RSSI agree, Provine’s book clearly suggests the wheels were in motion earlier. Yes, perhaps the phrase did not become popular until the 30-40’s, but the field itself was in development by the first two decades
Razib, when you say “never trust estimates of coalescence between two lineages” are you referring to the specific timing (in years or whatever) of coalescence?
well, there’s DDT resistance in mosquitos…that reversed following cessation of pesticide application. Although I’m not sure how many mut’s are involved in any given case of resistance…there are several possible, but not sure how many tend to all occur at the same time in a given population/individual.
If they use STRs (available in standardized kits for forensics) the whole process could be ~4 hours in a dedicated situation (I imagine OBL generates greater dedication than your typical knife wielding maniac)…turnarounds are slow because of volume, not length of lab time per sample
Even if this is the case, I’m worried that there are 8ish% of graduate degree people who can’t answer a survey, but the alternative is even more frightening, so I have to agree with you. I mean I know >8% of scientists think the world revolved around THEMSELVES, but… 🙂