The Unz Review: An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewPaul Craig Roberts Archive
9/11 Fourteen Years Later
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Troll, or LOL with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used once per hour.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

Millions of refugees from Washington’s wars are currently over-running Europe. Washington’s 14-year and ongoing slaughter of Muslims and destruction of their countries are war crimes for which the US government’s official 9/11 conspiracy theory was the catalyst. Factual evidence and science do not support Washington’s conspiracy theory. The 9/11 Commission did not conduct an investigation. It was not permitted to investigate. The Commission sat and listened to the government’s story and wrote it down. Afterwards, the chairman and cochairman of the Commission said that the Commission “was set up to fail.” For a factual explanation of 9/11, watch this film:

Here is a presentation by Pilots For 9/11 Truth:

Here is an extensive examination of many of the aspects of 9/11:

Phil Restino of the Central Florida chapter of Veterans For Peace wants to know why national antiwar organizations buy into the official 9/11 story when the official story is the basis for the wars that antiwar organizations oppose. Some are beginning to wonder if ineffectual peace groups are really Homeland Security or CIA fronts?

The account below of the government’s 9/11 conspiracy theory reads like a parody, but in fact is an accurate summary of the official 9/11 conspiracy theory. It was posted as a comment in the online UK Telegraph on September 12, 2009, in response to Charlie Sheen’s request to President Obama to conduct a real investigation into what happened on September 11, 2001.

The Official Version of 9/11 goes something like this:

Directed by a beardy-guy from a cave in Afghanistan, nineteen hard-drinking, coke-snorting, devout Muslims enjoy lap dances before their mission to meet Allah. 

Using nothing more than craft knifes, they overpower cabin crew, passengers and pilots on four planes.

And hangover or not, they manage to give the world’s most sophisticated air defence system the slip.

Unfazed by leaving their “How to Fly a Passenger Jet” guide in the car at the airport, they master the controls in no-time and score direct hits on two towers, causing THREE to collapse completely.

The laws of physics fail, and the world watches in awe as asymmetrical damage and scattered low temperature fires cause steel-framed buildings to collapse symmetrically through their own mass at free-fall speed, for the first time in history.

Despite their dastardly cunning and superb planning, they give their identity away by using explosion-proof passports, which survive the destruction of steel and concrete and fall to the ground where they are quickly discovered lying on top of the mass of debris.

Meanwhile in Washington


Hani Hanjour, having previously flunked Cessna flying school, gets carried away with all the success of the day and suddenly finds incredible abilities behind the controls of a jet airliner. 

Instead of flying straight down into the large roof area of the Pentagon, he decides to show off a little. 

Executing an incredible 270 degree downward spiral, he levels off to hit the low facade of the Pentagon. 
Without ruining the nicely mowed lawn and at a speed just too fast to capture on video.

In the skies above Pennsylvania

Desperate to talk to loved ones before their death, some passengers use sheer willpower to connect mobile calls that would not be possible until several years later.

And following a heroic attempt by some to retake control of Flight 93, the airliner crashes into a Pennsylvania field leaving no trace of engines, fuselage or occupants except for the standard issue Muslim terrorist bandana.

During these events

President Bush continues to read “My Pet Goat” to a class of primary school children.

In New York

World Trade Center leaseholder Larry Silverstein blesses his own foresight in insuring the buildings against terrorist attack only six weeks previously.

In Washington

The Neoconservatives are overjoyed by the arrival of the “New Pearl Harbor,” the necessary catalyst for launching their pre-planned wars.

(Republished from by permission of author or representative)
• Category: Foreign Policy • Tags: 9/11, Terrorism 
Hide 21 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. actually, our Zionist Occupation Government’s 9/11 “conspiracy theory” is no more (or less) absurd than many others that float about the interwebs. Re PCR’s points:

    1) in determined hands, against surprised, defenseless people, letter-openers can be – and clearly were – a lethal weapon. A concurrent blast of pepper spray in someone’s face also does wonders

    2) much of the “World’s Most Sophisticated Air Defense System” was involved in an Air Defense drill on 9/11. And thus unable to react quickly to the Real Thing; on 18 April, 1942, Dolittle’s B-25’s hit Tokyo smack in the middle of a Japanese air defense drill…and blew through the Jap fighters without losing a plane. One may also note that Boston ATC sat on the first hijacking, American 11, until 8:35, before notifying the military…11 minutes is insufficient time to react to this sort of thing. The second hijack – United 175 – occurred near Newark at about the time of Amer 11’s hit on the N. Tower, and hit the S. Tower about 18 minutes later. Again, this is insufficient reaction time. More substantial questions would be: how did the Jihadis know that a major air defence exercise would take place on 9/11? And how did the United 175 ‘jackers (flying a different route to LA) know that they were, in effect, getting a free ride down close to the target before they even needed to hijack? Had TWO planes been ‘jacked shortly after Boston take-off, you can bet alarm bells would have sounded sooner and louder

    3) Hani Hanjour. Yes, that was some piloting he did…or didn’t. Nevertheless, freeze-frame and still shots show a c. 300′ fireball at the strike-moment, and eyewitnesses (Paul Begala, among others) saw same. A tac missile does not make a 300′ fireball (see also WT strikes) on impact. A large airplane full of aviation fuel makes a 300′ fireball on impact

    4) the Pennsylvania crash. Actually, several hundred pounds human body parts (and much else) were recovered at the crash site, and were DNA’d to around 1/3 of the passengers. Go to the United 93 Wiki and examine the evidence yourself

    On the other hand, the Official Version is indeed full of holes, full of holes so big you could, well…fly an airplane through them:

    1) the Jihadi foreknowledge issue I mentioned above. In particular, how did the United 175 jackers know that their plane was taking a zig down to NYC before heading to LA?

    2) the asymptotical increase in negative bets on United/American stock in the several days before 9/11

    3) the Israeli film crew all set up and ready to go on the NJ side, their subsequent kid-gloves treatment by the FBI and, after their return to Israel, statements admitting in so many words that they had been sent over “to document the Event…”

    4) the collapses of the two Towers? Not my strong suit…but the Riesman video (among others) shows, from about 40 seconds before the collapse up to the collapse, what appears to be a hot thermate reaction at the NE corner of the south Tower…precisely the point of collapse initiation

    5) WTC7. Yes indeed, that’s looks exactly like a controlled demo. In fact, a really well done contr0lled demo

    6) Lucky Larry. Clearly, not luck…Design. His two offspring, who also worked in his 85th floor North Tower office, were late for work on 9/11 ’cause they were “delayed in traffic”. Right…

    7) Bush. The idiot-in-chief was along for the ride. Watch his facial expressions when Card informs him of the 2nd hit. It’s like, “wow…they did it. Now what do I do…OhYeah, I remember now…sit here for awhile, read the Prepared Statement, then board AF One…”

    Overall, it looks like the 9/11 Atrocity was conceived and partly planned by Cheney and that cloud of Zionist neo-conz surrounding the Bush43 regime: Wolfowitz, Feith, Pike, Zelikow, Zackheim, et al. Actual interfacing with the Sunni Jihadis via (Sunni) Saudi intel (this probably the subject of the surpressed 28-page section of the Official “Investigation”), plus some input from CIA and Israeli Mossad. The Jihadis (though not precisely the ones specified with such surprising swiftness by the Bush regime, given that at least 9 of the 19 ID’s are false), then pulled it off

    • Replies: @Si1ver1ock
  2. Priss Factor [AKA "The Priss Factory"] says: • Website

    “And following a heroic attempt by some to retake control of Flight 93, the airliner crashes into a Pennsylvania field leaving no trace of engines, fuselage or occupants except for the standard issue Muslim terrorist bandana.”

    “All human remains were found within a 70-acre (28 ha) area surrounding the impact point. Somerset County Coroner Wally Miller was involved in the investigation and identification of the remains. In examining the wreckage, the only human body part he could see was part of a backbone.[86] Miller later found and identified 1,500 pieces of human remains totaling about 600 pounds (272 kg), or eight percent of the total.”

    Roberts goes too far, discrediting himself with wild speculations and standard 9/11 conspiracy theorizing.

    To me, it seems credible that the airplanes were flown into the towers by the hijackers. It can’t be that difficult to fly a plane. Landing one would be tougher, but all these guys had to do was just fly it into something.
    So, who did it if not the terrorists? Did CIA or Mossad agents pledge to commit suicide via kamikaze attacks?

    I don’t think we have to go so far or looneytunes to see something fishy about what happened on 9/11.

    I think the Muslim hijackers did it, but I also think Israeli and some Jewish agents in the US knew something was up but didn’t share the information with US intelligence because attacks would push US into foreign intervention that would be good for Israel.

    As for Larry Silverstein, I wouldn’t be surprised if he got some insider tip.

    We should demand that government release all documents about 9/11. But to do this, it’s better to do away with the outlandish conspiracy theories that just discredit all skepticism in the eyes of the public.

    We know from USS Liberty that Jews can get away with so much.
    We also know how Jews in media, government, and intelligence spread lies upon lies to get US to invade Iraq. We also know they told lies about Gaddafi to destroy Libya.
    And the whole Ukraine thing was based on a lie.

    So, we shouldn’t trust the US government and Jews who pull the strings.

    But the idea of Muslim hijackers carrying out 9/11 seems credible. What is not credible is that everyone was surprised by events. I think some people knew. But they were shhhhh and may even have lent a hand to the terrorists indirectly because a War on Terror was just what they wanted.

    Instead of crackpot theories about whether there was a United 93, I think we should all focus on who knew and when? Release all documents to the public now.

    As for buildings collapsing, it makes sense to me because the planes severed the steel beams upon entry.

  3. God Bless Paul Craig Roberts and other honorable people.

    • Agree: Orville H. Larson
  4. 9/11 was a false flag attack. A mass murder to facilitate further mass murder. I stopped arguing about it many years ago. I still don’t understand people who don’t want to know the truth but I have accepted their existence as one of the mysteries of life.

  5. LondonBob says:

    The Sunday Times and Sibel Edmonds did a fair amount of work on 9/11 and the involvement of intelligence agencies facilitating it as well as likely foreknowledge on the part of others who let it happen before the story was spiked.

    • Replies: @Wizard of Oz
  6. Mudhole says:
    @Priss Factor

    9/11 was a TV show- Terror Theater- produced for a domestic TV audience. The operational priority of real terrorists would have been simultaneity – all strikes hitting at once in order to thwart the US air defense system. The actual strike planners didn’t have to worry about air defenses, since they had control of the US air defense system, and thus were able to draw the show out to 2.5 hours for maximum ratings and impact. Executive summary -no highjackers.

    • Replies: @Priss Factor
  7. Priss Factor [AKA "The Priss Factory"] says: • Website

    “9/11 was a TV show- Terror Theater- produced for a domestic TV audience. The operational priority of real terrorists would have been simultaneity – all strikes hitting at once in order to thwart the US air defense system.”

    I don’t doubt that there are people in the US government — especially super-Zionists — who harbored such dark thoughts and dreamed of carrying them out.

    It’s like DR. STRANGELOVE and FAIL SAFE were true to the extent that such lunatics did exist in the US military: people who really wanted to trigger a nuclear war with the USSR. (And of course, there were tons of Jewish spies working for the USSR during the FDR era. And these Jews even slipped the bomb secrets to Stalin.) But those films were outlandish in supposing a plan like that could really be pulled off.

    It may have been possible that 9/11 was an ‘inside job’ for the simple fact that there are wicked people in government, real sociopaths, who will stop at nothing to pull off something dirty. If Madoff got away with so much without getting caught cuz he was rich Jew protected by other rich Jews, then we know a lot of bad shit is happening.
    We also know about the cover-up of USS Liberty.

    But, and it’s a big fat but, what are the chances of a plan that outrageous, bold, that crazy, that immoral, and that crazy like 9/11 being kept a secret in government for so long by so many people? One thing for sure, a single person couldn’t have done it. A handful of people couldn’t have done it. It would have required a whole network of people working together. The idea that all those people would have gone along with a plan to blow up the twin towers, pentagon, and kill 1000s of innocent Americans is just too nuts. (This is why Stone’s JFK fails. According to his movie, EVERYONE in every department of government was IN on the plan but nothing leaked out.)

    Of course, US government used lies to invade Iraq. But then, the need for the lies was proof that US government couldn’t just plan and carry it out secretly. As US isn’t a totalitarian state, US government couldn’t have pulled off something like Operation Barbarossa against Russia: a total sucker punch. Since US couldn’t hide what it wanted to do Iraq, it had to make a big public case for the military action.

    Edward Snowden spilled lots of beans over something far less serious. If there were rumors in the US government about something like 9/11 being cooked up, wouldn’t someone have blown the whistle? Nixon couldn’t get away with a cheap burglary. Clinton got caught with his pants down. So, the idea that a wide network in US government could have pulled off 9/11 without anyone else knowing about it is too far-fetched.

    But I do believe that some people did know something. These were mostly probably Mossad agents with connections with some Jews in US government. People like Jonathan Pollard and Arnon Milchan, a real lowlife(but kudos to him for producing ONCE UPON A TIME IN AMERICA). And I think what happened was something more like ‘nudging’. Cass the Ass Sunstein wrote a book about how people can subtly be nudged in certain directions to make them do what you want them to do. Because they are nudged than pushed or forced, they think they are acting in free will when, in fact, they are being manipulated by B. F. Skinner’s pigeon.
    I believe some Mossad agents and some Zionists agents in the US government knew some plan was being hatched by Muslims. And these Muslims might have nudge-nudged into taking actions that eventually led to 9/11.

    It’s like what happens in Cronenberg’s eXistenZ and Mamet’s movies. People are nudged and counter-nudged into doing things. There are ‘tells’ to look for. It’s like what Max does to Noodles in ONCE UPON A TIME IN AMERICA. Max and Carol ‘nudged’ Noodles into making the phone call that supposedly led to Max’s death, but it was all just a trick for Max to take all the money. It’s like how the sly general nudges everyone in PATHS OF GLORY and makes them feel like they are acting of their own free will.

    I believe the total release of all 9/11 documents will reveal how the Muslim terrorists were nudged into action. You don’t even have to brainwash(like in THE MANCHURIAN CANDIDATE) if you know to brain-nudge.

    But guess what?

    PS. Of course, AIPAC uses nudging to control US politicians as well. AIPAC doesn’t directly tell people what to do. That would make them feel like slaves. Instead, AIPAC puts out feelers and invitations and etc that make people feel it’s righteous and cool to be on the side of Zionism and Jewish power.

    Just look at John McCain. He’s a total dog of the Jews but he’s been nudged to feel as if he’s a noble white man protecting helpless Jews from the next holocaust.

  8. Priss Factor [AKA "The Priss Factory"] says: • Website

    The Nudged Negro.

  9. Priss Factor [AKA "The Priss Factory"] says: • Website

    This is a funny story.

    Amateur Mossad operation.

    Don’t try it at home, fellas.

    Maybe he should be pardoned along with Pollard.

  10. @Priss Factor

    I’m so glad the pills work. But yes, they can’t get rid of that growing suspicion that there just might have been more people forewarned, or at least entertaining informed suspicions before 9/11, than has ever been admitted. No need for loony toon conspiracy theories: just acceptance of the great variety of human wickedness, as well as the negligence and stupidity….

  11. @Priss Factor

    Have you caught up with the technical stuff I referred to in two posts on Tom Engelhardt’s piece on 9/11 and consequences?

  12. @LondonBob

    Thanks for the link. Anything more known, especially about Sibel Edmonds?

    The only nit I could pick readily was to wonder what translation was needed of US intelligence people’s nefarious communications. I suppose it would be instructions translated into Farsi etc…??

  13. @Haxo Angmark

    Is that really you Haxo? Or is that your new mask?

    Here is something interesting to watch.

    and here

  14. Anonymous • Disclaimer says:
    @Priss Factor

    “As for buildings collapsing, it makes sense to me because the planes severed the steel beams upon entry.”
    … the day anyone can make flying aluminium tubes sever 4 independent rows of reinforced 2″ boxed steel columns, is the day I will place my dangly-bits on a chopping block.

    Didn’t happen. Can’t happen. Never will happen.

  15. Priss Factor [AKA "The Priss Factory"] says: • Website

    “the day anyone can make flying aluminium tubes sever 4 independent rows of reinforced 2″ boxed steel columns, is the day I will place my dangly-bits on a chopping block.”

    Speed is of the essence.

    If you swipe a piece of paper real fast, it can cut deep into flesh.

    It’s like a ping pong ball hitting your head. If you throw it someone, it can’t do much damage.

    But if you shoot it out of gun and make it go superfast, it can crack your skull.

    Why do asteroids do such damage? The speed.

    Those planes were flying really fast.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
  16. Priss Factor [AKA "The Priss Factory"] says: • Website

    I can’t help thinking that the people who run the US are just as evil as dictators and autocrats in other nations.

    Because of the US system of checks and balances and rule of law(still working to some extent), these leaders and elites can’t do too much harm, or at least too much harm in the US. But if these people had the kind of power of a Stalin or Hitler, some of them wouldn’t be any better, and many would be only marginally better.

    Foreign policy is useful in this regard because democratic leaders(under rule of law in their own nations) have freer rein in foreign policy than in their own nations.
    You can’t bomb protesters or opposition in your own democratic country, but you can drop bombs and shoot tons of people in other countries(especially if the media give cover to your actions). Bush II got raked over the coals over Katrina(which really wasn’t his fault), but he was given leeway to do so much damage abroad in Iraq. And Clinton and Albright could starve and kill 300,00o Iraqi women and children with impunity in the 90s. They got less condemnation over that than Bush II got over the handling of Katrina.

    And look at Obama’s sociopathic acts in Libya and Ukraine. And look how utterly conscienceless the neocons and Liberal Zionists are in having pushed policies that turned the Middle East into what Europe was like during WWII. What is happening in Middle East is their WWIII. It is hell on earth, and US had a bit role in it.

    In the US, government dare not send goons to shoot protesters, but when it comes to foreign policy, the true colors of US leaders and elites show themselves, and it is about on the level of scum like Saddam Hussein and Stalin and even Hitler.

    They are sociopaths. What is troubling is that the media, controlled by the Jomo Complex, has more or less been complicit in the sociopathy of the US government and elites.
    It’s almost certainly true that if US were not ruled by Jewish elites, the hellishness in the Middle East would not have happened. And if US media were not controlled by Jews, dangerous and destabilizing policies in the Middle East would have been more closely scrutinized.

    But at least in the US, the elites and government are checked by rule of law and the rights of dissenters are protected by free speech.

    But what happens when free speech is threatened? What happens when dissenting speech is called ‘hate speech’? Jews in America are using ‘hate speech’ laws to silence criticism of Jewish Power. Cleverly, Jews pretend as if they are banning ‘hate speech’ to protect ‘helpless’ minorities, but they are actually using it protect themselves, the most powerful people in America, from the criticism of other groups and individuals.

    When Palestinian-Americans call for boycott of Israel, it’s very possible that Jewish elites will one day ban it as ‘hate speech’ against Israel and Jewish people. ‘Hate speech’ laws will come to ban holocaust denial but aid and abet Nakba denial or Nakba rationalization.

    Those who hate free speech promote the concept of ‘hate speech’.

  17. Jason says:

    Mention Big conspiracy. Say End is nigh. Say buy gold.


    I could have been a columnist!

  18. tanabear says:

    The Priss Factory: “The idea that all those people would have gone along with a plan to blow up the twin towers, pentagon, and kill 1000s of innocent Americans is just too nuts.

    The neo-cons weren’t called the “Crazies” for nothing. In the end what matters is, what does the evidence show. The evidence that the official story is false is overwhelming. World Trade Tower 7 was brought down as a controlled demolition. World Trade Towers 1 and 2 were blown top-down through via the aid of explosive charges. One can believe whatever they wish about who is responsible but one must take the evidence into account. So did Al-Qaeda rig those buildings?

    Jason: “Mention Big conspiracy. Say End is nigh. Say buy gold.

    The 9/11 Truth Movement is not a conspiracy theory anymore than the official story is a conspiracy theory. The 9/11 Truth seekers simple posit a different set of conspirators.

    • Replies: @Jason
  19. Jason says:

    Several years ago I got into the details of Truther material and found it not only wrong but deeply dishonest.

    I finally caught on this was just entertainment for a subset of people. That’s fine, I just don’t like it taking energy away from a serious analysis of power.

  20. Anonymous • Disclaimer says:
    @Priss Factor

    @Priss factory.

    High speed…at sea level?
    Your theory has already been debunked here:

  21. tanabear says:

    Jason: “Several years ago I got into the details of Truther material and found it not only wrong but deeply dishonest. ”

    Translation: I read Popular Mechanics and believed every word.

    So 9/11 Truthers believe that explosive charges can blow-up buildings and other structures. But your detailed research led you to conclude that this is false. Did your research also lead you to conclude that the world is flat?

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to All Paul Craig Roberts Comments via RSS