The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection$
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 Washington Watcher II Archive
Respectable Right’s Conflicted Reaction to Orbán Shows White Ethnonationalism Is Coming to America
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • B
Show CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán delivered one of the most powerful speeches of his life recently, and the Leftist Regime Media lost its collective mind. Speaking at a Romanian event, Orbán stressed the importance of race to his version of nationalism, and declared that Hungary must resist becoming a “mixed-race” country. This was no declaration that Hungary is just defined by “ideas” or “culture.” Orbán believes that Hungarians define Hungary, and vows to protect his people from the ravages of globalism. This situation puts his Respectable Right U.S. fans in an awkward position. They want Orbán to be a friendly civic nationalist who simply wants to boost Hungarian birthrates in a non-racist way. But his powerful speech reminds us that nationalism must address race.

Counter-Currents website performed a great service by translating and posting the 9,000-word speech in full, and it’s well worth the read [The West Has Moved to Central Europe, by Viktor Orbán, July 27, 2022].

Orbán warned his audience about the many dangers posed to Western Civilization: the shrinking number of Europeans, the rise in non-European births, and mass migration, which he called “population replacement.” He endorsed Jean Raspail’s Camp of the Saints for showing “the spiritual developments underlying the West’s inability to defend itself.” Immigration has split the West, Orban says:

One half is a world where European and non-European peoples live together. These countries are no longer nations; they are nothing more than a conglomeration of peoples. I could also say that it is no longer the Western world, but the post-Western world. And around 2050, the laws of mathematics will lead to the final demographic shift: cities in this part of the continent—or that part—will see the proportion of residents of non-European origin rising to over 50% of the total.

And here we are in Central Europe—in the other half of Europe, or of the West. If it were not somewhat confusing, I could say that the West—let’s say the West in its spiritual sense—has moved to Central Europe: The West is here, and what is left over there is merely the post-West.

You would never see an American or Western European politician, with the exception of Eric Zemmour and maybe a few others, dare broach this subject. Few have the guts to point out the obvious: Importing non-westerners changes a nation.

Orbán is also the first head of state ever to endorse Raspail’s dystopian novel—the last copies of which are available at But the most controversial and racially-explicit part of the speech came a few paragraphs later:

In such a multi-ethnic context, there is an ideological feint here that is worth talking about and focusing on. The internationalist Left employs a feint, an ideological ruse: the claim—their claim—that Europe by its very nature is populated by peoples of mixed race. This is a historical and semantic sleight of hand, because it conflates two different things. There is a world in which European peoples are mixed together with those arriving from outside Europe. Now that is a mixed-race world. And there is our world, where people from within Europe mix with one another, move around, work, and relocate. So, for example, in the Carpathian Basin we are not mixed-race: We are simply a mixture of peoples living in our own European homeland. And, given a favorable alignment of stars and a following wind, these peoples merge together in a kind of Hungaro-Pannonian sauce, creating their own new European culture. This is why we have always fought: We are willing to mix with one another, but we do not want to become peoples of mixed race. This is why we fought at Nándorfehérvár [Belgrade], this is why we stopped the Turks at Vienna, and—if I am not mistaken —this is why, in still older times, the French stopped the Arabs at Poitiers.

Shrill hysterics from around the world followed Orban’s discussion of a “mixed-race world.” The International Auschwitz Committee of Holocaust Survivors demanded consequences. Romania’s foreign minister declared that “racism is a poisonous political invention.” Several European Union officials and members of parliament called for Hungary to be punished. And a Jewish adviser to Orbán resigned and attacked her former boss as a “Nazi” [Hungary’s Viktor Orbán faces outrage after saying Europeans shouldn’t become ‘mixed race’, by Rick Noack, The Washington Post, July 27, 2022].

But also interesting was the reaction of American conservatives. CPAC has refused to disinvite Orbán from its upcoming Texas conference. “Let’s listen to the man speak,” CPAC chairman Matt Schlapp said. “We’ll see what he says. And if people have a disagreement with something he says, they should raise it” [Viktor Orbán Will Still Speak at CPAC Despite ‘Nazi’ Speech Backlash, by Mark Niquette and Jeff Green, Bloomberg, July 26, 2022]

It’s good for CPAC to stand by Orbán, but it is rich because CPAC has, in the past, banned those who said the same things. Now, however, it allows a head of state who endorses the Great Replacement theory, Camp of the Saints, and racial nationalism to give a keynote address. What a difference being in office makes.

Other “conservatives” were not as accepting. Cathy Young, writing at The Bulwark, an ardent Never Trump rag, demanded that conservatives repudiate Orbán’s “white nationalism” [Do American ‘National Conservatives’ Condone Orbán’s White Nationalism?, The Bulwark, July 28, 2022]. Washington Examiner writer James Sweet said American conservatives should have nothing to do with Orban’s racism:

Racial discrimination should not be a component of a movement’s ideology. Conservatives can, and should, support strong borders without dehumanizing the individuals involved. There are a variety of valid reasons for increasing border security, but the “great replacement” and “race-mixing” are not among them. …

The future of conservatism relies on appealing to communities across the nation, regardless of the race and ethnicity of its citizens. While Orban’s statements apply to African and Middle Eastern immigrants in Europe, the implications of his rhetoric when applied to the U.S. are clear

[Conservatives shouldn’t ignore Orban’s ‘race-mixing’ comments, by James Sweet, Washington Examiner, July 25, 2022]

National Review’s Dan McLaughlin was also uncomfortable, but hesitated to condemn Orbán outright. He thinks a different standard must be applied to Hungary than to America:

It is, however, vital for Americans neither to project our own views of race and culture onto Hungary, nor to import a Hungarian sensibility on these matters into our politics and culture. Hungarians have sound historical reasons to see the nation-state of Hungary as inseparable from the Hungarian people, to the point that the nation has no reason for existence if its people cease to be Hungarian in culture, language, and national self-identification. Their reasons are not our reasons, their history is not our history, and their ways are not our ways

[Viktor Orbán and His People, July 27, 2022].

But what is this key difference between Hungary and America? Well, McLaughlin believes America is a “universalist” nation and “anyone could become an American.” In other words, cucking is limited just to America. Hungary can still insist on ethnonationalism.

More vocal Orbán fans said the same thing. Christina Pushaw, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis’ spokeswoman, also defended ethnonationalism for former communist republics but repudiated the idea for America. Eastern Europeans can easily become Americans, she said, but Americans can never become Eastern Europeans. Ethnonationalism for thee, but not for me.

Surprisingly, the usually cucky Rod Dreher stood up for Orbán. The American Conservative scribe has been instrumental in making Hungary a popular model for the American mainstream Right. Dreher has tried to sugarcoat Orbán for his cucky audience. He downplays the importance of mass migration and demographic replacement to the Hungarian prime minister’s appeal. Instead, Dreher admires Orbán simply because he stands up to “wokeness” and advocates family subsidies [How the American Right Fell in Love With Hungary, by Elisabeth Zerofsky, The New York Times, October 19, 2021].

In his first attempt to defend Orban’s mixed-race comments, Dreher audaciously claimed the Hungarian leader didn’t mean race but instead meant “nationality”! He also insisted Orbán, in referring to Muslims whom he didn’t want in Europe, was not referring to “brown and black people” generally. And mixing of peoples and immigration, he claimed, has been bad for Europeans, but not for Americans. That’s a curious claim considering all the damage the 1965 Immigration Act has done to America [Last Word On Orbán & ‘Mixed Race’, by Rod Dreher, The American Conservative, July 26, 2022].

In a follow-up article, Dreher, like NR’s McLaughlin, insisted that it’s OK for Hungary to be ethnonationalist…but not for America. However, he did dare to skewer anti-Orbán neocons in his squishy defense:

Over at T he Bulwark, Cathy Young lays into me and other supporters of Orbán (but mostly me) for supposedly favoring “ethnonationalism.” Bill Kristol tweets his agreement. This is curious, and not just because I reject the idea that the United States is or should be ethnonationalist. It’s because both Young and Kristol are Jewish, and supporters of the State of Israel and its right to exist, as am I. In what sense, then, are they not in favor of ethnonationalism? Is it only okay to think of your people as belonging to a nation that has a right to exist on its own terms if you’re Jewish, but not if you are Magyar?

[‘Race’, ‘Nation,’ And Modern Times, July 28, 2022]

That’s a very good question—and one likely to land Dreher in hot water. Shockingly, he hasn’t apologized for asking the obvious. Maybe Orbán is rubbing off on him after all.

For his part, Orbán insisted his comments weren’t racial. “It happens sometimes that I say something in a way that can be misunderstood but … the position I stand for, is a cultural, civilization (based) stance,” he said at a press conference alongside Austrian Chancellor Karl Nehammer. The Austrian leader seemed to accept Orban’s explanation [Hungary’s Orbán says his anti-immigration stance not rooted in racism after backlash, by Krisztina Than, Reuters, July 28, 2022].

That explanation was meant to appease foreign audiences. His real message was found in the speech delivered in Hungarian. And that’s the message American immigration patriots must hear.

We’re not civic nationalists. We don’t think Indian immigrants can easily join the Historic American Nation simply because they’re entrepreneurial or can speak English. We want to preserve the people who actually made this country and ensure they remain the majority.

It’s the same motivation that drives Hungarian nationalists to keep Hungary Hungarian. We want to keep America American.

Of course this puts American cuckservatives in an awkward position vis-a-vis Orbán. They want to pretend race isn’t real and Orbán is a mere civic nationalist. But his speech undercuts those assumptions. And instead of shunning him, Conservatism Incers invited Orbán to deliver a keynote address at the next CPAC and have not (yet) disinvited him.

That’s a big change for the Beltway Right. Ethnonationalism is apparently now acceptable—so long as it’s from Eastern Europe.

Prediction: it won’t be long before the American Conservatives Establishment is forced to retreat and accept ethnonationalism in their own country.

Washington Watcher II [Email him] is an anonymous DC insider.

(Republished from VDare by permission of author or representative)
Hide 19 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. Early-20th-Century Brazil try solving its ‘Negro Problem’ by mingling Blacks with Whites (read: miscegenation), which, after enough generations, would, it was thought, whiten Brazil’s ENTIRE population as the Black ‘germ plasm’ would be totally subdued. Three points:
    I) That’s genocide. Literally.
    II) It didn’t work at all. As everybody knows.
    III) Eventually, such plan was abandoned by the Brazilian élites.

    If I were Orbán, I’d use such a historical example and say something to the effect:
    “Opposing a mixed-race Hungary is the only true ‘anti-racist’ position. As I oppose genocide.”

  2. Sorry but the Man from Hungry is another Jewish Puppet. Israel owns him just like they own our politicians.

  3. Chris Moore says: • Website

    Over at The Bulwark, Cathy Young lays into me and other supporters of Orbán (but mostly me) for supposedly favoring “ethnonationalism.” Bill Kristol tweets his agreement. This is curious, and not just because I reject the idea that the United States is or should be ethnonationalist. It’s because both Young and Kristol are Jewish, and supporters of the State of Israel and its right to exist, as am I. In what sense, then, are they not in favor of ethnonationalism? Is it only okay to think of your people as belonging to a nation that has a right to exist on its own terms if you’re Jewish, but not if you are Magyar?

    Yes, if you believe what the ((Jews)) pretend to believe, which is that they’re “chosen” royalty, imbued with the inherent right to sit in judgment of the nations as a god-race. This method act is their essence, and they would cease to exist absent the grand pose. They would cease, forever.

    If someone were to go to the collective ((Jew)) and say “Come on. Between you and me, admit it: your entire racket is a big act for money, power and prestige.” If the ((Jew)) was under a truth serum and had 5 cocktails under his belt, maybe he’d wink. Maybe. But under no other circumstances would the ((Jew)) tip his hand.

    So the question becomes, why does everyone continue to go to the ((Jew)) scam artist and ask permission for anything? And the answer is: it’s because the Anglo cucks have trained themselves and the world look to the ((Jew)) for validation. And they did this because the ((Jew)) moneychanger racket was so convincing and effective, because the ((Jew)) has maintained the discipline for so long, he has steeled himself never to admit guilt. He’s a master of deceit and deception, both toward the goyim, and psychologically toward himself. And that’s exactly the kind of man the Anglo-elites of yore needed to maintain the finances of Empire — a role the ((Jew)) has carried on even long after those Anglo-elites have passed the scene.

    “Never let them see you sweat” is the Zionist slogan. But maintaining the Big Lie, over time, takes its toll. Especially since the Big Lie is based in mass murder.

    Tic-toc, Zionist, tic-toc… You WILL break eventually. And your psychopathic, god-race grand pose WILL be laid bare before the entire world as the murderous fraud and farce it has always been.

    In fact, it seems to be happening as we speak.

    • Replies: @Justvisiting
  4. Bookish1 says:

    If the man is pro israel so what? That doesn’t mean jews own him. I am pro israel and a white nationalist at the same time. My reasoning: if israel goes under we get even more jews in the west. Let them have a country so we have a place to send them when the time comes.

    • Replies: @niteranger
    , @Legba
  5. Bookish1 says:

    I hope Orban has good security wh,when he comes here

  6. Realist says:

    Speaking at a Romanian event, Orbán stressed the importance of race to his version of nationalism, and declared that Hungary must resist becoming a “mixed-race” country.

    Kudos to Mr. Orbán. Sadly none of our leaders are as intelligent.

  7. SteveK9 says:

    Bernard Schwarz wrote an essay in The Atlantic in 1995 on ‘The Diversity Myth’, one of the best written essays in English I have ever read.

    In one comment he addresses the question ‘what does it mean to be an American?’ and the answer was basically an American was a ‘modified Englishman’. For centuries we accepted European immigrants, but the goal for both America and the immigrants (in general) was assimilation. That goal has faded more and more.

    Now we have the question, can a purely civil society replace the Nation State? Orban is asking that, and Schwarz asked it 30 years ago. We don’t know the answer, but judging by America today, it doesn’t look good.

  8. Saint Rod probably doesn’t want to get Phil Giraldied over at TAC. For a while after Phil was banned from TAC, in the comments to foreign policy articles, someone was often writing, “Bring back Phil Giraldi.” Once Rod even posted one of my comments that had ((( ))). I’ll bet he got his ass chewed for that. And other commenters would call out America’s Israel-centric foreign policy. Now commenting over there has been sharply curtailed.

  9. @niteranger

    So tell us, Sister Christian, what world leader of European descent is doing any better than Orban? He’s the best that red-pilled, non-woke whites have for now.

    • Agree: Bookish1
    • Replies: @niteranger
  10. Dr. Doom says:

    The cat of White Genocide is out of the bag. Thanks, Bob, RIP.
    The Zion Pigs want to put it back in Schrodinger’s Death Box.
    No chance. No chance in Hell. No chance.

    Ethnonationalism is “celebrated” amongst the brown folks.
    White Men have LEARNED something.
    Sociology 101. In Group vs out group.

    No more Zion Pig Kosher Swill Fake “patriotism”.
    A Nation is ALL ABOUT RACE.
    The Culture is a phenotype of the genotype.

    The Bagel Boys have been abandoned by their Master.
    Satan does not want their fake ghey globull nonsense.
    Satan is ALL ABOUT PROGRESS, not sexual perversion with children.

    The Zion Pigs were useful idiots in The Great Game.
    They have always been EXPENDABLE ASSETS.
    They have taught the White Men to be ETHNOCENTRIC.

    Ah, what a quick teachable moment is existential threats.
    The Zion Pigs are no longer good for anything.
    Its time for them to be written off by The Corporation.

    When useful idiots outlive their usefulness, its liquidation time.
    Satan has never been overly sentimental, but He is an excellent liar.
    The problem today, is so few people are good at LYING.

  11. @Chris Moore

    “Is it only okay to think of your people as belonging to a nation that has a right to exist on its own terms if you’re Jewish, but not if you are Magyar?”

    How about a nation for Chinese?

    Or a nation for Japanese?

    The cuck-servatives have no answer there either–it exposes them for the stupid fraud that they are.

  12. @Bookish1

    You are a simpleton. Because Israel’s leaders always want war for profit and their own gain. Look at the Jewish Neocons that have taken control of our administration and the mess in the Ukraine. They are destroying our country as they control the narrative of BLM, Anitfa, and the Magic Pride movement. They have 24 hour attack against western civilization and whites. Which planet do you live on?

    Most of the world’s problems begin with Israel. Israel always wins…no matter which side they are on. They have a history of attacking their own host country until they destroy it.

    • Replies: @Bookish1
  13. @Sir Launcelot Canning

    If that’s your analysis of doing better we are in trouble. Most of Europe is already lost. This has nothing to do with Christianity; it has to do with what Jews have always done from starting wars to taking over the governments, media, and institutions which they will eventually do in Hungry given enough time.

  14. Legba says:

    I can think of a different place to send them.

  15. Ethnonationalism is apparently now acceptable—so long as it’s from Eastern Europe. Prediction: it won’t be long before the American Conservatives Establishment is forced to retreat and accept ethnonationalism in their own country.

    The prediction does not follow from the previous sentence or anything in the article. I’d like to believe it, but see no evidence that Conservatism Inc. has the slightest inclination to support white ethnonationalism. That will only arrive from a dissident Right.

  16. big daddy says:

    It is ok for Israel to be racist, isn’t it? So why not any country?

  17. Bookish1 says:

    I never said that I backed those jews in the U.S. I agree with you on what they are doing and am opposed to them as much as you are. But with Israel we have a place to send them.

  18. The sneaky Jew always plays for time. Even Orban will not live and govern forever. If necessary, Mossad will have him assassinated, which will seem like an accident. He would not be the first. Eurocratic corrupt willing Jew servants who sell their own people are everywhere. They are already impatiently waiting in the wings to “diversify” Hungary.

    This could be done, for example, by making Hungary’s social system more “attractive” for third world immigration. In addition, of course, the entire machinery of brainwashing (white guilt / worship of everything foreign) has to be anchored in the “education” system, which the West has undergone since decades.

    Finally, the island of Hungary cannot be defended forever against a surrounding overpowering sea of “multiculturalism, tolerance, cosmopolitanism and diversity”. The superial high priest of all hypermorality in the postmodern age clarifies with the raised warning forefinger: “Nationalism never again, it will end up in anudda Shoah!”

  19. Cutler says:

    I saw Matteo Salvini explicitly talking about Italians deliberately being replaced by subsaharan Africans to all his online followers during a live stream and he has repeated it many times at rallies and his party colleague whose name escapes me right now said the White Race in Italy faced replacement by endless Africans during a election race and won his race handily inspite of msm hysterics. So there are lots of examples of leaders all around the West saying what needs saying so I’m certain Washington Watcher is correct that Ethnonationalism is coming here too. Sooner than later I hope

Current Commenter

Leave a Reply -

 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments have been licensed to The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Commenting Disabled While in Translation Mode
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Washington Watcher II Comments via RSS
How America was neoconned into World War IV
Analyzing the History of a Controversial Movement
Shouldn't they recuse themselves when dealing with the Middle East?
The Shaping Event of Our Modern World
The Surprising Elements of Talmudic Judaism