The Unz Review - Mobile
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 Pat Buchanan ArchiveBlogview
Alone Perhaps, But Is Trump Right?
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments

At the G-20 in Hamburg, it is said, President Trump was isolated, without support from the other G-20 members, especially on climate change and trade.

Perhaps so. But the crucial question is not whether Trump is alone, but whether he is right. Has Trump read the crisis of the West correctly? Are his warnings valid? Is not the Obama-Merkel vision of a New World Order a utopian fantasy?

At the monument to the patriots of the Warsaw Uprising, Trump cited Poland as exemplar of how a great people behaves in a true national crisis.

Calling the Polish people “the soul of Europe,” he related how, in the Miracle of the Vistula in 1920, Poland, reborn after 12 decades of subjugation, drove back the invading Red Army of Leon Trotsky.

He described the gang rape of Poland by Nazis and Soviets after the Hitler-Stalin pact. He cited the Katyn Forest massacre of the Polish officer corps by Stalin, and the rising of the Polish people against their Nazi occupiers in 1944, as the vulturous legions of Stalin watched from the safe side of the river.

When the Polish Pope, John Paul II, celebrated his first Mass in Victory Square in 1979, said Trump, “a million Polish men, women and children raised their voices in a single prayer. … ‘We want God.’ … Every Communist in Warsaw must have known that their oppressive system would soon come crashing down.” And so it did.

The crisis of the West today, said Trump, is akin to what Poland faced. For it is about the survival of a civilization, rooted in Christianity, that has made the greatest of all contributions to the ascent of man.

What enabled the Poles to endure was an unshakable belief in and a willingness to fight for who they were — a people of God and country, faith, families, and freedom — with the courage and will to preserve a nation built on the truths of their ancient tribe and Catholic traditions.

Given the threats to the West, from within and without, said Trump, we need such a spirit now. What are those threats?

“The fundamental question of our time is whether the West has the will to survive. Do we have the confidence in our values to defend them at any cost? Do we have enough respect for our citizens to protect our borders? Do we have the desire and the courage to preserve our civilization in the face of those who would subvert and destroy it?

“We can have the largest economies and the most lethal weapons anywhere on Earth, but if we do not have strong families and strong values, then we will be weak and we will not survive.”

Trump professed confidence in the West’s will to survive. But whether the West still has the character seems an open question.

Across the West, the traditional family has been collapsing for decades. Not one European nation has a birth rate that will enable its people to survive many more generations. Uninvited migrants in the millions have poured in — are pouring in — from Africa and the Middle East. The elite of Europe have been gladly surrendering their national sovereignties to transnational institutions like the EU.

Christianity is more of a dying than a thriving faith on the Old Continent. And as the churches empty out, the mosques are going up. Before our eyes, the West is being remade.

In June, gays and lesbians celebrated in Berlin as the German Parliament voted to approve same-sex marriage.

In Moscow, from May to July, a million Russians stood in lines a mile long to view and venerate a relic of the 4th-century bishop, St. Nicholas, on display in a glass case in the Cathedral of Christ the Savior, rebuilt under President Putin.

Liberated from Leninism, Russia returns to the old faith, as Germany returns to Weimar.

At that G-20 gathering in Hamburg, hundreds of criminal thugs went on a three-day rampage — rioting, burning, looting and battling police, some 300 of whom were injured.

Were the autocrats of the G-20 — Xi Jinping of China, Vladimir Putin of Russia, Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey, Narendra Modi of India — impressed with the resolute response of Angela Merkel — the media-designated new “Leader of the West” — to mobs rioting in Germany’s second city?

At Harvard, Alexander Solzhenitsyn described what was on display in Hamburg: “A decline in courage may be the most striking feature which an outside observer notices in the West in our days. … Such a decline in courage is particularly noticeable among the ruling groups and the intellectual elite.”

Secularist and hedonist, New Europe worships at the altars of mammon. Handel’s “Messiah” cannot compete with moonwalking Michael Jackson’s “We are the World.”

Once Europe went out to convert, colonize and Christianize the world. Now the grandchildren of the colonized peoples come to Europe to demand their share of their inheritance from a West besotted with guilt over its past sins that cannot say “No!”

Patrick J. Buchanan is the author of a new book, “Nixon’s White House Wars: The Battles That Made and Broke a President and Divided America Forever.”

 
• Category: Foreign Policy • Tags: Donald Trump, EU 
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information



=>
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
    []
  1. It’s a ridiculous phrase created by the corporate media about German Chancellor Merkel: “Leader of the West.” Merkel is the most dubious and obscure politician Germany has ever created. She and the other European politicians pretend that the European Union can solve any crisis. So far, they have not solved a single one such as the Euro-crisis, the so-called migration-crisis, which rather resembles a mass migration. She has opened Germany’s borders for more than one million migrants without controlling them because apparently, this was not possible. But Hungary and the other Balkan states demonstrated that its possible. Merkel blamed them for practicing their sovereignty. The Western ruling elites despise Trump and Putin for their determination to wield the sovereignty of the nation-state.

    Read More
    ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc.
    AgreeDisagreeLOLTroll
    These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Troll, or LOL with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used once per hour.
    Sharing Comment via Twitter
    //www.unz.com/pbuchanan/alone-perhaps-but-is-trump-right/#comment-1930636
    More... This Commenter Display All Comments
  2. The Cathedral of Christ the Savior was rebuilt under Yeltsin, not Putin. Or, to be more accurate, was rebuilt under Luzhkov, the Mayor of Moscow, who funded it to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars when the federal government was essentially broke.

    Read More
  3. Anonymous says:     Show CommentNext New Comment

    Another great article by PJB. I wonder if it’s not better for the West to continue on its current path rather than try to restore itself? Maybe a descent into a Camp-of-the-Saints social collapse along with a collapse of the financial system and economy will be the best thing for the world overall? At the very least it will force Tel Aviv’s brutal and indiscriminate hitman into retirement.

    Right now I think hope for civilization (and Christianity) lies in the East. Venerable Fulton Sheen made reference to this in a talk in the 1960′s. Not only Eastern Europe and Russia, but in East Asia. Within 15 years China is set to become the most Christian nation. And ironically, the only thing threatening civilization and Christianity in the East is a demonic West now intent on destroying that. Even to the point of going out in a blaze of glory.

    Read More
  4. But aren’t the chickens of Christendom’s colonization of Europe and the Americas coming home to roost? I admire Pat but I don’t imagine his revanchist hope will carry the day. The America to which Trump alluded and Pat endorses is going down. I’m not happy about it. Ironically, its America’s internal opponents who are putting tribal, racial, gender loyalties above any loyalty they may feel to an America they despise. Linda Sarsour crossed the line the other day when she openly preached sedition and treason.

    My crystal ball tells me that the America of the future, in which the United States may be history, will likely be a poor, polyglot nation at war with itself until it settles into a state of “Third World” exhaustion to which a future generation will adapt. Of course, crystal balls are worth what you pay for them.

    Read More
  5. Well, I read the speech, in a version which included the chants of the crowd. It seems to me it was two speeches badly welded into one. The first, the foreign policy one, could easily be construed as anti-Rusia (pro expansive NATO). The second was a cheerleading effort, along the lines referenced by Buchanan. It spoke glowingly about Poland’s nationalism (and thus was correctly read by some German friends as “anti Merkel”) and more diffusely about “The West’s” achievements and will to survive. The Poles present received it enthusiastically, which must have been very flattering.

    Overall, a badly crafted speech, that can irritate both Russians and Germans by reminding them of past crimes and present policies where there is confrontation with the U.S. (role of NATO and refugees). One wonders what were the U.S. President’s diplomatic goals for that little venue, if indeed he had any.

    I usually agree with Buchanan, but not on this one. The US President is not a pundit, to be ” right” about his foreign policy is hardly enough. He has to be able to push it through. This requires clarity in his vision and the ability to find common ground, to influence his international partners (as Putin expresses it). He should not just go be provoking in Central Europe. If Trump is standing alone among world leaders, it is not because of righteousness, but because of incompetence.

    Read More
    • Replies: @HdC
    Sooo, stopping the wholesale murder of German expatriates in Poland is, according to you, a crime. Got it.

    I wonder how the USA, Britain, France etc. would have reacted if 35 000 or so of its expatriates had been murdered. HdC
  6. We need to start a campaign: Fire Nimrata Randhawa!

    Please, Mr. President.

    Read More
    • Agree: SolontoCroesus
    • Replies: @epebble
    Why? Isn't she just mouthing Trump's policies? (If there is such a thing)
  7. “We can have the largest economies and the most lethal weapons anywhere on Earth, but if we do not have strong families and strong values, then we will be weak and we will not survive.”

    Families and values along with traditions are what are under attack via Hollywood, large portions of academia (parts influenced by money and aggressive, loud mouths), media, and whore politicians.

    Look East young man and woman.

    Read More
    • Replies: @Rurik

    Look East young man and woman.
     
    perhaps with a ringside seat for watching Western Europe's descent into barbarism and Dante's n'th, will steel the resolve of Eastern Europe to forswear the suicidal insanity and death knell of the ((purveyors)) of 'diversity'. But their embrace of NATO is not a good sign.

    I keep waiting for Norway and Finland to see what's unfolding in Sweden and come to their senses, but the mind-rot that the zios have over the Western world is strong, and there are lots and lots of ugly, middle-aged, fat white women who want those desperate swarthy young men around.

    We'll just have to watch it all unfold I guess..

  8. Angela Merkel — the media-designated new “Leader of the West” —

    I checked, and she’s also referred to as the ‘leader of the free world’, and the ‘wearer of the mantle of the west’. blah, blah..

    the notable thing here is that when it comes to Merkel’s actions, vs. Trumps rhetoric vis-a-vis immigration, the rift between these two things could not be more jarring.

    Merkel represents the death (murder) of the Western world. She is the living incarnation of the anti-West (a literal abomination of the West), and is committed to seeing Germany and Europa wiped off the face of history for all eternity, to be replaced with a dystopian hell on earth- with a tiny cabal of zio-bankster/Anglo-pedophiles enslaving and mongrelizing the rest of the planet into one big zio-gulag, with all of us effectively treated as Palestinians are today, only with our children raised to worship at the feet of Moloch and to sacrifice their lives and their innocence to his demon’s fires.

    Trump, by contrast is sounding like the Lion of the West. A new Charles the Hammer Martel, ready and willing to take on the forces of evil that threaten our very existence and reinvigorate the spirit of the Western world to survive and persevere.

    a more stark contrast between pure good and evil ~ it’s hard to imagine.

    I only hope that Trump’s rhetoric is matched by his actions.

    Read More
  9. @bjondo

    “We can have the largest economies and the most lethal weapons anywhere on Earth, but if we do not have strong families and strong values, then we will be weak and we will not survive.”
     
    Families and values along with traditions are what are under attack via Hollywood, large portions of academia (parts influenced by money and aggressive, loud mouths), media, and whore politicians.

    Look East young man and woman.

    Look East young man and woman.

    perhaps with a ringside seat for watching Western Europe’s descent into barbarism and Dante’s n’th, will steel the resolve of Eastern Europe to forswear the suicidal insanity and death knell of the ((purveyors)) of ‘diversity’. But their embrace of NATO is not a good sign.

    I keep waiting for Norway and Finland to see what’s unfolding in Sweden and come to their senses, but the mind-rot that the zios have over the Western world is strong, and there are lots and lots of ugly, middle-aged, fat white women who want those desperate swarthy young men around.

    We’ll just have to watch it all unfold I guess..

    Read More
  10. Angela Merkel — the media-designated new “Leader of the West” —

    She’s more like the frumpy Frau from the pits of hell and the bane of the West in forcing her people to endure an Afro-Islamic invasion with the intent of racially bastardizing and replacing Germans. And it appears like she’s still going to win re-election in a landslide so the Faustian spirit and the German people are all but dead. Thanks Germany for all you’ve done for Western civilization and what you gave to the world, but the healthy portions of the West and Eastern Europe will take it from here while you keep re-electing Merkels and die slowly and painfully.

    Christianity is more of a dying than a thriving faith on the Old Continent.

    With few exceptions, Christianity has thrown in the towel and turned against the very race of people that that made it the largest religion in the world. Catholic organizations and other Christians are working to bring large numbers of Muslims refugees into America often at the expense of persecuted Christians. I liken many church leaders of all denominations to Sauron of the LOTR trilogy.

    In Trump were serious about reviving and defending Western civilization then he would be working to revive white birthrates in America while enacting an immigration moratorium and discouraging whites from entering into interracial relationships. He would encourage Europe to do the same instead of speaking in generalities. Whites are behind enemy lines and their own historic nations aren’t even safe havens anymore.

    Goldwater said that extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice, but I say extremism in the defense of racial survival is no vice. For without white European DNA there is no West other than in name.

    Read More
    • Replies: @KenH

    but the healthy portions of the West and Eastern Europe will take it from here
     
    I forgot to include Putin's Russia.
    , @Wally
    "In Trump were serious about reviving and defending Western civilization then he would be working to revive white birthrates in America while enacting an immigration moratorium and discouraging whites from entering into interracial relationships. He would encourage Europe to do the same instead of speaking in generalities."

    And how can Trump do that?
  11. The Enlightenment is what made the west great. The backwards Roman Catholicism so loved by Buchanan and so many Poles undermines it. Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization. They waged war for hegemony of backwardness. Copernicus was a swell guy, but Poland’s contribution to the ascent of the west since then has been pretty much zip. Funny how Buchanan’s cogent criticism of Poland’s role in starting the Second World War is forgotten in his fauning over Trump’s sophomoric speech.

    Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault. Don’t worry when dysfunctional weenies voluntarily take themselves out of the gene pool.

    Read More
    • Replies: @Anonymous

    Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization. They waged war for hegemony of backwardness. Copernicus was a swell guy, but Poland’s contribution to the ascent of the west since then has been pretty much zip.
     
    Essplainame, Lucy, how that's a "bad thing"? Who really gives a shit what you think of Poland and their global role which they choose NOT to be a global role?

    Bark, bark, Yorkie. LOL.
    , @animalogic
    All this talk of "western civilisation"reminds me of a quote attributed to Gandhi:
    "What do you think of western civilisation, Mr Gandhi ?"
    "I think it would be a good idea"he replied.

    Regardless of Poland's contributions to civilisation of the past, it remains a fact that today's Poland is one of the chief instigators of the "Russia is all evil, all the time" chorus. Its a great cheerleader for pushing NATO up to Russia's borders etc etc. These actions, to say the least, are fraught with danger: for Poland & what for passes for our civilisation.

    As for: "Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault."
    Economics & culture are of one large KNOT. It should be clear that Neo-liberalism cares nothing for families: the destruction of small business, of living wages & the general gross bias of Elites against people/families to corporations demonstrate just how elites care about families. Neoliberalism's willingness to dispense with morality in such things as advertising, movies etc if it will secure good profits has been clear for years (Of course, we as consumers, of such degenerate products are not innocent either)

    Nor does christianity fare too well in hyper-capitalist society: Jesus was pretty clear on this element: there's the problem of rich persons & the eye of needles, & that you can't follow two leaders: its Christ OR Mammon, I believe.
    , @SolontoCroesus

    The Enlightenment is what made the west great. The backwards Roman Catholicism so loved by Buchanan and so many Poles undermines it.
     
    Was it Enlightenment that moved Russia from Tolstoy to Trotsky from Pasternak to PNAC?


    Slavophilism, the messianism of backwardness, has based its philosophy upon the assumption that the Russian people and their church are democratic through and through, whereas official Russia is a German bureaucracy imposed upon them by Peter the Great. Marx remarked upon this theme: "In the same way the Teutonic jackasses blamed the despotism of Frederick the Second upon the French, as though backward slaves were not always in need of civilised slaves to train them." This brief comment completely finishes off not only the old philosophy of the Slavophiles, but also the latest revelations of the ’racists.’"
     
    https://redice.tv/news/racist-a-word-invented-by-ussr-s-leon-trotsky

    The Slavophiles which Trotsky alluded to were historically a group of traditionalist Slavs who valued greatly their native culture and way of life, and wanted to protect it. Trotsky on the other hand saw them and others like them as an impedement to his internationalist communist plans for the world. This man didn’t care one iota about the Slavic Russians whom he supposedly served. To him, Slavophiles, i.e. Slavs that committed the "crime" of loving their own people and trying to protect their traditional ways were simply "backward", and others like them were simply "racists". https://redice.tv/news/racist-a-word-invented-by-ussr-s-leon-trotsky
     

    , @Rurik

    Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault
     
    this is a very vapid thing to say

    families in the West are declining because they're under assault by the Fed at the top, which is yes, destroying their economies and the value of their earnings and savings- but more to the point, the decline of the Western family is due to these same ((elites)) flooding the lands of the West with incompatible throngs of non-Western peoples. Duh

    Rhodesia was a Western nation carved out of the jungles of Africa and created by Western peoples for Western peoples to prosper and persevere in. To say that it is losing its Western character because of its declining economy.. is not just dishonest, but ludicrous. It's losing its Western character because it was betrayed by the zio-Anglo pedophiles that run England and the West.

    here's the president of South Africa demonstrating how a culture becomes less Western, and it has nothing to do with economics

    http://images.dailymaverick.co.za/images/resized_images/706x410q7048b0595130aa463eb8df97a66a44d1ab.jpg

    , @MarkinLA
    Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization.

    Well except that Battle of Vienna thingy.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Vienna
  12. Anonymous says:     Show CommentNext New Comment

    Trump lacks both intellectual integrity and intellectual honesty. Or any philosophically-sound ethos, for that matter.

    If Russia has a lick of good sense, they’ll keep their nuclear deterrent operational, and ignore the collapsing decadent monster, the USA. They might also benefit from making it known that, say, 10% of their kick-ass nukes have “Destination Jerusalem” inscribed on the MIRV capsule.

    Russia has adequate resources to be a strong economy and a businesslike, but somewhat insular, nation of dedicated Russians. You know, kinda like the USA used to be for Americans. They might greatly benefit from pursuing that route.

    Sic transit, dammit, sic transit gloria mundi.

    Read More
  13. Anonymous says:     Show CommentNext New Comment
    @Thirdeye
    The Enlightenment is what made the west great. The backwards Roman Catholicism so loved by Buchanan and so many Poles undermines it. Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization. They waged war for hegemony of backwardness. Copernicus was a swell guy, but Poland's contribution to the ascent of the west since then has been pretty much zip. Funny how Buchanan's cogent criticism of Poland's role in starting the Second World War is forgotten in his fauning over Trump's sophomoric speech.

    Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault. Don't worry when dysfunctional weenies voluntarily take themselves out of the gene pool.

    Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization. They waged war for hegemony of backwardness. Copernicus was a swell guy, but Poland’s contribution to the ascent of the west since then has been pretty much zip.

    Essplainame, Lucy, how that’s a “bad thing”? Who really gives a shit what you think of Poland and their global role which they choose NOT to be a global role?

    Bark, bark, Yorkie. LOL.

    Read More
    • Replies: @Thirdeye


    Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization. They waged war for hegemony of backwardness.

     

    Essplainame, Lucy, how that’s a “bad thing”?
     
    I see you don't mind wars for hegemony of backwardness.

    .......Poland and their global role which they choose NOT to be a global role?
     
    They've been as global as their means allowed. In the interwar and post-Cold War eras their global role has been to align with world hegemons to gain advantages over neighboring states, with results that have turned quite bad. Somehow, the lesson that it's better to have a good policy towards neighboring states rather than alignment with your neighboring states' sworn enemies seems to escape them. They don't like EU's immigration policy but with all of the Atlanticists' other imperial bullshit is just fine and dandy with them.
  14. Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault.

    Do you mean that if we were to lower the economic level to the level of African countries things would improve for the families in the West?

    Read More
    • Replies: @Anonymous

    Do you mean that if we were to lower the economic level to the level of African countries things would improve for the families in the West?
     
    That's the entire theme behind "Helter Skelter" -- when you get to the bottom you go back to the top of the slide then you turn and go for a ride. I think Sir Paul summarized all of western political, economic, and historical theory right then and there.
    , @Thirdeye

    Do you mean that if we were to lower the economic level to the level of African countries things would improve for the families in the West?
     
    No, that's an incredibly stupid interpretation of what I said.
    , @Saxon
    No, he means the level of wealth redistribution to brown colonists is something you have to see to believe. Your average white person cannot afford to have a replacement level family of 3-4 children anymore, whereas your tax money goes to subsidize brown people breeding you out of existence.
  15. Anonymous says:     Show CommentNext New Comment
    @utu
    Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault.

    Do you mean that if we were to lower the economic level to the level of African countries things would improve for the families in the West?

    Do you mean that if we were to lower the economic level to the level of African countries things would improve for the families in the West?

    That’s the entire theme behind “Helter Skelter” — when you get to the bottom you go back to the top of the slide then you turn and go for a ride. I think Sir Paul summarized all of western political, economic, and historical theory right then and there.

    Read More
  16. @utu
    Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault.

    Do you mean that if we were to lower the economic level to the level of African countries things would improve for the families in the West?

    Do you mean that if we were to lower the economic level to the level of African countries things would improve for the families in the West?

    No, that’s an incredibly stupid interpretation of what I said.

    Read More
  17. @Anonymous

    Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization. They waged war for hegemony of backwardness. Copernicus was a swell guy, but Poland’s contribution to the ascent of the west since then has been pretty much zip.
     
    Essplainame, Lucy, how that's a "bad thing"? Who really gives a shit what you think of Poland and their global role which they choose NOT to be a global role?

    Bark, bark, Yorkie. LOL.

    Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization. They waged war for hegemony of backwardness.

    Essplainame, Lucy, how that’s a “bad thing”?

    I see you don’t mind wars for hegemony of backwardness.

    …….Poland and their global role which they choose NOT to be a global role?

    They’ve been as global as their means allowed. In the interwar and post-Cold War eras their global role has been to align with world hegemons to gain advantages over neighboring states, with results that have turned quite bad. Somehow, the lesson that it’s better to have a good policy towards neighboring states rather than alignment with your neighboring states’ sworn enemies seems to escape them. They don’t like EU’s immigration policy but with all of the Atlanticists’ other imperial bullshit is just fine and dandy with them.

    Read More
    • Replies: @Anonymous

    I see you don’t mind wars for hegemony of backwardness
     
    Not as you interpret "backwardness", obviously. You stepped right up and categorized Poland, just all by your little fluffy-head self, as being backward, perpetually archaic, rooted in RC values, hence wrong, wrong, wrong.

    So kiss my ass, Fluffy. Address your own issues; I did but identify them for you.
  18. @TheOldOne
    We need to start a campaign: Fire Nimrata Randhawa!

    Please, Mr. President.

    Why? Isn’t she just mouthing Trump’s policies? (If there is such a thing)

    Read More
  19. @utu
    Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault.

    Do you mean that if we were to lower the economic level to the level of African countries things would improve for the families in the West?

    No, he means the level of wealth redistribution to brown colonists is something you have to see to believe. Your average white person cannot afford to have a replacement level family of 3-4 children anymore, whereas your tax money goes to subsidize brown people breeding you out of existence.

    Read More
  20. @Thirdeye
    The Enlightenment is what made the west great. The backwards Roman Catholicism so loved by Buchanan and so many Poles undermines it. Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization. They waged war for hegemony of backwardness. Copernicus was a swell guy, but Poland's contribution to the ascent of the west since then has been pretty much zip. Funny how Buchanan's cogent criticism of Poland's role in starting the Second World War is forgotten in his fauning over Trump's sophomoric speech.

    Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault. Don't worry when dysfunctional weenies voluntarily take themselves out of the gene pool.

    All this talk of “western civilisation”reminds me of a quote attributed to Gandhi:
    “What do you think of western civilisation, Mr Gandhi ?”
    “I think it would be a good idea”he replied.

    Regardless of Poland’s contributions to civilisation of the past, it remains a fact that today’s Poland is one of the chief instigators of the “Russia is all evil, all the time” chorus. Its a great cheerleader for pushing NATO up to Russia’s borders etc etc. These actions, to say the least, are fraught with danger: for Poland & what for passes for our civilisation.

    As for: “Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault.”
    Economics & culture are of one large KNOT. It should be clear that Neo-liberalism cares nothing for families: the destruction of small business, of living wages & the general gross bias of Elites against people/families to corporations demonstrate just how elites care about families. Neoliberalism’s willingness to dispense with morality in such things as advertising, movies etc if it will secure good profits has been clear for years (Of course, we as consumers, of such degenerate products are not innocent either)

    Nor does christianity fare too well in hyper-capitalist society: Jesus was pretty clear on this element: there’s the problem of rich persons & the eye of needles, & that you can’t follow two leaders: its Christ OR Mammon, I believe.

    Read More
  21. @Thirdeye
    The Enlightenment is what made the west great. The backwards Roman Catholicism so loved by Buchanan and so many Poles undermines it. Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization. They waged war for hegemony of backwardness. Copernicus was a swell guy, but Poland's contribution to the ascent of the west since then has been pretty much zip. Funny how Buchanan's cogent criticism of Poland's role in starting the Second World War is forgotten in his fauning over Trump's sophomoric speech.

    Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault. Don't worry when dysfunctional weenies voluntarily take themselves out of the gene pool.

    The Enlightenment is what made the west great. The backwards Roman Catholicism so loved by Buchanan and so many Poles undermines it.

    Was it Enlightenment that moved Russia from Tolstoy to Trotsky from Pasternak to PNAC?

    Slavophilism, the messianism of backwardness, has based its philosophy upon the assumption that the Russian people and their church are democratic through and through, whereas official Russia is a German bureaucracy imposed upon them by Peter the Great. Marx remarked upon this theme: “In the same way the Teutonic jackasses blamed the despotism of Frederick the Second upon the French, as though backward slaves were not always in need of civilised slaves to train them.” This brief comment completely finishes off not only the old philosophy of the Slavophiles, but also the latest revelations of the ’racists.’”

    https://redice.tv/news/racist-a-word-invented-by-ussr-s-leon-trotsky

    The Slavophiles which Trotsky alluded to were historically a group of traditionalist Slavs who valued greatly their native culture and way of life, and wanted to protect it. Trotsky on the other hand saw them and others like them as an impedement to his internationalist communist plans for the world. This man didn’t care one iota about the Slavic Russians whom he supposedly served. To him, Slavophiles, i.e. Slavs that committed the “crime” of loving their own people and trying to protect their traditional ways were simply “backward”, and others like them were simply “racists”. https://redice.tv/news/racist-a-word-invented-by-ussr-s-leon-trotsky

    Read More
  22. Looking to Germany for leadership? Remember the Wars folks. Putin is the leader of the free World, Trump is just the tantrum throwing child of the deep state [Israel].

    Read More
  23. Anonymous says:     Show CommentNext New Comment
    @Thirdeye


    Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization. They waged war for hegemony of backwardness.

     

    Essplainame, Lucy, how that’s a “bad thing”?
     
    I see you don't mind wars for hegemony of backwardness.

    .......Poland and their global role which they choose NOT to be a global role?
     
    They've been as global as their means allowed. In the interwar and post-Cold War eras their global role has been to align with world hegemons to gain advantages over neighboring states, with results that have turned quite bad. Somehow, the lesson that it's better to have a good policy towards neighboring states rather than alignment with your neighboring states' sworn enemies seems to escape them. They don't like EU's immigration policy but with all of the Atlanticists' other imperial bullshit is just fine and dandy with them.

    I see you don’t mind wars for hegemony of backwardness

    Not as you interpret “backwardness”, obviously. You stepped right up and categorized Poland, just all by your little fluffy-head self, as being backward, perpetually archaic, rooted in RC values, hence wrong, wrong, wrong.

    So kiss my ass, Fluffy. Address your own issues; I did but identify them for you.

    Read More
  24. @KenH

    Angela Merkel — the media-designated new “Leader of the West” —
     
    She's more like the frumpy Frau from the pits of hell and the bane of the West in forcing her people to endure an Afro-Islamic invasion with the intent of racially bastardizing and replacing Germans. And it appears like she's still going to win re-election in a landslide so the Faustian spirit and the German people are all but dead. Thanks Germany for all you've done for Western civilization and what you gave to the world, but the healthy portions of the West and Eastern Europe will take it from here while you keep re-electing Merkels and die slowly and painfully.

    Christianity is more of a dying than a thriving faith on the Old Continent.

     

    With few exceptions, Christianity has thrown in the towel and turned against the very race of people that that made it the largest religion in the world. Catholic organizations and other Christians are working to bring large numbers of Muslims refugees into America often at the expense of persecuted Christians. I liken many church leaders of all denominations to Sauron of the LOTR trilogy.

    In Trump were serious about reviving and defending Western civilization then he would be working to revive white birthrates in America while enacting an immigration moratorium and discouraging whites from entering into interracial relationships. He would encourage Europe to do the same instead of speaking in generalities. Whites are behind enemy lines and their own historic nations aren't even safe havens anymore.

    Goldwater said that extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice, but I say extremism in the defense of racial survival is no vice. For without white European DNA there is no West other than in name.

    but the healthy portions of the West and Eastern Europe will take it from here

    I forgot to include Putin’s Russia.

    Read More
  25. @Thirdeye
    The Enlightenment is what made the west great. The backwards Roman Catholicism so loved by Buchanan and so many Poles undermines it. Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization. They waged war for hegemony of backwardness. Copernicus was a swell guy, but Poland's contribution to the ascent of the west since then has been pretty much zip. Funny how Buchanan's cogent criticism of Poland's role in starting the Second World War is forgotten in his fauning over Trump's sophomoric speech.

    Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault. Don't worry when dysfunctional weenies voluntarily take themselves out of the gene pool.

    Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault

    this is a very vapid thing to say

    families in the West are declining because they’re under assault by the Fed at the top, which is yes, destroying their economies and the value of their earnings and savings- but more to the point, the decline of the Western family is due to these same ((elites)) flooding the lands of the West with incompatible throngs of non-Western peoples. Duh

    Rhodesia was a Western nation carved out of the jungles of Africa and created by Western peoples for Western peoples to prosper and persevere in. To say that it is losing its Western character because of its declining economy.. is not just dishonest, but ludicrous. It’s losing its Western character because it was betrayed by the zio-Anglo pedophiles that run England and the West.

    here’s the president of South Africa demonstrating how a culture becomes less Western, and it has nothing to do with economics

    http://images.dailymaverick.co.za/images/resized_images/706x410q7048b0595130aa463eb8df97a66a44d1ab.jpg

    Read More
    • Replies: @Thirdeye
    Then kindly explain why it's also happening in Japan, where it's a closed society with a family crisis similar to the West's, i.e., people not starting families. It's economic. Economics in the west and Japan are no longer family friendly. It's actually worse in Japan because of the taboo against mothers working outside of the home. Young Japanese are so daunted by the expectations and economic hurdles of running a family unit that they retreat into a sort of perpetual adolescence.
  26. @Veritatis
    Well, I read the speech, in a version which included the chants of the crowd. It seems to me it was two speeches badly welded into one. The first, the foreign policy one, could easily be construed as anti-Rusia (pro expansive NATO). The second was a cheerleading effort, along the lines referenced by Buchanan. It spoke glowingly about Poland's nationalism (and thus was correctly read by some German friends as "anti Merkel") and more diffusely about "The West's" achievements and will to survive. The Poles present received it enthusiastically, which must have been very flattering.

    Overall, a badly crafted speech, that can irritate both Russians and Germans by reminding them of past crimes and present policies where there is confrontation with the U.S. (role of NATO and refugees). One wonders what were the U.S. President's diplomatic goals for that little venue, if indeed he had any.

    I usually agree with Buchanan, but not on this one. The US President is not a pundit, to be " right" about his foreign policy is hardly enough. He has to be able to push it through. This requires clarity in his vision and the ability to find common ground, to influence his international partners (as Putin expresses it). He should not just go be provoking in Central Europe. If Trump is standing alone among world leaders, it is not because of righteousness, but because of incompetence.

    Sooo, stopping the wholesale murder of German expatriates in Poland is, according to you, a crime. Got it.

    I wonder how the USA, Britain, France etc. would have reacted if 35 000 or so of its expatriates had been murdered. HdC

    Read More
  27. @Thirdeye
    The Enlightenment is what made the west great. The backwards Roman Catholicism so loved by Buchanan and so many Poles undermines it. Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization. They waged war for hegemony of backwardness. Copernicus was a swell guy, but Poland's contribution to the ascent of the west since then has been pretty much zip. Funny how Buchanan's cogent criticism of Poland's role in starting the Second World War is forgotten in his fauning over Trump's sophomoric speech.

    Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault. Don't worry when dysfunctional weenies voluntarily take themselves out of the gene pool.

    Poland never fired a shot in defense of western civilization.

    Well except that Battle of Vienna thingy.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Vienna

    Read More
  28. At Harvard, Alexander Solzhenitsyn described what was on display in Hamburg: “A decline in courage may be the most striking feature which an outside observer notices in the West in our days. … Such a decline in courage is particularly noticeable among the ruling groups and the intellectual elite.”

    The Matrix did it – they sowed the seeds of division and hate among our people.

    Together we are strong – looking out for the future of all.

    Divided we are weak – concentrating only on our personal identity – hating and fearing others.

    The 15,000,000 strong Jew Matrix did this to us – it is there for those of courage to see.

    LOOK!

    Peace — Art

    Read More
    • Replies: @SolontoCroesus
    What you fail to realize, Art, is that the "Matrix" did it to Germany & Germans first. http://www.solargeneral.org/wp-content/uploads/library/conjuring-hitler.pdf Jews destroyed the center of Christian Europe; it was not an accident, and US Christians were fully complicit.

    What we are experiencing today is the mop-up operation. Jesus has been removed from the cross and flushed in a vat of urine; Jews have been elevated to center of (self-) adoration in holocaust worship centers all over the world.

    The deep state's struggle is to retain the "international order" that was established at the end of WWII -- how many more times do you need to hear politicians & pundits/think tankers recite that phrase before you understand that the resurrection of Jesus has been reversed/replaced?

  29. @Art
    At Harvard, Alexander Solzhenitsyn described what was on display in Hamburg: “A decline in courage may be the most striking feature which an outside observer notices in the West in our days. … Such a decline in courage is particularly noticeable among the ruling groups and the intellectual elite.”

    The Matrix did it - they sowed the seeds of division and hate among our people.

    Together we are strong - looking out for the future of all.

    Divided we are weak - concentrating only on our personal identity - hating and fearing others.

    The 15,000,000 strong Jew Matrix did this to us - it is there for those of courage to see.

    LOOK!

    Peace --- Art

    What you fail to realize, Art, is that the “Matrix” did it to Germany & Germans first. http://www.solargeneral.org/wp-content/uploads/library/conjuring-hitler.pdf Jews destroyed the center of Christian Europe; it was not an accident, and US Christians were fully complicit.

    What we are experiencing today is the mop-up operation. Jesus has been removed from the cross and flushed in a vat of urine; Jews have been elevated to center of (self-) adoration in holocaust worship centers all over the world.

    The deep state’s struggle is to retain the “international order” that was established at the end of WWII — how many more times do you need to hear politicians & pundits/think tankers recite that phrase before you understand that the resurrection of Jesus has been reversed/replaced?

    Read More
  30. @Rurik

    Families in the west are declining because of economic, more than cultural, assault
     
    this is a very vapid thing to say

    families in the West are declining because they're under assault by the Fed at the top, which is yes, destroying their economies and the value of their earnings and savings- but more to the point, the decline of the Western family is due to these same ((elites)) flooding the lands of the West with incompatible throngs of non-Western peoples. Duh

    Rhodesia was a Western nation carved out of the jungles of Africa and created by Western peoples for Western peoples to prosper and persevere in. To say that it is losing its Western character because of its declining economy.. is not just dishonest, but ludicrous. It's losing its Western character because it was betrayed by the zio-Anglo pedophiles that run England and the West.

    here's the president of South Africa demonstrating how a culture becomes less Western, and it has nothing to do with economics

    http://images.dailymaverick.co.za/images/resized_images/706x410q7048b0595130aa463eb8df97a66a44d1ab.jpg

    Then kindly explain why it’s also happening in Japan, where it’s a closed society with a family crisis similar to the West’s, i.e., people not starting families. It’s economic. Economics in the west and Japan are no longer family friendly. It’s actually worse in Japan because of the taboo against mothers working outside of the home. Young Japanese are so daunted by the expectations and economic hurdles of running a family unit that they retreat into a sort of perpetual adolescence.

    Read More
    • Replies: @Rurik

    Then kindly explain why it’s also happening in Japan, where it’s a closed society with a family crisis similar to the West’s
     
    I assert that the crisis that you speak of, while daunting and real, is nothing like the crisis facing the West, which I would characterize as nothing less than existential.

    The people of Japan can go through terrible ordeals, and still come out thriving on the other side, not so the people of the West, when the people of the West have been replaced with non-Western people.

    to best flesh this out, someone created a photo essay of Detroit vs. Hiroshima

    http://reasonradionetwork.com/images/2012/05/Hiroshima_versus_Detroit.jpg

    https://tnixon16.wordpress.com/2009/10/09/detroit-vs-hiroshima-64-years-later/

    in a hundred years, Japan will likely be just fine. Not so the West, when Paris and London and Berlin look like Detroit and Baltimore, with the orcs marching to every last bastion of Western civilization. The genocide will be final and eternal.
  31. He’s torn between his “beliefs” (real or were just to fool us), and his deeply committed Zionist family, friends, and the whole cabinet that were handpicked by him. Trump is no different from others, and his campaign rhetoric of draining the swamp (it was filthy, but now it’s being filled with radioactive toxins), bashing Zaudi Arabia during his “wise guy” auction for POTUS (he’s now getting ready to send our people to kill, destroy and get killed), and happily doing Zionists’ bidding. The troll is leading this country to an abyss. It’s sad that we have intelligent people that still believe in this snake oil salesman!!!!!!!

    Read More
    • Replies: @truthtellerAryan
    Most of the stuff the troll says are usually scripted for him to sound respectable, whatever comes out of his pea brain is usually ghetto trash.... We're in for a ride, driven by Brand New Ziocons
  32. @truthtellerAryan
    He's torn between his "beliefs" (real or were just to fool us), and his deeply committed Zionist family, friends, and the whole cabinet that were handpicked by him. Trump is no different from others, and his campaign rhetoric of draining the swamp (it was filthy, but now it's being filled with radioactive toxins), bashing Zaudi Arabia during his "wise guy" auction for POTUS (he's now getting ready to send our people to kill, destroy and get killed), and happily doing Zionists' bidding. The troll is leading this country to an abyss. It's sad that we have intelligent people that still believe in this snake oil salesman!!!!!!!

    Most of the stuff the troll says are usually scripted for him to sound respectable, whatever comes out of his pea brain is usually ghetto trash…. We’re in for a ride, driven by Brand New Ziocons

    Read More
  33. @KenH

    Angela Merkel — the media-designated new “Leader of the West” —
     
    She's more like the frumpy Frau from the pits of hell and the bane of the West in forcing her people to endure an Afro-Islamic invasion with the intent of racially bastardizing and replacing Germans. And it appears like she's still going to win re-election in a landslide so the Faustian spirit and the German people are all but dead. Thanks Germany for all you've done for Western civilization and what you gave to the world, but the healthy portions of the West and Eastern Europe will take it from here while you keep re-electing Merkels and die slowly and painfully.

    Christianity is more of a dying than a thriving faith on the Old Continent.

     

    With few exceptions, Christianity has thrown in the towel and turned against the very race of people that that made it the largest religion in the world. Catholic organizations and other Christians are working to bring large numbers of Muslims refugees into America often at the expense of persecuted Christians. I liken many church leaders of all denominations to Sauron of the LOTR trilogy.

    In Trump were serious about reviving and defending Western civilization then he would be working to revive white birthrates in America while enacting an immigration moratorium and discouraging whites from entering into interracial relationships. He would encourage Europe to do the same instead of speaking in generalities. Whites are behind enemy lines and their own historic nations aren't even safe havens anymore.

    Goldwater said that extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice, but I say extremism in the defense of racial survival is no vice. For without white European DNA there is no West other than in name.

    “In Trump were serious about reviving and defending Western civilization then he would be working to revive white birthrates in America while enacting an immigration moratorium and discouraging whites from entering into interracial relationships. He would encourage Europe to do the same instead of speaking in generalities.”

    And how can Trump do that?

    Read More
    • Replies: @Anon
    He could say it, but like most racists, he's a coward.
    , @KenH

    And how can Trump do that?
     
    Take to twitter to encourage his fellow whites to have more babies. It was a-ok for him to say he wanted to be the champion of black America and bemoan the number of black babies lost to the abortion industry, so maybe he can take some time to advocate for a higher fertility rate for his own people.

    Work with Congress to provide tax incentives for whites to marry (other whites) and have babies. Give special job protection to whites. Illegalize all employment diversity programs in the private sector. Whites should be the first hired and the last fired just like in the bad old days.

    Tell Congress to ditch affirmative action. Not sure how old you are but believe it or not, Republicans used to trash affirmative action and promise to abolish it up until the late 90's when they decided to capitulate and become good whites. Even the great El Rushbo doesn't criticize it anymore.

    Deep six the H1B, H2B and other visa programs that displace white workers. Tell Congress all new spending bills are DOA until they pass a 25 year moratorium on all immigration, only granting few exceptions to highly skilled and educated white Europeans.

    If you're going to say that he can't say or do any of this then fine, but then there's no point in voting anymore and voting won't change or solve anything. We're long past the point of quarter measures and Aesopian, race neutral language.

    Every non-white group seeks special rights and privileges at our expense, so it's only fair that we, as the majority and descendants of the founding racial stocks, seek to collectively benefit at their expense.

  34. Anon says:     Show CommentNext New Comment
    @Wally
    "In Trump were serious about reviving and defending Western civilization then he would be working to revive white birthrates in America while enacting an immigration moratorium and discouraging whites from entering into interracial relationships. He would encourage Europe to do the same instead of speaking in generalities."

    And how can Trump do that?

    He could say it, but like most racists, he’s a coward.

    Read More
  35. @Wally
    "In Trump were serious about reviving and defending Western civilization then he would be working to revive white birthrates in America while enacting an immigration moratorium and discouraging whites from entering into interracial relationships. He would encourage Europe to do the same instead of speaking in generalities."

    And how can Trump do that?

    And how can Trump do that?

    Take to twitter to encourage his fellow whites to have more babies. It was a-ok for him to say he wanted to be the champion of black America and bemoan the number of black babies lost to the abortion industry, so maybe he can take some time to advocate for a higher fertility rate for his own people.

    Work with Congress to provide tax incentives for whites to marry (other whites) and have babies. Give special job protection to whites. Illegalize all employment diversity programs in the private sector. Whites should be the first hired and the last fired just like in the bad old days.

    Tell Congress to ditch affirmative action. Not sure how old you are but believe it or not, Republicans used to trash affirmative action and promise to abolish it up until the late 90′s when they decided to capitulate and become good whites. Even the great El Rushbo doesn’t criticize it anymore.

    Deep six the H1B, H2B and other visa programs that displace white workers. Tell Congress all new spending bills are DOA until they pass a 25 year moratorium on all immigration, only granting few exceptions to highly skilled and educated white Europeans.

    If you’re going to say that he can’t say or do any of this then fine, but then there’s no point in voting anymore and voting won’t change or solve anything. We’re long past the point of quarter measures and Aesopian, race neutral language.

    Every non-white group seeks special rights and privileges at our expense, so it’s only fair that we, as the majority and descendants of the founding racial stocks, seek to collectively benefit at their expense.

    Read More
  36. @Thirdeye
    Then kindly explain why it's also happening in Japan, where it's a closed society with a family crisis similar to the West's, i.e., people not starting families. It's economic. Economics in the west and Japan are no longer family friendly. It's actually worse in Japan because of the taboo against mothers working outside of the home. Young Japanese are so daunted by the expectations and economic hurdles of running a family unit that they retreat into a sort of perpetual adolescence.

    Then kindly explain why it’s also happening in Japan, where it’s a closed society with a family crisis similar to the West’s

    I assert that the crisis that you speak of, while daunting and real, is nothing like the crisis facing the West, which I would characterize as nothing less than existential.

    The people of Japan can go through terrible ordeals, and still come out thriving on the other side, not so the people of the West, when the people of the West have been replaced with non-Western people.

    to best flesh this out, someone created a photo essay of Detroit vs. Hiroshima

    http://reasonradionetwork.com/images/2012/05/Hiroshima_versus_Detroit.jpg

    https://tnixon16.wordpress.com/2009/10/09/detroit-vs-hiroshima-64-years-later/

    in a hundred years, Japan will likely be just fine. Not so the West, when Paris and London and Berlin look like Detroit and Baltimore, with the orcs marching to every last bastion of Western civilization. The genocide will be final and eternal.

    Read More
Current Commenter says:

Leave a Reply -


 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments become the property of The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Pat Buchanan Comments via RSS
PastClassics
The “war hero” candidate buried information about POWs left behind in Vietnam.
While other top brass played press agents for the administration’s war, William Odom told the truth about Iraq—though few listened.
What Was John McCain's True Wartime Record in Vietnam?