The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection$
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • B
Show CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeThanksLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Current Commenter
says:

Leave a Reply -


 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
$
Submitted comments have been licensed to The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Commenting Disabled While in Translation Mode
Commenters to FollowHide Excerpts
By Authors Filter?
Alastair Crooke Ambrose Kane Anatoly Karlin Andrew Anglin Andrew Joyce Audacious Epigone Boyd D. Cathey C.J. Hopkins E. Michael Jones Eric Margolis Eric Striker Fred Reed Gilad Atzmon Gregory Hood Guillaume Durocher Hua Bin Ilana Mercer Israel Shamir ISteve Community James Kirkpatrick James Thompson Jared Taylor John Derbyshire Jonathan Cook Jung-Freud Karlin Community Kevin Barrett Kevin MacDonald Larry Romanoff Laurent Guyénot Linh Dinh Michael Hudson Mike Whitney Pat Buchanan Patrick Cockburn Paul Craig Roberts Paul Kersey Pepe Escobar Peter Frost Philip Giraldi Razib Khan Ron Unz Steve Sailer The Saker Tobias Langdon A. Graham A. J. Smuskiewicz A Southerner Academic Research Group UK Staff Adam Hochschild Aedon Cassiel Agha Hussain Ahmad Al Khaled Ahmet Öncü Al X Griz Alain De Benoist Alan Macleod Albemarle Man Alex Graham Alexander Cockburn Alexander Hart Alexander Jacob Alexander Wolfheze Alfred De Zayas Alfred McCoy Alison Weir Allan Wall Allegra Harpootlian Amalric De Droevig Amr Abozeid Anand Gopal Anastasia Katz Andre Damon Andre Vltchek Andreas Canetti Andrei Martyanov Andrew Cockburn Andrew Fraser Andrew Hamilton Andrew J. Bacevich Andrew Napolitano Andrew S. Fischer Andy Kroll Angie Saxon Ann Jones Anna Tolstoyevskaya Anne Wilson Smith Anonymous Anonymous American Anonymous Attorney Anonymous Occidental Anthony Boehm Anthony Bryan Anthony DiMaggio Tony Hall Antiwar Staff Antonius Aquinas Antony C. Black Ariel Dorfman Arlie Russell Hochschild Arno Develay Arnold Isaacs Artem Zagorodnov Astra Taylor AudaciousEpigone Augustin Goland Austen Layard Ava Muhammad Aviva Chomsky Ayman Fadel Bailey Schwab Barbara Ehrenreich Barbara Garson Barbara Myers Barry Kissin Barry Lando Barton Cockey Beau Albrecht Belle Chesler Ben Fountain Ben Freeman Ben Sullivan Benjamin Villaroel Bernard M. Smith Beverly Gologorsky Bill Black Bill Moyers Blake Archer Williams Bob Dreyfuss Bonnie Faulkner Book Brad Griffin Bradley Moore Brenton Sanderson Brett Redmayne-Titley Brett Wilkins Brian Dew Brian McGlinchey Brian R. Wright Britannicus Brittany Smith Brooke C.D. Corax C.J. Miller Caitlin Johnstone Cara Marianna Carl Boggs Carl Horowitz Carolyn Yeager Cat McGuire Catherine Crump César Keller Chalmers Johnson Chanda Chisala Charles Bausman Charles Goodhart Charles Wood Charlie O'Neill Charlottesville Survivor Chase Madar ChatGPT Chauke Stephan Filho Chris Hedges Chris Roberts Chris Woltermann Christian Appy Christophe Dolbeau Christopher DeGroot Christopher Donovan Christopher Harvin Christopher Ketcham Chuck Spinney Civus Non Nequissimus CODOH Editors Coleen Rowley Colin Liddell Cooper Sterling Courtney Alabama Craig Murray Cynthia Chung D.F. Mulder Dahr Jamail Dakota Witness Dan E. Phillips Dan Roodt Dan Sanchez Daniel Barge Daniel McAdams Daniel Moscardi Daniel Vinyard Danny Sjursen Dave Chambers Dave Kranzler Dave Lindorff David Barsamian David Boyajian David Bromwich David Chibo David Chu David Gordon David Haggith David Irving David L. McNaron David Lorimer David Martin David North David Skrbina David Stockman David Vine David Walsh David William Pear David Yorkshire Dean Baker Declan Hayes Dennis Dale Dennis Saffran Diana Johnstone Diego Ramos Dilip Hiro Dirk Bezemer Dmitriy Kalyagin Don Wassall Donald Thoresen Alan Sabrosky Dr. Ejaz Akram Dr. Ridgely Abdul Mu’min Muhammad Dries Van Langenhove E. Frederick Stevens E. Geist Eamonn Fingleton Ed Warner Edmund Connelly Eduardo Galeano Edward Curtin Edward Dutton Egbert Dijkstra Egor Kholmogorov Ehud Shapiro Ekaterina Blinova Ellen Brown Ellen Packer Ellison Lodge Emil Kirkegaard Emilio García Gómez Emma Goldman Enzo Porter Eric Draitser Eric Paulson Eric Peters Eric Rasmusen Eric Zuesse Erik Edstrom Erika Eichelberger Erin L. Thompson Eugene Gant Eugene Girin Eugene Kusmiak Eve Mykytyn F. Douglas Stephenson F. Roger Devlin Fadi Abu Shammalah Fantine Gardinier Federale Fenster Fergus Hodgson Finian Cunningham The First Millennium Revisionist Fordham T. Smith Former Agent Forum Francis Goumain Frank Key Frank Tipler Franklin Lamb Franklin Stahl Frida Berrigan Friedrich Zauner Gabriel Black Ganainm Gary Corseri Gary Heavin Gary North Gary Younge Gavin Newsom Gene Tuttle George Albert George Bogdanich George Galloway George Koo George Mackenzie George Szamuely Georgia Hayduke Georgianne Nienaber Gerhard Grasruck Gilbert Cavanaugh Gilbert Doctorow Giles Corey Glen K. Allen Glenn Greenwald A. Beaujean Agnostic Alex B. Amnestic Arcane Asher Bb Bbartlog Ben G Birch Barlow Canton ChairmanK Chrisg Coffee Mug Darth Quixote David David B David Boxenhorn DavidB Diana Dkane DMI Dobeln Duende Dylan Ericlien Fly Gcochran Godless Grady Herrick Jake & Kara Jason Collins Jason Malloy Jason s Jeet Jemima Joel John Emerson John Quiggin JP Kele Kjmtchl Mark Martin Matoko Kusanagi Matt Matt McIntosh Michael Vassar Miko Ml Ole P-ter Piccolino Rosko Schizmatic Scorpius Suman TangoMan The Theresa Thorfinn Thrasymachus Wintz Godfree Roberts Gonzalo Lira Graham Seibert Grant M. Dahl Greg Garros Greg Grandin Greg Johnson Greg Klein Gregg Stanley Gregoire Chamayou Gregory Conte Gregory Wilpert Guest Admin Gunnar Alfredsson Gustavo Arellano H.G. Reza Hank Johnson Hannah Appel Hans-Hermann Hoppe Hans Vogel Harri Honkanen Heiner Rindermann Henry Cockburn Hewitt E. Moore Hina Shamsi Howard Zinn Howe Abbot-Hiss Hubert Collins Hugh Kennedy Hugh McInnish Hugh Moriarty Hugh Perry Hugo Dionísio Hunter DeRensis Hunter Wallace Huntley Haverstock Ian Fantom Ian Proud Ichabod Thornton Igor Shafarevich Ira Chernus Irmin Vinson Ivan Kesić J. Alfred Powell J.B. Clark J.D. Gore J. Ricardo Martins Jacek Szela Jack Antonio Jack Dalton Jack Kerwick Jack Krak Jack Rasmus Jack Ravenwood Jack Sen Jake Bowyer James Bovard James Carroll James Carson Harrington James Chang James Dunphy James Durso James Edwards James Fulford James Gillespie James Hanna James J. O'Meara James K. Galbraith James Karlsson James Lawrence James Petras James W. Smith Jane Lazarre Jane Weir Janice Kortkamp Janko Vukic Jared S. Baumeister Jason C. Ditz Jason Cannon Jason Kessler Jay Stanley Jayant Bhandari JayMan Jean Bricmont Jean Marois Jean Ranc Jef Costello Jeff J. Brown Jeffrey Blankfort Jeffrey D. Sachs Jeffrey St. Clair Jen Marlowe Jeremiah Goulka Jeremy Cooper Jeremy Kuzmarov Jesse Mossman JHR Writers Jim Daniel Jim Fetzer Jim Goad Jim Kavanagh Jim Mamer Jim Smith JoAnn Wypijewski Joe Atwill Joe Dackman Joe Lauria Joel Davis Joel S. Hirschhorn Johannes Wahlstrom John W. Dower John Feffer John Fund John Gorman John Harrison Sims John Helmer John Hill John Huss John J. Mearsheimer John Jackson John Kiriakou John Macdonald John Morgan John Patterson John Leonard John Pilger John Q. Publius John Rand John Reid John Ryan John Scales Avery John Siman John Stauber John T. Kelly John Taylor John Titus John Tremain John V. Walsh John Wear John Williams Jon Else Jon Entine Jonas E. Alexis Jonathan Alan King Jonathan Anomaly Jonathan Revusky Jonathan Rooper Jonathan Sawyer Jonathan Schell Jordan Henderson Jordan Steiner Jorge Besada Jose Alberto Nino Joseph Correro Joseph Kay Joseph Kishore Joseph Sobran Josephus Tiberius Josh Neal Jeshurun Tsarfat Juan Cole Judith Coburn Julian Bradford Julian Macfarlane K.J. Noh Kacey Gunther Karel Van Wolferen Karen Greenberg Karl Haemers Karl Nemmersdorf Karl Thorburn Kees Van Der Pijl Keith Woods Kelley Vlahos Kenn Gividen Kenneth A. Carlson Kenneth Vinther Kerry Bolton Kersasp D. Shekhdar Kevin DeAnna Kevin Folta Kevin Michael Grace Kevin Rothrock Kevin Sullivan Kevin Zeese Kit Klarenberg Kshama Sawant Lance Welton Larry C. Johnson Laura Gottesdiener Laura Poitras Lawrence Erickson Lawrence G. Proulx Leo Hohmann Leonard C. Goodman Leonard R. Jaffee Liam Cosgrove Lidia Misnik Lilith Powell Linda Preston Lipton Matthews Liv Heide Logical Meme Lorraine Barlett Louis Farrakhan Lydia Brimelow M.G. Miles Mac Deford Maciej Pieczyński Mahmoud Khalil Maidhc O Cathail Malcolm Unwell Marc Sills Marco De Wit Marcus Alethia Marcus Apostate Marcus Cicero Marcus Devonshire Marcy Winograd Margaret Flowers Margot Metroland Marian Evans Mark Allen Mark Bratchikov-Pogrebisskiy Mark Crispin Miller Mark Danner Mark Engler Mark Gullick Mark H. Gaffney Mark Lu Mark O'Brien Mark Perry Mark Weber Marshall Yeats Martin Jay Martin K. O'Toole Martin Lichtmesz Martin Webster Martin Witkerk Mary Phagan-Kean Matt Cockerill Matt Parrott Mattea Kramer Matthew Battaglioli Matthew Caldwell Matthew Ehret Matthew Harwood Matthew Richer Matthew Stevenson Max Blumenthal Max Denken Max Jones Max North Max Parry Max West Maya Schenwar Merlin Miller Metallicman Michael A. Roberts Michael Averko Michael Gould-Wartofsky Michael Hoffman Michael Masterson Michael Quinn Michael Schwartz Michael T. Klare Michelle Malkin Miko Peled Mnar Muhawesh Moon Landing Skeptic Morgan Jones Morris V. De Camp Mr. Anti-Humbug Muhammed Abu Murray Polner N. Joseph Potts Nan Levinson Naomi Oreskes Nate Terani Nathan Cofnas Nathan Doyle Ned Stark Neil Kumar Nelson Rosit Neville Hodgkinson Niall McCrae Nicholas R. Jeelvy Nicholas Stix Nick Griffin Nick Kollerstrom Nick Turse Nicolás Palacios Navarro Nils Van Der Vegte Noam Chomsky NOI Research Group Nomi Prins Norman Finkelstein Norman Solomon OldMicrobiologist Oliver Boyd-Barrett Oliver Williams Oscar Grau P.J. Collins Pádraic O'Bannon Patrice Greanville Patrick Armstrong Patrick Cleburne Patrick Cloutier Patrick Lawrence Patrick Martin Patrick McDermott Patrick Whittle Paul Bennett Paul Cochrane Paul De Rooij Paul Edwards Paul Engler Paul Gottfried Paul Larudee Paul Mitchell Paul Nachman Paul Nehlen Paul Souvestre Paul Tripp Pedro De Alvarado Peter Baggins Ph.D. Peter Bradley Peter Brimelow Peter Gemma Peter Haenseler Peter Lee Peter Van Buren Philip Kraske Philip Weiss Pierre M. Sprey Pierre Simon Povl H. Riis-Knudsen Pratap Chatterjee Publius Decius Mus Qasem Soleimani R, Weiler Rachel Marsden Raches Radhika Desai Rajan Menon Ralph Nader Ralph Raico Ramin Mazaheri Ramziya Zaripova Ramzy Baroud Randy Shields Raul Diego Ray McGovern Raymond Wolters Rebecca Gordon Rebecca Solnit Reginald De Chantillon Rémi Tremblay Rev. Matthew Littlefield Ricardo Duchesne Richard Cook Richard Falk Richard Faussette Richard Foley Richard Galustian Richard Houck Richard Hugus Richard Knight Richard Krushnic Richard McCulloch Richard Parker Richard Silverstein Richard Solomon Rick Shenkman Rick Sterling Rita Rozhkova Rob Crease Robert Baxter Robert Bonomo Robert Debrus Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Robert Fisk Robert Hampton Robert Henderson Robert Inlakesh Robert LaFlamme Robert Lindsay Robert Lipsyte Robert Parry Robert Roth Robert S. Griffin Robert Scheer Robert Stark Robert Stevens Robert Trivers Robert Wallace Robert Weissberg Robin Eastman Abaya Roger Dooghy Rolo Slavskiy Romana Rubeo Romanized Visigoth Ron Paul Ronald N. Neff Rory Fanning Rose Pinochet RT Staff Ruuben Kaalep Ryan Andrews Ryan Dawson Sabri Öncü Salim Mansur Sam Dickson Sam Francis Sam Husseini Samuel Sequeira Sayed Hasan Scot Olmstead Scott Howard Scott Locklin Scott Ritter Seaghan Breathnach Servando Gonzalez Sharmine Narwani Sharmini Peries Sheldon Richman Sidney James Sietze Bosman Sigurd Kristensen Sinclair Jenkins Southfront Editor Spencer Davenport Spencer J. Quinn Stefan Karganovic Steffen A. Woll Stephanie Savell Stephen F. Cohen Stephen J. Rossi Stephen J. Sniegoski Stephen Paul Foster Sterling Anderson Steve Fraser Steve Keen Steve Penfield Steven Farron Steven Starr Steven Yates Subhankar Banerjee Susan Southard Sybil Fares Sydney Schanberg Talia Mullin Tanya Golash-Boza Taxi Taylor McClain Taylor Young Ted O'Keefe Ted Rall The Crew The Zman Theodore A. Postol Thierry Meyssan Thomas A. Fudge Thomas Anderson Thomas Hales Thomas Dalton Thomas Ertl Thomas Frank Thomas Hales Thomas Jackson Thomas O. Meehan Thomas Steuben Thomas Zaja Thorsten J. Pattberg Tim Shorrock Tim Weiner Timothy Vorgenss Timur Fomenko Tingba Muhammad Todd E. Pierce Todd Gitlin Todd Miller Tom Engelhardt Tom Mysiewicz Tom Piatak Tom Suarez Tom Sunic Torin Murphy Tracy Rosenberg Travis LeBlanc Trevor Lynch Vernon Thorpe Virginia Dare Vito Klein Vladimir Brovkin Vladimir Putin Vladislav Krasnov Vox Day W. Patrick Lang Walt King Walter E. Block Warren Balogh Washington Watcher Washington Watcher II Wayne Allensworth Wei Ling Chua Wesley Muhammad White Man Faculty Whitney Webb Wilhelm Kriessmann Wilhem Ivorsson Will Jones Will Offensicht William Binney William DeBuys William Hartung William J. Astore Winslow T. Wheeler Wyatt Peterson Wyatt Reed Ximena Ortiz Yan Shen Yaroslav Podvolotskiy Yvonne Lorenzo Zhores Medvedev
Nothing found
By Topics/Categories Filter?
2020 Election Academia American Media American Military American Pravda Anti-Semitism Benjamin Netanyahu Black Crime Black Lives Matter Blacks Britain Censorship China China/America Conspiracy Theories Covid Culture/Society Donald Trump Economics Foreign Policy Gaza Genocide Hamas History Holocaust Ideology Immigration IQ Iran Israel Israel Lobby Israel/Palestine Jews Joe Biden NATO Nazi Germany Neocons Open Thread Political Correctness Race/Ethnicity Russia Science Ukraine Vladimir Putin World War II 汪精衛 100% Jussie-free Content 2008 Election 2012 Election 2016 Election 2018 Election 2022 Election 2024 Election 23andMe 9/11 Abortion Abraham Lincoln Academy Awards Achievement Gap ACLU Acting White Adam Schiff Addiction ADL Admin Administration Admixture Adolf Hitler Advertising AfD Affective Empathy Affirmative Action Affordable Family Formation Afghanistan Africa African Americans African Genetics Africans Afrikaner Age Age Of Malthusian Industrialism Agriculture AI AIPAC Air Force Aircraft Carriers Airlines Airports Al Jazeera Al Qaeda Alain Soral Alan Clemmons Alan Dershowitz Albania Albert Einstein Albion's Seed Alcohol Alcoholism Alejandro Mayorkas Alex Jones Alexander Dugin Alexander Vindman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Alexei Navalny Algeria Ali Dawabsheh Alien And Sedition Acts Alison Nathan Alt Right Altruism Amazon Amazon.com America America First American Civil War American Dream American History American Indians American Israel Public Affairs Committee American Jews American Left American Nations American Presidents American Prisons American Renaissance Amerindians Amish Amnesty Amnesty International Amos Hochstein Amy Klobuchar Anarchism Ancient DNA Ancient Genetics Ancient Greece Ancient Rome Andrei Nekrasov Andrew Bacevich Andrew Yang Anglo-America Anglo-imperialism Anglo-Saxons Anglos Anglosphere Angola Animal IQ Animal Rights Wackos Animals Ann Coulter Anne Frank Anthony Blinken Anthony Fauci Anthrax Anthropology Anti-Defamation League Anti-Gentilism Anti-Semites Anti-Vaccination Anti-Vaxx Anti-white Animus Antifa Antifeminism Antiquity Antiracism Antisemitism Antisemitism Awareness Act Antisocial Behavior Antizionism Antony Blinken Apartheid Apartheid Israel Apollo's Ascent Appalachia Apple Arab Christianity Arab Spring Arabs Archaeogenetics Archaeology Architecture Arctic Arctic Sea Ice Melting Argentina Ariel Sharon Armageddon War Armenia Armenian Genocide Army Arnold Schwarzenegger Arnon Milchan Art Arthur Jensen Arthur Lichte Artificial Intelligence Arts/Letters Aryan Invasion Theory Aryans Aryeh Lightstone Ashkenazi Intelligence Ashkenazi Jews Asia Asian Americans Asian Quotas Asians Assassination Assassinations Assimilation Atheism Atlanta AUMF Auschwitz Austin Metcalf Australia Australian Aboriginals Automation Avril Haines Ayn Rand Azerbaijan Azov Brigade Babes And Hunks Baby Gap Balfour Declaration Balkans Balochistan Baltics Baltimore Riots Banjamin Netanyahu Banking Industry Banking System Banks #BanTheADL Barack Obama Baseball Statistics Bashar Al-Assad Basketball BBC BDS BDS Movement Beauty Behavior Genetics Behavioral Genetics Belarus Belgium Belgrade Embassy Bombing Ben Cardin Ben Rhodes Ben Shapiro Ben Stiller Benny Gantz Bernard Henri-Levy Bernie Sanders Betar US Betsy DeVos Betty McCollum Bezalel Smotrich Bezalel Yoel Smotrich Biden BigPost Bilateral Relations Bilingual Education Bill Clinton Bill De Blasio Bill Gates Bill Kristol Bill Maher Bill Of Rights Billionaires Billy Graham Bioethics Biology Bioweapons Birmingham Birth Rate Bitcoin Black Community Black History Month Black Muslims Black People Black Slavery BlackLivesMatter Blackmail Blake Masters Blank Slatism BLM Blog Blogging Blogosphere Blond Hair Blood Libel Blue Eyes Boasian Anthropology Boeing Boers Bolshevik Revolution Bolshevik Russia Books Boomers Border Wall Boris Johnson Bosnia Boycott Divest And Sanction Brain Scans Brain Size Brain Structure Brazil Bret Stephens Bretton Woods Brexit Brezhnev Bri Brian Mast BRICs British Empire British Labour Party British Politics Buddhism Build The Wall Bulldog Bush Business Byzantine Caitlin Johnstone California Californication Camp Of The Saints Canada Canary Mission Cancer Candace Owens Capitalism Carlos Slim Caroline Glick Carroll Quigley Cars Carthaginians Catalonia Catholic Church Catholicism Catholics Cats Caucasus CCP CDC Ceasefire Cecil Rhodes Census Central Asia Central Intelligence Agency Chanda Chisala Chaos And Order Charles De Gaulle Charles Kushner Charles Lindbergh Charles Manson Charles Murray Charles Schumer Charlie Hebdo Charlie Kirk Charlottesville ChatGPT Checheniest Chechen Of Them All Chechens Chechnya Chetty Chicago Chicagoization Chicken Hut Child Abuse Children Chile China Vietnam Chinese Chinese Communist Party Chinese Evolution Chinese IQ Chinese Language Christian Zionists Christianity Christmas Christopher Steele Christopher Wray Chuck Schumer CIA Cinema Civil Liberties Civil Rights Civil Rights Movement Civil War Civilization Clannishness Clash Of Civilizations Class Classical Antiquity Classical History Classical Music Clayton County Climate Change Clint Eastwood Clintons Coal Coalition Of The Fringes Coen Brothers Cognitive Elitism Cognitive Science Cold Cold War Colin Kaepernick Colin Woodard College Admission College Football Colombia Colonialism Color Revolution Columbia University Columbus Comic Books Communism Computers Confederacy Confederate Flag Confucianism Congress Conquistador-American Conservatism Conservative Movement Conservatives Conspiracy Theory Constantinople Constitution Constitutional Theory Consumerism Controversial Book Convergence Core Article Corona Corporatism Corruption COTW Counterpunch Country Music Cousin Marriage Cover Story Covert Action COVID-19 Craig Murray Creationism Crime Crimea Crispr Critical Race Theory Cruise Missiles Crusades Crying Among The Farmland Crypto Cryptocurrency Ctrl-Left Cuba Cuban Missile Crisis Cuckery Cuckservative CUFI Cuisine Cultural Marxism Cultural Revolution Culture Culture War Czars Czech Republic DACA Daily Data Dump Dallas Shooting Damnatio Memoriae Dan Bilzarian Danny Danon Daren Acemoglu Darwinism Darya Dugina Data Data Analysis Dave Chappelle David Bazelon David Brog David Cole David Duke David Friedman David Frum David Irving David Lynch David Petraeus Davide Piffer Davos Death Of The West Deborah Lipstadt Debt Debt Jubilee Decadence Deep State DeepSeek Deficits Degeneracy Democracy Democratic Party Demograhics Demographic Transition Demographics Demography Denmark Dennis Ross Department Of Education Department Of Homeland Security Deplatforming Deportation Abyss Deportations Derek Chauvin Detroit Development Dick Cheney Diet Digital Yuan Dinesh D'Souza Discrimination Disease Disinformation Disney Disparate Impact Disraeli Dissent Dissidence Diversity Diversity Before Diversity Diversity Pokemon Points Dmitry Medvedev DNA Dogs Dollar Domestic Surveillance Domestic Terrorism Doomsday Clock Dostoevsky Doug Emhoff Doug Feith Dresden Drone War Drones Drug Cartels Drug Laws Drugs Duterte Dysgenic Dystopia E. Michael Jones E. O. Wilson East Asia East Asian Exception East Asians East Turkestan Easter Eastern Europe Ebrahim Raisi Economic Development Economic History Economic Sanctions Economy Edmund Burke Edmund Burke Foundation Education Edward Snowden Effective Altruism Effortpost Efraim Zurofff Egor Kholmogorov Egypt El Salvador Election 2016 Election 2018 Election 2020 Election Fraud Elections Electric Cars Eli Rosenbaum Elie Wiesel Eliot Cohen Eliot Engel Elise Stefanik Elites Elizabeth Holmes Elizabeth Warren Elliot Abrams Elliott Abrams Elon Musk Emigration Emmanuel Macron Emmett Till Employment Energy England Enoch Powell Entertainment Environment Environmentalism Epidemiology Equality Erdogan Eretz Israel Eric Zemmour Ernest Hemingway Espionage Espionage Act Estonia Ethics Ethics And Morals Ethiopia Ethnic Cleansing Ethnic Nepotism Ethnicity Ethnocentricty EU Eugene Debs Eugenics Eurabia Eurasia Euro Europe European Genetics European Right European Union Europeans Eurozone Evolution Evolutionary Biology Evolutionary Genetics Evolutionary Psychology Existential Risks Eye Color Face Shape Facebook Faces Fake News False Flag Attack Family Fantasy FARA Farmers Fascism Fast Food FBI FDA FDD Federal Reserve FEMA Feminism Ferguson Ferguson Shooting Fermi Paradox Fertility Fertility Fertility Rates Film Finance Financial Bailout Financial Bubbles Financial Debt Finland Finn Baiting First Amendment First World War FISA Fitness Flash Mobs Flight From White Floyd Riots 2020 Fluctuarius Argenteus Flynn Effect Food Football For Fun Forecasts Foreign Agents Registration Act Foreign Aid Foreign Policy Fourth Amendment Fox News France Francesca Albanese Frank Salter Frankfurt School Franklin D. Roosevelt Franklin Scandal Franz Boas Fraud Fred Kagan Free Market Free Speech Free Trade Freedom Of Speech Freedom Freemasons French French Revolution Friedrich Karl Berger Friends Of The Israel Defense Forces Frivolty Frontlash Furkan Dogan Future Futurism G20 Gambling Game Game Of Thrones Gavin McInnes Gavin Newsom Gay Germ Gay Marriage Gays/Lesbians Gaza Flotilla GDP Gen Z Gender Gender And Sexuality Gender Equality Gender Reassignment Gene-Culture Coevolution Genealogy General Intelligence General Motors Generation Z Generational Gap Genes Genetic Diversity Genetic Engineering Genetic Load Genetic Pacification Genetics Genomics Gentrification Geography Geopolitics George Floyd George Galloway George Patton George Soros George Tenet George W. Bush Georgia Germans Germany Ghislaine Maxwell Gilad Atzmon Gina Peddy Giorgia Meloni Gladwell Glenn Greenwald Global Warming Globalism Globalization Globo-Homo God Gold Golf Gonzalo Lira Google Government Government Debt Government Spending Government Surveillance Government Waste Grant Smith Graphs Great Bifurcation Great Depression Great Leap Forward Great Powers Great Replacement Greece Greeks Greenland Greg Cochran Gregory Clark Gregory Cochran Greta Thunberg Grooming Group Selection GSS Guardian Guest Guilt Culture Gun Control Guns GWAS Gypsies H.R. McMaster H1-B Visas Haim Saban Hair Color Haiti Hajnal Line Halloween HammerHate Hannibal Procedure Happening Happiness Harvard Harvard University Harvey Weinstein Hassan Nasrallah Hate Crimes Fraud Hoax Hate Hoaxes Hate Speech Hbd Hbd Chick Health Health And Medicine Health Care Healthcare Hegira Height Hell Henry Harpending Henry Kissinger Heredity Heritability Hezbollah High Speed Rail Hillary Clinton Hindu Caste System Hindus Hiroshima Hispanic Crime Hispanics Historical Genetics History Of Science Hitler HIV/AIDS Hoax Holland Hollywood Holocaust Denial Holocaust Deniers Homelessness Homicide Homicide Rate Hominin Homomania Homosexuality Hong Kong Houellebecq Housing Houthis Howard Kohr Huawei Huddled Masses Huey Newton Human Achievement Human Biodiversity Human Evolution Human Evolutionary Genetics Human Evolutionary Genomics Human Genetics Human Genomics Human Rights Human Rights Watch Humor Hungary Hunt For The Great White Defendant Hunter Biden Hunter-Gatherers I.F. Stone I.Q. I.Q. Genomics #IBelieveInHavenMonahan ICC Icj Ideas Identity Ideology And Worldview IDF Idiocracy Igbo Ilan Pappe Ilhan Omar Illegal Immigration Ilyushin IMF Impeachment Imperialism Inbreeding Income Income Tax India Indian Indian IQ Indians Individualism Indo-Europeans Indonesia Inequality Inflation Intelligence Intelligence Agencies Intelligent Design International International Comparisons International Court Of Justice International Criminal Court International Relations Internet Interracial Marriage Interracism Intersectionality Intifada Intra-Racism Intraracism Invade Invite In Hock Invade The World Invite The World Iosef Stalin Iosif Stalin Iq And Wealth Iran Nuclear Agreement Iran Nuclear Program Iranian Nuclear Program Iraq Iraq War Ireland Irish Is Love Colorblind Isaac Herzog ISIS Islam Islamic Jihad Islamic State Islamism Islamophobia Isolationism Israel Bonds Israel Defense Force Israel Defense Forces Israel Separation Wall Israeli Occupation IT Italy Itamar Ben-Gvir It's Okay To Be White Ivanka Ivy League J Street Jacky Rosen Jair Bolsonaro Jake Sullivan Jake Tapper Jamal Khashoggi James Angleton James Clapper James Comey James Forrestal James Jeffrey James Mattis James Watson James Zogby Janet Yellen Janice Yellen Japan Jared Diamond Jared Kushner Jared Taylor Jason Greenblatt JASTA Javier Milei JCPOA JD Vance Jeb Bush Jeffrey Epstein Jeffrey Goldberg Jeffrey Sachs Jen Psaki Jennifer Rubin Jens Stoltenberg Jeremy Corbyn Jerry Seinfeld Jerusalem Jerusalem Post Jesus Jesus Christ Jewish Genetics Jewish History Jewish Intellectuals Jewish Power Jewish Power Party Jewish Supremacism JFK Assassination JFK Jr. Jihadis Jill Stein Jimmy Carter Jingoism JINSA Joe Lieberman Joe Rogan John Bolton John Brennan John Derbyshire John F. Kennedy John Hagee John Kirby John Kiriakou John McCain John McLaughlin John Mearsheimer John Paul Joker Jonathan Freedland Jonathan Greenblatt Jonathan Pollard Jordan Peterson Joseph McCarthy Josh Gottheimer Josh Paul Journalism Judaism Judea Judge George Daniels Judicial System Judith Miller Julian Assange Jussie Smollett Justice Justin Trudeau Kaboom Kahanists Kaiser Wilhelm Kamala Harris Kamala On Her Knees Kanye West Karabakh War 2020 Karen Kwiatkowski Karine Jean-Pierre Karmelo Anthony Kash Patel Kashmir Kay Bailey Hutchison Kazakhstan Keir Starmer Kenneth Marcus Kevin MacDonald Kevin McCarthy Kevin Williamson Khazars Kids Kim Jong Un Kinship Kkk KKKrazy Glue Of The Coalition Of The Fringes Knesset Kompromat Korea Korean War Kosovo Kristi Noem Ku Klux Klan Kubrick Kurds Kushner Foundation Kyle Rittenhouse Kyrie Irving Language Laos Larry Ellison Larry C. Johnson Late Obama Age Collapse Latin America Latinos Laura Loomer Law Lawfare LDNR Lead Poisoning Leahy Amendments Leahy Law Lebanon Lee Kuan Yew Leftism Lenin Leo Frank Leo Strauss Let's Talk About My Hair LGBT LGBTI Liberal Opposition Liberal Whites Liberalism Liberals Libertarianism Libya Lindsey Graham Linguistics Literacy Literature Lithuania Litvinenko Living Standards Liz Cheney Liz Truss Lloyd Austin long-range-missile-defense Longevity Looting Lord Of The Rings Lorde Los Angeles Loudoun County Louis Farrakhan Love And Marriage Low-fat Lukashenko Lula Lyndon B Johnson Lyndon Johnson Madeleine Albright Mafia MAGA Magnitsky Act Mahmoud Abbas Malaysia Malaysian Airlines MH17 Manufacturing Mao Zedong Maoism Map Marco Rubio Maria Butina Maria Corina Machado Marijuana Marine Le Pen Marjorie Taylor Greene Mark Milley Mark Steyn Mark Warner Market Economy Martin Luther King Martin Scorsese Marvel Marx Marxism Masculinity Mass Immigration Mass Shootings Mate Choice Mathematics Matt Gaetz Max Blumenthal Max Boot Max Weber Maxine Waters Mayans McCain McCain/POW McDonald's Meat Media Media Bias Medicine Medieval Christianity Medieval Russia Mediterranean Diet Medvedev Megan McCain Meghan Markle Mein Obama Mel Gibson Men With Gold Chains Meng Wanzhou Mental Health Mental Illness Mental Traits Meritocracy Merkel Merkel Youth Merkel's Boner Merrick Garland Mexico MH 17 MI-6 Michael Bloomberg Michael Collins PIper Michael Flynn Michael Hudson Michael Jackson Michael Lind Michael McFaul Michael Moore Michael Morell Michael Pompeo Michelle Goldberg Michelle Ma Belle Michelle Obama Microaggressions Middle Ages Middle East Migration Mike Huckabee Mike Johnson Mike Pence Mike Pompeo Mike Signer Mike Waltz Mikhael Gorbachev Miles Mathis Militarized Police Military Military Analysis Military Budget Military History Military Spending Military Technology Millennials Milner Group Minimum Wage Minneapolis Minorities Minsk Accords Miriam Adelson Miscegenation Miscellaneous Misdreavus Mishima Missile Defense Mitch McConnell Mitt Romney Mixed-Race MK-Ultra Mohammed Bin Salman Monarchy Mondoweiss Money Mongolia Mongols Monkeypox Monopoly Monotheism Moon Landing Hoax Moon Landings Moore's Law Morality Mormonism Mormons Mortality Mortgage Moscow Mossad Movies Muhammad Multiculturalism Music Muslim Ban Muslims Mussolini NAEP Naftali Bennett Nakba NAMs Nancy Pelos Nancy Pelosi Narendra Modi NASA Natanz Nation Of Hate Nation Of Islam National Assessment Of Educational Progress National Debt National Endowment For Democracy National Review National Security Strategy National Socialism National Wealth Nationalism Native Americans Natural Gas Nature Vs. Nurture Navalny Affair Navy Standards Nazis Nazism Neandertals Neanderthals Negrolatry Nehru Neo-Nazis Neoconservatism Neoconservatives Neoliberalism Neolithic Neoreaction Nesta Webster Netherlands Never Again Education Act New Cold War New Dark Age New Deal New Horizon Foundation New Silk Road New Tes New Testament New World Order New York New York City New York Times New Zealand New Zealand Shooting NFL Nicholas II Nicholas Wade Nick Eberstadt Nick Fuentes Nicolas Maduro Niger Nigeria Nike Nikki Haley NIMBY Nina Jankowicz Noam Chomsky Nobel Peace Prize Nobel Prize Nord Stream Nord Stream Pipelines Nordics Norman Braman Norman Finkelstein North Africa North Korea Northern Ireland Northwest Europe Norway Novorossiya NSA NSO Group Nuclear Energy Nuclear Power Nuclear Proliferation Nuclear War Nuclear Weapons Nuremberg Nutrition Nvidia NYPD Obama Obama Presidency Obamacare Obesity Obituary Obscured American Occam's Razor Occupy Wall Street October Surprise OFAC Oil Oil Industry OJ Simpson Olav Scholz Old Testament Oliver Stone Olympics Open Borders OpenThread Opinion Poll Opioids Orban Organized Crime Orlando Shooting Orthodoxy Orwell Osama Bin Laden OTFI Ottoman Empire Our Soldiers Speak Out Of Africa Model Paganism Pakistan Pakistani Palantir Palestine Palestinians Palin Pam Bondi Panhandling Papacy Paper Review Parasite Burden Parenting Parenting Paris Attacks Partly Inbred Extended Family Pat Buchanan Patriot Act Patriotism Paul Craig Roberts Paul Findley Paul Ryan Paul Singer Paul Wolfowitz Pavel Grudinin Paypal Peak Oil Pearl Harbor Pedophilia Pentagon Personal Genomics Personality Pete Buttgieg Pete Hegseth Peter Frost Peter Thiel Petro Poroshenko Phil Rushton Philadelphia Philippines Philosophy Phoenicians Phyllis Randall Physiognomy Piers Morgan Pigmentation Pigs Piracy PISA Pizzagate POC Ascendancy Podcast Poetry Poland Police Police State Polio Political Correctness Makes You Stupid Political Dissolution Political Economy Politicians Politics Polling Pollution Polygamy Polygyny Pope Francis Population Population Genetics Population Growth Population Replacement Populism Porn Pornography Portland Portugal Portuguese Post-Apocalypse Postindustrialism Poverty Power Pramila Jayapal PRC Prediction Prescription Drugs President Joe Biden Presidential Race '08 Presidential Race '12 Presidential Race '16 Presidential Race '20 Prince Andrew Prince Harry Princeton University Priti Patel Privacy Privatization Progressives Propaganda Prostitution protest Protestantism Protocols Of The Elders Of Zion Proud Boys Psychology Psychometrics Psychopathy Public Health Public Schools Puerto Rico Puritans Putin Putin Derangement Syndrome QAnon Qasem Soleimani Qassem Soleimani Qatar Quantitative Genetics Quiet Skies R2P Race Race And Crime Race And Genomics Race And Iq Race And Religion Race/Crime Race Denialism Race/IQ Race-Ism Race Riots Rachel Corrie Racial Purism Racial Reality Racialism Racism Rafah Raj Shah Rand Paul Randy Fine Rape Rare Earths Rashida Tlaib Rationality Ray McGovern Raymond Chandler Razib Khan Real Estate RealWorld Recep Tayyip Erdogan Reconstruction Red Sea Refugee Crisis Religion Religion And Philosophy Rentier Reparations Reprint Republican Party Republicans Review Revisionism Rex Tillerson RFK Assassination Ricci Richard Dawkins Richard Goldberg Richard Grenell Richard Haas Richard Lewontin Richard Lynn Richard Nixon Rightwing Cinema Riots R/k Theory RMAX Robert A. Heinlein Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Robert Ford Robert Kagan Robert Kraft Robert Maxwell Robert McNamara Robert Mueller Robert Reich Robots Rock Music Roe Vs. Wade Roger Waters Rolling Stone Roman Empire Romania Romans Romanticism Rome Ron DeSantis Ron Paul Ron Unz Ronald Reagan Rotherham Rothschilds Roy Cohn RT International Rudy Giuliani Rush Limbaugh Russiagate Russian Demography Russian Elections 2018 Russian History Russian Media Russian Military Russian Nationalism Russian Occupation Government Russian Orthodox Church Russian Reaction Russians Russophobes Russophobia Rwanda Ryan Dawson Sabrina Rubin Erdely Sacha Baron Cohen Sacklers Sailer Strategy Sailer's First Law Of Female Journalism Saint Peter Tear Down This Gate! Saint-Petersburg Salman Rushie Salt Sam Altman Sam Bankman-Fried Sam Francis Samantha Power Samson Option San Bernadino Massacre Sandy Hook Sapir-Whorf SAT Satan Satanic Age Satanism Saudi Arabia Scandal Science Denialism Science Fiction Scooter Libby Scotland Scott Bessent Scott Ritter Scrabble Secession Self Determination Self Indulgence Semites Serbia Sergei Lavrov Sergei Skripal Sergey Glazyev Seth Rich Sex Sex Differences Sexism Sexual Harassment Sexual Selection Sexuality Seymour Hersh Shai Masot Shakespeare Shame Culture Shanghai Cooperation Organisation Sheldon Adelson Shias And Sunnis Shimon Arad Shireen Abu Akleh Shmuley Boteach Shoah Shorts And Funnies Shoshana Bryen Shulamit Aloni Shurat HaDin Sigal Mandelker Sigar Pearl Mandelker Sigmund Freud Silicon Valley Singapore Single Women Sinotriumph Six Day War Sixties SJWs Skin Color Slavery Slavery Reparations Slavs Smart Fraction Social Justice Warriors Social Media Social Science Socialism Society Sociobiology Sociology Sodium Solzhenitsyn Somalia Sotomayor South Africa South Asia South China Sea South Korea Southeast Asia Soviet History Soviet Union Sovok Space Space Exploration Space Program Spain Spanish Spanish River High School SPLC Sport Sports Srebrenica St Petersburg International Economic Forum Stabby Somali Staffan Stage Stalinism Standardized Tests Star Trek Star Wars Starvation Comparisons State Department Statistics Statue Of Liberty Steny Hoyer Stephen Cohen Stephen Jay Gould Stereotypes Steroids Steve Bannon Steve Sailer Steve Witkoff Steven Pinker Steven Witkoff Strait Of Hormuz Strategic Ambiguity Stuart Levey Stuart Seldowitz Student Debt Stuff White People Like Sub-Saharan Africa Sub-Saharan Africans Subhas Chandra Bose Subprime Mortgage Crisis Suburb Suella Braverman Sugar Suicide Superintelligence Supreme Court Surveillance Susan Glasser Svidomy Sweden Switzerland Symington Amendment Syria Syrian Civil War Ta-Nehisi Coates Taiwan Take Action Taliban Talmud Tariff Tariffs Tatars Taxation Taxes Technical Considerations Technology Ted Cruz Telegram Television Terrorism Terrorists Terry McAuliffe Tesla Testing Testosterone Tests Texas THAAD Thailand The AK The American Conservative The Bell Curve The Bible The Black Autumn The Cathedral The Confederacy The Constitution The Eight Banditos The Family The Free World The Great Awokening The Left The Middle East The New York Times The South The States The Zeroth Amendment To The Constitution Theranos Theresa May Third World Thomas Jefferson Thomas Massie Thomas Moorer Thought Crimes Tiananmen Massacre Tibet Tiger Mom TikTok TIMSS Tom Cotton Tom Massie Tom Wolfe Tony Blair Tony Blinken Tony Kleinfeld Too Many White People Torture Trade Trains Trans Fat Trans Fats Transgender Transgenderism Transhumanism Translation Translations Transportation Travel Trayvon Martin Trolling True Redneck Stereotypes Trump Trump Derangement Syndrome Trust Tsarist Russia Tucker Carlson Tulsa Tulsi Gabbard Turkey Turks TWA 800 Twins Twitter Ucla UFOs UK Ukrainian Crisis UN Security Council Unbearable Whiteness Unemployment United Kingdom United Nations United Nations General Assembly United Nations Security Council United States Universal Basic Income UNRWA Urbanization Ursula Von Der Leyen Uruguay US Blacks US Capitol Storming 2021 US Civil War II US Congress US Constitution US Elections 2016 US Elections 2020 US State Department USA USAID USS Liberty USSR Uyghurs Uzbekistan Vaccination Vaccines Valdimir Putin Valerie Plame Vdare Venezuela Victor Davis Hanson Victoria Nuland Victorian England Video Video Games Vietnam Vietnam War Vietnamese Vikings Viktor Orban Viktor Yanukovych Violence Vioxx Virginia Virginia Israel Advisory Board Vitamin D Vivek Ramaswamy Vladimir Zelensky Volodymyr Zelensky Vote Fraud Voting Rights Voting Rights Act Vulcan Society Waffen SS Wall Street Walmart Wang Ching Wei Wang Jingwei War War Crimes War Guilt War In Donbass War On Christmas War On Terror War Powers War Powers Act Warhammer Washington DC WASPs Watergate Wealth Wealth Inequality Web Traffic Weight WEIRDO Welfare Wendy Sherman West Bank Western Civilization Western Decline Western European Marriage Pattern Western Hypocrisy Western Media Western Religion Western Revival Westerns White America White Americans White Death White Flight White Guilt White Helmets White Liberals White Man's Burden White Nakba White Nationalism White Nationalists White People White Privilege White Race White Racialism White Slavery White Supremacy White Teachers Whiterpeople Whites Whitney Webb Who Whom Whoopi Goldberg Wikileaks Wikipedia Wildfires William Browder William F. Buckley William Kristol William Latson William McGonagle William McRaven WINEP Winston Churchill Woke Capital Women Woodrow Wilson Workers Working Class World Bank World Economic Forum World Health Organization World Population World War G World War H World War Hair World War I World War III World War R World War T WTF WVS WWII Xi Jinping Xinjiang Yahya Sinwar Yair Lapid Yemen Yevgeny Prigozhin Yoav Gallant Yogi Berra's Restaurant Yoram Hazony YouTube Yugoslavia Yuval Noah Harari Zbigniew Brzezinski Zimbabwe Zionism Zionists Zohran Mamdani Zvika Fogel
Nothing found
Filter?
TGGP
Comments
• My
Comments
2,426 Comments • 136,800 Words •  RSS
(Commenters may request that their archives be hidden by contacting the appropriate blogger)
All Comments
 All Comments
    Maybe the Establishment declaring “the racial reckoning” after George Floyd’s death wasn’t such a smart idea after all? Ever since late May 2020, blacks have been blasting away in the general direction of other blacks in huge numbers. But who could have predicted that?
  • You just double-posted the previous post’s content into this one.

  • As I wrote in my review of Quentin Tarantino's Django Unchained in January 2013:
  • TGGP says: • Website

    Encouraging young men to spend their time watching violence onscreen actually sounds much better than leaving them to come up with other ways to spend their free time. Violence has gone down for much of Tarantino’s violent career. As far as I’m aware, there’s no evidence fictional violence produces more real violence in aggregate.

    • Replies: @WJ
    @TGGP

    Maybe 5 black people saw Pulp Fiction. Maybe 8 black people saw Reservoir Dogs. The gunk put out by Tarantino is seen by mostly wannbe hip urban whites. I don't think Tarantino has any influence on people, black or white.

    Replies: @JimDandy

  • From the New York Times: Return to Office? Some Women of Color Aren’t Ready After more than a year of virtual work, employers are making plans to get back to the physical workplace. That has many workers worrying about the return of microaggressions and bias, too. By Ruchika Tulshyan June 23, 2021 “I actually like...
  • Since the story indicates that most white employees also prefer working from home, perhaps the headline could have been “Black workers are normal, only moreso”.

  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: Read the whole thing there?
  • If the cultural turn happened right after 1919, then shouldn’t the percentage have peaked prior to the 1920s rather than in the 1930s?

    I find it interesting that the percentage never exceeds 50% in any decade of that graph, even though fiction is mostly read by women.

  • Last weekend, 14 people were shot in Austin's Sixth Street entertainment district. One random bystander has since died, Douglas Kantor, an IT guy at Ford Motor Company in Michigan who was visiting Austin with his brother. According to Sailer's Law of Mass Shootings, more dead than wounded usually means a nonblack shooter, while more wounded...
  • TGGP says: • Website

    I was not expecting that bit at the end about his shooting the same guy a few days earlier. It shouldn’t have been that hard for the police to pick him up for that, and even if he was released without bail by a judge, that should have taken a few days by itself. Additionally, if you are talking to someone who shot you a few days ago “It’s whatever” does not sound like an appropriate response to a threat.

  • Here's the agenda for the Tolkien Society's Summer Seminar 2021: Saturday 3rd July Time Speaker Paper (BST) (CEST) (EDT) 15:00 16:00 10:00 Cordeliah Logsdon Gondor in Transition: A Brief Introduction to Transgender Realities in The Lord of the Rings 15:30 16:30 10:30 Clare Moore The Problem of Pain: Portraying Physical Disability in the Fantasy of...
  • @Steve Sailer
    @Anon

    Tolkien fought in the Battle of the Somme against the nation responsible for The Ring Cycle. "Lord of the Rings" is a Northern European tragic epic inspired by the self-destructiveness of Northern Europeans in the Great War.

    Replies: @Deogolwulf, @theo the kraut, @TGGP, @Louis Renault, @John Milton’s Ghost, @Anon, @pyrrhus

    Tolkien always denied his work was an allegory. I don’t think we can simply conclude it was inspired by the Great War rather than the myths he has explicitly cited and were his normal object of study.

    • Replies: @Desiderius
    @TGGP

    It’s obviously and undeniably both.

    , @Dan Hayes
    @TGGP

    But his work were an allegory!

    , @Chrisnonymous
    @TGGP

    I agree. Tolkien explicitly stated his works were not about the great war. Unless we are scholars more serious than those at this conference, we shouldn't ignore him.

    , @SimplePseudonymicHandle
    @TGGP

    Reasonably safe posture assuming his experience in the Great War informed his writing.

    , @Dutch Boy
    @TGGP

    Possibly true but more than a few have suspected that Tolkien's Orcs were an allegorical take on Turks, the mortal threat to Christian Europe throughout the late Middle Ages up to their defeat at Vienna in 1683. In an age where warring parties were barbaric in the extreme, the Turks reputation for barbarism exceeded all others.

    Replies: @YetAnotherAnon

    , @Anon
    @TGGP

    Right, and Tolkien is famously against allegory:


    "I cordially dislike allegory in all its manifestations, and always have done so since I grew old and wary enough to detect its presence. I much prefer history – true or feigned– with its varied applicability to the thought and experience of readers. I think that many confuse applicability with allegory, but the one resides in the freedom of the reader, and the other in the purposed domination of the author."
     
    Yet at other times he he wrote:

    "I dislike Allegory - the conscious and intentional allegory - yet any attempt to explain the purport of myth or fairytale must use allegorical language."

    The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien #131
     

    "The only perfectly consistent allegory is a real life; and the only fully intelligible story is an allegory. And one finds, even in imperfect human 'literature', that the better and more consistent an allegory is the more easily it can be read 'just as a story'; and the better and more closely woven a story is the more easily can those so minded find allegory in it."

    The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien #109
     
    and

    "Of course my story is not an allegory of Atomic power, but of Power."

    The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien #186
     

    "The Lord of the Rings is of course a fundamentally religious and Catholic work, unconsciously so at first, but consciously in the revision."

    The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien #142
     
    , @Oscar Peterson
    @TGGP

    The world wars--both of them--may well have had some inspirational role in LoTR. That is not the same thing as claiming it was an allegorical treatment of those wars.

    I also think the Hobbit was partially inspired by the Zionist resettlement (i.e., conquest) of Palestine between the wars. Tolkien was fairly explicit that Dwarfs stood in for Jews in his work, and the return to the land theme is unmistakable.

  • From iSteve commenter Mr. Blank on the spotty history of fictional predictions of today's increasing trend toward Woke Corporate Dystopia: “Demolition Man” is the earliest one I can think of, although there are elements of Woke Corporatism in Huxley’s “Brave New World” — enough that I doubt Huxley would be very surprised at how things...
  • TGGP says: • Website

    The problem seems to have been a failure to account for the human religious impulse.

    Christ, Marx, Wood and Wei,
    Led us to this perfect day.
    Marx, Wood, Wei and Christ,
    All but Wei were sacrificed.
    Wood, Wei, Christ and Marx,
    Gave us lovely schools and parks.
    Wei, Christ, Marx and Wood,
    Made us humble, made us good.

    • Replies: @Reg Cæsar
    @TGGP

    This by the guy who mocked "Aryan Darien", and everyone naïvely thought it was about sex.


    https://www.lwcurrey.com/pictures/104666.jpg?v=1541632030

  • From The New Yorker: This is reminiscent of Theodore Dalrymple's experience as a doctor in Africa: Unlike in South Africa, where salaries were paid according to a racial hierarchy (whites first, Indians and coloured second, Africans last), salaries in Rhodesia were equal for blacks and whites doing the same job, so that a black junior...
  • TGGP says: • Website

    Africa isn’t weird for that pattern. Rather, what we think is normal is “W.E.I.R.D.” per Joe Henrich. Bryan Caplan wrote about that norm elsewhere (first inspired by some ethnography of Mexican villages, which actually reminded me a bit of some descriptions of ancient Rome):
    https://www.econlib.org/archives/2006/11/the_envy_of_the.html

    • Agree: Redneck farmer
  • The Pittsburgh Pirates baseball club have a beautiful ballpark overlooking their impressive Robber Baron downtown, but they play in a small market, so their ownership, after the optimistic but brief Andrew McCutcheon Era, appears to be content with being the St. Louis Browns of the 2020s. Hence, plays like this in which the entire Pirate...
  • Which sitcom was it? Arli$$?

    • Replies: @Danindc
    @TGGP

    Good guess. I remember an Isteve post from 2004 that mentioned Arliss

  • [Excerpted from the latest Radio Derb, now available exclusively through VDARE.com] Earlier, by Steve Sailer: Nope, No Riot in Chicago Last Night Over Mexican Kid Shot by a Cop Here's a phrase due for an airing: "asymmetry of indulgence." That phrase was coined by conservative British journalist Ferdinand Mount. He was writing about how Leftist...
  • The two shootings you bring up at the top are in fact different and merit different treatment. The man who was shot was supposed to be tased, so the cop screwed up and it cannot be defended as a “good shooting”. Even if he had a warrant out, any sensible department would conduct an investigation to determine what should be done about that mistake. The second case was during a riot, in which the normal procedures of law enforcement for dealing with small numbers of offenders on a scene are insufficient. None of this is to say that people were right to be angry at “due process” (even if cops frequently do get away with indisputably “bad” shootings, like that black guy with a legal handgun shot in his car a few years ago) or that they should have been eager to throw away due process in the second case.

  • From the Miami Herald: After Senate Republicans pass anti-riot bill, Democrats call on GOP donors to protest BY ANA CEBALLOS AND MARY ELLEN KLAS HERALD/TIMES TALLAHASSEE BUREAU APRIL 15, 2021 08:47 PM, UPDATED 11 HOURS 48 MINUTES AGO The Florida House passed the anti-rioting bill HB 1, a broad anti-rioting legislation that aims to crack...
  • Isn’t “inciting a riot” already a crime?

    • Replies: @El Dato
    @TGGP

    CNN would be dragged off.

    Replies: @anon

    , @Robert Dolan
    @TGGP

    Inciting a riot is okay for blacks but not for whites.

    Blacks are allowed to run wild, burn, loot, and murder.....because of slavery.

    And if blacks are in the mood to kill whites, it's okay because of......slavery.

    Whites are not allowed to defend themselves from violent blacks because of.....slavery.

    Replies: @Desiderius

  • Despite several days of wits teeing off on the Lady Down in Texas's absurd story, her original tweet still has 20 times more Likes than Replies. A lot of people these days positively hunger for stories of white evilness, no matter how ridiculous.
  • @Jack D
    @TGGP

    1. The thread is a note of sanity and because it is coming from a PoC the other Lefties should (one would hope, at least) give it more credibility than if some deplorable white male said it. Nothing like this ever happened. There is no record of a single Vietnamese shrimper being murdered by the KKK let alone 30. As the US found out in Vietnam, Vietnamese men may be the size of 12 year old American boys but they are no pushovers.

    2. Thao is not a guy (unless he is a trannie). Thao:

    https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/696883365350223872/y0HfU7k0_400x400.jpg

    Replies: @fish, @TGGP

    Doh! I am nowhere close to familiar with Vietnamese naming patterns and assumed too much.

  • This guy did a more serious investigation of her claims:
    https://twitter.com/ThaoHaPhD/status/1375233367084466179

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @TGGP

    1. The thread is a note of sanity and because it is coming from a PoC the other Lefties should (one would hope, at least) give it more credibility than if some deplorable white male said it. Nothing like this ever happened. There is no record of a single Vietnamese shrimper being murdered by the KKK let alone 30. As the US found out in Vietnam, Vietnamese men may be the size of 12 year old American boys but they are no pushovers.

    2. Thao is not a guy (unless he is a trannie). Thao:

    https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/696883365350223872/y0HfU7k0_400x400.jpg

    Replies: @fish, @TGGP

  • From Vox: I presume "lock-in" means, in effect, monopoly. YouTube's near monopoly is why YouTube stars tend to make less money than podcast stars, even though that sounds backwards: TV stars generally make more than radio stars who make more than journalist stars. The 2.9% fee that payment companies like Stripe and Paypal charge is...
  • “(somebody with the pronoun “they” who is mad that Yglesias, Greenwald, etc. are on Substack)”
    I’m assuming that’s your wording, rather than a quote from the article as is currently indicated.

  • Singer Lana Del Rey has been triggering music critics for a decade for her pride in being a beautiful straight white American woman. But she's so smart (philosophy major in college) and aesthetically gifted (both in terms of her overall shtick and, on this new album, in massive melodic hooks) that she's gotten away with...
  • TGGP says: • Website
    @Dumbo

    Singer Lana Del Rey has been triggering music critics for a decade for her pride in being a beautiful straight white American woman.
     
    "Del Rey", isn't that hispanic? :D

    Anyway, it's a silly idea that "beautiful straight white women" are somehow under attack (except occasionally by blacks or other non-white rapists).

    They are still the top prize/higher status, and they know it.

    (The "Karen" slur is only against middle-aged or less attractive women)

    The hate is strictly against poor or low-status white males. And, unfortunately, still with support of many of those "beautiful straight white American" women.

    Replies: @Steve Sailer, @J.Ross, @Charles St. Charles, @slumber_j, @TGGP

    Yeah, she was initially derided as a phony for renaming herself after her first album (under her real name) didn’t make an impact. But the “poptimists” killed off the concern with authenticity associated with “rockism”. As a die-hard rockist, I will not give an inch to Del Rey.
    https://www.vox.com/culture/2019/10/30/20853231/lana-del-rey-authenticity-career-norman-fucking-rockwell
    The end of that article states that Billie Eilish is similar, but Eilish actually does fit the rockist mold of authenticity surprisingly well for a zoomer whose work is in a different genre. Siblings writing & recording their own music at home and uploading it to SoundCloud without any record company input is what the Wright brothers of NoMeansNo would have done if SoundCloud had existed in 1980.

    • Replies: @AShartIsBorn
    @TGGP

    You fell for the Billie Eilish marketing pitch, I see.

  • As I pointed out in my review of Ayaan Hirsi Ali's Prey, Northern Europe has a major problem with growing harassment and criminality against women walking down the street. But nobody was supposed to talk about it because the harassers aren't Northern Europeans. But then a white policeman was arrested for the London murder of...
  • TGGP says: • Website

    This actually seems significantly different from the Columbine (or Texas Clock Tower) shootings you discuss. It’s a spree shooting of three different parlors. He had to drive a significant ways away from the first to get to the second. And the police didn’t find him at the second either, but he was close enough by that when he started shooting up the third the officers on the scene were able to hear and respond (it’s not clear if he was caught there or elsewhere).

  • As I pointed out earlier, an adjunct law professor at Georgetown U. has been summarily fired for expressing in a private conversation "angst" over the low performance of many of her black students. Another professor to whom Sandra Sellers was speaking expressed neither agreement nor disagreement, so he has been suspended. The Establishment is aghast...
  • TGGP says: • Website

    The Volokh Conspiracy blog is currently hosted by Reason (previously they were hosted by the Washington Post, and before that self-hosted), but it seems odd to say that post was “at Reason”. Blog posts wouldn’t appear in the magazine, and Reason has no editorial control over the blog. Maybe it’s just me who remembers that lots of old posts (which were sometimes chained together in a way you could link to I haven’t seen anywhere else) can now be found at the new domain even though they have nothing to do with Reason.

  • Humor from The New Yorker (with some interpolations by me -- see if you can guess which): Plots of Nineteen-Eighties Movies if Their Protagonists Had Been People of Color By Carlos Greaves February 27, 2021 "Risky Business" -- After a suspicious neighbor calls the police on Joel Goodson, and his sex party gets raided, he...
  • TGGP says: • Website

    For those who don’t want to click through to check, here’s a rot13 of each person’s list:

    Carlos:
    Evfxl Ohfvarff RG Sreevf Ohryyre’f Qnl Bss Gur Oernxsnfg Pyho Fvkgrra Pnaqyrf Xnengr Xvq Envqref bs gur Ybfg Nex Pnqqlfunpx

    Steve:
    Punevbg’f bs Sver Qnf Obbg Gur Evtug Fghss Nznqrhf Xblnnavfdngfv Jvgarff

  • @Ray P
    Talk Radio by Oliver Stone - a controversial and outspoken white-advocate radio talk jock in Texas is forced off the air by the ADL. He dies mysteriously in an unsolved street robbery gone wrong while walking to his automobile.

    Replies: @TGGP

    Wasn’t that inspired by the real case of a radiohost murdered by neo-nazis?

    • Replies: @Ray P
    @TGGP

    Yes, the murder of Alan Berg which happened four years before the film.

    Replies: @Forbes

  • From Harvard Medical School: Anti-Racist Epidemiology Research suggests reparations for slavery could have reduced COVID-19 infections and deaths in U.S. By JAKE MILLER February 10, 2021 Research This article is part of Harvard Medical School’s continuing coverage of medicine, biomedical research, medical education and policy related to the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic and the disease COVID-19. Civil...
  • I know Steve reads Andrew Gelman, so I wonder why he didn’t make a joke about the Lancet specifically.
    https://statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/?s=Lancet

  • From NBC News, here is one of countless recent articles explaining that while, sure, it may look like most of the street violence against elderly Asians is perpetrated by blacks, but that's just a stereotype, while Experts all agree the real enemy is, as always, White Supremacy. But maybe you do need more cops? Last...
  • @jon
    @Altai


    I wonder who could have predicted that anti-Asian prejudice was highest in the places with the highest concentrations of them?
     
    No, no, multiculturalism reduces prejudice. Fear is based on the unknown, familiarity leads to solidarity. That's why Alabama is such a non-racist place, blacks and whites living side-by-side for centuries.

    Replies: @TGGP, @Wade Hampton

    Biculturalism leads to more conflict than genuine multiculturalism. I believe Sailer has noted that immigration into Canada helped weaken the Quebecois independence movement.

    • Replies: @AnotherDad
    @TGGP


    Biculturalism leads to more conflict than genuine multiculturalism. I believe Sailer has noted that immigration into Canada helped weaken the Quebecois independence movement.
     
    "Two" is a pretty unstable situation.

    It really only works well, when the two are having sex.
  • I was introduced to Glenn Loury as a “gutbucket liberal” on Bloggingheads.tv, but he had an ideologically varied past and is currently aligned with John McWhorter against the popular nonsense of Ibram Kendi. Reading the end of this post put me in mind of something he wrote recently:
    https://quillette.com/2021/02/10/unspeakable-truths-about-racial-inequality-in-america/
    One important difference is the emphasis he puts on African-American history as an example of how different things can be. But just as NBC/Scheinhart Wig Company would have a difficult time of making it 1997 again through science or magic, it’s unclear how to put the genie back in the box and return to the rates of social progress seen in the first half of the 20th century.

  • A reader writes: What's an easy to use source from the 21st Century?
  • Larry Summers lost his job after pointing out that the standard deviation is higher for men than women. Something that occurred to me: since IQ is also correlated with lifespan, the earlier deaths of the lowest IQ men could shift the male distribution upward at later ages. Of course, average male & female lifespan isn’t equal, as women live longer.

    • Replies: @Feryl
    @TGGP

    Along those same lines, older people are going to be more responsible due in no small part to so many Darwin award winners being liquidated in their youth and early adulthood.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk

  • Sure, Tolkien devoted careful attention to cultural and racial diversity, but mostly that of the Northern European variety. As I wrote for UPI in 2001: A century ago, fueled by Richard Wagner's operas, Northern European mythology was world conquering in high culture. Then, Germany literally tried to conquer the world. Following Hitler's Gotterdammerung, Teutonic and...
  • If you go to https://www.unz.com/isteve/ it results in:
    We’re sorry. That page could not be found.

  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: Read the whole thing there. [Corrected link] Another parallel:
  • In contrast, only a single Roman writer known to us warned that one should avoid living near swamps because they were full of little animals that get inside you and make you sick

    Who?

    • Replies: @fitzhamilton
    @TGGP

    Antoninus Faustus. Anglicized Tony Fausti. The fellow who told us AZT would cure us of shoving hamsters up our descending colons.

    , @El Dato, @Bardon Kaldian, @Indiana Jack
    @TGGP

    I think the writer referenced here is Marcus Terentius Varro, who in the 1st century BC warned against living near swamps because "there are bred there certain minute creatures which cannot be seen by the eyes, but which float in the air and enter the body through the mouth and nose and cause serious diseases."

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marcus_Terentius_Varro

  • From the New York Times opinion section: Tipping Is a Legacy of Slavery Abolish the racist, sexist subminimum wage now. By Michelle Alexander Ms. Alexander is a civil rights advocate, the author of “The New Jim Crow,” and a contributing Opinion writer. Feb. 5, 2021 Once upon a time, I thought that it was perfectly...
  • I never worked in a restaurant, but someone I know was a host in a chain prior to being able to legally serve (due to the drinking age). A waiter complains about being assigned too many black tables, so this host then decides to assign this waiter a black table whenever possible. Waiter blows up at the host, and gets fired, the rest of the restaurant staff side with the host (or at least that’s what said host told me). Moral of the story: the squeaky wheel does not always get the grease.

  • iSteve commenter George looks up what kind of high school Biden's cabinet-level nominees attended: As an alternative to race I used the type of high school they attended as a proxy for class. Whites, Asians and Jews mostly attended private school. Yellen and Garland went to public school possibly because they were old school being...
  • The one that stands out to me is the Secretary of Education attending a vocational school. People in America often wonder why we don’t have much vocational training like Germany.

    • Replies: @James O'Meara
    @TGGP

    When Mies van der Rohe was tapped to design the Seagram Bldg, we wasn't licensed in NY, but the Ed. Dept. grandfathered him in, when they determined that his prewar German technical high school degree was the equivalent of an M. Arch.

    Mies set up the arch. school at Illinois Inst. of Tech (ITT); his tireless promoter in the US, Philip Johnson, had a degree in Greek from Harvard (he started in Philosophy but Whitehead told him he was not cut out for it) but after several years promoting modern arch. got a degree from Harvard rather than ITT because Mies, though supposedly his idol, demanded too much... work.

    Johnson lived in his famous Glass House in Connecticut because CT didn't require a license to practice architecture. Elsewhere he had licensed architects in a given state sign off on his "drawings".

    Replies: @Hibernian

    , @Alden
    @TGGP

    Because a couple hours a day in a vocational class is a couple hours a day is a couple hours a day not being brainwashed in hate Whitey love gays are you really a different sex classes.

    Actually, it all started when Malcolm X write his autobiography. He claimed his high school counselor advised him to sign up for shop classes so he could be an auto mechanic or union carpenter. Because the construction unions and car repair shop owners hired kids from the high school shop classes.

    Malcolm claimed that insulted him as a barely black man. So the schools abolished the ship classes as racists. All blacks should go to college and law school don cha know?

    As with everything else shop classes are racist.

  • From Ross Douthat's column today in the New York Times: Then there’s the now-pressing question of who actually gets the vaccine first, which has been taken up at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in a way that throws the limits of science-trusting into even sharper relief. Last month their Advisory Committee on Immunization...
  • it’s model of how to choose the order in which to vaccinate is ridiculous

    “it’s” is used for “it is”, whereas the possessive can just be written as “its”. The sentence is a little confusing if you start by assuming the former and then have to go back and replace it with the latter.

  • Almost all M to F transgenders fall into one or the other of two extreme types: Those who are highly effeminate since toddlerhood; Or the alarmingly male-brained: e.g., soldier, economist, outer space entrepreneur, MMA fighter, world's greatest athlete, computer programmer, etc, or this frontline cop with forearms like Steve Garvey. Never anybody from the middle...
  • @BenKenobi
    @TGGP

    When this first happened and I read a headline that said "AV Club writer comes out as trans" I was hoping it was Nathan Rabin. Seriously, f*ck that guy. He belongs in the 9th circle of Hell.

    Replies: @TGGP

    You might not like his politics, but Rabin’s a better writer than most at the AV Club now (and better than VDW).

  • @Daniel H
    They will never get it. Isn't it old to them by this point? It was sort of (but not so much) on the edge 20 years ago or so when Donald McCloskey got a hold of some PR rep who bugged the New York Times to tell McCloskey's shameful story, but c'mon, male trannyism is older and staler than April's social panic about the shortage of respirators.

    Yawned this week when the cute as a button Ellen Page (2010..s, Sally Field) upped an announced that all 5'1"" 95 lbs of her will henceforth be known as Elliot, because deep inside she has always felt like a ball scratching, itchy, gnarly, fornicating, farting, burping brawling boy.

    Replies: @TGGP, @James J. O'Meara, @Colin Wright, @Pericles, @Henry's Cat, @(((They))) Live

    Page at least was never in a heterosexual marriage, unlike so many of the Type 2s Steve is discussing (as well as Vanderwerff).

  • Never anybody from the middle range of mild-mannered males. Nobody has ever heard of a nice liberal NPR announcer with an indoor-voice announcing he was now a woman.

    Why do you keep ignoring the example of Todd (now Emily) Vanderwerff? The one who accused Matthew Yglesias of making Vox “unsafe” by signing that open letter on free speech?

    • Replies: @Cloudbuster
    @TGGP

    Even Emily Vanderwerff prefers not to think about Todd Vanderwerff.

    I have never read something by a transgender person that didn't sound like it was read from the notes of a therapist. Vanderwerff sure didn't change my streak:

    https://www.vox.com/culture/2019/6/3/18647615/coming-out-transgender-handmaids-tale-emily-todd-vanderwerff

    Replies: @James O'Meara

    , @BenKenobi
    @TGGP

    When this first happened and I read a headline that said "AV Club writer comes out as trans" I was hoping it was Nathan Rabin. Seriously, f*ck that guy. He belongs in the 9th circle of Hell.

    Replies: @TGGP

  • In Tablet, neo-New Dealer Michael Lind offers an interesting theory of the FDR coalition and analogy to the Great Awokening as the new Establishment form of gentility: The Revenge of the Yankees How Social Gospel became Social Justice BY MICHAEL LIND NOVEMBER 15, 2020 Is America disintegrating into anarchy and civil war among races, religions,...
  • I had not realized The Ordeal of Civility was available via the Internet Archive. My local library has a copy, but it can’t be checked out, and I certainly don’t intend to sit down there for a long read now.

    • Replies: @Dan Hayes
    @TGGP

    Just one of the many benefits of reading the UR!😎

    , @Pheasant
    @TGGP

    Good book but written in tortuosly difficult jargon.

    Got through it once and never intend to revisit it.

    , @Uncle Remus
    @TGGP

    Copies of the Ordeal of Civility are readily found on out of print book sites such as ABE Books.

  • The Queen's Gambit on Netflix is a fictional TV miniseries about a girl in an orphanage in postwar America who, somehow, develops herself into a Bobby Fischer-like chess prodigy. From a nature-nurture perspective, the premise sounds implausible. The one great woman chess player, Judit Polgar (a solid world top ten player for a number of...
  • Yeah, the series comes down on the side of nature. The protagonist’s birth mother is a math PhD who went nuts and committed suicide, so as an orphan child she’s smarter than her peers and finishes her work in every class quickly enough to wander around and discover the janitor playing chess against himself. I suppose the fact that it was chess she discovered rather than some other quasi-mathematical topic to devote her substantial spare mental energy was arbitrary. The question is raised as to whether she might also have inherited her mother’s mental problems, but she seems to have gotten luckier on that trait.

    • Replies: @El Dato
    @TGGP

    Tow interesting questions are raised hereby:

    1)

    While some math prodigies were a bit deficient in human-interaction skills, are there any which commited suicide? They seem to be rare.

    Wikipedia does not deliver. There are 22 entries, but

    - Turing doesn't count, as his death is not a confirmed suicide, could have been an accident.
    - Walter Pitts is missing, basically he drank himself to death (he had a tough childhood).

    Others committed suicide to escape illness (Ramaujan) or Nazi camps (Hausdorff), these are different cases.

    2)


    I suppose the fact that it was chess she discovered rather than some other quasi-mathematical topic.
     
    Is chess quasi-mathematical? It is definitely both algorithmical and about pattern-matching, but would you expect a chess player to write a book about the consistency of the real number axioms?
    , @Badger Down
    @TGGP

    It's fiction! The "fact that it was chess" wasn't arbitrary at all. The writer thought it would make a better tale.

    , @Steve Sailer
    @TGGP

    Thanks.

    How many super high achieving women have come out of random backgrounds? My vague impression is that most have been the daughters of high achieving men.

    Replies: @Percy Gryce, @stillCARealist

  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: Read the whole thing there. Also, it's time for the second iSteve fundraising drive of 2020. Readers were most generous back in July, but now there are more bills to pay. Large or small, I find each donation to be a personal message of encouragement to keep doing...
  • @Travis
    @TGGP

    While it does include some Pokémon points for women and some select minorities which helps it gain more followers, it is quite clear who is at the top. Identity politics has a clear hierarchy which may become cause some division in a short time. Blackness will always trump gender, Blacks will always be above Mexicans in the woke hierarchy. People like George Zimmerman will be denied racial points and classified as white when it suits their agenda.

    Replies: @TGGP

    I recall that earlier Steve noted gays trumped blacks in cases like that Scrubs actor fired for a slur.

    • Replies: @njguy73
    @TGGP

    It was Isaiah Washington from Grey's Anatomy, not Donald Faison from Scrubs. Honest mistake.

    , @dfordoom
    @TGGP


    I recall that earlier Steve noted gays trumped blacks in cases like that Scrubs actor fired for a slur.
     
    He's correct. Gays trump blacks. And trannies trump gays.

    The fact that the LGBT crowd dominates the Coalition of the Fringes is significant. It allows white liberals to stay in charge.

    Replies: @The Wild Geese Howard

  • “Wokism” includes a racial element, which is particularly salient now, but it’s not just that. It’s got a whole theory of “intersectionality” which permits white people to claim pokemon points as well and racial minorities who run afoul of it to get cancelled. You can’t explain how it’s tied in to “World War T” if it’s just race.

    • Agree: dfordoom
    • Replies: @Travis
    @TGGP

    While it does include some Pokémon points for women and some select minorities which helps it gain more followers, it is quite clear who is at the top. Identity politics has a clear hierarchy which may become cause some division in a short time. Blackness will always trump gender, Blacks will always be above Mexicans in the woke hierarchy. People like George Zimmerman will be denied racial points and classified as white when it suits their agenda.

    Replies: @TGGP

  • From Joe Biden's Town Hall transcript on how to reform the police: Why not just shoot the knife or gun out of the bad guy's hand like on the TV Westerns that Joe avidly watched in 1955? From TV Tropes: Joe has been expounding upon his "shoot them in the leg" reform for months on...
  • You have to justify every round

    Given the very large numbers of rounds fired in numerous incidents, I find that particular bit hard to believe. “Shoot until the threat is neutralized” seems to be the thinking, and once the shooting starts there’s no need to rationalize an additional bullet.

    • Replies: @Twinkie
    @TGGP


    Given the very large numbers of rounds fired in numerous incidents, I find that particular bit hard to believe.
     
    Every round discharged by an LEO has to be accounted for after action.
  • My brain is too old and tired to follow all the ins-and-outs of Eastern European spy-vs-spy action, but the New York Post is headlining a scoop about apparent nefarious activities First Son (Presumptive) Hunter Biden has been up to in Ukraine. Here's what Twitter replies each time I try to tweet out the current cover...
  • Steve, why are you tweeting out links you haven’t even read? I suppose twitter has lower standards than your blog, but one would hope you’re engaging in at least a minimum of curation.

    • Thanks: Corvinus
  • An interesting accompaniment to Nathan Cofnas’s 2018 attempted debunking of Kevin MacDonald’s work on Jews was the subtle resurfacing of Steven Pinker’s claim that a more plausible theory of the Jewish historical experience can be found in “Thomas Sowell’s convincing analysis of ‘middleman minorities’ such as the Jews, presented in his magisterial study of migration,...
  • Israel is the largest producer and host of international online gambling sites

    The linked article does not say that. The headline is “Some of The World’s Largest iGaming Firms Are From Israel”, and it doesn’t bother to compare any other countries’ producing/hosting of such sites or say which is the largest. It says Israel has a “significant share”, but doesn’t put a number on that. The article in turn cites a source which has succumbed to linkrot, but it is accessible via the internet archive, and a live version can be found elsewhere (I think the embassy may have lifted it while only crediting the author for the photos):
    https://venturebeat.com/2015/10/23/the-deanbeat-two-decades-of-work-and-1b-in-sales-put-israels-game-industry-on-the-global-map/
    That doesn’t claim they are the “largest” either, instead making the more modest claim that they’ve had some recent (though perhaps tenuous) success and now have a “disproportionate” share. Since no actual numbers comparing other countries has been provided, it could well be possible that Israel is the largest, although I suspect the articles would have said that if it could be established.

  • Like Wikipedia, the New York Times keeps a list of COVID fatalities in its continuing "Those We've Lost" feature. Wikipedia's metric for inclusion is whether the victim had already had a Wikipedia page, while the NYT picks people for its own reasons, including that they are notable for how young they died. So the latter...
  • I expect they believe they have little power to get people to lose weight, given how difficult many who try find it. There are numerous other causes which may have even less hope for success that the media could take on, but they might find it harder to delude themselves about this. They might even have some personal experience in failing to lose weight, although being overweight is now correlated with being lower-class.

    • Agree: epebble
    • Replies: @Chrisnonymous
    @TGGP

    It's complicated by the interaction of media and medical experts. I doubt many in the media are knowledgeable, humble, and thoughtful enough to believe their pronouncements are not effective for people. However, many medical experts are. (In fact, I have been told this directly by a doctor who said I shouldn't bother trying to lose weight.) Since media mostly repeat what they're told by medical experts, they are inadvertently adopting the attitude you suggest.

    For the medical community, there are other complicating factors. For example, focusing on weight loss would put the lie (or at least appear to) to many of the other ideas being promoted such as the necessity of a vaccine before going back to work or the importance of community-wide lockdowns. to

    This is related to the arrogance problem. For example, I was pointing out that the UK's ICU patients were all fat and that Japan has a super-low BMI back in February or March, but I was derided as a flu-truther. Now, those who accused me have to eat their hat to promote weight loss. On a nation-wide scale, I think this kind of backtracking is preventing people from changing course.

    There is also the problem of advice. In a lockdown, everyone could have adopted intermittent fasting protocols much more easily than during their normal lives and anaerobic routines much more easily than jogging or exercise machines, but this is still not the medical community standards.

    But I think the biggest factor stopping weight loss advice was Trump, or rather TDS. The politics of masks vs no-masks and lockdown vs no-lockdown and HCQ vs no-HCQ all pushed out real discussion, which should always include cooperative brainstorming and listening to minority reports rather just taking sides. In this sense, blue-state and blue-blood Americans are largely responsible for creating a response that was less useful than it could have been.

    By the way, Steve,

    It's Tuesday, so if you're probing us for ideas to put into your next TakiMag article, I want to tell you I have been working on my own article on the theme of this missed pandemic opportunity. I'm not telling you to take credit or stop you but so I'm not accused of drinking your miljshake or not attributing you should I be published.

  • From the New York Post: It comes just a year after his organization, Not This Time, was paid $100,000 to sponsor a speaker series that was called “Conversations with the Streets.” Taylor led one of the first rallies in Seattle after the police-custody death of George Floyd, the Seattle Times said. He was later accused...
  • @ogunsiron
    @TGGP

    Last i heard it was NOT a "no knock raid ". That changes a lot about how i feel about that case.

    Replies: @TGGP

    The warrant was for a no-knock raid. They are currently claiming they did knock, but there are no recordings of them doing so and the surviving person in the house denies that’s the case.

  • @Handle
    @TGGP

    What happened to Taylor was tragic, however, it's worth noting that the police insisted since the incident back in March that they (1) did not go to the 'wrong' apartment - her name was on the warrant, or (2) execute the warrant in "no knock" fashion, as the Kentucky AG said, the evidence from cameras and a neighbor eye witness is that they knocked and announced their presence before they were fired upon. It's getting shot at from inside which led to their firing back in self defense and why they were not even indicted like ham sandwiches. Ironically and sadly, it is also the kind of messed up thing that happens and which in the attempt to avoid it is used to justify not knocking and announcing first.

    The family made both false claims, e.g., "thought they were being robbed", and the media has run with this agitprop for six months despite the facts being available and easily verifiable the whole time, and indeed they are still repeating them.

    Replies: @Charles St. Charles, @CCZ, @Redneck farmer, @wren, @Hippopotamusdrome, @Anonymous, @bruce county, @TGGP

    What cameras? My understanding is that the officers involved weren’t wearing bodycams, and no camera footage was shown in court. As for the neighbor:
    https://twitter.com/radleybalko/status/1308924095048933377

  • @Alden
    @Whiskey

    Taylor hadn’t worked as an EMT for a couple years. She worked with the boyfriend. He’s responsible for her being shot.

    Note; if you live with a felon with outstanding warrants , don’t sleep in his bedroom, never know when he’ll start shooting at police.

    Replies: @TGGP

    My understanding is that he legally owned a gun, which you generally can’t do with a felony conviction.

    • Replies: @Alden
    @TGGP

    Whatever the legal status of the gun, boyfriend shouldn’t have shot at police. It never ends well.

  • @Whiskey
    @TGGP

    Taylor was living large with her drug dealer live in boyfriend. There was a warrant issued and the cops announced themselves. Boyfriend shot it out with the cops keeping it real. She got shot.

    He was trash. She was trash.

    Replies: @El Dato, @Alden, @Jus' Sayin'..., @Anon, @TGGP, @Anonymous

    My understanding is that no drugs were found there. The boyfriend legally owned a gun, which you generally can’t do with a felony conviction.

  • For those who want to read all of Mau-Mauing the Flak Catchers, I host it here:
    http://teageegeepea.tripod.com/maumau.html

    While I have learned in recent years how much worse the alternative to “overpolicing” can be, existing policing still seems needlessly harmful a good deal of the time, and the Breonna Taylor case in the news today would seem to be an example.

    • Replies: @Whiskey
    @TGGP

    Taylor was living large with her drug dealer live in boyfriend. There was a warrant issued and the cops announced themselves. Boyfriend shot it out with the cops keeping it real. She got shot.

    He was trash. She was trash.

    Replies: @El Dato, @Alden, @Jus' Sayin'..., @Anon, @TGGP, @Anonymous

    , @Handle
    @TGGP

    What happened to Taylor was tragic, however, it's worth noting that the police insisted since the incident back in March that they (1) did not go to the 'wrong' apartment - her name was on the warrant, or (2) execute the warrant in "no knock" fashion, as the Kentucky AG said, the evidence from cameras and a neighbor eye witness is that they knocked and announced their presence before they were fired upon. It's getting shot at from inside which led to their firing back in self defense and why they were not even indicted like ham sandwiches. Ironically and sadly, it is also the kind of messed up thing that happens and which in the attempt to avoid it is used to justify not knocking and announcing first.

    The family made both false claims, e.g., "thought they were being robbed", and the media has run with this agitprop for six months despite the facts being available and easily verifiable the whole time, and indeed they are still repeating them.

    Replies: @Charles St. Charles, @CCZ, @Redneck farmer, @wren, @Hippopotamusdrome, @Anonymous, @bruce county, @TGGP

    , @PiltdownMan
    @TGGP

    https://i.imgur.com/dMGnOlH.jpg

    Bruce Gilden - Fifth Avenue, 1975.

    Replies: @Mike Pierson, Davenport Rector, Midfielder, @Reg Cæsar, @anon

    , @PhysicistDave
    @TGGP

    TGGP wrote:


    While I have learned in recent years how much worse the alternative to “overpolicing” can be, existing policing still seems needlessly harmful a good deal of the time, and the Breonna Taylor case in the news today would seem to be an example.
     
    The whole "War on Drugs" is a tragic exercise in absurdity.

    I have never tried illegal drugs, and I don't think it is wise for anyone to do so.

    However, a very large number of people -- and an awful lot of white people (including Hunter Biden) -- are determined to use drugs. We're not going to stop it as long as so many people are so determined to do it.

    So,, yeah, the whole mess with Breonna Taylor should never have happened.

    That being said...

    The absurdity of the War on Drugs is not the fault of low-level cops. It is the fault of legislators and, more broadly, the hypocrisy of society at large.

    And, critically, Taylor's moronic boyfriend shot at cops!

    This is, at best, terminal stupidity.

    She should not have died, but there is plenty of blame to go around. And very little of it attaches to the cops.

    Replies: @Anonymous, @J.Ross

    , @ogunsiron
    @TGGP

    Last i heard it was NOT a "no knock raid ". That changes a lot about how i feel about that case.

    Replies: @TGGP

  • First there was Jessica Krug, then CV "They" Vitolo-Haddad, and today there is Satchuel "They" Cole. These white women activists just don't get that while transgenderism is practically the coolest, most sacred identity imaginable in 2020, transracialism is Worse Than Hitler. From the Indianapolis Star: And if you dare joke about how Cole is a...
  • Dylan Matthews is right that a grad student isn’t really notable enough to get their own story. She should instead be an addendum to one of the higher profile frauds.

  • As others have said, Biden comes across here like a gangster working a protection racket on a speakeasy. After all, the vast majority of politics-influenced violence in the U.S. since Memorial Day has been committed by people who are anti-Trump. And because Biden is the official/nominal leader of anti-Trump forces, his threatening Four More Years...
  • It’s completely normal for a politician running against an incumbent to associate anything bad happening with said incumbent. Trump himself did it when he was in that position. And since Trump hasn’t managed to stop the rioting, he can’t very well claim things will get better as soon as he’s elected. I do think it’s possible that rioters will just get bored later, but that doesn’t make for an effective campaign argument.

    Is the problem with Democratic politicians or their constituents? Yglesias recently pointed out that the few Republican mayors of cities large enough to experience unrest haven’t done a better job, and Cochran in response merely noted that in small towns like the one he grew up in it would have been unthinkable for his neighbors to behave in such a way.

    • Replies: @William Badwhite
    @TGGP


    Is the problem with Democratic politicians or their constituents?...the few Republican mayors of cities large enough to experience unrest haven’t done a better job,
     
    Just off the top of my head: Miami and San Diego. Both have Republican mayors, neither have had rioting. Miami is run by Cubans that never got the White Guilt Memo and don't tolerate black crime and dysfunction outside of the black areas (Liberty City, Overtown); while in San Diego the mayor specifically told the police to aggressively deal with any rioting and that they would be backed by his administration 100%.
    , @Ben tillman
    @TGGP

    What are you talking about? There is no unrest in Oklahoma City or Salt Lake City or any other city with a Republican mayor.

  • Here it is August and Keith Ellison's Minnesota office was still keeping the bodycam footage from the cops bottled up. But now the Daily Mail has got their hands on some of it. The amount of fentanyl in George Floyd's system wasn't enough to always kill him, but it was definitely in the range where...
  • @Altai
    And since I know Steve loves the idea that bodycams were introduced to record all the epic police brutality but instead are helping cops get exonerated.

    2019 saw the release of a film whose premise is an entertaining one, black female cop catches corrupt white cops executing black man, one of them tries to kill her but she escapes with the whole event on her bodycam. But since the footage gets taped over every 12 hours, she has to evade both the cops and the black gangs (Who are in league with the corrupt cops) in a black ghetto where she is seen as the enemy in her attempt to get the footage uploaded.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QCfSeVCr7ng

    Replies: @TGGP

    In Chicago we actually did have police killing people for gangsters. Some of it stemmed from when the Housing Authority had their own police force (created out of perceived neglect from CPD), which was later incorporated back into CPD.
    https://theintercept.com/series/code-of-silence/

  • @SimpleSong
    My armchair analysis of the situation:

    While he did have fentanyl in his system, this was probably not a fentanyl overdose based on the way he was behaving. While he did have a large amount of fentanyl in his bloodstream, people who regularly use opioids rapidly develop tolerance and thus a serum level that would be a lethal dose in a normal person can be perfectly tolerable in a habitual user. People who overdose on fentanyl don't get agitated like Floyd appearas to, quite the opposite, they get sleepy, breathing slows, then stops, then they die. They don't have air hunger; in fact the problem with fentanyl is that it takes away air hunger. So someone complaining that they can't breathe is not consistent with a fentanyl overdose--people overdosing on fentanyl don't care if they can't breathe, and that's the problem.

    However the fact that he was complaining that he couldn't breathe early during the arrest suggests that he was having some other medical event at the time of arrest. This could have been any number of things, some of which can be detected on autopsy (heart attack, pulmonary embolism), some of which cannot (arrhythmia, severe bronchospasm.) Furthermore, these may have been caused by some of the other drugs found in his system (PCP I believe was found?), they may have been exacerbated by it, they may have just happened independently. It's pretty much impossible to know for certain.

    If an individual is having some sort of medical event that causes shortness of breath, the restraint techniques used by the police would almost certainly make the situation worse. Generally you want somebody sitting up so that their weight is off the diaphragm and they can breathe as deeply as possible. However they were clearly not choking him as he could speak, so the trachea wasn't obstructed. Regardless, it certainly made the situation worse.

    However from the police's perspective, it's difficult to know whether this guy really is having a cardiopulmonary issue or whether he's just faking to try to get out of being arrested. Even if they had training, they don't really have the equipment to figure this stuff out.

    Replies: @415 reasons, @TGGP, @Alden, @Art Deco, @Bozo the Clown

    So it sounds like if they’d kept him sitting in the cop car, rather than letting him out to lie down as he requested, he might have had better odds of surviving?

    • Replies: @SimpleSong
    @TGGP

    Might have changed it a bit but only very slightly. Positioning can help a little bit or hurt a little bit but you have to address the underlying medical issue. The restraint hold that was used is definitely not great for somebody who is having some sort of cardiopulmonary event, but, what are you to do when a criminal is combative and you don't even know if they are having a medical issue, you're not even trained to handle this stuff? It's simply a bad situation.

  • TGGP says: • Website
    @Anonymous
    @TGGP


    This video is just sad. It’s not a case of some arrogant punk who thinks “I don’t feel like getting arrested today”. It’s someone freaking out.
     
    Or it’s someone with a criminal history, probation status, or outstanding warrants acting with knowledge that arrest is going to lead to undesired consequences. If he was just “freaking out,” where did he come up with the wits to repeatedly lie to the police to try to get out of the arrest?

    Replies: @TGGP, @Percy Gryce

    I don’t see much evidence of him having his wits available. The stuff he’s saying wouldn’t get him out of any arrest. The closest he comes to even attempting that is saying “I ain’t like that”, although it was unclear what specifically he was denying there. At best he might have gotten an ambulance to arrive sooner, which would just result in him being handcuffed to a hospital bed and transferred to jail later.

    • Replies: @gutta percha
    @TGGP

    "The stuff he’s saying wouldn’t get him out of any arrest. "

    And yet in the hundreds of arrest bodycam videos online, you'll see plenty of people bleat and lie and spin BS distractions, thinking they can talk their way out of arrest. It's actually pretty common; seems to happen regardless of race of arrestee. I'm sure that cops get tired of hearing it so often.

    A great example is Rayshard Brooks. He improvised a full half-hour of continuous, pure, dense verbal bullsh!t, before he decided to fight the all-too-patient cops. It's exhausting and maddening to listen to.

    Replies: @Mr McKenna

  • This video is just sad. It’s not a case of some arrogant punk who thinks “I don’t feel like getting arrested today”. It’s someone freaking out.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    @TGGP


    This video is just sad. It’s not a case of some arrogant punk who thinks “I don’t feel like getting arrested today”. It’s someone freaking out.
     
    Or it’s someone with a criminal history, probation status, or outstanding warrants acting with knowledge that arrest is going to lead to undesired consequences. If he was just “freaking out,” where did he come up with the wits to repeatedly lie to the police to try to get out of the arrest?

    Replies: @TGGP, @Percy Gryce

    , @Cato
    @TGGP


    It’s not a case of some arrogant punk who thinks “I don’t feel like getting arrested today”. It’s someone freaking out.
     
    Well, yes, he was freaking out. I had a friend who was doing Angel Dust, like a lot of us in 1975. The cops tried to talk to him, and ended up shooting him. He was white. Shit happens all the time. So the real question here is not why Saint George freaked out,... but why the whole fucking world freaked out?

    Replies: @Neuday

  • From my new Taki's Magazine column: Read the whole thing there.
  • TGGP says: • Website
    @Alden
    @TGGP

    Been reading the ADL AJC websites again?

    Must be fund raising season. Give money so ADL AJC can protect you from the Cossacks and country club admissions committees.

    Whine whine whine. I live in a Jewish neighborhood. You should see the local library. I think half the books are about Jewish suffering.

    As for murdered young black men, please explain why is it a hate crime when young black thugs kill other young black thugs ?

    Knowing how jews operate and all about their neighborhood patrols, I don’t believe a word about how NYC Jews are victims of hate crimes.
    Victims of common street crimes car theft, robbery by black and brown criminals I believe

    The reason so many New Yorkers are victims of crime is that for the last hundred years NYC and the majority of Jews in this country have spent enormous time and money changing our criminal justice system to be pro criminal and anti victim.

    As a whole, American jews and the official organizations are pro black and pro criminal anti White anti law enforcement and anti victims of crimes.

    If visible Orthodox Jews are getting beat up by organized Jewry’s dearly beloved black criminals whose fault is that? Other Jews.

    Replies: @J.Ross, @TGGP

    No, I don’t think I’ve been to their website directly, just stats founds in mainstream publications.

    I didn’t say typical intraracial violence was a “hate crime”. The very point I was making was that Jews could be the main target of hate crimes yet overall at a lower risk of crime because “hate crimes” are such a tiny percentage of crimes. My impression is that even when these Orthodox Jews are being violently assaulted it’s rarely lethal (admittedly, that was back when the NYPD was successfully inhibiting typical knuckleheads from carrying guns).

    And I would like to devote some more space to the effectiveness of the NYPD. You talk about “so many New Yorkers” being victims of crime, and perhaps that’s becoming more the case now (although it also should be noted that none of the people shot recently were white and I don’t think asian either) and it was definitely the case in the past, but for a while NY really had it together. And I was arguing recently with someone about how rioting has predictably increased the homicide, resulting in more loss of “black lives” than can be reasonably attributed to police (particularly in NY, where the cops shoot people less often than the national average), and they were inclined to throw up their hands about how any effective law enforcement must infringe on civil rights. The NYPD had shown for years that effective law enforcement can result in less crime, less incarceration and even fewer arrests once the crime rate drops sufficiently. When NYers get fed up with crime again, they could return to that. And while other cities might not have the budget to afford the same ratio of officers to civilians, most could move in that direction, and considering the high costs of crime it would be worth the pay for more officers.

    • Replies: @Black-hole creator
    @TGGP

    A. Why should the rest of the country care about some medieval sect largely self-segregated in NYC ? I don't. I do care about who controls the media and the narrative, and more importantly who and how controls the jobs and the money.
    B. Every crime is a hate crime. If you disagree, please give me an example of a love crime.

  • TGGP says: • Website

    Something you could have mentioned but didn’t: Jews are the group most targeted for hate crimes in the U.S. Specifically, visibly Jewish Orthodox types in the greater NY area (ulta-Orthodox Jews also form some of the most officially “impoverished” communities, which per Scott Sumner shows how misleading poverty statistics are). This can be the case even if they’re less likely to be attacked compared to the general population overall because hate crimes are such a small fraction of total crimes. In terms of total crimes, young black males with less than a highschool education would be the most likely to be victimized, which would be in accord with “privilege” rankings except for particularly stupid “intersectional” ones which simply stack race and sex on top of each other rather than letting them interact as relevant for the outcome of interest.

    • Disagree: Alden
    • Replies: @Alden
    @TGGP

    Been reading the ADL AJC websites again?

    Must be fund raising season. Give money so ADL AJC can protect you from the Cossacks and country club admissions committees.

    Whine whine whine. I live in a Jewish neighborhood. You should see the local library. I think half the books are about Jewish suffering.

    As for murdered young black men, please explain why is it a hate crime when young black thugs kill other young black thugs ?

    Knowing how jews operate and all about their neighborhood patrols, I don’t believe a word about how NYC Jews are victims of hate crimes.
    Victims of common street crimes car theft, robbery by black and brown criminals I believe

    The reason so many New Yorkers are victims of crime is that for the last hundred years NYC and the majority of Jews in this country have spent enormous time and money changing our criminal justice system to be pro criminal and anti victim.

    As a whole, American jews and the official organizations are pro black and pro criminal anti White anti law enforcement and anti victims of crimes.

    If visible Orthodox Jews are getting beat up by organized Jewry’s dearly beloved black criminals whose fault is that? Other Jews.

    Replies: @J.Ross, @TGGP

    , @jon
    @TGGP

    OK, Uncle Leo: https://youtu.be/TYZBKqemQrU

  • Here's an article from The Wire in India on a topic I've wondered about for years but never seen anything about: America importing India's caste system. Because no white Christian American has ever been guilty of caste discrimination -- none of us understand it -- the U.S. media has shown zero interest in the topic...
  • TGGP says: • Website

    “It would seem to me that caste discrimination is religious, racial, and ethnic discrimination.”
    Language has long been one of the defining features of an ethnic group, but different castes speak the same language. The cross-cutting cleavages of caste and language has been given as the reason that the various parts of India didn’t develop into nation states. Pakistan is officially caste free due to being the country for Muslims, but it was initially dominated by Urdu-speaking Mohajirs who weren’t actually from any of the Pakistani states but instead from northern India. Eventually they ticked off the Bengali speakers in East Pakistan enough that they actually did split off to form a Bengali-speaking nation state, but an emphasis on Islam has so far been enough to keep the remaining components of West Pakistan united.

  • iSteve commenter Rapparee points to this 1912 recording:
  • I blogged about it over a decade ago. And I still haven’t gotten around to reading “The Ordeal of Civility”.

  • Matthew Yglesias, a junior co-founder of Vox, is the author of the upcoming book One Billion Americans: The Case for Thinking Bigger, which I look forward to writing a review of. Ezra Klein, the senior co-founder of Vox, is the author of Why We're Polarized, which I reviewed in Taki's Magazine under the title "The...
  • Ezra responds to that characterization here:
    https://twitter.com/ezraklein/status/1280960056733782018

    • Replies: @Thea
    @TGGP

    Well that is a bit surprising. Usually he plays cat and mouse but here he is clearly saying he disagrees with the premise of free speech.

    , @vhrm
    @TGGP

    Looking it up... "subtweet" i guess originally meant posting about someone without using their @username so that they probably wouldn't know about it. Here i guess it's more broadly "talking about someone behind their back"?

    Replies: @Barnard

    , @Clifford Brown
    @TGGP

    Team Yglesias all the way.

    https://s2.freebeacon.com/up/2014/10/yglesias_lg.jpg

    Which Latino Jewish man is higher on the Progressive Stack? Or is it better to be lower on the Progressive Stack? Son of Brazilian immigrant Klein or grandson of Cuban immigrant Yglesias? Yglesias' grandfather was prominent in the Communist Party (back when it sort of mattered). Yglesias grew up on the Upper West Side when it still had some edge. Klein grew up in ever pleasant Irvine, California, which never really had any edge. Looks like Yglesias wins the progressive stack comparison.

    As painful as it sounds, we must stand by Brother Yglesias in his battle with Boss Klein. Yglesias' autistic commitment to truth (even when he is completely wrong) is far preferable to the Klein's more socially aware commitment to power.

    This is not to let Yglesias of the hook. Yglesias posted on Twitter about his cozy cabin up in Maine which he loves dearly. Purchased by his Communist Party grandfather, Yglesias is obsessed with pointing out that it is indeed an actual cabin, and not some gauche sprawling summer estate.

    https://twitter.com/mattyglesias/status/1280826272852201472

    He is not wrong, the cabin looks quite charming and cozy, but one has to wonder what will the status of excluded, charming, cozy, wooded Maine cabins be if Yglesias achieves his main autistic policy objective of One Billion Americans.

    https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/matthew-yglesias/one-billion-americans/

    Seems like there might be a contradiction.

    Replies: @anon, @Che Blutarsky, @Kratoklastes, @bomag

    , @Not My Economy
    @TGGP

    Big flex

    (Privately) "I can end you at any moment"

    (Publicly) "Haha, we're great friends bro I would never"

    , @Anonymous
    @TGGP

    Without free speech you don’t have a real democracy. We were all taught this in school. And it’s true. Now here is Ezra Klein saying that defending free speech is wrong. Ezra Klein does not think free speech is a good thing.

    What does this tell you about the kind of America Ezra Klein wants?

  • David Kennedy, professor of criminal justice at John Jay College, argues that over 80% of homicides among black gang members aren't driven by the logic of the drug trade: "it's street code nonsense, honor culture." As an example, he points to a decade long beef with dozens of homicides in Hunters Point when he was...
  • TGGP says:

    Peter Moskos, who actually was a Baltimore cop for a while, said that basically all the homicides he dealt with stemmed from the drug trade (though that did include stupid beefing). That’s one guys view, but another thing worth considering is the impact on international homicide rates of access to US drug markets. That’s why latin America is more homicidal than Africa.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @TGGP

    My vague impression is that Mexico got a lot more homicidal after Mexico took the cocaine traffic away from Colombia in the early 1990s, but who knows how reliable old Mexican crime stats are. Driving around Mexico in the 1960s to 1980s I didn't see a lot of guns, but by the 1990s there were guys with heavy firepower standing around everywhere, so I stopped going to Mexico.

    There are also big differences in published murder rates in Central American countries, with leftist-run Nicaragua being much lower than, say, rightist-run Honduras. But, once again, who knows about Central American crime stats?

    Replies: @Skylark Thibedeau, @Voltarde, @al-Gharaniq, @Not Raul, @syonredux

  • From the Los Angeles Times opinion page: Op-Ed: Why California needs affirmative action more than ever By JENNIFER LEE Jennifer Lee is a professor of sociology at Columbia University and president of the Eastern Sociological Society. JUNE 26, 20203 AM In November, a new generation of California voters will have the opportunity to restore affirmative...
  • TGGP says: • Website

    I’m struck by how Asians feel entitled to argue in public in the Los Angeles Times about Is It Good for the Asians?

    It’s not that odd. It’s commonly argued that patriarchy is actually bad for men, so feminism is good, and that racism is bad for whites, so anti-racism is good (Scott Alexander had discussed the former as part of a motte-and-bailey argument, libertarian economists used to argue the latter when Jim Crow was in effect). She’s arguing against opponents of her position who are grounding their opposition in a form of self-interest, so it’s natural to argue against that. I didn’t see any evidence in those excerpts that Asians had ever actually benefited from affirmative action, but then I don’t think she actually believes that part of her argument.

    More recent immigrants may be […] less likely to experience the effects of systematic discrimination.

    So recent immigrants are privileged relative to their U.S born offspring? That seems extremely counter-intuitive to me.

    • Agree: Twinkie
  • How many members of the Forbes 400 owe the majority of their wealth to slavery? The oldest Forbes 400 fortune I know of offhand is the Hearsts', which goes back to the Nevada silver strike of 1859. Then the Hearsts profited from more big mining strikes in the late 19th Century. The DuPonts are too...
  • @JohnnyWalker123
    Weren't the slave fortunes generally destroyed during the Civil War?

    A lot of the slave-owning families died during the war or faced economic devastation. So for a slave fortune to exist, a family would have had to avoid destitution during this era.

    My guess is that this was pretty rare.

    Even if a family somehow kept their money, I'm not sure if they would've been able to grow their fortune. White Southern planters saw themselves as aristocrats, not merchants, entrepreneurs, or financiers.

    There was a group of people who might've held onto their wealth.

    Jews.

    Some German Jews were cotton traders or financiers in the Old South. I wouldn't be surprised if during the war, they sold off their holdings for gold and sent their wealth overseas. As a mercantile minority with global business networks, they would've been more economically agile than the more rooted White Southern planters.

    Replies: @Chris Mallory, @Lot, @TGGP, @VinnyVette

    The sons of slaveholding families married into families that had the most non-slaveholding wealth, and thus got back up near the top of the wealth distribution:
    https://voxeu.org/article/intergenerational-effects-large-wealth-shock

    • Replies: @JohnnyWalker123
    @TGGP

    Interesting. I did not know that.

    Thanks for the link.

  • From iSteve commenter JSQ: For example, as I've been pointing out for years, almost all of the time when the national media falls for a hate hoax, such as Jussie Smollett's, the local cops keep their wits about them. That kind of sensible skepticism must end.
  • I think that unrealistic hope and optimism has a lot to do with this. People are assuming that cops and the criminal justice system are to blame for a lot of the bad things that happen to black people. Remove them and the bad things go away too.

    Everything the refund the police people say isn’t wrong. Getting more mental health professionals to deal with the crazy people instead of the police is not a bad idea.

    But overall the people who want to eliminate the police aren’t facing facts. They don’t like the facts and want to avoid them by substituting wishful thinking for real thinking.

    I find it hard to believe that many places will do more than a limited reallocation of funds and replacement of police with other personnel, if they even go that far. Wholesale radical experiments with public safety don’t seem very popular.

    • Agree: Peter Johnson, JosephD, TGGP
    • Replies: @JosephD
    @notsaying

    I agreed with most of the protesters being deluded, but had qualms about the last line:


    Wholesale radical experiments with public safety don’t seem very popular.
     
    San Francisco has experimented strongly with with "deemphasizing" property crimes. NYC has stepped down on police measures as well. I see several places doing more radical experimentation and the consequent increases in crime.
    , @Chrisnonymous
    @notsaying

    I've seen a video of a police shooting of a mentally ill boy that could have clearly been prevented by the police just not acting so "police-y" so it's easy to imagine how you improve things. However, according to the NYPD, they were tasked with mental health calls because other agencies failed to deal with them adequately, and I can believe that.

    Replies: @Buffalo Joe

    , @Mr. Anon
    @notsaying


    I find it hard to believe that many places will do more than a limited reallocation of funds and replacement of police with other personnel, if they even go that far. Wholesale radical experiments with public safety don’t seem very popular.
     
    Really?

    I mean.................

    Really?

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_pandemic_lockdowns
  • From the Minneapolis Star-Tribune: Reminds me of the anti-Chinese riots on Guadalcanal in 2006. After a night of looting, the locals showed up the next afternoon at their favorite stores, which they had just trashed and burned down, to buy their evening dinner. They were much befuddled by the fact that the stores no longer...
  • TGGP says: • Website

    I’ve been staying in as much as possible since my employer shifted to having us work from home, only going out for groceries once a week. So it was just today that I saw my usual grocery store is boarded up, presumably due to last weekend’s riot. The next closest one was a Whole Foods, an imperfect substitute. I guess next week I’ll check if the nearby asian grocery is open.

  • In 2002, the great political scientist James Q. Wilson wrote a book chapter summing up a lifetime of studying the vexed issue of crime and race: A central problem—perhaps the central problem—in improving the relationship between white and black Americans is the difference in racial crime rates. No matter how innocent or guilty a stranger...
  • TGGP says: • Website
    @TGGP

    This disparity is not new; it has existed for well over a century. When historian Roger Lane studied murder rates in Philadelphia, he found that since 1839 the black rate has been much higher than the white rate.
     
    When I read William Stuntz' "The Collapse of American Criminal Justice", he said that while the black rate has been higher in recent times (I think since the Great Migration), in the 19th century the white rate was higher in both north & south. His citation was to Randolph Roth's "American Homicide". Stuntz compared the then largely-rural black population moving to cities and increasing their crime rates to the Irish immigrants, whose home counties in Ireland had relatively low rates despite the same people being quite criminal once they moved to U.S cities.

    Replies: @TGGP, @Anon

    I hadn’t noted the page number to Roth’s book when I read Stuntz, so I looked up the citation via Google Books:

    Roth notes that the end of the nineteenth century saw southern homicide rates surpass those in the Southwest, and saw a sharp rise in black homicide. See Roth, American Homicide, 387. The latter phenomenon happened in the North as well (ibid., 194-96, 387). Before the last years of the nineteenth century, whites were the more homicidal group. See, for example, the lower black homicide rate pre-1890 (ibid., 398).

    • Replies: @Curle
    @TGGP

    For decades after the civil war blacks were left alone to kill each other in the South at least, no? Did the authorities in the post war period keep accurate death records for blacks in the South?

    There’s a book, a few years old, called Sick From Freedom by Jim Downes where he attempts to recreate post war black deaths. I say recreate because records of black deaths in this time period are notoriously bad or were never kept in the first place.

    Replies: @Jonathan Mason, @anon

    , @ATBOTL
    @TGGP

    No one believes these numbers today. They just weren't counting a lot of black on black murders because no one cared.

  • TGGP says: • Website

    This disparity is not new; it has existed for well over a century. When historian Roger Lane studied murder rates in Philadelphia, he found that since 1839 the black rate has been much higher than the white rate.

    When I read William Stuntz’ “The Collapse of American Criminal Justice“, he said that while the black rate has been higher in recent times (I think since the Great Migration), in the 19th century the white rate was higher in both north & south. His citation was to Randolph Roth’s “American Homicide”. Stuntz compared the then largely-rural black population moving to cities and increasing their crime rates to the Irish immigrants, whose home counties in Ireland had relatively low rates despite the same people being quite criminal once they moved to U.S cities.

    • Replies: @TGGP
    @TGGP

    I hadn't noted the page number to Roth's book when I read Stuntz, so I looked up the citation via Google Books:


    Roth notes that the end of the nineteenth century saw southern homicide rates surpass those in the Southwest, and saw a sharp rise in black homicide. See Roth, American Homicide, 387. The latter phenomenon happened in the North as well (ibid., 194-96, 387). Before the last years of the nineteenth century, whites were the more homicidal group. See, for example, the lower black homicide rate pre-1890 (ibid., 398).
     

    Replies: @Curle, @ATBOTL

    , @Anon
    @TGGP

    The whole business sounds territorial. Cram people together, they start killing each other. Spread them out in the countryside, and they leave each other alone. If I were living in a black ghetto, I'd find blacks so annoying I'd be killing them too.

  • From Reuters: Sure, the quality would be higher than Frau Merkel's Million Marching Muslim Men Mob in 2015, but 2.9 million? Meanwhile, the Wall Street "There shall be open borders" Journal is trying to horn in on the action by demanding that Trump admit Hong Kongers (during a colossal depression with 10s of millions of...
  • @Anonymous
    @TelfoedJohn


    I’d happily let millions of HK Chinese in if it meant no other immigration.

    Look at the standard of doctors for instance:
     
    You’d happily give your country’s best jobs to foreigners? You are pathetic.

    Replies: @TGGP, @Dumbo, @thud

    I’d happily give the “best jobs” to people who do the best job. I wouldn’t want to die on an operating table out of your desire not to be “pathetic”.

    • Replies: @peterike
    @TGGP


    I’d happily give the “best jobs” to people who do the best job.
     
    And that's exactly why we can't have nice things. Idiots like you.
    , @Anonymous
    @TGGP


    I’d happily give the “best jobs” to people who do the best job. I wouldn’t want to die on an operating table out of your desire not to be “pathetic”.
     
    You’d sell out your people for a mess of pottage.

    There is plenty of medical talent to be found in the populations of the United States and Britain. And non-Western countries badly need the far scarcer talent that they have.

    Pathetic. You are cowardly trash.

    , @ATBOTL
    @TGGP

    People are like you are what is killing the West.

  • @Anon
    Canada did a mini version of this, and Vancouver is pretty changed. I think they reached the perfect cusp where both sides kind of assimilate to the other and meet in the middle, which is in a way worse than just having a big population of foreigners who never assimilate.

    Replies: @Buzz Mohawk, @TGGP, @Ian Smith, @Anon

    How was it worse?

    I had previously heard that Canadian multiculturalism was better than their older bi-culturalism where Anglo vs French Canadians basically hated each other.

    If the problem with Boris’ action was the quantity rather than the quality, then Trump taking in some would seem to be helpful.

    • Replies: @Saxon
    @TGGP

    Having 50 groups who all hate each other having to live cheek by jowl in an oligarchy posing as a democracy isn't better than what it used to be. Also, every single anti-white policy that exists in America exists in Canada. Even though they don't make sense. Affirmative action? It's there. Chiding about slavery that never existed in the country? Also there! If you're white, you're always the wrong party in any altercation. "Minorities" (soon to be the majority) can violently assault you with a deadly weapon like a machete all based on your race and scream about how much they hate whitey while doing it but suddenly the courts have trouble determining it to be a hate crime, because that's for you only when you transgress against these other people you've been saddled with by saying something that offends them.

  • [As noted yesterday, the following essay was written by a reader and commenter who requested the opportunity. In the spirit of the open inquiry and free expression UR is renowned for, its contents are neither endorsed nor condemned by this blog or webzine. On account of the essay's thoughtfulness, though, it has been deemed worthy...
  • TGGP says: • Website

    I thought your argument got off to a very wrong start by rather off-handedly asserting that the alternative to racial essentialism “cannot be” and then proceeding to ding any alternative theory for failing to be essentialist. That’s what the phrase “begging the question” originally referred to, but you seem to think your proof-by-assertion overrides that.

    All that aside, I’d like to ask you a question about one of your other assertions: what is your evidence that the people of Africa have less capacity for civilization than the native inhabitants of Australia or New Guinea? Remember that those people are as distantly related to Africans as anyone else on earth. And don’t ask me to prove some alternative theory, I can point out shortcomings in your argument (which is hardly the default theory of anyone but you) without that.

  • In the New York Times TV section, veteran iSteve Content Generator Salamishah Tillet, professor of African-American and African studies and creative writing at Rutgers University, Newark where she teaches a class on "Black Rage," brings us up to date on the important cultural trend in her favorite romance shows: Interracial Romance, With Black Women as...
  • TGGP says: • Website

    I don’t know about her first two examples, but the male lead of “The Lovebirds” is Kumail Nanjiani. He would have been classified as caucasian prior to the 1980s, but now he’s officially a Person of Color and the reviews I’ve read of the film indicate that both leads are wary of the police due to the assumption that they will be racist (are there any notable instances in the U.S of police being racist against south Asians?).

    • Replies: @prosa123
    @TGGP

    No one would ever consider Kumali Nanjiani white.

  • Congressman Justin Amash (Libertarian-Michigan) is of Levantine Christian descent: People of this ancestry have been considered white/Caucasian by the federal government for about 100 years. I believe there was a court case in the early 20th Century over this question, with the decisive argument being that Jesus was white and He was a Levantine Christian.
  • TGGP says: • Website
    @Anonymous
    Jesus was mixed he was half sephardic Jew and half goy probably a Roman or Greek father maybe a Phoenician...

    Read the new testament Jesus arrives and preaches like a space alien. Not a real Tribe member. Not a rabbi mentality. Outsider. His father could've been from far north areas of Empire. Jesus doctrine sounds like cold weather cooperation genetics talking.

    Gospels Jesus is free of Jewish neuroticism. Preaches freedom and not many control freak tendencies displayed. Might as well have landed from outer space.

    OTOH Paul preaches like a rabbi. Jew. Insider. Neurotic control freak obsessed with minutia and rules and ingroup outgroup dynamics. Paul's mind is same as for example someone like radio host Savage/Weiner. Same brainwaves... Tribe!

    Tribe thinking patterns are utterly apart from style/wiring of Jesus. Jews read the new testament and their Jewdar flatlines.

    Replies: @TGGP

    That’s ironic, since Paul is usually considered to have shifted Christianity away from the Jamesian variant focused on Jews to one angling more for evangelizing to gentiles, who weren’t required to adhere to kosher rules.

    I personally have always found most entertaining the interpretation of Koenraad Elst that Jesus wrote Revelations after Pilate faked killing him, but the rest of the New Testament was watered down stuff written later in an attempt to avoid ticking off the Romans.
    http://koenraadelst.bharatvani.org/books/pp/index.htm

    • Replies: @Mr McKenna
    @TGGP

    There's nothing 'watered down' about the Antitheses from the Sermon on the Mount.

    Jesus is saying "Take this Torah and shove it!"

  • TGGP says: • Website
    @syonredux

    Of the three candidates, I’m the only one not of white European ancestry.
     
    Really like the careful use of language there. If he simply said that he wasn't White, that would, potentially, open him up to "struggle session" critiques from genuine POC (Blacks, East Asians, etc), who might point out that he is legally White and enjoys privileges that they lack.This fellow, however, is clever enough to dodge that potential minefield:"Of course, I'm legally White, but I'm not 'White-White.' I'm White with an asterisk."

    Replies: @TGGP

    On the contrary, the standard line I hear nowadays is that every non-European is a “POC”, and even Europeans like Saami and Ashkenazi are sometimes said to have “pokemon points” as well. Amash’s statement is correct, though he could have just said “European descent”. And I’m all for people avoiding flack via saying correct things rather than absurd things.

    • Replies: @syonredux
    @TGGP


    On the contrary, the standard line I hear nowadays is that every non-European is a “POC”, and even Europeans like Saami and Ashkenazi are sometimes said to have “pokemon points” as well.
     
    It's tricky, though. Imagine if Teri Hatcher started describing herself as POC.......I'm fairly certain that she would be told to check her privilege.....


    https://i.pinimg.com/originals/62/ba/99/62ba999169b128ddea594f7915069d4b.jpg



    And does anyone count John Sununu as POC......



    http://static.politico.com/11/9e/74ab8a5a41cb9fc6856e0eecd2e1/ap-777942406200.jpg
  • It was a close run race: Who would crack first: the obscure small city gay mayor making a 1000-1 run for the Democratic nomination or me and my laziness in never learning how to spell his name and instead just copying-and-pasting it each time I used it? It was a hard-fought battle, but my inability...
  • To be fair to the late colonel, he did have a lot more possible spellings to choose from.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @TGGP

    Libya and Malta are pretty close geographically and both speak a version of Arabic.

  • From my new book review in Taki's Magazine: Read the whole thing there.
  • A good example of a left-wing social scientist who published “right-wing” findings is Oscar Lewis. That work was attacked by other leftists as “blaming the victim”, and his defenders mostly stuck to noting that Lewis’ Marxism was indisputable.

    • Replies: @Ian Smith
    @TGGP

    I’d never heard of Oscar Lewis but those books look interesting. Bryan Caplan’s reading of them doesn’t seem to have affected his support for open borders, though. 😏

  • As I mentioned yesterday, Carl Zimmer's article in the New York Times on the new ancient DNA paper with its ho-hum title, Ancient DNA from West Africa Adds to Picture of Humans’ Rise, is a model of how to construct articles upside down to bore complacent NYT subscribers with the opening paragraphs before revealing the...
  • In other words, most sub-Saharan Africans today are descended from Bantus, who are, historically, a genocidal conqueror race rather like the Yamnayas-Aryans of Eurasia.

    But the Bantu farmers didn’t swiftly drive hunter-gatherers to oblivion. The Shum Laka people survived for at least 1,000 years in the heart of Bantu country.

    My impression was that the Yamnaya wiped out agricultural societies in northern Europe rather quickly, while denser societies in southern Europe were less of a replacement scenario. Per Zimmer, the Yamnaya would presumably consider the Bantu to be real slackers in the genocide department. I should note, that sub-Saharan Africa retained macrofauna longer than other places, whereas they were quickly hunted into extinction in the Americas, and also retained hunter-gatherer populations longer than, for example, Europe and most of Asia. A common explanation is that they evolved alongside each other, rather than suddenly arriving with an overwhelming advantage the other couldn’t adjust to. Presumably that was the case for disease here vs during the Columbian exchange.

  • From my new book review in Taki's Magazine: Civil Rights Gone Wrong A couple of heavyweight conservative thinkers, Charles Murray and Christopher Caldwell, have important new books out this month: Murray’s upcoming Human Diversity: The Biology of Gender, Race, and Class and Caldwell’s The Age of Entitlement: America Since the Sixties. Caldwell, a distinguished prose...
  • William Stuntz complained in “The Collapse of American Criminal Justice” that SCOTUS made rulings intended to address the inequities of the Jim Crow South, but unfortunately rather than narrowly target the problem they made with substantive requirements or explicit anti-discrimination rules they instead made facially neutral general rulings on procedure nevertheless inspired by those southern cases which hampered the functioning justice system of the north. A similar interpretation is possible regarding what happened with legislative changes, although I would note that currently things like political correctness act through many non-legislative channels and that might continue to be the case even in the absence of the threat of lawsuits after the SCOTUS victories Steve imagines at the end of his article.

  • From BioRxiv: Hispanics/Latinos are a diverse group of admixed populations with African, European, and Native American ancestries. They remain understudied, and thus little is known about the genetic architecture of phenotypic variation in these populations. Using genome-wide genotype data from the Hispanic Community Health Study/Study of Latinos, we find that Native American ancestry has increased...
  • It’s also likely that there is a height gradient among Native Americans. The tallest, such as the Blackfeet, appear to be up around the Canadian border with the shortest in North America down in Central America.

    That’s somewhat surprising, since Allen’s rule is that colder temperatures should result in an animal having a lower surface area to volume ratio, typically meaning shorter limbs and a stockier frame. On the other hand, the “pygmy” phenotype seems to be associated with jungles and the peasants of agricultural civilizations seem to be shorter than the typical non-pygmy hunter-gatherer.

    • Replies: @nokangaroos
    @TGGP

    Allen´s rule means bigger, not shorter. Seen any spherical whales lately? :D

    , @Alden
    @TGGP

    Protein in the diet has a lot do do with it, even if it’s high protein oats and wheat opposed to very low protein rice and corn.

    , @Pickle Rick
    @TGGP

    Because native nations don’t always live today where they originated from geographically. They’ve migrated over the continent thousands of miles, just like the Indo-European nations (the Franks, Saxons, Goths, etc.). The horse culture of the plains that gave the Blackfeet the mobility and present territory they now have is less than 300 years old.
    They didn’t always live near the present Canadian border any more than the Delaware nation always lived in modern Oklahoma.

  • From the New York Times news section: If Germany really wanted to do the world a huge favor to make up for certain unfortunate events of the 20th Century, it would undertake to show the world how to make nuclear power safe. If anybody can make nuclear power work safely, it is Germans, with their...
  • Nuclear power is ALREADY safer than coal. People died because of the tsunami which hit Fukushima, and one person was killed by a mechanical crane in the reaction to the disaster at the plant, but the same would have happened if it were a coal plant. Three Mile Island didn’t have the casualties of Chernobyl either. As was already pointed out, Germany is not afflicted with tsunamis and earthquakes and like Japan, so they didn’t switch because of safety risks at their own plants. They switched because of low-information voters.

  • From Human Nature in 2012: The Importance of Physical Strength to Human Males Aaron Sell & Liana S. E. Hone & Nicholas Pound ... Warfare and the Hollywood Action Star If attitudes about warfare are causally tied to a man’s own sense of fighting ability, we would expect professions, industries, and coalitions of strong, powerful...
  • That paper is from back before the replication crisis made people sufficiently skeptical of many studies. I know Andrew Gelman savaged a similar paper on arm strength being correlated with a taste for redistribution.

    • Replies: @Steve Sailer
    @TGGP

    I noticed this pattern with movie stars -- action stars more on the right -- back in the 1980s. I wrote about it in 2000:

    https://www.upi.com/Archives/2000/12/29/Where-have-all-the-GOP-celebrities-gone/7631978066000/

    Replies: @ScarletNumber

  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: Read the whole thing there.
  • @Lot
    @TGGP

    “ Cochran/Harpending’s paper got some positive press when it was first published.”

    2005 was a different world.

    For one thing, the most important of that positive press was Nicholas Wade’s write-up in the NYT, which tends to set the tone for the rest of the prestige press.

    Now the biggest name writing about these types of issues in the press is Angela “Shut up, racist” Saini.

    Replies: @TGGP

    Like I said, I prefer general theories. The Bell Curve was extremely controversial when it was published, and remained so afterward. That the NYT has gotten worse and will tolerate even less science doesn’t change which extreme taboos still seem to constitute the “heartland”.

  • I mostly prefer more generic theories of political correctness, but I agree with Dan Moller contra Steve Sailer that the black-white IQ gap is the “heartland” rather than high Jewish IQ. Cochran/Harpending’s paper got some positive press when it was first published. He provides some evidence for that difference in his paper.

    • Agree: kaganovitch
    • Replies: @Lot
    @TGGP

    “ Cochran/Harpending’s paper got some positive press when it was first published.”

    2005 was a different world.

    For one thing, the most important of that positive press was Nicholas Wade’s write-up in the NYT, which tends to set the tone for the rest of the prestige press.

    Now the biggest name writing about these types of issues in the press is Angela “Shut up, racist” Saini.

    Replies: @TGGP

  • From the New York Daily News: In New York City, the Post is the right wing tabloid and the Daily News is the left wing tabloid. Not surprisingly, the Post is more interesting than the Daily News. Here's an interesting question: a few months ago, the Respectable Media was obsessed with how the movie Joker...
  • @Steve Sailer
    @Just Saying

    Perhaps, but what if 13 year olds in Harlem don't quite get the joke?

    Replies: @Jack D, @IC, @TGGP

    I don’t think 13 year olds in Harlem are watching prestige TV from the people that brought you The Leftovers. Get Out and Django Unchained perhaps, but not a subversion of a deconstruction of comic book superheroes.

  • From my new movie review in Taki's Magazine: The U.K. Vs. U.S. Detective Debate Steve Sailer December 11, 2019 The mystery movie Knives Out is an allegory about how Americans deserve to lose our homeland to Latin American immigrants out of our self-destructive hatred for each other. But that’s a good thing, the film says,...
  • I really hated Brick, disliked Looper and didn’t care about Last Jedi. Extrapolating from that trend, maybe this will finally be the Rian Johnson movie I actually like.

    The best movie about an old white man disinheriting his worthless offspring in favor of an immigrant is Clint Eastwood’s Gran Torino.

    • Agree: jim jones
    • Replies: @Jesse
    @TGGP

    Brick is brilliant, as long as you like modern day film noir with some 70s B movies thrown in. Looper could've cut the entire mid third, and added some hard science, and been like Inception.

    Replies: @Twodees Partain

    , @Hapalong Cassidy
    @TGGP

    Johnson’s best work is probably the several episodes of Breaking Bad he directed, including what is widely regarded as the best episode in the entire series.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ozymandias_(Breaking_Bad)

  • Here's my movie review of Midway in Taki's Magazine: The first small-type book for grownups I ever read was in 1967 when I was 8: a paperback history of the U.S.S. Enterprise aircraft carrier in World War II. So I have a lot to say about the Battle of Midway. Read the whole thing there.
  • Up until Steven Spielberg’s landmark 1998 D-Day movie Saving Private Ryan, Hollywood may have devoted more attention to the U.S. WWII effort against Japan than against Germany.

    That seems surprising to me, although I’m younger than you. We’re generally less interested in Asia than Europe so far fewer have heard of the Rape of Nanking compared to the Holocaust, its easier to get actors to play Euro-baddies than Japanese, and a lot of the fighting in the Pacific was over islands nobody cares about in a long slog against an outmatched enemy. I think we tend to find armies more interesting than navies as well, although I suppose a more maritime nation like the U.K could see things differently.

    • Replies: @syonredux
    @TGGP


    I think we tend to find armies more interesting than navies as well, although I suppose a more maritime nation like the U.K could see things differently.
     
    Dunno. The USA has a pretty impressive maritime history:John Paul Jones, Stephen Decatur, "Old Ironsdes" (AKA The USS Constitution), David Farragut , George Dewey, Clipper ships, ......
    , @William Badwhite
    @TGGP


    a lot of the fighting in the Pacific was over islands nobody cares about
     
    One advantage to that is huge amounts of war relics are still there. On a diving trip about 20 years ago I stopped for a day on Betio (sp?) atoll, which is where most of Tarawa was fought. You can wander in and out of the Japanese bunkers, all sorts of vehicles are just sitting there, rusting away.

    The below is not me, just a pic I found online. I have a zillion pics but not in electronic format.

    http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-OrTbAu_V-7A/UY8VyQD9TjI/AAAAAAAAASc/blBPtt-wGgI/s1600/Japanese+tank.JPG

    Replies: @nebulafox, @Ozymandias

    , @J.Ross
    @TGGP

    Europe is sad and shared, the Pacific was pretty much just us and (once we got going) as deliriously one-sided as a video game or movie serial. Hollywood instincts point to the Pacific every time.

    , @Ian M.
    @TGGP


    I think we tend to find armies more interesting than navies as well...
     
    Although submarine movies tend to be pretty popular, and pretty conducive to the generation of tense dramatic moments.
    , @Steve Sailer
    @TGGP

    Naval battles don't kill civilians.

  • Israel has the highest standard deviation of reading test scores of any country taking the new PISA test: 124 compared to an OECD average of 99. US is around 108. Ireland has the lowest SD of any above average scoring country at around 91. PISA is scored much like an SAT test with an intended...
  • Your point about the surprisingly low variance in Mexico reminded me of Greg Cochran recently arguing whether we should expect Saudi Arabian wealth to result in more brains.
    https://twitter.com/gcochran99/status/1201670758130274305
    I’m curious what the variance is there, although it’s possible that the really wealthy royals don’t take part in such tests.

    • Agree: jim jones
  • From the New York Times opinion page: New York City's Ku Klux Klan? As he walks away from the site of the attack — bloodied and draped in a hood and a noose — he sees a mugging. He could walk away. Instead, he acts. He fights off the attackers. The next morning, the local...
  • I never watched “Lost”, but Lindelof and Perrotta’s TV adaptation of “The Leftovers” was good enough I figure I’ll check this out eventually.

  • The dusty topic of Miami in the 1980s is back in the news, with the new Nobel laureate (sort of) in Economics Esther Duflo declaring that the boring, featureless history of Miami in the 1980s proves that low skill immigration has "zero" effect on the wages of low-skilled natives. And the Southern Poverty Law Center...
  • It’s spelled “Levitt”, not “Leavitt”.

  • In other words, the NYT wants you to know that the American family recently murdered by the Mexican cartel had it coming, for the usual Current Year antiquarianist reasons. They're not immigrants, they are settlers! Unmentioned: The Romneys were run out of Mexico during the Mexican Revolution of the 1910s. The Mexican government paid them...
  • Carlos Reygadas’ film “Silent Light” is set in Mexico but in the Plautdietsch aka “Low German” language of its Mennonite characters.

  • From my new column in Taki's Magazine: The Reviled Right by Steve Sailer, October 23, 2019 In 2019, two books demanding more censorship have each devoted a chapter to portraying me as a historic villain. In the first, Angela Saini’s Superior: The Return of Race Science, I was cast as a bad guy along with...
  • Beginning with the word “clueless” and prior to the word “2008” you’ve got a large block of text needlessly linking to the article the reader is already reading.

  • One of the weirder developments of this decade has been the rapid adaptation in the U.S. of a view previously relegated mostly to some Asian Islamic countries, such as Iran and Malaysia, that male homosexuals are, basically, defective women who should be encouraged by society to transition to a less defective version of womanhood using...
  • Vulture has a profile of the trans writer Andrea Long Chu, whose POV seems to bolster Bailey’s theory about autogynephiles vs the “always a little girl on the inside” narrative:
    https://www.vulture.com/2019/10/andrea-long-chu-on-her-debut-book-females.html

  • From the New York Times opinion section: In the future, white people will always be referred to as "white" people, while black people will be referred to as "Black bodies" with a capital B. I first noticed this trend with Ta-Nehisi Coates' hilarious bestseller in 2015, where blacks are "black bodies" and whites are "people...
  • Maybe they have to use scare-quotes because Italians were always legally considered white in the U.S:
    https://entitledtoanopinion.wordpress.com/2013/02/24/pathetic-that-this-even-has-to-be-pointed-out/

    • Agree: syonredux
    • Replies: @S. Anonyia
    @TGGP

    Spaniards were also always considered white, no matter how many of their crafty fair-skinned conquistador descendants (like Xochitl Hinojosa, that Anderson Cooper lookalike from Univision, author of “My Time Among the Whites” Jennine Capo Crucet, and Guillermo Del Toro) want to twist the facts to their advantage now. Thanks, Richard Nixon.

    , @Barnard
    @TGGP

    How far back does this stupid idea go? I first remember seeing it about the time of the blog post you linked to, in the early days of Obama's second term. The Tuskegee Institute updated their lynching map in an attempt to make people think Italian anarchists and Spanish cattle rustlers and horse thieves were victims of white supremacy just in the last couple of years. From what I can tell, they aren't making much progress with the public in getting this idea accepted.

    , @syonredux
    @TGGP


    Maybe they have to use scare-quotes because Italians were always legally considered white in the U.S:
     
    Indeed. All this talk about how "X" (Irish, Italians, Poles, Jews, etc) became White is utter bilge.


    William B. Taliaferro seems to have done pretty well for himself.....

    William Booth Taliaferro ( /ˈtɒlɪvər/ TOL-i-vər; December 28, 1822 – February 27, 1898), was a United States Army officer, a lawyer, legislator, Confederate general in the American Civil War, and Grand Master of Masons in Virginia.
     

    William Booth Taliaferro was born in Gloucester County, Virginia, to an Anglo-Italian family, the Taliaferros, who had settled in Virginia in the early 17th century from London. He was the son of Francis Amanda Todd (Booth) and Warner Throckmorton Taliaferro,[1] and the nephew of James A. Seddon, who would become Secretary of War for the Confederate States of America under Jefferson Davis.
     
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_B._Taliaferro
  • This is obviously a smart reform, but what we really need is mandatory immigration insurance. Just as you're not allowed to drive without auto insurance, you shouldn't be allowed to immigrate without obtaining, say, $5 million in coverage for all the ways you can harm Americans. Back in 2015, iSteve commenter Pittsburgh Thatcherite noted: Some...
  • As I’ve mentioned before, Robin Hanson has proposed requiring such insurance, but for everybody. There wouldn’t need to be a separate kind of insurance for gun-owners in that situation either:
    http://www.overcomingbias.com/2019/09/who-vouches-for-you.html

  • From the FBI's newly released 2018 crime statistics: FBI Expanded Homicide Data Table 11 Murder Circumstances by Weapon, 2018 Circumstances Percent Total Total murder victims NA 14,123 Total firearms NA 10,265 Total Specified Weapons 100.0% 10,093 Handguns 65.4% 6,603 Rifles 2.9% 297 Shotguns 2.3% 235 Other guns or type not stated NA 3,130 Knives or...
  • @Harry Baldwin
    A friend of man who was in the LAPD in the 1990s said the cops strongly suspected James Caan threw his cocaine dealer out a window, but they couldn't prove it so his death was ruled an accident. Caan had a serious drug problem and liked hanging out with mobsters, but who really cares when drug dealers die anyway?

    https://apnews.com/e3d53df1ea44ef4fae0992ef20541f21

    Odd that so many defenestrations occurred in Prague. The topic even has a Wikipedia page:
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defenestrations_of_Prague

    Replies: @TGGP

    There’s supposed to be a “Werther effect” where publicizing suicides results in more suicides, and now people in the media are moving to conceal the names of mass-shooters so as not to incentivize fame-seekers. I wonder if once defenestrations became a “thing” in Prague it just naturally occurred to more people as something worth doing.

    • Replies: @Jack D
    @TGGP

    I think certain kinds of execution are just more in tune with the culture of certain countries. For America the gun is the quintessential political assassination weapon. For Russians it is poison. For the French, it is the guillotine. Defenestrations occur more than once, but centuries apart, in Czech history, the most recent being the "suicide" of Czech Foreign Minister Jan Masaryk in 1948 when the Communists were consolidating their control over postwar Czechoslovakia. Defenestration carries the symbolic message that the victim does not deserve his "elevated" position in society and needs to be literally brought down a notch or two.

    Replies: @kaganovitch, @Anon

  • @Andrew M
    Handgun murders consist mainly of lowlifes killing other lowlifes; whereas the AR-15 is the weapon of choice for white schoolboys committing mass shootings of other white schoolboys. Middle America’s soccer moms are right to disproportionally fear rifles.

    Replies: @TWS, @TGGP, @B.

    School shooting were a big deal years ago, but I get the impression that mass shooters tend to target other public places now. The reason that the Aurora Colorado shooter chose a midnight screening was that he wanted the crowd to be full of adults.

    • Replies: @Neoconned
    @TGGP

    https://www.npr.org/2018/03/15/593831564/the-disconnect-between-perceived-danger-in-u-s-schools-and-reality

    https://news.northeastern.edu/2018/02/26/schools-are-still-one-of-the-safest-places-for-children-researcher-says/

    School shootings and mass shootings peaked in the 1990s and were higher in the 80s than the 2000s or the current decade.

    Most of what you hear is media hysteria pumping the narrative 24/7 that makes ppl think it's more common than it is.

    Before 9/11 most ppl got their news from boring droll newspapers or Brokaw/Rather type broadcasts. Post 9-11 Fox News created the 24/7 news cycle and CNN etc copied it there for ratings sake

    Its actually safer now than it has been in decades:

    https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2013/05/07/gun-homicide-rate-down-49-since-1993-peak-public-unaware/

    In LA and NYC for instance crime is at 1950s or 60s levels. And pretty much is the same in all cities not heavily populated by blacks....look at Seattle or Denver.....

  • @Mike Tre
    Your last sentence points out the pattern:

    Handgun = black = non news worthy crime.

    Long gun = white = legislation.

    Replies: @TGGP, @Realist, @Al Liguori

    The D.C sniper is a counter-example to your generalization, although that was also early enough that there wasn’t much call for rifle legislation.

    Some recent mass shooters have used rifles, but Brevik and the Virginia Tech Shooter amassed rather high bodycounts with just handguns.

    I’m actually surprised that rifles outnumber shotguns above. A sawed-off shotgun was once commonly associated with criminals. Sawing off a rifle, on the other hand, rather defeats the point of a long-ranged weapon.

    • Replies: @Harry Baldwin
    @TGGP

    ...but Brevik and the Virginia Tech Shooter amassed rather high bodycounts with just handguns.

    I assume you're referring to Anders Breivik. He did most of his killing with a Ruger Mini 14, a semiautomatic rifle in .223 caliber that can take 20- and 30-round magazines.

    , @Jack Henson
    @TGGP

    When you realise Ruby Ridge was, on its face, about sawed off shotguns you start thinking about the consequences of the NFA.

  • From the Washington Post news pages: Mary Rambaran-Olm speaks at an academic conference in Washington earlier this month, at which she announced her plans to resign as second vice president of the group formerly known as the International Society of Anglo-Saxonists. (Leah Newsom) By Hannah Natanson September 19, 2019 at 9:03 a.m. PDT Mary Rambaran-Olm...
  • I didn’t click through to the article. Did it explain what the ISAS changed its name to?

  • The leader of The Cars, the benchmark New Wave rock band of the late 1970s, Ric Ocasek, has died at age 75, which is a pretty good lifespan for a rock star. You'll note from his age that Ocasek didn't hit it big until his mid-30s with The Cars debut album in 1978, which featured...
  • this music biz veteran’s correct anticipation of what Kids These Days would be into after the long reign of the Blues: more linear guitar-riffing with nerdier references.

    Damn you Ocasek and Kids These Days!

  • Delaware has typically been the most corporate-friendly state going back to DuPont and the War of 1812, so it's not surprising that former Senator Joe Biden (D-DE, 1972-2008) is proposing no jail time for white collar criminals: I get the feeling the Joe's millennial aides actually believe that freeing all nonviolent criminals would help blacks...
  • A lot of people assume that “white-collar” criminals are overwhelmingly white. After all, “white” is right in the description and the term comes from a division of occupational class. But a whole lot of people are convicted of things like “fraud” which is white-collar as far as criminal offenses go even if they aren’t white-collar in occupation or just plain white. The prisons are not full of people like Bernie Madoff, who can usually afford good lawyers unless there’s a lot of overwhelming evidence of large scale crime. On the other hand, I don’t know that someone who takes a plea on some small-scale fraud charges is going to serve a lot of time in prison.

    If the prison population is going to be seriously reduced, it will have to involve people convicted of violent crimes. The late Mark Kleiman’s plan was to drastically enhance our parole system via things like GPS ankle-bracelets and immediate jail time for any parole violation, inspired by the success of Hawaii’s H.O.P.E program that got repeatedly recidivist meth-addict burglars to go clean and stay out of trouble. I think there was a lot of promise in that idea, but it’s mostly wonks discussing it rather than any politicians.

    • Replies: @unit472
    @TGGP

    Petty ( or violent) criminals are seldom in the position to commit the high dollar ( $10k+ ) embezzling or fraud schemes that will get you multi-year prison terms. Still lots of negro criminals engage in credit card and check cashing schemes that utilize volume to make up for the lower amount involved per transaction. Even here though the negro fraudsters will often use a white women as their 'front' as a tattooed ex-con trying to cash a $2000 check is going to undergo greater scrutiny than a middle aged white women.

    Replies: @Alden

    , @Cloudbuster
    @TGGP

    Middle Easterners seem to be extremely prolific white collar criminals.

    , @Anonymous
    @TGGP

    Amongst Democrats there's this myth that a huge number of black people are in (private) prisons for "getting caught with a gram of weed." It's nonsense, and most honest criminal-justice reformers (e.g., John Pfaff) will say as much. Convictions for murder, assault, theft, rape and dealing large quantities of drugs are the norm amongst prisoners. Maybe you could make the case a lot of that is overcharging on the part of prosecutors, but that's not what the left are saying. And of course Biden doesn't mean what he says: if pressed, I'm sure he'd say that e.g. the sentence for Felicity Huffman was an outrage because it was too *low*.

    As far as "white-collar crime," I'd guess most of it is low-level fraud involving government programs: Medicare fraud, food-stamp fraud, things like that. Probably a lot of Indians, MENA types and Eastern Europeans. I don't consider some junkie bouncing checks or forging prescriptions to be "white collar" in any meaningful sense of the word.

  • Since the 1970s, the U.S. has had a National Transportation Safety Board to inquire into the causes of jetliner crashers and the like and issue recommendations. We should also have a National Immigration Safety Board to investigate how we came to let in losers like, say, this Iraqi who sabotaged a jetliner to get some...
  • I know you’ve discussed requiring immigration insurance, which would select for people who are less likely to cause harm. Robin Hanson has endorsed requiring criminal insurance for everyone, and selecting immigrants by financial speculation on their net externalities. I think these are reasonable proposals to “pull the rope sideways” and could appeal both to those who want more vs less immigration as a form of improved policy.

    • Replies: @danand
    @TGGP


    "reasonable proposals to “pull the rope sideways”"

     


    TGGP, excuse the hijacking of your most excellent post. Couldn't resist, noose news is leading the TV news broadcasts locally.

    https://youtu.be/NeVdocLdaL0

    Replies: @Paleo Liberal

    , @Redneck farmer
    @TGGP

    Ohio and Pennsylvania's requirement that free Negroes put a $500 bond for good conduct prior to The War Of The Rebellion are considered bad things nowadays. The insurance proposals you linked to will be considered just as bad, if not worse.

    , @International Jew
    @TGGP

    If that idea catches on, its first victim will be gun mfgs and gun stores, which will be forced to buy ruinously expensive insurance against damage done by the guns they sell.

    Replies: @William Badwhite

  • A University of Calgary press release: As I've said a million times, there are two types of M to F transgenders, either extremely effeminate gay hairdresser types who played with girls' toys from earliest childhood; or totally non-feminine extreme male brain types, like this Professor of Robotic Engineering with the huge jaw who looks like...
  • Todd (now Emily) Vanderwerff might count as a counter-example to your generalization. He’d been married to a woman for years, and she’d written about their difficulties in attempting to have children, but there’s otherwise nothing especially masculine or right-wing about him.

  • My new column in Taki's Magazine, Alternative America, critically evaluates the current dogma that America before recently would have been impoverished without slavery and blacks. An anonymous iSteve commenter points us toward this passage about the impact of slavery on the American economy c. 1830 from Alexis De Tocqueville … in general, the colonies in...
  • @Corvinus
    @Buzz Mohawk

    Mr. Sailer is engaging in No Slavery Porn. Cheesy moustache, included.

    "Had there been no slavery in America, there would be no African Americans."

    You are only (wildly) speculating here. More than likely there would have been immigration from Africa at some point in time to our shores, especially if there was not a distinct animosity toward them. Regardless, we do have much more certainty that had the peculiar institution not been part of the United States, several important components of the economy of the Thirteen Colonies, like the shipping and rum industries, would have been stunted. Moreover, plantations were an integral part of the local southern economies, in particular foodstuffs, horses, and building materials.

    "And those Africans who would instead be in Africa would be much worse off than they are in America."

    Again, you are only (wildly) speculating. You are neglecting to consider the impact of European imperialism, which had a significant negative impact on their physical environment and their cultural ways of life.

    Replies: @TGGP

    Correct, as there are people descended from African immigrants in many western countries now, including Canada. They would be fewer in number though and have more cultural continuity with their countries of origin rather than being “African Americans” as we know them.

    In terms of the impact on Africa, it should be remembered that slavery already existed, and by some accounts I’ve read there were even larger numbers sent eastward to the Ottoman empire. Is the counterfactual to contain no slavery whatsoever? This would also imply no interventions to stamp out slavery, although there could still be justifications based on piracy or other matters. If slavery is only eliminated in the United States, that would still leave the Caribbean and Brazil.

    • Replies: @Corvinus
    @TGGP

    "In terms of the impact on Africa, it should be remembered that slavery already existed, and by some accounts I’ve read there were even larger numbers sent eastward to the Ottoman empire."

    Not sure about the exact figures, but the Ottoman Empire benefitted from the African slave trade.

    "African slaves were considered quite valuable and typically came from Central Africa. They would be sold in the slave markets at Fezzan in Libya and Upper Egypt or might have been brought to Mecca during the time of the pilgrimage and sold there. From the 16th century, Egypt and most of the Arabian Peninsula were under Ottoman control and in the 17th century, the Ottomans took over the Fezzan region. That gave them greater access to African slaves. Perhaps as much of Istanbul’s population as 20 percent consisted of slaves, although we have no idea of what percentage would have been Africans."

    http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/african-slaves-in-the-ottoman-empire-69858

    "This would also imply no interventions to stamp out slavery, although there could still be justifications based on piracy or other matters. If slavery is only eliminated in the United States, that would still leave the Caribbean and Brazil."

    I'm surprised Mr. Sailer did not recognize that pattern. It was out in plain sight. Had there not been slavery in the States, it is reasonable to assume this institution would have expanded in those locations to meet market demand for cash crops. If plantation owners in those locations were making significant amounts of money, with American farmers making a small dent in the international marketplace, it is reasonable to believe that there would be an effort made to bring in slaves. Moreover, America would be considered a "safe haven" by slaves since it had not existed here. So, if they eventually gained their freedom, it is reasonable to assume that they would immigrate to a place to escape persecution and find employment, similar to Europeans who sought a better life for themselves.

    Replies: @animalogic, @animalogic

  • From my new column: Read the whole thing there.
  • The Confederate connection to Lazarus’ poem is news to me. It’s particularly ironic since the statue was built to celebrate the Union’s victory in the Civil War:
    https://twitter.com/toad_spotted/status/1161445460130893824

    • Replies: @peterike
    @TGGP

    The Lazarus poem is the perfect encapsulation of the Jew-WASP ruling class. Emma Lazarus, the unattractive Jewess, hyper-Zionist and all-around trouble making agitator, writes a treacly paean to "Let in more of my relatives!" thereby undermining American social cohesion (a constant Jewish goal), while WASP ruling class nit-wit Georgina Schuyler uses her influence to have lines from the poem slapped on the Statue of Immigration, thereby providing at least half the impetus behind the multi-cultural ruining of America.

    Lazarus was bad enough, but without Schuyler's virtue signalling intervention, we might all have been saved from a lot more than some really bad poetry.

    Replies: @ben tillman, @Chris Mallory

  • Dear Liz: You are a law professor, right? Well, I've got a legal question for you: Isn't the tweet above both a lie and a libel? Bernie at least somehow managed to avoid using the word "murder:" But ... "end police violence against people of color"???
  • Slate of all places had a post yesterday on the mythical nature of the popular conception of Michael Brown’s death.
    https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2019/08/ferguson-narrative-legacy-wrong-police-violence.html
    That features John McWhorter, who is admittedly a regular Slate contributor, but that’s usually in the form of his Lexicon Valley podcast rather than anything topical.

    • Replies: @nebulafox
    @TGGP

    McWhorter's a bright dude. Blue-voting liberal, but intelligent, sane, and perceptive.

    I'd recommend anybody here to check out his articles, particularly his accurate noting of the disturbingly religious character of 21st Century white liberal attitudes toward race.

    Replies: @Paco Wové

  • Writing instructors long told students to use verbs in the active voice rather than in the passive voice when possible. But the needs of the The Narrative are far more important than such petty stylistic concerns when the goal is to pin the blame on the gun, as in Chicago, rather than the shooter of...
  • TGGP says: • Website

    One obvious reason not to specify in the story who shot all those people in Chicago is because we don’t have one single suspect. Many shootings will simply go unsolved, and the failure of police to stop the shootings will mean possible retaliatory violence and more guys carrying guns in case they run into come across other guys carrying guns. The NYPD managed to drop their murder rate by flooding dangerous areas with lots of cops and aggressively going after violence (drug dealers now act like pizza deliverymen, without having to fight over turf). Now that Manhattanites no longer have much fear of such violence, there are now complaints that the legal system is unfair to guys caught illegally carrying, correctly pointing out that existing violence incentivizes arming yourself but not “solving for the equilibrium” of what the effect of legal reforms would be.

    On the other hand, we have a study showing that deer season causes a huge jump in the carrying of rifles but zero effect on violence, because despite the well-publicized mass shootings, rifles are responsible for fewer homicides than fists.