The Unz Review: An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewPatrick Cockburn Archive
May's Visit to Turkey Shows How Desperate She Is to Strike Trade Deals
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Troll, or LOL with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used once per hour.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

As the international political order fragments, Theresa May flies from seeing Donald Trump, who speaks approvingly of the use of torture, to a meeting with President Recep Tayyip Erdogan who is presiding over the reintroduction of torture in Turkey.

The opportunism and hypocrisy of British foreign policy, as the UK flails around for new allies to replace the EU, is better illustrated by the Prime Minister’s Turkish trip than by her ingratiating speech to Republican Party leaders in Philadelphia. She told them that as close allies the US and UK would always win the war of ideas “by proving that open, liberal, democratic societies will always defeat those that are closed, coercive and cruel.”

Yet within 48 hours of adopting this high moral tone, May will be in talks with Erdogan which will be seen as endorsing the destruction of Turkish democracy; he is replacing it with a presidential system as dictatorial and repressive as anything seen in Latin America in the 1960s and 1970s. Since a failed military coup last July, a sweeping purge has seen at least 137,000 judges, teachers, journalists, civil servants and military personnel arrested or sacked, according to the government’s own figures.

The mass arrests and trials include anybody who protests or dissents from government policy. Two Kurdish leaders, whose party won five million votes in the last election, face over 200 years in prison. A Human Rights Watch report into torture by the Turkish police cites a forensic specialist who says that a suspect related how “the police had forced him to sit on his knees, bent forward so his forehead touched the floor, with his hands tied on his back, for 36 hours. Whenever he tried to move, the police hit him on the head and the back with a belt.” The police then placed him in a cell with several enlisted soldiers who severely beat him. “There was not a part of his body that was not covered in bruises and he suffered from a frozen shoulder from the stress-position,” said the forensic specialist, though the detainee was too frightened to make an official complaint.

Erdogan will hold a referendum in April on the new presidential system in which all power is focussed on himself. But since he has closed down or taken over at least 150 news outlets and jailed 141 journalists, he is likely to win approval of legal changes that will strip almost all power from parliament and the judiciary.

It takes considerable cheek on the part of May to solemnly state just before her visit to Turkey that the US and Britain’s special relationship is rooted in “the promise of freedom, liberty and the rights of man”. An unpublicised motive for the trip is probably the prospect of a substantial Turkish order for Rolls Royce engines for a new Turkish fighter, though so many Turkish air force pilots have been purged that there are reportedly now too few to fly the existing aircraft fleet.

This is not May’s first visit to the political sewers of the Middle East. In December, she went to Bahrain, the tiny toxic sectarian island kingdom where a Sunni monarchy oppresses a Shia majority and 2,600 people out of a population of 65,000 are in jail. She told the kings of Bahrain and Saudi Arabia and the rulers of Kuwait, Qatar and United Arab Emirates, all arbitrary monarchs, that “we in the UK are determined to continue to be your partner of choice as you embed international norms and see through the reforms which are so essential for all of your people.”

May is alone in detecting these reforms, but her support for the Gulf States may have encouraged Bahrain to carry out on 15 January its first executions in six years. A firing squad shot three men who alleged that they had been tortured into making false confessions, according to Amnesty International.

British governments commonly defend the combination of pro-democracy rhetoric with practical support for the most vicious autocracies by claiming that they are not the moral arbiters of the world and must put the interests of their own country – often in the shape of a juicy arms contract – first.

Such government cynicism is traditional, but May’s speech to the Republican Party leaders on Thursday suggests that she and her government are underestimating the gravity and divisiveness of the political turmoil in the US. Up to the inauguration of President Trump, it was possible to believe that he was a populist nationalist demagogue, with good political instincts, whose views and actions would be sobered by high office and would in any case be restricted by constitutional and institutional limits on his power.

But the last week has shown this is not happening: Trump is becoming more, not less, paranoid and extreme. His petty and incoherent speech to the CIA, his obsession with the numbers attending his inauguration, his hostility to the press and his confrontation with Mexico suggest a man not only incapable of coping with contradiction, but somewhat demented and not fully rational. He and Erdogan may be similar in their authoritarian hubris – the Turkish leader applauded Trump for “putting in his place” a CNN journalist by refusing to take his question – but there is no evidence that Erdogan is insane.

The growing belief that the leader of the US may be unhinged is becoming a seriously destabilising factor in the US and around the world. This view is well put by the Turkish journalist Asli Aydintasbas who tweeted: “I really can’t handle American going so insane. One thing when we go astray, another when US sounds like it has lost its marbles.”

It is not only the US and Turkey which have their leadership problems. May presents herself as the hard-headed exponent of common sense, a Margaret Thatcher with a human heart, but, when her speeches are carefully read, they are almost as full of wishful thinking and nostalgia for a vanished American and British supremacy as those by Trump.


British politicians have been attracted for the last 75 years by the belief that they could be junior partners of the US. May evidently believes that the election of Trump as President offers an opportunity to ride the American tiger once again, giving the new administration a degree of international respectability while restraining its worst excesses. Of course, this will supposedly be very different from the blank cheque Tony Blair gave George W Bush which landed the UK in the Iraq and Afghan wars; May says there will be no return to the failed policies of “Britain and America intervening in sovereign countries”.

This does not mean much, since she went on to say that the US and UK are not “going to stand idly by when the threat is real and when it is in our own interests to intervene”. But Trump won the election with contradictory pledges: as an isolationist with the slogan “America First” and as a nationalist who would make the US great and respected again. May might imagine that she can manage such an unpredictable tiger, but it is going to be a very dangerous ride.

(Republished from The Independent by permission of author or representative)
• Category: Foreign Policy • Tags: Britain, Turkey 
Hide 14 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. I pity the Brits. Obviously Ms.May is a Radical Muslim who will declare herself dictator for life and proceed to torture everybody.

  2. JEC says:

    Theresa May is a featherweight politician. She has no firm principles but has studied the Oxford Book of Political Platitudes for many years in search of “ideas”. Her “policies” are the expedients of the hour. She even believes in the myth of the “special relationship” between the US and the UK.

    Not much should be expected of her.

    • Replies: @KA
  3. KA says:

    The one replacing her will be worse than newly recreated post -election Trump .

  4. 5371 says:

    [Trump is becoming more, not less, paranoid and extreme. His petty and incoherent speech to the CIA, his obsession with the numbers attending his inauguration, his hostility to the press and his confrontation with Mexico suggest a man not only incapable of coping with contradiction, but somewhat demented and not fully rational.]

    This is highly mendacious gaslighting. Everyone who wasn’t wary of Cockburn already should definitely be so now.

    • Replies: @Johann Ricke
  5. Some continuity here – British governments have always maintained good relations with Ankara. The USA and Germany have generally been bigger arms suppliers to Turkey (Leopard tanks being chewed up in Al Bab are a German make manufactured under licence in Turkey, for example) but there are problems with both countries for Erdogan, and it is possible that the British government is trying to grap a piece of their action.
    Both are outliers in EU terms as well – Turkey has close EU links but will probably never attain full membership, while May is wrestling with the Brexit referendum.
    It is possible that May was also passing on messages from Trump though that is not clear in what has been published. Trying to keep Turkey from taking its ball into the Russian field (IMO partly a bluff) is no doubt also a motivation.

  6. Not exactly a ‘controversial perspective largely excluded from the mainstream media’, is it?

    Cockburn and many others in the media profess shock that Trump appears to be determined to keep most of the promises he campaigned on, that it wasn’t all a con job for the rubes who voted for him. It may be this shock is genuine, there were any number of sneering “Of course Trump won’t actually build the Wall…” articles.

    As for Erdogan, the critical thing is to detach him from Islamic State & Al-Nusra/Al Qaeda and bring Turkey into the alliance of Civilisation against ‘Radical Islamic Terrorism’. Britain and the USA have been equally guilty of backing R.I.T. in Syria, only Russia has clean hands there.

    • Replies: @Uebersetzer

    The mayor of an Istanbul district was summoned to the “Palace”, ie. the President’s office, and when she refused to go, she was jailed for “insulting the greatness of the state”. This is the nature of the beast, even before a referendum designed to give Erdogan more powers, and this is what May has made an arms deal with.

  8. @Simon in London

    R.I.T. is the gift that just keeps giving, for Britain, USA, Erdogan etc. They can promote it to further their goals, bomb it to further their goals etc. Nothing civilisational about it.

  9. The UK was Turkey’s main sponsor for EU membership. A coordinated deal by UK & Turkey could ratchet Turkey a bit closer to the EU economically and establish an Outer EU that Ukraine and other undesirables could join methodically. Not top of May’s list I am sure but a way to get some additional clout. British farming may be tiny economically, its bigger in multiplier terms and as a part of core Tory membership it is substantial almost everywhere they face a Lib Dem vote. Outside London the Tory party holds rural constituencies. Selling out the farmers to get a US trade deal may not go down well in more than 100 Tory/Lib Dem marginals. Tory Majority 14. There’s a long way to go yet.

  10. May’s Visit to Turkey Shows How Desperate She Is to Strike Trade Deals

    Amusing headline, given that the British (and European governments in general) continued trading with China during the massive humans rights abuses of the Mao period, when tens of millions were starved to death, just prior to which millions of landlords and family members were summarily executed to steal their property. Heck, the odds are that once Britain leaves, the EU will start selling advanced weaponry to China, where prisoners are vivisected as part of a large-scale organ peddling scheme. Turkey’s leader is a garden variety Muslim strongman. Compared to the Chinese government, he’s the living incarnation of Cincinnatus, and I’m not even an Erdogan fan. May’s not desperate, she just needs to get those trade ducks in a row before Brexit occurs, much as you need to get a job lined up before the day your resignation takes effect.

  11. @5371

    This is highly mendacious gaslighting. Everyone who wasn’t wary of Cockburn already should definitely be so now.

    Why would it surprise you that a member of the Cockburn family is left-wing? Especially when this column is a Guardian feature? Back in my Nation subscriber days, I used to devour his late brother’s columns religiously. Both are excellent writers, but they tend to put their best foot forward a little too assertively, leaving out a ton of relevant information that would torpedo their core arguments. But then again, these are newspaper/newsletter columns, not PhD theses.

    • Replies: @5371
  12. 5371 says:
    @Johann Ricke

    My complaint was not about him being left-wing. It was about his amplifying false news about Trump personally.

  13. My complaint was not about him being left-wing. It was about his amplifying false news about Trump personally.

    Some news items are too good to check. Especially if they confirm your biases. Left-wingers aren’t immune, given the problem of print deadlines.

  14. Halit says:

    You talking about Turkey,and Kurdish population wanted to divide part of Turkey for Kurdistan,we had Democracy didn’t worked,
    So how come American Presidents like George W.Bush and Trump are not Dictatorship ?
    Invading countries based on lies Iraq and Afghanistan / Syria Libya openly overthrown elected gaverments and creating huge migration and waterboarding is practically security agencies national passtime and mentione Turkey President keeping Turkey alive is beyond believe.
    Tereca May closing deal with Turkey,and Britain higher interest allows them to do business with Saudies although Britain keep higher moral ground of Saudies activities with these questionable but they do business anyway.
    Turkey still role l model for middle East and strong President like Erdogan is absulatly essential.
    So your comment is not worth reading.

Current Commenter

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone

 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments become the property of The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Patrick Cockburn Comments via RSS
Personal Classics
Full Story of the Taliban's Amazing Jailbreak
"They Can't Even Protect Themselves, So What Can They Do For Me?"
"All Hell is Breaking Loose with Muqtada" Warlord: the Rise of Muqtada al-Sadr