend Josiah Strong (1885).

    "Nothing can save the inferior race but a ready and pliant assimilation. Whether the feebler and more abject races are going to be regenerated and raised up, is already very much of a question. What if it should be God's plan to people the world with better and finer material?...Civilized nations are everywhere supplanting barbarous nations, and they succeed mainly, though not exclusively, through their arts, which are the products of the intellect."

    "Thus the Finns were supplanted by the Aryan races in Europe and Asia, the Tartars by the Russians, and thus the aborigines of North America, Australia and New Zealand are now disappearing before the all-conquering Anglo-Saxons...Whether the extinction of inferior races before the advancing Anglo-Saxon seems to the reader sad or otherwise, it certainly appears probable...The Anglo-Saxon has established himself in climates totally diverse--Canada, South Africa, and India--and, through several generations, has preserved his essential race characteristics."

    "...Thus, while on this continent God is training the Anglo-Saxon race for its mission, a complemental work has been in progress in the great world beyond. God has two hands. Not only is He preparing in our civilization the die with which to stamp the nations, He is preparing mankind to receive our impress."

    The Indo Europeans were from the Pontic-Caspian steppe and West Russian forest plain, which is in Europe. They were also not Aryan (Andronovo-Sintashta) as I have tried to explain to you dummies numerous times before. They did get genocided by Aryans in the Eurasian steppe belt, however.

  86. @hhh
    “The people who live in a place today are not the descendants of people who lived there long ago,” says Harvard University paleogeneticist David Reich. “There are no indigenous people"

    Your people have only been here for... 4500 years. So you are insane to support immigration restrictionism

    What about the cave paintings? One goes back about 66, 000 years in Maltrevsio Spain.

    DNA sample from 10,000 year old Cheddar Man found in Cheddar Gorge Somerset UK matched a local school teacher. He’s a direct descendant and there are others in the area ((Scientists)) claim Cheddar Man had dark brown skin. His pale White descendant has fair white skin.

    It’s Nat Geo, nothing but anti White propaganda

    • Replies: @Sam Coulton
    The individual you are referring to is a descendant of Cheddar Man on his maternal line. Basically, Cheddar Man's population got bleached by the Bell Beaker invaders, introducing new light skin genes that aren't present in Cheddar Man, and nobody today is a pure western hunter gatherer.

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/the-family-link-that-reaches-back-300-generations-to-a-cheddar-cave-1271542.html

    But there is no doubt: Mr Targett, a 42-year-old history teacher in Cheddar, Somerset, has been shown by DNA tests to be a direct descendant, by his mother's line, of "Cheddar Man", the oldest complete skeleton ever found in Britain, and now also the world's most distant confirmed relative
     
  87. @Lot
    “If you ever want to troll an SJW”

    Other suggestions:

    “I don’t see race.”

    “I never owned any slaves. What about the Muslim pirates kidnapping Christian slaves?”

    “I am actually mixed race, my grama’s grama was a Cherokee princess.”

    “Most crime is black on black. I think the anti-police liberals are secretly OK with that, it let them take over Brooklyn which used to be black but is now all hipsters.”

    “Nobody kills more black children than abortions. Hundreds every single day.”

    “Liberals are so ignorant of economics and American history, it takes me a lot of emotional labor to educate them all the time.”

    When I worked at a university I was once talking with a Chinese student I was friends with. Along comes a lesbian Hispanic activist SJW who was my affirmative action boss.

    So I introduced him to her as my son. He called me Mom. The lesbian Hispanic was just shocked , shocked that I, the blue eyed WASP devil had a Chinese son.

    • Replies: @Lot
    Real life trolling: even better.
  88. @hhh
    “The people who live in a place today are not the descendants of people who lived there long ago,” says Harvard University paleogeneticist David Reich. “There are no indigenous people"

    Your people have only been here for... 4500 years. So you are insane to support immigration restrictionism

    “The people who live in a place today are not the descendants of people who lived there long ago,” says Harvard University paleogeneticist David Reich. “There are no indigenous people”

    I’d suggest that David Reich shelve any plans he might have to visit Australia. Denying the existence of indigenous people would land him in a world of hurt. It might even land him in jail.

    It’s the Current Year in Australia as well, but the Current Year isn’t the same everywhere.

  89. @anonymous
    Absolute madness.

    So Iceland doesn't exist because its parliament has only been running for a thousand years? How about the Japanese royal family at two thousand?

    No? No such thing as Icelandic or Japanese people? Their whole histories are "meaningless"?

    “Absolute madness” is right.

    Once again we have a racially chauvinistic Jewish nationalist using (abusing) science to denounce White natioalism and “racial purity” while hypocritically ignoring the requirement to prove one is racially a jew before they can become an Israeli citizen.

    And all done with the typical brazen effrontery that many rightfully find so obnoxious and irritating.

    Eventually, like every prominent jewish intellectual or pseudo-scientist from Marx, Freud, Einstein (the Mark Zuckerberg of Physics), The Frankfurt Schoool, The French School, Chomsky, S.J. Gould, Carl Sagan, Jared Diamond and whoever else I forgot to mention, he’ll be discredted – after he’s gotten his point across and the damage is done.

    This is why Schopenhauer said that nothing about Judaism can be confused with Reason.

    Intellectually jews operate out of a combination of alchemy and superficially sophisticated gossip.

    Which is why they HAVE to demonize all of our thinkers and pathologize our love for them.

    Again, the insanity of their racial fanaticism rears its ugly head in the form of pseudo-intellectual black magic passing itself off as real science and presented with contemptuous self-satisfaction.

    No wonder they came up with the idea of “antisemitism” since they inspire it in everyone they come into contact with. The word should be redefined to mean “the inevitable reaction to contact with jewish people.

    Even with all of their power they remain an obnoxious and unimpressive people.

  90. @hhh
    “The people who live in a place today are not the descendants of people who lived there long ago,” says Harvard University paleogeneticist David Reich. “There are no indigenous people"

    Your people have only been here for... 4500 years. So you are insane to support immigration restrictionism

    “There are no indigenous people.”

    Well, there goes half the reason for hating White America.

    So much for Identity Politics.

    Thanks Reich.

    The communist pseudo-intellectuals, and the politicians and media talking heads who repeat their talking points like the chattering of an idiot only less interesting, will want to use Reich’s book as yet more White Man Bad ammo only to be stopped dead in thier tracks with that line.

    Again, Thanks Reich.

    What’s AOC and Omar, et al. going to do now?

  91. @Redneck farmer
    So it would appear NAT GEO has been taken over by the we need to return to the 1300s crowd. Because that's the technological level the New European It will be able to maintain.

    The New Europeans will be there until they’ve replaced the Real Europeans.

    After that, they’ll be Smart Citied, ie; Placed into Smart Cities and vaporized.

  92. @anonotron
    Europeans are literally the descendants of a group of people who wiped out almost all the people who had lived in Europe before them. That explains so much of all the bad things that people of European descent are accused of.

    “Europeans are literally the descendants of a group of people who wiped out almost all the people who had lived in Europe before them. That explains so much of all the bad things that people of European descent are accused of.”

    White Man Bad. Mama make cocoa. Give blanket. Basement cold.

  93. @anonymous
    Absolute madness.

    So Iceland doesn't exist because its parliament has only been running for a thousand years? How about the Japanese royal family at two thousand?

    No? No such thing as Icelandic or Japanese people? Their whole histories are "meaningless"?

    Not to mention Ancient Harkensteins; the authentic inventors of genetic hygiene.

  94. I trace National Geographic’s shameful decline to circa 2015 when shortly after hiring Susan Goldberg as editor, Rupert Murdoch’s Fox Corp. took a control of the magazine and fired many of its veteran staff writers and fact checkers. Some of the others resigned in disgust. Within a year this storied publication was blantantly pushing left-wing PC gobbledygook and in early 2017 its full decent became apparent when splashed on its front cover was its seminal “Gender Revolution” edition. For starters, this topic has nothing to do with either nations or geography and wholly inappropriate for such a publication but moreover actual gender change is nothing but pseudoscientific leftist make-believe.

  95. @Alden
    Who believes a word in Nat Geo since it was taken over by Jews.

    My mother the science teacher and environmentalist gave all her grandchildren life long Nat Geo subscriptions on their tenth birthdays. That was 30 to 40 years ago when Nat Geo was not a lying sack of Jewish anti White propaganda

    Even Ranger Rick, which she gave her grandchildren from 5 to 15 is now a lying sack. Mom’s grandchildren now subscribe to Ranger Rick for her great grandchildren. At least Ranger Rick improves their reading skills and is not nearly as politically correct as the school reading lists.

    Unbelievably lunatic liberal.
    There’s one book in the THIRD GRADE that pushes transgender. It’s a good story about a toy rabbit and different owners for about 50 years. Sometimes it’s dressed as a boy and gets a boy’s name. Sometimes it’s a girl’s name dressed as a girl. The first owner lost it. 50 years later she goes into a shop with her little grand daughter finds it all refurbished and buys it for the granddaughter.

    What to do, especially if your kids love school, like the teachers have lots of friends?? Tell them everything they’re learning except for math is a total lie?

    “Who believes a word in Nat Geo since it was taken over by Jews.”

    You come across as a buffoon when making such charges. Unfortunately, you are part and parcel to the Trumpian cleavage that has led the Coalition of the Fringes Left and Right to become even more hardened in their opinion of “Fake News”, “Fake Science”,”Fake American”, etc. Thankfully, normies realize that getting information about a requires reading from different angles and perspectives , then carefully contemplating what those ideas mean, rather than outright dismissing everything as being “false” or “fake”. Your thought process only facilitates ignorance rather than enlightenment.

  96. @Alden
    What about the cave paintings? One goes back about 66, 000 years in Maltrevsio Spain.

    DNA sample from 10,000 year old Cheddar Man found in Cheddar Gorge Somerset UK matched a local school teacher. He’s a direct descendant and there are others in the area ((Scientists)) claim Cheddar Man had dark brown skin. His pale White descendant has fair white skin.

    It’s Nat Geo, nothing but anti White propaganda

    The individual you are referring to is a descendant of Cheddar Man on his maternal line. Basically, Cheddar Man’s population got bleached by the Bell Beaker invaders, introducing new light skin genes that aren’t present in Cheddar Man, and nobody today is a pure western hunter gatherer.

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/the-family-link-that-reaches-back-300-generations-to-a-cheddar-cave-1271542.html

    But there is no doubt: Mr Targett, a 42-year-old history teacher in Cheddar, Somerset, has been shown by DNA tests to be a direct descendant, by his mother’s line, of “Cheddar Man”, the oldest complete skeleton ever found in Britain, and now also the world’s most distant confirmed relative

  97. @Alden
    When I worked at a university I was once talking with a Chinese student I was friends with. Along comes a lesbian Hispanic activist SJW who was my affirmative action boss.

    So I introduced him to her as my son. He called me Mom. The lesbian Hispanic was just shocked , shocked that I, the blue eyed WASP devil had a Chinese son.

    Real life trolling: even better.

  98. @Alden
    Who believes a word in Nat Geo since it was taken over by Jews.

    My mother the science teacher and environmentalist gave all her grandchildren life long Nat Geo subscriptions on their tenth birthdays. That was 30 to 40 years ago when Nat Geo was not a lying sack of Jewish anti White propaganda

    Even Ranger Rick, which she gave her grandchildren from 5 to 15 is now a lying sack. Mom’s grandchildren now subscribe to Ranger Rick for her great grandchildren. At least Ranger Rick improves their reading skills and is not nearly as politically correct as the school reading lists.

    Unbelievably lunatic liberal.
    There’s one book in the THIRD GRADE that pushes transgender. It’s a good story about a toy rabbit and different owners for about 50 years. Sometimes it’s dressed as a boy and gets a boy’s name. Sometimes it’s a girl’s name dressed as a girl. The first owner lost it. 50 years later she goes into a shop with her little grand daughter finds it all refurbished and buys it for the granddaughter.

    What to do, especially if your kids love school, like the teachers have lots of friends?? Tell them everything they’re learning except for math is a total lie?

    Have they honored the “lifetime subscription” the entire time?

  99. @Altai
    The other thing this misses is that the peoples of Europe have been more contiguous for longer than those of Africa, the Middle East, the Arctic and mainland East Asia and the rest of the Americas.

    Only Australian Aborigines and South East Asia have them beat and India have them tied.

    Totally wrong. Just wrong. The Americas were fully populated while Europe was under a mile-thick ice sheet. In other words, when there was no such thing as “Europeans.”

  100. @Charon
    Susan Rice condemns Chinese diplomat as 'racist disgrace'

    https://www-m.cnn.com/2019/07/15/politics/susan-rice-chinese-diplomat-tweets/index.html

    Funzapoppin!

    The Chinese diplomat declared that the black Emperor was a naked ape–heresy!

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to All Steve Sailer Comments via RSS
PastClassics
The “war hero” candidate buried information about POWs left behind in Vietnam.
Which superpower is more threatened by its “extractive elites”?
What Was John McCain's True Wartime Record in Vietnam?
Are elite university admissions based on meritocracy and diversity as claimed?