The Unz Review - Mobile
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 Tom Engelhardt ArchiveBlogview
Little Big Man
Into the Whirlwind
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments

He’s huge. Outsized. He fills the news hole at any moment of any day. His over-tanned face glows unceasingly in living rooms across America. Never has a president been quite so big. So absolutely monstrous. Or quite so small.

He’s our Little Big Man.

I know, I know… he induces panic, fear, anxiety, insomnia. Shrinks in liberal America will tell you that, since November 2016, their patients are more heavily medicated and in worse shape. He’s a nightmare, a unique monster. It’s been almost two years since he first entered the presidential race and in all that time I doubt there’s been a moment when the cameras haven’t been trained on him, when he wasn’t “breaking news.” (By May 2016, he had already reportedly received the equivalent in “earned media” of nearly $3 billion in free advertising.) He and his endless controversial statements, flubs, tweets, lies, insults, boasts, tales from outer space, and over-the-moon adjectives are covered daily the way, once upon a time, only Pearl Harbor or the Kennedy assassination was.

Think of him as the end of the world as we, or maybe anyone, including Vladimir Putin, knew it. To me, that means one thing, even though most of you won’t agree: I think we owe Donald Trump a small bow of thanks and a genuine debt of gratitude. He’s teaching us something invaluable, something we probably wouldn’t have grasped without him. He’s teaching us just how deeply disturbed our American world actually is, or he wouldn’t be where he is.

A Quagmire Country

Think of him as a messenger from the gods, the deities of empire gone astray. They sent us a man without a center, undoubtedly because 17 years into the twenty-first century our country lacks a center, and a man without a fixed opinion or a single conviction, except about himself and his family, because this country is now a swirling mess of contradictory beliefs and groups at each other’s throats. They sent us our first billionaire president who left countless people holding the bag in his various, often failed, business dealings. He brings to mind that classic phrase “those that sow the wind, shall reap the whirlwind” just as we’re now reaping the results of the 1% politics that gained such traction in recent years; and of a kind of war-making, American style, that initially seemed aimed at global supremacy, but now seems to have no conceivable goal. We’re evidently destined to go on killing ever more people, producing ever more refugees, cracking open ever more nations, and spreading ever more terror movements until the end of time. They sent a man ready to build a vanity wall on the Mexican border and pour more money into the U.S. military at a time when it’s becoming harder for Americans to imagine investing in anything but an ever-more powerful national security state, even as the country’s infrastructure begins to crumble. They sent a billionaire who once deep-sixed a startling number of his businesses to save a country that couldn’t be more powerful and yet has proven incapable of building a single mile of high-speed rail.

Into this quagmire, the gods dispatched the man who loves MOAB, who drools over “my generals,” who wants to build a “big, fat, beautiful wall” on our southern border, but was beyond clueless about where power actually lay in Washington.

He’s a man with a history but without a sense of history, a man for whom anything is imaginable and everything is mutable, including the past. In this, too, he’s symptomatic of the nation he now “leads.” Who among us even remembers the set of Washington officials who, only a decade and a half ago, had such glorious dreams about establishing a global Pax Americana and who led us so unerringly into an unending hell in the Greater Middle East? Who remembers that those officials of the George W. Bush administration had another dream as well — of a Pax Republicana, a one-party imperial state that would stretch across the American South deep into the Midwest, Southwest, and parts of the West, kneecapping the Democratic Party for an eternity and leaving that artifact of a two-party past confined to the country’s coastal areas. Their dream — and it couldn’t have been more immodest — was to rule the world and its great remaining superpower for… well… more or less ever.

They were to dominate America and America was to dominate everything else in a way no country in history — not the Romans, not the British — had ever done. As they saw it, in the wake of the implosion of the Soviet Union, there would be no other superpower, nor even a bloc of great powers, capable of obstructing America’s destined future. They and their successors would see to that.

The United States would be the land of wealth and power in a previously unimaginable fashion. It would be the land that made everything that went bang in the night — and in that (and perhaps that alone) their dreams would be fulfilled. To this day, Hollywood and its action films dominate planetary screens, while American arms merchants have a near monopoly on selling the world their dangerous toys. As our new president recently put it, their energies and those of the U.S. government should remain focused on getting countries across the globe to engage in “the purchase of lots of beautiful military equipment.” Indeed.

As for the rest of their dream of geopolitical dominance, it began to come a cropper remarkably quickly. As it turned out, the military that American presidents regularly hailed in these years as the “greatest force for human liberation the world has ever known” or “the finest fighting force in the history of the world” couldn’t even win wars against lightly armed insurgents or deal with enemies employing roadside bombs that could be built off the Internet for the price of a pizza. The U.S. military (and its allied warrior corporations) turned out not to be a force for eternal order and triumph but, at least across the Greater Middle East and Africa, for eternal chaos and the spread of terror movements. They were the whirlwind, which meant that neither that “pax” nor that “Americana” would come to pass.

While Rome Burned…

ORDER IT NOW

Meanwhile, back at home, a gerrymandered, near-one-party state did indeed come into existence as the Republicans swept most governorships, gained control of a significant majority of state legislatures, nailed down the House and the Senate, and finally, when Little Big Man entered the Oval Office, took it all. It was a feat for the history books — or so it briefly seemed. Instead, the result has been chaos, thanks in part to a Republican Party that is actually three or four parties and a president barely associated with it, as a war of all against all broke out. None of this should have been surprising, given a congressional party that had honed its skills not on ruling but on blocking rule. In the last months, it has largely proved incapable even of ruling itself, no less the wild man and his unpredictable team of advisers in the White House.

From his “big, fat, beautiful wall” to his “big league,” “phenomenal” tax plan to his “insurance for everybody” healthcare program, the president promises to be the living proof that the long dreamed of Pax Republicana is just another form of war without end on the domestic front.

His victory was, in a sense, a revelation that both political parties had been hollowed out, as every Republican presidential candidate except him was swept unceremoniously off stage and out of contention in a hail of insults. Meanwhile, the Democratic Party, by now a remarkably mindless (and spineless) political machine without much to underpin it, came to seem ever more like the domestic equivalent of those failed states the war on terror was creating in the Greater Middle East. In short, American politics was visibly faltering and, in the whirlwind that deposited Little Big Man in office, a far wider range of Americans seemed in danger of going down, too, including Medicaid users, Obamacare enrollees, meals-on-wheels seniors, and food stamp recipients in what could become a slow-motion collapse of livable lives amid a proliferation of billionaires. Think of us as a nation in the process of consuming itself, even as our president turns the White House into a private business. If this is imperial “decline,” it’s certainly a curious version of it.

It was into the growing hell that passed for the planet’s “sole superpower” that those gods dispatched Little Big Man — not a shape-shifting creature but a man without shape and lacking all fixed ideas (except about himself). He was perfectly capable of saying anything in any situation, and then, in altered circumstances, of saying the opposite without blinking or evidently even noticing. His recent trip to Saudi Arabia was a classic case of just that. Gone were the election campaign denunciations of the Saudis for their human rights record and for possibly being behind the 9/11 attacks, as well as of Islam as a religion that “hates us”; gone was his criticism of Michelle Obama for not wearing a headscarf on her visit to Riyadh (Melania and Ivanka did the same), and of Barack Obama for bowing to a Saudi king (he did, too). Out the window went his previous insistence that any self-respecting American politician must use the phrase “radical Islamic terrorism,” which he carefully avoided. And none of this was different from, say, swearing on the campaign trail that he would never touch Medicaid and then, in his first budget, offering plans to slash $880 billion from that program over the next decade.

Admittedly, Donald Trump — and yes, that’s the first time I’ve used his name, but there was no need, was there? — has yet to appoint his horse (or perhaps his golf cart) as a senator or, as far as we know, commit acts of incest in the tradition of Caligula, the first mad Roman emperor. Yet in many ways, doesn’t he feel something like an updated version of that figure or perhaps of Nero who so famously fiddled — actually, according to historian Mary Beard in her book SPQR, played the lyre — while Rome burned?

Fortunately, unlike every psychiatrist in town, I’m not bound by the “Goldwater Rule,” which prohibits a diagnosis of a public figure you haven’t personally examined. While I have no expertise in whether Donald Trump has a “narcissistic personality disorder,” I see no reason not to say the obvious: he’s a distinctly disturbed individual. That he was nonetheless elected president tells us a good deal about where we are as a country today. As Tony Schwartz, who actually wrote his bestselling book The Art of the Deal, put it recently, “Trump was equally clear with me that he didn’t value — nor even necessarily recognize — the qualities that tend to emerge as people grow more secure, such as empathy, generosity, reflectiveness, the capacity to delay gratification or, above all, a conscience, an inner sense of right and wrong.”

Now, that should be frightening. After all, given who he is, given his fear of “losing,” of rejection, of not being loved (or more accurately, adulated), of in short being obliterated, who knows what such a man might do in a crisis, including obliterating the rest of us. After all, he already lives in a world without fixed boundaries, definitions, or history, which is why nothing he says has real meaning. And yet he couldn’t be more meaningful. He’s a message, a warning of the first order, and if that were all he were, he would just be an inadvertent teacher about the nature of our American world and we could indeed thank him and do our best to move on.

Unfortunately, there’s another factor to take into account. Humanity had, in the years before his arrival, come up with two quite different and devastating ways of doing ourselves in, one an instant Armageddon, the other a slow-motion trip to hell. Each of them threatens to cripple or destroy the very planet that has nurtured us these tens of thousands of years. It was not, of course, Donald Trump who put us in this peril. He’s just a particularly grim reminder of how dangerous our world has truly become.

After all, Little Big Man now has unparalleled access to the most “beautiful” weapons of all and he’s eager to update and expand an already vast U.S. arsenal of them. I’m talking, of course, about nuclear weapons. Any president we elect has, since the 1950s, had the power to take out the planet. Only once have we come truly close. Nonetheless, for the control over such weaponry to be in the hands of a deeply unpredictable and visibly disturbed president is obviously a danger to us all.

ORDER IT NOW

It could be assumed that the gods who sent him into the Oval Office at such a moment have a perverse sense of humor. Certainly, on the second of those deadly dangers, climate change, he’s already taken action based on another of his fantasies: that making America great again means taking it back to the fossil-fueled 1950s. His ignorance about, and actions to increase the effects of, climate change have already taken the U.S., the second largest emitter of greenhouse gases on the planet, out of the climate change sweepstakes and into uncharted territory. These acts and the desire to promote fossil fuels in every way imaginable will someday undoubtedly be seen as crimes against humanity. But by then they will already have done their dirty deed.

If luck doesn’t hold, Donald Trump may end up making Caligula and Nero look like statesmen. If luck doesn’t hold he may be the Littlest Big Man of all.

Tom Engelhardt is a co-founder of the American Empire Project and the author of The United States of Fear as well as a history of the Cold War, The End of Victory Culture. He is a fellow of the Nation Institute and runs TomDispatch.com. His latest book is Shadow Government: Surveillance, Secret Wars, and a Global Security State in a Single-Superpower World.

(Republished from TomDispatch by permission of author or representative)
 
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information



=>
9 Comments to "Little Big Man"
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
    []
  1. Yes, I’m disappointed in Trump so far. But Trump deserves great credit for smashing the Bush crime family and the Clinton crime family. He also proved what most Americans already knew, the corporate media is filled with fake news and propagandists like Rachael Maddow. Trump provided the greatest show on earth as summarized here:

    I do believe the Deep State can swing elections, but the experts were convinced there was no need. Perhaps they did throw a million votes to Clinton in key states such as Ohio and Florida just to make sure. But Trump’s tide was so strong it overwhelmed their effort. It would have worked in Pennsylvania and Michigan, but no expert thought Clinton might lose those. Note the immediate post-election reaction from the Deep State, a massive effort to remove “fake news” from the internet, to include gutting Fox News.

    So Trump struggles, but at least we don’t have open borders, and smug millionaire pundits are angry. So watch that video to remember a great night in American history.

    Read More
    ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc.
    AgreeDisagreeLOLTroll
    These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Troll, or LOL with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used once per hour.
    Sharing Comment via Twitter
    http://www.unz.com/tengelhardt/little-big-man/#comment-1888198
    More... This Commenter Display All Comments
  2. Admittedly, Donald Trump — and yes, that’s the first time I’ve used his name, but there was no need, was there?

    No need at all if the subject is seen as USA 2017 and Trump is seen as proxy. Donald, alas, is us.

    http://robertmagill.wordpress.com

    Read More
  3. It’s strange how Leftists like Engelhardt really believe: If we can eloquently speak about values (like empathy or generosity), we are in possession of these values.
    But from an outsider’s perspective: If the Left had had empathy and generosity towards the white working class, why ever didn’t they win their vote?

    Read More
  4. I was only able to get through the first 2 paragraphs of this idiocy.

    For example: I know, I know… he induces panic, fear, anxiety, insomnia. Shrinks in liberal America will tell you that, since November 2016, their patients are more heavily medicated and in worse shape. He’s a nightmare, a unique monster.

    And exactly why does he induce any of that stuff? And exacatly why is he a nightmare, a monster?

    What the bloody hell are you talking about?

    Sincerely. I truly do not understand what exactly it is that causes this lunacy to be written and thought and said 24 hours a day. It is truly Trump Derangement Syndrome.

    There is nothing, nothing, no-thing, no thing that Trump has said or done that has been substantively different than what millions of people genuinely feel.

    Is it the grab them by the pussy thing? Have you listened to a Jay-Z song lately? Ever read any Henry Miller? And did you pay attention to what Trump said? “And they LET you…” Yep. It is a common fact that women go for the rich and the famous and the powerful.

    And that is somehow frightening to you? Or to anyone? What the hell? What the bloody Hell!!!

    As for anything and everything else that Trump has said: how is that any worse than what Hillary said or has done or said she would have done? In many if not most cases, what Hillary proclaimed (or evaded saying in many cases) would have instantly provided far worse outcomes than anything Trump said or has done since.

    You really need to get your head examined.

    This nonsense really has to stop. It’s the writing of a screaming hysteric completely unhinged.

    Oh, and the snarky reference to Vladmir? So you have Putin Derangement Syndrome as well.

    Put the pen down and get help.

    Read More
    • Agree: Jim Christian
    • Replies: @TomSchmidt
    Note this also:

    Admittedly, Donald Trump — and yes, that’s the first time I’ve used his name, but there was no need, was there?
     
    Now go read Paragraph number 4. The right isn't the only source of inconsistency.
    , @Jim Christian
    Excellent takes, Restless. Then, there was THIS jewel spewed by Engelhardt:

    "They sent a billionaire who once deep-sixed a startling number of his businesses to save a country that couldn’t be more powerful and yet has proven incapable of building a single mile of high-speed rail."
     
    Those same Gods sent us Clinton and Obama. Clinton was around eight years and so was Obama (Bush got a little involved with other stuff after 911). What high-speed rail did THEY ever put up? And if the project was ever attempted, the left-wing Democrat environmentalists would fight it every inch of the way. So now Trump, according to Engelhardt, is responsible for high speed rail 120 days in? Really? He's got the pipelines authorized (and one of them finished). He's striking down Obama's B/S regs. He's pissed off depraved typists like Engelhardt. Snowflakes all over the country in academia, feminism, and the society at large have melted down. In all of that is value. The moon is no longer bothered by the baying of liberal hacks like Engelhardt. But since I rarel ready The Post or Times anymore, it's good Ron Unz carries at least one snowflake, Engelhardt, so we can get a glimpse of the madness that IS left-wing media. I don't know how these folks perceive this shit. In every claim of deficit they claim in Trump, those claims could fairly be made in triplicate about Obama and Bill Clinton who had full terms for us to evaluate. At 120 days for Trump, they've already sewn it all up.
  5. @restless94110
    I was only able to get through the first 2 paragraphs of this idiocy.

    For example: I know, I know… he induces panic, fear, anxiety, insomnia. Shrinks in liberal America will tell you that, since November 2016, their patients are more heavily medicated and in worse shape. He’s a nightmare, a unique monster.

    And exactly why does he induce any of that stuff? And exacatly why is he a nightmare, a monster?

    What the bloody hell are you talking about?

    Sincerely. I truly do not understand what exactly it is that causes this lunacy to be written and thought and said 24 hours a day. It is truly Trump Derangement Syndrome.

    There is nothing, nothing, no-thing, no thing that Trump has said or done that has been substantively different than what millions of people genuinely feel.

    Is it the grab them by the pussy thing? Have you listened to a Jay-Z song lately? Ever read any Henry Miller? And did you pay attention to what Trump said? "And they LET you..." Yep. It is a common fact that women go for the rich and the famous and the powerful.

    And that is somehow frightening to you? Or to anyone? What the hell? What the bloody Hell!!!

    As for anything and everything else that Trump has said: how is that any worse than what Hillary said or has done or said she would have done? In many if not most cases, what Hillary proclaimed (or evaded saying in many cases) would have instantly provided far worse outcomes than anything Trump said or has done since.

    You really need to get your head examined.

    This nonsense really has to stop. It's the writing of a screaming hysteric completely unhinged.

    Oh, and the snarky reference to Vladmir? So you have Putin Derangement Syndrome as well.

    Put the pen down and get help.

    Note this also:

    Admittedly, Donald Trump — and yes, that’s the first time I’ve used his name, but there was no need, was there?

    Now go read Paragraph number 4. The right isn’t the only source of inconsistency.

    Read More
  6. @restless94110
    I was only able to get through the first 2 paragraphs of this idiocy.

    For example: I know, I know… he induces panic, fear, anxiety, insomnia. Shrinks in liberal America will tell you that, since November 2016, their patients are more heavily medicated and in worse shape. He’s a nightmare, a unique monster.

    And exactly why does he induce any of that stuff? And exacatly why is he a nightmare, a monster?

    What the bloody hell are you talking about?

    Sincerely. I truly do not understand what exactly it is that causes this lunacy to be written and thought and said 24 hours a day. It is truly Trump Derangement Syndrome.

    There is nothing, nothing, no-thing, no thing that Trump has said or done that has been substantively different than what millions of people genuinely feel.

    Is it the grab them by the pussy thing? Have you listened to a Jay-Z song lately? Ever read any Henry Miller? And did you pay attention to what Trump said? "And they LET you..." Yep. It is a common fact that women go for the rich and the famous and the powerful.

    And that is somehow frightening to you? Or to anyone? What the hell? What the bloody Hell!!!

    As for anything and everything else that Trump has said: how is that any worse than what Hillary said or has done or said she would have done? In many if not most cases, what Hillary proclaimed (or evaded saying in many cases) would have instantly provided far worse outcomes than anything Trump said or has done since.

    You really need to get your head examined.

    This nonsense really has to stop. It's the writing of a screaming hysteric completely unhinged.

    Oh, and the snarky reference to Vladmir? So you have Putin Derangement Syndrome as well.

    Put the pen down and get help.

    Excellent takes, Restless. Then, there was THIS jewel spewed by Engelhardt:

    “They sent a billionaire who once deep-sixed a startling number of his businesses to save a country that couldn’t be more powerful and yet has proven incapable of building a single mile of high-speed rail.”

    Those same Gods sent us Clinton and Obama. Clinton was around eight years and so was Obama (Bush got a little involved with other stuff after 911). What high-speed rail did THEY ever put up? And if the project was ever attempted, the left-wing Democrat environmentalists would fight it every inch of the way. So now Trump, according to Engelhardt, is responsible for high speed rail 120 days in? Really? He’s got the pipelines authorized (and one of them finished). He’s striking down Obama’s B/S regs. He’s pissed off depraved typists like Engelhardt. Snowflakes all over the country in academia, feminism, and the society at large have melted down. In all of that is value. The moon is no longer bothered by the baying of liberal hacks like Engelhardt. But since I rarel ready The Post or Times anymore, it’s good Ron Unz carries at least one snowflake, Engelhardt, so we can get a glimpse of the madness that IS left-wing media. I don’t know how these folks perceive this shit. In every claim of deficit they claim in Trump, those claims could fairly be made in triplicate about Obama and Bill Clinton who had full terms for us to evaluate. At 120 days for Trump, they’ve already sewn it all up.

    Read More
  7. Trump is as bad as the author says he is. That is first and foremost an indicator of how bad Hillary Clinton is.

    Read More
  8. “Only once have we come truly close.”

    Keep spewing the party-line, brother. You forgot to mention that that was also the “fault” of the Russians, even if it was us depth charging one of their nuclear-missile subs that almost took us over the edge, and it was one Soviet officer who decided to not concur to a launch that hauled us back from going over the edge.

    We’ve come quite close on several occasions, and it was the sober “professionals” who took us there. Trump knows his world now is a lot more comfy than that he will inhabit if he takes us over the edge … I wish I could say that for the “professionals” who keep revealing they think we can prevail in the next “big one.”

    Read More
Current Commenter says:

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone


 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments become the property of The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Tom Engelhardt Comments via RSS
Personal Classics
Eight Exceptional(ly Dumb) American Achievements of the Twenty-First Century
How the Security State’s Mania for Secrecy Will Create You
Delusional Thinking in the Age of the Single Superpower