The Unz Review: An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewPaul Craig Roberts Archive
The West Paves the Road to War with Lies
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Troll, or LOL with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used once per hour.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

Official statements from the Russian government indicate that the president and foreign minister continue to rely on the good will of “our Western partners” to work out a reasonable diplomatic solution to the trouble in Ukraine caused by Washington. Not only is there no evidence of this good will in Western capitals, the hostile measures against Russia are increasing. Moreover, hostile measures are on the rise even though their main effect is to disadvantage Europe.

For example, the socialist president of France has followed Washington’s orders and refused to deliver a ship that it owes to Russia under contract. The news reports are so incompetent that they do not say whether Russia has paid for the ship or whether payment was awaiting completion. If Russia has not already paid, then the failure to deliver will harm whoever financed the construction of the ship. If Russia has paid, then the idiot French president has placed France in violation of a contract and under international law France is subject to heavy financial penalties.

It is not clear how this hurts Russia. It is Russia’s strategic nuclear force that the West has to fear, not a helicopter carrier. What Hollande has taught Russia is not to do business with France or any country in NATO.

Russia should promptly take the contract violation to court. Either France will be sanctioned with penalties that could exceed the value of the contract or the West will prove that in its hands international law is meaningless. If I were Russia, I would give up a helicopter ship in order to establish this point.

Marine Le Pen, the only leader France has, is not in power, although her support is growing. Le Pen says that Hollande’s obedience to Obama “will have a huge cost for France: the lost of millions of working hours and a fine of 5 to 10 billion euro.”

Holland sought to justify his kowtowing to Washington with a lie: “Russia’s recent actions in the east of Ukraine contravene the fundamental principles of European security.”

To the complete contrary. It is the stupid actions of Hollande, Merkel, and Cameron who are endangering European security by enabling Washington’s drive to war with Russia.

According to news reports for whatever they are worth, Washington and its EU puppet are preparing more sanctions against Russia. Considering the incompetence of Washington and the EU, it is unclear who will be bitten by the sanctions–Russia or Europe. The point is that Russia has done nothing to deserve any sanctions.

The sanctions are based on Washington’s lie that, in Obama’s words (September 3),
“Russian combat forces with Russian weapons in Russian tanks” are deployed in eastern Ukraine. As Professor Michel Chossudovsky reports on Global Research, observers from the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) “have registered no troops, ammunition or weapons crossing the Russian-Ukrainian border over the past two weeks.”

These passages are from Professor Chossudovsky’s report on the OSCD findings:


“The OSCE Observer Mission is deployed at the Russian Checkpoints of Gukovo and Donetsk at the request of Russia’s government. The decision was taken in a consensus agreement by all 57 OSCE participating States, many of which are represented at the NATO Summit in Wales.

“The OSCE report contradicts the statements made by the Kiev regime and its US-NATO sponsors. It confirms that NATO accusations pertaining to the influx of Russian tanks are an outright fabrication.

“NATO backed up Obama’s statements with fake satellite images (28 August 2014) that allegedly ‘show Russian combat forces engaged in military operations inside the sovereign territory of Ukraine’. These statements are refuted by a detailed report of the OSCE monitoring mission stationed at the Russia-Ukraine border. The NATO reports including its satellite photos were based on fake evidence.

“It is worth noting that the OSCE carefully categorizes movements across the border, which largely consist of refugees.”

Just as Iraq, Afghanistan, and Libya were attacked on the basis of transparent lies and Syria and Iran were set up for attack on the basis of transparent lies, the sanctions against Russia rest solely on transparent lies. According to the UK Telegraph, the new sanctions will ban all Russian state-owned oil and defense companies from raising funds in European capital markets. In other words, any Western oil enterprises operating in Russia would be exempted.

One Russia response to sanctions should be to confiscate any Western firms operating in Russia as compensation for damages inflicted by the sanctions.

Another response is to obtain financing from China.

Another response is to self-finance energy and defense needs. If the US can print money in order to keep 4 or 5 mega-banks afloat, Russia can print money to finance its needs.

The lesson that Washington is teaching the larger part of the world is that a country has to be insane to do business with the West. The West views business as a hegemonic tool that is used to punish, exploit, and loot. It is astonishing that after so many lessons, countries still seek IMF loans. It is impossible not to know by now that an IMF loan has two purposes: the looting of the country by the West and the subordination of the country to Western hegemonic policy. Yet idiot governments still apply for IMF loans.

All of the escalation of the Ukrainian situation is caused by the US, EU, and Kiev. Apparently, Washington interprets Russia’s low-key response as evidence that the Russian government is intimidated. But when Putin holds all the cards and can wreck Europe by turning off the flow of natural gas and can reincorporate the entire Ukraine back into Russia in two weeks or less, how can Washington impose its will?

Is Russia so desperate to be part of the West that it will succumb to being another of Washington’s puppet states?

(Republished from by permission of author or representative)
• Category: Foreign Policy • Tags: Russia, Ukraine 
Hide 3 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. bossel says:

    “The news reports are so incompetent that they do not say whether Russia has paid for the ship”
    Or perhaps PCR is so incompetent in reading that he didn’t understand what was said about it. Let’s look at this evil, evil Western propaganda outlet BBC:
    “The deal is worth 1.2bn euros – and Russia is reported to have paid most of it, so breach of contract would mean France having to reimburse that money.
    In addition, France would be liable for an extra 251m-euro penalty ”

    “Considering the incompetence of Washington and the EU, it is unclear who will be bitten by the sanctions–Russia or Europe.”
    Well, again PCR’s showing his reading incompetence. Both “will be bitten”, only Russia probably a bit deeper than Europe. If PCR is really interested in it, maybe he can have someone read the following article (again from the evil BBC) to him:

    “The OSCE report contradicts the statements made by the Kiev regime and its US-NATO sponsors.”
    Yeah, right.
    “It is worth noting that the OSCE carefully categorizes movements across the border [only at the mentioned 2 border crossings, only there & nowhere else], which largely consist of refugees.”
    Really, people are fleeing Russia now? From the last OSCE update:
    “Since August 26, the majority of border crossers have been going back into Ukraine with an average net flow of minus 429 per day for both Border Crossing Points in the last week”
    The situation in Russia must be really dire if people are seeking refuge in a war zone.

    More from that last OSCE update:
    “Throughout the week, OTs observed a net increase in activity of young people dressed in military style crossing back and forth at the [Donetsk] Border Crossing Point. OTs also observed some of these people visibly wounded crossing back into the Russian Federation with white bandages and/or crutches. OTs also observed transfers of more seriously-wounded persons by ambulances. Some people dressed in military style were accompanying the wounded and were particularly well-equipped including holsters but without weapons.”

    “All of the escalation of the Ukrainian situation is caused by the US, EU, and Kiev.”
    Ah, yeah, obviously. All those soldiers from Russia going on an adventure vacation in Ukraine are sent by evil Western fascists. & opening up a new front near Mariupol was clearly a Western idea. No doubt about that.

    • Replies: @22pp22
  2. 22pp22 says:

    I have no doubt the Russians are involved, but if you think the US and EU are blameless in this fiasco, you are deluded.

    The demonizing of Russia predates the Ukraine. Remember P()55y Riot? Who has spread chaos to Syria and Libya, Russia or us?

    We are quite determined to help the world to a bright multicultural future and we don’t care how many people have to die in the name of this noble cause.

    Unfortunately, diversity doesn’t work and Ferguson is a portent of the future for balkanized America.

  3. Kiza says:

    Hey, bossel, look under your bed, there is a Russian man under it “well-equipped including holster but without a weapon”. 429 persons per day without armaments crossing into Ukraine, it must be a real Russian military invasion. Try: “The Eastern Ukrainian are winning, so the refugees are returning.”

    As a follower of Western media ‘truths’, you have to make up your mind: are there Russian military columns passing into Ukraine, or are there ambulances crossing back into Russia from Ukraine. I subscribe to a huge difference between a military invasion and volunteers and military advisers. There has been no war in the world in, at least, the last 50 years in which US military advisers and “retired military personnel” were not involved in. Also, I assume that there is no dispute that both sides have had military advisers in Ukraine from the start. The only difference is that the US advisers on high “war zone” per diems are sitting in airconditioned hotel rooms in Kiev and chasing gorgeous Kievan prostitutes after hours, whilst the Russian advisers are fighting side-by-side with rebels. The US advisers could not care less how many of the Ukrainian conscripts die, plus the longer the war lasts the more money they bring home.

    Only through the typical mental gymnastics of your “evil BBC” can this be turned into a military invasion by the Russians and no military invasion by NATO. In a few days NATO is starting fully equipped military drills in Ukraine. But this is not a military invasion, of course, because NATO are the good guys.

    Regarding the helicopter carriers, the contractual information is scarce, only BBC and RT to my knowledge have reported on those, this is why PCR has missed them. It does appear that your statement is correct: France now owes Russia Euro 1.6B. Somehow, knowing the West, I would not expect France to pay its debt. Someone must have advised the little French thief that he could get away with keeping the money, or charging Russia 1.6B for the damages its counter-sanctions caused to France. Besides France is totally bankrupt, where could it fund so much money to refund Russia? Finally, Euros are becoming worthless anyway, even quicker than the overprinted US$.

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to All Paul Craig Roberts Comments via RSS