The Unz Review - Mobile
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 James Kirkpatrick Archive
Yes, Virginia (Dare), There Is an “Alt Left”
It’s Totalitarian, It’s Captured the Democratic Party, and It’s Coming for America
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New Reply
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

There’s an interesting moment in Jonathan Allen and Amie Parnes’ book Shattered: Inside Hillary Clinton’s Doomed Campaign when two obscure Democrat operatives who involved in her presidential debate-prep sessions, Karen Dunn and Ron Klain, “stressed that Trump, contrary to popular opinion, had actually put forth a lot of policy ideas.” ( Editor Peter Brimelow had the same perception). President Trump just done it again. In his August 15 press conference, he very reasonably asked the Main Stream Media/ Opposition Party, in the context of their Charlottesville Fake News, “What about the Alt-Left that came charging at the, as you say, the Alt Right?” And in his August 23 Phoenix speech, as Leftists rioted in the streets and the MSM covered for them, he called out “AntiFa” by name. [Donald Trump Calls Out Antifa for Violence, Breitbart, August 23, 2017]

Neither of these concepts are welcome to our Ruling Class. An ADL analyst sniffs “the word was made up to create a false equivalence between the far-right and ‘anything vaguely left-seeming that they didn’t like’ “.[‘No such thing as the alt-left:’ Donald Trump’s phrase for counter-protesters dismissed by extremism experts, by Liam Stack, UK Independent, August 16, 2017]

This tells us, of course, that the terms are both useful and capture something essential about this movement. The Alt Left is an explicitly Cultural Marxist and overtly totalitarian movement with nothing in common with the classical liberalism which once defined the Left and, for much of its history, the Democratic Party. AntiFa is its communist paramilitary wing, completely without parallel on the Right. [ “They have no allegiance to liberal democracy”: an expert on antifa explains the group, by Sean Illing,, August 25, 2017] This Alt Left, along with race-based identity politics, have now completely captured the party of Jefferson and Jackson (and are in fact evicting them).

The term is “Alt Left” not totally new. It was used in two main forms before Charlottesville:

  • First, “Alt Left” was used by centrist liberals to criticize socialist critics who were opposing Hillary Clinton from the left.

Instead of the neoliberal economics, fashionable identity politics and foreign interventionism which characterizes Clinton Democrats, the Alt Left was more forthrightly socialist, discussed class politics instead of championing homosexual CEOs and displayed at least some skepticism about the theory that Russia was single-handedly funding all opposition to the Democratic Party. Significantly, it was Sanders supporters who shut down Trump’s Chicago rally, a clear harbinger subsequent epidemic anti-Trump violence. But most MSM outlets, conventionally Leftist and hungry for electoral victory, were hostile to these voices [Why The Alt-Left Is A Problem Too, by James Wolcott, Vanity Fair, March 2017]. Even after Charlottesville, Markos Moulitas of the once-influential Daily Kos website was complaining about the term “Alt-Left” to refer to these progressives.

While this conception of the Alt-Left was poorly defined, at least it referred, however vaguely, to something which actually existed.

This, Joseph Farah of WND claimed the “Alt Left” as a catch all term for a “racist” Leftist Establishment that “supports population control, eugenics and repression of minorities.” However, Farah also noted how “Alt Left” Democrats pay no price for “real associations with groups like the Communist Party USA, which has supported them without reservation for election cycle after election cycle.” [Let’s take a look at the ‘Alt Left,’ August 28, 2016].

(This may have been the first use of the term “Alt Left” among normie conservatives).

Fox TV personality Sean Hannity has been using the term “Alt Left” to refer vaguely to anti-Trump protesters, especially since the 2016 election, apparently just a general insult. [What is the Alt-Left? 5 Fast Facts You Need To Know, by Daniel Levine, Heavy, August 17, 2017]

And Dan Ganior at CNSNews has used the headline “Alt Left Insanity” in every one of his columns since President Trump’s election [Dan Gainor Archive, CNSNews]

In this sense, the “Alt” of “Alt Left” is being used by Conservativism Inc. mouthpieces to simply mean “bad” or “extreme” liberals—reminiscent of how SNL mocked the Alt Right by having Kate McKinnon’s Kellyanne Conway declare of President Trump’s Cabinet picks, “They aren’t bad, they’re Alt-Good” . [They’re Not Bad; They’re Alt-Good’: ‘SNL Takes On Trump Cabinet Picks,’ San Diego 7, December 12, 2016]

On the surface, “Antifa” themselves would be outraged by this. While MSM reporters are eager to write fawning profiles of “Antifa,” “Liberals get the bullet too,” as Antifa graffiti declared following the February riots at Berkeley against Milo Yiannopoulos . [Slate Offers Defense Of Antifa, by John Sexton, Hot Air, August 22, 2017].

And Leftists sympathetic to Antifa are hoping the opposition to “white nationalism” will lead to a growth in overly socialist and communist movements, not Clintonian crony capitalism.

Author Angela Nagle, who wrote a rushed and sloppy hatchet job on the Alt Right shrieking about how the movement should be shut down, says the Left must champion Bernie Sanders-style socialist policies in order to avoid “a purely oppositional politics to the far right.” However, Nagle does credit the Alt Right with at least trying to articulate some kind of meaning in opposition to “the nightmarish Silicon Valley model of modernity” . [Goodbye Pepe, The Baffler, August 15, 2017]

Yet it’s precisely Silicon Valley which is shutting down the Alt Right. Our own PayPal account has been terminated by the company, despite’s complete noninvolvement in the Charlottesville rally. The Daily Stormer, which may be neo-Nazi but eschews violence, unlike the AntiFa, lost both its CloudFire protection against hacking and has been stripped of its URL. (As of this writing, it’s viewable here; Andrew Anglin has a blog here). Sites including the National Policy Institute and Radix Journal have also been terminated. As a result, even mainstream sites like Breitbart sounding the alarm for freedom of speech [Cloudflare CEO: I Woke Up ‘In A Bad Mood’ And ‘Decided To Ban Daily Stormer’, by Charlie Nash, Breitbart, August 16, 2017].

The Electronic Frontier Foundation has protested this:

Cloudflare, whose service was used to protect the site from denial-of-service attacks, has also dropped them as a customer, with a telling quote from Cloudflare’s CEO: “Literally, I woke up in a bad mood and decided someone shouldn’t be allowed on the Internet. No one should have that power.”

We agree.” [ Fighting Neo-Nazis and the Future of Free Expression, By Jeremy Malcolm, Cindy Cohn, and Danny O’Brien,, August 17, 2017]

MSM journalists, the greatest enemies to political liberty and freedom of speech in the West, are cheering on the campaign, gleefully tracking groups which have survived the purge. [Tech companies are rushing to ban hate groups, but plenty remain, by Russell Brandom, The Verge, August 17, 2017] As the Left noted, corporations have now become the arbiters of “public morality” a.k.a. Political Correctness. [Are corporations becoming the new arbiters of public morality?, by Tara Isabella Burton, Vox, August 17, 2017]

Needless to say, Leftists need have no fear of being inconvenienced by CEOs. The so-called #Resistance, which usually takes the form of retweeting whatever corporate media Leftists like John Oliver or Stephen Colbert has said the night before, is not a militant street movement, but a coalition of SWPL scolds. And the “Antifa,” far from leading a workers’ movement, is in effect serving as the irregular troops of leftist CEOs—the smelly successors of the Pinkerton Detectives. Even (perhaps especially) overt Communists have long since abandoned appealing to actual Western workers—as Antifa now focus its efforts on trying to get workers fired for having the wrong opinions.

This paradoxical coalition of Communists, capitalists and Establishment Democrats all opposed to free speech for American nationalists also includes some Republicans. Cultural Marxism, of course, has already infected the moribund “conservative movement” by default, given its complete absence of intellectual defenses.

House Speaker Paul Ryan, having failed to accomplish anything of importance despite President Trump supporting his agenda, has now moved on to openly defending Antifa and puffing his chest out about the supposed Far Right: “We will not tolerate this hateful ideology in our society” [Paul Ryan on Charlottesville, by Penny Starr, Breitbart, August 21, 2017] Incredibly, Ryan also suggested, in the context of Charlottesville, that people “suspected of terrorism” (meaning everyone the MSM/ Ruling Class doesn’t like) should not be allowed to purchase guns [Speaker Ryan Talks Gun Control Following Charlottesville Car Attack, by Awr Hawkins, Breitbart, August 22, 2017]. The Second Amendment may soon join those lost liberties Americans could once take for granted—such as freedom of speech or the long vanished freedom of association.

Ultimately, the “Antifa” and the “Alt Left” are only a symptom of the real threat. They are simply carrying out the agenda of the powerful—what Paul Gottfried calls “the Managerial State.” The Establishment Liberals, the extreme Leftists, the Beltway cuckservatives, the supposedly neutral MSM, have all joined forces to push through a monstrous agenda of repression against anyone who believes that the Historic American Nation should have any kind of political expression.

The real threat from the “Alt Left” isn’t its willingness to ally with violence. We’re used to that. The real threat is these masked radicals waving Communist flags aren’t an “alternative” to the Establishment at all. Consciously or unconsciously, they are serving as the militant wing of the System.

And that System is now openly totalitarian.

James Kirkpatrick [Email him] is a Beltway veteran and a refugee from Conservatism Inc.

(Republished from VDare by permission of author or representative)
Hide 3 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. Brabantian says: • Website

    Significant aspect here is that the anti-war Left as well, has been hit with an internet censorship campaign these last few months, tho in a softer form than this month’s anti-Alt-Right pogrom

    But there is little effort to join Left & Right in an anti-censorship fight; this is mostly the fault of the Left given their uber-cucked, censor-the-Right views

    It’s striking how there is great whining, wailing & gnashing of teeth by anti-war Left websites, whose Google-manipulated web traffic has dropped by as much as 67 per cent in the last few months, hitting sites such as Global Research, Socialist Worker, Truth Out & the oily comment-censoring Trotskyites (Party Line Only allowed!) at the World Socialist Web Site

    These shadow-banned, downgraded-in-Google-search anti-war Left sites, have online petitions, protests etc on their own behalf, but typically say zero or little about the anti-alt-Right censorship pogrom that is much more severe

    And we have little effort either from corporate-funded civil liberties groups, especially the paedophile-friendly CIA-tied ACLU, past sponsors of the Man-Boy Love Association, who briefly intervened in Charlottesville to ensure the pre-packaged psy-op to destroy the alt-Right went forward as planned … and only slight peeping complaint but no real action from the also-corporate-goon-tainted EFF … all those millions of USA ‘civil liberties’ funding, and WTF? But all those groups never did much against lawyer mafias, judge bribery, jailing & financial raping of innocents, & all the other Big Rot of American life … the big-name civil-liberties NGOs have long been oligarch-friendly do-little fakers

    With both anti-war Left & Alt-Right shutting down, as Anatoly Karlin has suggested, what is left is the big centre of shite internet run by the pro-war oligarchs … with search dominated by multiple repetitions of the CIA’s Wikipedia Trojan Horse propaganda site, run by the shady ex-pornographer & friend of Israeli Presidents, Jimmy ‘Jimbo’ Wales

    Kids are going to the ‘Dark Web’ for their Stormer image-mash racist meme laugh fixes, but I can imagine fairly soon we’ll have laws criminalising accessing the Dark Web for ‘racist’ purposes

    First they came for the Daily Stormers, but I said nothing, because I was not a Daily Stormer …

    Read More
    These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Troll, or LOL with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used once per hour.
    Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
    More... This Commenter Display All Comments
  2. Alt-Left has captured both the Republican and Democrat party.

    The US 2-party system patronizes the victim culture because victim cultist are a super-majority of voters in the US and Israel.

    Alt-Left peddles victim culture crap in the form of broadcast disinformation-hysteria and federal entitlements for victim culture people.

    For some inexplicable reason, some non-thinking people don’t consider entitled-by-law neocons and Zionist to be Alt-Left victim cultist too.

    Zionist and neocons have the same declared enemy-oppressor as all the other loudmouthed Alt-Left victim cultist : Nazi and the so-called white supremacist.

    Simply opposing victim cultists federal entitlements automatically makes you at least an anti-Semite.

    If you are also white and Christian and oppose victim cult federal entitlements, you are automatically a Nazi white supremacist.

    That’s who mass media labels the alt-right, any persons that oppose federal entitlements for victim cultists.

    The victim cult is real:


    Feminist are federally entitled because of Male oppression
    Jewish are federally entitled because of Gentile oppression
    Queers are federally entitled because of Straight oppression
    Muslims are federally entitled because of Christian oppression
    Disabled are federally entitled because of Healthy oppression
    Afro-blacks are federally entitled because of White oppression
    Latinos are federally entitled because of Gringo oppression
    Hispanics are federally entitled because of Gringo oppression
    Military Veterans are federally entitled because of Militia oppression
    Native Americans are federally entitled because of Paleface oppression
    Asians are federally entitled because of Occidental oppression
    International Socialist are federally entitled because of Local Government oppression
    Social Justice Crony Capitalist are federally entitled because of Honest Businessmen oppression
    Zionist are federally entitled because of Anti-Fascist oppression

    Read More
    ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter Display All Comments
  3. Hey, I agree with the politics of the article, but why don’t we call these people the “cntrl-left”, as first seen by me in a Takimag article written by Steve Sailer? It’s an even better term. What gives? I wrote:

    We’ll make it quick. Sailer seems to have invented the term “cntrl-left” to match the existing “alt-right” term. I just think it’s damn brilliant. There’s the computer keyboard metaphor, of course, with the “cntrl” (control) key being an important key, moreso than the “alt” one even, unless you are a serious windows guy (the good ones I’ve seen barely touch the mouse – it’s too damn slow for them).

    The word “control” is what makes this term great, as that is really what the left is all about and always has been. Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, all of them, nothing but horrible examples of the cntrl-left in action.

    Read More
    ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter Display All Comments
Current Commenter says:

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone

 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments become the property of The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS
The evidence is clear — but often ignored
The unspoken statistical reality of urban crime over the last quarter century.
The major media overlooked Communist spies and Madoff’s fraud. What are they missing today?
The “war hero” candidate buried information about POWs left behind in Vietnam.
Are elite university admissions based on meritocracy and diversity as claimed?