The Unz Review: An Alternative Media Selection
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewAndre Vltchek Archive
Morsi Died, or Was Murdered, While Reciting a Patriotic Poem in a Cage
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information



=>
After the coup in Alexandria - they wanted Morsi back

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Troll, or LOL with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used once per hour.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

Former President of Egypt, Mohamed Morsi, had finished his 15-minute discourse in a courtroom, while being locked inside a sound-proofed cage. He read a poem about his love for Egypt, and then collapsed, and died.

His demise sent shock-waves all over Egypt, the region and the Muslim world.

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan refused to accept the official story, claiming that the former Egyptian president Mohamed Morsi “did not die, he was murdered”.

More came from different corners of the world. According to Reuters:

“A British member of Parliament, Crispin Blunt, who had led a delegation of UK lawmakers and lawyers last year in putting out a report on Mursi’s detention, slammed the conditions of Mursi’s incarceration.

We want to understand whether there was any change in his conditions since we reported in March 2018, and if he continued to be held in the conditions we found, then I’m afraid the Egyptian government are likely to be responsible for his premature death,” he said in remarks to the BBC.”

Human rights organizations, heads of state, as well as the common citizens of Egypt, were outraged by the demise of Mohamed Morsi (also spelt as Mursi), a former Egyptian leader who governed the nation after winning the first democratic elections in the modern history of the country in 2012, just a year after the brutal pro-Western dictator, Hosni Mubarak, was deposed in 2011.

Mr. Morsi was overthrown in 2013, in a violent military coup just one year after he was sworn into the highest office.

 

Let’s be clear: Mohamed Morsi was not a ‘good president’. In fact, he was not supposed to be a president at all: the original candidate from his party was disqualified from the elections on a technicality, and Mr. Morsi was asked to take his place. And he won, by a small margin.

He made some serious errors, politically, economically and socially.

He flooded tunnels between Gaza and Sinai.

And under his leadership, more than 40 people died during the violence in Port Said.

When he felt threatened, he used to give orders to fire poisonous gasses at the protesters.

But he was not a murderer. And in ‘modern’ Egypt, that was quite an achievement.

He tried to improve the dire situation in his country, but he kept failing.

On the other hand, he separated his government from the gangrenous military embrace. The western-sponsored Egyptian military has been managing to infiltrate everything (under Mubarak’s rule as well as now), fully controlling all aspects of the Egyptian state.

Mr. Morsi tried to please everyone in the terribly divided Egyptian society. But in the end, nobody was satisfied.

Hard-liners in his Muslim Brotherhood hated him for not being radical enough. The anti-religious Left despised him for not pushing harder for social reforms, and for a secular state. He was both obeying the US and the IMF, while at the same time alienating them.

In the end, he appeared like an uncertain, confused and weak man.

 

In 2012 and 2013, my friends, my left-wing comrades, were battling police in front of the Presidential Palace in Cairo. I was there, with them, filming, face covered with water-soaked rags in order to at least somehow protect myself from the highly poisonous teargas.

In those days, no one seemed to like Morsi.

The rallying cry during the anti-Morsi protests was:

“We sing to those who deserve to die;

Morsi-Morsi-Morsi!”

Protesters could not have known that 7 years later, their prophecy would come through.

After the military overthrew the democratically elected government (on 3 July 2013), massacres began. Officially hundreds, but most likely thousands of people lost their lives. Tens of thousands were arrested, disappeared, tortured, raped, and exiled.

Members of the Muslim Brotherhood were liquidated (soon after the coup it became a banned organization), but also various left-wing organizations and individuals, as well as all those people who were against the corrupt right-wing military and its dictatorship.

Several of my friends had to leave the country. Others are still in prison. Or in hiding.

Former dictator, Western puppet and assassin Hosni Mubarak, is now a free man again. He is 91 years old.

67-year-old Mohamed Morsi is dead.

 

During the Morsi era, as well as during and after the 2013 coup, I was working in Egypt, making a documentary film for the Venezuelan television channel Telesur (“Egipto – El Fin de Una Revolucion” – “Egypt, End of the Revolution”).

First, I investigated and wrote about the crimes committed during the reign of President Morsi in the city of Port Said: “Notes from a Besieged City”.

And then, I was right there, in the middle of the battles, when the Egyptian military overthrew Morsi’s government and began liquidating both the Muslim Brotherhood, and the Egyptian left wing. I described the events in my essays “Egypt End of Hope” and “Egypt in the Eye of the Storm”. Many more essays from Egypt were then compiled in my book “Exposing Lies of The Empire”.

Once, while filming after the coup, I found myself facing 5 talks, all pointing their cannons at me. How I survived, I am not sure. Others did not. By the time I finished collecting footage for my film, my body was covered by scars and bruises.

From among those individuals who used to work with me on the film, and from those who used to protest against then President Morsi, there is hardly anyone now who would support the current rule of pro-Western military junta.

Rallies in 2012 and 2013 were all about improving Egypt; about forcing Morsi to deliver what millions of mostly young Egyptians hoped would be a just, secular and socialist society. Morsi was expected to deliver, or to resign, giving way to a better, more ‘progressive’ leader.

What came instead was a coup, a return of the fascist clique of Mubarak, supported by the US, Europe and Israel.

Looking back, I believe that Mohamed Morsi was a decent human being, but at the same time a bad, untalented, naive and confused ruler. That was still much, much better than what was before and after him.

 

In her opinion piece for the New York Times, the Egyptian author Mona Eltahawy wrote about the demise of Mohamad Morsi:

“…He always looked like a man caught up in something much bigger than him. That he died in an Egyptian courtroom inside a soundproof cage designed to silence him, almost exactly six years to the day he took office and almost completely forgotten by all but his family and human rights activists, is a reminder of the bathos that surrounded him.”

Then, Ms. Eltahawy put his death into the context of the present-day Egypt:

“Decimated as it is, however, the Muslim Brotherhood is unlikely to be able to pull off mass protests in Egypt, where protests became all but impossible under a draconian law passed soon after Mr. el-Sisi came to power. This, too, is what Mr. el-Sisi has achieved: From July 2013, when Mr. Morsi was overthrown, and January 2016, when the Egyptian parliament reconvened, between 16,000 and 41,000 people, most supporters of the now-banned Muslim Brotherhood, were reportedly arrested or detained (Some were liberal or secular activists). Since then, a spike in death sentences and executions, extrajudicial killings, forced disappearances and a determined effort to wipe out any form of dissent have all but crushed the Brotherhood, as well as most other forms of opposition. Muslim Brotherhood supporters are insisting that Mr. Morsi be eulogized as a martyr at the same time that many state-owned media are reporting on his death without even mentioning that he was once president.”

Frankly speaking, the era of Morsi feels like the only period in modern Egyptian history, when ‘everything was possible’, and when one was at least allowed to dream and to fight for a much better future. Yes, of course, the fight was taking place through teargas, and people got injured, some even killed. But they dared, they were not broken and humiliated like now.

The so-called ‘Arab Spring’ was manipulated, and most likely ‘created’ by the West. But in 2011 to 2013, there was also a parallel, independent, left-wing upsurge of anti-establishment, anti-capitalist and anti-military movements. There was a struggle, and Egypt could have gone in any direction.

I will never forget that year; “the year of Morsi”. We were risking our lives, often suffering direct physical assaults. Different political factions were at each other throats. Steam was out. Passions were boiling. Nothing was certain, everything possible.

That year, while making my film, I was with a group of socialist doctors; true Marxists. They did not doubt that Egypt could go socialist, if they fought harder. I also worked with Wassim Wagdy, one of the leaders of Revolutionary Socialist Organization.

And then, everything collapsed, literally overnight. 3 July 2013.

ORDER IT NOW

When did I realized that everything was over? It happened in Heliopolis – in a affluent suburb of Cairo – in a park. Hundreds of rich families went to celebrate the coup, wearing T-shirts depicting el-Sisi and his cronies. It looked like some historic photos from 9-11-1973 – from the days when the coup perpetrated by General Pinochet against President Allende in Chile. It was different, of course it was; but it looked the same. US-sponsored coups always look the same. And so do the faces of the elites that support them!

I read about the demise of Morsi onboard MEA, from Istanbul to Beirut. I felt immense sadness. I did not know why, precisely. Certainly, it was not for the Mr. Morsi’s reign. But most likely it was for that time, for that hope that was now totally choked and abandoned. For the days when ‘everything was possible’; when people were ready and willing to fight for their country.

Egypt is a ‘failed’ state now. Scared, frustrated, poor and totally corrupt. A state that is devouring its own people.

When I go to one of countless slums of Cairo, these days, people look at me with open hate. They see me as a foreigner, as someone who helped to throw them back to hopelessness and misery. Of course, they don’t know that several years ago I fought for them, at least as a filmmaker, side-by-side with their nation’s socialist vanguard.

I also feel sadness for Morsi the man, if not Morsi the president. I somehow sense that the patriotic poem that he read before collapsing and dying, came straight from his heart.

In one single year when he governed, he did his best. His best was not good enough. He failed.

But he did not deserve to die like this, muzzled and humiliated, in a cage!

He deserved better. And his country, Egypt, deserves much, much better, damn it!

 

[First published by NEO – New Eastern Outlook]

Andre Vltchek is a philosopher, novelist, filmmaker and investigative journalist. He has covered wars and conflicts in dozens of countries. Four of his latest books are Revolutionary Optimism, Western Nihilism, a revolutionary novel “Aurora” and a bestselling work of political non-fiction: “Exposing Lies Of The Empire”. View his other books here. Watch Rwanda Gambit, his groundbreaking documentary about Rwanda and DRCongo and his film/dialogue with Noam Chomsky “On Western Terrorism”. Vltchek presently resides in East Asia and the Middle East, and continues to work around the world. He can be reached through his website and his Twitter. His Patreon

 
• Category: Foreign Policy • Tags: Egypt, Mohamed Morsi 
Hide 17 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
    []
  1. A beautiful testament, thank you!

  2. Another example of America showing the splendors of freedom and democracy to backwards middle-eastern societies. Al-Sisi is a product of the US Army War College and supposedly has a brother in the Mossad. At any rate, Israel seems to have supported his brutalities as did the degenerate Coptic “Pope” Tawadros.
    These countries would all be better off under sincere Muslims than secular intellectuals on one hand or decadent playboy autocrats on the other. But the US insists that whoever we support, he’s got to be AGAINST GOD.

    • Replies: @The Anti-Gnostic
  3. Perhaps if people like you had done less to undercut Morsi, and more to support him, the coup never would have happened.

    • Replies: @Lo
  4. @jack daniels

    The sincere Muslims were in the process of exterminating the Copts when the generals decided they’d had enough of sincere Muslims running the country.

    • Replies: @Colin Wright
  5. @The Anti-Gnostic

    ‘The sincere Muslims were in the process of exterminating the Copts when the generals decided they’d had enough of sincere Muslims running the country.’

    This happens to be just about the opposite of the truth, but hey…

    • Replies: @Talha
    , @The Anti-Gnostic
  6. Andre, I always read your essays and admire your tireless support for humanity’s disadvantaged and disenfranchised, but sometimes one’s most cherished beliefs require reassessment. The Egyptian coup, and the subsequent democratic election of Morsi is one morsel of history that begs deeper examination.Certainly, it was a thrilling time. I was in Turkey then and will never forget Zaman’s front page photo- an aerial shot of the massive crowd in Cairo after Morsi’s election. All was hopeful exuberance, myself included. Go Morsi! Go Erdogan! Go Muslim brotherhood!
    But all that was before the destruction of Libya and the commencement of the war against Syria.
    Morsi and Erdogan were classic stooges of the Americans, and by extension so were we. The MB is no better than a military dictatorship- perhaps worse, because the MB has a well groomed global network. It can easily be bribed with promises of wealth and power,which is how Morsi and Erdogan came to work for the benefit of U.S foreign policy under Obama and particularly in accord with the fevered visions of the messianic technocrat and Secretary of State, Clinton. But poor Mr Morsi didn’t have the street- smarts of Erdogan,who recognised the jig (ultimately,U.S.suzerainity of the M.E.), and suddenly dropped the Islamist label to become a nationalist, later purging all those in his Islamist AKparty who were too “ideological”- i.e. the Gulinists,who were also affiliated with U.S. interests.The newspaper Zaman went too. Erdogan is literally a survivor and his political machinations are Byzantine.Thus far they have worked for him, but he has had to drop public pronouncements of his superior MB credentials.
    I can never forgive Morsi for calling for recruits to fight as rebels in Syria,and his facilitation of Gadhaffi’s and Libya’s demise. He was obeying western masters.

    • Replies: @Andre Vltchek
  7. Talha says:
    @Colin Wright

    Yeah, I’d like to see proof from a neutral source about that charge. The Egyptian government doesn’t count obviously.

    Peace.

    • Replies: @Colin Wright
  8. @Talha

    ‘Yeah, I’d like to see proof from a neutral source about that charge. The Egyptian government doesn’t count obviously.’

    I do recall that prior to Morsi, the Egyptian government used to pretty obviously and regularly use the Copts as scapegoats; you may recall the great pig slaughter, and the response to various attacks on Copts used to be distinctly perfunctory.

    The Morsi government, by contrast, was very scrupulous about preventing mistreatment of Copts.

    Now that the secularists are back in the saddle, I imagine they’ll find the Copts still make good scapegoats — and I don’t see why they would have any more scruples about using them as such than they did in the past.

  9. @Australian lady

    Dear Australian Lady, agree with what you wrote. As you could see, I said that Morsi the president was bad, really bad. And my secular, left wing comrades in Egypt fought against him. So did I. There is not one line in my essay saying that Morsi was a positive ruler of Egypt.
    Degree to which al-Sisi and his clique is better or worse is debatable.
    The truth is, that present military junta is repulsive.

    • Replies: @Talha
  10. So many broken eggs, but we’ve yet to see an omelette.

    “Power is not a means, it is an end. One does not establish a dictatorship in order to safeguard a revolution; one makes the revolution in order to establish the dictatorship.” George Orwell

    If you took the most ardent revolutionary, vested him in absolute power, within a year he would be worse than the Tsar himself. – Mikhail Bakunin

    I see a pattern here.

  11. @Colin Wright

    The Copts were being slowly genocided under the Muslim Brotherhood government. Thank God the generals stepped in to stop Egypt’s slide into Mohammedan brutality.

  12. ‘The Copts were being slowly genocided under the Muslim Brotherhood government. Thank God the generals stepped in to stop Egypt’s slide into Mohammedan brutality.’

    I think the sinister Copts have made Putin their unwitting tool.

    Hey, if you can create bizarre fantasies without any basis in fact, why can’t I?

  13. Titive says:

    The Muslim Brotherhood is similar to Wahabism, as they both share the same ideological roots. Its organizational structure is often compared to an Islamic Freemasonry and this should give you a hint about who is really in charge. The other interesting detail is that it is a “globalist” sect, something they share with the Turkish Fethullah Gülen, who is also a “globalist Muslim”, safely based in Saylorsburg, Pennsylvania. Muslim globalism is extremely useful to mainstream Globalism. Especially in spring time. That’s also why, they are given all facilities to propagate Islam in Europe in order to manufacture the civilisational clash, dreamed by Bernard Lewis to bring about the definitive fall of Edom.

  14. Talha says:
    @Andre Vltchek

    Good sir,

    I have an in-law (husband of my sister in law) who was there around that time. He himself is a practicing Muslim but was not fond of Morsi’s administration – of course, he likes this current one even less. He never mentioned (and I haven’t seen any evidence from a reliable source) that the Morsi government either targeted Copts or deliberately removed or denied them state protection from extremist elements like some people here are alleging.

    Now you are also not a fan of Morsi so I would assume – if there is dirt on him – you would not be shy to reveal it.

    So…do you know of any credible source that can confirm that the Morsi government was actively committing genocide against the Copts?

    Peace.

  15. pravdof says:

    “…. after winning the first democratic elections in the modern history of the country…”

    That sentence is repeated on all the media. Why do the Western media never mention the fraudulent election process in favour of Morsi?
    https://www.voltairenet.org/article191279.html

  16. Lo says:
    @Colin Wright

    Leftists cannot help it. Even when their side wins, they end up devouring each other. They are people who are forever stuck in teenage rebellion phase.

Current Commenter
says:

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone


 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments become the property of The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Andre Vltchek Comments via RSS
PastClassics
Which superpower is more threatened by its “extractive elites”?
The “war hero” candidate buried information about POWs left behind in Vietnam.
What Was John McCain's True Wartime Record in Vietnam?
Are elite university admissions based on meritocracy and diversity as claimed?