The Unz Review - Mobile
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information

Topics Filter?
IQ Ideology And Worldview Review Global Warming Europeans Heredity Skin Color East Asians Shorts And Funnies Fertility Genetics Hbd Chick Sexual Selection Gregory Clark Polygyny American Nations Intelligence Nature Vs. Nurture Greg Cochran China Health And Medicine Gender And Sexuality Immigration Genetic Pacification Children Eye Color Hair Color Population Replacement Race/IQ Violence Baby Gap Colin Woodard Evolution Mathematics Gene-Culture Coevolution Neanderthals American Nations Obesity Fertility Hajnal Line Dysgenic Eugenics Iq Homosexuality Human Evolution Parenting Vitamin D Albion's Seed Archaic Humans Behavioral Genetics Northwest Europe Out Of Africa Model Affordable Family Formation Funny Henry Harpending Light Skin Preference Middle East Operational Sex Ratio Religion And Philosophy Richard Lewontin Ron Unz Western European Marriage Pattern Africa African Americans Antiracism Farmers Female Sexual Response Genes Guilt Culture Human Biodiversity Japan Male Homosexuality Peter Frost Clannishness Greece Inbreeding Misdreavus Monogamy Nicholas Wade Puritans Skin Tone Agriculture Amerindians Appalachia Blacks Cardiovascular Disease Cavaliers Conservatives Evolutionary Psychology Face Recognition Free Will Heart Health Immigration Pioneer Hypothesis Political Correctness Race Denialism Razib Khan Sexual Dimorphism South Korea Steven Pinker Sub-replacement Fertility Africans ASPM Atheism Balanced Polymorphism David Hackett Fischer Environment Estrogen Guns John Hawks Kinship Middle Ages Parasite Manipulation Parenting Russia Sandra Beleza Shame Culture Steve Sailer Twins Upper Paleolithic WasPage Addiction Alan Macfarlane Blue Eyes Brain Size Corruption Crime Diet Empathy France Franz Boas French Canadians Hbd Idiocracy Inuit John Tooby Leda Cosmides Liberals Peter Turchin Phil Rushton Race And Iq Religion Roman Empire Slave Trade Staffan Women In The Workplace A Troublesome Inheritance Adoption Affective Empathy Altruism Bill Maher Blond Hair Ed Miller Education England Evolutionary Biology Flynn Effect Genetic Load Globalization I Love Italians Map Posts Muslims North Korea Obama Pathogens Politics Quakers Race Racism Religion Sweden Twin Study Visual Word Form Area White Slavery Ancient DNA Bisexuality Borderlanders Britain Burakumin Canada Candida Albicans Chinese Evolution Davide Piffer Denisovans Economy Exercise Feminism Gay Germ Gregory Cochran Hunter-Gatherers Individualism Italy Judith Harris Market Economy Microcephalin Modern Humans Morality Personality Reprint Richard Dawkins Richard Lynn Richard Russell Solutions State Formation Suicide Terrorism Testosterone UV Vaginal Yeast A Farewell To Alms American Media Amygdala Archaic DNA Attractiveness Bacterial Vaginosis Cancer Charles Murray Christianity Cochran And Harpending Cousin Marriage Creationism Darwinism Deep South Dr James Thompson Gender Equality Genomics Germany Globalism Homicide Rate Joke Posts Manorialism Mental Health Mesolithic Multiregional Model Nbc News Neolithic North Africa Outbreeding Paternal Investment Physical Anthropology Reading Rickets Sex Recognition Single Women Sub-Saharan Africa Sub-Saharan Africans United States Western Europe Writing Abortion American Flag Antiquity Antisocial Behavior Appalachians Ashkenazi Jews Assimilation Attractiveness Boasian Anthropology Brain Broken Hill Bruce Lahn Cagots Castes Chanda Chisala Charles Darwin Chechens Chlamydia Communism Consciousness Craniometry Cuckold Envy Cultural Evolution Denmark Developmental Noise Donate. Dopamine Drugs Ebola Economics EEA Ellen Walker Elliot Rodger Face Shape Fat Shaming Female Homosexuality Finland Fossil Fuels Frantz Fanon G Gardnerella Vaginalis Gary Taubes Genetic Engineering Germ Theory Grumpy Cat H.B.O. Hair Lengthening Happiness Hbd Fallout Heart Disease Helmuth Nyborg Hemoglobin Heritability Hexaco Hispanics immigrants In The Electric Mist Internet Ioannis Metaxas Jamaica Jared Diamond Jason Malloy Jayman Jr. Jews John Durant Kevin Mitchell Korea Larry Summers Low-carb M.g. maps Mate Choice Melanin Mental Illness Mental Traits Mortality MTDNA Natural Selection New France Nigeria Once You Go Black Paekchong Pierre Van Den Berghe Psychopaths Psychopathy Pubertal Timing Racial Reality Robots Ruth Benedict Satoshi Kanazawa Scotch-irish Sexism Sexual Division Of Labor Sexual Maturation Single Men Skin Bleaching Slate Slavery Slavs Smoking Snow Space Space Program Stephan Guyenet Stephen Jay Gould Tatars Tiger Mom Trust Twintuition Victor Canfield Walter Bodmer White Americans Yankees Abc News Abigail Marsh Acadia Adoptees Ainu Alexandre Skirda Algeria Alpha Centauri Amy Chua Anatoly Karlin Ancestry Ann Coulter Anthropology Arctic Humans Assortative Mating Austronesians Automation Bad Science Behavior Genetics Birth Order Black Americans Border Reivers Brain Scans Brain Structure Brown Eyes Bruce Jenner BS Caitlyn Jenner Cameron Russell Canada Day Canadian Flag Carl Sagan Catholicism Changeability Chimerism Chris Stringer Civil War Climate Climate Change Cliodynamics Cognitive Empathy Colonists Consequences Correlation Is Still Not Causation Corruption Perception Index Costa Concordia Dads Vs Cads Dark Ages Darwin Data Posts Death Dienekes Different Peoples Is Different Doll Tests Donald Trump Drd4 Eastern Europe Economic Development Egypt Emmanuel Todd Energy Environmental Estrogens Environmentalism Ethnic Nepotism EU Eugenic European Union Extreterrestrials fallout Far West Farming Fast Food Fat Head Father Absence Flags Fourth Of July Fracking Fred Reed French Paradox Fukushima Game Gays/Lesbians Gcta Gender Gender Gender Reassignment George Bush Google Great Depression Greeks Green Energy GSS Halloween HBD Denial Healthcare Heather Norton Homo Altaiensis Human Genome Iceland Ideology Igbo India Iosif Lazaridis Islam Italianthro Iwo Eleru Jim Crow John Hoffecker Junk Food Keystone Pipeline Kimberly Noble Kin Selection Klingon La Terre Tremblante Lactose Latitude Law Lesbians Libertarians Life In Space Lifestyle Literacy Look AHEAD Low-fat Maine Manor Marxism Mass Shootings Math Menstrual Cycle Michael Lewis Michael Woodley Minnesota Transracial Adoption Study Moral Absolutism Moral Universalism Mormons Music Nancy Segal Nationalism Neocons New Atheists New French Norway Nuclear Energy Nurture Assumption Obamacare Occam's Razor Oil Industry Ottoman Empire Paris Spring Patrilocality Paul Ewald Paul Lepage Peak Oil People From Away Piigs PISA Planets Planned Parenthood Population Pornography Protestantism Quantum Mechanics Quebec Race And Crime Rachel Dolezal Red Hair Red State Blue State Red States Blue States Reproductive Strategy Republicans Rushton Sam Harris Samuel George Morton Saying What You Have To Say Scandinavians Scots Irish Scrabble Serenity Sexual Identity Sexually Transmitted Diseases Shanghai Cooperation Organisation Shared Environment Siberia Single Mothers SLC24A5 Sleep Smart Fraction Southern Poverty Law Center Space Space Race Spain Spanish Paradox SPLC Stanislas Dehaene Star Trek Subprime Mortgage Crisis Tard Tarder Sauce The Deep South The Far West Theoretical Physics Thomas Aquinas Thomas Talhelm Those Damn Yankees Tidewater Time Preference Tom Naughton Toxoplasma Gondii Tropical Humans Universalism Vioxx WEIRDO White Nationalists Woodley Effect
 Science Archive
FeaturesMost Recent
My impression of Damore’s Google Memo is that it is a thoughtful and well-considered personal opinion about workplace differences in abilities and attitudes. The tone is reserved, measured, and reasonable, avoiding sweeping claims. For example, it restricts its scope to the particular office in which he worked, and not Google as a whole. It is... Read More
This week’s big story on the CultMarx front was the firing of Google employee James Damore. The firing offense was, he had written a document titled Google’s Ideological Echo Chamber and circulated it on Google’s internal network. The document was leaked to journalists, the nation’s CultMarxists threw a collective fit of hysteria, and Damore got... Read More
The time has come for a review post on the laws of behavioral genetics. I will talk about why these laws are laws and why they are important. Eventually, this will be merged into my Behavioral Genetics Page, but for now, I will start with this primer. The five laws of behavioral genetics are: All... Read More
When did humans first become human? The answer is far from simple, because the question assumes that sometime in the past, humans achieved modernity and were locked within an evolutionary loophole where natural selection no longer applies. Despite the absurdity of this scenario, and in stark contrast to empirical data, it is widely believed that... Read More
The loathsome truth about psychology textbooks
I have a secret hope that one day one of my readers will write a psychology textbook, and that intelligence will be mentioned in an up-to-date and accurate manner. Years ago, when reading a new UK textbook that took an apologetic and partial view of racial differences in intelligence I planned to look at the... Read More
1.6% to 2.4%
There are two main approaches to understanding the evolution of intelligence. A) Study the differences in intelligence between genetic groups. B) Study the differences in intelligence within a genetic group. Approach A is currently not being funded, as far as I know, but please let me know if there are studies I should be commenting... Read More
I have always assumed that the Ancients were wiser than us, but I admit that my evaluation is subject to survivor bias: the best of their thinking has been passed on to us, the mediocre rest forgotten. The Ancients were not all at the level of Socrates, they also included the dullards that killed him.... Read More
Although the Bard warned against finding the mind’s construction in the face, we are apt to try. Can facial features show us the power of the brain behind the mask? Lee et al. (2017) think so. Unlike minor Scottish nobility planning regicide, they have made their judgments using the medium of facial photographs of... Read More
Apologies to the reader. Perhaps I wax tedious. But the question of intelligence is both interesting to me and great fun as talking about it puts commenters in an uproar. It is like poking a wasp’s nest when you are eleven. I am a bad person. Clearing the underbrush: Obviously intelligence is largely genetic–if it... Read More
Chanda Chisala and I post about each other so often that we should be employing the same agent. Properly managed, I might finally get onto a lecture tour circuit somewhere. The Shetlands, perhaps. Below is the post to which I am referring. My reply to Chisala’s post has hardly been prompt: one source of... Read More
Jim Flynn once observed that no-one was funding research into the genetics of racial differences in intelligence because they feared they would find something. Here is my psychologist’s summary of where we are as regards the genetics of intelligence in general: 10%. That is to say, by poking about in the genetic code researchers can... Read More
Grigoriev, Andrey & Lynn 2009 Studies of Socioeconomic and Ethnic Differences in Intelligence in the Former Soviet Union in the Early Twentieth Century Abstract: This is essentially a short history of psychometrics in the USSR/Russia. (1) The first measurement of Russian IQ was performed in 1909 by A.M. Schubert, who used the French Binet test... Read More
My first experience with Raven’s Matrices was as a psychology student. We did the test as a group, and then the Alice Heim 5 test of high grade intelligence, and finally inexpertly attempted to give each other the Wechsler test of adult intelligence. As you will have noted, the concept of intelligence and the ways... Read More
No sooner do I return from my own intelligence conference, about which more later, than I note, courtesy of another scholar, a fascinating new paper showing that 40% of the variance in IQ can be accounted for by a new measure of brain networks. This is strong stuff, so with a spinning head I tried... Read More
There is nothing like sex differences in intelligence to put you on the wrong side of half the population. The story so far is that the standard academic opinion on sex differences in intelligence is that there aren’t any, or that they are small, or that the few that exist counterbalance each other. Women are... Read More
My attitude to exercise was best summed up by cartoonist Paul Terry: However, I am not deaf to the cacophony of advisers recommending that people should keep active, particularly the over 50s. The notion seems to be that the elderly serve some undefined but useful purpose which could be prolonged by physical exertion. I find... Read More
Brain size and intelligence
Here is a very interesting paper on sex differences in brain size and intelligence, notable for linking people’s brain scans with their detailed intelligence test results. It has been accepted for publication in Intelligence. Sex differences in brain size and general intelligence (g) Dimitri van der Linden, Curtis S. Dunkel, Guy Madison Abstract Utilizing MRI... Read More
In my last article, “Scrabble Spells Doom for the Racial Hypothesis of Intelligence,” I argued that Africans should not be able to come anywhere near dominating the games of Scrabble (both English and French) or professional checkers, as they apparently do, if their real biological intelligence was anywhere near as low as their nominal IQ... Read More
There was a time when boys played games of marbles following strict playground rules: contestants had to stand a prescribed distance away from the little pyramid of marbles, and chuck only marbles of the prescribed size. Rules ruled. Piaget was intrigued by the explanations children gave for moral judgements, and the playground is the arena... Read More
It is a measure of the quality of British life that one of its longest running TV programs is “University Challenge”, a quiz show for university students. Yes, it has always been a minority interest, but it is a showcase of talent, an astounding example of what bright young people can get to know in... Read More
Lead poisoning reduces social mobility
There are still many people who believe that intelligence does not exist or that it cannot be measured, particularly if the summary result is given as a single figure. The argument seems to be that single figure cannot possibly represent their myriad abilities. Quite so. What are they to make of a recent finding by... Read More
I can claim to have been assaulted by micro-aggressions. I find myself profoundly hurt when people in my presence say “Intelligence – whatever that is”. They do it to vex me, which is beastly of them. Other aggressive behaviours include people in conversation denouncing anyone who holds a particular political opinion, without considering that I... Read More
Earth has not anything to show more foul
As these things go, it was not too bad. One idiot in a car murdered 3 people, with 7 more in a critical condition who may die, at least 40 with terrible injuries, and many more people traumatized. Crowds of tourists ran away from the place of slaughter at Westminster Bridge. Earth has not anything... Read More
Saturday is a relative slow day in my household, so it felt somewhat of a rebuke to read on the BBC that the Tsimané people have an ideal lifestyle, walking some 17,000 steps a day, as compared to the lethargic wealthy West, who aim for 10,000 daily steps but rarely take them. Those of... Read More
Despite being interested in intelligence, I am also on guard against judging the mind from the face (there's no art to find the mind's construction in the face) while probably doing just that all the time. I assume that I judge mental ability by conversations which go beyond pleasantries. Indeed, perhaps measuring how quickly people... Read More
Blade Runner had an impact on me, both as a film and because it was an introduction to the writings of Philip K Dick, whose whimsical work was based on wondering what it meant to be human. Are we as individuals merely constructions of fundamental genetic coding mechanisms, which create treasured but probably false memories... Read More
Smart groups are (simply) groups of smart people.
Few things attract more attention in the business world than new ways of making groups work well. As any fool knows, groups are a pain. They argue, dither, drift off course, waste time and resources, and produce loads of rubbish. Worse, all those participants draw salaries, so treasure is wasted. Surely, bosses think, any technique... Read More
Personally, after reading the above description, I have Linda in my mind’s eye, and I can just see her lecturing me on what sort of yoghurt I should eat. If I ever met her, I would not dream of admitting that I drive a diesel car, and that I have very recently taken up sketching... Read More
Add fertilizer and yields are boosted, up to a plateau; ignore the quality of the seed and yields slowly decline.
Everyone knows about the Flynn Effect, but very few about the Woodley Effect. When Woodley was working on his paper in 2013 “Were the Victorians cleverer than us? The decline in general intelligence estimated from a meta-analysis of the slowing of simple reaction time” I wrote to Charles Murray about his findings, and in his... Read More
Throughout my American Nations series (based on the books American Nations: A History of the Eleven Rival Regional Cultures of North America by Colin Woodard and Albion's Seed: Four British Folkways in America by David Hackett Fischer) I've talked about how North America is divided into distinct ethnocultural regions based on historic settlement patterns. These... Read More
It is good that people are discussing IQ. Fred Reed’s post has drawn many comments, too many for me to answer individually. Here I outline the main heads of his argument as I see them, and some of the relevant research. My summary of Reed’s post is: Intelligence is important; intelligence research is important and... Read More
No story about the brain is simple; no one study is definitive; and it takes many years to sort out conflicting and inconsistent findings and establish a weight of evidence. It is a fundamental truth that any researcher who can put a person in a scanner can publish a paper. Any researcher able to talk... Read More
In my earlier entry (Clannishness – The Series: How It Happened), we saw that the thing that made the difference between WEIRD Northwestern Europeans and their more clannish neighbors was the selective pressures that each underwent during their histories – particularly since the fall of Rome until the present. This era in time established the... Read More
  I have never played Scrabble. I may have tried once, but certainly gave up very quickly, before even finishing the game. I like words, but I don’t particularly like games. I can’t see the point of Scrabble, and would prefer to read a book, in which the words are assembled to convey meaning. Unscrabble.... Read More
Intelligence is worth talking about because both the reality of intelligence and perceptions regarding intelligence set limits on the possible and influence policy. For example, if the population of India on average really is below borderline retardation, the country can never amount to anything. If Latino immigrants really are as stupid as white nationalists hope,... Read More
Fundamentally solve the “intelligence problem,” and all other problems become trivial. The problem is that this problem is a very hard one, and our native wit is unlikely to suffice. Moreover, because problems tend to get harder, not easier, as you advance up the technological ladder (Karlin, 2015), in a “business as usual” scenario with... Read More
What is the use of Psychology? Surely knowing some psychology should confer an advantage? I mean a real advantage, over and above being able to give complicated post-event commentaries? How about this? If survival means avoiding premature death, then living is perpetual problem solving, and the better the solutions to problems, the better the standard... Read More
Flynn Effect background explanations.
    The Flynn Effect is important to understand; it is better understood now than ever before, but there is more to research; and it is probably more limited in its real-world consequences than people imagine, though the long-term consequences are still being debated. Say you take any test of ability, and as an example... Read More
  The Flynn Effect was originally noted by Rundquist (1936) and Lynn (1982) and then Flynn (1984). Credit should probably go to Runquist, but a happy compromise is to call it the FLynn effect, in honour of the two major researchers. The history has been described by Lynn, in part of a Special Issue on... Read More
My earlier entry (Clannishness – the Series: Zigzag Lightning in the Brain) established that there are deep distinctions between Northwestern European peoples and most of the rest of the world, and that these differences have a huge impact on the world, including on levels of human development, the strength of democracy and democratic institutions, scientific... Read More
I am still settling in at so please forgive me if I forget my lines and bump into the furniture, because the stage is much larger than my former small theatre. Not only that, but the cast is enormous, and the commentating audience ten times larger than usual, and rowdier. No country for an... Read More
Things move fast. A published paper comes to the attention of Steve Sailer and suddenly a section of a puzzle gets completed. Better still, the boundaries of ignorance get pushed backwards, which is always a good idea, and a fine Christmas present. From the isolation of my study, and from the depths of my... Read More
Baba Sy breaking world record for simultaneous draughts play.
The first logical way the American-invented cognitive game of Scrabble settles the score against radical hereditarians in the racial (Black-White) IQ gap debate is through a two step process: how do white female players compare to white male players in top-level elite Scrabble? Since many mainstream cognitive psychologists tell us that white women (like white... Read More
There are some topics which I have some interest in, such as prehistory illuminated by genetics, in which there is constant change and new discoveries every few months. If a new paper doesn't drop in a six month interval, I think something is wrong. There are other topics where I don't perceive much change, and... Read More
Why the Future is Looking Bright for Dullards
David H. Freedman’s “The War on Stupid People” (The Atlantic) provides a compelling argument that we collectively assign great weight to the trappings of intelligence. Academic credentials, standardized test scores, a professed interest in technology, and even the right kind of physical appearance (glasses, not too athletic) all serve as easily recognizable markers of intelligence,... Read More
This is atrociously long, criminally even, by internet standards but I post it anyway because I get occasional requests. Few will read it, which is understandable. Apologies. The Devil made me do it. Regular readers, if there is one, will have seen most of it before since in large part it is a gluing together... Read More
Appalachian white trash, presenting obvious neurological deficits consequent to inbreeding. A clear argument for eugenics.
Most considerations of eugenics, before wobbling off into discussions of Hitler, deal with intelligence and physical characteristics, notably health and strength. By those who constitute the best argument for eugenics, eugenics is usually interpreted as a means of oppressing the poor, maltreating the more bedraggled minorities, and euthanizing the retarded. Most commentators on the matter... Read More
Update: In light of further comments I may have been wrong about Hong's recent admixture! See the comments below (also, further discussion with Spencer Wells offline). I don't have total clarity on what's going on, because I'm sure my friends weren't lying...but they were also early adopters, and the methods may have changed. And, I... Read More
The above visualization is from a Reddit thread, Almost all men are stronger than almost all women. It's based on grip strength, and basically reiterates my post from last year, Men Are Stronger Than Women (On Average). The same metric, grip strength, is highlighted. The plot above shows that the "great divergence" occurs on the... Read More
A new paper in Nature Genetics, Characterization of Greater Middle Eastern genetic variation for enhanced disease gene discovery, is both interesting and important. But, as with the paper on the Andaman Islander genomes it starts out with a naive and misleading utilization of model -based clustering to frame the later results. Here's a major offending... Read More