The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection$
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • B
Show CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeThanksLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Current Commenter
says:

Leave a Reply -


 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
$
Submitted comments have been licensed to The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Commenting Disabled While in Translation Mode
Commenters to FollowHide Excerpts
By Authors Filter?
Alastair Crooke Ambrose Kane Anatoly Karlin Andrew Anglin Andrew Joyce Audacious Epigone Boyd D. Cathey C.J. Hopkins E. Michael Jones Eric Margolis Eric Striker Fred Reed Gilad Atzmon Gregory Hood Guillaume Durocher Hua Bin Ilana Mercer Israel Shamir ISteve Community James Kirkpatrick James Thompson Jared Taylor John Derbyshire Jonathan Cook Jung-Freud Karlin Community Kevin Barrett Kevin MacDonald Larry Romanoff Laurent Guyénot Linh Dinh Michael Hudson Mike Whitney Pat Buchanan Patrick Cockburn Paul Craig Roberts Paul Kersey Pepe Escobar Peter Frost Philip Giraldi Razib Khan Ron Unz Steve Sailer The Saker Tobias Langdon A. Graham A. J. Smuskiewicz A Southerner Academic Research Group UK Staff Adam Hochschild Aedon Cassiel Agha Hussain Ahmad Al Khaled Ahmet Öncü Al X Griz Alain De Benoist Alan Macleod Albemarle Man Alex Graham Alexander Cockburn Alexander Hart Alexander Jacob Alexander Wolfheze Alfred De Zayas Alfred McCoy Alison Weir Allan Wall Allegra Harpootlian Amalric De Droevig Amr Abozeid Anand Gopal Anastasia Katz Andre Damon Andre Vltchek Andreas Canetti Andrei Martyanov Andrew Cockburn Andrew Fraser Andrew Hamilton Andrew J. Bacevich Andrew Napolitano Andrew S. Fischer Andy Kroll Angie Saxon Ann Jones Anna Tolstoyevskaya Anne Wilson Smith Anonymous Anonymous American Anonymous Attorney Anonymous Occidental Anthony Boehm Anthony Bryan Anthony DiMaggio Tony Hall Antiwar Staff Antonius Aquinas Antony C. Black Ariel Dorfman Arlie Russell Hochschild Arno Develay Arnold Isaacs Artem Zagorodnov Astra Taylor AudaciousEpigone Augustin Goland Austen Layard Ava Muhammad Aviva Chomsky Ayman Fadel Bailey Schwab Barbara Ehrenreich Barbara Garson Barbara Myers Barry Kissin Barry Lando Barton Cockey Beau Albrecht Belle Chesler Ben Fountain Ben Freeman Ben Sullivan Benjamin Villaroel Bernard M. Smith Beverly Gologorsky Bill Black Bill Moyers Blake Archer Williams Bob Dreyfuss Bonnie Faulkner Book Brad Griffin Bradley Moore Brenton Sanderson Brett Redmayne-Titley Brett Wilkins Brian Dew Brian McGlinchey Brian R. Wright Britannicus Brittany Smith Brooke C.D. Corax C.J. Miller Caitlin Johnstone Cara Marianna Carl Boggs Carl Horowitz Carolyn Yeager Cat McGuire Catherine Crump César Keller Chalmers Johnson Chanda Chisala Charles Bausman Charles Goodhart Charles Wood Charlie O'Neill Charlottesville Survivor Chase Madar ChatGPT Chauke Stephan Filho Chris Hedges Chris Roberts Chris Woltermann Christian Appy Christophe Dolbeau Christopher DeGroot Christopher Donovan Christopher Harvin Christopher Ketcham Chuck Spinney Civus Non Nequissimus CODOH Editors Coleen Rowley Colin Liddell Cooper Sterling Courtney Alabama Craig Murray Cynthia Chung D.F. Mulder Dahr Jamail Dakota Witness Dan E. Phillips Dan Roodt Dan Sanchez Daniel Barge Daniel McAdams Daniel Moscardi Daniel Vinyard Danny Sjursen Dave Chambers Dave Kranzler Dave Lindorff David Barsamian David Boyajian David Bromwich David Chibo David Chu David Gordon David Haggith David Irving David L. McNaron David Lorimer David M. Zsutty David Martin David North David Skrbina David Stockman David Vine David Walsh David William Pear David Yorkshire Dean Baker Declan Hayes Dennis Dale Dennis Saffran Diana Johnstone Diego Ramos Dilip Hiro Dirk Bezemer Dmitriy Kalyagin Don Wassall Donald Thoresen Alan Sabrosky Dr. Ejaz Akram Dr. Ridgely Abdul Mu’min Muhammad Dries Van Langenhove E. Frederick Stevens E. Geist Eamonn Fingleton Ed Warner Edmund Connelly Eduardo Galeano Edward Curtin Edward Dutton Egbert Dijkstra Egor Kholmogorov Ehud Shapiro Ekaterina Blinova Ellen Brown Ellen Packer Ellison Lodge Emil Kirkegaard Emilio García Gómez Emma Goldman Enzo Porter Eric Draitser Eric Paulson Eric Peters Eric Rasmusen Eric Zuesse Erik Edstrom Erika Eichelberger Erin L. Thompson Eugene Gant Eugene Girin Eugene Kusmiak Eve Mykytyn F. Douglas Stephenson F. Roger Devlin Fadi Abu Shammalah Fantine Gardinier Federale Fenster Fergus Hodgson Finian Cunningham The First Millennium Revisionist Fordham T. Smith Former Agent Forum Francis Goumain Frank Key Frank Tipler Franklin Lamb Franklin Stahl Frida Berrigan Friedrich Zauner Gabriel Black Ganainm Gary Corseri Gary Heavin Gary North Gary Younge Gavin Newsom Gene Tuttle George Albert George Bogdanich George Galloway George Koo George Mackenzie George Szamuely Georgia Hayduke Georgianne Nienaber Gerhard Grasruck Gilbert Cavanaugh Gilbert Doctorow Giles Corey Glen K. Allen Glenn Greenwald A. Beaujean Agnostic Alex B. Amnestic Arcane Asher Bb Bbartlog Ben G Birch Barlow Canton ChairmanK Chrisg Coffee Mug Darth Quixote David David B David Boxenhorn DavidB Diana Dkane DMI Dobeln Duende Dylan Ericlien Fly Gcochran Godless Grady Herrick Jake & Kara Jason Collins Jason Malloy Jason s Jeet Jemima Joel John Emerson John Quiggin JP Kele Kjmtchl Mark Martin Matoko Kusanagi Matt Matt McIntosh Michael Vassar Miko Ml Ole P-ter Piccolino Rosko Schizmatic Scorpius Suman TangoMan The Theresa Thorfinn Thrasymachus Wintz Godfree Roberts Gonzalo Lira Graham Seibert Grant M. Dahl Greg Garros Greg Grandin Greg Johnson Greg Klein Gregg Stanley Gregoire Chamayou Gregory Conte Gregory Wilpert Guest Admin Gunnar Alfredsson Gustavo Arellano H.G. Reza Hank Johnson Hannah Appel Hans-Hermann Hoppe Hans Vogel Harri Honkanen Heiner Rindermann Henry Cockburn Hewitt E. Moore Hina Shamsi Howard Zinn Howe Abbot-Hiss Hubert Collins Hugh Kennedy Hugh McInnish Hugh Moriarty Hugh Perry Hugo Dionísio Hunter DeRensis Hunter Wallace Huntley Haverstock Ian Fantom Ian Proud Ichabod Thornton Igor Shafarevich Ira Chernus Irmin Vinson Ivan Kesić J. Alfred Powell J.B. Clark J.D. Gore J. Ricardo Martins Jacek Szela Jack Antonio Jack Dalton Jack Kerwick Jack Krak Jack Rasmus Jack Ravenwood Jack Sen Jake Bowyer James Bovard James Carroll James Carson Harrington James Chang James Dunphy James Durso James Edwards James Fulford James Gillespie James Hanna James J. O'Meara James K. Galbraith James Karlsson James Lawrence James Petras James W. Smith Jane Lazarre Jane Weir Janice Kortkamp Janko Vukic Jared S. Baumeister Jason C. Ditz Jason Cannon Jason Kessler Jay Stanley Jayant Bhandari JayMan Jean Bricmont Jean Marois Jean Ranc Jef Costello Jeff J. Brown Jeffrey Blankfort Jeffrey D. Sachs Jeffrey St. Clair Jen Marlowe Jeremiah Goulka Jeremy Cooper Jeremy Kuzmarov Jesse Mossman JHR Writers Jim Daniel Jim Fetzer Jim Goad Jim Kavanagh Jim Mamer Jim Smith JoAnn Wypijewski Joe Atwill Joe Dackman Joe Lauria Joel Davis Joel S. Hirschhorn Johannes Wahlstrom John W. Dower John Feffer John Fund John Gorman John Harrison Sims John Helmer John Hill John Huss John J. Mearsheimer John Jackson John Kiriakou John Macdonald John Morgan John Patterson John Leonard John Pilger John Q. Publius John Rand John Reid John Ryan John Scales Avery John Siman John Stauber John T. Kelly John Taylor John Titus John Tremain John V. Walsh John Wear John Williams Jon Else Jon Entine Jonas E. Alexis Jonathan Alan King Jonathan Anomaly Jonathan Revusky Jonathan Rooper Jonathan Sawyer Jonathan Schell Jordan Henderson Jordan Steiner Jorge Besada Jose Alberto Nino Joseph Correro Joseph Kay Joseph Kishore Joseph Sobran Josephus Tiberius Josh Neal Jeshurun Tsarfat Juan Cole Judith Coburn Julian Bradford Julian Macfarlane K.J. Noh Kacey Gunther Karel Van Wolferen Karen Greenberg Karl Haemers Karl Nemmersdorf Karl Thorburn Kees Van Der Pijl Keith Woods Kelley Vlahos Kenn Gividen Kenneth A. Carlson Kenneth Vinther Kerry Bolton Kersasp D. Shekhdar Kevin DeAnna Kevin Folta Kevin Michael Grace Kevin Rothrock Kevin Sullivan Kevin Zeese Kit Klarenberg Kshama Sawant Lance Welton Larry C. Johnson Laura Gottesdiener Laura Poitras Lawrence Erickson Lawrence G. Proulx Leo Hohmann Leonard C. Goodman Leonard R. Jaffee Liam Cosgrove Lidia Misnik Lilith Powell Linda Preston Lipton Matthews Liv Heide Logical Meme Lorraine Barlett Louis Farrakhan Lydia Brimelow M.G. Miles Mac Deford Maciej Pieczyński Mahmoud Khalil Maidhc O Cathail Malcolm Unwell Marc Sills Marco De Wit Marcus Alethia Marcus Apostate Marcus Cicero Marcus Devonshire Marcy Winograd Margaret Flowers Margot Metroland Marian Evans Mark Allen Mark Bratchikov-Pogrebisskiy Mark Crispin Miller Mark Danner Mark Engler Mark Gullick Mark H. Gaffney Mark Lu Mark O'Brien Mark Perry Mark Weber Marshall Yeats Martin Jay Martin K. O'Toole Martin Lichtmesz Martin Webster Martin Witkerk Mary Phagan-Kean Matt Cockerill Matt Parrott Mattea Kramer Matthew Battaglioli Matthew Caldwell Matthew Ehret Matthew Harwood Matthew Richer Matthew Stevenson Max Blumenthal Max Denken Max Jones Max North Max Parry Max West Maya Schenwar Merlin Miller Metallicman Michael A. Roberts Michael Averko Michael Gould-Wartofsky Michael Hoffman Michael Masterson Michael Quinn Michael Schwartz Michael T. Klare Michelle Malkin Miko Peled Mnar Muhawesh Moon Landing Skeptic Morgan Jones Morris V. De Camp Mr. Anti-Humbug Muhammed Abu Murray Polner N. Joseph Potts Nan Levinson Naomi Oreskes Nate Terani Nathan Cofnas Nathan Doyle Ned Stark Neil Kumar Nelson Rosit Neville Hodgkinson Niall McCrae Nicholas R. Jeelvy Nicholas Stix Nick Griffin Nick Kollerstrom Nick Turse Nicolás Palacios Navarro Nils Van Der Vegte Noam Chomsky NOI Research Group Nomi Prins Norman Finkelstein Norman Solomon OldMicrobiologist Oliver Boyd-Barrett Oliver Williams Oscar Grau P.J. Collins Pádraic O'Bannon Patrice Greanville Patrick Armstrong Patrick Cleburne Patrick Cloutier Patrick Lawrence Patrick Martin Patrick McDermott Patrick Whittle Paul Bennett Paul Cochrane Paul De Rooij Paul Edwards Paul Engler Paul Gottfried Paul Larudee Paul Mitchell Paul Nachman Paul Nehlen Paul Souvestre Paul Tripp Pedro De Alvarado Peter Baggins Ph.D. Peter Bradley Peter Brimelow Peter Gemma Peter Haenseler Peter Lee Peter Van Buren Philip Kraske Philip Weiss Pierre M. Sprey Pierre Simon Povl H. Riis-Knudsen Pratap Chatterjee Publius Decius Mus Qasem Soleimani R, Weiler Rachel Marsden Raches Radhika Desai Rajan Menon Ralph Nader Ralph Raico Ramin Mazaheri Ramziya Zaripova Ramzy Baroud Randy Shields Raul Diego Ray McGovern Raymond Wolters Rebecca Gordon Rebecca Solnit Reginald De Chantillon Rémi Tremblay Rev. Matthew Littlefield Ricardo Duchesne Richard Cook Richard Falk Richard Faussette Richard Foley Richard Galustian Richard Houck Richard Hugus Richard Knight Richard Krushnic Richard McCulloch Richard Parker Richard Silverstein Richard Solomon Rick Shenkman Rick Sterling Rita Rozhkova Rob Crease Robert Baxter Robert Bonomo Robert Debrus Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Robert Fisk Robert Hampton Robert Henderson Robert Inlakesh Robert LaFlamme Robert Lindsay Robert Lipsyte Robert Parry Robert Roth Robert S. Griffin Robert Scheer Robert Stark Robert Stevens Robert Trivers Robert Wallace Robert Weissberg Robin Eastman Abaya Roger Dooghy Rolo Slavskiy Romana Rubeo Romanized Visigoth Ron Paul Ronald N. Neff Rory Fanning Rose Pinochet RT Staff Ruuben Kaalep Ryan Andrews Ryan Dawson Sabri Öncü Salim Mansur Sam Dickson Sam Francis Sam Husseini Samuel Sequeira Sayed Hasan Scot Olmstead Scott Howard Scott Locklin Scott Ritter Seaghan Breathnach Servando Gonzalez Sharmine Narwani Sharmini Peries Sheldon Richman Sidney James Sietze Bosman Sigurd Kristensen Sinclair Jenkins Southfront Editor Spencer Davenport Spencer J. Quinn Stefan Karganovic Steffen A. Woll Stephanie Savell Stephen F. Cohen Stephen J. Rossi Stephen J. Sniegoski Stephen Paul Foster Sterling Anderson Steve Fraser Steve Keen Steve Penfield Steven Farron Steven Starr Steven Yates Subhankar Banerjee Susan Southard Sybil Fares Sydney Schanberg Talia Mullin Tanya Golash-Boza Taxi Taylor McClain Taylor Young Ted O'Keefe Ted Rall The Crew The Zman Theodore A. Postol Thierry Meyssan Thomas A. Fudge Thomas Anderson Thomas Hales Thomas Dalton Thomas Ertl Thomas Frank Thomas Hales Thomas Jackson Thomas O. Meehan Thomas Steuben Thomas Zaja Thorsten J. Pattberg Tim Shorrock Tim Weiner Timothy Vorgenss Timur Fomenko Tingba Muhammad Todd E. Pierce Todd Gitlin Todd Miller Tom Engelhardt Tom Mysiewicz Tom Piatak Tom Suarez Tom Sunic Torin Murphy Tracy Rosenberg Travis LeBlanc Trevor Lynch Vernon Thorpe Virginia Dare Vito Klein Vladimir Brovkin Vladimir Putin Vladislav Krasnov Vox Day W. Patrick Lang Walt King Walter E. Block Warren Balogh Washington Watcher Washington Watcher II Wayne Allensworth Wei Ling Chua Wesley Muhammad White Man Faculty Whitney Webb Wilhelm Kriessmann Wilhem Ivorsson Will Jones Will Offensicht William Binney William DeBuys William Hartung William J. Astore Winslow T. Wheeler Wyatt Peterson Wyatt Reed Ximena Ortiz Yan Shen Yaroslav Podvolotskiy Yvonne Lorenzo Zhores Medvedev
Nothing found
By Topics/Categories Filter?
2020 Election Academia American Media American Military American Pravda Anti-Semitism Benjamin Netanyahu Black Crime Black Lives Matter Blacks Britain Censorship China China/America Conspiracy Theories Covid Culture/Society Donald Trump Economics Foreign Policy Gaza Genocide Hamas History Holocaust Ideology Immigration IQ Iran Israel Israel Lobby Israel/Palestine Jews Joe Biden NATO Nazi Germany Neocons Open Thread Political Correctness Race/Ethnicity Russia Science Ukraine Vladimir Putin World War II 汪精衛 100% Jussie-free Content 2008 Election 2012 Election 2016 Election 2018 Election 2022 Election 2024 Election 23andMe 9/11 Abortion Abraham Lincoln Academy Awards Achievement Gap ACLU Acting White Adam Schiff Addiction ADL Admin Administration Admixture Adolf Hitler Advertising AfD Affective Empathy Affirmative Action Affordable Family Formation Afghanistan Africa African Americans African Genetics Africans Afrikaner Age Age Of Malthusian Industrialism Agriculture AI AIPAC Air Force Aircraft Carriers Airlines Airports Al Jazeera Al Qaeda Alain Soral Alan Clemmons Alan Dershowitz Albania Albert Einstein Albion's Seed Alcohol Alcoholism Alejandro Mayorkas Alex Jones Alexander Dugin Alexander Vindman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Alexei Navalny Algeria Ali Dawabsheh Alien And Sedition Acts Alison Nathan Alt Right Altruism Amazon Amazon.com America America First American Civil War American Dream American History American Indians American Israel Public Affairs Committee American Jews American Left American Nations American Presidents American Prisons American Renaissance Amerindians Amish Amnesty Amnesty International Amos Hochstein Amy Klobuchar Anarchism Ancient DNA Ancient Genetics Ancient Greece Ancient Rome Andrei Nekrasov Andrew Bacevich Andrew Yang Anglo-America Anglo-imperialism Anglo-Saxons Anglos Anglosphere Angola Animal IQ Animal Rights Wackos Animals Ann Coulter Anne Frank Anthony Blinken Anthony Fauci Anthrax Anthropology Anti-Defamation League Anti-Gentilism Anti-Semites Anti-Vaccination Anti-Vaxx Anti-white Animus Antifa Antifeminism Antiquity Antiracism Antisemitism Antisemitism Awareness Act Antisocial Behavior Antizionism Antony Blinken Apartheid Apartheid Israel Apollo's Ascent Appalachia Apple Arab Christianity Arab Spring Arabs Archaeogenetics Archaeology Architecture Arctic Arctic Sea Ice Melting Argentina Ariel Sharon Armageddon War Armenia Armenian Genocide Army Arnold Schwarzenegger Arnon Milchan Art Arthur Jensen Arthur Lichte Artificial Intelligence Arts/Letters Aryan Invasion Theory Aryans Aryeh Lightstone Ashkenazi Intelligence Ashkenazi Jews Asia Asian Americans Asian Quotas Asians Assassination Assassinations Assimilation Atheism Atlanta AUMF Auschwitz Austin Metcalf Australia Australian Aboriginals Automation Avril Haines Ayn Rand Azerbaijan Azov Brigade Babes And Hunks Baby Gap Balfour Declaration Balkans Balochistan Baltics Baltimore Riots Banjamin Netanyahu Banking Industry Banking System Banks #BanTheADL Barack Obama Baseball Statistics Bashar Al-Assad Basketball BBC BDS BDS Movement Beauty Behavior Genetics Behavioral Genetics Belarus Belgium Belgrade Embassy Bombing Ben Cardin Ben Rhodes Ben Shapiro Ben Stiller Benny Gantz Bernard Henri-Levy Bernie Sanders Betar US Betsy DeVos Betty McCollum Bezalel Smotrich Bezalel Yoel Smotrich Biden BigPost Bilateral Relations Bilingual Education Bill Clinton Bill De Blasio Bill Gates Bill Kristol Bill Maher Bill Of Rights Billionaires Billy Graham Bioethics Biology Bioweapons Birmingham Birth Rate Bitcoin Black Community Black History Month Black Muslims Black People Black Slavery BlackLivesMatter Blackmail Blake Masters Blank Slatism BLM Blog Blogging Blogosphere Blond Hair Blood Libel Blue Eyes Boasian Anthropology Boeing Boers Bolshevik Revolution Bolshevik Russia Books Boomers Border Wall Boris Johnson Bosnia Boycott Divest And Sanction Brain Scans Brain Size Brain Structure Brazil Bret Stephens Bretton Woods Brexit Brezhnev Bri Brian Mast BRICs British Empire British Labour Party British Politics Buddhism Build The Wall Bulldog Bush Business Byzantine Caitlin Johnstone California Californication Camp Of The Saints Canada Canary Mission Cancer Candace Owens Capitalism Carlos Slim Caroline Glick Carroll Quigley Cars Carthaginians Catalonia Catholic Church Catholicism Catholics Cats Caucasus CCP CDC Ceasefire Cecil Rhodes Census Central Asia Central Intelligence Agency Chanda Chisala Chaos And Order Charles De Gaulle Charles Kushner Charles Lindbergh Charles Manson Charles Murray Charles Schumer Charlie Hebdo Charlie Kirk Charlottesville ChatGPT Checheniest Chechen Of Them All Chechens Chechnya Chetty Chicago Chicagoization Chicken Hut Child Abuse Children Chile China Vietnam Chinese Chinese Communist Party Chinese Evolution Chinese IQ Chinese Language Christian Zionists Christianity Christmas Christopher Steele Christopher Wray Chuck Schumer CIA Cinema Civil Liberties Civil Rights Civil Rights Movement Civil War Civilization Clannishness Clash Of Civilizations Class Classical Antiquity Classical History Classical Music Clayton County Climate Change Clint Eastwood Clintons Coal Coalition Of The Fringes Coen Brothers Cognitive Elitism Cognitive Science Cold Cold War Colin Kaepernick Colin Woodard College Admission College Football Colombia Colonialism Color Revolution Columbia University Columbus Comic Books Communism Computers Confederacy Confederate Flag Confucianism Congress Conquistador-American Conservatism Conservative Movement Conservatives Conspiracy Theory Constantinople Constitution Constitutional Theory Consumerism Controversial Book Convergence Core Article Corona Corporatism Corruption COTW Counterpunch Country Music Cousin Marriage Cover Story Covert Action COVID-19 Craig Murray Creationism Crime Crimea Crispr Critical Race Theory Cruise Missiles Crusades Crying Among The Farmland Crypto Cryptocurrency Ctrl-Left Cuba Cuban Missile Crisis Cuckery Cuckservative CUFI Cuisine Cultural Marxism Cultural Revolution Culture Culture War Czars Czech Republic DACA Daily Data Dump Dallas Shooting Damnatio Memoriae Dan Bilzarian Danny Danon Daren Acemoglu Darwinism Darya Dugina Data Data Analysis Dave Chappelle David Bazelon David Brog David Cole David Duke David Friedman David Frum David Irving David Lynch David Petraeus Davide Piffer Davos Death Of The West Deborah Lipstadt Debt Debt Jubilee Decadence Deep State DeepSeek Deficits Degeneracy Democracy Democratic Party Demograhics Demographic Transition Demographics Demography Denmark Dennis Ross Department Of Education Department Of Homeland Security Deplatforming Deportation Abyss Deportations Derek Chauvin Detroit Development Dick Cheney Diet Digital Yuan Dinesh D'Souza Discrimination Disease Disinformation Disney Disparate Impact Disraeli Dissent Dissidence Diversity Diversity Before Diversity Diversity Pokemon Points Dmitry Medvedev DNA Dogs Dollar Domestic Surveillance Domestic Terrorism Doomsday Clock Dostoevsky Doug Emhoff Doug Feith Dresden Drone War Drones Drug Cartels Drug Laws Drugs Duterte Dysgenic Dystopia E. Michael Jones E. O. Wilson East Asia East Asian Exception East Asians East Turkestan Easter Eastern Europe Ebrahim Raisi Economic Development Economic History Economic Sanctions Economy Edmund Burke Edmund Burke Foundation Education Edward Snowden Effective Altruism Effortpost Efraim Zurofff Egor Kholmogorov Egypt El Salvador Election 2016 Election 2018 Election 2020 Election Fraud Elections Electric Cars Eli Rosenbaum Elie Wiesel Eliot Cohen Eliot Engel Elise Stefanik Elites Elizabeth Holmes Elizabeth Warren Elliot Abrams Elliott Abrams Elon Musk Emigration Emmanuel Macron Emmett Till Employment Energy England Enoch Powell Entertainment Environment Environmentalism Epidemiology Equality Erdogan Eretz Israel Eric Zemmour Ernest Hemingway Espionage Espionage Act Estonia Ethics Ethics And Morals Ethiopia Ethnic Cleansing Ethnic Nepotism Ethnicity Ethnocentricty EU Eugene Debs Eugenics Eurabia Eurasia Euro Europe European Genetics European Right European Union Europeans Eurozone Evolution Evolutionary Biology Evolutionary Genetics Evolutionary Psychology Existential Risks Eye Color Face Shape Facebook Faces Fake News False Flag Attack Family Fantasy FARA Farmers Fascism Fast Food FBI FDA FDD Federal Reserve FEMA Feminism Ferguson Ferguson Shooting Fermi Paradox Fertility Fertility Fertility Rates Film Finance Financial Bailout Financial Bubbles Financial Debt Finland Finn Baiting First Amendment First World War FISA Fitness Flash Mobs Flight From White Floyd Riots 2020 Fluctuarius Argenteus Flynn Effect Food Football For Fun Forecasts Foreign Agents Registration Act Foreign Aid Foreign Policy Fourth Amendment Fox News France Francesca Albanese Frank Salter Frankfurt School Franklin D. Roosevelt Franklin Scandal Franz Boas Fraud Fred Kagan Free Market Free Speech Free Trade Freedom Of Speech Freedom Freemasons French French Revolution Friedrich Karl Berger Friends Of The Israel Defense Forces Frivolty Frontlash Furkan Dogan Future Futurism G20 Gambling Game Game Of Thrones Gavin McInnes Gavin Newsom Gay Germ Gay Marriage Gays/Lesbians Gaza Flotilla GDP Gen Z Gender Gender And Sexuality Gender Equality Gender Reassignment Gene-Culture Coevolution Genealogy General Intelligence General Motors Generation Z Generational Gap Genes Genetic Diversity Genetic Engineering Genetic Load Genetic Pacification Genetics Genomics Gentrification Geography Geopolitics George Floyd George Galloway George Patton George Soros George Tenet George W. Bush Georgia Germans Germany Ghislaine Maxwell Gilad Atzmon Gina Peddy Giorgia Meloni Gladwell Glenn Greenwald Global Warming Globalism Globalization Globo-Homo God Gold Golf Gonzalo Lira Google Government Government Debt Government Spending Government Surveillance Government Waste Grant Smith Graphs Great Bifurcation Great Depression Great Leap Forward Great Powers Great Replacement Greece Greeks Greenland Greg Cochran Gregory Clark Gregory Cochran Greta Thunberg Grooming Group Selection GSS Guardian Guest Guilt Culture Gun Control Guns GWAS Gypsies H.R. McMaster H1-B Visas Haim Saban Hair Color Haiti Hajnal Line Halloween HammerHate Hannibal Procedure Happening Happiness Harvard Harvard University Harvey Weinstein Hassan Nasrallah Hate Crimes Fraud Hoax Hate Hoaxes Hate Speech Hbd Hbd Chick Health Health And Medicine Health Care Healthcare Hegira Height Hell Henry Harpending Henry Kissinger Heredity Heritability Hezbollah High Speed Rail Hillary Clinton Hindu Caste System Hindus Hiroshima Hispanic Crime Hispanics Historical Genetics History Of Science Hitler HIV/AIDS Hoax Holland Hollywood Holocaust Denial Holocaust Deniers Homelessness Homicide Homicide Rate Hominin Homomania Homosexuality Hong Kong Houellebecq Housing Houthis Howard Kohr Huawei Huddled Masses Huey Newton Human Achievement Human Biodiversity Human Evolution Human Evolutionary Genetics Human Evolutionary Genomics Human Genetics Human Genomics Human Rights Human Rights Watch Humor Hungary Hunt For The Great White Defendant Hunter Biden Hunter-Gatherers I.F. Stone I.Q. I.Q. Genomics #IBelieveInHavenMonahan ICC Icj Ideas Identity Ideology And Worldview IDF Idiocracy Igbo Ilan Pappe Ilhan Omar Illegal Immigration Ilyushin IMF Impeachment Imperialism Inbreeding Income Income Tax India Indian Indian IQ Indians Individualism Indo-Europeans Indonesia Inequality Inflation Intelligence Intelligence Agencies Intelligent Design International International Comparisons International Court Of Justice International Criminal Court International Relations Internet Interracial Marriage Interracism Intersectionality Intifada Intra-Racism Intraracism Invade Invite In Hock Invade The World Invite The World Iosef Stalin Iosif Stalin Iq And Wealth Iran Nuclear Agreement Iran Nuclear Program Iranian Nuclear Program Iraq Iraq War Ireland Irish Is Love Colorblind Isaac Herzog ISIS Islam Islamic Jihad Islamic State Islamism Islamophobia Isolationism Israel Bonds Israel Defense Force Israel Defense Forces Israel Separation Wall Israeli Occupation IT Italy Itamar Ben-Gvir It's Okay To Be White Ivanka Ivy League J Street Jacky Rosen Jair Bolsonaro Jake Sullivan Jake Tapper Jamal Khashoggi James Angleton James Clapper James Comey James Forrestal James Jeffrey James Mattis James Watson James Zogby Janet Yellen Janice Yellen Japan Jared Diamond Jared Kushner Jared Taylor Jason Greenblatt JASTA Javier Milei JCPOA JD Vance Jeb Bush Jeffrey Epstein Jeffrey Goldberg Jeffrey Sachs Jen Psaki Jennifer Rubin Jens Stoltenberg Jeremy Corbyn Jerry Seinfeld Jerusalem Jerusalem Post Jesus Jesus Christ Jewish Genetics Jewish History Jewish Intellectuals Jewish Power Jewish Power Party Jewish Supremacism JFK Assassination JFK Jr. Jihadis Jill Stein Jimmy Carter Jingoism JINSA Joe Lieberman Joe Rogan John Bolton John Brennan John Derbyshire John F. Kennedy John Hagee John Kirby John Kiriakou John McCain John McLaughlin John Mearsheimer John Paul Joker Jonathan Freedland Jonathan Greenblatt Jonathan Pollard Jordan Peterson Joseph McCarthy Josh Gottheimer Josh Paul Journalism Judaism Judea Judge George Daniels Judicial System Judith Miller Julian Assange Jussie Smollett Justice Justin Trudeau Kaboom Kahanists Kaiser Wilhelm Kamala Harris Kamala On Her Knees Kanye West Karabakh War 2020 Karen Kwiatkowski Karine Jean-Pierre Karmelo Anthony Kash Patel Kashmir Katy Perry Kay Bailey Hutchison Kazakhstan Keir Starmer Kenneth Marcus Kevin MacDonald Kevin McCarthy Kevin Williamson Khazars Kids Kim Jong Un Kinship Kkk KKKrazy Glue Of The Coalition Of The Fringes Knesset Kompromat Korea Korean War Kosovo Kristi Noem Ku Klux Klan Kubrick Kurds Kushner Foundation Kyle Rittenhouse Kyrie Irving Language Laos Larry Ellison Larry C. Johnson Late Obama Age Collapse Latin America Latinos Laura Loomer Law Lawfare LDNR Lead Poisoning Leahy Amendments Leahy Law Lebanon Lee Kuan Yew Leftism Lenin Leo Frank Leo Strauss Let's Talk About My Hair LGBT LGBTI Liberal Opposition Liberal Whites Liberalism Liberals Libertarianism Libya Lindsey Graham Linguistics Literacy Literature Lithuania Litvinenko Living Standards Liz Cheney Liz Truss Lloyd Austin long-range-missile-defense Longevity Looting Lord Of The Rings Lorde Los Angeles Loudoun County Louis Farrakhan Love And Marriage Low-fat Lukashenko Lula Lyndon B Johnson Lyndon Johnson Madeleine Albright Mafia MAGA Magnitsky Act Mahmoud Abbas Malaysia Malaysian Airlines MH17 Manufacturing Mao Zedong Maoism Map Marco Rubio Maria Butina Maria Corina Machado Marijuana Marine Le Pen Marjorie Taylor Greene Mark Milley Mark Steyn Mark Warner Market Economy Martin Luther King Martin Scorsese Marvel Marx Marxism Masculinity Mass Immigration Mass Shootings Mate Choice Mathematics Matt Gaetz Max Blumenthal Max Boot Max Weber Maxine Waters Mayans McCain McCain/POW McDonald's Meat Media Media Bias Medicine Medieval Christianity Medieval Russia Mediterranean Diet Medvedev Megan McCain Meghan Markle Mein Obama Mel Gibson Men With Gold Chains Meng Wanzhou Mental Health Mental Illness Meritocracy Merkel Merkel Youth Merkel's Boner Merrick Garland Mexico MH 17 MI-6 Michael Bloomberg Michael Collins PIper Michael Flynn Michael Hudson Michael Jackson Michael Lind Michael McFaul Michael Moore Michael Morell Michael Pompeo Michelle Goldberg Michelle Ma Belle Michelle Obama Microaggressions Middle Ages Middle East Migration Mike Huckabee Mike Johnson Mike Pence Mike Pompeo Mike Signer Mike Waltz Mikhael Gorbachev Miles Mathis Militarized Police Military Military Analysis Military Budget Military History Military Spending Military Technology Millennials Milner Group Minimum Wage Minneapolis Minorities Minsk Accords Miriam Adelson Miscegenation Miscellaneous Misdreavus Mishima Missile Defense Mitch McConnell Mitt Romney Mixed-Race MK-Ultra Mohammed Bin Salman Monarchy Mondoweiss Money Mongolia Mongols Monkeypox Monopoly Monotheism Moon Landing Hoax Moon Landings Moore's Law Morality Mormonism Mormons Mortality Mortgage Moscow Mossad Movies Muhammad Multiculturalism Music Muslim Ban Muslims Mussolini NAEP Naftali Bennett Nakba NAMs Nancy Pelos Nancy Pelosi Narendra Modi NASA Natanz Nation Of Hate Nation Of Islam National Assessment Of Educational Progress National Debt National Endowment For Democracy National Review National Security Strategy National Socialism National Wealth Nationalism Native Americans Natural Gas Nature Vs. Nurture Navalny Affair Navy Standards Nazis Nazism Neandertals Neanderthals Negrolatry Nehru Neo-Nazis Neoconservatism Neoconservatives Neoliberalism Neolithic Neoreaction Nesta Webster Netherlands Never Again Education Act New Cold War New Dark Age New Deal New Horizon Foundation New Silk Road New Tes New Testament New World Order New York New York City New York Times New Zealand New Zealand Shooting NFL Nicholas II Nicholas Wade Nick Eberstadt Nick Fuentes Nicolas Maduro Niger Nigeria Nike Nikki Haley NIMBY Nina Jankowicz Noam Chomsky Nobel Peace Prize Nobel Prize Nord Stream Nord Stream Pipelines Nordics Norman Braman Norman Finkelstein North Africa North Korea Northern Ireland Northwest Europe Norway Novorossiya NSA NSO Group Nuclear Energy Nuclear Power Nuclear Proliferation Nuclear War Nuclear Weapons Nuremberg Nutrition Nvidia NYPD Obama Obama Presidency Obamacare Obesity Obituary Obscured American Occam's Razor Occupy Wall Street October Surprise OFAC Oil Oil Industry OJ Simpson Olav Scholz Old Testament Oliver Stone Olympics Open Borders OpenThread Opinion Poll Opioids Orban Organized Crime Orlando Shooting Orthodoxy Orwell Osama Bin Laden OTFI Ottoman Empire Our Soldiers Speak Out Of Africa Model Paganism Pakistan Pakistani Palantir Palestine Palestinians Palin Pam Bondi Panhandling Papacy Paper Review Parasite Burden Parenting Parenting Paris Attacks Partly Inbred Extended Family Pat Buchanan Patriot Act Patriotism Paul Craig Roberts Paul Findley Paul Ryan Paul Singer Paul Wolfowitz Pavel Grudinin Paypal Peak Oil Pearl Harbor Pedophilia Pentagon Personal Genomics Personality Pete Buttgieg Pete Hegseth Peter Frost Peter Thiel Petro Poroshenko Phil Rushton Philadelphia Philippines Philosophy Phoenicians Phyllis Randall Physiognomy Piers Morgan Pigmentation Pigs Piracy PISA Pizzagate POC Ascendancy Podcast Poetry Poland Police Police State Polio Political Correctness Makes You Stupid Political Dissolution Political Economy Politicians Politics Polling Pollution Polygamy Polygyny Pope Francis Population Population Genetics Population Growth Population Replacement Populism Porn Pornography Portland Portugal Portuguese Post-Apocalypse Postindustrialism Poverty Power Pramila Jayapal PRC Prediction Prescription Drugs President Joe Biden Presidential Race '08 Presidential Race '12 Presidential Race '16 Presidential Race '20 Prince Andrew Prince Harry Princeton University Priti Patel Privacy Privatization Progressives Propaganda Prostitution protest Protestantism Protocols Of The Elders Of Zion Proud Boys Psychology Psychometrics Psychopathy Public Health Public Schools Puerto Rico Puritans Putin Putin Derangement Syndrome QAnon Qasem Soleimani Qassem Soleimani Qatar Quantitative Genetics Quiet Skies R2P Race Race And Crime Race And Genomics Race And Iq Race And Religion Race/Crime Race Denialism Race/IQ Race-Ism Race Riots Rachel Corrie Racial Purism Racial Reality Racialism Racism Rafah Raj Shah Rand Paul Randy Fine Rape Rare Earths Rashida Tlaib Rationality Ray McGovern Raymond Chandler Razib Khan Real Estate RealWorld Recep Tayyip Erdogan Reconstruction Red Sea Refugee Crisis Religion Religion And Philosophy Rentier Reparations Reprint Republican Party Republicans Review Revisionism Rex Tillerson RFK Assassination Ricci Richard Dawkins Richard Goldberg Richard Grenell Richard Haas Richard Lewontin Richard Lynn Richard Nixon Rightwing Cinema Riots R/k Theory RMAX Robert A. Heinlein Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Robert Ford Robert Kagan Robert Kraft Robert Maxwell Robert McNamara Robert Mueller Robert Reich Robots Rock Music Roe Vs. Wade Roger Waters Rolling Stone Roman Empire Romania Romans Romanticism Rome Ron DeSantis Ron Paul Ron Unz Ronald Reagan Rotherham Rothschilds Roy Cohn RT International Rudy Giuliani Rush Limbaugh Russiagate Russian Demography Russian Elections 2018 Russian History Russian Media Russian Military Russian Nationalism Russian Occupation Government Russian Orthodox Church Russian Reaction Russians Russophobes Russophobia Rwanda Ryan Dawson Sabrina Rubin Erdely Sacha Baron Cohen Sacklers Sailer Strategy Sailer's First Law Of Female Journalism Saint Peter Tear Down This Gate! Saint-Petersburg Salman Rushie Salt Sam Altman Sam Bankman-Fried Sam Francis Samantha Power Samson Option San Bernadino Massacre Sandy Hook Sapir-Whorf SAT Satan Satanic Age Satanism Saudi Arabia Scandal Science Denialism Science Fiction Scooter Libby Scotland Scott Bessent Scott Ritter Scrabble Secession Self Determination Self Indulgence Semites Serbia Sergei Lavrov Sergei Skripal Sergey Glazyev Seth Rich Sex Sex Differences Sexism Sexual Harassment Sexual Selection Sexuality Seymour Hersh Shai Masot Shakespeare Shame Culture Shanghai Cooperation Organisation Sheldon Adelson Shias And Sunnis Shimon Arad Shireen Abu Akleh Shmuley Boteach Shoah Shorts And Funnies Shoshana Bryen Shulamit Aloni Shurat HaDin Sigal Mandelker Sigar Pearl Mandelker Sigmund Freud Silicon Valley Singapore Single Women Sinotriumph Six Day War Sixties SJWs Skin Color Slavery Slavery Reparations Slavs Smart Fraction Social Justice Warriors Social Media Social Science Socialism Society Sociobiology Sociology Sodium Solzhenitsyn Somalia Sotomayor South Africa South Asia South China Sea South Korea Southeast Asia Soviet History Soviet Union Sovok Space Space Exploration Space Program Spain Spanish Spanish River High School SPLC Sport Sports Srebrenica St Petersburg International Economic Forum Stabby Somali Staffan Stage Stalinism Standardized Tests Star Trek Star Wars Starvation Comparisons State Department Statistics Statue Of Liberty Steny Hoyer Stephen Cohen Stephen Jay Gould Stereotypes Steroids Steve Bannon Steve Sailer Steve Witkoff Steven Pinker Steven Witkoff Strait Of Hormuz Strategic Ambiguity Stuart Levey Stuart Seldowitz Student Debt Stuff White People Like Sub-Saharan Africa Sub-Saharan Africans Subhas Chandra Bose Subprime Mortgage Crisis Suburb Suella Braverman Sugar Suicide Superintelligence Supreme Court Surveillance Susan Glasser Svidomy Sweden Switzerland Symington Amendment Syria Syrian Civil War Ta-Nehisi Coates Taiwan Take Action Taliban Talmud Tariff Tariffs Tatars Taxation Taxes Technical Considerations Technology Ted Cruz Telegram Television Terrorism Terrorists Terry McAuliffe Tesla Testing Testosterone Tests Texas THAAD Thailand The AK The American Conservative The Bell Curve The Bible The Black Autumn The Cathedral The Confederacy The Constitution The Eight Banditos The Family The Free World The Great Awokening The Left The Middle East The New York Times The South The States The Zeroth Amendment To The Constitution Theranos Theresa May Third World Thomas Jefferson Thomas Massie Thomas Moorer Thought Crimes Tiananmen Massacre Tibet Tiger Mom TikTok TIMSS Tom Cotton Tom Massie Tom Wolfe Tony Blair Tony Blinken Tony Kleinfeld Too Many White People Torture Trade Trains Trans Fat Trans Fats Transgender Transgenderism Transhumanism Translation Translations Transportation Travel Trayvon Martin Trolling True Redneck Stereotypes Trump Trump Derangement Syndrome Trust Tsarist Russia Tucker Carlson Tulsa Tulsi Gabbard Turkey Turks TWA 800 Twins Twitter Ucla UFOs UK Ukrainian Crisis UN Security Council Unbearable Whiteness Unemployment United Kingdom United Nations United Nations General Assembly United Nations Security Council United States Universal Basic Income UNRWA Urbanization Ursula Von Der Leyen Uruguay US Blacks US Capitol Storming 2021 US Civil War II US Congress US Constitution US Elections 2016 US Elections 2020 US State Department USA USAID USS Liberty USSR Uyghurs Uzbekistan Vaccination Vaccines Valdimir Putin Valerie Plame Vdare Venezuela Victor Davis Hanson Victoria Nuland Victorian England Video Video Games Vietnam Vietnam War Vietnamese Vikings Viktor Orban Viktor Yanukovych Violence Vioxx Virginia Virginia Israel Advisory Board Vitamin D Vivek Ramaswamy Vladimir Zelensky Volodymyr Zelensky Vote Fraud Voting Rights Voting Rights Act Vulcan Society Waffen SS Wall Street Walmart Wang Ching Wei Wang Jingwei War War Crimes War Guilt War In Donbass War On Christmas War On Terror War Powers War Powers Act Warhammer Washington DC WASPs Watergate Wealth Wealth Inequality Web Traffic Weight WEIRDO Welfare Wendy Sherman West Bank Western Civilization Western Decline Western European Marriage Pattern Western Hypocrisy Western Media Western Religion Western Revival Westerns White America White Americans White Death White Flight White Guilt White Helmets White Liberals White Man's Burden White Nakba White Nationalism White Nationalists White People White Privilege White Race White Racialism White Slavery White Supremacy White Teachers Whiterpeople Whites Whitney Webb Who Whom Whoopi Goldberg Wikileaks Wikipedia Wildfires William Browder William F. Buckley William Kristol William Latson William McGonagle William McRaven WINEP Winston Churchill Woke Capital Women Woodrow Wilson Workers Working Class World Bank World Economic Forum World Health Organization World Population World War G World War H World War Hair World War I World War III World War R World War T WTF WVS WWII Xi Jinping Xinjiang Yahya Sinwar Yair Lapid Yemen Yevgeny Prigozhin Yoav Gallant Yogi Berra's Restaurant Yoram Hazony YouTube Yugoslavia Yuval Noah Harari Zbigniew Brzezinski Zimbabwe Zionism Zionists Zohran Mamdani Zvika Fogel
Nothing found
Filter?
Arclight
Comments
• My
Comments
3,355 Comments • 365,800 Words •  RSS
(Commenters may request that their archives be hidden by contacting the appropriate blogger)
All Comments
 All Comments
    From WPDE: It's a pleasant but rather dull Christian hymn composed in 1900 by James Weldon Johnson and his brother. It's gotten trotted out a lot by the authorities during the Racial Reckoning, but it's not as as if black people care for it all that much. What should be the White National Anthem played...
  • I have no idea, but it’s interesting to see on X how many nominally conservative black commentators are upset that whites are offended that the so-called black national anthem is going to be played.

    Relatedly, I wonder how long the NFL is going to stick with its program of racial sloganeering in the endzones and on the back of players helmets, with inspiring words like “it takes all of us” or “be love.” Both are kind of darkly humorous, as the people that are being appeased by this certainly don’t think any of our national domestic problems involve them changing anything about their habits or love of anyone else.

    • Replies: @Rick P
    @Arclight

    The NFL as far as I can tell is the only major sport to still have BLM-era stuff on the field or on uniforms.

    Replies: @Arclight

  • An editorial in Science, the most famous American scientific journal: Braiding?
  • The concept and worship of the “noble savage” manifests itself all of the time in leftist politics, aside from this rather laughable insistence that native spiritual beliefs be treated as a comprehensive system to understand the world. The other obvious example is in its fetishization of black people and culture and absurd slogans like “listen to black women.” These same people would laugh at the belief systems of Christianity as worship of a magical sky god while literally demanding we act like the native sky god is real or there is something called black girl magic. At the end of the day it’s all a hatred of the Western civilization that makes their lives and comforts possible, because acceptance would mean yes, there really are superior cultures and methods of organizing society and it excludes a pretty big swathe of the planet and/or your ancestors.

    It also is a product of the problem of elite overproduction – no doubt the authors of the piece Steve has cited have extensive educational credentials and the student loans to show it yet work in what are essentially academic backwaters. They’ve put in their time, don’t really have anything to offer, but dammit want society’s respect and a secure living.

    • Agree: Mark G.
    • Replies: @Jim Don Bob
    @Arclight

    Well said.

    , @Santoculto
    @Arclight

    "Elite overproduction" is another Jewish-made scapegoat.

    , @Sick n' Tired
    @Arclight

    "It also is a product of the problem of elite overproduction – no doubt the authors of the piece Steve has cited have extensive educational credentials and the student loans to show it yet work in what are essentially academic backwaters. They’ve put in their time, don’t really have anything to offer, but dammit want society’s respect and a secure living."

    They're producing pieces like this to get themselves a chunk of DEI/Indigenous grant money our liberal diversity hire government is throwing at any woke study.

    Years ago a friend of mine applied for a bunch of grants being offered for ocean conservation/reef studies/fish population surveys in S. Florida. He was able to get a very nice boat and spent his days scuba diving, catching lobsters out of season to "study" them (lunch & dinner), bring girls out on the boat, to make extra money he ran private guided scuba tours and fishing trips. He said the initial grant process was tedious, but once he got funding for a few, they kept rolling in and getting renewed. He did it for 6-7 years until the grant money dried up.

  • I've been saying for a number of years that the Next Big Thing after transmania looks like polygamy (no doubt under some fashionable euphemism). From New York magazine: Cats are cuter-looking than actual polyamorists. From the Washington Post: This book about open marriage is going to blow up your group chat Molly Roden Winter’s memoir,...
  • What a revolting couple – the article claims the now-adult children of this very loose union are ‘blase” about their parents’ serial infidelity, but there is zero chance it hasn’t resulted in a lot of emotional damage for them. Kids whose parents divorce and dating often struggle with that, I can hardly imagine what it must be like to realize that mom and dad don’t even have the courage for that and are just banging a series of strangers who are periodically in your home.

    At any rate, I do think this is more likely to be a flash in the pan – whereas the trans/pronoun craziness is an easy thing to adopt because you can just declare yourself as such for attention, polyamory requires actual work to pull off and frankly the percentage of people who have a partner or spouse who would stand for this is incredibly low. Part of the glue that holds relationships together is mutual financial contributions and I guarantee you that a woman who lives in a ‘bright and airy’ Park Slope townhouse is not at all reliant on her teacher’s salary or worried about the economic consequences of her spouse deciding he’s ready to end a sham marriage. In contrast, a $60k/year teacher and their maybe $80k/year spouse generally understand that life is going to get a lot harder if they engage in serial adultery and the relationship implodes.

    • Agree: ic1000
  • James Hankins has been teaching history at Harvard since 1985. He's an expert on Renaissance political thought. Three of his many books have specialized on the Tuscan historian and statesman Leonardo Bruni (1370-1444). He's sort of a real life Ignatius J. Reilly from A Confederacy of Dunces. Hankins is not at all pleased by his...
  • Pretty entertaining read – it takes cojones to say that these days, and hopefully public displays of courage give others the spine to do the same. I do think that resistance to DIE is increasing with whites who are reasonably successful, but it still is very strong with the high credential but middling income white person who feels they are underpaid and undervalued and want more social standing.

    Like a lot of leftwing politics – and as Steve has noted on other issues – it’s really about people who feel like losers demanding an inversion of our social order to put them on top of the underserving current winners.

    • Agree: Thea, Poirot
    • Replies: @Santoculto
    @Arclight

    Partially but most of what we believe are fictional, including money and social divisions. In the end of day, it's not a social classe struggle but personality types.

    , @Poirot
    @Arclight


    it takes cojones to say that these days
     
    You need to be a Nobel prize winner like Steven Weinberg these days to get away with it.

    Steve also once told me that, when he (like other UT faculty) was required to write a statement about what he would do to advance Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion, he submitted just a single sentence: “I will seek the best candidates, without regard to race or sex.” I remarked that he might be one of the only academics who could get away with that.
     
    https://vdare.com/posts/steven-weinberg-rip
    , @kaganovitch
    @Arclight


    Like a lot of leftwing politics – and as Steve has noted on other issues – it’s really about people who feel like losers demanding an inversion of our social order to put them on top of the underserving current winners.
     
    Excellent typo, bro!
  • As I mentioned back in September, various tech billionaires like the Widow Jobs and Marc Andreessen have been buying up empty land in Solano County northeast of the San Francisco Bay to build a new city. Now more info is available. They are apparently going to call it California Forever, which sounds awkward: Get your...
  • It’s an interesting concept on paper, but it will take a huge amount of will and political dexterity to ensure it doesn’t fall victim to the political and cultural values of much of the white upper middle class that have dragged down places like San Francisco – ie, diversity is our strength, soft on dysfunction politics, etc.

    On the other hand, if they want to create what is essentially a larger California version of Carmel, Indiana it can be done by erecting enough economic and cultural barriers. Going back decades this city’s cops had a reputation for being extremely unforgiving – going 5 mph of the speed limit would be a ticket, if you had temporary tags on your car you’d get pulled over, the police show up to any call in strength. The city also established development standards in terms of materials and design that were very expensive to comply with, so there are essentially no businesses that can cater to lower class tastes at all.

    So perhaps if the developers have the will and the brains to try and attract upper middle class people with red state values, it can succeed. If it’s just a reset on failed blue state cities, it will end up the same way.

    • Agree: Frau Katze
  • Rep. Ted Lieu (D-Beverly Hills) has introduced a bill in Congress to nationally ban glue traps to catch rats. The U.S. government should force all 330 million people in the country to use whatever expensive way to catch rats is fashionable in Beverly Hills. What could go wrong? Seriously, this is an example of a...
  • A great example of the frivolity of our leadership class. Congress is really only obligated to pass annual appropriations, and they cannot even do that anymore except via a catch all continuing resolution rather than considering batches of somewhat related agencies to make adjustments.

    Aside from that we have a staggering illegal immigrant crisis, ruinous annual borrowing, and out of date/inadequate energy and transportation infrastructure.

    And yet we have legislation to ban glue traps and to borrow $14 trillion for reparations to America’s biggest fiscal and social burden, who have shown zero ability to leverage the trillions already expended on their behalf into any sustainable improvements in social or economic performance.

  • Genetic engineering, in its many varieties, is slowly becoming feasible. For example, last month the FDA approved two gene therapies for treating already-born people with sickle cell disease. Medical progress in recent decades has been slower than in the heroic 1850-1950 age, but it's likely to continue grinding forward. But what will people choose to...
  • @Twinkie
    @Arclight


    Border collies are a poor choice for people who don’t have the ability or desire to offer them lots of opportunities to do what they were bred to do – spend lots of time outside running around and/or following their owner’s instructions or herding. Along with high intelligence comes a restless nature that can only really be satiated by making sure they have lots and lots of work to do and without an owner that can provide that you end up with an unhappy and destructive dog. Most people would prefer a lower-energy and less demanding breed that is happy to get a walk or two a day and spends the rest of the time napping.
     
    THIS.

    The other thing is, people confuse intelligence with trainability (Border Collies have both). Siberian Huskies, for example, are also extremely intelligent (high problem solving ability), but they rank low in the trainability department. So, they prefer to escape from kennels and dig tunnels under your fence, if left bored, than herd sheep.

    Replies: @Arclight

    Unfortunately a lot of people just pick dogs for looks rather than understanding what traits they are going to have to live with, and whether it fits for where you live and the amount of hands-on effort you have to put in. Especially with border collies and blue heelers, things can really go sideways if an owner isn’t firm with the dog. Obviously pit bulls are a prime example of a breed that really doesn’t belong the hands of 90% of the people that have them.

    One thing I have often thought was if there was a gene therapy or some other mechanism that could extend the lifespan of dogs there would be a fortune to be made there, as people will spend crazy amounts of money on a beloved pet.

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @Arclight

    It costs $50,000 to clone a dog and there are people paying it. And they are often disappointed because the cloned dogs are not quite identical to their beloved Fluffy, not in appearance and not in personality, no more that identical twins (a natural form of clone) are 100% identical.

    If there was some way to extend dog life then there would be a way to extend human life, which would be a LOT more valuable.

    The most important thing about dogs is to match their personality traits to their owner and his lifestyle. As people have mentioned, border collies are highly intelligent dogs but they are also very active, high energy, almost hyper kind of dogs. So if it has a job to do (ideally herding sheep) it will perform admirably for many hours per day and both dog and owner will be happy. If you put it in a suburban house and give it nothing to do all day, it will destroy your house instead out of boredom and restlessness.

    Replies: @TWS

  • Border collies are a poor choice for people who don’t have the ability or desire to offer them lots of opportunities to do what they were bred to do – spend lots of time outside running around and/or following their owner’s instructions or herding. Along with high intelligence comes a restless nature that can only really be satiated by making sure they have lots and lots of work to do and without an owner that can provide that you end up with an unhappy and destructive dog. Most people would prefer a lower-energy and less demanding breed that is happy to get a walk or two a day and spends the rest of the time napping.

    Probably the same with kids – a huge share of the population would be incapable of seeing to the interests or needs of a high-IQ child, and probably wouldn’t want to if they understood what would be expected of them. A much larger share would be fine with kids who are more aesthetically pleasing or athletic instead, and frankly that would also boost their social standing more also.

    • Agree: Almost Missouri
    • Replies: @RAZ
    @Arclight

    A poor choice for most, definitely. My son lived in Western CO where there are lots of border collies since they are used as herders. And he and his wife have one from a shelter but they do tons of hiking, xx skiing, etc so it works out. But a border collie would be a poor choice for Steve or for me. I got cranky just now taking my doodle for his morning walk in 20 deg.


    Border collies are a poor choice for people who don’t have the ability or desire to offer them lots of opportunities to do what they were bred to do – spend lots of time outside running around and/or following their owner’s instructions or herding. Along with high intelligence comes a restless nature that can only really be satiated by making sure they have lots and lots of work to do and without an owner that can provide that you end up with an unhappy and destructive dog. Most people would prefer a lower-energy and less demanding breed that is happy to get a walk or two a day and spends the rest of the time napping.
     
    , @Twinkie
    @Arclight


    Border collies are a poor choice for people who don’t have the ability or desire to offer them lots of opportunities to do what they were bred to do – spend lots of time outside running around and/or following their owner’s instructions or herding. Along with high intelligence comes a restless nature that can only really be satiated by making sure they have lots and lots of work to do and without an owner that can provide that you end up with an unhappy and destructive dog. Most people would prefer a lower-energy and less demanding breed that is happy to get a walk or two a day and spends the rest of the time napping.
     
    THIS.

    The other thing is, people confuse intelligence with trainability (Border Collies have both). Siberian Huskies, for example, are also extremely intelligent (high problem solving ability), but they rank low in the trainability department. So, they prefer to escape from kennels and dig tunnels under your fence, if left bored, than herd sheep.

    Replies: @Arclight

    , @bomag
    @Arclight

    Good points.

    Experience in plant and animal science shows us that if you go for improvement in one trait; usually yield; you get fragility in other areas, and higher maintenance, that equals a less desirable variety overall. Getting an improving gradient is fraught.

  • From Richard Hanania's Substack: Huh? I began my Taki's column "DIE in the Air:" Back to Hanania: I think this discourse demonstrates the limits of anti-wokeness. It goes against my interest to say this, as it may make you less likely to buy my book on the topic, but I think that conservatives in many...
  • @Twinkie
    [I posted this on this other thread, but may be more appropriate here.]

    OT but relevant: https://www.military.com/daily-news/2024/01/10/army-sees-sharp-decline-white-recruits.html

    Army Sees Sharp Decline in White Recruits

    The Army’s recruiting of white soldiers has dropped significantly in the last half decade, according to internal data reviewed by Military.com, a decline that accounts for much of the service’s historic recruitment slump that has become the subject of increasing concern for Army leadership and Capitol Hill.
     

    A total of 44,042 new Army recruits were categorized by the service as white in 2018, but that number has fallen consistently each year to a low of 25,070 in 2023, with a 6% dip from 2022 to 2023 being the most significant drop. No other demographic group has seen such a precipitous decline, though there have been ups and downs from year to year.

    In 2018, 56.4% of new recruits were categorized as white. In 2023, that number had fallen to 44%. During that same five-year period, Black recruits have gone from 20% to 24% of the pool, and Hispanic recruits have risen from 17% to 24%, with both groups seeing largely flat recruiting totals but increasing as a percentage of incoming soldiers as white recruiting has fallen.

    The rate at which white recruitment has fallen far outpaces nationwide demographic shifts, data experts and Army officials interviewed by Military.com noted.
     
    The real impact on the military capabilities is actually more significant than even these dismal numbers warrant, because whites are highly overrepresented in the elite and combat occupational specialties.

    Replies: @J.Ross, @bomag, @JR Ewing, @Arclight, @Brutusale

    Whites “going Galt” will increasingly be felt across a broad spectrum, at which point the same people who were celebrating the diversification of various job categories will then slam whites for not fulfilling their social obligations by abandoning tough/dirty/complicated jobs that they once dominated.

    • Agree: Mark G.
  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: Read the whole thing there.
  • Timely overlap with this reporting from the NY Times:

    https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/15/nyregion/swim-lessons-children-nyc.html

    It’s nice to see things like this get attention at the local level, but it’s pretty scattershot because there is no easy way for the legions of race consultants to really monetize it for their own benefit.

  • From CNN in 2019: From CNN in 2021: More recently from CNN:
  • @Arclight
    @Jack D

    Good comments - there is no point in sending humans to the moon at this point. We checked that box before I was born and it's close enough that robotic landers can do whatever we want there for now. Missions that are centered around the 'firsts' of the people involved show that the mission in and of itself is not important.

    The hallmark of America's most powerful institutions these days is wasting vast amounts of money and effort on signaling virtue while not actually doing anything that moves us forward. The spell will break eventually, but like all decadent societies it's going to take one or more very traumatic events for that to happen. On the one hand, sometimes I feel like "let's get on with it." On the other, as a parent, I am very worried about the risks it poses to my children and how they could get swept into whatever is coming thanks to the catastrophically bad leadership class.

    Replies: @Guest007, @Mark G.

    To move forward requires a vision of where one is heading. When was the last politician or community leader was described as having a vision of the future. Obama talked about the future a lot but had no real vision for the future. And Trump is incapable of developing a vision about anything.

    • Agree: Arclight
    • Replies: @Buroaker
    @Guest007

    Trump had a vision

    Enforce existing laws and regulate existing institutions for the American citizen..

    Replies: @Guest007

    , @kaganovitch
    @Guest007


    To move forward requires a vision of where one is heading. When was the last politician or community leader was described as having a vision of the future.
     
    Of course they have a vision of the future! As Claudine Gay might put it. 'A black lesbian wearing a combat boot stamping on a White face forever.'

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian

  • @Jack D
    The whole point of the new moon mission is to land people of color and women on the moon and erase the shameful stain of the undiverse white male astronauts who landed there previously.

    It would better not to land anyone there at all than it would be to have a control room that ever looked like that again (from the POV of those promoting this mission). If you told them that we could land again if only they cleared out all the DIE deadwood and got serious white men back on the job, they would tell you not to bother because showing that POCs can do this is the whole point.

    Frankly, the manned space program was always propaganda theater. Space is a harsh environment and is better served by the use of remote equipment. Having humans prancing around up there adds vastly to the cost and risk of the program without any improvement in the results. The Mars lander missions have been up there for years giving great results. Humans can only bring enough supplies to endure moon conditions for a few days.

    The only thing that has changed is the goals of the propaganda. In the past it was to win the Cold War. In the current year it is to win the War Against Whiteness. The moon is the ultimate symbol of whiteness and must be penetrated by men of color.

    Replies: @Arclight, @Frau Katze

    Good comments – there is no point in sending humans to the moon at this point. We checked that box before I was born and it’s close enough that robotic landers can do whatever we want there for now. Missions that are centered around the ‘firsts’ of the people involved show that the mission in and of itself is not important.

    The hallmark of America’s most powerful institutions these days is wasting vast amounts of money and effort on signaling virtue while not actually doing anything that moves us forward. The spell will break eventually, but like all decadent societies it’s going to take one or more very traumatic events for that to happen. On the one hand, sometimes I feel like “let’s get on with it.” On the other, as a parent, I am very worried about the risks it poses to my children and how they could get swept into whatever is coming thanks to the catastrophically bad leadership class.

    • Replies: @Guest007
    @Arclight

    To move forward requires a vision of where one is heading. When was the last politician or community leader was described as having a vision of the future. Obama talked about the future a lot but had no real vision for the future. And Trump is incapable of developing a vision about anything.

    Replies: @Buroaker, @kaganovitch

    , @Mark G.
    @Arclight

    Most people as long as they have a house or decent apartment, a car and food to eat will go along with whatever the current rulers want. It is only when large numbers of people no longer have access to this basic middle class lifestyle that you will see drastic changes.

    By 2016 many people, especially in the Midwestern Rust Belt, had fallen out of the middle class after decades of offshoring factories. This led to the Trump upset. Things are even worse now. The Covid lockdowns destroyed large numbers of small businesses that gave their owners decent incomes and recently the inflation rate has exceeded wage increases.

    The Democrats know they are in trouble and are now even trying to use the legal system to put their main opponent in prison. We are moving towards an authoritarian clampdown to help keep the current corrupt elites in power.

  • From the Washington Post news section: Phoenix tangles with Justice Dept. over police misconduct investigation City officials have mounted a campaign to counter the federal findings before a report on the 2½-year probe is released to the public By David Nakamura January 11, 2024 at 12:00 p.m. EST The Justice Department’s misconduct investigation into the...
  • I personally have no idea, as my city is predominantly white and black, with Latinos being slightly less than their share of the population nationally and not much of a political force at all.

    Just going off the shootiness aspect in the snippets above, I am guessing that being largely free of the racial baggage blacks and whites have, they don’t hold back on extreme use of force out of a concern about the consequences that a black or white cop might. Also, it’s impossible to tell how many of the people shot truly didn’t deserve it or were YOLOing themselves into an armed confrontation, which is partly a cultural thing as well.

    • Replies: @The Germ Theory of Disease
    @Arclight

    "I personally have no idea, as my city is predominantly white and black, with Latinos being slightly less than their share of the population nationally and not much of a political force at all."

    Heh heh. Just you wait.

    Check back with me in like fifteen minutes.

  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: ... This is not
  • @Arclight
    For a smart guy, Cuban is offering a pretty childlike defense of DIE. There is obviously some other motivation rather than this being his genuine understanding of how it works.

    Anyhoo, as I have commented before, the champions of diversity always seem to miss the point that if one accepts that there are meaningful differences between groups that make them 'diverse', then it would be absurd to then believe they should be represented in proportions that would imply that these differences in ability, interests, or culture ultimately make zero difference in outcomes. In fact, true diversity would mean that there would disproportionate representation in various walks of life as a natural consequence of diverging group characteristics. In effect, proponents of diversity reject its real-life implications.

    Americans are culturally far more optimistic than most, and this combined with the belief in American exceptionalism has led vast numbers of people to buy into the idea that something that has never existed in human history can be brought into being here. Our society is going to learn the lesson of the emperor's new clothes the hard way as a result.

    Replies: @Anon, @Emil Nikola Richard, @Bill, @Alden, @AnotherDad, @AnotherDad, @Corvinus, @The Last Real Calvinist

    Americans are culturally far more optimistic than most, and this combined with the belief in American exceptionalism has led vast numbers of people to buy into the idea that something that has never existed in human history can be brought into being here.

    As AnotherDad has noted, this is a fantastic comment.

    You’ve nailed the inherent contradiction in American (but now, increasingly, all of the West’s) concept of ‘diversity’. How can the diverse be different and still be equal? That’s the question that haunts us.

    All of this descends from the radical vision of the early Christian church, which preached the world-upturning message that everyone — from the Roman emperor to his governors and centurions to Roman citizens to conquered ordinary people, and all the way down to common slaves — could be equal, as brothers and sisters who repented of their sins, believed in the crucified and risen Jesus, and followed Him.

    Paul dealt with the unity-in-diversity conundrum with his metaphor of the body: all parts are needed, all are equally valuable, all are to be glorified when they do what they are called to do — but all are indeed different.

    But here’s the problem: when a decaying Christendom abandons Christ, and its peoples start to believe that they themselves can ‘save the world’, then the body breaks down and ceases to function.

    And that’s where we are today.

    • Thanks: Arclight
  • When I was a kid, misers were still a rather big deal. They were common in fairy tales and 19th Century novels, like Ebenezer Scrooge and Silas Marner. But I never hear about misers anymore. And, sure enough, the word "miser" started to fall off in frequency in English language books after the hard times...
  • @Almost Missouri
    Don't forget the role of central banking and fiat currency! In the mercantilist era, the mercantilist/miser piled up gold or other specie. Today the "mercantilist"/miser piles up merely fiat banknotes which are depreciating even as the miser locks the safe door.

    In short, miserliness doesn't pay anymore, because the central banks make sure that it doesn't (not that they have any special animus against misers, but they just like stealing some of everyone's money each year, which they can do with banknotes but not with gold.)

    The Ngram curve is a pretty good inverse proxy for the rise parasitical central banks (or "banks").


    For some reason, misers have made a recent slight comeback
     
    The momentary rise of ZIRP and de facto negative interest rates?

    Replies: @Arclight

    I think this makes some sense – in the past you could actually hoard assets like that were used for currency or trading, today you cannot. The printer just runs and runs and the indolent receive a variety of cash and like-cash subsidies to ensure they can remain the way they are and vote the right way as well. Someone else being a penny pincher doesn’t really affect the great unwashed, whereas a couple of centuries ago in village life that would be different.

    In the modern age, even people that are not ostentatious about their financial position have many ways to signal it, whether consciously or not: the cars they drive, sending kids to private versus public schools, the brand of clothing they wear, the handbag the wife carries around, etc.

    One of the things that was a strange realization for me was that “millionaire” is not nearly as meaningful of a term as it used to be. Whereas in the past that indicated a pretty rarified financial position, today it’s basically upper middle class – probably close to 10% of the population falls into this based on home equity and retirement savings.

    • Replies: @Wilkey
    @Arclight


    Whereas in the past that indicated a pretty rarified financial position, today it’s basically upper middle class – probably close to 10% of the population falls into this based on home equity and retirement savings.
     
    But what is a retirement savings millionaire, really? That 6- or 7-figure 401(k) just replaced the pension that more and more people who work in the private sector no longer receive.
  • As I've been pointing out since October 7th, a key choice is coming up: as American Jews slowly realize that Diversity Inclusion Equity works against them because they are always classified in American quota-counting schemes as white (such as the #OscarsSoWhite whoop-tee-doo), will Jews respond by turning against DIE in general or will they demand...
  • Literally no non-Jews consider them an oppressed or under represented minority, and ironically if this actually comes to pass it would be because other Jews use their power in Hollywood to make it happen.

    • Replies: @Anon
    @Arclight


    Literally no non-Jews consider them an oppressed or under represented minority
     
    Uh, have you never heard of the Holocaust? Or the Inquisition? Or the pogroms?

    Replies: @The Germ Theory of Disease, @Alden

  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: ... This is not
  • @AnotherDad
    @Arclight

    Arclight this is a first rate point as well.


    Americans are culturally far more optimistic than most, and this combined with the belief in American exceptionalism has led vast numbers of people to buy into the idea that something that has never existed in human history can be brought into being here. Our society is going to learn the lesson of the emperor’s new clothes the hard way as a result.
     
    My take, there have been basically three kinds of societal organization:

    -- tribe -- one people with some sort of elected/fought for leader

    -- empire -- "guys with guns" (swords) controlling and taxing a larger territory which contains multiple subject tribes

    -- nation -- peoples of a larger territory merged into--or at least toward--one people with a common/dominant language, culture, religion


    Basically, the minoritarian project has been to attack America (an on to other Western nations) as a one-peopleish nation and as federal republic--where people govern themselves in their communities--and push it toward being a multi-ethnic empire governed by elite diktat. Elite diktat, the nation's people not allowed to govern themselves or protect and preserve their communities and nation for themselves is what minoritarians mean by "Our Democracy".

    The thing is the old empires--Romans, Ottomans, etc.--we actually far better about leaving people alone. Their mantra was really "pay your taxes and don't cause trouble". But they mostly left their subject peoples to govern their own affairs and live as they wished with their own language, religion, customs and culture.

    No such luck from the minoritarians! They specifically demand to get into everyone's business. They particularly hate the thought that there are white gentiles off in their pale-stale communities somewhere just living their lives as they see fit. Those people--my people--need to be fixed.

    So what we are getting is quite a bit worse than classic empire. We are getting the minoritarian super-state busybody that doesn't just want your taxes but simply will not leave you alone. It fills your community up with foreigners, enables crime from favored groups, spews anti-white propaganda in your schools and encourages your daughter to poison herself and "transition" into a "boy".

    Ancient Rome would be a huge upgrade.

    Replies: @Frau Katze, @Arclight, @The Last Real Calvinist, @Twinkie, @Corvinus

    Great point about the US domestically being converted from a nation to an internal empire. All the people that squawk about colonialism and so on are enthusiastically acting like a colonial empire only with the intention to subjugate and exploit people at home rather than abroad. I think I may have discovered a new level of hatred just typing this.

  • @Almost Missouri
    @MEH 0910

    Thanks.

    Loury says he disagrees with McWhorter so much that he doesn't know where to begin, but then he goes on to agree with and even exceed everything that Loury said...

    Replies: @Almost Missouri, @Arclight, @kaganovitch

    Loury and McWhorter recognize the system is corrupt by design, and that’s a reality avoided by nearly everyone in polite society. Loury in particular gets upset because he recognizes black shortcomings across a broad spectrum and the total lack of accountability there, and they both understand the nice white people who say all the right things ultimately don’t really expect much from blacks other than to be grateful for professional head-patting.

    I really do have a lot of sympathy for these guys. They are worthy of being taken seriously on merit but are at the same time extreme outliers for their group and know it. That’s got to be a pretty tough thing to carry around when they see all the black frauds making huge amounts of money and being lauded by all the right people when by rights they should be the ones being held up as black Americans at their best.

    • Agree: res, HammerJack, Jim Don Bob
  • For a smart guy, Cuban is offering a pretty childlike defense of DIE. There is obviously some other motivation rather than this being his genuine understanding of how it works.

    Anyhoo, as I have commented before, the champions of diversity always seem to miss the point that if one accepts that there are meaningful differences between groups that make them ‘diverse’, then it would be absurd to then believe they should be represented in proportions that would imply that these differences in ability, interests, or culture ultimately make zero difference in outcomes. In fact, true diversity would mean that there would disproportionate representation in various walks of life as a natural consequence of diverging group characteristics. In effect, proponents of diversity reject its real-life implications.

    Americans are culturally far more optimistic than most, and this combined with the belief in American exceptionalism has led vast numbers of people to buy into the idea that something that has never existed in human history can be brought into being here. Our society is going to learn the lesson of the emperor’s new clothes the hard way as a result.

    • Thanks: AnotherDad
    • Replies: @Anon
    @Arclight

    Cuban pushes DEI because he’s Jewish. They can’t help themselves.

    , @Emil Nikola Richard
    @Arclight

    Mark Cuban owns an NBA team. He employs Kyrie Irving. He needs a sense of humor. Also his best player is a white guy so he can afford to take the high road. : )

    , @Bill
    @Arclight


    For a smart guy, Cuban is offering a pretty childlike defense of DIE.
     
    Yes, he is describing 1970s-style Affirmative Action. The lie is painfully clumsy.
    , @Alden
    @Arclight

    Proportionate representation disappeared decades ago. It’s been no Whites need apply for the last 40 years. The Men of Unz must never go to any government office medical office or hospital any airport train station take a bus or college campus or leave their homes if they think proportionate representation exists..

    , @AnotherDad
    @Arclight

    Boy Arclight this is a first class comment. Two great points. The first


    Anyhoo, as I have commented before, the champions of diversity always seem to miss the point that if one accepts that there are meaningful differences between groups that make them ‘diverse’, then it would be absurd to then believe they should be represented in proportions that would imply that these differences in ability, interests, or culture ultimately make zero difference in outcomes. In fact, true diversity would mean that there would disproportionate representation in various walks of life as a natural consequence of diverging group characteristics. In effect, proponents of diversity reject its real-life implications.
     
    Solid gold. I'm made this point myself.

    Diversity means "difference". It's right there in the name and in the claim. If diversity actually had any benefit, it would be because diverse peoples are actually different different perspectives, talents, skills. And then it is a tautology that diverse peoples should be expected to excel and be represented in different proportions in different jobs and industries.

    ~~

    Beyond the obvious "job categories" issue--e.g. a strip club might hire different sorts of people for the dancers, the bouncers, the manager--diversity has no demonstrable benefit.

    In fact, there is basically zero data suggesting that racial/ethnic diversity is beneficial at all.
    Actually, successful organizations and successful nations tend to revolve around non-diversity--having highly capable men with a shared culture demanding high standards.

    Replies: @Jim Don Bob, @Twinkie

    , @AnotherDad
    @Arclight

    Arclight this is a first rate point as well.


    Americans are culturally far more optimistic than most, and this combined with the belief in American exceptionalism has led vast numbers of people to buy into the idea that something that has never existed in human history can be brought into being here. Our society is going to learn the lesson of the emperor’s new clothes the hard way as a result.
     
    My take, there have been basically three kinds of societal organization:

    -- tribe -- one people with some sort of elected/fought for leader

    -- empire -- "guys with guns" (swords) controlling and taxing a larger territory which contains multiple subject tribes

    -- nation -- peoples of a larger territory merged into--or at least toward--one people with a common/dominant language, culture, religion


    Basically, the minoritarian project has been to attack America (an on to other Western nations) as a one-peopleish nation and as federal republic--where people govern themselves in their communities--and push it toward being a multi-ethnic empire governed by elite diktat. Elite diktat, the nation's people not allowed to govern themselves or protect and preserve their communities and nation for themselves is what minoritarians mean by "Our Democracy".

    The thing is the old empires--Romans, Ottomans, etc.--we actually far better about leaving people alone. Their mantra was really "pay your taxes and don't cause trouble". But they mostly left their subject peoples to govern their own affairs and live as they wished with their own language, religion, customs and culture.

    No such luck from the minoritarians! They specifically demand to get into everyone's business. They particularly hate the thought that there are white gentiles off in their pale-stale communities somewhere just living their lives as they see fit. Those people--my people--need to be fixed.

    So what we are getting is quite a bit worse than classic empire. We are getting the minoritarian super-state busybody that doesn't just want your taxes but simply will not leave you alone. It fills your community up with foreigners, enables crime from favored groups, spews anti-white propaganda in your schools and encourages your daughter to poison herself and "transition" into a "boy".

    Ancient Rome would be a huge upgrade.

    Replies: @Frau Katze, @Arclight, @The Last Real Calvinist, @Twinkie, @Corvinus

    , @Corvinus
    @Arclight

    “always seem to miss the point that if one accepts that there are meaningful differences between groups“

    But the devil is in the details as to how and why those differences came about.

    “In fact, true diversity would mean that there would disproportionate representation in various walks of life as a natural consequence of diverging group characteristics.”

    So my vague impression is that Jews would still dominate banking, the legal system, and entertainment. Then I figure you and others would still find time to bitch and complain about this group.

    , @The Last Real Calvinist
    @Arclight


    Americans are culturally far more optimistic than most, and this combined with the belief in American exceptionalism has led vast numbers of people to buy into the idea that something that has never existed in human history can be brought into being here.

     

    As AnotherDad has noted, this is a fantastic comment.

    You've nailed the inherent contradiction in American (but now, increasingly, all of the West's) concept of 'diversity'. How can the diverse be different and still be equal? That's the question that haunts us.

    All of this descends from the radical vision of the early Christian church, which preached the world-upturning message that everyone -- from the Roman emperor to his governors and centurions to Roman citizens to conquered ordinary people, and all the way down to common slaves -- could be equal, as brothers and sisters who repented of their sins, believed in the crucified and risen Jesus, and followed Him.

    Paul dealt with the unity-in-diversity conundrum with his metaphor of the body: all parts are needed, all are equally valuable, all are to be glorified when they do what they are called to do -- but all are indeed different.

    But here's the problem: when a decaying Christendom abandons Christ, and its peoples start to believe that they themselves can 'save the world', then the body breaks down and ceases to function.

    And that's where we are today.
  • I started my new Taki's Magazine column: Of course, Twitter is no longer Twitter, it's what Elon Musk calls everything -- his 1990s financial services firm, his rocket ship company, his son, and lately Twitter -- X. If you are a supple-brained 16 year old (assuming I have any 16-year-old readers), this is likely no...
  • I have often wondered how economically effective naming sponsorships really are. There is an outdoor concert venue near my hometown that has had a series of corporate names since it was built but everyone just calls it by the original non-corporate name even though it must have been at least 30 years since it started a cycle of corporate sponsorship titles. Of the last three sponsored names I cannot recall buying a product offered by any of them or even considering it.

    I assume the value of naming rights has been extensively studied and found to have some kind of net positive benefit for whatever company decides to do this, but to me it seems more like a dog marking its territory.

    • Replies: @Moral Stone
    @Arclight

    Yea the extensively studied value is execs being able to spend company money via the “marketing budget” to get awesome box suites at sought-after sporting/concert events.

    , @Matthew Kelly
    @Arclight

    The Brooklyn-Battery Tunnel will always be the Brooklyn-Battery Tunnel to me (and I suppose a lot of other NYers).

    Ditto Tri-Borough Bridge, Tappan Zee Bridge, and so on and so forth.

    (And speaking of marking territory, these have all been renamed for D politicians.)

  • In the New York Times opinion page, @espiers demands that Artificial Intelligence systems grow-up and start playing Let's Pretend more about how the world is, like adult NYT columnists such as herself do, and stop telling the truth so much, like not-yet-socially constructed kids like her son do: I Finally Figured Out Who ChatGPT Reminds...
  • @Almost Missouri
    @Arclight

    Sailer's Second Law of Female Journalism could be that

    The most heartfelt articles by female "tech"* journalists tend to be demands that biologic values be overturned in order that, Come the AI Revolution, the journalist herself will be considered the universal moral paragon.

    ---------

    * We've commented before on how female tech journalism basically doesn't exist. All the Strong Wahmen claiming to be "tech journalists" are in fact gossip journalists who like to use social media. In Elizbeth Spiers's case, she is literally the founding editor of the epochal gossip blog Gawker, which was eventually put out of its misery by Hulk Hogan and Peter Thiel. Her standing to comment of anything of import is essentially nil.

    Replies: @Thea, @Arclight, @Corpse Tooth

    At the end of the day *most* people think that those like themselves should be in charge or would do an equal or better job than someone else, so to the extent that Spiers thinks urban high status white ladies should be the arbiters of society I kind of understand because all the people she interacts with are just like her and she likes how they favorably reflect on her own self image.

    The problem is that if you stop and look around for successful enterprises, when you find those largely run by protected class people they are in niche areas and are massive outliers. It’s a real life replication crisis that is forced on society through politics rather than experience.

  • This AWFL just wants AI to be a more powerful version of herself at the end of the day. The prospect of a super processing entity with the morals of a prog white woman is almost too terrifying to imagine.

    • Replies: @Almost Missouri
    @Arclight

    Sailer's Second Law of Female Journalism could be that

    The most heartfelt articles by female "tech"* journalists tend to be demands that biologic values be overturned in order that, Come the AI Revolution, the journalist herself will be considered the universal moral paragon.

    ---------

    * We've commented before on how female tech journalism basically doesn't exist. All the Strong Wahmen claiming to be "tech journalists" are in fact gossip journalists who like to use social media. In Elizbeth Spiers's case, she is literally the founding editor of the epochal gossip blog Gawker, which was eventually put out of its misery by Hulk Hogan and Peter Thiel. Her standing to comment of anything of import is essentially nil.

    Replies: @Thea, @Arclight, @Corpse Tooth

  • From the New York Times news section: The Misguided War on the SAT Colleges have fled standardized tests, on the theory that they hurt diversity. That’s not what the research shows. By David Leonhardt David Leonhardt has been reporting on opportunity in higher education for more than two decades. Jan. 7, 2024 After the Covid...
  • This is a good thing – yes, it’s clearly in the hope that they will identify more ‘diverse’ applicants they can accept in lieu of boring old white or Asian ones, but to the extent it helps separate urban achievers with totally bogus GPAs from those whose grades actually do reflect a combination of brains and effort I’m all for it.

    My city has adopted a policy where the worst grade a kid can get on an assignment is a 50 percent, even if it’s not handed in, so there are undoubtedly scholars graduating from high school here whose true GPA and base of knowledge are significantly worse than their transcripts would indicate, so testing would be very useful.

    • Replies: @Carol
    @Arclight

    The minimum 50% policy has become pretty much the rule at all *Title 1* schools because, you know, equity.

  • You might think that as pro sports gets more competitive, that who succeeds would become more egalitarian. But in many sports, the opposite has been true because the increased competition means that both nature and nurture matter, so wealthier kids who get more nurture benefit. For example, the paradox with golfers is that as the...
  • @Guest007
    @Paleo Liberal

    JJ Watt is married to a professional women's soccer player. Is there any doubt that their children will be very good athletes? What would not expect their children to become dentist.

    Replies: @ScarletNumber, @Arclight, @Brutusale

    Right – take Christian McCaffrey, whose dad was a notoriously fast white receiver, mom was a D1 soccer player and grandpa was an Olympic sprinter. Hopefully he meets a sporty lady and has many children.

    • Replies: @Guest007
    @Arclight

    Christian McCaffery is engaged to Olivia Culpo, a former Miss Universe and a current media personality/influencer. Their children will probably be screw ups.

    Replies: @Brutusale, @Jim Don Bob, @Rick P

  • @Tono Bungay
    Not that I'm an expert, but if I can extrapolate from music pedagogy, if a kid starts golfing early under excellent instructors, he'll have as low a chance as possible of developing bad habits. The golf swing strikes me as an extraordinary example of a motion that must be entirely right, reliably right. If he's never learned to do it badly, a young golfer has an enormous advantage over someone who tries to correct his swing later. Similar to speaking a second language: When we learn our native language, the identification of word and meaning is solid, but when we learn a second language, we sort of patch the second's vocabulary onto the first's and the result, in most cases, is nowhere near as smooth as with the first.

    Replies: @Arclight

    Agree with you on golf. Some years ago I was a member of a country club (at the urging of friends, not because I love golf) and had the kids get some experience playing and the pro there said that if you are not playing regularly by 12 years old you just won’t ever be competitive these days. Other sports I think raw athleticism can get you up to speed fairly quickly although obviously there is situational experience that matters as well.

    I recall not too long ago, Steve highlighted an article complaining about the lack of diversity in PWG (pretty white girl) sports, and I do think there is a certain aspect of financial gatekeeping in volleyball, soccer, golf, and lacrosse and the like to ensure the right class of people are involved, plus a lot of these club organizations are raking in money from parents as well. Part of having a bit of money is participating in things that signal that, and part of it is being able to select what kind of environment you and/or your kids have to move around in and what you can avoid.

    • Agree: Paul Jolliffe
  • From my new Taki's column: Why are black pedestrians being killed in car crashes twice as often per capita as 15 years ago? In contrast, why hasn't the Asian-American pedestrian death rate gone up much? Also, here are per capita death rates from CDC WONDER for motorist (driver and passenger) deaths in motor vehicle accidents....
  • Cell phones are definitely a huge contributor – both on the part of motorists and pedestrians, and it seems to me no one takes a back seat in their enthusiasm for noodling with their devices than blacks. Soccer moms are also pretty bad but they are generally home by dark so don’t count towards night time accidents as much as they could. Another factor that ties into this is the popularity of wearing headphones or ear buds while walking around, and not doubt the combination of distracted pedestrians in dark clothes and distracted drivers zipping through certain neighborhoods is a factor. One of the ‘equity’ criticisms in my city is that many lower income/black neighborhoods lack decent street lighting and sometimes sidewalks, and that’s definitely true.

    But on a broader scale, the move towards minimal punishment for all manner of crimes, including traffic offenses, means there are simply more people who take a lot of risks driving around. In one extreme case, a man walking on the sidewalk in his very nice neighborhood was mowed down and killed by a driver who apparently had multiple other at-fault crashes due to recklessness in the previous 2 years but still had her license. After killing this doctor and before getting charged for it, she managed to get into another crash that resulted in the death of the other driver as well.

  • From the Harvard Crimson:
  • Darn, was hoping this would drag out a bit longer. This was another one of those things where I have heard first-hand from left of center people that the situation was ridiculous and unacceptable. Hopefully the Chris Rufos of the world are out sniffing around for more high profile diversity hires to out as lightweights.

    What will be interesting is if the board doubles down on diversity or asks some kind of Larry Summers type of person to step in for a few years.

    • Replies: @Ghost of Bull Moose
    @Arclight

    Chris Rufo is very much in the Eye of Soros right now. I'll leave it at that.

    Replies: @Jack D, @Reg Cæsar

  • From The New Yorker: The $1.8-Billion Lawsuit Over a Teacher Test In the nineties, New York began requiring aspiring educators to take an exam. Thousands of people later claimed that the test was racially biased. By Emma Green October 31, 2023 ... But, in 1991, a new law went into effect that meant that Wilds-Bethea,...
  • I will admit the Warhol question could be perceived as a cultural gotcha question, but unless the majority of questions on the test involved stuff like this this, one would still have to have blown it on scores of “job-related” questions to have failed, to say nothing of repeat failures.

    At any rate, this is revealing in a way in that it yet again demonstrates that for the left the public sector is primarily viewed as a repository of workfare jobs for otherwise difficult to employ minorities, with the added bonus that it provides a mechanism to launder taxpayer money to the Democratic Party via public employee unions. If we make those illegal and destroyed public jobs as a source of campaign financing, I could probably live with using municipal public jobs as workfare so long as it didn’t involve things that involved maintenance of infrastructure or permitting reviews.

    • Replies: @ScarletNumber
    @Arclight


    At any rate, this is revealing in a way in that it yet again demonstrates that for the left the public sector is primarily viewed as a repository of workfare jobs for otherwise difficult to employ minorities
     
    Well by modern standards they are going to get either welfare or workfare, at least with the latter we are maintaining the polite fiction that they are earning their keep. Also, some of these public sector jobs have to be done by someone. Someone has to man the desk at the DMV and make your life difficult when you get there. My biggest issue with the system is that these workfare jobs not only provide superior benefits and job security to their private-sector counterparts, but now they are starting to pay more as well. There is literally no trade off involved except for the stigma of being a public employee.

    Replies: @Art Deco

  • Back when junk mail genius Morris Dees was running the Southern Poverty Law Center, the SPLC was pretty good at coming up with acronyms. For example, consider the cunning of the acronym "SPLC," which no doubt confused some elderly donors into thinking Morris's new 1970s operation was actually Martin Luther King's venerable 1960s SCLC (Southern...
  • I am not sure who these acronymic efforts are aimed at because they don’t seem to have wide adoption. I have had multiple recent conversations in which very normie people were mocking the profusion of terms one is supposed to know and how it’s impossible because new ones are always being invented. I suppose all it takes is one zealous coworker and HR department to make things unpleasant, but I don’t actually know anyone that has fallen victim to that at this point. Seems like the kind of thing that is rigorously adhered to in academic and NFP settings but has no real traction elsewhere.

    • Replies: @Frau Katze
    @Arclight

    Arclight says:


    I have had multiple recent conversations in which very normie people were mocking the profusion of terms one is supposed to know and how it’s impossible because new ones are always being invented.
     
    This whole trans thing is exhibit 1. A concept that never even occurred to me in earlier days.

    But now my niece tells me her 16-year old daughter has started going by the pronoun “they.” I’m too old for this.

    Replies: @AnotherDad

    , @Ralph L
    @Arclight

    What's an NFP setting? I ask unironically.

    On autogynephilia (you should prod Ron U to get this to pass spellcheck), I can see how a man can get off on wearing women's clothes and bossing people around, but then cutting your dick off after you've found something non-nubile that makes it hard in middle age and restricting future partners to the most twisted or desperate lesbians--it's worse than illogical, it's moronic.

    Replies: @Jim Don Bob

  • A Stanford professor advised the Oakland Police Department (OPD)to stop pulling over lawbreaking drivers for non-violent offenses like missing license plates. According to Timothy Gardner: From the New York Times news section: San Francisco’s Woes Are Well Known. Across the Bay, Oakland Has Struggled More. Oakland, Calif., has long prided itself on being th
  • @Wade Hampton

    Oakland is probably America’s most plausible city to gentrify ….Oakland politicians and institutions actively take steps to keep crime high so their constituents can afford to live in Oakland.
     
    Typical Sailerite theory. Thoughtful, clever, plausible, but more complex than necessary.

    In democratic polities, whenever you get concentrations of orcs, they elect politicians that create policies that favor orcs. Those policies tend to accelerate the decay of the civil society.

    Democracy in a polity with a low-IQ electorate (or open borders) is a recipe for disaster.

    Replies: @Arclight

    As a former Washingtonian, this is accurate in general. My black neighbors had the same general desires as myself and other gentrifiers – less crime, more neighborhood retail, etc. The problem is that getting those things would require modification of the behavior – including punishment – of their children, grandchildren, relatives, and neighbors and that is simply unthinkable. There was no active policing of each other either – it was totally verboten to interfere in someone else’s business, even if it meant having to see and hear a young woman being beaten senseless by your neighbor’s loser son right out on the sidewalk, no one will lift a finger. Add in the fact that in most places minority voters go strictly on racial lines and there is almost no hope or constituency for reformers to come in.

    • Thanks: bomag
  • From Science Direct: Aggression and Violent Behavior Available online 23 December 2023, 101905 Race, class, and criminal adjudication: Is the US criminal justice system as biased as is often assumed? A meta-analytic review Christopher J. Ferguson, Sven Smith Abstract It is widely reported that the US criminal justice system is systematically biased in regard to...
  • The civil rights era continues to produce poisoned fruit. The left completely internalized the idea that any divergence in outcomes between blacks and whites are entirely the fault of the latter and required zero examination or circumspection about the pathologies of the former. Fast forward half a century, and despite trillions of dollars in wealth transfers, pro-black messaging and actual discrimination, various social initiatives and applying a variety of pedagogies and social theories, certain facts stubbornly refuse to go away.

    Since this is essentially a religious/matter of faith issue rather than a fact-based one, the response is to invent more fantastical explanations rather than examine whether one’s underlying assumptions might be flawed. However, the real world refuses to go away and large numbers of people who are not particularly ideological are repeatedly confronted with crime and disorder that is impossible to ignore. As I have posted previously, the renaissance of core urban neighborhoods and central business districts is over and the pendulum is swinging the other direction and will continue to do so for a generation. This is going to be increasingly apparent to huge numbers of Americans, and consciously or not they will understand what direction this is coming from and this will affect our politics/culture accordingly.

    • Agree: AnotherDad
  • From Jewish Insider: Former ADL, AJC leaders Abe Foxman and David Harris call for scrapping DEI Their positions are in contrast with the groups’ current desire to work within the system By Haley Cohen December 20, 2023 Abe Foxman and David Harris, two former longtime leaders of prominent Jewish communal organizations, called for an end...
  • @megabar
    @Bardon Kaldian

    > This shows hypocrisy and ethnic self-centredness of dominant American Jewish public voices & leaders of their advocacy groups.

    Agreed. This is understandable, as all groups put their own interests first. It's natural and not particularly contemptible.

    What it does not show is self-awareness; the role of Jewish influence on Western values that has created this mess.

    Replies: @Arclight, @Almost Missouri

    Correct. I am not in the “it’s always the joooos” camp on the right whose almost religious beliefs around their control over society are essentially the same as the left’s when it comes to whites in general.

    However, Jews have played a hugely outsized role in the intellectual life of modern America, particularly in journalism, entertainment, media, and foreign policy and generally but not exclusively from the left. Therefore it’s not out of bounds to note their role in some of the most massive policy mistakes of the last 100 years and look at the latest positions with a gimlet eye.

    That said, if you have a group that punches way above its weight that has come around to the idea that the beast they helped unleash needs to be put down, welcome that. DEI is pure poison and it’s great if the left is now on the defensive around this issue as it prevents them from pushing forward on other fronts at least temporarily. I don’t think there will be a huge swing in Jewish political allegiance because old habits are hard to break, but to the extent that there is some it’s great – converts are often more zealous than anyone else, and obviously brings with them resources and influence.

    • Replies: @megabar
    @Arclight

    > That said, if you have a group that punches way above its weight that has come around to the idea that the beast they helped unleash needs to be put down, welcome that.

    I agree with that, but one shouldn't forget past decisions. Deciding whether a past disagreement is self-interest or a mistake (which may not repeat), or whether it's a more fundamental difference in values (which probably will repeat) is not always easy.

  • iSteve commenter JohnnyWalker123 writes: After reading about [Raj] Chetty’s study on social mobility back a few years ago, I decided to do my own analysis to determine the best states to live and raise a child. I don’t have access to a huge amount of “anonymized data” or a team of PHD researchers, but I...
  • An interesting exercise but have my doubts about just how accurate it is. My state is in the bottom half and I have family in a state way near the top that I visit several times a year and there is no way I would trade locations – partly due to weather (warmer here) but also because of politics. The strangest thing about visiting the allegedly high performing state is that people who I would normally expect to be right of center based on their lives, income, etc. – and would be where I live – are often unthinking Democrats, even when the collateral damage of putting this party in charge directly affects them and they know it. The levels of delusion are off the charts and would drive me absolutely crazy if I had to live there.

    I am well aware of the shortcomings of my state on a macro scale, and I also live in a large city so that sometimes means grinding my teeth at the local politics and incompetence. However, I have a high quality of life at a very reasonable price and the more troublesome elements of my burg I primarily only have to deal with in traffic or retail establishments, and my kids laugh at all the woke/trans stuff. It’s not perfect but I am pretty happy with my situation and I have close friends who are transplants from blue America that are also grateful to be raising their families here as well.

    • Agree: Achmed E. Newman
    • Replies: @Guest007
    @Arclight

    I joke all the time when meeting people that if they lived in a different state and county, that they would have different politics. Whites in Maryland can be Democrats because enough whites are Democrats that they can keep blacks out of real power. However, whites in Texas have to be automatic Democratic Party voters to keep Hispanics out of power. Thus, a white upper middle class voter is a Democratic in Howard County Maryland but a Republican in Plano Texas.

    Replies: @Art Deco

  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: Read the whole thing
  • @Ganderson
    @Arclight

    “ There’s also the fact that a lot of young basketball talent ends up playing loads of AAU games in which physical ability is highlighted but there not as much game fundamentals, and the latter is where white kids can shine more if allowed to develop”

    I don’t know shit about basketball (and care even less), but the point about development makes sense. In hockey, which I do know something about there used to be (by the Canucks who controlled the sport for many years*) tremendous bias against American, and American college players, as compared to those going the Canadian Junior route. What began to become clear, and was even noticed by some as far back as the 70s, is that college players have more time to develop, and get more practice time, and are thus more ready for the next level. Part of it is age, but… A top 20 NCAA team these days would beat a Tier 1 Junior team most of the time.

    Also hockey players tend not to have names like Jonquavious…

    * Here in Bruins-land there’s lots of nostalgia for the Original Six (Montreal, Toronto, Detroit, Chicago, Boston and the New York Rangers).

    I prefer to think of the Original Six Era as “The Time When Americans (or any other Non-Canadians) were not allowed in the NHL.” Billy Cleary of Boston and Harvard University (no info as to whether he plagiarized anything) and John Mayasich of Eveleth, MN and the University of Minnesota were the stars of the 1960 Gold Medal-winning US Olympic team- neither even tried to go the NHL route, as it meant years of riding the busses, with very little chance of making the bigs.

    Original Six… Bah Humbug!

    Replies: @Arclight, @Ian M.

    It’s not uncommon in youth basketball to see a kid on a team where he outshines everyone else and against weaker competition to generate highlight reel performances and recordings that get sent out to recruiters for HS or college. One of my kids played in a game in which the opposing team (who we knew) had a ringer show up for our matchup complete with tripods and multiple cameras. He then proceeded to score something like 50 of his team’s 60 points and we never saw him again. It was a useless exercise for everyone on the court.

  • I snarked five years ago about the brilliant staff assembled by Raj Chetty, now the Bill Ackman Professor of Economics back at Harvard, to do breakthrough analyses of anonymized official data from the IRS, Census, College Board, and the like: Chetty is of course a South Asian. Of the other 12 people in the photo,...
  • @ic1000
    > I can actually see a bit of logic behind the complaint about how your undergrad alma mater is weighted versus your own academic performance...

    I think you have it backwards. If Chetty wanted to prioritize staffing his lab with math-capable pre-docs, "What was your SAT Math score?" is a much better criterion than "What was your college class' average SAT Math score?"

    On the other hand: If Top Universities are good at recruiting the best black high-school seniors (they are), Chetty's rubric will give these applicants (i.e. mathy blacks attending top-tier universities) a leg up, compared to their competitors with less-desirable genetics.

    In 2019, Sailer highlighted Gringo's contribution in the Comments on the paucity of blacks with high SAT Math scores. From a 2006 article:


    In 2005, 153,132 African Americans took the SAT test. They made up 10.4% of all SAT test takers… we find that in the entire country 244 blacks scored 750 or above on the math SAT... Nationwide, 33,841 students scored at least 750 on the math test.
     
    Here is a more recent Brookings Institution commentary on a Chetty paper that also looks at 2015 scores: Race gaps in SAT math scores are as big as ever.

    ...we estimate that at most only 1,000 blacks and 2,400 Latinos scored above a 750, compared to some 16,000 whites and 29,600 Asians.

    [URL for the "Race gaps in math SAT scores" graph below the fold, as the image may not reproduce properly.]

    ... In fact, the truncated nature of the SAT math score distribution could even suggest that these race gaps would be even larger given a harder exam with a bigger score variance.
     

    If Chetty wants to tweet a photo of his lab that highlights a correct diversity of racial features and pigmentation (he does), he has a steep climb ahead. Each year, there are no more than ~250 (2005 data) or ~1,000 (2015 data) members of the crucial demographic who could apply to the Opportunity Insights pre-doc program with "Very good or better" math scores. And Chetty is seeking "Outstanding."

    Claudine Gay could explain the problem better than I can, and demonstrate the opportunities and pitfalls of the most-obvious and most-common solution to it.

    https://i2.wp.com/www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/reeves_racegaps_figure001.png

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon, @Arclight

    Appreciate your comment. It makes the squawking about using average school math scores short-sighted – like me, they don’t realize it’s actually probably a net add for ‘diverse’ applicants.

    All the same, it’s hard to respect Chetty in a lot of ways. He concocts fundamentally dishonest narratives on magic dirt/ZIP codes rather than going down uncomfortable paths in the pursuit of knowledge. Billions of dollars are spent annually by various actors that are steadfastly dedicated to not noticing. What an incredible waste of money and intellectual capital.

    • Agree: ic1000, Meretricious
  • I can actually see a bit of logic behind the complaint about how your undergrad alma mater is weighted versus your own academic performance as there are a lot of reasons why a student might not have gone to the most elite of schools – for Asians or whites its affirmative action working against them, for everybody it could simply be they got a better financial aid package, wanted to be in a specific location more than others, etc., etc. Giving a half point pat on the head for attending the better BHCUs is laughable – Spelman and Howard are considered the best, get undue credit in college rankings, and frankly are 3rd tier at best. Given the other criteria, this category probably serves as a way for Chetty to say “we tried” but not actually have to hire anyone significantly below the target caliber.

    The phenomena that Chetty and others like him repeatedly demonstrate but are determined not to measure is how much political shibboleths around race and diversity distort intellectual honesty.

    • Replies: @ic1000
    @Arclight

    Arclight, this comment at 2:00 pm GMT is a Reply to yours.

  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: Read the whole thing
  • We are now in an era in which a non-insignificant number of athletes are 2nd generation pros as well, and in some cases have mothers who were accomplished amateur athletes, so perhaps there is some civilizing influence going on there combined with shared interests that make these relationships work. I do find it interesting how LeBron James is the son of a teen mother but has stuck with his high school girlfriend (now wife) to raise his kids, but apparently she grew up with married parents and no doubt that influenced things. I suspect – but don’t know for obvious reasons – that amongst wealthy black ex-athletes that there is a social pecking order between those like James that have adopted a more mainstream and respectable existence that gives them continued access to respectable/white society versus those that are essentially still hood people with money.

    I do agree with Steve’s observation about the benefits of slower to physically develop white boys playing the game with fewer black competitors when young. I think it’s pretty well established that blacks hit puberty earlier than whites, and as parent of kids that play a lot of basketball it appears to me that generally there is on average noticeable physical separation by the end of middle school. There’s also the fact that a lot of young basketball talent ends up playing loads of AAU games in which physical ability is highlighted but there not as much game fundamentals, and the latter is where white kids can shine more if allowed to develop.

    • Replies: @Ganderson
    @Arclight

    “ There’s also the fact that a lot of young basketball talent ends up playing loads of AAU games in which physical ability is highlighted but there not as much game fundamentals, and the latter is where white kids can shine more if allowed to develop”

    I don’t know shit about basketball (and care even less), but the point about development makes sense. In hockey, which I do know something about there used to be (by the Canucks who controlled the sport for many years*) tremendous bias against American, and American college players, as compared to those going the Canadian Junior route. What began to become clear, and was even noticed by some as far back as the 70s, is that college players have more time to develop, and get more practice time, and are thus more ready for the next level. Part of it is age, but… A top 20 NCAA team these days would beat a Tier 1 Junior team most of the time.

    Also hockey players tend not to have names like Jonquavious…

    * Here in Bruins-land there’s lots of nostalgia for the Original Six (Montreal, Toronto, Detroit, Chicago, Boston and the New York Rangers).

    I prefer to think of the Original Six Era as “The Time When Americans (or any other Non-Canadians) were not allowed in the NHL.” Billy Cleary of Boston and Harvard University (no info as to whether he plagiarized anything) and John Mayasich of Eveleth, MN and the University of Minnesota were the stars of the 1960 Gold Medal-winning US Olympic team- neither even tried to go the NHL route, as it meant years of riding the busses, with very little chance of making the bigs.

    Original Six… Bah Humbug!

    Replies: @Arclight, @Ian M.

  • Can you remember all the way back to when Trump was fading in the polls among Republican voters and the third of a century younger DeSantis appeared likely to make the Republican nomination a strong two man race? Well, Democrats quickly began taking legal action against Trump, culminating today in a Colorado state court denying...
  • Not sure if this is truly a sign of desperation by the left or if it’s a sign that they think they are untouchable. Probably more of the latter, although if for some reason this stands and/or Colorado and other states refuse to comply with any SCOTUS ruling, couldn’t the House simply refuse to certify the electors from states that do this?

    In any case, yet another example of the left taking action that will bring into being the very thing they say they are trying to prevent. Removing the filibuster for approval of federal judges in the Obama years was then used by Republicans to get through multiple SCOTUS nominees. Alleging some organized white racial solidarity that doesn’t exist is harming minorities has led to policies that will almost certainly result in the birth of actual white racial consciousness, and now trying to implement a method in which partisan judges can prevent candidates from standing for election on the basis of crimes they haven’t been charged with, much less convicted of, would kick off a wave of retaliation that would make a national election impossible.

  • This is pretty funny. From DNYUZ: How College Football Is Clobbering Housing Markets Across the Country December 18, 2023 Rashe Malcolm loves her son Wayne and his girlfriend, but she’d also love it if they could move out of the three-bedroom home in Athens, Ga., that she shares with the couple, both 23, as well...
  • Yes, successful football programs make schools more attractive but no, it’s not short term rentals skewing the market. My wife went to a school that won the Rose Bowl twice while she was there and it resulted in a surge in interest in foreign and East Coast students who could pay the full freight and didn’t want to live in some run down rental or traditional dorm. Prior to Covid there was a 10 year boom in the construction of new highly amenitized student housing and the PSF rents owners could get were staggering compared to traditional new multifamily. That reset the rental market around a lot of campuses and naturally all other rentals get a boost from it as well.

  • The All White NFL All-Star team will run a 3 tight end offense and have Christian McCaffrey carry 37 times. Game statistics: All-White All Stars Rushing: 40 carries, 150 yards (Christian McCaffrey: 37 carries, 160 yards), 1 TD Passing: 25 out of 30, 200 yards, 1 TD Punting: 8 punts, 51 yard average Points After...
  • @R.G. Camara
    @ScarletNumber

    Tirico, as he has jovially repeated many times throughout his long broadcasting career, believes he isn't black and is merely dark-skinned Italian. Both of his parents who raised him are Italian and no has said anything about a cuck situation. It could be his mom was cheating but Tirico's persona doesn't hint at anything.

    Personally, I think Tirico has actually played into the whole "I look black" thing for his career, shaving his head, and likely getting tanning and makeup touchups to play up the mistake---and thus getting affirmative action points. Someone probably told him when he was young that he looked black with a tan and a lightbulb went off over his head.

    Certainly he doesn't announce at every game he's not black, but if asked he claims he's not---but who would ask? So he has the plausible deniability: hey, if you think I'm black, you're incorrect, but until you verbalize it I'm going to be out here doing my job that I was given by affirmative action points. And now that he's well-established in media he's fine with it.

    Replies: @ScarletNumber, @Mike Tre, @Arclight, @Larry, San Francisco, @Stealth

    From what I’ve read, Tirico is pretty hardcore insistent that his is a paisan and clearly doesn’t like the questions about his potential black heritage. I say fine, if he’s really proud of the Italian side that’s way better than the self-hating clowns like Nikole Hannah-Jones, Adam Serwer and the like.

    Obviously there are a lot more black NFL analysts today but I actually like several of them quite a bit. Louis Riddick has a sort of GM’s mind and is very sharp, Shannon Sharpe is good, Domonique Foxworth, and even Richard Sherman all have worthwhile insights. I actually find a lot of the white ones really annoying – Skip Bayless is awful, Rex Ryan is an aged fratboy, Greeny is just OK, and Rich Eisen is basically the only white guy I can listen to for an extended period of time. Nick Wright is also generally annoying but the only thing I like about his show is that he, Broussard and Wildes all clearly like each other, whereas there is a lot of tension on most of the others.

    *I would also add that Shannon Sharpe and Chad OchoCinco’s “Nightcap” is generally a pretty good show.

    • Replies: @Mike Tre
    @Arclight

    Shannon Sharp is awful. Overbearing blackity black. Talks like he has bubble wrap wrapped around his tongue. No white guy with that type of speech impediment would ever get that job.

    Richard Sherman? My god man. Get out of the house more often.

    Replies: @Rick P, @John Milton's Ghost

  • A great historic challenge for the American republic was reconciliation between the North and South following the Civil War. The country remained deeply divided in the late 19th Century. For example, baseball had become the "national pastime" in the North during the Civil War as soldiers killed time playing baseball in Union army camps. Up...
  • There is a reason the modern left is not allowing the accommodations or peace of the past remain standing – they have been waging a cold civil war that was largely out of sight or under the surface to the average American but is increasingly out in the open because they believe a decisive moment in which they are the new victors is close at hand, and unlike the last civil conflict they have no intention of showing any magnanimity towards the vanquished.

    • Agree: Renard
  • From The Lancet, the famous British medical research journal, as it celebrates its 200th anniversary this year:
  • I used to have a live and let-live mindset, now I am increasingly very pro-marginalization.

    • Replies: @Inquiring Mind
    @Arclight

    I want a live and let-live mindset, and I want my tote/hand/man-bag!

    The Trans Queer Engineering society at the U posted a handbill that they were hosting an open house at the Makerspace (wasn't such a thing back-in-the-day called a workshop?). They were giving away tote bags that they would monogram for you.

    I went there, and I did not see a visibly Trans or Queer engineer. All I saw was a group of South Asian dudes trying to figure out how to use the thermal monogram thingy along with a line of about 20 students waiting for a handbag that wasn't moving.

    I thought the Trans Queer engineers on campus were seeking to foster acceptance and inclusion by giving out some merch. I feel cheated.

  • Back when the George Floyd Racial Reckoning frenzy was at its peak of insanity in early June 2020, with the Mostly Peaceful Protests emptying the sneaker shops of America and burning down big city shopping streets, the New York Times op-ed page published an opinion piece by Republican Senator Tom Cotton calling for the military...
  • @SFG
    I always wonder how much the previously officially ‘neutral’ institutions like the NYT going from implicitly to obviously biased and dropping the pretense of objectivity helped elect Trump. It was probably a lot more obvious to Middle Americans the elites hated them.

    Replies: @Arclight

    Probably a same dynamic with modern commercials – I’ve had more than one left leaning relative comment that there are almost no white people in commercials anymore and minorities get shoehorned in to a ridiculous degree. My current favorite is the crusty old black llama farmer.

  • I've always found Joe Biden and his travails mildly amusing. He's not as hilarious as Donald Trump, but there are echoes. For example, he washed out of the 1988 presidential run because of repeated examples of plagiarism. Granted, it's hard to imagine Trump reading somebody else's stuff and thinking, "Wow, that's really good, better than...
  • @Jim Don Bob
    @Arclight


    A determined minority is what is required to effect large scale change and obviously the left over the last 50 years has shown more determination. The same can work for the right if it has the nerve to try and refuses to play by the rules the left has set out.
     
    The Left never gives up and many on the Right, me included, just want to be left the hell alone. Just look at all the gun control measures recently passed by states that fly in the face of the Bruen decision. The game here seems to be "we will pass these knowing they will be struck down but in the mean time you have to obey them and go hire lawyers to fight them." Lawfare indeed.

    2) This guy (https://cbradleythompson.substack.com/p/au-revoir-harvard) recounts Claudine "BLACK" Gay's recent adventures, but then highlights an August 2020 memo that then Dean Claudine Gay sent to the Harvard Faculty of Arts and Sciences.

    "People across the world have risen up in protest against police brutality and systemic racism, awake to the devastating legacies of slavery and white supremacy like never before. The calls for racial justice heard on our streets also echo on our campus, as we reckon with our individual and institutional shortcomings and with our Faculty’s shared responsibility to bring truth to bear on the pernicious effects of structural inequality."

    Harvard knew exactly what they were getting when they hired her.

    Replies: @Arclight

    It’s true that many on the right just want to be left alone, whereas the reason people on the left get up in the morning is to resume meddling in other people’s lives and making it worse for those they don’t like. That’s a big advantage in terms of where energy is directed.

    For people like us, it’s important to realize that the most effective way to shift public opinion is to make sure lots of ordinary people have to live with the consequences of progressive politics or be confronted with unpleasant facts – to the point of pain. Based on some of the things Chris Rufo has accomplished recently and things like shipping illegals to blue cities/states, the adoption of near-universal school vouchers in some states, it seems at least some kind of conservative ecosystem is emerging that has the energy to apply pressure that will take time to be fully felt but has big potential. Some financial support of those you feel are most effective is good and if there is an opportunity to volunteer your time or talent just a bit, that’s good as well.

    Our illustrious host here is a good example – his influence has grown and grown and it’s partly possible because some people are able to toss some money his way once or twice a year so he can keep doing what he does. Money well spent if you ask me – there is no question he has helped shift the Overton window on the right and perhaps in certain quarters of the left, and I am overdue for another contribution.

    The left was willing to play the long game and that’s why there are where they are. If you don’t want to directly work against them at least try to empower those that do.

  • Back when the George Floyd Racial Reckoning frenzy was at its peak of insanity in early June 2020, with the Mostly Peaceful Protests emptying the sneaker shops of America and burning down big city shopping streets, the New York Times op-ed page published an opinion piece by Republican Senator Tom Cotton calling for the military...
  • I mean it’s great to have someone like this show they recognize some of the toxic qualities of their staff and operational practices, but it’s sort of stating the obvious rather than a warning. He and others should have acted on this 10-15 years ago to have a meaningful impact and they didn’t. Not exactly a profile in courage.

    I subscribe to the NYT because it still has several sections around culture, science, cooking, business, etc. that are quite good and I enjoy. The news is even on occasion less partisan than one would expect. The op-ed portion is an insane dumpster fire – as Bennett notes, the contributors spend a lot of time describing their impressions of an America that doesn’t actually exist. I read Jamelle Bouie’s latest fever dream of an op-ed, titled how red and blue states are increasingly like different countries. “Accurate” I thought to myself before diving into a bizarro world account that had little hold on reality.

    You can basically read any op-ed headline and look at the author’s headshot and you automatically know exactly what they are saying.

  • I've always found Joe Biden and his travails mildly amusing. He's not as hilarious as Donald Trump, but there are echoes. For example, he washed out of the 1988 presidential run because of repeated examples of plagiarism. Granted, it's hard to imagine Trump reading somebody else's stuff and thinking, "Wow, that's really good, better than...
  • @AnotherDad
    The sheer mediocrity of Joe Biden is sort of dazzling. Over a long career he has demonstrated this repeatedly. (Even his personal corruption--using the leverage of US aid, so his loser son could collect bribes--was just pathetically open, direct, obvious, old style graft. It's only the protection of the hyper-politicized establishment in the Trump era that he skated free and clear on that. In bigger pond--a bigger state--someone more on the ball would probably have dispatched him long ago.

    But what really sets Biden apart is the absolute emptiness of his empty suit.

    A lot of these mediocrities do have a few ideas that they truly believe in and repeatedly show up in their positions, policies even if what most of what they do is transactional, crank turning. Bush and Gore--both mediocre but solidly smarter than Biden--come to mind. (Bush was motivated by his happy-dappy Christian world uplift do-gooderism--which happens to be a policy set--invade/invite--that is a disaster for Americans.)

    Biden's suit is empty. First he's an anti-war and civil rights poseur. Then quickly an everyman poseur. Then he's a lock up the (black) predators up tough on crime poseur. The only consistency in his Senate career was keeping Wall Street happy. Obama tapped him precisely because he was a generic "centrist" white guy without notable positions one way or another whose presence would reassure white voters while still keeping hope alive.

    But now--having shown no particular interest in it his whole life, nor any particular hostility to his own people--Biden in his late 70s suddenly converts to parroting the most crude atavistic anti-white-gentile attitudes and being the front man for their "drown the goyim!" immivasion.

    This is a man who is completely empty--a man of nothing. The Jews driving and blacks bureaucratically clunking along--while evil--at least have their tribal allegiance--and hatreds. Kapo comes to mind. But even the kapo is a higher order, he sells out to hopefully save his skin. Biden did not have to do any of this. Biden is an empty man, blackness reigns where his soul should be. A man for the Ninth Circle.

    Replies: @Joe Paluka, @Arclight

    I worked in Congress for a Dem over 2 decades ago and even then Biden was widely considered to be a total doofus that was laughed at by other members and their staffs – when Obama picked him as VP there was a lot of tittering over it although everyone assumed it was a meaningless appointment.

    I have a very low opinion of the left having once been actively involved on that side, but I have to admit it is still surprising how much self-gaslighting goes on by people who really ought to know better on the left about who Biden is and his mental capabilities even when he was decades younger, much less the husk that he is now. The same people that will lecture others about our precious democracy participated in a total fraud to get this stooge elected so thousands of mostly unknown operatives could carry out an ideological mission even most Democrats would not be on board with.

    • Thanks: Almost Missouri, S
    • Replies: @Guest007
    @Arclight

    If the Republicans were a functioning party, they would have nominated someone who could have beaten Biden. However, much like the Democrats nominated a very unliked candidate, the Republicans did the same in 2020.

  • @PhysicistDave
    Politicians do no doubt routinely use others' words without attribution: it would have been silly for Reagan to constantly cite the original source for the phrase "shining city upon the hill."

    But for Biden to "miscast some of his own forebears" in plagiarizing the Kinnock speech really was a bridge too far: that was not a failure of attribution but rather plain and simple lying.

    I urge everyone to read the Rufo exposé on the plagiarism committed by the president of Harvard (see here). She is guilty beyond any doubt, but, of course, Harvard has decided to mete out no punishment at all. If it were discovered that my wife or I had plagiarized our Ph.D. theses four decades after the fact, Stanford would still strip us of our doctorates. But not Claudine Gay.

    And, no, it is not mainly because she is a Black woman: it is because she is "connected."

    We live in a society in which everything is now based on artificial status -- how you are "connected." You happen to meet with the favor of the ruling class? You can cheat, steal, murder, etc. and get away with it.

    But for any reason you do not meet with the favor of the ruling class -- they will strip you of your assets, your dignity, your physical life.

    I urge everyone also to read this recent exchange between McWhorter and Glenn Loury (see here): they have both come to realize that Derek Chauvin did not kill St. George Floyd.

    Yes, I know most of us here already knew this, but it is good that Loury and McWhorter are now willing to admit that the mainstream media lied about this.

    The fundamental institutions in this society -- the schools, the universities, the media, the judiciary, the legal profession, the medical profession, etc. -- are now corrupt beyond all possiblity of redemption.

    It is Samson-in the-Temple time: time to pull it all down.

    This was once a pretty nice country. It can be again. But only if all of the institutions established in the last century -- from the Fed to the FBI and the CIA to Higher Ed to the public schools -- are torn down and burnt to ashes on the bonfire of history.

    We need to admit that this is now a deeply evil society controlled by profoundly evil people (largely though not exclusively White gentiles). And act accordingly.

    Replies: @Richard B, @NotAnonymousHere, @Observator, @Dr. DoomNGloom, @Nicholas Stix, @FPD72, @Pat Hannagan, @ic1000, @Arclight, @Joe Paluka, @Emil Nikola Richard, @danand, @Guest007, @Chrisnonymous, @Ron Mexico, @AceDeuce, @Gandydancer, @deep anonymous, @MEH 0910

    Largely agree with this – the kind of plagiarism Gay engaged in would have probably gotten me suspended in high school, yet it’s being hand-waved away by our betters. One of the key things to remember about the modern Left is that they resolutely reject the concept of objective truth or standards. Thus you can have fake narratives and twisted versions of events that must be accepted to prove their preferred version of reality or policy, or in this case having a black lady in charge is more important than her actual integrity or credentials.

    Like a lot of people on the right there was a period of time when I thought it would be possible to claw back the worst excesses of our age and society would revert back to a more sane and reasonable posture experienced in the not too distant past. But that’s not possible – as this post notes, the rot is too deep and many institutions as they currently exist must be razed. The left perversely frames any attack on captured institutions as a threat to democracy, but only fools think we have a functioning democratic system.

    Still, there is a lot of opportunity in front of us and there is no reason to be moderate – there is no going back to the past, the left will damn any opposition in the strongest possible terms no matter how mild the resistance, and they regularly provide examples of corruption that if called out will change a lot of perceptions over time. A determined minority is what is required to effect large scale change and obviously the left over the last 50 years has shown more determination. The same can work for the right if it has the nerve to try and refuses to play by the rules the left has set out.

    • Replies: @Luke Lea
    @Arclight

    "many institutions as they currently exist must be razed."

    Or simply replaced. A billion dollars is enough to found a small liberal arts college. There are plenty of billionaires around who might want to found such a college as their life's legacy. What better way to be remembered by future generations?

    I talk about this in some of the obscurer passages in my book:

    https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00U0C9HKW

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar

    , @Jim Don Bob
    @Arclight


    A determined minority is what is required to effect large scale change and obviously the left over the last 50 years has shown more determination. The same can work for the right if it has the nerve to try and refuses to play by the rules the left has set out.
     
    The Left never gives up and many on the Right, me included, just want to be left the hell alone. Just look at all the gun control measures recently passed by states that fly in the face of the Bruen decision. The game here seems to be "we will pass these knowing they will be struck down but in the mean time you have to obey them and go hire lawyers to fight them." Lawfare indeed.

    2) This guy (https://cbradleythompson.substack.com/p/au-revoir-harvard) recounts Claudine "BLACK" Gay's recent adventures, but then highlights an August 2020 memo that then Dean Claudine Gay sent to the Harvard Faculty of Arts and Sciences.

    "People across the world have risen up in protest against police brutality and systemic racism, awake to the devastating legacies of slavery and white supremacy like never before. The calls for racial justice heard on our streets also echo on our campus, as we reckon with our individual and institutional shortcomings and with our Faculty’s shared responsibility to bring truth to bear on the pernicious effects of structural inequality."

    Harvard knew exactly what they were getting when they hired her.

    Replies: @Arclight

  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: Jewish Generosity Steve Sailer December 13, 2023 As I’ve long pointed out, the most likely fault line where the Democrats’ imposing but fragile Coalition of the Fringes might fracture divides Jews and blacks. Two earlier black moments—the late-’60s Black Power era and the early-’90s Louis Farrakhan fad—both sputtered...
  • As I have posted in the past, many white progs think their allyship is providing them with some store of credit with the wokistas but it doesn’t – they still hate you and given the chance will act on it, as all the river to the sea people are demonstrating.

    Even with this in-your-face evidence, old habits die hard and I would guess the political left can still rely on Jewish support for quite some time yet, although to the extent some minds are changed or wallets closed, great. As other have noted, the persecuted minority mindset runs very deep, it’s just that literally no one else considers Jews to be that. A widespread awakening to that reality would be very useful, but we still have miles to go on that.

  • The Law of Intersectionality proves that black women, because they are women and they are black, will have the most interesting ideas. Who can even dream of all the fascinating new intellectual innovations they have in store for us? Hence, in the Washington Post opinion section, an opinion editor tells us about such novel topics...
  • I wonder if her mom not being the perfect ally is in any way related to her ungrateful and self-centered daughter’s personality made her a difficult person to share a household with?

    Mixed race people who decide to really lean into capital B blackness are really the worst – massive overcompensation and sanctimony. I am guessing fully black people don’t really like them either.

    • Replies: @Dragoslav
    @Arclight

    Agree. In Haiti, blacks killed all the mulattos.

    Replies: @Art Deco, @Muggles

  • Political historian Rick Perlstein tweeted: I respond: Rick Perlstein responded: I answered: Perlstein answered: I said in response:
  • @Dmon
    @Arclight

    I try to be hopeful, but all the stuff you mention - Democrat political split, open borders, crushing debt, low morale - all play right into the Cloward-Piven strategy. The goal is to basically destroy the fabric of society, so as to institute a nominally communist dictatorship (I say nominally communist because, as in every other dictatorship, the elites will still have plenty of material goods and creature comforts). The inability of the elected leaders to govern has already manifested itself in big blue cities, and it is not making these places anymore conservative or receptive to classical liberal ideas (guaranteed personal rights, equality under the law, etc.). If anything, it is only hastening the collapse of existing authority and greening the populace for the desired techno-police state, which governs by brute force through a symbiotic relationship with the "Intelligence" Establishment. The portion of the population which remembers and appreciates the advantages of a free country is aging and outnumbered. In a couple of decades, there won't be anybody around who understands that the US didn't have to be Brazil, that there was once an admired, successful 90% White country between Cartelexico and Sikhanada, or that people left largely alone in a free society live much better than people dependent on a remote incompetent corrupt government for their every physical need. As you say, history is not inevitable, and anything can happen, but right now the train is roaring down the tracks towards the washed-out bridge. I desperately hope I'm wrong, but here's a true story. I had a neighbor who sincerely believed that Hilary lost the 2016 election because the media's massive pro-Trump bias led them to allow Comey to sabotage her. This neighbor is a middle class manager, White, married with 2 kids. You cannot have a functional country that contains any significant number of people who are that deluded, and from what I can see, there are alot of them, the younger generations even more so. Again, anything can happen, and I am not giving up, but I would feel alot better about those Martians coming to save us if they'd stop disintegrating people.

    Replies: @Arclight, @Corvinus

    Don’t get me wrong – we are going to have to take our lumps for quite a while before there is a resolution one way or another, and where we are right now is still the run up to a more decisive period of turmoil. People like your neighbor are going to have to personally suffer for there to be a sea change, which means millions of good whites (or more likely their kids) will have to experience the blessings of diversity good and hard in school, job opportunities, safety, etc.

    Massive change happens when a critical mass of people are so sick of the status quo they will take whatever alternative is on offer so long as a core promise is to end the instability and insanity. The current spit on the left on Gaza/Israel is great, just stand back and let the fur fly. Many of our large cities are at the front end of a massive decline in their urban cores – 20 years of increased gentrification and renewal are going to be at least partially reversed thanks to the move to remote work and the crime and disorder of feckless mayors and the fact that most large city public school systems are awful and not everyone can afford private school.

    As I mentioned, DeSantis and Abbott had the brains to increase the pain on immigration by shipping them to other places and should keep that going full throttle. There will be other opportunities to make strongholds of the left have to deal with the consequences of policies they intended by borne by others. The key is not to chicken out for fear of being called a racist or fascist, but have the balls to heighten distress. The right has a long track record of losing by adhering to rules only one side is observing and ended up with its back against a wall. When that happens you can either submit or fight in any way that lets you win.

    • Agree: Achmed E. Newman
  • Back at the peak of the Mostly Peaceful Protests after George Floyd's demise, I wrote in Taki's Magazine: Q. Were you right? A. [Holds hand out palm down, wobbles it back and forth] Eh ... Black anti-Semitism tends to be more of a black male thing, while black women increasingly dominate wokeness, who tend to...
  • @Jim Don Bob
    @Arclight


    It will be interesting to see how the activist left factors into the 2024 election on this front – it’s possible they will do more than all the Evangelical Christian Israel worshippers have ever accomplished to persuade American Jews to alter their political allegiances and donor habits.
     
    I wouldn't bet any money on it. The history of millenial groups whose end of the world prophecies fail is that they don't say "Oh, well" and give up - they double down on their beliefs.

    You are right that much of the anti-Israel hate is more of the colonialist white oppressor versus dusky "native" nonsense that's been preached for years than it is anti-Semitism. A similar thing happened in South Africa in the early 90s.

    Replies: @Arclight

    I agree there might not be a lot of movement but any cracks in the facade are good…plus, the foaming at the mouth progs who are leading this right now are not going to be chastened. Through their actions they will provide additional opportunities for the left’s most important financial benefactors to rethink things. I really cannot wait for the Dem convention in Chicago.

  • From the New York Times: I can remember going to some rather austere, non-melodic punk or reggae concert 40+ years ago, and when it was over the venue put on "Dancing Queen" to clear the crowd out. But the Abba song was so infinitely better than what we'd just heard that it was the only...
  • Me too. There was a time when I subscribed to the Post because it did have more balanced news and political coverage and a decent op-ed roster. Now it’s totally unreadable and as I mentioned it doesn’t offer something like decent arts, culture, or real estate coverage to give people outside the Beltway any other reason to subscribe. It deserves to die…in darkness, lol.

  • Back at the peak of the Mostly Peaceful Protests after George Floyd's demise, I wrote in Taki's Magazine: Q. Were you right? A. [Holds hand out palm down, wobbles it back and forth] Eh ... Black anti-Semitism tends to be more of a black male thing, while black women increasingly dominate wokeness, who tend to...
  • @PhysicistDave
    @Arclight

    Arclight wrote:


    It’s amusing how the Palestinian cause is such a cherished part of leftist identity – after all, we are talking about a pretty small space on a map, a relatively small population, and a group a tiny share of Western people have any blood or personal ties to.
     
    Or just maybe some of us simply hate seeing Palestinian children murdered with weapons supplied by our own government?

    (And, yes, for the record, I do indeed also condemn the actions of Hamas on October 7. Hamas is and always has been a terror group. But two wrongs really do not make a right.)

    Replies: @Arclight

    I personally do not care about Israel and don’t support open-ended financial aid. What this is really about is the domestic forces that have come out in droves to condemn Israel and demand decolonization hold the exact same feelings about American whites and our culture and would act on it given the chance – it’s not a principled concern about Palestinians per se. What you are seeing directed against Israel is what is in store for the rest of us if this element remains ascendant, and right now they are demonstrating how far they have penetrated the intellectual centers of the left.

    • Agree: Dragoslav
    • Replies: @Mark G.
    @Arclight

    When I went to work for the military 40 years ago I took an oath to support and defend the Constitution against all enemies foreign and domestic. I look at all our foreign interventions and ask if they are furthering that goal and I really do not see how becoming involved in either Israel or the Ukraine does. So many of our foreign interventions seem either to just involve going after the traditional enemies of influential domestic ethnic groups or funneling more money to the military-industrial complex.

    I like working for the military but I want it to be used for the purpose the men who wrote the Constitution wanted it to be used for, which is the defense of this country in case we are actually attacked. I am probably an outlier in thinking in those terms.

    Replies: @Jack D, @turtle

    , @Hibernian
    @Arclight

    Agree with all of this except the first half of the first sentence.

    , @Curle
    @Arclight

    “What you are seeing directed against Israel is what is in store for the rest of us if this element remains ascendant”

    It has been happening to us for some time contemporaneous to Jewish ascendancy. Saving the Jews from their incivility and hostility to traditional gentile American culture(s), because there are several such cultures in the US, is not in the best interest of anybody who isn’t committed to destroying the legacy given some of us by our forefathers and indifferently adopted or rejected by subsequent arrivals or worse reinterpreted by opportunists.

    , @Ennui
    @Arclight

    If Palestinian civilians are the most deadly group on the planet, why are so many Israelis supporting relocating them here? Personally, I think they are to be preferred to our own lumpenprols. So, are Israeli hardliners lying about Palestinians, knowing full well they aren't dangerous, or do they not give a rat's behind about the US. Perhaps a bit of both, eh?

    LOL, but do go off on our thin line defending civilization standing side by side withour allies in Tel Aviv.

    , @PhysicistDave
    @Arclight

    Arclight wrote to me:


    I personally do not care about Israel and don’t support open-ended financial aid. What this is really about is the domestic forces that have come out in droves to condemn Israel and demand decolonization hold the exact same feelings about American whites and our culture and would act on it given the chance – it’s not a principled concern about Palestinians per se.
     
    Perhaps.

    Or perhaps what you say is true of some of them but not all of them -- just as the various attacks by commenters here on "the Jews" are on target for some Jews, but not all Jews.

    Nonetheless, innocent Palestinians are dying in large numbers and with the aid of our government and our tax dollars. We have an obligation to denounce this, even if most of those who denounce this are doing so in bad faith.

    An idea is not responsible for the people who hold it. There is such a thing as right and wrong.
  • @Lockean Proviso
    @Arclight

    While Palestine is small, Israel's influence in US politics is huge. Knowing the costs, both economic and political, of supporting expansionist Zionism should be a top priority to those who put America's self-interest first. Blank-check support for Israel has warped our foreign policy and is leading us down the road to ruin.

    Replies: @Arclight

    I do think this is a fair point – I personally think Israel needs to be treated like most other countries, a place that is sometimes useful to us and sometimes not, and certainly not the recipient of annual appropriations from the US taxpayers. At the same time, I don’t see anyone protesting our ritual billion dollar donations to places like Egypt and Pakistan or questioning what that enables either.

    So while I agree US support for Israel shouldn’t be unconditional, the overwhelming majority of the support for Palestinians is largely reflexive anti-Western, not principled humanitarian concerns. They feel the same way about American whites as they do Jewish Israelis and would apply the same “decolonial” principles to us if they could. This is the canary in the coalmine.

    • Agree: Mark G.
    • Replies: @Lurker
    @Arclight


    a place that is sometimes useful to us
     
    Israel has yet to be useful in any shape or form and its been that way for 75 years.
  • From the New York Times: I can remember going to some rather austere, non-melodic punk or reggae concert 40+ years ago, and when it was over the venue put on "Dancing Queen" to clear the crowd out. But the Abba song was so infinitely better than what we'd just heard that it was the only...
  • Personally I hate Mr. Brightside and change the channel when it comes on, but it is ubiquitous. The mention of Dancing Queen as the song played when the lights come on to signal a concert is over is funny – I have experienced that multiple times. Fortunately my own wedding did not feature a DJ so I was spared having to listen to a bunch of pop rock and disco.

    Yesterday the Washington Post’s staff apparently staged some kind of walkout, not that anyone would have noticed unless they had worked overtime on social media in the days prior to let everyone know how they deserved solidarity, presumably during work hours when they are being paid to journalism.

    However, this little wedding song piece does highlight one of the contrasts between the NYT and WaPo. Obviously the politics of the Times op-ed roster is standard dogmatic leftism, and the bias in their political and domestic news coverage is clear. On the other hand, the paper does still cover a wide variety of other subjects with often entertaining stories like this one. The Post is essentially a local paper with national political coverage that is at its best indistinguishable from the Times and often worse. I suppose with Mr. Bezos as owner there is theoretically a bottomless pile of money he *could* throw at this dog, but I am guessing in the end he won’t passively sit by as it gets ever more irrelevant and bleeds subscribers. Will be interesting to see what he does when he’s had enough.

    • Replies: @Ghost of Bull Moose
    @Arclight

    I hope Bezos treats the WaPo 'journalists' exactly as he treats his Amazon workhouse drones.

    , @Ganderson
    @Arclight

    Don’t a lot of convenience stores play country and/or classical music to keep the vibrants away?

  • Political historian Rick Perlstein tweeted: I respond: Rick Perlstein responded: I answered: Perlstein answered: I said in response:
  • @Dmon
    @Arclight

    Agree completely. But I worry that we've already had the crisis (the 2020 election), and the course is set.

    Replies: @Arclight

    That was awful, but history doesn’t stand still. There’s a lot of churn in the world – domestically the Dems have a real pickle in respect to the Israel-Gaza split in the party, the border situation is no longer just a concern of people on the right, our debt is crushing, and people are very unhappy with their prospects. Never underestimate the ability of the GOP to fumble an opportunity, but those are very good conditions for the right messenger(s) to use to inflict a lot of damage on the left. It might not result in a GOP presidential victory, but it will make it very hard for the Dems to govern.

    The right needs to learn from 2020 – the left deliberately inflicted distress on society to make it receptive to a change, if for no other reason than to make (they hoped) the bad stuff stop. It worked. There are some hints with the practice of dropping illegals off in blue cities and states that some on the right have learned from that.

    • Agree: Ben tillman
    • Replies: @Dmon
    @Arclight

    I try to be hopeful, but all the stuff you mention - Democrat political split, open borders, crushing debt, low morale - all play right into the Cloward-Piven strategy. The goal is to basically destroy the fabric of society, so as to institute a nominally communist dictatorship (I say nominally communist because, as in every other dictatorship, the elites will still have plenty of material goods and creature comforts). The inability of the elected leaders to govern has already manifested itself in big blue cities, and it is not making these places anymore conservative or receptive to classical liberal ideas (guaranteed personal rights, equality under the law, etc.). If anything, it is only hastening the collapse of existing authority and greening the populace for the desired techno-police state, which governs by brute force through a symbiotic relationship with the "Intelligence" Establishment. The portion of the population which remembers and appreciates the advantages of a free country is aging and outnumbered. In a couple of decades, there won't be anybody around who understands that the US didn't have to be Brazil, that there was once an admired, successful 90% White country between Cartelexico and Sikhanada, or that people left largely alone in a free society live much better than people dependent on a remote incompetent corrupt government for their every physical need. As you say, history is not inevitable, and anything can happen, but right now the train is roaring down the tracks towards the washed-out bridge. I desperately hope I'm wrong, but here's a true story. I had a neighbor who sincerely believed that Hilary lost the 2016 election because the media's massive pro-Trump bias led them to allow Comey to sabotage her. This neighbor is a middle class manager, White, married with 2 kids. You cannot have a functional country that contains any significant number of people who are that deluded, and from what I can see, there are alot of them, the younger generations even more so. Again, anything can happen, and I am not giving up, but I would feel alot better about those Martians coming to save us if they'd stop disintegrating people.

    Replies: @Arclight, @Corvinus

  • Back at the peak of the Mostly Peaceful Protests after George Floyd's demise, I wrote in Taki's Magazine: Q. Were you right? A. [Holds hand out palm down, wobbles it back and forth] Eh ... Black anti-Semitism tends to be more of a black male thing, while black women increasingly dominate wokeness, who tend to...
  • It’s amusing how the Palestinian cause is such a cherished part of leftist identity – after all, we are talking about a pretty small space on a map, a relatively small population, and a group a tiny share of Western people have any blood or personal ties to. There are a lot more benighted people and places to pick from, so it’s hard to avoid explanations other than anti-semitism as being a prominent factor.

    However, anti-semitism on the left is also linked to the fact that they absolutely love history’s biggest losers and loathe winners of moderate to lesser pigmentation. The same sentiment animates its absurd worship of blacks and illegal immigrants and white-hot hatred of, well, whites. It would be prudent for American Jews to realize that the left’s current open animosity is just a facet of a broader anti-white/Western bigotry and no amount of solidarity or allyship will change that – in fact it’s only going to get worse.

    Unfortunately as Steve notes, many have a deeply ingrained sense of victimhood and minority status despite vast wealth and influence, and this often leads them politically to embrace the left since it has positioned itself as the home of the supposedly underrepresented. I don’t think passing themselves off as members of the oppressed is really going to work with the current composition of the Coalition of the Fringes. Quite the opposite, in fact.

    It will be interesting to see how the activist left factors into the 2024 election on this front – it’s possible they will do more than all the Evangelical Christian Israel worshippers have ever accomplished to persuade American Jews to alter their political allegiances and donor habits.

    • Agree: Bardon Kaldian
    • Replies: @Jim Don Bob
    @Arclight


    It will be interesting to see how the activist left factors into the 2024 election on this front – it’s possible they will do more than all the Evangelical Christian Israel worshippers have ever accomplished to persuade American Jews to alter their political allegiances and donor habits.
     
    I wouldn't bet any money on it. The history of millenial groups whose end of the world prophecies fail is that they don't say "Oh, well" and give up - they double down on their beliefs.

    You are right that much of the anti-Israel hate is more of the colonialist white oppressor versus dusky "native" nonsense that's been preached for years than it is anti-Semitism. A similar thing happened in South Africa in the early 90s.

    Replies: @Arclight

    , @OldJewishGuy
    @Arclight

    “It would be prudent for American Jews to realize that the left’s current open animosity is just a facet of a broader anti-white/Western bigotry and no amount of solidarity or allyship will change that – in fact it’s only going to get worse.”

    Some of us realized this a long time ago. Not enough, unfortunately, but I hope and expect that our numbers will grow. Over time, the high fertility of the orthodox should give a strong push in this direction. The orthodox have their problems, but wokeness isn’t one of them.

    Replies: @Bardon Kaldian

    , @Lockean Proviso
    @Arclight

    While Palestine is small, Israel's influence in US politics is huge. Knowing the costs, both economic and political, of supporting expansionist Zionism should be a top priority to those who put America's self-interest first. Blank-check support for Israel has warped our foreign policy and is leading us down the road to ruin.

    Replies: @Arclight

    , @Colin Wright
    @Arclight


    '...There are a lot more benighted people and places to pick from, so it’s hard to avoid explanations other than anti-semitism as being a prominent factor...'
     
    ! Speaking for myself, Israel could have been founded by Eskimos. My feelings about it would be identical.

    The problem isn't that it's Jewish. The problem is that it's evil, and we support it.
    , @HammerJack
    @Arclight


    It’s amusing how the Palestinian cause is such a cherished part of leftist identity – after all, we are talking about a pretty small space on a map, a relatively small population, and a group a tiny share of Western people have any blood or personal ties to. There are a lot more benighted people and places to pick from, so it’s hard to avoid explanations other than anti-semitism as being a prominent factor.
     
    Well of course Jack, I mean Art. It couldn't possibly be the slaughter of tens of thousands of innocent civilians, not to mention the fact that we're forced to finance it, or the fact that we're the ones who face the occasional blowback. It must be that we're all nazis.
    , @PhysicistDave
    @Arclight

    Arclight wrote:


    It’s amusing how the Palestinian cause is such a cherished part of leftist identity – after all, we are talking about a pretty small space on a map, a relatively small population, and a group a tiny share of Western people have any blood or personal ties to.
     
    Or just maybe some of us simply hate seeing Palestinian children murdered with weapons supplied by our own government?

    (And, yes, for the record, I do indeed also condemn the actions of Hamas on October 7. Hamas is and always has been a terror group. But two wrongs really do not make a right.)

    Replies: @Arclight

    , @Curle
    @Arclight

    “There are a lot more benighted people and places to pick from, so it’s hard to avoid explanations other than anti-semitism as being a prominent factor.”

    It is an error to position this as a Left/Right phenomenon as compared to a Jewish Interest First phenomenon. Sizable numbers of conservatives are arriving at the same position as the Left, that Jewish self-interest contains no accommodation for the interests of other groups. One need not look to Palestinians for evidence of this phenomenon. That Jews in America have spearheaded a quite purposeful sabotage against historic norms of the gentile population and codified law re: mass immigration and did so with full knowledge of the huge opposition of the more historic American ethnic populations demonstrates that Jews possess aggressive anti-gentilist feelings towards their fellow Americans that they are too solipsistic as a group to moderate. It isn’t so much that anti-semitism doesn’t exist it a that anti-semitism by gentiles and others is less consequentially damaging to Jews than anti-gentilism (and other Jewish held ethnic hostilities) is to the objects of Jewish hostility. The numbers of Americans coalescing around an understanding that Jews are leaders in outgroup hate and that they should no longer be viewed as victims is the phenomenon you are seeing.

  • Political historian Rick Perlstein tweeted: I respond: Rick Perlstein responded: I answered: Perlstein answered: I said in response:
  • Leftist radicals (Cloward and Piven) in the 60s came up with a plan for political revolution that was essentially to sign up as many eligible people for welfare in the hope that it would overwhelm the system and force economic changes out of necessity to deal with a crisis.

    That’s probably at the heart of the Great Replacement as well, and the flood of illegals is designed to make the problem so large that politicians say we must just legalize them all rather than deport. Once that’s accomplished the left will have a stranglehold on national politics, and they will then push through redistributionist economic and social policies that would have no chance of being adopted with the legacy American electorate.

    We are clearly approaching some kind of moment of crisis in which the outcome will chart the course of the country for generations.

    • Agree: Mark G., Jim Don Bob
    • Replies: @Dmon
    @Arclight

    Agree completely. But I worry that we've already had the crisis (the 2020 election), and the course is set.

    Replies: @Arclight

    , @Chrisnonymous
    @Arclight

    I don't think redistributive state is the motivation. Look to gun control, 15 minute cities, and Bill Gates' farm land buy-ups to understand what the left is interested in and where the country is heading.

  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: DIE in the Air Steve Sailer December 06, 2023 As I may have mentioned now and then, there’s much wrong about the 2020s, but it’s also worth mentioning something right: We’re living in the golden age of airliner safety. The last fatal crash of a commercial flight of...
  • @Achmed E. Newman
    @Arclight


    He is absolutely no-nonsense at extremely fastidious in attention to detail.
     
    Indeed, that's the kind you need. Auditing could mean a lot of jobs, but if this guy is an inspector in the maintenance realm, well, I wrote about this too. With less competent maintenance, it's not like planes are going to start going down regularly. There'll just be more delays and even cancellations: Again:

    It takes very thorough mechanics and inspectors in the hangars at night to put the aircraft in the condition so there won’t be so many little things cropping up on the line. Line maintenance (working while passengers are impatiently waiting at the gate or onboard) mostly does electronic resets, deferrals, quick swap-outs of parts, and tightening up of knobs, wiring harnesses, etc.

    The less stuff that gets overlooked in the hangar, the lower chance of these intermittent little things cropping up during the day.

    That takes guys like your acquaintance.

    Replies: @Arclight

    He is definitely perfect for that kind of job. While I wouldn’t call him tightly wound, he is one of those guys where everything has to be done right no matter what it is and he is very disciplined in everything he does. Adding to that is that he really, really enjoys what he does for a living and is very proud of it. Hopefully there are a lot of other like him in similar roles.

  • The PISA test is a lavishly funded exam of math, reading, and science for a sample of 15 year olds in 77 countries (e.g., in the U.S., 4,450 students across 297 schools, public and private) that's given every 3 or 4 years. It's inherently hard to give a test in multiple languages and have it...
  • @Redneck Farmer
    @Arclight

    Accounting is a big, underappreciated issue. My understanding is a lot of "student services" in the rest of the world aren't considered part of the school budget, but are here.

    Replies: @Arclight

    Makes sense. One issue my local district is dealing with is that despite declining enrollment over the years demands that kids be able to go to school in their neighborhood means they have a number of aging school buildings that are operating at half capacity, so obviously there are a lot of unnecessary utility and maintenance costs as a result.

    Another issue is the cost of operating and maintaining a bus fleet and/or contracting it out. Not sure if it’s normal in many other countries for this to be part of the operating cost of a school district or if kids are more able to walk or use public transportation.

    Lastly, one thing that may be fairly unique in American school spending is that teachers unions are a huge source of cash for the Democratic party, so there is every incentive to keep staffing high and expensive to ensure the mandatory dues are healthy so they can be turned into political donations.

  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: DIE in the Air Steve Sailer December 06, 2023 As I may have mentioned now and then, there’s much wrong about the 2020s, but it’s also worth mentioning something right: We’re living in the golden age of airliner safety. The last fatal crash of a commercial flight of...
  • @Mr. XYZ
    Parity, not parody.

    Replies: @HammerJack, @Anonymous, @AndrewR, @Danindc, @Arclight, @Reg Cæsar, @Hibernian

    A couple of years ago my trash local paper ran a few op-ed columns written by blacks about how everyone ought to look to them more for leadership, and apparently a condition of that was these pieces were run without any editing whatsoever. Each piece was chock full of misspellings, huge grammatical errors and naturally circular logic. I half wondered if some subversive editor had insisted on publishing them untouched as a backdoor way of highlighting what diversity gets us but haven’t seen anything since that leads me to believe that the people that run the paper are not all in on equity.

    At any rate, Steve’s column is scary stuff. Somewhat on-topic I do know a black guy who is a safety auditor for an airline, and he grouses about the stuff he and his team turn up on a regular basis as well, although I have no idea what the demographics are of the people whose work he is double checking. My acquaintance wanted to be involved in aviation since he was a kid and deliberately pursued a degree that would allow him to do so, which seems to me to be the type of person you want involved in stuff like this. He is absolutely no-nonsense at extremely fastidious in attention to detail.

    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
    @Arclight


    He is absolutely no-nonsense at extremely fastidious in attention to detail.
     
    Indeed, that's the kind you need. Auditing could mean a lot of jobs, but if this guy is an inspector in the maintenance realm, well, I wrote about this too. With less competent maintenance, it's not like planes are going to start going down regularly. There'll just be more delays and even cancellations: Again:

    It takes very thorough mechanics and inspectors in the hangars at night to put the aircraft in the condition so there won’t be so many little things cropping up on the line. Line maintenance (working while passengers are impatiently waiting at the gate or onboard) mostly does electronic resets, deferrals, quick swap-outs of parts, and tightening up of knobs, wiring harnesses, etc.

    The less stuff that gets overlooked in the hangar, the lower chance of these intermittent little things cropping up during the day.

    That takes guys like your acquaintance.

    Replies: @Arclight

  • The PISA test is a lavishly funded exam of math, reading, and science for a sample of 15 year olds in 77 countries (e.g., in the U.S., 4,450 students across 297 schools, public and private) that's given every 3 or 4 years. It's inherently hard to give a test in multiple languages and have it...
  • US spending on education is probably largely a worthless metric, as it doesn’t really translate to the quality of instructors or anything like that. A big chunk of it is just the cost of maintaining the school district’s facilities, and the rest is often just a measure of how much the teachers unions have managed to chisel out of the taxpayers elected representatives (who are on the same side as the teachers, not the taxpayers) in wages.

    I have no idea how other countries spend on those items or if they tend to run leaner on the admin side (how could they not?), but as everyone here knows the demographic profile of a given district matters most. I would actually be interested to know what methods of instruction are typically followed in high performing Asian countries. At a guess a lot of it is likely rote work – particularly on math – but obviously our racial politics means there is an entire ecosystem of consultants and supposed reformers that are constantly trying to devise a silver bullet solution to tough to swallow results.

    • Replies: @Redneck Farmer
    @Arclight

    Accounting is a big, underappreciated issue. My understanding is a lot of "student services" in the rest of the world aren't considered part of the school budget, but are here.

    Replies: @Arclight

  • From the New York Times news section: Let me guess. A large fraction of female magicians are either the wives or daughters of male magicians? In general, the weirder the profession, the higher the percentage of women pros who are the wives or daughters of men pros. One of the dirty little secrets of feminism...
  • @MEH 0910
    @Arclight

    https://variety.com/2023/film/features/nia-dacosta-the-marvels-1235785554/


    How ‘The Marvels’ Got Its Blerd Girl Energy
    Nia DaCosta ignored the haters and made the movie her teenage self would want to see
    By Angelique Jackson
    Nov 9, 2023
    [...]
    The setting is apropos for how DaCosta’s life has played out over the past seven years — racing from one project to the next. DaCosta was 28 when her debut feature, “Little Woods,” starring Tessa Thompson and Lily James, won the Nora Ephron Award for female filmmakers at the Tribeca Film Festival. Then, with 2021’s “Candyman,” she became the first Black female director to hit No. 1 at the box office on opening weekend. When that milestone was announced, she was already on set for “The Marvels.” At 31, DaCosta became the youngest person — and the first Black woman — to helm a Marvel Studios picture.
    [...]
    She also wanted to satisfy the Blerd (Black nerd) in her, who’d grown up absorbed in comic book culture. The Brooklyn-born filmmaker was especially keen to tell Kamala’s story because she was a huge fan of the Ms. Marvel comics, which debuted when she was in her teens. “Usually I’m not like, ‘I like this person because I see myself — a tri-state area nerd who loves superhero and comic stuff and writes fan fiction,’” DaCosta says. “But she’s a great street-level hero, an heir to Spider-Man.”
    [...]
    Like other IP-based movies that star women and people of color, the impending release of 2019’s “Captain Marvel” met with such malignance that Rotten Tomatoes changed its policy to bar audience reviews on unreleased titles. In 2022, “Ms. Marvel” faced the same level of internet hate. And now, any post about “The Marvels” is flooded with comments criticizing Disney for “going woke” and rooting for the film to flop.

    DaCosta is familiar with the negative side of fandom — after all, she’s been a “big ol’ fan of nerdy shit for a long time” — but she’s not letting it get under her skin.

    “There are pockets where you go because you’re like, ‘I’m a super fan. I want to exist in the space of just adoration — which includes civilized critique,” she explains. “Then there are pockets that are really virulent and violent and racist — and sexist and homophobic and all those awful things. And I choose the side of the light. That’s the part of fandom I’m most attracted to.”
     


    https://variety.com/2023/film/news/bob-iger-disney-too-man-sequels-explains-marvels-flop-1235814475/

    ‘The Marvels’ Suffered From a Lack of ‘Supervision on the Set,’ Says Bob Iger; Disney CEO Admits Studio Has ‘Made Too Many’ Sequels Recently
    By Zack Sharf
    Nov 30, 2023

    Disney CEO Bob Iger said at the New York Times’ DealBook Summit (via CNBC) following “The Marvels” flopping at the box office that there was a lack of supervision on the set of the film as a result of the COVID pandemic. The combination of pandemic set restrictions and Disney’s increased output due to the launch of streamer Disney+ made it increasingly difficult for studio executives to oversee the onslaught of new productions.

    Since opening in theaters in November, the Brie Larson-led Marvel sequel has only grossed $77 million at the domestic box office and $187 million worldwide. It’s the biggest flop yet in the Marvel Cinematic Universe and is shaping up to be the first MCU title not to cross the $100 million mark domestically.

    ″‘The Marvels’ was shot during Covid,” Iger explained. “There wasn’t as much supervision on the set, so to speak, where we have executives [that are] really looking over what’s being done day after day after day.”

    “The Marvels” flop follows other underperforming Disney films from this year such as “Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania” and “Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny.” As Variety reported earlier this month, 2023 will mark the first time since 2014 (except for the pandemic-stricken years of 2020 and 2021) that Disney hasn’t launched a billion-dollar release. The studio had seven billion dollar grosses in 2019, including “Avengers: Endgame” and “The Lion King.”
     

    Replies: @MEH 0910, @Arclight

    Thanks. I personally am totally bored by the Marvel and DC stuff – I enjoyed the first Ironman, liked the Guardians of the Galaxy movies (haven’t seen the 3rd) and was forced to watch another 3 or 4 because of my kids and just cannot get into it. I think these cinematic universes have probably punched themselves out to some degree and even fans have gotten tired of the deluge of offerings and are more likely to skip them in the theaters.

    I do feel sorry for the director a bit – it’s not easy to make a good movie and being a superfan of the genre is not enough. Readers may recall that Ta-Nehisi Coates tried his hand at comic book writing and apparently did very poorly. Based on what you posted, DaCosta does have some pure love of the genre but I would guess the pressure to make it about grrrls is pretty intense and her angle to get the gig, whereas if she has just pitched a more conventional story she might not have gotten the movie made.

    I also do feel for blerds in general – it’s a tough balance to strike socially and it would be easy to just collapse into race-based rage as a result. That’s basically what happened to TNC – his natural instinct was to be a big soft geek but his militant dad and surroundings demanded he be something else to be authentic and have their approval, plus the scum that runs The Atlantic basically needed a black beard to launder their own anti-white hatred. Faced with the possibility of selling out and making great money or trying to carve his own independent path, he chose the former and I really cannot entirely blame him for it.

  • The Washington Post has put together a database of mass shootings, with yet another definition. The Post has defined "mass killings with a gun" as four or more dead, not counting the perpetrator. (The number wounded are irrelevant.) Different outlets have different definitions of Mass Shooting. For example, Gun Violence Archive and the New York...
  • Lest the public get the wrong – which is to say, the correct – impression about the nature of gun violence and possibly question leftist dogma on crime, punishment, and legislative initiatives around firearms, I guess a distinction must be made between shooters who take out multiple people with intentionality and those who are only after a single person but aren’t particularly fastidious in avoiding additional woundings or deaths.

    Like all things related to black underperformance, we must constantly redefine and lower standards in order to avoid extremely uncomfortable and politically fraught discussions. In some ways it really is an existential issue for the left – the almost unshakeable loyalty blacks show at the polls essentially all comes down to the promise to shield blacks from the consequences of their actions, be it crime, familial dysfunction, lack economic independence, etc.

    Due to the nature of the Democratic coalition, should a critical mass of non-black voters awaken to the cost of this indulgence and demand changes as the price of *their* loyalty, the party is going to have a big problem, so certain fictions must be maintained no matter how strained the explanations get. Fortunately for them, a lot of people that really ought to know better are not particularly interested in seeking out answers that might clash with their chosen political alignment.

    • Thanks: ic1000
    • Replies: @ThreeCranes
    @Arclight

    Well put.

  • From the New York Times news section: Let me guess. A large fraction of female magicians are either the wives or daughters of male magicians? In general, the weirder the profession, the higher the percentage of women pros who are the wives or daughters of men pros. One of the dirty little secrets of feminism...
  • @bomag
    @Arclight


    This ability to just live online and what it portends for the more introverted or poorly adjusted kids has yet to really make its impact felt on society, and frankly I don’t know what it will be.
     
    I'm watching and waiting.

    Some suggest one has always been able to escape in hobbies and books, so it's just a sideways move.

    Some suggest a Kaczynski type is now able to vent his frustrations over the internet and not act out.

    A functioning member of society has to have some measure of self control, and that includes stepping away from the keyboard and interacting with meat space.

    Replies: @Arclight, @Frau Katze

    The biggest thing as far as I can tell so far is the way kids who are out in the world and have to interact in person with adults and peers a lot and outside of school have better soft skills in human interaction and therefore navigate social situations with a lot more ease. Makes the teen years a bit easier, and in business (if that’s your path) that sort of thing matters a lot.

  • Since the 1990s, there has been a lot of improvement in golf ball and golf club technology, which means that today's pros wallop their drives way past where all time great drivers like Greg Norman and Jack Nicklaus could reach. It's not just that the ball goes further, but damaging sidespin is a lot less...
  • @Alec Leamas (working from home)

    So one idea was to cut back the equipment of the pros, but not of amateurs, the way that high school baseball players can use a $1,995 Louisville Slugger Meta Prime BBCOR (-3) Baseball Bat made out of that UFO that crashed at Roswell in 1947. Or something.
     
    A couple of years ago I - together with the other uncles - chipped in to buy a Meta Prime for the eldest nephew who was then the catcher on his high school varsity team. With custom color it came in just under $500.00.

    I think the 2019 -3 may be the bat which was banned by the NCAA so it was popular in some quadrants the way the wedges with the banned grooves were popular with amateur golfers.

    The prior Christmas it was a custom Nokona catcher's mitt (Nokona is the only manufacturer still making baseball gloves in the United States).

    His two younger brothers have no interest in baseball whatsoever. It's all football, basketball, and lacrosse. Fewer and fewer kids play baseball year over year, it seems.

    Replies: @Arclight

    I definitely did a double take when I saw that bat price – hard to believe it’s that much better than a bat that is in the hundreds. I just bought my youngest a $350 bat, which is pretty insane but I rationalized that he’ll be able to use it a couple of years and between rec, travel and all-stars he’s going to play at least 40 games a year and who knows how many practices so it will get a lot of use.

  • From the New York Times news section: Let me guess. A large fraction of female magicians are either the wives or daughters of male magicians? In general, the weirder the profession, the higher the percentage of women pros who are the wives or daughters of men pros. One of the dirty little secrets of feminism...
  • @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    @Arclight


    Essentially there are not enough black female nerds.
     
    My sense is that outside of being born into a performing family which would teach magic tricks as part of the family business, the vast bulk of people who get into magic do it while spending inordinate hours sequestered in their bedrooms as adolescents. I don't get the sense that black families - whatever their merits or deficiencies - allow children to sulk in a bedroom for years on end.

    Isn't magic a nerd power fantasy anyway? You see a bunch of hulking Conan types with swords who could kill everyone but you (slim and weak) can strike them all down with a lightning bolt from your hand because you've been reading an old book by yourself and practicing its contents for just this occasion.

    I wonder if a generation raised on Harry Potter has made obsession with magic "cool" now?

    Replies: @Arclight

    Hard to say – I don’t know anyone with kids (including myself) that has one that is interested in magic. I do think it is sort of a nerd/non-athlete sort of thing, but whereas in the not too distant past these types of kids might get into magic or D&D to do some kind of activity, nowadays they can just jump online and play Fortnite or whatever.

    This ability to just live online and what it portends for the more introverted or poorly adjusted kids has yet to really make its impact felt on society, and frankly I don’t know what it will be. Although my kids do like to play video games at times, it’s not the main focus of their attention fortunately – they play sports and like to get together with friends in person, so although it can be a lot to juggle shuttling them from this thing or that it’s way better than them sitting in their room talking to people they have never met on a headset.

    • Replies: @bomag
    @Arclight


    This ability to just live online and what it portends for the more introverted or poorly adjusted kids has yet to really make its impact felt on society, and frankly I don’t know what it will be.
     
    I'm watching and waiting.

    Some suggest one has always been able to escape in hobbies and books, so it's just a sideways move.

    Some suggest a Kaczynski type is now able to vent his frustrations over the internet and not act out.

    A functioning member of society has to have some measure of self control, and that includes stepping away from the keyboard and interacting with meat space.

    Replies: @Arclight, @Frau Katze

  • America has crucified itself in this decade over a single stat: In 2020-2022, blacks have been fatally shot by the police at a per capita rate 2.5 times higher than non-Hispanic whites (using data from the Washington Post database of fatal police shootings and the CDC WONDER database of deaths-by-cause): 2020-2022 WP Fatal Police Shootings...
  • A lot of obvious points to be made on this subject, but innumeracy – whether deliberate or not – is a fundamental element of modern mainstream journalism, often paired with a distinct lack of curiosity in phenomena beyond the talking points of favored advocacy groups.

    Obviously our cultural guardians want to keep certain inconvenient facts away from the public, but from my own interaction with younger journalists, they simply are not that smart nor do they view it as their responsibility to try to determine if the ‘facts’ presented to them actually make sense. Possibly their editors know better, but obviously they don’t demand more from their staff.

    During Floydmania, the WaPo diligently assembled a database of all fatal cop shootings and sorted them by race, and even at one point admitted in an article that in 80% of the killings of blacks who were classified as unarmed, the deceased had been actively assaulting or threatening either cops or other people at the scene. Despite having a lot of fairly accurate data at their fingertips, Post journalists and editors continued to pump out ‘news’ articles and op-eds painting America as having an epidemic of unjustified cop-on-black killings.

    • Thanks: Prester John
  • From the New York Times news section: Let me guess. A large fraction of female magicians are either the wives or daughters of male magicians? In general, the weirder the profession, the higher the percentage of women pros who are the wives or daughters of men pros. One of the dirty little secrets of feminism...
  • Essentially there are not enough black female nerds. I am a bit sympathetic in that it’s a very rare breed and many are probably under enormous social pressure in their middle school and high school years to conform to a more “authentic” black mode of social behavior. I had a couple of classmates like this in high school, and from my observations it was tough for these girls at times because they just didn’t fit neatly into any particular group – and the social pressure girls are under from their peers is totally different than what boys go through.

    • Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    @Arclight


    Essentially there are not enough black female nerds.
     
    My sense is that outside of being born into a performing family which would teach magic tricks as part of the family business, the vast bulk of people who get into magic do it while spending inordinate hours sequestered in their bedrooms as adolescents. I don't get the sense that black families - whatever their merits or deficiencies - allow children to sulk in a bedroom for years on end.

    Isn't magic a nerd power fantasy anyway? You see a bunch of hulking Conan types with swords who could kill everyone but you (slim and weak) can strike them all down with a lightning bolt from your hand because you've been reading an old book by yourself and practicing its contents for just this occasion.

    I wonder if a generation raised on Harry Potter has made obsession with magic "cool" now?

    Replies: @Arclight

    , @Yojimbo/Zatoichi
    @Arclight

    "Essentially there are not enough black female nerds"

    Actually, there really aren't enough black male nerds either. (e.g. Erkel doesn't count in the real world)

    , @MEH 0910
    @Arclight

    https://variety.com/2023/film/features/nia-dacosta-the-marvels-1235785554/


    How ‘The Marvels’ Got Its Blerd Girl Energy
    Nia DaCosta ignored the haters and made the movie her teenage self would want to see
    By Angelique Jackson
    Nov 9, 2023
    [...]
    The setting is apropos for how DaCosta’s life has played out over the past seven years — racing from one project to the next. DaCosta was 28 when her debut feature, “Little Woods,” starring Tessa Thompson and Lily James, won the Nora Ephron Award for female filmmakers at the Tribeca Film Festival. Then, with 2021’s “Candyman,” she became the first Black female director to hit No. 1 at the box office on opening weekend. When that milestone was announced, she was already on set for “The Marvels.” At 31, DaCosta became the youngest person — and the first Black woman — to helm a Marvel Studios picture.
    [...]
    She also wanted to satisfy the Blerd (Black nerd) in her, who’d grown up absorbed in comic book culture. The Brooklyn-born filmmaker was especially keen to tell Kamala’s story because she was a huge fan of the Ms. Marvel comics, which debuted when she was in her teens. “Usually I’m not like, ‘I like this person because I see myself — a tri-state area nerd who loves superhero and comic stuff and writes fan fiction,’” DaCosta says. “But she’s a great street-level hero, an heir to Spider-Man.”
    [...]
    Like other IP-based movies that star women and people of color, the impending release of 2019’s “Captain Marvel” met with such malignance that Rotten Tomatoes changed its policy to bar audience reviews on unreleased titles. In 2022, “Ms. Marvel” faced the same level of internet hate. And now, any post about “The Marvels” is flooded with comments criticizing Disney for “going woke” and rooting for the film to flop.

    DaCosta is familiar with the negative side of fandom — after all, she’s been a “big ol’ fan of nerdy shit for a long time” — but she’s not letting it get under her skin.

    “There are pockets where you go because you’re like, ‘I’m a super fan. I want to exist in the space of just adoration — which includes civilized critique,” she explains. “Then there are pockets that are really virulent and violent and racist — and sexist and homophobic and all those awful things. And I choose the side of the light. That’s the part of fandom I’m most attracted to.”
     


    https://variety.com/2023/film/news/bob-iger-disney-too-man-sequels-explains-marvels-flop-1235814475/

    ‘The Marvels’ Suffered From a Lack of ‘Supervision on the Set,’ Says Bob Iger; Disney CEO Admits Studio Has ‘Made Too Many’ Sequels Recently
    By Zack Sharf
    Nov 30, 2023

    Disney CEO Bob Iger said at the New York Times’ DealBook Summit (via CNBC) following “The Marvels” flopping at the box office that there was a lack of supervision on the set of the film as a result of the COVID pandemic. The combination of pandemic set restrictions and Disney’s increased output due to the launch of streamer Disney+ made it increasingly difficult for studio executives to oversee the onslaught of new productions.

    Since opening in theaters in November, the Brie Larson-led Marvel sequel has only grossed $77 million at the domestic box office and $187 million worldwide. It’s the biggest flop yet in the Marvel Cinematic Universe and is shaping up to be the first MCU title not to cross the $100 million mark domestically.

    ″‘The Marvels’ was shot during Covid,” Iger explained. “There wasn’t as much supervision on the set, so to speak, where we have executives [that are] really looking over what’s being done day after day after day.”

    “The Marvels” flop follows other underperforming Disney films from this year such as “Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania” and “Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny.” As Variety reported earlier this month, 2023 will mark the first time since 2014 (except for the pandemic-stricken years of 2020 and 2021) that Disney hasn’t launched a billion-dollar release. The studio had seven billion dollar grosses in 2019, including “Avengers: Endgame” and “The Lion King.”
     

    Replies: @MEH 0910, @Arclight

  • Lots of conservative intellectuals want to believe that Wokeness is a brilliant conspiracy by sinister geniuses. But mostly it looks like boring mediocrities with disagreeable personalities scratching each other's backs with other people's money. For example, from the Daily Mail: So, so far, the book's sales have justified an advance one-sixth of its $3 million....
  • I would guess that some of the calculus – like with books written by politicians – is that some ideologically-friendly foundation or NFPs buy a load of them to hand out at events, colleges, etc.

    It’s a nice little system – publishing house puts out ideological book, they get a few very large purchase orders that makes it worth their while, schools and NFPs place their preferred propaganda in the hands of tons of people, author gets exposure and money, repeat process. Look at the 1619 project – I am sure there are plenty of white cat ladies that bought it, but the real play was prepping the materials for schools and a lot of woke school systems are buying up that crap (like mine).

    Obviously there is only so much of that to go around, so the market is saturated with these books because the extremely insular and highly conformist group of editors grossly overestimated demand because they only consort with the like-minded. It’s sort of like that famous Pauline Kael quote about being surprised Nixon was elected – “no one I know voted for him.”

    • Agree: Frau Katze, res
  • From my movie review of Napoleon: Read the whole thing
  • @Sam Malone
    Here's a good review that echoes some of what Steve says. I'm disappointed that the movie appears to be pretty surface-level, biased, inaccurate, and wastes a lot of time on the Josephine romance.

    https://unherd.com/thepost/napoleon-the-movie-is-anglo-propaganda/

    "Squeezing 20 years of continent-wide political and military tumult into 158 minutes was always going to leave important chapters on the chopping block...Some liberties were so jarring as to remove the viewer from the cinematic experience. Napoleon charges sabre-first on his horse like an impatient captain at the first opportunity. The Battle of Austerlitz, his greatest triumph, becomes a cartoonish mousetrap on ice...Yet the film’s main flaw is its asinine plot, and apparent indecision as to what it wants to be. Scott evidently wanted to cover Napoleon from crib to coffin, but the film lacks any convincing narrative thread to hold it..."

    "A giant to the French, he remains an ogre to the English. What he was not, however, was a half-wit man-child. Phoenix plays Napoleon as a stupid figure, a characterisation the film struggles to square with the reality that the idiot depicted somehow became the most powerful man in Europe. Phoenix claimed that he wanted to explore this “petit petulant tyrant”, harking back to Britain’s viciously effective anti-Bonaparte cartoons. When the film (finally) ends, the black screen lists the casualties of Boney’s wars. This is a blatant attempt to induce guilt in any viewers who might still have any admiration for Napoleon after such a character assassination."

    "I would have gladly settled for a movie about an increasingly egotistical and tyrannical dictator, rather than an unconvincing melodrama and Wikipedia-deep exploration of the Napoleonic biggest hits. Even as a piece of Anglo propaganda, the film falls flat on its face. Scott had so many other angles to explore. His film could have been about Napoleon’s increasing obsession with winning the great power rivalry with England, but we are left guessing as to the strategic motives behind most of the battles in front of us."

    Replies: @Arclight, @Dennis Dale, @James J. O'Meara

    Thanks. Truly depressing that such a dynamic and interesting figure was reduced to this. Unfortunately the “Wikipedia-deep” level of historical interest in major historical figures will probably continue to grow as the distance between the present and men of consequence grows. Our culture is still firmly in the grip of ideological cultists who absolutely loathe Western civilization and the people who made it possible.

    Now that some British museum has deemed a little known Roman emperor transgender we will no doubt get some kind of biopic about that, or perhaps on Sporus, a kid Nero had castrated and dressed up like his dead wife.

  • Part of the Great Circle of Life in American schools is that the smart teachers and administrators who like smart students devise tracking systems so the smart kids can have their own classes where they are taught at a quick, less boring rate and get into more advanced materials. Eventually, the dumb teachers and administrators...
  • @Mr. Anon
    @Arclight


    The left loves to say “trust the science” but when they run up against a phenomena that resists all of their policy prescriptions, they never reconsider their underlying assumptions.
     
    Anyone who would say "trust the science" probably doesn't understand what science is.

    What they really mean is "trust the scientists", which is an even more dubious proposition, as the scientists in question might not be any good, or might not even be scientists.

    Science has become, like so many other facets of society, just another grift.

    Replies: @Arclight, @Truth

    Yes – theoretically “trust the science” means one should follow the evidence wherever it takes you, but generally it means “shut up and do what I want” these days. However, I do think in the wake of Covid that term has lost a lot of its potency for people.

    • Agree: Mark G.
  • It's been about 4 weeks since former Stanford student Abdulwahab Omira announced that he had been Islamophobically run down by an Aryan looking man in a black Toyota SUV. By remarkable coincidence, nobody else on the campus witnessed the car crash. A Stanford Review article made clear that many students view him as the local...
  • Not sure I see the era of endorsing lies grinding to a halt – after all, the left needs these lies to justify their politics, so unless they abandon their politics there is still a strong incentive to latch onto even the most transparently false stories about bigotry and oppression.

    • Agree: Almost Missouri
    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
    @Arclight

    I meant to write something to this effect, Arclight. Not only do they endorse lies, the ctrl-left creates lies, on an hourly basis. They don't even mind getting caught in the lying these days.

    Secondly, I don't know why our host keeps bringing up this George Santos guy. I'd never have heard of him except for here, and I'm pretty sure there are thousands of more well-known liars out there. Hillary Clinton, I mean, she'd lie about the weather forecast... just out of habit.

    Replies: @Stan Adams, @Jim Don Bob

    , @Mark G.
    @Arclight

    If we had moved from government enforced segregation to freedom of association there would still have been segregation after that but it would have been segregation by income. Blacks capable of adopting middle class values would have moved up into the middle class. Most blacks, though, were aware that many blacks would not be able to achieve this and opposed moving to freedom of association for that reason.

    , @Barnard
    @Arclight

    There would have to a price for endorsing obvious lies first. There hasn't ever been for amplifying hate hoaxes, even the most obvious ones. Even Sabrina Rubin Erdely ended up waking away from Rolling Stone with a better job than the one she had there. After a brief stop working for a Jewish group she now works for Boston Scientific as a "content strategist."

  • Part of the Great Circle of Life in American schools is that the smart teachers and administrators who like smart students devise tracking systems so the smart kids can have their own classes where they are taught at a quick, less boring rate and get into more advanced materials. Eventually, the dumb teachers and administrators...
  • @Carol
    @Arclight

    The 50% minimum grade is practically universal now in public k-12. And college professors are already dealing with the ramifications of this policy.

    Evidently the schools lose $$$ if they flunk or expel students. So it just is not done anymore.

    Replies: @Arclight

    Unfortunately, higher education has zero incentive for honesty in this regard – they need warm leveraged-up bodies to keep coming in the doors, so they are OK with this charade. Same for K-12 public education, need to keep teachers employed so they funnel their union dues to the Democratic Party.

    • Agree: Jim Don Bob
  • @Jim Don Bob
    @Arclight

    We as a country spent 60 years and untold trillions of dollars trying to lift blacks up to somewhere near whites. That didn't work, so now we are lowering standards everywhere, and bragging about it.

    Complex Systems Won’t Survive the Competence Crisis: https://www.palladiummag.com/2023/06/01/complex-systems-wont-survive-the-competence-crisis/

    Replies: @Arclight, @Achmed E. Newman

    The left loves to say “trust the science” but when they run up against a phenomena that resists all of their policy prescriptions, they never reconsider their underlying assumptions. Instead they insist they just need a new spin on an old policy, say not enough resources have been thrown at the problem, or just eliminate measuring the offending phenomena.

    As you note, trillions – likely tens of trillions – have been transferred to black America since the civil rights era in an effort to alter performance and outcomes, and the results have ranged from no change to outright disaster. Although they wouldn’t admit it, the left is intellectually exhausted by black America, so everything they put forth now is essentially rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic in an effort to look like they are ‘doing something’ rather than admit that really the best they have at this point is perpetual and very expensive subsidy of blacks in the hope they won’t cause too much trouble.

    Unfortunately some of this subsidy will come in the form of putting patently unqualified people in positions in which competence very much matters. The resulting failure will just result in the left saying we have to redouble our efforts on diversity because we didn’t try hard enough in the first place.

    • Replies: @res
    @Arclight


    The left loves to say “trust the science” but when they run up against a phenomena that resists all of their policy prescriptions, they never reconsider their underlying assumptions. Instead they insist they just need a new spin on an old policy, say not enough resources have been thrown at the problem, or just eliminate measuring the offending phenomena.
     
    That is true, but it is even worse. They only "trust the science" until it disagrees with one of their beliefs.

    Replies: @Reg Cæsar

    , @Bill Jones
    @Arclight


    Unfortunately some of this subsidy will come in the form of putting patently unqualified people in positions in which competence very much matters.
     
    Speaking of NYC Mayors...

    Replies: @From Beer to Paternity

    , @Mr. Anon
    @Arclight


    The left loves to say “trust the science” but when they run up against a phenomena that resists all of their policy prescriptions, they never reconsider their underlying assumptions.
     
    Anyone who would say "trust the science" probably doesn't understand what science is.

    What they really mean is "trust the scientists", which is an even more dubious proposition, as the scientists in question might not be any good, or might not even be scientists.

    Science has become, like so many other facets of society, just another grift.

    Replies: @Arclight, @Truth

  • @res
    @International Jew

    And as predicted (here), they are getting nothing but grief for it. It will never be enough.

    Replies: @Arclight, @The Anti-Gnostic, @Achmed E. Newman

    Correct – the reality is that a very large share of the black population does not believe that they have any obligation towards self-sufficiency and that the only real purpose of the government is to direct an ever-increasing stream of resources their way. Having tens of millions of people that have no intention of ever being a net add to larger society is a massive anchor on American potential and will be an even larger problem in the decades ahead without a significant change in our culture’s attitude towards people like this.

    • Agree: AndrewR
  • @SafeNow
    When such students were in a non-tracked class, the teacher had a grading curve that he used, and they were subject to it. But being in their own multiverse means they will be subject to that multiverse’s very own grading curve. I predict it will range from A to A-minus, with a few exceptions - - B-plus if you do virtually no work.

    Replies: @Anon, @Arclight, @Alan Mercer

    Indeed, grade inflation will be equitably applied. My city’s public school system adopted a new grading scale where the lowest score on an assignment is 50% – even if you didn’t do it at all, and had the balls to brag about how the HS graduation rate had gone up in the most recently-concluded academic year. Likewise, the local campus of the state university also announced that a 3.0 from the public school system is sufficient for automatic admission, so I am sure the average GPA in our public school system is about to take a huge jump.

    • Replies: @Carol
    @Arclight

    The 50% minimum grade is practically universal now in public k-12. And college professors are already dealing with the ramifications of this policy.

    Evidently the schools lose $$$ if they flunk or expel students. So it just is not done anymore.

    Replies: @Arclight

    , @Jim Don Bob
    @Arclight

    We as a country spent 60 years and untold trillions of dollars trying to lift blacks up to somewhere near whites. That didn't work, so now we are lowering standards everywhere, and bragging about it.

    Complex Systems Won’t Survive the Competence Crisis: https://www.palladiummag.com/2023/06/01/complex-systems-wont-survive-the-competence-crisis/

    Replies: @Arclight, @Achmed E. Newman

  • From the New York Post: Chauvin was convicted of the legally bizarre crime of murder by negligence, a factoid that has played a key rhetorical role in the media's efforts to post-hoc rationalize its psychotic break during the George Floyd racial reckoning: George Floyd was murdered. Sounds like negligence might possibly have played a role...
  • Our overlords couldn’t lynch Chauvin outright – although obviously there were many actors that would have happily done so given the opportunity – so this is the next best thing. The underlying message is that the most useless black person on the planet is infinitely more valuable to our rulers than any white person.

    However, the message has also been received by tens of millions of people who already understand what we are facing. If Chauvin dies or is killed next year, I would expect a lot of public commentators to repeatedly point out that a guy just going about his job was convicted of murder, over sentenced, and allowed to be killed by deliberate state negligence. Although a lot of GOP figures have shied away from pointing out the insane racial double standards in society, it has to be dawning on some that there is zero political downside at this point to stating the obvious.

  • From my new Taki's Magazine column: Read the whole thing there.
  • High minded appeals to reason and openness amongst the intellectual class is all well and good, but what really needs to happen is proscriptions against certain topics need to be openly defied by people with large public/media followings to create space for politicians (who are generally spineless and follow the herd) to act. There are some green shoots, but not nearly enough – yet.

  • From the Washington Post news section: A major immigrant rights group posted about Gaza. Its backers revolted. CASA, lauded for decades as a champion for the rights of the disenfranchised, now finds itself embroiled in a fight for its future By Ovetta Wiggins November 22, 2023 at 5:57 p.m. EST Gustavo Torres had just left...
  • So the Weinberg Foundation just redirected its money from one lefty group undermining our immigration laws and national cohesiveness to another? Some people refuse to learn their lesson it seems.

    • Replies: @Mr. Anon
    @Arclight


    So the Weinberg Foundation just redirected its money from one lefty group undermining our immigration laws and national cohesiveness to another? Some people refuse to learn their lesson it seems.
     
    What's to learn? Those groups were doing exactly what the Weinberg Foundation want them to do: promote immigration and undermine national cohesiveness. That's exactly what the foundation was paying them for. It's just that one of those groups thought you could criticize Israel too. They didn't understand that was a third rail. Other groups will understand it in future.

    Replies: @deep anonymous

  • At Marginal Revolution, Tyler Cowen recalls a 1981 book: The decline in the population of Ireland (whether measured as the entire island or, as in this graph, of the southern 26 of the island's 32 counties) following the 1846 potato blight famine was extraordinary. My guess is that Catholic Ireland took to heart the English...
  • I would like to know what Irish emigration looked like over the same period – I would assume that the most lusty younger Irish lads and lasses decamped for the US or parts of the British Empire to seek their fortunes, leaving behind a much older and/or vigorous population.

    • Replies: @Bill Jones
    @Arclight

    A very large number got as far as my native Liverpool.

    , @Anonymous
    @Arclight

    Likewise, internal migration: urbanization spurred by industrialization. The Irish countryside used to be a much more happening place.
    https://images.app.goo.gl/zL3LNY5p2JfQPDqw7

    Replies: @Gforce

    , @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    @Arclight


    I would like to know what Irish emigration looked like over the same period – I would assume that the most lusty younger Irish lads and lasses decamped for the US or parts of the British Empire to seek their fortunes, leaving behind a much older and/or vigorous population.
     
    IIRC, Irish outmigration continued during the decline and was redirected after the U.S. tightened its immigration policies in the 1920s, with Irish young people moving near (Scotland and England) and far (Canada and Australia, even Middle East) for employment opportunities.

    Also note that Ireland was a donor population for Catholic vocations during much of this period - which is to say they generated more priests and nuns than they kept domestically and therefore exported them (also near and far).

    Replies: @Colin Wright

    , @YetAnotherAnon
    @Arclight

    "the most lusty younger Irish lads and lasses decamped for the US or parts of the British Empire to seek their fortunes"

    There are large areas of English cities, 50 years ago almost entirely Irish, which are now almost entirely Asian or African. Catholic schools cater for a wholly Muslim catchment, the mega-pub where regular bar collections for the IRA were rumoured is now a Somali Community Centre, the training college for Catholic teachers sits among streets where white faces are rare.

    Nursing training in the UK used to attract lots of bright Irish girls, and in Elder Days Before The Fall the London hospitals used to put them together in the hospital accommodation.

    Replies: @Anonymous

  • And we are here as on a darkling plain Swept with confused alarms of struggle and flight, Where ignorant armies clash by night. -- Matthew Arnold, 1851 In Boomer mythology, America changed between the assassination of JFK on 11/22/1963 and the Beatles' appearance on the Ed Sullivan Show on 2/9/1964. Over the decades, I've come...
  • @Achmed E. Newman
    @Arclight

    Great comment, Arclight, but I think you should have added the great expansion of the Welfare State during Johnson's presidency as a 4th item that added to the ruin.

    Replies: @Arclight

    I sort of view that as part and parcel of the civil rights era since it was clearly intended to help blacks the most, but fair point. At any rate, the downstream consequences of the Johnson presidency have been enormous, and any semi-historically literate American should spit on his name.

  • Truly a tragedy – LBJ succeeding JFK was a disaster for our country whose effects are still strong today. Vietnam, Hart-Cellar, and the Civil Rights Acts – any one of these three items would have created significant long-term problems for the US, but all three? JFC.

    It doesn’t seem to me that LBJ was some kind of crypto progressive, just a grasping (and effective, in the short term) politician. Still, it’s an example of how an organized political movement can use the fractures created by policy to their advantage if they have patience and think long term.

    There is a lesson here for the right was well – we are in an era of fracture and turbulence and it will get worse in the years ahead. Be prepared to exploit it or reconcile yourself to permanent rump status. I don’t think ‘official’ organs like the GOP or the constellation of think tanks are remotely up to the task.

    • Agree: anonymouseperson
    • Replies: @Old Virginia
    @Arclight

    I think you're right about the disaster to the USA of the JFK to LBJ transition.

    I'm not sure that the Ronald Reagan to GHWBush transition wasn't just as much of a disaster.

    , @Achmed E. Newman
    @Arclight

    Great comment, Arclight, but I think you should have added the great expansion of the Welfare State during Johnson's presidency as a 4th item that added to the ruin.

    Replies: @Arclight

  • Earlier in the 21st Century, Washington DC was a trendy destination for gentrifiers. The federal government employs numerous well-educated, well-compensated workers, whose jobs were largely maintained after the 2008 crash. After 9/11 in 2001, federal agencies went on a huge spree of hiring armed men to prevent terrorists from attacking the Small Business Administration or...
  • @Chris Renner
    @Arclight


    The reality of DC is that although the demographics have changed somewhat, this neighborhood is bordered to the north and east by a lot of neighborhoods that are pretty resistant to gentrification, so this is a convenient place to victimize whites and get away easily.
     
    This, exactly. And H Street isn't all that geographically desirable for the average young white professional, either; unless they're a Hill staffer, the commute isn't great and the adjacent neighborhoods are nothing special. The neighborhoods between Rock Creek and N. Capitol St. have been much more appealing.

    Replies: @Arclight

    For me, the neighborhood made more sense at the time – we had rented on Capitol Hill and couldn’t afford to buy there, I didn’t have an office, and my wife’s job was just a mile and a half up Florida Ave so she could drive there easily. There were also a lot of older black couples who were at the end of their working careers or retired who had been there for a long time and they were generally very friendly and took care of their homes. To the extent I had some problem neighbors, often it was the children or relatives of people who had retired and left or died – I am guessing over the years more of that happened, which countered the arrival of more whites.

    Still, the Trinidad neighborhood to the north sucked and anything past 15th/Benning Road was crap, and will probably always be so.

  • Ah, the old neighborhood. It wasn’t as hostile as places like Petworth or Columbia Heights in the mid-aughts, but I sure didn’t walk around after dark unless it was from the NYAve metro station. Last visited maybe 5 years ago and although H Street had a lot more development, the neighborhood was still not awesome.

    The reality of DC is that although the demographics have changed somewhat, this neighborhood is bordered to the north and east by a lot of neighborhoods that are pretty resistant to gentrification, so this is a convenient place to victimize whites and get away easily. Add in a more laissez-faire attitude towards policing, and this neighborhood may have reached a generational tipping point for the worse.

    • Replies: @Chris Renner
    @Arclight


    The reality of DC is that although the demographics have changed somewhat, this neighborhood is bordered to the north and east by a lot of neighborhoods that are pretty resistant to gentrification, so this is a convenient place to victimize whites and get away easily.
     
    This, exactly. And H Street isn't all that geographically desirable for the average young white professional, either; unless they're a Hill staffer, the commute isn't great and the adjacent neighborhoods are nothing special. The neighborhoods between Rock Creek and N. Capitol St. have been much more appealing.

    Replies: @Arclight

  • From the New York Times opinion section: Charles Lindbergh addressing a crowd. Behind him are U.S. flags and signs reading “America First.” By David French Opinion Columnist In August, I wrote about the “lost boys” of the American right, many of them young and relatively unknown, who were outed for having secret or anonymous online...
  • @Arclight
    I cannot remember which large X account posted this comment about the current very open anti-Semitism on the left, but is was essentially "Dr. Frankenstein finally gets to meet his monster."

    Leftist whites of whatever variety have always assumed that their allyship with the POCs they whipped into an anti-white frenzy would count for something, like blood on the door so God wouldn't strike them down on the way to destroying the Egyptians. Unfortunately for all of us, they birthed a wrathful and remorseless deity that has legions of useful idiots champing at the bit to administer divine justice.

    Replies: @ChrisZ, @Bardon Kaldian, @AndrewR, @Corn

    Unfortunately for all of us, they birthed a wrathful and remorseless deity that has legions of useful idiots champing at the bit to administer divine justice.

    That’s some vivid and memorable writing, Arclight. Thanks.

    Also, I too am partial to a literate Frankenstein analogy.

    • Agree: bomag
    • Thanks: Arclight
  • I cannot remember which large X account posted this comment about the current very open anti-Semitism on the left, but is was essentially “Dr. Frankenstein finally gets to meet his monster.”

    Leftist whites of whatever variety have always assumed that their allyship with the POCs they whipped into an anti-white frenzy would count for something, like blood on the door so God wouldn’t strike them down on the way to destroying the Egyptians. Unfortunately for all of us, they birthed a wrathful and remorseless deity that has legions of useful idiots champing at the bit to administer divine justice.

    • Replies: @ChrisZ
    @Arclight


    Unfortunately for all of us, they birthed a wrathful and remorseless deity that has legions of useful idiots champing at the bit to administer divine justice.
     
    That’s some vivid and memorable writing, Arclight. Thanks.

    Also, I too am partial to a literate Frankenstein analogy.
    , @Bardon Kaldian
    @Arclight

    https://media.tenor.com/BgbXOk-v5GEAAAAC/godzillagigabash-burning-godzilla.gif


    https://i.pinimg.com/originals/a3/70/a5/a370a5b6f66ba89c473d502b070c4127.gif

    , @AndrewR
    @Arclight

    It's worse than offensive and inaccurate to lump Palestinians in the same "POC" boat as black Americans - it's insane. Israelis reaping what they sowed has nothing to do with the American jogger, who very much still serves his Hebrew masters well. In America's case, it's scary for us because blacks, with few exceptions, don't distinguish between Jew and white gentile.

    , @Corn
    @Arclight


    Leftist whites of whatever variety have always assumed that their allyship with the POCs they whipped into an anti-white frenzy would count for something, like blood on the door so God wouldn’t strike them down on the way to destroying the Egyptians. Unfortunately for all of us, they birthed a wrathful and remorseless deity that has legions of useful idiots champing at the bit to administer divine justice.
     
    I call them the “Please Load Us onto the Traincars Last” liberals
  • The now popular notion that "race does not exist" or that "race is a social construct" have grown greatly in use in books in recent decades, according to Google's Ngram of American books published in English from 1800 to 2019. (I don't know what context "race does not exist" was used in the 1840s to...
  • Really only lefty whites sincerely believe this – blacks do not, and most seem to think they are actually members of the superior race. Now it is true that this being the default position of polite white society means a lot of blacks meet an earlier end than is necessary, but blacks are not willing to really push back on it because going along means they remain the focus of attention of a lot of whites and they prize that above almost anything.

    • Replies: @Rob Lee
    @Arclight

    “…blacks are not willing to really push back on it because going along means they remain the focus of attention of a lot of whites and they prize that above almost anything.”

    “The ass that does not bray does not get fed.” Ancient truths once uttered always apply.

  • Here's a good article on the Hispanic Paradox that Hispanics tend to live a long time relative to their income and education from Stat: The ‘Hispanic Paradox’ intrigues a new generation of researchers determined to unravel it By Usha Lee McFarling Sept. 14, 2023 For 40 years, researchers have unsuccessfully tried to explain — or...
  • @The Anti-Gnostic
    @Jack D

    I generally agree with this. Latinos still live in and around extended family networks but to my observation the Catholic, parish-centered culture is long gone. They are either Evangelical or areligious.

    Replies: @Arclight

    Ditto – the family aspect can’t be overlooked, in my opinion. I would guess being more recent immigrants the communal family culture is stronger and/or a high percentage of the family lives within a reasonable distance instead multiple kids living hundreds of miles away from mom and dad. More help and happiness when people are close together.

    My personal family had multiple kids who moved away for college and stayed away for a long time but we all ended up moving back to our home city in our 30s. Although we each live in different parts of the metro area we do gather together with my parents for family dinners a couple times a month all year round. There’s no question that having us all nearby has contributed a lot to their quality of life and comfort.

  • Science used to be about making more accurate predictions, but now it's about affirming dogmas even at the cost of more dead bodies. As we all know, Race Does NOT Exist Biologically. It just doesn't. So therefore, doctors will no longer be allowed to use race in an algorithm predicting risk of heart attack or...
  • @deep anonymous
    @Arclight

    I fear that affirmative action is so deeply embedded in the administrative/bureaucratic state, both public and nominally private, that the SCOTUS decision will make no difference whatsoever. We already can observe that SAT/ACT scores have become "optional" or, in some cases, may no longer even be considered. Nothing but "wholistic admissions criteria" as far as the eye can see.

    The only practical effect of the putative abolition of race-based university admissions will be to lead idiot "responsible conservatives" to believe that the system can actually work. The reality is that our hopelessly decadent system continues to hurtle headlong into the depths of hell. Conservatives in a nutshell: always playing defense.

    Replies: @Arclight

    I have no doubt there are huge numbers of administrators in the public and private sector that will try to hang onto affirmative action and will have some success. However, the key to batting it down to the greatest practical extent is to make it as painful as possible for its practitioners to retain. It seems clear to me that there is no downside to the right being vocally against it and promising to do something about it if they are in power. But there has to be follow up – legislatively and through the legal system.

    Like illegal immigration the right is gun shy of an issue in which the public is largely on their side.

    • Replies: @deep anonymous
    @Arclight

    "Like illegal immigration the right is gun shy of an issue in which the public is largely on their side."

    Kind of illustrates why the Republicans are the Washington Generals of politics. Presumably the donor class does not support these issues, so public-facing Republican politicians merely pretend that they do. Both the donors and the political front-men/women/whatever hold their voters in contempt.

  • Actually, I think this is fine: if ladies want to play My Little Pony dress-up with their own horses on their own dime (and I don't see how this could be abuse of the horses, except maybe in very hot weather), go for it.
  • If ladies like this start to add in hoof extensions as well, we’ll have the world’s first ratchet equines.

    • Thanks: clifford brown
    • LOL: Renard
  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: Read the whole thing there.
  • When I was young I thought being an architect was a glamorous and well-paid profession. Once I got into real estate I realized most architects make less than $100k a year and do insanely boring stuff all day long. Same thing with law – most make a relatively modest living and the work (to my mind) would make me jump out of a window.

    As Steve notes, the idea that blacks are underrepresented in some field and need to have their numbers beefed up just means stealing from some other sector and thereby diminishing their influence elsewhere. Naturally the NYT doesn’t grok that – they think there are lots of undiscovered white collar-capable blacks working in nail salons or something that should be making their presence known in interior design and architecture, rather than the reality that the market is sending a very useful signal about supply.

    The line about how design suffers when it doesn’t have enough ‘reference points’ made me laugh. Having too many reference points in all areas is the reason for our cultural schizophrenia. The day when people can openly say not everyone has to be consulted – particularly those who contribute the least – cannot come soon enough, assuming it ever does, that is.

  • Science used to be about making more accurate predictions, but now it's about affirming dogmas even at the cost of more dead bodies. As we all know, Race Does NOT Exist Biologically. It just doesn't. So therefore, doctors will no longer be allowed to use race in an algorithm predicting risk of heart attack or...
  • It’s funny in a dark way how the refusal to acknowledge the role race plays in a broad variety of phenomena almost always ends up hurting those these policies are intended to help.

    Semi-related, Thomas Edsall has a piece in the NYT about how abortion proved to be a big motivator for voters but the end of affirmative action in higher ed has not. In short, a majority of the public opposes it (and always has) and is in general comfortable with inequality if they view it as a fair outcome. Naturally the ‘experts’ he consulted think the public needs to be gaslit into believing the outcomes they see are *not* fair and therefore require novel policies to address it. This really highlights one of the biggest problems with the left – they simply cannot stop tinkering with society no matter how much evidence there is that the public or reality doesn’t line up with their view of how the world ought to be.

    • Replies: @deep anonymous
    @Arclight

    I fear that affirmative action is so deeply embedded in the administrative/bureaucratic state, both public and nominally private, that the SCOTUS decision will make no difference whatsoever. We already can observe that SAT/ACT scores have become "optional" or, in some cases, may no longer even be considered. Nothing but "wholistic admissions criteria" as far as the eye can see.

    The only practical effect of the putative abolition of race-based university admissions will be to lead idiot "responsible conservatives" to believe that the system can actually work. The reality is that our hopelessly decadent system continues to hurtle headlong into the depths of hell. Conservatives in a nutshell: always playing defense.

    Replies: @Arclight

    , @The Germ Theory of Disease
    @Arclight

    "Naturally the ‘experts’ he consulted think the public needs to be gaslit into believing the outcomes they see are *not* fair and therefore require novel policies to address it."

    The solution to all of this should be obvious: get rid of any and all required credentials which bar blacks from doing anything whatsoever.

    Since we all can see from watching television, that blacks are obviously always the most qualified doctors, lawyers, computer engineers and financial advisors, we should simply allow all blacks to practice medicine, law, architecture, aerospace, surgery, computer design, all forms of engineering, and all forms of academic enquiry according to their whim, without any credentials whatsoever. Any and all deaths and disasters which result will simply be tabulated, or not, by similarly qualified, or not, unquestioned and unchallengeable black journalists and statisticians, so we'll never really know what hit us, right? Forewarned is forearmed... or not, really, because forewarned is racist. Right?

    Reparations 4evah!

    , @EdwardM
    @Arclight


    they simply cannot stop tinkering with society because of no matter how much evidence there is that the public or reality doesn’t line up with their view of how the world ought to be.
     
    FIFY
  • Remember the Education Reform juggernaut right before the Great Awokening? Various billionaires announced that to end racial inequality, All We Had to Do Is to Fix the Schools and that they'd just been to a conference in Aspen where they had a brainstorm about exactly how to do it, usually involving teaching public school students...
  • @res
    @Arclight


    the smarter and more more driven ones will recognize that in a world where competency is a luxury rather than the expectation they have the chance to really capitalize on that personally.
     
    Interesting take. Thanks.

    I wonder how the arms race of the diversity enforcers and evaders will play out. I fear you may be overoptimistic there.

    Replies: @Arclight

    Possibly, but a lot of times they just want to be able to report stats that are favorable. It is common for large cities to have minority subcontractor hiring requirements on projects that receive some municipal financing but look the other way when the minority business subs out the subcontract to a white business to do the actual work (personal experience with this). They are OK with the supposed disadvantaged businessperson being a pass through that gets a skim because their primary goal is to be able to put out a press release touting that some building project had 40% minority participation or whatever.

    Obviously a downside to this from the public interest standpoint is the contract is much larger than it really should be to make sure there is enough fluff in there for it to be worth everyone’s time, and repeat this process on say half a dozen large subcontracts on a project costing tens or hundreds of millions and there is a lot of fat in there.

    • Agree: Jim Don Bob
    • Replies: @Jim Don Bob
    @Arclight

    This scam is rampant in the federal government. An AA firm wins the award then "teams" with one of the beltway bandits who do most of the work. But, as Arclight says, the minority participation press release looks good, which is all that the diversicrats care about.

    Replies: @Shale boi

  • True, but there will be opportunities all the same. Large/public organizations will be forced to dumb down hiring for diversity, but smaller private ones can resist if they want and/or create the appearance of diversity by getting XBE certification.

    As big organizations really start to feel the bite of the competency crisis they will increasingly have to sub out work to companies that are not saddled with this handicap. Work for one of these businesses or start one yourself and things should go pretty well for you.

    For those of us in their late 30s or older, for the rest of your life will be lived in a world that doesn’t match up to the standards you experienced when you were younger and it’s depressing to see. But younger people have no memory of that world, and the smarter and more more driven ones will recognize that in a world where competency is a luxury rather than the expectation they have the chance to really capitalize on that personally.

    • Replies: @Farenheit
    @Arclight


    For those of us in their late 30s or older, for the rest of your life will be lived in a world that doesn’t match up to the standards you experienced when you were younger and it’s depressing to see
     
    As a late 50s dude, I sometimes explain to the youngsters about a mythical time when you went out in public and everyone was thin, there were no tattoos, people were dressed appropriately, and there was a commonly accepted set of manners.

    It's not just academics and professional competence that's taken a nose dive, it's pretty full spectrum now.

    Replies: @Art Deco, @Shale boi, @Beavertales, @22pp22, @Erik L

    , @res
    @Arclight


    the smarter and more more driven ones will recognize that in a world where competency is a luxury rather than the expectation they have the chance to really capitalize on that personally.
     
    Interesting take. Thanks.

    I wonder how the arms race of the diversity enforcers and evaders will play out. I fear you may be overoptimistic there.

    Replies: @Arclight

    , @Spangel226
    @Arclight

    You can still see the difference by simply going from a mostly white area to a mostly minority area. The standard of service one gets from pharmacy techs, waiters, repair people etc in more affluent/whiter areas is obviously different than what you get in lower class areas with a lot of blacks and Latinos. My experience is that first generation Latinos are generally reliable workers- they might not be bright, but they make up for it in motivation. But their kids are the ones who can’t pass the regents exam.

    Replies: @Anonymous Jew

    , @Poirot
    @Arclight

    "The older I get the more I admire and crave competence, just simple competence, in any field from adultery to zoology." — H. L. Mencken

    , @Alden
    @Arclight

    “Will be forced to dumb down for diversity”?

    That started by executive order 10925 in 1961 for the federal government federal contractors and state and local governments that received federal money for various projects. From school budding to roads highways and seers.

    Was accelerated in 1971 Griggs vs Duke Power and Kaiser vs Weber 1978.

    You’re not an American are you? Because affirmative action for dumb minorities has been the law of the land since 1961. Even if you live in Ogallala Nebraska you couldn’t have missed affirmative action.

    , @Rooster17
    @Arclight

    This is anecdotal but I notice a difference between the McDonald’s in a mostly White area in my town versus the higher minority area of town. The White kids are more likely to be personable and say have a nice day, where the black servers tend to not talk and just hand you the food, the overall quality is suspect too. I’m guessing this is happening all over the country in varying degrees, in all different industries. Like you said, the younger generation doesn’t even understand how bad it is, probably like my generation doesn’t understand either. I wonder, how much further down to we have to go?

    Replies: @mmack, @Stan Adams

    , @Yancey Ward
    @Arclight


    the smarter and more more driven ones will recognize that in a world where competency is a luxury rather than the expectation they have the chance to really capitalize on that personally.
     
    If this were a good thing, South Africa should be a golden paradise for competent white people today.
  • As you'll recall, the Western media and governments tended to imply in 2022 that the Russians blew up much of their own immensely valuable Nord Stream pipeline economic asset for reasons of malign Russianness that rational Westerners could never begin to understand. Or something. The popular Russians Did It To Themselves theory never made any...
  • @Dnought
    @Arclight

    Agree, but gosh there sure are a lot of "total rubes" out there. Makes me almost want to get into some kind of bridge-selling business.

    Chesterton wrote something about people who don't believe in God becoming capable of believing in anything, right? I guess as a corollary, in the present day, you could add that people who believe in trannys become capable of believing in anything.

    Replies: @MEH 0910, @Arclight, @quewin

    Absolutely – the number of conventionally intelligent people I have met that buy every major leftist/media (but I repeat myself) narrative hook, line and sinker is astonishing.

    Just underscores that a lot of people’s political beliefs are a product of who they want to signal to, rather than reasoned consideration.

    • Agree: ic1000
  • It was pretty obvious at the time, but naturally the media lapdogs dutifully reported the absurd theory that Russia blew up its own source of foreign revenue in the midst of a war it considers existential. You have to a total rube at this point to trust official messaging on just about any major foreign or domestic cultural issue at this point, but this was such a pathetic lie that outlets like the NYT and WaPo unblinkingly relayed to the masses.

    • Agree: Mr. Anon, Adam Smith
    • Replies: @Cagey Beast
    @Arclight

    But we can trust them this time.

    , @Rusty Tailgate
    @Arclight


    It was pretty obvious at the time, but naturally the media lapdogs dutifully reported the absurd theory that Russia blew up its own source of foreign revenue in the midst of a war it considers existential.
     
    It makes you wonder what else can be blown up with all the legacy media reporting that someone else did it. I bring this up with the 2024 campaign season in mind.

    Replies: @Rusty Tailgate

    , @Dnought
    @Arclight

    Agree, but gosh there sure are a lot of "total rubes" out there. Makes me almost want to get into some kind of bridge-selling business.

    Chesterton wrote something about people who don't believe in God becoming capable of believing in anything, right? I guess as a corollary, in the present day, you could add that people who believe in trannys become capable of believing in anything.

    Replies: @MEH 0910, @Arclight, @quewin

    , @quewin
    @Arclight

    Even more absurd was all the hand-wringing over the possibility of Russia ‘using energy as a weapon’ by the EU and US as if ‘standing with Ukraine’ wasn’t a thing.

    Too many people think there are no consequences to their actions.

  • Harvard's new president, a black lady named Claudine Gay, who got roasted by deep-pocketed Jewish donors for not issuing a sufficiently one-sided enough statement about the conflict in the Middle East, has now announced that Harvard will henceforward be extra anti-anti-Semitic, with the DEI department being tasked to put fighting anti-Semitism up there with fighting...
  • Interesting that the WaPo finally comes to this conclusion only after some fairly high profile donors decide to stop supporting their alma maters over the Gaza conflict. This same paper put together a police shooting database back in 2020 that showed that unarmed blacks getting killed by cops was actually very rare, yet they were all on board with the “racial reckoning” that inflicted a few score deaths, billions of economic damage, and enabled ideological coups in institutions across the country.

    As the kids say these days, seems sus.

    • Agree: ic1000
    • Replies: @cool daddy jimbo
    @Arclight


    This same paper put together a police shooting database back in 2020 that showed that unarmed blacks getting killed by cops was actually very rare,
     
    Rarer than getting struck by lightning. Twice.
  • From an AEI survey of 5000+ Americans: Basically, they are finding what Jean Twenge (here's my review of her recent book) has been talking about for a decade: young people (teens and 20s, what they call Gen Z) are having less fun than young people did in the past. They tend to be lonelier, spend...
  • Feminism is a cancer – it tells women the most fulfilling and meaningful life for them is to essentially act like men: lots of unattached sex, place career at the enter of their lives, put off having kids. These behaviors run counter to their natural inclinations so following this blueprint leads them to seek meaning elsewhere (often politics) but only leads to increasing unhappiness.

    For younger women, the Alphabet People stuff theoretically offers a valued identity and status, but it’s a hollow promise as well because it runs counter to the actual nature of 97% of women who are straight as an arrow. Again, pursuing behavior that actually doesn’t align with your nature will inevitably be unfulfilling and unhappiness sets in and manifests itself in other destructive ways.

    The only hope I get from the survey is the large number of young men that clearly do not trust the culture (they shouldn’t) and are hopefully going to be highly motivated in the next 20 years to try and bend it to their liking, which clearly isn’t in the direction of conventional progressivism. If that turns out to be the case, I think a lot of women will end up abandoning ‘feminism’ in favor of the security that men who are enterprising and/or good providers offer. I am unsure the economic conditions of the future will be such that the heritage American TFR starts to rise though.

    • Thanks: ic1000
    • Replies: @Alec Leamas (working from home)
    @Arclight


    Feminism is a cancer – it tells women the most fulfilling and meaningful life for them is to essentially act like men: lots of unattached sex, place career at the enter of their lives, put off having kids. These behaviors run counter to their natural inclinations so following this blueprint leads them to seek meaning elsewhere (often politics) but only leads to increasing unhappiness.
     
    I think the thrust of feminism is to convince a woman that she has interests more aligned with every human with a uterus who ever lived or is living than with their fathers, brothers, husbands and sons. Further in fact, it falsely convinces them that their interests are contrary to the interests of their fathers, brothers, husbands and sons, and that they should work together to diminish the lives of their fathers, brothers, husbands and sons. There's innate solipsism in women, and it is further cultivated by the media's messages - they're coddled and made to believe that they're the main character of the serial drama that is the Universe.

    The offer of arrested adolescence with lots of fun but consequence-less sex is the lure. Naturally, the reality does not match the promise depicted by gay male scriptwriters shot for premium cable. No, you're not going to live in a Manhattan apartment with a doorman, wear $1,500 high heels, and eat exotic ethnic foods every night on your assistant to the junior editor salary while turning down offers of commitment from a score of wealthy, handsome men between trysts with young, hunky blue collar workers.

    Once the investment in this lifestyle is secure and the years have made a course correction all but impossible, a victim will add her voice to that of the sirens calling the next generation of young girls top share the company of her misery.

    Replies: @ThreeCranes, @HallParvey, @The Wild Geese Howard

    , @Mr. Anon
    @Arclight


    Feminism is a cancer – it tells women the most fulfilling and meaningful life for them is to essentially act like men: lots of unattached sex, place career at the enter of their lives, put off having kids.
     
    It's not just that they act like men, it's that they act like a caricature of men constructed by feminists. Most men, or at least many men, don't even act that way.

    Replies: @Forgot my Name

    , @Blodgie
    @Arclight

    Why would women abandon feminism when it gave them the thing they wanted most: the advantage to compete with and beat men through Affirmative Action?

    Women are as competitive as men and perhaps moreso.

    They couldn’t compete on a level playing field so they needed Affirmative Action and there are no signs AA wi ever stop—even in positions where women are dominant with 75% of the jobs.

    AA is their kryponite against higher performing men.

    They will never give up this advantage and no one is even asking them to because both sides support AA for women.

  • Back on August 15, 2019, managing editor Dean Baquet apologized to the New York Times staff for the ignominious failure of the Times' management's Plan A to push Trump out of office -- RussiaGate -- and promised the Times was now going all in on their Plan B to get rid of Trump -- nonstop...
  • @Harry Baldwin
    @Arclight

    “Allyship” is a one-way street and the beneficiaries have no intention of returning the favor if given the opportunity.

    I feel it was an error in John Derbyshire's "The Rules: The Non-Black Version" that he suggested that having a black friend might protect you against a charge of racism. It will not. Even having a black spouse or adopting black children cannot guarantee immunity from that charge. In fact, even being black won't necessarily help, e.g., "Larry Elder is the Black face of white supremacy."


    (13) In that pool of forty million, there are nonetheless many intelligent and well-socialized blacks. (I’ll use IWSB as an ad hoc abbreviation.) You should consciously seek opportunities to make friends with IWSBs. In addition to the ordinary pleasures of friendship, you will gain an amulet against potentially career-destroying accusations of prejudice.
     

    Replies: @Arclight, @silviosilver

    He was probably sort of right at the time that column was written – since then we’ve had the Mike Brown, Freddie Gray, Breonna Taylor, St. George events that involved an unbelievable amount of brazen lying by the media and politicians that would have been hard to imagine then.

    Add in Russia collusion, transmania, Covid, and other events in the last 11-12 years, and it should be pretty obvious that the left in this country is dead serious about obtaining a stranglehold on power and there is no line they will not cross in pursuit of it.

    I have stated multiple times that I think demographic change means black politics will lose their potency in the future – but we aren’t there yet.

    • Replies: @silviosilver
    @Arclight


    I have stated multiple times that I think demographic change means black politics will lose their potency in the future – but we aren’t there yet.
     
    I hope like hell you're right, but sometimes, I dunno...

    Eg, because of friends' children, I'm around quite a few white teens. The parents usually agree wholeheartedly with my racial talking points (though they generally have no idea how radical I really am on race), and the kids are by no means doctrinaire "anti-racists" (toss the n-word around for fun, that sort of thing). But every now and then I get these doleful reactions about my "racism" from their kids that make me think they are every bit as clueless about race as they appear. (You know, 1 dude in 20 out of their friends is black, so they think they know something. Some people are just fated to learn the hard way.)