The Unz Review: An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewC.J. Hopkins Archive
The Worst Literal Hitler Ever
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

So, the GloboCap-Resistance Minneapolis Putsch appears to have not gone exactly to plan. Once again, Trump failed to go full-Hitler, despite their best efforts to goad him into doing so. They gave it quite a good shot, however. It was more or less a textbook regime-change op, or “color revolution,” or whatever you call it. All the essential pieces were in place. All they needed Trump to do was declare himself dictator and impose martial law, so the generals could step in and remove him from office.

Unfortunately for the Resistance, Trump didn’t do that. Instead, he did what he usually does, which is make a total ass of himself on international television. Which … OK, was cringeworthy, but didn’t quite provide the GloboCap gang with the pretext they needed to perp-walk him out of the Oval Office. Which, needless to say, was incredibly frustrating. After four long years of propaganda foreplay, there we were, finally at the moment of truth, and Adolf goes and loses his erection.

This guy is the worst literal Hitler ever.

Still, as far as regime-change ops go, and given that this one was a domestic operation, so trickier than the usual foreign version, I’d give the Resistance a B+ for effort.

Now, before my “conspiracy theorist” readers get too excited about where I’m going with this column … no, this was not a “fake” uprising. There was an authentic uprising at the center of it. There’s always an authentic uprising at the center of every regime-change op, or at least the type that GloboCap has been carrying out and attempting recently. Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, Syria, the Ukraine, Bolivia, Venezuela; these things go pretty much by the numbers.

Here’s a quick breakdown of how that works.

First, you need your civil unrest, large-scale protests, rioting, looting, indiscriminate violence, and so on. Any number of “trigger events” will be sufficient to get this going. Once it is, you can grow it and focus it. A lot of this unrest needs to be authentic, so it’s best to conduct an overwhelming multi-year propaganda campaign to delegitimize and demonize your target as some sort of treasonous Hitlerian monster who’s responsible for every major problem in the country. That way, no matter which trigger event gets things going, it will be his fault.

You will want your local government officials to allow this civil unrest to go on until it reaches the point where rioters and looters are rampaging through the hearts of cities, raiding both high-end corporate chain stores and local mom-and-pop-type businesses, and brutally assaulting their defenseless proprietors. This does not mean that these local officials have to restrain or stand down their cops. On the contrary, you want them to unleash their cops, on the protesters, rioters, and TV reporters (during their “live” reports, if possible), and just generally beat the living crap out of everyone. The goal is to generate as much hatred as possible against the regime you are trying to change, and to pressure your designated Hitler-target into losing his patience and overreacting, so you want things to get extremely ugly.

Then, you unleash the power of the media to whip folks up into a mindless frenzy of rage against your designated Hitler. You have your “respectable” pundits publish articles calling for his removal from office. You get the military (and former military) to start making noise about how your Hitler is out of control and on the brink of fascism. Then you wait for your Hitler to overreact and attempt to call in the military and impose some form of martial law, at which point you can safely depose him, and pretend that democracy has won the day.

The media is essential here, because you need to convince the majority of the public (i.e., not just the people protesting and rioting) that things have gotten so out of control, and your imaginary Hitler has gotten so dangerous, that a military coup is the best solution.

What you’re looking for are headlines like these:

“We are teetering on a dictatorship” — CNN

“‘Words of a dictator’: Trump’s threat to deploy military raises spectre of fascism” — The Guardian

“Donald Trump is Trying to Start a Race War” — Rolling Stone

“Remove Trump Now” — Slate

“The Trump Presidency is Over.” — The Guardian

“Trump Must Be Removed” — The Washington Post

Also, while the media are doing their thing, you want to get any former members of the intelligence community (or the secret police) to issue public statements like this:

“There should be no place in American society, much less in our government, for the depravity being demonstrated daily by Donald Trump. Members of his Cabinet who enable such behavior are betraying their oath of office by supporting an increasingly desperate despot.” — John Brennan, former CIA director

Then you bring the politicians and the military in. This kind of language will usually do it:

“The fascist speech Donald Trump just delivered verged on a declaration of war against American citizens. I fear for our country tonight and will not stop defending America against Trump’s assault.” — Senator Ron Wyden

“These are not the words of a president. They are the words of a dictator.” — Senator Kamala Harris

“‘There is a thin line between the military’s tolerance for questionable partisan moves over the past three years and the point where these become intolerable,” a retired general said.” — The New York Times

“We must reject and hold accountable those in office who would make a mockery of our Constitution … We can unite without [Trump], drawing on the strengths inherent in our civil society. This will not be easy, as the past few days have shown, but we owe it to our fellow citizens; to past generations that bled to defend our promise; and to our children.” — General James “Mad Dog” Mattis, former Secretary of Defense

Once the generals have started in growling, you get the media to hype that, hard. Headlines like these will get people’s attention:

“Revolt of the Generals” — The Washington Post

“The Officers’ Revolt” — Slate

“President Donald Trump is facing an unprecedented revolt from the elite corps of ex-military leaders and presidents …” — CNN

“The US president’s desire to act the strongman poses urgent questions that America’s generals, voters and allies must all answer” — The Guardian Editorial Board

If you can, it is always a really nice touch if you can drum up … oh, let’s say 280 former national security officials who are really concerned about the state of democracy and “the misuse of the military for political purposes,” and get them to spontaneously call each other up and decide to write a letter together accusing your Hitler of “dividing Americans,” which the media can then disseminate, widely.

And, of course, what you need for the “educated classes” is an official propagandist like Franklin Foer (who broke the big story about the non-existent “Trump-Russia server” back in 2016 and was rewarded for his service to GloboCap with a lucrative staff writer position at The Atlantic) to come right out and explain that what’s happening is a textbook regime-change operation (because you don’t have to dupe the “educated classes,” most of whom will already be on your side). Something more or less like this:

“Twitter’s decision to label Trump’s posts as misleading was a hinge moment … once Twitter applied its rules to Trump — and received accolades for its decision — it inadvertently set a precedent … a cycle of noncooperation was set in motion. Local governments were the next layer of the elite to buck Trump’s commands. After the president insisted that governors ‘dominate’ the streets on his behalf, they roundly refused to escalate their response. Indeed, New York and Virginia rebuffed a federal request to send National Guard troops to Washington, D.C. Even the suburb of Arlington, Virginia, pulled its police that had been loaned to control the crowd in Lafayette Square. As each group of elites refused Trump, it became harder for the next to comply in good conscience. In Sharp’s taxonomy, the autocrat’s grasp on power depends entirely on the allegiance of the armed forces. When the armed forces withhold cooperation, the dictator is finished.”

As I said, it went pretty much right by the book.

After four long years of official propaganda designed to convince the Western masses that Donald Trump is literally Hitler, GloboCap, the liberal Resistance, and the corporate media all did their best to harness the authentic protests and rioting that routinely follow the murder of an unarmed Black person by the cops, and use it to remove him from office. It would have been a spectacular catharsis, a fitting climax to the War on Populism, but Trump refused to play his part … so, OK, maybe he’s not as dumb as I thought, or at least not totally suicidal.

No matter, it’s still a big win for GloboCap. Forcibly removing Trump from office is, and has always been, gravy. The main goal of the War on Populism is to delegitimize and demonize him, and everyone who voted for him (and Jeremy Corbyn, and even Bernie Sanders, and everyone who voted for them). Trump is just a symbol, after all. It’s the dissatisfaction with global capitalism (and its smiley, happy, valueless values, and its post-ideological ideology) that GloboCap is determined to crush, so they can get back to the unfinished business of restructuring the entire Middle East, and anywhere else that’s not playing ball, and dissolving what is left of national sovereignty, and transforming the world into one big marketplace, where there will be no fascists, no evil Russians, no religious extremists, no racist statues, no offensive movies, or books, or artworks, no more unauthorized ass-clown presidents, and everyone will be “contact-traced” with their digital health-certificate implants, and the children will stand inside their little “social-distancing” boxes and circles and sing the Coca-Cola theme song through their anti-virus masks at school …

Sorry … I got a little off-track there. I forgot that this was strictly about racism, and police brutality, and nothing else. I’ll try to stick to the script from now on, but it might be difficult, given my “privilege.” Maybe, if I wrapped myself in kente cloth and got down on my knees in public, that might help me get my mind right. Or, I don’t know. What do you think?

C. J. Hopkins is an award-winning American playwright, novelist and political satirist based in Berlin. His plays are published by Bloomsbury Publishing and Broadway Play Publishing, Inc. His dystopian novel, Zone 23, is published by Snoggsworthy, Swaine & Cormorant. Volume I of his Consent Factory Essays is published by Consent Factory Publishing, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Amalgamated Content, Inc. He can be reached at or

Hide 217 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. Biff says:

    That was a brilliant last two paragraphs.

    Encore please!

  2. The main goal of the War on Populism is to delegitimize and demonize him, and everyone who voted for him (and Jeremy Corbyn, and even Bernie Sanders, and everyone who voted for them

    Oh please. Bernie Bros were at the center of this insurrection. Is it mere coincidence that they acted out only weeks after their hero was officially eliminated from the race? Some of them even promised last winter that this was the game plan, as exposed by Project Veritas. They’re on video predicting major riots if he doesn’t win!

    And let’s stop pretending that they represent some populist movement. They’re communists, and a big proportion of them are only in Bernie’s corner for selfish, venal reasons — he will eliminate their student loan debt. Or would, if he ever got near the Oval Office. If someone promised to wipe away $100,000 of my debt I’d probably throw my toys out of the bassinet too if they didn’t win.

    • Agree: Z-man
  3. R.C. says:

    Good analysis.

    • Agree: Curmudgeon
  4. A123 says:

    No matter, it’s still a big win for GloboCap. Forcibly removing Trump from office is, and has always been, gravy. … . Trump is just a symbol, after all. It’s the dissatisfaction with global capitalism (and its smiley, happy, valueless values, and its post-ideological ideology) that GloboCap is determined to crush,

    Except it is actually the reverse. A big loss for the SJW Globalist DNC.

    The fast poll numbers are not toward looking. In a few weeks that media machine will move on to something else. Black voters will have to live with the failure of Blue City Mayors and Blue State governors. Burnt out stores and closed employers.

    The disband the police cry has already caused a major employer to jettison Minneapolis.

    St. Louis refused to jail criminals thus maximizing the risk to black voters and their property.

    Hopefully the end of the SJW Globalist DNC is here. They created racial hate to build their power. They lost control of the hate, and they are now powerless.

    No one believes their media shills anymore. Look at the string of headlines the author provided. Every one of those stories was ignored or treated as comedy by voters. It was a leading indicator of SJW dysfunction when Comedy Central’s The Daily Show became their #1 news source. Even the SJW’s themselves at some internal level no longer believe in SJW Globalist dogma.

    PEACE 😷

    • Replies: @Reg Cæsar
    , @obwandiyag
  5. Bro43rd says:

    One of the best authors on UR, keep up the good work Mr Hopkins! As civil society degrades at least we can have a good laugh with your material, TY.

  6. Chris Moore says: • Website

    So the ZOG fascists are continuing to cast Trump as Hitler, and continuing to project their own guilt onto their political enemies. The infiltrated and co-opted American establishment are ZOG fascists, and left-wing useful idiots don’t even see it. This is how the ZOG fascists hijacked Russia under Bolshevism, as well.

    The Russian “anti-Semite” Aleksander Solzhenitsyn who was once a Marxist true believer has a great quote that applies to all the left-wing useful idiots today:

    “And how we burned in the camps later, thinking: What would things have been like if every Security operative, when he went out at night to make an arrest, had been uncertain whether he would return alive and had to say good-bye to his family? Or if, during periods of mass arrests, as for example in Leningrad, when they arrested a quarter of the entire city, people had not simply sat there in their lairs, paling with terror at every bang of the downstairs door and at every step on the staircase, but had understood they had nothing left to lose and had boldly set up in the downstairs hall an ambush of half a dozen people with axes, hammers, pokers, or whatever else was at hand?… The Organs would very quickly have suffered a shortage of officers and transport and, notwithstanding all of Stalin’s thirst, the cursed machine would have ground to a halt! If…if…We didn’t love freedom enough. And even more – we had no awareness of the real situation…. We purely and simply deserved everything that happened afterward.”

    Until the sheep realize that ZOG is a fascist entity, the wolves will continue to enslave them. And then they’ll sit around in their concentration camps grinding their teeth about what fools and cowards they were. But if one could magically transport them back in time, knowing what they know now, they STILL wouldn’t act against ZOG — just as Palestinians wouldn’t act against the Zionists invading their shores in pre-’48, and are today sitting around their Gaza concentration camp grinding their teeth, and have been for the last 70 years.

    Such is the nature of the sheep, who truly need a violent, Moses-like shepherd who will deal with the biological entity ZOG in the only terms that ZOG can understand.

    But then ZOG will go into its “persecuted” shtick, alluded to by Hopkins in the article above.

    Alternately, the entitled “Chosen,” then the downtrodden “Persecuted” — the ZOG modus operandi.

    • Replies: @Curmudgeon
    , @Uomiem
    , @schrub
  7. @Bragadocious

    I so agree. Antifa surely was all in for Bernie, only to find out he didn’t have guts. They should have learned that the first time.

    • Replies: @Twodees Partain
  8. Cyrano says:

    What led to this current division in America is the wrong choice which the electorate made in the last election.

    Obviously they elected the wrong candidate (opposite to the wishes of the deep state) – and caused them tremendous pain and suffering,

    There is a simple way to fix the US electoral system. Let’s face it, the Americans have been spoiled for far too long with multitude of choices (2, sometimes 3). It’s easy to see how someone can get confused with such a myriad of choices.

    Why not simplify the process? In the next election field only 1 candidate – a real deep state darling, and let see if the Americans can manage to elect a wrong candidate out of a choice of 1. Stop giving them so many options.

    • LOL: Twodees Partain
    • Replies: @Nuzhat
  9. Look upon it as Soleimani’s Revenge.

    Lowlife Orange Man killed him, and his fans cheered.

    They did all that for Jewish Power, but Jewish Power pisses on the Orange Man.

    RIP Soleimani.

  10. @Chris Moore

    ZOG is a fascist entity,

    You could not be more wrong.
    Fascists actually improved the lives of working people. They nationalized banks, and stopped usury. They implemented universal health care. If it were fascist, there would be full employment and little or no immigration.
    The ZOG is purely in service to the moneyed interests who control the financial system. Not all wealthy people, but those who swear allegiance to a foreign entity.

    • Replies: @Chris Moore
    , @Anonymous
    , @Ace
  11. Thomasina says:

    Some economist I read said that the “average” student debt is approximately $10,000.00. Of course, there are many who owe a whole lot more, but will have the means to pay it off eventually.

    Most are definitely not carrying $100,000.00 in debt.

  12. Chris Moore says: • Website

    Fascists actually improved the lives of working people. They nationalized banks, and stopped usury. They implemented universal health care. If it were fascist, there would be full employment and little or no immigration.

    You’ve described Israel, in part. Israel is a quasi-fascist crime state.

    So maybe ZOG is a grifter-fascist entity — state socialism (guaranteed profits) for the “chosen”-connected bankers and industries, for the propaganda class (MSM), for the political class… with a vast welfare state, bought with table scraps and bitter, their rage directed at the ever-shrinking middle class and the deplorables, who are expected to play be free enterprise rules. And the MSM and political class make sure that the “racist” middle class and Christians are scapegoated.

    My point is the country is being run of, for and by a Zionist syndicate, with its lodestar being quasi-fascist Israel. And they pull inside jobs like 9/11 when they want an excuse for geopolitical theft and mass murder in Israel’s neighborhood, and an excuse to set up a domestic police state in the U.S.

    • Replies: @Commentator Mike
  13. My personal preference would be to see Trump crack down hard. But as you put it, he’s the worst literal Hitler ever. Couldn’t even have the looters shot with rubber bullets.

    • Replies: @Mr McKenna
  14. @Thomasina

    Some economist I read said that the “average” student debt is approximately $10,000.00.

    Whoever that ‘some economist’ was, it sounds like they were mixing numbers as required.

    The average student debt was $31,172 in 2019 (‘average’ being the total debt owed, divided by the number of individuals with student debt); this was at the end of a decade in which total student debt doubled.

    Like all wealth/income quantities, student debt balances will be distributed approximately lognormally, so the mode will be less than the median, which in turn will be less than the mean (i.e., the average).

    In fact the distribution is much more skewed than income: while ~33% of incomes are above average, only 25% of student debt balances are above the average.

    They might have been talking about the median, or perhaps was including graduates with zero balances. Apparently ⅔ of millennials have zero college debt – either they accumulated small balances that they’ve already paid off, or they somehow self-funded their tuition.

    The average is nowhere near $100k, though: according to the NY Fed, only about 3% of student loan balances are over $100k.

  15. I like your style, C.J. Hopkins, but no, this was not ALL about Trump. Also, I agree with Bragadocious that other than the black people out for destruction, free sneakers, and to get on a TV, the others involved are flat-out Communists. I see a close parallel to 1920s Germany here. That’s NOT to say anything about President Trump here, as you are right about the huge effort to take him down.

    Any Hitler remarks of mind would go more like, if you read about the Communists that planned to add Germany to their list of triumphs, after Russia (the BIG ONE), you see how a man like that could get very far in society. Perhaps we ought to think hard on how to avoid a repeat of that scenario, while still crushing the Commie bastards like the antifa-tards.

    That said, you write very well, with just a little bit of confusion on ideology. Oh, and no matter what the real cause of death will be determined to be, George Floyd was just another violent, worthless black man.

    • Agree: chris
    • Replies: @chris
    , @Tom
    , @Emslander
    , @anonymous
  16. haha says:

    Bravo! Brilliant!! When do we get the next article?

  17. Exile says:

    A much better piece than many of late from C.J. and a good description of the mechanics of Clown World color revolution.

    The only thing missing is what motivates this (((wealthy cosmopolitan elite))) that seems to have vested interests in the success of “GloboCap” and turmoil in the Middle East, Asia & South America alike.

  18. Rooster 3 says:

    Democratic city, with democratic mayor, democratic police chief, with democratic Anitifa, and Democratic BLM, destroy city… and blame Trump…. is there any other study needed to prove liberalism is a mental disease and TDS is real?

    • Replies: @Mr McKenna
    , @VinnyVette
  19. Wally says:
    @Priss Factor

    Except that Soleimani was a savage butcher, highly disliked by Iranians.

    Iranian Persecuted Christians: Majority of Iran Supported Soleimani Airstrike:
    Day 51 of Iran Protests: Iranians Celebrating the Death of Qassem Soleimani in Iran and Across the Globe :
    Regime officials confirm 1,500 killed in Iran’s nationwide protests:
    Iranian Celebrities Join Protesters in Challenging Oppressive Iranian Regime:

    much more:

    • Replies: @Priss Factor
    , @Ace
  20. chris says:
    @Achmed E. Newman

    Sorry, I agree right up to the last sentence, if you were to say GF was ‘a’ violent black man, ok.

    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
  21. Pft says:

    Still playing the Deep State out to get Trump again. Lol, those caught up in these false paradigms are never going to get it. This operation is all about those on top , the elite (wearing red or blue or green) against the rest of us to force change that will bring us into a Global Technocratic State, with the herd locked in their national pens.

    In his book, Machiavelli on Modern Leadership: Why Machiavelli’s Iron Rules Are as Timely and Important Today as Five Centuries Ago, Michael Ledeen proclaimed, “Change –above all violent change –is the essence of human history.”“Total war,” says Ledeen, “not only destroys the enemy’s military forces, but also brings the enemy society to an extremely personal point of decision, so that they are willing to accept a reversal of the cultural trends. The sparing of civilian lives cannot be the total war’s first priority… The purpose of total war is to permanently force your will onto another people.”

    Only this time the Total War isn’t being fought in Iraq, its coming home.

    Order out of Chaos. To create a New Order one must demolish the old order. Trumps a Trojan Horse of the so called Deep State and Democrats. Why do you think the Dems are running Demented Biden against him. They got their guy in already. He has done more for the elite in 3 years than any President-ever .

    Whats the purpose of the riots and anti-police protests? Create Problem -Get Reaction-Offer Solution. The solution will be privatized policer forces. 115 billion spent on police each year. Corporations owned by the elite want that action. Maybe Eric Prince is working on that now. Trumps all into public private partnerships. Democrats are too.

    Obviously the unconstitutional lockdowns Trump permitted and encouraged Governors to conduct helped energize the crowds (no work or school). With 1000 killings by police a year, 25% against unarmed people, it was just a matter of time before one got caught on video (more whites get killed than blacks but plenty of blacks too). Throw in some agent provocateurs to get them violent enough with excessive force from Israeli trained militarized police and results are predictable

    • Agree: bluedog, Harold Smith
    • Replies: @SolontoCroesus
    , @Ace
  22. DaveE says:

    FUNNY piece, Mr. Hopkins – Thank you. I needed a laugh and this was the best one I’ve had in a long time.

    Shlomo is mighty nervous these days – the Assyrians (or whoever it was that week) are closing in and they’re out of slings.

  23. @A123

    The disband the police cry has already caused a major employer to jettison Minneapolis.

    It was hardly “major”. The Target and Cub stores across the street employed more.

    But it could be the first drop of a tsunami.

  24. Ghali says:

    It is very strange comparison indeed. Hitler was a cultured, intelligent and educated leader, characterised by a humbled nature. By contrast, Trump is an oafish, supremacist and self-aggrandising narcissist who is uneducated and lacks the intelligence of a human.

    • Replies: @Sulu
  25. padre says:

    I think Trump is a bit confused, he is not sure, does he want to be Hitler or Mussolini!

  26. Nuncle says:

    This article was ignorant on so many levels. Hitler did not go ‘full-Hitler’ because he did not need to – he came to power by democratic and constitutional means. The enemies of the Nationalist Socialist state were rounded up in a relatively orderly manner and order imposed in a matter of a week or so. This was because his measures had the support of the overwhelming majority of the German people. Even those who did not vote for him were pleased to see law and order restored. And most of the action was in one city (Berlin). If you weren’t in Berlin at the time, you wouldn’t have even noticed.

  27. @Fidelios Automata

    C.J. Hopkins:

    I’d give the Resistance a B+ for effort.

    Funny, we call ourselves the Resistance, and the Establishment and Deep State call themselves the Resistance. Will the real Resistance please stand up?

    The fake one can remain on its knees.

    • LOL: DaveE
  28. Trump demands Seattle officials ‘take back’ cop-free protest zone

    President Trump on Wednesday night demanded that Seattle officials “take back” what has become a cop-free protest space in the center of the city.

    Demonstrators have occupied the roughly six-block Capital Hill area dubbed the “Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone” or CHAZ.

    Inside the zone people congregate as free snacks are reportedly doled out at a “No-Cop Co-op” and films on racial justice are screened at night.

    Trump on Twitter slammed Washington Gov. Jay Inslee and Mayor Jenny Durkan for allowing the area to be handed over to protesters he described as “domestic terrorists.”

    He also warned that he would take action if they did not shut the demonstration down.

    IMHO this is a tactical error. Trump should let the Dems’ cities wreck themselves. They are so determined to do so–why not let them stew in their own juices? Let Minneapolis and Chicago close down their police departments. I’ll bet they don’t actually have the nerve, but if they do, why should Trump get in between them and their destiny?

    He won’t come out of it looking good. He’ll just make himself even more of a target than he is already. I’m sure it’s frustrating for him to see the disaster unfolding, but he shouldn’t get in the way of this train wreck.

    • Replies: @Mr McKenna
  29. Tom says:

    Even real sharp guys like C.J. have to skip through hoops.
    He’s got to know those October Revolution Descendent J-Birds are behind this thing big-time.

  30. Tom says:
    @Achmed E. Newman

    Well said, but we are already in the Neo October Revolution. The only institution still not in the grip of Communism are local police departments. Once they are co-opted, it’s post October 1917 Russia all over again. Or as the chess players say ‘end game’.

    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
  31. In your formula for a colour revolution you forgot to mention unidentified snipers on the rooftops shooting at the rioting mobs. OK, they don’t always use them but where they have they have been effective at furthering the chaos that leads to regime change.

  32. @Chris Moore

    Israel is a quasi-fascist crime state.

    Lest we forget what Einstein had to say about this state, his letter to NYT below the tag


    Letters to the Editor
    New York Times
    December 4, 1948


    Among the most disturbing political phenomena of our times is the emergence in the newly created state of Israel of the “Freedom Party” (Tnuat Haherut), a political party closely akin in its organization, methods, political philosophy and social appeal to the Nazi and Fascist parties. It was formed out of the membership and following of the former Irgun Zvai Leumi, a terrorist, right-wing, chauvinist organization in Palestine.

    The current visit of Menachem Begin, leader of this party, to the United States is obviously calculated to give the impression of American support for his party in the coming Israeli elections, and to cement political ties with conservative Zionist elements in the United States. Several Americans of national repute have lent their names to welcome his visit. It is inconceivable that those who oppose fascism throughout the world, if correctly informed as to Mr. Begin’s political record and perspectives, could add their names and support to the movement he represents.

    Before irreparable damage is done by way of financial contributions, public manifestations in Begin’s behalf, and the creation in Palestine of the impression that a large segment of America supports Fascist elements in Israel, the American public must be informed as to the record and objectives of Mr. Begin and his movement. The public avowals of Begin’s party are no guide whatever to its actual character. Today they speak of freedom, democracy and anti-imperialism, whereas until recently they openly preached the doctrine of the Fascist state. It is in its actions that the terrorist party betrays its real character; from its past actions we can judge what it may be expected to do in the future.

    Attack on Arab Village

    A shocking example was their behavior in the Arab village of Deir Yassin. This village, off the main roads and surrounded by Jewish lands, had taken no part in the war, and had even fought off Arab bands who wanted to use the village as their base. On April 9 (THE NEW YORK TIMES), terrorist bands attacked this peaceful village, which was not a military objective in the fighting, killed most of its inhabitants ? 240 men, women, and children – and kept a few of them alive to parade as captives through the streets of Jerusalem. Most of the Jewish community was horrified at the deed, and the Jewish Agency sent a telegram of apology to King Abdullah of Trans-Jordan. But the terrorists, far from being ashamed of their act, were proud of this massacre, publicized it widely, and invited all the foreign correspondents present in the country to view the heaped corpses and the general havoc at Deir Yassin. The Deir Yassin incident exemplifies the character and actions of the Freedom Party.

    Within the Jewish community they have preached an admixture of ultranationalism, religious mysticism, and racial superiority. Like other Fascist parties they have been used to break strikes, and have themselves pressed for the destruction of free trade unions. In their stead they have proposed corporate unions on the Italian Fascist model. During the last years of sporadic anti-British violence, the IZL and Stern groups inaugurated a reign of terror in the Palestine Jewish community. Teachers were beaten up for speaking against them, adults were shot for not letting their children join them. By gangster methods, beatings, window-smashing, and wide-spread robberies, the terrorists intimidated the population and exacted a heavy tribute.

    The people of the Freedom Party have had no part in the constructive achievements in Palestine. They have reclaimed no land, built no settlements, and only detracted from the Jewish defense activity. Their much-publicized immigration endeavors were minute, and devoted mainly to bringing in Fascist compatriots.

    Discrepancies Seen

    The discrepancies between the bold claims now being made by Begin and his party, and their record of past performance in Palestine bear the imprint of no ordinary political party. This is the unmistakable stamp of a Fascist party for whom terrorism (against Jews, Arabs, and British alike), and misrepresentation are means, and a “Leader State” is the goal.

    In the light of the foregoing considerations, it is imperative that the truth about Mr. Begin and his movement be made known in this country. It is all the more tragic that the top leadership of American Zionism has refused to campaign against Begin’s efforts, or even to expose to its own constituents the dangers to Israel from support to Begin.

    The undersigned therefore take this means of publicly presenting a few salient facts concerning Begin and his party; and of urging all concerned not to support this latest manifestation of fascism.

    M. GALLEN, M.D.

    New York, Dec. 2, 1948

  33. Anonymous[423] • Disclaimer says:

    Fascists actually improved the lives of working people. They nationalized banks, and stopped usury. They implemented universal health care. If it were fascist, there would be full employment and little or no immigration.

    Hitler had an early welfare state financed largely by confiscations from his enemies (typical Left, actually).First he squeezed the Jews, then he squeezed conquered countries, which were pretty much looted. See:
    The book is Götz Aly, _Hitler’s People’s State – Plunder, Race War, and the Nazi Welfare State_, 2008, ISBN-10: 0805087265; ISBN-13: 978-0805087260

    I’ve read Götz Aly’s book, and it is very well documented. What Aly says happened, apparently happened.

    In any case, the US adopted the measures you suggest right after WW II (and called it the “mixed economy”). “Lector, si monumentum requiris, circumspice.”

  34. Petermx says:

    Maybe that is because Trump’s blood is only 50% German, the other 50% being British. That might also ex;plain why Trump lies frequently and murders Iranian leaders in cold blood. He’s very Churchillian.

    • Replies: @Chris Moore
    , @hillaire
  35. Herald says:
    @Priss Factor

    Look upon it as Soleimani’s Revenge.

    Lowlife Orange Man killed him, and his fans cheered.

    They did all that for Jewish Power, but Jewish Power pisses on the Orange Man.

    RIP Soleimani.

    Nothing too contentious there, simply laying out a few facts and of course, the more they piss on him, the more he grovels and tries to please. It’s always a win win for them.

  36. Anonymous[423] • Disclaimer says:

    Trump is following what Cassius Clay, later Muhammad Ali, described as “rope a dope”.
    In military terms, that’s called “trading territory for time”. In the article above, it’s called “being the worst Hitler ever”.
    Trump had decades of experience operating in NYC, a place notorious for bureaucracy and crime, organized and freelance. The result is that his opposition
    * has discredited its media arm,
    * half of its universities will (a) close and (b) no be missed, with the rest going lean on departments and staff,
    * All political entities hostile to Trump have severely frightened their inhabitants, severely reduced their tax base, promised to worsen conditions by abolishing police, thinly hiding that they have already run out of money, and looking like fools walking in circles chanting “We won the war!”.
    * The Federal bureaucracy has engaged in a criminal conspiracy, and the people who participated in that can now be charged for criminal acts, and the existing influence networks can be dismantled _within the clear intent of the criminal code_.
    * Trump’s opposition trying in public to corrupt elections by setting up massive vote fraud and visibly supporting street fighters.

    All in all, Trump’s opposition has weakened itself to an astonishing extent. Also obviously, this latest round of “old reliable” riots unmasked resources that would better have been saved until October or November, closer to the election. Revealed, they can be destroyed within the intent of existing law.

    Granted, the “rope a dope” strategy eventually failed long term, causing to brain injury. Trump is also running out of time/territory in which to practice his equivalent of rope-a-dope.
    However — if he’s reelected – he wins. As to successors should Trump win again, expect somebody like Flynn to be the next President because he’s qualified and can beat his chest and say “Behold! I have been wronged!”

    So expect even more desperate moves by Trump’s opposition. It’s now or never for them, use it or lose it.

    • Agree: VinnyVette
    • Replies: @Ace
  37. Anon[203] • Disclaimer says:

    C J,
    Thanks for helping me understand whats really happening and why. Great article!

    • Agree: Ace
  38. Anonymous[661] • Disclaimer says:

    Good article, Hopkins. I was indeed surprised (and glad) to see Trump resist the bait.

  39. geokat62 says:

    … no more unauthorized ass-clown presidents

    Trumpstein was 100% kosher-approved.

    • Disagree: Derer
    • Replies: @geokat62
    , @Derer
  40. @chris

    Well, thanks for the partial [Agree] then, Chris. Tell me, who was this guy worth something to, his kids that he hadn’t seen in years, society, including the woman whose gut he held a gun to, …?

  41. Z-man says:

    Biff says; That was a brilliant last two paragraphs.

    I disagree. I think the first two or three paragraphs were hilarious and great.
    I’m a Trumpster and I say that Donald should shut up ‘all the time‘ for putting his foot in his mouth. I’m also dissapointed when he says one thing on Tuesday and his kikenvermin son in law or his posture perfect tw’i’t daughter make him take it back by Thursday. He is not being served well by his advisors including the top kikenvermin Steven Miller. Donny’s walk to the Church was cringeworthy.
    But it doesnt matter, as the writer observed. The opposition, the MSM/Deep State/Globohomo/Neocon/Corporate/PC Cabal is so transparent and obvious that even low IQ BLM supporters will have second thoughts of voting for Sleepy Joe Biden.
    Populism is here to stay because the alternative is … just look at Italy. The American Demo’krat party is pretty much in charge of the Italian goverment right now, ‘Shit lib’/PC/Globohomo/Deep State types and the right wing populists are gaining in the polls even with some of their dubious pro corporate policies.
    Trump 2020-24… and beyond*! Brahahaa!!!

    *My favorite scenario is that (after Trump is re-elected when Biden trips over his shoes and goes into senile shock and is replaced by thug faced Mario Cuomo’s son) aunt ‘Nan Pelosi, ‘Up-Chuck’ Schumer and chinless Mitch McConnell all meet with ‘tragic’ endings either separately or in unison (like a ‘kiln’ explosion at a congressional cook off) and Donald, under emergency powers, dissolves congress and smoothly runs America until Rand Paul is appointed President in 2026. But he has to send his weird Orthodox Jew son in law and his ditzy daughter packing back to ‘NY City One’, Mar Lago or wherever. Bruuha!

  42. @Tom

    The institutions are indeed RUN by the Commies, Tom, but I don’t know if there is the amount of deep infestation of the institutions that Russia had in October of 1917. Perhaps it doesn’t matter what the regular people want, but I doubt the Russians of 1917 were as well armed as the Americans of 2020. I don’t know the answer.

    Speaking of the end game, though, Tom, I am not a chess player, but close to a serious chess player. The end game could be a lock for one side or the other, for for a draw, depending on how many of each piece is left on either side, but that’s all dependent on the winning (or drawing) party(s) doing it just right. Except for at the very top levels, I think we are dealing with sub-moron level individuals this time.

    • Replies: @Tom
  43. This notion that “the Generals” can remove Trump for calling in the military to suppress a riot is completely theatrical bullshit to make Trump look like he is “against” this government. Trump didn’t do anything because he works for the Jews who planned these riots. “Defund the police” is also theatrical nonsense that is not going to happen except in the sense that these local governments are going to go bankrupt eventually.

    ZOG needs Donald and white people to wage their wars, they need white people to support Zion Don the war-monger and they want to be able to pretend they were against it all along.

    Jared Kushner’s buddies probably have maps of all the places that were to be burned, they’re probably planning on shipping the blacks to spread chaos and carnage and destroy real estate values ALL OVER WHAT REMAINS OF WHITE AMERICA so as to make a killing on the burned out places they are going to buy for pennies on the dollar.

    • Agree: Uomiem
  44. Nodwink says:

    This Bernie Sanders?

    Bernie Sanders doesn’t agree with push to defund and abolish police departments, wants better training and pay

    What a hardcore anarcho-extremist!

  45. Hey CJ, as good as your article was, when you called the death of Floyd a ‘murder’, you have now aligned yourself with the very forces you seem to be railing against. Final grade: FAIL

    • Replies: @foolisholdman
    , @Ace
  46. mcohen says:



    You got the right kind of rage
    I see you’ve come of age
    You’re a burning hot keyboard warrior
    Oh the horror,the horror

    Twitter is your battle ground
    What’s that hashtag you’ve found
    Pulled it out the gutter
    A machine gun putter

    You fire those tweets off all day
    When the deplored come out to play
    But you better watch out
    This is no party boy scout

    Gonna take your toys away
    Then what will you say
    Your freedom of speech
    Eaten like a peach

  47. Skip the Kente Cloth, lest you be accused of cultural appropriation.

  48. Z-man says:

    My ‘princess’ of a daughter who hates me because of my political leanings has nevertheless saved me and herself thousands on ‘higher’ education. She decided to go to a ‘State’ school instead of a ‘private’ one. I quietly jumped for joy and wispered ‘whoopie!’ Because of big daddy her debt will be very little and my son after his US ‘world’ tour is back and in community college saving daddy even more, ahh… life is good.

  49. jadan says:

    Wondered who CJ Hopkins might be, so I read this piece. Is he serious or trying to make some political comedy? So long as he makes fun of Trump he thinks he can get away with promulgating one of Trumps favorite they’re-all-out-to-get-me scenarios. When you have to borrow your content from Trump, you’ve really hit bottom! When you trivialize the social unrest going on, you need to shut your stupid mouth. Won’t be curious ab out CJ Hopkinds again

  50. bluedog says:

    Ah yes where would we be without the communist we would have to dream up another boggy man, for after all the MIC and their hair brained puppets must have one to demonize as they pick the country clean.There’s no money for roads or bridges but always money for some super gun,there’s no money for railroads or high speed rail but always money for a trillion dollar duck that don’t fly,there’s no money to build new plants and factories because the 1% says they need the wealth from obscene profits made in some far off land, as they exploit the workers near and far. There’s no money to address poverty or the homeless camps but there’s always money for billion dollar ships,damn those communist anyway its all their fault if you don’t believe it just ask their puppets….

  51. bluedog says:

    Now I noticed that you didn’t name the name of that economist because without a doubt he fails to exist.Now the cost of going to just a trade school is over $30,000 this I know for a fact as the grandson just went thru one,and that a two year course so what does a four or five year cost,maybe in some far off land it may be so but not in the good ole U.S.A. where EVERYTHING should make a profit, so said St, Ronnie Reagan as he destroyed the not for profit health care system….

  52. bluedog says:
    @Achmed E. Newman

    Ah yes and now you sit in judgement but your kind always do,I wonder what those who sit in judgement of you would have to say,probably not for tender ears…..

    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
  53. Keep the surplus population buzzing, no matter what. The streets are the playing grounds. Divert all attention from what matters.

    Trump has no policies, neither the visible political organs, the media, they are designed to keep them(excess populations since the death of agriculture and industry who had a need for man power), “busy”. The author assists, willingly or not in his attributed task to make sense of what is not, is meaningless. To keep them “busy”.

    All real policies are obscured. The matter of our times is how to erase complex infrastructure, established modes of the middle class included, and surplus hominims. Corona marks the U-turn, from post industrial con-Z-umerism short-sighted and short term profiteering, to confinement and ultimately obligatory compaction of the bulk of the world population because there is no alternative. The elites should invite sympathy since they are in dire straights. An immense task to accomplish and still preserve their privilege. What they are undertaking is tearing down the edifice of Babel that was menacing their dominance. A scarecrow task.

    The elites “wealth” is build upon a “cardboard” world, the rain can make their “hard” assets soggy anytime. Again we should have some understanding, and sympathy for our rulers, try to grasp some of their well-meant intentions, since explaining, they will not. Rectal extraction should be tought in what is left of higher education.

    He who builds on information in the public domain, and aspires to be a cliometrician, is pulling his own leg.

  54. Trump is NOT going anywhere and he will be reelected because the business of Israel isn’t finished just yet. Only the Donald, under the guise of a tough guy, can deliver what so many an ass-licker in the Whitehouse has so far failed to deliver… even the rambling fool Joe Biden won’t be able to ignore the protocols regarding the unfortunate Palestinians observed by most nations, notwithstanding a desire to wash their hands off of both, the Arabs and the Jews.

  55. anon[330] • Disclaimer says:

    Is there anything more grotesque and pathetic than the modern “West”? Controlled by Jewish parasites at the top while nigger-worship is the main cultural glue. It would be a much better world had the Soviet Union nuked this bitch back in the 1970s.

  56. No More


    In the space in-between
    We declare sovereignty

    For if chaos cannot stand
    Neither can Souza’s band

    For duo parties no more
    You are a one-way store

    Power flows
    Power grows

    Everything on top
    Makes a local stop

    If you are mine
    You say
    Makes no difference
    How you play

    But that’s where you are
    That’s where we are

    For we have seen through
    Invisible no more
    We may close your store

    For you will see
    Power does not flow

    Stack the decks
    Give us more of the same
    Always your game

    Little twist here
    Little twist there
    Got news for you

    We’re not buying
    No more lying

  57. After much consideration about recent events, it seems to me that the country is having ANOTHER nervous breakdown. Of course, the whole planet is just one big asylum for the insane. Those of us who wish to go about our daily lives avoiding the violence and mayhem which erupt around us are awakening to the reality that this may not be possible for much longer. Perhaps it’s another outbreak of mass paranoia, or, possibly it may be a clarifying moment of reality ? Hard for me to determine being as I am after all, only one of the billions of inmates. But if I could, I’d have busted out of here a long time ago. As it is, I guess I will prepare for the worst as best I can, and keep a sharp eye out for the more violent sociopaths and psychopaths which populate the land, and infest “society” at EVERY level.

  58. Mefobills says:

    There are a lot of myths about Nazi funding.

    The Reinhardt plan, and later Schacht used “labor certificates” in the form of Bills. Oeffa and Mefo Bills were a form of credit at first, and later when discounted they found new Reichsmarks.

    The New Reichsmarks were a from of debt free money, which was then taken up in taxes.

    This is why from 33 to 38 the tax roles almost tripled. There is no way that confiscating existing money from Jews will make tax roles increase 3X.

    Here is a link that dispels some of the mythology.

    NSDAP and Fascist Italy were both mixed economy types, where STATE CREDIT channeled into industry and the commons.

  59. Oh, I almost forgot…while the inmates are convulsing…the REAL PROFESSIONAL THIEVING continues…right before OUR eyes….

  60. @follyofwar

    True, no guts but he has a lotta chutzpa. He ran a fake primary campaign for the ’16 election and sold out, the he had the chutzpa to try to do it again for the ’20 campaign. It took some real brazenness to try getting paid twice for the same silly looking move.

  61. Mefobills says:

    In any case, the US adopted the measures you suggest right after WW II (and called it the “mixed economy”). “Lector, si monumentum requiris, circumspice.”

    The “American System of Economy” was mixed economy, which ran mostly from 1868 to 1913. Prior to that it ran in Mass Bay, then Penn Colony, then under Washington and Adams.

    This form of mixed economy is also called Industrial Economy, where state credit channels into industry. The U.S. in the early years was a battle ground between finance capital and state capital.

    Frederick List took the American System to Germany, where it was later defeated in WW1 by Finance Capitalism out of London. The U.S. became finance capitalist and less “mixed economy” after 1913 progressive era acts. FDR briefly resurrected elements of mixed economy by spending into the commons and industry, but left in place Woodrow Wilson’s usurpation.

    And as an aside, just follow the Jew if you need to figure things out. Wilson was maneuvered to install finance capitalism into the U.S., especially by “British and Jewish” interests.

    NSDAP germany was probably the most evolved form of mixed industrial economy (American System).

    Mussolini nationalized the banks in 1926 because the bankers had been voting absentee stocks, thus swinging the markets, and taking unearned income for themselves.

    Right after WW2, U.S. adopted British/Jewish method more fully, which includes Atlantacism, Rim Theory and finance (wall street and london) controlling the world.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
  62. Tom says:
    @Achmed E. Newman

    I appreciate your thoughtful response. Russia was a mess at the time and ripe for the jackals of the Gangster Terror State. In the animal kingdom, predators always prefer the weak and wounded. Frankfurt School Marxists fled ‘30s Germany only to set up shop in Columbia University and elsewhere spreading their malignant theories of egalitarianism over the next 80-plus years.

    The scary thing today is that USA electronic media (Z-World) propaganda machine is now the equivalent of several divisions of tanks and bombers, all to take down the majority. The masters of mass psychology were Bernays and Freud, both from the same tree as Marx, Bronstein and thousands of their extended kin who seem genetically programmed toward Marxism. In the USA soft terrorism such as PC, has now given way to physical terror. Black trash and Antifa serve as the Neo Street Bolsheviks (ideology not necessary) of the Media/Corporatist leviathan, who desire a Marxist world culture. Whites, being such a tiny and disposable segment of the world population, are the natural oppressor class. The entrepreneurial brilliance they created will be sucked into the Marxist Corporate Monopoly vacuum cleaner. The West will be one giant grotesque Abstract Expressionist painting (yet another example of handiwork by those lying 2-facers of Western Culture). Satan is loose and the lie is his weapon of destruction.

    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
  63. @Thomasina

    True, but the ones carrying $100k would surely love to vote for Bernie. That’s the point, after all.

  64. Some crummy Hitler. The bum hasn’t even annexed the Sudetenland or got back the Polish Corridor yet.

    Trump was a big fish in the crooked world of New York real estate development, but now he’s swimming with the Great White Sharks at the very top of the imperial power structure, and doing a piss-poor job of it too. He does have the tenacity of a New York cockroach though, just can’t get rid of the nasty jerk.

  65. Emslander says:
    @Achmed E. Newman

    I thought for a while that we were like Germany in the twenties, but we’re not. We haven’t been defeated and then humiliated in war, yet. Our religious leaders no longer care about personal morality, only communal morality. We don’t have a populous that even cares about what’s going on. The Boomers living in the Villages think everything is hunky dory and enjoy NBC’s pap news programs that reassure them that all is perfectly fine. You mention $26T in national debt, increasing soon to $30T, and they laugh at you.

    We have a lot of pain still to go through before a leader arises and, I’m afraid, Hitler is gone.

  66. anon[210] • Disclaimer says:

    After four long years of propaganda foreplay, there we were, finally at the moment of truth, and Adolf goes and loses his erection.

    Biggest laugh I’ve had in months!

  67. TG says:

    Ha! Very amusing post.

    “Mr. Trump, my father fought Hitler, he knew Hitler, and you’re no Hitler!”

    They just don’t make fascists like they used to.

    But at least this little Hitler circus (“Hitlerzirkus” – gotta love those compound German words) will prevent us from noticing how the oligarchs are looting the country and driving the working class of all races into poverty, because noticing little things like that is clearly racist and an expression of white privilege.

  68. I’m all over the map when it comes to Trump. Honestly don’t know what to think. What I have come to realize he is one man with the entire bureaucratic aristocracy against him. No clue why except he ran on draining their swamp. Then I look at Kushner, and back to WTH is wrong with you Trump. Even with that, I have heard more talk about Jewish influence then ever before.

    Am curious, would it be Hitler like to build a wall around the new city-state of whatever was formerly know as Seattle? Naturally Trump acknowledges their independence first.

    • Replies: @Uomiem
  69. @Wally

    Wally worships Himmler and other Nazi butchers, but calls an Iranian savior of Syria a ‘butcher’.

    • Replies: @Wally
  70. Chris Moore says: • Website

    Maybe that is because Trump’s blood is only 50% German, the other 50% being British.

    The British half would also explain why he whored his daughter of to a Shylock.

    • Replies: @schnellandine
    , @Petermx
  71. neprof says:

    The irony of the past six months is that Sanders proposals, which were criticized because of their cost, have been dwarfed by the spending of late. The deficit last month was $1 trillion…for one month!

    What was spent as a result covid shutdown could have wipe out all student debt, provided medicaid for people making up to 40K a year. In short, Sanders’ proposals were cheap to what was past w/o thought in just a few weeks.

    Too bad (at least for his supporters) Sanders is wimp and didn’t man-up to the DNC after the ’16 elections, endorsing HRC.

    If a Populist does emerge, he/she going to have to be a real tough cookie.

    • Replies: @MarkinLA
  72. There is only one reason this Commie Putsch failed. White men with guns.

    • LOL: bluedog
  73. @Chris Moore

    why he whored his daughter of to a Shylock

    Might it have been a simple case of linking her more strongly to her mother’s heritage, if not part of his?

    pre/post nose job:

    • Agree: TheTrumanShow
    • Replies: @aandrews
  74. Petermx says:
    @Chris Moore

    True, and Churchill in particular was very close to Jews who paid him large amounts of money to attack Germany to the detriment of both countries and most of the world.

  75. ROTFL. What a time to be alive.

    • Replies: @Uomiem
    , @fish
  76. Uomiem says:
    @Old and Grumpy

    I’m all over the map when it comes to Trump

    Sounds like cognitive dissonance. You know Trumpstien is a pos but you want to believe in him

    Hopuim Crisis

    What I have come to realize he is one man with the entire bureaucratic aristocracy against him

    Why didn’t the gop even attempt to keep him out of office?

    How is he even still alive?

    Why did the democrats vote to expand his war powers?

    Why are the only people in jail or house arrest Trumps allies?

    Some more.

    Myth of Trump

    Snap out of it man

  77. schrub says:
    @Chris Moore


    “So the “ZOG fascists are continuing to cast Trump as Hitler”

    Is this an oxymoron?

    Fascism? Communism? I am bit confused. Which is which?

    I spent a few minutes researching this and I think I found a good definition of communism. It came from one of the early to mid twentieth century’s more influential and revered religious figures, Rabbi Stephen Wise of Chicago. His definition was simple and concise:

    “Some call it communism, I call it Judaism”.

    Simple huh?

    These people are Bolsheviks (Bolshies) not Fascists. Don’t confuse the two.

    • Replies: @Harold Smith
    , @Chris Moore
  78. Uomiem says:
    @Priss Factor

    A jogger was apprehended attempting to break into a home this morning…

  79. Mefobills says:

    Tedore, in Hitler’s Revolution says this about court historians:

    It would be more useful for the authors of such legends (lies about Hitler) to question for example why, after the victorious Allies established democratic governments throughout Europe in 1919, this state form became practically extinct there in 20 years. Russia, Italy, Hungary, Poland, Lithuania, Austria, Germany, Greece, Spain, Slovakia, and soon thereafter France adopted authoritarian regimes. Several of these countries closed ranks with Germany. Hitler gave viable, popular political form

    to a growing anti-liberal tendency on the continent

    . Volunteers from over 30 nations enlisted to fight in the German armed forces during World War II. Only by the sword did the Western democracies and their Soviet ally bring them to heel. Surely the motives of such men merit investigation. Simply dismissing the leader who harnessed and directed these dynamic human resources as a demented megalomaniac is no explanation.


    Populism today is anti-liberal which is why our finance and jewish oligarchy obsesses over Trump as if he was Hitler.

    Trump’s base is populist, but Trump is weak on authoritarianism, and butt-smoochios Zion.

  80. @Tom

    Thanks for the reply again, Tom. That was an excellent comment, especially that last paragraph and last sentence. Indeed the lies have been just so pernicious over the last few decades. They are the type of lies that take long to explain the falsehoods in, due to every premise involved being a lie itself.

    I think you are right that this war has been fought in the information world this time, and with a long massing of “troops” by the Communist side, while our side could/would not believe it was even going on the whole time. One could compare this to the Eastern Front of WWII also, as if the Germans had no idea that the USSR had massed their war machine for years before. So, Hitler struck first (and NO, I’m no fan of his – this is just about an analogy) Yet, none of our side has been striking at all against the left’s information war machine*.

    One could say that the American military was a shell and not at all ready for anything in 1940, but then flash forward to 1944 and look at the Willow Run Ford plant churning out an average of one Liberator bomber per hour! Could patriotic Americans come back from our position, or is it too late?


    * There’s probably a long German word for that. Anyone? “InformationWehrMacht”, I guess?

  81. I never understand the laser focus some of the writers have on Trump or any politician.

    He doesn’t matter, non of them matters.

  82. Shaman911 says:

    The Jews put a Hollywood actor in power for a reason. This was planned years ago!

  83. @bluedog

    Those who sit in judgement could look up my arrest record on-line, perhaps my credit score (just —-, as I don’t use credit, 20 years and counting without owing any money to anyone), and note that I haven’t robbed anyone at gun point, and never stolen anything since some Star Trek guns as a kid, and bubble gum… etc.

    Nah, I probably shouldn’t categorically put George Floyd in the “worthless” bucket, as you are right that his final judgment is not for me anyway.

    However, fewer George Floyd’s and more of me would make a more stable, safe, and productive America. I’m pretty sure about that. You are making me think, Bluedog, so thank you for that.

    • Replies: @Sick of Orcs
  84. You keep calling Trump an idiot Hopkins… But they can’t take him down. He must be doing something right.

  85. Robjil says:

    Our faux free press is our real Press/ident.

    Who ever is voted in is a puppet.

    If the puppet goes against what the Press wants,

    then the Press works on ways to get rid of that puppet.

    Same old game since 12 23 1913.

  86. Wally says:
    @Priss Factor

    – Except that your laughably alleged “Nazi butchers” did not do what you fantasize.
    And you have no proof they did. Simple as that.

    – And per the information I posted and you ignored, I suggest that you debate the masses of Iranian people concerning Soleimani.

    Unz Review readers can see ranting Priss Factor further sliced & diced here:

    That was easy.

    • Replies: @profnasty
  87. Marcali says:

    When and how many times was it that Hitler deployed troops against German citizens?

  88. A week ago I posted a 1600 word comment exactly along these lines:

    But CJ only takes it to Step 4:

    Coup phases:
    1- Attack & Weaken Economy
    2- Create riots, chaos
    3- Neutralize local Sheriff & Police Forces
    4- Recruit Military Generals
    5- Bring back old faces & prop them up as coup leaders
    6- Takeover

    Next is the Obamas rising from the ashes over in Kalorama to usurp the throne and calm a fevered nation. Finally, full-tilt Venezuela and kiss yer ass goodbye.

  89. anonymous[263] • Disclaimer says:
    @Achmed E. Newman

    Oh, and no matter what the real cause of death will be determined to be, George Floyd was just another violent, worthless black man.

    Whitevil scum like you will always find justification for the hateful ideology by which your diseased hearts throb, and the pestilential blood which courses through your veins.

    What really matters now is that the most evil entity on earth burns. That most evil entity, is what it is, because of gutter lowlifes like you.

    I pray that it burns to the ground. Fallujah comes to mind, but I will take whatever I can get.

  90. @schrub

    Maybe Rabbi Harry Waton can help clear up the confusion:

    “The triumph of fascism will be the triumph of the communist soul. But the communist soul is the soul of Judaism. Hence it follows that, just as in the Russian revolution the triumph of communism was the triumph of Judaism, so also in the triumph of fascism will triumph Judaism”

    (Waton, Harry. “A Program For The Jews And An Answer To All Anti-semites Program for Humanity.” New York: Astoria Press, 1939, p. 155. Print.)

  91. Chris Moore says: • Website

    These people are Bolsheviks (Bolshies) not Fascists. Don’t confuse the two.

    Was the British Empire Bolshevik too? Because Hebrew moneybags ran that in its later stages as well.

    Marxism was just another (materialist) layer of the Great Game. Some useful idiots (Hebrew and otherwise) are true believers, but most know it’s just another angle of Mammon/Power worship, another power grab, and they’re acting out their part for their portion of filthy lucre, only now they’ll be cashing in via “Globalism.”

    You can’t serve both God and Mammon. Which do you think the sick and corrupt WASP empire serves? Why do you think the WASP empire was so easily taken over by the Zionist empire?

    Marxism and Mammonism are two sides of the same coin, and Fascism is baked into that same coin, as is Globalism.

    If Germany had stayed true to “anti-Semitic” Christendom/Western Civilization of history, it couldn’t have lost the war to the Synagogue of Satan/Nest of Vipers because they never would have attained the power they did anywhere in Germany.

    Same goes for Russia.

    If the West is to survive, it must return to the “anti-Semitic” fundamentals of the Christendom that forged it. Half measures won’t cut it.

    • Replies: @Mefobills
  92. MarkinLA says:

    The last thing we need is wiping out student debt. Plenty of people get real degrees that makes it possible to pay the loans off. Many families sacrifice so their members don’t have huge debt loads. Instead we should subsidize people with worthless degrees – many of them part of this childish hysteria.

    • Agree: DaveE
  93. @Palerider1861

    How was that not a murder?

    • Replies: @Mr McKenna
    , @Curle
  94. Mefobills says:
    @Chris Moore

    Bolshies were funded into existence by finance capital.

    Jewish method is to use dialectic. Dialectic is no taught in publik skoooool, so the average westerner is easily duped by dialectic method.

    Fascism came into existence to fight against Bolshevism and its off-shoot, communism. It also came into existence to balance Capital vs Labor.

    Labor was a new category… a new class of people after the industrial revolution, and capital was abusing labor. Jews have always been attracted to capital, and are finance “international” capitalists. Claiming to be on the side of labor, is part of a dialectic.

    Below is a good definition of fascism, which is in alignment with HISTORICAL fascism. Both Mussolini’s Italy and NSDAP germany, were authoritarian fascist governments, where CAPITAL was below the polity. Corporations and Capital hidden string pullers were not allowed to rise up and control the affairs of state.

    Fascism is a form of government & social system which authentically serves the interests of the people and nation as a whole. The word “Fascism” comes from the Italian word “fascio” meaning “the group” or more specifically, “in consideration of the group.” Fascism is rooted in the notion that people must stay true to two mental concepts throughout their lives: 1) the individual’s needs (themselves) and, 2) the group’s needs (their nation)… always evaluating how their individual actions affect the group. Thus Fascism rejects the self-centered “me me me” mentality so common under Capitalism. For example, in a Fascist nation each person is expected to maintain a healthy diet & lifestyle. For if not, they may become seriously ill and thus require expensive health care; this would negatively impact the group (i.e., they’d become a financial burden on the nation).

    Continuing this line of thought, under Fascism all people of one’s ethnicity are considered the greater family of that person. Hence, a Fascist nation is thought of as one giant family of several million people. Therefore, just as one must not do anything to hurt their brother or sister in their immediate family, under Fascism one must not do anything which would hurt the nation/group (i.e., the greater family). This is the essence of Fascism: individualism balanced with a strong consideration of the group.

    The U.S. is not fascist, it is corporatism, where money and an ((in-group)) along with other monied interests control the polity for selfish gain.

  95. “This guy is the worst literal Hitler ever.”

    ROTFL! That’s like saying “apples are the worst oranges ever.”

    “Forcibly removing Trump from office is, and has always been, gravy. The main goal of the War on Populism is to delegitimize and demonize him, and everyone who voted for him (and Jeremy Corbyn, and even Bernie Sanders, and everyone who voted for them).”

    More nonsense.

    If the “establishment” didn’t want Trump in the white house, they would’ve run somebody more electable than Clinton against him in 2016.

    If the establishment didn’t want Trump in the white house, they wouldn’t have undermined Clinton’s campaign with a faux “investigation” into alleged email improprieties; nor would they have scared some disgruntled Sanders supporters into Trump’s camp by ordering their servant, Obama, to attack the Syrian army at Deir Ezzor in Sept. 2016.

    If the establishment didn’t want Trump in the white house, there would be some meaningful opposition to his actions and policies; e.g., there’d have been some serious political opposition to his withdrawal from the INF treaty.

    If the establishment didn’t want Trump in the white house, they would’ve included his various war crimes and other impeachable crimes among the impeachment charges against him and they would’ve removed him from office.

    If the establishment didn’t want Trump to stay in the white house, they would be running someone more electable than Biden against him in the 2020 election.

    Apparently the reason they want Trump in the white house is because he is so breathtakingly ignorant and stupid, so profoundly mentally ill and morally bankrupt that he can be manipulated into doing almost anything.

    “Trump is just a symbol, after all.”

    On the contrary, Trump is not just valuable to his “deep state” handlers, he is irreplaceable. His extreme value lies in his extreme manipulability. He is apparently willing to serve his handlers’ ultimata on the independent world and follow through, no matter the risks. Try getting a banal self-serving career political opportunist to risk it all for the extremists’ hopeless agenda.

    • Agree: Derer
    • Replies: @Wally
  96. Derer says:

    Trump can blow away those miserable crying insects anytime. The difference is, he is supported by the silent majority in this country, while those miserable power grabbing “hyenas” expressing their self-serving interests. Brennan?…he should be in jail or a straight jacket.

  97. Fat Orange is the weakest president we ever had. He’s also the last White guy to be president, though like all good #gop, pretends Whiteness doesn’t exist.

    • Replies: @Derer
  98. Chris Moore says: • Website

    Continuing this line of thought, under Fascism all people of one’s ethnicity are considered the greater family of that person. Hence, a Fascist nation is thought of as one giant family of several million people. Therefore, just as one must not do anything to hurt their brother or sister in their immediate family, under Fascism one must not do anything which would hurt the nation/group (i.e., the greater family). This is the essence of Fascism: individualism balanced with a strong consideration of the group.

    And there comes a time when members of that family WILL do something to hurt the family, out of greed or out of ambition or out of lust or out of misguidedness or out of grievance or out of orneriness or just because they are sociopaths or in some way stunted or warped…

    Under Christian civilization, these renegades would have been shunned, marginalized, sent to the back alleys to do their dirty deeds or sell their pornography or practice their Voodoo. In extreme cases, more extreme measures were called for, as when Moses brought out the long knives against the Hebrew hedonists and nihilists and stunted materialists.

    There will always be problematic people and groups, no matter what. The question is, how does a civilization deal with them?

    Christian civilization has a bias toward “turn the other cheek,” but when forced to, will get out the long knives.

    I believe we are at that point today. But Fascism will simply turn America into an Israel-like police state and global trouble maker.

    Remember, Hitler also played the “Chosen”/”Persecuted” shtick that the Zionists are experts at. I’m not saying a Fascist-like system shouldn’t be implemented in parts of Europe, just as I’m not calling for all-out war on Israel, but as the moral authority of the West, neither Zionism/Marxism nor Fascism would work.

    • Replies: @Mefobills
  99. @Achmed E. Newman

    Saint Carotid was hardly worthless, he employed police, jails, lawyers, judges, prisons and finally the funeral industry. To the State he ranked higher than lowly taxpayers.

    • Replies: @Achmed E. Newman
  100. Wally says:

    Thanks for proving what most already know.

    – You’re in denial of scumbag Floyd’s lengthy violent criminal record.

    – You’re in denial that there is absolutely no proof that his death was due to “racism”.

    – You’re in denial of the fact that it is Euro-whites who are the ones being subjected to “systemic racism”, as proven by black on white violent crime statistics and deaths of whites caused by police statistics.

    – Leave it to a low information Communist like yourself to label fighting back as “hateful ideology”.

    That “hateful ideology” must be why the US is the no.1 preferred destination of ‘immigrants’.

  101. Wally says:
    @Harold Smith

    “On the contrary, Trump is not just valuable to his “deep state” handlers, he is irreplaceable. ”

    – LOL. That must be why they so desperately want him out.

    – You’re making no sense.

    Good news:
    Trump to Resume Iconic MAGA Rallies Within Weeks
    Donald Trump Signs Exec Order to Curb Big Tech’s ‘Unchecked Power’
    Trump Signs Executive Order Stripping Social Media Companies Of “Liability Shield”

    • Replies: @A123
    , @Harold Smith
  102. @Sick of Orcs

    Ahaa, the old Broken Windows economic theory of the Keynesians – second time I fell for that this month!

  103. @anonymous

    Tell that to the woman George Floyd forced a gun to the stomach of, to rob, #263. I happen to be close to agreeing with you on that evil entity, the US Feral Government. However, I’m hoping we Americans are the ones to burn it to the ground, not racetards like yourself. Have your people even discovered fire yet?

  104. fish says:
    @Priss Factor

    …….Justin Trudeaus Press Secretary and Chief of Staff had no explanation for Mr. Trudeaus inexplicable behavior.

    “It’s just something he enjoys doing……Blackface. We don’t know if it was a traumatic incident during childhood…..really we have no idea!”

    The Prime minister is expected to retain his office despite this horribly offensive habit.

    Now here’s Bob with the local weather.

  105. A123 says:

    The GOP is considering moving the GOP convention to Jacksonville, FL.

    If they can catch a break versus rain, Trump could make an outdoors acceptance speech with a crowd of 90,000+.

    PEACE 😇

  106. Mefobills says:
    @Chris Moore

    Remember, Hitler also played the “Chosen”/”Persecuted” shtick that the Zionists are experts at. I’m not saying a Fascist-like system shouldn’t be implemented in parts of Europe, just as I’m not calling for all-out war on Israel,

    Nobody in the West is calling for all out war on Israel, that is Jewish projection… the fear centers of their overactive amygdala. Of course if Jews keep pushing and destroying civilizations as they are wont to do, then their “fears” may come true.

    National Socialism was securing a CHRISTIAN Europe against Bolshevism. The entire Waffen SS movement was Europeans working together against godless Bolshies.

    page 269

    In Amsterdam, 50,000 people attended an anti-Communist rally in support of the German war effort. Regarding Scandinavia, the SD reported, “The German-Russian conflict has turned attitudes in Norway more favorably toward Germany. . . . There are countless volunteers for the SS Nordland regiment.” In Belgium, “Flemish nationalist circles are unconditionally on Germany’s side in the struggle against Bolshevism.”59 Eventually over 20,000 Flemish served in the Waffen SS, many joining to combat “the arch-enemy of Christian Europe” in the East.60 The Swiss journalist Armin Mohler wrote, “They came because they hoped for the German Reich to forge a unified Europe of free nations. They wanted neither a commissar state nor a society of everyone competing against one another. There was much idealism then, such as is really only possible among the young

    Trump is not fascist, and is not at all like Hitler, other than being a populist. Further, the U.S. is in the pocket of Zion,and is finance capitalist. The better historical analog for the U.S today is Weimar Germany before national socialism (fascism). The U.S. also has an internal Jew problem the same as Weimar.

    The internal enemy is to be feared more than the external.

  107. This is a push for a Communist Revolution. No more and no less.
    I:n 1917 Jacob Schiff financed the Bosheviks (Read: Jewish Communists) with 20$ million. Now it is Soros and his massive NGO network.
    Back then the Jews looted Russia AFTER they achieved power. Killing Christians became a norm. ‘Anti-Semitism’ was illegal and no synagogue was torched. Churches, priest, monks and monasteries were, however, all fair game.
    Now their is so much Jewish power that the looting has largely already taken place (started in September, 2019) and ConJob19 and rioting have served to prevent the masses from even thinking about that.
    This is an extremely well planned and well executed looting operation by Jewish finance (Wall st. investment banks and the big daddy Rothschild Federal Reserve private central bank), hidden from the masses by Jewish Propaganda (Sulzberger’s, Zucker and the rest of the Jew owned mass media) and supported by all the bought and paid for sell-out politicians, celebrities and other assorted vermin.
    The saddest part of this whole affair is the black community. The riots will split the community between those who understand they are being used and screwed and the moron faction which thinks getting free shoes is awesome and Wakanda is coming soon. If it wasn’t so sad it would be laughable. It must be hard to be part of a community represented by Al Sharpton type hustlers and race baiter. Then again, Middle America gets RINO’s who seem happy to take AIPAC money then sell their Bill of Rights away.
    Something needs to change. Kneeling is weakness. Kneeling isn’t going to help anyone.
    America needs leaders who stand for something. Perhaps it is time for America to lead and hopefully Washington, D.C. and the state legislators will follow.
    This has been the year of the HOAX: the COVID 19 hoax (necessary to hide the financial meltdown), Federal Reserve Hoax (caused by greedy Jewish thieves) and the Floyd Hoax (the video is an absolute hoax; see for a detailed breakdown) absolutely required to divide and distract America.
    I firmly believe that there is a huge political backlash coming in November and, if attempts are made to rig the election, there will be more violence but coming from a different group with legitimate grievances.

    • Agree: anon8383892
    • Replies: @anon8383892
  108. @Pft


    Ledeen on Machiavelli is a blasphemy, an obscenity, an outrage; the oft-repeated Jewish trick of debasing a European – Italian thinker to suit Jewish evilness.

    Try Maurizio Viroli on Machiavelli if you want to understand The Prince as well as Niccolo the man and his enormous contribution to the intellectual foundation of European western civilization.

  109. hillaire says:

    No such thing as British blood …you are showing your general American ignorance of other cultures old boy. Britain is an archipelago of which Great Britain is the largest island, no it’s not pretense to greatness. The closest to British blood would be the welsh, inhabitants of said island at the time of the Roman occupation,though according to myth descended from the trojans who alighted with Brutus.
    the Angles and Saxons from whom the majority of English descend, were well, Germans.
    the Scots…. picts and scandinavians, Churchil half jew through his mother jenny jerome, american socialite.

    • Replies: @Hibernian
    , @VinnyVette
  110. @Mefobills

    The internal enemy is to be feared more than the external.

    That internal enemy is a fifth column of Israel.

    Your solution is eye for an eye. My solution is Christian imposition of the rule of law on difficult, lawless, savage peoples, Hebrew desert raiders, and British-heritage pirates — if they want to dwell in the West.

    • Replies: @Mefobills
  111. @steinbergfeldwitzcohen

    Don’t go appealing to leadership from on high, unless it’s really heaven. Media stars and federal political kabuki drama is meaningless. The more they can suck people into that drama, the less empowered those people can be locally, which is the only place anyone can apply their real political power and sovereignty, directly. Everything else is animated by what is channeled up the chain. No one wants to take responsibility at ground level, they just appeal for a takeover by the good guys at the top, but how would they know if they’re actually good guys? Epistemological problem, only solved by having direct local sovereignty which is represented then at the state and federal levels. Nothing wrong with Wakanda, or the La Raza state, or the SJW state, or the WN state, or any of them. They got them all crammed in together like rats and the rats just want to kill each other. Just need some space. The “Union” implies differences to unite. Don’t fear the differences.

  112. @bluedog

    I could rebut all those points but why bother…I’ll just say look at the losers in Seattle to see communists in action. Never built anything, incapable of building anything, broken people whose only “goal” is to appropriate that which doesn’t belong to them.

  113. Derer says:
    @Sick of Orcs

    What are you doing? It appears “only White guys are racists” is a big lie. Are you insane suggesting Trump is the weakest president. Why then sniveling Democrats are going berserk for 4 years.

  114. Hibernian says:

    Jenny Jerome was Jewish because…

    The Jeromes were rich.

    Dad was a financier.

    The name sounds Jewish (to some people.)

    There’s a street, Jerome Avenue, named after the family, in the Bronx.

    In other words, she wasn’t.

  115. @Mefobills

    Profound historical and psychological insights unique to the experience of this reader which both 1) make compelling sense; and 2) fit right in with God Incarnate Jesus’ words beginning at John 8:44:

    Bolshies were funded into existence by finance capital.

    Jewish method is to use dialectic. Dialectic is no taught in publik skoooool, so the average westerner is easily duped by dialectic method.

    Fascism came into existence to fight against Bolshevism and its off-shoot, communism. It also came into existence to balance Capital vs Labor(*).

    Labor was a new category… a new class of people after the industrial revolution, and capital was abusing labor. Jews have always been attracted to capital, and are finance “international” capitalists. Claiming to be on the side of labor, is part of a dialectic.

    The truth always fits together.

    *Isn’t that sentence intending to say “It also came into existence to fortify Labor in the face of (((Finance Capitalist))) abuse?”

    • Agree: Mefobills
  116. Derer says:

    “Whitevil scum like you (Achmed Neman) will always find justification for the hateful ideology”

    Actually that “hateful ideology” is well reflected in your sentence. BTW be happy that “whitevil scum” give you some breadcrumb so that you go not hungry.

  117. @Wally

    “‘On the contrary, Trump is not just valuable to his “deep state” handlers, he is irreplaceable.’

    – LOL. That must be why they so desperately want him out.”

    That’s just a bare assertion.

    First, if “they” were so desperate to get rid of him, they’d get rid of him, wouldn’t they? They’d do things like run electable candidates against him. They’d do things like impeach and remove him for his impeachable war crimes. They’d do things like unleash the talking heads against him for withdrawing from the INF treaty and starting a nuclear arms race which will likely end in nuclear war, etc.

    They don’t seem to care at all that he’s leading us to planetary extinction by way of nuclear war, but they simply will not stand for his promotion of hydroxychloroquine to treat COVID-19? Surrounding Russia and China with intermediate range nuclear missiles is right as rain, but touting a drug that may save lives at a time when no other treatment is apparently available is a crime against humanity?

    Doesn’t this kind of “opposition” seem a little ridiculous to you?

    Second, if “they” were so desperate to get rid of him, there’d be some hint of an actual reason for it (i.e. something other than they just don’t like his face), right? I’m still waiting to hear some cogent explanation as to why they’re so *desperate* to get rid of him when they seem to offer no meaningful political or legal opposition to any of his policies.

    “– You’re making no sense.”

    Well I’m not the one here making bare assertions; you are. I admit I could be wrong, but if you’re to convince me, you’ll have to propound some kind of an argument in support of your claims; hand-waving alone won’t suffice.

    • Replies: @Wally
    , @Authenticjazzman
  118. Derer says:

    “I’ve read Götz Aly’s book, and it is very well documented.”

    You still do not know that all information about Hitler is falsified. Even his own Main Kampf subsequent additions are falsified to make him evil.Where were those “exceptionally smart” losers that he defeated in the arena of thoughts.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
  119. @Mr McKenna

    Tucker Carlson, whom I admire very much, has wondered how Seattle authorities have been ‘so weak’ as to let this happen.

    That is a good question, but now that it has happened I believe that the state and federal authorities should leave them alone. If people are being raped and killed in CHAZ then the officials will have to get involved, of course, but otherwise they should be left to their own devices.

    Raping and killing are this guy’s exceptions. How on earth do we draw the line? One problem is our (taxpayers’) liability whenever the inevitable ‘bad things’ do happen in the CHAZ and/or other zones like it, which are bound to pop up. It’s a real dilemma, because while I really do want them to stew in their own juices–it’s the only way they’ll learn–we cannot disavow all responsibility if only for the reason given above: we’ll be soaked.

  120. Please give a break to Hitler. God bless his soul.

  121. Pianki says:

    Trump is my choice in 2016 and this year. He does not take any Crap and he sticks to his promises. His campaign issues were dead on.

    • Replies: @schnellandine
  122. @Rooster 3

    Democratic city, with democratic mayor, democratic police chief, with democratic Anitifa, and Democratic BLM, destroy city… and blame Trump….

    Thank you. A quote worth saving, and remembering.

  123. @foolisholdman

    Do you really need explanations? First of all, no premeditation. Note that the guy who claimed they had bad blood between them from the club has now admitted he made it all up. Second, Floyd didn’t die until he was in the squad car. Third, near as can be determined (by the coroner) he died of a heart attack brought on by stress plus multiple chemical intoxication. Does that sound like murder to you? Is all of this new to you? Really?

    Leaving all of that aside, if you insist, do you really think Chauvin would pose for the camera if he thought the guy under his knee was dying? Really?

    A ‘witness’ is claiming that Floyd did not resist arrest despite that resistance clearly evident in video recordings.

    None of this excuses either man’s behavior. But seriously, really?

  124. @Pianki

    and he sticks to his promises

    Ha! He’s the most blowharding do-nothing president of my lifetime—a big-talking Twatter poseur/traitor. If he ever was genuine in intent, something got to him before the inauguration.

    His appointments suck.
    His sick devotion to Twatter bragging and lying sucks.
    His betrayal of those most in support of his supposed agenda sucks.

    He’s a disloyal nepotism junkie and Israel-first fraudster who reads aloud at a level somewhere below that of a proficient 2nd-grader. He promises the moon, then stabs supporters in the back. I hope he’s trounced in November; will be dancing in the street, assuming most of us aren’t in labor camps / graves.

    • Agree: Achmed E. Newman
  125. Incitatus says:

    “So, the GloboCap-Resistance Minneapolis Putsch appears to have not gone exactly to plan. Once again, Trump failed to go full-Hitler, despite their best efforts to goad him into doing so.”

    “Putsch’? Looked more like four cops snuffing a shacked black man and resultant riots.

    “They gave it quite a good shot, however. It was more or less a textbook regime-change op, or “color revolution,” or whatever you call it. All the essential pieces were in place. All they needed Trump to do was declare himself dictator and impose martial law, so the generals could step in and remove him from office.”

    Really? Thank goodness Tiny-Hands, secure in his bunker, then photographed with daughter-supplied Bible, resisted. What a (bone-spur) man of courage!

    “No matter, it’s still a big win for GloboCap. Forcibly removing Trump from office is, and has always been, gravy. The main goal of the War on Populism is to delegitimize and demonize him, and everyone who voted for him.”

    Except Trump is a dime-a dozen media-narcissist-oligarch and no “putsch” is forthcoming.

    Other than that, great article.

  126. aandrews says:

    “Maybe, if I wrapped myself in kente cloth and got down on my knees in public…What do you think?”

    Totally lame and unauthentic. The true example has been set by the twenty-something Jewish mayor of Minneapolis, “crying” his eyes out in front of the golden casket at George Floyd’s funeral. Anything short of that will be troubling and cause for concern.

  127. Wally says:
    @Harold Smith

    Regardless of your TDS you simply cannot hide the fact that they want nothing more than to get rid of him, and they have offered numerous reasons, have made numerous failed attempts to do just that.

    – I remind you that the Deep State in NOT infallible. in fact they have proven that fact.
    – They tried ‘Russian collusion’.
    – They tried impeachment. Thanks for mentioning it.
    – They tried blaming the CV19 pandemic on him, even though he was the one who fought it.
    – They tried the hydroxychloroquine lie. Thanks for mentioning it.
    – They’re desperately organizing anti-Trump voting fraud.
    – Practically all “talking heads” are against him.
    – Many others didn’t like INF Treaty, so what?
    – What nuclear war is he threatening? Show us his “threat”.
    – Agreed, Hillary and Biden are idiots. It’s all the ‘Marxist – Democrats’ have. LOL

    The Complete Collusion Against Trump Timeline:
    The curious timeline for taking down Trump
    Democrats fail AGAIN in scheme to remove Donald Trump from office:
    Dems last gasp to smear Trump:

    • Replies: @Harold Smith
  128. aandrews says:

    Looks like the carpet doesn’t match the drapes, too.

    • Replies: @schnellandine
  129. Mefobills says:
    @Chris Moore

    Your solution is eye for an eye. My solution is Christian imposition of the rule of law on difficult, lawless, savage peoples, Hebrew desert raiders, and British-heritage pirates — if they want to dwell in the West.

    My solution is two part, both of which are a “kindness.”

    1) Removal using the money system. I have outlined how to do that in my comment history.
    2) Use Justinian law to restrict remaining troublemakers from sensitive organs of our civilization. Namely: Politics, Government Jobs, School Teachers and Education, Money Counting or Money Creation.

    No way a liberal “democratic” type society has the “sack” to limit in-groups from doing damage, and to expel troublemakers.

    I don’t advocate eye for an eye, that is Jewish and Muslim base thinking.

    People have implanted false memories in their heads about fascism and national socialism is. Usually they cannot even define fascism if you ask them. It wasn’t the Fascists that were aggressors bent on war.

  130. chinoche says:

    The National Security State realizes that Trump is a racist liability. That’s why they are pushing Black Lives Matter as an instrument to show we in the United States are not racists. Confederate symbols are being torn down for the world public to observe. This is needed to fight the Hybrid War against China and continue the wars in the Middle East along with expansion of NATO eastward towards Russia.
    It’s similar to LBJ signing the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and escalating the racist war in IndoChina
    We will see if the same rallies will be organized in opposing US Imperialists Wars around the world.

  131. @aandrews

    I’ll leave that to you!

    Cor blimey, what a detestable robot she is.

  132. Fox says:

    If it’s in the Spiegel (leftist German rag, licensed to be fit to be printed by the American occupational administration in Germany in 1946, preferred source of pre-chewed opinions by the virtue-signalling crowd having passed through university “education” in the FRG), and if it’s from G.Aly (a Hebrew), then it must be authoritative, mustn’t it?
    I think the commenter named Mefobills can tell a lot of how Germany’s liquididy came about after Hitler became Chancellor. It was certainly not by confiscating anyone’s assets.

  133. @A123

    You are an idiot. You didn’t even get the article. Didn’t even comprehend it. You are just another one trying to move the conversation back, ever again, to niggerniggernigger all the way home.

    Thus, you are a troll. And I mean one who works for what Hopkins calls “Globocop.”

  134. @bluedog

    bluedog it’s very clear you’re just a big fat commie stooge. Stop trying to fake us out. It short-circuits our 40-watt bulbs. Play fair.

  135. @Wally

    “I remind you that the Deep State in NOT infallible. in fact they have proven that fact.”

    Did I suggest otherwise? No, so you don’t need to remind me. Of course they’re not infallible; they’re evil, and evil ultimately destroys itself.

    “– They tried ‘Russian collusion’.”

    It was political theater.

    “They tried impeachment. Thanks for mentioning it.”

    Thanks for thanking me, but the “impeachment” was only for show; it was political theater. Otherwise, his impeachable war crimes would’ve been included in the charges against him, for example.

    BTW if “they” are really out to “get him” why doesn’t he fight back by demanding an investigation into 9/11 for example? I’ll tell you why: because it’s all political theater.

    “– They tried blaming the CV19 pandemic on him, even though he was the one who fought it.”

    LOL! Well who else should get the blame for his prime time mishandling of it, the man in the moon?

    “– They tried the hydroxychloroquine lie. Thanks for mentioning it.”

    Thanks for thanking me, but it was political theater, just like everything else.

    “– They’re desperately organizing anti-Trump voting fraud.”

    Or so you desperately claim.

    “– Practically all “talking heads” are against him.”

    Well of course they are; why wouldn’t they be? The problem is that they ignore the worst things he does, e.g., committing heinous war crimes which risk WW3, killing Venezuelans and Iranians with sanctions, seizing Syrian oilfields, exiting nuclear treaties, needlessly provoking Russia and China at every opportunity, abandoning the doctrine of MAD, etc. He sets us up for an eventual nuclear showdown while they scream about hydroxychloroquine. And you pretend it’s real.

    “– Many others didn’t like INF Treaty, so what?”

    ROTFL! Seriously?

    “– What nuclear war is he threatening?”

    A nuclear war kind of nuclear war.

    “Show us his ‘threat.’”

    If observation and common sense reasoning are insufficient, what kind of evidence do you need to see?

  136. @Priss Factor

    RIP Soleimani.

    I’m glad you’re dead, Soleimani.

  137. Nuzhat says:

    Excellent. Thank you.

  138. Anonymous[944] • Disclaimer says:
    @Achmed E. Newman

    who was this guy worth something to

    GF was worth a considerable amount to the bureaucracies charged with handling him, and to the City governments in which these bureaucracies lie.

    Here’s a joke to use as a mnemonic:

    A High School class is taken to a Federal courthouse. They are impressed by the building, and are taken inside. They get a lecture on the Department of Justice, the various courts, the Federal and local enforcement agencies, the size of the prison population, and are then taken down to a trial in progress. The trial hasn’t started, and the students are impressed by the judge’s podium and the people standing by, with a prisoner, waiting for the judge. The teacher describes the total budget of the DoJ, and its importance to the Nation.
    Then the prisoner raises his handcuffed hands, and said “Yeah, but _I’m_ the guy who makes it all happen!”

    • Thanks: schnellandine
  139. I’m basing my conclusion on Trump’s record (No wall, no curtailing immigration, etc.)

    I like the guy but don’t see real leadership coming from the WH. Trump and the Grand Ole Pissdrinkers had TWO YEARS to pass anything unopposed and did nothing.

    Craftier leftists long ago concluded Trump is a toothless shit-tweeter but still need to unite their kooks with sensational hatred.

    All is vanity anyway, friend. Demographic terrorism ensures even if Trump wins again. he’s the last White president. Be of good cheer! Buy arms. We were never going to vote our way out of this.

    • Agree: Achmed E. Newman
  140. Anonymous[944] • Disclaimer says:

    Well, a couple of things:

    First, the US economy was, back in the 1950s and 1960s, always referred to as a “mixed economy”. The Federal government set policy goals and constraints, industry complied with them. The “finance economy”, which we supposedly have now, didn’t come along until later. Even later, considering what happened to Enron and Arthur Anderson, which apparently didn’t follow policy guidance (perhaps were just used as fall guys / examples), the finance community wasn’t exactly dominating the Feds. I, personally, think that the “finance economy” is permitted by the Feds because it can be taxed, no other reason. Example: High speed trading is simple robbery, but it’s taxable robbery.

    Second, this is from the article you referenced:

    Nevertheless, I would classify its economics as fascist, since ultimately business, the economy, private property, and individual endeavor were all deemed subordinate to the dictates of the State, which supposedly embodied in mystical Rousseauian fashion the will of the people. Its economic posture therefore resembled that of the United States since the New Deal.

    That describes the Federal position on economics up until PC, which has apparently now become dominant outside of Trump’s influence (such as it is).

    Finally: Hitler did not finance his welfare economy entirely from Jewish people. However — he was always short of money for that welfare economy (this was behind the increased euthanasia decision), and he did confiscate all Jewish owned assets to the best of his ability. Not only did he confiscate them, but the usual routine was apparently to open a Jewish house, haul its contents out front, and auction them off on the spot. This minimized administrative costs and ensured that the public knew that the money had a Jewish source. The other methods you describe amount to fraudulent securities sales (since Germany would be unable to meet payment schedules). There is some speculation that Hitler’s territorial annexations and subsequent lootings were forced by this inability to meet payment schedules. These forms of financing reinforced Polish motives for the eventual Polish resistance to German demands, and helped swing US public opinion against Nazi Germany.

    The analogy with the USA now is that the USA is running out of resources, and using increasingly desperate means to get funding for urban areas (riots didn’t work, perhaps Autonomous Zones will free up some funds, or maybe get a Democrat elected President and the funds can simply be collected). This is a very dangerous situation, because the funds to be taken are not discretionary income for the people from whom they are being taken. The US industrial plant has depreciated and can no longer generate enough surplus to support the urban areas. The increase in deaths of despair among rural populations suggests that the inadequate amounts that urban areas are already taking more than can be sustained.

    As Hitler and later the USSR found out, closing the budget gap by confiscation isn’t a stable long term strategy. Now the USA is also finding that out.

  141. @Harold Smith

    ” They’d do things like run electable candidates against him”

    There are no “electable” candidates to be found within the ranks of the Democats, as they are all stupid, crazy freaks, and you yourself never fail to amaze with your idiotic BS.

    AJM “Mensa” qualified sine 1973, airborne trained US army vet, and pro Jazz artist.

    • Replies: @Harold Smith
  142. profnasty says:

    Limp wristed pundits are still using the Great One’s name to describe evil. The one man who stood up to evil. And now ZOG has got US’ balls in a vice. Good.
    Watch NASCAR boys suck it. The NHL is on it’s knees. Oh, Canada….puleeze.//I predict a defacto loss for Trump’s traditional rhetorical ideals. ZOG will win, it always does. Try to find a Black man with clean feet. Pretty soon, you’ll be kissing them.

  143. Anonymous[944] • Disclaimer says:

    You still do not know that all information about Hitler is falsified.

    OK, I’ll play that silly game. If all information about Hitler is falsified, and your information is about Hitler, than your information is falsified.

    • Replies: @Derer
  144. @Anonymous

    “If you’re selling a solution, it pays to have a lot of problem.”

  145. Curle says:

    Floyd had enough Fentanyl in his system to cause cardiac arrest. The Fentanyl is referenced in the autopsy relative to cause of death.

    Fentanyl causes exactly the symptoms witnesses in the video or present in the record; the foaming, unsteady on feet, breathing problems and cardiac arrest. If the struggle in the car or prefatory to entering the car involved Floyd disposing of evidence through ingestion you’d have precisely the events caught on tape and in that exact sequence.

    NIOSH (Institute of Occupational Safety and Health) advises first responders dealing with Fentanyl to prioritize avoiding any aerosolization of the Fentanyl which is easy with that substance.
    Breathing on others is one way to aerosol the chemical. Dermal contact with the chemical is to be avoided (on Floyd’s hands). Further, in advice referencing a Fentanyl gas attack used by Russian terrorists, first responders were advised that propping up patients in cardiac arrest can worsen outcomes (even though every media doctor is criticizing police for not doing so).

    Want to see for yourself? Look up NIOSH Work Group Report 2018 Fentanyl and First Responders.

  146. @Anonymous

    That’s right, the Nazi welfare state was funded in the usual way: OPM (other people’s money). Which is just great until, you know, their money runs out.

    • Replies: @Alexandros
  147. @Beefcake the Mighty

    This argument is so silly it is incredible anyone makes it. As if government of a State should be financed by the cabinet members taking part time jobs at 7/11.

    All States are financed by somebody elses money. There is nothing unsustainable with the concept of a welfare state as long as the population at large are hardworking and honest. That’s why it works in Scandinavia, and to a lesser degree in Western countries in general, but fails in lazy populations with a thieving mindset.

    And it is even more silly to compare Hitler’s welfare state to what we see in the West today. His government money did not go towards footing the bill for ghetto momma’s and deadbeats so they could keep producing more deadbeats and gangbangers. If you refused to work in Germany they put you in a labor camp. Programs such as the Winterhilfe were largely privately funded, and it was expected that the rich produce their fair share. Failure to do so would lead to social alienation and loss of government contracts. If you stashed your money abroad to avoid taxation you were liable for the death penalty. No loop holes for the German elite back then.

    The result was a financial powerhouse with a population backing their leader to the hilt. A State so solid it took a worldwide coalition to bring it down by force.

    • Agree: Fox
    • Replies: @Anonymous
  148. Anonymous[406] • Disclaimer says:

    It is funny how similar the Hitler fan-boys and Team China retards sound. (And yeah, I agree the Holohoax is just that, and that Germany was not primarily responsible for the war, but give me a goddamn break.)


  149. aandrews says:

    “Floyd the Landlord”.

  150. wakeUpNow says:

    paid agitators is *not* a theory, man sheesh

  151. Ace says:

    Your first four links report only general dissatisfaction in Iran with the Regime or are thin gruel indeed about the personal responsibility of Soleimani for any internal events. Reporting on his external activities is laughable and uses text that floated all the way from Haifa up the Potomac to the State Department.

    In one link, all there is about Soleimani comes from the mouth of an U/I dissident. The protests reported appear to be superficially focused on the downing of Flight PS752.

    Another link is to an MEK mouthpiece that I do not see as a credible source.

    Another is to an article about “nationwide protests that erupted in November over gasoline prices.”

    A few Christian expatriates who had a hard time in Iran have my sympathy but forgive me if I observe that one swallow does not a summer make. Nor do I think a couple of Christian converts provided persuasive evidence of what “the majority of Iranians” think.

    Breitbart quotes an earlier piece of theirs that is the usual smorgasbord of flapdoodle about Iran:

    Soleimani, a major general and the head of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) Quds Force, was responsible for Iran’s terrorist operations abroad, particularly against the United States. He was believed to have coordinated a significant number of human rights atrocities in Syria in defense of dictator Bashar al-Assad and was in charge of organizing terrorist activity in Lebanon, Iraq, Yemen, and Latin America, among other areas.

    He prioritized the use of roadside bombs to injure and kill American soldiers in battlefields like Iraq, where Iran largely controls the government in Baghdad and its proxy forces on the ground.

    Yes, yes. “Terrorist” operations abroad and, horrors, the use of mine warfare. I hate that any Americans lost their lives as a result of any IED (or manufactured ones) but we should not have sent them there in the first place and, more to the point, mine warfare is an acceptable part of warfare, just as US artillery, helicopter gunships, depleted uranium warheads, and the like are. Here’s the US Army text on it: FM 20-32.

    Breitbart’s language that Soleimani “was believed to have coordinated a significant number of human rights atrocities in Syria in defense of dictator Bashar al-Assad” is positively cartoonish. The “dictator Assad” garbage is straight out of Pompeo’s and the FCO’s fevered imaginations.

    • Replies: @Wally
  152. Ace says:

    Mussolini went after the mafia. That article may have appeared here at TUR.

  153. geokat62 says:

    geokat62- Trumpstein was 100% kosher-approved.

    Derer – Disagree:

    Do me a favour and watch this video and tell me if you still disagree…


  154. Bolteric says:

    Ironic that kneeling is the honorific sign of solidarity when the Minneapolis officer used it to subdue and snuff out the problem negro.

    • Replies: @Robjil
  155. Ace says:

    Trump’s limited success at altering the balance of power is not due to any remarkable insight but simply from his being “not them.” He has a visceral patriotism but absolutely no insight into the essence of the initial great experiment. Compare his views on the stock market as an indicator of the health of the economy and his disdain for out-of-control spending, budgets as well as his pressure on Powell to drop rates into the basement and you then see that Trumpism is a mile wide and an inch deep. His businessman’s sense of who gets what out of any deal has served him well in his dealings with China and that has redounded to our benefit. I’ll give him that.

    However, at a time when the demographic changes have advanced far into the rear areas — and thus attacking vote fraud head on is vital — he has been a huge disappointment. (Ditto with regard to crucifying AntiFa, but that’s another story.) His “attacks” on illegal immigrants, support for more legal immigration and H-1B visas, and vote fraud have been feeble to nonexistent.

    I don’t know about your “trading space for time” idea. Trump has made little hay from the ongoing attempted coup d’etat aimed at him. Little beyond some pathetic Tweets for heaven’s sake, I suppose. He’s let some of his closest allies twist in the wind and he has essentially run out the clock on turning the tables on his enemies. I mean, the false FISA warrant applications were something begging to be acted on — a shooting-fish-in-a-barrel exercise — but the perjurers have been totally confident that the de facto statute of limitation will run in January 2021.

    • Replies: @Ace
  156. Ace says:

    ** 25% against unarmed people **

    Tucker did a segment on that. There were 10 police killings of apparently unarmed black IIRC. Your 250 unarmed people stat is way off.

  157. Ace says:

    All killings are homicides. Whether they are intentional, reckless, or justified is another issue. Not all killings are murder.

  158. Wally says:

    “I’ve read Götz Aly’s book, and it is very well documented. What Aly says happened, apparently happened.”

    – Really?

    – So what “documents” are shown which supposedly prove the absurdly impossible “holocaust”?

    – What “documents” are shown which supposedly prove that Germany “pretty much looted” other countries?

    We await.

    • Agree: Fox
  159. Wally says:

    Here you go, Iranian women and free speech activists have had enough of the Iranan Soleimani types:

    Iranian police arrest 29 for involvement in hijab protests:
    Protests continue in Iran and women actively participate:
    The Significance of Women in the Recent Protests in Iran:
    Regime officials confirm 1,500 killed in Iran’s nationwide protests:
    Protests in Iran Hit Boiling Point, Amplifying Calls for Regime Change:
    Iran tortures, kills protesters; 8,000 citizens arrested:

    • Replies: @Ace
  160. Ace says:

    You’ve still done nothing to shed any light on Soleimani. If all your new links purport to show is that “Soleimani types” are responsible for this or that in Iran you’ve got nothing.

    Who was this man Soleimani and why his “types” are reprehensible are questions you do not answer. The Breitbart article is pathetic, as I indicate.

    Soleimani was targeted because he

    (1) was effective in organizing resistance to the American occupation in Iraq,

    (2) was effective in helping the Syrians fight our precious ISIS and al Qaida proxies,

    (3) scared the Israelis because of his assistance to Hezbollah,

    (4) scared the Israelis because he threatened to interfere with their plan for Greater Israel, and

    (5) helped, no doubt, the Houtis in Yemen resist our and the Saudi aggressive war on Yemen.

    He was an effective military leader not the Mesopotamian Freddy Kruger.

    Considering your otherwise insightful commentary on (((other issues))), I am surprised by your staking out this particular position.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
  161. Anonymous[406] • Disclaimer says:

    It’s because Wally is probably some kind of agent provocateur. A Holohoax denier (he’s right about that one) who regurgitates the neocon line on Iran? Something’s not making sense there. A minimum, his non-stop spamming serves to work against revisionism by turning off open-minded observers.

    • Replies: @Ace
  162. Sulu says:

    Sorry but Hitler, though he must have been intelligent, left school at 15. He was the uneducated narcissist that thought he knew better than everyone around him. Nice try at historical misinformation though.


    • Replies: @Alexandros
    , @Alexandros
  163. Robjil says:

    Pelosi worships only Israel and most Congress does too. This pose is very Israeli. The picture of Congress doing this Israeli pose, is a perfect picture of Congress Zombies worshiping Israel. Silence, don’t talk back, take in all the revelations from Zion MSM, no thinking or debating allowed for that it is a great sin and a crime to speak or question the Super Zion.

    So, I’d like to highlight some of the things that this USA Today article has left out, because I think it’s interesting that there’s a taboo against certain aspects of this story being told. I just mentioned the Israelis being at the forefront of training American police in terror tactics today. They trained many Twin Cities officers and may very well bear some of the responsibility for the death of George Floyd, since one of the things that they taught them was the knee on the neck thing which actually the Israelis developed in Palestine, in 2004-2005 or so. Then they started teaching it to American officers, and that’s how it got into the United States. But we never talk about that in the mainstream media or the universities. Anybody who brings it up here in the United States gets shot down by the immensely powerful Jewish Zionist lobby.

    • Replies: @Bolteric
  164. @Sulu

    Education is the facilitation of knowledge, skills and learning. Hitler was one of the most well read and experienced men in all of history. His capacity and breadth of knowledge was unmatched. Therefore he was highly educated.

    You must confuse the word with getting a stamp of approval from mediocrities at some government institution.

  165. @Sulu

    Education is the facilitation of knowledge, skills and learning. Hitler was one of the most well read and experienced men in all of history. His capacity and breadth of knowledge was unmatched. Therefore he was highly educated.

    You must confuse the word with getting a stamp of approval from mediocrities at some government institution.

    • Replies: @Sulu
    , @Sulu
  166. Ragno says:

    You are a troll. And I mean one who works for what Hopkins calls “Globocop.”

    Yes; except he calls it “GloboCap”, you mouth-breathing simpleton.

    • Replies: @Commentator Mike
  167. Ace says:

    Quite so. The substance of his views on Soleimani/Iran is right out of DOD/State talking points and his sources are patently worthless. It’s as though Ronald Reagan suddenly came out in favor of UBI or as though Paul Ryan came out in favor of a scorched earth policy in dealing with the Democrats.

  168. Bolteric says:

    Israel Krav Maga. Who knew?

  169. @Ragno

    GloboCop works for GloboCapitalists so not much difference there.

    • Replies: @Ragno
  170. Derer says:

    It is easy. I take that falsified info and take the opposite being truth. For instance when lying morons say Hitler got one testicle, the truth is he got two. Of course you will insist he got one.

  171. Sulu says:

    Let me guess. You don’t possess any higher education, do you?


    • Replies: @Alexandros
    , @Fox
  172. Sulu says:

    Please don’t presume to lecture me on a subject that it appears you know little about. Hitler was a fool that led his country to death and destruction. If he had stayed within the borders of his country he likely would have gone down in history as one of the greatest leaders of Germany of all time. If he had chosen to listen to the good advise of his generals he might have captured and united all of Europe and the left would probably be pulling down his many statues right now. But instead he was a “know it all” that pissed it all away because of his monstrous ego.

    Hitler is analogous to the guy that wins the lotto and ends up dead in a few years because of his folly. 80% of being smart is being smart enough to know when you don’t know something and having the maturity to not bullshit yourself that you do. And then being able to take good advise. Hitler, apparently, could do none of that.


    • Replies: @Alexandros
  173. @Sulu

    Let me guess, you lack the intelligence to read a dictionary.

    • Replies: @Sulu
  174. @Sulu

    What subject would that be? The definition of the word ‘education’, or Adolf Hitler? The former you are demonstrably wrong, the latter your knowledge limits itself to propaganda tropes from the 60s. Your “expertise’ on WW2 is pitiful. You fit the exact stereotype of a man with above average intelligence who thinks he is superior because he read Ian Kershaw from front to back once.

    If Hitler had listened to the advice of his generals the Rhineland would still be demilitarized, Schussnigg would be in charge of Austria, Benes in Czechoslovakia and the French campaign would be bogged down in another Schlieffen plan.

    If he listened to their advice in Russia the entire army would be out of food, fuel and shelter in front of Moscow while Stalin’s armies surrounded their flanks. They would do a Napoleon retreat in the winter, leave behind all their heavy equipment and expose their soldiers to the icy steppe and lose the war right there. If he had listened to his own advice instead of theirs they wouldn’t have wasted precious resources trying to take Moscow in 1941, and they wouldn’t have thrown away their last mobile strike force in the battle of Kursk in 1943.

    The effective operational capacity of 600 miles for the Wehrmacht and the numerical and material superiority of the Red Army and fighting on 4 fronts is not why Germany lost the war, no it was Hitler and his “foolishness”. Those generals must have considered themselves bona fide magicians if they thought much could be done to overcome the cold hard facts of those arithmetics. Their tactical skill won Germany battles, no doubt, but it was the strategic mind of Hitler which got them as far as they did. And maybe if they had followed his orders to the letter Germany might have been victorious. If they had only followed their own the war would have ended after Poland at the latest.

    • Replies: @Sulu
    , @Beefcake the Mighty
  175. Fox says:

    But you do have an “education”, Sulu? What gives you the idea that only certified education is real? There are a lot of people leaving the universities with Ph.D.s, some going on to become professors, who don’t shine with much of an intellectual sun, even they have an “education”.
    Mozart and Bach didn’t have much of an education, yet their music is still listened to now. And did Shakespeare have much of what amounts to “education” in your mind?
    People who conversed with Hitler seemed to have all been impressed by the breadth of his knowledge, grasp of the subject and depth of understanding; that can only mean that he could discuss subjects competently. Two examples of his insight into subjects completely at odds with his daily tasks come to mind: On one occasion he suggested a design change of German war ships – to reduce in size the forecastle; this was done, as the engineers agreed that this was an advantageous change. The second item that comes to mind is that, according to Hermann Giesler, Hitler was the inventor of transport containers; they discussed the plans for a large-gage railroad spanning all of Europe, and Hitler suggested that loading goods in containers would facilitate efficient exchange of goods.
    He also wrote all of his speeches himself, an accomplishment few politicians could ever match. He had a certain taste in art and was an accomplished painter himself; he had a wide knowledge of architecture, etc.
    All of this knowledge he acquired through his private studies.
    Education is supposed to convey competence in human affairs. The certificate shows that one has passed tests which in an agreed-upon manner attest to it. But, as you know, there are exceptions: Some people have such certificates and are incompetent. Some people don’t have such certificates and are competent, sometimes highly competent, as with Mozart, or Shakespeare, or Hitler.

    • Replies: @Sulu
  176. Sulu says:

    Albert Speer claimed that when England declared war on Germany for invading Poland, Hitler was stunned. He did not expect them to do so. But they did. This was Hitler’s first mistake. A pretty big one if you ask me.

    And the nightmare for his generals was fighting a war with England in the West and Russia in the East at the same time. And Hitler handed it to them. Instead of invading and subduing England first, Hitler attacked Russia. If he had subdued England America would not have had a platform from which to launch her massive aerial bombing campaign that eventually destroyed Germany.

    Another huge mistake Hitler made was declaring war on America right after the attack by the Japanese on Pearl Harbor on Dec 7, 41. I realize that his pact with Japan obligated him to do so but if he had delayed it’s not like Japan was going to fight Germany over it. They had their hands full fighting America. If he had not done so it would have delayed America’s entrance into the war in Europe and things might have gone very differently.

    Hitler was obviously intelligent but uneducated. Speer claimed he was an amateur at everything he did. And that included military strategy. And one of the things I see time and time again from people that are uneducated is that they frequently disdain education. Probably because they feel insecure due to their lack. So they tell themselves that they don’t really need it and then overcompensate for it by trying to be a “know it all.” But the problem with being a know it all is that you really do have to know it all. And no one does.

    Hitler was an uneducated know it all that was so arrogant and egotistical that he allowed his own need to be the smartest guy in every room to lead himself and his country to ruin. You can romanticize him all you want but that won’t change the fact that he lost the war.


    • Replies: @Alexandros
    , @Fox
    , @Dave Bowman
  177. Sulu says:

    So tell me. What is your level of education? Hmm?


    • Replies: @Alexandros
  178. @Authenticjazzman

    “…and you yourself never fail to amaze with your idiotic BS.”

    Well thanks for taking some time away from painting swastikas on your front door to share your critical opinion. I couldn’t ask for a better endorsement.

  179. Sulu says:

    But, as you know, there are exceptions: Some people have such certificates and are incompetent. Some people don’t have such certificates and are competent, sometimes highly competent, as with Mozart, or Shakespeare, or Hitler.

    I definitely agree with that. I have met scores of people that have no real formal education that I thought were intelligent, well read, accomplished people. And the stereotype of the over educated pedant that can’t dress himself in the morning is well known and valid.

    We all know people that can shine in the classroom but can’t do much in the real world. And the opposite is also true. There are those that can shine in the real world but couldn’t pass a test to save their life. But the truly great intellects are those that can manage to do both. And those are a small minority. But I will give you an example of one in my next paragraph.

    If you want me to give a counterpoint to someone like Hitler that fits my idea of an educated military genius it would have to be Douglas MacArthur. Top of his class at West Point and graduated without a single demerit. I can’t even imagine how he did that. And at one time he probably held more power than the President because he was the absolute dictator over Japan after the war. His accomplishments are so vast and the stories of his intellect so numerous that it would be pointless for me to try and list them. If you are interested just try reading one or two of his biographies. I think he was the most impressive military mind America ever produced.

    As for people like Mozart, he was a musical genius certainly. But his talent was in that category only. In other venues he was quite incompetent. He could never handle money and was notoriously broke his entire life. I have heard it said that genius is not what you possess but what possesses you. I suspect that applied to Mozart.

    I still like what Twain said, “I never let my schooling interfere with my education.”

    As for myself, I have a bit of both. I have never been so delusional as to erroneously think of myself as a genius. But there is a fair body of evidence and accomplishment that sets me apart from the great unwashed. So I will have to settle for being above average.


  180. Ragno says:
    @Commentator Mike

    First rule of Unz Club is never defend Unzsite trolls.

  181. Derer says:

    Who are those supporters…is it Schiff, Schumer, Nadler or those 3 lawyers slandering Trump during the hearing or 1/3 of the Supreme Court? Go further and check for donation to Democrats from the same people. Primary purpose of political donations to both parties is the tax exemption.

  182. @Alexandros

    What are you talking about? Kursk was indeed pointless, but it was Hitler’s idea, not his generals. They were in fact winning the battle until Hitler called off the offensive (ostensibly because of the Allied landing at Sicily, which makes no sense.) And whose idea was it to not break free at Stalingrad when they had the chance?

    • Agree: Fox
    • Replies: @Alexandros
    , @Fox
  183. @Sulu

    Albert Speer claimed a lot of things. He was not an honest man.

    While it is true that Hitler hoped it would not come to war, he did not make his decision until Von Brautitsch assured him that a war against England, France and Poland was winnable. And he was right about that. Germany won that war. What tipped the scales was the hostile intentions of the USSR and their unprecedented level of armaments which nobody in the world could even fantasize the scale of. It wasn’t Ribbentropp either who provided Hitler with false estimations. Contrary to British propaganda he thought England would go to war and conveyed this to Hitler. After seizing the diplomatic correspondence in Prague in 1939, Hitler’s comment was “England wants war”. So beyond a shadow of a doubt he considered a war with England a very real possibility and only took steps to that end after being reassured by his military leaders that such a war was winnable.

    The Generals, and Hitler, rightly feared a two front war. But with the Molotov pact that scenario disappeared in the short term. It enabled Germany to defeat Poland and their enemies in the West before pushing their entire weight on the USSR. That was considered winnable. Not only had Russia been defeated easily enough in WW1, but a mere two decades ago Russia was a backwards, agricultural country. If somebody had proposed that such a country now possessed more modern tanks, airplanes and guns than the rest of the world put together, without hard facts to prove it, they would rightly have been considered off their rocker.

    Germany could never invade England without a massive downscaling of their land army, their strongest military arm by far, and doing so would take time and leave them vulnerable to invasion in the East. Nor did they wish to invade England. They might be able to possess the island, but the Royal Navy would just sail off to Canada and continue the war from there with American support. There would be n0 resources in the English homeland to help the German war effort, only more expenses. And the colonies would fall to the USA. This was exactly what Stalin was hoping to achieve by pitting Germany against the West. A weakening of his fascist and capitalist enemies while Europe lay open for the taking to the huge army he was creating. Invading England does not win the war for Germany. Only neutralizing Russia and gaining access to its resources does.

    The triparte alliance did not obligate Germany to declare war on the USA. Only if Japan had been attacked would they be obligated. The reason they did so was because there already existed a de facto state of war with the USA, and an all out war was a question of when, not if. Hitler and his admirals figured it was better to start sinking tonnage going to the UK now rather than later when the enemy would be more potent. It could potentially starve the UK out of the war and give Germany the year or so they needed to defeat the USSR. Then it would not matter that the USA had the largest industrial capacity in the world. The German hold on the European continent would be unassailable. If not, the war was lost in any case. Hitler chose it because it would enable him to start sinking American convoys to the UK, and heighten the chance Japan might help out in the Soviet rear. It would also bolster the axis alliance, showing the world that they stood together in thick and thin. Germany would grow weaker over time, not stronger. Victory had to be attained within a year or they would lose.

    Speer claimed he wanted to assassinate Hitler when in reality he was among those who tried to sway Hitler from going down with the ship in Berlin. He let the American military incorporate bogus documents to defame Hitler into his best selling biography. Giesler called him the Cesare Borgia of the Third Reich. An ambitious, callous man who would do anything to advance himself and save his neck.

    In reality Hitler was a skilled and accomplished military strategist. He knew all the theory and had read all the relevant authorities. He knew the capacities of armament better than anyone. He created the strategy which enabled Germany to fight a world war all on his own. He planned the French campaign single handedly. He got Germany back to their WW1 strength and possessions without firing a shot, conquered most of Europe and got all the way to Volgograd before suffering a narrow defeat. Was he inferior in skill to Hannibal? To Pyrrhus? Less accomplished than Napoleon or Caesar? They were all losers too, but you don’t see anybody trying to downplay their military accomplishments just because they lost. Fact is Germany only got as far as they did due to him, and if he had followed other people’s advice, they would lose far earlier than they did. That makes him superior and fully qualified.

    • Replies: @Sulu
  184. @Beefcake the Mighty

    It was the generals who wanted the battle. Hitler’s gut feeling told him they should avoid it, but it was one of those times where he gave in to their “superior” advice. In terms of losses they were winning the battle like they did practically every battle with the Soviets. But it would be at a too great a loss and with no chance to exploit the victory. Kursk was a big pocket, but still just a pocket on a huge front. Wasting their entire strength would make them liable to penetrations across the entire front which could collapse everything. With invasions coming in the South and the West they could not afford it. Preventing a continental landing while bleeding the USSR dry was their only option at that point. Might have worked too if certain officers hadn’t been cowards and traitors.

    Breaking free from Stalingrad was not possible without sacrificing Army Group South. They chose the risk of losing an army instead of losing an entire army group. A prudent and correct decision.

  185. Fox says:
    @Beefcake the Mighty

    Have to take back the “Agree” for Beefcake’s comment; that was meant for what Alexandros wrote. Alexandros is correct on every point.

  186. @Sulu

    My relevant education is reading 100 books and thousands of articles on Adolf Hitler and WW2. I might not know as many tiny details as an Ian Kershaw or a Richard Evans, but I know a lot of things they don’t because I care about truth, not narrative. I’ve read Holocaust deniers. They haven’t. I’ve read Giesler, they haven’t. I’ve read Walendy and Schultze Rhonhof. They haven’t. I’ve read Leon Degrelle, they haven’t. I’ve made efforts to separate the propaganda from the truth. They have not cared to do so.

    • Replies: @Sulu
  187. Sulu says:

    Look, to a certain degree you are doing what we all do. You are picking your sources and you are choosing who to believe and who to disbelieve. Due to that I believe that neither of our viewpoints can be dismissed or validated with any real degree of certainty. The real question of history ought to be how can anyone speak with any degree of authority about events that occurred years before he was born.


  188. He is not Hitler, but is it good enough?
    President Trump does not send troops to meet the rioters, he does not arrest the mayors of the cities who told him to buzz off, he does not depose the generals who apologize for taking photos with him, and he does not intercept the millions streaming to the rebels. The popular American satirist C. Hopkins argues in his column in the Unz Review that this is good and clever. Trump refuses to play the role of Hitler, and does not give his opponents any reason to remove him and seize power.
    Yes, he won’t make a convincing Hitler. But he will do as Yanukovych.
    Opponents of Trump steam full speed ahead. The mayor of Seattle told President Donald Trump to “go back to your bunker”. Washington D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser says President Trump is living in her backyard.
    One site demands that everyone who protects the statues of the Confederates be arrested for rebellion. “Armed Group Protects Confederate Statue in Kentucky: Arrest Them for Insurrection and Sedition.”
    They are indignant at Trump, who met with West Point cadets – in the midst of a pandemic. “Trump Exposes 1100 Graduating West Point Cadets to Possible Coronavirus Infection So He Can “Dominate” the Weekend Media” How can you compare it to the Democrats’ meeting with BLM activists?
    ‘This Is Deadly’: Trump HHS Scraps Protections for Transgender Patients and Those Seeking Abortions.
    But Trump is folding and retreating. They told him – how dare you to stage a rally on June 19? After all, this is a holiday for black Americans, the day when Lincoln freed the last slaves. On such a holy day, it is impudent of Trump to show his face in public! And Trump retreated, shifted the rally to the June 20, although 300,000 have already booked for the rally.
    I’m not a conservative, no way, I am not a supporter of the current regime. I think that a revolution – even the fake one, organized by Soros out of gaylib crowd, slightly sprinkled by Africans for colour – will do some good for America. The American troops are already leaving Germany after only 75 years of occupation. There are more than 100 major bases overseas that can be evacuated if the revolution persists. Fine and dandy.
    But, Mr Hopkins, do not tell Trump that he has chosen the right strategy. Like, if he won’t get provoked – everyone will respect his authority. Let’s be frank, comrade. Tell Trump: if his main consideration is first of all not to be called a bloody tyrant by a liberal site, there is a place for him in the hospitable Rostov, next to Yanukovych. Let him decide.

  189. Sulu says:

    I’ve made efforts to separate the propaganda from the truth. They have not cared to do so.

    Though we have different viewpoints on WWII I suspect we may be on the same page.

    Oh, I happen to have two Bachelor degrees, one of which is in Science as well as a pilot’s license. But I have no formal education in History.


    • Replies: @profnasty
  190. Fox says:

    Hitler could not believe that England was so stupid as to declare war on Germany over something that was:
    1. None of England’s business
    2.Was going to lead to England’s demise as a world power
    3.Had been recognized as a just cause (= correct the miscarriage of good sense committed at Versailles with establishing the German Eastern border after the First War) by a great many of English people as well as English politicians (including the famous Churchill, Lloyd George)
    4.While the attempted attempted enlistment of the SU against Germany up until August 19, 1939, had failed, when Stalin disinvited the English military emissaries.

    Hitler was also stunned at the English declaration of war, as Poland had been increasingly provocative following the first English guarantee to Poland of March 1939. That included the Polish declaration that any attempt of incorporation of Danzig into the Reich, even by the free will of the German City of Danzig to do so, would be considered an act of war. (Note: here is Democracy in action); firing of German civilian aircraft from the Lufthansa with anti aircraft cannons (25th of August; shelling of the German border city of Beuthen (30th of August); assassination of the German consul in Cracow (30th of August); arson of German farms in Poland; murder of Germans in Poland, cross-border raids of Polish military and Polish gangs into Germany). About 70000 refugees from Poland in summer of 1939 arrived in Germany.
    Remember the Kosovo war and how it was oh-so-justified and cheered on by all the good people and sheeple because the oh-so-terrible Serbs did oh-so-terrible things to the Kosovars? The hypocrisy of Democrats and the reasoning with which they allow themselves to do whatever fogs up the inside of their skulls is always amazing.
    Hitler did not think that England would sink so low as to go to war in the light of the belligerent reality of Poland. He did, however, not understand that Poland acted as England’s patsy, because England really did want war to break out and to achieve the objective it was of utmost importance to make Germany appear to have started it. It is possible that the medieval Balance of Power doctrine sported by England was the motive power, but it is also possible that the Focus group, founded and financed by Jewish interests saw Poland as a great opportunity to start the war that was promised to come (again, from the Jewish side) from the beginning of Hitler’s chancellorship. Churchill was bought by this group, and since he had no character, but had need for money and loved the idea of war, he was hired by this subversive group and Churchill henceforth made use of his many inside and outside connections to promote the idea of W a r.
    What makes you think that Hitler led Germany to ruin? Was it not the declaration of war by England and France over something they should have been happy to help resolve? Every offer of peace or conflict resolution coming from Hitler was rejected by the Democracies from the very beginning when England rejected the already accepted mediation offer from Mussolini of September 2, 1939 (accepted by France and Germany), with Hitler agreeing to halt further military operations.
    And if Hitler was so wrong in misjudging the peaceful amassment of 5 million Red Army troops with unimaginable amounts of attack weaponry at the western border in June of 1941, why did the US then build up the hair-trigger system of instant attack against the Soviet state post-1945? If they were so harmless and bucolically self-involved at a time when they were ready to steamroll over Western Europe in 1941, why not operate under the same assumption until 1990 and safe the trillions invested in bombs and planes and propaganda and legal restrictions of 5th-column communist parties in the West wars to contain the Soviets? The Soviet troop build-up is, by-the-way, either denied to have been so (then where did the millions of Russian POWs come from), or said to have been for a maneuvre (a big one, indeed). That Hitler could have correctly recognized what was going on is, however, denied. Had he been right, yet waited to see what’s next, what might have happened?

    What led Germany, and in its late consequence now, when all of the western societies are falling into the pit of chaos because of a lack of purpose to exist on a basis of mythologies that have the feel of being wrong, to ruin is the absolute will to war and destruction of Germany by her enemies and the eventual “unconditional surrender” demand. That Germany fought under these conditions issued by her murderous enemies (remember the hate propaganda, the bombings of cities) can only surprise someone who has no concept of a will to live.

    • Replies: @Sulu
  191. @Sulu

    Albert Speer claimed that when England declared war on Germany for invading Poland, Hitler was stunned

    If the weakling and charlatan Speer said that, he was lying or badly mis-remembering. What he said (if he said it) is simply historically incorrect – thereby throwing your first point out of the window, as follows:

    If you bother to watch or listen to the famous newsreel from 3rd September 1939, the British Prime Minister, Chamberlain, said these exact words:

    “…made clear to Germany that, unless a solemn undertaking was received by 12:00 o’clock today to withdraw all German troops from Polish territory, a state of war would exist between our two countries. I have to tell you now that no such undertaking has been received, and that consequently, this country is at war with Germany”.

    Therefore technically, Great Britain did NOT in fact ever “declare war” on Germany – as is popularly imagined. Instead, Hitler was given a clear ultimatum – a choice – to withdraw. He made a choice – NOT to withdraw – and war was the default result. This is not a matter of semantics – it proves that Hitler had a choice at that time. If he had been so shocked by Britain’s taking a final political and military stand on Poland’s behalf, he had the option to agree, BEFORE the deadline, to withdraw from Poland in the coming days – but he chose not to. He chose instead to save face – by refusing to climb down from an untenable position.

    I read somewhere decades ago that it has been established that every single strategic decision Hitler made during the war, which later proved to be a WRONG decision – from the mis-judgement over Poland in 1939 to the Battle of the Bulge counter-offensive in 1944 – was in fact made by him personally, often over-ruling his Generals in the process.

    Hitler was a fine, loyal and remorseless true German patriot, who saw many decades off what would happen to European society if Jewish usury and cultural sabotage by Germany’s enemies was allowed to continue – and he did what needed to be done. He kick-started Germany’s self-esteem from the streets through the bankrupt ashes of the first war and the Depression; he put Germany back to work with the autobahnen and the re-vitalised arms industry, defying the hated Treaty of Versailles in the process; and most importantly, he removed the power of the Jewish usurers to leech and destroy the economy. He achieved all this and much more. But unfortunately, history is very clear that, as a military General, he was a very good Corporal.

    • Replies: @Alexandros
    , @Sulu
  192. Sulu says:

    I have had variations of this conversation before with several different posters. I don’t rule out the possibility that Hitler was entirely justified in invading Poland in an effort to protect the German minority there and as an effort to correct the injustice inflicted on Germany by the treaty of Versailles. But whatever you say about Hitler you have to admit that he lost the war.
    But all of this is moot. The war has been over for 75 years. I’m more concerned as to whether or not we are going to get a Hitler here in America, because we sorely need one. Hopefully our Hitler, if we get one, will have better luck.


    • Replies: @Fox
  193. Fox says:

    Since you have been through such discussions and you do principally understand the situation leading to the events beginning with September 1, 1939, then you can look at the whole complex with the question in mind:

    Given, I were in a situation just like that Hitler as in in summer of 1939, what would I think I’d do?

    Do nothing and watch the Germans in Poland being done away with?
    Protest- to whom?
    Make yet more suggestions for a solution – without an answer?
    Ignore the Polish army mobilized and threats?
    Appeal to good sense and reason?
    Wait for a suggestion from Poland or England, both of whom are studiously playing dumb and haughty?
    Both of whom don’t want another “Munich”?

    I can understand from what I know, the decisions made by Hitler in 1939, but also in 1941. They might have been wrong, we never know what would have happened if- but there were reasons and they can’t be made ridiculous by resorting to intended world conquest or the Hillgruber nonsense of “ideological race war of annihilation”. It tells me that the lot of conventional and by dint of that automatically anti-Hitler historians doesn’t ever have to find serious reasons for the coming about and spread of the war to a worldwide conflict. So much easier to posit a thesis and then scribble around it for decades until nothing but a fiction will be discussed, and eventually mistaken for the reality that never was.
    I can only say that I wish that there had been no war; at a minimum, it has thrown back human development by centuries, and it might very well lead to the extinction of the world of people of the white race along with that race. It might even cast a pall like a curse upon the whole future of humans.
    And all of that over the question whether the German city of Danzig with its 99% German population ought to have the right to determine its own political affiliation.

    • Replies: @MarkinLA
  194. @Dave Bowman

    I read somewhere decades ago that it has been established that every single strategic decision Hitler made during the war, which later proved to be a WRONG decision – from the mis-judgement over Poland in 1939 to the Battle of the Bulge counter-offensive in 1944 – was in fact made by him personally, often over-ruling his Generals in the process.

    Hitler admitted he made mistakes. Paraphrased:

    “Mr. Churchill has made a list of 10 mistakes I’ve made. He’s wrong, I’ve made many more mistakes than that! But none so big as dragging England into a war that will destroy the British Empire.”

    But Ardennes is not one of them. First off the failure of the operation made no difference in the outcome of the war. It in fact saved German lives since their ability to resist was spent faster. But there was no possibility for Germany to maintain their defenses indefinitely. They had to make a move. Hitler himself gave the operation a mere 10% chance of success. If they had been able to capture a bit of fuel and the weather had been slightly better, it could have worked. In any case it was preferable to the idea of just sitting it out and wait for inevitable defeat, which was the general’s idea. They were right in judging the operation to have a very small chance of success, but as usual they failed to see the bigger picture where Germany will lose the war and face unconditional surrender unless some miracle stratagem is pulled off. They had nothing, Hitler had something.

    Poland is more difficult to calculate. On the one hand attacking them lead to a world war which ended in a German defeat. On the other hand Poland was the weak link in a military alliance surrounding Germany, and making every effort to provoke warfare so the West could be brought into the equation. If Hitler did not act first, he could find himself in a two front war with a fully prepared France/England on one side, and a heavy militarized Poland with the very real possibility of the USSR joining in on the other. At a time of their choosing. All Britain and Stalin needs to do is cut off trade, blockade the iron ore from Sweden and Germany will be more or less forced to capitulate. Avoiding war and preserving the regime could be a scenario, but with Stalin cannibalizing his entire country to build a world conquering war machine, that seems unlikely. And long term, after Hitler, it’s hard to see a Nazi regime surviving without military might to back it up. There are limits to how much Germany can do with autarky and leaders lacking Hitler’s mass appeal and genius when the whole world stands against you. It’s a close call, but in my opinion the moral imperative edges it to be a right decision. Nor were the German generals unwilling in that enterprise. Hitler said “normally I have to push my generals to action, but with Poland I have to hold them back!”.

    • Replies: @MarkinLA
  195. Sulu says:
    @Dave Bowman

    My source for that assertion was… Inside The Third Reich by Albert Speer. I have no idea if he was a weakling or charlatan. That judgement is left to history.

    This is not a matter of semantics

    I’m sorry but I have a hard time taking that statement with any degree of seriousness. At the very least you are attempting to split hairs. At the most you are engaging in sophistry. England declaring that a state of war will exist between Germany and England if Hitler doesn’t withdraw from Poland is still a declaration of war. It’s merely a conditional declaration of war.

    Yes, Hitler did have a short window in which he could have prevented war with England by withdrawing from Poland. Why he chose not to is open for conjecture. My guess is he knew that war with England was inevitable so even if he had miscalculated by thinking he would have Poland without war he was confident that he would win and as you pointed out he did choose to save face.

    Hitler had rolled the dice before and come out the winner without risking a drop of German blood. Austria, the Sudetenland. It’s not surprising that he got over confident and thought he could have Poland too.

    But as I said in another post, all of this is moot. It was over 75 years ago. And no, I don’t believe the official bullshit history written by the Jews. I have already found too many holes in it. But it is difficult for me to see how any of us can think we have the true facts about events that occurred before we were born.


  196. MarkinLA says:

    And all of that over the question whether the German city of Danzig with its 99% German population ought to have the right to determine its own political affiliation.

    It’s always about Germany getting back its 1918 borders – borders which were created by the dismemberment of Poland. Funny that Germany, Austria, and Russia didn’t seem to think Poles had the right to determine their own political affiliation.

    • Replies: @Fox
  197. MarkinLA says:

    If Hitler did not act first, he could find himself in a two front war with a fully prepared France/England on one side, and a heavy militarized Poland with the very real possibility of the USSR joining in on the other.

    Didn’t Hitler have a non-aggression pact with Poland? Why not just honor it? Why not create an alliance in the east against possible Russian aggression? Why not stop before Poland and restore Czechoslovakia minus Sudetenland? Russia could not fight a war with all of it’s neighbors in the west if they were armed and had access to German military technology.

    The whole defending Germans in Poland was just another excuse for a war he wanted. Germany could have simply taken them in. I imagine Poles were treated like welcomed royalty when Poland was dismembered especially given the Germans attitude toward Poles. Wasn’t Germany in the process of trying to take the Polish out of the Poles they controlled? The idea that Poles could ever be justified being mad is ridiculous.

    • Replies: @Fox
    , @Alexandros
  198. Fox says:

    November 1916, the Polish Kingdom being reconstituted by proclamation by the German and the Austrian Emperors, respectively, Poles swore eternal loyalty and gratitude. Didn’t last for more than two years, this gratitude, that is.
    I don’t know where the borders of Poland lay, but they were not in Germany.

  199. Ace says:

    I meant indifference to out-of-control spending, disdain for budgets….

  200. Fox says:

    The non-aggression pact with Poland was cancelled in April of 1939, along with the naval agreement with Britain, as any basis for such amicable agreements was eliminated by England’s unconditional guarantee of Poland against Germany, and Poland increased its agitation against Germany and the Germans who had been forcibly incorporated into Poland by Poland’s occupation of two German provinces, as well as the fraudulent taking of Upper Silesia in 1921.
    Friendship or love needs two willing participants, and Poland did not want friendship or an amicable relationship with Germany.
    By the way, did Poland ever quit the area of Czecho-Slovakia it occupied in 1939?
    There were very few Poles in Germany, and they could freely have their Polish clubs and schools and enjoy their Polishness to the hilt round the clock. The Polish associations were only closed in August of 1939 in response to the anti-German measures in Poland.
    That the Poles, however, persecuted Germans in Poland despite having signed the accord for the protection of minority rights, caused alone in summer of 1939 70000 Germans to seek refuge in Germany. All the small-minded and mean things the Poles, including the good catholics there could come up with, were committed by the Poles against Germans, such as closing down the German schools, requiring Polish to be used in dealings with state offices (despite the contrary being agreed upon in the Minority Protection Accord), forbidding German being spoken in public, forbidding sermons in German, not recognizing German degrees and professions, not allowing public contracts to go to Germans, and of course the small and large brutalities such as thug violence, arson, murder, threats of war, in late August firing anti-aircraft guns on Lufthansa planes, shelling of Beuthen, cross border raids by Polish military or private gangs…

    I can’t see how this could ever be forgotten, and Poland will not be able to forget its behavior that made it a willing participant in the English war policy against Germany. Every European eventually waking up to the horrible fallout of the war to eliminate Germany will come to look at Poland and understand its misery-bringing role. And every day the land taken from the Germans, that is Eastern Germany, with avarice, envy and greed reminds Poles of the past they are trying to deny, and you are no exception, as your words attest. Poles hate the Germans because they know that they, the Poles, the have done them, the Germans, horribly wrong.

    • Agree: Alexandros
  201. @MarkinLA

    Hitler did want an alliance in the East, hence the non aggression pact already in 1934. He did offer to restore Czechia. The problem was neither Poland or England were interested in such an agreement. They wanted war. That’s why he ended up in Stalin’s lap, the only willing taker, who also, down the line, wanted war.

    When those facts became abundently clear, Hitler said “well, if they want war they’ll have it”. Nobody could claim he hadn’t tried every move to avoid it. Of course, within the limits of fairness and German honor. He wasn’t going to prostrate himself to appease enemies.

    • Replies: @MarkinLA
  202. MarkinLA says:

    Hitler had already proven that his agreements weren’t worth the paper they were written on. So the other side deciding to dig their heels in is makes perfect sense.

    This whole Hitler was the good guy and everybody else is responsible for the war is just lunatic nonsense.

    • Replies: @Alexandros
  203. @MarkinLA

    Not so. Hitler did not break the Munich agreement. It stipulated the terms for the annexation of the Sudeten area, nothing more. It was Great Britain and Neville Chamberlain, who in September 1938 signed a friendship declaration with Germany, that broke a promise when they immediately started arming for war and in January 1939 the same Prime Minister told Mussolini he was considering war against Germany. What exactly had Germany done to deserve this change of heart in the previous months? The protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia was still months away from happening.

    The myth of Hitler as a breaker of oaths is propaganda at its crudest.

    • Agree: Fox
  204. profnasty says:

    I have a SUNY History BA.
    No big deal.

  205. Sidney says:

    “This guy is the worst literal Hitler ever.” I’m assuming by this statement that you mean Trump(nor any leader today), can hold a candle to Adolph Hitler in performance. A.H. the most lied about man in history, did more for his nation at incredible odds, than all leaders since put together.

  206. @obwandiyag

    Yeah, making everything about race is obie’s job!

  207. anastasia says:

    Now, before my “conspiracy theorist” readers get too excited about where I’m going with this column … no, this was not a “fake” uprising. There was an authentic uprising at the center of it.


  208. @Bragadocious

    From outside America, we find it very strange that such an highly educated society does not know the difference between communism and socialism. You have (rightfully) been taught to fear and hate communism, then you were told that socialism is actually communism, and now you all heartily embrace communism and call it capitalism!
    It would be funny, if you fucking bolsheviks were not cruising the entire palnet killing off all the non-Jewish and anti-Zionists! You even kill Jews, because the Zionists told you they are sand-fleas and ragheads and camel-jockeys…all the childish names you can think of to excuse your childish politics.
    So, yes, Bernie Sanders is far from perfect, but he is a socialist, Hillary is a communist, so is Obama, Clinton, Bush, Bush, Johnson, Merckel, Macron (oh, gods, he thinks he’s the friggin’ Kommissar) and every other member of the Zionist cacastocracy.
    Just thought I’ll say that.

  209. @hillaire

    And once that combination of “bloods” became stableized over centuries, the end result is “British blood!”

  210. @Rooster 3

    You said it about as accurately and succinctly as good be said. Agree!

  211. vot tak says:

    “No matter, it’s still a big win for GloboCap. Forcibly removing Trump from office is, and has always been, gravy.”

    Except trump is a salesman for “globocap”. If they are dissatified, all they need to do is fire him. Maybe less koolaide consumption is in order…

  212. Maybe Jarvanka Trumpstein actually believes in the 10th amendment?

Current Commenter

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone

 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments have been licensed to The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All C.J. Hopkins Comments via RSS
Our Reigning Political Puppets, Dancing to Invisible Strings
The unspoken statistical reality of urban crime over the last quarter century.
Talk TV sensationalists and axe-grinding ideologues have fallen for a myth of immigrant lawlessness.