
◄►◄❌►▲ ▼▲▼ • BNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
Trump's critics quickly seized on this moment, launching a barrage of tweets and articles claiming he had refused to condemn white supremacy outright. However, it's essential to note that Trump has previously denounced white nationalists following the 2017 Unite the Right rally, stating that he condemned neo-Nazis and white supremacists while also suggesting there were "very fine people" on both sides of the protest. This complexity in his messaging has fueled ongoing narratives that he is sympathetic to white supremacist ideologies, a notion that has been utilized by his opponents, particularly Joe Biden, to frame their campaign narratives.
In the debate, Biden claimed that Antifa is merely an "idea" rather than an organized group, a statement that contradicts the existence of various Antifa factions which have engaged in activism under that banner. The discussion around Antifa and its structure has been contentious, with many on the right arguing that these groups are not only real but pose a significant threat to public safety. The media’s framing of Antifa and the conflation of various leftist groups with the broader concept of left-wing extremism complicates the dialogue surrounding political violence and accountability. Trump's insistence on this distinction reflects a broader narrative he has pushed regarding the threat posed by leftist groups compared to the far-right.
Another significant topic was Critical Race Theory (CRT), which Trump criticized during the debate. Wallace framed this issue as a matter of ending racial sensitivity training, which Trump rightly argued is distinct from CRT, a framework that posits systemic racism in American institutions. Critics of CRT argue that it promotes divisive and anti-white sentiments, with Trump asserting that taxpayer dollars should not support a program he considers racist. Biden dismissed these claims, countering that Trump's remarks were indicative of his own racism. The debate around these issues reflects deeper societal divides regarding race, identity, and the role of government in addressing systemic inequalities. As the election approaches, both candidates will likely continue to leverage these issues to galvanize their respective bases, underscoring the polarizing nature of contemporary American politics.
## I. Overview of the Debate Dynamics
A. President Trump’s assertion about media bias
1. Trump claimed he was debating Chris Wallace, not Joe Biden.
2. Highlights a broader trend of media opposition to Trump.
## II. Media Reaction to Trump's Comments
A. Claims of Trump's refusal to denounce white supremacy
1. Outrage over lack of specific disavowal of the Proud Boys.
2. Tim Scott’s comments reinforcing the narrative of Trump "misspeaking."
B. Social media response
1. Numerous stories and tweets criticizing Trump’s stance.
2. High engagement on critical tweets, indicating public interest.
## III. Transcript Highlights from the Debate
A. Discussion between Chris Wallace and Donald Trump
1. Wallace prompts Trump to condemn white supremacist groups.
2. Trump expresses willingness to condemn but seeks specifics.
B. Trump's statement regarding the Proud Boys
1. "Proud Boys, stand back and stand by" interpreted as a call to action.
2. Trump emphasizes left-wing violence as a broader issue.
## IV. Misinterpretation of Trump's Statements
A. Analysis of Trump's language
1. Possible verbal misstep with “stand back and stand by.”
2. No direct call for Proud Boys to march or act violently.
B. Context of the Proud Boys
1. Described as a multiracial group of civic nationalists.
2. Questioning the need for them to "stand down" in the context of violence.
## V. Historical Context of Trump's Disavowals
A. Trump's previous disavowal of white nationalists
1. Reference to his statements after the Unite The Right rally in 2017.
2. Contrasting narrative of Trump as a supporter of white supremacy.
B. Misrepresentation of Trump’s comments
1. Biden’s campaign leveraging the mischaracterization of Trump's statements.
## VI. Discussion on Antifa
A. Biden's claim that Antifa is merely an "idea"
1. Refutation of this statement; Antifa as organized groups.
2. Acknowledgment of specific Antifa leaders and funding sources.
B. Media portrayal of Antifa
1. Historical media references to Antifa as a group.
2. Expectation for Biden to recognize the existence of organized Antifa.
## VII. Critical Race Theory (CRT) and Debate Misrepresentation
A. Wallace's framing of CRT as racial sensitivity training
1. Distinction between CRT and sensitivity training.
2. Claims that CRT is inherently anti-white and racist.
B. Implications of teaching CRT
1. Concerns about the survival of institutions teaching inherent racism.
2. Public perception of taxpayer funding for CRT initiatives.
## VIII. Political Ramifications of the Debate
A. Biden's campaign strategy
1. Linking Trump’s comments to white supremacy to undermine his support.
2. Potentially defamatory claims connecting Trump to Rittenhouse.
B. The ongoing chaos in American cities
1. Contrasting Biden's focus on Charlottesville with current unrest.
2. Suggestion that media bias protects Biden from scrutiny.
## IX. Conclusion: Trump's Position and Public Perception
A. Trump’s perceived lack of support for white interests
1. Criticism of Trump for not defending his supporters from 2016.
2. Desire for a stronger nationalist stance from Trump.
B. Fair-mindedness as a controversial trait in current politics
1. Notion that fairness should be a given in a healthy society.
2. The current political climate framing fairness as a scandal.
This outline captures the key arguments presented in the article regarding the recent presidential debate, media responses, and broader implications surrounding the discussion of race, violence, and political narratives.
Last night’s presidential debate revealed the faulty assumptions most media are using against President Trump. President Trump was right when he said to moderator Chris Wallace, “I guess I’m debating you, not him, but OK.” President Trump is debating almost all media outlets and journalists.
This morning, there are countless stories and tweets that President Trump “refused” to denounce white supremacy. Many people claim they are outraged because President Trump didn’t specifically disavow the Proud Boys. Tim Scott is also falling into this trap by saying the president “misspoke.”
Colbert calls Trump's refusal to condemn the white nationalist men's rights group Proud Boys “one of the most telling, one of the most upsetting moments, not only of the night, but of my lifetime” https://t.co/HgFPfz39yZ
— Marlow Stern (@MarlowNYC) September 30, 2020
Trump refuses to denounce white supremacy, says "stand back and stand by" on Proud Boys movement https://t.co/djPe4dZoNP pic.twitter.com/SG2kzUwBqv
— The Hill (@thehill) September 30, 2020
Trump didn’t denounce White supremacists. He told them to “stand back and stand by.” This wasn’t an accident.
— Marc Lamont Hill (@marclamonthill) September 30, 2020
That last tweet has almost 310,000 likes.
What did President Trump actually say?
Chris Wallace: (41:33) You have repeatedly criticized the vice president for not specifically calling out Antifa and other left wing extremist groups. But are you willing tonight to condemn white supremacists and militia groups and to say that they need to stand down and not add to the violence in a number of these cities as we saw in Kenosha and as we’ve seen in Portland.
Donald J. Trump: (41:57) Sure, I’m willing to do that.
CW: (41:59) Are you prepared specifically to do it.
DJT: (42:00) I would say, almost everything I see is from the left wing not from the right wing.
CW: (42:04) But what are you saying?
DJT: (42:06) I’m willing to do anything. I want to see peace.
CW: (42:08) Well, do it, sir.
Joe Biden: (42:09) Say it, do it say it.
DJT: (42:10) What do you want to call them? Give me a name, give me a name, go ahead who do you want me to condemn?
CW: (42:14) White supremacist and right-wing militia.
DJT: (42:18) Proud Boys, stand back and stand by. But I’ll tell you what: Somebody’s got to do something about Antifa and the left because this is not a right-wing problem this is a left wing.
JB: (42:28) He’s own FBI Director said unlike white supremacist; Antifa is an idea not an organization-
DJT: (42:35) Oh, you got to be kidding me.
JB: (42:36) . . . not a militia. That’s what his FBI Director said.
DJT: (42:41) Well, then you know what, he’s wrong.
CW: (42:42) We’re done, sir. Moving onto the next… [crosstalk 00:42:46]
DJT: (42:46) Antifa is bad.
JB: (42:47) Everybody in your administration tells you the true, it’s a bad idea. You have no idea about anything.
DJT: (42:53) You know what, Antifa is a dangerous radical group.
CW: (42:56) All right, gentlemen we’re now moving onto the Trump-Biden record.
DJT: (42:58) And you ought to be careful of them, they’ll overthrow you.
President Trump did say he was “willing” to condemn “white supremacists and militia groups.” However, he wanted specifics. Joe Biden named the Proud Boys. The Proud Boys are a multiracial group of civic nationalists. President Trump may have made a verbal fumble when he said, “stand back and stand by” instead of “stand down,” but he certainly didn’t call for them to march. In any event, why should the Proud Boys have to stand down? They aren’t the ones burning shops and attacking police.
Chris Wallace vaguely referred to “white supremacist and right-wing militia” but didn’t give specifics. However, he mentioned “Kenosha,” which is almost certainly a reference to Kyle Rittenhouse. Video evidence suggests Mr. Rittenhouse shot leftist protesters who attacked him.
What makes this even more absurd is that President Donald Trump specifically disavowed white nationalists after Unite The Right in 2017. “I’m not talking about the neo-Nazis and the white nationalists, because they should be condemned totally,” he said at the time. He simply added that there were “very fine people” on both sides and that antifa were “troublemakers.” Nonetheless, this lie that he supported white supremacists won’t die. Indeed, it’s the lie on which Joe Biden built his campaign. President Trump also said that if the Robert E. Lee statue was taken down, George Washington’s would follow. Journalists mocked him, but history has already proven him right.
Joe Biden said antifa were just an “idea,” not an organization. I’ve written a book on the subject; I speak with authority. “Antifa” is a brand, a front for leftist groups. However, those groups exist. They aren’t just an “idea.” There are specific antifa groups, with specific leaders, and specific sources of funding. They call themselves “antifa” because it is better than calling themselves anarchists or communists.
Journalists know antifa groups exist. They have referred to antifa as a group. For example, CNN did so in 2018 and 2020. CNN referred specifically to the group Rose City Antifa in 2019. Vice embedded with antifa in 2018. Andy Ngo, at great risk to himself, tracks specific people and groups. Now, however, Mr. Biden expects us to believe such groups don’t exist.
Critical Race Theory was also an important topic in the debate, but Mr. Wallace misled viewers: “This month, your [President Trump’s] administration directed federal agencies to end racial sensitivity training that addresses white privilege or critical race theory. Why did you decide to do that, to end racial sensitivity training?”
Critical Race Theory is not “racial sensitivity training.” Critical Race Theory holds that American institutions are inherently racist. It says all whites are racist. It is openly anti-white. No country can survive if its own government teaches that its institutions are illegitimate. I wish President Trump called it “anti-white” but his essential point that he ended it because it was “racist” is correct. It is racist against whites. Most Americans would probably be horrified if they knew what their tax dollars were funding. However, if it is called “racial sensitivity training,” it seems harmless.
critical race theory explained in one pic pic.twitter.com/BOVlRiW96a
— Look, Fat, go vote for someone else (@jer2911tx) September 30, 2020
Mr. Wallace clearly wanted it to sound benign. “What is radical about racial sensitivity training?” he asked. President Trump, again accurately, said that the instructors receive a great deal of money to teach that America is a horrible place. Joe Biden’s response was simply to deny reality. “Nobody’s doing that,” he said. “He’s [President Trump] the racist.”
Mr. Biden’s campaign thinks that President Trump’s comments on race last night hurt the president’s chances for re-election. It put up an ad that linked Kyle Rittenhouse to white supremacists. This is a potentially defamatory claim.
There’s no other way to put it: the President of the United States refused to disavow white supremacists on the debate stage last night. pic.twitter.com/Q3VZTW1vUV
— Joe Biden (@JoeBiden) September 30, 2020
Complaining about Charlottesville is absurd when American cities have been in chaos for months thanks to left-wing rioters. Furthermore, an independent report showed that state and local authorities allowed and arguably encouraged violence at the Unite the Right rally in 2017. However, many journalists either don’t know or pretend not to know. Mr. Biden’s campaign can act this way because media figures are covering for him.
President Trump has not done nearly enough to support white interests. He hasn’t defended the people who supported him so passionately in 2016. I wish President Trump were the pro-white, strong-willed nationalist of the Left’s nightmares. If anything, he’s far too weak. But President Trump is fair-minded. In a healthy country, this would be taken for granted. In 2020 America, it’s a scandal.

RSS








