The Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 Jared Taylor Archive
Making Sense of Race
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information



=>

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeThanksLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

Edward Dutton, Making Sense of Race, Washington Summit Publishers, 2020, 359 pp., $24.99 (soft cover)

The first chapter of Making Sense of Race ends with these words: “Clearly, race is a biological reality. It needs to be understood. The most up-to-date research on it needs to be widely known. Its implications need to be explored. That is the purpose of this book.” It would be hard to think of a more worthy goal, and Edward Dutton, who teaches evolutionary psychology at Asbiro University in Poland, achieves it admirably. The pity is that books like this are shoved into obscurity, so the people who need to read it won’t.

For those who do, there are many rewards. For anyone new to the biology of race, Dr. Dutton describes how evolution produced physical race differences. He also includes an excellent introduction to how r-K theory applies to race, a subject first explored in 1994 by Philippe Rushton and that remains one of the most important modern perspectives on race. This book is an excellent Rushton primer, and even adds important refinements to his work.

Dr. Dutton has no patience for the idea that race is a social construct. He writes that the animal equivalent of race — subspecies — is universally accepted. One common definition of a subspecies is a group within a species that can be distinguished by untrained observers at least 75 percent of the time. By that standard, races are clearly subspecies.

People who deny race point out that there is more genetic variation within members of the same race than between races — but that’s true for dog breeds, and not many people think the difference between a terrier and a pug is all in our minds. As with humans, the DNA that varies most within a breed make little or no genetic difference. The 30 percent of the dog genome — about 15 percent in the case of humans — where we find patterns of difference between subspecies are the parts that produce physical and temperamental differences. In the case of dogs, these are the traits breeders cared about; in the cases of humans, they are the traits that had evolutionary importance.

Sports fans note race differences all the time. The last time a white man won the 100-meter dash in the Olympics was in 1980 (he was a Scot named Allan Wells). Even then, men of West African origin dominated the sprints. Likewise, every winner in the World’s Strongest Man competition, held each year since 1977, has been white. There are very few black swim champions; their bones are denser so they float lower in the water, which increases drag. The best ping pong players are Asians, probably because the sport requires such quick reactions. Of all the races, Asians have the quickest reaction times and the highest intelligence. Blacks have the slowest and the lowest.

Jul 25, 1980 – Allan Wells wins gold in the men’s 100m event during the 1980 Summer Olympic Games. (Credit Image: © TASS via ZUMA Wire)
Jul 25, 1980 – Allan Wells wins gold in the men’s 100m event during the 1980 Summer Olympic Games. (Credit Image: © TASS via ZUMA Wire)

Dr. Dutton notes other race differences. Amerindians almost never have Type A or B blood, and the overwhelming majority have Type O. Race is an important criterion for organ-donor compatibility, and is even more important for bone-marrow transplants. White Americans move around more in their sleep than black Americans, probably because whites evolved in colder areas and moving around kept them warm at night. Whites are three times more likely than blacks to have restless leg syndrome, probably for the same reason.

For all people, volar skin — on the palms of hands and soles of feet — is light colored. This is especially noticeable in blacks. Why? Because pigmented skin is metabolically expensive. It protects Africans against too much ultraviolet light, but there is less need to protect the volar areas because they don’t get much sun. In places where there isn’t much sun, dark skin is a disadvantage because skin makes vitamin D when exposed to sunlight. Somalis living in Scandinavia need to take D supplements to stay healthy. The reason Asians have straight hair is probably because it lets in more sun than curly hair, and was therefore an advantage in the north.

Asians also have relatively flat faces, which protects against frostbite. Their “yellow” appearance is caused by a layer of fat below the skin that protects against cold, and the epicanthic fold that “slants” their eyes reduces glare from snow. Southeast Asians have these traits but to a lesser degree, because they evolved where it was warmer.

African Bushmen have a similar epicanthic fold that evolved independently, probably to protect against the sun’s glare in the desert. DNA analysis finds that Bushmen are the closest people on earth to the first homo sapiens. DNA has changed over the millennia, and that of Bushmen is the most ancient and therefore also the most varied.

“Bush-Men Hottentots armed for an Expedition” by Samuel Daniell, from his book African Scenery and Animals (1804).
“Bush-Men Hottentots armed for an Expedition” by Samuel Daniell, from his book African Scenery and Animals (1804).

We have learned a lot about ancient DNA by studying the remains of Neanderthals and a related archaic human group, the Denisovans. Denisovans interbred with humans up until about 30,000 years ago, which means there were probably populations of them as recently 15,000 years ago. Three to five percent of the DNA of Melanesians and Australian Aborigines is Denisovan, as is 7 to 8 percent of Papuan DNA. Europeans have 2 to 4 Neanderthal DNA but little or no Denisovan. Some Africans have a tiny amount of Neandertal DNA, which they would have got from ancient migrations back into Africa.

Dr. Dutton includes a table of racial groups that shows how genetically similar and dissimilar they are. Europeans are most distant from Pygmies, Bushmen, and Australian Aborigines and — as one would expect — closest to non-European Caucasians, such as Arabs and high-caste Indians. The groups separated by the greatest genetic distance are Amerindians on the one hand and Bushmen and Pygmies on the other. Dr. Dutton notes that Pygmies are of normal height as children but do not have an adolescent growth spurt. No one knows why they evolved that way.

Some important evolutionary differences appeared since the discovery of agriculture. Groups that never raised crops, such as Eskimos, Bushmen, Maoris, and some Amerindians, tend to have special characteristics. One is an inability to handle alcohol, because beer- and wine-making appeared only where there was agriculture. Groups that have been around alcohol for a long time have fewer people who either cannot tolerate it or become easily addicted. Such people were selected out. Groups that did not develop agriculture or did so relatively late are also more susceptible to type 2 diabetes, probably because they have less experience with a high-carbohydrate diet.

Attawapiskat, Canada; Although Attawapiskat is officially a dry community, the illegal sale of alcohol is a major problem. Staff Sergeant Joseph Loutitt of the Nishnawbe Aski Police Services sifts through about 300 bottles of alcohol seized from one truck. (Credit Image: Toronto Star / ZUMAPRESS.com)
Attawapiskat, Canada; Although Attawapiskat is officially a dry community, the illegal sale of alcohol is a major problem. Staff Sergeant Joseph Loutitt of the Nishnawbe Aski Police Services sifts through about 300 bottles of alcohol seized from one truck. (Credit Image: Toronto Star / ZUMAPRESS.com)

Agriculture also selects for a longer time preference. Farmers have to clear land, plant seed, tend crops — and wait. Hunter/gatherers get quick rewards right away. People without agriculture are therefore not used to planning ahead. The classic example is Bushmen, who could not be taught to raise livestock; they ate the animals rather than breed them.

Eskimos have the usual combination — they did not farm, have a drinking problem, and tend not to plan ahead — but have the largest brains of any racial group. Brain size is correlated with intelligence, and with the usual pattern: Asians, then whites, then Africans. Eskimos, however, have an average IQ of about 90. What accounts for their big brains? They have very good spatial skills, which help in featureless terrain, and this ability probably required a big brain. The average man’s brain is larger than the average woman’s brain, probably because of superior spatial abilities.

Autism, schizophrenia, and genius

Dr. Dutton contrasts autism — which is more common in men than women — with schizophrenia, which is more common in women. Autistic men are high in testosterone and have brains with exaggeratedly male features. They are notoriously insensitive to the feelings of others. Schizophrenia is a low-testosterone condition often coupled with pathological sensitivity. Schizophrenics see so much meaning and intent everywhere that it drives them crazy. People further out on the schizophrenia scale are also more likely to have intense religious experiences; they are probably powerful visions of meaning and intent. Schizophrenics are also somewhat feminine in that they tend not to be so good at systemizing experience logically and rationally.

Geniuses are likely to be very smart but also autistic. They are smart enough to see things in novel ways, and autistic enough either not to care that their creations may upset others or not even to realize that others will think they are deviant. Newton, for example, had a foul temper and few friends. Dr. Dutton suspects that there have not been many genius-level thinkers in East Asia because the evolutionary environment was so harsh. It was so demanding that it selected for high intelligence, but he argues, “For East Asians, the selection pressure for cooperativeness in such a harsh ecology would be so strong that it would be dangerous to risk producing geniuses.”

Portrait of Nikola Tesla. Credit: ZUMA Press / Fine Art Images
Portrait of Nikola Tesla. Credit: ZUMA Press / Fine Art Images

Some people associate left-handedness with genius, and it is another high-testosterone trait. Men are about 23 percent more likely to be left-handed than women, but left-handedness rates vary by race and nation: 13.2 percent in the Netherlands, 2 percent in Korea.

Religion, intelligence, and the fate of the West

Dr. Dutton has a lot to say about religion:

In Western societies, those who collectively worship a moral god are more like to be married, less likely to be divorced, are more likely to have children, and more likely to have larger numbers of children. They have lower rates of physical and mental illness, live longer, are more likely to get over serious illnesses, and have lower morbidity. Religiousness is also associated, even in non-religious societies, with low Neuroticism, high Agreeableness, and high Conscientiousness.

Religion is therefore good for society. People who think God is watching them are likely to be empathetic and cooperative because they try to do what God wants. As Dr. Dutton notes, “in general, the kind of behavior God would be understood to want would be group-oriented, pro-social behavior.” Until recently, people who were not religious — and therefore less social — were less likely to succeed in life and have children, so their genes were weeded out. Religious behavior, which is about 40 percent heritable, can therefore be thought of as evolved:

Religious ideas are products of evolution in the sense that the negative “mutations” have been weeded out over generations of selection. In effect, morals and other ideas attributed to God are, in reality, the net experience of human endeavor that has happened to be successful, at least for that particular group, over a substantial period of time. Presenting that experience in terms of divine laws is, therefore, an extremely powerful way of preserving them to ensure future evolutionarily adaptive behavior.

In this sense, atheism is a harmful mutation. Dr. Dutton argues that this mutation has accumulated along with many others because so many defectives now survive to adulthood. Under Darwinian conditions, infant mortality was 40 percent; it is now half a percent in rich countries. This means harmful mutations increase every generation, and since 84 percent of the genome helps build the brain, more defective brains are surviving to adulthood. This means more autism, depression, schizophrenia, etc. Dr. Dutton argues that “such people are more likely to espouse maladaptive worldviews — including being irreligious, anti-natalist, anti-nationalist, and multiculturalist.” He calls these people “spiteful mutants,” adding that they “gradually persuade others to adopt their fitness-damaging ideas — not having children, believing that life is meaningless, or putting the interests of other groups above their own.”

Non-religious population by country, 2010. (Data from Pew Research. Image by Pharexia via Wikimedia.)
Non-religious population by country, 2010. (Data from Pew Research. Image by Pharexia via Wikimedia.)

This a particular threat to whites because, like Asians, they have evolved high intelligence, but they are less ethnocentric. Dr. Dutton argues that high intelligence leads to empathetic thinking and openness to new experiences, which can be dangerous if not tempered with ethnocentrism:

Intelligent people will let foreigners into the society because they assume they are ultimately honest and good and everything will be OK in the end. Also, registering high in Openness, the intelligence will be excited and fascinated by the exotic and different. Being high in empathy, immigrants, or potential immigrants, if they are from poorer societies, then the intelligent will be strongly inclined to want to improve their lot in life. And again, being trusting, they will assume that this will be reciprocated. For the intelligent, there are no enemies at the gates; they see only intelligent people like themselves.

Religious people tend to be more ethnocentric, with a better developed sense of us-versus-them. However, in the West, high intelligence is associated with atheism, which tends to come with the negative traits we saw earlier. And yet, Dr. Dutton notes that intelligent Westerners appear to have invented a new religion that has a kind of Christian logic:

We have sinned (racism, slavery, colonialism, etc). We seek contrition (anti-racism, color-blindness). And we hope for redemption (a post-racist society). Among other things, this belief system has suppressed a serious discussion of racial reality — instituting new designations for what is “sacrilege” and who we consider “heretics.” This is because, if race differences in outcomes are significantly genetic, they have nothing to do with our “sins,” leading to a fundamental challenge to the New Church and all those invested in it.

Unlike Christianity, this religion is a potentially suicidal threat to society. Also, unlike Christianity, it holds out no hope for salvation because whites are life-long racists no matter what they do or think. Jews appear to be the one non-Asian, high-IQ group that has retained a high level of ethnocentrism despite declining religious belief. Jews may be ethnocentric by nature. Dr. Dutton cites a study that found Israeli infants were much more likely than north-German infants to become “inconsolably upset” in the presence of strangers.

Along with a new religion of self-destruction, whites have sharply dysgenic breeding patterns. As Richard Lynn has pointed out, the correlation between a child’s IQ and his number of siblings is negative — on the order of -0.2 — because dim parents have more children than smart parents. Dr. Dutton notes that in Britain, the only people with above-replacement fertility are on welfare, which means they have an average IQ of about 80. He also notes that in Medieval Europe, about two percent of the adult male population in every generation was executed for crimes. Now, the same people have children.

The implications of this are obvious, but no one dares say so. The famous British atheist Richard Dawkins was slammed viciously for tweeting that even though he thought eugenics is immoral, it would certainly improve humans just as it improves roses and dairy cows.

What should whites do about any of this? Dr. Dutton does not say, but by stating the facts clearly and persuasively, he makes sense of race in a way that leaves no doubt as to the choices we must make. Surprisingly, this book is on Amazon. Buy it while you can.

(Republished from American Renaissance by permission of author or representative)
 
• Category: Race/Ethnicity, Science • Tags: Race, Racial Reality 
Hide 12 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
    []
  1. I went ahead and purchased the Kindle edition for $2.99. Looking forward to reading it.

  2. The State Religion of Woke include anti-racism as a moral imperative. It has brainwashed the masses to mistakenly mix up two different kinds of judgment. We judge people’s skills according to performance metrics. But we confuse it with judging people’s character according to morality. Then we mistakenly go one step further, and mix up the different consequences of these different kinds of judgment, believing it all to be one universal morality play. This is quite obviously pseudo-morality based on a category error, but the left has been enormously successful in pushing it down everyone’s throat.

    The truth is, segregation is neither moral nor immoral. But forced integration degrades performance standards, hands out artificial achievement, breeds resentment, erodes character, unleashes repressed violence, tramples freedom of association, and drags communities down into chaos. That is truly immoral. We’ve been brainwashed into a moral delusion based on false guilt. The only way forward is to create a new understanding about race and morality that morally justifies white’s freedom of association, segregation, and ethnic nationalism. Call it neoracism. Decouple the current linkage between antiracism and morality, show it to be invested in pseudo-morality, and demonstrate a new racially aware morality instead. Otherwise, nothing will change.

  3. This review is fun because its examples of human biodiversity – dense black bones, big Inuit brains – extend beyond the usual, politicized ones.

    But I think caution is always advised when big claims are made about human genetics and evolution. Things are often not as they seem, or as they are portrayed.

    • Replies: @Damocles
  4. A really good explanation here in general though some of the theories tend to be a bit nonsensical, like the straight hair of E Asians is probably due to a population bottleneck more than anything else, so people with straight hair somehow ended up dominating the populations of eastern Asia, the characteristic eyefolds of East Asians along with the Khoisan and even Nilotic Africans are probably more likely an ancient development rather than a climate adaption, the fact that their distribution covering virtually all latitudes means that a climatic explanation seems very unviable. Dark skin colour seems to correlate heavily with the sunniest regions rather than those that are equatorial, like the line across Africa at roughly 15 degrees north contains virtually all the darkest peoples while the equatorial regions often produce Africans who look much more similar to African Americans(in other words much lighter in general though with A Americans that is due to mixture with Whites and also the fact that many came from equatorial Africa.)

    • Replies: @songbird
    , @HbutnotG
  5. songbird says:
    @oliver elkington

    A really good explanation here in general though some of the theories tend to be a bit nonsensical, like the straight hair of E Asians is probably due to a population bottleneck more than anything else

    Seems like it would be easy to test. I mean, you could test heat-shedding with an infrared camera, in cold conditions. Do it with enough people, and the confounding factors would balance out. Occasionally, there are NE Asians with curly or wavy hair. They would make good test subjects.

  6. Thomasina says:

    “Geniuses are likely to be very smart but also autistic.”

    I believe the football player, Messi, would fit in this category. This guy IS a genius and probably is autistic. The best playmaker, the best passer, the best dribbler, best body feints, best shielder, one of the greatest goal scorers, has incredible acceleration and speed, and possesses genius-level vision. The way he is able to score goals by almost always putting the ball inches away from the goalie’s hands or one inch from the post. His mind must be one great big “angle machine”. An absolute artist.

    Coaches and other players have explained how Messi is not always there, often doesn’t seem to even be in the game, how he just wanders around the pitch sometimes until…..

    The following video doesn’t even do him justice. You’d have to watch all of his videos to get a feel for his capability. He is far above the rest, in a class of his own.

    • Replies: @Thomasina
  7. Thomasina says:
    @Thomasina

    I see the video is blocked. You can see it on Youtube under the title “Football’s Greatest Genius HD”.

    Another good one to watch, if you’re interested in what a genius looks like, is “From Little to Legend”. I’ll see if this one posts:

  8. Thomasina says:

    “The best ping pong players are Asians, probably because the sport requires such quick reactions. Of all the races, Asians have the quickest reaction times and the highest intelligence.”

    Yeah, maybe in ping pong. Take a game where creativity and genius are required and you’re not going to see Asians there. I know that sounds rude, and I don’t mean it to be, but it is true. Have you ever seen them drive? Look out!

    The constant glorification of Asians re intelligence? Maybe in math, but only after it’s hammered into their heads from an early age. Hammered.

    “This a particular threat to whites because, like Asians, they have evolved high intelligence, but they are less ethnocentric.”

    I think all races are ethnocentric. Asians would NEVER allow floods of foreigners into their country, not in a million years.

    What’s happening in this country is not because of religion (although it is partly because of that), but propaganda and conditioning by the country’s elites. Whenever people complain, they are shamed and made to feel guilty, and they buy into it because they want to appear “good, kind and nice”. This behavior has got to go.

    People need to realize that wanting to keep people out doesn’t mean you hate or dislike foreigners, that you think you’re better than them, or that when you voice these opinions you’re not still good, kind and nice. All it means is that you want to protect your own culture, your own tribe.

    It used to be blacks vs. whites and that was a big enough problem on its own. Now it’s, “What do the Asians think?” What?

    When there is no glue that binds, you end up in pieces.

    • Agree: throtler
  9. Damocles says:
    @Mitchell Porter

    Sure, let’s be cautious as we explore, but please let us explore some more.

    I have just ordered a paperback copy. Dr. Dutton is a gifted teacher.

  10. Jared Taylor: “… Dr. Dutton notes that intelligent Westerners appear to have invented a new religion that has a kind of Christian logic …”

    Having a kind of Christian logic means it’s not a new religion, just a different, secular form of Christianity. Christianity gives rise to Wokeism just as surely as nits give rise to lice. Therefore, anyone opposed to Wokeism must also oppose Christianity.

    Curiously for someone who claims to be an expert on evolution, Dutton seems to have no sense that it’s impossible to extrapolate what will work in the future from what has worked in the past. Conditions change, and the future is unpredictable. Dinosaurs ruled the Earth for more than 150 million years, and so at the time it would have seemed like insanity to pick the tiny, weak mammals to succeed them and inherit dominance on the planet. But then the asteroid hit.

    Similarly, there’s no way to tell in advance what is or isn’t a “spiteful mutation”. The only certainty would seem to be that the inherent anti-racism of Christianity is a means by which the white race is destroying itself; seeking to transform itself into something different. A multi-racial New Western Man, a man fully adjusted to technological society, is under construction. He’ll be a genetically engineered organism in principle similar to the New Soviet Man, only updated to reflect Woke goals.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_soviet_man

  11. MarkU says:

    A very interesting article which makes lots of good points.

    Another advantage of large brain size in the case of the Inuit might be that a larger head size would be useful for heat retention in cold climates, a smaller surface area to volume ratio.

  12. HbutnotG says:
    @oliver elkington

    The eyefolds of E Asians obviously was selected for when that loess was blowing around. It didn’t get 1,000 ft deep overnight. And, I didn’t need no stinkin’ archeology digs to figure that out, either. Some people probably developed eyelashes like camels, I presume, but without the humps and a bad habit of spitting they were considered undesireable.

Current Commenter
says:

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone


 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments have been licensed to The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Commenting Disabled While in Translation Mode
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Jared Taylor Comments via RSS