The Unz Review - Mobile
A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media
 TeasersRussian Reaction Blog
Protestantism and the Financially Literate Ethic
🔊 Listen RSS
Email This Page to Someone

 Remember My Information



=>

Bookmark Toggle AllToCAdd to LibraryRemove from Library • BShow CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead More
ReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All Comments
AgreeDisagreeLOLTroll
These buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Troll, or LOL with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used once per hour.
Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter
Search Text Case Sensitive  Exact Words  Include Comments
List of Bookmarks

According to a recent n=150,000 global survey by Gallup and S&P, there is an astounding lack of financial literacy in the world.

To gauge financial literacy, they asked a series of four questions on basic financial concepts such as risk diversification, inflation, simple interest, and compound interest. They were very simple and typically only had 2-3 possible answers. Here is the most “difficult” question:

Suppose you had 100 US dollars in a savings account and the bank adds 10 percent per year to the account. How much money would you have in the account after five years if you did not remove any money from the account?

The possible answers were:

[more than 150 dollars; exactly 150 dollars; less than 150 dollars; don’t know;
refused to answer]

Demonstrating understanding in three out of the four areas qualified you as financially literate. Only a third of the world’s population reached that threshold, rising to a modest 53% in the advanced OECD countries.

global-financial-literacy-world-map

One surprising pattern is that there was very little variation in financial literacy between low-income and middle-income countries; there was only a sustained increase once countries began to exceed the $12,000 GDP per capita mark. Presumably, that is approximately the point when people start doing things like getting credit cards and taking out mortgages, so they are forced to come to grips with concepts like compound interest whether they like it or not. But there are plenty of both negative outliers (e.g. Japan, Korea, Italy, Portugal), as well as a few positive ones (e.g. Bhutan, Myanmar, Botswana).

economic-development-and-financial-literacy

Curiously, the correlation between financial literacy and cognitive ability appears to be surprisingly low. In other words, basic financial literacy has a low g loading.

There is a relationship to be sure, but exceptions abound, even in the rich country list. High IQ Japan, Korea, and China do a lot worse than one might expect. Botswana and South Africa do much better than what their national IQ levels might imply; in fact, South Africa is the highest-scoring of the BRICS countries.

g7-vs-brics-financial-literacy

Although conventional coverage of the national differences in financial literacy highlighted in this report by mainstream journalists like Leonid Bershidsky predictably focus on things like education levels and exposure to financial services, the really big explanatatory factor seems to be religious/cultural.

On the global scale, the Protestant world comprise nine of the world’s top 10 most financially literate countries, and an amazing 17 of the world’s top 25 – which is also a convenient threshold representing 50%+ financial literacy. (By which point the stock of both developed world Protestant countries pretty much ends). The world’s offshore bank, Switzerland, is a relatively disappointing 15th.

9 of the top 10 countries are within the Hajnal line of Europe, or are their descendants; and 17 of the top 25.

Predictably, the non-Protestant exception in the top 10 is Israel. The Jews can sure count their shekels.

Another correlation that seems to exist is with time preference. Countries where people displayed a willingness to wait to get a greater sum of money in one month’s time, as opposed to getting a smaller sum right now (inflation-adjusted), also tended to perform much better on financial literacy metrics.

The Catholics and Orthodox Christians tended to do a lot worse, even though as we know IQ differences between them and the Protestant world are fairly minor. Likewise with the Confucian civilization.

This suggests that Protestant populations have tended to culturally evolve (or gene-culturally evolve) an “intuitive” understanding of finance like things, while the rest of the world pretty much has to figure it out from zero. More intelligent populations with financial experience, such as the Japanese, tend to be relatively better at it (43% financially literate); less intelligent populations without much financial experience, such as the Indians and Iranians, do much worse at it (<25% financially literate).

Still, there remain some curious cases nonetheless. How does dirt poor and only 60% literate Bhutan manage to take 20th place, with 54% financial literacy? Myanmar also does surprisingly well for a country of its socio-economic and hisorical profile, taking up the 24th slot. Both are Buddhist, but otherwise, Buddhists do not appear to perform especially well; Cambodia is one of the worst, while Thailand is middling between Myanmar and Cambodia. Nor does it appear to have anything to do with the particular sect of Buddhism: Bhutan follows Vajrayana Buddhism, while Myanmar follows Theravada.

Financial Literacy 2015 via S&P/Gallup

# Country % Financial Literacy
1 Norway 71.3%
2 Denmark 71.3%
3 Sweden 71.2%
4 Israel 68.4%
5 Canada 68.3%
6 United Kingdom 67.1%
7 Netherlands 66.1%
8 Germany 65.7%
9 Australia 63.7%
10 Finland 62.9%
11 New Zealand 61.5%
12 Singapore 59.4%
13 Czech Republic 58.4%
14 United States 57.4%
15 Switzerland 57.1%
16 Belgium 55.3%
17 Ireland 55.1%
18 Estonia 54.4%
19 Hungary 54.2%
20 Bhutan 53.7%
21 Luxembourg 53.2%
22 Austria 53.0%
23 Botswana 52.2%
24 Myanmar 51.8%
25 France 51.7%
26 Spain 49.1%
27 Latvia 48.3%
28 Montenegro 48.2%
29 Slovak Republic 48.1%
30 Greece 45.0%
31 Uruguay 44.8%
32 Tunisia 44.7%
33 Lebanon 44.4%
34 Malta 44.2%
35 Croatia 44.1%
36 Slovenia 44.0%
37 Kuwait 43.5%
38 Japan 43.0%
39 Hong Kong SAR, China 42.7%
40 Poland 42.4%
41 South Africa 41.7%
42 Turkmenistan 41.1%
43 Mongolia 40.7%
44 Chile 40.7%
45 Zimbabwe 40.6%
46 Zambia 40.4%
47 Tanzania 40.3%
48 Ukraine 40.0%
49 Kazakhstan 39.7%
50 Senegal 39.7%
51 Bahrain 39.5%
52 Lithuania 38.7%
53 Mauritius 38.7%
54 United Arab Emirates 38.3%
55 Russian Federation 38.1%
56 Kenya 38.0%
57 Serbia 38.0%
58 Togo 38.0%
59 Madagascar 37.7%
60 Cameroon 37.7%
61 Belarus 37.5%
62 Benin 37.0%
63 Italy 36.9%
64 Taiwan, China 36.9%
65 Azerbaijan 36.3%
66 Malaysia 35.7%
67 Sri Lanka 35.4%
68 Dominican Republic 35.4%
69 Costa Rica 35.1%
70 Malawi 35.1%
71 Gabon 34.8%
72 Bulgaria 34.7%
73 Côte d’Ivoire 34.7%
74 Brazil 34.7%
75 Cyprus 34.6%
76 Uganda 34.2%
77 Korea, Rep. 33.4%
78 Mali 33.4%
79 Mauritania 33.3%
80 Algeria 33.0%
81 Jamaica 32.9%
82 Burkina Faso 32.8%
83 Belize 32.6%
84 Colombia 32.2%
85 Indonesia 32.2%
86 Puerto Rico 32.2%
87 Ethiopia 32.1%
88 Congo, Dem. Rep. 31.9%
89 Mexico 31.6%
90 Ghana 31.5%
91 Niger 31.5%
92 Saudi Arabia 31.3%
93 Congo, Rep. 31.0%
94 Guinea 30.4%
95 Ecuador 30.3%
96 Georgia 29.7%
97 China 28.1%
98 China 28.1%
99 Argentina 28.0%
100 Peru 27.6%
101 Egypt, Arab Rep. 27.5%
102 Thailand 27.4%
103 Moldova 27.4%
104 Bosnia and Herzegovina 27.2%
105 Iraq 27.2%
106 Namibia 26.7%
107 Panama 26.5%
108 Pakistan 26.3%
109 Chad 26.2%
110 Nigeria 26.1%
111 Portugal 26.0%
112 Rwanda 25.8%
113 Guatemala 25.7%
114 Venezuela, RB 25.1%
115 Philippines 25.0%
116 West Bank and Gaza 24.6%
117 Burundi 24.4%
118 Vietnam 24.4%
119 Bolivia 24.4%
120 Turkey 23.6%
121 India 23.6%
122 Jordan 23.6%
123 Honduras 22.9%
124 Romania 21.7%
125 Macedonia, FYR 21.5%
126 Uzbekistan 21.4%
127 El Salvador 21.1%
128 Sierra Leone 21.0%
129 Sudan 20.7%
130 Iran, Islamic Rep. 20.5%
131 Kosovo 19.9%
132 Nicaragua 19.8%
133 Bangladesh 19.2%
134 Kyrgyz Republic 18.9%
135 Cambodia 18.4%
136 Nepal 18.3%
137 Armenia 18.2%
138 Haiti 17.9%
139 Tajikistan 16.9%
140 Angola 15.3%
141 Somalia 15.2%
142 Afghanistan 14.1%
143 Albania 13.8%
144 Yemen, Rep. 13.3%
 
• Category: Economics • Tags: Culture, Finance, Literacy, Protestantism 
Hide 17 CommentsLeave a Comment
Commenters to Ignore...to FollowEndorsed Only
Trim Comments?
  1. Sampling in poor countries is so inadequate that 90% of the results of such surveys are nonsense.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    The only results from poor countries to trust is IQ tests.
  2. If the Protestant nations did the best, the Hindu nations (India and Nepal) did the worst. That seems to be the only correlation.

    What also stands out is Subsaharan Africa doing much better than the Indian Subcontinent and West Asia. And Bhutan, Botswana and Burma doing better than China, Japan and Russia.

    • Replies: @5371
    And right on schedule, you swallow all the nonsense like mother's milk.
  3. @Bliss
    If the Protestant nations did the best, the Hindu nations (India and Nepal) did the worst. That seems to be the only correlation.

    What also stands out is Subsaharan Africa doing much better than the Indian Subcontinent and West Asia. And Bhutan, Botswana and Burma doing better than China, Japan and Russia.

    And right on schedule, you swallow all the nonsense like mother’s milk.

  4. Looks to me there is a hole in your argument.

    A country like Iran, or any of the middle eastern countries don’t have experience with commerce?

    Really? I mean the homes of the trade caravan, the bazaar, the Satrap’s Court, trading ships even…

    Just saying trade goes WAY back in this neck of the woods.

    Of course a certain religion has a problem with interest on loans. But that religion would have found it necessary to have that problem circa 700 AD then right?

    Anyway. This was such a cool, interesting part of the world till that monster/abomination religion came along and turned everything into crap.

    I’d like to turn back the clock; Zoraoasterism in Persia, the Byzantines back big in Turkey, animists and funky people in the Balkans…

    And Isis, Marduk, and the Temple of Sin back in Babylon.

    Actually we are going to have to move Baghdad about a 100 miles and rename it. And those Shias are gonna sh*t when they see the new order. Shame Hussein is gone, that’s one man who would have gotten my vision and been on board.

    Then we’ll have cat worshipers and 220 million gods in Egypt (trust me this place gave India a run for it’s money)…

    A man can dream. Of course in my fantasy middle east you’d find Christianity in only one place, Byzantium. I’m totally cool with Judaism being in Israel though.

    • Replies: @Seamus Padraig

    A country like Iran, or any of the middle eastern countries don’t have experience with commerce?
     
    Commerce and finance are not the same thing, Sunbeam. Commerce means trading real goods; finance means playing shell games with money.

    Here's my own hypothesis regarding religion and finance: Historically, both Islam and the Catholic Church forbid usury; the Jews and Protestants, in general, did not. It makes perfect sense then that the latter would have a greater cultural affinity for finance than the former.

    Anatoly, didn't the Orthodox Church also ban usury?

    Regarding the Buddhists, Confucians, Animists, etc., I have no general hypothesis to offer.
  5. @5371
    Sampling in poor countries is so inadequate that 90% of the results of such surveys are nonsense.

    The only results from poor countries to trust is IQ tests.

  6. @Sunbeam
    Looks to me there is a hole in your argument.

    A country like Iran, or any of the middle eastern countries don't have experience with commerce?

    Really? I mean the homes of the trade caravan, the bazaar, the Satrap's Court, trading ships even...

    Just saying trade goes WAY back in this neck of the woods.

    Of course a certain religion has a problem with interest on loans. But that religion would have found it necessary to have that problem circa 700 AD then right?

    Anyway. This was such a cool, interesting part of the world till that monster/abomination religion came along and turned everything into crap.

    I'd like to turn back the clock; Zoraoasterism in Persia, the Byzantines back big in Turkey, animists and funky people in the Balkans...

    And Isis, Marduk, and the Temple of Sin back in Babylon.

    Actually we are going to have to move Baghdad about a 100 miles and rename it. And those Shias are gonna sh*t when they see the new order. Shame Hussein is gone, that's one man who would have gotten my vision and been on board.

    Then we'll have cat worshipers and 220 million gods in Egypt (trust me this place gave India a run for it's money)...

    A man can dream. Of course in my fantasy middle east you'd find Christianity in only one place, Byzantium. I'm totally cool with Judaism being in Israel though.

    A country like Iran, or any of the middle eastern countries don’t have experience with commerce?

    Commerce and finance are not the same thing, Sunbeam. Commerce means trading real goods; finance means playing shell games with money.

    Here’s my own hypothesis regarding religion and finance: Historically, both Islam and the Catholic Church forbid usury; the Jews and Protestants, in general, did not. It makes perfect sense then that the latter would have a greater cultural affinity for finance than the former.

    Anatoly, didn’t the Orthodox Church also ban usury?

    Regarding the Buddhists, Confucians, Animists, etc., I have no general hypothesis to offer.

    • Replies: @Hibernian
    Old Joe Kennedy was pretty good at finance... ...and bootlegging.
  7. Anonymous • Disclaimer says:

    In Japan, household budgets and finances are managed by the women. Japanese salarymen hand over their salaries to their wives, who give them an allowance or pocket money in return. I imagine it may be similar in Korea and China. It could be that the men there never deal with and know much about finances, sort of like how when wives used to do all the cooking and cleaning, few men knew how to cook.

    “Why male Japanese wage-earners have only ‘pocket money’”

    http://www.bbc.com/news/business-19674306

    The 15th of each month is a big day for 36-year-old Yoshihiro Nozawa: it is the day he gets paid.

    But every month, he hands over his entire salary to his wife Masami.

    She controls the household budget and gives him a monthly pocket money of 30,000 yen ($381; £243). Despite being the breadwinner, that is all the money he can spend on himself over the next 30 days.

    “I started controlling the household budget when I became a housewife after having children,” says Masami.

    “Suddenly, there was only one income and their educations and private lessons cost a lot.”

    Yoshihiro nods but he says 30,000 yen doesn’t go far in the world’s most expensive city, Tokyo.

    “She makes me a lunch box every morning so that helps a lot,” he says as he eats his lunch alone in a nearby park from his office.

    His only luxury is cigarettes, which he spends one third of his monthly allowance on.

    “I think I may have to quit if the price goes up again,” he says.

    Yoshihiro may be eating his lunch alone but he is not unique.

    According to a survey conducted by research firm Softbrain Field, 74% of Japanese household budgets are controlled by women and it is not just couples with young children.

    47-year-old Taisaku Kubo has been getting 50,000 yen a month from his wife Yuriko for the past 15 years.

    He has tried to negotiate a pay rise each year but his wife makes a presentation to explain why it cannot be done.

    “She draws a pie chart of our household budget to explain why I cannot get more pocket money,” says Taisaku.

    On the hand drawn chart, his pocket money is stated as 8.8% of the monthly budget.

    “The biggest expenditures are home loan and taxes,” says his wife Yuriko. “We don’t have children so I want to make sure that we’ll have enough money after his retirement.”

    Just like that, Taisaku loses his argument for a pay rise.

    “I’ve given up my car, motorbike and many expensive hobbies,” he laughs.

  8. @Seamus Padraig

    A country like Iran, or any of the middle eastern countries don’t have experience with commerce?
     
    Commerce and finance are not the same thing, Sunbeam. Commerce means trading real goods; finance means playing shell games with money.

    Here's my own hypothesis regarding religion and finance: Historically, both Islam and the Catholic Church forbid usury; the Jews and Protestants, in general, did not. It makes perfect sense then that the latter would have a greater cultural affinity for finance than the former.

    Anatoly, didn't the Orthodox Church also ban usury?

    Regarding the Buddhists, Confucians, Animists, etc., I have no general hypothesis to offer.

    Old Joe Kennedy was pretty good at finance… …and bootlegging.

    • Replies: @Ivy
    Old Joe should've doubled down on the swimming lessons for the kiddies.
    , @Seamus Padraig

    Old Joe Kennedy was pretty good at finance… …and bootlegging.
     
    I could be pretty good at finance too, if, like old Joe Kennedy, I had inside information!
  9. Three questions out of five require manipulating percentages in your head. Many people have a problem with doing that; they just don’t get percentages. But they often easily get the same problem if you restate it in dollars and cents.

    Also, I can see how in lower trust societies people may have a different perspective on Question 1, which asks if it’s safer to invest in a single or multiple businesses. As far as the researchers are concerned the correct answer is multiple businesses. But a person from a low trust society would likely think that the safest way is to invest all your money into a single business – your own. This would be far more preferable to handing out the money to a bunch of strangers of questionable trustworthiness.

  10. @Hibernian
    Old Joe Kennedy was pretty good at finance... ...and bootlegging.

    Old Joe should’ve doubled down on the swimming lessons for the kiddies.

    • Replies: @iffen
    Some of the boys could swim pretty good, just not good enough to save their traveling companions.
  11. Is it Protestantism though, or harsher environments?

    Harsh or challenging environments create people who need to keep on the ball (crafty people survive, lazy people die). A lot of Protestant countries are also Northern European, where planning ahead (harsh winters) is nessesary to survive.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    The British Isles and North Sea area is pretty mild because of the Gulf Stream compared to NE Europe and Russia and elsewhere.
  12. @Anon
    Is it Protestantism though, or harsher environments?

    Harsh or challenging environments create people who need to keep on the ball (crafty people survive, lazy people die). A lot of Protestant countries are also Northern European, where planning ahead (harsh winters) is nessesary to survive.

    The British Isles and North Sea area is pretty mild because of the Gulf Stream compared to NE Europe and Russia and elsewhere.

    • Replies: @Anonymous
    True but Malthusian pressure in Britain favoured the hard workers survivng

    Read Gregor Clark's A Farewell to Alms
  13. @Ivy
    Old Joe should've doubled down on the swimming lessons for the kiddies.

    Some of the boys could swim pretty good, just not good enough to save their traveling companions.

  14. Mormons are great businessmen. The early Mormon church encouraged converts to immigrate to Utah. The converts mostly came from England, Denmark, Sweden, Norway, and I believe Germany.

    Here is an unofficial and incomplete list of common Mormon last names:

    http://furtherlightandtruth.blogspot.com/2011/03/list-of-most-common-mormon-surnames.html

  15. @Hibernian
    Old Joe Kennedy was pretty good at finance... ...and bootlegging.

    Old Joe Kennedy was pretty good at finance… …and bootlegging.

    I could be pretty good at finance too, if, like old Joe Kennedy, I had inside information!

  16. @Anonymous
    The British Isles and North Sea area is pretty mild because of the Gulf Stream compared to NE Europe and Russia and elsewhere.

    True but Malthusian pressure in Britain favoured the hard workers survivng

    Read Gregor Clark’s A Farewell to Alms

  17. Anatoly, did you know PISA 2012 had a financial literacy component? Have a look at page 36 of the PISA overview and the sample test questions.

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to All Anatoly Karlin Comments via RSS