The Unz Review: An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewIsrael Shamir Archive
"Protecting the Jews"
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information



=>

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Troll, or LOL with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used once per hour.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

Justify your actions by the need to protect the weak and vulnerable. This is the first rule of political rhetoric. If you bomb Syria, do not admit you did it to install your puppet regime or to lay a pipeline. Say you did it to save the Aleppo kids gassed by Assad the Butcher. If you occupy Afghanistan, do not admit you make a handsome profit smuggling heroin; say you came to protect the women. If you want to put your people under total surveillance, say you did it to prevent hate groups target the powerless and diverse.

Remember: you do not need to ask children, women or immigrants whether they want your protection. If pushed, you can always find a few suitable profiles to look at the cameras and repeat a short text. With all my dislike for R2P (Responsibility to Protect) hypocrisy, I can’t possibly blame the allegedly protected for the disaster caused by the unwanted protectors.

This thought came to my mind during my recent visit to France for the publication of my new book In The Name of Christ. France is going through a rapid shrinking of freedom. All the nations experience that, but France leads. For years they had laws that banned things displeasing to Jews; and now they expand these laws punishing not only saying or writing but also thinking, implying or winking. The bill criminalising anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism may be voted on very soon. As the law voted in 2015 (after the Charlie Hebdo attack), against the “apology of terrorism”, the new law will allow the government to seize anyone, just for a tweet or a post on Facebook, and send a person for 18 months to “preventive imprisonment”, even before he comes to a court. The judge will sanction him on the basis of “intimate conviction” of his “hidden intentions”.

This fight against alleged antisemitism has become – like in the UK – a powerful tool of the ruling elites against the people. It is used against the Gilets Jaunes (the Yellow Vests), and against the opposition in general. The authorities apply the R2P principle to assault French freedom, that is they allegedly protect the Jews, as if Jews need protection, and in the name of Jews they steal freedom of all.

With a certain poetic license, one can proclaim the Jews are innocent of this assault, like the Aleppo kids are not guilty of bombing Syria and Afghan women are not guilty of American occupation. The Jews have been used as proverbial victims, but so were children and women. The guilt and responsibility is of those who use them as a pretext.

You may argue that the comparison is forced, for the French Jewish bodies actively participate in this campaign against French freedom. Yes, that’s true, but these organisations are voluntary self-appointed guardians of Jewish interest. Jews didn’t vote for them, didn’t elect them. The government was free to disregard them saying they do not represent their Jewish citizens. Actually, that was the traditional French approach, refusing to deal with Jewish organisations saying the French Jews are French and they do not need an intermediary. If the government preferred to listen to them, it is only because they say what the government wants to hear.

In Annecy, one of France’s prettiest medieval towns I had met Maître Viguier, the lawyer for Mr Alain Soral, and over the pot of cheese fondue the place is famous for he told me an amazing story.

In the course of their demo, the Yellow Vests had burned a picture of a French TV personality, Bernard Henri Levi (BHL for short), and of some other worthies. This event had been depicted in a jolly video clip that you can watch with pleasure and the clip had been uploaded on a website associated with Alain Soral.

The CRIF (or/and LICRA and other bodies) had accused Mr Soral of antisemitism, a criminal offence, on the strength of this fact, and demanded 2 years of prison + 30,000 euros, requested as punishment + 82,500 as compensations for the “victims”. The Maître said the elites try to unite the Jewish people against Gilets Jaunes and against ordinary French people. Other supporters of the GJ, Jean Bricmont and M. Chouard are the next on the list, after Soral.

The CRIF said that the rap was in coded language. The burned picture of BHL suggests a great fire to burn every Jew. “Between 1940 and 1945, the Nazis called the Jews ‘vermin’ and ‘parasites’ that should be exterminated”, they say. And that’s why the word “parasites” in the clip necessarily refers to Jews that should be exterminated. A very weak logic; Socrates would send these CRIF sophists back to the holes they usually hide from sunlight. Whatever the Nazis said, they have no copyright on the word ‘parasites’. In the Soviet Union after the October 1917 Revolution, when Jews occupied quite a prominent place in the society, the most popular revolutionary song said the parasites have no right to rule the land.

Parasites are those who do not toil but consume; and this is not a specific Jewish feature. By claiming that Jews are the parasites, the self-proclaimed Jewish organisations indulge in vile antisemitism, I told them.

ORDER IT NOW

What’s wrong in burning a picture of BHL? BHL is a French citizen who is entitled to his views. However, none of his views could or should be accepted as “the Jewish position”. The French Jews, and certainly the Jews of the world, hold a wide variety of views, some of them agree with BHL in some points and some disagree, sometimes disagree strongly. Mr BHL had been a fervent supporter, or even an instigator of the NATO attack on Libya in 2011 that had made this rather prosperous North African country a failed state ruled by Islamist armed gangs. Mr BHL had been a fervent supporter or an instigator of the Kiev 2014 coup that deposed the legitimate president of the Ukraine and had brought followers of the Nazi Quisling Stepan Bandera to power. Mr BHL had tried to ignite the ire of his French compatriots against the GJ. These and other strong views of Mr BHL had caused indignation of some French citizens who expressed their indignation by burning his photo. These acts by Mr BHL and his adversaries are perfectly legitimate within the limits of free public discourse.

What is not and can’t be legitimate is an attempt by the CRIF to create a false impression as if those opinions and acts by Mr BHL were an expression of the Jewish position. This is an obnoxious anti-Semitic lie. The Jews of France, of Israel and of the world didn’t necessarily wish Libya to be bombed or Kiev upturned; the Jews have no united single political position on French elections or on French political movements. Some French Jews support the GJ, and some reject them. Some vote for Mr Macron and some for Mme Le Pen or Mr Soral.

It’s only vicious anti-Semites who claim that all Jews follow and support BHL. This nasty claim had been upheld by a self-proclaimed “Jewish organisation” CRIF.

Let me reiterate: the body called CRIF does not represent French Jews, for it was not elected by French Jews. Its leadership is not accepted by French or any other Jews. It is a political organisation with its own goals; its goals do not coincide with those of majority of Jews in France or elsewhere.

While it is possible to argue that in some cases CRIFF acts in the interests of the Jews by fighting anti-Jewish prejudice, in this particular case the CRIF acts against the Jewish interests, as this action is likely to enforce the anti-Jewish prejudice of all Jews acting together for some dubious goal like break-up of Libya or Ukraine or for other controversial goal.

The Jews qua Jews have no position on these topics. Mr BHL is neither an elected representative nor a spiritual authority for the Jews in France or anywhere else. He does not dress as an observant Jew, he does not observe Jewish laws and customs; his family famously includes apostates; his actions were always those of a free agent; he never consulted with Jewish authorities, spiritual or temporal.

He is perfectly entitled to his views and opinions; however he may not claim he acts in the Jewish interests or represents the Jews. Even less so CRIF may present a protest against BHL as an act against Jewish people as the whole; as an act of anti-Semitism. If somebody is anti-Semitic it is CRIF that suggest that an attack of BHL is an attack on the Jewish people. If this would be a case, should we consider a condemnation of the Black comedian Mr Dieudonné – an act of anti-black racism?

It is perfectly legal to burn the image of BHL in Israel; and I intend to do it tomorrow in Tel Aviv on the Gordon Beach, I told them. No court in Israel would accuse me of anti-Semitism if I burn his picture; or a picture of Mr Netanyahu who is anyway an elected representative of the Jewish state of Israel. While Israeli flag is protected from desecration, an image of a person of a Jewish origin is not. It is free to burn or despoil it in any way you like.

I am certain that French citizens are not less free than Israeli citizens, and I hope that the French court will reject the frivolous claim of the self-proclaimed Jewish body called CRIFF against Mr Alain Soral. It would be good if Mr BHL would find courage to support Mr Soral against CRIF by affirming that he was not and is not acting as a legitimate representative or spiritual authority of the French Jews. It would be even better if the French Republic would accuse CRIF for encouraging anti-Jewish prejudice by frivolous claims.

If the French Republic finds it necessary to condemn Mr Alain Soral for whatever reason, let her do it without pretence of acting for the Jewish cause. Keep Jews out of this polemics! The Jews have enough troubles of their own without being used as a sort of supreme argument in an intra-French dispute.

This is what I said to the French lawyer, and he produced my argument in the French court. You can read all this argumentation here in French or just watch a conversation (in English with French translation) I had with a popular French presenter Jean-Michel Vernochet and the charming poet, political thinker and my translator Mme Maria Poumier:

The Jewish stories keep you forever busy, and I am glad that I could be of help to the besieged French while defending the Jews. God knows, Jews have enough sins of their own without having to bear and defend sins of the French establishment.

It would be sad and unwise to conclude this piece on such a sombre note, while glorious summer delights our eyes. Let us cross the Channel, where the indomitable 93-year-old Malaysian Prime Minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad, or just Dr M for short, spoke to English students in the Cambridge Union debating society on Sunday (Jun 16). Cambridge audience had been tickled pink by Dr M’s scintillating wit, a newspaper reported.

“I have some Jewish friends, very good friends, they are not like the other Jews, that’s why they are my friends,” – said Dr M causing wave of laughter. I hope he counts me among his friends since he invited me to his Kuala Lumpur 15 years ago and I duly reported about Malaysia and about him, the man who had fought Soros and IMF and won. Read here how he did it.

Many times he called Israel ‘the force behind all the woes of the Middle East’. Nor was he ever scared to be labelled antisemitic. And still this great man (whose very name horrifies Jewish activists and jerks the Cambridge University Labour Club to declare its “solidarity with British Jews”) ruled his country over 40 years, and recently had been re-elected as the candidate of the opposition party. He is well over ninety, and still going strong.

ORDER IT NOW

So be of good cheer, my friends and readers! Follow the example of Dr M and don’t be afraid of being called youknowwhat. This is not the end of the world. The voice of the Jews is powerful only when it goes in unison with real powers, and when their opponents are meek and weak-kneed. Strong-minded men can sail through their opposition as easily as they go through market-women’s squabble.

Israel Shamir can be reached at [email protected]

This article was first published at The Unz Review

 
Hide 123 CommentsLeave a Comment
123 Comments to ""Protecting the Jews""
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
    []
  1. The voice of the Jews is powerful only when it goes in unison with real powers

    Your buddy Mahathir Mohamad noted as much in 2003 when he said [PDF, 145] that Jews ‘have now gained control of the most powerful countries and they, this tiny community, have become a world power.’

    The question is: How will the people of Western countries free themselves from Jewish control when political, financial and media power is in the hands of Jews and their lackeys?

  2. druid55 says:

    Bernard henri Levy is the scum ofo the worst kind! Pseudo-philosopher, only got to his position of prominence because he is a Jew!!!!

    • Agree: Alfred, Wally, Moi
    • Replies: @anon
  3. Talha says:

    Meanwhile…

    “Just stop resisting!” – Israel (and also at times rapists)

    Peace.

    • Agree: Colin Wright
    • LOL: Digital Samizdat
  4. @Talha

    ‘Just stop resisting!” – Israel (and also at times rapists)

    Peace.’

    I’m not recommending a trial, but I suspect that even if the Palestinians did stop resisting, the Jews wouldn’t be able to resist continuing to torment them.

    Some people make better rulers than others. The British, for example, always managed to rule others with less trouble than, say, the Russians. In his historical novel about his native Bosnia, The Bridge on the Drina, Ivo Andric notes that in the interval of their rule, the Austrians managed to get far more out of Bosnia with far less trouble than the Turks ever did.

    All cultures are not identical. No shock there. It’s beginning to become evident that what their other virtues, Judaism and Jewish culture do not make for a particularly successful Master Race.

  5. Talha says:
    @Colin Wright

    I’m not recommending a trial, but I suspect that even if the Palestinians did stop resisting, the Jews wouldn’t be able to resist continuing to torment them.

    It would be an interesting experiment. My guess; the settlement building pace would increase given Palestinians are not fighting back.

    Peace.

    • Replies: @Niebelheim
  6. Anonymous[227] • Disclaimer says:

  7. HEREDOT says:
    @Johnny Rottenborough

    Great wars, economic destruction, unprecedented social political disasters, no other solution

  8. I don’t know but no matter what ideological stripe a Jew expresses. when he/she use their power it is always in line with the Zionist interest globally.

    I imagine that if Ron Unz or Gilad Atzmon rose to be prime minister of Israel there would be no change in Israeli policies from Netanyahu and Likud.

    its the same in the States, England, France everywhere. no matter where Jews normally exist on the ideological spectrum, when it counts they act for Chosen, expansionist Israel

    I note this is response to comments in the article that differentiates between Jews and where they may stand on issues we are all involved in. practical experience proves Shamir wrong. when it matters all Jews act the same way. they may talk different games but act in concert with “Chosen” global interests

    my response is simple: an intellect like Ron Unz is very useful, clears up a lot, helps general understanding forward on all issues he deals with. but I do not expect him to act in opposition to Jewish collective interest regardless. that is the way we all behave especially the Jews, and the Chinese for eg… to degrees greater than all other ethnic groups those two

  9. no, Shamir:

    the regime in France oppresses the French people on behalf of organized Jewry precisely

    because it IS a shabbatz goy regime: that little piss-ant Macron was and is a (((Rothschild))) employee. And whoever takes his place will be another (((Rothschild))) employee.

    • Agree: Nehlen
  10. PPB says:

    BHL representative of Jews in general? No, he’s much more iconic of the stratum of French culture that idolizes the aromatic subtleties of decaying organic matter. Even if most everyday French people and Jewish citizens of France still have their Gallic and Semitic noses screwed on too straight to fall for such pompous pretense, they’re not the impresario who determines which acts appear onstage.

    Though at least Marcel Marceau actually knew when to shut up.

  11. renfro says:

    You may argue that the comparison is forced, for the French Jewish bodies actively participate in this campaign against French freedom. Yes, that’s true, but these organisations are voluntary self-appointed guardians of Jewish interest. Jews didn’t vote for them, didn’t elect them. The government was free to disregard them saying they do not represent their Jewish citizens. Actually, that was the traditional French approach, refusing to deal with Jewish organisations saying the French Jews are French and they do not need an intermediary. If the government preferred to listen to them, it is only because they say what the government wants to hear.

    Sorry I don’t buy your defense unless French Jews are very different than US Jews.
    I seriously doubt a non Jew in the US government thought up the idea of criminalizing BDS, which neither the government nor the public gets any benefit from.

    • Replies: @Biff
    , @L.K
    , @foolisholdman
  12. I think it would be better for everyone, jews included, if the organized Jewish community had less influence in the highest levels of society in western countries. I also think it would be helpful if it wasn’t such a taboo to criticize them and their culture. Every other ethnic, racial, and religious group that I know of is subject to criticism. Jews should join the party.

    I want what’s best for all people, including Jews. Thank you to Israel Shamir, Gilad Atzmon, Ron Unz and others for reminding us that there are decent people of Jewish heritage out there.

    • Agree: Robjil
    • Replies: @Sick of Orcs
    , @Richard B
  13. @ben sampson

    Nah, I would bet my money on Ron being a stand up guy. But one guy is not going to change much if he doesn’t have total control of the govt.

    Case in point, the ass clown president we have in the white house.

    The orange hair is a better distraction than Reagan ever was.

  14. YN1F says:

    Sure, Mr. Israel Shamir, the “authorities” are just “using the Jews” as a stand-in victim class so that they can strip the freedoms from the citizenry under R2P. Poor Jews are just being “scapegoated” by the “elite”, doncha’ know… There are plennnnty of patriotic, loyal, freedom-loving Jews who aren’t on-board with these draconian “antisemitism” measures. The fact that no one ever sees these “good Jews” organizing and speaking out notwithstanding…

    Riiiiight. Message delivered loud and clear.

    …and REJECTED as utter BS.

  15. @Colin Wright

    The British, for example, always managed to rule others with less trouble than, say, the Russians.

    Yes, indeed! The thirteen British colonies in North America prove your point splendidly.

  16. swamped says:

    “Strong-minded men can sail through their opposition as easily as they go through market-women’s squabble”…hilarious – & not so subtly aimed at an emasculated American audience, no doubt. Just the sort of macho bluster you could get away with in a France that’s so hamstrung by ever-tightening speech strictures in other areas – but never in an America in the grip of a flagellating feminism. While at the same time, America as a whole is much more relaxed about alleged “anti-semitism” (despite some official attempts to pump it up) & Monsieur Soral would never be in such a fix as he is in France, if he had paraded around Lafayette Square burning up BHL mugshots, or pic’s of Marty Peretz &the whole repellent neo-con Semitic crew at New Republic who gave BHL his unbecoming start. Hell, you could even burn the g.d. Israeli flag here in Brighton Beach. So send M. Soral on over & let him let loose unconstrained. And in return, we’ll send some of our pussy whipped American males over to Gaul to clear out their milquetoast minds.

  17. Parfois1 says:

    Let me reiterate: the body called CRIF does not represent French Jews, for it was not elected by French Jews. Its leadership is not accepted by French or any other Jews. It is a political organisation with its own goals; its goals do not coincide with those of majority of Jews in France or elsewhere.

    It hurts when people like Shamir are compelled to using semantics for protection against the potential threat of incurring the wrath of the French anti-semitic laws. I understand trying to erect a Chinese wall between the CRIF/DHL-Jews nexus may help to disconnect them as a legal argument in a court of law; but insinuating that those three bodies are independent of each other is stretching naivety to incredible lengths. (Of course it is otiose to say that the world “Jews” is not the sum of all persons labeled as Jews, but an abstraction of a collective body recognised as representative of themselves and with which they identify with).

    Given the reach of legal interpretation to invade subjective feelings and thoughts in matters of “hate-crime”, it does not augur well if the French precedent expands – as it is more likely to – to other countries of the “civilized West” tripping over themselves to curry favour with their Jewish masters, 1st Amendment or other constitutional safeguards notwithstanding. One wonders whether the citizens of the “1st world” soon may have to migrate to the”3rd world” to enjoy the freedom denied in their country of birth. That would be a strange irony for the anti-migration crowd!

    Perhaps it is already happening: Peter, an architect friend of mine, 10yrs ago escaped from “freedom” to Communist Vietnam because he felt “oppressed” with so many laws and rules intruding into his “personal space”. He’s still there and enjoying it.

  18. Mass-deportation of muslim and african immigrants would solve many problems.

    • Agree: Sergey Krieger
    • Replies: @Sergey Krieger
    , @bjondo
  19. @ben sampson

    Wow! I wonder what the two gentlemen may have to say about your post.

    • Replies: @ben sampson
  20. @Philip Smeeton

    But not all and not the most important.

  21. Halfway into this article, I kept wondering whether Israel Shamir was trolling us really hard here. I kept wondering why he was being so logical, so reasonable, so fair in this piece? We all know that the Cabal absolutely hates reason, logic and fairness. As Gilad Atzmon would say, all that stuff is so Athens!

    The Cabal prefers Jerusalem: esoteric systems of thought which are choc-a-bloc with vague, circular and even contradictory notions which they can twist around at will to suit the interests of the Tribe. Now Jews are certainly capable of proper reasoning–they can hold their own in the natural sciences, for example. But where they really thrive is in the realm of pseudo-theories such as Talmudic exegesis, Freudian psychoanalysis, Cultural Marxism and French Post-modernism.

    So I kept wondering why Shamir was making so much sense here–and then I suddenly saw that this was all being done for the benefit of the French legal system:

    This is what I said to the French lawyer, and he produced my argument in the French court.

    And at last I understood!

  22. Biff says:
    @renfro

    I seriously doubt a non Jew in the US government thought up the idea of criminalizing BDS, which neither the government nor the public gets any benefit from.

    You don’t have to be German to be a Nazi, and likewise, you don’t have to be Jewish to be a Zionist. Lots of non-Jews in Congress want to criminalize BDS.

    • Replies: @mr meener
    , @Wally
  23. @Pinche Perro

    You are correct, sir, but any criticism of The Chosen–however constructive or well-meaning–summons Zombie Hitler and the 4 Horsemen of the Holocaust: Decentralized banks, Nationalism, Shiksas and Bacon.

  24. alexander says:

    I know this is off topic,

    But since we are discussing France, and its laws ….etc…

    Does anyone know if the French government has completed its full forensic fire investigation of the tragic fire at Notre Dame ?

    I trust they “have” done one by now….No ?

    Does anyone know the results ?

  25. mr meener says:

    all you gotta know is when the head rabbi in pissrael said…goyim are put here to serve the jews and israel. he is 100% right. name one leader of a 1st world power that does not kneel before the jew. even 3rd rate countries are doing it

  26. Truth3 says:

    Shamir has gone full-on Sophist with this one.

    Lying about how and what the Jews are doing to control the rest of Mankind does not have a place where Truth is required to change the Joo-Noo-World-Order paradigm.

    Jews… the great majority of them, act and think in unison…a Tribe. If they didn’t, they would be… well… Ron Unz or Gilad Atzmon. Jew-born but not Tribal. And you don’t see too many like Ron or Gilad, do you?

    If that wasn’t true, you’d see tens of thousands of Jews protesting against the Jew determined attempts to subjugate the rest of Mankind, as they have subjugated the Palestinians for 7 decades plus.

    Truth. It’s a wonderful thing.

  27. Richard B says:

    “The guilt and responsibility is of those who use them (Jews) as a pretext.
    You may argue that the comparison is forced.”

    Yes, I would. Because it is!

    “The French Jews, and certainly the Jews of the world, hold a wide variety of views, some of them agree with BHL in some points and some disagree, sometimes disagree strongly.”

    Presumably Mr. Shamir knows who Gilad Atzmon is. Then he might want to check out Mr. Atzmon’s video on “The Jewish Cognitive Elite.” In it he gives an excellent talk on how Jews present themselves as divided on various issues but reassures us that they are united on the issue of Jewish Supremacy. Though, of course, they don’t call it that.

    The irony of this article is that Mr. Shamir himself is protecting the Jews.

    The more power Jewish Supremacy acquires the harder it is to use the same old rhetorical bait-and-switch arguments. Which, I’m sorry to say, is what this otherwise fine article amounts to.

    • Replies: @mr meener
    , @L.K
  28. To see how the zionists control the zio/US read the book Blood In The Water by Joan Mellen about the joint Israeli and zio/US attack on the USS Liberty and the 52 year coverup of this war crime by Israel and the zio/US.

    The deception and traitorous acts of Israel and the zio/US knows no bounds!

    • Agree: Ace
  29. Richard B says:
    @Johnny Rottenborough

    “The question is: How will the people of Western countries free themselves from Jewish control when political, financial and media power is in the hands of Jews and their lackeys?”

    Well, certainly not by writing articles like this one. In it Mr.Shamir gives us a demonstration of how to write a rhetorically twisted article. Though, of course, he thought he was doing something else.

    Seriously, in an article titled “Protecting the Jews” he accuses an elite that are being used by Jews of using Jews by projecting Jews in an article that itself is protecting Jews by accusing the elite Jews are using of using them .

    I don’t know about the rest of you but I’m sick and tired of this spirit-crushing, life-destroying pretzel logic all for the purpose of protecting the Jews.

    • Replies: @renfro
  30. mr meener says:
    @Biff

    yes non jews that the jews own

  31. mr meener says:
    @Richard B

    Shamir is a very smart guy and excellent writer but he cant supress the inner demon that makes him protect jews and communists it is in his DNA. reminds me of the great Lon Chaney in the wolfman series. no matter how hard he tried to fight it when the moon came out he turned into the wolf. same with Shamir

  32. Richard B says:
    @Pinche Perro

    “I want what’s best for all people, including Jews.”

    I wish that was possible and I certainly felt that way until I accepted the fact that the majority of Jews I know and have come across in the flesh and in print simply do not want what’s best for us because they only want what’s best for them.

    All the Jews who occupy and control the power centers of the West want three things:

    1. to be placed above criticim
    2. loved unconditionally
    3. blindly obeyed

    As more and more of us are beginning to realize, the consequences of these insane demands are immense.

    So much so, that one is justified to extend the definition of Evil as,

    Any individual or group who has the power to effectuate the insane demands to be placed above criticism, loved unconditionally and blindly obeyed.

    • Replies: @Commentator Mike
  33. As always. Everywhere they control turns the natives of those lands into displaced persons in their ancient ancestral homelands – Aren’t we all Palestinians now? Of course there is no reason to blame them as that is bigoted and soon to be illegal everywhere on earth.

    Everywhere that resisted them for the precise reasons they repeatedly demonstrate throughout history, ultimately proves the concerns of the native inhabitants absolutely warranted. The Rape of Lakewood, the Opening of the Gates of Toledo, the Genocide of Mamilla and the placing of a modern parking lot on the mass graves of 90,000 Hellenic Europeans who were exterminated by the ancestors of our tormentors, the Kazarian Extermination of Christian Ukraine and the NY Times praising the forward progress, the ongoing ethnic cleansing of the natives of Palestine – so many historical precedents and ongoing acts of genocide that we mustn’t connect and are forbidden from seeing.

    • Replies: @anarchyst
    , @Fred Flintston
  34. @Macon Richardson

    LOL! Or India and Pakistan.Or the Sudan. Or Kenya. Or …

  35. @mr meener

    Shamir also denies any Jewish involvement in 9/11.

  36. @Richard B

    All the Jews who occupy and control the power centers of the West want three things:

    1. to be placed above criticim
    2. loved unconditionally
    3. blindly obeyed

    LOL, sounds like anybody’s wife. Or just about any woman.

  37. anarchyst says:
    @Sic Semper

    On a much smaller scale, at least here in “the good ol’ USA”, American police forces routinely send their “trainers” to Israel to “see how it’s done”. Witness the increase in unjustified murders committed by American police, “shoot first and be absolved of responsibility later”, getting a taxpayer-paid vacation in the process. Demanding instantaneous, but conflicting compliance by multiple police officers is the largest problem. Google “Daniel Shaver” for an example…
    It is interesting to note that far more whites are unjustifiably murdered by American police officers than blacks. “I feahed fo mah life” is the common excuse and works in most cases.
    We are all Palestinians, now.

  38. Anon000 says:

    In that interview I noticed Shamir is looking better these days. Maybe from a healthy diet and exercise (and better haircut)?

    “[Bernard-Henri Lévy] was a founder of the New Philosophers (Nouveaux Philosophes) school. This was a group of young intellectuals who were disenchanted with communist and socialist responses to the near-revolutionary upheavals in France of May 1968, and who developed an uncompromising moral critique of Marxist and socialist dogmas.” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernard-Henri_Lévy

    “I believe that, of all the achievements of my people, none has been nobler than the part the sons and daughters of Israel have taken in the great movement which has culminated in a free Russia.” — Rabbi Stephen Samuel Wise, The New York Times, March 24, 1917.

    “Jews occupy almost all important ambassadorial positions; universities , professions, judiciary and administration now have a greater percentage of Jews than of any other nationality. Antisemitism has been declared a state offense and is punished as counterrevolution.” — Rabbi Stephen Samuel Wise, Opinion magazine, December, 1933

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Samuel_Wise

    Zionism is their nationalism and communism is the bulldozer to eliminate all other nationalisms.

    The devil’s plan is to rule the whole world and his people are almost ready to deliver it to him. They control the world through finance (money)* with Zionism as their nationalism. They have historically used communism and socialism as their bulldozer to eliminate all other nationalisms and now use immigration and multiculturalism.

    * “Taking him to a high mountain, the devil showed him all the kingdoms of the world and their splendor. ‘I will give you all these,’ he said, ‘if you fall at my feet and worship me’.” (Luke 4:8-10).

    But their number one target for 2000 years has been the Catholic Church. They hate Jesus Christ. The communists in Spain, led by Rosenberg, murdered priests and nuns and then exhumed the bodies of nuns and propped them up outside the walls of their convents to mock them and attach obscene and offensive placards to their bodies.

    Nice people.

    We as Christians cannot tolerate any anti-Semitism so we must do what we’ve done for 2000 years and channel it into prayers for conversion. The power of prayer is irresistible. No doubt it was the prayers of faithful nuns in Rome which led Rabbi Israel Zolli, Chief Rabbi of Rome (1940-45), to be baptized in the Catholic Church in 1945 and receive Holy Communion before his death in 1956.

    • Agree: Al Liguori
    • Replies: @Sic Semper
    , @Colin Wright
  39. @Sic Semper

    A little more info on the parking lot and the rape of Lakewood would be much appreciated. The other instances of jewish treachery I have a grasp of.

  40. nsa says:
    @Johnny Rottenborough

    “How will the people free themselves from jew control?”
    The premise here is ass backwards……..white people in general, and Americans in particular, crave more jew control, not less. Half of all white people actually worship a mythical non-white jew zombie …….not a viking zombie, not a teutonic zombie, not an anglo-saxon zombie, not an irish zombie, not even a frigging polack zombie. Noooooooo…..has to be a fictitious non-white jew zombie.

  41. The key to unlocking the zionist chains that hold Americans in slavery on the zionist plantation aka the zio/US is to abolish their illegal and unconstitutional and privately owned money and debt creation machine aka the FED and also their IRS both of which were fastened on America in 1913.

    Free America abolish the FED and IRS!

  42. Titive says:

    “The government was free to disregard them saying they do not represent their Jewish citizens. ”
    Is this the same type of freedom that the British Royal Family has, when it comes to circumcise or not its Royal babies?

  43. anarchyst says:

    Lately there has been more “noise” about the jewish “holocaust” from jews themselves.
    In fact, the so-called “United States Holocaust Memorial Museum” (jewish “freak show”) has been protesting against those who are stating that there is moral equivalency with other instances of “mass genocide”, most of which are of much greater magnitude than that of the so-called jewish “holocaust”.
    In fact, when compared to the jewish Bolshevik communist “purges” and the Ukrainian “Holodomore”, the so-called jewish “holocaust” pales in comparison.
    As TRUTH comes out about this minor event in human (jewish) history, more and more people are seeing what a massive fraud has been perpetrated against the people of the world.
    One would think that jews would be happy to know that far less than “six-million” perished, but jewish reaction has been just the opposite. It is jewish fear that their “cash cow” is finally being exposed for the massive fraud that it is…

    • Replies: @Sic Semper
  44. @Macon Richardson

    ‘Yes, indeed! The thirteen British colonies in North America prove your point splendidly.’

    Interestingly and to some extent they do. You’ll note that prior to the outbreak of unrest in the mid-1770’s, there was almost literally no British garrison in the colonies — and whatever there may have been would have been to protect them from external threats.

    Of course Britain eventually lost control of her empire — the modern map demonstrates that irrefutably. However the point remains that while she held it, she was generally able to hold it with a minimum of force. For example, towards the end of the eighteenth century, British India and the princely states had a combined population of just under 300 million. To control these — and protect the frontiers — Britain required a garrison that contained 66,000 actual British soldiers. That works out to one white soldier for every four thousand-odd Indians.

    • Replies: @Colin Wright
  45. @Anon000

    What they did to Spain for 1000 years is unforgivable. That it is purposely forgotten makes all the more sense

  46. Wally says:
    @Biff

    What is a “Nazi”?

  47. @anarchyst

    Conservative estimates place the number of exterminated Ukrainians at 25 Million, the most ludicrous estimates of the “holocaust” place the number at 6 million, a number that does not bear up to scrutiny by the Red Cross’ official statistics. Each revision downward is never taken into account.

    Easily a five to one rate with the Ukrainians dutifully forgotten to history. Woe the irony of the tales of holocaust survivors 75 years later all over the world who are still telling their “stories” – I have yet to see a Holodomor Survivor tell theirs be it in 1940 let alone 2019. It would seem if there are millions of “survivors” 80 years later, it was not that effective of a liquidation.

    Anyone hear the tales of the Holodomor survivors? There weren’t any not five years, fifty nor 75 years later.

  48. @Johnny Rottenborough

    Your question, “How will the people of Western countries free themselves from Jewish control when political, financial and media power is in the hands of Jews and their lackeys?,” shows you to be as screwy with your asinine Jewish conspiracy theories (almost as ridiculous as the old trope, “Seven bald Jews in Zürich rule the whole world!”) as your buddy Israel Shamir with his anti-American conspiracy theory, ” If you occupy Afghanistan, do not admit you make a handsome profit smuggling heroin; say you came to protect the women,” and his absurd implication that the USA government (controlled by Jews of course) has spent trillions of dollars and lost thousands of US soldier in Afghanistan in order to smuggle Afghan heroin onto the world market.

    You and Shamir should go on a play date together, bring along the most Jew-hating Muslim you can find and you all can have a merry ol’ time of blaming all your problems, and the world’s problems, on the minuscule portion of the world that happens to be Jewish.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
  49. sally says:
    @Johnny Rottenborough

    It is necessary to understand that the everyday Jews and Christian Zionist are being used and have been used by the EZ, to accomplish the demands and goals of Economic Zionism. The everyday Jews (white or of color) are victims, deferentially educated, elevated to authoritative positions, and taught to respond to their Jewish Racial Heritage or Christian religious beliefs like epitomes in a immune system. In exchange for a devoted and proper response these victims of the propaganda are elevated to live a little better, life-style then the unfortunates. The EZ designate the believers to be slave drivers, with obligatory purpose to keep the unfortunates in line.

    So the elevated devotees are in fact instruments of the EZ. And workings of EZ depends on the devotees to control the behaviors of the governed unfortunates [distributed behavior control]. The EZ have chosen to use the elevated eligible victims of propaganda to drive and direct the toils the governed unfortunates must endure to make EZ work.

    The condition imposed on the Jew or devotee condition for his or her little bit better life-style is to bow down and to look the other way when Economic Zionism is active. Failure to do that, may deprive the elevated victims of his or her elevated status.

    Economic Zionism is a system of economics similar to organized crime.. it demands a monopoly in everything, it tolerates no competition, it takes no prisoners and it has no moral or humanistic instinct.. wars, sanctions, propaganda, lies, schemes, weapons, threats and other means are used to destroy competition, to gain advantage, broken promises, lies, etc. are no problem hence deceitful, misleading, false flag events, and outrageously misleading, continuously feed propaganda. EZ discounts humanity, even its own if they fail, as its property, as its slave, as an fuel to churn the pumps that generate the profits in EZ…EZ sees all resources around the globe as its own… No one but the EZ are entitled to own anything.. Once again, failure of an individual or corporate entity to maintain proper economic strength and political power ejects that entity from among the select few to human or corporate victim status. The EZ will eat their own so to speak.

    • Agree: Parfois1
    • Replies: @Druid
  50. @Colin Wright

    ‘…For example, towards the end of the eighteenth century, British India and the princely states had a combined population of just under 300 million..’

    Edit: for ‘eighteenth,’ read ‘nineteenth.’

  51. @ben sampson

    Your generalisation about Jews is either muddled thinking or imagination working hard in the absence of any real acquaintance with Jews. Just not true that they will in the end all line up for Israel above all. I know many of whom that is simply not true and, with your interest in the subject, you should be aware of vigorous Jewish critics within Israel against Israel’s human rights abuses.

    It is true as far as I can see that most Jews will defend Israel in some ways and might say that there were enough people slandering Israel in an unbalanced way for it them to say that they would defend Israel if push came to shove.

    • Replies: @ben sampson
  52. @Anon000

    ‘“Jews occupy almost all important ambassadorial positions; universities , professions, judiciary and administration now have a greater percentage of Jews than of any other nationality. Antisemitism has been declared a state offense and is punished as counterrevolution.” — Rabbi Stephen Samuel Wise, Opinion magazine, December, 1933

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Samuel_Wise’

    This quotation doesn’t seem to be in the Wikipedia article cited.

    • Replies: @Colin Wright
    , @Anon000
  53. @Justsaying

    me too! their responses would likely be enlightening

  54. BobbyT says:

    I have a problem with antisemitism. Why don’t you ever hear of antibedouinism? Or antiphilistineism? There’s only one. Antisemitism. What is it the Sematic people do that is so against the social norm that there constantly being persecuted for it? And isn’t that there fault? Shouldn’t they have to conform to the social norm, rather than the person calling them out being punished? Makes no sense to me.

  55. Talha says:
    @BobbyT

    I have a problem with antisemitism.

    Actual racial hatred of Jews should simply be classed under normal racism like for anyone else – not sure why they get a special category.

    Peace.

  56. @Colin Wright

    Yep. As near as I can make out, Rabbi Wise never said anything like the above. Something similar seems to have appeared in Opinion in December 1933 — but the author was a Mr. Zukerman, whoever he was.

    Now, you can prove me wrong, and leave me with egg on my face, but it’s my opinion that it’s easy enough to show a disproportionate association between Jews and Communism with verifiable facts. Relying on spurious quotations is both unnecessary and counter-productive.

  57. bjondo says:
    @Philip Smeeton

    Mass deportation, imprisonment of those responsible
    for whatever immigrant problems perceived.

  58. pyrrhus says:
    @Talha

    “Just lie back and think of Tel Aviv”…you untermenschen…

  59. Greg Bacon says: • Website

    If over 100 landlords had kicked me out of their rentals, due to my slovenly, thieving, crazy behavior, would I look in the mirror and change?
    Not if I was a Jew. I’d just constantly kvetch about how mean, miserable and anti-Semitic those nasty landlords were.

    And people wonder how someone like Hitler came into power.

    • Replies: @anarchyst
    , @Craig Nelsen
  60. @Wizard of Oz

    my real acquaintance with Jews can indeed be questioned. it is not extensive but substantial somewhat..ordinary working class Jews and a few professional ones to no great depth. and my imagination is not hard at work on this at all. actually its a comment made by another Jew that came to me relative to this same question of protecting Jews.

    it was noted that there are indeed Jews in positive critique of Likud/Zionist Israel and Jewish global polices who are seemingly sincere but that Jew in question. and it could have only been Gilad Atzmon or Mr Shamir himself in one of his recent contributions..who pointed out that yes indeed Jews are in every organizational leadership across the spectrum but no matter which side prevails they are indeed Jews

    I thought this an opportune point to raise that question, in view of what is happening in France in particular. the situation is not getting better, cant get better from a capitalist point of view. the people are losing in the west our collective social prognosis is not good. Chris Hedges last year came out directly calling for massive civil opposition as the way forward, an immediate precursor to revolution change

    Hedges does not call for violence but I do not see that violence can be avoided. the situation in my estimation is that bad

    Chomsky says that he sees no incipient fascism as parallel to the 1930’s but in that he is calming the people down. there is worse than incipient fascism because this is not the 1930’s. current we have a massive and developing technology that in the hands of the capitalist have made ordinary people redundant. redundancy makes every ordinary person a revolutionary conscious of it or not. the capitalist are conscious of it and their response is an attempt at creating a world over which they will have absolute control indefinitely

    is there evidence of this? everywhere look..yes indeed. so don’t look for a recurrence of the 1930″s and fascism. that makes no sense. look for developing Brave New World. how else can this day of capitalism 2019 be resolved from the capitalist point of view?

    so I am looking for Mr Shamir and Mr Unz right there! is this an accurate assessment..and if it is our popular responses are urgent, essential, comprehensive complete and final. we have arrived we have at a point of collective decision about the human future..whether we can survive at all given the way we have lived over the past thousand years at least. the options and potentials are Brave New World, popular democracies or war and environmental collapse.

    I am not interested at all in Jews fighting Israel for fighting sake. the situation is simple indeed: fight Israel because it is a suicidal anachronism that must disperse itself or merge and build a decent collective nation where they are. and I do wish to see an an a resolution of what appears to be Jewish religious insanity, based on what I know of the Jewish religion and their idea of being the chose and given the world and the rest of humanity as their own group ownership

    I am keen to an edge about thorough social revolution in the west and Jewish power stands against that potential 4-square everywhere. yet human freedom to control and apply the technological stage in the collective interest is equal to human survival, not the other way around

    so that is where I am coming from. Mr Unz has done intellectual work presented here I don’t think many around are capable.. of but I have not seen where he has dealt with this most urgent of topics. Mr Shamir as well

    • Replies: @Wizard of Oz
  61. anarchyst says:
    @BobbyT

    Most of today’s ((jews)) are NOT “semitic” but are eastern European converts to judaism…
    It is laughable to see them use the “anti-semitism” “race card”…

    • Replies: @Greg Bacon
  62. anarchyst says:
    @Greg Bacon

    Just recently there was a cabal of jews flying out of the Detroit airport that stunk so bad that they were kicked off the flight, and given a hotel room (overnight) so they could “clean themselves” up and fly out the next day.
    Of course, the old “anti-semitism” canard raised up its ugly head brought on by the jews’ own behavior…
    If I were the airline, I would have NOT given them a free night’s stay in a hotel…
    Once again, playing their own “victimhood” card, these jews felt that their own behavior was not responsible for how others reacted to them.

    • Replies: @Commentator Mike
  63. @BobbyT

    Actually antisemitism covers also antibedouinism and antiphilistineism since Bedouins and Palestinians are semites, while most of the Jews, the Khazarian ones, are not. So why did they choose not to call it straight out anti-Jewism but hide under that semite umbrella? Well they just like to confuse and complicate things unnecessarily, or necessarily for them. And then you must have heard the one about not naming the Jew, about not being found out. So the semite umbrella suits him just fine so abuse may run off like water off a raincoat.

  64. @anarchyst

    I’ve read of such cases elsewhere, like in a Swiss hotel. Why? Are they allergic to water? All the Jews I’ve known were no different in their hygiene than others they lived amongst, nor did I notice that their body odour was as strong as that of some other races/cultures.

    • Replies: @TheDraveckySnap
  65. L.K says:
    @renfro

    Sorry I don’t buy your defense unless French Jews are very different than US Jews.
    I seriously doubt a non Jew in the US government thought up the idea of criminalizing BDS, which neither the government nor the public gets any benefit from.

    Agreed.

  66. L.K says:
    @Richard B

    Presumably Mr. Shamir knows who Gilad Atzmon is. Then he might want to check out Mr. Atzmon’s video on “The Jewish Cognitive Elite.” In it he gives an excellent talk on how Jews present themselves as divided on various issues but reassures us that they are united on the issue of Jewish Supremacy. Though, of course, they don’t call it that.

    Atzmon then has reached conclusions in this regard similar to those of retired professor Kevin MacDonald, who has researched and written extensively about Jewish influence and behavior.

    From what I can tell, they seem to be correct.

    • Replies: @Johnny Rottenborough
  67. Old Jew says:
    @Talha

    Talha ,

    Most of the time your comments make sense….

    But above you slipped

    ….. “(and also at times rapists)”

    Can you cite any case where IDF soldiers raped Palestinian women
    (…… or Pakistani virgins?…..)

    • Replies: @Talha
    , @Antares
  68. @L.K

    L.K—Atzmon talks in this interview about reading Kevin MacDonald: ‘And it was heaven! I learned so much. It was beautiful. What a level of scholarship. He knows so much.’

  69. Cyrano says:

    Mistakes have been made, Jews will be blamed. Take multiculturalism for example. It was invented in order to demonstrate a phony generosity towards population that it’s not quite entitled to that “generosity”.

    The reason why multiculturalism was invented, was to avoid being fair towards those that deserve little bit more fairness – the domestic working class. But nowadays, being fair towards white people is racist, being “generous” towards anyone else makes you a great humanist.

    The Jews hitched a ride on the multiculturalism bandwagon for their own interests – not to destroy their “white homelands”, but because it’s a litmus test for their own safety. When western countries start becoming “unfriendly” towards the 3rd worlders – that’s a sign for the Jews that they could be next.

    And I don’t blame them, their experiences living in foreign countries pretty much throughout their history is a mixed back of acceptance and intolerance. How much of that intolerance they deserved is a question, they certainly didn’t deserve the extreme outbursts of unpopularity like the holocaust.

    I still think that the blame for all the mess in the western world rests on the shoulders of the western elites, who are preoccupied with retaining their wealth, their counties can go to hell – as far as they are concerned – and they are pretty much on their way there.

  70. The jews don’t need protection; the world needs protection from the jews.

    • Agree: DESERT FOX
  71. Greg Bacon says: • Website
    @anarchyst

    Most of today’s ((jews)) are NOT “semitic” but are eastern European converts to judaism…

    Try to bring up that bit of truth and you’ll be set upon in the same way a pack of hungry Pit Bulls would do to a rabbit.

    Good Goyim always remember to worship their most holy holocaust, with the grandkids of those millions of survivors now demanding reps, due to trauma to their DNA.

    Always demand that Israel be protected by American troops and money, regardless of what crazy scheme the Khazarians have cooked up and never, never NEVER ask why there are so many Jews in the upper ranks of our financial system.

  72. Greg Bacon says: • Website

    Can you cite any case where IDF soldiers raped Palestinian women
    (…… or Pakistani virgins?…..)

    I imagine that after the typical IDF diaper wearing thug shoots a Palestinian women in the stomach, she’s no longer appealing.

    On the other hand, there’s that IDF Chief Rabbi that says its OK for his toy soldiers to rape Goyim women, due to the stress of war and all of that. Actually, this butthead got promoted AFTER he instructed his soldiers to rape Goy women:

    After Apology Over Rape Comments, Eyal Karim Sworn In As IDF Chief Rabbi

    Replying to a reader’s question on the Kipa website that year, Karim said: “Although intercourse with a female gentile is very grave, it was permitted during wartime (under the conditions it stipulated) out of consideration for the soldiers’ difficulties. And since our concern is the success of the collective in the war, the Torah permitted [soldiers] to satisfy the evil urge under the conditions it stipulated for the sake of the collective’s success.”

    https://jewishweek.timesofisrael.com/after-apology-over-rape-comments-eyal-karim-sworn-in-as-idf-chief-rabbi/

    I’m guessing that the rabid Rabbi’s grave concerns were that ideologically pure Aryan, oops, excuse me, Khazarian blood would be mixing with those nasty Gentiles.

  73. @Cyrano

    It doesn’t really matter what the jews’ intentions are toward whites; the results of their handiwork means the destruction of white people.

    Horace Kallen wasn’t thinking about white well being when he invented cultural pluralism.

    You’re trying to claim that jews are innocent scapegoats and that is clearly not the case when they’ve been kicked out 109 times for the same kind of nasty behavior.

    They want to rule over all humanity but they have no right to do so, and they are not mentally equipped to rule over others. The jews’ particularism disqualifies their group from having the moral high ground and the wisdom to lead humanity.

    jews do what is good for the jews, and this racist outlook is the core of 90% of the problems that humanity faces today. The jews’ hyper-ethnocentrism endangers all of us.

    It’s not “scapegoating” to speak the truth about the subversive nature of organized jewry.

    • Agree: anarchyst, DESERT FOX
    • Replies: @Cyrano
  74. “the indomitable 93-year-old Malaysian Prime Minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad”

    I hope that his indomitable spirit is in his other ministers, The American FDA has gone to Indonesia demanding that they totally shut down their industry that produces kratom for export. This is being done at the behest of the opioid producing pharmaceutical companies since the former FDA head, Scott Gottlieb had no luck in getting kratom banned.

    Kratom is being used by pain management patients to wean themselves from addiction to opioids. It’s a non-psychoactive, non-addictive natural leaf that has been used in Asia for millennia and the opioid producers want it banned. Indonesia is the main producer and exporter of kratom, so the current crop of pinheads in the FDA think it reasonable to bully Indonesia into killing one of their industries to help bureaucrats in the USA collect their bribes from Big Pharma for eliminating alternatives to addictive opioids.

  75. Anonymous[246] • Disclaimer says:
    @MartinAlaskan

    ‘the old trope, “Seven bald Jews in Zürich rule the whole world!”)’

    Tell me more.

  76. Talha says:
    @Old Jew

    Hola Senor,

    I believe you misunderstood my comment (I can see why it could be construed that way).

    I was not saying IDF are rapists – I think their record is fairly good on that front honestly, though I’m sure some have committed or attempted rape if the situation allowed them to get away with it – but that’s not massively different from soldiers of other forces.

    What I meant was, that “Just stop resisting” which is what the Israeli official is stating is also something someone might here a rapist say.

    Hope that makes sense.

    Peace.

    • Replies: @Old Jew
  77. Anonymous[246] • Disclaimer says:
    @Cyrano

    ‘rests on the shoulders of the western elites,’

    The dominant factor of which is the Jewish elite minority. Gentile elites are deracinated.

  78. Cyrano says:
    @Robert Dolan

    I think that if there is one quality that the Jews possess and which most people find annoying – it’s their adaptability. Throw them in the middle of the communist revolution – they come out as the most outspoken commie-tsars, throw them in the middle of capitalist degeneracy – they come out as the most successful capitalist tsars. They never invent the system, but they find the way to use it to their advantage. I would still blame those who invent the rules, not those who learn how to play the game the best.

    • Replies: @Druid
  79. Antares says:
    @Old Jew

    You didn’t understand the comparison. Interestingly, I made the exact same comparison years ago, independently of Talha. I had never read it anywhere. It did not come out of my mind but out of the situation.

  80. @Commentator Mike

    I’ve experienced two male Jewish roomates who must have incarnated in the form of skunks during past lives. Each was good-looking and very wealthy. Despite these advantages, skunk number one smelled so terrible at times we eventually threw him in the fraternity showers and then locked him out on the roof mid-Ann Arbor winter buck naked afterwards. He found a frozen orange there somehow and hammered out a glass pane to unlock the window. We almost attempted to drive the point home a second time such was the fetidness. My other Tribal roomie was my childhood BFF for decades until he went “super Jewish” last year and purged all of his goy friends without advance notice. The BFF reeked of BO to the extent his bath towels retained their bouquet after they had been laundered. Once, he couldn’t meet his half of the rent and attempted to hide on our fire escape when the buiing manager knocked and entered. I answered with the customary bullsh!te and my check but the manager wasn’t fooled and said he could smell my friend was home. It could have been a bath towel that betrayed, I suppose. In fairness, those of us from European backgrounds tend to stink behind our ears although that aroma is one of aged cheese and there’s nothin’ wrong with it, I say.

  81. Anon000 says:
    @Colin Wright

    I included the Wikipedia link just as a bio. This quotation comes from Make Yourself An Ark! by Fr. Andrew O’Brien, p. 35. http://www.staugustinechapel.org/Library/books_pdf/Fr%20Andrew%20OBrien%20Make-Yourself-an-Ark.pdf
    He has no footnotes. On the next page he quotes Rabbi Wise’s son:

    James Waterman Wise, son of Rabbi Stephen, in an article in the magazine that he edited, New Masses, on October 29, 1935, took to task promi- nent Jews who, as he wrote, “hysterically deny that Communism is Jewish and frenziedly repudiate Jews who are Communists. Their statement libels Soviet Russia and lies about the Jewish people.”

    Maybe he got the magazine or the attribution wrong. Not cool. I’ll dispose of this book immediately.

    • Replies: @Ace
  82. @ben sampson

    Well you certainly seem sincere. (No subtle ambiguity in my words here. I recall attending a typically brilliant lecture by Isaiah Berlin on, in effect, the history of “sincerity” as a virtue. It decidedly wasn’t enough to save heretics in Catholic or Protestant 16th century Europe, or much of the Muslim world now). But I hope you are wrong and unnecessarily worried.

    In Australia I look forward to our having, despite dysgenic breeding, but because of a more or less sensible immigration policy, enough smart energetic people to maintain the prosperity that allows the multitude of not very bright to enjoy life in our version of welfarist liberal democracy. You might cite the huge political donations of the likes of Sheldon Adelson in support of your almost apocalyptic fears. Let me contrast Australia’s situation. At the last federal election the two main parties (Liberals plus Nationals, still in government and Labor – meant to win according to the polls) spent of the order of $20 million each. The big spending ($50 million and counting) was done by Clive Palmer for his United Australia Party which didn’t win a seat in either house but probably helped defeat Labor. Clive Palmer is decidedly not Jewish.

  83. Parfois1 says:
    @Cyrano

    I still think that the blame for all the mess in the western world rests on the shoulders of the western elites, who are preoccupied with retaining their wealth, their counties can go to hell – as far as they are concerned – and they are pretty much on their way there.

    But you are deluded to think that way, a heretic against the orthodoxy of the overwhelming commentariat here who bleat “we are the poor victims of the vile Jews who keep us in chains” or some thing like that – the very same thing they, the Jews say, the eternal victims. Ouch! Have I discovered they are ad idem (of the same mind)!

    And, of course the ruling elite at the top of the perch laugh their heads off in amusement and relishing the thought that they are safely protected while the deplorable proles exhaust themselves in impotent rage against the Jews, their fellow allies in victimhood, and the browns and blacks from the tropics.

    Another thing as hypocritical is the glaring similarity between the current US Jewish-led ruling elite with all previous generations of ruling elites. What they are doing now is not different from what they have done before since Monroe’s time – gunboat diplomacy imperialism – except for a brief respite when the USSR was on the scene to prevent foolish velleities.

    Besides, the Jewish supremacists in power now are only doing what is expected of anyone in the same position: to derive and profit from their position of power! They maybe more blunt than previous capitalist regimes (perhaps they enjoy seeing the goyim’s faces pressed on the dirt under a Jew boot) but what would you expect of a symbiotic union of Zion and Capitalism in greed and power?

    • Disagree: Robert Dolan
    • Replies: @Robert Dolan
    , @Robjil
  84. @Parfois1

    Dumbass, the difference between whites complaining and jews whining is that whites really ARE getting fucked, while jews are pretending to be victims while screwing everybody in sight.

    What an absurd comment!

    The ruling elite at the top are JEWS. The jews aren’t working for some secret WASP elite that nobody can locate. The jews displaced the WASP elite and that is why the west is DYING.

    You defend the rapacious jews and you claim that they are doing what is expected of people in positions of power?

    Fuck you, you moronic lowlife imbecile. The WASP elite might had had its’ share of assholes, but they surely served the people below with far more regard than the hostile jewish elite that is WRECKING every white nation on earth.

    I had to read your bullshit comment three times because the idiocy was so breathtaking.

    Now go back to the glory hole where you belong you stupid POS.

    • Agree: DESERT FOX, Druid
    • Replies: @Skeptikal
  85. @Cyrano

    Jews are well and truly part and parcel of those western elites. Not all Jews mind you, but those that count for anything.

    • Replies: @Cyrano
  86. renfro says:
    @Richard B

    I don’t know about the rest of you but I’m sick and tired of this spirit-crushing, life-destroying pretzel logic all for the purpose of protecting the Jews.

    So am I, I find it insulting that we are expected to fall for such pilpul as this article.

    Oh yes , ‘elites’ who are 99% interested only in money and power and the ‘government ‘interested only in not being overthrown have decided that the way to protect elite and government interest is to pass laws on anti-Semitism for the Jews…..rotflmao

    I have read few gatekeeping for the Jews essays as absurd as this one.

  87. Johnny Rottenborough above asks “How will the people of Western countries free themselves from Jewish control when political, financial and media power is in the hands of Jews and their lackeys?”

    Think about it. Every time a nation or ethnic group singles out the Jewish Zio lobby to stop their abuses of power they simply feed on the polarity. What is at the root of the problem? From the point of view of the host nation, is it not their exclusiveness in which the silver rule does not extend outside of their ethnic group, and their are no limits? Look at what they did to Syria. However, from their point of view, is it not an exclusiveness in which any criticism and prejudice is used to reinforce it and strengthen the justification for the polarity? They likely ask, “Why should anyone or any group be more loyal to a host nation or a world of human zombies who despise their unique identity and are jealous of their success?” We ask, “But what of the continuation of WWI, the control of finances, the media, the legislatures, WWII, the creation of Israel and 9/11??” They say it was all necessary for Israel.

    So we find more and more examples of the restlessness and abuse of power and we become more and more polarized. To what end? We find most Jewish people to be loyal to their tribe but quite reasonable, very intelligent, and good citizens believing that the silver rule extends beyond their tribe. We find a minority of elites made up of assholes from all tribes, ethnic groups and religions fuking us and the rest of the world over and over again and we remain powerless to depose them. If it is really one tribal group behind so much of the trouble in the world, then it is likely that group with the most power which is the most corrupt. In this respect I cannot help but point the finger at my own ancestral tribe or group which is Anglo group.

    So how do we change selfish or exclusive groups to respect the basic rights of others and get out of their abuse-of-power, might-makes-right disorder and stop the bullshit? The answer is that we need religious and deeply entrenched values which are truly universal and not the “me first” or exclusive ones in which people think they have a right to inflict harm to others which they do not want done to themselves. Instead of feeding a polarity which only makes the opposition stronger and more alienated and then leads to more and more violence and suffering, we have to start with openly inviting and praying for the conversion of all such who are suck in such a backward time warp and prison of their own exclusiveness.

    • Replies: @Parfois1
  88. Cyrano says:
    @Commentator Mike

    What are the Jews supposed to do? Join the western proles in the doldrums in order to gain popularity with them? If I was a Jew I wouldn’t do that either. It’s a thankless job of solidarity with those that don’t count for much – influence and wealth wise. For all the mess in the west I would still blame their elites – particularly those of Anglo-Saxofon persuasion – for their trickery and phoniness.

    • Disagree: Robert Dolan
    • Replies: @Svigor
    , @Svigor
  89. Parfois1 says:
    @Fred Baggins

    . Instead of feeding a polarity which only makes the opposition stronger and more alienated and then leads to more and more violence and suffering, we have to start with openly inviting and praying for the conversion of all such who are suck in such a backward time warp and prison of their own exclusiveness.

    You are right about appealing to moral reasoning to break the mindless cycle of “blaming the other” when in fact it is within our power to change the conditions leading to the appalling state of affairs in the Western nations where a tiny minority sways the will of the overwhelming majority. How do they do it?

    Just read the lessons of history. It is all splashed before our eyes, and then deduce from the cause and effect connection why we are here. My culprit is greed: the greediest you are the more powerful you’ll get. And that’s why a small tribe is now the most dominant force in the world. Of course, this does not happen in a mechanical sense in a vacuum, it happens in the physical and social world with its multitude of synapses firing controlled and random rounds under the direction of a superior brain: allegorically Goldstein, the Jewish brain.

    Quite early after getting a notice to quit from the Romans (and even before in Egypt), the Jews, in the same fashion as the little nuisances, attached themselves to the rich and powerful. Therefore, clever as they are, they use the host for protection and exploitation while remaining hiding in the orifices of the host. While the same process happened elsewhere, the account from ecclesiastical sources at the time indicate that Jews collaborated with the Muslims in the invasion of Iberia (VIII Century) and became the tax farmers for Islam and advisers to the khalifs. Later there was swift retaliation by the Christian proles leading to kings enacting laws making Jews property of the Crown as a device for protection, paid of course.

    There you are. The French (and others) laws for the protection of Jews as a privileged breed, are not recent inventions, they were in use in the Middle Ages. But those were the times when the monarchs had absolute power, which they did sometimes to withdraw protection and even ordering expulsion – it was a precarious protection subject to the whim of a king. And that was the case up to the last Czar.

    On the other hand, with the rise of Mercantilism and Capitalism in Europe, within societies veering to Liberalism, the conditions were set for Jewry to prosper beyond being a protected species and aiming for greater ambitions. It took some time to reach the top, soon the apogee, but one has to admire their perseverance, single-mindedness, cohesion and, if you are a capitalist stooge, their greed – the lubricant that opens the gates of power and filthy lucre.

  90. Svigor says:

    “Protecting the Jews”

    In the spirit of that theme:

    Go ahead and make Aliyah ASAP, boys.

    Don’t say we never warned you.

  91. Svigor says:
    @Cyrano

    Leave. They have a country. Which is more than Whites have. For now. By the time that is corrected, I’m guessing Whites will not have warm feelings for the tribe.

    • Replies: @Antares
  92. Svigor says:
    @Cyrano

    For all the mess in the west I would still blame their elites – particularly those of Anglo-Saxofon persuasion – for their trickery and phoniness.

    The well of goys willing to throw everyone under the bus on behalf of Jews seems bottomless, but it’ll run out sooner than later. Probably right around the time the throwing becomes a liability, rather than an asset.

    The idea that Whites are going to blame their own kind, rather than the alien Jew, is naive. Even if Jews weren’t the main culprits, it’d be naive. Read up on Social Identity Theory. Sure, the zeitgeist is bucking the normal trends of human nature, but it’ll snap back to nature eventually, as it always does. As it has so many times before. Perfect time to get out now while you’re way up against the house, Jews.

    But they never listen.

    Couldn’t happen to a nicer bunch, tho.

  93. Ace says:
    @Anon000

    Maybe he didn’t. Why dispose of the book?

  94. @renfro

    I seriously doubt a non Jew in the US government thought up the idea of criminalizing BDS, which neither the government nor the public gets any benefit from.

    The pressure to ban BDS probably came from Tel Aviv.

    • Replies: @Craig Nelsen
  95. @Talha

    That’s how it was for the Wild West. Out with the teepees, in with MacDonalds and the freeways.

    • Replies: @Talha
  96. Robjil says:
    @Parfois1

    The biggest problem with our J Elite is that it has total protection with big 6 umbrella.

    911 was an Israel and US, its colony, job.

    Yet no one says anything. Why? The big 6 protection umbrella.

    Chuck Orloski noted that Bollyn’s article talked about Ehud Barak as being one the prime suspects in the 9/11 crime. The article is quite interesting. It brings up quotes from Socrates. Graetz, a 19th century German Jewish historian, hated German culture and Greek culture. Ironic, Socrates could one of the reasons he was so anti-Greek.

    http://www.bollyn.com/9-11-archive-2010/#article_12561

    The history of the past 100 years has been J advisors pushing for wars – WWI, WWII and the present 9/11 wars. Douglas Reed’s The controversy of Zion explains how they did it in the first two big wars. In the present wars it so obvious, neocons are J or J driven.

    All J advisor wars in the past 100 years have been about destruction – total destruction. Wesley Clark mentioned the theme for the present wars – Destroy seven nations. A Torah concept from Deut. 7.1-2.

    “Badness always manifests in destruction and corruption, while goodness always manifests in preservation and benefit.
    – Socrates in Plato’s Republic (ca. 374 B.C.) ”

    The ADL has been on a mad rush for complete censorship of anyone who questions any crimes by big Js or Israel. The ADL is thus the most “anti-semitic” group in the world according to Socrates’s thinking. J Criminals going unpunished grow worst and worst. What will it take for the ADL to allow anyone to question J and Israel crimes? a nuke war?

    “And how can it be profitable for a person’s immorality to go unnoticed and unpunished?  The consequence of a criminal getting away with his crimes is that he becomes a worse person.”
    – Socrates in Plato’s Republic, “Happiness and Unhappiness”

  97. Talha says:
    @Niebelheim

    That’s probably how it would go.

    Peace.

  98. You’re right there. As long as the economy prospers and there is enough to go around for everybody, ethnic tensions can be kept under control. But if the economy drops or collapses, then people start looking for someone to blame, rightly or wrongly. But I fear that if and when it gets to that stage, the Jews will be gone to other pastures and we’ll be left here with the Muslims. It won’t be pretty.

    • Replies: @Commentator Mike
  99. bjondo says:

    Shamir’s point correct.
    The only hope for the Sorals.
    IS playing 4 dimensional chess.

    Some parts of West are insane.
    Other parts totalitarian.

    Gotta outwit.

    5ds

  100. Half-Jap says:

    Perhaps the most powerful defense of Jewry I’ve ever seen. Even I feel a certain pride in the arguments made, in which politically interested organizations do not and shall never represent the rest of us not in agreement with them. The ‘JEWS’ are easily demonized for varied good and imagined reasons, but they are not just a ‘they.’ They do tend to support one other, but they are contentious. Any victory would be aided by the Jews, who understand the value of kin and connection.

    • Replies: @Craig Nelsen
  101. Antares says:
    @Svigor

    I certainly don’t want to start another discussion here, but I have to mention that that is not their country.

  102. Druid says:
    @Cyrano

    Abuse the game the best!

  103. Druid says:
    @sally

    In other words, the behaviour of the EZ is Talmudism. If the ordinary Jew gains financial power, they will gladly embrace their Talmudism as well, or be attacked by their fellows

  104. Skeptikal says:
    @Robert Dolan

    “The WASP elite might had had its’ share of assholes, but they surely served the people below with far more regard than the hostile jewish elite that is WRECKING every white nation on earth.”

    Absolutely.
    The WASP elite had some sense of identification and caring for the unfortunate, the needy, etc.
    Cared a lot more for society as a whole and had more of a service ethic to all of society—not just to poor Jews.
    I think it might be the difference between Christianity, taking Christ as a model or a guide, and Judaism (where are the human models? Moses? ).
    Many WASP elites were god-fearing.

    • Agree: Robjil
  105. @foolisholdman

    The pressure to ban BDS probably came from Tel Aviv.

    Tel Aviv and Los Angeles. Haim Saban, owner of Univision, dual nationality Jewish billionaire pushed the ban BDS thing. The Wikileaks Podesta dump has Saban, Soros, the Clinton campaign, and a Jewish academic acting as an Israeli government representative exchanging emails and working out the strategy.

    It is an outrage that Assange is in jail and Soros isn’t.

  106. @Half-Jap

    Any victory would be aided by the Jews, who understand the value of kin and connection.

    …another way of saying “nepotistic”.

    It isn’t Jewish nepotism that’s the problem, it’s that they continue to practice nepotism while condemning our nepotism as evil. They renamed our nepotism “racism” and convinced us it was the worst possible sin. They exploited our cultural value of fair play to gain a toehold in the media, in government, in academia, and in business, then engaged in relentless nepotism until they obtained a strangle hold or near strangle hold in many crucial areas. Hostile and lethal.

    You are right that it is wrong to say “the Jews” did this because, obviously, not all Jews are the same. It is also “wrong” to say the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor. But you won’t win on Jeopardy answering that way.

    What “victory” in your quote above?

  107. @Greg Bacon

    If over 100 landlords had kicked me out of their rentals, due to my slovenly, thieving, crazy behavior, would I look in the mirror and change?

    Well, maybe not. Not if there were still a supply of landlords willing to rent to you. You might decide it is more profitable to take the place, extract every bit of value you can, not pay the rent, sublet to others, then, when finally forced out, rip out the appliances and wiring on your way out.

  108. half the world is burning (thru wars, hunger, etc) and you sir would like us to care about some spoiled brats burning pics of some self-important yid? i hope you will treat your readers with some topic more useful next tine. toda raba!

  109. Ma Laoshi says:

    Part of me says that the French now need some quality time feeling the boot on their necks, all the better to be confronted with the consequences of their own choices. Last election they had a socialist, a nationalist, and a conservative on the menu–no doubt all with severe flaws. Then they went “But how do we know that our choice is the right one without jewish approval? After all, everybody knows that jews are better and higher than ourselves.” So just to be on the safe side, they elected a Zionist Rothschild investment banker. A fair case can be made that Trump betrayed his voters, but Macron has mostly done what could’ve been safely predicted–in many cases what he openly promised.

    In Mr. Shamir’s reasoning, the Talmud is shining through. What do I know, it may even be the truth, or at least the right way to play it in a courtroom. But do you expect this to connect with the French public, who were mostly brought up without the Talmud? Isn’t our struggle a struggle against the power which certain words have over us? Why not say: “A-word? There hasn’t been nearly enough A-word for over a generation, and as a result our kosher friends think they can get away with literally anything in the absence of a countervailing force. So bring on the A-word.” Kinda would make the point that we are the majority, and we are not afraid any more.

  110. Israel Shamir,is unconvincingly trying to get absolution for the Jews,and lay almost the full blame on the governments of the European countries,forgetting that all those governments acts as they were elected to serve the Jewish people more than their own citizens.It takes only one Jew in Australia or England,objecting a speech event by David Icke, the municipal authority of that town will obediently cancel the event. Jews in fact enjoys this power,no matter how falsely they claim that they don’t agree with it,it matches their sense of being special,smart,and perhaps the chosen people.

    How many French Jews are organized to fight the influence of CRIF and LICRA? How many British Jews are fighting back the smear campaign against Jeremy Corbyn? Where are the American Jews against AIPAC, ADL,? Of course there are many,but definitely not enough,very weak,and I think it’s not real.

    The overwhelming picture of the Jews around the world is not nice( to say the least),they’re very small minority in all western”democracies”,but they control almost all the financial and banking institutions,they control the politicians,they control the press and media,they control the education policy,they control the Judiciary,they almost even control the military,Israel attacked USS Libertyin the 6 days war,killing and wounding Americans deliberately,and they get away with it,Israel occupies Palestinian’s land,destroys their homes,kill and wound demonstrators,defy all international and human rights laws,and not a mention of objection,criticism,let alone sanctions from the western governments side.

    The whole picture of the Jews and Jewish deeds is mired with blood,destruction and wars, at present and deep in past history, and more people around the world are beginning to pay attention to those facts and link them to the Jewish character, & Jews as race,tribe & religion,and they’ll not stop to separate the few good Jews from the overwhelmingly powerful evil group,and since majority of the Jews are silent and ineffective against the evil criminal Jews,they’ll be regarded as accomplices in the crimes.

    My advice to Mr. Shamir is that instead of trying to disentangle the Jewish people from the Jewish crimes,he should start to organize a powerful movement to educate the Jews that what’s been done in their name is against their interests,and will blowback against them, this movement is about saving the Jews from the evil ones,

    • Agree: DESERT FOX
  111. anarchyst says:

    Presently, the jews are “biting off more than they can chew and swallow” with the criminalization of those who do not believe the “holocaust” fable. More and more people are realizing that almost everything any jewish “holocaust survivor” states is based on outright fabrications and impossibilities. From the color of smoke defining “jewishness” to “blood spurting from the ground” indicating jewishness and “shrunken heads, jewish soap and lampshades, oh my…the fabrications just kep on coming. Let’s not forget the Yad Vashem “database” that is artificially inflated to keep the “six-million” dream alive.
    The jews’ latest attempts to prosecute those who do not bow to the religion of “holocaustianity” WILL fail, as more and more people realize that censoring the quest for TRUTH by criminalizing ANY honest investigation of the “holohoax” is problematic to most normal human beings.
    Attempts to criminalize the BDS movement will lead to the same results.
    Look out, jews–being expelled from country 110 is on the horizon.

  112. @mr meener

    he cant supress the inner demon that makes him protect jews and communists it is in his DNA

    Bravo.

    And Mr Shamir, I genuinely believe, is a GOOD man, educated, worldly-wise, healthily-cynical, massively intelligent and morally sound, who is trying hard to see the light, keep hold of righteousness and preach the truth.

    So imagine what it’s like being – or trying to talk to – millions of “ordinary” Jews who don’t have any of those priorities, believe everything Zionist propaganda tells them, and donate money to monsters and demons like Soros who tell them Jews are about to be wiped out (again) and must be protected from anti-Semitic hate.

    There is NO dealing with these deranged and morally-degenerate people. They have to be quarantined forever AWAY from our world in order to protect the sane and the capable from profound destructive, demonic moral and mental contagion.

  113. anon[423] • Disclaimer says:
    @druid55

    A lot of average talent scientist make it to the top, because they are Jewish. Then they get noble prize

  114. anon19 says:
    @Cyrano

    The Jews are 99% to blame sport.

  115. Titus says:

    You may argue that the comparison is forced, for the French Jewish bodies actively participate in this campaign against French freedom. Yes, that’s true, but these organisations are voluntary self-appointed guardians of Jewish interest. Jews didn’t vote for them, didn’t elect them. The government was free to disregard them saying they do not represent their Jewish citizens

    Sure thing, Israel. I suppose next you’ll tell us the Bolshevik Revolution wasn’t a Jewish operation. Oh wait… You already did that in an article on Unz.

    Your error here is the fallacy of division (aka NAXALT). A fallacy of division is the error in logic that occurs when one reasons that something that is true for a whole must also be true of all or some of its parts.

    Whether or not every single Jew in France support the actions of these “organisations” is irrelevant. Jews are still the people influencing the outcomes. You have a remarkable capacity weave scapegoating of Jews into your critique of the Jewish community. Wizardy.

  116. Vojkan says:

    You get more jail time in France for criticising Jews than for acts of violence that inflict physical injuries or destroy people’s property.

  117. JamesinNM says:

    After Christ’s death and resurrection, Christians with changed hearts regardless of ethnic background are the real Jews and God’s chosen people (Romans 2:28-29).

  118. @Colin Wright

    About the character of British rule I suggest you consult the people of India.

  119. I hate to say this Israel/Adam, but on the one hand, your article is brilliant, on the other, lackluster.

    Inherent contradictions and palatable incoherence.

    Your authoritative voice is grounded in being Jewish. Same goes for Atzmon, same goes for me.

    If you were really Christian, what could you really say about Jews? Atzmon can be asked the same question. Perhaps I can as well.

    Perhaps your Christianity is like that of Mystical Anarchism…?

    We risk ending up like Arthur Meyer of Le Gaulois. (viz e Coralnik in “Accross the Great Divide”)

Current Commenter
says:

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone


 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments become the property of The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Israel Shamir Comments via RSS