The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection$
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 TeasersiSteve Blog
"Dog"
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information



=>

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • B
Show CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeThanksLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

This is a good small road movie from a few months ago with Channing Tatum as an ex-Army Ranger and a similarly Iraq-damaged Belgian Malinois Shepherd war dog named Lulu. Tatum needs his former commanding officer to sign off on his job application for a high paying Blackwater-type mercenary job, but the officer doubts that Tatum’s brain has recovered. However, when Lulu’s handler, an old war buddy of Tatum’s, drives into a tree at 120 mph, the officer offers to sign Tatum’s form if he will get the hero dog / crazed beast to New Mexico in five days for the handler’s funeral.

Tatum is a consistently solid movie star and he is strong in both the comic and sentimental scenes. Bill Burr is noteworthy as an ex-military cop. I don’t know much of anything about the modern military, but the screenplay seemed reasonably realistic.

The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.

 
Hide 144 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. I sure do like Jane Adams. She’s cute as a button.

  2. crazed beast

    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    LOL:

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    • Replies: @PhysicistDave
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Jenner Ickham Errican quoted "Mart" as saying:


    This is the reading list of a 17 year old. There's no way this midwit hasn't been artificially pushed by a handful of powerful people
     
    Well... Lev Fridman is 39 years old and is only now reading 1984?

    Does seem a bit late.

    I do wonder about people who make up a reading list based on others' suggestions. It seems a bit like going on a diet or working out because it is "good for you."

    I don't read books because it is, in some abstract sense, good for me.

    For example, I recently read P. J. E. Peebles' The Whole Truth: A Cosmologist's Reflections on the Search for Objective Reality, just published in 2022, because I am curious about what is now known about cosmology. It is an eccentric though well-written book: Peebles, who is a Nobel laureate in the field, uses cosmology to present his views on epistemology. Sure to drive philosophers (and people who think they know philosophy like a few commenters here!) absolutely up the wall!

    And I also just read Christopher Blattman's 2022 book Why We Fight: The Roots of War and the Paths to Peace because of all the discussion about the war to liberate the Donbass. Nothing specific about Ukraine, but it turns out to present some really eye-opening perspectives about applying game theory to issues of war and peace.

    And I just finished Timothy Zahn's 2022 novel, The Icarus Plot simply because it was fun -- entertaining and imaginative "space opera."

    I have a long list of books I want to read because I want to know the specific knowledge contained in those specific books.

    And what I want to know but do not yet know is going to differ from any other human being. There is no uniform list of worthwhile books.

    Indeed, what is worthwhile for any human being when he is twenty will have little overlap with what is worthwhile when he is forty.

    Books are still where we store the systematic knowledge humans have acquired about the nature of reality. You want to know something about such knowledge -- find the appropriate book.

    But to read a book because someone else thinks it would be good for my soul in some way... well, I have things to do and promises to keep and miles to go before I sleep.

    Replies: @Bill P, @AndrewR, @J.Ross, @Ralph L, @Bill, @Craken, @John Foster

    , @R.G. Camara
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Reading a book a week reminds me of Woody Allen's old clunky joke:

    "I took a speed reading course. Then I read War and Peace in an hour. It's about...Russia."

    , @PiltdownMan
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    There isn't a single Victorian era novel by an British author in that list. And a lot of people with a reading habit in Mr. Sailer's generation likely had read half those books by the time they turned twenty.

    Replies: @Anon, @Known Fact

    , @AndrewR
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    What boring drama. Pseudointellectuals all the way down.

    , @HammerJack
    @Jenner Ickham Errican


    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)
     


    The MORE tag is always applicable.

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=F4t4qtbvQbo
    , @MEH 0910
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    https://twitter.com/lexfridman/status/1609609380630253569

    Replies: @Lichen, @Harry Baldwin, @MEH 0910

    , @Chrisnonymous
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Taleb, while not an idiot, is a fool. I respect Dave Pinsen and appreciate his comments on iSteve. However, I suspect both of them have not discerned Lex Fridman's intentions. I don't pretend to know what it is, but I would point out that a public reading list that invites others to read along is quite a different thing from a private list of interests.

    Replies: @Anonymous

    , @BB753
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Yuval Noah Harari? Klaus Schwab's boot-licker? Please!

    Replies: @Barbarossa

    , @neutral
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    I wonder why Lex Fridman is being pushed so much, I am completely stumped, his early life section has nothing remarkable. I suppose it will remain a mystery.

    Replies: @SunBakedSuburb, @Telimektar

    , @AnotherDad
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Could we agree to limit comments to say no more than 6" of twitter grab and two annoying videos?

    ~~

    As to content: Dude can read whatever he wants, but it strikes me a pretty boring list. (A bunch of it I've read and most of the rest not what I'd want to read now. Though I still haven't read Sun Tzu.)

    Like a lot of older men, my tastes now run much more to non-fiction and actually learning something. If commenters want to offer their recommendations, especially in the history and general "how we got here" space I'll take note.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Twinkie

    , @Rusty Tailgate
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    I publicly committed to reading Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit, but between friends, I had to set it aside five pages in, because I find I'm having to devote all my free time to tweeting about numerous memes that I do not wholly agree with.

    , @Anonymous
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Some of Lex's books are good. I still need to read Brave New World.

    The Bell Curve
    Culture of Critique
    Yggdrasil's content
    Early Steve Sailer highlights on HBD etc.

    Those are probably the most influential books of my adult life. Also a chronological ordering of the Koran was worthwhile. I had to do it myself in the 2000 era; now it is done for you.

    https://skepticsannotatedbible.com/quran/chrono.htm

    Also the Gulag Archipelago.

    I think Mein Kampf and the Communist Manifesto are also worth reading to understand events of the 20th century.

    And as Steve says, read a proper multi-volume childrens' encyclopaedia or 3 for good measure. Any recommendations there?

    , @Ghost of Bull Moose
    @Jenner Ickham Errican


    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)
     
    These are all good choices. I'd like to add:

    How to Be an Auntie Racist by Ex Ibram Kendi
    Do The First Thing That Pops Into Your Head by Malcolm Gladwell
    My Lovely White Teef Bones
    This Land is Our Land, Now Get Out Whitey: An Immigrant's Eviction Notice by Suketu Mehta
    Golf Course Design: Fascinating! by Steve Sailer

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican

  3. The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.

    You have zero idea how aspergers you come across with that “observation” do you?

    I’m not criticising just observing.

    This movie sounds typically pro-war, destroy your family for the Bush and Clinton family biennial worship of Moloch and Davos Man, doesn’t anyone know about Hitler and Ann Frank and the shoa, here’s a dog to identify with as we subliminally urge you on to slaughter The Other!

    Btw, did you know that to be a Tunnel Rat in Vietnam you had to be below 6 foot in height?

    I wonder how many of them “Ann” Coulter would deign fuck if he would be so moved.

    I haven’t seen it yet but I will see The Banshees of Inisherin

    • Troll: Guest007
    • Replies: @AKAHorace
    @Pat Hannagan

    This movie sounds typically pro-war, destroy your family for the Bush and Clinton family biennial worship of Moloch and Davos Man, doesn’t anyone know about Hitler and Ann Frank and the shoa, here’s a dog to identify with as we subliminally urge you on to slaughter The Other!

    There is not much connection between ideological truth and artistic merit. A lot of great WWII movies were pretty much propaganda, but are still very watchable.

    , @Anon
    @Pat Hannagan

    Steve doesn't come off as aspie to me by correctly pointing out that that these dogs are not very charismatic with their rather invisible features. You on the other hand come off as someone with full blown autism with your inability to control your emotions.

    , @SunBakedSuburb
    @Pat Hannagan

    "You have zero idea how aspergers you come across ..."

    "The Shimmery"

    It's a reboot of Rosemary's Baby with Steve playing the roles of Mia Farrow's husband and their baby. The devil will be played by the sleek, objectionable animal Steve picked up in Burbank.

    , @Anonymous
    @Pat Hannagan


    "The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera."

    You have zero idea how aspergers you come across with that “observation” do you?

    I’m not criticising just observing.
     

    You have zero idea of how the movie business works when criticizing Steve’s rather astute observation, don't you?

    First, I’ve been in the movie business. Dogs with dark fur are generally not considered whatsoever because of they are a pain in the ass to light. Audiences, as Steve noticed of his own accord, like to see a dog's face.

    Second, I was asked more than once to consider auditioning my own dog, a dark-haired mid-sized "Benji" type, as the casting person noticed she was very bright and wonderfully tempered, but only if I’d consider dying her hair a lighter shade, for the reason stated above.

    I always declined. Didn’t want to put her through it, and I didn’t want to deal.

    Dark-haired dogs can get cast, but it’s the exception, not the rule.

    Finally, I noticed in a few key scenes in that movie, they lit the shit out of that dog. Particularly one of the last shots of the two out on the cliff out over the ocean. A couple of shots were even overexposed—to light up the dog for the ending, doing it in such a way that it looked "artistic," but the technical intent was to light that dog up.

    They had a very good cinematographer, who had his hands full with that dog, and did a great job.

    And finally… shut the fuck up.

    Replies: @Greta Handel

    , @Recently Based
    @Pat Hannagan


    You have zero idea how aspergers you come across with that “observation” do you?

    I’m not criticising just observing.
     
    WTF? What do you think a a criticism is?
    , @Decoy
    @Pat Hannagan

    I encourage people to look into The Banshees of Inisherin. Wonderful all around: acting, writing, cinematography. A bit dark in the 2nd half so not for everyone.

  4. I don’t know much of anything about the modern military, but the screenplay seemed reasonably realistic.

    What’s realism nowadays?

    Nazis Are Actually Fine Now, According to the Southern Poverty Law Center and Anti-Defamation League

    https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2022-12-31/strange-new-respect-nazi-adjacent-pagans

    • Replies: @Stan Adams
    @Bill Jones

    I saw this billboard today:
    https://media.nbcmiami.com/2022/12/Miami.Okeechobee-e1671204353387.jpg

    The bitchy, snippy tone doesn't inspire much sympathy. It conjures up an image of a Karen Kohen type wagging her finger in your face: "Three of my grandparents died at Auschwitz, so don't call me a stuck-up bitch!"

    Replies: @Veteran Aryan, @Beavertales

  5. @Jenner Ickham Errican

    crazed beast
     
    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    https://twitter.com/Martpoasting/status/1609603296628731904

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    https://twitter.com/MetaPrime001/status/1609694185766162432

    LOL:

    https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1609751283119935490

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    https://twitter.com/EvanPlatinum/status/1609713244436074496

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZU7k5RMnqY

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.


    https://youtu.be/wcf6iQDWPEo?t=164

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    https://twitter.com/thebobferguson/status/1609418835681214467

    Replies: @PhysicistDave, @R.G. Camara, @PiltdownMan, @AndrewR, @HammerJack, @MEH 0910, @Chrisnonymous, @BB753, @neutral, @AnotherDad, @Rusty Tailgate, @Anonymous, @Ghost of Bull Moose

    Jenner Ickham Errican quoted “Mart” as saying:

    This is the reading list of a 17 year old. There’s no way this midwit hasn’t been artificially pushed by a handful of powerful people

    Well… Lev Fridman is 39 years old and is only now reading 1984?

    Does seem a bit late.

    I do wonder about people who make up a reading list based on others’ suggestions. It seems a bit like going on a diet or working out because it is “good for you.”

    I don’t read books because it is, in some abstract sense, good for me.

    For example, I recently read P. J. E. Peebles’ The Whole Truth: A Cosmologist’s Reflections on the Search for Objective Reality, just published in 2022, because I am curious about what is now known about cosmology. It is an eccentric though well-written book: Peebles, who is a Nobel laureate in the field, uses cosmology to present his views on epistemology. Sure to drive philosophers (and people who think they know philosophy like a few commenters here!) absolutely up the wall!

    And I also just read Christopher Blattman’s 2022 book Why We Fight: The Roots of War and the Paths to Peace because of all the discussion about the war to liberate the Donbass. Nothing specific about Ukraine, but it turns out to present some really eye-opening perspectives about applying game theory to issues of war and peace.

    And I just finished Timothy Zahn’s 2022 novel, The Icarus Plot simply because it was fun — entertaining and imaginative “space opera.”

    I have a long list of books I want to read because I want to know the specific knowledge contained in those specific books.

    And what I want to know but do not yet know is going to differ from any other human being. There is no uniform list of worthwhile books.

    Indeed, what is worthwhile for any human being when he is twenty will have little overlap with what is worthwhile when he is forty.

    Books are still where we store the systematic knowledge humans have acquired about the nature of reality. You want to know something about such knowledge — find the appropriate book.

    But to read a book because someone else thinks it would be good for my soul in some way… well, I have things to do and promises to keep and miles to go before I sleep.

    • Replies: @Bill P
    @PhysicistDave


    Well… Lev Fridman is 39 years old and is only now reading 1984?
     
    Hey, maybe he's re-reading it. I've read it at least twice. I could definitely reread Old Man and the Sea about now. Hemingway may have been an asshole, but that's one beautiful piece of fiction.

    As for dog fiction, I'm currently reading Where the Red Fern Grows -- with my 8yo. It has finally convinced me to get the kid a puppy. We're going to look at a litter today.

    Replies: @HammerJack, @MEH 0910

    , @AndrewR
    @PhysicistDave

    Please elaborate on the Blattman book. Sounds interesting.

    Replies: @PhysicistDave

    , @J.Ross
    @PhysicistDave

    Fridman glows in daylight but this list isn't a bad list if you to podcast about classics. Is this really supposed to be a personal reading list (of books he hasn't read before), and not a program for his podcast?

    , @Ralph L
    @PhysicistDave

    Didn't every Boomer and later HS kid in the US read 1984 and The Great Gatsby? I mean, the ones that could read. Have they been dropped from the curriculum to make room for Toni Morrison and T'Sneezy Coates?

    Replies: @John1955, @Mark G.

    , @Bill
    @PhysicistDave


    And what I want to know but do not yet know is going to differ from any other human being. There is no uniform list of worthwhile books.
     
    That's a little like saying that there is no right side of the road to drive on or there is no right language to speak. It's not false, but it's also not true.

    Thanks for mentioning Peebles' book. Looks interesting. I will read.

    Replies: @PhysicistDave

    , @Craken
    @PhysicistDave

    I don't know what knowledge is contained in a specific book until I read it. And, since there are very often multiple books that purport to explain the same subject, trustworthy advice on which ones to try first can be valuable. Of course, if the book is within one's field of expertise, such advice may not be needed. But, I sometimes wander away from the range of my expertise and, on occasion, I'm lucky enough to find reliable signposts. An example: "The Nuclear Express"--a history of global nuclear weapons proliferation recommended by a couple of physicists. Reviews/critiques can also be useful for the intellectual interloper, as they put a book in context. Professors have syllabi in which they mandate the reading of certain material, implicitly excluding the rest as less suitable for their students. All of this applies to books that are truth seeking. For literature, the criteria are different, lists of recent books less useful--although the Western Canon is highly useful for filtering older works.

    Now I think of it, a list of subjects that are ignored or maligned in mainstream education might be more generally useful than a book list. I consider it abstractly good for me that I at least know these subjects exist. While swimming with the academic fish, I had scarcely heard of the dark school of psychometricians, and, when I did catch a glimpse at the edge, it was dismissed as low status or pseudoscience. Only when I found dry land and clambered my amphibian self out of the obscure depths did I discovered Psychometrics and its significance for "Understanding Human History" (another book discovered by recommendation). Propaganda is also a subject. It ought to be recognized as such, all the more so given the increasing asymmetry in power between the masses and the propaganda machines. Another: Practical Reasoning (should replace the typical intro to stats course, but run for at least two semesters). Logic and logical fallacies. Anti-Metaphysics, a subject designed to cure the temptation to squander time in the wasteland of metaphysics. Realpolitik--something you get little taste of even if you take a BA in polisci. Not unrelated, but studiously ignored: Military History. History of Science and Technology. The Nature of Economic Systems, with historical illustrations of each in action. I have met middle-aged and elderly people, formally "educated," who do not realize that these are real subjects of inquiry in which some knowledge has been attained. The mind control institutions prefer it should be so. I know this is nuts: I'm imagining a functional education system in a functional country.

    Replies: @Rob, @PhysicistDave

    , @John Foster
    @PhysicistDave

    On cosmology, "Genesis" by Guido Tonelli, who works at CERN, came out in English not too long ago and is pretty good.

  6. @Pat Hannagan
    The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.

    You have zero idea how aspergers you come across with that "observation" do you?

    I'm not criticising just observing.

    This movie sounds typically pro-war, destroy your family for the Bush and Clinton family biennial worship of Moloch and Davos Man, doesn't anyone know about Hitler and Ann Frank and the shoa, here's a dog to identify with as we subliminally urge you on to slaughter The Other!

    Btw, did you know that to be a Tunnel Rat in Vietnam you had to be below 6 foot in height?

    I wonder how many of them "Ann" Coulter would deign fuck if he would be so moved.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2-jGAVT-Elk

    I haven't seen it yet but I will see The Banshees of Inisherin

    Replies: @AKAHorace, @Anon, @SunBakedSuburb, @Anonymous, @Recently Based, @Decoy

    This movie sounds typically pro-war, destroy your family for the Bush and Clinton family biennial worship of Moloch and Davos Man, doesn’t anyone know about Hitler and Ann Frank and the shoa, here’s a dog to identify with as we subliminally urge you on to slaughter The Other!

    There is not much connection between ideological truth and artistic merit. A lot of great WWII movies were pretty much propaganda, but are still very watchable.

  7. “Magic Mike” is back!

  8. @Pat Hannagan
    The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.

    You have zero idea how aspergers you come across with that "observation" do you?

    I'm not criticising just observing.

    This movie sounds typically pro-war, destroy your family for the Bush and Clinton family biennial worship of Moloch and Davos Man, doesn't anyone know about Hitler and Ann Frank and the shoa, here's a dog to identify with as we subliminally urge you on to slaughter The Other!

    Btw, did you know that to be a Tunnel Rat in Vietnam you had to be below 6 foot in height?

    I wonder how many of them "Ann" Coulter would deign fuck if he would be so moved.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2-jGAVT-Elk

    I haven't seen it yet but I will see The Banshees of Inisherin

    Replies: @AKAHorace, @Anon, @SunBakedSuburb, @Anonymous, @Recently Based, @Decoy

    Steve doesn’t come off as aspie to me by correctly pointing out that that these dogs are not very charismatic with their rather invisible features. You on the other hand come off as someone with full blown autism with your inability to control your emotions.

    • Agree: silviosilver
  9. Channing Tatum looked cool in this memorable Mountain Dew commercial back in 2002.

    “Step Up” was decent.

    He should change his name to “Chad” Tatum.

  10. @Jenner Ickham Errican

    crazed beast
     
    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    https://twitter.com/Martpoasting/status/1609603296628731904

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    https://twitter.com/MetaPrime001/status/1609694185766162432

    LOL:

    https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1609751283119935490

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    https://twitter.com/EvanPlatinum/status/1609713244436074496

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZU7k5RMnqY

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.


    https://youtu.be/wcf6iQDWPEo?t=164

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    https://twitter.com/thebobferguson/status/1609418835681214467

    Replies: @PhysicistDave, @R.G. Camara, @PiltdownMan, @AndrewR, @HammerJack, @MEH 0910, @Chrisnonymous, @BB753, @neutral, @AnotherDad, @Rusty Tailgate, @Anonymous, @Ghost of Bull Moose

    Reading a book a week reminds me of Woody Allen’s old clunky joke:

    “I took a speed reading course. Then I read War and Peace in an hour. It’s about…Russia.”

  11. @PhysicistDave
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Jenner Ickham Errican quoted "Mart" as saying:


    This is the reading list of a 17 year old. There's no way this midwit hasn't been artificially pushed by a handful of powerful people
     
    Well... Lev Fridman is 39 years old and is only now reading 1984?

    Does seem a bit late.

    I do wonder about people who make up a reading list based on others' suggestions. It seems a bit like going on a diet or working out because it is "good for you."

    I don't read books because it is, in some abstract sense, good for me.

    For example, I recently read P. J. E. Peebles' The Whole Truth: A Cosmologist's Reflections on the Search for Objective Reality, just published in 2022, because I am curious about what is now known about cosmology. It is an eccentric though well-written book: Peebles, who is a Nobel laureate in the field, uses cosmology to present his views on epistemology. Sure to drive philosophers (and people who think they know philosophy like a few commenters here!) absolutely up the wall!

    And I also just read Christopher Blattman's 2022 book Why We Fight: The Roots of War and the Paths to Peace because of all the discussion about the war to liberate the Donbass. Nothing specific about Ukraine, but it turns out to present some really eye-opening perspectives about applying game theory to issues of war and peace.

    And I just finished Timothy Zahn's 2022 novel, The Icarus Plot simply because it was fun -- entertaining and imaginative "space opera."

    I have a long list of books I want to read because I want to know the specific knowledge contained in those specific books.

    And what I want to know but do not yet know is going to differ from any other human being. There is no uniform list of worthwhile books.

    Indeed, what is worthwhile for any human being when he is twenty will have little overlap with what is worthwhile when he is forty.

    Books are still where we store the systematic knowledge humans have acquired about the nature of reality. You want to know something about such knowledge -- find the appropriate book.

    But to read a book because someone else thinks it would be good for my soul in some way... well, I have things to do and promises to keep and miles to go before I sleep.

    Replies: @Bill P, @AndrewR, @J.Ross, @Ralph L, @Bill, @Craken, @John Foster

    Well… Lev Fridman is 39 years old and is only now reading 1984?

    Hey, maybe he’s re-reading it. I’ve read it at least twice. I could definitely reread Old Man and the Sea about now. Hemingway may have been an asshole, but that’s one beautiful piece of fiction.

    As for dog fiction, I’m currently reading Where the Red Fern Grows — with my 8yo. It has finally convinced me to get the kid a puppy. We’re going to look at a litter today.

    • Replies: @HammerJack
    @Bill P

    Please consider a shelter. Breeders are the Spawn of Satan. No matter what they tell you, they are motivated by money alone, and every single breed has been mangled.

    I also recommend: a big, fenced yard, and a large loving family. And it's a 15-year commitment±. Finally, since you asked ;) do the bonding well before you start any training.

    Replies: @The Wild Geese Howard, @Brutusale

    , @MEH 0910
    @Bill P


    As for dog fiction, I’m currently reading Where the Red Fern Grows — with my 8yo.
     
    Lex Fridman is considering adding that one to his reading list:

    https://lexfridman.com/reading-list/

    Here’s some other suggestions I’m considering. Others are welcome:
     

    • The Dead by James Joyce
    • The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman
    • Ward No. 6 by Anton Chekhov
    • Anthem by Ayn Rand
    • The Book of Five Rings by Miyamoto Musashi
    • The Four Agreements by Don Miguel Ruiz
    • Nightfall, Last Question by Isaac Asimov
    • The Little Trilogy by Anton Chekhov
    • The Nose, The Overcoat by Gogol
    • Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad
    • Notes from Underground by Dostoevsky
    • The Giver by Lois Lowry
    • The Prince by Machiavelli
    • Disgrace by J. M. Coetzee
    • Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury
    • The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho
    • The Road by Cormac McCarthy
    • Where the Red Fern Grows by Wilson Rawls
    • A Good Man Is Hard to Find by Flannery O’Connor
    Beyond Good and Evil by Friedrich Nietzsche
    • On Writing by Stephen King
    • Solaris by Stanislaw Lem
    • Childhood’s End by Arthur C Clarke
    • Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K Dick
    • Flowers for Algernon by Daniel Keyes
    • I, Robot by Isaac Asimov
    • The Diary of a Young Girl by Anne Frank
    • Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov
    • Ender’s Game by Orson Scott Card
    • Surely You’re Joking, Mr. Feynman by Richard Feynman
    • Dead Souls by Gogol
    • 12 Rules for Life by Jordan Peterson
    • Snow Crash by Neal Stephenson
    • The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress by Robert Heinlein
    • Three-Body Problem by Cixin Liu
    • Stranger in a Strange Land by Robert Heinlein
    • Godel, Escher, Bach by Douglas R. Hofstadter
    • The Idiot by Dostoevsky
     

    Replies: @MGB, @duncsbaby, @J.Ross

  12. @Jenner Ickham Errican

    crazed beast
     
    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    https://twitter.com/Martpoasting/status/1609603296628731904

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    https://twitter.com/MetaPrime001/status/1609694185766162432

    LOL:

    https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1609751283119935490

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    https://twitter.com/EvanPlatinum/status/1609713244436074496

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZU7k5RMnqY

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.


    https://youtu.be/wcf6iQDWPEo?t=164

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    https://twitter.com/thebobferguson/status/1609418835681214467

    Replies: @PhysicistDave, @R.G. Camara, @PiltdownMan, @AndrewR, @HammerJack, @MEH 0910, @Chrisnonymous, @BB753, @neutral, @AnotherDad, @Rusty Tailgate, @Anonymous, @Ghost of Bull Moose

    There isn’t a single Victorian era novel by an British author in that list. And a lot of people with a reading habit in Mr. Sailer’s generation likely had read half those books by the time they turned twenty.

    • Replies: @Anon
    @PiltdownMan

    Yeah, most seem like high school tier. On the other hand, digest The Art of War and Brothers Karamazov in one week each ... lol.

    Replies: @Bill Jones, @J.Ross, @AKAHorace

    , @Known Fact
    @PiltdownMan

    Speaking of British authors, he could add one of Graham Greene's meatier novels, just to observe a master at work. Or if he does Lowry's Under the Volcano we'll give him a mulligan and let him skip the 60-page forward.

  13. Perhaps this is a good time for the iSteve 50 or 100 books list.

    • Replies: @Redneck farmer
    @PiltdownMan

    Still trying to determine if that's a good or bad idea.

  14. @Bill P
    @PhysicistDave


    Well… Lev Fridman is 39 years old and is only now reading 1984?
     
    Hey, maybe he's re-reading it. I've read it at least twice. I could definitely reread Old Man and the Sea about now. Hemingway may have been an asshole, but that's one beautiful piece of fiction.

    As for dog fiction, I'm currently reading Where the Red Fern Grows -- with my 8yo. It has finally convinced me to get the kid a puppy. We're going to look at a litter today.

    Replies: @HammerJack, @MEH 0910

    Please consider a shelter. Breeders are the Spawn of Satan. No matter what they tell you, they are motivated by money alone, and every single breed has been mangled.

    I also recommend: a big, fenced yard, and a large loving family. And it’s a 15-year commitment±. Finally, since you asked 😉 do the bonding well before you start any training.

    • Thanks: Kylie, bomag, Inverness
    • Troll: TWS
    • Replies: @The Wild Geese Howard
    @HammerJack


    Please consider a shelter.
     
    I don't disagree, but in some areas it can be remarkably difficult to find a shelter with a number of pups that lack any ancestry from the bully breeds.

    Replies: @Anonymous, @Inverness

    , @Brutusale
    @HammerJack

    Some breeders are the Spawn of Satan.

    FIFY

    The girlfriend is on her third dog in 40 years, all the same breed from the same family in Kentucky. First lived 18 years, the second, 15, and the third is a very frisky 7 years old.

  15. @Jenner Ickham Errican

    crazed beast
     
    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    https://twitter.com/Martpoasting/status/1609603296628731904

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    https://twitter.com/MetaPrime001/status/1609694185766162432

    LOL:

    https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1609751283119935490

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    https://twitter.com/EvanPlatinum/status/1609713244436074496

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZU7k5RMnqY

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.


    https://youtu.be/wcf6iQDWPEo?t=164

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    https://twitter.com/thebobferguson/status/1609418835681214467

    Replies: @PhysicistDave, @R.G. Camara, @PiltdownMan, @AndrewR, @HammerJack, @MEH 0910, @Chrisnonymous, @BB753, @neutral, @AnotherDad, @Rusty Tailgate, @Anonymous, @Ghost of Bull Moose

    What boring drama. Pseudointellectuals all the way down.

  16. @PhysicistDave
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Jenner Ickham Errican quoted "Mart" as saying:


    This is the reading list of a 17 year old. There's no way this midwit hasn't been artificially pushed by a handful of powerful people
     
    Well... Lev Fridman is 39 years old and is only now reading 1984?

    Does seem a bit late.

    I do wonder about people who make up a reading list based on others' suggestions. It seems a bit like going on a diet or working out because it is "good for you."

    I don't read books because it is, in some abstract sense, good for me.

    For example, I recently read P. J. E. Peebles' The Whole Truth: A Cosmologist's Reflections on the Search for Objective Reality, just published in 2022, because I am curious about what is now known about cosmology. It is an eccentric though well-written book: Peebles, who is a Nobel laureate in the field, uses cosmology to present his views on epistemology. Sure to drive philosophers (and people who think they know philosophy like a few commenters here!) absolutely up the wall!

    And I also just read Christopher Blattman's 2022 book Why We Fight: The Roots of War and the Paths to Peace because of all the discussion about the war to liberate the Donbass. Nothing specific about Ukraine, but it turns out to present some really eye-opening perspectives about applying game theory to issues of war and peace.

    And I just finished Timothy Zahn's 2022 novel, The Icarus Plot simply because it was fun -- entertaining and imaginative "space opera."

    I have a long list of books I want to read because I want to know the specific knowledge contained in those specific books.

    And what I want to know but do not yet know is going to differ from any other human being. There is no uniform list of worthwhile books.

    Indeed, what is worthwhile for any human being when he is twenty will have little overlap with what is worthwhile when he is forty.

    Books are still where we store the systematic knowledge humans have acquired about the nature of reality. You want to know something about such knowledge -- find the appropriate book.

    But to read a book because someone else thinks it would be good for my soul in some way... well, I have things to do and promises to keep and miles to go before I sleep.

    Replies: @Bill P, @AndrewR, @J.Ross, @Ralph L, @Bill, @Craken, @John Foster

    Please elaborate on the Blattman book. Sounds interesting.

    • Replies: @PhysicistDave
    @AndrewR

    AndrewR asked me:


    Please elaborate on the Blattman book. Sounds interesting.
     
    The central message of the book is that war is always costly for both sides (obviously true in the case of Ukraine, of course), and therefore both sides usually have an incentive to avoid war and usually do succeed in avoiding war.

    So, the real question is: why do attempts to avoid war sometimes fail?

    Blattman approaches the question from a game-theoretic perspective -- incentives, strategy, asymmetric information, etc. -- but he goes lightly on the theory. He does a nice job of focusing on actual cases of violent conflict and on what went wrong to lead to violence.

    He does deal with obvious issues outside game theory in the narrow sense -- e.g., psychological motivations.

    The main point on which I would differ with him is he says that a strong state is a good way to avoid civil war.

    Yes, but... sometimes a strong and overbearing state is what leads to rebellion. And sometimes it is strong states that start wars with other states.

    Anyway, the book has no big message to sell except that it is good to try to understand what starts wars in the hope that we can avoid them.

    It is quite readable, given that it is a non-fiction book on a serious subject.

    Hope this gives you the info you want.

    Replies: @J.Ross

  17. @PiltdownMan
    Perhaps this is a good time for the iSteve 50 or 100 books list.

    Replies: @Redneck farmer

    Still trying to determine if that’s a good or bad idea.

  18. Another flick where the team can’t think of anything deep to say, so they feature a cripple, no make that a cripple and a crippled dog (good grief) to substitute for depth.

    I am of two minds about the damaged veteran trope: On the one hand it’s embarrassing to watch what used to be a point of pride curdle into a whimper for pity and hand-0uts.

    On the other hand it is truly shameful that the country destroyed and wrecked so may young lives in pointless wars that we couldn’t be bothered to win. Even worse, as Ukraine is demonstrating, the politicians and banksters don’t even have the wits or wisdom to avoid another pointless war.

    If Hollywood had any soul they would make a movie to shame the Neo-cons and turn the country against all the endless, counter-productive meddling. Or how about a movie about a veteran who comes home to find his hometown over-run by illegals and amnesty scammers.

    There you go: An ex-Army ranger from Lewiston, Maine, who comes home from Mogodishu, after watching his buddy’s body dragged through the streets, beaten on by cheering mobs of young Somalis. He comes home and finds his parents house surrounded by overcrowded apartments of pregnant, haughty Somali women in hajibs… Based on a real-life story.

  19. @Jenner Ickham Errican

    crazed beast
     
    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    https://twitter.com/Martpoasting/status/1609603296628731904

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    https://twitter.com/MetaPrime001/status/1609694185766162432

    LOL:

    https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1609751283119935490

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    https://twitter.com/EvanPlatinum/status/1609713244436074496

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZU7k5RMnqY

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.


    https://youtu.be/wcf6iQDWPEo?t=164

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    https://twitter.com/thebobferguson/status/1609418835681214467

    Replies: @PhysicistDave, @R.G. Camara, @PiltdownMan, @AndrewR, @HammerJack, @MEH 0910, @Chrisnonymous, @BB753, @neutral, @AnotherDad, @Rusty Tailgate, @Anonymous, @Ghost of Bull Moose

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    [MORE]

    The MORE tag is always applicable.

  20. @Jenner Ickham Errican

    crazed beast
     
    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    https://twitter.com/Martpoasting/status/1609603296628731904

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    https://twitter.com/MetaPrime001/status/1609694185766162432

    LOL:

    https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1609751283119935490

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    https://twitter.com/EvanPlatinum/status/1609713244436074496

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZU7k5RMnqY

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.


    https://youtu.be/wcf6iQDWPEo?t=164

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    https://twitter.com/thebobferguson/status/1609418835681214467

    Replies: @PhysicistDave, @R.G. Camara, @PiltdownMan, @AndrewR, @HammerJack, @MEH 0910, @Chrisnonymous, @BB753, @neutral, @AnotherDad, @Rusty Tailgate, @Anonymous, @Ghost of Bull Moose

    • Replies: @Lichen
    @MEH 0910

    Even if none were rereads, so what? Sure, you can’t digest Dostoyevsky in a week.

    Mocking someone for wanting to plug the holes in his reading is what seems midwit.

    , @Harry Baldwin
    @MEH 0910

    If he didn't want to be mocked, he should have made it clear that he'd read a number of the books previously. It does look like one of those summer reading lists they used to give us in high school.

    I tried listening to Fridman's podcast but can't tolerate his dreary voice. Regrettably, I have a similar problem with Glenn Greenwald, whom I greatly respect and to whose Substack I have subscribed. He's now doing regular newscasts and his nasal, stressed-sounding voice is not pleasant to listen to. Dan Bongino gets so worked up talking about the news that I don't think it's good for my blood pressure to listen to him. I'm impressed that the "Red Scare" girls frequently mention Steve Sailer and race realism, but they annoy me with their vocal fry and constant laughing at their own remarks. They sound very sexy though and I can understand guys getting off on it. My favorite podcast is the weekly summation of the news by Matt Taibbi and Walter Kirn. They maintain a detached, somewhat amused manner while discussing the current mess.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Reg Cæsar

    , @MEH 0910
    @MEH 0910

    Lex Fridman on Twitter drama over reading list
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxZY-NI9knw
    Jan 8, 2023

    Excerpted from:

    1984 by George Orwell | Lex Fridman
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Sk6lTLSZcA
    Jan 8, 2023


    A few takeaways from re-reading 1984 by George Orwell.
    Other books I'm currently reading can be found here: https://lexfridman.com/reading-list/

    OUTLINE:
    0:00 - Intro
    1:02 - 1984 world & characters
    4:20 - Love
    12:42 - Hate
    17:21 - Power
    25:56 - 1984 applied to today
    47:14 - Twitter reading list drama
     

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican

  21. Tatum is a consistently solid movie star and he is strong in both the comic and sentimental scenes

    He gave one heck of a performance as a “bottom” on a leash in the comedy movie The End. I mean, he looks like he belongs in our modern Pentagon!

    Go USA!

  22. @PiltdownMan
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    There isn't a single Victorian era novel by an British author in that list. And a lot of people with a reading habit in Mr. Sailer's generation likely had read half those books by the time they turned twenty.

    Replies: @Anon, @Known Fact

    Yeah, most seem like high school tier. On the other hand, digest The Art of War and Brothers Karamazov in one week each … lol.

    • Replies: @Bill Jones
    @Anon

    I'm about to embark on a re-read for the first time in forty years of Dostoevsky's Devils. I've got the one I've read somewhere but am too idle to hunt it down or dig it up.
    Anybody got any views on which translation?

    Replies: @JimDandy

    , @J.Ross
    @Anon

    I noticed that. Dune in a week. I wonder if he just took titles from some top 10 list (all those sci-fi titles are in the same "top 50" that I found as a set of audiobooks; similarly the classics are something you'd get from a top 10 list). There are great classics which are very short, but the way he has them jumbled, and all assogned the same amount of time ...

    , @AKAHorace
    @Anon


    Yeah, most seem like high school tier. On the other hand, digest The Art of War and Brothers Karamazov in one week each … lol.
     
    Well, the Little Prince will give her a chance to catch up to her schedule.
  23. Among other “year in review” pieces,
    this one must provide everybody some reason for scorn.

    https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/pornhubs-year-review-reveals-darkest-and-dirtiest-searches

  24. @Anon
    @PiltdownMan

    Yeah, most seem like high school tier. On the other hand, digest The Art of War and Brothers Karamazov in one week each ... lol.

    Replies: @Bill Jones, @J.Ross, @AKAHorace

    I’m about to embark on a re-read for the first time in forty years of Dostoevsky’s Devils. I’ve got the one I’ve read somewhere but am too idle to hunt it down or dig it up.
    Anybody got any views on which translation?

    • Replies: @JimDandy
    @Bill Jones

    I read Robert Maguire's most recently--Penguin Classic. I don't know if that's supposed to be the best one, but it's excellent, imo.

  25. “However, when Lulu’s handler, an old war buddy of Tatum’s, drives into a tree at 120 mph, the officer offers to sign Tatum’s form if he will get the hero dog / crazed beast to New Mexico in five days for the handler’s funeral.”

    so it’s a remake of smokey and the bandit. or perhaps midnight run?

    • Replies: @Wokechoke
    @Mike Tre

    Oliver Reed’s Hannibal Brooks…saving the elephant movie. Getting drunk with him must have been a laugh.

  26. @MEH 0910
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    https://twitter.com/lexfridman/status/1609609380630253569

    Replies: @Lichen, @Harry Baldwin, @MEH 0910

    Even if none were rereads, so what? Sure, you can’t digest Dostoyevsky in a week.

    Mocking someone for wanting to plug the holes in his reading is what seems midwit.

  27. @PiltdownMan
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    There isn't a single Victorian era novel by an British author in that list. And a lot of people with a reading habit in Mr. Sailer's generation likely had read half those books by the time they turned twenty.

    Replies: @Anon, @Known Fact

    Speaking of British authors, he could add one of Graham Greene’s meatier novels, just to observe a master at work. Or if he does Lowry’s Under the Volcano we’ll give him a mulligan and let him skip the 60-page forward.

    • LOL: PiltdownMan
  28. @PhysicistDave
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Jenner Ickham Errican quoted "Mart" as saying:


    This is the reading list of a 17 year old. There's no way this midwit hasn't been artificially pushed by a handful of powerful people
     
    Well... Lev Fridman is 39 years old and is only now reading 1984?

    Does seem a bit late.

    I do wonder about people who make up a reading list based on others' suggestions. It seems a bit like going on a diet or working out because it is "good for you."

    I don't read books because it is, in some abstract sense, good for me.

    For example, I recently read P. J. E. Peebles' The Whole Truth: A Cosmologist's Reflections on the Search for Objective Reality, just published in 2022, because I am curious about what is now known about cosmology. It is an eccentric though well-written book: Peebles, who is a Nobel laureate in the field, uses cosmology to present his views on epistemology. Sure to drive philosophers (and people who think they know philosophy like a few commenters here!) absolutely up the wall!

    And I also just read Christopher Blattman's 2022 book Why We Fight: The Roots of War and the Paths to Peace because of all the discussion about the war to liberate the Donbass. Nothing specific about Ukraine, but it turns out to present some really eye-opening perspectives about applying game theory to issues of war and peace.

    And I just finished Timothy Zahn's 2022 novel, The Icarus Plot simply because it was fun -- entertaining and imaginative "space opera."

    I have a long list of books I want to read because I want to know the specific knowledge contained in those specific books.

    And what I want to know but do not yet know is going to differ from any other human being. There is no uniform list of worthwhile books.

    Indeed, what is worthwhile for any human being when he is twenty will have little overlap with what is worthwhile when he is forty.

    Books are still where we store the systematic knowledge humans have acquired about the nature of reality. You want to know something about such knowledge -- find the appropriate book.

    But to read a book because someone else thinks it would be good for my soul in some way... well, I have things to do and promises to keep and miles to go before I sleep.

    Replies: @Bill P, @AndrewR, @J.Ross, @Ralph L, @Bill, @Craken, @John Foster

    Fridman glows in daylight but this list isn’t a bad list if you to podcast about classics. Is this really supposed to be a personal reading list (of books he hasn’t read before), and not a program for his podcast?

  29. @Anon
    @PiltdownMan

    Yeah, most seem like high school tier. On the other hand, digest The Art of War and Brothers Karamazov in one week each ... lol.

    Replies: @Bill Jones, @J.Ross, @AKAHorace

    I noticed that. Dune in a week. I wonder if he just took titles from some top 10 list (all those sci-fi titles are in the same “top 50” that I found as a set of audiobooks; similarly the classics are something you’d get from a top 10 list). There are great classics which are very short, but the way he has them jumbled, and all assogned the same amount of time …

  30. I can’t do dog movies, I get too emotional. Even old Lassie episodes are problematic — Gramps can just fend for himself at the bottom of that well.

  31. @Bill P
    @PhysicistDave


    Well… Lev Fridman is 39 years old and is only now reading 1984?
     
    Hey, maybe he's re-reading it. I've read it at least twice. I could definitely reread Old Man and the Sea about now. Hemingway may have been an asshole, but that's one beautiful piece of fiction.

    As for dog fiction, I'm currently reading Where the Red Fern Grows -- with my 8yo. It has finally convinced me to get the kid a puppy. We're going to look at a litter today.

    Replies: @HammerJack, @MEH 0910

    As for dog fiction, I’m currently reading Where the Red Fern Grows — with my 8yo.

    Lex Fridman is considering adding that one to his reading list:

    https://lexfridman.com/reading-list/

    Here’s some other suggestions I’m considering. Others are welcome:

    [MORE]

    • The Dead by James Joyce
    • The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman
    • Ward No. 6 by Anton Chekhov
    • Anthem by Ayn Rand
    • The Book of Five Rings by Miyamoto Musashi
    • The Four Agreements by Don Miguel Ruiz
    • Nightfall, Last Question by Isaac Asimov
    • The Little Trilogy by Anton Chekhov
    • The Nose, The Overcoat by Gogol
    • Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad
    • Notes from Underground by Dostoevsky
    • The Giver by Lois Lowry
    • The Prince by Machiavelli
    • Disgrace by J. M. Coetzee
    • Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury
    • The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho
    • The Road by Cormac McCarthy
    • Where the Red Fern Grows by Wilson Rawls
    • A Good Man Is Hard to Find by Flannery O’Connor
    Beyond Good and Evil by Friedrich Nietzsche
    • On Writing by Stephen King
    • Solaris by Stanislaw Lem
    • Childhood’s End by Arthur C Clarke
    • Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K Dick
    • Flowers for Algernon by Daniel Keyes
    • I, Robot by Isaac Asimov
    • The Diary of a Young Girl by Anne Frank
    • Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov
    • Ender’s Game by Orson Scott Card
    • Surely You’re Joking, Mr. Feynman by Richard Feynman
    • Dead Souls by Gogol
    • 12 Rules for Life by Jordan Peterson
    • Snow Crash by Neal Stephenson
    • The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress by Robert Heinlein
    • Three-Body Problem by Cixin Liu
    • Stranger in a Strange Land by Robert Heinlein
    • Godel, Escher, Bach by Douglas R. Hofstadter
    • The Idiot by Dostoevsky

    • Replies: @MGB
    @MEH 0910

    HG Wells, ‘The Island of Dr Moreau’. Fabian socialists torturing those they seek to civilize.

    , @duncsbaby
    @MEH 0910

    Where's my fave?

    https://storage.googleapis.com/hipcomic/p/2795191c422db7cda93549305be30e08.jpg

    Replies: @Ray P

    , @J.Ross
    @MEH 0910

    The Nose and The Overcoat are each short stories (presumably this is an anthology?). The Giver is literally a children's or young adult book. The Four Questions by Ruiz is self-help twaddle, a hair better than Deepak Chopra. And -- On Writing By Stephen King? Ha ha ha ha, very amusing, now please face the wall.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

  32. @MEH 0910
    @Bill P


    As for dog fiction, I’m currently reading Where the Red Fern Grows — with my 8yo.
     
    Lex Fridman is considering adding that one to his reading list:

    https://lexfridman.com/reading-list/

    Here’s some other suggestions I’m considering. Others are welcome:
     

    • The Dead by James Joyce
    • The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman
    • Ward No. 6 by Anton Chekhov
    • Anthem by Ayn Rand
    • The Book of Five Rings by Miyamoto Musashi
    • The Four Agreements by Don Miguel Ruiz
    • Nightfall, Last Question by Isaac Asimov
    • The Little Trilogy by Anton Chekhov
    • The Nose, The Overcoat by Gogol
    • Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad
    • Notes from Underground by Dostoevsky
    • The Giver by Lois Lowry
    • The Prince by Machiavelli
    • Disgrace by J. M. Coetzee
    • Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury
    • The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho
    • The Road by Cormac McCarthy
    • Where the Red Fern Grows by Wilson Rawls
    • A Good Man Is Hard to Find by Flannery O’Connor
    Beyond Good and Evil by Friedrich Nietzsche
    • On Writing by Stephen King
    • Solaris by Stanislaw Lem
    • Childhood’s End by Arthur C Clarke
    • Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K Dick
    • Flowers for Algernon by Daniel Keyes
    • I, Robot by Isaac Asimov
    • The Diary of a Young Girl by Anne Frank
    • Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov
    • Ender’s Game by Orson Scott Card
    • Surely You’re Joking, Mr. Feynman by Richard Feynman
    • Dead Souls by Gogol
    • 12 Rules for Life by Jordan Peterson
    • Snow Crash by Neal Stephenson
    • The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress by Robert Heinlein
    • Three-Body Problem by Cixin Liu
    • Stranger in a Strange Land by Robert Heinlein
    • Godel, Escher, Bach by Douglas R. Hofstadter
    • The Idiot by Dostoevsky
     

    Replies: @MGB, @duncsbaby, @J.Ross

    HG Wells, ‘The Island of Dr Moreau’. Fabian socialists torturing those they seek to civilize.

  33. @HammerJack
    @Bill P

    Please consider a shelter. Breeders are the Spawn of Satan. No matter what they tell you, they are motivated by money alone, and every single breed has been mangled.

    I also recommend: a big, fenced yard, and a large loving family. And it's a 15-year commitment±. Finally, since you asked ;) do the bonding well before you start any training.

    Replies: @The Wild Geese Howard, @Brutusale

    Please consider a shelter.

    I don’t disagree, but in some areas it can be remarkably difficult to find a shelter with a number of pups that lack any ancestry from the bully breeds.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    @The Wild Geese Howard

    Yep. I volunteer at my local shelter and the majority of dogs are at least part pit bull. I had thought when I began volunteering that I would help with the dogs but, as someone with limited dog experience, I find the dogs too intimidating. So I just pet cats and bunnies.

    , @Inverness
    @The Wild Geese Howard

    Females with minor admixture generally have no problem passing the shelters' aggression tests.

    And shelters are generally very strict about this, because they will get sued.

  34. @Jenner Ickham Errican

    crazed beast
     
    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    https://twitter.com/Martpoasting/status/1609603296628731904

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    https://twitter.com/MetaPrime001/status/1609694185766162432

    LOL:

    https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1609751283119935490

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    https://twitter.com/EvanPlatinum/status/1609713244436074496

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZU7k5RMnqY

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.


    https://youtu.be/wcf6iQDWPEo?t=164

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    https://twitter.com/thebobferguson/status/1609418835681214467

    Replies: @PhysicistDave, @R.G. Camara, @PiltdownMan, @AndrewR, @HammerJack, @MEH 0910, @Chrisnonymous, @BB753, @neutral, @AnotherDad, @Rusty Tailgate, @Anonymous, @Ghost of Bull Moose

    Taleb, while not an idiot, is a fool. I respect Dave Pinsen and appreciate his comments on iSteve. However, I suspect both of them have not discerned Lex Fridman’s intentions. I don’t pretend to know what it is, but I would point out that a public reading list that invites others to read along is quite a different thing from a private list of interests.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    @Chrisnonymous


    Taleb, while not an idiot, is a fool. I respect Dave Pinsen and appreciate his comments on iSteve. However, I suspect both of them have not discerned Lex Fridman’s intentions. I don’t pretend to know what it is, but I would point out that a public reading list that invites others to read along is quite a different thing from a private list of interests.
     
    Taleb is an angry old man that fancies himself as philosopher and mathematician. 🤣
    Taleb = 🤡


    https://i.pinimg.com/originals/6d/e7/b5/6de7b552ad0d2413587a0fb497e8b075.jpg
    Lex Fridman: BS, MS, and Ph.D. in computer and electrical engineering.
    Fridman worked at Google working in AI and machine learning and has presented academic papers at conferences in human factors in computing.

     



    https://i.huffpost.com/gen/173648/thumbs/r-NASSIM-TALEB-large570.jpg
    Nassim Taleb: MBA and Ph.D. in management science.
    Taleb worked in finance as a derivatives trader.

     

  35. “How to Read a Book” by Mortimer Adler (and revised) (or the like; there are many) is a good place for a kid (of any age?) to start. Otherwise, the kid better have the Sparknotes nearby to understand what the heck is going on. In my small English Lit class in college there was a guy who could really weave those webs. When the departments gave out the prizes, upon graduation, for best student, he won the Lit prize. He didn’t need the Adler-type book. He was a natural. Hate me, troll me, but very few of us are that guy.

    • Replies: @Reg Cæsar
    @SafeNow


    How to Read a Book by Mortimer Adler
     
    Adler was Auster before Auster:

    [Ken] Myers notes that Adler finally "surrendered to the Hound of Heaven" and "made a confession of faith and was baptized" as an Episcopalian in 1984, only a few years after that interview [with Myers]. Offering insight into Adler's conversion, Myers quotes him from a subsequent 1990 article in Christianity magazine: "My chief reason for choosing Christianity was because the mysteries were incomprehensible. What's the point of revelation if we could figure it out ourselves? If it were wholly comprehensible, then it would just be another philosophy."

    According to his friend Deal Hudson, Adler "had been attracted to Catholicism for many years" and "wanted to be a Roman Catholic, but issues like abortion and the resistance of his family and friends" kept him away. Many thought he was baptized as an Episcopalian rather than a Catholic solely because of his "wonderful – and ardently Episcopal – wife" Caroline. Hudson suggests it is no coincidence that it was only after her death in 1998 that he took the final step. In December 1999, in San Mateo, where he had moved to spend his last years, Adler was formally received into the Catholic Church by a long-time friend and admirer, Bishop Pierre DuMaine. "Finally," wrote another friend, Ralph McInerny, "he became the Roman Catholic he had been training to be all his life".

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortimer_J._Adler#Religion_and_theology
     

    Replies: @Anonymous

    , @John Foster
    @SafeNow

    Don't forget the follow-up, "How to Read Two Books."

  36. @Anon
    @PiltdownMan

    Yeah, most seem like high school tier. On the other hand, digest The Art of War and Brothers Karamazov in one week each ... lol.

    Replies: @Bill Jones, @J.Ross, @AKAHorace

    Yeah, most seem like high school tier. On the other hand, digest The Art of War and Brothers Karamazov in one week each … lol.

    Well, the Little Prince will give her a chance to catch up to her schedule.

  37. Kohberg, alleged killer of four Idaho college students, was a registered Libertarian.

    https://aynrand.no/did-ayn-rand-admire-killer-william-hickman/
    Ayn Rand on her idealized killer:

    «[The boy in my story is] very far from him, of course. The outside of Hickman, but not the inside. Much deeper and much more. A Hickman with a purpose. And without the degeneracy. It is more exact to say that the model is not Hickman, but what Hickman suggested to me.» (p. 22)

    «[the reaction to] this case is not a moral indignation at a terrible crime. It is the mob’s murderous desire to revenge its hurt vanity against a man who dared to be alone. It is a case of ‘we’ against ‘him.’» (p. 37)

    «Yes, he is a monster – now. But the worse he is, the worst must be the cause that drove him to this. Isn’t it significant that a society was not able to fill the life of an exceptional, intelligent boy, to give him anything to out-balance crime in his eyes? If society is horrified at his crime, it should be horrified at the crime’s ultimate cause: itself. The worse the crime – the greater its guilt. What could society answer, if that boy were to say: ‘Yes, I’m a monstrous criminal, but what are you?’

    «This is what I think of the case. I am afraid that I idealize Hickman and that he might not be this at all. In fact, he probably isn’t. But it does not make any difference. If he isn’t, he could be, and that’s enough. The reaction of society would be the same, if not worse, toward the Hickman I have in mind. The case showed me how society can wreck an exceptional being, and then murder him for being the wreck that it itself has created. This will be the story of the boy in my book.» (p. 38)

    «[The] claim that Hickman’s greatest crime is his anti-socialness confirmed my idea of the public’s attitude in this case – and explains my involuntary, irresistible sympathy for him, which I cannot help feeling just because of this and in spite of everything else.» (p. 42)

    • Replies: @prosa123
    @New Dealer

    Of course Reddit is full of people, I suspect mostly women, calling him an Incel and saying that's why he did it. Leaving aside the fact that it's women who are responsible for the increasing number of Incels, we don't actually know if he was one.

    , @Reg Cæsar
    @New Dealer


    Kohberg, alleged killer of four Idaho college students, was a registered Libertarian.
     
    Murder would seem to violate the non-aggression principle. Perhaps he's an anarchocapitalist, who flunked his business courses.

    Replies: @New Dealer, @J.Ross

  38. @Bill Jones

    I don’t know much of anything about the modern military, but the screenplay seemed reasonably realistic.
     
    What's realism nowadays?


    Nazis Are Actually Fine Now, According to the Southern Poverty Law Center and Anti-Defamation League

     

    https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2022-12-31/strange-new-respect-nazi-adjacent-pagans

    Replies: @Stan Adams

    I saw this billboard today:

    The bitchy, snippy tone doesn’t inspire much sympathy. It conjures up an image of a Karen Kohen type wagging her finger in your face: “Three of my grandparents died at Auschwitz, so don’t call me a stuck-up bitch!”

    • Replies: @Veteran Aryan
    @Stan Adams


    The bitchy, snippy tone doesn’t inspire much sympathy.
     
    "We are not the people who ran the gas chambers, we are the people who came and shut them down. Thanks for your gratitude."

    Shame them back.
    , @Beavertales
    @Stan Adams

    Why were these billboards popping up in American and Canadian cities in 2022, and who is bankrolling them?

  39. To work for a Blackwater type organization these days you would need a moral lobotomy.

    ‘Operator Culture’ has fallen from grace these days, as the accusations of murder in Afghanistan pile up against Australian and British special forces. Then there is the Eddie Gallagher affair, the controversial commander Richard Marcinko and financial malfeasance in SEAL Team 6, and drug abuse and murder at Fort Bragg.

    It’s nice to have a movie that celebrates the better nature of some of the SF guys, but they are not fully men if they don’t come to terms with the fact they are, as Smedley Butler put it, enforcers for a capitalist mafia. They are more like the simple hound, which is loyal and subservient to his master.

    After military life, these guys often want to continue living the dream, as PMCs or feds, ready to use brawn as Pavlovian attack dogs.

    That’s not the message which needs to be promoted these days. True heroes are the J6 prisoners rotting in jail, not the steroid monkey who would arrest them without question, or fight for Ukraine.

    Maybe Hollywood would like to tackle the American Gulag? Didn’t think so.

    • Replies: @Harry Baldwin
    @beavertales

    the controversial commander Richard Marcinko

    When I was in the ad business, I worked with a director who started out shooting low
    budget TV commercials for best-selling books, including one of Marcinko's. They were filming on one of NYC's West-Side docks. Marcinko and a crew of actors playing SEALS, armed to the teeth, would secure the area and then Marcinko would snarl into the camera, "If you want to know how this turns out, read 'Red Cell.'"

    They had to wait until twilight to get the lighting they needed, so everyone was hanging around the set all afternoon. Marcinko showed up drunk, then retired to his trailer and continued to drink. The director chose to leave him alone, but there was a young woman on the set who was anxious to meet him. She timidly knocked on the door of his trailer, entered and said, "Mr. Marcinko, I wanted to meet you because my father served with you in Vietnam. His name is Peter Murphy. I'm Colleen Murphy." [Not actual names.]

    Marcinko said, "Peter Murphy? I remember him. Shit, you're Murph's kid?"

    "Yes, I am," she answered. "He always talked about you. Ever since I was a kid I heard about you."

    "Holy shit. Murph. Old Murph. And you're his kid," said Marcinko. "Incredible. Say, you know what Colleen? There's something you could do for me."

    "Really? What's that?" she asked.

    "If you'd just bend over that desk there, I think I have time to fuck you before we shoot this commercial."

  40. @New Dealer
    Kohberg, alleged killer of four Idaho college students, was a registered Libertarian.

    https://aynrand.no/did-ayn-rand-admire-killer-william-hickman/
    Ayn Rand on her idealized killer:

    «[The boy in my story is] very far from him, of course. The outside of Hickman, but not the inside. Much deeper and much more. A Hickman with a purpose. And without the degeneracy. It is more exact to say that the model is not Hickman, but what Hickman suggested to me.» (p. 22)

    «[the reaction to] this case is not a moral indignation at a terrible crime. It is the mob’s murderous desire to revenge its hurt vanity against a man who dared to be alone. It is a case of ‘we’ against ‘him.’» (p. 37)

    «Yes, he is a monster – now. But the worse he is, the worst must be the cause that drove him to this. Isn’t it significant that a society was not able to fill the life of an exceptional, intelligent boy, to give him anything to out-balance crime in his eyes? If society is horrified at his crime, it should be horrified at the crime’s ultimate cause: itself. The worse the crime – the greater its guilt. What could society answer, if that boy were to say: ‘Yes, I’m a monstrous criminal, but what are you?’

    «This is what I think of the case. I am afraid that I idealize Hickman and that he might not be this at all. In fact, he probably isn’t. But it does not make any difference. If he isn’t, he could be, and that’s enough. The reaction of society would be the same, if not worse, toward the Hickman I have in mind. The case showed me how society can wreck an exceptional being, and then murder him for being the wreck that it itself has created. This will be the story of the boy in my book.» (p. 38)

    «[The] claim that Hickman’s greatest crime is his anti-socialness confirmed my idea of the public’s attitude in this case – and explains my involuntary, irresistible sympathy for him, which I cannot help feeling just because of this and in spite of everything else.» (p. 42)
     

    Replies: @prosa123, @Reg Cæsar

    Of course Reddit is full of people, I suspect mostly women, calling him an Incel and saying that’s why he did it. Leaving aside the fact that it’s women who are responsible for the increasing number of Incels, we don’t actually know if he was one.

  41. @Jenner Ickham Errican

    crazed beast
     
    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    https://twitter.com/Martpoasting/status/1609603296628731904

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    https://twitter.com/MetaPrime001/status/1609694185766162432

    LOL:

    https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1609751283119935490

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    https://twitter.com/EvanPlatinum/status/1609713244436074496

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZU7k5RMnqY

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.


    https://youtu.be/wcf6iQDWPEo?t=164

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    https://twitter.com/thebobferguson/status/1609418835681214467

    Replies: @PhysicistDave, @R.G. Camara, @PiltdownMan, @AndrewR, @HammerJack, @MEH 0910, @Chrisnonymous, @BB753, @neutral, @AnotherDad, @Rusty Tailgate, @Anonymous, @Ghost of Bull Moose

    Yuval Noah Harari? Klaus Schwab’s boot-licker? Please!

    • Replies: @Barbarossa
    @BB753

    My wife grabbed Harari's "Sapiens" from the library for the kids to check out. She thought it looked like a neat "sciency" read.

    Fortunately, I saw it, recognized Harari's name and decided that I'd better take a read thorough myself to vet it. It's a very well put together work with a lot of pretty good material. There are quite a number of points that I agreed with wholeheartedly.

    He approaches the norms and sacred cows of all historical periods with a detached irreverence...until he gets to the Woke dogma of the present day. Then it's all transgenders this and George Floyd that, blah blah blah. It's a slick piece of propaganda if you want your kids to be told how ignorant everyone was "back then" and how enlightened our attitudes are now. The first volume wasn't bad but the last part of the second volume was pure poison, the effect of which is made worse by how slickly packaged and authoritative the work appears up that point.

    Needless to say, I made my wife aware of what they really were and she packed them right back off to the library.

    The takeaway is that you have to vet every damn thing these days!

    Replies: @RSDB

  42. @PhysicistDave
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Jenner Ickham Errican quoted "Mart" as saying:


    This is the reading list of a 17 year old. There's no way this midwit hasn't been artificially pushed by a handful of powerful people
     
    Well... Lev Fridman is 39 years old and is only now reading 1984?

    Does seem a bit late.

    I do wonder about people who make up a reading list based on others' suggestions. It seems a bit like going on a diet or working out because it is "good for you."

    I don't read books because it is, in some abstract sense, good for me.

    For example, I recently read P. J. E. Peebles' The Whole Truth: A Cosmologist's Reflections on the Search for Objective Reality, just published in 2022, because I am curious about what is now known about cosmology. It is an eccentric though well-written book: Peebles, who is a Nobel laureate in the field, uses cosmology to present his views on epistemology. Sure to drive philosophers (and people who think they know philosophy like a few commenters here!) absolutely up the wall!

    And I also just read Christopher Blattman's 2022 book Why We Fight: The Roots of War and the Paths to Peace because of all the discussion about the war to liberate the Donbass. Nothing specific about Ukraine, but it turns out to present some really eye-opening perspectives about applying game theory to issues of war and peace.

    And I just finished Timothy Zahn's 2022 novel, The Icarus Plot simply because it was fun -- entertaining and imaginative "space opera."

    I have a long list of books I want to read because I want to know the specific knowledge contained in those specific books.

    And what I want to know but do not yet know is going to differ from any other human being. There is no uniform list of worthwhile books.

    Indeed, what is worthwhile for any human being when he is twenty will have little overlap with what is worthwhile when he is forty.

    Books are still where we store the systematic knowledge humans have acquired about the nature of reality. You want to know something about such knowledge -- find the appropriate book.

    But to read a book because someone else thinks it would be good for my soul in some way... well, I have things to do and promises to keep and miles to go before I sleep.

    Replies: @Bill P, @AndrewR, @J.Ross, @Ralph L, @Bill, @Craken, @John Foster

    Didn’t every Boomer and later HS kid in the US read 1984 and The Great Gatsby? I mean, the ones that could read. Have they been dropped from the curriculum to make room for Toni Morrison and T’Sneezy Coates?

    • Replies: @John1955
    @Ralph L

    -Didn't every Boomer read...-

    1.SELECT FEW Boomers read 1984 and Great Gatsby complete and unabridged
    2.ALL Boomers who managed to graduate from HS read 1984 & Great Gatsby Cliffs Notes

    Now that the Statute of Limitations is expired I can probably confess to #1...
    Yet back then to be branded as a Nerd or an Egghead was no fun, no fun at all...
    Being L7 (aka Square aka Square from Delaware) was not so bad if one was a Jock at the same time.

    , @Mark G.
    @Ralph L


    Didn’t every Boomer and later HS kid in the US read 1984 and The Great Gatsby? I mean, the ones that could read.
     
    1984 really had an impact on me when I read it as a sixteen-year-old. It involved a man who lived in a society where he was constantly watched, there seemed no chance of escape, and he was not treated as an individual. I identified with that character because that is how I felt in my large public school. For the same reason I had earlier identified with the main character in the sixties tv series The Prisoner.


    I hated school and would daydream about running off and living in the woods like in my favorite childhood novel My Side of the Mountain, about a boy who does so after reading Thoreau. I happened to live across the road from a huge, wooded area covering several hundred acres and would spend hours roaming it with my collie dog and those were the happiest hours of my childhood. People often say Atlas Shrugged turns people into libertarians but my exposure to these early influences combined with my hatred of government schools did it for me before I even discovered Ayn Rand.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @HammerJack, @Twinkie

  43. Many military dogs made the ultimate sacrifice, for example “clearing a building” and taking the blast, saving human lives. During the Vietnam era, the military dogs were left behind. This was shameful. Fortunately, things are different now. Almost all military dogs are retired to their new job, patrolling their handler’s house and yard, then taking a nap on the couch. The rest of the dogs are adopted by U.S. people other than the handler. This process costs money, and there are donation opportunities, especially on veterans holidays. Thanks for calling attention to this film, Steve.

    • Thanks: Kylie
    • Replies: @Reg Cæsar
    @SafeNow


    During the Vietnam era, the military dogs were left behind. This was shameful.
     
    Winnie, the Ontarian black bear named for her adoptive Winnipeg regiment, and the inspiration for you-know-whom, was left at the London Zoo. They didn't think she could bear the strains of war on the Continent. She flourished therein for 19 years.

    https://i.guim.co.uk/img/media/0181adfd2e402e0b486dd56f4e0f0746ec383b97/0_526_1085_651/500.jpg?quality=85&auto=format&fit=max&s=dc464c162051f290815f522af5f055bc

  44. Reading lists?

    Boomers get excited about this? What’s on or not on? Books?

    Today’s kids won’t read anything longer than it takes in fifteen minutes on a very tiny cell screen.

    So in 30 years they will be blind as well as ignorant and undoubtedly, stupid…

    But in 30 years, that’s not a problem you need to worry about.

  45. The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.

    Korean Jindos on the other hand…… Who would have thought Steve would turn into a Hollywood stage ‘parent’?

  46. @PhysicistDave
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Jenner Ickham Errican quoted "Mart" as saying:


    This is the reading list of a 17 year old. There's no way this midwit hasn't been artificially pushed by a handful of powerful people
     
    Well... Lev Fridman is 39 years old and is only now reading 1984?

    Does seem a bit late.

    I do wonder about people who make up a reading list based on others' suggestions. It seems a bit like going on a diet or working out because it is "good for you."

    I don't read books because it is, in some abstract sense, good for me.

    For example, I recently read P. J. E. Peebles' The Whole Truth: A Cosmologist's Reflections on the Search for Objective Reality, just published in 2022, because I am curious about what is now known about cosmology. It is an eccentric though well-written book: Peebles, who is a Nobel laureate in the field, uses cosmology to present his views on epistemology. Sure to drive philosophers (and people who think they know philosophy like a few commenters here!) absolutely up the wall!

    And I also just read Christopher Blattman's 2022 book Why We Fight: The Roots of War and the Paths to Peace because of all the discussion about the war to liberate the Donbass. Nothing specific about Ukraine, but it turns out to present some really eye-opening perspectives about applying game theory to issues of war and peace.

    And I just finished Timothy Zahn's 2022 novel, The Icarus Plot simply because it was fun -- entertaining and imaginative "space opera."

    I have a long list of books I want to read because I want to know the specific knowledge contained in those specific books.

    And what I want to know but do not yet know is going to differ from any other human being. There is no uniform list of worthwhile books.

    Indeed, what is worthwhile for any human being when he is twenty will have little overlap with what is worthwhile when he is forty.

    Books are still where we store the systematic knowledge humans have acquired about the nature of reality. You want to know something about such knowledge -- find the appropriate book.

    But to read a book because someone else thinks it would be good for my soul in some way... well, I have things to do and promises to keep and miles to go before I sleep.

    Replies: @Bill P, @AndrewR, @J.Ross, @Ralph L, @Bill, @Craken, @John Foster

    And what I want to know but do not yet know is going to differ from any other human being. There is no uniform list of worthwhile books.

    That’s a little like saying that there is no right side of the road to drive on or there is no right language to speak. It’s not false, but it’s also not true.

    Thanks for mentioning Peebles’ book. Looks interesting. I will read.

    • Replies: @PhysicistDave
    @Bill

    Bill wrote to me:


    That’s a little like saying that there is no right side of the road to drive on or there is no right language to speak. It’s not false, but it’s also not true.
     
    Well, obviously, I am not objecting to people recommending books!

    Indeed, a month or so ago, a commenter here informed me that Lenny Susskind, who was on my thesis committee, is coming out with a popular book on General Relativity. Since I am writing a book on the same subject, this was crucial information for me to have, and I am indebted to that commenter.

    What I am objecting to is the sort of silly stuff like "50 books every educated person should read." Yes, I actually do think people should read 1984, mainly because the warning it gives is so important.

    But while I read and enjoyed Huck Finn, The Odyssey, and To Kill a Mockingbird, I am reluctant to say that a person is culturally stunted if they not have read those three books. (Incidentally, Harper Lee was most assuredly not a liberal. Read her first book: Go Set a Watchman. She was a libertarian conservative, a self-conscious limited-government, states-rights Jeffersonian.)

    This is even more so with non-fiction books. I could name a number of non-fiction books that were critical for me in understanding reality better. But, in almost all cases there are other books that could serve almost as well.

    Replies: @Bill

  47. @SafeNow
    “How to Read a Book” by Mortimer Adler (and revised) (or the like; there are many) is a good place for a kid (of any age?) to start. Otherwise, the kid better have the Sparknotes nearby to understand what the heck is going on. In my small English Lit class in college there was a guy who could really weave those webs. When the departments gave out the prizes, upon graduation, for best student, he won the Lit prize. He didn’t need the Adler-type book. He was a natural. Hate me, troll me, but very few of us are that guy.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar, @John Foster

    How to Read a Book by Mortimer Adler

    Adler was Auster before Auster:

    [Ken] Myers notes that Adler finally “surrendered to the Hound of Heaven” and “made a confession of faith and was baptized” as an Episcopalian in 1984, only a few years after that interview [with Myers]. Offering insight into Adler’s conversion, Myers quotes him from a subsequent 1990 article in Christianity magazine: “My chief reason for choosing Christianity was because the mysteries were incomprehensible. What’s the point of revelation if we could figure it out ourselves? If it were wholly comprehensible, then it would just be another philosophy.”

    According to his friend Deal Hudson, Adler “had been attracted to Catholicism for many years” and “wanted to be a Roman Catholic, but issues like abortion and the resistance of his family and friends” kept him away. Many thought he was baptized as an Episcopalian rather than a Catholic solely because of his “wonderful – and ardently Episcopal – wife” Caroline. Hudson suggests it is no coincidence that it was only after her death in 1998 that he took the final step. In December 1999, in San Mateo, where he had moved to spend his last years, Adler was formally received into the Catholic Church by a long-time friend and admirer, Bishop Pierre DuMaine. “Finally,” wrote another friend, Ralph McInerny, “he became the Roman Catholic he had been training to be all his life”.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortimer_J._Adler#Religion_and_theology

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    @Reg Cæsar


    …another friend, Ralph McInerny, “he became the Roman Catholic he had been training to be all his life”.
     
    Funny enough the late Prof. Ralph McInerny was friends with Unz’s own E. Michael Jones and gave Jones money* to keep Jones’ Fidelity Press running (according to Jones’ book Logos Rising [Fidelity Press, 2020]).

    *McInerny got rich from his Father Dowling mysteries being made into a television show.

    Replies: @Art Deco

  48. @Jenner Ickham Errican

    crazed beast
     
    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    https://twitter.com/Martpoasting/status/1609603296628731904

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    https://twitter.com/MetaPrime001/status/1609694185766162432

    LOL:

    https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1609751283119935490

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    https://twitter.com/EvanPlatinum/status/1609713244436074496

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZU7k5RMnqY

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.


    https://youtu.be/wcf6iQDWPEo?t=164

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    https://twitter.com/thebobferguson/status/1609418835681214467

    Replies: @PhysicistDave, @R.G. Camara, @PiltdownMan, @AndrewR, @HammerJack, @MEH 0910, @Chrisnonymous, @BB753, @neutral, @AnotherDad, @Rusty Tailgate, @Anonymous, @Ghost of Bull Moose

    I wonder why Lex Fridman is being pushed so much, I am completely stumped, his early life section has nothing remarkable. I suppose it will remain a mystery.

    • LOL: fnn
    • Replies: @SunBakedSuburb
    @neutral

    "I wonder why Lex Fridman is being pushed so much ..."

    I wonder why Yuval Noah Harari is being pushed so much by young intellectuals like Lex Fridman. Is nihilism still fashionable amongst the cosmopolitans? Or is it the thrill of being augmented and surveilled that floats their cookies? Such a bright future they prophesize (for them).

    , @Telimektar
    @neutral

    A guy on Youtube calculated that this Friedman's guy political guest were 70% Jewish, they were also overrepresented quite a lot in other categories but not nearly has much. Joe Rogan had 42% Jewish political guests. It's really nice to have a broad perspectives on the world isn't it, no nepotism involved whatsoever....

  49. Tatum needs his former commanding officer to sign off on his job application for a high paying Blackwater-type mercenary job, but the officer doubts that Tatum’s brain has recovered.

    Back in the day, if you wanted a federal job, the civil service gave you a test. (I used it a couple of times for summer jobs and an internship at NASA after graduation.) Then there was a 5 pt, “veteran’s preference” and a 10 pt. “disabled veteran’s preference” that could be tacked on top.

    I have some foggy memory that some whiny XX bureaucrat decided it was unfair that veterans were getting a leg up over her because of their military service which was overwhelmingly male. And sued for sex discrimination and … heck if I know what happened after that. So no idea how it works now.

    But under that system, this pretty much guaranteed that any disabled veteran who hadn’t been reduced to vegetable could find some sort of federal employment doing something within his capability.

    Of course, even better … not having stupid wars that kill/maim good young men.

    • Replies: @Jim Don Bob
    @AnotherDad

    The federal civil service test was ruled racist in the Carter administration, and no one ever bothered to even try to create a new one that would pass judicial scrutiny. NYC spent years and mucho dinero trying to come up with a fire fighter's promotion test where the results are (hint hint) "equitable".

  50. @SafeNow
    Many military dogs made the ultimate sacrifice, for example “clearing a building” and taking the blast, saving human lives. During the Vietnam era, the military dogs were left behind. This was shameful. Fortunately, things are different now. Almost all military dogs are retired to their new job, patrolling their handler’s house and yard, then taking a nap on the couch. The rest of the dogs are adopted by U.S. people other than the handler. This process costs money, and there are donation opportunities, especially on veterans holidays. Thanks for calling attention to this film, Steve.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar

    During the Vietnam era, the military dogs were left behind. This was shameful.

    Winnie, the Ontarian black bear named for her adoptive Winnipeg regiment, and the inspiration for you-know-whom, was left at the London Zoo. They didn’t think she could bear the strains of war on the Continent. She flourished therein for 19 years.

  51. @Jenner Ickham Errican

    crazed beast
     
    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    https://twitter.com/Martpoasting/status/1609603296628731904

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    https://twitter.com/MetaPrime001/status/1609694185766162432

    LOL:

    https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1609751283119935490

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    https://twitter.com/EvanPlatinum/status/1609713244436074496

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZU7k5RMnqY

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.


    https://youtu.be/wcf6iQDWPEo?t=164

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    https://twitter.com/thebobferguson/status/1609418835681214467

    Replies: @PhysicistDave, @R.G. Camara, @PiltdownMan, @AndrewR, @HammerJack, @MEH 0910, @Chrisnonymous, @BB753, @neutral, @AnotherDad, @Rusty Tailgate, @Anonymous, @Ghost of Bull Moose

    Could we agree to limit comments to say no more than 6″ of twitter grab and two annoying videos?

    ~~

    As to content: Dude can read whatever he wants, but it strikes me a pretty boring list. (A bunch of it I’ve read and most of the rest not what I’d want to read now. Though I still haven’t read Sun Tzu.)

    Like a lot of older men, my tastes now run much more to non-fiction and actually learning something. If commenters want to offer their recommendations, especially in the history and general “how we got here” space I’ll take note.

    • Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @AnotherDad


    Could we agree to limit comments to say no more than 6″ of twitter grab ...
     
    Depends on context and content. In this case, I gave those with an itchy scroll finger a heads-up. For it all to flow, the full layout was necessary.

    ... and two annoying videos?
     
    AD, if you played the second Youtube video (outro cued) and weren’t vibing, something’s wrong. :| Those videos were posted meta-tangentially as part of an on-and-off friendly debate about music between me and Dave Pinsen.
    , @Twinkie
    @AnotherDad


    Though I still haven’t read Sun Tzu.
     
    I suggest Samuel B Griffith's translation of it highly, even though it's fallen out of favor in recent years.
  52. @AnotherDad
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Could we agree to limit comments to say no more than 6" of twitter grab and two annoying videos?

    ~~

    As to content: Dude can read whatever he wants, but it strikes me a pretty boring list. (A bunch of it I've read and most of the rest not what I'd want to read now. Though I still haven't read Sun Tzu.)

    Like a lot of older men, my tastes now run much more to non-fiction and actually learning something. If commenters want to offer their recommendations, especially in the history and general "how we got here" space I'll take note.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Twinkie

    Could we agree to limit comments to say no more than 6″ of twitter grab …

    Depends on context and content. In this case, I gave those with an itchy scroll finger a heads-up. For it all to flow, the full layout was necessary.

    … and two annoying videos?

    AD, if you played the second Youtube video (outro cued) and weren’t vibing, something’s wrong. 😐 Those videos were posted meta-tangentially as part of an on-and-off friendly debate about music between me and Dave Pinsen.

  53. @SafeNow
    “How to Read a Book” by Mortimer Adler (and revised) (or the like; there are many) is a good place for a kid (of any age?) to start. Otherwise, the kid better have the Sparknotes nearby to understand what the heck is going on. In my small English Lit class in college there was a guy who could really weave those webs. When the departments gave out the prizes, upon graduation, for best student, he won the Lit prize. He didn’t need the Adler-type book. He was a natural. Hate me, troll me, but very few of us are that guy.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar, @John Foster

    Don’t forget the follow-up, “How to Read Two Books.”

  54. @HammerJack
    @Bill P

    Please consider a shelter. Breeders are the Spawn of Satan. No matter what they tell you, they are motivated by money alone, and every single breed has been mangled.

    I also recommend: a big, fenced yard, and a large loving family. And it's a 15-year commitment±. Finally, since you asked ;) do the bonding well before you start any training.

    Replies: @The Wild Geese Howard, @Brutusale

    Some breeders are the Spawn of Satan.

    FIFY

    The girlfriend is on her third dog in 40 years, all the same breed from the same family in Kentucky. First lived 18 years, the second, 15, and the third is a very frisky 7 years old.

  55. @PhysicistDave
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Jenner Ickham Errican quoted "Mart" as saying:


    This is the reading list of a 17 year old. There's no way this midwit hasn't been artificially pushed by a handful of powerful people
     
    Well... Lev Fridman is 39 years old and is only now reading 1984?

    Does seem a bit late.

    I do wonder about people who make up a reading list based on others' suggestions. It seems a bit like going on a diet or working out because it is "good for you."

    I don't read books because it is, in some abstract sense, good for me.

    For example, I recently read P. J. E. Peebles' The Whole Truth: A Cosmologist's Reflections on the Search for Objective Reality, just published in 2022, because I am curious about what is now known about cosmology. It is an eccentric though well-written book: Peebles, who is a Nobel laureate in the field, uses cosmology to present his views on epistemology. Sure to drive philosophers (and people who think they know philosophy like a few commenters here!) absolutely up the wall!

    And I also just read Christopher Blattman's 2022 book Why We Fight: The Roots of War and the Paths to Peace because of all the discussion about the war to liberate the Donbass. Nothing specific about Ukraine, but it turns out to present some really eye-opening perspectives about applying game theory to issues of war and peace.

    And I just finished Timothy Zahn's 2022 novel, The Icarus Plot simply because it was fun -- entertaining and imaginative "space opera."

    I have a long list of books I want to read because I want to know the specific knowledge contained in those specific books.

    And what I want to know but do not yet know is going to differ from any other human being. There is no uniform list of worthwhile books.

    Indeed, what is worthwhile for any human being when he is twenty will have little overlap with what is worthwhile when he is forty.

    Books are still where we store the systematic knowledge humans have acquired about the nature of reality. You want to know something about such knowledge -- find the appropriate book.

    But to read a book because someone else thinks it would be good for my soul in some way... well, I have things to do and promises to keep and miles to go before I sleep.

    Replies: @Bill P, @AndrewR, @J.Ross, @Ralph L, @Bill, @Craken, @John Foster

    I don’t know what knowledge is contained in a specific book until I read it. And, since there are very often multiple books that purport to explain the same subject, trustworthy advice on which ones to try first can be valuable. Of course, if the book is within one’s field of expertise, such advice may not be needed. But, I sometimes wander away from the range of my expertise and, on occasion, I’m lucky enough to find reliable signposts. An example: “The Nuclear Express”–a history of global nuclear weapons proliferation recommended by a couple of physicists. Reviews/critiques can also be useful for the intellectual interloper, as they put a book in context. Professors have syllabi in which they mandate the reading of certain material, implicitly excluding the rest as less suitable for their students. All of this applies to books that are truth seeking. For literature, the criteria are different, lists of recent books less useful–although the Western Canon is highly useful for filtering older works.

    Now I think of it, a list of subjects that are ignored or maligned in mainstream education might be more generally useful than a book list. I consider it abstractly good for me that I at least know these subjects exist. While swimming with the academic fish, I had scarcely heard of the dark school of psychometricians, and, when I did catch a glimpse at the edge, it was dismissed as low status or pseudoscience. Only when I found dry land and clambered my amphibian self out of the obscure depths did I discovered Psychometrics and its significance for “Understanding Human History” (another book discovered by recommendation). Propaganda is also a subject. It ought to be recognized as such, all the more so given the increasing asymmetry in power between the masses and the propaganda machines. Another: Practical Reasoning (should replace the typical intro to stats course, but run for at least two semesters). Logic and logical fallacies. Anti-Metaphysics, a subject designed to cure the temptation to squander time in the wasteland of metaphysics. Realpolitik–something you get little taste of even if you take a BA in polisci. Not unrelated, but studiously ignored: Military History. History of Science and Technology. The Nature of Economic Systems, with historical illustrations of each in action. I have met middle-aged and elderly people, formally “educated,” who do not realize that these are real subjects of inquiry in which some knowledge has been attained. The mind control institutions prefer it should be so. I know this is nuts: I’m imagining a functional education system in a functional country.

    • Replies: @Rob
    @Craken

    Important subjects not taught would be a very interesting list. Think of it as Dark Arts/Defense Against the Dark Arts.

    Steve, how about an open thread for people to make subject/book suggestions?

    , @PhysicistDave
    @Craken

    Craken wrote to me:


    I don’t know what knowledge is contained in a specific book until I read it.
     
    The "paradox of information": it is very difficult to evaluate the value of information until you have the information and have internalized it.

    This is one of the central reasons libraries are so important: I probably check out ten times as many books from the library as I end up reading cover to cover. (Why don't I just browse in the library? Because the Sacramento library is a medium-size library, but we have a fantastic, free inter-library loan system spanning much of California. So, to "browse" a book, I basically have to order it on inter-library loan.)

    And I probably start reading -- at least ten or twenty pages -- three times as many books as I end up reading cover to cover.

    Craken also wrote:

    Now I think of it, a list of subjects that are ignored or maligned in mainstream education might be more generally useful than a book list. I consider it abstractly good for me that I at least know these subjects exist.
     
    Indeed. Again, the nice things about libraries is that librarians do still tend to stock books that interest only a few people, indeed books that would offend many people.

    Craken also wrote:

    Not unrelated, but studiously ignored: Military History. History of Science and Technology. The Nature of Economic Systems, with historical illustrations of each in action.
     
    Yeah. The problem of course is that you can earn a BA in economics at a good university and never learn how and why Hayek showed that socialism cannot work (the so-called "socialism calculation debate" -- see, for example, Don Lavoie's Rivalry and Central Planning: The Socialist Calculation Debate Reconsidered ).

    Current-day academia is not very good at passing on accumulated human knowledge. The knowledge, however, is there in libraries, but it takes some searching to find it.
  56. The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.

    I’m basically uninterested in the dog. It is after all, a dog. I saw “The Incredible Journey” as a kid. I think that has me covered. A few years later I saw some movie that was about a woman’s love affair with a lion. It was nice. (Spoiler: they went their separate speciesist ways in the end. “Separation” the best policy.) But I think I’d rather see movies about people. That said, I can live with the unphotogenic dog if necessary to see a good movie.

    The question for all movies these days is whether they have annoying jammed superfluous/discordant/anachronistic/annoying blacks into it rendering it–whatever its other merits–unwatchable.

    • Replies: @Colin Wright
    @AnotherDad

    '...The question for all movies these days is whether they have annoying jammed superfluous/discordant/anachronistic/annoying blacks into it rendering it–whatever its other merits–unwatchable.'

    Past the inevitable token, if there're blacks in it, I won't watch it.

    Post-Summer of George, it's a matter of principle. They started a race war, and I'd no more watch a movie with blacks in it now than I would check out Goebbel's latest offering if it were 1943.

    Seriously. My daughter recommended the recent remake of Dune. My first -- and only -- question was 'Are the Fremen black?'

    'Yes.' Then I won't watch it. Ten years ago -- sure. Now? No.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

  57. @BB753
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Yuval Noah Harari? Klaus Schwab's boot-licker? Please!

    Replies: @Barbarossa

    My wife grabbed Harari’s “Sapiens” from the library for the kids to check out. She thought it looked like a neat “sciency” read.

    Fortunately, I saw it, recognized Harari’s name and decided that I’d better take a read thorough myself to vet it. It’s a very well put together work with a lot of pretty good material. There are quite a number of points that I agreed with wholeheartedly.

    He approaches the norms and sacred cows of all historical periods with a detached irreverence…until he gets to the Woke dogma of the present day. Then it’s all transgenders this and George Floyd that, blah blah blah. It’s a slick piece of propaganda if you want your kids to be told how ignorant everyone was “back then” and how enlightened our attitudes are now. The first volume wasn’t bad but the last part of the second volume was pure poison, the effect of which is made worse by how slickly packaged and authoritative the work appears up that point.

    Needless to say, I made my wife aware of what they really were and she packed them right back off to the library.

    The takeaway is that you have to vet every damn thing these days!

    • Thanks: BB753
    • Replies: @RSDB
    @Barbarossa

    E. Michael Jones has an interesting discussion of Sapiens which he published as a booklet, I think, and which sets up his own foray into metahistory in Logos Rising. As usual with Jones I recall thinking the critique was a bit too personal at times, but he does make some interesting points about the assumptions, sometimes contradictory ones, which get smuggled into a book like Sapiens.

    I think the booklet had the rather unfortunate title of Jewish Fables, but that's Jones for you.

    Harari is probably a good historian and he has a knack for bold pronouncements but he seems to have very little philosophical acumen and tends not to think through his own statements with any particular care.

    Replies: @Barbarossa

  58. Anonymous[870] • Disclaimer says:
    @Reg Cæsar
    @SafeNow


    How to Read a Book by Mortimer Adler
     
    Adler was Auster before Auster:

    [Ken] Myers notes that Adler finally "surrendered to the Hound of Heaven" and "made a confession of faith and was baptized" as an Episcopalian in 1984, only a few years after that interview [with Myers]. Offering insight into Adler's conversion, Myers quotes him from a subsequent 1990 article in Christianity magazine: "My chief reason for choosing Christianity was because the mysteries were incomprehensible. What's the point of revelation if we could figure it out ourselves? If it were wholly comprehensible, then it would just be another philosophy."

    According to his friend Deal Hudson, Adler "had been attracted to Catholicism for many years" and "wanted to be a Roman Catholic, but issues like abortion and the resistance of his family and friends" kept him away. Many thought he was baptized as an Episcopalian rather than a Catholic solely because of his "wonderful – and ardently Episcopal – wife" Caroline. Hudson suggests it is no coincidence that it was only after her death in 1998 that he took the final step. In December 1999, in San Mateo, where he had moved to spend his last years, Adler was formally received into the Catholic Church by a long-time friend and admirer, Bishop Pierre DuMaine. "Finally," wrote another friend, Ralph McInerny, "he became the Roman Catholic he had been training to be all his life".

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortimer_J._Adler#Religion_and_theology
     

    Replies: @Anonymous

    …another friend, Ralph McInerny, “he became the Roman Catholic he had been training to be all his life”.

    Funny enough the late Prof. Ralph McInerny was friends with Unz’s own E. Michael Jones and gave Jones money* to keep Jones’ Fidelity Press running (according to Jones’ book Logos Rising [Fidelity Press, 2020]).

    *McInerny got rich from his Father Dowling mysteries being made into a television show.

    • Replies: @Art Deco
    @Anonymous

    The show was on the air for < 2 seasons. It's a reasonable wager McInerney was wealthy from his popular books. He was extraordinarily prolific. Jones began going off the rails before McInerney died.

  59. @MEH 0910
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    https://twitter.com/lexfridman/status/1609609380630253569

    Replies: @Lichen, @Harry Baldwin, @MEH 0910

    If he didn’t want to be mocked, he should have made it clear that he’d read a number of the books previously. It does look like one of those summer reading lists they used to give us in high school.

    I tried listening to Fridman’s podcast but can’t tolerate his dreary voice. Regrettably, I have a similar problem with Glenn Greenwald, whom I greatly respect and to whose Substack I have subscribed. He’s now doing regular newscasts and his nasal, stressed-sounding voice is not pleasant to listen to. Dan Bongino gets so worked up talking about the news that I don’t think it’s good for my blood pressure to listen to him. I’m impressed that the “Red Scare” girls frequently mention Steve Sailer and race realism, but they annoy me with their vocal fry and constant laughing at their own remarks. They sound very sexy though and I can understand guys getting off on it. My favorite podcast is the weekly summation of the news by Matt Taibbi and Walter Kirn. They maintain a detached, somewhat amused manner while discussing the current mess.

    • Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @Harry Baldwin


    I’m impressed that the “Red Scare” girls frequently mention Steve Sailer
     
    Their flirting is relentless !

    https://twitter.com/nobody_stop_me/status/1609940904328011780

    https://twitter.com/annakhachiyan/status/1606723304429359104
    , @Reg Cæsar
    @Harry Baldwin


    My favorite podcast is the weekly summation of the news by Matt Taibbi and Walter Kirn. They maintain a detached, somewhat amused manner...
     
    No surprise that that Kirn is detached-- that describes his hometown enclave of Marine-on-St-Croix, wedged between a state park to the west, and a river to the east, across which is another state's "state natural area".

    https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0615/7205/5240/products/enhanced-matte-paper-framed-poster-_in_-white-18x24-transparent-638ade88ee489.png?v=1670045392

    https://c8.alamy.com/comp/2EHKMCJ/marine-on-st-croix-minnesota-map-1967-124000-united-states-of-america-by-timeless-maps-data-us-geological-survey-2EHKMCJ.jpg


    Little Wally/Walt/Wat would have bought his bubble gum at one of America's last genuine 19th-century general stores, in operation to this day.

    https://i1.wp.com/www.twincities.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/the-wagon-004.jpg

    Seems kind of strange to see a Walter born in 1962. I think Kirn is a junior. Another Minnesotan Walter, the dentist who shot Cecil in Africa, was born about the same time. Not many "boomers" carry the name, let alone late ones.

    https://engaging-data.com/baby-name-visualizer/?n=walter&sex=m&data=n

  60. ot: kinda debunks a lot of false narratives we’ve been forced to accept all of our lives, and likely a better film than magic mikes attempt to be a serious actor.

    The Stigler-Brown Incident Animation

  61. @beavertales
    To work for a Blackwater type organization these days you would need a moral lobotomy.

    'Operator Culture' has fallen from grace these days, as the accusations of murder in Afghanistan pile up against Australian and British special forces. Then there is the Eddie Gallagher affair, the controversial commander Richard Marcinko and financial malfeasance in SEAL Team 6, and drug abuse and murder at Fort Bragg.

    It's nice to have a movie that celebrates the better nature of some of the SF guys, but they are not fully men if they don't come to terms with the fact they are, as Smedley Butler put it, enforcers for a capitalist mafia. They are more like the simple hound, which is loyal and subservient to his master.

    After military life, these guys often want to continue living the dream, as PMCs or feds, ready to use brawn as Pavlovian attack dogs.

    That's not the message which needs to be promoted these days. True heroes are the J6 prisoners rotting in jail, not the steroid monkey who would arrest them without question, or fight for Ukraine.

    Maybe Hollywood would like to tackle the American Gulag? Didn't think so.

    Replies: @Harry Baldwin

    the controversial commander Richard Marcinko

    When I was in the ad business, I worked with a director who started out shooting low
    budget TV commercials for best-selling books, including one of Marcinko’s. They were filming on one of NYC’s West-Side docks. Marcinko and a crew of actors playing SEALS, armed to the teeth, would secure the area and then Marcinko would snarl into the camera, “If you want to know how this turns out, read ‘Red Cell.’”

    They had to wait until twilight to get the lighting they needed, so everyone was hanging around the set all afternoon. Marcinko showed up drunk, then retired to his trailer and continued to drink. The director chose to leave him alone, but there was a young woman on the set who was anxious to meet him. She timidly knocked on the door of his trailer, entered and said, “Mr. Marcinko, I wanted to meet you because my father served with you in Vietnam. His name is Peter Murphy. I’m Colleen Murphy.” [Not actual names.]

    Marcinko said, “Peter Murphy? I remember him. Shit, you’re Murph’s kid?”

    “Yes, I am,” she answered. “He always talked about you. Ever since I was a kid I heard about you.”

    “Holy shit. Murph. Old Murph. And you’re his kid,” said Marcinko. “Incredible. Say, you know what Colleen? There’s something you could do for me.”

    “Really? What’s that?” she asked.

    “If you’d just bend over that desk there, I think I have time to fuck you before we shoot this commercial.”

  62. @Harry Baldwin
    @MEH 0910

    If he didn't want to be mocked, he should have made it clear that he'd read a number of the books previously. It does look like one of those summer reading lists they used to give us in high school.

    I tried listening to Fridman's podcast but can't tolerate his dreary voice. Regrettably, I have a similar problem with Glenn Greenwald, whom I greatly respect and to whose Substack I have subscribed. He's now doing regular newscasts and his nasal, stressed-sounding voice is not pleasant to listen to. Dan Bongino gets so worked up talking about the news that I don't think it's good for my blood pressure to listen to him. I'm impressed that the "Red Scare" girls frequently mention Steve Sailer and race realism, but they annoy me with their vocal fry and constant laughing at their own remarks. They sound very sexy though and I can understand guys getting off on it. My favorite podcast is the weekly summation of the news by Matt Taibbi and Walter Kirn. They maintain a detached, somewhat amused manner while discussing the current mess.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Reg Cæsar

    I’m impressed that the “Red Scare” girls frequently mention Steve Sailer

    Their flirting is relentless !

  63. @Jenner Ickham Errican

    crazed beast
     
    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    https://twitter.com/Martpoasting/status/1609603296628731904

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    https://twitter.com/MetaPrime001/status/1609694185766162432

    LOL:

    https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1609751283119935490

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    https://twitter.com/EvanPlatinum/status/1609713244436074496

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZU7k5RMnqY

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.


    https://youtu.be/wcf6iQDWPEo?t=164

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    https://twitter.com/thebobferguson/status/1609418835681214467

    Replies: @PhysicistDave, @R.G. Camara, @PiltdownMan, @AndrewR, @HammerJack, @MEH 0910, @Chrisnonymous, @BB753, @neutral, @AnotherDad, @Rusty Tailgate, @Anonymous, @Ghost of Bull Moose

    I publicly committed to reading Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit, but between friends, I had to set it aside five pages in, because I find I’m having to devote all my free time to tweeting about numerous memes that I do not wholly agree with.

  64. @Anonymous
    @Reg Cæsar


    …another friend, Ralph McInerny, “he became the Roman Catholic he had been training to be all his life”.
     
    Funny enough the late Prof. Ralph McInerny was friends with Unz’s own E. Michael Jones and gave Jones money* to keep Jones’ Fidelity Press running (according to Jones’ book Logos Rising [Fidelity Press, 2020]).

    *McInerny got rich from his Father Dowling mysteries being made into a television show.

    Replies: @Art Deco

    The show was on the air for < 2 seasons. It's a reasonable wager McInerney was wealthy from his popular books. He was extraordinarily prolific. Jones began going off the rails before McInerney died.

  65. @Ralph L
    @PhysicistDave

    Didn't every Boomer and later HS kid in the US read 1984 and The Great Gatsby? I mean, the ones that could read. Have they been dropped from the curriculum to make room for Toni Morrison and T'Sneezy Coates?

    Replies: @John1955, @Mark G.

    -Didn’t every Boomer read…-

    1.SELECT FEW Boomers read 1984 and Great Gatsby complete and unabridged
    2.ALL Boomers who managed to graduate from HS read 1984 & Great Gatsby Cliffs Notes

    Now that the Statute of Limitations is expired I can probably confess to #1…
    Yet back then to be branded as a Nerd or an Egghead was no fun, no fun at all…
    Being L7 (aka Square aka Square from Delaware) was not so bad if one was a Jock at the same time.

  66. Anonymous[187] • Disclaimer says:
    @The Wild Geese Howard
    @HammerJack


    Please consider a shelter.
     
    I don't disagree, but in some areas it can be remarkably difficult to find a shelter with a number of pups that lack any ancestry from the bully breeds.

    Replies: @Anonymous, @Inverness

    Yep. I volunteer at my local shelter and the majority of dogs are at least part pit bull. I had thought when I began volunteering that I would help with the dogs but, as someone with limited dog experience, I find the dogs too intimidating. So I just pet cats and bunnies.

  67. Anonymous[292] • Disclaimer says:
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    crazed beast
     
    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    https://twitter.com/Martpoasting/status/1609603296628731904

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    https://twitter.com/MetaPrime001/status/1609694185766162432

    LOL:

    https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1609751283119935490

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    https://twitter.com/EvanPlatinum/status/1609713244436074496

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZU7k5RMnqY

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.


    https://youtu.be/wcf6iQDWPEo?t=164

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    https://twitter.com/thebobferguson/status/1609418835681214467

    Replies: @PhysicistDave, @R.G. Camara, @PiltdownMan, @AndrewR, @HammerJack, @MEH 0910, @Chrisnonymous, @BB753, @neutral, @AnotherDad, @Rusty Tailgate, @Anonymous, @Ghost of Bull Moose

    Some of Lex’s books are good. I still need to read Brave New World.

    The Bell Curve
    Culture of Critique
    Yggdrasil’s content
    Early Steve Sailer highlights on HBD etc.

    Those are probably the most influential books of my adult life. Also a chronological ordering of the Koran was worthwhile. I had to do it myself in the 2000 era; now it is done for you.

    https://skepticsannotatedbible.com/quran/chrono.htm

    Also the Gulag Archipelago.

    I think Mein Kampf and the Communist Manifesto are also worth reading to understand events of the 20th century.

    And as Steve says, read a proper multi-volume childrens’ encyclopaedia or 3 for good measure. Any recommendations there?

  68. @Harry Baldwin
    @MEH 0910

    If he didn't want to be mocked, he should have made it clear that he'd read a number of the books previously. It does look like one of those summer reading lists they used to give us in high school.

    I tried listening to Fridman's podcast but can't tolerate his dreary voice. Regrettably, I have a similar problem with Glenn Greenwald, whom I greatly respect and to whose Substack I have subscribed. He's now doing regular newscasts and his nasal, stressed-sounding voice is not pleasant to listen to. Dan Bongino gets so worked up talking about the news that I don't think it's good for my blood pressure to listen to him. I'm impressed that the "Red Scare" girls frequently mention Steve Sailer and race realism, but they annoy me with their vocal fry and constant laughing at their own remarks. They sound very sexy though and I can understand guys getting off on it. My favorite podcast is the weekly summation of the news by Matt Taibbi and Walter Kirn. They maintain a detached, somewhat amused manner while discussing the current mess.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Reg Cæsar

    My favorite podcast is the weekly summation of the news by Matt Taibbi and Walter Kirn. They maintain a detached, somewhat amused manner…

    No surprise that that Kirn is detached– that describes his hometown enclave of Marine-on-St-Croix, wedged between a state park to the west, and a river to the east, across which is another state’s “state natural area”.

    Little Wally/Walt/Wat would have bought his bubble gum at one of America’s last genuine 19th-century general stores, in operation to this day.

    Seems kind of strange to see a Walter born in 1962. I think Kirn is a junior. Another Minnesotan Walter, the dentist who shot Cecil in Africa, was born about the same time. Not many “boomers” carry the name, let alone late ones.

    https://engaging-data.com/baby-name-visualizer/?n=walter&sex=m&data=n

  69. @Craken
    @PhysicistDave

    I don't know what knowledge is contained in a specific book until I read it. And, since there are very often multiple books that purport to explain the same subject, trustworthy advice on which ones to try first can be valuable. Of course, if the book is within one's field of expertise, such advice may not be needed. But, I sometimes wander away from the range of my expertise and, on occasion, I'm lucky enough to find reliable signposts. An example: "The Nuclear Express"--a history of global nuclear weapons proliferation recommended by a couple of physicists. Reviews/critiques can also be useful for the intellectual interloper, as they put a book in context. Professors have syllabi in which they mandate the reading of certain material, implicitly excluding the rest as less suitable for their students. All of this applies to books that are truth seeking. For literature, the criteria are different, lists of recent books less useful--although the Western Canon is highly useful for filtering older works.

    Now I think of it, a list of subjects that are ignored or maligned in mainstream education might be more generally useful than a book list. I consider it abstractly good for me that I at least know these subjects exist. While swimming with the academic fish, I had scarcely heard of the dark school of psychometricians, and, when I did catch a glimpse at the edge, it was dismissed as low status or pseudoscience. Only when I found dry land and clambered my amphibian self out of the obscure depths did I discovered Psychometrics and its significance for "Understanding Human History" (another book discovered by recommendation). Propaganda is also a subject. It ought to be recognized as such, all the more so given the increasing asymmetry in power between the masses and the propaganda machines. Another: Practical Reasoning (should replace the typical intro to stats course, but run for at least two semesters). Logic and logical fallacies. Anti-Metaphysics, a subject designed to cure the temptation to squander time in the wasteland of metaphysics. Realpolitik--something you get little taste of even if you take a BA in polisci. Not unrelated, but studiously ignored: Military History. History of Science and Technology. The Nature of Economic Systems, with historical illustrations of each in action. I have met middle-aged and elderly people, formally "educated," who do not realize that these are real subjects of inquiry in which some knowledge has been attained. The mind control institutions prefer it should be so. I know this is nuts: I'm imagining a functional education system in a functional country.

    Replies: @Rob, @PhysicistDave

    Important subjects not taught would be a very interesting list. Think of it as Dark Arts/Defense Against the Dark Arts.

    Steve, how about an open thread for people to make subject/book suggestions?

  70. @Mike Tre
    "However, when Lulu’s handler, an old war buddy of Tatum’s, drives into a tree at 120 mph, the officer offers to sign Tatum’s form if he will get the hero dog / crazed beast to New Mexico in five days for the handler’s funeral."

    so it's a remake of smokey and the bandit. or perhaps midnight run?

    https://youtu.be/8QAEmCuBnck

    Replies: @Wokechoke

    Oliver Reed’s Hannibal Brooks…saving the elephant movie. Getting drunk with him must have been a laugh.

  71. Anonymous[366] • Disclaimer says:
    @Chrisnonymous
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Taleb, while not an idiot, is a fool. I respect Dave Pinsen and appreciate his comments on iSteve. However, I suspect both of them have not discerned Lex Fridman's intentions. I don't pretend to know what it is, but I would point out that a public reading list that invites others to read along is quite a different thing from a private list of interests.

    Replies: @Anonymous

    Taleb, while not an idiot, is a fool. I respect Dave Pinsen and appreciate his comments on iSteve. However, I suspect both of them have not discerned Lex Fridman’s intentions. I don’t pretend to know what it is, but I would point out that a public reading list that invites others to read along is quite a different thing from a private list of interests.

    Taleb is an angry old man that fancies himself as philosopher and mathematician. 🤣
    Taleb = 🤡


    Lex Fridman: BS, MS, and Ph.D. in computer and electrical engineering.
    Fridman worked at Google working in AI and machine learning and has presented academic papers at conferences in human factors in computing.


    Nassim Taleb: MBA and Ph.D. in management science.
    Taleb worked in finance as a derivatives trader.

    • Agree: Bill
  72. @PhysicistDave
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Jenner Ickham Errican quoted "Mart" as saying:


    This is the reading list of a 17 year old. There's no way this midwit hasn't been artificially pushed by a handful of powerful people
     
    Well... Lev Fridman is 39 years old and is only now reading 1984?

    Does seem a bit late.

    I do wonder about people who make up a reading list based on others' suggestions. It seems a bit like going on a diet or working out because it is "good for you."

    I don't read books because it is, in some abstract sense, good for me.

    For example, I recently read P. J. E. Peebles' The Whole Truth: A Cosmologist's Reflections on the Search for Objective Reality, just published in 2022, because I am curious about what is now known about cosmology. It is an eccentric though well-written book: Peebles, who is a Nobel laureate in the field, uses cosmology to present his views on epistemology. Sure to drive philosophers (and people who think they know philosophy like a few commenters here!) absolutely up the wall!

    And I also just read Christopher Blattman's 2022 book Why We Fight: The Roots of War and the Paths to Peace because of all the discussion about the war to liberate the Donbass. Nothing specific about Ukraine, but it turns out to present some really eye-opening perspectives about applying game theory to issues of war and peace.

    And I just finished Timothy Zahn's 2022 novel, The Icarus Plot simply because it was fun -- entertaining and imaginative "space opera."

    I have a long list of books I want to read because I want to know the specific knowledge contained in those specific books.

    And what I want to know but do not yet know is going to differ from any other human being. There is no uniform list of worthwhile books.

    Indeed, what is worthwhile for any human being when he is twenty will have little overlap with what is worthwhile when he is forty.

    Books are still where we store the systematic knowledge humans have acquired about the nature of reality. You want to know something about such knowledge -- find the appropriate book.

    But to read a book because someone else thinks it would be good for my soul in some way... well, I have things to do and promises to keep and miles to go before I sleep.

    Replies: @Bill P, @AndrewR, @J.Ross, @Ralph L, @Bill, @Craken, @John Foster

    On cosmology, “Genesis” by Guido Tonelli, who works at CERN, came out in English not too long ago and is pretty good.

  73. @Bill Jones
    @Anon

    I'm about to embark on a re-read for the first time in forty years of Dostoevsky's Devils. I've got the one I've read somewhere but am too idle to hunt it down or dig it up.
    Anybody got any views on which translation?

    Replies: @JimDandy

    I read Robert Maguire’s most recently–Penguin Classic. I don’t know if that’s supposed to be the best one, but it’s excellent, imo.

  74. @Jenner Ickham Errican

    crazed beast
     
    Don’t mind if I do!

    Off-topic but very important! (MORE tag not applicable here)

    https://twitter.com/Martpoasting/status/1609603296628731904

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley
    (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    But seriously, posting reading lists or music playlists, etc. in public is risky business. Many people don’t know what they don’t know and reveal themselves to mentally inhabit Basic Bitch (NPC-adjacent) territory rather than being the public ‘intellectuals’ they think they are. End result: sketchy scores on the self-administered Voight-Kampff / Turing test, narrator: unreliable.

    https://twitter.com/MetaPrime001/status/1609694185766162432

    LOL:

    https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1609751283119935490

    Dave Pinsen retweeted:

    https://twitter.com/EvanPlatinum/status/1609713244436074496

    Bonus “stoner friendly” mirror images & sound smackdown:

    Dave, question— would one retweet this wan ‘90s-Madonna-tier murk …

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZU7k5RMnqY

    … if one knew the slammin’ outro below could exist? No, one would not.


    https://youtu.be/wcf6iQDWPEo?t=164

    But to Mr. Pinsen’s credit, his retweet of the performance below was a great choice. Live David Byrne duets are perfect New Year’s Eve music.

    https://twitter.com/thebobferguson/status/1609418835681214467

    Replies: @PhysicistDave, @R.G. Camara, @PiltdownMan, @AndrewR, @HammerJack, @MEH 0910, @Chrisnonymous, @BB753, @neutral, @AnotherDad, @Rusty Tailgate, @Anonymous, @Ghost of Bull Moose

    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)

    These are all good choices. I’d like to add:

    How to Be an Auntie Racist by Ex Ibram Kendi
    Do The First Thing That Pops Into Your Head by Malcolm Gladwell
    My Lovely White Teef Bones
    This Land is Our Land, Now Get Out Whitey: An Immigrant’s Eviction Notice by Suketu Mehta
    Golf Course Design: Fascinating! by Steve Sailer

    • Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @Ghost of Bull Moose


    Golf Course Design: Fascinating! by Steve Sailer
     
    I’ll buy that one for the coffee table, but I may skip the rest. Too busy!
  75. @AnotherDad
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Could we agree to limit comments to say no more than 6" of twitter grab and two annoying videos?

    ~~

    As to content: Dude can read whatever he wants, but it strikes me a pretty boring list. (A bunch of it I've read and most of the rest not what I'd want to read now. Though I still haven't read Sun Tzu.)

    Like a lot of older men, my tastes now run much more to non-fiction and actually learning something. If commenters want to offer their recommendations, especially in the history and general "how we got here" space I'll take note.

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican, @Twinkie

    Though I still haven’t read Sun Tzu.

    I suggest Samuel B Griffith’s translation of it highly, even though it’s fallen out of favor in recent years.

  76. @neutral
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    I wonder why Lex Fridman is being pushed so much, I am completely stumped, his early life section has nothing remarkable. I suppose it will remain a mystery.

    Replies: @SunBakedSuburb, @Telimektar

    “I wonder why Lex Fridman is being pushed so much …”

    I wonder why Yuval Noah Harari is being pushed so much by young intellectuals like Lex Fridman. Is nihilism still fashionable amongst the cosmopolitans? Or is it the thrill of being augmented and surveilled that floats their cookies? Such a bright future they prophesize (for them).

  77. The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.

    Dog racist!

    Since you have a dog now (purportedly a Jindo-mix) and seem to be into dogs, might I recommend this?

    • Replies: @Reg Cæsar
    @Twinkie


    Dog racist!
     
    Dog = God.

    Replies: @Joe Stalin

    , @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @Twinkie


    might I recommend this?
     
    Nice. I’ve read about Hachi in Hachette Filipacchi (Smelle magazine).
  78. @Pat Hannagan
    The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.

    You have zero idea how aspergers you come across with that "observation" do you?

    I'm not criticising just observing.

    This movie sounds typically pro-war, destroy your family for the Bush and Clinton family biennial worship of Moloch and Davos Man, doesn't anyone know about Hitler and Ann Frank and the shoa, here's a dog to identify with as we subliminally urge you on to slaughter The Other!

    Btw, did you know that to be a Tunnel Rat in Vietnam you had to be below 6 foot in height?

    I wonder how many of them "Ann" Coulter would deign fuck if he would be so moved.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2-jGAVT-Elk

    I haven't seen it yet but I will see The Banshees of Inisherin

    Replies: @AKAHorace, @Anon, @SunBakedSuburb, @Anonymous, @Recently Based, @Decoy

    “You have zero idea how aspergers you come across …”

    “The Shimmery”

    It’s a reboot of Rosemary’s Baby with Steve playing the roles of Mia Farrow’s husband and their baby. The devil will be played by the sleek, objectionable animal Steve picked up in Burbank.

  79. @AndrewR
    @PhysicistDave

    Please elaborate on the Blattman book. Sounds interesting.

    Replies: @PhysicistDave

    AndrewR asked me:

    Please elaborate on the Blattman book. Sounds interesting.

    The central message of the book is that war is always costly for both sides (obviously true in the case of Ukraine, of course), and therefore both sides usually have an incentive to avoid war and usually do succeed in avoiding war.

    So, the real question is: why do attempts to avoid war sometimes fail?

    Blattman approaches the question from a game-theoretic perspective — incentives, strategy, asymmetric information, etc. — but he goes lightly on the theory. He does a nice job of focusing on actual cases of violent conflict and on what went wrong to lead to violence.

    He does deal with obvious issues outside game theory in the narrow sense — e.g., psychological motivations.

    The main point on which I would differ with him is he says that a strong state is a good way to avoid civil war.

    Yes, but… sometimes a strong and overbearing state is what leads to rebellion. And sometimes it is strong states that start wars with other states.

    Anyway, the book has no big message to sell except that it is good to try to understand what starts wars in the hope that we can avoid them.

    It is quite readable, given that it is a non-fiction book on a serious subject.

    Hope this gives you the info you want.

    • Thanks: AndrewR
    • Replies: @J.Ross
    @PhysicistDave

    Interesting, but almost no one predicted a comic book level of evil in the form of a war lobby that literally works continually to neutralize the will of the people and start unnecessary wars, let alone one that jumps parties when convenient. Voting cannot remove the unelected.

    Replies: @PhysicistDave

  80. OT — It turns out that the Andrew Tate nonsense was to distract from a US Virgin Islands attorney general suing JP Morgan over a connection with Jeffrey Epstein, and promptly being fired without explanation.
    https://lawandcrime.com/live-trials/live-trials-current/jeffrey-epstein/virgin-islands-attorney-general-loses-her-job-days-after-suing-jpmorgan-chase-in-connection-with-the-jeffrey-epstein-probe/
    But hey, the Idaho police would’ve caught Kohberger much faster had he relied upon distinctive pizza boxes.

  81. @PhysicistDave
    @AndrewR

    AndrewR asked me:


    Please elaborate on the Blattman book. Sounds interesting.
     
    The central message of the book is that war is always costly for both sides (obviously true in the case of Ukraine, of course), and therefore both sides usually have an incentive to avoid war and usually do succeed in avoiding war.

    So, the real question is: why do attempts to avoid war sometimes fail?

    Blattman approaches the question from a game-theoretic perspective -- incentives, strategy, asymmetric information, etc. -- but he goes lightly on the theory. He does a nice job of focusing on actual cases of violent conflict and on what went wrong to lead to violence.

    He does deal with obvious issues outside game theory in the narrow sense -- e.g., psychological motivations.

    The main point on which I would differ with him is he says that a strong state is a good way to avoid civil war.

    Yes, but... sometimes a strong and overbearing state is what leads to rebellion. And sometimes it is strong states that start wars with other states.

    Anyway, the book has no big message to sell except that it is good to try to understand what starts wars in the hope that we can avoid them.

    It is quite readable, given that it is a non-fiction book on a serious subject.

    Hope this gives you the info you want.

    Replies: @J.Ross

    Interesting, but almost no one predicted a comic book level of evil in the form of a war lobby that literally works continually to neutralize the will of the people and start unnecessary wars, let alone one that jumps parties when convenient. Voting cannot remove the unelected.

    • Replies: @PhysicistDave
    @J.Ross

    J.Ross wrote to me:


    Interesting, but almost no one predicted a comic book level of evil in the form of a war lobby that literally works continually to neutralize the will of the people and start unnecessary wars...
     
    Well, of course, Orwelll actually did predict that in 1984:

    "Oceania has always been at war with Eastasia."
     
    And yet most people who have read 1984 have just chucked that into the memory hole: they remember the surveillance state, the falsification of history, etc., but they forget that one of the major themes of the novel is the use of perpetual war as a means of controlling the populace.

    And of course that very ability to forget one of the central themes of 1984 actually validates the central message of 1984, doesn't it?

    Any chance we could ever get Corvinus, Jack D, HAsbara, et al. to grasp this?

    At all?

    Replies: @J.Ross

  82. @Craken
    @PhysicistDave

    I don't know what knowledge is contained in a specific book until I read it. And, since there are very often multiple books that purport to explain the same subject, trustworthy advice on which ones to try first can be valuable. Of course, if the book is within one's field of expertise, such advice may not be needed. But, I sometimes wander away from the range of my expertise and, on occasion, I'm lucky enough to find reliable signposts. An example: "The Nuclear Express"--a history of global nuclear weapons proliferation recommended by a couple of physicists. Reviews/critiques can also be useful for the intellectual interloper, as they put a book in context. Professors have syllabi in which they mandate the reading of certain material, implicitly excluding the rest as less suitable for their students. All of this applies to books that are truth seeking. For literature, the criteria are different, lists of recent books less useful--although the Western Canon is highly useful for filtering older works.

    Now I think of it, a list of subjects that are ignored or maligned in mainstream education might be more generally useful than a book list. I consider it abstractly good for me that I at least know these subjects exist. While swimming with the academic fish, I had scarcely heard of the dark school of psychometricians, and, when I did catch a glimpse at the edge, it was dismissed as low status or pseudoscience. Only when I found dry land and clambered my amphibian self out of the obscure depths did I discovered Psychometrics and its significance for "Understanding Human History" (another book discovered by recommendation). Propaganda is also a subject. It ought to be recognized as such, all the more so given the increasing asymmetry in power between the masses and the propaganda machines. Another: Practical Reasoning (should replace the typical intro to stats course, but run for at least two semesters). Logic and logical fallacies. Anti-Metaphysics, a subject designed to cure the temptation to squander time in the wasteland of metaphysics. Realpolitik--something you get little taste of even if you take a BA in polisci. Not unrelated, but studiously ignored: Military History. History of Science and Technology. The Nature of Economic Systems, with historical illustrations of each in action. I have met middle-aged and elderly people, formally "educated," who do not realize that these are real subjects of inquiry in which some knowledge has been attained. The mind control institutions prefer it should be so. I know this is nuts: I'm imagining a functional education system in a functional country.

    Replies: @Rob, @PhysicistDave

    Craken wrote to me:

    I don’t know what knowledge is contained in a specific book until I read it.

    The “paradox of information”: it is very difficult to evaluate the value of information until you have the information and have internalized it.

    This is one of the central reasons libraries are so important: I probably check out ten times as many books from the library as I end up reading cover to cover. (Why don’t I just browse in the library? Because the Sacramento library is a medium-size library, but we have a fantastic, free inter-library loan system spanning much of California. So, to “browse” a book, I basically have to order it on inter-library loan.)

    And I probably start reading — at least ten or twenty pages — three times as many books as I end up reading cover to cover.

    Craken also wrote:

    Now I think of it, a list of subjects that are ignored or maligned in mainstream education might be more generally useful than a book list. I consider it abstractly good for me that I at least know these subjects exist.

    Indeed. Again, the nice things about libraries is that librarians do still tend to stock books that interest only a few people, indeed books that would offend many people.

    Craken also wrote:

    Not unrelated, but studiously ignored: Military History. History of Science and Technology. The Nature of Economic Systems, with historical illustrations of each in action.

    Yeah. The problem of course is that you can earn a BA in economics at a good university and never learn how and why Hayek showed that socialism cannot work (the so-called “socialism calculation debate” — see, for example, Don Lavoie’s Rivalry and Central Planning: The Socialist Calculation Debate Reconsidered ).

    Current-day academia is not very good at passing on accumulated human knowledge. The knowledge, however, is there in libraries, but it takes some searching to find it.

  83. @Bill
    @PhysicistDave


    And what I want to know but do not yet know is going to differ from any other human being. There is no uniform list of worthwhile books.
     
    That's a little like saying that there is no right side of the road to drive on or there is no right language to speak. It's not false, but it's also not true.

    Thanks for mentioning Peebles' book. Looks interesting. I will read.

    Replies: @PhysicistDave

    Bill wrote to me:

    That’s a little like saying that there is no right side of the road to drive on or there is no right language to speak. It’s not false, but it’s also not true.

    Well, obviously, I am not objecting to people recommending books!

    Indeed, a month or so ago, a commenter here informed me that Lenny Susskind, who was on my thesis committee, is coming out with a popular book on General Relativity. Since I am writing a book on the same subject, this was crucial information for me to have, and I am indebted to that commenter.

    What I am objecting to is the sort of silly stuff like “50 books every educated person should read.” Yes, I actually do think people should read 1984, mainly because the warning it gives is so important.

    But while I read and enjoyed Huck Finn, The Odyssey, and To Kill a Mockingbird, I am reluctant to say that a person is culturally stunted if they not have read those three books. (Incidentally, Harper Lee was most assuredly not a liberal. Read her first book: Go Set a Watchman. She was a libertarian conservative, a self-conscious limited-government, states-rights Jeffersonian.)

    This is even more so with non-fiction books. I could name a number of non-fiction books that were critical for me in understanding reality better. But, in almost all cases there are other books that could serve almost as well.

    • Replies: @Bill
    @PhysicistDave

    We speak past one another. I am defending stuff like "50 books every educated person should read" while admitting that any such list is, in a certain sense, arbitrary. Just like which side of the road you drive on or which language you speak. These are both, in a certain sense, arbitrary, and, in a certain sense, very far from arbitrary.

    Not only is it critical that you drive on the same side of the road as everyone else and speak the same language as everyone else, but it is also critical that there be a side of the road everyone drives on and a language everyone speaks. Disaster would ensue if there were not.

    And disaster has ensued in the US because there are not 50 books every educated person has read (and all the stuff which goes along with that). Our hideous, thin, ugly, utterly amoral, low-context culture is the disaster.

    I'm certainly not defending the list Fridman posted, by the way, which looks like something Vox Dei would come up with (well, except it doesn't have a strategy guide to Advanced Squad Leader on it).

  84. @Twinkie

    The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.
     
    Dog racist!

    Since you have a dog now (purportedly a Jindo-mix) and seem to be into dogs, might I recommend this?

    https://youtu.be/TIl2o1hm1F4

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar, @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Dog racist!

    Dog = God.

    • Replies: @Joe Stalin
    @Reg Cæsar


    Dog = God.
     
    White God (2015).

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tf-4MrCEdTU
  85. @Stan Adams
    @Bill Jones

    I saw this billboard today:
    https://media.nbcmiami.com/2022/12/Miami.Okeechobee-e1671204353387.jpg

    The bitchy, snippy tone doesn't inspire much sympathy. It conjures up an image of a Karen Kohen type wagging her finger in your face: "Three of my grandparents died at Auschwitz, so don't call me a stuck-up bitch!"

    Replies: @Veteran Aryan, @Beavertales

    The bitchy, snippy tone doesn’t inspire much sympathy.

    “We are not the people who ran the gas chambers, we are the people who came and shut them down. Thanks for your gratitude.”

    Shame them back.

    • Agree: Twinkie
  86. OT – Scott Adams is threatening to sue Ben Garrison and pro-vaxxers are tweeting no matter what happens, it’s the thought that counts. How’s everything going on the vaccine front?

    https://metatron.substack.com/p/the-dam-is-breaking

    https://www.rintrah.nl/the-trainwreck-of-all-trainwrecks-billions-of-people-stuck-with-a-broken-immune-response/

  87. @Ghost of Bull Moose
    @Jenner Ickham Errican


    Some worthy extra suggestions from yours truly:

    Tuesdays With Morrie Povich
    The Fat-Body Problem
    Harry Potter and the Haunted Loo
    Babar Gets Wrecked
    Golf and the Art of War
    The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Forensics
    How Uncanny Was My Valley (Lex Fridman, summer 2023)
     
    These are all good choices. I'd like to add:

    How to Be an Auntie Racist by Ex Ibram Kendi
    Do The First Thing That Pops Into Your Head by Malcolm Gladwell
    My Lovely White Teef Bones
    This Land is Our Land, Now Get Out Whitey: An Immigrant's Eviction Notice by Suketu Mehta
    Golf Course Design: Fascinating! by Steve Sailer

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Golf Course Design: Fascinating! by Steve Sailer

    I’ll buy that one for the coffee table, but I may skip the rest. Too busy!

  88. @Stan Adams
    @Bill Jones

    I saw this billboard today:
    https://media.nbcmiami.com/2022/12/Miami.Okeechobee-e1671204353387.jpg

    The bitchy, snippy tone doesn't inspire much sympathy. It conjures up an image of a Karen Kohen type wagging her finger in your face: "Three of my grandparents died at Auschwitz, so don't call me a stuck-up bitch!"

    Replies: @Veteran Aryan, @Beavertales

    Why were these billboards popping up in American and Canadian cities in 2022, and who is bankrolling them?

  89. @Twinkie

    The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.
     
    Dog racist!

    Since you have a dog now (purportedly a Jindo-mix) and seem to be into dogs, might I recommend this?

    https://youtu.be/TIl2o1hm1F4

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar, @Jenner Ickham Errican

    might I recommend this?

    Nice. I’ve read about Hachi in Hachette Filipacchi (Smelle magazine).

  90. @New Dealer
    Kohberg, alleged killer of four Idaho college students, was a registered Libertarian.

    https://aynrand.no/did-ayn-rand-admire-killer-william-hickman/
    Ayn Rand on her idealized killer:

    «[The boy in my story is] very far from him, of course. The outside of Hickman, but not the inside. Much deeper and much more. A Hickman with a purpose. And without the degeneracy. It is more exact to say that the model is not Hickman, but what Hickman suggested to me.» (p. 22)

    «[the reaction to] this case is not a moral indignation at a terrible crime. It is the mob’s murderous desire to revenge its hurt vanity against a man who dared to be alone. It is a case of ‘we’ against ‘him.’» (p. 37)

    «Yes, he is a monster – now. But the worse he is, the worst must be the cause that drove him to this. Isn’t it significant that a society was not able to fill the life of an exceptional, intelligent boy, to give him anything to out-balance crime in his eyes? If society is horrified at his crime, it should be horrified at the crime’s ultimate cause: itself. The worse the crime – the greater its guilt. What could society answer, if that boy were to say: ‘Yes, I’m a monstrous criminal, but what are you?’

    «This is what I think of the case. I am afraid that I idealize Hickman and that he might not be this at all. In fact, he probably isn’t. But it does not make any difference. If he isn’t, he could be, and that’s enough. The reaction of society would be the same, if not worse, toward the Hickman I have in mind. The case showed me how society can wreck an exceptional being, and then murder him for being the wreck that it itself has created. This will be the story of the boy in my book.» (p. 38)

    «[The] claim that Hickman’s greatest crime is his anti-socialness confirmed my idea of the public’s attitude in this case – and explains my involuntary, irresistible sympathy for him, which I cannot help feeling just because of this and in spite of everything else.» (p. 42)
     

    Replies: @prosa123, @Reg Cæsar

    Kohberg, alleged killer of four Idaho college students, was a registered Libertarian.

    Murder would seem to violate the non-aggression principle. Perhaps he’s an anarchocapitalist, who flunked his business courses.

    • Replies: @New Dealer
    @Reg Cæsar

    Or he's a Chicago economist who reckons that the victims could have paid him to refrain from the massacre. /s

    , @J.Ross
    @Reg Cæsar

    He may be totally innocent but a lot has already come out suggesting he was studying crime with perfection and not prevention in mind. He may have felt that "country club" resentment: a call to a local podcast claimed to be him goes out of its way to plant the idea that the killing was a frat hazing gone wrong, because after all fratboys are bad. There's a Daily Mail story claiming he did some big talk short of confessing while in jail.
    But his car was one of the first things noticed and discussed when bits of information became available. If he was a Stayvon attempting a perfect crime and then gets caught because he used his own car, he's probably going to be mad.

    Replies: @HammerJack

  91. OT & Too Soon?

    A Jeremiad of Dunces

    Rumor has it that Jeremy Renner* turned down the role later filled by Channing Tatum in The Dog so that he (Jeremy) could star in the upcoming “Snow Pierce” Plowman. When asked by a reporter, who had somehow gotten to his hospital bedside, if he had made a career mistake, the delirious and heavily medicated actor gasped, “You’re a lying, dog-faced pony soldier!”

    [MORE]

    * “The Yiddish surname Renner is based on the German Renner, which means ‘runner/messenger.’ Another German Jewish surname with the same meaning is Laufer.” Jeremy Renner is not Jewish, but I’ll buy the rest of the above and assume that “Laufman” rhymes with “Kaufman.” A World War I folk etymology from the 24th Century asserts a similar definition for “Hitler.”

    Also see: Jeremy Irons will star in a sequel as an aged and rusty Ferrous Bueller

    See also: In celebration of the purported effects of an estimated 5% component of Sub-Saharan ancestry in Ashkenazi Jews, Jack D. will be writing a biography of the indicted “horndog” Ron “Unz” Jeremy

    • Replies: @duncsbaby
    @reactionry

    He is the oldest of seven siblings, the youngest of whom was born in 2011, which made him a new big brother at 40 years old. His mother has Irish ancestry. Renner is also of German descent.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeremy_Renner

  92. @J.Ross
    @PhysicistDave

    Interesting, but almost no one predicted a comic book level of evil in the form of a war lobby that literally works continually to neutralize the will of the people and start unnecessary wars, let alone one that jumps parties when convenient. Voting cannot remove the unelected.

    Replies: @PhysicistDave

    J.Ross wrote to me:

    Interesting, but almost no one predicted a comic book level of evil in the form of a war lobby that literally works continually to neutralize the will of the people and start unnecessary wars…

    Well, of course, Orwelll actually did predict that in 1984:

    “Oceania has always been at war with Eastasia.”

    And yet most people who have read 1984 have just chucked that into the memory hole: they remember the surveillance state, the falsification of history, etc., but they forget that one of the major themes of the novel is the use of perpetual war as a means of controlling the populace.

    And of course that very ability to forget one of the central themes of 1984 actually validates the central message of 1984, doesn’t it?

    Any chance we could ever get Corvinus, Jack D, HAsbara, et al. to grasp this?

    At all?

    • Replies: @J.Ross
    @PhysicistDave

    Sort of, but Stalinists and neocons have different motives and work differently.

  93. Anonymous[954] • Disclaimer says:
    @Pat Hannagan
    The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.

    You have zero idea how aspergers you come across with that "observation" do you?

    I'm not criticising just observing.

    This movie sounds typically pro-war, destroy your family for the Bush and Clinton family biennial worship of Moloch and Davos Man, doesn't anyone know about Hitler and Ann Frank and the shoa, here's a dog to identify with as we subliminally urge you on to slaughter The Other!

    Btw, did you know that to be a Tunnel Rat in Vietnam you had to be below 6 foot in height?

    I wonder how many of them "Ann" Coulter would deign fuck if he would be so moved.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2-jGAVT-Elk

    I haven't seen it yet but I will see The Banshees of Inisherin

    Replies: @AKAHorace, @Anon, @SunBakedSuburb, @Anonymous, @Recently Based, @Decoy

    “The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.”

    You have zero idea how aspergers you come across with that “observation” do you?

    I’m not criticising just observing.

    You have zero idea of how the movie business works when criticizing Steve’s rather astute observation, don’t you?

    First, I’ve been in the movie business. Dogs with dark fur are generally not considered whatsoever because of they are a pain in the ass to light. Audiences, as Steve noticed of his own accord, like to see a dog’s face.

    Second, I was asked more than once to consider auditioning my own dog, a dark-haired mid-sized “Benji” type, as the casting person noticed she was very bright and wonderfully tempered, but only if I’d consider dying her hair a lighter shade, for the reason stated above.

    I always declined. Didn’t want to put her through it, and I didn’t want to deal.

    Dark-haired dogs can get cast, but it’s the exception, not the rule.

    Finally, I noticed in a few key scenes in that movie, they lit the shit out of that dog. Particularly one of the last shots of the two out on the cliff out over the ocean. A couple of shots were even overexposed—to light up the dog for the ending, doing it in such a way that it looked “artistic,” but the technical intent was to light that dog up.

    They had a very good cinematographer, who had his hands full with that dog, and did a great job.

    And finally… shut the fuck up.

    • Thanks: Harry Baldwin
    • Replies: @Greta Handel
    @Anonymous

    You seem pretty upset by someone focusing on your life’s work.

    Without stepping in any more of the dog doo, can you refute Pat Hannagan’s comment?

    Replies: @Anonymous

  94. @Reg Cæsar
    @New Dealer


    Kohberg, alleged killer of four Idaho college students, was a registered Libertarian.
     
    Murder would seem to violate the non-aggression principle. Perhaps he's an anarchocapitalist, who flunked his business courses.

    Replies: @New Dealer, @J.Ross

    Or he’s a Chicago economist who reckons that the victims could have paid him to refrain from the massacre. /s

  95. @Ralph L
    @PhysicistDave

    Didn't every Boomer and later HS kid in the US read 1984 and The Great Gatsby? I mean, the ones that could read. Have they been dropped from the curriculum to make room for Toni Morrison and T'Sneezy Coates?

    Replies: @John1955, @Mark G.

    Didn’t every Boomer and later HS kid in the US read 1984 and The Great Gatsby? I mean, the ones that could read.

    1984 really had an impact on me when I read it as a sixteen-year-old. It involved a man who lived in a society where he was constantly watched, there seemed no chance of escape, and he was not treated as an individual. I identified with that character because that is how I felt in my large public school. For the same reason I had earlier identified with the main character in the sixties tv series The Prisoner.

    I hated school and would daydream about running off and living in the woods like in my favorite childhood novel My Side of the Mountain, about a boy who does so after reading Thoreau. I happened to live across the road from a huge, wooded area covering several hundred acres and would spend hours roaming it with my collie dog and those were the happiest hours of my childhood. People often say Atlas Shrugged turns people into libertarians but my exposure to these early influences combined with my hatred of government schools did it for me before I even discovered Ayn Rand.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Mark G.

    My Side of the Mountain

    I'm wondering whether I read "Where the Red Fern Grows" or "My Side of the Mountain."

    , @HammerJack
    @Mark G.


    I happened to live across the road from a huge, wooded area covering several hundred acres and would spend hours roaming it with my collie dog and those were the happiest hours of my childhood.
     
    That actually sounds pretty wonderful, and I congratulate you for finding that respite.
    , @Twinkie
    @Mark G.


    the sixties tv series The Prisoner.
     
    I liked that show a lot when I was a teen, but, as an adult, found it hollow - all atmosphere and no substance.
  96. @MEH 0910
    @Bill P


    As for dog fiction, I’m currently reading Where the Red Fern Grows — with my 8yo.
     
    Lex Fridman is considering adding that one to his reading list:

    https://lexfridman.com/reading-list/

    Here’s some other suggestions I’m considering. Others are welcome:
     

    • The Dead by James Joyce
    • The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman
    • Ward No. 6 by Anton Chekhov
    • Anthem by Ayn Rand
    • The Book of Five Rings by Miyamoto Musashi
    • The Four Agreements by Don Miguel Ruiz
    • Nightfall, Last Question by Isaac Asimov
    • The Little Trilogy by Anton Chekhov
    • The Nose, The Overcoat by Gogol
    • Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad
    • Notes from Underground by Dostoevsky
    • The Giver by Lois Lowry
    • The Prince by Machiavelli
    • Disgrace by J. M. Coetzee
    • Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury
    • The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho
    • The Road by Cormac McCarthy
    • Where the Red Fern Grows by Wilson Rawls
    • A Good Man Is Hard to Find by Flannery O’Connor
    Beyond Good and Evil by Friedrich Nietzsche
    • On Writing by Stephen King
    • Solaris by Stanislaw Lem
    • Childhood’s End by Arthur C Clarke
    • Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K Dick
    • Flowers for Algernon by Daniel Keyes
    • I, Robot by Isaac Asimov
    • The Diary of a Young Girl by Anne Frank
    • Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov
    • Ender’s Game by Orson Scott Card
    • Surely You’re Joking, Mr. Feynman by Richard Feynman
    • Dead Souls by Gogol
    • 12 Rules for Life by Jordan Peterson
    • Snow Crash by Neal Stephenson
    • The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress by Robert Heinlein
    • Three-Body Problem by Cixin Liu
    • Stranger in a Strange Land by Robert Heinlein
    • Godel, Escher, Bach by Douglas R. Hofstadter
    • The Idiot by Dostoevsky
     

    Replies: @MGB, @duncsbaby, @J.Ross

    Where’s my fave?

    • Replies: @Ray P
    @duncsbaby

    Wolf yodels are now illegal in the U.K.

  97. @Mark G.
    @Ralph L


    Didn’t every Boomer and later HS kid in the US read 1984 and The Great Gatsby? I mean, the ones that could read.
     
    1984 really had an impact on me when I read it as a sixteen-year-old. It involved a man who lived in a society where he was constantly watched, there seemed no chance of escape, and he was not treated as an individual. I identified with that character because that is how I felt in my large public school. For the same reason I had earlier identified with the main character in the sixties tv series The Prisoner.


    I hated school and would daydream about running off and living in the woods like in my favorite childhood novel My Side of the Mountain, about a boy who does so after reading Thoreau. I happened to live across the road from a huge, wooded area covering several hundred acres and would spend hours roaming it with my collie dog and those were the happiest hours of my childhood. People often say Atlas Shrugged turns people into libertarians but my exposure to these early influences combined with my hatred of government schools did it for me before I even discovered Ayn Rand.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @HammerJack, @Twinkie

    My Side of the Mountain

    I’m wondering whether I read “Where the Red Fern Grows” or “My Side of the Mountain.”

  98. @Pat Hannagan
    The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.

    You have zero idea how aspergers you come across with that "observation" do you?

    I'm not criticising just observing.

    This movie sounds typically pro-war, destroy your family for the Bush and Clinton family biennial worship of Moloch and Davos Man, doesn't anyone know about Hitler and Ann Frank and the shoa, here's a dog to identify with as we subliminally urge you on to slaughter The Other!

    Btw, did you know that to be a Tunnel Rat in Vietnam you had to be below 6 foot in height?

    I wonder how many of them "Ann" Coulter would deign fuck if he would be so moved.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2-jGAVT-Elk

    I haven't seen it yet but I will see The Banshees of Inisherin

    Replies: @AKAHorace, @Anon, @SunBakedSuburb, @Anonymous, @Recently Based, @Decoy

    You have zero idea how aspergers you come across with that “observation” do you?

    I’m not criticising just observing.

    WTF? What do you think a a criticism is?

  99. @PhysicistDave
    @J.Ross

    J.Ross wrote to me:


    Interesting, but almost no one predicted a comic book level of evil in the form of a war lobby that literally works continually to neutralize the will of the people and start unnecessary wars...
     
    Well, of course, Orwelll actually did predict that in 1984:

    "Oceania has always been at war with Eastasia."
     
    And yet most people who have read 1984 have just chucked that into the memory hole: they remember the surveillance state, the falsification of history, etc., but they forget that one of the major themes of the novel is the use of perpetual war as a means of controlling the populace.

    And of course that very ability to forget one of the central themes of 1984 actually validates the central message of 1984, doesn't it?

    Any chance we could ever get Corvinus, Jack D, HAsbara, et al. to grasp this?

    At all?

    Replies: @J.Ross

    Sort of, but Stalinists and neocons have different motives and work differently.

  100. @MEH 0910
    @Bill P


    As for dog fiction, I’m currently reading Where the Red Fern Grows — with my 8yo.
     
    Lex Fridman is considering adding that one to his reading list:

    https://lexfridman.com/reading-list/

    Here’s some other suggestions I’m considering. Others are welcome:
     

    • The Dead by James Joyce
    • The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman
    • Ward No. 6 by Anton Chekhov
    • Anthem by Ayn Rand
    • The Book of Five Rings by Miyamoto Musashi
    • The Four Agreements by Don Miguel Ruiz
    • Nightfall, Last Question by Isaac Asimov
    • The Little Trilogy by Anton Chekhov
    • The Nose, The Overcoat by Gogol
    • Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad
    • Notes from Underground by Dostoevsky
    • The Giver by Lois Lowry
    • The Prince by Machiavelli
    • Disgrace by J. M. Coetzee
    • Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury
    • The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho
    • The Road by Cormac McCarthy
    • Where the Red Fern Grows by Wilson Rawls
    • A Good Man Is Hard to Find by Flannery O’Connor
    Beyond Good and Evil by Friedrich Nietzsche
    • On Writing by Stephen King
    • Solaris by Stanislaw Lem
    • Childhood’s End by Arthur C Clarke
    • Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K Dick
    • Flowers for Algernon by Daniel Keyes
    • I, Robot by Isaac Asimov
    • The Diary of a Young Girl by Anne Frank
    • Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov
    • Ender’s Game by Orson Scott Card
    • Surely You’re Joking, Mr. Feynman by Richard Feynman
    • Dead Souls by Gogol
    • 12 Rules for Life by Jordan Peterson
    • Snow Crash by Neal Stephenson
    • The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress by Robert Heinlein
    • Three-Body Problem by Cixin Liu
    • Stranger in a Strange Land by Robert Heinlein
    • Godel, Escher, Bach by Douglas R. Hofstadter
    • The Idiot by Dostoevsky
     

    Replies: @MGB, @duncsbaby, @J.Ross

    The Nose and The Overcoat are each short stories (presumably this is an anthology?). The Giver is literally a children’s or young adult book. The Four Questions by Ruiz is self-help twaddle, a hair better than Deepak Chopra. And — On Writing By Stephen King? Ha ha ha ha, very amusing, now please face the wall.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @J.Ross

    I read "On Writing" by Stephen King. It's a good self-help book for writers by a guy who has made more money writing than just about any other American writer.

    Replies: @J.Ross

  101. @Reg Cæsar
    @New Dealer


    Kohberg, alleged killer of four Idaho college students, was a registered Libertarian.
     
    Murder would seem to violate the non-aggression principle. Perhaps he's an anarchocapitalist, who flunked his business courses.

    Replies: @New Dealer, @J.Ross

    He may be totally innocent but a lot has already come out suggesting he was studying crime with perfection and not prevention in mind. He may have felt that “country club” resentment: a call to a local podcast claimed to be him goes out of its way to plant the idea that the killing was a frat hazing gone wrong, because after all fratboys are bad. There’s a Daily Mail story claiming he did some big talk short of confessing while in jail.
    But his car was one of the first things noticed and discussed when bits of information became available. If he was a Stayvon attempting a perfect crime and then gets caught because he used his own car, he’s probably going to be mad.

    • Replies: @HammerJack
    @J.Ross

    Good point about the car. I'm still mystified by the whole story. What was he doing and why? Why did he choose those victims?

    How and why did he execute his plan in a place and time where he stood a very good chance of discovery? He could hardly have planned for the others in the house not to notice.

    How did he even manage to kill four people without anyone making appreciable noise?

    Replies: @J.Ross, @Reg Cæsar

  102. @J.Ross
    @MEH 0910

    The Nose and The Overcoat are each short stories (presumably this is an anthology?). The Giver is literally a children's or young adult book. The Four Questions by Ruiz is self-help twaddle, a hair better than Deepak Chopra. And -- On Writing By Stephen King? Ha ha ha ha, very amusing, now please face the wall.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    I read “On Writing” by Stephen King. It’s a good self-help book for writers by a guy who has made more money writing than just about any other American writer.

    • Replies: @J.Ross
    @Steve Sailer

    Steves stick together.
    >make money
    Oh that's right, you don't want your writing to result in the extrajudicial death of unelected bureaucrats.

  103. @duncsbaby
    @MEH 0910

    Where's my fave?

    https://storage.googleapis.com/hipcomic/p/2795191c422db7cda93549305be30e08.jpg

    Replies: @Ray P

    Wolf yodels are now illegal in the U.K.

  104. @Anonymous
    @Pat Hannagan


    "The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera."

    You have zero idea how aspergers you come across with that “observation” do you?

    I’m not criticising just observing.
     

    You have zero idea of how the movie business works when criticizing Steve’s rather astute observation, don't you?

    First, I’ve been in the movie business. Dogs with dark fur are generally not considered whatsoever because of they are a pain in the ass to light. Audiences, as Steve noticed of his own accord, like to see a dog's face.

    Second, I was asked more than once to consider auditioning my own dog, a dark-haired mid-sized "Benji" type, as the casting person noticed she was very bright and wonderfully tempered, but only if I’d consider dying her hair a lighter shade, for the reason stated above.

    I always declined. Didn’t want to put her through it, and I didn’t want to deal.

    Dark-haired dogs can get cast, but it’s the exception, not the rule.

    Finally, I noticed in a few key scenes in that movie, they lit the shit out of that dog. Particularly one of the last shots of the two out on the cliff out over the ocean. A couple of shots were even overexposed—to light up the dog for the ending, doing it in such a way that it looked "artistic," but the technical intent was to light that dog up.

    They had a very good cinematographer, who had his hands full with that dog, and did a great job.

    And finally… shut the fuck up.

    Replies: @Greta Handel

    You seem pretty upset by someone focusing on your life’s work.

    Without stepping in any more of the dog doo, can you refute Pat Hannagan’s comment?

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    @Greta Handel


    You seem pretty upset by someone focusing on your life’s work.

    Without stepping in any more of the dog doo, can you refute Pat Hannagan’s comment?
     

    I’m not upset at all, Pat.

    It’s what I’d cheerfully say to you at Denny's as I chowed on my "Hammy Slammy."

    Btw, I refuted your comment quite nicely. You claimed Steve’s observation about dark-faced dogs was Asperger's induced, and I told you why you might be an ignorant twit, since anyone who knows about filming dark-faced dogs know it’s a pain in the ass, since you have to deal with it for every scene the dog is in, limiting your cinematic choices.

    It’s like willfully adding another 100 problems to your SAT, without getting extra credit for it. Unless it involves a creative choice, cinematographers like their jobs to be easier, not harder. That’s why they don’t ask for dark-faced dogs in a dog movie. It limits their lenses, their lighting, their blocking out the scene. Unless there’s a damned good reason, they logically, practically, don’t want it.

    That is, when Lulu is lit well, Tatum's face will get blown out. When Tatum is lit perfectly, Lulu looks like she’s guarding the gates of hell. In the context of that movie, the cinematographer used that problem creatively, because Lulu was, at times, a hell dog.

    But you'll notice at the end of the movie, it was "fuck Tatum, let’s light that bitch up good," and they did, which worked perfectly. Beautiful redemption shots at the end. Beautiful, well lit Lulu. Sorry, Tatum.

    Lit creatively, and well.

    So… again… shut up, Pat.

    And pass the syrup.

    Replies: @Greta Handel

  105. @Mark G.
    @Ralph L


    Didn’t every Boomer and later HS kid in the US read 1984 and The Great Gatsby? I mean, the ones that could read.
     
    1984 really had an impact on me when I read it as a sixteen-year-old. It involved a man who lived in a society where he was constantly watched, there seemed no chance of escape, and he was not treated as an individual. I identified with that character because that is how I felt in my large public school. For the same reason I had earlier identified with the main character in the sixties tv series The Prisoner.


    I hated school and would daydream about running off and living in the woods like in my favorite childhood novel My Side of the Mountain, about a boy who does so after reading Thoreau. I happened to live across the road from a huge, wooded area covering several hundred acres and would spend hours roaming it with my collie dog and those were the happiest hours of my childhood. People often say Atlas Shrugged turns people into libertarians but my exposure to these early influences combined with my hatred of government schools did it for me before I even discovered Ayn Rand.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @HammerJack, @Twinkie

    I happened to live across the road from a huge, wooded area covering several hundred acres and would spend hours roaming it with my collie dog and those were the happiest hours of my childhood.

    That actually sounds pretty wonderful, and I congratulate you for finding that respite.

  106. @J.Ross
    @Reg Cæsar

    He may be totally innocent but a lot has already come out suggesting he was studying crime with perfection and not prevention in mind. He may have felt that "country club" resentment: a call to a local podcast claimed to be him goes out of its way to plant the idea that the killing was a frat hazing gone wrong, because after all fratboys are bad. There's a Daily Mail story claiming he did some big talk short of confessing while in jail.
    But his car was one of the first things noticed and discussed when bits of information became available. If he was a Stayvon attempting a perfect crime and then gets caught because he used his own car, he's probably going to be mad.

    Replies: @HammerJack

    Good point about the car. I’m still mystified by the whole story. What was he doing and why? Why did he choose those victims?

    How and why did he execute his plan in a place and time where he stood a very good chance of discovery? He could hardly have planned for the others in the house not to notice.

    How did he even manage to kill four people without anyone making appreciable noise?

    • Replies: @J.Ross
    @HammerJack

    The story thus far, could be completely false:
    'E's mental, innit?
    He studies criminals, to learn about himself.
    He visits an Idaho restaurant.
    An aside from 4channers: I went to school at U of I and those women are completely mindblowing.
    Also: Mormon women are gorgeous when they're young.
    But then: Ick!
    And: I'll show you, bitch!
    But this could be wrong and he might be innocent.
    (but how without any noise
    [glug glug].)

    , @Reg Cæsar
    @HammerJack


    How did he even manage to kill four people without anyone making appreciable noise?
     
    Depends on how you do it. Hannah Duston and Mary Neff were shown by an abducted English boy who, on the surface, had "gone native" how the Indians killed groups of people in their sleep without waking anybody. They did just this, and escaped.

    The murder-suicide of a student and her Canadian hockey player boyfriend in their sleep by her jealous ex at Geneseo State a few years ago was accomplished in a similar way. There are a lot of Indians in Western New York; one wonders where he learned the trick.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hannah_Duston

    Replies: @Bill P, @Jim Don Bob

  107. @neutral
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    I wonder why Lex Fridman is being pushed so much, I am completely stumped, his early life section has nothing remarkable. I suppose it will remain a mystery.

    Replies: @SunBakedSuburb, @Telimektar

    A guy on Youtube calculated that this Friedman’s guy political guest were 70% Jewish, they were also overrepresented quite a lot in other categories but not nearly has much. Joe Rogan had 42% Jewish political guests. It’s really nice to have a broad perspectives on the world isn’t it, no nepotism involved whatsoever….

  108. @HammerJack
    @J.Ross

    Good point about the car. I'm still mystified by the whole story. What was he doing and why? Why did he choose those victims?

    How and why did he execute his plan in a place and time where he stood a very good chance of discovery? He could hardly have planned for the others in the house not to notice.

    How did he even manage to kill four people without anyone making appreciable noise?

    Replies: @J.Ross, @Reg Cæsar

    The story thus far, could be completely false:
    ‘E’s mental, innit?
    He studies criminals, to learn about himself.
    He visits an Idaho restaurant.
    An aside from 4channers: I went to school at U of I and those women are completely mindblowing.
    Also: Mormon women are gorgeous when they’re young.
    But then: Ick!
    And: I’ll show you, bitch!
    But this could be wrong and he might be innocent.
    (but how without any noise
    [glug glug].)

  109. @Steve Sailer
    @J.Ross

    I read "On Writing" by Stephen King. It's a good self-help book for writers by a guy who has made more money writing than just about any other American writer.

    Replies: @J.Ross

    Steves stick together.
    >make money
    Oh that’s right, you don’t want your writing to result in the extrajudicial death of unelected bureaucrats.

  110. @Barbarossa
    @BB753

    My wife grabbed Harari's "Sapiens" from the library for the kids to check out. She thought it looked like a neat "sciency" read.

    Fortunately, I saw it, recognized Harari's name and decided that I'd better take a read thorough myself to vet it. It's a very well put together work with a lot of pretty good material. There are quite a number of points that I agreed with wholeheartedly.

    He approaches the norms and sacred cows of all historical periods with a detached irreverence...until he gets to the Woke dogma of the present day. Then it's all transgenders this and George Floyd that, blah blah blah. It's a slick piece of propaganda if you want your kids to be told how ignorant everyone was "back then" and how enlightened our attitudes are now. The first volume wasn't bad but the last part of the second volume was pure poison, the effect of which is made worse by how slickly packaged and authoritative the work appears up that point.

    Needless to say, I made my wife aware of what they really were and she packed them right back off to the library.

    The takeaway is that you have to vet every damn thing these days!

    Replies: @RSDB

    E. Michael Jones has an interesting discussion of Sapiens which he published as a booklet, I think, and which sets up his own foray into metahistory in Logos Rising. As usual with Jones I recall thinking the critique was a bit too personal at times, but he does make some interesting points about the assumptions, sometimes contradictory ones, which get smuggled into a book like Sapiens.

    I think the booklet had the rather unfortunate title of Jewish Fables, but that’s Jones for you.

    Harari is probably a good historian and he has a knack for bold pronouncements but he seems to have very little philosophical acumen and tends not to think through his own statements with any particular care.

    • Replies: @Barbarossa
    @RSDB

    Yeah, I agree that Harari is a decent historian and seemingly a smart guy. Overall, I really kind of wanted to like Sapiens. It's very well presented and very authoritative sounding. Also, the graphic novel format (and visual formats in general) tend to blunt the critical faculty of the reader which makes it that much easier to make a dubious point flow seamlessly.

    Even as a critical reader I could feel a certain emotional pull to the arc that Harari wanted to put forward, which is why I found it to be a particularly disturbing piece of propaganda. I don't mind if my kids are exposed to a certain amount of Woke arguments, especially when they can be put in context and the logical flaws exposed. I think of it a bit like a philosophical immune system; it needs to exercised or kids will be wholly unprepared for the cultural onslaught.

    Again though, as a critical reader I found Harari's didactic gushing tone as he fawned over current Woke norms to be quite cringe-worthy, jarring, and out of place with the rest of the books' tone of wry detachment deployed when dissecting any other era's sacred cows.

    I'll check out E. Michael Jones critique of Sapiens, so thanks for mentioning it.

    Replies: @RSDB

  111. @Reg Cæsar
    @Twinkie


    Dog racist!
     
    Dog = God.

    Replies: @Joe Stalin

    Dog = God.

    White God (2015).

  112. @Pat Hannagan
    The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.

    You have zero idea how aspergers you come across with that "observation" do you?

    I'm not criticising just observing.

    This movie sounds typically pro-war, destroy your family for the Bush and Clinton family biennial worship of Moloch and Davos Man, doesn't anyone know about Hitler and Ann Frank and the shoa, here's a dog to identify with as we subliminally urge you on to slaughter The Other!

    Btw, did you know that to be a Tunnel Rat in Vietnam you had to be below 6 foot in height?

    I wonder how many of them "Ann" Coulter would deign fuck if he would be so moved.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2-jGAVT-Elk

    I haven't seen it yet but I will see The Banshees of Inisherin

    Replies: @AKAHorace, @Anon, @SunBakedSuburb, @Anonymous, @Recently Based, @Decoy

    I encourage people to look into The Banshees of Inisherin. Wonderful all around: acting, writing, cinematography. A bit dark in the 2nd half so not for everyone.

  113. @The Wild Geese Howard
    @HammerJack


    Please consider a shelter.
     
    I don't disagree, but in some areas it can be remarkably difficult to find a shelter with a number of pups that lack any ancestry from the bully breeds.

    Replies: @Anonymous, @Inverness

    Females with minor admixture generally have no problem passing the shelters’ aggression tests.

    And shelters are generally very strict about this, because they will get sued.

    • Thanks: The Wild Geese Howard
  114. @AnotherDad


    The one shortcoming of the movie is that Belgian Malinois dogs have fairly dark faces and dark eyes, so they aren’t all that charismatic on camera.
     
    I'm basically uninterested in the dog. It is after all, a dog. I saw "The Incredible Journey" as a kid. I think that has me covered. A few years later I saw some movie that was about a woman's love affair with a lion. It was nice. (Spoiler: they went their separate speciesist ways in the end. "Separation" the best policy.) But I think I'd rather see movies about people. That said, I can live with the unphotogenic dog if necessary to see a good movie.

    The question for all movies these days is whether they have annoying jammed superfluous/discordant/anachronistic/annoying blacks into it rendering it--whatever its other merits--unwatchable.

    Replies: @Colin Wright

    ‘…The question for all movies these days is whether they have annoying jammed superfluous/discordant/anachronistic/annoying blacks into it rendering it–whatever its other merits–unwatchable.’

    Past the inevitable token, if there’re blacks in it, I won’t watch it.

    Post-Summer of George, it’s a matter of principle. They started a race war, and I’d no more watch a movie with blacks in it now than I would check out Goebbel’s latest offering if it were 1943.

    Seriously. My daughter recommended the recent remake of Dune. My first — and only — question was ‘Are the Fremen black?’

    ‘Yes.’ Then I won’t watch it. Ten years ago — sure. Now? No.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @Colin Wright

    Javier Bardem is black?

  115. Anonymous[954] • Disclaimer says:
    @Greta Handel
    @Anonymous

    You seem pretty upset by someone focusing on your life’s work.

    Without stepping in any more of the dog doo, can you refute Pat Hannagan’s comment?

    Replies: @Anonymous

    You seem pretty upset by someone focusing on your life’s work.

    Without stepping in any more of the dog doo, can you refute Pat Hannagan’s comment?

    I’m not upset at all, Pat.

    It’s what I’d cheerfully say to you at Denny’s as I chowed on my “Hammy Slammy.”

    Btw, I refuted your comment quite nicely. You claimed Steve’s observation about dark-faced dogs was Asperger’s induced, and I told you why you might be an ignorant twit, since anyone who knows about filming dark-faced dogs know it’s a pain in the ass, since you have to deal with it for every scene the dog is in, limiting your cinematic choices.

    It’s like willfully adding another 100 problems to your SAT, without getting extra credit for it. Unless it involves a creative choice, cinematographers like their jobs to be easier, not harder. That’s why they don’t ask for dark-faced dogs in a dog movie. It limits their lenses, their lighting, their blocking out the scene. Unless there’s a damned good reason, they logically, practically, don’t want it.

    That is, when Lulu is lit well, Tatum’s face will get blown out. When Tatum is lit perfectly, Lulu looks like she’s guarding the gates of hell. In the context of that movie, the cinematographer used that problem creatively, because Lulu was, at times, a hell dog.

    But you’ll notice at the end of the movie, it was “fuck Tatum, let’s light that bitch up good,” and they did, which worked perfectly. Beautiful redemption shots at the end. Beautiful, well lit Lulu. Sorry, Tatum.

    Lit creatively, and well.

    So… again… shut up, Pat.

    And pass the syrup.

    • Replies: @Greta Handel
    @Anonymous

    Apparently not.

  116. @AnotherDad

    Tatum needs his former commanding officer to sign off on his job application for a high paying Blackwater-type mercenary job, but the officer doubts that Tatum’s brain has recovered.
     
    Back in the day, if you wanted a federal job, the civil service gave you a test. (I used it a couple of times for summer jobs and an internship at NASA after graduation.) Then there was a 5 pt, "veteran's preference" and a 10 pt. "disabled veteran's preference" that could be tacked on top.

    I have some foggy memory that some whiny XX bureaucrat decided it was unfair that veterans were getting a leg up over her because of their military service which was overwhelmingly male. And sued for sex discrimination and ... heck if I know what happened after that. So no idea how it works now.

    But under that system, this pretty much guaranteed that any disabled veteran who hadn't been reduced to vegetable could find some sort of federal employment doing something within his capability.

    Of course, even better ... not having stupid wars that kill/maim good young men.

    Replies: @Jim Don Bob

    The federal civil service test was ruled racist in the Carter administration, and no one ever bothered to even try to create a new one that would pass judicial scrutiny. NYC spent years and mucho dinero trying to come up with a fire fighter’s promotion test where the results are (hint hint) “equitable”.

  117. @HammerJack
    @J.Ross

    Good point about the car. I'm still mystified by the whole story. What was he doing and why? Why did he choose those victims?

    How and why did he execute his plan in a place and time where he stood a very good chance of discovery? He could hardly have planned for the others in the house not to notice.

    How did he even manage to kill four people without anyone making appreciable noise?

    Replies: @J.Ross, @Reg Cæsar

    How did he even manage to kill four people without anyone making appreciable noise?

    Depends on how you do it. Hannah Duston and Mary Neff were shown by an abducted English boy who, on the surface, had “gone native” how the Indians killed groups of people in their sleep without waking anybody. They did just this, and escaped.

    The murder-suicide of a student and her Canadian hockey player boyfriend in their sleep by her jealous ex at Geneseo State a few years ago was accomplished in a similar way. There are a lot of Indians in Western New York; one wonders where he learned the trick.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hannah_Duston

    • Replies: @Bill P
    @Reg Cæsar

    Apparently he killed two girls who were sleeping alone, then he came upon the couple and killed the male (Ethan Chapin) first. The only one who fought back was Ethan Chapin's girlfriend, who probably woke up as her boyfriend was being slaughtered.

    Heavy blades can do a lot of damage quickly. Just the other day I cut clear through my own skin in a cooking slip-up that involved little force. A sharp, long blade with some force behind it goes through flesh before you know it -- that's why I'm usually pretty careful when cutting up an animal. You can cut too far too fast and ruin your cuts if you don't take it easy.

    It's totally gruesome to think of doing this to innocent young people, but alas it isn't so (physically) hard to do. Blades are extremely effective.

    Ethan Chapin came from Skagit County, just a half hour down I-5 from me. A few years ago I'd thought about moving to Moscow, ID myself. He has two surviving triplet siblings. It really baffles to try to wrap one's mind around this crime, but the idea of "broken soul" comes to my mind. How could someone butcher people like that? Only someone who has rejected and lost his own humanity.

    Replies: @Twinkie, @prosa123

    , @Jim Don Bob
    @Reg Cæsar

    You only have to hit someone in the head once if you use a hatchet.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar

  118. @Reg Cæsar
    @HammerJack


    How did he even manage to kill four people without anyone making appreciable noise?
     
    Depends on how you do it. Hannah Duston and Mary Neff were shown by an abducted English boy who, on the surface, had "gone native" how the Indians killed groups of people in their sleep without waking anybody. They did just this, and escaped.

    The murder-suicide of a student and her Canadian hockey player boyfriend in their sleep by her jealous ex at Geneseo State a few years ago was accomplished in a similar way. There are a lot of Indians in Western New York; one wonders where he learned the trick.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hannah_Duston

    Replies: @Bill P, @Jim Don Bob

    Apparently he killed two girls who were sleeping alone, then he came upon the couple and killed the male (Ethan Chapin) first. The only one who fought back was Ethan Chapin’s girlfriend, who probably woke up as her boyfriend was being slaughtered.

    Heavy blades can do a lot of damage quickly. Just the other day I cut clear through my own skin in a cooking slip-up that involved little force. A sharp, long blade with some force behind it goes through flesh before you know it — that’s why I’m usually pretty careful when cutting up an animal. You can cut too far too fast and ruin your cuts if you don’t take it easy.

    It’s totally gruesome to think of doing this to innocent young people, but alas it isn’t so (physically) hard to do. Blades are extremely effective.

    Ethan Chapin came from Skagit County, just a half hour down I-5 from me. A few years ago I’d thought about moving to Moscow, ID myself. He has two surviving triplet siblings. It really baffles to try to wrap one’s mind around this crime, but the idea of “broken soul” comes to my mind. How could someone butcher people like that? Only someone who has rejected and lost his own humanity.

    • Replies: @Twinkie
    @Bill P


    that’s why I’m usually pretty careful when cutting up an animal. You can cut too far too fast and ruin your cuts if you don’t take it easy.
     
    Don’t you put your index finger next to the blade when you get close to the lower organs?

    Blades are extremely effective.
     
    Within about 20 feet or so, someone wielding a blade is more dangerous than someone with a handgun. Blades can do a horrific amount of damage in a short time span, and it takes very little skill to do that damage.

    Replies: @Bill P

    , @prosa123
    @Bill P

    Apparently he killed two girls who were sleeping alone, then he came upon the couple and killed the male (Ethan Chapin) first. The only one who fought back was Ethan Chapin’s girlfriend, who probably woke up as her boyfriend was being slaughtered.

    It didn't help that Kaylee Goncalves and Maddie Mogen were clearly intoxicated in the food truck video.
    One theory is that Bryan Kohberger's targets were Maddie and Xana, with Kaylee and Ethan collateral damage. Maddie and Xana worked at the Mad Greek restaurant, one of the only restaurants in Pullman-Moscow which had vegan items on the menu. Kohberger is a vegan. It is possible that while patronizing the Mad Greek he got in a conversation with them and found out where they lived. They might have invited him to a party and given him the location, note that their house was a known party spot.
    What doesn't add up is that according to rumor, yes it's only rumor, some or possibly all of the victims were stabbed well beyond what would be sufficient to be fatal. In fact one of the girls, likely either Kaylee or Maddie, was nearly beheaded.

  119. @Mark G.
    @Ralph L


    Didn’t every Boomer and later HS kid in the US read 1984 and The Great Gatsby? I mean, the ones that could read.
     
    1984 really had an impact on me when I read it as a sixteen-year-old. It involved a man who lived in a society where he was constantly watched, there seemed no chance of escape, and he was not treated as an individual. I identified with that character because that is how I felt in my large public school. For the same reason I had earlier identified with the main character in the sixties tv series The Prisoner.


    I hated school and would daydream about running off and living in the woods like in my favorite childhood novel My Side of the Mountain, about a boy who does so after reading Thoreau. I happened to live across the road from a huge, wooded area covering several hundred acres and would spend hours roaming it with my collie dog and those were the happiest hours of my childhood. People often say Atlas Shrugged turns people into libertarians but my exposure to these early influences combined with my hatred of government schools did it for me before I even discovered Ayn Rand.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @HammerJack, @Twinkie

    the sixties tv series The Prisoner.

    I liked that show a lot when I was a teen, but, as an adult, found it hollow – all atmosphere and no substance.

  120. @Bill P
    @Reg Cæsar

    Apparently he killed two girls who were sleeping alone, then he came upon the couple and killed the male (Ethan Chapin) first. The only one who fought back was Ethan Chapin's girlfriend, who probably woke up as her boyfriend was being slaughtered.

    Heavy blades can do a lot of damage quickly. Just the other day I cut clear through my own skin in a cooking slip-up that involved little force. A sharp, long blade with some force behind it goes through flesh before you know it -- that's why I'm usually pretty careful when cutting up an animal. You can cut too far too fast and ruin your cuts if you don't take it easy.

    It's totally gruesome to think of doing this to innocent young people, but alas it isn't so (physically) hard to do. Blades are extremely effective.

    Ethan Chapin came from Skagit County, just a half hour down I-5 from me. A few years ago I'd thought about moving to Moscow, ID myself. He has two surviving triplet siblings. It really baffles to try to wrap one's mind around this crime, but the idea of "broken soul" comes to my mind. How could someone butcher people like that? Only someone who has rejected and lost his own humanity.

    Replies: @Twinkie, @prosa123

    that’s why I’m usually pretty careful when cutting up an animal. You can cut too far too fast and ruin your cuts if you don’t take it easy.

    Don’t you put your index finger next to the blade when you get close to the lower organs?

    Blades are extremely effective.

    Within about 20 feet or so, someone wielding a blade is more dangerous than someone with a handgun. Blades can do a horrific amount of damage in a short time span, and it takes very little skill to do that damage.

    • Replies: @Bill P
    @Twinkie


    Don’t you put your index finger next to the blade when you get close to the lower organs?
     
    Depends what I'm cutting. Usually yes, but I like using a flexible blade for boning, and sometimes you just grip the handle with that.

    Btw i cut myself by just being stupid and using a knife as a wedge. It wasn't even a very sharp or good knife, which is why I underestimated what it could do. If it had been one of my Japanese knives I couldn't have avoided the ER. Would have cut clear to the bone (I use fine Arkansas stones on my good knives).

    Replies: @Twinkie

  121. @RSDB
    @Barbarossa

    E. Michael Jones has an interesting discussion of Sapiens which he published as a booklet, I think, and which sets up his own foray into metahistory in Logos Rising. As usual with Jones I recall thinking the critique was a bit too personal at times, but he does make some interesting points about the assumptions, sometimes contradictory ones, which get smuggled into a book like Sapiens.

    I think the booklet had the rather unfortunate title of Jewish Fables, but that's Jones for you.

    Harari is probably a good historian and he has a knack for bold pronouncements but he seems to have very little philosophical acumen and tends not to think through his own statements with any particular care.

    Replies: @Barbarossa

    Yeah, I agree that Harari is a decent historian and seemingly a smart guy. Overall, I really kind of wanted to like Sapiens. It’s very well presented and very authoritative sounding. Also, the graphic novel format (and visual formats in general) tend to blunt the critical faculty of the reader which makes it that much easier to make a dubious point flow seamlessly.

    Even as a critical reader I could feel a certain emotional pull to the arc that Harari wanted to put forward, which is why I found it to be a particularly disturbing piece of propaganda. I don’t mind if my kids are exposed to a certain amount of Woke arguments, especially when they can be put in context and the logical flaws exposed. I think of it a bit like a philosophical immune system; it needs to exercised or kids will be wholly unprepared for the cultural onslaught.

    Again though, as a critical reader I found Harari’s didactic gushing tone as he fawned over current Woke norms to be quite cringe-worthy, jarring, and out of place with the rest of the books’ tone of wry detachment deployed when dissecting any other era’s sacred cows.

    I’ll check out E. Michael Jones critique of Sapiens, so thanks for mentioning it.

    • Replies: @RSDB
    @Barbarossa


    Overall, I really kind of wanted to like Sapiens. It’s very well presented and very authoritative sounding.
     
    Yes-- one trouble is that Harari is not as authoritative as he makes out, because he is not a scientist and not a philosopher, and he insists on talking science and philosophy, being "sciency" as your wife put it. At least when I was a kid reading Stephen Hawking and Michio Kaku on physics, they were actual physicists.

    Again though, as a critical reader I found Harari’s didactic gushing tone as he fawned over current Woke norms to be quite cringe-worthy, jarring, and out of place with the rest of the books’ tone of wry detachment deployed when dissecting any other era’s sacred cows.
     
    That's a good point too. As Chesterton says, the definition of the true savage is that he laughs when he hurts you; and howls when you hurt him. It's very easy to be detached and wry when talking about things other people hold dear, harder when it affects the self.
  122. @Twinkie
    @Bill P


    that’s why I’m usually pretty careful when cutting up an animal. You can cut too far too fast and ruin your cuts if you don’t take it easy.
     
    Don’t you put your index finger next to the blade when you get close to the lower organs?

    Blades are extremely effective.
     
    Within about 20 feet or so, someone wielding a blade is more dangerous than someone with a handgun. Blades can do a horrific amount of damage in a short time span, and it takes very little skill to do that damage.

    Replies: @Bill P

    Don’t you put your index finger next to the blade when you get close to the lower organs?

    Depends what I’m cutting. Usually yes, but I like using a flexible blade for boning, and sometimes you just grip the handle with that.

    Btw i cut myself by just being stupid and using a knife as a wedge. It wasn’t even a very sharp or good knife, which is why I underestimated what it could do. If it had been one of my Japanese knives I couldn’t have avoided the ER. Would have cut clear to the bone (I use fine Arkansas stones on my good knives).

    • Replies: @Twinkie
    @Bill P

    Almost any knife can be made extremely sharp. It's just that knives with low hardness won't stay sharp for long.

    I use diamond plates on a guided system to sharpen my blades. I finish with a strop leather with some compound on it.

    Replies: @Bill P

  123. @Bill P
    @Reg Cæsar

    Apparently he killed two girls who were sleeping alone, then he came upon the couple and killed the male (Ethan Chapin) first. The only one who fought back was Ethan Chapin's girlfriend, who probably woke up as her boyfriend was being slaughtered.

    Heavy blades can do a lot of damage quickly. Just the other day I cut clear through my own skin in a cooking slip-up that involved little force. A sharp, long blade with some force behind it goes through flesh before you know it -- that's why I'm usually pretty careful when cutting up an animal. You can cut too far too fast and ruin your cuts if you don't take it easy.

    It's totally gruesome to think of doing this to innocent young people, but alas it isn't so (physically) hard to do. Blades are extremely effective.

    Ethan Chapin came from Skagit County, just a half hour down I-5 from me. A few years ago I'd thought about moving to Moscow, ID myself. He has two surviving triplet siblings. It really baffles to try to wrap one's mind around this crime, but the idea of "broken soul" comes to my mind. How could someone butcher people like that? Only someone who has rejected and lost his own humanity.

    Replies: @Twinkie, @prosa123

    Apparently he killed two girls who were sleeping alone, then he came upon the couple and killed the male (Ethan Chapin) first. The only one who fought back was Ethan Chapin’s girlfriend, who probably woke up as her boyfriend was being slaughtered.

    It didn’t help that Kaylee Goncalves and Maddie Mogen were clearly intoxicated in the food truck video.
    One theory is that Bryan Kohberger’s targets were Maddie and Xana, with Kaylee and Ethan collateral damage. Maddie and Xana worked at the Mad Greek restaurant, one of the only restaurants in Pullman-Moscow which had vegan items on the menu. Kohberger is a vegan. It is possible that while patronizing the Mad Greek he got in a conversation with them and found out where they lived. They might have invited him to a party and given him the location, note that their house was a known party spot.
    What doesn’t add up is that according to rumor, yes it’s only rumor, some or possibly all of the victims were stabbed well beyond what would be sufficient to be fatal. In fact one of the girls, likely either Kaylee or Maddie, was nearly beheaded.

  124. (I use fine Arkansas stones on my good knives).

    One of these fine Arkansas stones?

    CRATER OF DIAMONDS STATE PARK

    What do you use to sharpen your Arkansas toothpick (below)? These were somewhat unpopular with legislatures in neighboring states.

    [MORE]

    • Replies: @Bill P
    @Reg Cæsar


    What do you use to sharpen your Arkansas toothpick
     
    Why, novaculite, of course

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novaculite

    This company has a good selection of bench stones:

    https://arkansaswhetstone.net/

    But be forewarned -- it takes a long time to polish a blade by hand with the finest novaculite. If you're a bit OCD about it you can end up working on a blade for an hour to get it just right. The coarser stones are good enough for most purposes, but when you really work on quality steel with extra-fine novaculite it keeps its edge for months and cuts as clean as steel can cut.
  125. @reactionry
    OT & Too Soon?

    A Jeremiad of Dunces

    Rumor has it that Jeremy Renner* turned down the role later filled by Channing Tatum in The Dog so that he (Jeremy) could star in the upcoming "Snow Pierce" Plowman. When asked by a reporter, who had somehow gotten to his hospital bedside, if he had made a career mistake, the delirious and heavily medicated actor gasped, "You're a lying, dog-faced pony soldier!"



    * "The Yiddish surname Renner is based on the German Renner, which means 'runner/messenger.' Another German Jewish surname with the same meaning is Laufer." Jeremy Renner is not Jewish, but I'll buy the rest of the above and assume that "Laufman" rhymes with "Kaufman." A World War I folk etymology from the 24th Century asserts a similar definition for "Hitler."

    Also see: Jeremy Irons will star in a sequel as an aged and rusty Ferrous Bueller

    See also: In celebration of the purported effects of an estimated 5% component of Sub-Saharan ancestry in Ashkenazi Jews, Jack D. will be writing a biography of the indicted "horndog" Ron "Unz" Jeremy

    Replies: @duncsbaby

    He is the oldest of seven siblings, the youngest of whom was born in 2011, which made him a new big brother at 40 years old. His mother has Irish ancestry. Renner is also of German descent.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeremy_Renner

  126. I dunno, it was a pretty good movie. It hit every note. But I’m in the Army 29 years now, eight years in the Green Berets. Was in Afghanistan before Big Army came in, in 2002. I’m not trying to throw my dick on the table, but this movie was just so pat and mawkish.

    I mean, it hit some chords, but this is what the ‘good side’ of Hollywood thinks of us. I thought I was going to cry like a baby, but came away stopping it every once in a while just to make a sandwich and guess what the obvious next thing was going to be–batted 1000.

    Chaning looked great, and I think that was what half of the movie was about. Surprised Mark Wallberg didn’t do a cameo as a pissed-off NCO doing pull-ups.

    Not trying to hate, but it was a very average movie.

    • Thanks: Jim Don Bob
    • Replies: @Jim Don Bob
    @Tim


    But I’m in the Army 29 years now, eight years in the Green Berets.
     
    Why only 8 years in the Green Berets? Did you flunk out? ;-)

    I thought they were like the Marines - once a Marine, always a Marine.

    Thank you for your service.
  127. @Reg Cæsar

    (I use fine Arkansas stones on my good knives).
     
    One of these fine Arkansas stones?


    https://www.mining.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/diamond-found-at-arkansas-park-expected-to-fetch-1-million.jpg

    CRATER OF DIAMONDS STATE PARK


    What do you use to sharpen your Arkansas toothpick (below)? These were somewhat unpopular with legislatures in neighboring states.


    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/20/Arkansas_Toothpick.jpg

    Replies: @Bill P

    What do you use to sharpen your Arkansas toothpick

    Why, novaculite, of course

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novaculite

    This company has a good selection of bench stones:

    https://arkansaswhetstone.net/

    But be forewarned — it takes a long time to polish a blade by hand with the finest novaculite. If you’re a bit OCD about it you can end up working on a blade for an hour to get it just right. The coarser stones are good enough for most purposes, but when you really work on quality steel with extra-fine novaculite it keeps its edge for months and cuts as clean as steel can cut.

  128. @Anonymous
    @Greta Handel


    You seem pretty upset by someone focusing on your life’s work.

    Without stepping in any more of the dog doo, can you refute Pat Hannagan’s comment?
     

    I’m not upset at all, Pat.

    It’s what I’d cheerfully say to you at Denny's as I chowed on my "Hammy Slammy."

    Btw, I refuted your comment quite nicely. You claimed Steve’s observation about dark-faced dogs was Asperger's induced, and I told you why you might be an ignorant twit, since anyone who knows about filming dark-faced dogs know it’s a pain in the ass, since you have to deal with it for every scene the dog is in, limiting your cinematic choices.

    It’s like willfully adding another 100 problems to your SAT, without getting extra credit for it. Unless it involves a creative choice, cinematographers like their jobs to be easier, not harder. That’s why they don’t ask for dark-faced dogs in a dog movie. It limits their lenses, their lighting, their blocking out the scene. Unless there’s a damned good reason, they logically, practically, don’t want it.

    That is, when Lulu is lit well, Tatum's face will get blown out. When Tatum is lit perfectly, Lulu looks like she’s guarding the gates of hell. In the context of that movie, the cinematographer used that problem creatively, because Lulu was, at times, a hell dog.

    But you'll notice at the end of the movie, it was "fuck Tatum, let’s light that bitch up good," and they did, which worked perfectly. Beautiful redemption shots at the end. Beautiful, well lit Lulu. Sorry, Tatum.

    Lit creatively, and well.

    So… again… shut up, Pat.

    And pass the syrup.

    Replies: @Greta Handel

    Apparently not.

  129. This post and comment thread demonstrate how Exceptionally! mass culture has indoctrinated the American people into autistic identification with Uncle Sam.

    This is a good small road movie from a few months ago with Channing Tatum as an ex-Army Ranger and a similarly Iraq-damaged Belgian Malinois Shepherd war dog named Lulu.

    Never mind why Our Heroes were in Iraq to suffer so touchingly, they’re Iraq-damaged. And they need to be repaired to stand with Ukraine.

    Iraq-damaged. Hollywood would never feed you a movie about them, but how would you describe Madeleine Albright’s 500,000 worthits?

  130. @Reg Cæsar
    @HammerJack


    How did he even manage to kill four people without anyone making appreciable noise?
     
    Depends on how you do it. Hannah Duston and Mary Neff were shown by an abducted English boy who, on the surface, had "gone native" how the Indians killed groups of people in their sleep without waking anybody. They did just this, and escaped.

    The murder-suicide of a student and her Canadian hockey player boyfriend in their sleep by her jealous ex at Geneseo State a few years ago was accomplished in a similar way. There are a lot of Indians in Western New York; one wonders where he learned the trick.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hannah_Duston

    Replies: @Bill P, @Jim Don Bob

    You only have to hit someone in the head once if you use a hatchet.

    • Replies: @Reg Cæsar
    @Jim Don Bob


    You only have to hit someone in the head once if you use a hatchet.
     
    Yeah, but there's the noise to consider. It might wake the other potential victims.
  131. @PhysicistDave
    @Bill

    Bill wrote to me:


    That’s a little like saying that there is no right side of the road to drive on or there is no right language to speak. It’s not false, but it’s also not true.
     
    Well, obviously, I am not objecting to people recommending books!

    Indeed, a month or so ago, a commenter here informed me that Lenny Susskind, who was on my thesis committee, is coming out with a popular book on General Relativity. Since I am writing a book on the same subject, this was crucial information for me to have, and I am indebted to that commenter.

    What I am objecting to is the sort of silly stuff like "50 books every educated person should read." Yes, I actually do think people should read 1984, mainly because the warning it gives is so important.

    But while I read and enjoyed Huck Finn, The Odyssey, and To Kill a Mockingbird, I am reluctant to say that a person is culturally stunted if they not have read those three books. (Incidentally, Harper Lee was most assuredly not a liberal. Read her first book: Go Set a Watchman. She was a libertarian conservative, a self-conscious limited-government, states-rights Jeffersonian.)

    This is even more so with non-fiction books. I could name a number of non-fiction books that were critical for me in understanding reality better. But, in almost all cases there are other books that could serve almost as well.

    Replies: @Bill

    We speak past one another. I am defending stuff like “50 books every educated person should read” while admitting that any such list is, in a certain sense, arbitrary. Just like which side of the road you drive on or which language you speak. These are both, in a certain sense, arbitrary, and, in a certain sense, very far from arbitrary.

    Not only is it critical that you drive on the same side of the road as everyone else and speak the same language as everyone else, but it is also critical that there be a side of the road everyone drives on and a language everyone speaks. Disaster would ensue if there were not.

    And disaster has ensued in the US because there are not 50 books every educated person has read (and all the stuff which goes along with that). Our hideous, thin, ugly, utterly amoral, low-context culture is the disaster.

    I’m certainly not defending the list Fridman posted, by the way, which looks like something Vox Dei would come up with (well, except it doesn’t have a strategy guide to Advanced Squad Leader on it).

  132. @Tim
    I dunno, it was a pretty good movie. It hit every note. But I'm in the Army 29 years now, eight years in the Green Berets. Was in Afghanistan before Big Army came in, in 2002. I'm not trying to throw my dick on the table, but this movie was just so pat and mawkish.

    I mean, it hit some chords, but this is what the 'good side' of Hollywood thinks of us. I thought I was going to cry like a baby, but came away stopping it every once in a while just to make a sandwich and guess what the obvious next thing was going to be--batted 1000.

    Chaning looked great, and I think that was what half of the movie was about. Surprised Mark Wallberg didn't do a cameo as a pissed-off NCO doing pull-ups.

    Not trying to hate, but it was a very average movie.

    Replies: @Jim Don Bob

    But I’m in the Army 29 years now, eight years in the Green Berets.

    Why only 8 years in the Green Berets? Did you flunk out? 😉

    I thought they were like the Marines – once a Marine, always a Marine.

    Thank you for your service.

  133. @Jim Don Bob
    @Reg Cæsar

    You only have to hit someone in the head once if you use a hatchet.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar

    You only have to hit someone in the head once if you use a hatchet.

    Yeah, but there’s the noise to consider. It might wake the other potential victims.

  134. @Bill P
    @Twinkie


    Don’t you put your index finger next to the blade when you get close to the lower organs?
     
    Depends what I'm cutting. Usually yes, but I like using a flexible blade for boning, and sometimes you just grip the handle with that.

    Btw i cut myself by just being stupid and using a knife as a wedge. It wasn't even a very sharp or good knife, which is why I underestimated what it could do. If it had been one of my Japanese knives I couldn't have avoided the ER. Would have cut clear to the bone (I use fine Arkansas stones on my good knives).

    Replies: @Twinkie

    Almost any knife can be made extremely sharp. It’s just that knives with low hardness won’t stay sharp for long.

    I use diamond plates on a guided system to sharpen my blades. I finish with a strop leather with some compound on it.

    • Replies: @Bill P
    @Twinkie

    Diamond is kind of rough on the edge. I use it for tools but not my good knives. I've found that there are two kinds of sharp: microserrated and polished. With rougher stones or diamond sharpeners you get an edge that cuts very well, but doesn't last all that long. I'm fairly sure that's because it creates a saw-like edge that, while effective, blunts quickly.

    If you polish the edge it cuts well and stays sharp for a surprisingly long time.

    Of course stropping is a polishing method, but nothing beats the finer grades of Arkansas whetstones. The only problem with them is that it takes a lot of work to properly polish an edge, especially on good steel like VG-10 (my preference for cooking knife steel). But it does pay off. My knives can stay very sharp for months despite frequent use.

    Replies: @Twinkie

  135. @Colin Wright
    @AnotherDad

    '...The question for all movies these days is whether they have annoying jammed superfluous/discordant/anachronistic/annoying blacks into it rendering it–whatever its other merits–unwatchable.'

    Past the inevitable token, if there're blacks in it, I won't watch it.

    Post-Summer of George, it's a matter of principle. They started a race war, and I'd no more watch a movie with blacks in it now than I would check out Goebbel's latest offering if it were 1943.

    Seriously. My daughter recommended the recent remake of Dune. My first -- and only -- question was 'Are the Fremen black?'

    'Yes.' Then I won't watch it. Ten years ago -- sure. Now? No.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer

    Javier Bardem is black?

  136. @Twinkie
    @Bill P

    Almost any knife can be made extremely sharp. It's just that knives with low hardness won't stay sharp for long.

    I use diamond plates on a guided system to sharpen my blades. I finish with a strop leather with some compound on it.

    Replies: @Bill P

    Diamond is kind of rough on the edge. I use it for tools but not my good knives. I’ve found that there are two kinds of sharp: microserrated and polished. With rougher stones or diamond sharpeners you get an edge that cuts very well, but doesn’t last all that long. I’m fairly sure that’s because it creates a saw-like edge that, while effective, blunts quickly.

    If you polish the edge it cuts well and stays sharp for a surprisingly long time.

    Of course stropping is a polishing method, but nothing beats the finer grades of Arkansas whetstones. The only problem with them is that it takes a lot of work to properly polish an edge, especially on good steel like VG-10 (my preference for cooking knife steel). But it does pay off. My knives can stay very sharp for months despite frequent use.

    • Replies: @Twinkie
    @Bill P


    Of course stropping is a polishing method, but nothing beats the finer grades of Arkansas whetstones.
     
    I use diamond plates, because most of my knives are made from super steels such as Böhler M390 or CPM 20CV, typically to about 62 HRC. These days, I consider VG-10 a pretty "basic" alloy (most knives made with it are usually around 58-59 HRC). It's decent, but doesn't stay sharp long and tends to chip easily at acute angles common in Japanese knives. It's easier to sharpen compared to super steels though. I consider it inferior to even CPM S30V or S35VN.

    With a leather strop and a 0.25 micron emulsion compound, I can mirror-polish any knife edge. And I mean mirror-polish (that doesn't mean I do - for many uses, e.g. cutting rope and similar materials, I prefer toothier edges).

    Replies: @Bill P

  137. @Bill P
    @Twinkie

    Diamond is kind of rough on the edge. I use it for tools but not my good knives. I've found that there are two kinds of sharp: microserrated and polished. With rougher stones or diamond sharpeners you get an edge that cuts very well, but doesn't last all that long. I'm fairly sure that's because it creates a saw-like edge that, while effective, blunts quickly.

    If you polish the edge it cuts well and stays sharp for a surprisingly long time.

    Of course stropping is a polishing method, but nothing beats the finer grades of Arkansas whetstones. The only problem with them is that it takes a lot of work to properly polish an edge, especially on good steel like VG-10 (my preference for cooking knife steel). But it does pay off. My knives can stay very sharp for months despite frequent use.

    Replies: @Twinkie

    Of course stropping is a polishing method, but nothing beats the finer grades of Arkansas whetstones.

    I use diamond plates, because most of my knives are made from super steels such as Böhler M390 or CPM 20CV, typically to about 62 HRC. These days, I consider VG-10 a pretty “basic” alloy (most knives made with it are usually around 58-59 HRC). It’s decent, but doesn’t stay sharp long and tends to chip easily at acute angles common in Japanese knives. It’s easier to sharpen compared to super steels though. I consider it inferior to even CPM S30V or S35VN.

    With a leather strop and a 0.25 micron emulsion compound, I can mirror-polish any knife edge. And I mean mirror-polish (that doesn’t mean I do – for many uses, e.g. cutting rope and similar materials, I prefer toothier edges).

    • Replies: @Bill P
    @Twinkie


    most knives made with it are usually around 58-59 HRC
     
    Mine are rated 61, which is plenty hard for my purposes, and VG-10 doesn't stain/rust easily. I cook a lot, so I like a steel that doesn't corrode if you don't wipe it with an oiled cloth immediately after every use. For my boning knife I have a softer, more flexible carbon steel, maybe 56-57 hardness.

    I just bought my oldest son one of those pm steel blades (Zero Tolerance knife) and while it's pretty impressive it's a bit too rigid for my purposes.

    To see a real sharpening fanatic check out this guy:

    https://youtu.be/PRMu-WEaFNE

    Replies: @Twinkie

  138. @Twinkie
    @Bill P


    Of course stropping is a polishing method, but nothing beats the finer grades of Arkansas whetstones.
     
    I use diamond plates, because most of my knives are made from super steels such as Böhler M390 or CPM 20CV, typically to about 62 HRC. These days, I consider VG-10 a pretty "basic" alloy (most knives made with it are usually around 58-59 HRC). It's decent, but doesn't stay sharp long and tends to chip easily at acute angles common in Japanese knives. It's easier to sharpen compared to super steels though. I consider it inferior to even CPM S30V or S35VN.

    With a leather strop and a 0.25 micron emulsion compound, I can mirror-polish any knife edge. And I mean mirror-polish (that doesn't mean I do - for many uses, e.g. cutting rope and similar materials, I prefer toothier edges).

    Replies: @Bill P

    most knives made with it are usually around 58-59 HRC

    Mine are rated 61, which is plenty hard for my purposes, and VG-10 doesn’t stain/rust easily. I cook a lot, so I like a steel that doesn’t corrode if you don’t wipe it with an oiled cloth immediately after every use. For my boning knife I have a softer, more flexible carbon steel, maybe 56-57 hardness.

    I just bought my oldest son one of those pm steel blades (Zero Tolerance knife) and while it’s pretty impressive it’s a bit too rigid for my purposes.

    To see a real sharpening fanatic check out this guy:

    • Replies: @Twinkie
    @Bill P


    Mine are rated 61, which is plenty hard for my purposes, and VG-10 doesn’t stain/rust easily. I cook a lot, so I like a steel that doesn’t corrode if you don’t wipe it with an oiled cloth immediately after every use.
     
    That's very unusual as VG-10 heat-treated to HRC 61 is going to be very chippy. Which make and model knife is it?

    My basic knock-around kitchen knife is a Miyabi I bought very cheaply on clearance (I don't give really good knives to my wife as she is monkey-handed with them) and is made of MC63 steel (aka Takefu SG2 or 3G). It's forged to HRC 63-64. Its chromium content is about 16%, so it's going to be about as stain-resistant as VG-10 (which has about 15%).

    I'm a big fan of M390 and CPM 20CV (which is basically an American version of M390). They have about 20% chromium, so they are considerably more stain-resistant than VG-10 while outperforming the latter in just about every category except price. They are truly excellent all-around super steels.

    To see a real sharpening fanatic check out this guy:
     
    I'm not what one of these Internet guys who sharpen more than use their knives, but the green compound he puts on his strop doesn't hold a candle to the CBN (cubic boron nitride) emulsion compound I use.
  139. @Barbarossa
    @RSDB

    Yeah, I agree that Harari is a decent historian and seemingly a smart guy. Overall, I really kind of wanted to like Sapiens. It's very well presented and very authoritative sounding. Also, the graphic novel format (and visual formats in general) tend to blunt the critical faculty of the reader which makes it that much easier to make a dubious point flow seamlessly.

    Even as a critical reader I could feel a certain emotional pull to the arc that Harari wanted to put forward, which is why I found it to be a particularly disturbing piece of propaganda. I don't mind if my kids are exposed to a certain amount of Woke arguments, especially when they can be put in context and the logical flaws exposed. I think of it a bit like a philosophical immune system; it needs to exercised or kids will be wholly unprepared for the cultural onslaught.

    Again though, as a critical reader I found Harari's didactic gushing tone as he fawned over current Woke norms to be quite cringe-worthy, jarring, and out of place with the rest of the books' tone of wry detachment deployed when dissecting any other era's sacred cows.

    I'll check out E. Michael Jones critique of Sapiens, so thanks for mentioning it.

    Replies: @RSDB

    Overall, I really kind of wanted to like Sapiens. It’s very well presented and very authoritative sounding.

    Yes– one trouble is that Harari is not as authoritative as he makes out, because he is not a scientist and not a philosopher, and he insists on talking science and philosophy, being “sciency” as your wife put it. At least when I was a kid reading Stephen Hawking and Michio Kaku on physics, they were actual physicists.

    Again though, as a critical reader I found Harari’s didactic gushing tone as he fawned over current Woke norms to be quite cringe-worthy, jarring, and out of place with the rest of the books’ tone of wry detachment deployed when dissecting any other era’s sacred cows.

    That’s a good point too. As Chesterton says, the definition of the true savage is that he laughs when he hurts you; and howls when you hurt him. It’s very easy to be detached and wry when talking about things other people hold dear, harder when it affects the self.

  140. @Bill P
    @Twinkie


    most knives made with it are usually around 58-59 HRC
     
    Mine are rated 61, which is plenty hard for my purposes, and VG-10 doesn't stain/rust easily. I cook a lot, so I like a steel that doesn't corrode if you don't wipe it with an oiled cloth immediately after every use. For my boning knife I have a softer, more flexible carbon steel, maybe 56-57 hardness.

    I just bought my oldest son one of those pm steel blades (Zero Tolerance knife) and while it's pretty impressive it's a bit too rigid for my purposes.

    To see a real sharpening fanatic check out this guy:

    https://youtu.be/PRMu-WEaFNE

    Replies: @Twinkie

    Mine are rated 61, which is plenty hard for my purposes, and VG-10 doesn’t stain/rust easily. I cook a lot, so I like a steel that doesn’t corrode if you don’t wipe it with an oiled cloth immediately after every use.

    That’s very unusual as VG-10 heat-treated to HRC 61 is going to be very chippy. Which make and model knife is it?

    My basic knock-around kitchen knife is a Miyabi I bought very cheaply on clearance (I don’t give really good knives to my wife as she is monkey-handed with them) and is made of MC63 steel (aka Takefu SG2 or 3G). It’s forged to HRC 63-64. Its chromium content is about 16%, so it’s going to be about as stain-resistant as VG-10 (which has about 15%).

    I’m a big fan of M390 and CPM 20CV (which is basically an American version of M390). They have about 20% chromium, so they are considerably more stain-resistant than VG-10 while outperforming the latter in just about every category except price. They are truly excellent all-around super steels.

    To see a real sharpening fanatic check out this guy:

    I’m not what one of these Internet guys who sharpen more than use their knives, but the green compound he puts on his strop doesn’t hold a candle to the CBN (cubic boron nitride) emulsion compound I use.

  141. @MEH 0910
    @Jenner Ickham Errican

    https://twitter.com/lexfridman/status/1609609380630253569

    Replies: @Lichen, @Harry Baldwin, @MEH 0910

    Lex Fridman on Twitter drama over reading list

    Jan 8, 2023

    Excerpted from:

    1984 by George Orwell | Lex Fridman

    Jan 8, 2023

    A few takeaways from re-reading 1984 by George Orwell.
    Other books I’m currently reading can be found here: https://lexfridman.com/reading-list/

    OUTLINE:
    0:00 – Intro
    1:02 – 1984 world & characters
    4:20 – Love
    12:42 – Hate
    17:21 – Power
    25:56 – 1984 applied to today
    47:14 – Twitter reading list drama

    • Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican
    @MEH 0910

    Thanks.

    Strange guy. He speaks in platitudes, like a superficial pop-psychology ‘life coach’. His low-key disposition might induce some into thinking he has intellectual or moral gravitas, but many others are suspicious of him, for good reason: He comes off guarded and shady, like a mid-level underworld operative running a front business.

    He also contradicts himself about the significance (to him) of the book list: He defends it both as an impromptu lark on one hand (it’s no big deal guys, whatever) and a profound list of essential classics on the other (the list is unassailable and beyond criticism). It can’t be both. Either he’s serious about it or not. But he won’t elaborate in any meaningful way, beyond saying he feels sad about the Twitter drama.

  142. My daughter signed me up for Amazon Prime for Christmas, but so far I’ve not found much on Prime Video that interests me. Much of it looks stupid and/or woke.

    Any suggestions?

  143. @MEH 0910
    @MEH 0910

    Lex Fridman on Twitter drama over reading list
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxZY-NI9knw
    Jan 8, 2023

    Excerpted from:

    1984 by George Orwell | Lex Fridman
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Sk6lTLSZcA
    Jan 8, 2023


    A few takeaways from re-reading 1984 by George Orwell.
    Other books I'm currently reading can be found here: https://lexfridman.com/reading-list/

    OUTLINE:
    0:00 - Intro
    1:02 - 1984 world & characters
    4:20 - Love
    12:42 - Hate
    17:21 - Power
    25:56 - 1984 applied to today
    47:14 - Twitter reading list drama
     

    Replies: @Jenner Ickham Errican

    Thanks.

    Strange guy. He speaks in platitudes, like a superficial pop-psychology ‘life coach’. His low-key disposition might induce some into thinking he has intellectual or moral gravitas, but many others are suspicious of him, for good reason: He comes off guarded and shady, like a mid-level underworld operative running a front business.

    He also contradicts himself about the significance (to him) of the book list: He defends it both as an impromptu lark on one hand (it’s no big deal guys, whatever) and a profound list of essential classics on the other (the list is unassailable and beyond criticism). It can’t be both. Either he’s serious about it or not. But he won’t elaborate in any meaningful way, beyond saying he feels sad about the Twitter drama.

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to All Steve Sailer Comments via RSS
PastClassics
The Surprising Elements of Talmudic Judaism
Analyzing the History of a Controversial Movement
The Shaping Event of Our Modern World