RSSHi Ron,
I admire and respect your knowledge. You have consistently hit the nail on the head. However, I am not sure about your theory in this article about the Soviets and their intentions.
Have you read “Conjuring Hitler” by Guido Preparata? It proposes the thesis that it was Britain (controlled by the international bankers, mostly Zionists) who was running the WWII show, and that Stalin would not act without Britain’s and the bankers’ consent. After all, Stalin had inherited a massive control structure from Lenin that was set up by British and banking capital just a few decades earlier. Stalin owed them.
Makia
Somebody upthread had already asked me about the Preparata book, which I'd read a few years ago. I repeated my (very negative) verdict for me but since I put it under a MORE probably you and many others didn't see it. So I might as well repeat it again here:
Have you read “Conjuring Hitler” by Guido Preparata? It proposes the thesis that it was Britain (controlled by the international bankers, mostly Zionists) who was running the WWII show, and that Stalin would not act without Britain’s and the bankers’ consent.
https://www.unz.com/runz/american-pravda-understanding-world-war-ii/?showcomments#comment-3488251Replies: @Makia Freeman
Well, I ordered a copy of the Preparata book, and read it. I hate to say it, but he comes across as a total conspiracy-crank and a crackpot.
The book significantly references the short earlier Antony Sutton book on Wall Street/Hitler, which I’d brought a couple of years ago, so I dug it out and finally read it. Sure enough, Sutton also comes across like a conspiracy-crank and a crackpot.
I’m certainly not saying these books are totally worthless since they gather together lots of interesting references. But the candor and/or judgment of the authors is so dreadful, I just don’t think I can trust them on anything at all.
One interesting thing I’ve noticed about WWII conspiracy-cranks is that they’re usually utterly, *utterly* terrified of discussing the Jewish role in promoting the war, even though (as I cited in my article) the private statements of Chamberlain and numerous other key players put Jewish influence at the absolute center.
For example, neither Preparata nor Sutton have any entry for “Jews” in their detailed index, with Sutton for safety’s sake, even avoiding any index entry starting with the letter “J.” So you write a “conspiracy” book about Wall Street, Hitler, and WWII and have no index entry for “Jews”—ha, ha, ha. Quite a number of the key individuals Sutton mentions were Jewish, but you’d never know it from Sutton’s book.
Sutton also repeatedly mentions Hitler’s diabolical plan to conquer the entire world. Hmmm…
Meanwhile, Preparata focuses on the diabolical plot of the British elites to destroy Germany. Okay. But instead of simply attacking Germany when it was almost totally disarmed and helpless in the 1920s, they plotted to build up a very powerful German military under Hitler, and *then* start a war (and get defeated in 1940!) presumably because that was much more “challenging.”
Similarly, everyone knows of Parvus, the Jewish Marxist from Russia, whom the Germans used to provide heavy financing to Lenin’s Bolsheviks in hopes of promoting a revolution. The plan succeeded, and with their Russian allies in revolutionary turmoil, the British almost lost the war to Germany. Okay. But based on zero evidence, Preparata claims that Parvus was actually a *British* agent, who tricked the Germans into funding the Bolshevik Revolution and thereby almost winning the war. Those diabolical British!
Preparata also seems to believe that during the 1920s and 1930s, the British elites and the top Soviets were secret allies, both cooperating to build up Hitler’s military machine so as to better destroy Germany. He also believes that all the top British figures who seemed to be pro-German or friendly towards Hitler, from Edward VIII on down, were actually part of a diabolical anti-German British plot. Although everyone thought that Churchill and Chamberlain were bitter adversaries, they were actually secretly working together to destroy Germany by building up the German military into the strongest in the world.
I could provide a very long list of Preparata’s additional crackpottery, but it just isn’t worth it.
I think I’ve heard that the LaRouchies always claimed that there was a secret British conspiracy currently running the world, so I’d guess that Preparata sold lots of his books in those circles.
Somebody upthread had already asked me about the Preparata book, which I'd read a few years ago. I repeated my (very negative) verdict for me but since I put it under a MORE probably you and many others didn't see it. So I might as well repeat it again here:
Have you read “Conjuring Hitler” by Guido Preparata? It proposes the thesis that it was Britain (controlled by the international bankers, mostly Zionists) who was running the WWII show, and that Stalin would not act without Britain’s and the bankers’ consent.
https://www.unz.com/runz/american-pravda-understanding-world-war-ii/?showcomments#comment-3488251Replies: @Makia Freeman
Well, I ordered a copy of the Preparata book, and read it. I hate to say it, but he comes across as a total conspiracy-crank and a crackpot.
The book significantly references the short earlier Antony Sutton book on Wall Street/Hitler, which I’d brought a couple of years ago, so I dug it out and finally read it. Sure enough, Sutton also comes across like a conspiracy-crank and a crackpot.
I’m certainly not saying these books are totally worthless since they gather together lots of interesting references. But the candor and/or judgment of the authors is so dreadful, I just don’t think I can trust them on anything at all.
One interesting thing I’ve noticed about WWII conspiracy-cranks is that they’re usually utterly, *utterly* terrified of discussing the Jewish role in promoting the war, even though (as I cited in my article) the private statements of Chamberlain and numerous other key players put Jewish influence at the absolute center.
For example, neither Preparata nor Sutton have any entry for “Jews” in their detailed index, with Sutton for safety’s sake, even avoiding any index entry starting with the letter “J.” So you write a “conspiracy” book about Wall Street, Hitler, and WWII and have no index entry for “Jews”—ha, ha, ha. Quite a number of the key individuals Sutton mentions were Jewish, but you’d never know it from Sutton’s book.
Sutton also repeatedly mentions Hitler’s diabolical plan to conquer the entire world. Hmmm…
Meanwhile, Preparata focuses on the diabolical plot of the British elites to destroy Germany. Okay. But instead of simply attacking Germany when it was almost totally disarmed and helpless in the 1920s, they plotted to build up a very powerful German military under Hitler, and *then* start a war (and get defeated in 1940!) presumably because that was much more “challenging.”
Similarly, everyone knows of Parvus, the Jewish Marxist from Russia, whom the Germans used to provide heavy financing to Lenin’s Bolsheviks in hopes of promoting a revolution. The plan succeeded, and with their Russian allies in revolutionary turmoil, the British almost lost the war to Germany. Okay. But based on zero evidence, Preparata claims that Parvus was actually a *British* agent, who tricked the Germans into funding the Bolshevik Revolution and thereby almost winning the war. Those diabolical British!
Preparata also seems to believe that during the 1920s and 1930s, the British elites and the top Soviets were secret allies, both cooperating to build up Hitler’s military machine so as to better destroy Germany. He also believes that all the top British figures who seemed to be pro-German or friendly towards Hitler, from Edward VIII on down, were actually part of a diabolical anti-German British plot. Although everyone thought that Churchill and Chamberlain were bitter adversaries, they were actually secretly working together to destroy Germany by building up the German military into the strongest in the world.
I could provide a very long list of Preparata’s additional crackpottery, but it just isn’t worth it.
I think I’ve heard that the LaRouchies always claimed that there was a secret British conspiracy currently running the world, so I’d guess that Preparata sold lots of his books in those circles.
Hi Ron,
Regarding Sutton, I find his works to be quite valuable, regardless of whether he didn’t perceive the Jewish threat or didn’t have the courage to speak out against it. His work is very well researched and sourced. He pinpointed the key international banking families (many but all of whom were Jewish) and their machinations. The Jewish Rothschilds are at the center of it.
Others such as Carroll Quigley clearly demonstrated that the world was run via the Anglo-American Establishment and its Round Table with concentric circle. The inner contained a Rothschild.
“Jewish power” led by the Rothschilds has used countries like the UK and the US to push it agenda, but it is an entity unto itself, using nations and empires like a parasite uses hosts. Thus, the power Sutton, Quigley and Preparata described is that same power, just using Britain at that time as a way to achieve its goals.
The goals of :
1. Destroying (then occupying) Germany
2. Preventing a strategic German-Russian alliance
were only part of the reason for WWII. The overriding reason was:
3. The justification for a Jewish state carved out of or stolen from Palestine
If Britain and allies were to have attacked Germany in the 1920s, it would not have achieved goal #3. Additionally, the power that runs the world is very evil and cunning; it prefers to use deception and false flag attacks so as to pretend it’s the victim or the defender. It rarely comes out as the attacker because it needs to manipulate public perception in its favor. Building Germany up so as to goad it into attacking its neighbors would then give Britain and the US (led by the bankers) the excuse they needed to permanently bring Germany to its knees AND whip up antisemitism to justify Israel.
The concept of balancing world powers/alliances to as to create a longer war occurs again and again throughout history. The same thing happened after WWII when Jewish spy Victor Rothschild gave the Soviets nuclear knowhow stolen from Britain. The bankers make money selling arms to both sides and control the outcome by deciding who to give the most money/weapons to.
Well, I frankly think that the Preparata book was totally idiotic, mostly aimed at conspiracy-cranks.Replies: @Corvinus
Building Germany up so as to goad it into attacking its neighbors would then give Britain and the US (led by the bankers) the excuse they needed to permanently bring Germany to its knees AND whip up antisemitism to justify Israel..