The Unz Review - Mobile
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 BlogviewAndrew Napolitano Archive
The Titanic Has Set Sail
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information


Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Troll, or LOL with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used once per hour.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

Over the New Year’s weekend, President Barack Obama’s chief policy adviser and closest strategist, Valerie Jarrett, told a talk show host that her boss would have a happy legacy because there was an absence of scandal in his administration. When first I heard this preposterous claim, I thought I had misheard it. Yet it is apparently true that President Obama and his team somehow can overlook recent history and behave as if events with which we are all familiar never happened.

Here is the back story.

When Obama became president in 2009 and enjoyed significant Democratic majorities in both houses of Congress, he and his colleagues devoted themselves entirely to an issue nowhere in the Constitution — health care. They did not address other issues dear to them and their base, such as guns, abortion, taxes, war, jobs and civil liberties. Rather, they sought to alter radically the relationship of the federal government to every person in America by imposing upon each of us the obligation to purchase a product — namely, health insurance — whether we wanted it or not.

The abominable statute they enacted, which has caused millions of folks to lose their primary care physician and millions more to see their premiums skyrocket and still millions more to see their full-time jobs become part-time, has acquired the nickname Obamacare.

Instead of reducing taxes or regulations or spending so more folks would have better-paying jobs, the president and his folks were determined to tell us all how to stay healthy. Obamacare passed on a party-line vote, with not a single vote to spare in the Senate.

At the time it was enacted, the president argued vociferously that the financial consequence of not obtaining health insurance — the penalty for disobeying the law — was not a tax. He made that argument because he had promised Democrats — many of whom lost their congressional seats for going along with his utopian experiment — that he would not raise taxes to accomplish his purposes.

When the statute was challenged in the federal courts and the various challenges were consolidated before the Supreme Court, the challengers did not dispute the claim that the penalty was not a tax. A court cannot consider arguments or evidence not put to it. For instance, in an automobile accident, if all eyewitnesses state that a traffic light in question was green at the time of the collision, the court may not find that it was red.

Yet notwithstanding agreement among the parties before the Supreme Court and notwithstanding the absence of any evidence that the penalty was a tax, the Supreme Court made new law by declaring this non-tax to be a tax and then ruling that Congress can tax anything it wants — so Congress can force you to purchase a product you don’t want by taxing you if you fail to make the purchase.


None of this is new. It is the president’s known legacy. It is a legacy of the colossal failure of the central planning of one-fifth of the economy. It has resulted in an expansion of federal powers and a reduction in the availability of health care providers and is yet another glaring rejection of the Constitution as the supreme law of the land.

While all of this was going on, the scandals Jarrett overlooked were brewing. Operation Fast and Furious, which began in the George W. Bush administration, exploded under Obama, when the guns the feds intentionally had let slip into the hands of Mexican gangs were used to kill one of their own.

Then came Libya, where heavy armaments the feds secretly had passed into the hands of terrorists masquerading as rebels were used to kill the U.S. ambassador and topple a friendly government.

Then came the seizure of telephone records of journalists critical of the administration by the Department of Justice, which secretly convinced a federal judge that talking to a whistleblower and reporting on his questionable behavior somehow involved reporters criminally in that behavior.

Then came the targeting by the IRS of conservative advocacy groups by denying them tax-exempt status for political reasons.

Then came the Secret Service scandal in which dozens of agents were caught in sexual encounters on foreign trips in hotels where the president was staying — encounters that involved the loss of laptops and itineraries and jeopardized the president’s physical safety — and two directors lost their jobs.

Then came the Edward Snowden revelations that the government was capturing every keystroke of every person using every computer and mobile device in the United States yet was still failing to keep us safe and that a senior Obama official had lied about this under oath. And all this was done without the approval of Congress, using a secret court that rationalized its way around the Constitution.

While all this was happening, the president was secretly using drones to kill Americans and others in foreign lands — folks never charged with crimes — using laughable legal authority as justification. Also, then-Secretary of State Hillary Clinton was exposing state secrets — including the names and whereabouts of undercover American agents — to friend and foe alike, and the FBI declined to recommend prosecution. And while Clinton was under investigation, her husband, former President Bill Clinton, had a private meeting on an airport tarmac with the attorney general — whom he had once appointed a U.S. attorney — at which they claim they discussed their grandchildren.

Which legacy is worse, failure or scandal? Is it any wonder Donald Trump tapped into the raw nerves of the folks the president and the Democrats forgot about and rode their anger to victory? Americans today are less free, less prosperous, less safe and trillions more in debt than we were eight years ago. Can Trump effectively change course after so much damage has been done? We soon will know.

Copyright 2017 Andrew P. Napolitano.

• Category: Ideology • Tags: Barack Obama 
Hide 12 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. In Washington DC, scandal is defined as a penis being in the wrong place at the wrong time. Criminal breach of the Constitution is business as usual.

  2. MEexpert says:

    The Judge forgot to mention the biggest scandal under Obama. ISIL/ISIS/IS.

  3. Not better off than eight years ago, no kidding.

  4. Now we all know how Kafka felt. I never dreamed that mainstream society could become so completely irrational until it happened. Of course its been a process and has taken a long time to devolve, but today almost every aspect of our economy, political establishment, education system, entertainment industry, mainstream media, you name it, is completely irrational.

    Until the last six months I had viewed this as only wishful fantasy, but now it is no longer inconceivable for me to see my wife agreeing to sell our house and most of our assets, quit our jobs, and go live in a small house in the middle of nowhere.

  5. From my sojourns in the realm of religion, I have learned that people really do respond to the leaders that are over them, for better or for worse.

    In Obama’s case, it has definitely been for the worse. As Alfred1860 said, mainstream society has become irrational. Given the demented leadership we’ve had, that was to be expected.

    It remains to be seen whether Mr. Trump can influence society to improve in this regard, or whether Generation Snowflake is simply too far around the bend to retrieve.

  6. Nope, none of that happened.

    What also didn’t happen was the funneling of hundreds of millions of dollars to Democratic donors fronted by so called Green-energy firms, like Solyndra, all of which appear to have gone Tango Uniform after the principals pocketed the cash through lavish pay packets. Billions more to donors if you count the auto company bailouts as sops to the unions. And cash for clunkers.

    Nope, no scandals during the past eight years.

    Nothing to see here … move along.

  7. The US right mostly want to prevent any public medical care for Americans, in the same way they want to gut social security. The function of Progressives to to covertly support them, which is why the Affordable Care Act is increasingly unaffordable, and benefits the insurance, drug, and medical institutions.

  8. Taras77 says:

    Jarrett is one of several harpies surrounding obama: rice, nuland, power, jarrett, and recently clinton. It seems that they have been mobilized to launch a “save the legacy” campaign but unless one has been asleep for the last 8 years, it will not succeed-obama is/was a fraud from day one and has been on puppet strings since he was selected not elected.

    • Replies: @Authenticjazzman
  9. Americans today are less free, less prosperous, less safe and trillions more in debt than we were eight years ago. Can Trump effectively change course after so much damage has been done?

    No, but the “damage” started long before Obama. Obama is a symptom, not the disease.

  10. N30rebel says:

    Can Trump effectively change course after so much damage has been done? We soon will know.

    My guess is that Trump is the last person to exit the clown car.

  11. @Taras77

    “Puppet strings” : Yes and no. If he was only a “Puppet” this could then somehow exonerate him from the damage he has inflicted upon the country, as if he maybe did not want to destroy it, and was forced to do so by his masters.
    Nope he was not, is not, a victim of hidden powers rather he fully had intended to himself bring about the results which have been manifested .
    Of course this does not mean that there are not “Hidden” powers, with their malevolent goals, who are backing him.
    Authenticjazzman, “Mensa” society member of forty-plus years and pro jazz artist.

  12. Thank God there are still men like Napolitano in this country. He’s never afraid to call out officialdom on its bullshit.

    O-Bomb-a’s presidency was just as depraved as those of his predecessors Dubya and “Blow Job Bill” Clinton.

Current Commenter

Leave a Reply - Comments on articles more than two weeks old will be judged much more strictly on quality and tone

 Remember My InformationWhy?
 Email Replies to my Comment
Submitted comments become the property of The Unz Review and may be republished elsewhere at the sole discretion of the latter
Subscribe to This Comment Thread via RSS Subscribe to All Andrew Napolitano Comments via RSS
Are elite university admissions based on meritocracy and diversity as claimed?
The sources of America’s immigration problems—and a possible solution
The evidence is clear — but often ignored
What Was John McCain's True Wartime Record in Vietnam?
Hundreds of POWs may have been left to die in Vietnam, abandoned by their government—and our media.